Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Agriculture, Forestry & Economic Development

February 1, 2017 ·Committee Room 138 ·17:19
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (3)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1217 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1217 Branscum TO PROVIDE FREE HUNTING AND FISHING LICENSES FOR V…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1256 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1256 Sabin TO PROVIDE THAT SALES BY A COTTAGE FOOD PRODUCTION OP…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1380 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1380 D. Douglas TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS TRESPASSER RESPONSIBILITY…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
Or somewhere you have to be if you'd sit down just a minute. We've got a couple introductions to do and no bells to run, but we'll get this over with. I know everybody's got a busy schedule. all right members uh while we're here first of all i want to introduce to you some future leaders of this state and possibly future leaders of agriculture we have a group of young people here from the bergman ffa chapter thank you all for coming We always appreciate our FFA chapters and the leadership skills that they teach our young people and build future leaders to take our place when we get old and senile. But, okay, with that, we also have some fine folks, some of our partners from ADEQ here. Ms. Julie, would you like to introduce yourself and your staff that you have here and tell us what you are doing over at ADQ? And
▶ Play
you are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is Julie Chapman. I'm the Senior Associate Director of the Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality. We're led by our Director, Becky Keogh. Many of you, I'm sure, have crossed paths with her. I want to, at the outset, clear up what could possibly be some confusion for new members. She has an identical twin sister who also serves in the Hutchinson administration, Barbara Webb. So if you're talking to one about workers' comp and they look totally ignorant of the subject, it's because you're talking to Becky. So they'll play you, too, a little bit. So don't fall for that trap. But I really appreciate being here. A couple of big things that I want to point out to you all. we are we've changed our department extraordinarily um the our approach to permitting our approach to the um regulated community in the last year and a half but we've had to do those changes within some very strict boundaries set by the epa what's happening now in washington is extraordinary there was a bill introduced today to eliminate the epa entirely out of florida and so we we're monitoring what's going on in Washington, D.C., but when I say that the planes are shifting, they're shifting very quickly. What's wonderful is that we have Senator Bozeman representing the state of Arkansas. He sits on the Public Health and Works Committee, so he was in charge of Scott Pruitt's confirmation hearing. We were able to make some very Arkansas-specific questions. I know some of y'all worry with the Illinois, I guess, Representative Douglas, that's in your, we were able to pinpoint some very precise Arkansas-related questions as a part of that confirmation process. He has made it, Pruitt has made it out of the works committee. I think there will be a fight on the floor, but I guess I'm here to report that Arkansas's voice, we have a front row seat to this dialogue. Another thing that we bring to the table on that national battle, Director Keough is one of three executive council members of the Environmental Council of the States. This is a state organization. All states are members of this organization, and the leadership of that organization, they meet with the director of the EPA via a personal conference call, closed doors every single week, and they meet in person once a quarter. So when I say we have a front row seat to how the new EPA will look, if there even is an EPA, we need to hear from you all. We need to be able to channel what your local needs are, where you've hit roadblocks with the EPA as we start formulating a different national approach to environmental regulation. So if you'll indulge me for a minute, we've prepared these books for you. one of the I guess Director Keogh's directions for our our agency is you all are our board of directors Governor Hutchinson is our CEO the regulated community those are our customers and our and our shareholders are the taxpayers that's how we run ADEQ now and as our board of directors y'all need to know what who what we do and what's going on so their booklets they have your name on the front but these party favors at least it is our hope will be very contain useful information for you to be a better legislator they're district specific they talk about all of the grants that you get in your district and every regulated facility and most importantly they have our our leadership team you put a face with it you need to know something about air land or water here's who you go to and here's how you get to them and if you have any problem getting through or not getting an answer i want to know about it um we have enterprise services this we think it is an enterprise figuring out the right answers for arkansas arkansas specific answers kevin white over here has joined our team i guess in other agencies this might be considered a constituent services role you've got an issue you've got a question you want somebody from adq in your community you call kevin we'll be there um and there are also some gis maps beth do you have those these these also are personalized with your district um they'll have your name on them but it will show your district and it will show every regulated facility in and any permit that's currently operational um as you go through these materials if you don't have certain grants in your district i i would ask that you take special note of that because what what we see are the same people ask for money over and over again and we'd like to at least let you all know of some of the grant programs we have and maybe you all could take advantage of those and and you don't so we we offer the same people apply the same monies there so look look in the grant section of your notebook and if there are brownfield any kind of projects that that you're not getting in your district come and talk to me about it because there could be some opportunities that you all have not even known of and with that I'll be glad to answer any specific questions I I guess the elephant in the room is the the hog farm that the drilling study I think at a time in the future we will be giving you a specific briefing on that and that permit process is going going forward now There was just an appeal on an ancillary permit that our agency has defended, and we're waiting the result of that appeal on behalf of CNH Hog Farms. And it's an ancillary, a secondary appeal that is, or a secondary permit from the first. So it's still in a little bit of a legal quagmire that I can't talk about the full ending of it, but we are vigorously defending the permit as it was issued. And that's something that Director Keough, I think, would have me emphasize to you all that our permitting process, what we're committed to are protective permits, that they protect the environment, they protect the people living there, but they also protect the people who invest a considerable amount of money following these regulatory boundaries that those permits will withstand legal challenge, they will withstand third-party lawsuits. And so that portion of the protection of the permit is something relatively new to ADEQ. And so we've really worked on getting our backlog, but any permit that you see that's taking a long time, it's probably because we're trying to run the legal traps on the front end so when they get those permits they will withstand any kind of legal challenge and we're looking at the appellate horizon when we're writing those so with that i'll be glad to answer any questions i hope you like the party favors beth thompson you all know i i think she's worked for been around more governors and she's probably been in the capital more than all of us together but she works in constituent services so she can help you get to kevin and they did a great job preparing all these materials i i think it's they're kind of nerdy but they're things that i think will help you all um really um look at look at what facilities specifically you have that that we permit and we can help you have a more um deep dialogue on that so you'll you'll kind of know when you get the phone call we're starting so with that i'll entertain any questions or if there's anything you would like a specific specific comments on mr chairman let me start out here and
▶ Play
then Representative Meeks will go to you. First of all, Ms. Julie, I want to thank you all for being here today and talking to us and preparing this information to educate us better on what's going on with ADQ in our districts. Secondly, I want to thank you all for the job you're doing and your shift towards making decisions based on sound science. That's what we have to have, educated research decisions and based on sound science not just whichever way the wind might be blowing today in political favoritism so thank you all for your your leadership heading the the organization department in that way okay representative meeks did you have a question sir you are recognized thank you mr chair i have i have two
▶ Play
if that's uh permissible and and you may be able to see what your first one is and what like oh okay okay and you may be able to answer both these, and it may be too early to have answers to these. Under the previous administration, we saw a spiked increase in the number of FIPs, the federal interventions, and then also there was the issue with the clean coal and the concern there. What are we seeing in regards to those two fronts? Is it too early yet, or have you seen any new decisions
▶ Play
on those two? So specifically, I'll put this in context, but you're spot on. A FIP is a federal implementation plan. So we're a delegated authority. We get many of our authorities through the EPA where we say it's called cooperative federalism and that there are minimum standards the federal government sets and then we find state approaches for that. Well, to give you perspective, a state approach is called a state implementation plan. In the first six years of the Obama administration, where you submit a state implementation plan and you say, this is what we think is the best answer for Arkansas to meet these federal guidelines. In the first six years of the Obama administration, they overfiled the SIPP. They put their own federal, they said, no, you're going to do it this way. Your state approach is inadequate, so it's called a FIPP. They overlay it on the SIPP, and they say, you're going to do this. There were 10 times more FIPS issued throughout the United States of America. Listen to these numbers. 10 times more FIPS issued in the first six years of the Obama administration than the prior three administrations combined. This is not an RD issue. This is a state's rights issue. And when Director Keough submitted a list of concerns to the new director, that topped the list. We, right now, are actively involved in the Eighth Circuit court litigation on our regional Hays plan. We have a state implementation plan that makes every single checkoff we got fibbed. There's, at least in my estimation as a lawyer and the attorney general agrees, there's no reason to have fibbed that unless you're trying to drive a different agenda that doesn't comport with your federally delegated regulatory authority. We're fighting that in court now. We're hearing from Washington that there's a very likely chance that once Pruitt is confirmed, they will no longer defend those challenges. That will be a quick answer to that. We still are looking at the Clean Power Plan. It's in the federal circuit now. Kind of a weird, we got a little bit of a glimpse of the future when the Supreme Court of the United States issued a stay on that. That told us two things. One, they would probably take the case, and they would probably find that the EPA had acted beyond its regulatory authority. It was a very close vote for the state. It was a 5-4 vote. One of those voters is no longer with us. So now it's a 4-4 vote. So all of a sudden, it became very unclear. As of 8-30 last night, it's looking more like a 5-4 vote in that at least, no matter what the federal circuit does, by the time it gets to the Supreme Court, they will find that that Clean Power Plan, I mean, you've got an almost 3,000-page regulation that was promulgated on about 12 words of authority, and at least, and I'm, my background is a law professor, a constitutional, but I'm a strict constructionist, and it's going to take a long way to get me 3,000 pages from 12 words so um i i would suspect that the newest supreme court nominee would have that same approach they're saying that he's very scalia-esque which is strict constructionist so does that answer your question yeah yes it sure does and as those develop uh please
▶ Play
keep us posted but yes i think it's moving in the right direction
▶ Play
it's looking um but you know i i thought the five four think wow this is the great what could possibly go wrong and then things go wrong so you never you never know but it's it's looking like we're we're going to see extreme changes i i have to read the the uh the congressman from florida the abolishing the epa bill i haven't seen that yet but um i mean that'll that'll at least um put things in perspective of the need for change definitely all right thank you thank you
▶ Play
mr follow up do you or did that answer your question okay any other members have any questions for uh miss julie here you know i
▶ Play
used to be called professor cullen and then i got called kelly's girlfriend now i miss julie i don't know i don't know
▶ Play
Speaker 6 14:46
which one i like best just trying to show
▶ Play
respect where i do okay enough from the peanut in the gallery over here okay but uh anything else uh yes sir recognized. Go ahead. Use your mic,
▶ Play
please, Jack. Representative Fortner. This is just a comment. I would encourage all of you, men and women, to go over and tour their facility. As a new legislator, I went over there to see because I had heard so much. And I can tell you, I believe, in my opinion, it's a new day. They took more than ample time. They made me feel more than welcome, and they answered every question, even the ones that were uncomfortable. And the director took personal time with me, and I think she would with any one of you. So it's a good thing. It's a good thing. So take advantage of it. thank you sir and
▶ Play
thank you miss julie we appreciate it and
▶ Play
i appreciate you all letting me speak for the committee and please find any of us if you have any other follow-up questions and we look forward to a partnership going forward and we'll be reporting back giller our board of directors so i want to make make you well aware of what's going on and make sure that we're um moving the ball in the direction that you all have legislated it to be moved
▶ Play
okay thank you thank you ma'am and thank your staff for being here and for these great handouts and party favors there a couple more housekeeping items just want to recognize mark cochran here vice president of vision of agriculture here and his assistant miss stephanie nepling here glad you all are here i also have one other guest that i want to recognize i have with me here today my sister Miss Judy Bell she made me what I am today so anyway members I appreciate you today we are going to be getting more legislation in here we've got more bills to run uh we've got a couple things to work out on some we'll get some good stuff going here and um thank you all for your attendance and we will have another committee dinner soon but anyway thank y'all have good day
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1217 Branscum TO PROVIDE FREE HUNTING AND FISHING LICENSES FOR VOLUNTEER FIREFIGHTERS

-2:00 - 17:22 45 segments 5 speakers

HB1256 Sabin TO PROVIDE THAT SALES BY A COTTAGE FOOD PRODUCTION OPERATION AT AN ONLINE FARMERS' MARKET ARE EXEMPT FROM THE DEFINITION OF "FOOD SERVICE ESTABLISHMENT".

HB1380 D. Douglas TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS TRESPASSER RESPONSIBILITY ACT.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Dan M. Douglas Unverified
12 segments
Julie Link Unverified
26 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 6
1 segment
Representative Jack Fortner Unverified
3 segments