Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Advanced Communications and Information Technology

February 8, 2017 ·Committee Room 130 ·51:32
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (2)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1364 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1364 Hendren TO ESTABLISH THE PUBLIC POLICY OF THE STATE OF ARKA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1410 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1410 Meeks TO AMEND THE TELECOMMUNICATIONS REGULATORY REFORM ACT…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
Speaker 1 0:00
platforms and this way you'll have an idea of what options are available so I'll turn it over to Joey so we have
▶ Play
Speaker 3 0:11
three devices for you today actually four counting the one that Tim's got the standard one that we're using for customers nowadays is our 7370 this is a laptop very thin very light enterprise This one has a touch screen. It comes with a silver back. There's no touch screen, but this is a carbon fiber back with the touch screen. Great device. Very light. You can see how I'm holding it. We'll pass that around in a sec. Second one, you all know and love the XPS 13. I'm sure you've seen some of these floating around internally. There is a newer version out of this. It actually has a hinge change to where it can now flip backwards and be more like a two-in-one device rather than just the traditional laptop. So same look, same feel, you know, from the touch and whatnot, same weight profile, but it now has that two-in-one flip capability.
▶ Play
That one's the newer version of what we currently have. That's the Neuron. Now, these two laptops, are they laptops slash tablets? Or how would you characterize them? Or what would be the two primary differences between the two models? So the
▶ Play
Speaker 3 1:40
7370, the black one, is a traditional laptop. It's probably going to be your lightest option from a weight perspective. The silver one you see, the newer version is a 2-in-1, so it can be a crossover between the two. Now, the screen does not separate from the laptop, you know, from the keyboard portion, so it is still one device, but you can flip it over and use it like a tablet, like you've seen. Okay. On the 2-in-1, are they both running Windows 10, or
▶ Play
what platform are they? There's 10 on both. Okay. Representative McCollum, do you have a question?
▶ Play
Yes, on this second one right here. so you said the newer version as in not the one we're holding today but it has the capability to fold back into more of a tablet type correct the silver the one with the silver back thank you
▶ Play
any other questions on these two models the second one is the one
▶ Play
that can flip back and act like a tablet also is it touchscreen also so that said correct so it functions like a tablet so it's touch screen and everything that you
▶ Play
know when will that newer version be available oh it's been out since
▶ Play
Speaker 3 2:46
January I just don't have it in my possession okay okay all right colleagues any
▶ Play
other questions on these two models okay so
▶ Play
Speaker 3 2:59
this is the 7275 this is actually a two-in-one device as well similar if you've seen a surface pro a Microsoft surface pro so you can see the profile here when it's separated. It's got a keyboard. It's a hard keyboard. You can kind of hear the clicks, I'm sure, in the background. Makes a little bit of a difference. I've used keyboards that don't have a click to them, and it doesn't feel like a keyboard when you're using it, so it's a little more difficult to use. So we do also sell the Surface Pro. So we have this form factor, which has this nice canvas feel to it, and we have the Microsoft Surface Pro as well if you want the actual tablet that can separate and again is that
▶ Play
Windows 10 platform Windows 10 platform all all these are Windows
▶ Play
Speaker 3 3:46
10 Windows 10 okay and Tim brought the ones that you all see the latitude 11 you've used these before there is there are keyboard options for this one where it will dock in the keyboard and you can use it in your lap there's a soft keyboard for this one it's a little more difficult to use in the lap it's more if we're using on a table, but it is a smaller device and slightly lighter than
▶ Play
the 7275 being passed around. That one's the same. And on these devices, I know as a lawmaker, sometimes we're called on to give, you know, PowerPoints, presentations, things like that. How are they, It used to be you would use DVDs to load software. The ones that are more of the tablet ones, is there a way to use those to do PowerPoint presentations or if I want to load more software on it, are we using thumb drives or how does that take place with these newer
▶ Play
Speaker 3 4:45
devices? So for presentations, for all of those devices, they have a port on the side called a lightning port, which is a very small newer USB connector. And you'll see this little device right here has VGA, HDMI. It has an Ethernet port as well as a USB port, a full-sized USB port. So that's kind of how you would use a USB key to bring in more information or to
▶ Play
Speaker 1 5:12
present. Okay. Okay, thanks. The other thing I would add is on this particular model, this is the stack that we just purchased for the Bureau for the analyst positions. and so they have a very mobile light. They have ability to carry all of their equipment, handle all of the audio-visual requirements, power requirements. They can even charge their cell phone on the same power that they're charging their laptop while they're running their committee meeting. And so that's just, if we want to look further into this, we have about 12 of these in the Bureau that we use on a regular basis that so far we've been really happy with. And so I guess
▶ Play
the next question that I would have is, you know, the reason why we're doing this is to kind of test the different technologies. If we picked two or three devices, would there be where we could, you know, play with them for a week or so to see what we like and what we don't like? Or is this, you know, we decide on one and we go? Or what are you guys kind of thinking? Or what's
▶ Play
Speaker 3 6:12
your policy there? So we have a try and buy program. I can send you all the devices and you can play with them, test them out for up to 60 days. If you like them, make a purchase for them. If not,
▶ Play
Speaker 36 6:24
return them with no strings attached. Okay. Representative Dodson.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. On this particular device, is the keyboard charged separately from the device, or does the device charge the keyboard? There is no battery in that keyboard.
▶ Play
Speaker 3 6:40
That device has its own battery and supports itself. So it's not Bluetooth keyboard? No, it requires those connectors you see. It has to
▶ Play
be connected. Correct. Okay. Thank you. Okay. Colleagues, any other questions? So, Representative Saver, did you have any? Okay. So, I guess at this point, we'll let Representative Del Rosso get to the table here. So, are these the four primary devices that we're looking at?
▶ Play
Speaker 1 7:14
We'll let them kind of pass it around. The only other device that we didn't show today was the Microsoft Surface, but that particular model is almost a near identical representation, but Dell can also sell those and have the warranties and support for that as well. Okay. Thank
▶ Play
you Mr. Chair, sorry I might have missed this but you said this was the device that you're currently using and is in committees or was it that device, the one with the keyboard
▶ Play
Speaker 1 8:09
attached. The tablet device in your hand is the one we're currently using that we just purchased. And does this have a keyboard support? Yes. With the stack that we bought for the committee rooms that we didn't purchase the keyboards, but yes, you could have a clamshell keyboard attached to that device
▶ Play
as well. And would that keyboard be Bluetooth or direct connect? Physical connection. Okay. Thank you.
▶ Play
I'll go ahead and prep center. Thanks. This is more of a comment than a question. I would say, I don't want to speak for everyone, but just out of flexibility and getting around, I would imagine folks would be more interested in the tablet-like. We probably, for the most part, already have laptops, and I think we've seen the advantage of having the tablets in the conference rooms. And then, so if you could, could you break down, I know you mentioned the difference between the keyboards and the two tablets, but could you expand maybe even more on some of the differences between the two tablets
▶ Play
Speaker 3 9:19
that are being passed around here? So yeah, the 7275 with the Canvas backing, that one's got a larger screen. It's going to be a little more premium feel to it. It's going to have a little better processors in it, A little more RAM capability from a technical standpoint, you know, those are speeds and feeds. The utilization, that one doesn't sit in the lap as well as the Latitude 11 does with its keyboard. So that one's made more to use on a table. You can see with the little kickstand in the back. But otherwise, from a specs capabilities perspective, they're pretty much identical machines. It's whether you want the larger screen, the thinner profile of the 7275, or if you want the smaller screen, slightly thicker profile of the 5000
▶ Play
series. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So if I understand it correctly, this device, the smaller device, is the one that's in all the committees right now. So from a functionality standpoint, if we decided that we wanted to move away from having all of these in committee and use the devices that are already purchased and assign them to individuals, that would potentially save us quite a bit of cost of purchasing another platform or a bunch of other devices.
▶ Play
Speaker 3 10:38
You could purchase the keyboards, and they would act as a normal laptop two-in-one
▶ Play
device. With already current technology that we have already purchased, right? Correct. Thank you. Correct.
▶ Play
Any other questions? So I guess maybe why don't we kind of take a week or so and kind of mull over which of these four, and let's maybe narrow it down to two. And what I would suggest, and anybody's more than welcome to come up with something else, is maybe let's narrow it down to two. We'll get five of each for trial. Let half the committee use one of them for a week. Let the other half play with the other one for a week. and then the following week we'll swap them and then we can narrow it down to a choice from there if that sounds reasonable to
▶ Play
Speaker 80 11:37
everybody. Just a quick question. Do these come with like little briefcases to carry them in? Do these have little
▶ Play
Speaker 3 11:44
carrying cases? Yeah, we have several styles. I can send an accessory sheet along with that kind of shows all the different accessories available because there's too many to bring into the conference room today but yes that you have about two or three bag options you have two or three battery options you'll it'll show the little hockey puck sized adapter that I showed so it'll have a lot of all those
▶ Play
things on it that are thank you all right colleagues any other questions okay everyone good
▶ Play
with that plan is that will that be so just as a thought if we are if we're going to be getting some trial versions I would suggest that we get this one as a trial and maybe get some of the keyboards for the committee laptop or committee ones so we can see those but then also possibly get a few of the trials for the laptop that has the touch screen that goes all the way over so that we have three different devices but we're only actually getting two sets of new devices. Okay.
▶ Play
So Representative Dotson's suggestion is we do five of the foldable, the newer ones that have the touch screen keyboard attached, five of the one with the portfolio. Yeah, that one right there. So five of those and then a couple of keyboards that match up with the current tablets that and just a question you know we'll be able to
▶ Play
Speaker 65 13:25
provide us a cost differential on each of those three different options so we yeah there'd be no problem there okay
▶ Play
all right so it sounds like we have a plan is there any other questions from the committee all right well we'll pass those back to y'all so you'll have those and then gentlemen we
▶ Play
Speaker 68 13:54
appreciate you being here and look forward to
▶ Play
thanks again mr. chairman and the members of the committee all right colleagues next we're gonna go to ask mr. Brett Hooten if he would come on up and the last General Assembly, we passed a law creating a open data and transparency task force. The idea was to look at how we are handling data within the state and opportunities for efficiencies and so forth. Mr. Hooten was tasked by the governor to lead that task force. They have the report ready. So I'm going to let him, if you would, just introduce yourself to the committee and tell us what the committee found. Absolutely. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Thank you, members of the committee. Thank you for the opportunity to present the report to you. My name is Brett Hooten, and last year I chaired the Open Data and Transparency Task Force. The task force was comprised of about four legislators, eight department directors, and then four other appointees. I really appreciate their work through the course of the year. We were supposed to meet at least every other month. I think we ended up meeting about nine times last year, so it was a significant effort, and I appreciate what they did. You should have in front of you, or it's going to be in front of you, our report that we put together that includes a recommendation as well. I also want to thank the staff support we received from DIS and specifically Linda Englehart for her support throughout the effort. Linda, if you would, please raise your
▶ Play
hand so everybody knows, puts a name with a face. All right, thank you, sir. So we were tasked, in a general sense,
▶ Play
without getting into the specific details, with how the state could better utilize the data that the state maintains, holds, and is frankly a steward thereof. Most large companies would consider their data to be one of, if not their most valuable resource, and the state maintains an inordinate amount of data. However, that data is typically not maintained in a fashion that is transparent, available to the public, or even as useful as it could be within state governments, as it sometimes is not easily able to be shared between departments or agencies. That untapped potential in the data maintained by the state is exceptional, both from uses internal to state government and external to state government. We broke our recommendation and really our analysis into two parts. And you'll see that reflected in the report. The first part deals with data warehousing, and the second part deals with data transparency. And we'll talk about them separately. And it is possible to implement the two parts separate from each other, however, there are significant efficiencies gained by utilizing them together. We'll talk first about part one, which we titled data warehousing. And when you think about data warehousing, it's important not to think in the traditional warehouse sense. It's not necessarily a single spot where you have everything. Think of it instead as more of a networking of data so that all the data can talk to each other, be accessed with appropriate security and privacy controls in place, and can be accessed in combination with each other. And really the data warehousing does a few things. The first is it allows for cross-departmental data sharing and data communication without having a manual process to share data between the departments. It allows for quick and automatic analytics, which helps to filter for fraud, waste, and abuse, allows for more efficient and secure data sharing between departments, and can reduce error from having multiple data entries and ensures only the correct users have access. this. So if you think about a citizen today, how many different data records does the state maintain for those individuals? I don't know the answer, and our task force doesn't necessarily know the answer either. But that's just one instance where you have multiple records for the same citizen that could potentially have different types of data for that individual, and that data may not always be the same. That's simply because with millions of records, there's inevitably going to be data errors. Being able to compile the data so that it talks to each other can help reduce those errors, reduce the amount of time data has to be entered, and makes it so it's not quite as manual a process. At the beginning of our discussion last year with the task force, we wanted to look at what are other states doing on this effort. We actually were very fortunate. We had one representative from the state of Ohio actually attend our meeting in person. We also had three other states who participated via a video conference. Those three were Indiana, North Carolina, and Iowa. In those discussions, they reviewed multiple efficiencies that were gained, and I want to point out specifically the representative from North Carolina offered that with multiple states working on this, there's value in working together, and the state of North Carolina offered their assistance. As we move forward, or if the General Assembly and the governor decides to move forward with this effort, that they are interested in working with us to share their lessons learned and also to learn from what we want to do as well. One example of some of the work the other states have done, one state actually implemented as a pilot program a centralized data warehouse that focused on law enforcement and the court system and integrated offender data. That worked so well that today they actually used that same infrastructure to have 25 different initiatives across departmental boundaries, with the eventual goal of having no silos within those departments. Siloing is obviously a problem within state governments, a problem within private companies as well that is constantly trying to be addressed, and this data warehousing solution where all that data can talk to each other is one way to help address the siloing concern. Other testimony that was more broad and more general indicated that housing the data across multiple agencies in a format that allows for research and analytics, provides for the ability to more efficiently and effectively secure data, more efficiently use information and technology infrastructure, collaborate, corroborate, and identify voter fraud. There's one notable example, or I would say the most notable example, and you'll see in your report we reference several reports that you can find online, and one is a report put out by McKinsey and Company that talks about the macro level of potential there is in savings on the data warehouse and making that data public, which we'll talk about in part two. There's also reference to a report put out by the state of New York when they implemented data warehousing solution with the corresponding analytics. And just in focusing on tax fraud, Only one area where analytics can be useful. In one single year, they reduced fraudulent tax returns by $1.2 billion. They also increased tax collections by $100 million, representing about a $1.3 billion savings in one single year. Now, obviously, that's the state of New York. I'm sure their tax revenues are much more significant. it. But nonetheless, I think it represents the potential efficiencies that could be created by a program that utilizes a centralized data warehouse and the corresponding analytics. So as we talk about the recommendation, you are going to see in there a proposal for a couple of new positions to help implement whatever proposal comes out of the General Assembly. So while it is creating new positions, we do believe, and the task force believes, that the overall efficiencies and savings from this project could be quite substantial. So I want to talk about the recommendation on part one, the data warehouse, and we broke it up into three phases, and that's really for implementation purposes, and it allows you to not have to jump in all the way before you know how the program is going to proceed. It does recommend the creation of two new positions. The first is a chief data officer within the Department of Information Systems. The second is a chief privacy officer, and that chief privacy officer is also important. The primary concern that was brought up throughout our discussions was the issue of data privacy and securing the data. It's extremely important that as we look towards a centralized data component that we can't solve everything, and not all data can still be seen by all departments, and that's intentional. There's some data through either state statute, federal statutes, that simply cannot be shared throughout all departments. That chief privacy officer is to help to ensure compliance with those obligations. Once those positions are in place, we recommend that a feasibility and cost study be performed. We did not have it within our resources to go in and do a cost estimate on the entire cost of what a data warehousing solution would be. However, we do think a feasibility and cost study should be the first step and one of the first action items for a chief data officer. We also recommend the creation of a panel on data and transparency. One of the great benefits of the legislation that was passed that created the Open Data and Transparency Task Force was that it did include departments from across state government and the directors of those departments. We think that's important going forward to ensure that there's buy-in to ensure a smooth transition into a centralized data warehouse. This panel on data and transparency, we recommend it be made up in a similar fashion to the open data and transparency task force, however, unlike the task force whose work concluded at the end of last year, this would be an ongoing panel that would work with the chief data officer and the chief privacy officer. The next step that was included in phase one was a process to identify data that could be included in a data warehouse, and primarily we called that working on a data catalog. So the responsibility of the CDO and the panel would be to first catalog all data housed within the state at different agencies and departments, determine what format that data is in, and identify what of that data is appropriate to include in a data warehouse and what of that data is considered sensitive or private. That would of course include a privacy review. The last item would be to include a scope of the data warehouse. We did not scope out what a full data warehouse would include in terms of hardware, software, or networking components. That would be a responsibility of the chief data officer. After that, the additional phases are really going to be guided on what that scope would entail and the scope outlined by the General Assembly. But we anticipate that's when you would actually start integrating the data into the data warehouse. Everything in phase one is preliminary and getting ready to move into that data integration to ensure that integration happens both smoothly, timely, and in a manner that ensures the protection of citizens' data. The last is really what the full vision of the statewide data warehouse would be. We want to ensure whatever's put in place is scalable. We don't want to box ourselves into a solution that we can't grow with. One potential item to think about in terms of ways it could expand local government data right now is not easily accessible by departments within the state. If we could create a program or a solution that's able to be scalable to, at some point in the future, effectualize including those local governments, I think that would be a significant value there. Lastly, I just want to remind everybody about the security. Even in a data warehouse, and I think especially in a data warehouse, you can better control who accesses the data and ensuring that when that data is transferred, it's done so in a more secure fashion.
▶ Play
The second part was data transparency. And, Mr. Hood, before you do the second part, I wanted to stop and see if there's any questions on the first
▶ Play
part. So the first part, data warehousing. Okay, Representative Blake. In other states that are using this data warehouse with big data, What state agencies are they using, I guess, commonly for – are we seeing DF&A as well as the state police and Department of Corrections, procurement? Do you have a list?
▶ Play
Speaker 78 26:45
I don't have a list, but what I
▶ Play
can tell you is that it varies significantly from state to state. Some states, and one of the ones that the example we referenced here, really started with a pilot program focused on the criminal justice side of government. They started with integrating the courts, law enforcement, parole, onto a single information system. And from there, they've expanded it to 25 others. And so it can get quite broad. I think you have other states that have been more progressive and moved more quickly, and you see that they are using it for a broad range of departments
▶ Play
within the state. And I'd follow up one of the practical examples that we heard of this and it was kind of one of those ingenious and I think it was the state of Michigan. They were having problem finding child support dads who weren't paying their full child support because the data was outdated. Well, they combined the data from the child support enforcement agency with their hunting licenses and they found out that a lot of those dads they couldn't find with child support had hunting license. They combined the data, and they found it was like over half of them. And so the state had the data. It was just in two different silos. And when they started combining them, they found efficiencies, and they were able. So that was kind of a practical example of how this can be used. It's kind of one of those ingenious things. Well, why didn't anybody think of that before? But, you know. Okay.
▶ Play
Speaker 80 28:13
Representative Brown. Thank you, Representative Meeks. One of the things that came up, I believe, in the health care task force discussions was the number of people who had insurance under our private option that were ineligible, legally ineligible, to be on that program. And I think we had some discussion at that time how if we could integrate our data, say with driver's license or whatever, it would have turned up that those people weren't actually residents of the state. And that's the kind of efficiencies we're looking at, right?
▶ Play
Absolutely. And with that example, anything you can think of where there may be data on an individual be valuable to one effort, but maybe it's held in a different department. Anything like that, you can even create it with data analytics so that it's automatic. So those searches don't have to be an ad hoc, oh, I wonder if I can find this data somewhere else. If you structure your centralized data warehouse appropriately and have appropriate analytics associated with it, those checks can be automatic. And that's what you see with the state of New York. Their $1.2 billion in savings was not by manually going in and spot checking, but having it written so that it automatically spits out those results and can automatically create incident reports or investigation reports to let the investigators know where they need to look and target their investigations. Thank
▶ Play
you. Okay. Any other questions on this, colleagues? Okay.
▶ Play
Representative McCall. So I think we understand a lot of the advantages that can come with the relationship of the data from the different departments. I'm curious in hearing currently, which departments do we have a study that aren't able to talk to each other? And currently, is there any type of data warehouse that we talk about right now? Is this just another step in basically starting from the beginning with primary keys from every different type
▶ Play
of data source that we have? Yeah, so each department will right now obviously use control of their data. DIS also participates and for some departments manages that. I think you would see though that cross-departmental usage right now is somewhat, manual is not the right word, but it's not efficient for a couple of weeks. We heard some good examples of requesting data from one department to the other. You may receive the data, but it's not in a format that's extremely usable for you, And so there's some post-processing that has to take place to utilize that data. I do think as a part of that initial data catalog development, and that's one of the reasons why we put it at the very beginning in our recommendation, and when I conclude I'll talk about the things that are actionable, that would be appropriate to be actionable at this time, it would include of all data components within all departments, what the format of that data is in, who has access to it today, and what it would take to standardize that data. So I don't have an answer to your question on the macro level, but I do know that there would be significant effort
▶ Play
Speaker 80 31:20
to put that catalog together. Thank you. Through an unfortunate situation with a constituent of mine, I've learned that our DHS, I don't know if their entire system is on COBOL, but I've got a very ill constituent that keeps falling out of the system, and they have to keep manually adding him back in, and they are supposed to be converting to a new system, I think, by June. I'm just curious, how many of our state agencies are on antiquated computer systems? I imagine it's significant, but we did not look into
▶ Play
the specific systems that are being used. So, but each of those,
▶ Play
Speaker 80 32:00
like, you probably would want them to upgrade their system to be able to, so they could talk to each other better, right?
▶ Play
I think what's more important than the system they use is the format in which the data is in. And so there would have to be some updates potentially to be made on how the data is held and maintained to ensure that data is shareable. If they're using systems that require data to be in a certain format and that format is not usable by other departments, then it would be a situation where there may have to be some system updates at the departmental level as well. I think that's something that would need to be identified through that data catalog process.
▶ Play
Speaker 80 32:39
So you're saying that even if we have some departments that are still using these old computer systems, they could actually format their information so it would be compatible to be shared?
▶ Play
Potentially, and I don't think you could answer that question without having an IT professional look at it, and I am not one, what I think would be important would be their system that's accessing their data, sitting somewhere, the format of that data that's sitting there is what's important, not necessarily the system they're using to access that data. Now if that data has to be in a certain format so their antiquated system could access it, then there may have
▶ Play
to be updates that would be required. Thank
▶ Play
you. Colleagues, any other questions? Okay, let's go to part two. Part two deals with data transparency, and when we talk about data transparency, I want to shift your thinking from how data is used internally within the state to what value could be provided by making the data that the state maintains accessible to the public, both for private citizens and public companies. When you think about the state, one of the comments that your chairman made during our task force was that the state and the departments are really stewards of this data. And so as stewards of the data, what is the most efficient and cost-effective use of that and what efficiencies can be provided to the public for that data? Data transparency means making data available in a manner that is usable and easily accessible. And it's important that that data be maintained in a machine-readable format. And what I mean by that is you can make something transparent and public by taking a Word document and putting it on the website, or taking a PDF document and putting it on the website. On a macro level, that's not very usable for most public companies. They're not able to take that data, massage it, and utilize it to provide value to the local economy. So what's important is that you provide that data in a machine-usable format. It's XML files, CVS files, CSV files, not the pharmacy, CSV files, data that can be uploaded and utilized. Now, I'll give you one example that was discussed, LinkedIn, you're probably familiar with LinkedIn. In other states, LinkedIn is able to pull unemployment data straight from the state's website. They didn't utilize that data on a county by county level to target unemployed with job opportunities and so they're able to to enhance their targeting because they have that sufficient that data available from the state right now if someone wants to access the state's unemployment data you can get it on a grant on a high level they're unable to use that to target and that in addition to of course providing value to the company provides value to the the local citizens and especially those that are unemployed and those businesses that are searching for applicants so that's just one example another example was a company that presented to the task force and they are in other states able to pull from the state's website all the vacancies at its parks and campgrounds and you can think of it as like a hotels.com except for campgrounds but it utilizes state data to let individuals know where there are vacancies without having to manually go to the state website and look at different parks identify where there are vacancies, then decide where you want to go. Puts it in more of an aggregated format, and then they can share that with potential customers and those who want to utilize the campgrounds within the state. For this, it's a fairly simple concept in terms of making the data transparent, but it has broad benefits. And we, again, have this recommendation broken into three phases. And this phase is easier if you have the data warehouse solution because all the data is maintained in a single or accessible through a single process. But this is possible on an agency-by-agency basis. One good example of an agency internal to the state that's doing this now is GIS. They have an exceptional website where you can go out and look at almost all the data that they maintain that can be made public. If you have some time, it's really interesting to go out there and click around on. So it is able to be done without the data warehousing solution, but you receive a lot more efficiencies if you do it together, including the creation of those two new positions and the panel. The first is develop a statewide data standardization policy. So I mentioned that some data you can make it transparent and public, but it's not very useful. process similar to the data catalog, but would be more focused on standardizing the data so that it can be shared in a format that's usable by the public. The second, and probably the most important, is the categorization of that data between what data is private or sensitive, what data is non-sensitive, and then even data that individually may be sensitive, aggregated may not be sensitive. We heard an example of one state that was able to publish their infant mortality rates, and individuals were able to, or companies were able to run analytics to look at this public data and try to cross compare to see if there was correlations between infant mortality and other data maintained by the state. And so there's a lot of, you really open the door to innovation by having outside companies being able to look at the data rather than it's something that the state has just done. But that can only be done if that data standardization policy is in place, and then also that there is correct controls over the privacy of the data. Second phase is, of course, the publication of the data, and again, when I mean publication of the data, I don't mean just putting out a PDF on the website, but posting where the files could actually be downloaded to be utilized by private companies. And then the last is to enhance efficiencies and citizen transparency. We actually propose that there be an annual review by the chief privacy officer, the chief data officer, and the panel to determine if there's additional data that could be made transparent. Either that's because data is now housed by the state that wasn't before, and what can we do with that data, or is there data that maybe is more sensitive than it used to be because of additional data points added to it that we need additional controls around to ensure that it is protected. So we do propose an ongoing review of that. That recommendation sounds easier. shorter, but there's more work on the front end for the standardization of the data and ensuring the privacy of the data since it is data that would go public. So with that, I would like to, I could take questions at this time or I could mention what I think is actionable at this time
▶ Play
and then take questions at the end. Why don't we go ahead and
▶ Play
look at the actionable stuff and then we'll go from there. So in our report, in the executive summary, we mentioned there are six items that we think are important that could be moved forward with without jumping into full implementation of the entire report. The first two are the creation of those two positions, the chief data officer and the chief privacy officer, and the creation of a panel on data and transparency. The fourth is a requirement for the CDO in coordination with the CPO, so the chief data Officer, the Chief Privacy Officer, to perform a feasibility and cost study, as described in Part 1 regarding the data warehouse. The fifth item is a requirement to develop the data standards and specifications as discussed in the transparency section. And then lastly, to evaluate and identify what data could be published. So this is all work that should not require the addition of new hardware, new networking. It's the upfront work to see what all is possible and in the cost and feasibility thereof. And so we feel that's something that's actionable without having to go in all the way. And it would give the assembly additional information to further provide input on what the scope of a data warehouse solution could look like. So with that, that concludes the presentation of the report, but I'd obviously be willing to answer any questions. Okay. Colleagues, any questions
▶ Play
on these two items? Okay. Thank you.
▶ Play
How long would that take? In our scope, or in the report, we actually identified the time frame for each phase. Now this is our estimate, so of course that could change. The phase, let me get to it so I don't speak incorrectly. We recommended that phase one of the data warehousing would probably take between 12 to 18 months. That's primarily for two reasons. One is that data catalog could be a significant effort to undertake for the chief data officer and the panel. And the second, and one thing that I think is extremely important that we were able to get consensus on during our discussions, is that you get buy-in from the different agencies and departments. As you can imagine, there's always concern on when there's data that you're perceived to own, even though you're really a steward of that data, and giving up some control over that. to others on that. So it's important to get buy-off from the different departments and agencies and having them all at the table to talk about it. And so we think that it is worth spending the time up front to do that effort so that the integration goes smoothly. So we're really talking a year
▶ Play
Speaker 80 42:25
to a year and a half. Follow-up. So, but now, Wendy, you want, timeline-wise, creation of these two positions and the panel, That seems like something you'd want to do rather immediately. Yeah. Yeah, so the year to
▶ Play
year and a half would be once those positions are in place. And that's the piece that we would have to do. So by releasing this report, if we accept these recommendations, then we would have to file legislation to create this panel and then get with the Department of Information Systems to see if they have pool positions available where they could make these two hires. Thank you. And for those that are not familiar, I know some of the veterans here remember, I think, Representative Mayberry, the first year, I think it was first or second year, our first or second term, we created the transparency portal where any citizen can go online and look at the expenditures of state government. I don't know how many of you have ever gone on there. So there's a perfect example of transparency. But if you try to go on there and look at that data, it can be kind of unwieldy, trying to figure out where you're going. And one of the things that we would like to see is there's a lot of state governments that make this data available, and you have private entities will go out and develop apps around that data and put it in nice, you know, pretty formats and graphs that's easy to read. A perfect example, like on the GIS data, if, you know, if you go to Google Maps or MapQuest right now, and you Google an address, it'll drop a pinpoint on the exec. Well, the way that's made available is that state data that they've got from the GIS folks to be able to do that, and so that requires that standardization, and those are the kind of things that we're looking at. Any other questions? Okay. Seeing none, without objection, we will file this report, and colleagues, if any of you are interested in looking at this legislation or working on this legislation, just get with me afterwards and we'll kind of develop our game plan, so to speak. With that, Mr. Hoot, we thank you. We definitely appreciate the work that you and the task force did on this. Thank you very much. Appreciate your time. Okay. We have one last presenter today. It is the, I think it's the quarterly report, Mr. Matthews. If you would, take the end of the table. And if you would, kind of briefly go over what the report is and then present the report. And with that, you're recognized,
▶ Play
sir. Okay, thank you. My name is Donnie Matthews. I work for the Department of Information Systems. I manage our Customer Relationship Management Division. And for some of you that may be new, just to give you a brief background, we're a state agency. We coordinate IT efforts throughout the state. We've got roughly 220 employees. We're a cost recovery agency, so we actually bill out for our services. We've got roughly from a month-to-month basis around 330 entities that we bill each month, and that can range from DHS to the barber board. And so we provide roughly $8 million a month in IT solutions to state agencies, boards, commissions, a few k-12 obviously a few higher ed entities and some city county governments so we uh we provide a quarterly report to the legislature and it's supposed to give you a general idea of the advice and type of recommendations we're making as it relates to it and so that's what we do obviously there's a lot going on so it's not a comprehensive list so what i like to do is kind of hit some of the high points give you a general idea on the things that we're seeing and then obviously answer any questions you may have as far as it relates to DIS and the services we provide so that's okay we have several items in this month's report one of the things I want to give you an update on was the k-12 broadband project and so we're making steady progress there we're upgrading the broadband to all k-12 schools throughout the state we work real closely with Department of Education to do that we've currently converted 216 out of 276 school districts throughout the state so we're still on track to meet our it's a two year project that is due to be completed this summer and we're still on track to complete that within the time frame so we convert districts throughout the week with the ultimate goal of having everyone on the new network by the beginning of the next school year so we're making good progress there work closely with the vendors and then obviously the Department of Education to do that so one of the things we do a lot of people don't think in these terms as relates to IT, facility moves. So a good example of that is the Department of Heritage. They recently brought on a new facility. We worked real closely with them to make sure that we provided all the logistics as it relates to IT to make that as smooth as transitions as possible. So we helped them move, obviously, all of their equipment, reroute the networks, install new phones, help with any cabling or any fiber work that needed to be done there. So that was a big project for us. A couple of smaller moves, just to give you an idea of kind of what we do. Community Corrections has a new facility in West Memphis. We're working real closely with them. We actually have people there today, kind of helping with logistics of that. They have another site in Danville, a smaller site we're helping get installed. The Board of Engineers, I don't know if you know, they have the facility over here in front of the Capitol, the White Building. It's being renovated, so they've moved temporarily. We helped with that move to provide all the IT that goes along with that. During this last quarter, we worked real closely with our state agencies on a cybersecurity risk assessment, basically to go in and work with them to see where there may be holes as it relates to cybersecurity, make recommendations associated with that. That was a very large project for us. This is kind of a timely one, legislative tracking. We actually provide a legislative tracking application that a lot of our agencies use so that they can track bills that come across internally, make comments, make edits, and so they're aware of what's going on with the legislature. We have two state data centers. We have one at the MAC building, and then we have another one out on West Little Rock. And so a lot of what we do revolves around those data centers. We're working closely with customers that are collapsing services that they're providing today, maybe in more of an unsecured environment. We're working with them to get that in the state data center, secure that data, to make sure we're being stewards of the state's data. Working real closely with the crime lab on a project to do that. Another one we're working with is assessment coordination department. One of the big things we've been working on over the past few months is with parks and tourism. And so they're looking to make technology upgrades to a lot of the parks. We recently converted two of their larger phone systems, Lake DeGray, Resort, and Mount Magazine, to our voiceover IP solution that we manage. and then we're also working real closely with them on public wi-fi so they're trying to compete with hotels and other things you go and you have wi-fi so we're working real closely with them to do that in a secure manner so the public can take advantage of wi-fi when they're at the lodges or the parks um working real closely with the real estate commission they're looking to update their licensing application and so they've come to us with help for that so we're making a lot of recommendations as it relates to that and hopefully going to start that project very soon so that's a That's a pretty big development effort for us. That's basically all I had. I'd love to have
▶ Play
any questions of you. One question, since you mentioned cybersecurity, can you tell the committee how often there are cyber attacks against state systems? Sure. Well, we have a lot of,
▶ Play
of course, I'm not from our cybersecurity group, so I'll speak at a high level, but we have a security division that secures the state's network and secures the state's data, and that's basically their job, right? We have several people associated with that. We have several tools that both monitor and prevent intrusion into the state network. So it's constant. The numbers are very high. And so obviously we get you the stats on that. But we're being proactive in that monitoring. We notify the agencies when we see something's up, right? So we have contacts at each agency. We reach out to them and say, hey, you need to look at this. Or in some cases we say, hey, you need to get this device off the network to make sure that the state's data and the state network are as secure as possible. And
▶ Play
correct me if I'm wrong, I've heard that our state networks get hit thousands of times a day. Is that correct? It's staggering the number of attacks we have on our... Which is not uncommon.
▶ Play
They're not just for us. This is kind of throughout the industry. Okay. All right, colleagues,
▶ Play
any questions for Mr. Matthews? All right. Seeing none, thank you, sir. We appreciate you being here today. All right, colleagues, I have nothing else on the agenda, and I know everybody's ready for lunch, So we'll stand adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

PRESENTATIONS

1. Open Data & Transparency Task Force, Findings and Recommendations Report, Brett Hooton, Chairman

14:40 - 45:10 77 segments 6 speakers

2. Department of Information Systems, Advice and Recommendation Report, December 31, 2016, Donnie Matthews, Information Systems Manager

45:10 - 51:29 17 segments 2 speakers

Regular Agenda Subtitle Sponsor Number

HB1364 Hendren TO ESTABLISH THE PUBLIC POLICY OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS ON THE USE OF K. ELECTRONIC DEVICES.

DEFERRED Subtitle Sponsor Number

HB1410 Meeks TO AMEND THE TELECOMMUNICATIONS REGULATORY REFORM ACT OF 2013; AND TO S. PROHIBIT A TELECOMMUNICATIONS PROVIDER FROM RESTRICTING RESIDENTIAL INTERNET DATA USAGE.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Speaker 1
5 segments
Speaker 3
18 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
37 segments
Representative Austin McCollum Unverified
6 segments
Representative Frances Cavenaugh Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 36
1 segment
Representative Jim Dotson Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 80
8 segments
Speaker 65
1 segment
Speaker 68
1 segment
Brett Hooten Unverified
52 segments
Representative Charles Blake Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 78
1 segment
Donnie Matthews Unverified
13 segments