Public Health, Welfare and Labor Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (26)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1021
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1021 TO PROVIDE PAY EQUITY FOR WOMEN; AND TO AMEND THE WAGE DISC…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1034
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1034 C. Fite TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING HEARING INSTRUMENT DIS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1040
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1040 Farrer TO LIMIT THE PRACTICE OF ATHLETIC TRAINING IN A NONC…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1160
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1160 A. Mayberry TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF A "SPECIALIST SIGN E…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1180
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1180 Bentley TO AUTHORIZE ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES TO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1181
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1181 Sullivan TO CREATE THE TRANSITION TO PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1182
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1182 Sullivan TO AUTHORIZE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO ALLO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1183
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1183 Dotson TO PROVIDE CONSISTENCY AND EFFICIENCY OF CHIROPRACTI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1186
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1186 Brown TO REMOVE THE COLLABORATIVE PRACTICE AGREEMENT AS APP…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1204
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1204 Magie TO ALLOW PHARMACISTS TO MAKE BIOLOGICAL PRODUCT SUBST…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1205
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1205 Magie TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS ANESTHESIOLOGIST ASSISTANT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1215
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1215 Love TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING THE PRACTICE OF MASSAGE TH…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1228
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1228 Hammer TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY OF AN ADVANCED P…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1237
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1237 Hammer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS SURGICAL TECHNOLOGISTS ACT; A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1250
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1250 M. Gray TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS DENTAL PRACTICE ACT; TO AMEND…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1254
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1254 Magie TO TRANSFER REGULATORY AUTHORITY OVER ADVANCED PRACTI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1255
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1255 D. Ferguson TO CREATE A TEMPORARY CHARITABLE DENTAL LICENSE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1257
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1257 Richey TO CREATE THE COMMUNITY HEALTH WORKER ACT.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1264
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1264 Pilkington TO PROVIDE FOR REIMBURSEMENT FOR HEALTHCARE SERV…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1267
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1267 L. Fite TO CREATE THE USED TIRE RECYCLING AND ACCOUNTABILIT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1280
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1280 Magie TO PROHIBIT THE USE OF TANNING EQUIPMENT BY MINORS; A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1300
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1300 Miller TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES TO PRIOR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1405
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1405 Lundstrum TO AMEND LAWS RELEVANT TO UNEMPLOYMENT TAXES, UNE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1411
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1411 Penzo TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECKS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1413
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1413 Boyd TO CREATE THE ALTERNATIVE TO DISCIPLINE ACT; AND TO PR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB95
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB95 Irvin TO WAIVE THE LICENSURE RENEWAL FEE CHARGED BY THE ARK…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 14, 2026
of us. If we could, I'll go ahead and let DHS come to the table. They've got a rule to run first. If you guys look on your agenda and in your packet, it's A on your agenda. And, Brad, if you would introduce you and your colleague, and then you're recognized to proceed.
Thank you. Good morning, chairs. Good morning, committee. My name is Brad Nye. I'm with the Office of
Speaker 7
0:43
Legislative and Intergovernmental Affairs for DHS. And I'm Robbie Nix, the Director of Policy and Research for the Division of Behavioral Health Services, DHS. And the rule for review today is the rehabilitative services for persons with mental illness or RSPMI moratorium amendment number seven. The purpose of this rule is to extend the current RSPMI moratorium on DBHS certified RSPMI sites until June 30th, 2017.
This update is necessary so that DBHS maintains control over the amount of RSPMI sites that are certified to provide behavioral health services. To enroll as a Medicaid provider, RSPMI sites must be certified by the Division of Behavioral Health Services. And we have no information that any eligible Medicaid beneficiary experiences difficulty obtaining medically necessary RSPMI care or services. With that being said, I'm open for any questions or comments.
Are there any questions from the committee? Seeing none without objection, this rule stands reviewed. Thank you, guys. Thank you for putting us on the agenda today. Thank you. Is Ms. Elizabeth in the room with OMEG and ready to go? Office Inspector General, Medicaid Inspector General. I won't use those letters. I'm sorry. You introduce yourself and your colleague, and you're ready to go.
Speaker 14
2:15
Hello, can you hear me now? Yeah, thank you. So my name is Elizabeth Smith, and I'm the Medicaid
Speaker 24
2:32
Inspector General for Arkansas, and I wanted to talk to you a little bit about our office, tell you a little bit about myself, and answer any questions that you might have about our office. As you know, the Office of Medicaid Inspector General was created in 2013 by the legislature.
The purpose that we serve is program integrity. It's a federal requirement by CMS when CMS gives the states money to administer for Medicaid. This role of program integrity has always existed since CMS had created Medicaid and allowed the states to administer Medicaid. This role was served in DHS at the state Medicaid agency until 2013 when it was separated and my agency was created. I was appointed in the summer of 2015 by Governor Hutchison. Previously I served
as his chief legal counsel and prior to that I served at UAMS as the general counsel for the University of Arkansas system for about eight years. Before that I worked for the attorney General's office in state agencies. I also represented medical entities at the Mitchell firm doing medical malpractice defense work, and prior to that, I was a prosecuting attorney here in Pulaski County for the state of Arkansas. I went to law school and college in Fayetteville at the University of Arkansas, and I grew up here in Little Rock, so I appreciate your time
for us to talk today about this agency. You do have a handout. We prepared a PowerPoint, but I didn't realize you don't have PowerPoint capabilities in this room. I think it would be great if you did. So the mission of the Medicaid Inspector General's Office is to fight fraud, waste, and abuse in the Medicaid program. We detect fraud, waste, and abuse in a number of ways. We then recover improperly paid Medicaid funds.
What we look at is whether the services were actually provided to the patient. the services that are billed, whether those are actually provided to the patient. We look to see if the services that were billed were billed correctly and whether they have documentation, the provider has documentation to support that billing. If we determine that there is fraud or abuse in the Medicaid program by a provider or by a recipient, we'll refer those cases for prosecution.
We refer provider fraud to both the Medicaid Fraud Control Unit, MFUKU, at the AG's office and also to the United States HHS for prosecution. We will also refer to local law enforcement agencies if the MFUKU unit doesn't take it or if it doesn't go through the feds. We also receive referrals on or investigate fraud that recipients commit,
and we will send those over to the fraud unit at the Department of Health, I mean, yeah, Department of Human Services, and also to local law enforcement. We also recommend and implement changes in the Medicaid program, and a lot of you heard from me when we were recommending changes to the group psychotherapy billing code, and we have others that we have recommended and others that we will bring forward as well. The main way that we decide where we go for audits
is utilizing data analytics. I created a team for data analytics when I came to the Medicaid Inspector General's office. We only had auditing people, nurses and auditors, and a few management staff, and we had one person who could analyze the claims data that would come in and basically what they would do is just pull the claims that were filed by a provider and see how much money had been spent and see what those claims were for
and make determinations based on that. We also had just received a computer tool through Optum that could analyze some of that data and that was just coming on right before I started in the position. we realized quickly that we needed more people to actually be able to analyze the data and hone in on how we are going to determine where the fraud is and where the abuse and waste is, rather than just looking at a broad brush and taking a large amount of information and almost doing,
I mean, I think in the past they had been doing random audits. We really want to do a focused audit based on a real reason and a purpose. Just so you all know, when a provider is audited, it is a little cumbersome on the provider because we are asking them to go back and obtain records of patients that they had seen some months ago. We ask them to copy those and send them to us or put them on a flash drive, an encrypted flash drive, or send them to us electronically, and then they can mail those in typically
if we do a desk audit. Sometimes we'll do a field audit where we actually go to the provider's office and we'll let them know what we're looking for and we'll ask them for the records, and then they will comply. They'll stop what they're doing. Their billing office will stop what they're doing, and they'll collect those patient records. And so we're trying to be more focused and have smaller areas of audits and be very focused in our determinations when we go for audits because we don't want to be predatory, and we know it's cumbersome on the providers. So on your handout, you'll see, I think it's my fourth slide, it's called OMIG Data Analytics.
We use a fraud detection system, and I think this is real interesting, and I hope you'll find it as interesting as we do. The provider spike detection system is a tool that we use, say we get a complaint, where someone calls in and says, I think this provider is not billing appropriately. And so we will put that provider's information, we'll look at their information in our computer system, and we can see all of those provider billings for years.
And we can see, wow, there's a spike in every August. This provider spends twice as much, they bill twice as much money in August. Why would that be? You know, that might be a red flag. Or if we see that something has happened with a provider, maybe we had done an audit on a provider, we can go in and look and see, gosh, their billing dropped very distinctly after our audit. And so we think, well, either they've corrected their behavior or maybe something was going on.
And so those are things that we use, and it's real interesting to look at over time to see when those spikes are and what's going on with the actual provider. We also can do a review of a group of providers. We call outlier identification is one of the issues, and that's where you might see a group of providers and one person is outlier. They have way more billing than somebody else. And those are two of the ways that we will find fraud is when you have someone who's billing two or three times as much as the next provider or as a provider in the same area.
We do peer review analysis. So we may look at a group of providers. You know, we did one specifically with dentists, and we had a peer review analysis, and we looked to see, and there was a number of dentists that were billing a whole lot more than the other group of dentists. Well, then we looked into it, and we actually spoke with some of them, and we found out those are pediatric dentists. And so they billed differently. It was one particular billing code. They billed differently than people who see adults.
And so those are things that we are learning from the data and that we are working with the providers to make determinations about and try to make sure that what we're finding, you know, the computer may say, red flag, this looks like a problem. But then when we actually look down into the data, we realize, well, it's not so much a problem, it's just something we need to understand. We'll also conduct algorithms, and that's where you'll take maybe two or three pieces of data and compare those, and the computer will pull that information for you. We had one where you have an ambulance, a bill for an ambulance ride,
and you ask the computer if there is an associated hospital visit because you would assume that they should have, if they have an ambulance ride, they're probably going to a hospital. And so we had the computer analyze that and make determinations about it. We used also algorithms as well as geographic visualization for another having to do with opioids, and we're just getting into that, and we're hoping that we can make some headway with this. We didn't have a geographic visualization tool in our package that we got,
the software that we have from Optum, and one of my data analytics team members has actually built something using something called Jeffy, which this is kind of over my understanding, but she was able to plot the coordinates of the state of Arkansas and where these people actually lived and where they were getting the opioids and compare that to where the physicians are that are prescribing those.
And we've just been looking at that this week, and we're going to keep working on that and see what we can find with it. But it's very interesting when you see people living in one part of the state but getting their medicines from another provider far away or even out of state. We see both recipients and providers out of state. So those are tools that we think are going to be very helpful for us in fraud detection as well as in making recommendations for the program, the future of the program.
So the next slide is about OMIG protocol. I've told you about our audits. Another thing that we're doing, this is more to work closely with the providers, is sending out provider awareness letters. When we see an issue, we just had one with hospital one-day stays where a patient may have been admitted to the hospital. Their admit date and their discharge date was the same day, but the hospital may have billed for more than a 24-hour stay.
It's not necessarily fraud. They may have admitted the patient. So some of those things come up as questions. So we looked at the data, and we did a number of audits initially, but then for the other providers, we sent out letters to those providers and said, here is the claims data that we have some concerns about. We don't necessarily believe it's fraud, but we're concerned about your manner of billing. Would you please take a look at your billing and make a decision as to whether or not you think it was appropriate?
And we've gotten a lot of really good responses back. Some of them have given us explanations as to why the billing is that way and specifically for each code. And then some have said, oh, wow, you're right. We do need to pay some money back. And so we've actually gotten some self-reports based on that. That's a lot less intrusive than an audit, and it takes a lot less time of state resources. We only have 30 people in our office, and we only have a few. you know there's only so many hours in a day when the auditors are able to go through line by line
the medical records and the billing records so this has been very successful and I think it's working out and it's really looking to increase the integrity of the program to make sure the providers know what's going on we had one provider who had gotten a new computer billing system and they didn't realize that their billing system was up coding for them and we sent them a provider awareness letter, and they actually really appreciate it because it could have been a really big problem had it gone on for a long time because they could have been receiving a lot of money that they would have to recoup, they would have to pay back, but this way
we got it stopped pretty quickly. So they were able to work with their system and correct it. We always do ask for a corrective action plan when we conduct an audit and we have findings. We also ask for corrective action plans on self-reporting just so that we can make sure going forward that the providers are correcting that behavior. We conduct a lot of provider education. The next slide lists educational outreach. Bart, he goes out to a lot of different provider education sources.
I also have Brett Hayes here, and he also speaks at a number of provider workshops. These workshops are put on all over the state by various groups. AFMC does a number of them, and then other agencies hold workshops, and we do a lot of that workshop training. We also do training on our audits. Our auditors will speak with the billing office, with the provider, and meet with those people in the office to make sure they understand appropriate billing practices, and if there's a problem, they will take the time to show the manual
and make sure they understand how to appropriately bill for Medicaid. We have also spoken at a few national programs regarding the system that we have here in Arkansas. I made a presentation regarding our group psychotherapy initiative and the behavioral health transformation issues at a conference for the National Association of Program Integrity for Medicaid. We also have had our data analytics team speak at the Medicaid Institute from CMS at the Department of Justice National Advocacy Center headquarters.
They've explained our tools that we use and the things that we're using going forward. We've told other states about our provider awareness letters, and we're making recommendations how other states can bolster their program integrity units. we have also one of our initiatives i'll tell you about a little later is a crossover initiative that we have we were asked by other states to have them learn from us on how they can recover improperly spent funds that they didn't even know had been occurring until we we told them about it
so the other thing that i mentioned earlier is the medicaid policy reform that we've been we've made recommendations for group psychotherapy. We've made some recommendations on vision. Those haven't come through yet. We've made some recommendations on pharmacy, and those have been very successful. Typically, what we'll find is that a policy may be either too broad or it may be vague. Sometimes those policies are too restrictive. I know you might wonder, well, why would we care if we had a restrictive policy? Well, the problem that program integrity
sees with a restrictive policy is it keeps it might keep a provider from being able to bill appropriately for billing for something that they actually do they may not be able to bill for that so that might give them the incentive to bill improperly and figure out a way to subsidize what what work that they are doing you hear all the time from providers well gosh I don't get paid very much for Medicaid I mean why do you care that I've over they don't really say why do they care But, you know, they feel like they don't get paid very much, and so they may look to subsidize themselves by skimming other billing codes.
And so what we want to see is appropriate billing, appropriate billing codes. We want to make sure that the providers are getting paid for what they're doing. Some of our policies, I'm sure you all know, there's some that are old that need to be removed. And then, obviously, when there is a negative fiscal impact based on the way the policy is written, sometimes it's because the policy is too broad or vague, but we're making recommendations and working real closely with DHS to make recommendations on changes that would be necessary.
So our next slide is our 2016 fiscal year report. We filed our report on October 1st, which is a requirement that we file an annual report. And in that report for the fiscal year 2016, we showed the number of audits and contacts that we had with providers. Our recoupments and recoveries totaled $2.7 million in 2016. We had 51 fraud referrals for providers and 38 beneficiary fraud referrals.
We had a total of 1,516 reviews. reviews. We did everything from field audits, desk audits, recoupment letters, provider awareness letters, and letters regarding the False Claims Act compliance. And so our total contact to and from providers was 1,516. A few of our initiatives from 2016 that were highlighted in that report were the crossover claims. What we determined was in Medicare
and Medicaid, there are dual eligible recipients where someone may have both Medicare and Medicaid. And if Medicare pays, Medicaid is the payment of last resort. And so we want to make sure that Medicaid doesn't pay unless they're supposed to pay, right? So if a provider bills for Medicare, and they then bill for Medicaid, and they're supposed to bill for Medicare, and then they bill for Medicaid next, what was happening in these crossover issues was the Medicare claim would get reversed or rejected, and the provider would pay back Medicare, but the Medicaid payment was still outstanding.
They had still gotten the money from Arkansas State Medicaid. It was still in their bank. It was still in their pocketbook. But they hadn't reversed that amount. And for each provider, the amounts didn't total very much. But the total for the state, about how much was it, Bart? I think
Speaker 39
21:07
in 2016 we recovered over half a million dollars. And it is an electronic process. It wouldn't necessarily be fraud, but when you bill Medicare, there'd be an automatic payment of Medicaid the system but the reversal
void would not happen automatically as required the Medicaid program required the providers themselves and to reimburse Medicaid when their Medicare claim was voided and it was an issue where it might happen a couple years later and it's kind of hard to go back and figure that out but since it didn't happen automatically we had a number of providers who had not made those reversals and voids of the Medicaid money as well. So we felt like that was money that needed
Speaker 24
21:43
to be returned, and we were able to recover that. And so that was one of the initiatives that we were able to share with other states
and explain how we did it and how we will continue to make sure that that happens in the future. And I realize half a million dollars may be little, but we add that up. We add that to all the other monies that we recover, and we find that to be very important. Another initiative had to do with OIG sent a letter, noticed that there were, Herceptin is a medicine that's utilized, a pharmaceutical that's utilized, and it's very expensive. OIG had done a review of states across the nation
and decided to look and see about whether or not the Herceptin claims were being paid appropriately. They sent Arkansas a letter. They thought we owed back about $130,000. And rather than just immediately paying that money back out of the Medicaid program, we looked into that to see were each of these claims appropriately paid. And we found out that actually a number of those had been reversed, and so we were able to counter what the OIG had originally stated.
We were able to say, no, we don't owe $130. I think we were able to reduce that by what was
Speaker 39
23:01
the final? I can't remember all these numbers. Ultimately, they had not performed a good audit, and we found that out and we determined that about $75,000 to $80,000 that had been reversed and the remainder we
Speaker 24
23:17
actually recouped from providers so that we wouldn't have to pay that without receiving it. So a few others, we've looked at school district matching funds. For students in a school who receive speech OT and PT therapy,
if they receive that through the school, The school district is required to pay the state match, the 30% that would be paid by Medicaid. We determined actually through a fraud issue where the school district didn't commit fraud. There was a therapist who was working in a school who was overbilling, double billing, billing when the students weren't there and when they weren't seeing the students. And in that investigation, we determined that we found out that the school district had not been paying the matching funds on that.
So we've been working very closely with the Department of Education. We worked with that school district in particular. We sent out letters to all the superintendents of all the school districts, making sure that they understand how that matching requirement works and that they are supposed to be paying those monies. And so we've been recovering funds through that way. we are reviewing emergency transportation I mentioned the ambulance issue that we had looked at previously so we're doing some reviews on that we're seeing some inconsistencies
in the way our policy manuals are written so we will be making some recommendations for changes on that coming forward I mentioned the hospital one day stay reviews the provider awareness letters you all know about group psychotherapy and behavioral health transformation which we're looking forward to in July. We did make recommendations on some edits for the pharmacy program, and that has been very successful, and we have some vision therapy recommendations coming forward. For 2017, we've already been through quarters one and two, and since our annual report isn't due
until October, I thought since I had a minute, I might tell you a little bit about what we've done just in these past two quarters, we've had 116 desk and field audits, 648 provider self-audit requests, 403 crossover recoupment letters, and that's what we were talking about, those crossover claims. 33 total provider recipient fraud referrals, and that's in just the first two quarters of this year. Last year we had, I think it was 53 fraud referrals, and so we're on track
to be having a number more fraud referrals than before. Our recoupments now stands at $1.79 million, which is a 30% increase from last year, so we are looking forward to bringing in a lot more money. We have had increased self-reporting by providers, and just in the behavioral health recommendation, behavioral health identification that we've brought forward, we have seen over $7 million in reduced billing.
through a group psychotherapy and the behavioral health issue that we had brought forward. And so just in this state fiscal year, we've seen a $7 million reduction. We will continue our crossover claims in 2017. We'll continue on the school-based therapy reviews and recommendations. We are starting an initiative. We've actually been working on this since August of last year. Very closely with DHS, we're working on the personal care assistant and home health service worker issue we believe that they need to be
registered identified in some fashion within our data within the billing data and within our computer system right now a home health company or a personal care company can bill to take care of patient number one eight hours worth of care gets billed, but we don't know who provided each hour of that care, and our concern is what we're seeing, we've had fraud referrals on this issue, we've talked with other states,
it's a big problem where we see overlaps in billing by the personal care providers, the people who are taking care of these patients one-on-one, they're not identified in our system, and we think that's very important, and there's a number of things that we've been working real closely with DHS and Craig Cloud on those issues. We'll continue doing audits. We're looking at peer group audits and continue with all the other things that we've been telling you about. Do you all have any questions?
I hope I haven't taken too much time. We do have quite a few questions lining up for you,
Speaker 51
28:08
so whenever you're ready, start taking them. Yes, thank you. Representative Love, you got a question? thank you Mr. Chair the question I have is concerning the recoupments and the recovery dollars once you recoup those dollars then what
Speaker 24
28:21
happens to them? So that money goes back into the state Medicaid program what we recover
is both the federal and the state portion we have to pay back the federal portion and that's 70% of what was paid out and so the state DHS has a mechanism and by which they pay the money back to the feds when the amount is identified as needing to be recovered. And then that 30% stays back within the state Medicaid program. Okay. All
Speaker 51
28:55
Ms. Smith, you've mentioned pharmacy a couple times since I've walked in the room. Could you elaborate a little bit on what your plans are there? Oh, the
Speaker 51
29:07
just know I've heard pharmacy twice. Oh, good. And I've got plans to do something with there. I just was wondering while we have you right here if you could just elaborate on what the plans
Speaker 24
29:16
are. Definitely. Well, what I'll do is I'll let Bart explain what there were a couple of edits that we made recommendations to with pharmacy. And I just I think I mentioned those twice because those were recommendations for changes in the Medicaid program.
And they were actually successful. And I think that I think you
Speaker 39
29:33
may be familiar. He'll explain. Thank you. When the DSS contract was awarded, a major piece of the FADS program was a pharmacy review. And what we have seen from Optum is they actually employed a full-time pharmacist in the state of Arkansas, which is very important, so we can go out and perform models, and she would have the actual background and knowledge of what's going on, and I think she's done a pretty good job with that. Our recoupments have not been very high compared to the work that's going on,
But what we have seen, especially she made some edit recommendations along with Jason at DHS, the biggest one was the Refill Too Soon edit that they put in place and also the edit requiring reversal within two weeks of pharmacy if the drugs weren't picked up. In our October review, Optum reported over a million dollars based on the Refill Too Soon edits in place that was saved by that. We're also continuing to regulate that. We're going to look at some things moving forward. One thing is, and I don't have all the knowledge, but the 340B pharmacies,
is that a pharmacy that may get drugs at a reduced rate, and they then in turn have to bill at a reduced rate for the drugs they receive at a reduced amount. We're going to be looking at that, making sure that we're compliant with that. But overall, we're continuing with the pharmacy reviews that were set up with that DSS contract and making sure we're compliant with that RFP, but making sure we're doing it the right way when it comes to pharmacy reviews. So for you and for others, it's not anything different what we're doing now. Just continuing on, trying to find the right way to audit and review those.
Speaker 51
31:08
You recognize for your follow-up. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just want to say I agree that refill too soon edit was a good edit, and I appreciate that work. Thanks. Representative Bentley, you have a question?
Thank you, Chair. Elizabeth, thank you so much for all the hard work that you've done. and I appreciate it on behalf of this data. I've got a quick question for you. On the opioid prescriber data with the data analytics, can you see spikes in that, in opioid prescription?
Speaker 24
31:40
We will. We can. What I looked at just this week with my data team was a map with, it was almost like a string map and connections. But, yes, we could. If there's something specific that you're interested in, we can look at that. You know, the Health Care Task Force brought forward the, I think it's been called the Opioid Frequent Flyers, where they had four, a recipient that had four or more prescriptions for opioids from four different pharmacies, from four different, and that would be an analytic, and that would have been an algorithm that would have pulled that information.
And so from that, we're trying to tackle it and get some ideas what to do. But I'm happy to talk with you if you have some
thoughts. I just hope we would look at that and see what we could do. Since we have such a huge problem
Speaker 24
32:33
with that, what could we use in the analytics to find folks that are abusing it? Right. And I'm on a work group where we are looking at making determinations on places to have Narcan brought around to various areas within the state to make sure that the law enforcement agencies have that available as necessary.
Thank you. Thank you. Representative McGee, Dr. McGee, better yet. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. I apologize if I ask this question. Maybe you went over it and I dismissed it, but what were your vision therapy recommendations? As an ophthalmologist,
Speaker 24
33:13
Yes, yes, good. So we've made a recommendation. We've worked with DHS and AFMC. We have reviewed. We found a concern.
It actually has to do with a vision therapy for pleoptic therapy and some other issues related to that. And we have worked with DHS and AFMC has put forward a recommendation. It's still at DHS in the policy office getting ready to be recommended. So it's not actually on y'all's desk yet, hasn't been sent over yet. But I would love to send you a copy of that and be happy to talk with you about it. I would appreciate it. Because I think you'd be interested, for sure.
Speaker 78
33:53
I'd be really interested. Afterwards, we can talk about it. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative
Speaker 85
34:01
Hammer, you recognize? Thank you, Mr. Chair. You mentioned about having to recoup some money from the schools. That school that you found they weren't putting their match. Have you recouped that
Speaker 24
34:12
money? We did. They quickly paid it back. Right. And so that amount of money, it was about $180,000. and that was total state funds. I know I mentioned earlier with recoupments,
70% goes to the feds, but this was total state money because it was the state match that they weren't paying in, and so we didn't have to pay any of that $180,000 back to the feds, but we did. We worked closely with that school district. We can bring forward a presentation about the whole school-based issue. It's kind of convoluted. it's a lot there's a lot of detail that goes in that follow-up mr. chair you
Speaker 85
34:55
recognize and that's where that was my next question was as as you get deeper into this and as you broaden your base of where areas you're looking are you seeing symptomatic problems that are occurring as schools you know begin to offer more services that are built to Medicaid services themselves or can you kind of give us a quick review of that if you're seeing that to become the trend? Is it problematic? I think what we saw
Speaker 39
35:22
with that billing issue is you have a school district
who has usually an accountant or a bookkeeper, and they may not have the expertise to be a Medicaid biller as well as all the other bills and things they keep up with. Some schools outsource that. Some schools use MITS, which is a State Department of Education program, but it can be concerning and problematic. So we have seen that total with the Medicaid match funds we recovered from multiple school districts, but one was a major one. They weren't aware of the issue and they didn't have the expertise and they were relying on outsourced private entities to do that.
And there's an issue with the old MMIS and how that's set up for them to build that way that caused the issue so it is a big issue we did we sent over three or four hundred letters to school districts at the first of the year saying be aware of your match be aware of your requirements and what we're going to look at hopefully is to see if that had an impact because we'd hope to see this first half of the school year more match funds being paid because school
districts that may not have been aware of that are not now aware you have to pay that back so we're going to try to run some analytics it'll take a while to do that but hopefully we can see that our initiative in our approach has actually caused moment to
Speaker 24
36:45
be saved and paid back and if I could the the way it works is the speech therapist is if it therapy that's provided within the school the speech therapist is required to there when the bill is submitted there's a modifier that's supposed to be placed on the claim and either the school if the
school district is billing or if it's being billed through METS or if the speech therapist is billing separately outside of the district or outside of the METS program it's on the therapist to place that modifier on the money that goes to the therapist is the same the modifier is what triggers then a bill that comes to the school district from the Medicaid from state Medicaid and it says dear school district you owe this amount of match money so the school district did not receive a bill for that amount of match money it's not like they had a bill that
they didn't pay they didn't know because the therapist was committing fraud and not only was the therapist billing for more services than were being provided the therapist also was not utilizing that modifier and so these there it's kind of a long it's kind of a long story and so some some therapists provide services in the schools and some therapists provide services outside the schools and we we saw actually the one of the ways this came up we in the same week we had an
issue this issue with fraud but we also got a letter from a school district from an attorney on behalf of a school district that said hey we paid $13,000 in matching funds for kids that don't go to our schools anymore and don't receive services we want our money back and I said what's going on that was one question I said what how does this all work and why is why are one person is paying too much and these people are not paying enough and so that's what we've done is we've investigated it and we've worked closely with the Department of Ed they've been very willing to talk with to
help us the MITS group has been meeting with us we've we've learned a lot we're still working on it and we're wanting to make sure that we can make good recommendations going
Speaker 85
38:49
forward mr. chair comment to the chair please maybe and I know we're fixing it into an even bigger pace of work but somewhere before we get out session I'd like to ask maybe if they could just come back before this committee or when we're out of session we would at least get a report from them and make this a topic of discussion because I'm afraid school districts as
is being implied may be sitting there thinking doing something's okay and that money's got to be paid for somewhere out of that school's budget and and so I'd like to at least have that on discussion and I'd like to be moved the bottom list let me ask one last quick question please
Speaker 85
39:31
bills that's fine thank you the 2.7 that was actually recovered that you're showing on your report and the referrals that you show that you made was that money where was that money paid back to it has
it all been collected and those referrals is that like to the prosecuting attorney or who who did
Speaker 39
39:48
that go back to please so it's it's when we When we report, we report on recoupments and collections because those are two separate numbers. Sometimes we will have a recoupment, maybe it will be a $100,000 case with a provider and they appeal it or we win or we're successful in getting that recouped. However, they may pay that back over time with recoupments from their future Medicaid payments. Sometimes we settle cases and they pay it all up front or in installments.
It just depends on the situation. So when we report recoupments, that is sometimes reversals, which happen automatically, sometimes it's through settlements and payments, and sometimes it's through future payments from Medicaid billing. Collections, we also track those, and they will sometimes lag behind the amount of recoupments, but we both track recoupments and collections each and every year. On the fraud referrals, any time we find a credible allegation of fraud, we're required to report that to the Attorney General's office for investigation.
Most of our referrals do go to the Attorney General's office. If it is not provider-related fraud and it's beneficiary fraud, we refer that back to DHS for their review of that as well. Thank you. And once again,
I want to thank you guys for the hard work you guys do and appreciate you keeping the integrity of the system intact. Thank you so much. We appreciate your time. Guys, we've got a little housekeeping to do. House Bill 1040 is going to go to deferred without objection. I've got an agreement from the sponsor.
We have some special guests with us today. I want to recognize one of them to give us a good introduction. Can I get Mr. Jeff Hankins, Vice President of Economic Development for the ASU system? And you're going to recognize our special guest. Thank
you. Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman. I appreciate it. Our special guest is the leadership from the New York Institute of Technology College of Osteopathic Medicine on the campus of Arkansas State in Jonesboro.
First of all, we have Dr. Barbara Ross Lee. She's the Vice President for Health Sciences and Medical Affairs, and she's the founding dean of the campus. She and NYT agreed to partner with us to develop this school in three very short years. She is a pioneer in medical school education. She was the first African-American woman to become dean of a medical school in this country.
She started serving inner-city Motown way back when and then moved into medical education and has been on the forefront of leadership in the country regarding medical education. So this is, she has led this project from the beginning. She has recently turned over the dean position to Dr. Shane Spites, who is also here, a native of Arkadelphia. She's been practicing medicine in Jonesboro for many years. We also have Dr. Amanda Diehl, who is assistant dean of the College of Osteopathic Medicine.
And, again, we're very grateful for everything that she has brought to the Delta and the Mid-South to help Arkansas State transform medical care and medical education throughout the region. So I want me to welcome Dr. Barbara Ross-Lee. Well, good morning. I am
Speaker 96
43:27
very pleased to have this opportunity to speak to you and bring you up to give you a status report on the second medical school in the state of Arkansas.
My title is Vice President for Health Sciences and Medical Affairs at the New York Institute of Technology and served as the founding dean for this very innovative public-private collaboration that allowed us to open a medical school on the campus of A-State in Jonesboro. I just wanted to let you know that we started our first class this past August. We are approved for a class of 115 students per year. And the first class, our purpose for doing this is to educate physicians in Arkansas
that would serve in Arkansas and the Delta region. So in the first class, 48% of our class are from the state of Arkansas. Over 90% of the entire class, of course, including those from Arkansas, are from the Delta region and the Delta states. So we're very proud of what we've accomplished in this first year. We are right in the middle of finalizing the class for the second year, which will start in August of 2017.
Two-thirds of that class has already been named, and indeed we still have a significant percentage of that class who at this point are coming from the region and from Arkansas. So I wanted to address some of those questions that I have heard as I've interacted with communities around the state about this new medical school. So as I go through, please, if I don't touch the bases of the things you've heard and clarify them for you. Feel free to ask me when I complete this.
As you know, the reason that we, NYIT and Arkansas State University came together was to address a significant workforce shortage in the state of Arkansas, specifically related to physicians, and specifically related to generalist physicians, and those physicians are the family physicians, the general internists, the general pediatricians, OB-GYN. Those are the specialties that are in significant shortage in the state. NYIT has a very strong track
record in educating and producing those kinds of physicians that serve in underserved areas, mostly in New York, but all around the country. And so we wanted to bring that expertise to Arkansas to address this issue. Now, for those of you who are aware of the medical education process, most of your knowledge is based upon the MD model, which is certainly practiced by the University of Arkansas Medical School. That model requires large tertiary care hospitals
that are broadly based with deep subspecialties. The osteopathic model is different. Osteopathic Medicine educates its students in community-based hospitals, and all of your communities have hospitals, and all of your communities probably have some level of physician shortage. So we educate our students in those communities, which increases their likelihood for staying
to practice in those communities. And that is the model that we bring to this endeavor at Arkansas State University. It's important also that part of our philosophy is to have a continuum of education. Not only do we have to be concerned about medical education, but I know that we're all aware that there seems to be a shortage of graduate medical education in the country, not just in the state of Arkansas.
And so part of our initial strategy was to increase the number of residency training slots in the state of Arkansas. And I'm pleased to say that we have facilitated the development of over 200 additional GME positions in the state today, and we still anticipate another 200 over the next year or two as hospitals come on board to develop residency training programs. programs. And we're very pleased with that. But medical education does not start or certainly
the potential physicians don't start from the first day of medical school. It requires a pipeline that begins as early as K-12. So part of what we have launched and are beginning to launch much more broadly is what we call a pipeline with K-12 programs bringing in high school students into the medical school, providing them with some exposure and experience to medical education, as well as undergraduate programs in the institutions of higher education
in the state of Arkansas. We have a BSDO program. It's an articulated program with the undergraduate degree and these students go directly into medical education. We have articulation agreements with five higher education institutions in the state of Arkansas. And so we are building that pipeline as we go. Having said that, one of the unique features of being able to start a brand new medical school
is that you can incorporate those future needs and expectations of physicians into the curriculum without having to change a lot of other things. Based on that, we've launched certificate programs for our students. So in addition to meeting all of the requirements to graduate and get a DO degree, they also must earn two certificates, or they're encouraged to earn two certificates.
The four certificates that we are offering based upon the needs of the communities that are underserved and certainly rural communities are a certificate in evidence-based medicine, a certificate in health informatics, a certificate in population health, and most importantly, a certificate in telemedicine. And so we are delivering telemedicine education to our medical students beginning in their very first year. Having said that, I hope that I've given you a snapshot of what we're doing in Arkansas State University,
and I'm open to questions.
Yes, ma'am, and we have a few. Lining up. Representative Ferguson, Vice Chair, has got the first
question. Thank you so much, Dr. Ross Lee, for being here. I certainly hope the osteopathic school in Jonesboro will help my area in West Memphis to attract physicians. I do have a question. Did you say you've created
Speaker 96
50:46
200 GME residency positions? We facilitated the development of 200 GME positions.
And part of the reason I use that terminology is we, in osteopathic medicine, we tend not to control the residency training programs. We partner with hospitals to provide some research and other kinds of resources that small community-based hospitals may need. But the residency programs are owned or certainly managed and directed by the hospitals. So we help them to see how they can do it,
and we provide some of the resources they may not have that are required for residency training, but they are not our programs. The programs belong to the hospitals. I'm sorry.
I have to go speak at the Heart Association. That's what my timer was for. No, I applaud that, and I know the people that are on this committee for a while have known that that's been a real concern of mine. is, you know, we've increased the size of medical schools, but we haven't concurrently increased residency positions because they were frozen back when Clinton was president.
In fact, we had 20 students from UAMS last year who didn't get a residency because they didn't match and had to scramble to find positions, and they can't practice medicine if they don't do a residency, even in family practice. So how are these graduate medical education residencies being paid for? Are they being paid
Speaker 96
52:19
for by the hospital or by CMS? There are two different ways. One is being, well, two strategies. One hospital is supporting these residency positions on their own, so it's kind of self-pay.
But the other programs are being supported or will be supported by CMS because, number one, there's a phenomena in graduate medical education called virgin hospitals. These are hospitals who've never had residency training programs before. The cap immediately for Medicare on expansion caps those hospitals that have been involved in graduate medical education in the past. But hospitals that haven't been involved, new hospitals that are located and serve underserved communities,
specifically like rural areas, can apply for support from Medicare, and they tend to receive it based upon the depth of the need. And so half of the programs that are established are self-supported, and the others are supported by CMS. That's great. Thank you. I applaud your efforts to do
that because I think certainly where people tend to do the residency is where they tend to stay in practice. We found that with the AHECs. The other thing, I don't know if the committee understands that the Medical Board license
osteopaths and MDs equally. They're both doctors under the Medical Board licensure, but thank you so much and I applaud
Speaker 96
53:50
your efforts. Can I take this opportunity to say, because I usually start when speaking trying to explain MD-DO. The MD degree and the DO degree are equivalent across this country. medicine is an American phenomena. Osteopathy exists all around the world, but osteopathic medicine is an American phenomena, which is why DOs are licensed in every state in this
country and it's an equivalent degree, so much so that very recently the residency training track have come together. So both professions graduate from undergraduate school, but they all go into the same residency training programs okay thank you representative ladyman you got
it's not a question it's more of a statement but I wanted to mention this I appreciate dr. Ross Lee
coming and just so you all know she didn't know she was coming until eight o'clock this morning when I text Shane Broadway I found out that she was coming to Little Rock and I asked Shane if she would come talk to us so you know you did a great job for preparing for three hours so I appreciate that and then also I wanted to tell the committee that in Jonesboro we have already seen or in the cricket in the Northeast Arkansas area we've already seen a good economic impact from this school with the faculty and the students moving in for the first year it's been a really good program and I just wanted to thank
Speaker 96
55:27
much. Can I ask my new dean, Dr. Spites, can you come and sit up here with me so I
don't feel quite so alone? Yes, and I would too share the thank yous with Representative Ladyman for what you guys are doing because it is definitely a hole in our communities in the rural areas, and from what I've seen and what I've read, this will help fill a big gap and we definitely need that gap filled so thank you guys for what you do and hope we can
continue to support you in any way. Thank you. Representative McGee are you ready? you're recognized to run house bill 1280 and if you would have your debt your guests introduce their selves and we'll get
started mr. chair i have with me today dr brian russell who's going
to testify in a minute about the importance of House Bill 1280. He's a practicing dermatologist trained at UAMS. He currently is president of the Arkansas Dermatology Association. He's going to give us his five-minute, three-to-five-minute update on why this is such an important bill. What this bill does, committee, is at the present time in Arkansas, if you're under 18 years of age, all you have to have is parental consent to use a tanning facility. What this bill does is it does away with that and basically says if you're under 18, you cannot use a tanning facility.
And the reason for that and the reason it's so important is tanning facilities, although that sounds pretty benign, that they are carcinogenic. They cause cancer. They are ranked as a level one carcinogen right there with asbestos and with tobacco. So this is a public health issue, and I'm sure Dr. Russell will get into a little more testimony about what it means from the dermatological standpoint. And with that, Mr. Chair, I'd like to turn over to Dr. Russell, and we'll try to go as
quick as we can. Thank you. Just
Speaker 131
57:46
yourself for the committee, he's recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ladies and gentlemen, and distinguished members of the House Public Health Committee, as As Dr. McGee said, I am a dermatologist in Conway and president of the Arkansas Dermatological Society. We represent all 61 dermatologists in the state, and we have a half a dozen members here today in support of House Bill 1280.
Now I would imagine that all of you entered public service for much the same reason that we entered careers in medicine, and that's to be instruments of positive change for our It's my pleasure today to tell you that you can make one of the easiest decisions you will ever render as a legislator to be a positive instrument for change. As dermatologists in the state, we treat a variety of different skin conditions like eczema, psoriasis, chronic diseases, but far and away the most important thing we deal
with on a daily basis is skin cancer. cancers number more than all other cancers in this country combined, and they take on many different forms. There are over a hundred different types, but three account for the vast majority. Most people are familiar with basal cell and squamous cell carcinoma. Those cancers alone number five million as of the last reporting in this country. Thankfully,
rarer is melanoma, but melanoma is far more deadly and it is a preventable cancer. Something that I feel committed to doing in our community in Conway is teaching and I have students from UCA and Hendricks College rotate with me on a regular basis and it always surprises me how astounded they are when they see the number of cancers that we see every day. I I have a GI colleague in town who sees 15 to 20 colon cancers a year.
We see, my wife and I practice together, we see 5 to 10 a day. It's an extraordinary number. We know that upwards of 90 and in some cases 99% of all cancers are caused by ultraviolet radiation and there are two ways in this country that you can be exposed to ultraviolet radiation, sunlight and tanning beds. We do a good job of educating our kids on the dangers of sunlight. I think everybody here probably applies sunscreen on a regular basis.
But, oddly, we allow our children to get into tanning beds. Tanning beds that as of two years ago were classified by the Food and Drug Administration as, as Dr. McGee said, class one carcinogens on par with cigarette smoking. Currently, we allow teens to utilize these tanning beds with consent of their parents. Now, I would ask, would anyone here consent to purchasing tobacco by their teenagers at a tobacco store
and give their consent for that to happen? I think not, but we allow it to happen with tanning bed usage. Now, this bill removes the burden of consent from parents and makes it illegal for minors in our state to use tanning beds. Just as 15 other states currently do in our union, the FDA has actually made recommendation that all states convert to this form of tanning bed usage. This bill absolutely will save lives in our state.
It will also decrease the burden of health care expenditures and it will be an investment in our children. you as public servants can rest easier tonight knowing that you did a good thing by supporting this bill all right I had a few questions for a sponsor representative love
you reckon you're recognized for question no no question motion at the proper time okay I got you noted representative hammer you recognized for a question thank mr. chair I noticed at the end of the bill
Speaker 85
1:01:57
that physicians are excluded under certain conditions or from using phototherapy devices could you talk to that just a little bit as to which devices and I'm sure I don't know any doctors that have tanning beds in their offices but could you just explain that one a little
Speaker 131
1:02:14
bit please there are two reasons for that one is that in the communities that have poor access to medical care there are a couple of conditions and actually more than a couple but two primary conditions that I spoke of earlier psoriasis and eczema
which are very responsive to very refined ultraviolet light delivery systems we have those in our clinics they are not tanning beds so we didn't want there to be confusion over the medical use of ultraviolet light and the cosmetic use of ultraviolet light follow up mr. you recognize thank you
Speaker 85
1:02:55
and just make sure I'm reading this right the class a misdemeanor that's proposed in
this bill if a parent walks in with a child to a tanning facility and says she's 17 but it's prom and I just want to get her two or three times so that she can tan up and if that it then becomes the burden of the owner of the tanning facility to tell the parent no because I could be charged with a class A misdemeanor if I let you take my daughter in there and do that am I interpreting the
Speaker 131
1:03:27
bill correctly yes sir or you actually feel that makes it easier on the tanning bed owners as it is now the burden falls on them getting
consent from parents and it's actually much more difficult and not implemented on a regular basis. Thank you,
for a question. Mr. Chair, so just to be clear, this is prohibiting the use of only tanning equipment at a tanning facility, not tanning
Speaker 131
1:04:01
equipment in other locations? We put a provision, an amendment in there to not prohibit use in a private setting like a home.
We didn't want there to be too much invasion of privacy. So it's limited to commercial facilities. Representative Boyd, you recognize for
Speaker 51
1:04:28
be already covered this. So it says that a physician can do this in his or her own office, but if someone who's had psoriasis a physician has just told me to go to the
tanning bed would they be able to write a prescription for someone under 18
yes yes representative Payton you had a question thank you mr. thank you mr. chair can you just go through some of the options other than tanning beds I mean I know they can go outside some spray on things to obtain the tan for palm like representative hammer brought up but uh and then also i mean we've discussed that this seems to
rise to the same level as smoking would could you discuss um as far as alcohol you know we regulate it with minors matter of fact all the way up 21 years old i mean i know it's not the cancer issue But, I mean, what level would
Speaker 131
1:05:33
you place this against alcohol use? I'll address that second question first. Actually, it's an interesting question. Up until lately, we did not realize how addictive tanning could possibly be.
And in recent studies in the last 10 years, we have actually figured out that there are addictive components to tanning just as in other agents such as alcohol abuse. There have been formulations of questionnaires that have shown that tanning has a propensity to generate repetitive behaviors. And so it's our hope that by targeting teenagers to prevent them from at the vulnerable stage of life, that that repetitive behavior will be countered.
It is known, like I said, that ultraviolet light is carcinogenic. It was actually one of the first known carcinogens far before cigarette smoke. And the mechanism is very well delineated. It is on par, as I said, with a class one carcinogen by the World Health Organization. Representative Boyd, did
you have another question? Representative Pilkington, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And this may be a little bit of an odd question, so try to follow me on the logic here. Currently right now, as I understand it, when you go to a tanning salon and you're under the age 18, you have to have parental consent, which is a parent with you. Now if this bill passes, they go into a tanning salon and all they have is an ID. How do we prevent people from coming in with a fake ID? It's a lot easier to fake an ID than to fake a parent. And so, if anything, I mean, are we not making it easier for them to go in because, I mean, teens have fake IDs.
Speaker 131
1:07:27
Well, certainly there's no foolproof system. I would counter that I don't think that it's easier to come up with a fake ID than it is to come up with a parent. There are studies in Minnesota that I investigated that showed up to 88% of 15-year-olds who presented at tanning beds weren't even asked for parental consent in spite of the state laws. There is absolutely no enforcement of this rule. And I think that by taking the burden away from the tanning bed manufacturers in a way,
they simply say, if you're not 18, you can't tan. I think that is far easier than coming to a salon with or without a parent, either breaking law or coming up with consent that is really not that important in terms of the tainting salons business. They would far rather administer the service than not as evidenced by the poor implementation of the rule.
Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a
question. thank you and i guess that brings me uh what was said brings me up to the question of enforcement who is responsible for inspecting these uh this tanning uh salon to make sure that they are actually complying with the law you know a lot of times police officers or whatever will use underage to go in and try to catch the the people serving underage minors or whatever are you going to have police now having to do something above and beyond to try to catch these folks
who are not enforcing this particular law. So if you could speak to the enforcement part of it.
Well, Representative Meeks, I think that you have to fall back to what Dr. Russell said. It's up to the tanning bed salon owner to make that determination. This makes it easier for them. It makes it easier for them to just say, you're not 18, you can't do it. It's easier to do that for them than it is to have their parent.
Now, who are you going to get to enforce it? I don't know. I don't think you're going to have the police. It's not going to be like going in and doing alcohol sales in the private clubs in Conway where the ABC comes in and checks everyone. And I don't think that you're going to have a number of police that are going to do it. I think one of the things that this does do is it raises awareness. And if they begin to turn down people that are under 18, even the younger kids are going to begin to learn that this isn't good for us. It's kind of like, just like we said a minute ago,
how many of us as parents would let our kids under 18 go buy tobacco products in today's world? We wouldn't. Now, when I was a kid growing up, I did at 12. I went and bought my mother cigarettes for her. But it raises awareness to such an extent that it will decrease the use. It's not going to completely get away. We don't get around everybody not using it or be able to completely enforce it, but it will raise public awareness and decrease the number of skin catchers that we have in the future.
Speaker 51
1:10:50
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Seeing you have one more question, Representative Boyd. Mr. Chair, may I re-ask the same question I did
and phrase it a little differently? i really don't like rehashing old material but it's fine if i'm not allowed to
Speaker 51
1:11:09
but i would like to go for it okay again i've read this bill and maybe i'm missing it but my question is could if dr mcgee wanted to prescribe phototherapy could he write a prescription and send somebody to a tanning bed or is it only or do the physicians control access to
phototherapy for people with psoriasis or some other disorder that responds to ultraviolet light I mean, that's my question, and it's not clear to me that Dr. McGee could write a prescription and send someone to a tanning
Speaker 131
1:11:41
facility. Absolutely, and we actually, when we were debating this bill in our society meeting last year, that was the one thing that came up. We did not want to limit access, especially in rural areas where their patients can be far away from dermatologist offices.
So that provision is specifically there to allow prescriptions to be written and to go to tanning beds if you're under age 18. You satisfied with that answer,
Representative Boyd? Seeing no further questions, are there anyone in the audience? You got a question, Representative? Mayor? You're recognized for a question. Thank you.
Speaker 85
1:12:28
I'm taking on to what he said,
and Dr. McGee, I just offer this up as a friendly suggestion in the form of a question. One, I'm wondering if they have any of the tanning bed operators ask this because they feel the need to have that kind of coverage to intervene for a parent who's not being responsible over their child's activities, and before it gets to the Senate, it might need to be clarified because If I'm reading the number two and that's your cover for somebody writing a prescription, it doesn't seem to state that clearly enough, so I'd just offer that up as a friendly suggestion.
Would you agree or disagree, or what do you think?
I would agree. I would agree that we could change that. I would like to try to get it out of committee and through the House, and I think that's probably been an important issue. You could do that before it goes before the Senate
committee maybe? Yes. Thank you. We could do that. All right. see enough other questions or anyone in the audience speak against the bill for the bill and I have a motion for Representative Love you want to state your motion
Speaker 51
1:13:33
yes for a man that will never use a tanning bed
I do say that we should go ahead and I would say do pass for this Mr. Chair
we have a motion do pass is there any discussion on the motion seeing none all those in favor say aye all those opposed I rule the ayes have it your bill passed we got a roll call two hands
Speaker 161
1:14:23
Yes. No. Yes. No. Representative Coleman. Representative McCollum. Yes. Representative Henderson. Yes. Representative Boyd. Yes. Representative Gonzalez.
No. Representative Bentley, Representative Lundstrom, Representative Ladyman, Representative Payton, Representative Walnut, Representative Miller, Representative McGee, Representative Ritchie, Representative Meeks, Representative Branscombe,
Representative Hamler. Representative Love. Vice
McGee, congratulations. Your bill passes with 11 votes.
And Representative Miller, are you ready to go to the end of the table?
Speaker 147
1:16:45
Representative Miller, whenever you're ready, we're ready for House Bill 1300. All
OK, all right. What about now? Is that a little better? OK, all right, good deal. Committee, I'm before you today just to run House Bill 1300 to address the disability, the developmental disability waiver waiting list. Sometimes you've got to do things because they're the right thing to do.
This bill is a simple bill, but it will have a big impact on a lot of lives, if passed, life-changing effects. Folks on this waiting list, I know we're all familiar with it. Representative Mayberry ran the bill a couple of weeks ago that allowed for the shifting of tobacco settlement money to come over to cover this waiting list. This is an issue that we've been familiar with for some time.
What Representative Mayberry's bill did is brought over enough funding. It was a good bill. I was proud to support it. It covers 500 to 700 folks on a 3,000 person waiting list. Um, that's great, but what if your family is number 701 to 3,000, that would still leave you kind of feeling like you're hanging out in the breeze.
This bill, I want to address one thing first. this bill is not going to have a negative impact on human development centers, nursing homes, or other type of institutional care. That is not our intention. We simply want to make these 3,000 folks that are on this waiting list a priority to get the services that they need. I understand the concern from
the nursing homes. They're afraid it's going to affect their bottom line, plain and simple. I can assure you I'm not trying to take one penny of business away from nursing homes, human development centers, or other type of institutional care. We simply want families to have the choice of caring for their loved one at home and being able to receive the the benefits that they that they need that they deserve most everyone on the
waiting list could already be in an institution could already be in a nursing home if their families had not made the decision to care for them at home another concern that's been brought up is the woodwork effect of this legislation folks are gonna come out of the woodwork to sign up for this the the woodwork effect was a term that we all got real familiar with when we did the private option a few years ago this is a whole different ballgame there's
not going to be a hundred thousand folks come out of the woodwork for this you have to have a severe disability a qualifying disability folks I don't even physically qualify to be on this waiting list that's the facts some things up I just asked that I asked that y'all think about this think about if if you had a loved one that was on this waiting list if you had been waiting for a decade or
longer to get these services you've seen the state of Arkansas expand our health care system and expand things that we've been doing to care for folks and yet you've been sitting there waiting on services for over a decade we have a chance to correct that right now and I just asked that the committee do the right thing and give this give this a due pass thank you
Speaker 85
1:21:50
thank you mr. chair of the 3,000 are currently on the waiting list those are not in nursing homes or the human development centers now correct that is correct okay follow-up mr. chair yes sir you recognize for follow-up it seems that there's a hinge pin in this bill that if there are not enough community providers as determined by the department that this explain that last
part where it seems like that hinge pin is if there's not enough community providers the the expectation of responsibility to move forward with this is
is is is mandate that DHS have this list eliminated within three years and and there is the the hinge pin that you're talking about is at the at the end of the three years if there are not enough providers in the state to care for to treat right now right now according to
reports there's not enough providers in the state right now to care for all three 40,000 of these folks now. I happen to believe that when When these folks move from off the waiting list on to the waiver the providers will show up When there's a when there's a funding mechanism there the providers are going to show up in order to in order to do this work so that that's the one thing that we did put in there that at the end of three years if If it's determined that there's not an adequate number of providers,
then the three-year limitation would be, I guess, defunct or whatever at that point until we got the adequate number of providers in the state, if that makes sense. Mr. Chair, I'd like to
appropriate time, please. Okay. I'm sure you'll get a chance for that. All right, Representative Payton, you got a question?
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Miller, your bill basically requires DHS to prioritize spending
and put the members of the waiting list at a higher priority. From what you're saying, every member of this waiting list has already been determined to have a medical necessity. Do you know of any DHS spending that is currently targeted at citizens without medical necessity? Thank you for the question, Representative Payton. I believe the
first paragraph of the bill would address some of that.
Yes, I mean, obviously this has been brought to light and been made much more of a concern after we've done Medicaid expansion. We've done the private option now. Arkansas works. I'm not trying to rehash that debate or anything, but folks on this waiting list have sat and seen billions of taxpayer dollars spent here in the state of Arkansas on able-bodied working-age adults for their insurance and other needs, and they're still sitting there waiting.
And so this bill is intended to assure these folks that they are a priority moving forward with the state within DHS. Representative Ladyman, do you have a question? Yes,
I agree with your bill here. I think it's a good bill. It's something that needs to be done. I totally agree with getting that list down to zero. my concern is when you talk about prioritizing this funding to that
waiting list and and I think the question was asked people in human development centers are not on this list there are some people in human development centers on this list it may be a small amount but when people go into the Human Development Center I'm very familiar with this I've been in all of them in the state they try to get them on the list and they actually go to the top of the list because they usually are the ones that are at most of most need and that's fine but the human development centers are needed there are people that cannot function on this
waiver list they're not capable they're needed and they if you've ever seen some of the living facilities in these human development centers they need to be improved tremendously there's a lot of needs out there but my concern is when you talk about prioritizing funding and this will be the top priority i know you say there's nothing coming from the human development centers but that's open to discussion in my opinion is there any way you could put something in here that would would clarify that that that we're not saying okay the human development centers are going to be
below the uh the waiting list folks or funds are not coming from that if you understand my question Is there
some way to clarify that? Well, yes, sir, there is, and I'm open to discussion about that. I would say, you know, the Human Development Center discussion goes on every year, and I agree with you. We need to improve a lot of things within those Human Development Centers. Facilities need to be updated.
I'm a hundred percent on board with that and and we'll support that fully what what I'm saying with this bill is that if if you are in a human development center your family and and and you or whatever have made the decision to go that route and then you are being you're being cared for if you're on the waiting list your family wants to keep you at home but they're having to do it all on their own without assistance and without help and and and so I want to see
those folks who have waited for over a decade get the care that they that they want I totally agree about the Human Development Centers be happy to discuss that with you know I do not want to take funding away from Human Development Centers at all and if we need to address that maybe over on the Senate end or something like that be happy to do it thank you and I
don't want to I don't want you to misunderstand I wouldn't ask this year follow-up representative ladyman sorry mr. chairman thank you I was not asking more money for the HDC's
but just not to take away from but any
more questions from the committee for sponsor yeah i got you all right um if i if you don't mind representative walmac you recognize for one last question for sponsor thank you mr chair uh representative miller
would you be willing to pull this down and put some language there kind of addressing mr ladyman's concern i think the intentions are completely honorable and pure and i'm i would love to be on board with it but
I would love to have some assurance in language in this bill that there will be an effort made to make sure that we don't pull funds. You know, the Human Development Center population, because I agree with you, that's the same group, really, we're working at, but I would love to see language in the bill to offer some protection there. Is that a possibility?
I wouldn't say it's an impossibility. I would say there's been no secret that we were going to do this bill since Representative Love and I sat down here two years ago and ran virtually the same bill. And anyway, the bill's been filed for over a week, and we're just now hearing about this. But if that's the desire of the committee,
I'm open to that discussion. But I'm not wanting to take anything away from human development centers or put any undue burden on them or anyone else in that category. We simply want to fund this waiting list. And I would be happy to give you my word
we can make that amendment on the Senate end or whatever, if that'll work. OK, Representative
get the department to the end of the table and see if they have anything to add and then see if they can answer a few questions from members. You going to stay up here with us? Representative, former Representative Link,
if you don't mind, introduce yourself and Ms. Stone.
Speaker 196
1:31:23
I think it's Mike's hot, but it's good. It sounds real hot. It is hot. Mr. Chair, I'm Kelly Rank, legislative intergovernmental affairs for Department of Human Services. Good
Speaker 198
1:31:36
morning. Melissa Stone, Director of the Division of Developmental Disability Services for the Department of Human Services. Okay, do you all have
Speaker 196
1:31:45
any kind of statement about the bill,
or do you all just want to go straight into questions? If I could do kind of the usual disclaimer, we're not here for or against this bill. We are here to give testimony, and unfortunately the way the testimony is going to sound probably sound like we're against the bill but to be full disclosure we're not against it there are a number of issues that you know Department Human Services will have dealing with the statute if it's passed but that's not we're not here to work against it matter of fact you know as far as this statement goes we're completely in agreement with with representing Miller and we are working
to do away with this waiting list the the Mayberry's bill is wonderful that idea was probably brought to them by the department as we found the money to do that not probably it was I mean that was in agreement with the department found the money was in the first our first priority was to we got to get this waiting list eliminated or decreased so we are working toward that with this mandate obviously it will be done can use bill passes can you talk about those issues
you just mentioned I'm curious to hear what what those could be so I agree
Speaker 198
1:32:57
with Kelly I think we've testified several times that the DD waiver wait list is a priority not only for DDS but for DHS and the governor and we are actively working on ways to come up with additional funding mechanisms to pay for the waiver the difference between the way that this bill is currently drafted and the bill that was signed into law on Friday is that the bill that was signed using the tobacco settlement funds was a pool of dollars that was no longer being utilized because Arkansas Health Network program had been terminated.
And so it wasn't pulling funding away from an ongoing program. So I think our concern would simply be that this would, based on some rough calculations I did last night, if we just go on the average cost of what each waiver client costs right now, we would need about $43 million of state general revenue within our current Medicaid budget that has obviously at this point in time been allocated for other programs that would be ongoing.
So that's the difference between how this bill is currently drafted and the tobacco settlement funding. But all that being said, again, we are not here to oppose. it would be something we would we would work through but it is that's just the reality of that the money is being utilized for other ongoing Medicaid programs at this time representative hammer you're recognized
Speaker 85
1:34:32
mr. chair we've sat through multiple meetings over the last couple years regarding the individuals that are in the community
waiting for these services what is the current status of community providers that would be able to take on this population as of right now would it be a thousand fifteen hundred three thousand can you give us that snapshot
Speaker 198
1:34:58
no follow-up mr. chair please yes sir so currently the particular group of provider we refer to for this population is the DDS waiver provider network we have around 90 and waiver providers who are certified to provide various
services under our DDS waiver. The last time that we went and pulled data showed that about 65 of those providers were actively in use. Just to give an example, with the tobacco settlement funding, we anticipate serving between 500 and 900 new individuals. We sat down, we have an implementation team on how we're going to roll those clients into the waiver services quickly because we agree they've been waiting a long time and they need to get services as soon as we can do it we are trying to cultivate and grow about
375 direct care workers to support those clients because we are in the midst of an employment shortage and we are working with providers to try to come up with incentives and certifications and various projects on how to grow that particular pool of people follow-up mr. chair you recognize for one follow-up thank you the
Speaker 85
1:36:14
environment several years ago when we were taken to court and had
to by court order take care of all these people what's the difference in the environment when that happened and today that if we don't deal with this legislatively it's just something waiting for somebody to initiate the action in the courts and we'll have to deal with it anyway so I don't want to I don't want to give
Speaker 198
1:36:39
you the wrong information on that I was not at DDS when the court case came which is about 10 years ago but I'd be happy to research that and did to provide a response if you would if you would
provide that to mr. Phil and he'll get that to the committee representative love you
Speaker 51
1:37:00
recognized for a question thank you mr. chair and I think this is I'm I'm going to speak directly to the former chair of the committee. A couple of years ago, as Representative Miller did state, we did run a bill in regards to CFCO, and the match was much greater for CFCO versus the Medicaid rate that we're getting, 70 to 30, or 75 to 25. Can you speak to me in regards to, and then this bill,
I guess the bill that Representative Miller has, if we would have passed it two years ago, this bill wouldn't be necessary. So can you speak to me on how you will prioritize waiting list clients and why CFCO was not really given a fair assessment by DHS? Well, not being at DHS
Speaker 196
1:37:55
at the time of the CFCO discussions,
discussions. I don't know that it wasn't given a fair look by DHS. I think DHS kind of brought CFCO to the body, which at that time I sat, and I don't think that the body was favorable towards CFCO is my recollection. I know that Tammy Harlan is here. I'm going to revert
Speaker 196
1:38:22
wasn't DHS at the time. I'm Certainly not in any mode of arguing with your representative at all.
You follow that matter a lot closer than I did, so I would certainly defer to you on however CFCO came about. What we're looking at is this bill and what it may bring to DHS, and there's no way at all to predict what would come about in the next three years, especially with the changes we're going to see in CMS and in the federal government remember we're dealing with the federal money I mean Medicaid is federal money and and the ways that we go about it and the waivers which we
seek in order to obtain that money and I think it would be my prediction and probably it would be clear to most people of this committee that we're gonna see changes federally and how that money comes about and it may loosen up our budgets in ways that we can't even think of right now I'm not sure it may be more burdens on on state to use state funding to pay for without federal aid so it absolutely impossible to predict how we would meet this mandate in three years it may be easily met but I can tell you this with the governor's power
to priority of depleting this waiting list and that being passed on down to DH if the money starts loosening up and we're able to make that match I'm confident that we're going to do it with that with a mandate or
you're recognized for a question thank you mr. chair I may do a poor job articulating this but isn't the vast amount of evidence that a member on the DD waiver that gets funded and gets care at home
saves us a lot of money from if they were to go into institutionalized care and don't all of these people on the waiting list qualify for institutionalized care so let
Speaker 198
1:40:28
me start with your latter question if that's okay so yes everyone that's on the wait list, which is about 2,900 people right now, have filled out an application packet and the appropriate testing and have been deemed eligible for institutional level of care, which means at this very moment, they could ask to be admitted into a human
development center or a private facility. As far as the cost, we're very careful to say it's not an apples for apples comparison because there's a daily rate, a bed rate for living in a human development center and there's a daily rate for being on the waiver and they're very comparable but there's a lot of other costs that go into a human development center such as medical, food, rent that's being accounted for in that bed rate
that aren't being accounted for in the waiver. You'll hear it from both sides depending on who you're speaking to on if there is cheaper in the community or more cost-effective in an institution. I know that based on just the capital improvements that sometimes happen with the buildings, such as that with the human development centers, the cost is a little higher. If I could have a follow-up.
You're recognized for a follow-up. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So some of the questions surrounding how this would affect funding for human development centers, is that just based on the fear that they may lose a patient
Speaker 198
1:42:06
or two? No, sir. So right now, if you are admitted into a human development center and you would like to go back out into the community and receive services, under federal law, we're required to give you a waiver slot and we transition you out into the community. So no, it's not a fear,
and I don't want to speak for the human development center parents, But as far from DDS's perspective, it's not a fear that they're actually going to lose clients or lose people to fill beds. I think it's more of a fear that because it's saying to prioritize funding and not saying all of these programs, including nursing homes, assisted living, all of these programs are paid for out of the Medicaid budget. And because this is not extra money, this is going towards a program, I think there's fear that money will be pulled from one of the other programs to pay for this one.
Am I out of questions? I'll put you at the end of the queue because I've got
a whole list. Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Could you give us a status on the waiver that is currently requesting, such as has it been approved yet and if it would actually cover what this
Speaker 198
1:43:21
bill is actually trying to accomplish? Yes, sir. So the waiver that is under amendment right now, as you know, is every effort in writing that waiver and through those amendments
is to make the waiver as cost-effective as possible and serve the most people that we can. But it would be a stretch to say that we are going to make it so cost-effective that it will serve this many people under the current funding. So I guess a follow-up, Mr. Chair. Yes,
Speaker 230
1:43:53
you recognize. so this waiver would not cover cover this bill you would potentially have to ask you know after
this waiver is either proved or disproved whatever the case would be you probably would have to come back either in a year or two years or three years and ask for an additional waiver to cover
Speaker 198
1:44:15
additional people that we're saying so the way that it works is when you ask CMS you have a maximum number of what they call slots, I guess, and a maximum financial dollar amount to fund those slots. So if this was added we would have to go in and ask for an additional 2,500 slots and show that we had the money to support those slots
Speaker 51
1:44:46
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm gonna go back to Ms. Stone. I'm I'm going to go back to what Representative Payton, I guess, picking up from where he is. In regards to the HDCs and the wait list, how many people on the waiting list are in the HDCs? How many people?
Speaker 198
1:45:04
So there should not be anyone on the wait list that's in an HDC.
If they ask for a slot while they're in an intermediate care facility, which also would include a nursing home or a human development center, They are given a slot under federal law, and we transition them into the community. So I guess technically they could be on a list during the time period it takes us to get them transitioned out. So from the moment they ask for it to the 60 to 90 days until we get them back out into the community, they would be waiting. Okay. All right. Thank you.
Representative Payton, you're recognized for another question. Thank you,
Speaker 230
1:45:43
Mr. Chair. And if you can recall my line of question, it was based on why the
human development centers would be concerned about losing funding. So this bill asks for you to prioritize your funding and your spending. Do the human development centers have a reason to fear that they're so low on the list of priorities that they would receive a cut in funding?
Speaker 198
1:46:10
So as the director of DDS, they're very high on my priority list, the Human Development
Centers, but this is asking the Medicaid budget, which involves a lot more than me. The majority of our programs at DHS are funded through Medicaid funding, so it would be above me on prioritizing, I believe. Representative Lateman you're recognized
cost comparison here that we're discussing and I know I've seen some of the
numbers where it shows that people on the waiting list that go out in on the waiver program that the cost is less than at the Human Development Center but as you said I don't think that captures all the cost and let me ask you a couple questions to try to confirm that if someone is in a human development center and they go out on the waiver program when they're in that human development center if the center has a work center they are participating in that correct if they're able to do that based on the
evaluation of that particular person they also get physical therapy if they qualify for that through the HDC they also get speech therapy they get occupational therapy they get many many things when they go out on the waiver program the waiver program itself does not provide sheltered employment that's basically up to whoever's responsible for that person or that person themselves also it it might pay for physical therapy but there are
associated cost with that that really is not covered by the waiver program there are many other things like that that are not counted so I would next is that true that's
Speaker 198
1:48:08
my question so the funding streams yes it's complex I agree with you that many things that are encompassed within the daily rate of an HTC when a client transitions on to waiver that they receive things such as therapy and medical and pharmacy outside of the waiver through the medicaid state plan ultimately it's
all medicaid dollars but yes you have to look at the totality of the services and add them up to get a cost so i do agree with you you recognize
thank you mr chair so we can't definitively say and i'm not trying to put you on the spot here i'm just trying to get the facts we cannot definitively say that one is more expensive than the other because we can't capture all those costs I mean, we have an opinion. Is that correct? Yes.
Speaker 198
1:48:59
I would say I don't have a definitive cost analysis in front of me today, but I'm happy to follow up with you on working on this issue. Thank you very much.
Mr. Chair, if I could, one more follow-up. Let me
come right back to you because you're allowed a question and a follow-up, and then we'll put you back in the queue. Representative Meeks you're recognized for question and then I'm coming back to Representative
Lateman okay thank you and I guess representative Peyton kind of spurred this on because this does say the Department of Human Services shall
analyze and so you're looking at spending within the whole department which I'm assuming would include things such as our Children and Family Services Center and everything else so and this might be the question that mr. link means to do so in this case if this bill were to pass then you potentially would have to take money from our children and family services from other programs that we you know with that we really want to be able to fund but this would
cause you to have to potentially pull funding from other areas in order to in order to pay basically in order to meet the requirements of this law is that correct yes that is correct represent
Speaker 196
1:50:16
makes and again so we throw in the the fluid factor of what's going to happen federally into this too so there obviously there's no way to know or there's not like a priority list hanging on the wall DHS of number one priority is X number two is action and this would make it to where when we walk in there'll be number one priority in three years is
funding this but yeah the money's gonna have to come obviously from somewhere and there's no way I mean in this bill doesn't tell us from where that money will be moved so that'll be up to obviously Department Human Services and the governor to find where that money from where it will be moved into this program and his phone up
when you're talking about state funds if you really wanted to go to the next step
that we might also have to pull money from other sources such as education prisons as far as a priority of the governor in order to potentially meet this would you also say that that is a fair statement as well
Speaker 196
1:51:21
well yeah I mean the state general revenue I think the estimate that Melissa Gabriel was 43 million in state revenue so that's got to come obviously from somewhere and you guys hold the purse strings I mean ultimately comes from from wherever you
decide I mean the governor makes a recommended budget and ultimately it's up to the legislature as to where that money comes from so yeah I mean we've got to find 43 million somewhere although does this I'm not sure that this bill states it must be found
all right thank you representative hammer you recognize for question. Thank
Speaker 85
1:52:04
you, Mr. Chair. First question would be, as it stands today, even if this bill
went through, do we have the waiver slots or the slots in the waiver that would allow this intent of this bill to move forward because we have the slots available in the current waiver to take care
Speaker 198
1:52:24
of the 3,000? So currently our waiver allows us to serve right around 4,100. We're going to have to go in and ask centers for Medicare and Medicaid to allow us additional slots to fund additional people.
Speaker 85
1:52:38
Follow up, Mr. Chair. Something that was said by one of y'all, I can't remember, I just heard it, but as far as establishing what it costs, I got the impression from the answer to the question a while ago that we don't have a way to 100% say it costs us this much to take care of a person in this scenario. Did I misunderstand that, or could you clarify that? Because it would be hard to base budget numbers if you don't have a good system in place to determine true cost.
Speaker 198
1:53:11
So as you know, we continuously at DHS work on our IT functioning so our systems will talk to each other. One of the roadblocks right now is we can't accurately pull the data or easily pull it to see if the clients that are on waiver are also receiving other state services such as food stamps or maybe HUD assistance. So those dollars right now we're working to capture so we can get an accurate depiction of the waiver client cost to the state of Arkansas
versus the cost of a resident or an HGC. Representative Ladyman, I'm back to
question, but is there going to be discussion at the end of this? I might want to make a statement later. There will be discussion on a motion if we have a
motion. Okay. Thank you. I'm sure we will, by the way. I'm just saying.
Seeing no further questions for the department, I have people signed up to speak for and against. Okay. If we could, can we get Mr. Zach Hall to the end of the table? He's going to speak for the bill. Mr. Zach, can you hold on one second? Mr. Payton, I'll hear your motion. I'm not saying I'm going to accept it. I understand. I'd
like to make a motion that we postpone it to the first item of business Tuesday?
I would tell you that I would take that motion if it was second item because I already have something important on first. Okay, I'd like
to make a motion that we postpone it to the second
item of business on Tuesday. I'll take that motion. Can we discuss it? Yeah. Is that debatable? The motion is debatable, so I'll hear your discussion, Representative Meeks. Well, we've got people
that are here to speak for and against, and I just want to make sure that if we postpone it, We're not putting anybody out of their way.
Maybe they've driven a couple hours or whatever. So I would say if people are okay with coming back. Representative Meeks, I would tell you that
I share that same concern. So if the committee would indulge, we could hear Mr. Zach and whoever else wants to speak. But we would do the same as we did Tuesday and postpone that vote to the later meeting without rehashing those items. Okay, thank you. Representative Payton, would you be okay with
that? I would. I'd just like to mention that I don't think we're going to have time's not going to afford everybody to speak anyway.
So I would agree. People interested may want to. Some of these people on
the list are common setters in our meetings. OK, thank you, Mr. Zach, if you would introduce yourself for the committee
Speaker 230
1:56:05
and proceed with your testimony. I'm Zach Hall with the Arkansas AWA Waiver Association and the waiting list people. Can I have a guest come up with me? Yes sir. I would like Wanda White to
come up. I will strip for myself to read to the congregation. I have been on the waiver waiting list for many years. Now I have waiver services. I am happy today I'm out of HDC I also am here today to ask you guys to get the people that are
still on the waiting list services I am happy if this bill would pass I know lots of friends and people are on the waiting list Thank you, Mr. Zach, and are there any questions
from the committee for Mr. Zach? Representative Payton, you're recognized for a question. If you said so, I may
have missed it, but how long were you on the waiting list? Many years. Thank you.
a question, too, as well. We had talked in the task force about people on the wait list maybe not needing all services. what primarily services are you waiting for?
Speaker 232
1:57:55
you're recognized to answer a question. Hello, I'm Linda White with the Arkansas Waiver
Speaker 233
1:58:00
Association. The question was that some people may require not all service,
what types of services? Yeah, I understand that most of the people on the waiting list are undergoing a reassessment to determine what tier level of services they might need. Has he had that assessment to know, I mean, does he need supportive living? What type of services is
Speaker 232
1:58:23
he primarily waiting for? Well, many individuals will be, have been assessed with a preliminary assessment and then will go through another reassessment. That will determine the level of care that those individuals would need.
And surprisingly enough, it's been found that many of the men, women, and some of the children aren't requiring a tremendous amount of services and supports. Some individuals and families are requiring as little as some 10, 12 hours a week, whereas other individuals, as Zach and I know, require more additional services of up to 24 hours, seven days a week of intense supports and services. So to answer your question, there are many individuals who are at a point of requiring a variety of services as little, very little services that they need and some more intensive services and complex services and support.
I guess I was asking him specifically what services he was specifically waiting for and where is he on the waiting list? because I know we've allotted some additional money that will get 500 people off the waiting list. I am actually not on the waiting list,
Speaker 230
1:59:35
but I have some people that are still on the waiting list. So can I ask a question? May I ask a second?
Yes, ma'am. So are you receiving services now? Yes. I'm not on the waiting list. Yes. Okay, thank you.
Speaker 85
1:59:58
Representative Hammer, you're recognized for a question. Thank you. I understood, make sure I understood correctly, you said you were in an HDC and then moved out to the community, is that correct? Correct. The time that you were in the HDC, for the whole time that you were in the HDC, how much were you counseled or educated or made aware of your opportunity to move out of the HDC into the community?
Speaker 230
2:00:21
Lots. I had family working with me. I had people at HDC working with me, trying to get me out of HEC. I had an annual meeting, and they asked me if I'm ready to get out of the HDC. Very good. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Thank you. Representative Ladyman, you're recognized for a question.
Yes. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Hall, thank you for coming and talking to us. You're welcome. I just had a question about now that you're off the list and you're out on the waiver program, what are some of the things that you're able to
Speaker 230
2:01:10
do? I mean, are you able to do all your work program? Yes, I work at ICM, and I do different stuff there. I make dog treats. I make art.
I also go to, sometimes I go to the movies, sometimes I go grocery shopping, things like that. Do you enjoy the work? Yes. Do you enjoy the pay? Yes. Thank you very much. Seeing no further questions, Mr. Zach,
I do want to thank you for coming and testifying against this committee today. You're welcome. Ms. Carol, Sherman, do you guys want to testify today or Tuesday?
go to the end table. if you would ma'ams introduce yourselves for the committee and then you're recognized to proceed and for the committee's record their speaking is concerned I don't know if that's for or against
Speaker 243
2:02:45
going to want me to go first I didn't find out about this bill until yesterday, so I apologize. Typically, I would send out emails to the... Say who you are. I am Jan Fortney. I'm sorry. I know so many of you. I'm sorry. Jan Fortney. I'm a mother of a profoundly disabled daughter, adult daughter, at the Conway Human Development Center. She's been there about 23 years.
She's 41. We'll be 42 in March. So she was at home for a long time. We waited a long, long time ourselves for these kinds of services at the center, which is what she needed. So I understand the waiting part. It's just terrible. But I do want to say that I'm also a member of our statewide parent group. All of our HDCs have parent groups, and all of those belong to a group that we get together
that's the statewide group, which is all of the parents that have loved ones at the HDCs. I wanted to address HB 1300 today because I read it last night, and while I appreciate the spirit of the bill, and I fully want that waiting list fully funded, truly I do. the DD waiting list has been a sore spot for so many of us
and it's divided us from time to time and that is not necessary we need to give these services to people that need them not the ones that don't need them like representative Miller said able bodied Arkansans I have concerns that if it's passed it could affect other already existing programs just like many people have already said but the words analyze and reprioritize is what bothered me in the bill I think that you know we have a good working relationship with director
stone from DDS and I know it's a priority for her and her whole department and I feel like that it is for DHS as a whole as well Miss Carol and I have attended every one of the health care task force reform meetings and I mean every one of them and even before that the payment care of improvement initiatives for years we know that the department has changed I feel like it's for the better I feel like they're truly in
their hearts they want to do what's right for these people they truly truly do I would hate to see a bill that would tie their hands to help the ones that are already helping in order to try to help others. I think they need to move forward with the plan that the governor put forth and the task force, you know, and Mayberry's bill addressed with the tobacco settlement money. Moving forward to do those 500 to 900 people, that would just be awesome.
I think the governor even proposed, well, at first, The tobacco settlement money, it's going to draw down $29 million, I think. So that's pretty substantial compared to the $43 million. I think that's starting to work toward eliminating the waiting list is what I'm trying to say. I believe that the governor has also made known that any savings that the Arkansas Works is going to generate would be used to address the rest of the individuals and their services that they need that are on the waiting list.
I know many of y'all heard that same thing. I think there's a plan already in motion. And so this bill concerned me. It could make some substantial cost cuts to some programs that would really hurt these programs. And I'm going to tell you, as a mother from CHDC, I guess it was in 2010 or 2011, I can't remember the year, but we took an 11% cut across the board. and it was it was tremendous our program suffered and I know for a fact that DDS
has already found cuts to make in in their programs and to have to if this bill would have passed it had to make them cut some more our folks would not be getting the care that they need so I think that's all I have to say if
Speaker 244
2:07:30
a statement as well? Thank you. Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, thank you for the opportunity to come and express concern about this bill, which if
passed would mandate that a certain group of individuals qualified to receive services would go ahead of everyone else. And unless the bill contains language that would mandate that it wouldn't come from another DDS program, I would have to be against it. i've heard so many discussions and inferences here about the cost of care at the human
development center i apologize i realize i didn't say who i was i'm carol sherman i live in little rock my son john is 48 he functions on the level of a young toddler he can't come here and advocate He has been at the Arkadelphia Human Development Center for many years And before that at the Conway Human Development Center for respite care When we were young people
I'm 74 now I can't take care of John I want to express my unending thanks to you Our elected representatives For the support you have given the Human Development Centers over the years the cost of care is as Melissa said so complex it's impossible to put a dollar amount on a young family able to take care of a child during holidays on the weekends and at night that's a
piece then you have cost shifting to other programs if they're in public school that's their day piece Waiver, by definition, does not include room and board. That's another piece. So when you see the HTC per diem cost, it's all-inclusive, and they have set costs. They have the most severe of the population. I'm sorry, we would like to provide you with the current profile of an HTC person.
I know at John's Center, over 50% require one-on-one feeding. They cannot feed themselves safely. What's the dollar amount for that? The level of cognition, there's just how do you put a dollar amount on what it takes to take care of someone who has no concept of danger?
and who is nonverbal. That's my child. And on the grounds of an HDC where he lives, I've described this before, one of the greatest joys I have is to stand at his cottage and see him coming from a great distance where he has gone for his daily training program, walking in safety, unaided, going home.
And no one's going to abuse him. No one's going to, a car won't strike him. He can walk that path in safety. So thank you for your public service. Thank you for the consideration of these emotional issues. Jan and I, I believe, speak for our statewide parent guardian association Association and urging you not to mandate
one needed program over another. I'll be happy to answer any questions. Seeing none, we would thank
you guys for coming and testify. Representative Miller, do you have anything to say before we adjourn to Tuesday? I can just say
Speaker 246
2:11:52
it Tuesday. I'm hungry, let's go eat. With that, we stand adjourned. Thank you.
Agenda
HB1040 Farrer TO LIMIT THE PRACTICE OF ATHLETIC TRAINING IN A NONCLINICAL SETTING.
HB1264 Pilkington TO PROVIDE FOR REIMBURSEMENT FOR HEALTHCARE SERVICES PERFORMED BY A WALK-IN CLINIC OR EMERGENT CARE CLINIC WHEN THE PATIENT DOES NOT HAVE A PRIMARY CARE PROVIDER ASSIGNED.
HB1267 L. Fite TO CREATE THE USED TIRE RECYCLING AND ACCOUNTABILITY PROGRAM.
HB1280 Magie TO PROHIBIT THE USE OF TANNING EQUIPMENT BY MINORS; AND TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "TANNING EQUIPMENT".
HB1300 Miller TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES TO PRIORITIZE SPENDING WITH THE DEPARTMENT AND THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO FULLY FUND HOME- AND COMMUNITY-BASED SERVICES FOR INDIVIDUALS WITH DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES
HB1405 Lundstrum TO AMEND LAWS RELEVANT TO UNEMPLOYMENT TAXES, UNEMPLOYMENT BENEFITS AND UNEMPLOYMENT ELIGIBILITY.
HB1411 Penzo TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECKS FOR NURSING LICENSURE TO REMOVE A CONFLICT IN THE LAW.
SB95 Irvin TO WAIVE THE LICENSURE RENEWAL FEE CHARGED BY THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF DENTAL EXAMINERS, THE STATE BOARD OF OPTOMETRY, AND THE ARKANSAS STATE MEDICAL BOARD FOR CERTAIN ACTIVE-DUTY MILITARY HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONS.
HB1413 Boyd TO CREATE THE ALTERNATIVE TO DISCIPLINE ACT; AND TO PROVIDE FOR TREATMENT OF NURSES LICENSED IN ARKANSAS WHO SUFFER FROM IMPAIRMENT.
Scope of Practice Bills Will be Considered in Committee During the Week of February 13, 2017 - February 17, 2017
Subtitle Number Sponsor
HB1034 C. Fite TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING HEARING INSTRUMENT DISPENSERS.
HB1180 Bentley TO AUTHORIZE ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES TO HAVE SIGNATURE AUTHORITY.
HB1181 Sullivan TO CREATE THE TRANSITION TO PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY ACT; AND TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY OF ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES.
HB1182 Sullivan TO AUTHORIZE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO ALLOW AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE TO BE A PRIMARY CARE PROVIDER.
HB1183 Dotson TO PROVIDE CONSISTENCY AND EFFICIENCY OF CHIROPRACTIC COVERAGE IN THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM; AND TO ALLOW MEDICAID RECIPIENTS DIRECT ACCESS TO A CHIROPRACTIC PHYSICIAN WITHOUT REFERRAL FROM A PRIMARY CARE PHYSICIAN.
HB1186 Brown TO REMOVE THE COLLABORATIVE PRACTICE AGREEMENT AS APPLICABLE TO ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES; AND TO CLARIFY THE PROCESS NECESSARY FOR AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE TO QUALIFY FOR PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY.
HB1204 Magie TO ALLOW PHARMACISTS TO MAKE BIOLOGICAL PRODUCT SUBSTITUTIONS.
HB1205 Magie TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS ANESTHESIOLOGIST ASSISTANT ACT
HB1215 Love TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING THE PRACTICE OF MASSAGE THERAPY TO INCLUDE THE PRACTICE OF CUPPING.
HB1228 Hammer TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY OF AN ADVANCED PRACTICE NURSE.
HB1237 Hammer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS SURGICAL TECHNOLOGISTS ACT; AND TO ESTABLISH THE REGISTRATION OF SURGICAL TECHNOLOGISTS.
HB1250 M. Gray TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS DENTAL PRACTICE ACT; TO AMEND THE DENTAL HYGIENIST COLLABORATIVE CARE PROGRAM; TO MODIFY THE APPOINTMENTS TO THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF DENTAL EXAMINERS; AND TO MODIFY DENTISTRY SPECIALTY LICENSES.
HB1255 D. Ferguson TO CREATE A TEMPORARY CHARITABLE DENTAL LICENSE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1257 Richey TO CREATE THE COMMUNITY HEALTH WORKER ACT.
HB1254 Magie TO TRANSFER REGULATORY AUTHORITY OVER ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES FROM THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF NURSING TO THE ARKANSAS STATE MEDICAL BOARD.
HB1021 TO PROVIDE PAY EQUITY FOR WOMEN; AND TO AMEND THE WAGE DISCRIMINATION Love LAWS CONCERNING PROHIBITED CONDUCT AND REMEDIES FOR VIOLATIONS OF THE WAGE DISCRIMINATION LAWS.
HB1160 A. Mayberry TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF A "SPECIALIST SIGN ELECTRICIAN".
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Chair
Unverified
Speaker 2
Speaker 7
Speaker 14
Speaker 24
Speaker 39
Speaker 51
Speaker 28
Representative Mary Bentley
Unverified
Representative Stephen Meeks
Unverified
Speaker 53
Speaker 78
Speaker 85
Speaker 96
Representative Deborah Ferguson
Unverified
Representative Jack Ladyman
Unverified
Speaker 112
Speaker 131
Representative Austin McCollum
Unverified
Representative John Payton
Unverified
Representative Aaron Pilkington
Unverified
Speaker 106
Speaker 161
Speaker 171
Speaker 147
Representative Josh Miller
Unverified
Speaker 86
Representative Richard Womack
Unverified
Speaker 192
Speaker 196
Speaker 198
Speaker 230
Speaker 217
Speaker 226
Speaker 232
Speaker 233
Speaker 242
Speaker 218
Speaker 243
Speaker 244
Speaker 246