Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

State Agencies & Govt'l Affairs- Constitutional Issues Subcommittee

February 21, 2017 ·Committee Room 151 ·40:38
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (20)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HJR1003 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HJR1003 Gillam AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION TO AMEND T…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1007 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…I ready for the next one? Yes, sir. You recognize. This is House Joint Resolution 1007. And the subtitle, an amendment to the Arkansas Constitutio…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1002 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1002 S. Meeks AN TO CONSTITUTION ARKANSAS THE FOR PROVIDE AMENDM…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1004 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1004 Leding AN AMENDMENT TO ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION, ARTICLE 5, SE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1005 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1005 Lowery THE PUBLIC EDUCATION PARTNERSHIP AMENDMENT OF 2018.”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1006 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1006 K. Hendren A CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT REPEALING THE FISCAL…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1008 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1008 Dotson AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION TO PROVIDE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1009 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1009 Dotson AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION TO PROVIDE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1010 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1010 Dotson AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNING…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1011 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1011 Drown AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNING…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1012 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1012 Shepherd AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION TO REVIS…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1013 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1013 Ballinger AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION REVISIN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1014 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1014 A. Mayberry AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1015 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1015 A. Mayberry ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION SHALL NOT SPECIFICALLY BE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1016 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1016 Lundstrum CONSTITUTION ARKANSAS CONCERNING VOTER AN AMENDME…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1017 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1017 C. Douglas AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION PROVID…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1018 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1018 Shepherd AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1019 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1019 Gazaway AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNIN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1020 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1020 Davis AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION TO REPEAL T…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1021 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1021 Sorvillo A CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT PROVIDING THAT A MONUME…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
I will call the meeting to order, Chair sees a quorum. Mr. Hendron, you're recognized to present HJR 1006.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Is that the, that's the one I don't, I've got a copy of, that's the one about the fiscal session, the annual session? Yes, sir. okay what this i uh as some of you know i'm kind of i try to be kind of plain spoken and get it down where i can understand it and uh i know there's another bill already another resolution floating around to make this an annual session then there's another one down on the other end by some disreputable member down there to do similar to what this one does but when this thing when this thing was passed when we get to that next one I'll talk a little bit more about that when this thing was adopted several years ago I was down on the other end and I campaigned across the state about this because since 1979 we've been able to do business on a biannual basis budgeting for two years and it had worked well in my philosophy all the way through whether we're doing an amendment this constitution or proposed amendment is if it ain't broke don't get around fixing it And so that's what this bill does. All this does is undo something that shouldn't be done. I took the rules the other day, a rule change that would say we couldn't go ahead and raise money during the fiscal session, which is a rule we changed. It doesn't have a whole lot to do with this, but it's ironic that some of the folks that didn't support that support turned to change this into an annual session instead of a fiscal session. So those are the competing ones that you all know out there. You're going to have a chance to send it out to the people. Well, let's make this fiscal session an annual session. And mine just says, throw it in the trash can. So that's what it does. It gives the people of Arkansas a chance to undo what I think and what a lot of folks think were the mistakes. So that's basically what it does. It just repeals the fiscal session. So what are you supposed to say? Can I make a motion on this committee? I guess I can. I move. We pass. And we have a question. That's probably as far as it goes. We have
▶ Play
a question, Representative Henry. Yes, sir. Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Henry, you made the statement, if it ain't broke, don't fix it. So what's broke now that we
▶ Play
need to fix? Because, well, in this member's opinion, and I believe in a number of voters in the state of Arkansas, as I said previously today, the ultimate arbiter, that's going to be next year in the elections. But I don't think the people needed this to start with, I think it's been an unnecessary expense. I think it gets a lot of stuff done that we're doing that doesn't need to be done. And I just don't think the people of Arkansas want it. And I'm speaking for them in my opinion, and I'd like to at least have a chance to put it out there and see if they understand it. And this is one amendment that's hard to misunderstand. Throw it in the trash can. The label could be right across the top, and I'll be talking about labeling on this next amendment that I'm going to propose.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Hemner, I've got a question myself. The voters of the state voted on this once before, and they chose to choose to have these fiscal sessions. Are you thinking they made a mistake? Yes, I don't think they knew
▶ Play
what they were voting on, and I'm going to explain that to you more clearly, Mr. Chairman, in this next deal, because quite frequently, when this legislature puts out proposed constitutional amendments, they are not clearly labeled. They are misleading to the voters of the state of Arkansas, and this next amendment gives this committee and this legislature a chance to fix that. And as you know, as I'm sure you know, is that the courts or the attorney general, somebody secretary said, I guess, reviews the one the public do to see if we're misleading the voters. But the ones that you and I do down here as members of this legislature, we just tell them anything we want to, and it goes on to ballot. So I guess the answer specifically to your question, no, I don't think they understood for fully what they were doing. And some of us have been around here who all know what they were doing because we've seen
▶ Play
the results of it. Representative Wardlaw, you recognize her question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This will be my last one, I promise. Oh, I love them. Go ahead. You brought up a good point there. You said
▶ Play
Speaker 11 4:55
that when the public brings forth an amendment, and I'll better hold this to
▶ Play
the next bill because this has ... Yeah. Okay. Is there ... I'd be glad to talk about it twice, but that's okay. We don't have anyone signed up to speak for or against the amendment. So at this time, Representative Henry, you're recognized to present H.J.R. 1007. What about that one? Do we not do anything? The process we've been going through is we're hearing all of the amendments first, and then after we've heard them all, then we are going to have a vote on which ones to refer to the full committee.
▶ Play
Speaker 23 5:34
Mr. Chairman, how many have we got
▶ Play
out there so far? Because I missed a meeting or two, and I'm sorry about that.
▶ Play
Yours would be number 10, that were presented. We had 21 filed, but not all of them. Then by
▶ Play
not being here, I'm in the top 10, right? Anyway. Okay. Am I ready for the next one? Yes, sir. You recognize. This is House Joint Resolution 1007. And the subtitle, an amendment to the Arkansas Constitution concerning ballot titles of the constitutional amendments proposed by the General Assembly, which is we. And Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, I have before me in my little hot hand here the copy of the last thing, bigger last thing that we put on the ballot. The legislature did. I don't think I was down here for that two-year period. This is the one John Woods and who was Mr. Saban, Representative Saban. And I want to read you the titles. And what mine deals with is tell the people where they can understand it. And what really bothered me, Mr. Chairman, a member of this committee, in the last week or two, I have found out intentionally down here in Little Rock when this thing was put on the ballot, people were told this was misleading, but whoever's in charge of that deal didn't change it. And frankly, it's like I said this in Sunday school class yesterday and got made a Democrat really mad, I think. I said, you know, I supported Trump all the way through. But if he knew about that stuff on that thing that he said he didn't know anything about, then get ready for President Pence. But I think when you make a mistake, that's one thing. But when you intentionally lie to people, that's something else. And I don't think, I know God doesn't tolerate it, and I don't think we ought to either. But here's the deal. This, I think, how many pages was this thing? Seventeen? Seventeen pages that we put out there to the people of Arkansas. And here's the title of that document. An amendment regulating contributions to candidates for state or local office, borrowing gifts from lobbyists to certain state officials, providing for setting salaries of certain—I like that one, because I got mine doubles, and you did, too, for $40,000. Providing for the setting of salaries to certain state officials, and here's the key, ladies and gentlemen, members of this committee, and setting term limits for members of the General Assembly. Now, why I'm bringing this bill here, the other one, is that setting is a lie. And that's pretty blunt stuff. And what really bothered me about it, I had thought maybe it established, but the document says setting. And the sad thing about this, ladies and gentlemen, the people crafting this thing, whoever it was, the insiders down here at the time, that was pointed out to them by lawyers that the state of Arkansas already had term limits. We weren't setting term limits, and the terminology that was suggested to be used here was extending term limits, which is what it was. And I know a little bit about term limits because I've been playing with them for the last 20 out of 40 years. And it didn't say extend. It said set term limits. And so that gets my blood pressure up. Now, I haven't had my pill for that today, so I better just calm down. So what my resolution says is this. And some leading figure just recently, I didn't realize that. Maybe many of you didn't. But somebody that most of us know around here in Arkansas said, you know what? If the people do an amendment referred to the people by signatures or whatever, it has to go to somebody to get to see if it's kind of telling the truth. But we down here can do it, and nobody reviews it, and that's because of the Constitution. And so what this constitutional amendment that I hope we can get in the top 11 says this. An amendment of the Constitution of the State of Arkansas requires that constitutional amendments proposed by the General Assembly contain a ballot title, and providing that the ballot title of a constitutional amendment proposed by the General Assembly be subject to the same standard of review applied to the ballot of titles of proposed constitutional amendments initiated by the people of Arkansas under Constitution Article 5, Section 1. And I've always believed in the golden rule. I still believe it. I believe we're 100 equals down here, 135 in this legislature, and I believe we need to treat the people of Arkansas like we want to be treated, and that's what would happen with this amendment if we can get it adopted. That's my spiel. Representative Ward-Law, you recognize for a question? Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. I'm going to ask my question now. Good. You made a good point there. You said when the people refer an amendment out or ask for a refer out, You know, they get their signatures, they send their ballot in for title in for review. Would you not agree, here's my question, that the medical marijuana ballot was confusing even though it was reviewed by the good folks in the Attorney General's office or Secretary of State's office, whichever you said that reviews them? Oh, I think it could have used some more work, absolutely. But that
▶ Play
does not mean we ought to keep doing what we're doing because we're pros at misleading people down here. or at least that's been my experience. Follow-up. Well, just for me, I'm not talking about you guys, just me.
▶ Play
Well, I mean, if you're going to fix it, why not fix it for all? That way it's not misleading, even if it goes through that process or comes through this process, either one. Because if I understood you right, yours only address amendments referred out by the legislature. Well, the people's already required in the Constitution. That's
▶ Play
already there. you see the people who wrote the constitution probably had more common sense of those of us at least this guy sermon down here today because it's already in the constitution for the people but it's not for us down here that that's what this thing does is it just put it on even par who's that down there in my seat boy i done lost my vice chairmanship already how about that you're welcome to it
▶ Play
except you're liable to get you
▶ Play
shot down there representative laderman you're recognized for a question Thank you, Mr. Chair. I thought, and maybe I'm wrong, but I thought that all constitutional amendments were reviewed, or at least, well, the amendment itself and the title was reviewed by the Attorney General, and they gave the blessing that it was okay or not okay. And it's my understanding that all of them are reviewed because the one that I had last year, I got a note that said the Attorney General approved it. So I think that process goes forward now. I think it's the same, although you may be correct and probably are, that we may get a little more leeway than those that come from the people. I'm talking about people in the legislature. But I think that process is already in place, Representative Hendren. Who would you recommend to review that, and how would we know as Representative Ladel? Wardlaw, excuse me, says, I mean, how would we know that they would do a better job than it's being done now? Well, two or three answers to that.
▶ Play
Number one is that a lot of people in Arkansas and people that we both know think that it's not equal, and this refers to, in fact, I actually got my Constitution out the other day there at my desk, and it's about that thick, and I actually read it, you know? I thought, well, I wonder what's in this thing. And so I get down to Article 5, Section 1, read it. It says that any initiative by the people of the state of Arkansas will be reviewed, I think, by some commission or whatever the Constitution says. But that does not apply to whatever this legislature puts out when we get through with this. And all this does, Representative Leiterman, is just put it equal now. We may need to do something else, as Representative Wardlow said. We may need to do something else. However, when you start doing that, then you start getting mails like I'm getting on this SJR1 that says now we're going to let the legislature set the rules for the courts. So I didn't want to go quite that far with this first step. I like to buy it. Who was it the other day? Sturge? Let's just eat an elephant one step at a time. All we're saying here is make the same thing for the legislative proposals to the Constitution. Make it the same as the people. That's all this
▶ Play
does. Whatever that might be, Representative Leiterman. Representative Gonzalez. to recognize her question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Hendrion, I know how you like reading bills down here. You read one to us earlier on the House floor. It didn't make much difference, though, did it? It will sooner or later, though. Yeah, I guess it didn't. My question is, a lot of what you're talking about, I think, is covered in HJR 1003 in Gillum's bill. Have you read that language, and does that satisfy your concerns? Yeah, I did. And
▶ Play
let me tell you about that bill because there was talk of putting mine in it. But if anybody on this panel or in this committee or in this legislature knows what all that thing does, I'll give them a gold star. And that does exactly what I'm opposed to down here, committee members. You put so much stuff out there, nobody understands what it is. And we talked about combining this in that, and I said, hey, just put it down on the bottom shelf so I can understand it. And that's why Representative Latham, and I can tell him right off the bat, Representative Latham, all this does is make it equal for the people in the legislature on this constitutional proposal. That's all this does. The other one you're talking about, I don't know what all that thing does. Follow-up, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
You recognize for follow-up. Thank you. Would you be willing to talk with Representative Ballinger, letting him
▶ Play
explain that to you so he could have that gold star? Well, I talked to him the other day, and we almost got into a religious discussion with him about which one of us was more full with Jesus, And I
▶ Play
don't think that's what this is
▶ Play
all about. Representative Douglas, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. If there is a process in place right now, but you don't feel like it is maybe bringing the integrity to the title like you would wish, do you think it's something you could do by law, by code, instead of by amendment if this doesn't pass from the committee?
▶ Play
I don't know. I just met a fellow here that I'd never met before. He says his name is Scott Trotter, and he said he'd signed up to speak for this bill. And if I've got anybody here to speak for it, I probably ought to shut up and quit doing the damage and let him do it. So I think, Mr. Chairman, if you'd agree, when you're ready for testimony, maybe these questions he could, he's a lawyer I guess, could answer these better than I can.
▶ Play
All right we have a representative or a Scott Trotter signed up to speak for the bill. That was before I
▶ Play
explained it, he may not now, we'll just have to see. Mr. Trotter,
▶ Play
please identify yourself for the record, and you're recognized. I'll be happy
▶ Play
Speaker 50 16:44
to. I'm Scott Trotter. I was very active here at the legislature many years ago. I'm an attorney. I'm 65 years old. I've been in practice for 30 years. I have written ballot titles. I've challenged ballot titles. I've defended ballot titles. I've written constitutional amendments that have been approved by the voters, and I've written initiated acts that have been approved by the voters. So I have a fair amount of experience here. And Kim Hendren and I don't know each other, but I did call him the other day just to say I noticed this HJR 1007 and that I liked it. And so I'm happy to tell you why I do and also try to answer some of those questions that maybe Representative Hendren wasn't exactly prepared to answer in all respects. The Supreme Court for decades has used a different standard to evaluate the sufficiency of a ballot title that the legislature wrote when referring an amendment. and that standard is different from the one that they use when they judge a ballot title for a constitutional amendment that's written by the people. Okay, and so as a result, frankly, it makes it much harder to challenge a ballot title that the legislature has written, and I can tell you what the standard is that the court has adopted on its own, which is called manifest fraud okay the ballot title that the legislature has written for a constitutional amendment has to exercise a manifest fraud on the voters and the court has defined the word manifest and the word fraud and the court has even said that it's a giant hill that you have to climb if you're going to be successful in challenging a ballot title written by the legislature. And that is why for decades many of the ballot titles on the referred amendments from the legislature can be very scant in what they actually include. So now let me compare that to the standard that the Supreme Court uses when judging a ballot title on an amendment as written by the people. Well, if it is misleading in any material way, meaning if certain key things are left out of the ballot title, or if it has any partisan coloring, if it could be said to just not accurately describe what is in the proposed Constitution Amendment, then that means the Supreme Court will find the ballot title written by the people insufficient, and they'll knock it from the ballot, OK? And I'll just be frank about it. I was the sole attorney who filed the lawsuit last September that challenged the ballot title on the so-called medical injury tort reform amendment. And I got a unanimous decision from the court that it was misleading. And that was a ballot title that had been written by the proponents, primarily the nursing home industry, that put that on the ballot. And so the easier standard was applied that allowed me to point to the flaws in the ballot title and have it challenged. If it had been that very same ballot title written by the legislature and referred to the ballot word for word, I would have had a much harder time challenging it. So now that I've explained that, if I could, let me just describe for you the way I perceive this particular SJR 1007. First of all, right now to answer one of your questions, when the legislature does write a ballot title, it does not get reviewed by the Attorney General for sufficiency before it goes to the ballot. When you all refer a constitutional amendment and you got a ballot title, it is referred. And that is what is going to appear on the ballot. There's no middleman that looks at it, the attorney general or otherwise. When it is an initiated amendment from the people, then that is where the attorney general reviews it and has to approve it before you even go and get signatures. Okay, the way I perceive 107 is that it is saying, with regard to the standards of review that the court would use in reviewing a ballot title written by the legislature versus one written by the people, that it's going to be the same standard. It's going to be the same standard. It's going to be the standard that the court has historically applied to judge the sufficiency of a ballot title that is written by the people. And then also, as I understand his proposal, it also says that when you challenge a ballot title, you get to go directly to the Supreme Court to initiate your lawsuit. Right now, just listen carefully, there is a difference. When a ballot title written by the legislature is going to be challenged, you have to start out in circuit court at the lower court level, get a decision, and then an appeal is taken to the Supreme Court, whereas it's different when it's a ballot title that the people have written. In that instance, you have a direct line to the Supreme Court to file your lawsuit. That's where it starts. It's in the Supreme Court. It's called original action. And so, once again, Representative Hendren's bill says you can have original action to challenge a ballot title written by the legislature, that means you can go directly to the Supreme Court and the standard for review of the sufficiency of the ballot title will be the very same as the standard that they have used to judge ballot titles written by the people. Okay, how about if I pause and see if anybody has any questions
▶ Play
on that? Representative Dotson, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So, Mr. Trotter, if I may, the current process, as I understand it, requires that the ballot title be a part of the resolution that the legislature votes on. So we'll know exactly the popular name and what's going on about the ballot title according the state law currently, and if I'm understanding it correctly, that allows for 135 elected members of the legislature to determine whether or not this is a sufficient title as the people's representatives. What this is suggesting is that the legislature defer to the executive or the judicial branch to determine whether or not we made a good
▶ Play
Speaker 50 24:13
decision? Well, not entirely. And let me just get real specific in my understanding of the law. The Supreme Court has said, and I agree, the Constitution with regard to allowing the legislature to refer three amendments does not even require that a ballot title be used, period. But the legislature has, in most instances or all instances that I know of, the legislature has specified what ballot title to be used. If the HJR is silent on what ballot title to use, then they usually just take the title that's on the front page of the bill, you know. But in recent years, the legislature at the very end of an HJR usually says, this is what the popular name is going to be on the ballot, and this is what the ballot title will be. In the instance, I'll give you an example, this HJR 3 by Speaker Gillum, which is now the meat of it's been amended in. Well, he takes a different approach. At the very end of his, he sets out, well, let me put it this way.
▶ Play
Speaker 57 25:36
Mr. Trotter, you need to stay on this
▶ Play
Speaker 50 25:40
particular bill. Yeah. Okay. Usually what happens, if they really want to write a longer ballot title than they do in the HJR, and they don't necessarily use the little short ballot title that's up at the top of the page. That's my point. But I think the reason I support this is that I think it should be even Stephen. I think that the legislature, in writing a ballot title, ought to have to go through the same burden of proof when there's a court challenge as a ballot title that's written by the people. And keep in mind, the Constitution is the people's document. You know, the only reason the legislature exists is because the people decided to adopt a Constitution that created the legislative, executive, and judicial branches. So why would the people be a lot more likely to have their ballot title declared invalid versus the legislature? That's a simple principle that I support.
▶ Play
We have no one else signed up to speak for or against this bill. Well, Representative Hendren, would you like to close for your
▶ Play
resolution? I think I probably already said I didn't know I knew this
▶ Play
thing so well, so I'm closed. Thank you, sir. Is Representative Davis? Okay. Representative Davis, you're recognized to present H.J.R. 1020.
▶ Play
All right, thank you, Mr. Chairman, committee. Let me get this up here real quick. All right, Mr. Chairman and committee members, I appreciate your time. I don't think this one's going very far, but I think we can have a little fun discussing it here for a few minutes. HGR 1020 essentially would eliminate the fiscal session as we currently know it and and in some ways the regular session as we currently know it and create a regular or general session annually every year I know that at first glance that raises a lot of eyebrows but one thing I would have you consider is that the way we have this written is that both of those sessions would be limited with hard caps. They would start out as 45-day sessions, and then it would require a two-thirds vote to extend an additional 10 days to 55, and a three-fourths vote to extend an additional five days to 60, and there is no provision to extend any session beyond 60 days. So if you consider we run regular sessions around 90 days now and fiscal sessions around 30 days in the even number years that's 120 days this would be essentially the same or similar amount of time in session but they would both be regular sessions one of the reasons why I think this could be beneficial and just I guess I'm just a nerd enough about this stuff that I like to sit around and think about what are what are things we could do differently to make our processes work a little bit better and we we all members and advocates and other people in the capital anybody in this business we commonly joke and and refer to the pressure in a regular session we talk about how things can get rushed we talk about just how busy we are and the volume of things that we deal with in a regular session and how those things tend to build towards the end of that that session. I contend that a lot of that is because particularly House members serving two-year terms feel like we have one shot in this term. I contend that a lot of those bills, a lot of those issues, members would agree to defer to the second regular session of their term if they knew they were going to have one. I also contend that we would have fewer special sessions. I would also agree with some that have said the legislature has enacted some substantial statutory changes through special language in the fiscal session I think that has happened I think if we're gonna do that do we need to open it up and do it right and run it like a regular session so just an idea just a way that something to consider, might let a little pressure off of members and advocates alike, might lend itself to more patience and willingness to compromise in one session and wait until the next to see if additional changes need to be made in any particular proposal or statute. You know, I think we can all probably think of instances where we've thought somebody has requested us to stop at 75% of what we think we want, and I think if you knew you had that next session less than a year away, more times than not, members would be willing to concede that and to see how things work, rather than to let pressure build like we do now and try to force things through. I guess that's all my comments. Mr. Chairman, I'd be happy to take questions. Representative Wardlaw, you recognize for a question?
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Would this mean that on our budgetary items, we wouldn't do a binary budget, we would do a single-year budget with this in place? I think that would be right. We
▶ Play
would continue to just budget one year at a time. And I'll be the first to say there's a lot of things that this would change that aren't addressed specifically in here. You know, would we have full budget hearings every year like we do before a regular session? The budget hearings we have before a fiscal session, I think are generally condensed, not as broad as budget hearings before regular, you know, those things would have to be determined, but they're not addressed in the Constitution, so I've not addressed them here. We
▶ Play
have no one signed up to speak forward. Representative Douglas, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Yes. I think this is a good idea, but have you also thought of limiting the number of bills per representative, per session. I've heard that floated around. And not that you couldn't expand beyond that, but that would set a cap per session and say if someone else didn't file all theirs, you know, we could.
▶ Play
I'm familiar with the concept, and you're right. I mean, people toss that idea around. Obviously, it's not included in this. I personally, at first blush, am not a fan of that. Right. I feel like members of the legislature should have all the freedom and leeway they need to address concerns of their constituents. Mm-hm. So personally, I'm not in favor of that. It's not addressed here. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. We have
▶ Play
no one lined up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Henry, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I guess, Representative Davis, is your concept, do you prefer a citizen legislature or a full-time legislature? Citizen. Do you think that whenever we, that we're required to come down here for 60, 90 days and, of course, we know that we extend it, we'll extend this one, that's done routinely and has been for years, that do you think that makes it easier for people that are farmers or chicken farmers or business people or engineers like you and I are, I guess, does that make it easier for us to take care of our responsibilities at home, not only at home, but in our business and our church and the responsibilities that we have there? Do you think going to an annual thing rather than, and also doesn't Texas still have biannual or whatever they call them down there in Texas? I think they do, but whatever, not necessarily that's good necessarily. What's your concept? Do you think going to an annual session every year would make it easier for you and me as engineers or farmers and so forth, and as members of our community be more active there?
▶ Play
I do, Representative Hendren. I'm not sure about Texas and how often they have sessions, but that's one point advantage that I neglected to mention, but with a hard cap of 60 days on each one, I feel like it gives individual members the ability to better plan for how long am I going to be in session If we start January 9, then I'm out March 9, you know that for a fact. You don't have to wonder, am I going to be here until the end of March, the 1st of April, so on and so forth. I also think having it annually makes it more of a regular item for our constituents and other advocates around the Capitol to, you know, prepare and know when it's coming. There's no, you know, the more regular it is, I think the better. One of the questions
▶ Play
that keeps coming up to me in Benton County as I attend committee meetings and meetings up there and different civic clubs and so forth, is when we went to term limits and put term limits on, which used to be six years in the House and two terms plus in the Senate, then we changed the rules down here and said any member could attend any meeting at any time and get paid for it, which I guess—and you know, it's interesting, and we never go back the other way, that we've extended term limits now to 16 years in the House or Senate, but we've never taken a step back to cut down on people attending meetings. And I've seen this, and probably you have too, and it really bothers me. You walk into a meeting, sign the docket, and then walk out and collect $150 or whatever it is. And I've had people ask me that question, is we've turned into a full-time legislature when you can go down here and pick a committee every day and sign in, get your transportation and so forth. So as you go to this, would this annual session you're proposing here have a way to maybe to roll us back a little bit where we don't get paid for every day
▶ Play
that we're down here already? Well, it doesn't address anything like that directly, but I think it raises another good question. Like I said, this concept will really change a lot of things, and I think one of the reasons a lot of people think we're maybe act more like a full-time legislature now is the volume of issues that we take up in legislative council. I've served on legislative council two terms now, several, I don't know, it seems like half a dozen subcommittees, and when you're on that many committees on top of your A and B and so on and so forth, you've got a lot of meetings. You're here a lot. If the legislature met in full every year, what sorts of things are we handling in council that we could hold off and address as a full body in a regular session? I don't know, but I think it's worth thinking about. And I think that could serve to lighten the load of committee meetings and requirements
▶ Play
in the interim period. We have no one signed up to speak for or against this resolution. Do you have any other closing comments you'd like to make, Representative Davis? No, Mr. Chairman. I appreciate your time. All right. Thank you. Members, this committee has been charged with the responsibility of referring four of these items out to the full state agencies committee. By my count, if you want to verify what I believe has been presented to this committee, That's 1-0-0-2, 1-0-0-3, 1-0-0-6, 1-0-0-7, 1-0-0-8, 1-0-0-9, 1-0-11, 1-0-14, 1-0-16, 1-0-19, and 1-0-20. 1-0-0-5, excuse me. So what is the will of the committee? Representative Ledeman,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a motion. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I move that we put HGR 1016 forward to the
▶ Play
full committee. I have a motion to refer this resolution to the full committee. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Opposed. The motion is passed. We refer 1016 to the full committee. Representative Dobson, you're recognized for a motion. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. I move that we refer HJR 1003 to the full committee. Okay, we have a motion to
▶ Play
refer HJR 1003 to the full committee. Is there any discussion? Mr. Chairman, I know I'm not a committee member, but I'm sorry, sir. Have there been comments on 1003 since the guts were put in yesterday? Yes, we heard that testimony last week. On the amendment. Yes. Yes, sir. Okay. I was unaware of that because I had something to say about that and I signed up to speak against it. We heard that amendment last week, sir. We have a motion. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. Motion is passed. Representative Wardlaw, you recognize for
▶ Play
a motion? I'll make a motion that we hear H.J.R. 1011 to the full committee. Okay, we
▶ Play
have a motion to refer H.J.R. 1011 to the full committee. Is there any discussion? All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Nay. Motion is passed. We'll refer H.J.R. 1011 to the full committee. Okay, Representative Gonzales, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
motion. Make a motion that we refer 1008 to the full
▶ Play
committee. Okay, we have a motion to refer HJR 1008 to the full committee.
▶ Play

Agenda

HOUSE JOINT RESOLUTIONS TO BE CONSIDERED FOR REFERRAL TO THE HOUSE STATE AGENCIES & GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS COMMITTEE

-14:09 - 0:00 1 segment 1 speaker

HJR1002 S. Meeks AN TO CONSTITUTION ARKANSAS THE FOR PROVIDE AMENDMENT THE TOAPPOINTMENT OF EMERGENCY INTERIM SUCCESSORS TO CERTAIN CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICES UPON THE OCCURRENCE OF A CATASTROPHIC EVENT.

HJR1003 Gillam AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION TO AMEND THE PROCESS FOR MEASURES AND CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS ON THE PLACING PROPOSED BALLOT FOR CONSIDERATION BY VOTERS AT AN ELECTION.

HJR1004 Leding AN AMENDMENT TO ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION, ARTICLE 5, SECTION 1, CONCERNING THE FILING OF INITIATIVE PETITIONS AND THE PROCESS FOR CHALLENGING THE SUFFICIENCY OF A PETITION.

HJR1005 Lowery THE PUBLIC EDUCATION PARTNERSHIP AMENDMENT OF 2018.

HJR1006 K. Hendren A CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT REPEALING THE FISCAL SESSION OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY.

0:00 - 7:23 22 segments 5 speakers

HJR1007 K. Hendren AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNING THE BALLOT TITLES OF CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS PROPOSED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY.

7:23 - 26:55 55 segments 10 speakers

HJR1008 Dotson AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION TO PROVIDE THAT THE STATE HIGHWAY COMMISSION SHALL BE GOVERNED IN THE SAME MANNER AS ALL OTHER STATE AGENCIES.

HJR1009 Dotson AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION TO PROVIDE THAT INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER LEARNING SHALL COMPLY WITH LAWS ENACTED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY THAT AFFECT INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER LEARNING.

HJR1010 Dotson AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNING THE FUNDING OF PUBLIC EDUCATION OFFERED TO THE CITIZENS OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS.

HJR1011 Drown AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNING THE APPLICABILITY ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION, OF AMENDMENT 33, OF HIGHER TO INSTITUTIONSLEARNING.

HJR1012 Shepherd AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION TO REVISE THE METHOD OF SELECTION OF JUSTICES OF THE SUPREME COURT.

HJR1013 Ballinger AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION REVISING THE PROCESS FOR AND CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS SUBMITTING TO MEASURES PROPOSED VOTERS FOR APPROVAL OR REJECTION.

HJR1014 A. Mayberry AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNING THE INCREASE OF THE RATES FOR SALES AND USE TAXES.

HJR1015 A. Mayberry ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION SHALL NOT SPECIFICALLY BESTOW POWERS, PRIVILEGES, OR AUTHORITY TO SPECIFIC INDIVIDUALS OR BUSINESS ENTITIES IDENTIFIED BY NAME.

HJR1016 Lundstrum CONSTITUTION ARKANSAS CONCERNING VOTER AN AMENDMENT THE TOIDENTIFICATION WHEN CASTING A BALLOT.

HJR1017 C. Douglas AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION PROVIDING CERTAIN ADDITIONAL RIGHTS TO VICTIMS OF CRIMES.

HJR1018 Shepherd AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNING CIVIL ACTIONS AND COURT PROCEDURES.

HJR1019 Gazaway AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNING AWARDS IN CIVIL ACTIONS.

HJR1020 Davis AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION TO REPEAL THE FISCAL SESSION OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY AND TO PROVIDE FOR ANNUAL REGULAR SESSIONS OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY.

26:55 - 40:40 44 segments 8 speakers

HJR1021 Sorvillo A CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT PROVIDING THAT A MONUMENT OR STATUE SHALL NOT BE PLACED UPON THE STATE CAPITOL GROUNDS UNLESS AT LEAST TWO HUNDRED THOUSAND QUALIFIED ELECTORS OF THE STATE SIGN A PETITION IN FAVOR OF THE PLACEMENT.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Jon S. Eubanks Chair Unverified
27 segments
Representative Kim Hendren Unverified
36 segments
Representative Jeff Wardlaw Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 11
1 segment
Speaker 23
1 segment
Representative Jack Ladyman Unverified
1 segment
Representative Ledeman Unverified
4 segments
Representative Justin Gonzales Unverified
4 segments
Representative Dan M. Douglas Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 50
18 segments
Representative Jim Dotson Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 57
1 segment
Representative Andy Davis Unverified
16 segments