Revenue and Taxation Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (19)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1388
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1388 Douglas TO REQUIRE OUT-OF-STATE SELLERS AND FACILITATORS TO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1014
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1014 Leding TO CREATE THE TEACHER'S CLASSROOM INVESTMENT DEDUCTI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1028
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1028 Lemons TO EXEMPT CERTAIN BUSES, COACHES, AND OTHER MOTOR VE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1031
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1031 Bentley TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX EXEMPTION FOR INCENTIVES RE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1037
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1037 Wardlaw PROPERTY; TAX-DELINQUENT OF PROHIBIT TO AND TO SALE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1153
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1153 Boyd TO CLARIFY THE MEANING OF "ACTUAL AND OBVIOUS ERRORS"…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1221
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1221 Sabin TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE SALES AND USE TAX EXE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1225
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1225 Magie TO REPEAL THE EXEMPTION FOR AND REQUIRE THE DISCLOSUR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1227
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1227 Farrer TO REDUCE INCOME TAX RATES IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES;…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1252
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1252 Rye TO AMEND THE INCOME TAX DEDUCTION ALLOWED FOR MEDICAL A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1253
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1253 Wardlaw TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT THAT CERTAIN RETAILERS PR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1395
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1395 Leding TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR TAXPAYERS THAT EM…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1396
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1396 Leding INCOME INDIVIDUAL TAX SCHOLARSHIPS, EDUCATION THE TO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1397
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1397 Leding TO EQUALIZE THE SALES TAX TREATMENT OF DUES AND MEMB…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1399
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1399 Ballinger HONOR ARKANSAS VETERANS ACT OF 2017.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1409
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1409 House TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION FROM THE INCOME TAX FOR SERVIC…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1412
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1412 Ballinger TO PROVIDE FOR A PARTIAL PROPERTY TAX EXEMPTION F…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB114
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB114 Hester TO AMEND THE REQUIREMENTS FOR PUBLISHING NOTICE OF D…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB120
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB120 J. English TO AMEND ARKANSAS TAX LAW CONCERNING INCOME TAX,…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 14, 2026
Okay. Members, we're going to call a meeting to order. And right now we're going to take up House Bill 1388. And there will be a amendment on the bill to present it first. In the amendments, you're going to find the amendments on the tablet as well.
Representative Douglas, when you get to the end of the table, sir, you're welcome to recognize yourself, and you're
welcome to proceed with your amendment. Thank you, Mr. Chair, committee members, good morning. Good to see you all here this morning. First of all, I have an amendment to House Bill 1388. It should be on your tablets if anybody has any questions. Basically, the main part of this amendment is just changing.
We had before a notification would be sent by first-class mail. We're in a new age here, members, and so we included mail or by electronic means, email, whatever. Okay. Any questions on the amendment? This is your amendment and your bill, sir? My amendment, my bill, sir. Any questions, members? I make a motion
to do pass. Adopt. I'm sorry, I make a motion to adopt. Scott, Ms. Balz, makes a motion to adopt.
Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Any opposed? Nope. The amendment
is adopted. Thank you, Mr. Sharon. Thank you, committee members, for
You're ready to proceed on your bill. Okay. Thank you, sir. Members, we're in a new day and age, and Main Street America is under attack. We now have our brick-and-mortar stores that employ our local people, pay local property
taxes to support our schools and support our communities under a disadvantage because there are internet retailers, out-of-state retailers, that are not collecting and remitting sales and use tax because they're not required to under federal law at this time. This is a disadvantage to our local retailers. You can go out and you can go to any business in your town, in your city, and talk to them, retail business,
and they will tell you that people will come in, they'll look at items, they'll utilize their salespeople, they'll take their time, get the information, turn around, order it online. One reason sometimes is because they do not collect and remit sales tax. So it's a disadvantage. It's killing our local businesses. I don't know if you all heard on the news recently, The Limited, whatever they sell, that's not my bag of tea there to shop at The Limited, but I'm more tractor supplier or Walmart-type guy myself,
but they are closing all of their brick-and-mortar stores and just going online. Just think about your own towns. If we lost all of our small businesses, all of our retail establishment, what downtown would look like then or the shopping districts and where would these people work. We have got to correct that. Additionally, whenever we look at a new administration, we have a new administration, a new president.
One of his main focuses is going to be on tax reform. The Congress, Representative Paul Ryan, one of their main objectives is income tax reform. We just passed a bill here in the Arkansas legislature that says we will set up a task force to address income tax reform. We want to lower the income tax rate in the state of Arkansas to make it a more competitive business environment
and better for our citizens out there. The thing is, you cannot lower the rate unless you either one-cut expenses or broaden the base. I sat next to a senator from North Carolina in a recent task force meeting I attended, And he talked to me about how their revenue was doing so good and they're coming in above projections because they had reformed their tax structure.
They had lowered their corporate and personal income tax rates and expanded their base. And I said, you know, I know whenever I eat too much how that expands my base, but how do you expand your tax base? He said, we cut out loopholes. We cut out some exemptions. Committee members, right now we have one big loophole, and that is people that are legally bound to pay sales and use tax
on purchases of tangible items that are not. Part of it is because they don't know. Part of it is because they forget. Part of it is they don't track it, but they're not required to. This bill, this bill, 1388, it is based on a bill that was passed in the state of Colorado. This bill has withstood constitutional muster. There was a lawsuit filed.
It was decided in federal district court that this was a constitutional bill, on the Supreme Court refused to hear an appeal, thereby upholding the lower court's ruling. So this bill has passed muster. And it's really a simple bill. All this bill does is to require out-of-state retailers that do not collect and remit sales and use tax
to, first of all, tell the purchaser that if you purchase this item, you owe sales and use tax. I don't know if any of you all remember, years ago, none of you all remember, you're not old enough, there was a TV show, Lost in Space, and a robot, anytime something came up bad, a warning, Will Robinson, warning, that's what's going to happen whenever you go to checkout before you hit confirm, a screen's going to come up and say, warning, you owe
sales and use tax on it in your state. And it's your responsibility as a purchaser to pay that sales and use tax. It's not a new tax. It's what we're supposed to be doing right now. I only know of one person that does that in the state of Arkansas. There may be more. Uvalde Lindsey keeps track of that, makes his wife keep track of all her purchases and remits a check to the state of Arkansas every year on sales and use tax.
That's what we all should be doing, what we're legally bound to be doing. But back to the bill, it requires the online retailer that does not have a nexus or a physical presence in the state to warn people, tell them the tax is due. It's your responsibility. Then at the end of the year, just like you get a credit card statement with all of your purchases listed there, you'll get a statement from this retailer that says, here's what
you bought. Here's how much money you spent that sales and use tax will be due on. It'll also send another copy of that to the Arkansas Department of Finance and Administration. That way everybody knows what they owe. Okay? We hope we don't have to get into looking at tally sheets and sending people bills
or people having to keep up with this. we hope the online retailers will comply. It's hard to put a number on how much revenue this would bring in, and it's not all about getting revenue. We all know that we have plenty of places for money to be spent. The governor has said that he would like to take any monies
that are collected by these revenue increases, put it in a lockbox to be used for income tax cuts to lower that rate. And this is how we broaden the base. It's really a simple bill. It's about catching the state of Arkansas up with the future.
We're in the 21st century, and we need to bring our state into that century and catch up with new technology. I could go on and on, I don't know what else to say, it's simple. We know that sometimes it's tough to do the right thing, but this is the right thing for the state of Arkansas. Other states are doing it. Other states are collecting these sales and use taxes, and we're going to be left alone
in an island out here. And the reason these other states are getting collections, retailers volunteering to collect and remit is because they passed legislation saying this is what we expect. This is what we demand from people that prosper from selling goods to our citizens. And with that, I'll close for right now and be happy to take any questions. Thank you, sir.
First of all, you offered an inaccurate testimony. Lost in space was danger, not warning. I just want to clarify that. I stand corrected.
I have slept since then, Mr. Chair. Just wanted to make that point
of reference. Rep. Douglas, can you walk us through just the dynamics, take away, strip away all the other stuff you just said, walk away the dynamics of how this would be collected? Okay, you bet.
You go purchase something on the Internet. Before you hit confirm, you enter all your credit card information or PayPal or whatever it is. Monty, you didn't know I knew about PayPal, did you? I do. But you get it down there. down there, before you confirm, a screen comes up and say, you owe this tax. It's that simple. You know, there's no doubt, you know, you're warned that you owe this tax. You don't have to pay it right then because they're not collecting and remitting, but it's your responsibility.
Then at the end of the year, you would get a statement, just like a credit card statement says, all your purchases and you know the total on the end and what you owe, then you would remit that to the state of Arkansas. It's that simple. Mr. Vice Chair.
Speaker 24
12:28
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Dan, we talked about this a little bit, but give me the logistics of what if somebody
comes in and purchases something all year, $4, and the tax on it's 24 cents, a quarter, a quarter. How is that going to be collected? How is that person going to send in a quarter to the state
of Arkansas? Representative Farrar, thank you for that question. We talked about this earlier before the meeting, and that came up. I'll be honest, that's one thing I hadn't thought about. Talking to DFA, anybody from DFA want to come down and help address that? What we talked about,
and we were going to try to get an answer. I hadn't got the answer back yet, but we need to just put a line on the income tax form that says Internet sales tax due here, and it'd be figured right in with that. That would be the easiest, simplest way. DFA was going to see if we could do that through regulation or whatever change, or if we need to include it in the bill, we'll let them speak. And if it's something we need to include, that's such a great idea, Representative Farrar,
but we need to amend it on the Senate end, hopefully.
Paul, can you – do you have anything to add to that, sir? Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Regarding the last point that Representative Douglas was talking about, we currently have the ability for a taxpayer to pay their use tax that is owed on their Arkansas individual income tax return. So that mechanism is already in place.
Certainly, if a taxpayer wants to utilize the other mechanism that they can print out the report and send it in, even if it is a nominal amount, we can accept a form of payment that's in form of a check or a money order, even if it's a small amount. But certainly, we also, you know, there are other ways that individuals can pay their taxes in Arkansas that are electronic in nature. We currently have the ATAP portal that many taxpayers utilize.
We certainly have other types of fees that are paid online. For example, we have already established the ability for a taxpayer to pay driver's license reinstatement fees online as well. We certainly can investigate ways and look at a method that a taxpayer certainly, if they have a small purchase or a very large purchase, could establish a portal for those types of transactions. We'd be happy to look into that to make it as easy as possible for
taxpayers and minimize the amount of paper filing that was necessary for the taxpayers and for the department
Speaker 24
15:20
to process. Okay. I guess that kind of leads to the second question. Is DF&A equipped to do this? Or do
they have their new equipment or special help to do this? We certainly already have the mechanisms in place to accept use tax payments either on the income tax return or through the paper filing, but certainly we could work with DIS to determine just how difficult
or costly it would be. I certainly think that we should look very seriously at this possibility of being able to have a simple portal for a taxpayer to file their use tax. And as you
say, to make sure, we already have on the income tax form the place to submit use tax, so right there is the perfect, for the 25 cents or something, I think lots of times stuff's rounded off to a dollar anyway, they could voluntarily pay that to highways,
I'm sure. Well, I'm pretty sure nobody would ever
have a quarter, but maybe. And also, Mr. Vice Chair, if many of our taxpayers utilize the online tax preparation software companies, as you might have walked through the Q&A that is conducted when you are doing your – a question will be asked, did you have any online internet purchases during the year that you haven't paid your use tax on? And you can enter in that figure at that period of doing your Q&A, and then that amount of
the use tax can be calculated and added to your tax
due on your return. Paul, is this a tax DFA thinks that's already on the books and it's just this is a mechanism trying to figure out a way to
clean this up or does DFA think this is a brand new tax? Mr. Chair, this is absolutely not a new tax. This tax was passed in 1949. The issue that has been challenging for the state is that the tax, even though it's owed,
is just not being sent in. And there is just not, in the law, a mechanism is similar to this bill that the taxpayer can be educated that a tax is owed on the transaction. And also, if that tax does not get sent into the state, there's also the mechanism for these online retailers to notify DFA just so that we can make sure that on these purchases where use tax is owed that we receive some type of return in payment.
Thank you, sir. Representative Collins, I know you want to make
a remark or a question. Yeah, it's a question because one of the things that would be confusing to people listening is if I were to say on the one hand we've had a tax that's been out there for umpteen years and then on the other hand, make it look like I'm confused about how one would pay the tax. The reality is we've had for years and years and years, true, a form called a use tax form. And in fact, you can file it quarterly, just like you file your income taxes quarterly. And in fact, doesn't DF&A also give people immunity if you start paying taxes in a given year
and say I'm honestly starting now giving people immunity for the rest of the year if they comply for
the rest of the year? Well, there's certainly circumstances where DFA has been for a taxpayer that has been audited for use tax purchases, and quite often that taxpayer may indicate to the auditor, we're sorry, we want to comply with Arkansas law, but our CPA, our attorney, had no understanding or knowledge of the use tax, that obligation to pay.
And so certainly there are circumstances where DFA wants to do equity and get that taxpayer to comply and certainly adjustments to interest under the law, it would be appropriate to make sure that there's some type of ability to give some relief to the taxpayer. Mr. Chair, if I could just follow. So there's
two types of use taxpayers. The ones that you spend most of your time with today are large businesses, nonprofits, et cetera, and
it's worth the kind of investigation and effort that you go through. But I'm talking about for Mr. or Ms. Arkansas. And they're out in their home, they've been buying these things, and all of a sudden they realize, oh my gosh, I didn't know I was supposed to pay tax on this, when that individual goes and downloads the use tax form in March of 2017 and says to themselves, oh my gosh, I'm not sure what I did last year or the other year, I'm not sure if I'm been evading taxes, doesn't the form, and if it's a question that needs to be answered later, please bring it back, doesn't the form say, okay, we understand that you're
starting now and we're not going to target you just because you're beginning to pay these I'm fairly certain it does, unless it's changed in the last year or so. MR. Representative Collins, I would have to just
take a quick look at the form. I'm not sure that there is a provision of immunity. MR. Hang on just a second, Paul.
I think DFA is trying to work through that, and we're going to try to find that
Speaker 45
20:53
question here. Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, Tom Ashley with DFA.
We accept the annual reports from Arkansas consumers for their use taxes. The forms were placed in the package of materials for their individual income tax return, and we also have those forms available on our website. We receive those returns on an annual basis from Arkansas consumers generally, and we process those as a one-time annual report with no penalties and interest applied. And so their concern about that issue is not how we process the one-time annual report
from consumers. MR. Thank you very much. MR. My apologies for cutting you off like that. Sir, do you have anything else you want to add to that? MR. No, Mr. Chair. MR. I just saw your colleagues over doing a lot of talking back and forth. I just want to kind of help out there. So, okay, we're going to start working down the list. We've obviously got a lot of
questions here coming. Representative Bragg, you're recognized, sir. MR. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator Douglas, other states have implemented this.
Have there been any problems with enforcement if a retailer just doesn't comply? Do
we know? Is there any way to track that, or? I really haven't heard anything, Representative Bragg. It's hard to tell what complaints other states have had and the ones that haven't complied. Let me defer to some
of my associates here. As you might recall in Representative Douglas' discussion of this bill, the Colorado version
of this bill has been in litigation for several years. It went up to the U.S. Supreme Court, and just recently we had the Supreme Court deny cert in December of 2016, so it would be difficult to see how the retailers would respond to the Colorado's approach because it has been, for the most part, held in abeyance until the outcome of the
litigation. Okay, a follow-up. As far as the DFA process, you know, a taxpayer would receive
a statement from the retailer, and that same statement would go to DFA and I, does that? The annual statement would come to DFA. Yeah, and then if the taxpayer, for some reason, did not pay that or paid just part of it, does
DFA have a mechanism? Will they be sending a tax due bill? That's correct. If there was a determination made by our sales tax or audit department that a transaction took place that was subject to Arkansas use tax, you know, we would
contact that taxpayer, send a letter of inquiry, just to make sure that that product was, for example, it could have been delivered, but it could have been, there might be a reason that use tax would not apply. Maybe the product was actually returned to the retailer. And that, and so certainly there would be no tax owed. But if we did make a determination that use tax, according to our records that we received, was owed, we would notify the taxpayer in writing. And at some point, we would also, if we did not get a payment for the tax, we
would issue a notice of proposed assessment. And then the taxpayer would be able to protest that notice of proposed assessment and would be entitled to an administrative hearing if they disagreed that the tax was actually owed. So there would be a mechanism for the taxpayer to dispute the tax in the event the taxpayer was of the position that there was no use tax owed on the transaction. Okay. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. You're welcome, sir. Mr. Vice Chair. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Let
Speaker 24
24:40
me ask you this. With the Internet, the way it is now and people
purchasing things, how will this bill handle out-of-country purchases? I mean, I've bought things from China. Does this bill address that? Well,
certainly. Do you want me to address that? No, right ahead. Okay. Well, certainly there's always going to be companies that are going to be able to ship items into the United States that our state laws and as well as our U.S. federal laws are going to be very difficult to touch upon. But certainly it would be, we would rely upon other avenues in
our audit department, certainly if there was a customs declaration that was made for the item that was shipped into the United States, we would have a third-party resource for the information to make sure. But certainly under this law, there might be retailers that are exclusively outside of the United States that ship their items in either by a third-party carrier that it might be difficult to have that information if they do not comply with the requirements of our state law.
Representative Dyson, you're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Reading through this bill, I guess the question I have is, do we have the jurisdiction to enforce this
at all on out-of-state companies? Yes, we do. Because of if we pass this bill, we will. because it has been held constitutional by the United Supreme Court
and their refusal to review it. That means that it is our state law, just like we could refuse to accept California wine in this state if we wanted to, Representative Dotson. But this is our state law, and it applies to anybody that does business in this state, whether they have a nexus or not, According to the recent
I do not disagree with any aspect of that statement. Okay. And then the $5 and $10 penalty that you would incur for failure to do this, is this not increasing revenue for those types of companies that don't comply with that? And that fee would be kind of a tax on those companies if they didn't comply with this?
It would be a fine on them for not complying with Arkansas law, just like if you drive exceed the speed limit, you can get a fine. Same thing, Representative Dodson. All right. Thank you. Representative
Saban, you're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I actually had sort of two real small technical questions and two kind of broader questions. and I'm willing to do them however you want me to do them. Let's hear all of them. Okay. The first question just has to do with the fact that the notice
that the seller has to provide on the Internet. I mean, there's obviously no stipulation in the bill of what form that notice would take, so it could be some very fine print as somebody's checking out, and it just would concern me, number one, that the consumer may not be aware, actually, of what they're getting into when they're making the purchase. I was wondering
if you could address that real quick. I can't. What about you, Paul? Representative Sabin, when this bill was being drafted, you know, we thought there
might be a concern with retailers that are wanting to communicate with their customers electronically. And certainly the retailer has the option of sending by first-class mail the annual statement with the ‑‑ I was talking about a time of purchase, just to clarify. Certainly, certainly. So there, but we certainly, there are going to be situations that, you know, a retailer that is trying to comply with the requirements of the bill, but certainly is putting this
in the very fine print that possibly no consumer would ever read or maybe very little. But we're really wanting to address in this bill the complaint that the consumer is not educated about the use tax in Arkansas. So certainly if it's not communicated at the time of the purchase, it's certainly going to be within that annual statement as well. They're going to have two opportunities to educate the customer. But we're requiring
them to do it at time of purchase.
And I didn't mean for this just one question again to get into it, but I do worry a little bit that, number one, I mean, we're requiring notice. We're not specifying what form that notice takes. And if most of us who've ever purchased anything on the Internet, I mean, you don't even put what state you're in until you're checking out. And so most retailers would have to probably redo their entire e-commerce platform because you can't track people by IP addresses because those are easy to mask as well. And so once you start to think about the actual implementation of this, I just wonder if there's
been any thought to the notice that we're requiring these
retailers to make. You know, there's multiple ways that could be done, Representative Saban, and yes, it does not say that it cannot be very fine print, but it says notify the purchaser. That could be done in an email when you get a confirmation email, it could be done multiple ways there. But I don't think the retailers are going to hide anything in such small print that
it can't be noticeable because then they would, I feel like, open themselves up to a breach of the law there by trying to mask it. And let me just add this. We don't really want to get in the business of DF&AA getting all these annual reports. easiest thing for retailers to do, and what they have been doing at an increasing rate
is just saying, we don't want to go through this hassle. Let's just collect and remit the tax. That's what this boils down to. This is kind of like a, hey, if you don't want to, you don't have to. But if you don't, this is what you're going to have to do to comply with Arkansas laws. Okay. And that makes sense to me. I
mean, I agree with you. I think that obviously the reason why we don't have that situation is because of the federal law right now that we're trying to get changed. The second technical question I had was just about, you know, the
realistic implication of this for most consumers in Arkansas, which is that with as much activity as happens over the Internet, for instance, you know, I have no idea what my wife is buying on the Internet right now, for all I know, you end up with a stack of paper, God knows how high, coming into you in January, and so does DF&A, multiplied by three million citizens. So just the idea that the citizens of Arkansas would be receiving that amount
of paperwork and then having to dive through that in order to fulfill their taxes and comply with the law and just kind of wanted to ask you about you know just the realistic nature of dfna even being able to handle that kind of influx of paperwork at the beginning of
the year well there again i defer back to my previous statement representative sabin i don't think we'll see that many because most people are going to say most retailers are going to say hey if i've got to do this i just as well collect and remit it because that's where it's going to in this country amazon's
already collecting at least 32 states. Arkansas is not one of them. In fact, I heard somebody say that it's 46 states now, but Arkansas is not one of them. It's coming, but the states that they are not collecting in are states that have failed to put any legislation in place asking or requiring them to do so. Right. And I'm going to pare my last
question down just completely because I don't want to take up too much more time.
But just I wanted to return to this enforcement mechanism to your point because I know that you know most of the states where Amazon is collecting sales tax right now it's because they actually have a you know some kind of physical location whether it's a warehouse or something like that. You know there's really no enforcement mechanism in this legislation at all obviously in terms of you know there's a fee but I mean a retailer could choose not to just basically ignore this whole thing if they don't have any kind of presence in Arkansas, and there's really nothing that we could ever do to require that they fulfill this, I mean, eventually we would
hope again that the federal law will be adjusted to make the playing field more level and fair, but I just wonder, again, you know, what really can the state of Arkansas do? We can't limit people's ability to access particular websites that don't comply. So really, I mean, what's keeping a retailer from just not worrying about this whatsoever? You all
know the enforcement mechanisms better than I did.
Certainly, just as a one point, we would certainly, with the administrative burden that is required upon DFA when we receive these annual statements, we would certainly want to work with these retailers that are filing these reports so that we could receive that information electronically, so we are not receiving voluminous records at the beginning of each year of online purchases. We would want to see about, like many of our taxpayers provide, to receive those types of records electronically so that they can utilize our
computer systems to match the reporting that we receive from the retailers with the reports that we receive from the taxpayers throughout the year. Certainly, there's always going to be circumstances where you're going to have a taxpayer, perhaps, you know, out of the United States that is going to completely disregard any obligations of our law. We hope that there aren't any taxpayers within the United States that are choosing to disregard our law and force us to, you know, issue the penalty notices and then have to collect upon
those notices. But certainly our hope with this type of legislation is that we are able to educate the taxpayers about their obligation to pay use tax that is already owed, and also to hope that the retailers are also being able to be in a position where they feel that they are legally allowed to release the information to DFA, because I think that some retailers might feel as though they don't want to release this information to us unless there's a state law in
place that directs them to do so. Representative Saban, if I didn't answer all aspects of your question,
please. Thank you. Representative, I think Representative Gray just walked out. Representative Hendren, you're recognized, sir. Thank
you, Mr. Chairman. This is not a question that I enjoy asking, but it needs to be asked and it needs to be said because I have information that my colleagues need to know.
And the reason this is difficult, Representative Douglas and I share districts as Dodson as well, and we're from the same part of the state. When I was a Democrat, I attended regularly the Democratic Committee meetings in my county, and as a Republican, I continue to do that. And this bill, I'll ask two questions at the end of this. This bill, I think, is similar to what Congressman Womack has introduced the last two sessions in the U.S. Congress to make this uniform nationwide, and it's been discussed outwardly.
And why I'm taken aback, a lot of these bills down here, we don't have input from our public. This one I do have, and I'm going to share that with you, so you need it as well. And I think I need to share that before I ask the question. I know others have given some background, so that's why I'm doing this. One of the Republican committee meetings in Bentonville in the last couple, three months, this came up with Representative Womack, and I've talked to Steve about this personally. They decided to write a letter, the committee, and as you probably know, Republican Party's birthplace is in Benton County, and they're very active up there still.
And that committee voted, as far as I know, unanimously. I don't think I voted for it because it's not the way I would have done things. But they voted to send a letter to Congressman Womack emphatically saying that they were not in favor of his legislation as long as it did not. They didn't put this. They were not in favor of his bill. I'm not in favor until there's an offset, but that's in a minute. But they sent that letter, and I told Congressman Womack the letter was coming later. And then the last committee meeting I went to is that they'd ask if they'd have gotten a response from Congressman Womack.
He hadn't responded yet. I believe that's exactly the same bill, very similar to what Representative Douglas has in this bill. And I know that that committee, as far as I'm concerned, unanimously opposed to this. And that gets me paused as I think about this because that's where I'm from. The question that they raise and that I raise is, this is a tax increase, however you slice it, unless it's offset. Now, we're very careful of saying in this committee and on the floor that it's tax neutral when it serves our purposes.
But when we come to a bill like this, we say, well, the impact statement says we don't know what the impact is. It's unknown. We don't know. So we do know there's going to be an increase of cost to out-of-state resellers because they're going to have to do these reports. But again, the impact statement says we don't know how much. We do know there's going to be an increase in taxes that people stay. So it just bothers me just a little bit as a member of this legislature and a representative of that group in Benton County that sent me down here and sent the others of us down here that I don't ask, what is the impact of this?
is an increase. And as far as we know, I don't know any cutting taxes here at all. So I guess my question after you, you all have that information now. So kind of like in the Bible says, I've given the warning. That's what people have said. And I knew it. And I've told you. So that's all I can do about that. And we'll do as we please. But
my question is this. Do you think it's a tax increase when there is no corresponding offset in some state taxes? Representative Hendrick, no, I do not. Because if you remember right, and most of you that were here in the 90th General Assembly, Representative Kelly Link introduced and passed legislation that said increases in collection of sales taxes from online out-of-state retailers, if Congressman Steve Womack had got that passed, that Marketplace Fairness Act through Congress,
If he'd got that passed, every dime collected from those collections will go to income tax reductions. So there is your offset, Representative Hendren. And let me tell you, while we don't know how much the economic impact the future revenue would be, because it's hard to tell, I tried backing into the numbers after Christmas. I saw where online shopping was overshadowed brick-and-mortar shopping on Black Friday and that weekend.
I tried to back into the numbers, and you can come up to some semblance, you know, how many billion were spent nationwide divided by 330 million times 3 million to come up with how much money would have been spent in Arkansas. But we don't know if that money was spent on walmart.com, who would collect and remit sales tax, or academy.com, who would collect and remit sales tax, or tractorsupply.com, who have fiscal presence here and do collect and remit those taxes.
We don't know if it was spent with them or if it was spent with Amazon or some of these other out-of-state retailers. It's not a new tax. It's a tax that is due, it is a tax that should be being paid, but by not having the proper legislation in place, we are enabling people to not take their proper obligation in paying
their taxes. We're enabling them not to do it. And let me tell you, there's another impact, and that is the impact of not doing this, not passing legislation, because, Representative, when we start going to our towns and we go downtown, we've seen downtown businesses close up, and we've seen downtowns die, small businesses, because of the big retailers going out to the edge of the towns, the big stores.
Wait until those places start closing. Look at all the jobs that will be lost. Look at all the property taxes that support our schools. Wait until our retail brick-and-mortar businesses close, and then you will see a direct impact. Okay. In
the impact statement here, it says the increased compliance with Arkansas's sales tax laws by Arkansas purchasers is anticipated. The amount of revenue collected is unknown. And I guess the question I'd follow up, if, as you say, that there's been a law passed
that says that it has to go to income tax reduction, why didn't
the Revenue Department put that in the impact statement? I don't know. Representative Hendren, the bill from 2015 that Representative Link sponsored that eventually became an act of the state of Arkansas. That pertains to a passage of a federal law, which
alludes. So you have the bills that were introduced in Congress, the Main Street Fairness Act, the Marketplace Fairness Act. Those are the types of bills that would have to be a change in federal law that would direct and authorize the state of Arkansas in order to collect sales and use tax from out-of-state, remote, or online sellers. Certainly, but for your constituents, concerns about this being a tax increase, this certainly is not a new tax. It is a tax that's
just already owed. The issue that's the problem for the state is that we are not in a position to know the extent of the sales that are made to the state of Arkansas by retailers that do not have a physical presence here. This bill is intended to address that. And regarding your concerns regarding the fiscal impact, and it is very difficult along those lines that I just discussed to know exactly what the rate of compliance would be. If this bill were to be
passed into law, there may still be a level of noncompliance from the taxpayers and from the retailers, but the state would be in a better position to collect upon those. We would anticipate that a majority of the taxpayers that currently owe the tax would be more than willing to send in the amounts. We certainly believe that our Arkansas taxpayers want to follow the law and want to make sure that their obligations are paid, but at this point, it would be difficult to
estimate in our revenue impact what that level of compliance would be because we have those unknowns about the amount of sales that are being made here, but also the amount of compliance that we would have voluntarily. And I
just respond to that is that you're entitled to your opinion of this, that it's not a tax increase. I believe it is. And the ultimate arbiter, that will be the voters of the state of Arkansas at the appropriate time. And I think we'd all agree with that. Thank you, Mr.
Chairman. Thank you. Let's, I don't represent, Greg, you have a question,
but indulge me here just a second, sir. All right. Thank you. Uh, let's just back up, uh, Walter, uh, Tom or Paul, one of the three guys, feel free to answer this. If you can, I'm going to put you guys on the spot. I want to refer back to the 1949 case law that put this actually into law. And I'd like somebody to explain the brief history of that to where we get
to hear if you don't care? Well, certainly, Mr. Chairman, we already had the, prior to the
compensating use tax be enacted in 1949, we had the gross receipts tax or sales tax that it predated the use tax. But once we had implemented the sales tax, it didn't take long for the members of the General Assembly as well as other states to notice that out-of-state companies that would compete with our brick-and-mortar companies, could send in catalogs, make other efforts to sell products to our market. But there wasn't a mechanism to force those out-of-state retailers to
collect the tax from the customers. So the General Assembly enacted the compensating use tax at the time in order to make sure that those purchases that were made from out-of-state retailers and sent into the state of Arkansas, that the taxpayer had the obligation to pay the tax on that item because the state was not in a position to force the out-of-state companies to collect the tax from the Arkansas customers.
Okay. Okay. So in DFA's opinion, this is lawful, but basically this bill, what it does, says the logistics of letting Arkansans comply with the law. Is that correct? CHRIS JERRAM- That is correct, Mr. Chair. CHRIS JERRAM- Thank you. Members, any other questions? If not, we're going to move towards the audience portion of this. Anybody in the audience want to speak against this bill? I'm not seeing anybody.
We have Mr. Rendy. Lynn, you want to speak for the bill, sir? LYNN RENDY- You still need me? Randy, if you don't care, recognize yourself, sir, and who you're
Speaker 74
48:34
with, and you're free to proceed. Randy Land, Executive Director of the Arkansas Home Furnishings Association. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Thank you, committee members. I know sometimes these are very tough issues. The point that I would like to make today is more about the fairness issues. In talking to one of our larger furniture retailers in the state as of yesterday, Hank Brown, who was planning on being here today with Hank's Furniture, he reminded me of two things. He said Hank's Furniture last year paid a remitted $3,400,000 in sales tax in Arkansas, and
they paid $600,000 in property tax. The people that we're talking to worried about if we offend them for having to put something on a note or to send a letter or let our customers notify, they pay none of these fees. None of them. Also, if you would, for just a moment, I want you to think about a furniture store in your district,
whether it's in your city or in your county. And you think about that person. Most of you know that person personally. They're your local support. They're members of the Chamber of Commerce. They support the schools financially, giving to every program out there. They also are in your civic clubs, your Rotary, your Kiwanis, your Lions Club. They support your fire, your police, and are very active in any charitable organization in your community.
These are the guys that are getting hurt. In the last few years, Arkansas has lost nearly 50 furniture stores. Fifty. And what's happened is our laws are so much lenient than other states on these issues that they're targeting Arkansas Internet sales more than anyone. And we're losing these to, in our industry, mostly North Carolina, where they call and they say, you know, yeah, or Internet.
You don't have to pay sales tax. So our people do it. What happens? They ship it. And all of you know, some of the furniture doesn't like it comes in damaged. Then they call our guys and want them to come out and fix it. That's just not fair to us. This is a fairness issue. It's not a new tax. It stated it. It was a tax made in 1949. It is not a new tax.
You know, not very often. You see it a lot in bars and restaurants, but every once in a while, we see one of our stores. They put a padlock on if they didn't remit the sales tax. I mean, I don't understand. I mean, that's a fair law, and we should, and by law, we will. If we don't, it will be padlocked. But what are you doing to these Internet sales and Internet retailers that's killing and shutting down our stores?
I've got a gentleman today that represents one of our larger furniture stores and has, in fact, several. And I hope that you ask him a lot the questions that you need to have answered in just a few minutes. But I want to leave you with this. In our industry, we just want something fair. We don't mind. Competition is good for everybody,
but we just want to play on the same level playing field. Thank you.
Thank you, sir. Randy, we'll take questions. I'm sorry. Any questions? Thank you, sir. We appreciate you. Mr. David Ray, you recognize, sir? to speak against the bill please recognize
Speaker 77
53:00
yourself sir my name is david ray with americans for prosperity arkansas um mr chairman uh thank you
i just i would just like to very quickly um just concur with representative hindrance point that he made um it's really we can sit around and really parse the language of this and debate whether it's a new tax or a tax increase or not a tax increase. I think at the end of the day, a simple way to determine how people view this is whether or not it's going to cost them more money than they're paying now. And the fact of the matter is, there is no offset in this bill.
I believe that the bill that Representative Douglas was referring to, And I think that's reflected in the testimony from DF&A, that that would only occur in the event of passage of federal legislation. And I understand the arguments relating to fairness in this instance, but we should also consider what's fair for the taxpayer. And lastly, I would just state that this would be much better to be addressed with a uniform
piece of legislation at the federal level than a messy patchwork of 50 solutions in 50 different states. Thank you. Members, any questions? Mr. Ray,
would you take a question, sir? I'll try. Okay. Representative Deaves, you're recognized, sir. Thank
you. Thank you, David, for those comments. You know, you and I have had some discussions in the past of tax policy and exemptions. I don't really, and I generally agree with most everything you said, but except for the part where you said it's going to cost the taxpayer more if this goes through.
They're already supposed to be doing this. So are they breaking the law by not complying? I do understand that it's going to be uncomfortable for someone who gets a notice from DF&A in January or whatever and it says, hey, you bought X amount of dollars of products on wherever online and you owe $300 or $400. That's going to be uncomfortable, and it's going to be likely hard to pay for some folks. So that is an issue that I have, but they already owe that, if I understand it correctly.
Speaker 77
55:20
Well, I understand that it's uncomfortable for folks in government for there to be a tax that is difficult logistically for them to collect. But I think that this would result in, I mean, we wouldn't be sitting here debating this if it wasn't going to result in increased revenue. So it would result in taxpayers paying more than they already do. And I think, you know, most folks, I think this point was alluded to yesterday over on
the Senate side, that there is a very small amount of people who remit the use form. Um, and I, you know, I would just say that I think most citizens remit and pay their taxes in the same manner that most of you do. Well,
if I could continue just for a second, I understand what you're saying, but I don't want to, I just want to be clear that, that if I understand this correctly, you're framing this in a way to where it's going to be a new tax increase because there's additional
revenue. there will be potentially additional revenue. It's revenue that's already owed on purchases, but the burden is on the taxpayer to comply and to fill those forms out. So, and I don't know if this will do any good, this particular bill. Maybe it will, maybe it won't. The hope I think is that it will force online retailers to comply and collect sales tax at that level. That would be a lot more comfortable for everybody that purchases products, but I don't know that it's entirely fair to say that just because there's additional revenue, this is an additional tax.
While I understand what you're coming from, I still come back to the point that it's already owed. I'm likely guilty of that as well, purchasing things on Amazon. So, you know, I just have a hard time agreeing that it's a tax increase.
Speaker 77
57:14
Well, I certainly understand the points you're making, and I respect your opinion. and I think that there are legitimate points to be made on both sides of this,
and your arguments are not wholly without merit. I would just say that this bill is aimed at getting around the fact that constitutionally the Supreme Court has ruled that states cannot force remote retailers to remit and collect sales tax. And so essentially the strategy that this bill takes is to say we're going to put in place a regulatory setup that is cumbersome enough that it will be less burdensome to collect and remit.
So that's essentially what it's doing. Well, I appreciate that, and I
also respect your opinion and the work that you do, so thank you. Thank you. Do you
have one more question you take, Mr. Wray? Sure. Mr.
Wray? Thank you, Mr. Chair. This might be a question for legal staff. Is there any difference legally in not paying this tax and not paying our income tax? I don't know the answer to that question. Okay.
Thank you. Mr. Wray, appreciate you. Thank you. Mr. Wray, I'm going to butcher this name and I apologize. DAVID HAMBURCHEN? I'm sorry. Thank you. Just go down to the end of the table, please, sir, and recognize yourself, and fix my mistake on your last name, and I would appreciate that. That's the first time anybody's mispronounced my name. I understand. I get called a lot of different names,
so I know the feeling. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is David Hambacon, like ham and bacon all smashed into one word. I'm from Conway.
I have a furniture store there, and I'm one of the principals in the Lazy Boy Furniture gallery store here in Little Rock and I have another furniture store in Fort Smith I really don't think I can add much to what Randy has said or really to what anybody has said for us it is a fairness issue as a retailer in the state of Arkansas as a citizen though we were discussing about it not being a new tax from what I can tell and I'm a layman it's already on the books it's
owed granted there are people here in the state who are just ignorant of the fact that they owe it and I'm sympathetic but I was thinking on while we were discussing this you know I've been pulled over before some of our great state troopers may have pulled me over and I was going 45 in a 30 and what did they test it I didn't know I didn't know it was 30 ignorance of the law is no excuse. So I can't help it. I don't think any of us can help with it. It's already on
the books. And if this is a mechanism by which we can begin the process to educate our consumers that is is owed, it may change their mind. They may start walking into my store instead of buying something on QVC, which is the hope. And I had one other thing I
Speaker 84
1:00:32
was going to say. I can't remember what it was. It was really good. I do that all the
time. Anyway, I appreciate the time you've given me today.
I'd be more than happy to entertain any questions about retail or why we think this is a serious issue. I think everybody understands it is. The one thing I was going to add, you look around this room, and though there may be some young folks in here, a lot of us have no hair or gray hair, this problem is only going to get worse. It's not going to go away. I've seen it in my business. I think everybody has seen it. As Representative here mentioned about Internet sales over Christmas, they were now more than brick-and-mortar stores.
It's going to get worse, and we need to at least begin the process. This isn't going to fix it, but it's a good place to start. So I would hope that the committee would pass the bill. Thank you, sir. Anybody in the audience want to
speak against the bill? If not, we have one more person who wants to speak for the bill, And that's Mr. Michael Lindsay. Are you here, sir? Please recognize yourself and who you're with, and you're free to proceed. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee.
Speaker 89
1:01:48
Michael Lindsay, Director of Public Affairs for Walmart. So on behalf of our 54,000 Arkansas associates and 125 retail sites here in the state, we are very supportive of Representative Douglas Bill. We want to thank him for bringing this forward. And our comments are the same as what you've heard from everybody else. it's about fairness. It's about promoting free enterprise principles. I think one of the things that we find as a company is most interesting is that customers, their buying habits are changing.
This isn't 1980 anymore. And so we are seeing more and more of our customers move online. And as a company, as the world's leading retailer, we are trying to follow that trend too. So since Since 2011, we've seen online sales increase by 62% to over $330 billion a year. That's a big deal. And that trend is not going to stop. And so we as a company are trying to track that trend. The difference between us and other online remote retailers is that we collect remit sales tax in all 50 states.
And so we would like to have the same laws apply to other online retailers. Some of the comments, and I'll wrap up quickly and say that some of the other comments about can you require an out-of-state online retailer to collect, we've seen Amazon in probably more than 40 states over the past couple years voluntarily, once these bills pass, voluntarily start collecting taxes. And so we really feel like if this bill passes, Amazon comes to the table. And so I think that's important to remember that Arkansas is an outlier in the country
right now. So we would appreciate a good vote on this bill, and we support it, and I'd be happy to take any questions if anybody has any. CHAIRMAN
BRYANT, Thank you, Michael. Any questions, members? Thank you, Michael. Anybody else in the audience want to speak against the bill or for the bill? If not, Representative Douglas, you want to close for your bill, sir? I'm sorry. Hold on just a second. Representative Dodson. CHAIRMAN BRYANT, I asked Mr. Douglas a question. CHAIRMAN BRYANT, No, sir.
Pat? Okay. Let me hear your question. Can I
have your question? No. I just, it was an idea, a question if Mr. Douglas or Representative Douglas would be willing to possibly consider amending this bill. I'll allow that. Okay. Representative Douglas, it seems from listening to testimony and the for and against that the biggest concern that a lot of people have is whether or not these new revenues, what's going to happen with them and various things like that if people start collecting new revenues,
whether it's considered a tax or not a tax. Would you be interested in considering an amendment, I know it was referenced previously something that we did a couple of years ago, Representative Link, requiring these funds to go toward income tax reduction if we started collecting it at the federal level, but adding some sort of a similar clause into this that would require any new funds that came in based
off of reporting from out-of-state online retailers, new taxes that were collected from that that came in the general revenue to put those toward income tax reduction efforts? Reverend Douglas, before you answer that question,
I'd like to say something towards that. go down that road, be cognizant of this, that then you get into unlawful delegation to one General Assembly dictating to the next General Assembly what you can do.
So I just want to put that out there, and Representative Douglas, you're
free to proceed on that. Okay. And Representative Dodson, with all due respect, no, I would not be amenable to that amendment for this reason. We have a duty as members of the Arkansas General Assembly to look over the public fisc to protect it and to guard it and to pay, set our budget to spend money where it is needed to protect our society, to keep our prisons open, to do the business of the state
of Arkansas. We can set any tax policy we want. If the revenues go up, then we can decide, as we just did, to pass an income tax reduction. It is our decision and our responsibility and our duty to do that with what we have in front of us. At the end of the year, we see what money we have. It's our responsibility, our duty, our charge by our voting constituents as citizens of this state for us to make those decisions.
We make them every year, every budget, and so we already have that authority right now. Thank you, Representative Douglas. Close for you, Bill, now,
Representative Douglas. Okay, thank you, members. I'll try
and make this real quick. I want to tell you a little story about a retailer that had an innovative idea. They decided what we need to do is let the people shop at home. They can choose the products they want at home, and then they can order them at home,
and we'll ship them to their house address. Boy, that was a great innovative idea. It's called the Sears and Roebuck Catalog. In 1949, laws were passed, the use tax, to address this very thing because they didn't have a presence in every state at that time. And the use tax was passed so that people would pay for their purchases that they make. Sounds kind of like Amazon's story, but now Sears is going broke because of online retailers.
They won't be a presence in the state much longer. That innovative company will be gone. There's been reports maybe by the end of the year. We have to protect our businesses so that they will not go that way. As far as addressing some of the questions about what our constituents like, is it a new tax or not, I got an email from one of my constituents. And he said, I should be able to choose what taxes I pay and what taxes I don't pay.
Well, that'd be real nice. I think most of us would like to do that. How many taxes do you think we'd collect? Just because somebody says they don't like it doesn't make it right. My wife tells me that all the time. As far as tax increases, we have income taxes. I sell cattle. If cattle are $1,500 a head, I pay more income tax.
If they're $500 a head, I pay less. But if I make more, I pay more. Right now, if you buy, you're supposed to pay. If you buy more, you pay more. It's a fairness issue. It's about moving the state forward. and if we stick our heads in the sand and say we're not going to act, we're not going to act on our responsibilities, representatives of this state,
we will be last again in another category, and it's sales tax remittance. If you want to lower the income tax rate, if you want to give tax relief to certain groups, we have to have the money. It takes X amount of dollars to run state government. If we get increases here, we can lower income tax rates, but that's our decision to make whenever we look at the balance sheet of this state.
And with that, Mr. Chair, I would move a due pass, and I would appreciate a good vote.
Members, we have a motion on the table for due
have a little discussion. Thank you very much. One of the things about this issue, which has really surprised me dramatically, nationally and in Arkansas, is that common sense is flying out the window, in my view, and instead we're
mixing things together in a way that is creating more confusion than really exists. There is a reality that when the law is passed, especially as Republicans, the law enforcement party where we believe very strongly in enforcing the law, that is a different animal than what the tax rates are. Technology changes all the time in a number of areas and we adapt to that. So here we have a scenario where there is a federal solution that is being talked about. And people are saying the federal solution is something that is in debate.
When I talk to or others talk to the people in Washington, D.C., what we are told is as a state, it is your responsibility to enforce your laws. Quit asking us to do your work. So people here in this state have looked at methods and ways to better enforce the laws that we have on the books. There are three reasons why people do not pay their taxes. Number one, they do not know they are due.
Number two, it is too confusing or too much of an inconvenience to comply with the law. And number three, they are a tax fraud, a tax evader, and a tax cheat. Of those three reasons, I believe the first two, people are unaware or they are confused and don't understand how to do it, are the majority of the issue. Not that the people of Arkansas are tax cheats and tax evaders. This bill is a perfect balance of informing, making aware, and making clear and convenient
for all Arkansans when there are online purchases have already had the taxes paid, like when you buy from about 80% of online retailers, and when they haven't. And like most people, we all have a file where we throw our papers all year long to do our income taxes. And this is just another two or three or eight pieces of paper you throw in that file. It's a great bill. That's my discussion. Thank you,
members. What just took place is Representative Collins opened up a debate after the motion is made.
That is a proper order. Representative Gray,
you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Collins has articulated it much better than I can. But as a Democrat and a member of the law abiding party, I feel incumbent to say that I appreciate Representative Douglas bringing this bill. I also appreciate Representative Collins' point that this is strictly a means to inform a public that is otherwise unknowing. And I think it is unfair to anyone sitting at this table, regardless of party or
for someone to characterize this as a burden that we would further put on in the form of a new tax. So I'm fully supportive, and I appreciate Representative Douglas for bringing this bill. Representative Hendren,
you're recognized, sir. Just a quick comment. Since 1979 down here off and on, I have found that more common sense resides with the voters than it does with those of us who reside down here. Thank you, sir. Are we good?
We have a motion on the floor for do pass as amended. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, say no. No. Ayes have it, sir. You pass your bill.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. You're welcome. You're welcome. Retailers of the state of Arkansas, thank
you, too. We have one more bill to look at today, members. Is Senator Jane English in the room?
Agenda
REGULAR AGENDA Subtitle Sponsor Number
HB1253 Wardlaw TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT THAT CERTAIN RETAILERS PREPAY SALES TAXES.
HB1388 Douglas TO REQUIRE OUT-OF-STATE SELLERS AND FACILITATORS TO PROVIDE NOTICE TO D. ARKANSAS PURCHASERS REGARDING TAX DUE ON CERTAIN PURCHASES AND TO REPORT SALES MADE TO ARKANSAS PURCHASERS.
HB1037 Wardlaw PROPERTY; TAX-DELINQUENT OF PROHIBIT TO AND TO SALE THE REGULATE OWNERS OF TAX-DELINQUENT PROPERTY FROM BIDDING ON OR PURCHASING TAX-DELINQUENT PROPERTY.
HB1395 Leding TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR TAXPAYERS THAT EMPLOY A RECENTLY RETURNED VETERAN.
HB1396 Leding INCOME INDIVIDUAL TAX SCHOLARSHIPS, EDUCATION THE TO FROM EXEMPT AWARDS, AND GRANTS FROM NONPROFIT VOLUNTEER SERVICE ORGANIZATIONS.
HB1397 Leding TO EQUALIZE THE SALES TAX TREATMENT OF DUES AND MEMBERSHIP FEES FOR CERTAIN CLUBS AND FACILITIES; AND TO LEVY A SALES TAX ON DUES AND MEMBERSHIP FEES TO CERTAIN FACILITIES AND CLUBS.
HB1014 Leding TO CREATE THE TEACHER'S CLASSROOM INVESTMENT DEDUCTION.
SB120 J. English TO AMEND ARKANSAS TAX LAW CONCERNING INCOME TAX, SALES AND USE TAXES, TO SUPPLEMENT THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID AND AND THE SOFT DRINK TAX; PROGRAM TRUST FUND TO OFFSET DECREASED DEPOSITS FROM TAX REVENUES.
HB1412 Ballinger TO PROVIDE FOR A PARTIAL PROPERTY TAX EXEMPTION FOR DISABLED VETERANS IN PROPORTION TO THE EXTENT OF THE DISABILITY OF THE VETERAN.
DEFERRED BILLS Subtitle Sponsor Number
HB1028 Lemons TO EXEMPT CERTAIN BUSES, COACHES, AND OTHER MOTOR VEHICLES FROM SALES AND USE TAXES.
HB1031 Bentley TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX EXEMPTION FOR INCENTIVES RECEIVED UNDER THE COMMUNITY MATCH RURAL PHYSICIAN RECRUITMENT PROGRAM.
HB1153 Boyd TO CLARIFY THE MEANING OF "ACTUAL AND OBVIOUS ERRORS" ON THE PART OF A COUNTY ASSESSOR IN THE ASSESSMENT OF REAL AND PERSONAL PROPERTY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1221 Sabin TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTION FOR SALES BY A CHARITABLE ORGANIZATION.
HB1225 Magie TO REPEAL THE EXEMPTION FOR AND REQUIRE THE DISCLOSURE OF CERTAIN UNDER RECORDS OF FREEDOM TAX ADVERTISING THE PROMOTION AND INFORMATION ACT OF 1967
HB1252 Rye TO AMEND THE INCOME TAX DEDUCTION ALLOWED FOR MEDICAL AND DENTAL EXPENSES; AND TO REMOVE THE THRESHOLD FOR CLAIMING AN INCOME TAX DEDUCTION FOR MEDICAL AND DENTAL EXPENSES.
HB1263Jett TO CREATE A SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTION FOR PARTS FOR AND REPAIR OF AGRICULTURAL EQUIPMENT AND MACHINERY.
HB1227 Farrer TO REDUCE INCOME TAX RATES IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES; AND TO REDUCE INCOME TAX RATES BASED ON THE GROWTH OF INCOME TAX COLLECTIONS.
SB114 Hester TO AMEND THE REQUIREMENTS FOR PUBLISHING NOTICE OF DELINQUENT TAXES ON MINERAL INTERESTS.
HB1399 Ballinger HONOR ARKANSAS VETERANS ACT OF 2017.
HB1409 House TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION FROM THE INCOME TAX FOR SERVICE PAY AND ALLOWANCES OF FOREIGN SERVICE PERSONNEL.
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Speaker 1
Representative Joe Jett Chair
Unverified
Representative Dan M. Douglas
Unverified
Speaker 24
Representative Warwick Sabin Chair
Unverified
Representative Charlie Collins
Unverified
Speaker 45
Representative Ken Bragg
Unverified
Representative Jim Dotson
Unverified
Speaker 31
Representative Kim Hendren
Unverified
Speaker 74
Speaker 77
Representative Les Eaves
Unverified
David Hambacon
Unverified
Speaker 84
Speaker 89
Speaker 34
Representative Michelle Gray
Unverified