Public Health, Welfare and Labor Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (33)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1267
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “If you're ready to present your bill, House Bill 1267. And I believe”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1300
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…Doc. Representative Miller, are you ready to go? Let's go. House Bill 1300, continuation. He has an amendment.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1021
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1021 TO PROVIDE PAY EQUITY FOR WOMEN; AND TO AMEND THE WAGE DISC…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1034
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1034 C. Fite TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING HEARING INSTRUMENT DIS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1040
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1040 Farrer TO LIMIT THE PRACTICE OF ATHLETIC TRAINING IN A NONC…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1160
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1160 A. Mayberry TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF A "SPECIALIST SIGN E…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1180
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1180 Bentley TO AUTHORIZE ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES TO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1181
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1181 Sullivan TO CREATE THE TRANSITION TO PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1182
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1182 Sullivan THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO ALLOW AN ADVANCED…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1183
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1183 Dotson TO PROVIDE CONSISTENCY AND EFFICIENCY OF CHIROPRACTI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1186
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1186 Brown TO REMOVE THE COLLABORATIVE PRACTICE AGREEMENT AS APP…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1204
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1204 Magie TO ALLOW PHARMACISTS TO MAKE BIOLOGICAL PRODUCT SUBST…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1205
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1205 Magie TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS ANESTHESIOLOGIST ASSISTANT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1215
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1215 Love TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING THE PRACTICE OF MASSAGE TH…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1228
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1228 Hammer TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY OF AN ADVANCED P…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1237
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1237 Hammer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS SURGICAL TECHNOLOGISTS ACT; A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1250
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1250 M. Gray TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS DENTAL PRACTICE ACT; TO AMEND…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1254
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1254 Magie TO TRANSFER REGULATORY AUTHORITY OVER ADVANCED PRACTI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1255
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1255 D. Ferguson TO CREATE A TEMPORARY CHARITABLE DENTAL LICENSE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1257
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1257 Richey TO CREATE THE COMMUNITY HEALTH WORKER ACT.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1264
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1264 Pilkington TO PROVIDE FOR REIMBURSEMENT FOR HEALTHCARE SERV…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1405
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1405 Lundstrum TO AMEND LAWS RELEVANT TO UNEMPLOYMENT TAXES, UNE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1411
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1411 Penzo TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECKS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1413
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1413 Boyd TO CREATE THE ALTERNATIVE TO DISCIPLINE ACT; AND TO PR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1428
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1428 Lundstrum TO AMEND LAWS CONCERNING UNLAWFUL ABORTIONS; TO A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1434
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1434 Collins TO CREATE THE SEX DISCRIMINATION BY ABORTION PROHIB…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1437
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1437 D. Ferguson TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING TELEMEDICINE; AND…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1439
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1439 M. Gray TO AMEND THE HEALTHCARE QUALITY AND PAYMENT POLICY…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1443
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1443 M. Gray TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE ARKANSAS STATE BOAR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB170
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB170 Irvin TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION FOR LICENSURE FOR HEALTHCARE P…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB229
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB229 S. Flowers TO REQUIRE CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECKS FOR ALCOHO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB78
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB78 Bledsoe TO REQUIRE THE ARKANSAS STATE MEDICAL BOARD TO PERF…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB95
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB95 Irvin TO WAIVE THE LICENSURE RENEWAL FEE CHARGED BY THE ARK…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 14, 2026
If you're ready to present your bill, House Bill 1267. And I believe
Chairman. It's on the tablets, committee.
KLC 166. All right. Yes, sir. I would appreciate
a good vote on the amendment. It changes the bill and makes it
a better bill. I have a motion on the amendment. So moved by Representative Bentley. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed. Your amendment passes. Representative Fite, you're recognized to present House Bill 1267 as amended.
Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair, committee. I appreciate this opportunity to explain the bill. And let me first start off and say that the county judges voted to support this bill.
Also, Farm Bureau supports this bill. And this bill brings accountability and efficiency to government. It requires them to do a business plan in which they are funded back on according to their cost. Arkansas Economic Development will help them develop this plan, and ADQ will approve this plan. In no way does it take away their authority. All it's doing is setting up a business plan on which they get reimbursed from. Right now, if we have the present number of tires that are processed this year,
as was last year with the revenue stream, we'll have a shortfall of somewhere around $900-something thousand dollars. So this has quite a bit of urgency to that bill. The electronic manifest will help accurately count the tires. The used tire will help us also determine if there's used tires coming in from out of state and be able to track those. That's one thing right now. We have over 400,000 more tires that were processed than were sold in the state of Arkansas.
It also reestablished an abatement program. The abatement program today has been used to prop up these tire districts, and it will do an abatement program to allow your local community to clean up local tire dumps. And that's probably one of the bigger parts of the bill that I like. As I say, it requires a business plan. We have a big problem with the Internet tires. we sat here and nationwide
it's 20-29% of those tires are sold online and again I would be happy to answer any questions you might have
motion okay I'm going to hold that we do have one person signed up to speak against Mr. R.D. Hopper Hooper if you would represent the fight let him have the end of the table
if you would introduce yourself for the
Speaker 78
3:30
committee and you're recognized to speak against the bill thank you very much I'm R.D. Hopper I'm owner of Sonny's Auto Recycling in Jacksonville Arkansas I am president of the International Auto Recyclers Association Association, former president of the Arkansas Automobile Recycler Association, and someone that this bill would affect.
So I'm very familiar with reading bills. I've been on the government affairs of the International Lottery Recyclers Association for 15 years. I read a lot of bills that go through Washington, and as a president of the association, I look a lot of legislation that goes into a lot of states and just talked to California yesterday about their entire bill and how it's affected some of the things in their states so with that being
said I'll address some of my concerns about the bill you know it's 31 pages so a friend of mine tell me you eat an elephant one bite at a time but it would take a long time to go over every aspect of this bill and what concerns me but I'll tell you some of the things that concerns me the most the first thing it does it raises the tax on selling tires 100% from $2 are not 100% but
50% from $1 to $3 this bill creates a new tax for mounting tires which there is not an existing tax for mounting tires right now so this tax would encompass this bill also eliminates the definition in the bill of the tax applies currently to new tires so you pay a disposal fee for your tires now when a new tire is sold this bill eliminates that to where you would be paying a fee for any tire that gets
mounted and it gets taken off of a rim so it expands the scope of the current tax by over a hundred percent more tires will be this is a tax on use tires now now it's a tax on new tires now this tax is going to generate I would say this bill would generate probably besides the one dollar extra that it's adding for mounting and the one dollar extra for dismounting and taking in use tires as well as new tires I would say just for my looking through this bill that it
would probably raise the tax on tires by probably two hundred percent will probably generate two hundred percent more money than what is generating right now now the people that it's going to affect the most it also brings in a tracking system electronic tracking system to track all tires so what this is going to do the most oh also I'm also in Department of Justice National Motor Vehicle set on advisory board to track total loss cars in the Department of Justice and sit on the compliance committee at the Department of Justice
to track total loss vehicle so I've got some experience with with tracking electronic tracking systems so besides besides creating the tracking system and these doubling the taxes and doubling the scope of the taxes it is going to have all kinds of regulations for counties cities small businesses now to electronically track all the tires that they most mount and dismount the people this bill will affect the most it will not directly affect me immediately it
gives the adq the power to quit putting tiles in the landfill in three years this bill says that the adq cannot stop tires going in landfill for three years but after that three-year moratorium then they can stop allowing tires to go landfill and they can take all this tax money that they're getting from the hardest-working people that buy used tires and can't afford new ones we're going to take that money and pop up a new industry to recycle these tires where they don't have to go to landfill which will have to buy millions of dollars
worth of equipment and pop up a business permanently that is a non-profit business and still businesses in the world in the state of Arkansas to do what's most profitable myself I bought a $8,500 tire shredder to where I cut my tires four times so they can go in landfill so I do not create a health
hazard and I have I believe this bill has nothing to do with health it It shouldn't even be in this committee. But after I cut the tires, then I paid to have them taken to the landfill. I also have a $5,000 tire machine to dismount the tires, $8,500 machine. So I do things for the environment of the state of Arkansas. I do things responsibly. I do not need another tracking system. We do not need another branch of government. This tracking system, they're going to make government more efficient.
It's going to be about like the DHS whenever you come up to making things more efficient in a more tracking system. Right now, the Department of Justice National Motor Vehicle Tracking System for Total Loss Cars operate at a 25% efficiency right now. You can call Tom Brighton about that at the Department of Justice. He'll give you the report from DOJ, and he will tell you that the only people that they survey or monitor are the people that are crazy enough to try to do things right and
get on the tracking system. There is no way the state of Arkansas can track every tire in this state. There is no way they can monitor every business. And they will go after the people that are doing it right. And this will affect the poor people in rural communities that are trying to drive back and forth to work and buy used tires. And the people that are already on government assistance, these people will be hit the hardest. This is the people that my business helps every day in a profitable manner and provides jobs
Every day my industry does and does things responsibly for the natural state without government involvement and without creating another Bureaucracy which in here says they can change the rules themselves They can create boards and they can do things without an elected official or ever coming back to this board so I've read this 31 page bill twice I can answer some questions about it I'm not But I can tell you that it doubles taxes expands the size of government
it makes more regulations for small businesses puts them out of business and the state of Arkansas has enough taxes already on the hard-working people and really want to think people that can afford new tires that much because they buy one set of new tires that last them for years but people that can't afford new tires they have to buy more tires on a regular basis and they buy used tires that last them six or eight months and they'll be hitting with this tax several times so this people will target the people that struggling in this state the most that's that is my stance on this bill as auto
recycler and as a small business owner and as someone that as a former justice of a piece of the county, seeing how this would affect it. So I'm sure most government officials will be for this because it is going to make a lot of money accessible to a lot of people. So that's my statement, and I'll take any questions if anybody would like to ask them. Representative Payton here recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and certainly appreciate you being here, Mr. Hopper,
to take time out of your small business to talk about this. I think you and I would agree that the best way to recycle a tire is to take it off of one vehicle and put it on the next one and wear it out before you throw it away. How many times do you think this used tire tax will be collected on the same tire over and over as it changes from vehicle to vehicle? Three to four times. So each new tire will be taxed three to four times. It would discourage the highest form of recycling is to repurpose something
for the use that it was intended for. And this bill will tax one tire three to four times in the process and will discourage the highest form of recycling and will cause more of a problem than it will solve. And as a follow-up, I mean, you and I are both in the industry. We see the network of people that it takes to redistribute these used tires from wherever they came off to the next person that's willing to give $10 or $15 for that tire
and put it on the next vehicle and wear it out. How do you think this bill would discourage the redistribution of those used tires? Would they end up going to the landfill instead of being reused? Yes, I believe. As a lot of bills, this would force people on the ground right now. People are buying the tires responsibly and recycling responsibly. So, I believe this would cut down on the used tire dealers immensely in the state of Arkansas. And when you cut down on the used tire dealers, as you say, representative,
when you cut down on those dealers, you put more tiles in landfill and you recycle less power. So, I believe this electronic tracking device would eliminate probably 25% of our used tire market right now and the people that are in that business that you're referring to. and it ultimately would cause less recycling and put more tires in landfills. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Vice Chair Ferguson, do you
have a question? Yes, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Speaker 111
13:34
It's called the Tire Recycling Program for a reason. The goal is not to shred up tires and put them in the landfill. Are you actually recycling anything into usable products, selling them somewhere, or are you
Speaker 78
13:50
landfill? man right now with the processes that are available and the machinery available is not profitable to repurpose these tires to use them for other use besides putting them on the tar cars i recycle 75 percent to 80 percent of the tires that i get in my business
Speaker 111
14:07
i don't mean the tires i'm saying you're shredding the tires and in the shred you're putting in landfill. The goal is to take the shred and to make it into a usable product. Are all the shred, are you putting
Speaker 78
14:23
in a landfill? Yes, ma'am. The 20% of tires that are not reusable that I get in my business does go in a landfill because right now that is the only profitable way to
Speaker 111
14:35
handle them. I mean, other shredders are selling them for usable
purposes have you trying to do that the equipment
Speaker 78
14:42
is very expensive and that's the reason this bill says it has to make subsidies for people to do so you're exactly right this bill will create other uses for tires and will prevent some of them from going to landfill besides the ones that go in the black market but the ones this bill doesn't force in the black market well the big business will be subsidized by the taxpayers to do something that's unprofitable and keep them out of the
landfill. So it will accomplish your goal to the detriment of the taxpayers. Seeing no
further questions, thank you, Mr. Hopper. Thank you. Representative Fite, does anyone else in the audience speak for or against the bill? Representative Fite, you're recognized closed for your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Some of the amendments have addressed some of the issues he spoke of today. Again, the purpose of this bill is for efficiency in government, and I can't stress that enough. There will be accountability once this bill is implemented for local government. I'm closed. Representative Gonzalez, did you
have a motion? If I had a motion, do pass. Representative Gonzalez, as amended. And is there any discussion on the motion?
See you none. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed? No. Rule the ayes have it. I got two hands. Mr. Price,
Speaker 37
16:41
will you proceed with a roll call? Representative Love, Representative Hammer, Representative Branscombe, Representative Meeks,
Representative Ritchie Representative McGee Representative Miller Representative Walmert Representative Payton Representative Ladyman Representative Lundstrom
Representative Bentley, Representative Gonzales, Representative Boyd, Representative Boyd, Representative Henderson, Representative Henderson, Representative McCollum.
Representative Coleman? Yes. Representative Pilkington? Yes. Vice Chair Ferguson? Yes. Chair Wardlaw? Yes. Yes. With a vote of 12 yeses, your bill has passed. Congratulations, Representative Feigler. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right, committee, we're now going to hear from Dr. Joe Thompson and his group,
and then we'll proceed back to Beals after this. Dr. Thompson, if you would introduce yourself for the committee and you proceed with your presentation.
Speaker 52
18:40
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm Joe Thompson, President and CEO of the Arkansas Center for Health Improvement and a professor in the Colleges of Medicine and Public Health at UAMS. Mr. Chair, I want to use your time judiciously, but there are three things that we'd like to put in front of you today. One is just a little background of our center and its resource for you and your use going forward on deliberations of different policy issues.
The second is an update on the transparency initiative. And the third is, which I'll start with, is a commendation for your engagement on the Capital Go campaign. This committee, the leadership, is really demonstrating the opportunity to lead a healthier lifestyle. We're watching the leaderboard. My team, if you will, Michael Knox, Suzanne McCarthy, Craig Wilson, these are the faces that you will see over here, and you should consider them an asset and a resource for you.
Mr. Price is handing out a brief packet that I'll use as a prop to go through. On the left side of it, you have an overview and a timeline of our center's history and our activities. We have been around about 20 years. We're administratively housed in UAMS. I have a signed agreement with the chancellor that says our policy goals and objectives are independent of UAMS. So while we're administratively housed, that's where my paycheck and our team's paycheck comes from, we're here to serve you and the executive branch and the private sector on
advancing policies. Over the last 20 years, we have helped you and others with information. We really do three things. We look at other states to see what policies they have put in place that worked or, sometimes importantly, what policies they thought were going to work and backfired on them so that we can actually identify those opportunities and background history for you. We have also done empirical development using data to actually generate information.
We did a workforce study five years ago about where all the providers were practicing in the state. We have done work around the insurance expansion. We are supporting this administration as we have the last two administrations in providing empiric information for decisions that they have to recommend to you and we want to extend that offer to you. And then third is we have been pretty heavily involved in program development across the state. We were integrally involved in the passage of the Tobacco Settlement Act that funded
the College of Public Health, the Biosciences Institute and others. And as you go forward, the fingerprints of our center as a catalyst to help make change have been present. I think now we are faced with some new challenges from the federal perspective. On the left side of your packet you will see an issue brief. This is the kind of document that we do on the new payment effort that the federal government, through the Center for Medicaid and Medicare Services, is deploying, called MACRA. It's the Medicare and Children's Health Insurance Program Reform Act.
This effectively retired the doc cuts that were in place by Medicare, and we've been working closely with the major payers, Blue Cross, Qualchoice, Centene, Medicaid, the Hospital Association, the Medical Society over the last five years, change the way that we're paying from a fee-for-service system to more of a value-based system where you're getting better outcomes and later this month we'll release a Walmart supported state tracking report that puts all of that
information in one place. This is the source for where Medicaid has been paying primary care providers some of the shared savings that they're getting out of the program. This is also the source where our specialists in hospitals have financial incentives to get better outcomes at a lower cost and They have been very strongly engaged, and I think those programs, those new payment programs are intentionally being put in place to protect our providers from some of the Medicare payment changes under MACRA. If you're in an alternative payment mechanism, you're not subject to the impact of MACRA
on the provider population. So we've been working in that space diligently. You've got a packet, if you will. It's called Arkansas at the Forefront of Health System Innovation. I think as you go to other states, you will hear about our value-based payment transformation effort. You will hear about some of the workforce development efforts we've had underway. This is a list of all of the issue briefs, all of the background documents that we have on our website, and that I think some will be of importance to you as you are challenged with different policy decisions,
for which I'll just tell you, we highly recognize and value the work and effort that you all are putting in. It doesn't come to you because it's an easy decision. It comes to you because it's a difficult decision, and one of the things we want to make sure is that you've got information and knowledge both from our state with respect to data and other states with respect to experience. So in this list, you've got payment transformation efforts. You've got insurance coverage issues. You've got how we finance the health care system. We've got issues around our health insurance marketplace, special populations,
our workforce, research and data. Our team really strives to provide accurate and objective information on this, and we've been a resource for many of you over the past years. For those of you that are new, I wanted to make sure that you're cognizant of our availability and of our intent to be able to support you. Let me go to the third and maybe the most important thing that is developing. On the right side, you have a fact sheet about the Arkansas Health Care Transparency Initiative. This was passed by the General Assembly last session.
It went through the Insurance and Commerce Committee because it is about health care transparency in terms of financing. It was unanimously voted on both ends, the House and the Senate, by the Insurance and Commerce Committees and passed with a large margin the General Assembly on both houses. This effectively requires all insurance carriers, public and private, to share their claims data into a transparency initiative all-payer claims database to allow information to be available for your use, whether that's in scope of practice, whether that's in health care financing, whether that's tracking trends in Medicaid or Medicare.
These are present in about 14 states. The legislation explicitly authorizes the commissioner of the insurance department to have the authority to execute this, and it authorizes our center to the extent funds are available to develop and collect it. As a report now, we have three years of data from Medicare, from Medicaid, from the commercial payers that have more than 2,000 covered lives, from the dental insurance providers, from workers' comp, and are in the process of transforming that into a tool that could be available and for use by you.
You've got a couple of examples that we tried to show what it could be done for. This is the cost you may have seen on the news of the EpiPen, the thing that people give themselves self-injections, and the cost increases that have occurred just in our state over the last two years, almost a 100% increase you can see for Medicaid and for the commercial coverage. The red portion of the bar is the coinsurance that individuals are paying. The blue portion is what the insurance company or Medicaid is paying.
We've had discussions with the Attorney General staff about how to protect Arkansas consumers with this information from the 100-plus drugs that are going through the roof because of the pharmacology increases in prices. So this is an application of the All-Payer Claims Database. Explicitly and also in the legislation is a call for the cost of health care to become more transparent. As people have higher and higher deductibles, they are exposed to more and more of the cost, and people need information to be able to select which providers that they would want to go to.
We did a study of the dental claims, and these are real claims from real providers across our state that we looked at on the top tier. It's just a regular exam with an x-ray and cleaning and examination. The middle tier is the extraction of a single tooth. And the bottom tier is if you needed a root canal, what it would cost you to go get a root canal. We chose dentistry first because so many Arkansans lack dental insurance and they're paying 100% out of pocket. Over on the right side, if you look on the 50th percentile column,
that's the median or the middle price. and you can see for some providers it doesn't make a difference, but for other providers, if you happen to choose that provider, you may be paying as much as twice out of pocket for what other individuals would charge for the same service. So this is actually, we have reviewed this with the leadership of the Dental Association. We're going to move judiciously, but this is what I think there's an increasing demand by those with high deductible or consumer-driven health savings accounts to have information available.
We have had conversations with your Bureau of Legislative Research. We think that they will be able to use this information to support your committee here, also on the Senate end, insurance and commerce on both ends, the task forces. We were the source of data for the Stephen Group last year when they undertook the Medicaid assessment for the task force. There are external interests here that are willing to pay for access to the data too. We've had over 20 of these requests, and you can see they vary from developing health care systems
to a graduate student at the University of South Florida that want access to the data to study different aspects. We have also gone through a procurement. The specialty associations have gone through each of their specialty associations and said these are things that we should not be doing. So, for example, the American College of Cardiology says we should not be doing an EKG every year on every body when they come in for their annual assessment. The ophthalmologists have said we should not be doing pre-op laboratory for a cataract surgery, which is not needed.
Now, these are things that generate costs and waste and inefficiency in the system, but these are what the specialists have said they should not be doing. Those specialists have come out across their 50-some-odd specialty organizations with five things that either should or should not happen, and they've been put into this waste calculator that we plan to put on top of the All-Pair Claims Database to improve our awareness of where we have waste and inefficiency in the system to try to help drive down the trend line of what our health care costs are.
Finally, and let me offer this, and I'll be glad to take questions. We've tried to be helpful. You've got a little card on the right side. It has one of these QR symbols that will take you to our website for all of those issue briefs and all those cost-effectiveness things. The things that are coming up, again, that we are driving toward, but we want to be responsive to any of the issues that you have, are the development of the tools for the All-Payer Claims Database. We have a study underway now to look at the number of individuals that could possibly
qualify for a marijuana prescription or marijuana access under the PASS Act. We're also looking at time to payment by insurance carriers. Insurance carriers sometimes don't pay timely from a provider's perspective and we'll be able to say when the service date was and when the paid date was so that we'll be able to look at the insurance carrier profiles. And we're engaged with the health department on helping supplement some of their surveillance activities. look at, for example, which county has the most or a high level of type 2 diabetes in
their Medicare population, and of those diabetics, how many are getting appropriate care to help avoid downstream threats of cardiac disease or renal disease or blindness. So these are all applications that we are engaged with your respective state agencies. We're working closely with Administrator Gillespie and her team at the Department of Human Services, obviously with Commissioner Kerr at Insurance and with Nate Smith at the Health Department. We've worked closely with your Bureau of Legislative Research. We've got
engagement and a high level of interest from the Medicaid Inspector General. She could look at something that she sees in Medicaid happening and also look over in the commercial sector to see is it happening in the commercial sector too, in which case it's a broad system issue, or is it only happening in the Medicaid sector, which would be a higher index of suspicion for fraud or inappropriate billing behavior. And finally, engagement with the governor's office. I think everybody is supportive here. We will be working with those agencies to try to secure some funding for access here.
The transparency bill itself enabled us to bill this off of grant fundings. It does have some sustainability requirements over time. We think that should be a shared public and private sector responsibility. We've talked to the Biosciences Institute and other researchers about the utility and value of this database for their purpose. So I think just to close out, our center is here. We've been here for a couple of decades. You see the breadth of information, fact sheets, work that we have. If you have a specific topic of interest that you would like for us to explore,
we're open to be able to do that. We've done that historically. I think what we can guarantee is that we will be true to our mission, which is to be a catalyst to improve the health of Arkansans through program development, public policy development, and public advocacy. We work for the average Arkansan, and we want to be supportive and available to you in your endeavors to do the same. So thank you very much for your time. Be glad to take questions. We've got an opportunity coming up on the Capital Go campaign that we're developing, which could possibly let you extend to your constituents' participation
and broaden some of those activities out into the state to enable those of you that would like to have a constituency team competing to be able to do that also. So thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Be glad to take questions. Representative Bentley you have a question thank
you for coming today and thank you for the information you provided where can we get the information on diabetes that you talked about per county I'd really be interested in seeing that we'd
Speaker 52
33:04
be glad to make that available to Mr. Graham and he can circulate it to the committee it's in some of the developing documents that we did for the insurance department or along
the development of the all-payer claims database and and I think that's probably going to be one of the public-facing efforts that we have are these county maps that let people know where the diseases are, where the providers are, where the challenges that you get faced with making decisions about across the state to optimally have that. But we'll get that to Mr. Graham and get that circulated to you this afternoon. Thank you. Representative
Lundstrell, you got a question? Thank you, Chairman Wardlaw. Two questions. One, you mentioned marijuana.
Speaker 52
33:42
Could you go back over that again? Sure. So the all-payer claims database and the transparency initiative collects from payors, public and private, so Medicaid, Medicare, commercial carriers. The bill also requires self-insured companies that receive public dollars, so your state employees, your public school employees, the university system claims are in this claims database already. We have three years of claims, and let me just say we don't have anybody's name in here. This is completely de-identified.
It is not on the Internet. It can't be hacked, and so we have three years of claims, and in those claims are diagnoses associated with what was paid for. The act, the Marijuana Act itself, has a list of eligible conditions for which an individual would be eligible to seek marijuana, not prescription, but you all have changed it to a consumption card. And so we are going through the all-pair claims database for those conditions
that are specifically have an ICD-9 diagnosis tied to it to see how many people could be potentially eligible for an application for a consumption card. Follow-up, Mr. Chairman? May
I have a follow-up? You recognize. Are you connected with the
Speaker 52
35:03
Medical Society? How does that work? So we work closely with the Medical Society and the Hospital Association. I have a 21-person board that is made up of a broad group of individuals.
I've got strong R's. I've got strong D's. I've got a community health center. And we can get you the list of the membership of our board, which guides us. And we work closely, again, with the hospital association, the medical society, the carriers, as well as the family physicians, the academy of pediatrics. We try to be connected across all the different organizations
statewide. any further questions seeing none thank you dr. Thompson and thank you for all the work you're
doing over there you had to push your button again Craig Suzanne Michael are going
Speaker 52
35:53
to be over here if y'all need something don't hesitate to just flag them down and say do you have it because if you've got the question we want to be able to be responsive to your to your to your needs Thank you
very much. Thank you, Doc. Representative Miller, are you ready to go? Let's go. House Bill 1300, continuation. He has an amendment.
It is on the tablet. There is an amendment, and it's on the tablet. Representative
Miller, if you don't mind, let's take up the amendment first. yes thank you mr. chair the amendment simply states that I know when we met last Thursday there was some concern that funding for eliminating this waiting list was going to
come from human development centers. That's never been the intent, and I wanted to make that clear, so therefore, we've brought this amendment before you all today. I got a motion to
approve the amendment. Any discussion on that motion? Seeing none, all those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? Amendment passes. You're recognized to present your bill as amended, please, sir. All right. Thank you, Mr. Chair. folks again
I'm not going to belabor the point I know we talked about it quite a bit last week
the individuals and their families that are on this waiting list do not have a big money lobbying group here to represent them at the Capitol nobody in the legislature that I know of has been receiving big campaign contributions on behalf of these 3,000 folks they haven't been heard from, they haven't had a loud voice down here at the Capitol for over a decade. If they had, my guess is there wouldn't be a waiting list today.
I think it's time that we do something for the people simply because it's the right thing to do. We're trying to provide an opportunity for these individuals and their families to have the ability to live their lives the way they want to and to the fullest capacity possible. I know that there is opposition to this bill. This bill will force some tough decisions. Do these folks behind me and in this room today
deserve to continue to be swept under the rug and out of sight while we rush out here to spend millions of dollars on healthy, able-bodied, working-aged adults. I'm not trying to have that debate, just trying to ask the question, do these folks not deserve the same priority? Making hard decisions goes with the job of running government.
That's what happens. When you seek an elected office, that goes along with the territory. When you want to run a state agency, that goes along with the territory. I realize that folks are scared of making hard decisions. I'm not. But the folks on this waiting list deserve to be heard from. One other angle that I want to touch on real quick, and then I'm going to hush, is folks there is actually an economic impact that goes along with this if we
get this done in the next three years there's going to be a minimum of 3,000 jobs created on account of this I've been down here for four years and I don't know any of any legislation that I've been a part of or seen come through that's actually created at least 3,000 jobs it could be closer to 5,000 they may not be really high paying jobs but still their jobs these caregivers are
going to live here in Arkansas they're gonna spend their paychecks here in Arkansas we will get we will get something in return the opposition is from institutional care and government agencies not from folks back home in our districts I just want to see this happen I can't magically create a pot of money but I can with your help get the ball rolling if you'll read the bill we're
not asking that all 3,000 folks be covered July 1 2017 we're talking about over three years last week we heard testimony that the governor wants to see this done DHS wants to see this done if everybody wants to see this done then let's do it and with that I'll shut up because I'm pretty sure there's other folks that want to talk or ask questions i think we got a few questions representative miller
uh representative ladyman you were the first i seen motion at the proper time i got you noted now
Speaker 78
41:43
i got representative meeks for a question thank you representative miller there's no doubt that your heart is in the right place but this brings me to the question that i asked last week and that is if we pass this bill we are in essence prioritizing these folks that are on the waiting list and again I absolutely agree we ought to do
everything we can to get them off the waiting list but they would take higher precedence over other things such as our foster care system which is under DHS our aging the spending that we do on aging is that not correct
I don't believe that would have to be the case representative Meeks I think you and I both have served along with many others on legislative council and we've seen
DHS come before legislative council with different proposals different contracts we just sat through this previous fall when DHS came in with several attempts to to cut spending in other places in order to raise money for Arkansas works I foresee this as sort of being that same type of deal over the next three years of DHS looking to see where there is areas where they can cut
wasteful spending and come up with the money you know they're also there's I don't think there's anything in this bill that is going to prohibit DHS from coming after they start analyzing this and really start putting a hard look on it when they come back to the legislature in a year or two and say hey we need this or we need that. And so that would be my response.
Obviously, I know you've worked hard in the foster care arena, and I totally respect that. And I don't want to see that necessary services be cut for that. I want to see these folks get covered. And I'm afraid that if we don't do this today, like I sat here two years ago with Representative Love, and I know we've got 500 to 700 that are now going to be covered but I'm afraid if we don't do this today then this is still just going to be a talking point
for a while and I'm ready to see it be
an action point Thank you Any further questions from the committee?
Speaker 78
44:29
Representative Payton you're recognized for the question Representative, thank you Mr. Chair Representative Miller, is it true that with a three-year timeline that if it was discovered that it was going to be crippling to other activities of DHS, that we'd have another fiscal session, general session, and fiscal
session, three opportunities to make adjustments if necessary? Representative Payton, you are a very
wise man. Yes, sir. That is true. Thank you. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. The love you two show each other. Representative Gonzalez, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. What is the actual cost of this? What kind of money are we talking about?
Well, I know DHS and DDS were up here earlier.
They had estimated, I think, $43 or $44 million a year. I know there's been some other numbers that have circulated. I also know that DDS is working hard on a more cost-effective waiver program, which thing I fully support. So I believe that we could see these costs go down. Personally, I think it could be done for a total of somewhere around $34 million to $36 million a year.
um it i'm not gonna i'm not gonna um sit down here and say it's not expensive it is expensive uh but i think we all know we've done things in the last few years that are expensive and if we're going to do this i want to see this population taken care of representative gonzalez would you like to hear
And we'll get the department up behind Representative Miller.
Do you know what we're currently spending on this population? I'm sure the department
would have a good answer for that. Representative Pilkington, do you have
a question for the sponsor? His follow-up was my question. Okay. We'll have the department at the end of the table shortly. Are there any further questions from the committee? That's all I have listed. Representative Miller, if you would, we'll get the department to the end of the table. and see if I can answer a few of these questions.
Mr. Link, Ms. Stone. If you guys would introduce yourself for the committee and then Representative Gonzalez, are you ready to ask your question? Mr.
Speaker 78
47:14
Chair, Kelly Link, Legislative Intergovernmental Affairs for the Department of Human Services. Melissa
Speaker 92
47:21
Stone, Director of the Division of Developmental Disability Services with the Department of Human Services. Sorry about that, Representative
Gonzalez. I didn't see you at the coffee machine.
You're recognized, Representative. Yeah, so same questions, I guess. What are the costs of
Speaker 92
47:43
implementing this, and what are we currently spending? Currently spending on the individuals who are on the wait list? So we did a rough breakdown. Many of the individuals on the DDS waiver wait list are eligible for Medicaid state plan services. In 2016, we spent $56,748,524, approximately.
It would be mixed. And as far as how much we anticipate needing to sub the wait list under our current costs, and as Representative Miller said, we are working to make a more efficient waiver. But currently the average cost is $54,000 for waiver services, so we estimate we would need $43 million in state general revenue to save the people currently on the waiting list. And that would be on top of the tobacco settlement funds.
Yes. And that's an additional to the $56 million. Is that your follow-up, Representative? Yes. And get close to the mic for us, please. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So that's an additional money on top of the
Speaker 92
48:50
$56 million currently being spent. Yes. The money being spent right now is for state plan services such as pharmacy, therapy, personal care, things of that nature that you utilize through the Medicaid state plan. Okay. I have another question. Ms.
Stone, I've got a question off what you just stated.
You made a statement that you would need $43 million out of general revenue. is that to match federal funds or is that included in the
down the federal match so 43 million out of state GR would be the state's proportion representative Peyton
Speaker 78
49:32
you're recognized for a question thank you mr. chair miss stone I think I'm correct in saying it's the stated objective of the governor and DHS and
and many members of the legislature to see this waiting list go away, be addressed. Do you believe that three years is an unrealistic timeline when everybody seems to want to make it go away? I think
Speaker 92
49:58
my response to that would be this is very much a priority for DDS, and for me personally, and for DHS, and you're correct for the governor's office. And there's a row of clients sitting on the back row that, you know, we don't necessarily want to come up here and oppose this because, you know, they're all on the back row and we have more in foster care and they also are waiting on DD waiver services.
So this is a very hard thing to say that we don't, we're opposing it based on financial restrictions. We do not have current funding to serve the wait list as we're currently operating. Thank you. Well, as I try
Speaker 78
50:43
to get my head around this, you know, I don't think in life or in business or anything else we accomplish much without setting objectives and timelines to
go with those objectives. So if you think three years is not long enough to figure out how to cover this population, which is only 3,000 people compared to the 240,000 people that we were able to cover at the drop of a hat a couple years ago. What timeline would you think would be reasonable? Mr. Payton, let me, and obviously, if we had a timeline, we would lay that out for you and come to you and say we would like legislation to lay out this timeline.
You know, myself and Department of Human Services, like yourself, we're not sure what's going to happen federally. We think positive things. We think there's going to be more open doors and more open opportunities, but we can't guarantee that today. We took step one. We took a big stepping stone just, what, two weeks ago? Where the tobacco settlement was signed into law two weeks ago, and that's a big stepping stone. That's 500 to 700 people, something we've been looking for in a way to finance for quite some time. We know there's more stepping stones. We just don't know exactly where they're at in the water yet, and we don't want to fall in.
we don't you know we don't want to make a mess of this DHS and you know I'm speaking on behalf of Melissa and her department especially because I get to work there and see their passion I promise you especially in her division where they get to work with these people daily they want this as much as anybody that's it's at this table as much as anybody that's behind us they want this and we were able to take that financial stepping stone a couple weeks ago we
know there's more stones ahead we want to find them so what you're asking is a time okay well can we set this for five years can we say for two years can we set for three years represent payment we don't know but we do know we want to get there it's it's frightening to have this mandate put on us and that's where the department is is concerned of a mandate for multiple reasons not just the money we also have to have the people that can serve this population and currently if you talk to hospitals and other care places yes we agree 3,000
jobs created but we don't know that there's 3,000 people ready that can do that job in three years from now and so it's kind of concerning against a mandate is what we're concerned with we have the same goals that you do we have the same goals as people behind us in the rest of the state we want to get there a representative Meeks you're recognized for a question thank you mr. chair and you know this is a what I would consider a realistic scenario so
just help me to understand in light of this bill passing it's been reported in the news widely that we could have a 50 to 60 million I think they quoted a 57 million dollar shortfall in the budget that we would have to figure out where the cuts may come or where whatever the case would be if this bill were to pass and we do come up with a shortfall either this year or next year then this program would take priority over other programs under DHS when you're talking
about whether or not you have to make cuts is that correct is that accurate Well, you know, I said this last week, I'll say it again, we don't have this flow chart on the wall that says number one priority is behavioral health, number two is developmentally disabled or anything else. We simply have to look at the entire package at DHS and figure out how can we finance all this? You know, if there's cuts to be made, where can we find the cuts where it does the least damage to the most vulnerable?
And that's how we would find those representatives. you know and Discerning what is the most vulnerable is is subjective, but that's what we'd have to do We'd have to find out okay If we've got to cut four million or whatever it is if we have to make these these cuts and that we got to find them again Federally, we don't know what's going to happen. We don't know if we're going to be required You know with with more flexibility in the state plans state plan amendments There may also become more requirement of state spending to to meet those flexibilities
We don't know the future, but we do know the desire, and we want to find stepping stone number two and move more people off that list as soon as we can. Follow up, if I could. But this bill, though, because you said you don't personally prioritize. You're looking at the big picture and everything of that nature, but this bill passes. If this bill passes, that would then put this at basically priority number one on the list of everything else that we may deem worthy as far as vulnerable populations and everything of that nature.
This then becomes one priority. And would it keep you from having to make cuts? Or can you explain to me, since this bill is passing, if it does, okay? If it passes, if we have to make cuts because of revenue, would this keep you from making cuts to this program and have to make deeper cuts in other areas?
Yes, it would. Thank you Mr. Chair. Thank you Representative Payton you're
Speaker 78
56:22
recognized for another question. Thank you Mr. Chair. Mr. Link you've
continually cited the unknowns that may be out there and as I mentioned earlier you know we would have opportunities to address it, extend the timeline, change things every year because DHS is one of the big six that gets visited during the fiscal session is it your assumption or is it your fear that this body would totally ignore DHS's request or information when if that it was
becoming critical and not extend the timeline no I know I know this body well having been a part of it recently and I know that this body would never ignore an agency in crisis and especially an agency that cares for the most vulnerable so I don't I would certainly not assume that if you pass this and then there is a problem in a crisis if we came back and said we simply can't get it done I would expect flexibility from this body yes sir I certainly appreciate you saying so thank you mr. chair thank you representative
Bentley you recognize for a question we just real quick before you start we've We've got quite a few folks signed up to speak for the bill. We have zero to speak against the bill, so just be mindful of the time because I want to be sure and give everybody their fair second at the end of the table. Just real briefly, and
I apologize, I wasn't here last week. I was on the other end of the building presenting the bill, so I couldn't be here. But could you briefly just go over for me, these 3,000 folks that are on the current waiting list, what are they receiving now? Are they getting any treatment, physical therapy, OTPT, any of those things?
What things are they getting now? about things we're missing so I can just briefly I'm sorry
Speaker 92
58:13
I wasn't here last week that's no problem I don't I don't mind going over it so the the spill would affect the people who will not come off with the tobacco settlement funds so we're talking about around 2,300 to 2,500 people give or take those individuals on the wait list as I said in state fiscal year 16 and Medicaid spent about $56 million on their care.
Those would be from state plan services. So any optional or mandatory state plan service, so pharmaceuticals, hospitalizations, doctor's visits, occupational therapy, physical therapy, speech therapy, developmental day treatment, programs that they can go during the day, specialized types of child care for children with high medical needs, personal care assistance, non-emergency transportation, see if I'm forgetting anything, EPSDT screens for kids, those would be, and autism therapy
if it's recommended through an EPSDT screen. So those are basic state plan services that are available. You're recognized. Just to help
me understand, so those people are receiving those now or they are not? The 2,300 are not receiving those or they are receiving those now? They are receiving those now. So what were the additional things that they'd be
Speaker 92
59:46
receiving if we pass this legislation? So the DDS home and community-based waiver offers additional services that are not
available under the Medicaid state plan and the the biggest service that is currently utilized by the recipients is what we refer to as supported living which is a could be a direct care worker that comes in and does training with you to help gain independence also under the waiver we have options such as environmental modifications that might not be available if you need a bathroom made handicap accessible respite for caregivers of children with developmental
disabilities supported employment opportunities so we would pay to help get you a job and have a job coach present so there's it's a different set of services that goes alongside the services being received under the Medicaid state plan. Thank you. Seeing no further questions,
we'll move along to the people to speak for the bill. We have Miss Loretta Ferguson from the Medicaid waiver. Miss Ferguson, if you would introduce yourself for the committee and
Speaker 111
1:01:05
you're recognized to speak. My name is Loretta Ferguson Cochran. I am a parent of number 387, who hopefully will finally receive waiver services after being on waiver since our application went in in 2007. I am currently an associate professor at Arkansas Tech University. I am still about $50,000 in debt over for the last 10 years of things I've paid for for my son that would have been covered under waiver. He has autism.
He's doing very well because of those supports. I pay for Medicaid for my son. I buy in with Tefra. I actually pay a higher premium for his health care insurance or his Medicaid than I do for his health care insurance. And I got my mandate to take care of my son on December 3, 2001, and I will not leave him behind. So no matter what, I've had to give up. Job promotions, opportunities, additional income, changes in living situations.
I refuse to do that. I refuse to put my son in an institution or in any other form of care when he has the opportunity to be independent. He has the same right as my other two children to live and be accepted in society where they want to be. It's his choice. That's what waiver provides him. 60% of the children in Arkansas receive income-based Medicaid, like our kids, that sort of thing. 60% of the children at a minimum on the wait list can't afford to mortgage a house the way I did
to pay for my child and what he needed. This bill, if waiver could be provided to those children, we didn't get any help when my son was diagnosed. We got nothing, nothing. I paid for it all the way myself and this bill would allow parents like me when their child is diagnosed and they first land on the waiver list not to wait 10 years to get help but get help that they can't pay for then things I paid out of pocket that made a difference a huge difference in my son's ability to be
independent in a regular classroom he does have a parapro but he's in regular education he's actually in pre-AP geometry so it allowed him to play on the community football team for years because I paid for that worker to be there to help him I paid for that so that he could you you don't just turn a kid loose with autism without the right supports I appreciate that there are tough choices I do I've made them some of them very hard but I did that because my
a son deserves what my other two children have. Whatever the child in his school has, he gives you a chance to play football, to go to school, to enjoy his time in the community, go to the Arkansas Regional Innovation Hub and take a class in 3D programming and robotics and design a drone, just like every other kid. He just needs those extra supports. And his life is no more or no less valuable than my other two children. Thank you.
Seeing no questions, thank you for testimony. We have anybody in the audience speak against the bill? Seeing none, I'll move to the next. We have Mr. Mark George speak for the
introduce yourself and your guest, then you'd recognize to speak.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is Mark George. During several previous meetings of this committee, you have heard about someone that sued the state over the wait list, which the last time the wait list was at zero. I thought you might be interested in meeting the plaintiff in that suit. This is my daughter, Tessa. The case was Tessa G. v. Arsar, Department of Human Services. Rence key voter, please. Thank you. Excuse me.
Tessa was born with Down syndrome, which is considered a developmental disability. In 2003, which is when the suit was decided, she was five years old. At that time, she had had two heart surgeries, was still being fed through a tube, and could not speak more than a few words. Since that time, Tessa's life has not been about her disabilities but has been a testament to her abilities. She has danced in the Nutcracker with a Moscow ballet.
She has played baseball with Garth Brooks and hit home runs off of Cliff Lee and Dallas Keuchel. She plays soccer. She can ride a horse by herself. Having turned 19 a couple of weeks ago, she is going to be graduating from high school this year where she's only on a roll she is an example to everyone disabled or not of what an individual is capable of achieving the waiver program has played an important role in her
achievements and after she graduates from high school is going to play an even more important role unlike with our non-disabled children individuals like tests are seldom asked what do you want to do when you graduate from high school if asked Tess is not going to say I want to live in an institution attend segregated day programs or work in a sheltered workshop those programs focus on her deficits Tessa has dreams she wants to go to college get a competitive
integrated job, live in a place of her own, and even get married. And you know what? She's capable of achieving those dreams. And with the services and supports available through the waiver that focus on her abilities, those dreams have a chance of becoming a reality. Now there's been a lot of discussion about how it might, how much it might cost to eliminate the wait list, or whether waiver costs are cheaper than HDC costs.
Such discussions are really a red herring. The state, as it should, provides for a continuum of care at one end of that continuum are the human development centers. And, you know, Arkansas has chosen to include those as part of its state plan, which means they are now an entitlement program with no predetermined enrollment or spending cap. On the other end of the continuum is the waiver program.
It is not an entitlement, and it has a cap on enrollment and spending. The integration mandate of the Americans with Disabilities Act is upheld by the U.S. Supreme Court in the Olmstead case, requires that services provided by the state must be furnished in the most integrated setting appropriate to the needs of qualified individuals with disabilities. That's a quote from the law. For many people, their home and community is the most integrated setting appropriate for them.
As long as the state continues to choose to maintain HTCs as an entitlement program along that continuum, it has a legal obligation to provide the equivalent services and supports to individuals in their home and community. So this continuum is not defined as HDCs or waiver. A continuum must be understood as including HDCs and waiver.
The waiver program does not focus on Tessa's disabilities. It focuses on her capabilities. She has dreams, like all of us, and the services and supports available through the waiver program are an important means of helping her to live independently and inclusively in her community. There are currently 3,000 individuals with an intellectual or developmental disability
that have been waiting far too long to receive the same services and supports that TESSA receives that they also need to achieve their dreams of independence and inclusion. This bill really does not ask you to elevate the needs of these individuals, my daughter and others, above the needs of others, nor does it ask you to consider whether waiver
services are less expensive than institutional services. It simply asks you to support making the provision of care to disabled Arkansans a true, continuous continuum. Mr. Chairman, Tess and I would appreciate a good vote by this committee. Thank
you. Thank you, sir. Thank you guys for testifying for the committee. Representative Payton, you have something for me? Yes, sir.
Speaker 78
1:11:02
Mr. Chair, I'd like to make a motion. In light of the fact we have a lot of people to speak for this bill and we want to hear
them all, can we limit each speaker to two minutes? It's a proper motion if you'd like it to. I'd like to make that motion. That's a proper motion, non-debatable. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed. Okay, audience, what that does is it's going to allow everyone to speak. You're just going to have two minutes, and you'll be timed from the chair. So with that, we'll bring S. Ty Johnson.
I hope I pronounced that right. Miss Johnson if you would introduce yourself our committee
and you're recognized to speak hi my name is Esther Johnson but everyone calls me SD I was born very floppy with low muscle time I have a muscle disease called congenital
myopathy. Basically, most of my muscles are weak so I can't walk. So I use a wheelchair to get around. I have a tracheostomy so I can use a ventilator to help me breathe, mostly at night. But my disabilities don't stop me. I enjoy doing everything all teens do. I go to school,
I'm in the choir, play T-ball, and I love social media. I live with my family and attend rest of our junior high. At school, I have a nurse who goes with me to handle with my daily needs. But when I graduate, I will no longer receive those services. I hope to attend college and to someday live in my own home.
But without daily help, this cannot happen. I am number 1,622 on the medical waiver waiting list. Medical waiver would give me the supportive services I need to be, I need to live an independent life. I hope to be a motivational speaker someday to encourage others who may face whole things in their lives.
Without waiver, supporting living services, my dreams will not be mine. I will have to live where I can receive the care I need instead of living my life and my dreams. Ma'am, that's your two
minutes. Okay. And you have no idea how hard it is to stop you. I appreciate you coming and testifying, and thank you for what you're doing. Thank you. And with that, I'll have Ms. Pam Forrester.
Forrester. If you would introduce yourself for the committee and you're recognized to speak, you
have two minutes, ma'am. We'll give you a one-minute warning. Okay, I'll probably need that. My name is Pam Forrester. I am mom to Elizabeth. Some of you actually know Elizabeth. some of you actually know me. Two years ago, I was a congressional staff member for Congressman Steve Womack. I spent four years serving the public, serving many, many, many of these
families who would call our office and would work very hard to get them the services that they need. Nobody knowing that I actually was a part of them and had to keep that very quiet and not share that with everyone as part of my job. But two years ago, I made the decision to, I was forced to make the decision to leave my job. I'm a single mom of four children. My income, even as a congressional staff member, so for people who think that we make a lot of money, we don't. I did not pay for Elizabeth to have a nanny or a babysitter.
I could not hire a qualified nurse to take care of Elizabeth who is a spastic quadriplegic, cannot walk, talk, eat, speak. She spends her life in a wheelchair and 24-7 hour care is dependent on now me. I want to work. I need to work. I like to work and I have been forced to not work. I've lost my health care. I've lost my children's health care. The only state assistance I took when I left that job was for Elizabeth's Medicaid. So I am paying out of pocket for absolutely
everything else that we do um I don't receive the services that some of the the board spoke of we don't receive physical therapy or occupational therapy or speech therapy because Elizabeth doesn't qualify for it um part of the Medicaid waiver would actually allow us to be able to start receiving those services um that we don't receive now um Elizabeth would be allowed to um And actually, to be honest with you, I would be allowed to have a life with Elizabeth
and have a life with my other children with this waiver. I would be allowed to go to work because it would be help. Ma'am, that's your two minutes. I knew it. Thank you. Thank you. You can ask questions and I'll finish. Am I good? You're good. Okay. Thank you. Thank
you all. If we could, Willie Johnson, speak for the bill. Mr. Johnson, if you would, introduce yourself for the committee,
and we'll give you one finger for your one-minute mark.
Speaker 130
1:17:02
I'm Willie Johnson. I live in Russellville. I'm actually Esty's dad. I wanted to tell you about two of my sons who have received waiver and what it's done for them. My wife and I have adopted several special needs kids, and one of these boys has cerebral palsy. He's intellectually disabled. He's 31 years old. After he graduated from high school, we helped him waver.
He had waver. He got supportive services, and we helped him to buy a house that he could live in by himself. And so he did that. He's paid for this house, and he still lives there with supportive services. It's worked really well. The other son, he's 36. He's intellectually disabled. He also has emotional problems where he has outbursts of violence. We did the same thing for him when he graduated. We put him in alternative living situations.
We helped him buy a house, and that worked for about 10 years. Right now he's in the Human Development Center in Conway, and we appreciate that. It worked out best for him to end up there. We have other children with waiver services that are still living at home, and the benefit for these kids is after they leave the home because otherwise they just get lost out there or they stay at home.
So we've chosen to try to make them as independent as possible once they leave home. And it's worked real well. Besides Esty, we have two other children that are on the waiting list, So we would really like to see the waiting list cleared. That's all I have to say. Thank you, sir. Is there
anyone else in the audience speak for or against the bill? You'll speak for? Yes. OK, if you would introduce yourself for the committee
Speaker 78
1:19:02
and you have two minutes. I figured. Yeah, Mr. My name is Nick Rose, and the people that are behind me, I'm going to reverse the roles on you guys. You guys are back here, and they're up here, and they're asking the same, you guys are asking the same questions that they are, and let's say we're going to help you, but it
doesn't come true now how would you feel about that this is a good bill representative mayor felt like heck for this bill he needs this bill to be passed out of this committee and I hope you think up here but in your heart nothing else that's my
opinion thank you anyone else speak for against the bill sir you
recognize for two minutes if you would introduce yourself for the committee
and you're welcome to proceed thank you my name is Michael Thornton I'm a self advocate for myself and others with disabilities I've spoken before the committee before on a bill that was two years ago by representative letting I'm speaking on behalf of my friends back here on the back row with disabilities they're people that have lives that have hearts that have minds that matter I
speak that will play to live the people that want to receive services and I I understand financial issues are at play, but also wisdom is at play, too. To be wise in helping people with disabilities be better people, to live lives that are worth living, that is what the state needs to work on, to provide further services as much as possible.
And I will take any questions if needed. Thank you. Thank you, sir. Seeing
no questions, thank you for your testimony. Thank you very much. Seeing we have no one else speak for or against, Representative Ma'am? Four. Four? Okay, this will be the last one. We're going to let Representative Miller close for his bill. Yeah, if you would introduce yourself for the committee, and you're welcome to
proceed. Two minutes. My name is Veronica Tess Myers. I'm the mother and advocate for Alexander Myers.
I'm here to support the bill because even though my son receives waiver services, there are individuals on this list, the complete list, that are not receiving those services that they are eligible for and entitled to. And this bill would help to eliminate that issue. I continue to support all individuals of special needs, developmental disabilities, and intellectual disabilities, even though sometimes people have asked me, why do I
still do this? But there is a reason to fight and to continue to advocate, and I just would like to have a good vote for Representative Miller and his bill that we're voting on
today. Thank you, ma'am. Representative Miller, you are recognized to close for your bill. Thank
you, Mr. Chair and committee, for your indulgence. I certainly can't say anything any better than what these folks have said.
I will say this briefly in closing. I don't have all the answers. This is going to be a process. I want to get the ball rolling. I know the agency brought up earlier an issue about there being a lack of actual providers, folks to do the work. There is a clause in the bill that addresses that that says if there is a lack of providers, then the three-year time limit is actually,
it makes an exception in that case. I happen to believe that there will be enough providers. when this mechanism gets in place and starts working. Folks, I want to tell you that 13 years ago, I had just got moved home from rehab after my accident. And there was a waiver available for me, slightly different than the disability, the DD waiver.
But I have no doubt that had that not been in place and I've been able to get on it and to obtain some independence and be able to rejoin the workforce, I wouldn't be here today. I know that. These waivers have a big impact, a big impact on these folks. And with that, I would just appreciate a good
vote. Thank you, Representative. Representative Ladyman, you're recognized for that motion now.
You thought I was going to forget. Yes, I'd like to make a motion. And then as people that were here Thursday know that I had some concerns about this bill, and I appreciate Representative Miller adding the amendment, and I'd
like to make a motion due pass. As amended, right? As amended. As amended. Thank you. We got a motion due pass as amended. Is there any discussion on the motion? Representative
Speaker 78
1:24:52
Meeks, you're recognized for discussion. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And this is very difficult for me to actually do, because I know Representative Miller's heart.
I know he's genuinely passionate about this particular issue. And, you know, we both made a commitment to be able to adequately fund the waiting list. And I think we've made a good first step in doing so. I think the money from the tobacco settlement was a good first step. It is not the only step in order to fix the issue with our waiting list. I'm glad and stand alongside you, stand alongside the governor, DHS,
in continuing that particular work. But I still have a problem with this bill, and that is the precedent that it actually sets. To Representative Payton's point, yeah, we have fiscal sessions every year. We have a general session in two years, but that still does not alleviate my concerns about unintended consequences of this bill of the fact that we are prioritizing even though it's a very worthy cause that we're doing it that we're prioritizing the funding for this particular area.
It would be very easy for me to go in and file a bill to say we're going to adequately fund our foster care system that has over 5,000 kids in it right now that we're going to adequately fund it so that we have caseloads of no more than 20 per worker and that we have enough CASA workers and that we have enough mental and behavioral services to do that. But I'm not because of the same reason I can't support this bill, and that is the precedent that it set. And it's not foster care versus DD waiting list
or versus CHDC or versus anything else. It is the fact that we as a state would be very dangerous in order for us to start doing this particular thing. And so today, I'm asking my members to vote against this bill, but at the same time, make that promise, make that commitment, that even though we may not have this bill, if it doesn't pass, that we're still going to be committed to resolving this waiting list
and making sure that all these folks get the adequate services that
they need. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Representative Meeks. I'm going to make a note behind Representative Meeks. Every bill we've took up in this committee, I've asked for discussion, and it's that type of discussion that I'm looking for from the committee to actually give why or who without a question to the committee of how you feel. Representative
Speaker 78
1:27:30
Payton, did you have discussion? Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair. Members, I've been unashamedly in support of this idea, you know,
ever since Representative Miller became my friend, which was, to many people's surprise, it was when we got here. I didn't know him very much. As a matter of fact, I supported his opponent back home in his first race. But the truth of the matter is there is a lot to be said for the efficiencies of fully funding this waiting list.
and I understand that a lot of people have brought up, you know, well, we don't know the future and we're afraid of what this may do to the budget. I've pointed out that there's ample opportunity to make adjustments as we go forward. But scripture says without a vision, the people perish. Setting goals and timelines is nothing new, okay? If you're not doing that in your personal life and your businesses, I mean, you know, you're missing out on a lot of opportunity.
There is an opportunity to take care of this waiting list. It was brought to zero very quickly whenever a lawsuit was lost, and we were forced to do it. You know, having a mechanism to put a little pressure on to make sure that we get there is nothing to fear. The steps of a good man are ordered by the Lord. we don't have to fear where those steps are and those rocks in the water we just have to step out thank you mr. chair thank you representative Payton any
further discussion on the motion represent the appeal continue to recognize
for discussion what concerns me most about this bill is that it's an unfunded mandate I feel like we've already got a budget shortfall we've just cut taxes and then we're gonna now put another 54 million dollar hole in our pocket for people that are receiving benefits i mean this isn't an easy vote but i feel like we can't let emotions trump logic here and that's just all i
want to say thank you representative seeing no further discussion all those in favor say aye all those opposed
I'm going to put it on the roll
Speaker 37
1:30:05
Mr. Price if you would call it a roll Representative Love Representative Hammer Representative Hammer Representative Branscombe Representative Branscombe Representative Meeks
Representative Ritchie Representative Ritchie Representative McGee Representative Miller Representative Womack Representative Payton Representative Leidyman Representative Lundstrom
Representative Bentley Representative Gonzales Representative Boyd Representative Boyd Representative Henderson, Representative Henderson, Representative McCollum, Representative
Coleman, Representative Pilkington, Representative Ferguson, pass. Chair Ward-Long. Pass. One, two,
With six yay votes, your bill has failed, Representative Miller. All right. Thank you for your presentation. See you in no further business. We stand adjourned. Thank you.
Agenda
HB1264 Pilkington TO PROVIDE FOR REIMBURSEMENT FOR HEALTHCARE SERVICES PERFORMED BY A WALK-IN CLINIC OR EMERGENT CARE CLINIC WHEN THE PATIENT DOES NOT HAVE A PRIMARY CARE PROVIDER ASSIGNED.
HB1267 L. Fite TO CREATE THE USED TIRE RECYCLING AND ACCOUNTABILITY PROGRAM.
HB1300 Miller TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES TO PRIORITIZE SPENDING WITH THE DEPARTMENT AND THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO FULLY FUND HOME- AND COMMUNITY-BASED SERVICES FOR INDIVIDUALS WITH DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES.
HB1405 Lundstrum TO AMEND LAWS RELEVANT TO UNEMPLOYMENT TAXES, UNEMPLOYMENT BENEFITS AND UNEMPLOYMENT ELIGIBILITY.
HB1411 Penzo TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECKS FOR NURSING LICENSURE TO REMOVE A CONFLICT IN THE LAW.
SB95 Irvin TO WAIVE THE LICENSURE RENEWAL FEE CHARGED BY THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF DENTAL EXAMINERS, THE STATE BOARD OF OPTOMETRY, AND THE ARKANSAS MEDICAL STATE BOARD FOR CERTAIN ACTIVE-DUTY MILITARY HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONS.
HB1413 Boyd TO CREATE THE ALTERNATIVE TO DISCIPLINE ACT; AND TO PROVIDE FOR TREATMENT OF NURSES LICENSED IN ARKANSAS WHO SUFFER FROM IMPAIRMENT.
HB1428 Lundstrum TO AMEND LAWS CONCERNING UNLAWFUL ABORTIONS; TO AMEND LAWS CONCERNING THE PROCEDURE OF DENIAL, SUSPENSION, OR REVOCATION OF A HEALTH FACILITIES SERVICE LICENSE; AND TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING ABORTION CLINICS.
HB1434 Collins TO CREATE THE SEX DISCRIMINATION BY ABORTION PROHIBITION ACT.
HB1437 D. Ferguson TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING TELEMEDICINE; AND TO CREATE THE TELEMEDICINE ACT.
SB78 Bledsoe TO REQUIRE THE ARKANSAS STATE MEDICAL BOARD TO PERFORM AN ANALYSIS OF THE INTERSTATE MEDICAL LICENSURE COMPACT TO DETERMINE WHETHER THE STATE OF ARKANSAS SHOULD PARTICIPATE IN THE INTERSTATE MEDICAL LICENSURE COMPACT.
HB1439 M. Gray TO AMEND THE HEALTHCARE QUALITY AND PAYMENT POLICY ADVISORY COMMITTEE.
HB1443 M. Gray TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC
EXAMINERS.
SB170 Irvin TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION FOR LICENSURE FOR HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONALS OFFERING FREE HEALTHCARE SERVICES THROUGH A PROGRAM IN PARTNERSHIP WITH THE FEDERAL INNOVATIVE READINESS TRAINING.
SB229 S. Flowers TO REQUIRE CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECKS FOR ALCOHOLISM AND DRUG ABUSE COUNSELORS LICENSEES; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ALCOHOLISM AND DRUG ABUSE COUNSELORS.
Scope of Practice Bills Will be Considered in Committee During the Week of February 13, 2017 - February 17, 2017
Subtitle Sponsor Number
HB1034 C. Fite TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING HEARING INSTRUMENT DISPENSERS.
HB1180 Bentley TO AUTHORIZE ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES TO HAVE SIGNATURE AUTHORITY.
HB1181 Sullivan TO CREATE THE TRANSITION TO PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY ACT; AND TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY OF ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES.
HB1182 Sullivan THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO ALLOW AN ADVANCED TO AUTHORIZE PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE TO BE A PRIMARY CARE PROVIDER.
HB1183 Dotson TO PROVIDE CONSISTENCY AND EFFICIENCY OF CHIROPRACTIC COVERAGE IN THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM; AND TO ALLOW MEDICAID RECIPIENTS DIRECT ACCESS TO A CHIROPRACTIC PHYSICIAN WITHOUT REFERRAL FROM A PRIMARY CARE PHYSICIAN.
HB1186 Brown TO REMOVE THE COLLABORATIVE PRACTICE AGREEMENT AS APPLICABLE TO ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES; AND TO CLARIFY THE PROCESS NECESSARY FOR AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE TO QUALIFY FOR PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY.
HB1204 Magie TO ALLOW PHARMACISTS TO MAKE BIOLOGICAL PRODUCT SUBSTITUTIONS.
HB1205 Magie TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS ANESTHESIOLOGIST ASSISTANT ACT.
HB1215 Love TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING THE PRACTICE OF MASSAGE THERAPY TO INCLUDE THE PRACTICE OF CUPPING.
HB1228 Hammer TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY OF AN ADVANCED PRACTICE NURSE.
HB1237 Hammer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS SURGICAL TECHNOLOGISTS ACT; AND TO ESTABLISH THE REGISTRATION OF SURGICAL TECHNOLOGISTS.
HB1250 M. Gray TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS DENTAL PRACTICE ACT; TO AMEND THE DENTAL HYGIENIST COLLABORATIVE CARE PROGRAM; TO MODIFY THE APPOINTMENTS TO THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF DENTAL EXAMINERS; AND TO MODIFY DENTISTRY SPECIALTY LICENSES.
HB1255 D. Ferguson TO CREATE A TEMPORARY CHARITABLE DENTAL LICENSE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1257 Richey TO CREATE THE COMMUNITY HEALTH WORKER ACT.
HB1254 Magie TO TRANSFER REGULATORY AUTHORITY OVER ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES FROM THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF NURSING TO THE ARKANSAS STATE MEDICAL BOARD.
HB1021 TO PROVIDE PAY EQUITY FOR WOMEN; AND TO AMEND THE WAGE DISCRIMINATION Love LAWS CONCERNING PROHIBITED CONDUCT AND REMEDIES FOR VIOLATIONS OF THE WAGE DISCRIMINATION LAWS.
HB1160 A. Mayberry TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF A "SPECIALIST SIGN ELECTRICIAN".
HB1040 Farrer TO LIMIT THE PRACTICE OF ATHLETIC TRAINING IN A NONCLINICAL SETTING.
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Jeff Wardlaw Chair
Unverified
Speaker 3
Representative Lanny Fite
Unverified
Speaker 78
Speaker 111
Representative Deborah Ferguson
Unverified
Speaker 37
Speaker 52
Representative Mary Bentley
Unverified
Representative Robin Lundstrum
Unverified
Representative Josh Miller
Unverified
Representative Justin Gonzales
Unverified
Speaker 85
Speaker 92
Speaker 67
Esther Johnson
Unverified
Pam Forrester
Unverified
Speaker 130
Michael Thornton
Unverified
Veronica Tess
Unverified
Representative Jack Ladyman
Unverified
Representative Aaron Pilkington
Unverified
Speaker 48