Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Judiciary Committee

February 2, 2017 ·Committee Room 149 ·2:05:03
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (40)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1041 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1041 B. Smith TO PROTECT THE RIGHTS AND PRIVILEGES GRANTED UNDER…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1006 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1006 Tucker TO AMEND CERTAIN CRIMINAL OFFENSES CONCERNING ABUSES…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1007 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1007 Tucker TO PROTECT CITIZENS WHO ARE VICTIMS OF JUDICIAL ETHI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1045 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1045 B. Smith CONCERNING CRIMINAL VICTIM NOTIFICATION; AND CONCE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1055 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1055 Hammer TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "MARITAL PROPERTY" FOR PU…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1095 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1095 A Johnson CONCERNING THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A CONCEALED HANDG…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1152 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1152 Watson CONCERNING THE ABILITY OF AN AUXILIARY LAW ENFORCEME…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1158 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1158 Petty CONCERNING THE ENTRY UNDER CAUSE OF THE DEATH ON A PE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1173 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1173 Tucker TO AMEND AND MAKE CONSISTENT THE OFFENSES OF SEXUAL…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1175 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1175 TuckeR TO REQUIRE LIFETIME REGISTRATION ON THE ARKANSAS SEX…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1177 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1177 Tucker INCREASING THE AVAILABLE SENTENCES FOR CERTAIN SEX O…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1197 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1197 Sturch TO ESTABLISH A METHOD FOR A PERSON WHO WAS FALSELY A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1236 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1236 Gazaway TO PROTECT THE PRIVACY OF SURVIVING AMILY MEMBERS O…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1248 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1248 J. Williams TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION UNDER THE FREEDOM OF INF…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1251 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1251 Walker TO CREATE THE "HELPING OUR PEOPLE EXCEL (H.O.P.E.) A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1260 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1260 Maddox TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING REIMBURSEMENT FOR JUROR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1265 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1265 Richey OF CARRYING A OR CONCEALED AND CONCERNING POSSESSION…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1268 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1268 Murdock CONCERNING THE USE OF AN IGNITION INTERLOCK DEVICE.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1299 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1299 Brown CREATING THE OFFENSE OF POSSESSION OF A HANDGUN WHILE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1354 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1354 Nicks CONCERNING DISTRICT COURT CLERK EMPLOYMENT”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1355 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1355 Shepherd TO MAKE TO TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 24 OF TH…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1356 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1356 Shepherd TO MAKE TO TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE CODE 7 O…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1357 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1357 Shepherd TO MAKE LEGISLATIVE CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 3 OF THE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1358 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1358 ShepherD TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 22 OF THE A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1359 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1359 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 21 OF THE A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1360 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1360 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 9 OF THE AR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1361 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1361 Speaks TO AMEND THE GROUNDS FOR DIVORCE OR SEPARATION UNDER…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1362 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1362 Payton CONCERNING THE RIGHTS OF A CONCEALED HANDGUN LICENSE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1367 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1367 Watson CONCERNING AN AUXILIARY LAW ENFORCEMENT OR A RETIRED…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1375 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1375 Tucker TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE FILING REQUIREMENTS…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1382 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1382 Gazaway TO ESTABLISH PROCEDURES TO BE FOLLOWED AFTER A CLAI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1385 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1385 Lemons TO BE KNOWN AS "SHANNON'S LAW"; AND CONCERNING THE P…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1415 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1415 Shepherd 6 TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 6 OF THE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1416 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1416 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 17 OF THE A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1417 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1417 Sturch CONCERNING THE OFENSE OF SEXUAL SOLICITATION; PROVID…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1420 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1420 C. Fite TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS DOMESTIC VIOLENCE SHELTER AC…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1422 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1422 ShepherD TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO THE TITLE 12 OF T…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1423 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1423 CORRECTIONS TECHNICAL 12 TO Shepherd MAKE TO TITLE ARKANSAS…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB102 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB102 Rice TO CLARIFY THE LAW CONCERNING THE FINES, FEES, AND COS…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB24 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB24 B. Johnson CONCERNING CRIMINAL DETENTION FACILITY REVIEW CO…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
will come to order. The chairman sees a quorum. First item on our agenda is a special order on House Bill 1041. Representative Smith, you're recognized to present House Bill 1041.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Thank you, committee members. Today I'll be running House Bill 1041 in reference to American laws for American courts or as it's also become known as Arkansas Laws for Arkansas Courts. Basically, it is an act to protect the rights and privileges granted under the Arkansas Constitution and the United States Constitution to declare American laws for American courts. Today, I also have with me Colonel Deckert, an attorney, and I'll let him introduce himself and then we'll jump in and begin to explain what this law is about. Thank you. Colonel Deckard. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 11 1:34
you, Representative Smith. Mr. Chairman, ladies and gentlemen, I hope everybody can hear me and pardon me in advance because I seem to have picked up some little bug along the way. I'm usually not this FM DJ sounding. my name is paul deckard i am a retired colonel in the marine corps i do represent the center for security policy and if it's all right with you i'm going to read a brief prepared statement at which point in time under the guidance of representative smith i'll answer any questions you have to the best of my ability why american and arkansas laws for america for american and arkansas courts Some 235 years ago, America's forefathers gathered in Philadelphia to debate and write a unique document. That single-page document announced the formation of a new country, one that would no longer find itself in the clutches of a foreign power. That document was the Declaration of Independence. Eleven years later, many of those same men gathered again to lay the foundation for how the United States of America was to be governed. The U.S. Constitution, a form of government like no other, by the people, of the people, and for the people. For more than two centuries, hundreds of thousands of courageous men and women have given their lives to protect America's sovereignty and freedom. America's constitutional rights must be preserved in order to preserve unique American values of liberty and freedom. State legislatures have a role to play in preserving constitutional rights and American values of liberty and freedom. If states did not have such a role to play, why then do states have constitutions which often mirror, echo, and reinforce the U.S. Constitution? America has unique values of liberty, which do not exist in many foreign legal systems, including among, but not limited to, those values are the rights are freedom of religion, freedom of speech, freedom of the press, due process, right to privacy, right to keep and bear arms. Civil and criminal laws serve as the bedrock for American values. We are a nation of laws. Unfortunately, increasingly, foreign laws and legal doctrines are finding their way into U.S. cases. Invoking foreign laws and foreign legal doctrines, especially in family law cases, is a means of imposing an agenda on the American people while circumventing the U.S. and state constitutions by using foreign laws which do not recognize our constitutional rights and liberties in U.S. courts. The potential impact of using foreign and international laws and legal doctrines in U.S. courts on the liberty of ordinary American citizens are as profound as they are despairing. The embrace of foreign legal systems, some of which are inherently hostile to our constitutional liberties, is a violation of the principles on which our nation was founded. The founders of our nation believe that the United States of America and its individual states should never be subservient to any foreign power, country, or legal system, and that no foreign power, country, or legal system should be allowed to encroach upon our rights under the Constitution. The purpose of American and Arkansas laws for Arkansas courts is to preserve the sovereignty of the U.S. and Arkansas and their respective constitutions by preventing the encroachment of foreign laws and legal systems that run counter to our individual constitutional liberties and freedom. By passing American and Arkansas laws for Arkansas courts, we will be preserving individual liberties and freedoms which become eroded by the encroachment of foreign laws and foreign legal doctrines. It is imperative that we safeguard our Constitution's fundamentals, particularly the individual guarantees in the Bill of Rights, the sovereignty of our nation and its people, and the principles of the rule of law, American and Arkansas laws, not foreign laws. It is very important to note that virtually identical legislation has passed in Tennessee, Louisiana, Arizona, Kansas, Mississippi, Alabama, Oklahoma, North Carolina, and Washington. And that there has been no impact on business, commerce, or international relations in any of these states of any kind. Additionally, I think that it should be brought to everyone's attention, Not that you're not already inherently aware of it, but the international trade that stems out of Tennessee via air, out of the Memphis airport, Louisiana, out of the ports of southern Louisiana, whether it be break bulk cargo or energy products, oil, natural gas, coal that comes down from the upper Mississippi Valley. Mississippi and Alabama, both of whom just opened additional international automobile production plants with Japanese and European car companies, and the same with North Carolina that just added an additional European car company there. Many of the concerns that stem from the idea of trade restrictions are directly limited in this bill because the bill clearly states, line 27 beginning with letter E, that non-natural persons are not affected. There are a lot of things that
▶ Play
we could talk about, ladies and gentlemen. My time is yours. I would like to add another brief statement before we take questions from the committee. There's been some opposition, a lot of opposition, and some of these folks are here today. I've met with many of these opposition leaders and constituents and explained maybe a different view of how this bill actually benefits everyone. After having spent, I added it up, I probably spent 25, 26 years overseas, not as a tourist, but living and working, taking on residency status, being there on work permits and visas in my career. I totally came under Chinese law, Taiwanese law, the laws of the country of Thailand and Burma. I worked quite often in the country of Laos and came under their laws as well. Following all of that work in the East, I was sent to Iraq in 2005. and then after a month of traveling the country and as a potential countrywide leader or chief of party for an NGO, I was exposed to everything that the Iraqi people dealt with in their daily lives. In early 2006, I returned to Iraq with two suitcases flying into Baghdad International airport, and for those of you who are military, you know the typical name for that airport is Bayop. I arrived there with my wife and a 12-year-old daughter, and we lived on the economy for two years, unsupported by the U.S. government or U.S. military forces in Iraq. Everything that we experienced as a foreign family in a war zone in Iraq was the same thing that my Iraqi neighbors experienced, a country that was wrecked by war, multiple 30 years of war. And one of the things that this bill will do is as immigrants and even refugees come back, leave their country and arrive here at some point in the future, this bill will protect them. Because when they set foot on American soil, they literally will be protected by the same laws that protect me and my family and you and your family, all the rights and privileges of our U.S. Constitution and the Constitution of the state of Arkansas. And so while many folks tend to focus on the negative, I prefer to focus on the positives and say, this is a good law, and that's why I'm presenting it today. And with the chairman's permission, I'd like to entertain questions. Thank you,
▶ Play
Representative Smith. I have a couple questions, and then we also have some committee members with some questions. And I believe, as to my two questions, I believe the colonel touched on these, but I just want to make sure that I have these clear in my notes. With regard to other states that have adopted similar legislation, could you restate what states those are? Yeah, certainly.
▶ Play
Speaker 11 11:22
The downside of being organized is sometimes you get overly organized and then you forget which page you're on. Once again, those states are Louisiana, Tennessee, Arizona, Kansas, Oklahoma, Washington, Florida, North Carolina, and Alabama.
▶ Play
And then my follow-up to that is... I'm sorry, in Mississippi. Okay, and my follow-up to that is when did these states adopt similar legislation? Is it this year, last year, or has it
▶ Play
Speaker 11 12:14
been in effect for a number of years? I believe I have dates for everybody. I've got 2010 for Louisiana and Tennessee, 2011 for Arizona, 2012 for Kansas, 2013 for Oklahoma, 2013 also for Washington, 2014 for Florida, 2014 also for North Carolina and Alabama, 2015 for Mississippi. All
▶ Play
right. And then my final question, and this is a question that I've discussed with Representative Smith, I think on occasion, of particular concern to me is that we do have corporations and other entities that are headquartered and do business here in the state of Arkansas, many of which are international corporations or entities doing business around the world. And I believe you touched on this, but my concern is oftentimes when it comes to the contracts that these entities enter into, they agree to the choice of law being a foreign country. And so my question is, again, what specifically is in this bill to make sure that there's not an unreasonable restriction on the ability of businesses to transact business internationally?
▶ Play
Speaker 11 13:49
Yes, sir, Mr. Chairman, and that's often a concern. So specifically, I am making sure I quote this directly to everybody who's got a copy of the bill in front of them. So page 4 of your bill, at line 27, letter E, I will read, Without prejudice to any legal right, this section does not apply to a corporation, partnership, limited liability corporation, business association, or other legal entity that contracts to subject itself to a foreign law, legal code, or system. I think that should be about as clear as
▶ Play
we can get. Thank you. Representative Charlene
▶ Play
Fite, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Either of you. You mentioned specifically that this is needed because of some family law cases. Would you mind giving a brief example of some
▶ Play
of those? I'll start, and then perhaps the colonel can bring more clarity to that. In the past, we've had individuals from other countries come here and because of their status for one reason or another and just for purely falling in love, they have married American women, had children, and then for some reason or another because of a dispute, maybe there was an issue where instead of taking it through the courts, They would just basically leave the country with a child or children, leaving no recourse for the family member left behind. And so once they're out of the country, there's no recourse. And many of these women in our nation have lost any contact with their small children, as well as the grandparents, who wanted to be a part of that grandchild's life. But because of foreign law, they had no recourse, no court to hear their case, no one to advocate for them because they were out of our jurisdiction. Is there more that you?
▶ Play
Speaker 11 16:09
There are a number of instances that have happened around the country. I am not immediately aware of a specific case in Arkansas. there are a number of cases that have come out of maryland there are a number of cases i'm looking at five or so that came out of ohio there have been a number of cases that have come out of minnesota there have been a handful of cases that have come out of florida but as far as specifically a case coming out of arkansas i'm not aware of one which goes to the concept of, for those on the committee who paid any attention to military sciences, the concept of what's called left of bang. Once an incident happens, you're right of bang. You're in cleanup mode. You're reacting. When you've got states that surround you, these issues have happened in Tennessee. These issues have happened in Ohio. These issues have happened in Missouri. states that surround you have had issues of foreign law intruding particularly in the area of family law whether it be arranged marriages where a minor child was not given an opportunity to exercise their rights because of something that was imposed on them whether it's mother's loss of a child as in the example that the representative representative Smith pointed out whether it's mother's loss of access to a child and an inability to retrieve that child, or whether a court, because it was overwhelmed, and I'm sure that while all courts and judges do their best, I do not know of a single court in this country that is so overstaffed that they are leisurely able to review everything with the degree of rigor they would care to. They've become placed in situations where they've got a foreign judgment that comes before them and a reasonable presentation is made and they often acquiesce. They do so because there has been no clear expression of the will of the people by the people's legislature, the ones who actually make the law. By clearly establishing a path for judges to clearly hang their hat on, A lot of these issues could be resolved because there is no reaching into the fringes. By doing this before you have a series of crises in the state of Arkansas, you are acting left of bang. You are acting before the problem, and you're clearly expressing the will of the legislature, in other words, the will of the people of Arkansas, as to how courts should act. I hope that answers the question. Well,
▶ Play
there is one case in the state of Arkansas that I'm aware of. It happened several years ago out of Jonesboro, Arkansas, with a faculty member at Arkansas State University. There was a dispute, a family dispute. I believe it was over a separation or a divorce case. And the husband decided he was not going to prevail and took the child and left to return to his original country of origin during the court proceeding. And so this left the constituent up in Jonesboro, Arkansas, without any recourse. And there's no follow-up because we don't have an opportunity to chase down one of the parents who does flee the United States. And so I was told that this individual, Senator Cooper, brought this to my attention in 2015. She hasn't seen her daughter in probably a decade and more than likely never will. And so we're trying to establish some groundwork here to prevent future problems, future legal issues such as that.
▶ Play
representative tucker you're recognized for a question thank you mr chair thank you for being here colonel and thank you for your service to our country i just want to follow up on these examples that representative fight race and that you've discussed representative smith because i'm a little confused i think about what the purpose of the law is and its application my understanding of the law is that with the examples you've described, if those people, and those are horrific situations that I would not wish upon anybody, but if they're no longer in the jurisdiction of Arkansas, the United States, then I don't see anything in this bill that helps that situation. What I understand the purpose of the bill to be is that if you have people here in the United States and you're in court and you're trying to resolve a dispute, we're trying to direct the court which law to rely upon in order to resolve that dispute. And so I guess I want to make sure I understand that correctly. And if I don't, please help me understand. But so I guess I would follow up on Representative Fite's question to ask, are you aware of any examples in the United States, in Arkansas in particular, but in the United States where a court has relied upon some non-American law and in the course of that reliance has abridged one of these rights outlined in the bill that we, that the bill is seeking
▶ Play
Speaker 11 21:41
to protect. And regrettably, pardon me, because I'm on a whole bunch of cold medicine right now. Uh, I'm not remembering the case site, but it's a case out of Maryland where the concept of a comedy of a foreign judgment created the problem. Uh, comedy is a legal principle whereby we accept a judgment from outside, whether it be foreign judgment, Arkansas accepting a judgment out of Texas or from a foreign nation. They're granted acceptance unless there are clear violations, something that states that they should not be. There was a situation for custody of a minor child due to a foreign couple that lived in the Baltimore, Maryland area. The husband left the mother and child and went back to his home of origin, happened to be Pakistan. He attained a divorce while in Pakistan. He attained a judgment that said he had custody of that child. He came back to the United States, filed to have that judgment naturalized in the state of Maryland, and the judge said, okay, because there was no law that would have said there should be an exception to comedy here. There was no federal regulation because it's a family law issue, which is beyond the scope of federal law. There was no state law stating anything for clarity, and the judge made a mistake. He accepted the judgment of the foreign court, a court where there was no equal representation under the law because the other party was not even in the same country, much less the same courtroom. There was no attorney provided to represent her in her absence, as we would do here. That did not take place. So there was no equal representation, violation of our laws. There was no opportunity for her to speak. All of these things took place. Unfortunately, the judgment was naturalized in the state of Maryland, made a Maryland judgment. The individual, with the accompaniment of the sheriff's office, took possession of the child, went back to Pakistan. The mother continued her appeals process. The appeals court said the lower court was wrong. The lower court was proven wrong. Of course, the lower court didn't have anything to go on except that which they thought was right at the time because there was no clear expression of the will of the people of Maryland via the voice of the legislature. However, this lady now has vindication via an appeal. And he has their child in a foreign country. and I don't think the child's getting extradited back here anytime soon, and she, as a divorced woman, is not allowed to go back there. So that's the sort of thing I would hope
▶ Play
Arkansas could avoid. Thank you. So I just want to understand that's a terrible situation, but the Court of Appeals found that the trial judge had made the wrong decision without this law being on the
▶ Play
Speaker 11 25:13
books. Yes, sir, that's correct, Because, unfortunately, there is no way for us to know how many times trial courts err unless the people have the means to take it to an appeal. There is no published record of trial court actions. We only get the appeals courts. So if these people do not have the means to take it to an appeal, we have no record of how often it happens. Our record is purely retrospective via appeals courts. But that is true regardless of whether this law
▶ Play
is in place or not. Is that right? That is true. Can I have one more, Mr. Chairman? Last one, I hope. You never trust a lawyer when he says he only has one more question.
▶ Play
Speaker 51 25:56
Well, hopefully Representative Blake will be okay with that. My other question for
▶ Play
now is, as a lawyer, I am curious, because this does have some implications for the practice of law and what law judges can look at. My guess is most judges kind of have their own mind about what law they should look at when determining the cases in their court. And so I'm concerned about the separation of powers. I'm just curious if that factored into your analysis and whether you all have worked with any lawyers or judges about how to structure this in a way where it doesn't interfere with the separation of powers process.
▶ Play
Speaker 11 26:35
We have the short answer is yes. We have in every state where this has taken place. And in every state where this has taken place, there has usually been extensive work initially with the domestic bar. The domestic bar always comes and goes, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. And then you explain to them, all right, this is what we've got. This is what we're looking at here. And they go, okay, we weren't aware of that because we've been dealing with the things in our narrow vein that are more common throughout the United States, parity of split time between mom and dad because it's not 1952 anymore, and all those sorts of things. So the short answer is yes, we always work with lawyers. Two, it's usually the domestic bar that comes in heavy. Three, a lot of the commercial bar, as the points that were raised by the chairman earlier on, the commercial bar aspect tends to come in wondering about issues like choice of law and the degree to which this will affect trade and foreign contracts. So those things are all in there. That has been in there, and there are several firms that we've dealt with around the country that have had input, and then state by state as well. I hope that answers your
▶ Play
question. Representative Blake, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Smith, you stated in your opening remarks that you've come under a lot of different laws in a lot of different countries. How many different laws have you come under in the state of Arkansas? How many different laws have I come under? How many different, you went through a list that you've been under Taiwanese law, you've been under, how many different laws have you come under while you've been in Arkansas? I've come under
▶ Play
every law that's on the books in the state of Arkansas as you do. Okay, so this bill, follow up, this
▶ Play
bill is an act to protect the rights and privileges granted under the Arkansas Constitution and the United States Constitution to declare American laws for American courts. are there not American and Arkansas laws in Arkansas and
▶ Play
American courts right now? There are. The problem is we are going to be facing new challenges through our legal system that judges have rarely had to deal with, but those days are coming because our demographics are changing And we need to make some things very clear for our judges as they deal with cases that may involve foreign law and help them understand that even though there may be foreign law that someone wants to bring into a case, that under the Arkansas Constitution, as well as the Constitution of the United States, that is the primary focus of our court system here. And, you know, I'll mention, sometimes because of immigrants arriving here that are really, they're not as well protected. They don't know how to move in our culture, in our society. They're not assimilated. They tend to group in small enclaves, and they feel comfortable among their own people. But some of those same people who have escaped war and famine and chaos and tyranny, poor political systems, they're here now, and I want them to know that everything that we enjoy as full U.S. citizens, whether we were naturalized or whether we were born here, they have those same rights and privileges that I have. But in some of these small enclaves, what happens is there will be some elder, some leader rise out of the group that says we're here, but we're still going to run our lives based on law from our originating country. And that puts some people who wanted freedom at risk of running foul against their own people group after they've arrived in our country. Can you give
▶ Play
any evidence for what you just said?
▶ Play
Has that ever happened in the state of Arkansas? Well, it will happen. I don't have it right now. This is the left bang, right bang theory that the colonel was mentioning. If you look at Dearborn, Michigan, if you look at Minneapolis, Minnesota with the Somali population there, the Iraqi population in Dearborn and in other areas of our country, people are not assimilating. They don't feel comfortable for one reason or another. And part of it is they feel trapped in a system that they tried to escape. And I have personally helped, I think, four different families leave Iraq on special immigrant visas. They're in the United States now. Some are living in Dallas, Texas. Some are up in Dearborn, Michigan. They're spread out in these areas. And I'm in regular contact with these people by phone every month, just checking on them, seeing how they are. And I often ask, do you feel pressured to still be subservient to foreign laws that you came out from under when you arrived in the United States? And they say to me, without a doubt, with the exception of the one family down in Dallas, this is predominantly up in Dearborn, Yes, there's a lot of pressure for us not to assimilate, but to remain in our little group and not press out and explore this great nation. And so there's
▶ Play
Speaker 11 32:53
a lot of pressure. Sir. Representative Blake, if I may. there are a lot of boards, commissions, international organizations that weigh in and give guidance within specific areas of practice of the law. Many people are aware of things like uniform commercial codes that get adopted in whole or in part by differing states in order to help promote trade and so forth. One of the things that has been popular in the last 20 years has been in regard to family law. I'll give you a brief example of foreign aspects that have come in and created confusion. There is the Hague Convention on Civil Aspects of Child Abduction. The language from that is what has been used for the Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act in the United States, which has been adopted in whole or in part in many different states. The problem with the international language and translation is it creates problems in the courts, because their determination as to whether or not those principles have to be applied if you adopt it, or whether you can opt out to use your state law, is this excruciatingly clear phrase. or not fundamental principles of human rights were applied. Fundamental principles of human rights. What is your definition of fundamental principle of human rights? It's kind of like pornography. I'll know it when I see it. It's created problems in several states trying to come up with clarification of this extremely vague international language that has come into these subsequent codal statutes that states adopt in whole or in part. If clear will of a state is not expressed, creation of confusion occurs for the trial court level. I hope that's an example. Representative House, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Y'all were talking about something. I think Representative Tucker hit on it pretty good. There's two kinds of jurisdiction. One is subject matter jurisdiction. Our circuit courts have authority over divorces in this state. And then there's in personum jurisdiction over the person. A couple of the Saudi cases I am familiar with because I go to church with one of those mothers. It's not that they didn't have subject matter jurisdiction. It's just that the Saudi Arabia government says, we ain't giving you the kid. and we don't care what your courts say. So it was in persona. You don't have the physical ability to grab that child, which you would do if you were actually located within the continental United States. This is a question. I'll get around to it. We deal with foreign law pretty regularly around here, not only divorce cases that happen in other states, but divorce cases that happen in foreign countries. Normally what I have seen happen is the courts will take, for instance, a Mexican divorce, they'll say, okay, fine, you're divorced. We're not going to use Mexican law to separate Arkansas property or custody of the kids or visitation. And have seen the same thing happen with Texas or Minnesota or wherever you got your divorce. So the concept of foreign law, as a matter of fact, the professor that wrote foreign law textbook is from the University of Arkansas. um the the black textbook the horn book that we we would recognize now my question is this um a couple she is an absolute horrible wife as bad as a spouse can possibly be she is and the other person in the marriage the husband is the most wonderful dad the most wonderful husband provider that you can possibly imagine. They were married in Israel, and they now have four kids living in the state of Arkansas. She gets to court, and she says, we were never married. These are my kids. How is our court to determine whether a marriage occurred without referring to Israeli law? Well, representative, I'm really fighting
▶ Play
Speaker 11 37:26
the urge to put on a black robe and rule on this, but I think that hypothetical goes beyond what we're talking about here, although I really, really like it. Okay. I don't doubt that you would look to, and I don't think that this prohibits the looking to Israeli law. what you would do is look to the degree to which any of the fundamental rights enumerated in this bill, echoed in the Arkansas and U.S. Constitution, were adhered to or not adhered to. I am not even remotely an Israeli law scholar, and I do not know what specifics they would have there. but one would do as one normally does and analogize so the extent to which they were married for some period or they were together for some period of time Louisiana for instance doesn't recognize common law marriage but if they've been together for 10 years or more I believe Arkansas does therefore she can claim whatever she wants but if they held themselves out and had children together as a function of law they are but again I've been neither an elected nor appointed judge representative but I see your point and I don't think that this prevents you from looking to any other law what it does is it says we're going to stop where there's a
▶ Play
clear violation so that's what the law is in this state which is the courts always ask some very fundamental questions Were the parties present? Were they able to obtain counsel? Were they afforded a measure of due process? Is it fair? Is it coercive? The courts already do that here, so I'm struggling because I want to vote for this. I'm trying to figure out how this changes what we have already. So thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative
▶ Play
Dalby, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. With all due respect, Representative and Colonel, I have been a member of the judiciary in this state. And any person who, and I'm going to get to my question, any person who has been a member of the judiciary raises their hand, takes an oath of office to apply the laws of the state of Arkansas and the laws of the United States and uphold the Constitution. Can you cite any member of our judiciary who has not done that? I cannot. Absolutely not. And follow up, please. And as I understand, there are no cases, no Arkansas Supreme Court cases or Arkansas appellate court cases that have applied foreign law as opposed to Arkansas law. Is that correct? That's what I understood you to say. Is that correct? I don't think I said that. Okay. Do you know of any cases
▶ Play
then? I know that there was a local case up in Jonesboro, but when the father fled with the child, it left the mother with no recourse, and so the
▶ Play
case ended. Another follow-up, if I may. it appears to me that this is a federal jurisdiction or a federal court question as opposed to what happens in Arkansas with our Arkansas judges, Arkansas courts applying Arkansas law. Would you agree with me
▶ Play
on that? I don't think I can agree with that fully.
▶ Play
And one other question, please. And it seems to me from what you have said and what the colonel has said, this is really aimed at our family law code, and would this not be something that needs to be addressed in the family code section and not such an overarching view of all of our courts when our judges and our judicial system is already bound to uphold Arkansas law and federal law? So it's not a domestic issue question and not such a broad sweeping question as we have here today.
▶ Play
Speaker 11 41:57
I would argue that while the majority of cases that we have seen, because of their emotional nature and people finding the resources to get them to the appellate level, have been on the family court level. We do not have a full record of where all these instances may take place, and it would be negligent to narrow it to that scope. and therefore this is a
▶ Play
more appropriate venue. Representative Whitaker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. First question for Representative Smith.
▶ Play
If you have your way, if this becomes the law of Arkansas, could you explain for the committee what the enforcement mechanism is? Are we going to go in and put handcuffs on judges and haul them away? Well, I would hope not. Well, could you shed some light on
▶ Play
how would this be enforced? The whole point of this bill is to give judges another reason to do the right thing when these cases come up in the future in their courts.
▶ Play
And I have just one, if I may, for the colonel. Colonel, thank you as a fellow veteran and I thank you for your service. Thank you, sir. I didn't catch it, and maybe I just wasn't listening or something else popped up on the screen at the time. Could you tell me a little bit more about
▶ Play
Speaker 11 43:25
your organization, its nature, and its mission statement? The Center for Security Policy is a 501c3 organization that advocates for causes and does outreach and educational evolutions around the country for varying different groups. My main focus is veteran outreach, so I speak at a lot of VFWs, American Legions, Military Order of the World Wars. And since I'm here, if any of you need a speaker for one of those organizations in your district, feel free to get in touch with me. I'll be glad to show up and do that. As a
▶ Play
legionnaire, I would love to have you visit sometime.
▶ Play
Excellent. Thank you so much. Absolutely. All right. I see no further questions. So we will move to our sign-up sheet for public comment. First up to speak against the bill is Imam Al Dunaway. And there was another individual who had signed up alongside Hashim Zareem. Yes, Hashim Gori. Okay. And is that, who's going to speak? There
▶ Play
were two. Okay. He wants me to go first for then. All right. He's new to the country, so
▶ Play
I've been here 50 years. Okay, you can have a seat and introduce yourself to the committee. And if you're speaking on behalf of an organization, please let us know who you're speaking on behalf of, and you may make your comments. Okay. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair and the ladies and gentlemen. Will I be permitted to have our Sheikh sit next to me so that he can help me out? Because I'm not a religious scholar, and he is, so I would like him to be on my side, because in case if the questions arise, he would be able to answer. Without objection, I'll allow it. Thank you, Representative Smith. I appreciate you. Come here. Sit next to me. Okay. My name is Hashim Ghori. I came to this country. Shall I start, sir? Just a second. And
▶ Play
Speaker 102 45:35
if we could, go ahead and have a seat.
▶ Play
Thank you. If you would, go ahead and state
▶ Play
your name as well. Okay, my name is Mahmoud Hassan, doctor, associate professor, and I am the imam or the priest of the Islamic Center of Iraq.
▶ Play
Speaker 96 45:54
Okay, now you may proceed with your comments. Thank you. Yes, sir. Thank
▶ Play
you so much. I appreciate this. As you can see, I'm a little bit nervous because I've never been to any committee meetings like this, but it is an honor and privilege. I came to this country in 1967 in Alabama. I'm an Auburn graduate. I became a U.S. citizen in 1977. And I got my graduate degree in veterinary medicine, not in Islamic Sharia. I want to make it clear, but I learned a lot of things. And so, and our imam is new in the country, maybe a year. So I'm trying to help him out. So when the matter comes to religious law, I'm going to refer it to him. But I would like to say in a very simple language, I should say, when we say assalamu alaikum, that means peace be upon you. So if I say assalamu alaikum to him, he will say walaikum wasalam, that is the Sharia. When we start something, we recite in the name of God. So we say, Bismillahirrahmanirrahim, or Bismillah, that is in the name of God, that is Sharia. So Sharia is very simple, how we follow in our individual life. Just like the Americans say, what I practice in my religion, whether I'm a Jew, Christian, Presbyterian, or Baptist, it is my thing. It is my personal belief, I follow what I like. So Sharia is like that. My Sharia will be a little different than somebody living in Saudi Arabia because I don't, I live in America and some of the views are different. So Sharia is not a constant thing. It varies from country to country to country. There are 56 countries in the world that Muslim countries, only five follow the Sharia law. Some of the countries follow very strict laws and that is their interpretation. The Islam has been in existence more than 1,400 years. So the Sharia law has evolved. It varies from country to country. So Sharia mandates that Muslims respect the law of the land. I've been here in Arkansas since 1979. I'm abided by the law of the state of Arkansas and the federal laws. and wherever you live in USA if you live in Ohio, you follow the Ohio law or Minnesota law or whatever the law it's mostly the federal laws it is also against the Sharia to impose Sharia on anyone else for example, my practice will be a little different than his because he comes from Egypt, I come from India so it's a cultural thing, it's religious Sharia consists of three things. The Quran, the holy book, the teachings of Prophet Muhammad, and then the followers, the ulama, the alim, the learned people, how they interpret the law. So it is not a static thing. It changes all the time. Muslim Americans are subject to the same laws and constitution as any other American, as any one of you. It is also, it is about freedom to practice our faith without infringing on anybody else. I would like to add that all observant Muslims practice Sharia. And for example, the Sharia says we should pray five times a day, but some don't. So it's a Sharia. So it's up to me to pray five times a day. Some people just go to Friday for prayer, just like some of the people, you know, just go one Sunday and next Sunday they may not go. So you cannot tell me to go because it is me, it is my belief, how I practice my religion. So all observant Muslims practice Sharia, defining Sharia as a threat. Therefore, it is the same thing as saying that all observant Muslims are a threat. So this country is guided by U.S. Constitution and laws. This is a great country. I'm here in this country for the last 50 years, and I got very well benefited. Professionally, I'm, like I said before, a veterinarian, and I help the poultry industry, this great industry in Arkansas. and I'm not a religious scholar but I would like to say that Sharia law does not intend to replace the American laws. We have excellent laws on the book. The people who have talked to me those are instances, examples that happen but when you live in this country, when you commit a crime you have to go to the jail, you have to go by the You have to go by the same laws of Pulaski County, the state of Arkansas, not your Saudi law or not your any other country law. You are living in this country. You have to follow the American laws, the American Constitution. So in case of dispute, we are required to follow American law, not the Sharia law. So that's all I have to say, Your Honor. if my religious scholar can help me out if needed. But I just want to make it in very simple terms that I cannot tell you what to do. You may be a Baptist or a Presbyterian because that is your Sharia. The same thing.
▶ Play
All right, we have, thank you for your comments. Yes, sir. We do have at least a question. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Do you practice a version of Sharia law that, and I think you can answer this, but I just want to make sure, that violates either the U.S. or
▶ Play
the Arkansas Constitution? No, sir. I have the, excuse me, sir. Yeah. I
▶ Play
have the freedom to practice my religion. Okay. Is there, are there either countries or peoples that practice a version of Sharia law that would violate the U.S. or Arkansas Constitution? I don't think so, sir. You don't think that there is individuals, people? I mean, let's say, you know, the Islamic State, do they practice a version of Sharia law that would violate the U.S.? Or, I mean, you know, one of the things, we have equal protection, which would extend both to male and female, husband and wife. And so you're saying there are not versions of Sharia law that would violate the equal protection clause of
▶ Play
Speaker 115 52:41
the U.S. Constitution? Not that I know of. You live in this country, you follow
▶ Play
the law simple. Okay. So then, may I follow up? So could you explain how this bill would affect you then if you're a version of Sharia and there is no individual who practices any version of Sharia that would violate the U.S. or the
▶ Play
Arkansas Constitution? Yes, sir. I'll give you an example. We are located near ULR, the Islamic center of Little Rock. We have an incident. Somebody, our imam, came from Saudi Arabia, and we have difficulties understanding him. and he wanted to do his, he didn't understand the American system, American things, how we hired him, and we fired him. He went to the court. It went to the Arkansas High Court. And the court says, the court has no jurisprudence or nothing to say about the religious law. So the case was thrown out. So this tells me that the American law is the law he has to follow. May I follow?
▶ Play
I'm sorry. And this may be something that ought to be deferred to discussion. Maybe we'll do that. And what you're talking about is the government getting involved in church polity, which this does not extend to. So whether it's my Baptist church or whether it's your Islamic center or whether it's any other group, the First Amendment, the U.S. Constitution, prohibits us from going into the separation of church and state that's been interpreted into the First Amendment would prohibit us from going into that, irregardless of this case law. I mean, I understand how there could
▶ Play
be some confusion there. Yeah, that's exactly what I'm talking about. The court system and the legislative authority has to be followed if you live in Arkansas, Pulaski County. Your Sharia law is your personal thing. How I follow? Differently. There are so many different sects of Islam. We have a Jamaat Khana Islam over there, Ismailia. They follow their Sharia. There may be some, there are so many sects, Sunni, Shia, Ahmadiyya, Ismailia, and all that. So they follow their own thing, it's their thing. I have nothing against them. I think you brought up a good point that needs some
▶ Play
clarity, and so maybe during discussion, you know, there'll be something we ought to cover. Representative House,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question. Marhaba. Welcome to your capital.
▶ Play
please inform the Islamic Center that there is no mention of Sharia in this bill that we're discussing. It's not mentioned by name. And would you just pass that on to our neighbors and citizens in
▶ Play
your congregation? Were you aware of that? Well, somehow I get the understanding that it is an anti-Sharia law. It is this. The Sharia is the basic thing which we are concerned about because of the misunderstanding. Islam is a very misunderstood religion in the world. There's a lot of things happening because of the misconception. Islam is a part of the monotheistic religion. The Jews, Christians, and Muslims are the monotheistic people. The Islam calls the Jews and Christians and respect them as the people of the book. The book is referred to Torah and Injil, which is Bible and the Quran. We all follow the same God. The Jews call Yahweh, the Christians call Jesus the God, and we call Allah. The same thing. I'm going to interrupt
▶ Play
you, yes. And thank you, by the way, while I'm thinking about it, for the invitation to Eid al-Fatir last year. You invited me and I came, and it was a wonderful Eid celebration. Yes, sir, thank you. The bill does not mention, it just says do not apply foreign law in the courts to decide issues used in the U.S. Constitution. That's what the bill says. And I have mentioned earlier in a conversation about Mexican law and Israeli law, and we could talk about Canada and all that, but I just wanted to clear that no one has attacked Sharia in this bill, which is what we're discussing. Other people have other feelings. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chairman. Yeah, excuse me, sir. I appreciate your questioning and explaining to me, but what is the purpose of this law? Is it judicial? Is it legislative? Is it criminal law that you want to clarify in your own ways in your constitution? What is that you are really after we need to know?
▶ Play
Speaker 123 57:47
We're trying to find that answer,
▶ Play
right? thank you very much sir we have a scholar here please ask him some questions he went to Jameh Azhar which is the number one religious institution in the world which is in Egypt he's a scholar from Jameh Azhar Egypt and then he went to Scotland, UK to get his PhD in the comparative religion so I would love any one of you to ask him a question
▶ Play
Speaker 128 58:19
to clarify about this. Thank you
▶ Play
so much, sir. Thank you. First of all, I thank you all. If you could give me just a
▶ Play
minute. We'll give you just a minute, okay? Because we're going to have to move on to
▶ Play
some other speakers, but you're recognized. To make it clear, the Sharia or the Islamic law came for the welfare of humanity, came to make things easy. It did not come to make people's life difficult. If anybody in any part, Iraq, Syria, is doing an evil on behalf of Islam, he does not represent Islam. That religion doesn't call for intimidate, terrify people. It calls for, as my colleague Dr. Ghori said, it means peace. As-salamu alaykum, peace, peace upon you. Anybody who is doing something evil, he does not represent me, he does not represent Islam. Although they have chosen an Islamic name or a Muslim name, but identically they do not represent Islam at all. That's it. Thank you very much.
▶ Play
Thank you for your comments. Thank you. Seeing no further questions, we're going to move back to our list. There's actually no one signed up to speak for the bill. Next on the list to speak against the bill is Rabbi
▶ Play
Speaker 134 59:48
Gene Levy. Rabbi, you can have a seat. Introduce yourself, who
▶ Play
you're speaking on behalf of. And I would say, as I reminded at Tuesday's meeting, and I know there are a number of members of the public that are here at our meetings, As we move into the public comment, let's try to not be completely repetitive of things that we've heard before out of respect for the committee's time. But we do want to give everybody, as many people, an opportunity to come and make their opinion known. I appreciate that. First of all, I'm
▶ Play
Speaker 136 1:00:26
not Rabbi Levy. Not that all Jews look alike. I am Rabbi Winnick. Rabbi Levy had to leave. He was here, and he just stepped out a moment ago for a previous thing. He asked me to fill in for a moment. But I will attempt to do that. The truth is I'm not sure that I want to speak either for or against the bill. I'm happy to share a quick thought, but I don't want to be on the record as coming as
▶ Play
against the bill. Well, we will recognize you to make a comment, neither for nor against, but you're
▶ Play
Speaker 136 1:00:57
recognized to make a brief comment. I would only, as I understand the bill, I appreciate that the laws of this land are meant for the protection of this land. and as understood by the citizens of this country and the citizens of this state. And I do understand that different peoples in different places around the world or different cultures have different understandings of what they think is how to protect their citizens and they won't always agree. So one person saying it's a good law in one place doesn't mean that everybody else agrees it's good and that that just might be different. I would hope to think that our culture would tolerate both a combination of the things that we've heard which is a commitment by everybody who chooses to live on our land to follow the laws as have been understood by the citizens here, by county, state, federal, and yet we would within that, so not having foreign laws, Jewish laws or other religious laws overtake the laws of the land, and yet within that have a bill that would not make, I guess I can speak personally from Jewish tradition in other countries not here where there were little laws that didn't seem like they were very painful. It was, it didn't. The Nuremberg laws in years ago, one little law didn't matter and one little law didn't matter and one little law didn't matter until a lot of laws mattered together. And I don't think that's the purpose of this law, but I can appreciate people of my fellow similar cultures that might appreciate some language within the law, this very law, which says both we want to protect the citizens here of every culture to not have their personal freedoms, their American understanding of personal freedoms violated, and yet to maybe have something that says, but within that reinstate within such a thing. It would make people from a different culture not feel at ease by reinstate that within American culture and law, once people's rights have been protected, we very much celebrate the freedom of spiritual practice and religion. And it might be that there, I would just like to think there's some compromise within that would be protecting people from both sides of what we want to make sure that nobody's rights are harmed. And yet people don't feel that this is the beginning of something else where they will eventually be, have their rights
▶ Play
taken away. Thank you for your comments. All right, seeing no questions, we will move to the next on the list is Graham Catlett, who signed up to speak against the bill.
▶ Play
Mr. Catlett, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. It's an honor to be here before you today. My name is Graham Catlett, and I'm an attorney in Little Rock. During the last 30 years, I've focused my practice on international business transactions. I'm also the immediate past chairman of the Arkansas District Export Council, and my current role is to sponsor a group we call Export University, which goes around the state teaching people and companies about how to export. I speak to about 100 different companies or people each year about how to improve their exporting. Exporting is big business in Arkansas. About 15% of all manufacturing jobs in Arkansas depend on manufacturing, and our shipments exceed $7.5 billion. There are about 1,600 companies that export, and 1,400 of those are small to medium-sized businesses in all of your local jurisdictions. The reason that I'm opposed to this is that I think it will add to the costs and bureaucracy unnecessarily of having any small to medium-sized company export. Right now, many companies don't enter into written contracts when they export, and so they automatically fall under the law of a United Nations Sale on Goods Treaty. So if this law were enacted, payments due under those agreements might not be enforceable in Arkansas, which would be a terrible result. But even as a minimum, it's going to require Arkansas small and medium-sized businesses to review the terms of this law to see if it does adversely affect them. We would hope that the provision in the agreement that says it doesn't apply to certain entities who subject themselves to contract under foreign law would take care of it, but I don't think that occurs. First of all, what does it mean to subject yourself to a contract? And second, many and probably most sale transactions in Arkansas are done without a written contract. These are companies that get on the Internet and work out a sale deal with a European or an Asian or Latin American company, and there is no written contract. So this exception wouldn't apply. Even though the exception might apply, there are other foreign agreements that protect Arkansas companies, such as international treaties on patents, trademarks, and other types of business arrangements. So from my standpoint, this would have a chilling effect, an unnecessary additional cost effect, and does nothing to protect Arkansas business.
▶ Play
For that reason, I oppose it. Thank you for your comments. Next on the list is Myra Keith. You may have a seat. State your name and who you represent, and then you may make
▶ Play
your comments. Of course. Good afternoon. My name is Mireya Reith, and I'm the founding executive director of Arkansas United Community Coalition, as well as your current chair of the Arkansas State Board of Education. And I, first and foremost, want to thank Representative Smith in having the opportunity to engage with him on a few bills over this session. It's obvious that he's coming at this from a good place, and we understand that. And we want to thank the colonel for his service as well. I'm the daughter of a Marine, and so know what it means that it's not just our soldiers that we send out there. It's our whole families, and I know what it means to care for them. And the reason I'm here today, to highlight something I think was slightly alluded to, but to offer maybe a little bit more emphasis. As many of you might have seen coming into today's committee session, several members of our Latino and immigrant community here, just as we see many folks from our different faith communities here. And I think it all comes from sort of the same place. Notice a lot of nodding here in the committee about what is the actual intent of this bill and some concerns that were raised because of some of the broad language that were crouched, right, when this bill was presented. I think we're concerned in part because it seems that what is promulgating this is a very specific case, something that hasn't happened here in Arkansas per se. It seems to come from a basis of some sort of value or understanding that us immigrants, and I do identify as a second generation immigrant, I'm the very proud daughter of Mexican immigrants, and this idea that we're in enclaves and don't assimilate, and this idea that somehow there needs to be some additional protections. We understand and obviously feel sympathy for families that have seemed to have got caught up in the system from other states, and that is definitely a tragedy. Families are first for all of us, and obviously we don't want to see that happen, but creating laws on possible scenarios, things that have not happened, things that are written in such a broad way that could have greater implications, and we've heard from our faith community on one, and the other one I want to bring forth for you is when you start talking about foreign identifications, identifications, foreign licenses, foreign contracts. You're also starting to talk about things as simple and essential as our identifications. As many of you all know, we have a Mexican consulate right here in Little Rock that has worked very actively to make sure that we have identifications in the hands of individuals that identify as foreign nationals and are Mexican. And that's a strong, important secondary ID that a lot of our members of our community to use. And it's one that a lot of our state agencies have depended on as a way of being able to validate identifications. And I can appreciate Representative House comments in regards to there's no specific mention here of faith or specific countries. Our concern is that this law, one, doesn't seem to be necessitated, and two, the risk that it could imply to things like other face to identifications from other countries is so great. Why do we really need this? And, again, to be operating in the scenario of hypotheticals and to be putting forth some values around, again, our immigrant community, which, again, concerns us and why we're here today and why so many of our Latino communities showed up as a statement that we are here to be part of the Arkansas system, and that includes our civic processes and even accompanying these conversations here today. And so we just ask for the indulgence of this committee. Again, we feel the risks are too great of implications. It's not clear enough. It's obviously given enough folks concern that we're here to oppose the bill. And so we just ask that you either vote no to it or table to a leather time until these issues can be clarified. Thank you so much. Thank you for
▶ Play
your comments. Next on the list, Emmanuel Alvarez. Mr. Alvarez, you may have a seat to state your name. Thank you. If you're representing an organization, please let us know and you may make
▶ Play
Speaker 149 1:11:50
your comments. Yes, sir. My name is Emmanuel Alvarez. I'm U.S. Army Infantry Staff Sergeant retired, and I'm an emissary of Samoa, Michoacan, Mexico. I work hand in hand with the consulate, but not directly with them. I'm not a government organization. I'm simply a representative. So I want to make that clear. The thing is, based on what I've listened to, is there is no real basis on the bill as far as an example that has happened. We're working off on all hypotheticals. And the only thing I want to touch down on is that the language of the bill, what I would like to see is that it gets revisited and that it specifically protects those consular IDs and our passports. Because if we're going to have litigation that makes those types of identified documentation invalid, then it's going to create problems along the way that are not unnecessary and are going to cost money and time and things that we don't necessarily want to spend on. So what I want to stress is that not necessarily disagreeing with the bill, But I want to stress that the language be clear to protect and exempt those matricular and consular IDs so that if in case something comes up in the future, that immigrants have a valid form of identification that is respected by the courts. That's pretty much all I wanted to touch down on, and I have nothing further as far as that
▶ Play
is concerned. Thank you for your comments. Yes, sir. Next up, speak against the
▶ Play
Speaker 151 1:13:37
bill, D. Bruce Hill. Mr. Chair, motion at the proper time. Mr. Hill,
▶ Play
if you'll have a seat, state your name and who you represent. You may make your comments.
▶ Play
Speaker 155 1:13:55
My name is D. Bruce Hill. I represent the Arkansas Unitarian Universalist Justice Ministry. We are a 501c3 organization which speaks out on behalf of Unitarian Universalist principles on public matters. We are against this House bill, and I will try and not be repetitive. First of all, thank you all this morning for the opportunity to speak. And thank you for the discussion beforehand, because my major concern and the organization's major concern was that this bill was a bill that had no real purpose. We weren't aware of any real problems, especially here in Arkansas. However, the problems that were laid out by the representative and by the colonel all have to do with family court members. I'm sorry, family court members and issues. And that is a very narrow stream of thought. This bill is not narrow. It is a wide spectrum. It covers everything that possibly could be. And I think that you all have a certain number of hours in the day, in the weeks, in the months, to cover 3,000 bills that have been filed. and I'm not sure this bill is worth a lot of your time and effort and taxpayer money. I want to just mention a civilization. I come from an Italian family. I'm second generation. My grandparents came over in the 1900s, early 1900s. They spoke only Italian. My mother spoke both Italian and English and I came along and me and my brothers only speak English we're half Italian we have certain mannerisms like we do talk with our hands a lot but the fact of the matter is my grandparents had their enclave my parents sort of spread out and me and my brothers we just don't recognize that any longer there's another problem with the bill that nobody else has spoken about, but which is of concern to us as Unitarian Universalists. The bill seeks to protect certain basic rights all Arkansans and all citizens of the United States have. However, there is an eighth protection, which is at the first line on page two, the right to marry as marriage is defined by Arkansas Constitution, Amendment 83. So, in my looking at the bill, I see on the one hand, this bill seeks to protect the rights of all Arkansans to certain basic rights, but it excludes a whole class of Arkansans who choose to marry someone of the same sex. Now, that right was guaranteed by the Supreme Court ruling in 2015, Obergefell v. Hodges, and it was in 2015. So on the one hand, you're saying this bill protects these certain inalienable rights, except for this right that was determined by the Supreme Court to be in the U.S. Constitution. What message is that sending to the citizens of Arkansas? Is it the message that just because the Supreme Court makes a ruling doesn't mean that it applies to Arkansas? I think that's what this bill says. I think what this bill says is that if you love a person of the same sex, you are not a full-fledged citizen of Arkansas. And simply for that reason alone, we are against the bill. Thirdly, while I understand the bill is not meant to be anti-Sharia, I believe it is viewed by the public as such. and if you want to look at it even further there are communities in the United States there may be one here in Arkansas that I'm not aware of where the Hasidic law governs the conduct of American citizens who are of the Jewish faith there may be laws in Christian churches which govern the conduct of Arkansas citizens. This bill also impacts all of those rights. I understand the need for the family matter issue to be resolved. This bill doesn't do it, and I don't think it's worth amending to just cover that. I believe I'm done, and if you have any questions,
▶ Play
I'll be more than happy to answer them. Thank you for your comments. We have one more individual signed up to speak, and that is Brandon Markin to speak against the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 161 1:19:24
Hello. I just showed up because I'm a citizen and I wanted to speak out against HB 1041 on the grounds that I don't think it represents who we are as Arkansans. I've always looked to the representatives of the state for reason in an often unreasonable national political climate. I think HB 1041 is unnecessary because Arkansans are already under the protection of the Constitution and American law. That's never been a question. And besides being vague, the only effect I believe it will have is to alienate communities that are already marginalized. I believe legislating a fear-based agenda based on anecdotes is beneath this body. Looking around this room, we can see who is being represented. And I just want to remind you that there are also a lot of people who don't look like you and are from different cultures who you represent as well. And finally, we're not Tennessee, Arizona, Alabama, or Oklahoma. We're Arkansas. And I hope that you will express your independence and vote no. And that's the entirety of my comments. Thank you for your comments. All right, that concludes the
▶ Play
list of individuals who have signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Smith, what's your motion? Do pass. We have a motion. Do pass. Are there any questions or further discussion? Representative
▶ Play
Whitaker, you recognize them. This was a good hearing. We got to hear a lot of good information from both the presenters and from the public. There are any number of issues that were raised that give me pause about this legislation. But at the end of the day, I'm going to be a no vote because I think this particular bill is an unwarranted and unconstitutional invasion of the prerogative of the judicial branch. And therefore, I cannot support it. Representative Ballinger, you're
▶ Play
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I think the issue of the church polity is one that this body ought to be looking at and considering, and if individuals out there are concerned about that, I think it's something that we ought to address, is that, you know, the First Amendment itself, as interpreted by the Supreme Court, there's a separation of church and state, and we do a little bit of church law in my firm, so that, you know, it's something we deal with all the time, is that you want the church to be able to make the decisions and kind of stay out of the court as much as possible. Well, this doesn't affect and direct that. One of the things that I would say, and, you know, no offense, Representative Smith, but it doesn't do a whole lot, and I hope it would actually never do anything. I mean, as long as a judge goes out and says, I'm going to follow the laws, and he takes an oath to say that I'm going to follow the laws, and I'm going to follow the Supreme Court of Arkansas, I'm going to follow the U.S. Supreme Court, then it will do nothing. You know, it has zero effect. I mean, I hate the fact that we're going to spend two hours on a bill that does nothing, but that's essentially what it does. It doesn't, it's not nearly, it doesn't have the boogeyman effect. I think that anybody who's in a corporation out there that is dealing with this, they're exempted. That's not a hard thing for a corporation to do. I think that they're, I mean, you know, obviously when we start using terms like Sharia, you know, which is associated with a specific religion, you know, nobody in here wants us out there running over a person's religion, in particular if it's a minority religion. That's one thing that is foundational to our country. I don't want that. However, there are versions of Sharia that's not Islam, that's an ideology that is not consistent with our Constitution. And so an individual can go to Pakistan, can get an order, where a woman has nowhere near the rights that she's protected here under what they call Sharia law. It's different, you know, and we have to make sure we define the terms. It's not the same as these gentlemen use. I'm sure that, and I don't know them, but I'm going to take them at their word, The Divergent Sharia law is perfectly consistent with our Constitution, both U.S. and state. And if that's the case, they will be unaffected by this. I'm ashamed that individuals will feel like we're specifically targeting a religion because that's not what this is doing. It's specifically targeting the Constitution and freedom. And if it weren't for, and I hate to bring up, but, you know, we have a Supreme Court justice who's out there saying we should look more towards foreign laws than the U.S. Constitution. I mean, Ruth Bader Ginsburg has opened it. She's a sweet person, was great friends with Scalia, not an evil person. But her view is we ought to look more at foreign laws than U.S. Constitution. And I'm sure there's people in the state who see her as, you know, somebody that they would want to mirror. And if that's the case, I don't think that many of them would do this. Maybe they never would. But if they would, I think what we can provide as a legislature is some clarity to say, okay, just follow the Constitution. That's what we're supposed to do. If you're taking that oath, this is what you're supposed to do. And then if they do that, if they do what they're supposed to do,
▶ Play
this law will never, ever, ever be used.
▶ Play
That's my opinion. Any further comment? Representative Blake. I tend to agree with Representative Ballinger that this bill does absolutely nothing. And I also agree that when we first came to this chamber, we were all told that it's not a good precedent to pass legislation. that does absolutely nothing. So especially legislation that could be unconstitutional. And I hope before we vote, we remember why we're here and what we're doing. But thank you. Any further comment? We have a motion do
▶ Play
pass. All those in favor indicate by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. The ayes have it. Representative Smith, the motion is passed. Do pass. Thank you. We'll move on to the remainder of our agenda. Representative Speaks has a bill. She's come over from education that she'd like to try and run. If I can find it on our list. Okay, House Bill 1361. Representative Speaks, you're recognized. Thank you, Chairman.
▶ Play
The House Bill 1361 that I bring to you today is just an amendment to the grounds for divorce or separation under the Covenant Marriage Act of 2001. The only thing that I have done with this bill is add, in two places, mental abuse that had been left out of it. So I'm asking for a good vote, and if I can answer any questions.
▶ Play
Representative Fite, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Sure. I'm not that familiar with covenant marriage and what's covered in that. I know in other decrees of divorce, one of the grounds is general indignities. Does that enter at all here with covenant marriage? Is
▶ Play
there a provision for general indignities? The only thing that I could find in that, that it said abuse, but did not cover the mental abuse. It was physical, and the other thing was sexual.
▶ Play
Representative Blake, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. Do we have
▶ Play
a definition of mental abuse? I do have. Please. It's an emotional abuse or mental abuse, and it is a form of abuse. It can psychologically cause trauma, including anxieties, chronic depression, or post-trauma stress disorder.
▶ Play
Follow up. Is that definition, is that defined in this legislation? The only thing I had
▶ Play
added, because when I talked to the attorneys, I had been asked to put the mental abuse in this, and so that's all we added. So I'm sure it would cover that, because it is mental abuse. But it does not spell it out. Representative Whitaker?
▶ Play
No, no problem. Okay. Any further questions? Representative Fite, you recognize. Representative Speaks, could
▶ Play
you help us a little bit in the history of exactly the difference in a covenant marriage and a regular marriage and the difficulty in getting a divorce under each one? Because I'm not really totally
▶ Play
clear about that. Yes, this was all done in 2001 when Governor Huckabee was here. And he'd done this to try to curtail some of the divorces that was happening. And so you had people that did sign a contract. It's a contract, and it's very binding. And that's where it generated from. If you sign that, there were only two things. When I read the bill that said that you could get a divorce, It takes, you have to go to counseling, both of you. Then you have a two-year separation there before you can get a divorce. And then the mental abuse was never added, so if your spouse had been causing mental abuse on you, you could not get a divorce. It's
▶ Play
very binding. Any other questions? All right. No one has signed up to speak on this bill. Representative Speaks, are you
▶ Play
closed for the bill? Yes, and I appreciate a
▶ Play
good vote. Representative Whitaker, you're recognized for a motion. Move, do pass. We have a motion, do pass. Is there any discussion? All those in favor, indicate by saying aye. Any opposed? The motion passes. Thank you. Representative Lemons, are you here to run a bill? Yes, sir. Which one is that? House Bill 1385. Okay. House Bill 1385. Representative Lemons. representative lemons you're
▶ Play
recognized thank you mr. chair i have with me today miss shannon woods if she would come up here and join me please and mr. chair i do appreciate the opportunity to do this today out of uh out of sequence Ms. Woods was gracious enough to take off today to join us, so we wanted to get her testimony before she had to go back to work. Thank you, Mr. Lemon. Good morning, committee members. I'm here today to present to you House Bill 1385, which is concerning the possession and the sale of blue lights and law enforcement insignia. To my side is a young lady that I've come to know and respect, Ms. Shannon Woods, from my hometown of Cabot. You will note from the title of the proposed legislation that this carries her name, and in her honor, we call it Shannon's Law. I would like Ms. Shannon Woods to tell you why this law is important. Before I do, I would like to give you the proposed changes to the existing law that governs the blue lights and law enforcement insignia. These changes are small, but very strong. At the present time, it is unlawful to normally purchase, sell, or transfer a blue light or a blue lens cap outside the realm of law enforcement. We are adding possession to this, to the other unlawful practices mentioned above. Also in this bill, we are raising the stakes with respect to the type of felony committed. From D to C, with respect to the unlawful use and possession of blue lights and blue lens caps. And with respect to the law enforcement insignia, outside of what is allowed by law, abuse of this code would increase from a Class A misdemeanor to a Class D felony. Our law enforcement agencies serve in a world much different than what they have in the past. In some areas, the use of blue lights and regulated or related insignia put a large target on our law enforcement officers. We need as much assurance as possible. when we see a blue light or a law enforcement insignia that it is, in fact, a law enforcement officer. We want this bill to be a game changer for all the people in law enforcement as well as the people they are sworn to protect. With the Chair's approval, I would now like to hear Ms. Shannon Wood's testimony. You're recognized. Thank you all for giving me the opportunity to speak today. When I was 17, it was July 11, 1997, I was pulled over on the outskirts of Cabot by who I thought was a police officer. I was kidnapped and raped, and it was a horrific ordeal. Thankfully, the blue light rapist was caught two months after my attack. But he, I was his fifth victim, and I would hate to see something like that happen again. There were three attempted stops in 2015 in Lono County, and there were four attempted stops in Pulaski County in October of 2016, and the perpetrators, to my knowledge, were
▶ Play
never caught. Thank you for your testimony. Thank you for being here today. Representative
▶ Play
Tosh, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lemons, directing your attention, I just want to make sure of something. and direct your attention, which requiring here that any sale, and I'm having a little difficulty finding now, but any sale of blue lights, that it has to be reported to the Arkansas State Police? Am I reading that correctly? Yes, sir. Is that
▶ Play
a requirement in this? A follow-up, Mr. Chairman? Well, actually, if I could, yes, that's already required by present statute. We're not adding that. That's already in the statute.
▶ Play
Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. You may have the answer to this, and my guess is it should be codified somewhere already. But it's my understanding that the blue light laws are different in different states, where some other states, first responder, you know, if you're a volunteer firefighter, you can have blue lights, some states can't, you know, all that's different. Is it, like, if you are a guy from Oklahoma, you know, volunteer firefighter, you have blue lights on your truck or in your possession that you use when you're responding, and you come over to Fort Smith to eat, shop, whatever, would this then put them in violation of
▶ Play
that? To be honest, I'm unsure about that. That's a very good point. You know,
▶ Play
and I absolutely support what you're doing. My question is, you know, if someone here may be able to provide that clarity, if they can, that's great. If not, you know, until either we know that all those, even if there is any state that actually allows them to have blue lights, I would hate for them to be guilty of a felony and, you know, all they're doing is just passing through Arkansas. So to be honest with you, Mr. Representative, that
▶ Play
really did not occur to me. I'm hoping that it is in the present annotated law. I hope that there's some because the blue light law has been around for some time. So I'm hoping that it is in there. However, two things we did try to accomplish. First, auxiliary police officers were not mentioned in the original blue light law. So we're giving them the opportunity to carry their blue lights. And also we wanted to make sure that companies operating in the state of Arkansas that sell these and their employees, are allowed to do just that. So we're trying not to be, you know, adversarial to those companies as well. And that's so,
▶ Play
I mean, you know, I never want to pick on a person for carrying a piece of legislation and tell them that they need to do something to encompass something that wasn't in your legislation. However, what you are doing is moving it from a misdemeanor to a felony. Yes, we are. And so, you know, it's one of those things that, and, you know, I can't imagine a prosecutor prosecuting on that. However, you know, if we can make sure that either that's in there or in the code somewhere else or make a change to this legislation, I'd recommend it.
▶ Play
Okay. Thank you, sir. Representative Tucker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And I really just have concerns similar to Representative Ballinger. And so I fully support what you're trying to do here. I guess I'm just a little concerned about how broad the language is. And the example I was going to cite was not somebody driving through Arkansas, but when I put my Christmas tree up in December, whether I'm guilty of a Class D felony at that point. If they're red or
▶ Play
Speaker 210 1:38:46
green, you're okay. I know I've got some blue ones in there.
▶ Play
So anyway, I fully support what you're doing, but I guess I would just follow up with Representative Ballinger. If something could just be tightened up a little bit, I would be fully supportive. because I fully support what you're trying to do. Anyway, do you agree with that or disagree with that? That's my question. The only thing I would not agree
▶ Play
with is if you put Christmas flights on your vehicle and drove around town.
▶ Play
All right, I see no further question. No one has signed up on this bill. Are you closed for the bill? In
▶ Play
closing, I would like to say a very special thank you to Shannon for being here today. You know, putting a face on the laws that we debate is always a good thing. The courage that Shannon has shown has been incredible. It would have been so easy for her to crawl into a hole, to stay quiet, and we would have never known any better. And we wouldn't have blamed her. However, she is a perfect example of how someone can take a horrible event in her life and turn it into something that is where she could be a positive role model for others. And she's my rock star. And thank you for your time, and I would ask
▶ Play
for a good vote. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Feit, you recognize? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Motion to pass. Okay, we have a motion to pass. As Representative Lemons, I guess, in the way of discussion, to follow up on Representative Ballinger and Representative Tucker's concerns, would you be willing, if this motion were successful, would you be willing to look at whether there needs to be an amendment possibly on the Senate end to take care of some of the concerns that they've raised? Absolutely. Okay. I figured so. Thank you. Any other discussion? representative gray you're recognized thank you mr
▶ Play
chair and just there's one thing in here that's bothering me and it's it was added um on line 29 on page one but the word possess that for some reason that's bothering me and so i just wanted to bring that to light if we're looking at a possible amendment that you know i live in rural arkansas where we've got old old used cars we've got tons of antique stores i mean we have lights that go back lots of years and so possess was not in the original language so now you're great you're essentially taking in a lot of people who do collecting and um i just i want you to be cognizant of that that people that didn't have an issue before because they weren't actually using the lights could now be guilty of a Class D felony. So just something to think about. Thank you. And if I could throw this in,
▶ Play
we could look at the possibility of changing maybe the verbiage to say something like, it is unlawful to possess a blue light that is attached to a vehicle or something of that nature. Because there are antique stores that may have that laying around and we certainly are not going after them. Representative Ballinger, Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Maybe adding a mental state, so a mens rea that, you know, possessed with the intent to use or something like that is kind of what I'd recommend. And, you know, I think that you have the general support of the committee and it's got to come back through here for us to concur an amendment. So, you know, my guess is that you're a pretty amicable guy. We'll probably get that worked out. Absolutely. Representative Tucker, you're recognized. I just
▶ Play
want to say for the record that I agree with what Representative Ballinger just said.
▶ Play
I'm so glad I have a part of that. I'm so glad I
▶ Play
could help you. All right. So we have a motion do pass. Any further discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The motion passes. Thank you so very much. Thank you for uniting this committee. Thank you all again for your time.
▶ Play
And thank you for being here. All right.
▶ Play
Representative Richmond has been waiting patiently. Are you ready to run a
▶ Play
bill? how about how about this i've got uh i've got a number of
▶ Play
technical corrections we can we can batch them just for everybody's reference they won't let me batch them on the floor so i'm not trying to even as much as i enjoy being down front right that's uh all right so So I would ask without objection that we take up House Bill 1355, 1356, 1357, 1358, 1359, 1360, 1422, and 1423. I would certainly like to entertain a motion that we batch those bills. Representative House moves that we batch the bills. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? And these are all technical correction bills, and I would move due pass. I do not believe anybody signed up to speak. Against? Okay. All right, Representative Gray, move due pass. Any discussion? All in favor, indicate by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed? Okay. Thank you very much. Okay, Representative Tosh would like to run House Bill, is it a House Bill? Senate Bill 24.
▶ Play
Representative Tosh, you're recognized. thank you mr chair committee this bill here is um this is one that uh has been brought to me uh it's in regards to reducing the size of the criminal detention facilities review committees just for your information currently uh that committee consists of 144 appointees and it covers 28. They're set up in judicial districts. There's been some issues in regards to that as far as being able to keep each committee member informed of the changing guidelines as it relates to these detention centers inspections, keeping them all on the same page and keeping them up to date on current information. It's taken a lot of work from the staff of DF&A. And to keep this going. This is an efficiency bill, and hopefully this bill here is intended to, like I said, to be an efficient, effective, and economical in a timely update. What we're going to do with this bill is reduce it to eight in 40. In other words, there'll be eight criminal detention review committees, and they'll be made up of 40 members. They'll still be a five-member team. The only thing we're going to do is broaden their scope of inspections for the jails. We'll just add some counties to those teams, and I think it'll help us to be able to keep them updated, keep them current on changing laws as far as state and federal laws that has to be complied with that are detention facilities, and it's just an efficiency bill. And I would
▶ Play
ask for a good vote. Representative Whitaker, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Representative Tosh, thank you for bringing this bill. I'm just, just a procedural thing. Have you got feedback from the sheriffs and folks who run the detention centers? Yes, sir.
▶ Play
Everyone's good with this. As a matter of fact, a lot of people like it because it'll be easier to – it'll be able to keep – it's a difficult time now for the governor to be able to appoint people that, you know, they just want to appoint anybody to these committees and trying to find 144 people that's got some type of background as far as how those facilities need to be inspected and how they need to be run. And this will narrow that scope down to 40, which will make it easier to keep hopefully a group of people that have a little better background in doing those inspections. Thank you, sir. Thank you. Representative Rushing, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Representative Tosh, this is kind of a follow-up to Representative Whitaker. And we've passed this by Sterling and the criminal detention people that do the inspections, and they're all okay with it and everything. They're all on board with it, yes. They all agreed to it, and as
▶ Play
a matter of fact, they support this concept. All right, thank you. Any further questions? No one has signed up to speak
▶ Play
for or against the bill. Are you closed for the bill? I am. I asked for a good bill. All right. I take it you move, do pass. I do pass, yes. I'm sorry about that. No, you're good. We have a motion, do pass. Is there any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. We're now moving to Senate Bill 102 by Senator Rice and Representative Richman. And it's my understanding that last week we put an amendment on the bill that added Representative Richman as a sponsor. I'm being told that there's another amendment and that you would like to expunge the vote by which the previous amendment passed and then adopt the amendment and then consider the bill as amended. Is that? That is correct. All right. So do we have a motion to expunge the vote by which amendment number one to Senate Bill 102? Representative Dalby, we have a motion. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. now we have amendment two to senate bill 102. Amendment 2 should show up on your screen as DTP 124. It's not showing on mine. The amendment will pass out a hard copy. The amendment adds Representative Richmond as a co-sponsor and changes $25 to $50. Thank you. Okay. All right, so does everybody have a copy of the amendment? We have a motion to adopt the amendment. Representative Fite moves adoption. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The amendment number two is adopted. Representative Richmond, Senator Rice, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 102 as amended.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. If you recall last week, we come here to the table and discussed this bill extensively, had some other people here, and we got a lot of good input, got a lot of good questions. We took that into consideration, and because I could see your pain, could feel your pain, and I am a compassionate, caring person, I wanted to alleviate that situation. You all know that, you know, that we took that advice and we incorporated it into this amendment so that we would not severely affect the revenue of the counties out there that depend on some of these court costs and things to help fund their jails and other things. And we think we've come to a very good compromise here. I mean, $125, $150 for a seatbelt fine is too much. $50, you know, the individual gets a spanking, but he doesn't get the beating. Thank you very much. Any questions? Representative Tucker. Thank you for trying to alleviate
▶ Play
our pain, Representative. I always appreciate that. I'm there for you. I guess I'm just curious. When we talked about the impact this was going to have on state and county budgets last time, and it was never 100% clear, and I'm just wondering if you have that information now with the amendment
▶ Play
you've made. i think with what the testimony was last time the jd you know if he's here today you can ask him back up he didn't have a list of everything that it did some of y'all pulled it up i still don't have a clarification on that what we have done is met with the sheriff's association we met with association of county counties The biggest concern and what was in the forefront of the 2009 bill that I co-sponsored with stated concerns was the $20 fine on top of the $25 that would go to county jails. That is what has been agreed to, which would be $45, because we discussed in there last time most all the fines that I had heard of were $50 and up. We amended this for $50. I did find out in testimony of meeting with these groups $125, $120. I don't know where it stops. I don't know. Everybody knows. That was from some of the sheriffs that told me that it's higher than I thought it was. And they also shared with me that some of the grants that they get, as I stated in the state police, is not part of this because they don't get the fine. But some of the grants they get and what I expressed to you, my concern as I continue to ask questions during the interim and in council, what do you agree to on these grants? I thought we had outlawed quotas a long time ago, but maybe we haven't. But I can tell you there is a perceived three stops per day required for a seatbelt fine or for seatbelt violation. Again, this does not do away the violation. We have upped our original figure to $50 penalty, which is, to me, still substantial. It does not take away the primary stop. I think there's a bill filed that would do that. and you are affecting revenues greatly there, and the other things are left in place. I'd be glad to answer any other questions. Representative Rushing, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
I think one of my, still one of my biggest concerns about this bill, and I do appreciate y'all taking it back and, you know, trying to work with it, But one of my biggest concerns still is the fact that we have other traffic violations. And correct me if I'm wrong, because I could be, because I don't know everything. But we still have other traffic violations out there that are going to incur court costs. And so we're taking one traffic violation and saying that we're not going to incur court costs for it any longer. And no additional court costs and fines and fees can be implemented. But if you have a speeding ticket, you still may have to. If you run a stop sign, you still may have those. If you don't use your blinker, I think was an example, you could still incur costs for that. So is that true that we do still have other traffic violations that incur these court costs? And if so, where does this stop? I mean, why is it fair for one and not the other, I guess? That's my question.
▶ Play
If I can, I'd be glad Representative Richmond to express his views, too. As I stated when we were here before, I don't have in my mind another violation that does not put other people in jeopardy. Every violation that you mentioned, with the exception of seatbelt, while it puts the driver in the predicament, it doesn't put other people in danger, such as speeding, texting, turning without signal, and those things. I think those are enhanced violations to the point they can harm or kill someone. Not wearing a seatbelt, again, while we are still leaving things in here that will encourage you to wear your seatbelt. We are not saying it's to that level. I don't feel like that's a slippery slope on this one thing. Again, keep in mind, I've totally documented in my mind that we have a problem across the state of Arkansas. In particular places, not just one or two. that are using seatbelt stops because they're easily spotted, visible. After I was in this committee the other day, I've got a three-page letter in my pocket from somebody, and I've got their number, but I haven't talked to them yet, that says their daughter was targeted and she was wearing her seatbelt. They say she left home, he went out and watched her snap her seatbelt and was going from point A to point B. She was stopped on I-49 up in northwest Arkansas, and the officer came up, she had her seat belt on, he said, you didn't have that on when I spotted you. She said, yes, sir, I did. He said, no, you didn't, and it's one of those things. I'm not trying to indict anybody on that, but it's subjective. We have places that are using this, incentivized it for revenue. We've had some good discussion here that that can get out of hand, and I think places that it are, but I again say when I'm putting somebody in danger, I should be fined at a
▶ Play
greater rate, I feel like. Thank you for that question, Representative Brushing. Again, I go back to the intent of the original legislation when the legislators passed this, in that it was $25 was the max. And we've seen it grow from that to basically where you're taking home, you know, a third of somebody's take-home pay for a week. That's how big the fines have grown. And just reemphasizing what Senator Rice has said in that this is the one situation out there where when you don't put on that seatbelt, that's a bad thing because you can get injured. But when you don't put on that seatbelt, you're not really endangering anybody else except yourself, okay? And if you don't have your children or other people put on the seatbelt, of course, they're being endangered as well, and that will be addressed by law enforcement. I don't see this being a slippery slope. Again, and we have, once again, we have listened to what the people said here, and they are in agreement, and they are satisfied. As far as I know, the people that were concerned about this think that this is okay.
▶ Play
Representative Whitaker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Rushing's question satisfied mine. Thank you. Any other questions? Representative Tosh, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just want to make sure I understand, Senator and Representative, that I noticed in the amendment it says that fine not to exceed, and it doesn't say anything about, and I think I heard a question or two, but I wasn't real sure about the answer, and I just want to make sure that some court can't come back based on the language in this amendment where it says fine not to exceed $50, can they come back? Because it didn't say, I'm just trying to make sure that it's a definite, they can't add court costs to this, and that's what I'm afraid of because a lot of times in our bonds that people have to post any time they've been perceived as some type of violation is it says fine and court costs. So the fine is basically what we as a legislative body hand out in certain misdemeanors, certain violations, but then the courts are the ones that add the court cost to it. I'm just trying to make sure to safeguard that this doesn't go back to the way it originally was, that somehow we haven't left an opening here for the courts to still add court cost on top of
▶ Play
the $50. I'd welcome any of the lawyers on the panel to weigh in. Do what? I said I would welcome any of the lawyers on the committee to weigh in, And, you know, that, again, I have to rely on BLR. And if that's open, the intent of this is a $25 fine plus the court cost, and what we agreed to was setting a $50 fee. But that's not my intent to go to $50 and have $20
▶ Play
added on top of it. For what it's worth, in the original bill, And we've got plenty of other attorneys here that can speak up, too. In the original bill, which apparently these portions were unamended by the amendment today, there is an exclusion. The general court cost provisions specifically now would reference an exclusion for the seatbelt violation. And then there is language that's being struck from 2737.706 that previously allowed or stated court costs under 1610.305 shall be assessed. And that is struck, and that's not part of the amendment. So it appears that the court costs, at least as to these references here, that is being struck. Representative Whitaker. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
And I would assure you, too, that following what the section that the chairman just is the very clear language, other fines, costs, or fees shall not be assessed. That's your money shot right there. Thank you. Thank you. I knew you all could do it. See what happens when
▶ Play
you get a few lawyers together. Every once in a while, something goes. Any other questions? No one has signed up to speak for against the bill. Are you closed for the bill? I am closed for the bill. Okay. What's the pleasure of the committee? We have a motion do pass as amended. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Any opposed? The noes have it. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and the committee. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Moving back to the agenda, any other bills, any members of the committee are wanting to run today? Which one? Okay, Representative Tucker, you're... All right. I appreciate the committee's diligence today. I think we probably cleared up about half of our agenda, even though most of that were my bills. If there's no further business without objection, we're adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

SPECIAL ORDER OF BUSINESS, FEBRUARY 2, 2017, 10:00 A.M.

HB1041 B. Smith TO PROTECT THE RIGHTS AND PRIVILEGES GRANTED UNDER THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION AND THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION; AND TO DECLARE AMERICAN LAWS FOR AMERICAN COURTS.

0:14 - 1:49:35 301 segments 33 speakers

HB1007 Tucker TO PROTECT CITIZENS WHO ARE VICTIMS OF JUDICIAL ETHICS VIOLATIONS; TO CREATE A CAUSE OF ACTION AGAINST JUDGES AND JUSTICES WHO HAVE BEEN CONVICTED OF CERTAIN OFFENSES; AND TO CREATE AN EXCEPTION TO JUDICIAL IMMUNITY.

HB1006 Tucker TO AMEND CERTAIN CRIMINAL OFFENSES CONCERNING ABUSES OF PUBLIC OFFICE; TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ABUSE OF OFFICE; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ABUSE OF PUBLIC TRUST.

HB1045 B. Smith CONCERNING CRIMINAL VICTIM NOTIFICATION; AND CONCERNING THE RELEASE OF A PERSON WHO COMMITTED A CRIMINAL ACT AND WAS ADJUDICATED TO HAVE A MENTAL DISEASE OR DEFECT.

HB1152 Watson CONCERNING THE ABILITY OF AN AUXILIARY LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN AND TO BE EXEMPTED FROM LICENSING THE REQUIREMENTS TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN.

HB1158 Petty CONCERNING THE ENTRY UNDER CAUSE OF THE DEATH ON A PERSON'S DEATH CERTIFICATE WHEN THE PERSON WAS EXECUTED DUE TO A SENTENCE FOR A CAPITAL OFFENSE.

HB1173 Tucker TO AMEND AND MAKE CONSISTENT THE OFFENSES OF SEXUAL INDECENCY WITH A CHILD AND SEXUAL ASSAULT IN THE FOURTH DEGREE; AND TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "SEXUAL ABUSE" UNDER THE CHILD MALTREATMENT ACT.

HB1175 TuckeR TO REQUIRE LIFETIME REGISTRATION ON THE ARKANSAS SEX OFFENDER REGISTRY FOR A PERSON CONVICTED OF RAPE WHEN THE RAPE INVOLVED THE USE OF FORCE

HB1177 Tucker INCREASING THE AVAILABLE SENTENCES FOR CERTAIN SEX OFFENSES WHEN COMMITTED AGAINST A FAMILY OR HOUSEHOLD MEMBER.

SB102 Rice TO CLARIFY THE LAW CONCERNING THE FINES, FEES, AND COSTS THAT MAY BE ASSESSED FOR A VIOLATION OF THE MANDATORY SEAT BELT USE LAW.

1:49:35 - 1:26:37

HB1236 Gazaway TO PROTECT THE PRIVACY OF SURVIVING AMILY MEMBERS OF A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER WHO DIES IN THE LINE OF DUTY; AND TO EXEMPT CERTAIN LAW ENFORCEMENT RECORDS FROM DISCLOSURE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY

HB1248 J. Williams TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION UNDER THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967 CONCERNING CERTAIN LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIVE RECORDS.

HB1251 Walker TO CREATE THE "HELPING OUR PEOPLE EXCEL (H.O.P.E.) ACT OF 2017"; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.

HB1260 Maddox TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING REIMBURSEMENT FOR JUROR ORIENTATION COSTS.

HB1268 Murdock CONCERNING THE USE OF AN IGNITION INTERLOCK DEVICE.

SB20J. Hendren CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF AGGRAVATED ASSAULT UPON A CERTIFIED LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER OR AN EMPLOYEE OF A CORRECTIONAL FACILITY; TO PROVIDE A MORE SERIOUS PENALTY FOR KNOWINGLY DISCHARGING A FIREARM AT A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER.

HB1299 Brown CREATING THE OFFENSE OF POSSESSION OF A HANDGUN WHILE INTOXICATED; AND CONCERNING THE PLACES AND LOCATIONS A CONCEALED HANDGUN LICENSEE IS PROHIBITED FROM CARRYING A CONCEALED HANDGUN.

HB1354 Nicks CONCERNING DISTRICT COURT CLERK EMPLOYMENT

HB1355 Shepherd TO MAKE TO TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 24 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING RETIREMENT AND PENSIONS.

HB1356 Shepherd TO MAKE TO TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE CODE 7 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING ELECTIONS

HB1357 Shepherd TO MAKE LEGISLATIVE CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 3 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES

HB1358 ShepherD TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 22 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC PROPERTY

HB1359 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 21 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC OFFICERS AND EMPLOYEES

HB1360 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 9 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING FAMILY LAW.

HB1361 Speaks TO AMEND THE GROUNDS FOR DIVORCE OR SEPARATION UNDER THE COVENANT MARRIAGE ACT OF 2001; AND TO ADD MENTAL ABUSE AS A GROUNDS FOR DIVORCE AND SEPARATION UNDER THE COVENANT MARRIAGE ACT OF 2001.

1:26:37 - 1:47:29 69 segments 12 speakers

HB1362 Payton CONCERNING THE RIGHTS OF A CONCEALED HANDGUN LICENSEE.

HB1367 Watson CONCERNING AN AUXILIARY LAW ENFORCEMENT OR A RETIRED LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER CARRYING A CONCEALED HANDGUN; AND CONCERNING RETIRED LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS.

SB24 B. Johnson CONCERNING CRIMINAL DETENTION FACILITY REVIEW COMMITTEES; TO REDUCE THE SIZE OF TO REDUCE EXPENSES; AND TO ENCOURAGE STATE GOVERNMENT;EFFICIENCY.

1:47:29 - 1:31:12

HB1375 Tucker TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE FILING REQUIREMENTS FOR A PETITION TO QUIET TITLE; AND TO ABOLISH THE REQUIREMENT THAT A PETITIONER SEARCH VOTER REGISTRATION RECORDS.

HB1382 Gazaway TO ESTABLISH PROCEDURES TO BE FOLLOWED AFTER A CLAIM IS FILED AGAINST A SMALL ESTATE.

HB1385 Lemons TO BE KNOWN AS "SHANNON'S LAW"; AND CONCERNING THE POSSESSION AND SALE OF BLUE LIGHTS AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INSIGNIA.

1:31:12 - 2:04:59 94 segments 11 speakers

HB1415 Shepherd 6 TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 6 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING EDUCATION

HB1416 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 17 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PROFESSIONS, OCCUPATIONS, AND BUSINESSES.

HB1417 Sturch CONCERNING THE OFENSE OF SEXUAL SOLICITATION; PROVIDING FOR IMPOUNDMENT OF A MOTOR VEHICLE; AND PROVIDING FOR HUMAN TRAFFICKING AWARENESS EDUCATION FOR EDUCATORS.

HB1420 C. Fite TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS DOMESTIC VIOLENCE SHELTER ACT; TO CREATE THE ESTABLISH TO FOR PROCEDURES AND VIOLENCE DOMESTIC FUND; SHELTER FUNDING DOMESTIC VIOLENCE SHELTERS.

HB1422 ShepherD TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO THE TITLE 12 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING LAW ENFORCEMENT, EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT, AND MILITARY AFFAIRS.

HB1423 CORRECTIONS TECHNICAL 12 TO Shepherd MAKE TO TITLE ARKANSAS CODE OF THE

HB1055 Hammer TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "MARITAL PROPERTY" FOR PURPOSES OF DIVISION OF PROPERTY IN AN ACTION FOR DIVORCE.

HB1095 A Johnson CONCERNING THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A CONCEALED HANDGUN LICENSE FOR CURRENT OR FORMER MEMBER OF THE UNITED STATES ARMED FORCES.

HB1197 Sturch TO ESTABLISH A METHOD FOR A PERSON WHO WAS FALSELY ACCUSED OF A CRIMINAL OFFENSE TO MAKE A CLAIM FOR REIMBURSEMENT FOR HIS OR HER EXPENSES PAID TO AN ATTORNEY IN DEFENSE OF THE FALSE ACCUSATION.

HB1265 Richey OF CARRYING A OR CONCEALED AND CONCERNING POSSESSION THEUNCONCEALED HANDGUN; TO ESTABLISH A LICENSE TO CARRY AN UNCONCEALED HANDGUN; AND TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair Unverified
64 segments
Representative Brandt Smith Unverified
28 segments
Speaker 11
46 segments
Representative Lanny Fite Unverified
3 segments
Representative Clarke Tucker Unverified
11 segments
Speaker 51
1 segment
Representative Charles Blake Unverified
9 segments
Representative Douglas House Unverified
10 segments
Representative Carol Dalby Unverified
4 segments
Representative David Whitaker Unverified
7 segments
Hashim Ghori Unverified
23 segments
Speaker 102
1 segment
Mahmoud Hassan Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 96
1 segment
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
21 segments
Speaker 115
1 segment
Speaker 123
1 segment
Speaker 128
1 segment
Speaker 134
1 segment
Speaker 136
7 segments
Graham Catlett Unverified
6 segments
Mireya Reith Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 149
4 segments
Speaker 151
1 segment
Speaker 155
10 segments
Speaker 161
3 segments
Representative Nelda Speaks Unverified
9 segments
Representative Tim Lemons Unverified
17 segments
Representative Dwight Tosh Unverified
11 segments
Speaker 210
1 segment
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
4 segments
Representative Marcus E. Richmond Unverified
6 segments
Representative Laurie Rushing Unverified
4 segments
Senator Terry Rice Unverified
12 segments