State Agencies
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (32)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1004
· 7 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1004 Blake TO CREATE THE DEMOCRACY ACT; TO REQUIRE AUTOMATIC VOT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1005
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1005 Tucker TO REQUIRE REPORTING AND DISCLOSURE OF ELECTIONEERIN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1008
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1008 Tucker TO INCREASE THE PENALTY FOR TAKING CAMPAIGN FUNDS AS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1009
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1009 Leding TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING APPROVED POLITICAL ACTIO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1011
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1011 Sabin TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING POLITICAL ACTION COMMI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1012
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1012 Sabin TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING POLITICAL ACTION COMMI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1046
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1046 Tucker TO PERMIT PAID MATERNITY LEAVE FOR STATE EMPLOYEES.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1065
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1065 Watson PERMITTING THE ARKANSAS COMMISSION ON LAW ENFORCEMEN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1151
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1151 Davis TO REQUIRE THAT REGISTERED VOTERS BE NOTIFIED BY MAIL…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1179
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1179 Ballinger TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING APPROVED POLITICAL AC…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1207
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1207 Dalby TO AMEND REQUIREMENTS FOR CAMPAIGN SIGNS AND MATERIAL…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1270
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1270 Johnson TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ELECTIONS AND BALLOTS.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1289
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1289 Ballinger TO PROMOTE AND IMPROVE EFFICIENCY AND QUALITY IN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1386
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1386 Lemons TO REQUIRE THE FILING OF FINAL AGENCY RULES WITH THE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1430
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1430 Tosh CONCERNING LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER STANDARDS AND TRAIN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1447
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1447 M. Gray TO TRANSFER THE STATE BOARD OF ELECTION COMMISSIONE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1570
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1570 Brown TO PROVIDE STATUTORY GUIDANCE CONCERNING INTERSTATE C…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1622
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1622 Johnson TO CREATE PROCEDURE FOR ADDRESSING BURDENSOME REQUE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1623
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1623 Johnson TO AMEND THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967; TO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1633
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1633 Dotson TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE MAINTENANCE AND MANA…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1675
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1675 Sturch TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1696
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1696 D. Meeks TO TRANSFER THE STATE CHILD ABUSE AND NEGLECT PREV…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1707
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1707 M. Gray TO AMEND THE DATES OF THE GENERAL PRIMARY ELECTION…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1725
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1725 D. Douglas TO TRANSFER VARIOUS STATE AGENCIES TO THE ARKANS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1728
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1728 Ladyman TO REPEAL THE COMMUNITY SERVICES ADVISORY COUNCIL.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1736
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1736 Hammer TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE REPORT OF A LOSS OF…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HJR1001
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1001 Ballinger APPLYING TO THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS TO CALL A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB131
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB131 G. Stubblefield TO EXEMPT FROM THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB273
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB273 Standridge PERMITTING ACT 309 INMATES IN THE CUSTODY OF THE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB292
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB292 Maloch TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE TRANSFER AND INVESTM…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB373
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB373 Hester TO EXEMPT ATTORNEY-CLIENT COMMUNICATIONS AND ATTORNE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB377
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB377 Hickey CONCERNING THE ELIGIBILITY OF AN INMATE OF THE DEPAR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 13, 2026
We do have several bills that I've been notified that we have to run today. I know, Representative Tosh, you have another committee to go to, and you've got just a couple of amendments, so if you want to take them to the table. And then we have Representative Blake, who's first on the calendar, then Representative Dalby, and then we'll start taking up committee bills after that. Are there any other legislators from another committee that's in the room? Okay. All right, good.
That's the order we'll plan on going in, and Representative Tosh has promised to make this short, so we'll get him out of committee. Representative Tosh, you are recognized to present the amendments and the bill of 1430. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. Committee members ran this bill in here a few weeks back, and since that time, there
was a few errors that were brought to our attention, and simply this here, I just want to discuss those three amendments with you very quickly here. The only thing we did was, when we talk about a law enforcement officer, there was some language in the other bill that caused somewhat of some confusion as to a law enforcement officer. And this just simply clears it up that a law enforcement officer is anyone in the state that's been appointed through the state statute other than someone that might be elected, which
would be a sheriff or a constable. And we know their authority comes from the constitution and not state statute. And the only other change we made in the original presentation of the bill was that once you are hired by a law enforcement agency, that you have to attend an academy within nine months. The old language was 12. We reduced that to nine. And a little bit of concern in regards to the fact
that the law enforcement commission could only extend under extraordinary circumstances that up to three months, which made it 12. We changed the language to allow the Arkansas Law Enforcement Commission to be able to extend that if the case was presented to them and they felt like it was justified, then they could extend it two or three times at three months at a time, whatever they felt necessary to meet the needs of those demands. The third amendment that we addressed was that under current law concerning auxiliary officers,
that you can have two auxiliary officers for each full-time officer that you have employed, or you can have one auxiliary officer for each 1,000 persons in a political subdivision. We wanted to make sure that the language was extremely clear in regards that auxiliary officers, when those are counted against you that it does not include a school resource officer or a search or rescue officer, those would not be counted against you as your limit on number of auxiliary officers.
And that's the amendments, and I'll take any questions. Okay, and just for the, so everyone
knows kind of where this is in the procedure, this was a bill that we had passed out of the committee, that after it passed out of the committee there were some people had some concerns and wanted some clarifications that you re-referred to us, and you've got those taken care of now, is that correct? That is correct, Mr. Chair. Okay, so do I have a, okay, I've got a motion from Representative Douglas to pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? All right, congratulations, you passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair, thank me.
Okay, Representative Blake. You're recognized to run your amendment first for HB 1004. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And
I promise if I get a good vote, I'll be quick too. Okay. But this is the – oh, my God. Already, Dodson? This is an amendment that was brought to me – actually, the first part of the amendment was brought by Representative Dodson to make the bill stronger.
If you look on page three, line 29, it actually changes that language by rule to by law. On page 3, it deletes the references to the U.S. Constitution. And on page 4, it also changes the language to correct the language. On page 4, it deletes line 3 and 4, which talks about the Office of Driver Services having
to agree, have precedent over the Secretary of State. So it omits all that language. And then the last part of the amendment was brought to me by actually Representative Ballinger. And what it does is it also requires that the Register of Vital Records immediately notifies the Secretary of State when there has been deaths, so we could clean and scrub
the deceased people from voting rolls. So I would like a good vote on the amendment. Okay. Do we have what's the will
of the committee on the amendment? We have a motion from Representative Dodson to adopt the amendment. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Okay, you have adopted your amendment.
All right, on to the heavy lifting. Colleagues, my kids looked at me last night and said,
Dad, you look tired. And I responded to them, I'm tired. I look tired because I am tired. It's been a long session. I know it's March 1st, but it's been a very long session. We've had a lot of battles. Some of us have taken a lot more losses than others. But the good news that I'm coming with you today is that this doesn't have to be one of those battles. HB 1004 is a good piece of legislation that addresses a specific issue, and it helps people.
So it's good policy. What is HB 1004? It's the Democracy Act. It's automatic voting registration. Don't let that scare you. Automatic voter registration. It's a very good bill. I said it addresses some issues, and those issues specifically, according to a Pew report in 2012, approximately 24 million, one of every eight voter registrations in the United States are no longer valid, and approximately 2.7 million people have registrations in more
than one state. One of the reasons for this problem is that many of us are unlikely to live in the voting precinct all of our lives. So about one in eight Americans moved during 2008-2010 election years. Some Americans, including those serving in the military and young people, move more often. For example, census and other data indicate that as many as one in four young Americans move every year. Any given year, one in every four young Americans will move.
So we have the study identified that there's approximately 12.7 million records nationwide They appear to be out of date and no longer reflect the voters' current information. And of that, about 12 million records have the wrong address. So, HB 1004, it is a bill that addresses the integrity of our election system. We keep hearing about the security of our voting registration system.
This bill addresses that. The accuracy of our voting rolls, this bill addresses that as well. And the updating of an archaic voting registration system that we currently have. HB 1004 does all of those things. And the caveat is that it encourages participation in the democratic process by eligible voters. I'm going to make that by eligible voters. So the first thing that I mentioned that this bill does is it protects the integrity of
our election system by making sure that only eligible Arkansans can register the vote. It uses a secure database to verify that eligible Arkansans are registered. A county clerk will register a person to vote unless any of the following conditions are satisfied. The person's records reflect that he or she affirmatively declined to become registered to vote during a transaction with the Office of Driver Services. The person's records do not reflect that he or she attested to meeting all voter requirements
and that the county clerk determines that the person is ineligible to vote. So what happens is there's going to be two points of contact. One at the Office of Driver Services where questions will be asked about, are you eligible to vote? Would you like to decline registration? And then the second port of contract will be done at the county clerks, where the appropriate county clerk will register the person to vote unless they decline registration, that the
person's records do not attest to meeting all voter-eligible requirements, or the county clerk determines that the person is ineligible. So it also secures our voter registration system. It creates a secure electronic database to make it easier for officials to maintain accurate lists of eligible voters. So I think I gave all of you a flow chart on how the process will work. So the Office of Driver Services, which is the DMV, will provide the Secretary of State
electronic records of each person who obtains or renews a driver's license, personal ID or gets a duplicate, those records of a person transmitted will constitute a complete affidavit of registration. The Secretary of State will immediately submit the records collected from the Office of Drivers of Services to the county clerks. There will be no waiting period, and then the county clerk will determine if that person is eligible.
So the records that will be provided to the Secretary of State can only be used for the purpose of outreach, education to voters conducted by the Secretary of State. The Secretary of State cannot sell, transfer, or allow any third party access to that information unless it's permitted by law. So the third thing, which I said it mentioned, is that it makes sure that our voting rolls
are accurate. Representative House, I'm not sure if he's here yet, but he mentioned a situation where he went, he was knocking on doors, and he went to a single-bedroom apartment, and there were eight different registered voters in that single-bedroom apartment. And this bill fixes that issue, because it allows Arkansas to automatically update their voting registration after a change of address or whenever needed. Anytime a resident obtains or renews a driver's license, their voting registration information
is automatically updated, automatic voter registration. Their information is automatically updated. So we will have the most updated information for eligible voters, and those voters will be registered at correct precincts. Now, it also modernizes our registration system. The Secretary of State will immediately submit records collected and transmitted to the appropriate county clerk. There will be no more waiting periods, and the records are secure and passed electronically. Representative Dotson and Representative Sabine is not in here either.
We serve on the advanced comm and IT committee, where we've been discussing data warehousing and sharing data between state agencies. We've been discussing how that ability to share that information will improve our efficiency and costs in state government. This bill is a perfect example of that. We're going to be sharing info from the Office of Driver Services to Secretary of State to
county clerks automatically, electronically. So what this bill is going to do is going to streamline the process in how people are registered. It's going to make sure that system is more secure. Now the last thing, the thing that I'm excited, I know most of us are excited about, is that it encourages participation in the democratic process. We all want to make it easier for eligible Arkansans to vote.
This bill does that. According to the Department of Finance Administration, in 2016, 807,578 driver's licenses were issued. In 2015, 774,854 driver's licenses were issued. And in 2014, 785,824 driver's licenses were issued. And the DF&A can't determine how many people were issued driver's licenses since you can't
break down how many are duplicates. But DF&A does state that those duplicate licenses are a very small fraction of those licenses. So what we have is we have 807,000 in 2016 driver's license issued, 774,000 in 2015, and 785,000 in 2014. That's 2.3 million new licenses that have been issued in the last three years. So we're going to be able to capture a lot more people and make sure that their data
and information is correct on our voting registration rolls. Now, I do know we passed a bill out of this committee that requires voter ID. The great thing about this bill is this bill complements that bill to address the voting registration system to make sure it's accurate and to make sure it's accessible. Now, I'm not reinventing the wheel here. In 2016, a Republican-dominated House in West Virginia actually passed voter ID and automatic
voter registration in the same session. And some are calling it the most secure and most accessible registration system in the nation. So what we're looking at here is making sure that we have accurate data on our voting rolls, making sure that we're taking off those dead people off the rolls, since that is a concern
for everyone, and allowing people to automatically register at the DMV. I'm open for questions, Mr. Chair. Okay. Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized for
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Blake,
I was looking at this impact statement, and it looks like approximately $42,000 per year. I didn't even mention that,
$42,000 per year. Yeah. I didn't finish my question.
Speaker 45
16:09
Yeah, go ahead. You interrupted me. I don't get but a follow-up here. the the cost of this i mean if there's 135 of
us if we all filed a bill that cost so much money per year and the budget's already as tight as it is how do you propose we find this money and where do you propose we we gather this money up from
well i you know i i'm telling you how much it costs and you know we passed the voter id bill with with with no fiscal impact report
So what I'm suggesting is that we have an opportunity to improve our registration system for $42,000 a year. We will get with the Secretary of State and figure out where that $42,000 is. I'm sure if all of us are filing a bill for $42,000, then that would be a concern.
But what I'm presenting to you today is bringing our system out of the old way, making sure that we are becoming more accessible to voters and securing our voting registration system for $42,000 a year. Follow-up, Mr. Chair? You're recognized. And I understand what
you're saying, but I, for one, have filed bills in the past that
do cost, and before I proceeded with those bills, I found out exactly where that money was going to come from. and insured that money to be appropriated properly to pay for my bill, and that's what I'm trying to insure from you is that you have, and I'm not saying that you haven't. I'm asking you, have you? And I didn't hear that from your answer. And before I vote yes on this bill, I'd like to feel comfortable that it's going to be funded. The last thing I want to do is put an unfunded mandate on my county clerks
or my DMV office, and there's no money to cover what has to be done for that
information to be shared back and forth. Yes, I have, early in the year, I have had conversations with the Secretary of State. We're going to diligently find this $42,000, and I wish that was the same concept and concern we had with all bills.
especially the voter ID bill that came through here as well, that we suspended the rules to not require a fiscal report. So I will be diligent in making sure we can fund this mandate. Representative Hamer, you're recognized for a question. Could we get the agency up here? Secretary
of State, yeah, in fact, I know that they were signed up to speak on this bill. But I'm happy to ask them if they wanted to come down to the end.
Probably would be better. Let's go ahead and get through the question process, then we'll have them come
down and testify. Okay. Could I have a follow-up to the presenter? Sure. One thing, and I'm sorry, I had to step out of the room and take a phone call, but can you just in a very short capsule form tell me what this bill is being doing? What is this bill doing that's not currently already being done? because you mentioned about going to the Revenue Office and signing up with the driver's license. I was thinking that was something that could already be done. So could you just hit the two or three quick bullets that show the difference between what's being done now
and what this bill would do? Real quickly, you walk into the DMV to change your address, to get a new license, to correct your license. After you give them all the information needed, you'll be asked three questions. Are you an eligible voter? would you like to decline your registration, and if you would like to register with a party. After that happens, those records will go from the Office of Driver Services to Secretary of State, from the Secretary of State to the county clerk with no waiting period, and you're
registered. Or if you don't choose to be registered, you're
wait for the secretary, please. Okay. Representative Smith, you're recognized for a
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Blake, I've got a question, and this may just be a simple response, and I hope it is. But we passed a bill that became law, I believe, last general session to move a driver's license from a four-year renewal to an eight.
You had mentioned that people move quite frequently. I know most of my life, being a pastor's son, we moved every three years. I don't know if my dad ran out of material or if he just, or what it was, you know. He was just so good, that's all. Question is, though, do you think as mobile as our population is now that people will take the time to go in and change their driver's license knowing that, hey, I could drive on this license for eight years
and nobody would ever question me? Well, that is a concern. Now, you're supposed to go change your license every time you move. Or if you need a new license, or if I'm still a young man, so I had to go get my license renewed because I turned 33, well, 32 last year. So there are set ages where you have to go from 18 to 21, 21 to, if it's eight years now, 27.
So what we're going to have is we're going to encapture more people than we have now. Now, those numbers, so that I also got numbers that say there are 11 million visits to the DMV each year. Now, out of the numbers I gave you were just driver's license. There were not IDs. They were not changing address. Those were driver's license issued, 2.5 million, 2.5 million, 2.3 million in the last three years. So what we're doing, even if the people don't actually change their license every time they move,
we're going to be updating our voting registration, because if they have to get a new license, if they do go change their address, if they have to get a renewal, then we are updating their current information. And I think that's a better system than the one we have now. Okay, any other questions from the committee?
All right, not seeing any questions from the committee. Do we have some, we do have some people who are signed up to speak on this bill.
I think the first person signed up is Leslie Bellamy with the Secretary of State's office. You're speaking against HB 1004. I'm the Director
Speaker 77
23:40
of Elections for the Secretary of State's office. I've been in Arkansas elections for over 20 years, and I'm rather passionate, and I want to see as many people get registered as possible as well. This does place an unfunded mandate, as I see it, on us to get about a $25,000 program enhancement
to our power profile, which is our current voter registration system. We do have an outreach coordinator right now that goes around and trains DMVs to ask and do basically most of what this bill is asking to be done already. We do have a problem with driver services at times getting things in a timely manner. That's a concern for me with this. It's automatic. And there were over 700,000 declinations last year. In the two months of 17, there's already been over 124,000 declinations.
If these people get into the voter rolls, that creates another unfunded mandate on our county clerks to continue to try and update that system, and it will take them eight years because of the National Voter Registration Act to get them out of their rolls, even if they're not participating. And they also have to send out cards, so that creates a postage cost to the clerks. So that's my problem with the bill that it, I feel like it forces them to do things that's going to cost counties when they're already, they're taking people off the rolls already through this National Voter Registration Act.
We're educating driver service workers on how to ask these questions already. It's my fear. It just puts a burden on our clerks. And I would like my assistant director to speak on some of the problems with the Constitution. I'm
Speaker 80
25:30
Peyton Murphy, Assistant Director of Elections for the Secretary of State. I feel there might be some constitutional problems running afoul of other provisions of Amendment 51. Amendment 51, Section 9, requires the permanent registrar or the county clerk to register when
illegible and complete application is received. And this, as far as I can tell, is not illegible and complete application. It's three questions. You know, it's a lot of the same information. but may be lacking somewhere. Section 14 requires a list of registered voters to be made available, and this would prevent any third-party access to the list of registered voters, the information obtained from driver services. So that would typically be in a list
of registered voters that was made available to the public. Unknown is currently not a party option. We might have to have a system change to accommodate that. He addressed the notification of deaths. As it stands, we receive death records from vital records once a month, and this is passed along to the county, so we're already doing that.
Uh, we, information can currently be updated by voters easily, be it at the driver services or various agencies, libraries, uh, our, our VR system. We've, we don't feel this will make it any more secure. We're already removing, um, well, county clerks remove voters who have not voted after a certain time period after notifying them. and we just feel we already have a way to clean, keep the system clean.
Thank you. Representative Hammer, are you
recognized for a question? And you probably just answered a lot of it, but what I hear you saying is that for what we are currently doing, what this bill proposes to do doesn't, I guess the question is, Does it bring that much new to the table to justify the $42,000, which regarding the 42,000, that's a lot of money. But if it provides to a pure process, that's pocket change if you know that every vote counts
and every vote that is cast is being counted and it's being counted appropriate. So I guess I'd like a little comfort level from the secretary that is there, Is there not enough changes to justify the $42,000, or what could you do without having to have the $42,000 to get the bill where it needs to be? I feel
Speaker 77
28:15
like most of what we already do, what this bill is asking us to do, we already do. We may not do it in a mandated manner, but one thing it does do that is currently not being done is it puts probably a lot of people that really didn't want to register,
and they just answer yes in a hurry, it puts them into the system. And then it takes a county clerk eight years to get them out of the system, which actually, in my mind, makes our voter registration rolls less secure because then they're in a holding pattern. If they're inactive for they missed four years, they're taken out, but they're inactive in a status before they can be taken out, which still allows them to vote in an inactive status. They have to be taken out in a removable status, and it takes eight years to do that.
So this, to me, if we're putting people in that maybe didn't really want to get registered and it's just automatic, I think it makes our system less secure, and I think it's a burden
on our clerks. Follow-up, Mr. Chair. You're recognized for follow-up. Based on your answer you gave, it almost sounds like if this bill was to go through and what it would mandate you to do, that it wouldn't make those in the voting block a pure voting block,
but it might actually create some more difficulties or some folks that don't need to be in there because they haven't met the criteria, and I'm stumbling through that. So would you just kind of reclarify that, make sure I'm not misinterpreting what
Speaker 77
29:49
you said? Yes, I think it most certainly could allow people into the voter rolls that had really no intention of, to me, voting is such a right. It's a right that we should have to apply for and want to participate in. If you make it automatic and somebody's just in a rush
and they go in to update their license and then they're in a county clerk's voter rolls for eight years, maybe, that they never voted, just bogging the system down, or it holds them in their eight years when maybe they've already changed addresses two or three times and not updated because people don't always change their driver's license. And I think one representative brought up that point that you can get your driver's license for eight years now, so there might not be a way to clean these up for that entire eight years. The NVRA process is something that county clerks have to comply with for federal law,
and that will increase their mail outs. It could double it as much with you having over 700,000 in a year's time of declinations. That could really put a huge burden on our clerks financially. It puts a burden and an undated mandate on us to enhance our power profile system when I feel like we're already doing these things that's in this bill already. Mr. Chair, would you ask them
to define their term declamation? I think I know what it is, but in case it's used moving forward in any questions,
could we get a clarification of what they
mean when they say that, please? Yeah, well, I'll recognize you for that
Speaker 77
31:24
question. Did you get that question? Does it need to rephrase it? No, Representative, I understood. I have reports that I get monthly, bi-monthly. I have a yearly report here on how many Arkansas residents updated their information, and then I have on how many actually declined to register to vote. And that's what I said when we have a staff member that trains different driver services all over the state on what questions to ask and how to prepare these.
And I feel like we're already doing a lot of this and they're given that opportunity to be registered or update their information at the time they get their driver's license already. And then we do process that and send it. We get batches electronically that we send to clerks already from the DMV. Representative Douglas, you're recognized for a
Speaker 98
32:23
question. You know, I hate to be in a position where, you know, we want our cake and we want to
eat it. I mean, you know, one of those things where we want integrity in the voter rolls, but yet we don't want to spend a little money to get it. And if you're saying we're doing all these things already, then where is that great expense? And is that going to be a one-time expense on the front end? And then year after year, those expenses would go down. So that would be my first question. The
Speaker 77
32:59
enhancement to the program would be, from what the vendor has told me, of around $25,000.
That would be a one-time charge. Right. And then the burden of the expense won't necessarily lie on us from that point. It would lie on the clerks by every other year having to meet the National Voter Registration Act if this increases their roles to the point that they have to send these because these people aren't participating. They're just becoming registered when they go get their driver's license with no intention
Speaker 98
33:29
of voting. But we don't know that. We don't know that. We have no idea when they sign up to vote what their intentions are,
and I'm confused about that statement.
Speaker 77
33:39
They're already asked right now these same questions without having to change our program. Then
Speaker 98
33:45
why are we not for this then if we're doing it already? Mainly right now I'm
Speaker 77
33:54
not for it because of the $25,000 charge that I'd have to try to come up with. And as well, the clerks that I've spoke to, they don't want more and more non-participating voters on their rolls,
and they feel like this will add more and more
Speaker 98
34:13
of that to their rolls. I'm having trouble with that being a negative of having more voters on the rolls. Maybe I'm just not seeing the picture very clearly, but I think that would be a good problem to have more voters on the rolls. But I see your position that if they're on the roll and not voting, but we don't know that. We could be increasing access to voting, and that could be a good thing.
So thank you, Mr. Chair. You
had mentioned the cost to the clerk's office because of the requirements to send out postcards, which is something I'm not familiar with. And do we have any idea of what you're talking about as far as what the quantity of that would be? I mean, what is the difference? So is it primarily based, let me just clarify my question, is it primarily based on if they'll never participate, they're required to send them notice in order to take them off the
rolls, and is that primarily the cost there, is that postcard that would go out?
Speaker 77
35:20
Yes, it would be basically the participation, and they're forced to do that from the National about a registration act, so it's kind of hard to give an estimate of what that cost could be to each county, because it would be based upon participation or non-participation. Okay. So, at this point, we wouldn't know what
that cost would be because of the fact that we, you know, this would be a new program, more people would be signed up and on that. Okay. Representative Ferguson, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I think Representative Douglas had addressed one of my questions, and I think you addressed That's the second one, but I did have a follow-up, as it relates to the expense of the county clerks. Are we talking about just the mailing expense, if you added 500 more people to the roles of the county clerk in my county, in Jefferson County, you add maybe 1,000? We're talking about 1,000 more mailers on a bulk mail permit. Is that what we're talking about, or are we talking about something else?
Speaker 77
36:18
It would be the bulk mail as well as the confirmation cards. They have to purchase those, and then it is very time-consuming for this process, and that is some of the clerk's concerns, is that they already have a pretty big workflow for a low, you know, a lot of them have a low staff, so every other year, this is a great burden on them to get this out the door, and that was their concern, the ones that I've talked to, is that this will create even more of a burden of getting this out the door in
the timely fashion that they have to. One more follow-up, Mr. Chair, if I will. Representative Ferguson. So, they're doing this anyway.
Speaker 77
37:02
Is that what you just said, or did I misunderstand you? They're doing this anyway. Their
fear is they're not doing it on the scale that this will require them to do. So, if this bill passes, then you add another 500 or 1,000, let's say, in my county to the roads, then the clerks are saying that's problematic?
So they have to create 1,000 more mail-out cards and 1,000 more postage? Well, see, in your county you said
Speaker 77
37:36
Jefferson? Yes. It wouldn't be 1,000. It would have been if, like, they would have automatically registered 19,930 people that declined. If they wanted to register, right? Yeah, if they chose to register. Okay.
And that's just their fear is that it creates more, you know, it becomes more time consuming to them and that their roles become bogged down for eight years with people that are
maybe not participating. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Hammer,
are you recognized for a question? A point of clarification. So will this bill mandate that they have to require, or will they be able to continue to volunteer to register?
Because if we're talking, you know, a forced $19,000 is different than a volunteer unknown number that we don't know how many will do it. Is that correct? And could you enlighten
me on that, please? No mandate. Nobody will be mandated to register. You only register if you
Speaker 120
38:46
want to. Follow-up, Mr. Chair? You're recognized. Which isn't that the way it
is now? That is the way it is now, but what we're changing is the actual process.
We're streamlining it, making it quicker, making it easier. So once you go into the DMV, now you have to fill out a paper form with all the information you just gave to the DMV. You have to go back and still fill out that form and give it to the person. And now they have a form that they have to send over to the secretary. They already have an electronic database. So instead of transferring, it seemed like it would be less work. Instead of transferring information from a form to a database to send to the secretary
of state, now you're asked a question. And if you decline registration, it's not sent. If you don't decline registration and you want to be registered, it's automatically sent to the Secretary of State. Secretary of State sends it to the county clerk. So this is not forcing anyone to register that does not want to register. It would be very clear. The Secretary of State actually will have, it's in the bill, that they will set up the questions, that they will set up the process.
So if they want to make it easier, they have the rules. They will be dictating what the question is. If there's a fear of people moving too fast and answering yes when they don't want to, that will be up to the Secretary of State promulgating those rules and setting those guidelines up. I have a question. So currently
the process, just to make sure I'm clear on it, they don't ask that question, do you want to register to vote?
If they want to register to vote, they actually have to request the form to do so. So now the 19,000 people in Jefferson County will be asked, do you want to register to vote? And it's just a matter
of them saying yes. Is that correct? Well, they are asked if you want to register to vote right now, and you can register. If you say, I want to be registered to vote, you can then register. But this is streamlining the process and saying, are you eligible to register, would you not
Speaker 125
41:10
like to be registered, plain and simple? Are they asked that question now, though, is
what I'm asking. Are they asked, any time you're in the DMV, you're doing other business, you're getting your tags or whatever, are they asked, would
Speaker 77
41:22
you like to register to vote, is that part of the process? They are trained to ask. We do have a problem with them asking sometimes, and we do have a problem with basically some of the batches being held and turned in right sometimes after the registration deadline that we have to take care of. That's my fear too, is these batches, we're already doing electronic batches.
They're already being asked the question. I'm not sure I understand what this bill actually helps us to do that we're not already doing. Just a clarification for you,
Chairman Ballinger, I just said I went to
DMV last year and got a new license, and I was not asked if I wanted to register to vote. Yeah.
You know, my question, and this is something that's obviously the will of the committee and what they want to do, and it sounds like there may be some fundamental concerns with
the Secretary of State's office with the idea of registering people, more people who are probably not going to vote in the process, some concerns about the costs associated with that. And it also sounds like there are other concerns that may be more that has to do with actually the functioning. And so, you know, my thinking is, and this is just, you know, I'm just one member of the committee, even if I'm sitting here, is that there's some of those processes that may be able to get worked out. And I don't know if the Secretary of State's office is willing to work with you.
Have you reached out to them to
talk to them? Briefly earlier, I sent an inquiry asking how the process would work, asking what the process, asking how this would cost. Now, in the legislation, they have total control over the process, but these three things will be asked. They have control over the questions. They have control over how they will handle it, but what it's mandating is that you ask these three questions. You know,
I'm not sure if there is any common ground.
I know that there is some interest in trying to accomplish what you're wanting to do, and I would say the Secretary of State's office is trying to pursue that. If you have some ideas in order to do that, I think even this committee is willing to vote for $40,000 in order to clean up the rolls if that's going to happen. But one thing I would say that it's imperative, especially since the Secretary of State's Office is going to be the one carrying this out, just my humble opinion, is that it probably wouldn't be a bad idea that you guys, you know, powwow with each other to try to make
it the best possible. If you come back in here and you say the Secretary of State's Office wouldn't work with us at all, well, that's going to make it a little easier for the committee to make this decision. make the decision. The Secretary of State's office says, you know, the representative is not going to work with us on putting that together. From my standpoint, it would make it a little easier, make the decision. But if you guys would try to work together to get it the best possible, it would kind of make me feel better. And we still got a little bit of time, not a lot, but we still got a little bit of time that you could do that. I mean, my recommendation would be that you pull it down, you meet with them, and in good
faith, try to get it to be where it clicks together as much as possible, and then come back and then we'll decide whether fundamentally we want more people to register who we know probably aren't going to show up, but some of them may. But is that in the public interest to do so? And that is a debate that I think is worthy having. So as a politician who runs and has to send out mailers, I like the idea of knocking on a door and sending a mailer to somebody who's actually going to be there, rather than going to a person's house and having eight people and really none of them being there.
It makes it more efficient and effective and all that for us to communicate with our constituents. But I don't want to do so in a way that's going to make it difficult for the Secretary of State to do their job as well. Representative
Hammer, you have a question? If that's the direction this bill is going to go for today, I'd like to also ask that when they come back to the table, the Secretary of State be prepared to identify verify where they're going to get the money from within their budget.
I'd like to know that sooner than later, please. Yeah. The Secretary of State's been pretty efficient. I don't want to necessarily brag on one, but I like the fact that they've not increased
their budget and their budgets went down. So my guess is that they usually can scrimp to find the money, but at the same time, they've already done that, so it could be a little more difficult for them to do that. Any other questions or comments on the committee? So what's the, I mean, as far as would you want to pull the bill down and work on it or do you want to move forward and close for your bill? Is there anyone
here else to speak for the bill, speak for or against the bill?
I want to make sure that everyone has the opportunity. I think that's a good point. I don't have anybody else who has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Is there anybody in the audience that has just failed to sign up? So no, at this point, nobody else has it, but that's a good point, Representative Blake. I think that we've kind of had our debate. You know, when we come back, I can't guarantee you that there won't be further debate. But at the same time, at
least everybody knows where you're going. I am totally willing to sit down with the Secretary of State's office today or tomorrow
and have a conversation, because if we're serious, if we're as a state, if we're serious about cleaning up our voter registration rolls, and we're serious about allowing those people who want to register to register easier and more effectively. And if we're serious about having a secure data voter registration system, then we should all be fine with having $42,000 spent to make sure that we are, but to have the most secure
voting registration system that we can have. So yes, I'll be willing to sit down and address the Secretary of State and their concerns.
Okay. Thank you. I appreciate it very much, Representative Blake. All right. Representative Dalby, you are recognized to run House Bill 1207.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is House Bill 1207, and I have some amendments first that I would like to address. Okay. As you'll recall, I came before this committee, goodness, I guess it's been a month or more ago, on House Bill 1207. Just for the committee's sake, because I
know there's probably some confusion, your amendments are engrossed in the bill. So you can run your bill. I think you started out great. I think addressing the amendments is probably a good idea so that everyone knows what you
amended in your bill, but your amendments are already engrossed, and you're in good
shape with it. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm still learning some of the ropes on my end down here. We all are. Going to the amendments, what I did is after I met with y'all a month or so ago, I pulled my bill down, took your suggestions, went back, and then basically redrafted and did this all over again. What you'll note, the major changes, there were some questions about printed campaign materials and what those meant.
So I changed and gave a definition to those to spell it out so that there would be no confusion. Secondly, there was some question about political trinkets, I guess the best way. We had a discussion, if you'll recall, on fingernail files and ink pens. And so we have defined that as printed campaign materials do not mean political paraphernalia, including without limitation stickers, buttons, pins, T-shirts, nail files, and other similar trinkets,
which I think will address that. I took out some language that one of the committee members had a question on in regard to clearly printed and how would that define, so we just left that completely out. Then in Section 2, at the suggestion of the Election Commission, I added the language or a magazine for the printed material. Right now, the law requires that if you run an ad in a newspaper, you put paid for by at the bottom of it. This would include any of the magazines because those are quite prevalent now in our communities, those local magazines.
And that was at the suggestion of the Election Commission. And you'll notice in Section 2, Subsection C, printed materials shall contain the words paid for by, sponsored by, or furnished by the sponsor who paid for the campaign materials. This is actually, I believe, what most of us are doing currently. If you're not doing it currently, there is a clause in here that will not penalize you. that in the event that you already have those items printed up that don't have this language in it
and you're running again for re-election, you can use those materials without any penalty. And with that, I believe I've explained what the differences are. I think it's a much better bill. I want to thank the committee for giving me suggestions and working with me to try to make it a better bill. And as I stated previously, I believe that this is a good bill because it offers transparency to the voters in our districts, not only when we're running for something, but when somebody's sending out printed campaign materials, et cetera,
against our campaigns, we'll have an opportunity to see who is paying for those. With that, I'll be happy to entertain any questions.
I have one question, and I probably should know this, but what is the penalty if you fail to comply with this? So if we did do yard signs and didn't put our name on it, what would be the penalty for an elected official or
somebody running for office? As I recall, Mr. Chair, the penalty is listed out in this as a Class A misdemeanor.
Okay. I did not change that, nor did I address that. That's
been the law. Yeah, so if it's a violation of the law and it's not addressed, then it's a Class A misdemeanor. Correct, but I did not change that. Right. Any other questions from the committee? Okay. We do have one person who signed up to speak against, Mr. Dan Greensburg. If you don't mind introducing yourself for the record. You're recognized. My
name is Dan Greenburg. I'm an attorney and president of the Advance Arkansas
Institute. I want to begin by actually going into a little bit more detail about Chairman Ballinger's question, because there's a list of misdemeanors that Representative Dalby has amended here, and there's actually a special penalty for those misdemeanors. I call them political misdemeanors. And if you violate any misdemeanor on this list, you've not only created criminal liability at the level of a Class A misdemeanor, but there's a lifetime
ban for state government employment and a lifetime ban with respect to being a public official. That's in 7.1.103, I believe. And so I just caution this committee against creating a very large penalty for what I see as something that could happen with respect to, while being a fairly innocent mistake. I mean, you know, if you imagine that, you know, Jane Smith decides to run for school
board, and she ends up, for instance, writing a personal note to the mayor saying, you know, I would really appreciate a meeting because I'd like to talk to you about my campaign. She doesn't disclose that on the note that she writes. I think that's conceivably a violation. If she prints up something on her home computer and hands it out at the county fair and she doesn't put a disclaimer on that, I think that's a conceivable violation. And, you know, it's easy for people like all the members in this room to follow these things when they run for reelection because most of you all are successful enough so that you have campaign consultants who have the time and the resource to pay attention to these things.
But it's really very difficult for political amateurs who are running for school board or running for first-time political office to comprehend the scope of these election laws. And, you know, I mean, it's great for me when you all continue to regulate running for office. I've made a fair amount of money advising people and charging people as to how to run for office. But I think there are some downsides for the public when we overregulate political activism. And I think that we're kind of in danger of doing that here.
I think that there are also some other concerns that extend beyond what I would say is over-penalization. I certainly don't think that most yard signs need any kind of disclosure. If I have a sign that says, vote for Bob Ballinger, it's not typically a mystery as to who paid for that. And I also want to say something that's been said in this committee before, and I'm sure will be said in this committee again, which is that sometimes it's important to protect anonymous speech.
It's almost going to be a cliche, because people have talked about the Federalist Papers in this committee before, and people will talk about the Federalist Papers in this committee again, but some anonymous speech should be protected. If I were to write a letter to someone about a future small-scale political campaign, And if I were to write a letter to a local newspaper saying, you know, here's some court documents you could look at because there were some shady business dealings, and I don't even sign my name to it, let alone provide a disclosure statement, I think that that might fall under the scope of this.
And so I think that there are some dangers in regulating this kind of speech generally beyond the way that they're already regulated. And I guess finally, I'd say that most of the speech is already disclosed necessarily when people fill out these campaign reports that they turn into the Ethics Commission that we have all come to know and love. So, you know, transparency is great. Always support transparency as long as it's government transparency. And what we're talking about here is a little bit different.
It's really transparency of what in some sense are private affairs. the reason you want transparency in campaigns is to avoid bribery and corruption. And when there's no money going back and forth, as is often the case in these small-scale political campaigns, I don't see bribery concerns, and I don't see these compelling reasons for transparency. I finally want to close by apologizing to Representative Dalby. I gave her my name and my number in a previous conversation, and I should have been more assertive and aggressive in pointing out some of this stuff. And I think
I'm really at fault for not being more aggressive about that, and in particular, bringing to everyone's attention this lifetime ban on candidacy and lifetime ban on state government if you violate this thing. So I do want to apologize for what may seem like a surprise, and I wish I'd been more aggressive in bringing this to Representative Dalby's attention. Thank you. Thank
you. I don't see any questions from the committee. Representative Dotson, sorry, you are recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Excuse me. Mr. Greenberg, if what I heard you say was correct, if I understand it, if someone violates something in this, the potential penalty, whatever that may be, if it's a class A misdemeanor or some other misdemeanor, the ban is permanently holding office or being employed in the state. government at all. And so we're not just talking about an ethics violation potentially in this
sort of scenario where you could be prosecuted for it, but this would be a direct violation of that, which a court would hold you guilty for and would almost have a
requirement to prosecution. I'm not sure if I completely understand your question, but once you're found guilty, this, then the lifetime penalty attaches. Yes. So once you're found guilty of violating this or any other 7.1.103 offense, then there's a lifetime ban from being an officeholder and
a lifetime ban from state
employment. Okay. I think there's still prosecutorial discretion. The prosecutor does not have to prosecute for this. However, if it's a clear violation, it would be kind of hard for him to avoid doing that. Representative Dalby, I have a question for you. Would your intent be, would you want to have that lifetime
ban for somebody who violated this provision? Well, once again, this provision is just in with all the other provisions. And so this is a comprehensive statute that this is just being
added into. So I think that was a decision that was made long before I ever got here, that the legislature decided that violations of this code section merited that. And I guess that's
my question, is that, you know, that's true, but we're adding this. So if your opinion is, you know, this should warrant the same kind of lifetime ban, and so, and I'm not even sure, I mean, I respect Mr. Greenberg to have, you know,
to be interpreting this correctly, but at this point, this is kind of the first time I've thought about it myself, and so if what you're saying is that you think that not having your name on the bottom of yard sign warrants the lifetime ban, then we need to move forward and run the bill. If not, and I know you've been very faithful and worked hard to getting this together, and I wish that this would have been brought up to your attention earlier, but would you want to meet with Mr. Greenberg?
You're an attorney, a sharp attorney. You could look at the law and see whether it does it. And so ultimately, it's in your court. But the question is, would you want to put a lifetime ban on a person from running for politics if they inadvertently left a name off the bottom of their yard sign because they didn't know they were required to? If the answer is yes, then let's move forward with this piece of legislation. If the answer is no, I probably wouldn't want to go that far, Or then would you want to either get that clarification that it doesn't do that in spite
of Mr. Greenberg, you know, his understanding of it, or that you would want to make an amendment actually list this as an ethics violation and not a misdemeanor violation. And then I know that would be more change that you'd have to do to a bill that you've already worked real hard on. But would you want to move down that path rather than, you know, pushing forward with what could be a lifetime
ban? Well, I guess the real question, the overarching question as I understand it, Mr. Chair, is
does the legislature want to do away with lifetime bans on all campaign activities, which is what I'm hearing possibly Mr. Greenberg is wanting to be done so that there is a lifetime ban if—take away the lifetime ban if there is a violation on the newspaper ads or a lifetime ban on the radio or television ads. And evidently, the legislature decided that that was important enough.
And I think that campaign materials rise to that level, because most of our campaigns in Arkansas, at least at my level, didn't involve a lot of TV, radio, now it may in some larger markets, or even newspaper. Most of our campaigning was done by letters, push cards, yard signs. And so, I guess, you know, I really don't want to pull it down. I think that it's important enough because that's the emphasis that we do.
But I think if this committee thinks it's important that we do away with a lifetime ban for all campaign violations, that's outside the scope of what I had anticipated. I would agree with that. What
you're doing is you're creating what prior to now was not a violation and is now going to be a violation. So I just wanted to make sure that we had clarity. As far as I'm concerned, you got the right to run your bill and we'll run your bill. And, you know, historically, I've not known that that code section directly dealt with what I always thought of were ethics violations.
So, you know, from my standpoint, that's actually kind of new news to me. Representative Tosh, you're recognized for
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And Representative Dogg, I really appreciate you bringing this back and the hard work that you've done on this. I've got one. Something's been said here today that I wasn't aware of that really concerns me. And it's the fact that, you know, across this state, we've got a lot of state employees. And maybe I misunderstood what was said, and be sure to correct me if that's the case. But we've got a lot of state employees, and they run for office.
They run for local school boards. I mean, we could go on and name. And unintentionally, somehow, they violate this statute. And what really concerns me is because of that, what I would consider an unintentional violation, now they could be subjected to losing their state job. Is that what I'm hearing here today?
Evidently, that's Mr. Greenberg's position on it.
I guess if the committee is interested in doing away with that ban, I can once again pull this down and completely do away with any lifetime bans. which seems to me guts what the legislature had wanted to do whenever they first issued it. But if that's the will of the committee and you don't want any criminal penalties for violation of any kind of campaign laws or anything like that, I can certainly, once again, know that was not my intention to head down that path
of taking away an action for somebody who flagrantly violates this statute. But if the committee wants to take away any kind of penalties, I can run it again. But I'm not giving up. Representative Tosh, you're recognized for a follow-up.
And I promise you, I understand your point, and I think all of us would be in agreement. We've got to have some type of laws in place. But to me, when we put in play a statute that actually could affect someone's livelihood,
I mean, it's one thing if you keep them from running from office and you ban them from that. But I think we've crossed a line that we don't need to cross when we actually say, hey, because of this mistake in your political adventure, now we're going to take away your employment as a state employee. I just don't see how those things can be intertwined, how we can cross that line to the point that we do someone that way through statute. That really is concerning me when I heard that here today.
Representative Tosh, may I ask a question so I'll understand which direction to go. If that's a concern, and I certainly understand that concern, then my question would be to you and to this committee, then do we want to also take away the lifetime ban for failure to put the disclaimer in newspaper ads or the failure to put those disclaimers on radio or television ads that we have had all of this time
and have had that particular penalty? Is that what this committee is wishing this legislation to do? Because I'll be happy to do it and take that out.
Representative Dalby, I don't mind addressing that. I mean, I think that the, I think, you know, there's, nobody has the right to ask you to do more than what your bill, what you intend on doing. If you wanted to address, you know, further things like that, then I think it's probably a good time to do it because you're dealing in that code section. The first thing that I would, you know, I don't have time to research this issue.
As much as I respect Dan, I don't know if I agree with him 100%. And having been here when that lifetime ban was put in place, I'm pretty positive that was not the intent of the legislation. So it could have been, it could be, that legislation could have been overly broad. And so, but at the same time, what I wouldn't want to do is move forward, you know, going along with what Representative Tosh said, you know, if he, because I do represent, respect Representative Greenberg, and I know that he's not going to come down here and lie. He very clearly believes that.
I just don't know if we want to move down this path until we're sure about it. And, you know, it really stinks to have come to this committee, been asked to bring down your bill, you amended it, you've done everything, basically you've been asked, and now you're asked to do it again. Totally get that that's not a comfortable place to be. But at the same time, I'd hate to move forward with something that is a lot bigger than what our real intent is or what your real intent is. So, but that's, obviously, if you want to run your bill, you've got the right to do so. So I'm not telling you you've got to pull it down, but I probably would recommend you do pull it down.
Representative Hamer, you're recognized for it. I'm sorry. Representative Eubanks, do you have a question? I'm getting out of the way.
Okay, Representative Hamer, you're recognized for a question. Thank you. And I was reading the bill, and only because I'm dealing on another bill that this has been brought up. Is there anywhere in this language that distinguishes, and you attorneys can straighten me out, between that concept of knowingly versus purposely, you know, where somebody inadvertently leads it off, and if they are going to be held accountable to what this bill is intended to do, it could
be proven by a good lawyer, hey, that was just a screw-up, they messed up, they didn't really mean to do it, and that avenue is able to be exercised. Is that anywhere in the relevancy of the discussion on this bill?
To the sponsor, I would ask that first. I think, Representative Hammer, I have not looked at that, but I think always that is a defense to anything. But I don't have a good answer to it because we didn't go down, I didn't go down that route of looking at changing the criminal penalties.
was adopted, would that be covered under the part that you didn't change so that if somebody inadvertently left something off that they, with a good attorney, could show it was not intentional and be able to plead their case to get out from underneath that lifetime ban? MS. I think so. MR. All right. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. REP. REP. REP.
REP. REP. REP. REP. REP. REP. REP. What I've kind of keyed in on is basically what you're adding is a section for political campaign materials that will, in essence, define them as paid political advertisements. And if I'm reading the code section correctly, which I could be mistaken here, but the reason
why I think that's probably a little bit higher level and a higher threshold is because you You actually have to pay a newspaper entity or radio station or television or something like that, and they won't sell it to you unless it has that disclaimer on there because of this law or because of law similar to this. However, when you're printing something off your printer at home or when you're printing something at a print shop, they don't have that level of regulation on them to require
before they sell you something what content is in. They just sell you the signs. So it all puts the criminality back on the individual candidate who's attempting to run for office, which may or may not know the depth of these laws even as well as we do here today, which sometimes we don't. So my concerns remain with the bill. I don't know. Would you agree that you're adding a definition to paid political advertisements in this bill
is kind of the end result of it. It may not be the intent,
but that's kind of the end result. Are you asking me to respond? I wasn't quite sure if that. My intent was and is still that any campaign material that goes out trying to influence a voter to vote for you, for an individual would disclose who's paying that.
Now, that's my true intent. To me, it is a transparency issue. I understand the concerns of the committee. I don't want my bill to fail. I'll be up front. I've been working hard on it since day one. I've listened to y'all's concerns, and once again, I'll be happy to pull it down and see if we can work this out. It's not my intent to ever ban somebody from their job or to ban them from running for office. It's my intent that we be above board and transparent in our dealings with the voters.
And that is my sole purpose behind that. I understand unintended consequences. I think that we have probably strained this gnat to a far out position that I can't even imagine would ever be taken by a prosecutor of worth his or her salt. But with that being said, I'll pull it down and see if we want to take out the lifetime bans for this whole entire section. I'll be happy to do it.
Well, I mean, if you're doing that, then we don't necessarily take further questions, but I'd recommend it. We do have a couple of people who have questions. So
Speaker 98
1:12:45
Representative Douglas, and we'll get you, Representative Hendren. And I'm not as familiar with this as I should be in that world, but would it be possible to simply change it to a number of years? I think so, Representative.
And, you know, the lifetime ban, I think, has us all a little bit jittery. and then, you know, maybe define the type of, you know, of penalty. Not only is it, you know, going to be a number of years, which, I mean, a five-year ban can knock somebody out of political office, I mean, for a lifetime, as well as a lifetime ban could. Sometimes your window of opportunity is small. So, I would think a simple tweak like that we might be open to.
I appreciate that. And if the committee will indulge me, I will take another run at it to make it so that it addresses the concerns of this committee and also assures the voters of the state of Arkansas of our true passion to be transparent in our campaigns and to let people know who is paying for our campaign materials and if we are. Because I truly believe that that is important. It's important, I believe, to everybody that sits not only on this committee
but in the General Assembly, and it's important
to me. Do you still want to take away one more question?
Sure, I'll be happy to take questions all day. Representative Hendren, you're recognized for a question. Well, as I sit here and listen to this discussion, the thing that occurs to me is that I've had constituents ask me fairly recently about school districts, city councils, colleges, other publicly supported facilities and operations campaigning for issues before this legislature
or before whatever, just issues like we put out a deal, vote for me. How does that impact that if there's an issue before the voters in a school district or in a city or in a county or in the state, for that matter, and the entity that has an interest in that, for instance, the school district, are they required, are they allowed, first of all, to do that with funding based on this legislation here? Greenberg may know something about that. And if they're allowed to do that, do they have to put paid for by such and such school district?
Representative, it's my understanding and my reading of this particular code section is this is narrowly aimed at people who are running for office, not those issues, not bond issues, not whatever the school district or the city may be involved in, but it's aimed at just the candidates. You're recognized for a follow-up. Then
the question I'd follow up with that with is, and it also add to that, paying the
transportation and the costs and the lodging and so forth that's involved in doing that. I guess my question is, why should it not apply to those entities just
like it does to the candidates for office? I think, Representative, and I am not an expert in campaign laws necessarily, that there are other code sections that address the level of activity that a school board or a city
board can take in an election. And that is outside the purview of this particular section we're discussing. Okay. I'm not seeing any other questions. I appreciate your
forbearance with our committee. I think in the end, if we get that cleared up, it's not going to be something you have to carry on the House floor and over into the Senate, it's going to be a better bill if we can get that worked out. So I appreciate your forbearance with us, Representative Dalby. And I appreciate
it. And just to let you all know, I'll be back. Thank you.
Okay. Thank you. Senator Stubblefield, are you still in the room? I thank you for waiting around on us. You are recognized to present Senate Bill 131.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I will say one thing, we need to get the House as architect on the Senate end. Senate Bill 131 is a safety and security bill that probably would never have,
there would never have been a need to run this 20 or 30 years ago, any more than there would have been a need to run the enhanced penalty bills like Representative Tosh and I ran. But our society has changed. We don't live in the same world we lived in 30, 40 years ago. You know, we didn't have TSA. We didn't have a lot of things. In fact, when I first came here, we didn't have metal detectors when you walked into the Capitol. One morning, I'll never forget, one morning five years ago, I walked into the Senate chamber and looked up in the gallery to the West Gallery, and there was an individual laying in the
the seats with a backpack leaned up against the railing and had no idea what he was doing there. So we called the Capitol Police and come to find out this individual had walked all the way from Pine Bluff. Had walked in the Capitol, was up in the gallery with a backpack and was just resting. But this bill, let me just tell you what it does first of all. But it exempts anything, emergency plans, security plans, risk assessments,
anything that would be detrimental to the safety and security of either the public or the police officers here at the Capitol or Capitol Hill. And I have a little, it's not a handout because I don't have enough to give everybody one. But one of the reasons for this bill, back when Governor Huckabee was governor, the Secretary of State's office devised a security plan to get the governor out of the Capitol in case there was an emergency.
Senator Stubble, would you want that distributed to the committee? Because we can make a copy. But if you just want
to... Sure, they can. Okay. That security plan was put in place. It was supposed to be, you know, top secret. The next morning, the next morning, that blueprint of the security plan was on the front page of the Arkansas Democrat. So that in and of itself tells you that, you know,
there is need for some type of security. I grew up on a farm, and my dad taught me a long time ago that it's much better to be proactive than it is to wait until something bad happens, especially something as bad as losing a life before you act. So as a result of how this society we live in has changed and we're not living in the same world we were, and I'm sure it'll be different 50 years from now, but I think this bill is necessary.
And I'll be glad to take any questions. Okay. Representative
Tosh, you're recognized for your question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Senator, for bringing this bill. We passed a bill similar the other day as a contingency emergency plan, and that's exactly what this is. And that's all this is, is a contingency emergency plan just to protect the staging areas, you know, who would be in command, you know, where the staff would meet, where the evacuation would take place. It's really not keeping anything from, you know, from the public or anyone else as far as pertinent documents that would be necessary the way I see it, but also make sure I'm correct about this.
I think I am, if there for any reason was an ongoing investigation, some type of criminal investigation, then any records that any information pertained in that investigation, obviously once that investigation was closed, would be subject to, would be subject to disclosure. Those would be available. Exactly. I just want to make sure that that was pointed out, that those, those needs would be met And this in no way would protect those.
It just simply protects information that if someone else had it, could make it very detrimental to the evacuation or the safety of those involved in this contingency plan. Is that correct? That's correct. Okay, no further questions. Representative Hammer, you're recognized for a question. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. Now, this was brought up the other day on the House floor, I think, by Representative Drown, so I want to ask to make sure it applies to the same thing. As far as aligning with any federal guidelines or aligning with any federal expectations when it comes to Freedom of Information Act in areas of security and sensitive nature such as this,
does your bill parallel with what's done at the federal level where they try to secure, you know, federal buildings or capital buildings? Well, any federal
laws, you know, they preclude state laws. I mean, they're over state laws, so is that
or Chair? Yeah, you're recognized. I'm just saying that in what you're attempting to do, it is like what we've already done, and that is that this doesn't violate any federal laws when it comes to making sure that areas that need to be secured are secured,
even if it goes over into the FOI area. No, this is not violated. That's right. Thank you. Okay. Any
other questions from the committee? All right. Not seeing any. I know that we have one person who's signed up, has a large ears with the Press Association. Am I mispronouncing that? If you don't mind coming in, introduce yourself and we'll get your name correctly. If you don't mind introducing yourself for
the record. I'll be happy to do that, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. I'm Tom Larimer. I'm executive director of the Arkansas Press Association. We are the trade association for the newspapers of Arkansas. There are 120 newspapers in Arkansas, at least one in every county. I'm sure that you all are familiar with your newspaper people back home. I'm hearing a lot from my constituency, which are the newspapers of Arkansas, and bills like this one are one that I'm hearing about. There appears to be an unprecedented assault on open government in Arkansas.
I have no argument with securing security plans. My concern with this bill that I raised earlier is that it closes to public scrutiny a tax-supported, publicly paid-for agency of state government. If you'll read this bill, records and information relating to is used in there considerable time. that could be construed to be anything, be well beyond the security plans.
And again, I'm not sure I would have an objection to that. But our concern is here is that this has the potential to, again, invoke the old unintended consequences of closing to public scrutiny records that are open for a reason. The FOI has been a terrific tool for the people of Arkansas. It has helped keep government open and transparent. It has helped facilitate the exposure of corruption.
And we've seen a great example of that just recently, that that would never have come to light, more than likely, without the FOI being strong and vital and serving the people of Arkansas very well. So it's that potential for corruption, the potential for, you know, if you close something and put it out of sight from the public, it not only creates the potential for corruption. I'm going to suggest to you that it's going to happen if eventually, given the opportunity to to do something without any sort of public oversight or any sort of transparency at all.
Bad things are going to happen, and that's where we're going down this road with this bill and some others that are presently in the pipeline right now, too, that would impact the Freedom of Information Act. That's our position that the newspapers of Arkansas are taking on this bill, and it is our concern at the FOI coalition also that this is where we're going with bills like this. I couldn't let this go by without making a statement in opposition to it. I appreciate the time. You know, one thing
I want to say is that collectively, and we visit about this in here
and we've visited about it with leadership, is that there's no doubt there's a lot of FOI bills, and so we need to be concerned about whether or not we basically gut FOI all together by the collective. And so we do need to consider the collective. However, one thing that I think would be helpful on that is if each individual bill is judged on its merit and how it, you know, whether it is necessary for security or whether it's not necessary for security. And then if we want to preserve FOI, we need to make sure that we try to narrow each bill
down to only do what's necessary for it to be done. Or else, if we just take a blanket, we're opposed to all of it. I have a feeling that you're going to find many of them passing. It may not be as narrow as what you'd want. Just my opinion. But Representative Hammer, you're
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. The first one would be, I sense that you're an individual of fairness and all that other good stuff. I'm just curious, you see the concern as far as putting something on the front page of the paper that just undermines the whole intent, and that is the security and protection of not only we as legislators,
but the public that comes in the building. So do you have something to offer in the way of suggestion to achieve the objective of the bill without going to the other side of what you're
concerned about? You're addressing that to me, Representative Hammer? Yes, sir. Okay, thank you. I don't have a recommendation on that. You know, part of the strength of the FOI and what it's been able to do for the people of Arkansas for 50 years is that it keeps government open. The security plans, you know, with that route, I doubt seriously.
There's no evidence that anybody's ever used the FOI to get information that would allow them to develop an attack of any kind. Um, that was, it's really kind of ridiculous to think that it actually would happen. But, you know, the fact is, as long as it's a public document, it can be published, whether or not it's publishing, uh, publishing is good judgment. Um, that's subject for debate, but the fact is it's a public record and it is subject to publication and that's just part of, uh, living in a free and open government.
It's the price we pay. Follow up. Mr. Chair, you recognize, I just want to clarify what you said, make sure I didn't you misunderstand something, because what I understood you to say in part of your answer to my question was that never has anybody taken advantage of seeing documents printed in the paper, such as what Senator has held up and used it for malicious intent or to stage or wage attacks like, say, something like a parade route or a government set of plans. Was that what you intended to say or what you meant to say?
What I said was there's no evidence that anybody's ever utilized the FOI by making a request for those sort of security plans in order to facilitate some sort of skullduggery. No, I didn't say exactly what you heard that I said. That's not what I said. There's just no evidence that it's ever been used for that. And you mentioned the parade route. I mean, we publish parade routes all the time. You know, publishing it doesn't mean anybody's going to do anything about it.
I'm not sure it's all that secret to begin with, because everybody that's going to be involved in whatever security implementation of any security plan is going to know what it is, and it can remain confidential. But at the same time, again, it is a public record at this point, and I would like to see us keep as many public records as possible open and available to the people of Arkansas. That's what the FOI was intended to do, and I just hate to see it undermined and eroded in the fashion that it is presently during this legislative session.
And that includes this bill here. I just think it's overly broad. Again, the security plans, you know, I can almost find it in me not to make the argument against that. But when you start talking about records and other information, that pretty much, that's everything. That's who's on the security force, what they're being paid with public money. everything that's related to it. So yes, I would have a problem with that. All right, thank you,
Mr. Chair. All right, Representative Douglas, you're recognized for a question.
Speaker 98
1:30:34
Thank you, Mr. Chair. What is my security as a public citizen that if information that would harm the public, you would have, and you collectively as the print media or TV media or whatever, would have the good judgment not to publish. Because I see no restraint on the part of the media to show good judgment
when they fall upon public documents that could lead to security issues. So what is my security that you will show restraint when you get documents that should not be printed? Well, Representative Douglas, as a
public figure, you signed on for that, number one. I'm talking about my people
So go ahead and answer. I'm not thinking of any specific incidences that you may be referencing there, But, again, my contention is and our contention is that the citizens of Arkansas are best served when the government operates in the sunshine and open and transparent to the public. So in
Speaker 98
1:31:59
other words, you're telling me you have no ethics that would lead to any restraint if a document fell into your possession that, you know, would obviously not be something that should be public?
Well, you're asking me to make a value judgment based on my values and my ethics. And, yeah, certainly I've been in that situation. I've edited and published newspapers all over the country, and I've been in that situation several times. And more often than not, we didn't publish it. But that's not to say that somebody out there in the fourth estate would have the same compunction about publishing it. Again, that's part of living in a free and open society. It's what happens.
Thank you. Representative Gray, you recognize for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And there have been several, quite a few FOIA bills. Most are very specific in nature, not broad in nature at all, and we have looked at those. I guess my question would be, you know, a lot of times you get an onslaught of bills based on a reactionary type method, not necessarily a proactive method. So a lot of these bills that we're seeing are reactionary to specific events that have happened in footage, whether it's video footage or whatever it is that's being put out in the media
or on Facebook or on websites that does not need to be out there. So most of these bills are reactive bills. So I guess just a very direct question. Would you ever agree to any FOIA exception? Well, we have
in the past. It's not that we just automatically are opposed to everything. We're just automatically opposed to anything that creates any sort of an issue with the FOIA that might have some unintended consequences. And I think that's what we're talking about here in this bill.
And I won't reiterate my reasons for that because I've already said them. But, yeah, no, I think there's easily opportunity there. It's not a perfect bill. As Senator Stubblefield has said, we live in a very different world than what it was in 1967 when this bill was signed into law by Governor Rockefeller. There's always room for improvement. The Internet didn't exist in 1967. We didn't have e-mail. We didn't have text. There was a lot of reasons that the FOIA needs some updating. So, no, I could see a scenario wherein we could work with whoever to bring it into the 21st century now that we're well into that.
So, yeah. My answer would be that, sure, we'd
Speaker 208
1:34:34
be open to that. Okay, follow up just real quick. You recognize. Okay, you just don't
think security is one of those issues that should, the security of the elected officials, constitutional officers, the people
of Arkansas is enough to cause an exclusion? Well, again, as I said, the security measures would be one thing. I don't have an issue with the security measures as much as I do closing all the other records and information pertaining to, in this case, the state capitol police. There would be absolutely no way of knowing what sort of individuals we have working in
those positions, what they're paid, what their background is, or so forth. And that would be my concern in any tax-supported agency of exactly, you know, who's doing what, what they're being paid, how they're contracting with and for how much and how they're spending this public money. But we'll not know that if this bill becomes law. Reverend Smith, you're recognized for a question.
time. Okay. Representative Hamer, you recognize for a question? Thank you. And I
just want to make sure there's a platform for you to express your heart's opinion about this as you've already done, but I want to qualify it in this one question. It's your position representing the press association that as you want us as public servants to be transparent and open with all documentation so the public can have the sunlight put on it.
It's your intent to do that as it is also the intent of the public that if you are privileged to information that it is reported in an accurate, unslanded way so that the public gets the pure sunshine as filtered through you. Is that a fair statement? You want us to be as open and transparent when it comes to matters involving FOIA as Because the public wants you, as the media, to be as open and transparent with the facts
that become your possession by your investigation. Is that true? I would agree with that, yes. Okay,
thank you. Representative Hendren, you're right, can I answer your question? Well, perhaps there ought to be somebody on the other side of this deal. I want to thank you for coming and standing up for the FOI. And the question I have is, in 1979, when I was a freshman on the other end, Senator Max Howell decided to hire his nephew or cousin or something to be a state trooper to stand out in front of the Senate.
And we were going to pay him $60,000 a year. Four of us freshmen voted no. And after we had voted no, Senator Howell did this to us, called us to the front door and said, I want to know why you voted that way. And our answer, Senator Wood was one of these, I think Wayne Dowd, I don't know if he was another one, but several of them that you'd know. We said we just didn't think we needed to spend that for the people of Arkansas. And what my problem with this is, any time we erode Freedom of Information Act law, it's a step in the wrong direction, and I appreciate you being here standing up for that.
What this place down here needs is more sunlight rather than less. And so I'm opposed to loosening this up in 2017, just like I was in 1979. So thank you for your taking a stand today. Thank you. Okay. Any other
questions from the committee? Sure. Thank you. I listened to what
you had said about the salaries and all that stuff, that you wouldn't have access to that. But to my knowledge, this doesn't change the transparency website.
All that information would still be available on the transparency website. Do you not agree with that based on this bill? I'm not
sure that would be the case. It says records and other information. So that could be construed to be just a whole lot of information, including salaries.
No, that's not true. The issue would be that's created under another code section, statutory section, that's not being amended directly in this bill. So if that is all required to be published under a code section, I'm not sure why that would be any different. All right, any other questions from committee?
All right, seeing no other questions, Senator Stubblefield, you're recognized to close. Well,
I appreciate Mr. Larimer being here, but I will say one thing. You know, there's not one person sitting in this Capitol today whose life is worth more than somebody walking down that street or somebody at Maumelle or anybody else in the state of Arkansas. But by your being here, you're in a unique situation that they're not in. Just by the fact that you've been elected to represent them, you are in a unique situation that puts you in a little more danger than they are in.
But your life is not any more valuable. You're worth the same. You're the same.
So, I'd ask for a good vote. Okay. We actually have a couple of motions on the table. Representative Douglas, I'm sorry. In fact, let's do this. Well, did you have a question, Representative Brown? I actually have a statement. A statement. Okay. Let me get the motion, then we'll speak to it if that's okay. Representative Douglas, what's your motion? Motion to pass. Okay. So, we have a motion to pass on the table.
Anybody who has any comments, Representative Brown, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
What I want to say is, first of all, if the governor of this state were a target today, I would want to thank the media for the information that was put out on December 30th of 1998, if indeed these security protocols have not changed. As a person who is well-versed in this business and understands what it takes to put together a targeting package, the majority of the information you use is open source.
And the fact that this lists the exact protocols that were used, where the governor's dropped off, the escape routes that he has in the capital. And mind you, this was from 1998. This was prior to 9-11-2001 in ISIS. But we live in a different world, as the senator has said. And this is a treasure trove to somebody who is setting up a targeting package, if indeed they've deemed this target softer than the other states. So when it comes to the security protocols that are used within this Capitol, the security
procedures regarding the legislature, the governor, and anybody else, I think that those should not be privy to the public eye because we're talking about the safety of not only those folks that I just mentioned, but those folks who come to visit this Capitol. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Okay. Any other discussion from the committee?
Okay. The motion on the table is to pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Opposed. Ayes have it. Congratulations. Senator Stuboff, you passed your bill. Thank you, committee.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Okay. Next on the list is Representative Dotson. Are you prepared to run 1633? Yes. You are recognized for run 1633. Representative Dodson. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. If I may, I invite Kelly Boyd from the Secretary of State's office.
This bill is a bill brought to us by the Secretary of State's office, and I will turn it over to him to discuss the particulars of it and answer any questions this committee might have.
If you'd introduce yourself for the record, Mr. Boyd, I'd appreciate
Speaker 220
1:42:27
it. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. I'm Kelly Boyd, Chief Deputy Secretary of State. This bill's title is actually longer than what it does. This is revising 1935 language.
That's when this bill was originally written. At that time, there were reasons for it. All this bill does is currently the governor's office, the Secretary of State, and the Department of Health try and manage the leasing of the Capitol cafeteria. There are some issues that we're going to have to address with some construction in the cafeteria that requires some decisions to be made. We visited with both of those entities, and they agree with this language. It will simply put operations of the Capitol cafeteria the way it is now in code under our
name. It just cleans that up. And there is a provision on the back page, on page two. Right now, the lease money for the cafeteria goes into the treasury. We would like to capture that money and place it into the maintenance fund that we have so that we can expend that money directly on the cafeteria. Right now, it all comes out of our budget, any repairs, equipment. We pay for all the equipment, repairs, whatnot in there. So this would give us a more efficient manner of managing that instead of coming back and asking the Treasury for more money, we can just spend
the money that comes in off
the rent. Okay. I see no questions from the committee. Okay, we do
Speaker 14
1:43:55
have a question from Representative Ferguson. You're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Ward, one quick question.
The other facility down there next to the cafeteria, is that in any way affected by this legislation, or is it all together?
Speaker 220
1:44:10
The other facility, you're I, Senator. The barbershop? Yeah. The unopened barbershop?
Now, we already have complete control over that facility. Okay. All right. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. Okay. Reverend Gonzalez, you're going to answer your question.
Speaker 227
1:44:30
Yeah. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I was just looking at this. In the old language, it says that you are directed to receive bids, and the new language says that you may receive bids. Can you address
Speaker 220
1:44:41
that, please? We just wanted that flexibility. In the future, we may change the way the operations are done there.
Currently, the rent on the place right now is $500 a month. It may be that we receive a better offer to operate that thing with no rent. It may be that we receive more rent. It just gives us flexibility in how we manage the operations. Okay. Any other questions from
the committee? All right, no other questions from the committee. There's nobody signed up to speak for or against this bill. Representative Dotson, you recognize a close for your bill.
Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. I'm closed and make a motion do
pass. Okay, we have a motion do pass on the table. Any discussion on that motion? All right, all in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Congratulations, Representative Dotson, you passed your bill. I have been requested for Representative Davis, by Representative Davis, to take up a piece legislation so he can get to his committee. Is there any objection to letting Representative Davis speak? Present his bill? Okay. Kind of hoping for objection to Representative Davis.
You are recognized to present Senate Bill 373, Representative Davis. Thank you, Mr.
Chairman. Thank you, committee. Brief explanation. It's a short bill. The problem we have is that FOI is being used to circumvent a discovery process, an attorney-client
privilege when the client is a public entity. This bill would protect that attorney-client communication under FOI. Okay. Any questions from the
committee? Okay. We do have a press association who is signed up to speak against. Anybody else want to present anything on that? So let's see if you all don't mind making room for the press association.
Mr. Chairman, I have my company here is from U of A and ASU, and if there are questions from the committee, they'd be happy to take
them. Okay. We don't have any, although something that I made a mistake, we do have three people sign to speak against, so we may not be able to fit you in, but we'll try. In fact, let me go ahead and just pause. I know I hate doing this in the middle of the bill, but I want to try to put out notice if we can.
We do have a couple of bills that we did not take up. You know, I would want to know whether this committee was okay with meeting upon adjournment and try to finish some of those, run whatever we can, get some stuff done, because it looks like we're not going to be meeting on Friday. So, okay, well, I'm getting nodding heads, so I'll go ahead and put out notice that we'll be meeting upon adjournment, and then that way we can pick it up. And if we end up in a position where we can't finish this before you have to go to your committee, Representative Davis, then we'll pick this up upon adjournment. That way we'll just be clear that we do have some time.
We don't have to push through this so quickly. Okay, if these folks want to do a presentation, if not, then we'll start. We can move on. Okay, then the first person on the list is Mr. Larimer. I hope I'm getting that right now. Your writing is almost as bad as mine with the Press Association. If you all don't mind making room for him to come down, if you'll introduce yourself for the record, I'd appreciate it.
Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, and I printed that on there too, so you
printing apparently is not too good either. I'm not casting any stones at all. Okay. Again, I'm Tom Larimer from the Arkansas Press Association. And again, the newspapers of Arkansas are very concerned, as is the FOI Coalition, regarding this bill. And again, its unintended consequences. The way I read this bill is that any agency in government,
whether it's a school or a college or a city or a county that wants to make secret a document, all they have to do is run it through their attorney, and it's automatically assigned privilege. I can understand the motive for this legislation to protect interests in cases of litigation, but unfortunately, the unintended consequence here would be to allow any government agency, as I said, to make confidential or make secret communication if all they have to do is
routinely run it through their attorney. That certainly does not promote transparency in government in Arkansas, certainly not in keeping with the tenets of the Freedom of Information Act. And I just don't see this promoting open government in Arkansas. In fact, I perceive it doing just the opposite. And as I referenced earlier, a big part of what the FOIA does is expose corruption in government. This would certainly create a great potential for more
corruption in government by making secret any communication that any government agency elects to make by running it through their attorney. It's a simple process. Whereas in the case of litigation, an attorney, all it has to do is ask any court to be granted that privilege in respect to a specific case in litigation. I don't know, and my legal advisor doesn't know of any case where that's ever been refused.
This is just making it a blanket, but it's also opening up a whole bag's worth of unintended consequences that we have serious reservations about. I appreciate it if you'd consider that closely and keep that in mind as you're considering this
bill. Okay. I'm seeing no questions for the committee. I appreciate your testimony. Mr. Joey McCutcheon. If you will introduce yourself for the record.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is Joey McCutcheon. I'm here as
of Western Arkansas. If you don't mind, turn your mic on Mr. McCutcheon. Thank you. My name is Joey McCutcheon. I appreciate you having me today. I'm here as a citizen and also on behalf of Western Arkansas Transparency in Government group, which is a sunshine in government group that I have formed in Fort Smith. As Mr. Larimer has said, our Freedom of Information Act is the people's law.
Currently, it's one of the recognized nationally as one of the strongest laws in the country. U.S. Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis once said publicity is justly commended as a remedy for social and industrial diseases. Sunshine is said to be the best of disinfectants and I think that's so true when we're talking about the corruption that we seem to be seeing across
this state, I'd also like to read the legislative intent back in 1967 when Republican Governor Rockefeller passed this as his major piece of legislation. It is vital in a democratic society that public business be performed in open and public manner so that electors shall be advised of the performance of public officials and of the decisions that
are reached in public activity and in making public policy. Toward this end, this chapter is adopted, making it possible for them or their representatives to learn and fully report the activities of public officials. These 12 words effectively become our Freedom of Information Act, and that's scary. Open government is going down the tubes pretty quickly if this is a past, in my opinion.
And the reason that I say this is I believe very strongly that this guts our Freedom of Information Act. Effectively, all that has to happen for these government records to now be non-transparent is for a CC to be sent to a lawyer or these documents to be run through their attorney. And that's very troublesome, particularly in light of the legislative intent. We must remember that government attorneys work for me and you and everyone in this room.
And what's going to happen is that the people are going to be prevented from seeing what is going on regarding the most important issues. The city of Fayetteville versus Edmark case is a classic example of that. the citizens. The city of Fayetteville was facing at least a $7 million burden as a result of the actions and decisions of public officials. And in that case, this information would not be made
public. The goal of this, it's been stated, and I read it in the newspaper, I guess, this morning, We seem not to trust newspapers anymore. Benjamin Franklin once said that those who give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety. With that, I would say that if the goal is to protect a fair trial, as stated in the Edgemark case, that probably should not be a concern.
That's a job of trial courts to control the admissibility of evidence and the rules of evidence. And courts have the authority to control all actions before it. And this provides safeguards for a fair trial, if that is in fact the concern. With that said, I would just say that the right to the public to know should never be trumped by the self-protective instincts
of government bureaucracy. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Okay, thank
you. I don't, Representative Gray, do you have a question? Okay, you're recognized to ask a question. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. Mr. McCutcheon, so when I go look at your webpage for what you do professionally, you know, it appears you're a plaintiff attorney. You represent med mal, wrongful death, all kinds of suits in your professional designation. Have you ever requested information from UAMS through a FOIA for what would normally be considered privileged in the rest of the attorney world
to use in one of your own cases? No, ma'am,
I have not, but I have requested information from the Fort Smith School Board, from Ecclesia College, and I may have that pronounced wrong. Recently, I've requested that information, and we're now in a lawsuit because of that, looking at the corruption that's gone on in that. So I have had to represent a party in that regard, and I think that we'll probably open up a new can of worms in regard to that.
But the point is that this is going to effectively do away with our citizens' ability to request records by a simple 12 words. But no, I have not. And frankly, this isn't about whether I'm a trial lawyer or not. I do transparency cases all over this state. And I have a transparency and government group in this state.
And I know how difficult it is. And if we want to create more litigation, this
Gray, you're recognized for a follow-up. Thank you. Would you not agree that it's a very unfair playing field for the plaintiff versus defendant if, for instance, UAMS's attorneys, all their working papers in a lawsuit are possibly foiable? Would you not agree that that's an unfair advantage
Speaker 240
1:57:59
for the plaintiff attorney? No, I don't. This is about transparency in government.
You didn't answer my question. Well, I'm trying to get to that if you'll let me. What I'm trying to get to is that's the purpose of trial courts is to govern our rules of evidence and to decide which evidence the court's going to hear. So, no, I don't agree with that supposition. One outs.
Okay. Representative Davis, you said, do you have a motion for Reps? I'm sorry, Representative Dotson, sorry about that. Did you have a motion?
Okay. Okay. All right. Is there any other questions from the committee? All right. I appreciate your testimony. I appreciate you having me. Okay. Mr. Glenn Hoggard, if you don't mind introducing yourself for the record,
that'd be fine. GLENN HAGGERT, Chairman Ballinger, committee. My name is Glen Hoggard. I'm a practicing attorney license here in Arkansas. I do not have a case that is either what would be considered a plaintiff's case or a defendant's
case. I practice in juvenile court and I practice in domestic relations court. I'm here because it appears I've become an elder statesman in my life. I'm sad to observe that, but I want to tell you all about a case that I was involved in shortly after I graduated from Washington Baptist University when I was a reporter for the Arkansas Radio Network. It was the Vertak case in Jacksonville. It was in 1979. The Fed, the EPA, I believe, announced publicly in 1979 that the Vertak chemical plant had
managed to poison the land around the plant, the well water in the biomedical watershed, and possibly the air around that plant in Jacksonville, Arkansas, was something called dioxin that none of us had heard of prior to that announcement. Turns out it was a very poisonous chemical that caused cancer at a high rate. As you might imagine, the citizens of Jacksonville had several reactions. They were all worried immediately that they were being poisoned. They were worried immediately that the value of their homes had just cratered, that no
one would ever again buy a home in Jacksonville. And they were all worried about the health of their children. The Vertec plant endeavored to do what I since would be called damage control. That's not a term we used in 1979. And they hired a prominent Little Rock law firm, which arranged for a meeting with the Jacksonville City Council. The Jacksonville City Council and the mayor went to this meeting, and the media, including myself as a member of the Arkansas Radio Network, were precluded from attending.
I should tell you, because it's important, that the mayor of Jacksonville at that time is my father-in-law, my wonderful father-in-law, and has been that for 35 years. He was not at that immediate point in time. I apologize for the aside, but I believe in letting you know all the things that you should know. the fact that this bill is not narrowly construed, as was Senator Stubblefield's bill, this bill is broad. As was mentioned earlier by Mr. Larimer, all it would take in this bill to
keep the media from attending a meeting of the entire city council and the mayor would be to include the city attorney, thus making the communications privileged under the attorney client privilege. I deal with attorney client privilege daily. I'm a practicing attorney now. I understand what that means. I agree with Mr. Larimore that a CC on an email would turn every communication that's made into a protected from Freedom of Information Act communication.
I want to tell you this. I've spoken with former Senator David Johnson about this bill, spoke with him about it Friday, and he has convinced me, and I believe it is correct to say, that, as Representative Gray alluded earlier, there probably should be an exception for active litigation. It is probably improper to allow an unlevel playing field in active litigation. I find it somewhat disingenuous for state attorneys, state hired attorneys to say that we need this to be made level. It needs to be equal, that this should be a level playing
field. That's not true. State hired attorneys are different. It should not be a level playing field. They should be held to a higher standard than privately engaged attorneys in regard to the public's record, in regard to the public's right to know the public's information. I want to say this. I also believe that if a body asks its engaged attorney for an opinion letter, a legal opinion. There probably should be an exception for that as well as this bill is envisioned.
But I want to say this. As was mentioned earlier, in 1967, Governor Rockefeller offered the Freedom of Information Act to bring the state of Arkansas City Council meetings, didn't even have quorum courts then, but quorum court meetings now, and for that matter, legislative committee meetings into the public specter. It's been the law for 50 years. Mr. McCutcheon mentioned City of Fedeville versus Edmark. If there was ever a question about whether or not attorney-client
privilege was covered by the Freedom of Information Act, that Supreme Court opinion answered that question in 1990. It's been the law for 27 years. It's as though all of a sudden these other Freedom of Information Act bills have given rise to government attorneys to say, we need to get this even up. Again, if you want to exempt active litigation, I'm fine with that. I think that's fair. Senator Johnson has convinced me of that. If you want to exempt opinion letters
from attorneys, I'm fine with that. But everything else is going to be a gaping hole in the Freedom of Information Act that you can drive a truck through by simply throwing CC on an email. Chairman, if I may use your city as an example, I don't have any problem with Senator Johnson at Central Arkansas Water. I don't have any problem with Mr. Hagemeyer or Mr. Phelps at their state institutions and universities they represent. They do a good job. They're going to follow the law. They're going to follow the dictates. But what I have a problem with is if I go to the city of St.
Paul and I make a freedom of information request, the city clerk's going to be deciding whether or not I get that document or not. And he's going to look at the email. It's going to say, well, well, look, we've included our attorney here, therefore, this should be exempt. And I don't think that's what should happen. I don't think that's the intent of this bill, but I think that's what the logical conclusion is, that that's exactly what will happen with this bill. And so I'm going to ask y'all to, at a minimum, seek to amend it to exclude only active litigation and attorney opinion letters from the Freedom of Information Act
or otherwise defeated. Thank you. I appreciate your presentation and your testimony. I have no questions from the committee, so I know, Representative Davis, from my understanding from conversations is that you may not intend for this to go as far as what they're saying. I don't know that it would, but the question, I think that there are a lot of conversations, this is just from my point of view, that are in communications that as an attorney that
are exempted under attorney-client privilege. And it's not just active litigation. It's the kind of stuff that gets you in active litigation. I can see some value to having that also exempted. However, you don't want to go as far as a person being able to CC an attorney on every message and that being exempted. Is that correct? Yes, sir. That's a fair statement. Okay. I mean, what would you want to possibly, I mean, we've already talked about coming back
after session. I know that you have a committee that should have started five minutes ago. Yeah. Do you want to bring this back and maybe with an amendment that would do that and we
can deal with it? Mr. Chairman, if it pleases the committee, what I'd like to do is allow these two gentlemen to make a brief statement as to the intent of the legislation. And then afterwards, I think I would like to pull it down and bring it back when we have
more time for a broader debate. Okay. All right. I appreciate that. You all are recognized. And if you want
to introduce yourself for the record. Sure. Thanks, Representative. My name is Brad Phelps. I'm general counsel for the
Arkansas State University System. With me is Mark Hagemeyer, who's chief counsel for the University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences. The reason this bill has been brought forward was for a couple of things. Number one, it's some of our public institutions, and Mark can speak to this in a second, who are engaged in trial. Lawyers for UAMS have actually had their trial notebooks requested under the FOI, which for any practicing lawyer, you don't have the ability, if you're a
public institution, to request your opponent's trial notebook. I do think there's a bit of unfairness there in response to one of the points earlier. I also want to say that there is already protection afforded some attorneys who work in state government. You know, the Attorney General's Office, where I used to work, has a working papers correspondence exception. This bill, actually, I know that just because other states pass laws isn't a reason we should pass them, but I would
like to note that over 40 other states have similar protections, so this isn't an idea that is unique to institutions in Arkansas, there does seem to be a pretty well-established trend of states who recognize this. And finally, I wanted to mention earlier, there was a statement made that in response to some of these requests that your remedy should be just to go to court if you have an active case and seek relief from the judge. The problem is that under the FOI, when you receive an FOI request, unless your documents are in active use or storage, you have to respond to that
request immediately. And as a practical matter, um, you have courts who have a number of cases, a number of parties, and it is not practical, uh, to be able to get in front of them and have a ruling either yay or nay on your, on your request. Um, so I do think, uh, for all of those reasons, I think this bill has a lot of merit, um, to it. And, uh, I appreciate your consideration.
Thank you. My name is Mark Hagemeyer, and I'm the managing lawyer at UAMS, and I'd just like to give a couple of examples of the kinds of litigation tactics that do go on.
A couple of things I have seen in my own career there in the past nine years are lawyers walking into a deposition and requesting your deposition outline at the time of the deposition, which absolutely, Representative, Chairman, you're smiling. You can imagine how that sort of throws off what's going to happen for the rest of the day. I've had my pleadings on the eve of filing motions for summary judgment. I've had requests come in for all documents that you utilize in preparation for your motion.
And that is going to be tomorrow when the deadline falls, a public document through the court system. And so I would contend that this really does essentially just level the playing field. I certainly, I've been reviewing this language for weeks. I would have never thought as a public attorney who receives my pay through the people of the state of Arkansas that just because Dr. Ron copies me on an email that is going out to his executive staff that somehow I would be able to invoke an attorney-client communication privilege,
language, which went out to the CFO and the chief information officer, et cetera. I would not be so bold as to say some other attorney might not contend that. I don't know. That would certainly not be the position that I would take after 25 years of public service. Yeah. I
don't think that's legislative intent, and so there's a good chance that we would be able to get it interpreted more narrowly. The question is that I've kind of got a sense from different people is if we can, since we we really don't have time to finish this now, if we can get an amendment that would just
clarify that, that that's what we're talking about is things that otherwise would be privileged information if it weren't for it being a government entity, then I think that that's going to remove most of the heartburn, at least the biggest arguments that the opposition has put forth that I think could be legitimate, just like you, that I could see a government attorney trying to interpret it that way at some point, and I don't know how the courts would treat that. Probably not very well, but we don't know. Representative Davis, are you wanting to pull your bill down and come back after we adjourn
session? Yes, sir. Okay. All right. Then, Representative Hammer, you're recognized. Do you have a question in general or for the— I want to brief . Okay. All right. So, you're dismissed, and we'll see you back after session. Representative Hammer, you're recognized for a point of personal privilege. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. One thing I want to remind the members of this committee and I was sitting here listening to all the debates, some of the comments that were said, was that when we had JPR up and running this last time, and I apologize, we ran out of time, but also when the subject was put on the table in October before our term was going to finish up as JPR,
one of the subjects was to take up a look at Freedom of Information Act. The next day, the way the article came out, it was as though we were attacking God. And I just want to remind the committee members that this subject was offered to be put on the table, but the shadow of doubt that was put over why we would be doing it, I think might drive some of the reason why we've got so many Freedom of Information Act bills before us now, that if the tone would have been different, it might have set the stage for this session. So I just wanted to bring that up.
Thanks for the point of personal privilege, Mr. Chair.
Okay. All right. Seeing no other issues or questions, we are adjourned until upon adjournment. Thank you.
Agenda
HB1430 Tosh CONCERNING LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER STANDARDS AND TRAINING; CONCERNING THE ARKANSAS COMMISSION ON LAW ENFORCEMENT STANDARDS AND TRAINING; TO REPEAL OBSOLETE LANGUAGE; AND TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS.
REGULAR AGENDA
Number Sponsor Subtitle
HB1004 Blake TO CREATE THE DEMOCRACY ACT; TO REQUIRE AUTOMATIC VOTER REGISTRATION; AND TO AMEND AMENDMENT 51 OF THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION.
HB1570 Brown TO PROVIDE STATUTORY GUIDANCE CONCERNING INTERSTATE CONVENTIONS UNDER THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION, ARTICLE V.
HB1622 Johnson TO CREATE PROCEDURE FOR ADDRESSING BURDENSOME REQUEST FOR AN AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1623 Johnson TO AMEND THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967; TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING INFORMATION FOR PUBLIC GUIDANCE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1633 Dotson TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE MAINTENANCE AND MANAGEMENT OF PUBLIC PROPERTIES AND OTHER FACILITIES IN THE STATE CAPITOL BUILDING; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
SB273 Standridge PERMITTING ACT 309 INMATES IN THE CUSTODY OF THE DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION WHO ARE HOUSED IN A COUNTY JAIL TO WORK FOR LOCAL NONPROFIT ORGANIZATIONS; CONCERNING ACT 309 INMATES; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1207 Dalby TO AMEND REQUIREMENTS FOR CAMPAIGN SIGNS AND MATERIALS.
HB1675 Sturch TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS' MEMORIAL.
HB1696 D. Meeks TO TRANSFER THE STATE CHILD ABUSE AND NEGLECT PREVENTION BOARD TO THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES THROUGH A TYPE 3 TRANSFER; AND TO ABOLISH THE STATE CHILD ABUSE AND NEGLECT PREVENTION BOARD.
SB131 G. Stubblefield TO EXEMPT FROM THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967 CERTAIN RECORDS OF THE STATE CAPITOL POLICE.
SB292 Maloch TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE TRANSFER AND INVESTMENT DUTIES OF THE TREASURER OF STATE; TO AMEND THE TIME REQUIREMENTS APPLICABLE TO CERTAIN TRANSFERS OF STATE FUNDS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
SB373 Hester TO EXEMPT ATTORNEY-CLIENT COMMUNICATIONS AND ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT FROM THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967.
SB377 Hickey CONCERNING THE ELIGIBILITY OF AN INMATE OF THE DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION TO PARTICIPATE IN A WORK-RELEASE PROGRAM OR UNDER ACT 309 OF 1983.
HB1707 M. Gray TO AMEND THE DATES OF THE GENERAL PRIMARY ELECTION AND PREFERENTIAL PRIMARY ELECTION; TO AMEND THE TIME PERIOD FOR FILING AS A CANDIDATE FOR A PRIMARY ELECTION; AND TO AMEND THE TIME FOR THE FISCAL SESSION.
HB1725 D. Douglas TO TRANSFER VARIOUS STATE AGENCIES TO THE ARKANSAS AGRICULTURE DEPARTMENT THROUGH A TYPE 4 TRANSFER.
HB1728 Ladyman TO REPEAL THE COMMUNITY SERVICES ADVISORY COUNCIL.
HB1736 Hammer TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE REPORT OF A LOSS OF PUBLIC FUNDS.
DEFERRED BILLS
Number Sponsor Subtitle
HB1008 Tucker TO INCREASE THE PENALTY FOR TAKING CAMPAIGN FUNDS AS PERSONAL INCOME; AND TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF ARKANSAS LAW RESULTING FROM INITIATED ACT 1 OF 1990 AND INITIATED ACT 1 OF 1996.
HB1005 Tucker TO REQUIRE REPORTING AND DISCLOSURE OF ELECTIONEERING COMMUNICATIONS; AND TO RESTRICT THE AMOUNT OF MONEY SPENT ON CAMPAIGN COMMUNICATIONS PRODUCED IN COORDINATION WITH A CANDIDATE FOR OFFICE.
HB1046 Tucker TO PERMIT PAID MATERNITY LEAVE FOR STATE EMPLOYEES.
HJR1001 Ballinger APPLYING TO THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS TO CALL A CONVENTION FOR PROPOSING AMENDMENTS PURSUANT TO ARTICLE V OF THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION.
HB1011 Sabin TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEES; AND TO PROHIBIT DIRECT CONTRIBUTIONS FROM POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEES TO CANDIDATES.
HB1012 Sabin TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEES; AND TO PROHIBIT DIRECT CONTRIBUTIONS FROM POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEES TO CANDIDATES.
HB1065 Watson PERMITTING THE ARKANSAS COMMISSION ON LAW ENFORCEMENT STANDARDS AND TRAINING TO MAKE ADDITIONAL SALARY PAYMENTS ABOVE THE BASIC CERTIFICATE LEVEL.
HB1179 Ballinger TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING APPROVED POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEES; AND TO PREVENT A MEMBER OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY FROM FORMING MORE THAN ONE (1) APPROVED POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE.
HB1009 Leding TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING APPROVED POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEES; AND TO PREVENT A MEMBER OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY FROM FORMING MORE THAN ONE (1) APPROVED POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE.
HB1270 Johnson TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ELECTIONS AND BALLOTS.
HB1289 Ballinger TO PROMOTE AND IMPROVE EFFICIENCY AND QUALITY IN THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES; AND TO REORGANIZE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES.
HB1386 Lemons TO REQUIRE THE FILING OF FINAL AGENCY RULES WITH THE ARKANSAS STATE LIBRARY; AND TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURE ACT.
HB1447 M. Gray TO TRANSFER THE STATE BOARD OF ELECTION COMMISSIONERS TO THE OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OF STATE; TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING COMPLAINTS OF ELECTION LAW VIOLATIONS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1151 Davis TO REQUIRE THAT REGISTERED VOTERS BE NOTIFIED BY MAIL OF THE DATES FOR CERTAIN SPECIAL ELECTIONS; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING SPECIAL ELECTIONS.
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Bob Ballinger Chair
Unverified
Representative Dwight Tosh
Unverified
Representative Charles Blake
Unverified
Representative Jeff Wardlaw
Unverified
Speaker 45
Representative Kim Hammer
Unverified
Speaker 66
Representative Brandt Smith
Unverified
Speaker 77
Speaker 80
Speaker 98
Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson Chair
Unverified
Speaker 100
Speaker 120
Speaker 125
Representative Carol Dalby
Unverified
Dan Greenburg
Unverified
Representative Jim Dotson
Unverified
Representative Kim Hendren Chair
Unverified
Senator Gary Stubblefield
Unverified
Speaker 187
Representative Lane Jean
Unverified
Representative Michelle Gray
Unverified
Speaker 208
Chair
Unverified
Representative Karilyn Brown
Unverified
Speaker 220
Speaker 14
Speaker 227
Representative Andy Davis
Unverified
Speaker 237
Joey Mccutcheon
Unverified
Speaker 240
Glen Hoggard
Unverified
Brad Phelps
Unverified
Mark Hagemeyer
Unverified