Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Advanced Communications and Information Technology

February 1, 2017 ·Committee Room 151 ·54:09
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (2)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1364 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1364 K. Hendren TO ESTABLISH THE PUBLIC POLICY OF THE STATE OF A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1410 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1410 S. Meeks TO AMEND THE TELECOMMUNICATIONS REGULATORY REFORM…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
We do have pictures today, so. All right, I'm going to go ahead and call the meeting to order. And I'd like to welcome everyone to our initial meeting of the Advanced Communications and Information Technology Committee. I will be your chair for this term, and with me I'll have Warwick Sabin, Representative Sabin as my left-hand man. I'm looking forward to working with Mr. Saban and with all of you. That's right. You've got to keep it lighthearted, right? So, anyways, originally what we were going to do is we were going to start off by doing our photograph, but because we've got a lot of members that have not shown up yet to try to give them a few minutes to come in today, what I'd like to do is normally we start with introductions and talk about what the purpose of the committee is. So what I'd like to do is I'm going to kind of take things out of order, and I'd like to go around the room and let all the guests that are in the room, if you would, let you introduce yourselves and the different various groups that you're with so the members can kind of start to get to know you and your affiliations. And then hopefully by the time we get that complete, then we'll have more of our colleagues fill in here, and then we can proceed from there. So let me start with the introductions or start by introducing our staff. Normally, our staff analysis or committee analyst is Ms. Veneria Smith. She was our analyst last term, and she's done a great job, and we're looking forward to working with her again. However, unfortunately, she couldn't be here. So Ms. Brown is standing in for her today, and she's at a lot of our committees. and so we appreciate her making sure I don't get in trouble this morning. Our administrative assistant is Ms. Rowe, and she's over there. And our legislative attorney is Jennifer Lilo. Lilo, I don't think she's here this morning. She's not here this morning. So with that, what we're going to do is why don't we actually, I want to see if Representative Saban has any remarks, and then we'll go from there.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just want to briefly say I'm very, very honored to be serving as vice chair of this committee. As many of you know, these issues aren't just part of what I'm concerned about legislatively, but I direct the Innovation Hub in North Little Rock, and we deal with a lot of these issues in that capacity as well. And I've also been pleased to be able to work with Representative Meeks on designing some initiatives to really try to expand accessibility to broadband internet service in the state of Arkansas at the speaker's direction. So we look forward to working on those issues as well as all the other things that are coming before the committee. Thank you. Thank you. So
▶ Play
why don't we start going around the room? I guess we'll start here with Ms. Hill, who's also been instrumental in our broadband work. But we'll start here and just kind of work our way around the room.
▶ Play
Speaker 8 3:06
I'm Marty Patel. I'm a lawyer with Mitchell Williams here in Little
▶ Play
Speaker 10 3:11
Rock. I'm Randy Richmond. I'm with the Arkansas Municipality and the attorney over there. You guys can put it here just so we had someone in the group.
▶ Play
Speaker 16 3:20
Good idea. Hello, I'm Dana Will. We're at Green. We're from the Welfare. We represent Winstreet Community. Good morning. I'm Shelby Johnson. I direct the Arkansas Geographic Information Systems Office. We have a statutory requirement to report to this committee once a year. We also have served the committee by providing maps and analysis of the broadband status of the state of Arkansas. I'm pleased to be here. We have Jonathan Moran here with me. He's our deputy director in the agency.
▶ Play
Speaker 18 3:56
Mr. Johnson. I'm Ken Williams from the Department of Finance and Administration. Mr. Chairman, I'm Lynn
▶ Play
Speaker 19 4:02
Pickcock. The last time this committee met, I
▶ Play
Speaker 21 4:06
was corporate with Cox Communications. Now I'm a contract lobbyist, still representing Cox and some other items. I'm Angela
▶ Play
Speaker 18 4:12
Dewell. I am with Cox Communications. I'm Steve Rall.
▶ Play
Speaker 25 4:23
I'm a
▶ Play
Speaker 26 4:30
director for
▶ Play
Speaker 28 4:36
the Art Court of
▶ Play
Speaker 29 4:44
Communications.
▶ Play
Speaker 30 4:48
Good morning.
▶ Play
Speaker 25 4:52
Good
▶ Play
Speaker 31 4:57
morning. Thank you. Thank you for your question. Stephen Fulkerson.
▶ Play
Speaker 33 5:08
I direct the Arkansas Research and Education Office.
▶ Play
Speaker 34 5:14
I'm Justin Allen. I represent South
▶ Play
Speaker 21 5:18
Arkansas Telephone Company. I'm Steve Smith. I'm a senior partner with Ronan Technology Advisors. We're a broadband consultant firm. We work with different providers. Okay, all right, and why don't we
▶ Play
go ahead and we'll transition to our members. And maybe we'll start over here with Representative Dotson. I think you may, are you the only veteran that was on this committee with me last term? You were
▶ Play
Speaker 38 6:04
like, he was here two years
▶ Play
Speaker 37 6:08
ago, okay. I'm Fran Cavanaugh, representative
▶ Play
of District 60. Austin McCollum from Bentonville,
▶ Play
this is my first term, honored to be
▶ Play
here. Andy Mayberry, District 27. In a previous life, I worked for Altel Corporation on the mobile side, the landline side, and also the information services side. So
▶ Play
Speaker 44 6:41
I'm very happy to be pleased to be a
▶ Play
Speaker 76 6:49
part of this committee. Representative Carolyn Brown, District 41. That's primarily Sherwood. in a previous life. I also work for Alltel in the Mobile Division. Oh,
▶ Play
Speaker 41 6:59
you're the one. Yes. And I'm very pleased to be here. Thank
▶ Play
you. Charles Blake, District 35 here in Little Rock. I'm sorry, District 36 here in Little Rock. I've never worked for Alltel. That's okay. But I do have AT&T
▶ Play
Speaker 38 7:17
service. There you go. All right. There you go.
▶ Play
Okay. All right. It looks like we've got a quorum now. We're only missing two members. We'll see if they'll file. Just a basic housekeeping. As you all know, that a quorum has to be present for us to start each meeting. And we need six members of this committee to constitute a quorum. We will meet in this room during session, Typically, talking with Representative Sabin Wednesday afternoon seems to be a good day. We've got some flexibility there, so if that becomes an issue, just get with me and we can try to work with that. Let's see. Of course, we're going to leave the tablets in the room. We're going to try to get our committee photograph hopefully taken here in a few minutes. And just a reminder that everybody in here has an alternate, so if you're not able to make a meeting, definitely see if you can find one of the alternates. The purpose of this committee is to look at technology and communications-related issues within the state, and that includes everything from the Department of Information Services. We also work with, of course, Mr. Johnson with the Geographic Information Office, all of our telecommunications broadband providers. Some of the issues we've been looking at, of course, is the Internet access issue. We also look at things with the AWIN system. The AWIN is our statewide interoperability, it's what allows first responders to communicate with each other. There's been some issues with that that we're going to look at. We're also going to look at open data, transparency issues, we're going to look at warehousing data issues. And if all that's great to you, we'll get some experts in to help us with that. Today, we're going to have Ms. Jones who is the Deputy Director of the Department of Information System is going to start by giving us the broadband report. And next week, it is my hope to have the final report of the open data. I'm going to try to get an email copy of that to everybody this week for you to go over, but we'll take a look at that report next week. And then at some point, we'll take a look at the Aowin issue. When we get into the interim, I'd also like to start looking at, as a committee, things related to emergency management in general. For example, there's no committee that's looking at the Department of Emergency Management. Are we as a state prepared to handle emergencies? And obviously one of the key components of that is the technology and the communications involved in making sure all that goes. So anyways, looking forward to working with everybody. And with that, why don't we have, Ms. Jones, if you're ready, have you come to the end of the table, let you reintroduce yourself? Do we need to do the photo? Do you want to go ahead and do the
▶ Play
Speaker 58 10:21
committee photo now? Representative Whitaker will not be here, and Representative Adele Rose will not be
▶ Play
reached. Okay, all right, so if you'll excuse us for a minute, let's go ahead and we'll get the committee photograph out of the way, and then we'll come back to Ms. Jones, I apologize about that. OK, so.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 11:04
Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
All right, now we'll go back to the broadband manager's report. This is a report that we're supposed to get annually. And as soon as you get settled there, if you would please introduce yourself for the committee, and then you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Good afternoon. My name is Jessica Jones, and right now I'm the acting director of the Department of Information Systems. And here with me is, I'll let him introduce himself.
▶ Play
Speaker 62 12:51
I'm Don McDaniel, the division director for Department of Information Systems at the State Network.
▶ Play
Okay, so today I'm going to present to you the broadband manager's report. I'm not going to go in detail on the report. I'm going to give you a background, the reason why we do this report. I'm going to give you some statistics. I'm going to highlight and talk about some of the challenges trying to put together this report. So to kind of give you a background, according to the Arkansas Code and Noted 25-4-125, it was designated that the director for the Arkansas Department of Information Systems to serve as a state broadband manager. to promote, develop, and coordinate broadband expansion for all areas of the state. And as Mr. Chairman mentioned, we're supposed to provide this report on a semi-annual basis to this committee as well as to the Governor's office. So when we talk about broadband, I think it's important for everybody, because I know some of you members are new, to define broadband. So according to the Arkansas definition, Act 947 of 2009, It defines broadband as the means of, it means any service used to provide internet access at a minimum speed of 768 kilobits per second. Now, according to the FCC's definition, it categorizes an internet service as broadband if it transmits at a speed of 25 megabits per second for download and 3 megabits per second for upload. So when we talk about broadband in this report, we're referring to the definition, to the FCC's definition. So we're always going to be talking about the 25 megabits per second download and the 3 megabits per second upload. And also when we talk about broadband, of course, there's different types of broadband. As we know, it could be either DSL, fiber, satellite, Wi-Fi, and different types. But I'll mention if I touch on one on a specific. If you look at on page three, when we talk about what is the state of broadband coverage in Arkansas, we provided a map that it was published by the Arkansas Democrat Gazette. And in this map, you can see it shows where the speed of at least 25 megabits per second is available in this state. And one of the counties, you can see that Pulaski County is one of the counties that has the highest availability for broadband. Some of the counties that you see, they have, if you have a color map, they're color coded white. This just means that they have a lack of the speed of the 25 megabits per second. So they're getting broadband, but they're not getting the least amount of speed. So they might be getting 10 megabits per second. One of the major broadband mapping results that it used to be provided in this report was accomplished by Connect Arkansas. Connect Arkansas was the state's designated grantee that received approximately $6.1 million in general grants. Connect Arkansas supported a number of broadband related initiatives, And including surveys to better understand barriers to broadband adoption. And initiatives to expand broadband adoption in Arkansas. Unfortunately, in 2015, this organization was dissolved due to lack of funding. So one of our challenges is to gather current broadband mapping. So we do not have that available for you. And the most recent mapping that we have, and that's in that report, it comes from 2015. And that was provided by the Arkansas Geographic Information Systems Office. And that report shows coverage by broadband type. In regards to fixed broadband, in January 2016, the FCC released a broadband progress report. And in this report it is stated that 25% of the population in Arkansas do not have access to broadband. Meaning to the speeds of 25 megabits for download and three megabits for upload. So this brings about 745,000 people without access to broadband. This entails to about 298,000 households without access to, again, the 25 megabits per second download and the three megabits per second upload. Out of that, we have approximately 169,000 households without access to the 10 megabit downloads and one megabit upload. So it is estimated that after CAF 2, after the telcos have completed this work, that we will have around 39,000 households without access to the 10 and 1 megabits per second. Regarding the state of broadband adoption in Arkansas, according to the FCC's Broadband Progress Report, The overall adoption rate for fixed broadband in Arkansas, it's about 24%. And they talk about how cost continues to be the number one obstacle for broadband adoption at home. One of the state initiatives that the Department of Information Systems is working along with the Department of Education is the Arkansas Public School Computer Network Broadband Up Rate. So, what we call the app scan. As some of you know, in early 2015, we probably had about 58% of the school districts that were meeting the FCC's internet access target to 100 kilobits per second per student. So it was in early 2015 that Governor Hutchinson made a priority and the Department of Education along with DIS to ensure that the state's K through 12 public schools have sufficient high speed broadband services. So the ultimate goal is for all Arkansas public schools to reach 200 kilobits per second per student of a highly secure, state-funded, high speed broadband connectivity. In July 2015, Fort Smith school district was the first school district that got connected to the upgraded high speed network. And as of today, the number of upgrades that we currently have is 215 out of 279, 76 school districts. Our target completion date is set for July 2017. The project has been a highlight for our department, the progress of it is wonderful. However, we're still dealing with a couple of challenges. Some of the challenges right now is working with individual vendors to release the school districts from existing direct internet access contracts. Some of the school districts have current contracts that will expire either June 30, 2016, or after June 30, 2016. So we are in the process of negotiating to see if they will release those school districts from their current contract. So that's one of the challenges that we're facing, but we are excited about the project. That has put Arkansas as one of the top leaders regarding K through 12 connectivity. And that's good news for our state. If you look on page 12, this is an interactive map that was developed in partnership with the Arkansas Geographic Information Systems Office. And this map pretty much keeps track of the progress of this project. So I invite everybody to get that link and put it in one of your browsers. And you can see the schools or the districts that have been upgraded, that have been installed, or they're being scheduled or have been ordered. So this is a really good map. And like I said, I invite everybody to just go look at that link whenever you get some free time. Another initiative that the Department of Information Systems is currently working on is the Dark Fiber Transport Services. So back in November 2016, DIS issued an invitation for bid for Dark Fiber Transport Services. The deployment of this Dark Fiber is going to create a high speed optical network, which is going to accommodate speeds of 1040 and 100 gigabit Ethernet. So the main goal is to create two fiber rings connecting the state's two data centers and other state buildings having a need for greater bandwidth. Appendix 5 has got more information on this particular initiative. Another initiative that I know this committee has been working on is on the border-to-border broadband. It's my understanding that this committee has been working on a plan to connect every home and business to high-speed broadband. So our department is really looking forward to the final report and see what solutions or recommendations come out of that. Those are some of the highlights of the report. I don't know if you guys have any questions. We'll be happy
▶ Play
to answer if there's any. Okay, so in summary, as Ms. Jones stated, we definitely have some challenges. There are actually still people in Arkansas that are using dial up. But on a positive note, thanks to the governor's leadership and especially with the coding and what DIS has done, by this summer, Arkansas will be one of the top states in the nation as far as broadband access to the public schools. So that's definitely an area to be proud of. The CAF funds that she referred to, if you're not familiar with that, that's part of the Connect in America Fund. And over the next five years, the federal government is going to be investing, unless the Trump administration changes it, close to a billion dollars in Arkansas in broadband infrastructure. So with that in mind, Representative Brown, you had a
▶ Play
Speaker 76 24:00
question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. And you may have just answered the question, but I didn't fully understand everything. So this broadband build-out, right now we're looking at the public schools, and is the state financing the extension of the broadband lines to these schools? Well, yes. The
▶ Play
Speaker 62 24:25
Department of Education is using their existing budget money. The increase in bandwidth per student has gone by a factor of 40. It was five kilobits per student, and now we're up to 200 kilobits per user, and it's the same money. Fiber deployment, there's more fiber out there than there has been in the past. Vendors have placed that. They're also placing fiber to get to some of these schools, but we got really good pricing from vendors. They stepped up, and the Department of Education is not having to spend any more money to go from 5 kilobits to 200,
▶ Play
Speaker 76 25:09
a factor of 40. Thank you. Follow up? And when we're talking about access to broadband, and we want it available for every business and every home, is that being I'm just trying to understand we're not being critical I just want to know who's paying for what and so currently let's say one of the local vendors that we might have here in Little Rock they might build out to a more rural community if they have enough customers and they don't build out if they don't have enough customers or are we dependent upon this federal money for that build-out? I'm just trying to get a concept of how the system's going to be paid for, and I would really like for everybody to have access, but where's the
▶ Play
Speaker 62 26:02
money coming from? Well, the vendors, and there are a number of them here today, have to make a business case for it. So it's revenue and expense. And there's capital, of course, in there too. But they've got to make that work, so it's a combination of the CAF funds and having enough potential business, take rate, if you will, to make it work for them.
▶ Play
Thank you. And that's one of the challenges that we're looking at. I think Representative Sabin said that this is essentially our version of the electrification issue of the last century, where how do you make that business case to get out to these rural areas, and that's the challenge. and I have been to conferences all over the nation and I have talked to leaders similar to them in other states and this is an issue that every state is facing and no one has a real good answer for that yet. Any other questions from the committee? Seeing none, thank you and thank you for the work that you all have done and we look forward to continue working with you in the future. Thank you. Okay. At this time, I'm going to ask Mr. Carlock if he would come to the table. He is on the Bureau of Legislative Research, so he works for us in essence. And I'll kind of let him get into this in a little more detail. But on your desk, you should have this digital proposal. Every few years, we upgrade the technology in the house. You know, we all have laptops and so forth. Well, the time has come for us to start looking at doing that again. And the goal is instead of buying 100 different pieces of equipment for all the members and then finding out that something doesn't work, we get to be the guinea pig. So they want to start with us and let us find what works before we expand out to everybody. And I may have just stole your presentation, but Mr. Carlock, if you would. But please introduce yourself and kind of talk to us a little bit
▶ Play
Speaker 86 28:10
about what we're thinking. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and committee. Again, I'm Tim Carlock, Assistant Director for Information Technology with the Bureau of Legislative Research. I have a 20-year-plus background in information technology. I also started in 1994 for Alltel Information Systems Banking, Systematics, actually. Um, and I was, uh, uh, we coded in C back then. I'm a software developer, um, but I specialized in general ledger accounting systems, uh, for about 10 years. And then I had a, a nine year run with the legislative audit, the sister agency of the Bureau of Legislative Research. And again, we did, uh, I did more, uh, auditing and general ledger type work with the accounting and auditing systems. and then I came to the Bureau with a software background and then took over for the previous assistant director. That's kind of my quick background. And as the chairman said, we have an option now. We're on a four-year rotation to refresh our hardware, and we thought it would be a good idea to try and create a process that allows the committee to have some input and maybe prove certain ideas as far as moving forward and how we want to, and I just want to be able to help the committee and give them guidelines or answer any questions or bring in any experts that I need that the committee requests to try and help you guys make that assessment. Just a quick review, the House currently has two stacks. We have the members each work on an XPS 13 Dell. We've been very happy with the equipment. It's been very durable, highly stable, as well as the tablets that are owned at the committee layer. Also, this particular IRIS system, good or bad, we've written this in-house. This is an in-house technology. Most of our technologies are in-house. With our staff, we have several software developers and network engineers that work on-site to help us um provide the services that you you
▶ Play
require and for the committee members iris is the um bill that allows us to look at the bill so just make sure everyone and um
▶ Play
Speaker 86 30:36
so i'm i'm gonna um again i'll be happy to answer questions but the the main idea i'm also trying to hopefully by the next meeting have a dale representative here the account exec uh that i work with generally for purchasing equipment and i'm hoping he'll have a demonstration for the new equipment again there's tablets hybrid tablets laptops um you don't see desktops very much anymore but all of this equipment well and also just the uh your your phones are so and so the smartphones that you have are so powerful now that even they may be down the road that we may need to determine if maybe those phones are adequate to run all the systems um that you're used to so that's really It's really kind of going to be an open process where we just kind of go where your questions take us. I did have a couple of points I wanted to go over with the highlights. In the handout, you can kind of see the cost of what the general hardware costs. And so you can imagine every four years on the rotation, it's, you know, 100. In fact, we actually just deployed 125 of the tablets. They're brand new for this session. So that stack will still exist for the next four years if we want to keep that the same. But there are technologies that I want you to be aware of because, again, we have an option where we could have a tablet for each member, and based on their context of where they are in the building, we have a wireless network essentially that covers the entire campus from the Big Mac building to the Capitol on multiple floors, and then behind me on the north side of the Capitol apartments. I'm sure you guys are all familiar with that access, but that being said, the same way that IRIS runs the advanced communications committee for this meeting, if you were in the afternoon, if you took your member-granted piece of hardware into the house chamber for the afternoon, you would then also have the calendar show up through that system as well. The idea is to try and give you all the information within a context that makes sense to the end user. And again, I'm also interested personally because I want to be able to support you guys year in and year out and make sure we're constantly proving the technology is available. I'm also interested in hearing on your productivity habits, how you use your equipment and what's viable. Again, if we're all using phones and not really doing a lot of uh, using the laptop so much that maybe may help us make some decisions down the, down the road. Um, just a couple of topics for discussion. The Senate uses iPads, um, and that's a platform that they want to use. It's generally difficult. Um, again, we don't, we, we want to support that. There are some gaps, um, and I can go into more details if that becomes of an, if that particular their brand is an interest, but generally they don't work in a way that I'm familiar with as far as enterprise support. And they're a great company, obviously, great products, but as far as enterprise, if I have problems with the XPS and I call Dell, they give me another XPS right off the fly while they try and work on the problem as opposed to taking it away, and then that person is absent of their gear. It just seems they'll be, they're about to get into that market. I know they have a business process that's already up and running, but they're competing against the Microsofts, the IBMs. You know, IBM especially, again, going back to my early days with mainframes and systematics, IBM's been an enterprise solution provider for decades, maybe almost a century. So that's kind of where I'm at. But again, I'm not, I'm kind of agnostic on brands. I'm not going to give you an opinion one way or the other on that, but I can give you technical ideas of what I prefer to deploy on. Again, I kind of talked about the IRIS integration, and in my notes I mentioned a passkey model. Again, if we want to look into that for further discussion, remember if you forgot your passkey, I don't know how productive you might be during the day. So, again, that may be the counter to keeping the tablets in the rooms, and that way at least if you show up, you have everything you need to be productive in your committee meeting. Also, further down the road, I'd be very open to whatever tools you guys are interested in using, things that we're not directly providing, but it ends up, I mean, there's new applications that people give to you to carry on your business, And the more I know about that, probably the better to be able to help. And the last point, something to consider, and it may not be a high priority for us at the moment, but it is something we worked on when I was with legislative audit. But that deals with if you have a device, do we want to include deep encryption? Do we want to add those services? Do we want a mobile? They have technologies where we can, if you lose your laptop, they can find it using GPS and all that kind of stuff. It costs, but, again, if that becomes a priority. I know data, just with the working papers and the confidentiality of emails and all that, I deal with that on a regular basis with all the members. And, again, so I just want to make sure that's something you guys can consider as well when you're choosing what type of hardware we're going to deploy on. So any of those concerns, I'm open to, again, bringing more people to the table and trying to, you know, basically create an educational part of the process. But that's kind of my overview of the process, and I'm happy to take any questions. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
And, you know, like he was saying, we go into the House chamber, and there's 100 pieces of paper in there for our calendars and all that every day. If we could get rid of that, that would save a lot of staff time. It would save a lot of paper. And for those of you that have been in the budget room, you all know, I mean, there's a lot of paper. So if we implement the technology right, we could actually increase a lot of efficiencies here at our level of government. So does anybody have any
▶ Play
questions, Mr. Carlock? Thank you, Mr. Chair. I've actually been looking forward to this discussion for quite some time. I've been here four years now, and I think I've turned on that Dell computer five times. It's absolutely worthless to me. And I think that's the case with a good number of the members. I mean, I have a MacBook Pro that I use for most things. And, you know, this session, these new pads in the committee rooms, I want to commend you on getting something that works this time. Because they haven't worked for the last four years that I've been here. I don't know if they worked before that or not. But ArcLague is what I live and die by as far as getting information, calendar events. The only thing that our colleague doesn't do is update amendments to the pad in committee. And quite frankly, if we're having an amendment to a bill, oftentimes I'll ask for it in paper form, because I could never get these things to work before. I'm fairly technology savvy. Everything else I use on my phone or this, and now that the screens on these Apple iPhones are large enough to read off of, I don't carry my iPad anymore. Now, I mean, obviously I'm a Mac user and I love the Mac technology. So the touchscreen on an iPad, I've been envious of the Senate for several years because they have technology that works. And we don't on the house end. So it's been kind of frustrating. But all that being said, and I don't know as far as a platform, you know, if it's a touchscreen-type platform that you could use as far as individual member devices, maybe a Surface Pro or something like that that has a keypad that you can make notes and do different things like that on. But, you know, the connectivity, the Internet connectivity to get to ArcLeg, and I'm sure this, it's called IRIS is the program? Yes, sir. I just, it's not been my, I've not been a fan of it. And I hope I'm not hurting anybody's feelings if you wrote it. but it's just from a technology standpoint, ArcLeg is a lot more intuitive. And whoever wrote that has done a really good job at keeping that updated. And I don't know if there's a question in there, but that's
▶ Play
Speaker 82 40:13
my two cents, so would you agree? So thank you. Thank you, sir. Yes, I'm fine with the
▶ Play
Speaker 86 40:20
discussion, so you don't need to throw a question on there. Absolutely. I absolutely appreciate the comments. You're not hurting my feelings. And make you aware, so we haven't refreshed this stack, mainly because we were aware that the XPS stat, because we were mainly aware that a lot of users either brought their own equipment in and were happily, and again, they're reading bills off of ArcLeg, and that's terrific. So that is also an option I want you to make. We're perfectly comfortable by not refreshing a stack of hardware if you guys recommend not doing that. And that's kind of where we're at right now, which means that as these start to die, most of their warranties are done. But as they start to die, the idea was to just, they would just fade away and we wouldn't replace them. So that is, again, that's also an option. We don't have to purchase new equipment, but we can. On the Iris, there are, absolutely, the only thing I would say about the last rollout, we had one stack on your first four years of frustration were, I believe at the time we ordered the first stack of these. Dell's, they were one of the first tablets that had a touch pad that also ran a full operating system. And that was, and so they weren't really ready for prime time, but it was kind of one of those things where we bought, the technology hadn't caught up. Four years later, these are much nicer. I completely agree. They're Windows 10, more RAM, and everything seems to just be running better. The touch and everything, no pins. I mean, they've just put out a better product. So that's kind of my only piece on that. And then absolutely, we're definitely opening, we definitely want to make the IRIS system better and always want to create enhancements. There are certain models within the system that I, just so you guys are aware, the ArcLeg website actually is the single source for all of our information. And this IRIS system actually pulls from that same system. It does not recreate anything. And then amendments, there is a way to get the amendments to reveal themselves during the committee. If they're not, once they're made public, the analysts can, as long as those amendments are available in digital format, which they are, I think they actually are. But that's definitely something we can look back to and make sure that that's working properly. But the goal was that they could reveal amendments in committee on the fly. I did write the piece. These devices are all actually sitting in a chat room. If you notice, they're all green or orange or whatever. Green means they're all chatting together. That's kind of the technology we can do in-house. And, again, as problems or issues present themselves, we would try and engineer a solution for that, basically. But, absolutely, the more criticism we get, the better opportunity we have to make those enhancements. down the road, so thank you for your comments. If I may
▶ Play
follow up, I don't know if anybody else is in line. I'll get back in line if somebody else is. I'll defer and come back. Okay, thank you,
▶ Play
Speaker 76 43:51
sir. Representative Brown. Thank you, Representative Meeks. I heard the discussion, and I just have some comments. I guess I'm kind of geeky. I like to keep up with technology. I finally gave up on my old laptop. and I bought a new HP Notebook with Windows 10. I was afraid my other one was going to die and take all my stuff with it, so I thought I'd better upgrade. But I also have the MacBook Air, the iPad, and the iPhone. I love Mac, but I do understand for enterprise work, the IBM DOS type, I don't know if DOS is still back there, but the DOS platform has been easier for enterprise work. I have to say that doing number crunching with Excel is something I'm much more comfortable with than on the Mac. So I have put Excel on my Mac, but it didn't work just like on my laptop. And I like Word for editing. One thing, and those are just my preferences, because I'm generally fairly skilled in those two. One thing I would like to be able to do is when I get a bill, I would like to be able, PDF or whatever, to be able to make notations in the document while I'm reading it rather than having to print it out and make my notes in the margins because my handwriting is not fast and it's not very legible anymore. Use the keyboard too long. Um, I would like to be able to make notations directly on the bill so that when I'm in committee or whatever, I've got my, my questions right there. Um, maybe on my, maybe not on this, but on whatever other device I have with me, um, that would be very helpful or, or even, you know, to send feedback to BLR about things I would like to change.
▶ Play
Speaker 86 46:03
Thank you. Thank you. Absolutely, I will research that. The way we make notes across the street with PDF is we have a license for each member that can do those properties through Adobe Acrobat. I think it's about $120 a license per user. So that's probably the thing I'll look at first. but I also I thought there was a way through the Adobe reader to make basic notations but I'll I will definitely make that thank you and there may be thank
▶ Play
Speaker 76 46:39
you yep thanks and as I recall y'all are
▶ Play
I think one of the ways the technologies are going y'all are working on apps for the phones and for the tablets that are specific to the arc leg
▶ Play
Speaker 86 46:54
is that yes sir we're we're actually rolling out. We also have a lot of in-house applications that do all the bill drafting and all the editing, um, and maintain all the, uh, uh, uh, now not authentication, but, uh, validation of the, of the actual bills. It goes through a very rigorous process versioning. Um, and all of that is now being built on a C sharp language with a SQL backend and we're creating a new client that's already sitting there and it'll be, we'll be upgrading to Windows 2000 or Office 2013 with Windows 10 on all devices this summer. That's the goal. Um, and the other thing I would point out, we're, we're actually in a good place as far as our base technology. We're on what we're on a 2012 R2 base domain controller, which it's 2017. So not too bad. Um, and the only reason I bring that up is that I want to make sure that we're flexible enough and have enough options and opportunities as technologies are delivered and become popular. I don't want to have to say no. So we're not running a 30-year-old mainframe or anything in our shop. We're all brand new. Everything is brand new. All the languages I use are what programmer I can find the people to program because that's the languages that most of them know and are comfortable with. So I'm trying to use, I'm trying to make sure that we don't get caught in a situation where we have some type of legacy system that isn't supported because I can't either find the resources, the talent, or the architects to help me figure that out. So we're, at least, that's one thing I wanted to make
▶ Play
that we're in a good place. And just from the discussion here in the committee, it sounds like, you know, There's different preferences, and so how hard would it be instead of getting 100 one size fits all pieces of technology? How hard would it be to say, come up with an option of two or three different things and then let the members choose? Is that possible or does that add complexity or is that?
▶ Play
Speaker 86 49:01
It definitely adds complexity, but if you stay within the same operating system stack, it's very much minimized. And, again, to Representative Dodson's point, a lot of the reading, you know, we generally expect people to bring their own device, and it could be an iPhone 7 or an Android or a whatever phone, to actually read the bills off of the website. So as long as we're talking about browsing only, it's really not a concern. But any time you take it one step further where you want to actually have a business solution involved, integrated into the process, in other words, an in-house system or something we purchase, it immediately changes based on what your core stack is. Okay. All right. Representative
▶ Play
Donson, do you? Thank you, Mr. Chair. You know, and I get the business enterprise and the ability for business enterprise stuff. However, at least in my experience so far in the legislative processes, for the most part, 99.9% of everything we do is what can be web-based. And so whatever the platform is that someone has a preference, if it's Mac or it's Windows-based, I think more than likely, since the ArcLeg is able to be interchangeable that way, The only challenge that I've had when using my Apple devices is attachment to emails that I get from BLR or from house staff. They don't come through unless I log in directly into the website with my mail client on my devices. So that is a challenge. I would imagine if we went to any sort of Apple device, I'm not sure what the security is or what holds that, But the WINDAT files that come up as attachments are kind of a headache. Absolutely. So that is one challenge. If I can make some suggestions as you're thinking about these things. I mean, I don't think the Senate have these in their committee rooms. There's no committee devices. And I'm not entirely certain that we need committee devices if every member has a device assigned to them already. But that's a duplication of devices, one of which, like I said, is most likely never used, especially if they have a personal preference on a different time. So I think there's a cost savings potential there, especially if we can get a kind of a universal device, like a tablet that has a keyboard or something attached that can fit both users' function. It just has to be a snappy enough screen that you don't get frustrated like the old ones. But the other thing that I would suggest is possibly having some sort of a printer in room. That if someone wants a paper form of their bill to go down and present at the bottom of the table or whatever it happens to be, sit here and mark it up. I mean, to Representative Brown's point, one of the frustrating things about having an all digital medium is not being able to take notes and I have a process, so I oftentimes will request that I have a printout of various bills or bring a printout with me, even though I'm a technology geek when having devices. Having a printer in a room to be able to print something off quickly or even share and make markups and hand it around to somebody, that would be very beneficial, I think. Um, especially if somebody happened to forget their device, if we go to
▶ Play
Speaker 76 53:00
a single device. Representative Brown? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Um, one other thing, um, even though I like the, uh, Microsoft products, I don't know that we really, uh, I don't know how many of my colleagues do a tremendous amount of number crunching and texting, uh, text, uh, developing, uh, on for their jobs as legislators. Um, you know, I really don't think that that's a big priority. That's my personal opinion. I think whatever little number crunching we can do, we, we don't need a full blown system for that. Maybe a tablet
▶ Play
Speaker 63 53:35
or a notebook would be sufficient. Actually, to that point,
▶ Play
I use open office for a lot of my stuff, and of course, that's, you know, free, open source. Does anybody else have any other questions or discussion on this? Okay, seeing none. So kind of think about that over the next week, and then we'll have Mr. Carlock. We'll try to put him on the schedule for next week and maybe look at some of the new options that we might have available as a committee and kind of figure out how we might want to go forward with that. Okay? Thank you, sir. We appreciate you. I appreciate it. Thank you all so much. All right. And.
▶ Play

Agenda

A. Call to Order

B. Opening Remarks 1. Representative Stephen Meeks, Chair 2. Representative Warwick Sabin, Vice Chair

PRESENTATION

Arkansas Broadband Manager’s Report, Department of Information Systems, Yessica Jones, Deputy Director

12:38 - 54:10 100 segments 8 speakers

REGULAR AGENDA Subtitle Sponsor Number

HB1364 K. Hendren TO ESTABLISH THE PUBLIC POLICY OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS ON THE USE OF ELECTRONIC DEVICES.

HB1410 S. Meeks TO AMEND THE TELECOMMUNICATIONS REGULATORY REFORM ACT OF 2013; AND TO PROHIBIT A TELECOMMUNICATIONS PROVIDER FROM RESTRICTING RESIDENTIAL INTERNET DATA USAGE.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
29 segments
Representative Warwick Sabin Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 8
1 segment
Speaker 10
1 segment
Speaker 16
2 segments
Speaker 18
2 segments
Speaker 19
1 segment
Speaker 21
2 segments
Speaker 25
2 segments
Speaker 26
1 segment
Speaker 28
1 segment
Speaker 29
1 segment
Speaker 30
1 segment
Speaker 31
2 segments
Speaker 33
1 segment
Speaker 34
1 segment
Speaker 38
2 segments
Speaker 37
1 segment
Representative Frances Cavenaugh Unverified
1 segment
Representative Austin McCollum Unverified
1 segment
Representative Andy Mayberry Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 44
1 segment
Speaker 76
15 segments
Speaker 41
1 segment
Representative Charles Blake Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 58
1 segment
Jessica Jones Unverified
20 segments
Speaker 62
4 segments
Speaker 86
32 segments
Representative Jim Dotson Unverified
15 segments
Speaker 82
1 segment
Speaker 63
1 segment