Aging, Children and Youth Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (16)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1678
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1678 Beck CONCERNING VISITATION WITH AN INCAPACITATED PERSON OR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HR1034
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “This is House Resolution 1034. Madam Chair, you are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. In…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1034
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1034 C. Fite TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING HEARING INSTRUMENT DIS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1059
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1059 House TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF VIOLATION…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1297
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1297 Farrer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS MILITARY HERITAGE PROTECTION…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1381
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1381 Gazaway TO AMEND THE GROUNDS FOR DENYING PERMANENCY PLANS T…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1445
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1445 Lowery TO CREATE THE PARENT-CHILD RELATIONSHIP PROTECTION A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1475
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1475 K. Hendren TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE APPOINTMENT OF G…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1530
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1530 Gazaway TO CLARIFY THE LAW CONCERNING LEAVE OF ABSENCE FOR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1568
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1568 Rushing TO GRANT VISITATION RIGHTS TO GRANDPARENTS WHEN A P…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1636
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1636 Richey TO PROVIDE BIRTH PARENTS WITH THE OPTION TO REDACT T…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1654
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1654 RushingCONCERNING THE RIGHTS OF GRANDPARENTS INVOLVED WITH…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HR1013
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1013 Sorvillo HONORING THE 308TH TITAN II STRATEGIC MISSILE WING…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HR1025
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1025 S. Meeks RECOGNIZING THE CHICKAMAUGA CHEROKEE PEOPLE'S UNIQ…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB132
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB132 J. Hutchinson CREATING THE COMMISSION FOR PARENT COUNSEL; C…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB268
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB268 J. Hutchinson CONCERNING THE TERMINATION OF A GUARDIANSHIP.”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 13, 2026
Good morning, members. I think we'll have a few more members coming in, but we're going to go ahead and get started. We will first run any resolutions this morning, if members have resolutions to bring forward? Is anyone here to run Senator Ingram's resolution?
Representative Wing, will you take the chair while I run my resolution? All right, we're
This is House Resolution 1034. Madam Chair, you are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. In 2008, a seemingly very healthy young man was diagnosed with colorectal cancer. This was a big surprise to his entire family because he was the picture of health, and the only symptoms he had were some rectal bleeding.
He underwent a year of treatment, several surgeries, chemotherapy, radiation, but today he is again the picture of health. That young man is my youngest son, Joseph. So I want to encourage all of you to recognize the month of March as Colorectal Cancer Awareness Month. This is one of the most treatable cancers, and the earlier we can recognize it, the sooner it can be treated,
and the sooner people can get back on a healthy path. Arkansas has a very high rate of colorectal cancer, and I would like to encourage all of you, especially those of you who are over 55, to be screened. It's not a pleasant thing to talk about, but it is wonderful when we can take early action and go ahead and have a healthy life. So I ask for a good vote. Thank you. Are there any questions by the committee?
Representative Walker, you're recognized. Motion. What is your motion? Do pass. Any discussion on the motion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, nay. Congratulations, Chairwoman Fite. Your resolution has
Without objection, we will now move to House Bill 1678.
Representative Beck, you are recognized to present your House Bill. Thank you, Madam Chair.
First of all, I'd like to thank the committee for allowing us to come before the committee and the scheduling, because we have quite a few people that want to speak to this bill, and we certainly appreciate you guys adjusting your schedule. I also want to thank the CASEM group for all the help that they've been in drafting of this bill, as well as their efforts across the country in terms of pushing this very, very important initiative, which is the visitation of spouses and children to incapacitated individuals.
With that said, I'd like to start by House Bill 1678. I think the best way to explain it is in the very first line of the thing. It says, an act concerning the visitation with an incapacitated person or award. And I think that really sums up exactly what the bill does. It allows a person, an incapacitated person, the right to see their child or possibly their child to see them.
So with that said, why would we need this? Are guardians a problem? Are caretakers a problem? The answer to that is no, they're not. Typically, they are not the problem. 99% of the time all that works very well but when it doesn't the main tool that the bad care taker uses is isolation and that's why visitation is so important we've got to make sure that that person is
visited by people of their relatives or people that have interest now with that said what does this bill do How does it approach this? It really doesn't change a lot other than it says that. When there's a question about visitation, it just brings an additional set of eyes to the table. Those set of eyes might be the court. Those set of eyes might be a professional health caregiver that says that the individual is capable of seeing that.
It just brings an additional set of eyes on the topic. So how does it do this? Well, what it requires is, if I'm a relative, or as it's stated in the definition section of this bill, an interested person, I have a right to petition the court for visitation. In that petition, what I would ask is this. I would state what my relationship was to the individual.
I would also state who the individual, the caretaker or guardian, whoever, is for that person as far as restricting my access and how my visitation is being restricted. At that point, the court could do something just as simple as say, you know, you're not an interested person. You don't have this connection, this ongoing connection that's defined in this bill. Or they could say, you know, based upon history that we have right here in front of us,
that you're not, it would be not in the best interest of the ward to see you. So that's the other thing. Now, I have heard of some people, there are some concerns that this would add additional court cases and litigation. But I would address that in another way. If there's one person out there, one person, and I have to run 10 people through one additional step just to make sure that the incapacitated person is in fact getting the ability to see their daughter or son, then so be it.
Some of the people would say that the hoops that are set up in this are too large, but I don't think that's true. I think that what's set up in this bill is that a mother has a right to see her children. That's the first path we should take. Now, if there's a problem with that child, it should be obvious past history. It will not be a big case against this. Now, the other thing that I would say, in most cases, in most of these cases,
this is not a case where there's one individual. Those people are usually pretty easy to pick out. I mean, we all have those relatives, right? I mean, it's the relatives that you hope don't show up for dinner sometimes. But this is a case where probably all the children are isolated from it. It's not a single case. In that case, what this thing, additionally in this bill, what it does is this. It says that once the petition is filed, if it's a frivolous petition and I shouldn't
have access, then the courts, right here in the bill, the courts say that I have the right, the courts have the right to levy the expenses of the court and reasonable attorney fees against that petitioner. So that would be a deterrent from someone just coming up and doing some kind of frivolous, bring up a frivolous petition. It also says that if the caretaker is at fault here, if the caretaker is a problem, the courts have the same ability. They can
and put the cost back on to that caregiver so that it doesn't affect the person that's trying to petition. It does shift the presumption that the parent or the child or whoever the incapacitated person might be, the ward, it does shift that over to say that it is in their best interest to see their relatives. Let that additional set of eyes take a look at this situation and once they take a look at this, then they can make the call. I think I'm going to close right there and I'm going
to turn over to my witness here. I think it can shed a whole lot of light on this. As I mentioned earlier, this is law in 15 other states. The Kasem group has done a great job of promoting this in other states. And hats off to that group for all their efforts traveling all over the country to promote this. This is a good bill. And with that, I'll turn it over to my witness.
Thank you. And would you please introduce yourself to
the committee? Absolutely, and good afternoon, Madam Chair and committee members. My name is Carrie Kasem. I'm from the Kasem Cares Foundation. My father was Casey Kasem. And the last year of his life, his wife decided to isolate him, not allow any of us kids to see him, none of his, his brother couldn't, his aunts, his uncles, all of his friends, he was completely isolated. We called the police, and, and let me, let me back up just a bit. This is a man we saw every week.
We talked to him every day on the phone. We were extremely close. I am who I am today because of my dad. We were told straight out, you're never going to see your dad again. And we thought, okay, we'll just call the police. Call the police. They couldn't help us. Well, we called Adult Protective Services. They'll help. They didn't help us. Okay, well, we'll go to court. Well, we went to court and even though my father, when a court-appointed doctor
was sent there, Dr. Trader, and a court-appointed attorney was sent. He said emphatically, I want to see my children. Not only did he say that, he said, I want, my sister Julie is a PA, a physician's assistant, and she said, I want her making medical decisions on my behalf. He was very cognizant when they went to visit him. The doctor and the PVP attorney came back to court and said, Casey Kasem wants to see his children. Even after all the lies and hearsay that my stepmother told in the court
and in the press, got it straight from my father. Like every single state without this bill, California had no jurisdiction or had no law in place to allow a judge to just rule on visitation. It would have been done. We would have set up a visitation schedule. There was absolutely no way. The judge looked at both parties and said, Casey Kasem wants to see his kids. Now go in the hallway and figure this out. Those were her exact words.
When my case went public, I started getting hundreds of letters from across the country. People that don't have money. People that can't afford an attorney. People that have been isolated for years from their parents. there is no law that allows you to just ask for plain and simple visitation and all the other person that caretaker whether it's a guardian somebody with the power of attorney or a spouse they can just come into court and hearsay and say oh they're terrible kids oh they upset this person oh they just there's no evidence we had to prove we were good children we had to show
pictures she said we were estranged we showed pictures up until literally the week she took from us. So it's just a common sense law to ask for visitation to your sick loved one. Most of the time these people are not completely incapacitated. If you send somebody over there, whether it's a lawyer, a social worker, somebody from, you know, the court, and they ask them, do you want to see your kids? And the mom or dad said, yeah, I'd love to see my kids,
especially when you have dementia. Statistically, the Alzheimer's Association says you need to be surrounded by loved ones. You need to be surrounded by familiar faces. You need touch. You need love. If you isolate someone with Alzheimer's or dementia, they die 50% faster. That's a statistic. Alzheimer's doctors will tell you that. So what I'm asking, it's a very common sense, Bill. It's just visitation.
if there is a child that is abusive someone who has a history of violence maybe a history of financial abuse then there's going to be a trail and that caretaker can bring that in and say look, this person has a history of abuse we don't want this kid in but most of the time when you find isolation it's everyone it's not just one kid, it's everyone it's all the kids, they're all bad so let me
say this I fought a fight for eight months it cost me $350,000 to see my dad again visitation should not be for the 1% and this is not just happening to people with famous last names and money I have hundreds of letters that I can give you including five people here from Arkansas that are going through this I was on the buzz this morning We had four callers call in and say they're going through this now. I asked them to come down here.
It's happening here. It's a simple solution. Let a judge decide on visitation or not without going through an entire expensive trial over POA, power of attorney, or guardianship. It's working in, like the representative said, it's working in 15 states right now. It can work here. Thank you so much. Thank
you for your testimony. Thank you for being here. We have some questions from committee members.
Representative Meeks. Thank you, Madam Chair. You partially answered my question with your own story, so I really appreciate that. My question is, in a case where a person cannot communicate their wishes, because it seems to me that if they communicate, they say, yeah, I want to visit, to me it seems like an easy decision to actually make, but in a place where they're not able to communicate their wishes or maybe they didn't have it specified in a will or other contract that says, hey, I want to visit or I don't want to visit, how has that situation actually worked out? Very good question. We've
had people actually have to show a history of visitation and phone calls, so you look back at the history of visitation and phone calls beforehand, and you can bring those into court. You can also bring witnesses into court as well. If there is no history, and if you do go ask the ailing loved one, do you want to see your kid, and they say no, that's it, end. There's no forced visitation here. If that person does not want visitation, absolutely, then that is their wishes. There's a federal law that allows, and this is unfortunately not in personal homes, but
nursing homes and hospitals. It's been around for over 20 years. It's a federal law that allows a person who is sick and ailing that's been put into a hospital or a nursing home, when they say they want to see somebody, no matter if they're under guardianship, no matter if they're under POA or if the spouse says no, if they say they want to see somebody, that facility has to let that person in. That's already in law but it does not happen in residential homes, and people don't know about that law. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair.
Representative Kavanaugh. Thank you, Madam Chair. I appreciate what you're going through. I've been a guardian of two parents and also a stepmother who has Alzheimer's currently. And with that, I understand what it is, and I've had a nephew that's been kept from his mother, very similar situation with Alzheimer's. So I understand both sides of the situation. I keep hearing you repeatedly say, this is just about visitation. It is not.
Page six, line four, starts taking away guardianship rights. So it is not just about guardianship. I mean, it's not just about visitation. And I'm all for visitation. I'm like you. They need it. It does help them. but when you start tying the hands of a guardian who is trying to do what their loved one is wanting, you are beginning to tie the hands. One thing that bothers me in particular is as a guardian
of an ill father who had a request to withhold life-saving treatment, you say I can't do that unless I go to court. That was a wish of my dying father and you're telling me that I I can't go to court and do what my father's wishes were without consent. Absolutely
not. I had to fight that for my dad, too, because my dad had a nondisclosure. I mean, sorry, an NDA. And I had to fight my stepmom who wanted to keep him alive as he was choking on his own fluids.
This is what this says. It says, page
6, line 4, a guardian appointed on or after October 1, 2017, shall not make any of the following decisions without filing a petition and receive an express court order. And number B says consent to withhold life-saving treatments, experimental treatments, termination of parental rights. You go down a list of things that keeps us from doing what our parents have asked us to do.
I agree with you on this, and can we amend that and take it before it hits floor? We have asked Representative Beck to pull it down so that he could do that. that would be great for all of us because that is a great concern of us
as guardians i understand that because i had to fight that with my my dad's guardian and you're right he wanted he did not want life-saving measures my father was choking on his own lungs and his his feeding tube was backing up and he was dying and the more fluid we gave him the the sicker he got he was in more pain we had
to go to court and overturn her objections to keep him on life-saving it because he would have drowned to death and it would have been very painful I agree with you completely if that is the dying wish of a
person then that needs to be upheld no matter what but this session in particular takes away Representative Kavanaugh this section in particular takes away lots and lots of rights of very good guardians and I understand that there are some guardians that are not well
but what we're doing is we're punishing the good guardians because of a few bad guardians, and I would ask that y'all rethink that.
I understand that. Thank you. One more thing. There are a lot of guardians that, not a lot, there are some very good guardians, but the ones that do take advantage of this will unfortunately not follow the person's wishes, and that's what this was trying to do, but I understand where you're coming from. Representative Beck,
what are your wishes here? Well, If this is a point of contention on this bill, I'll give you my word that before it goes on the floor, I will amend it to
take that section out. All right. Thank you. We had some other questions. Representative Birch? Thank you, Madam Chair. There's some other concerns, and I don't think there's anyone in this room
that is not compelled by your story to do something, because we want families to be able to visit. But there's some concerns with how this is written and some of the greater impacts that may have been unintentional that I'd really like to be able to visit with Representative Beck about. You mentioned that this is just about family. There's a definition. It creates an interested person definition, And it says it means a person who has a significant and ongoing affectionate relationship with an incapacitated person.
That's an incredibly broad characterization. And when you add that then to the fact that this, in both places, whether there's a ward or whether there's a guardianship or not, there's a shifting of the burden of proof so that the person who's caring for the guardian who's caring for and correct me if I'm wrong this is going to be my question I apologize I'm getting to the question the way this is is if I'm a guardian of someone and entrusted by the court
and with the responsibility to take care of the person I now have to hire an attorney and hire medical experts to prove that the person who wants to see the person I'm trusted and were taken care of, I have to prove that they're not worthy of or the danger to the person I'm responsible for. So the shifting of the burden, so it's not the burden on the plaintiff, it's actually the burden on the respondent, bothers me a lot.
I hear that. Do you have any, or has that been a concern in any of the other states where you've brought this legislation, or has it been
addressed in any way, the shifting of the burden of proof? Just so I'm clear exactly on the question, because you came up with the fact that it's broad, meaning anybody who wants to petition somebody who's affectionate. We put that in there because there were people who didn't, sorry, there were people that didn't have, they weren't adopted through papers, but yet they would call somebody mom
or dad, or maybe their grandparents raised them, but they weren't a son or a daughter, so we were asked to put that in there. We have, in other states, made it just for family members' blood. So that did, there were some, and then Wisconsin and Louisiana made it for anybody who has close ties. It just depends. If you, if you know, that can be amended for sure. And the burden of proof, the problem is what I have seen for three years is when
somebody is granted guardianship, when a judge grants somebody guardianship, they believe that guardian is going to do what's best and what's right. Unfortunately, every time we go up and this happened to me, there's hearsay. A guardian can say, oh, that kid is upsetting to their parent. Oh, that kid just wants money. Oh, that kid has been estranged. They're coming back for other things. And it's hearsay. There's no proof of it. And so this is the only problem
we have is there's no proof at all. And how do we get it? How do we? It's the only place I've ever seen hearsay be a demissible. I don't know how to get around that where you can actually, like on both sides, I think there needs to be some evidence of showing that the kid wants to visit, showing that the kid has had phone calls, and then there's evidence in the fact that, well, maybe this kid has had a history of violence, maybe there's a police report on him, something, you know?
Representative Burt, should you have a follow-up? I do, thank you, and I appreciate that. I think it's the purview of the court and the judge to make that determination as to how to weigh the hearsay testimony. I would give the judge that responsibility they already have, but one of the other things I wanted to address. In the state of Arkansas, there's an adult protection services under the Department of Human Services, and the Maltreatment Custody Act, this language purports to change definitions, and in the way I read this, it would significantly change some of the rights and
responsibilities that the state of Arkansas would incur with regard to the people that are entrusted are placed as wards of the state of Arkansas that DHS is responsible for. Has there been any communication or any coordination with the Department of Human Services in the state of Arkansas as to how this will impact the many people that are in the custody of the state of Arkansas or who may come into the custody of the state of Arkansas based on the change of the definition in
this act? If you're talking about the definition,
is this working? We're having a little trouble hearing
little bit closer to you, please? If you're talking about the definition of the person in there, that is a new definition. That is not a change to the definition. In that section, it is a new definition. We did not delete. As far as the rights, as far as the DHS would have, we have not struck anything out of this.
We've only added definitions, and those definitions as they apply to our visitation rights. Representative Gray. Thank
Speaker 57
27:45
you. Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Beck, I don't think there, to echo Representative Birch, I don't think there's a person sitting in this room that doesn't want to address this issue. and absolutely appreciate the testimony that has been offered today.
I would ask you, and Madam Chair, I apologize if this is out of protocol, but I would ask rather than us take a vote on this today, obviously the bill's been filed, it's here, we're not going to miss a deadline. If we could hear the testimony of the people that have traveled here today on this bill but not take a vote and give an opportunity for members of the committee along with the Department of Human Services to maybe have a little more conversation with you about this bill instead of taking a vote. But I would hate to see this fail
for lack of an understanding on language when it's such an
important issue. Representative Beck, would you tell us your wishes,
please? I will agree to pull it down. We'll get all the testimony in here today. But I will ask for questions of this so we can address all these issues. And then next week, we will talk about the possible changes to this and return back to this committee. If that's agreeable with you, Madam Chair.
Thank you, Representative Beck. So going forward, what we will do is go ahead. We have several people signed up to speak for or against this bill. However, some of their concerns may be allayed by the changes that you're planning to make. But we would like to go ahead and hear from these witnesses today. and then when you make the changes in the bill and bring it back to us, it will be a much quicker process and we can go ahead and take our vote at that time. So with the committee's permission, that's what we'll do at this point. And would you, excuse me, I think I have recognized all the people who had questions
and some may come forward as we have other witnesses come and speak. Would you like to bring forward any other witnesses or did you just wish to have people come and speak for or against?
I think at this point it would be best just to have people come
up and speak for and against the bill. All right, thank you. We have, I'm sorry, I may mispronounce this, Ione Daniel to speak for the bill.
and will you introduce yourself to the committee please and correct my
mispronunciation of your name hi madam chair and committee my name is ian daniels i'm with the casem cares coalition i joined this coalition because my father was isolated and i was blocked with visitation and when I heard that Carrie, that this was happening in the news with her,
someone brought me the article and said, if this is happening to her and she can't do anything about it, what are you going to do about it? And so I began listening to her radio show to find out how she was going to deal with this situation. Meanwhile, I tried to see my father and my children. We flew down to New Orleans. I was born and raised there. and we were close my whole life. My stepmother knew this and it seemed like as soon as she got the power of attorney,
the relationship shifted and my father would have never, ever, ever said he did not want to see us or any of his kids. And so this is my experience and the police told me I had to file for visitation and I just stood there and said, I don't understand and I had the help of Alzheimer's Association in San Diego who was directing me who felt like this was a situation in which my father might have been in danger and she
was directing me to get a police report while I was there which I was able to do and the police looked at me and said as if they'd never heard of such, they looked at me like we couldn't do anything about this. Like, I feel bad for you. And I really didn't, I had never heard of such a thing. So I followed Carrie to see what she was doing, and when I heard about the bill, I knew it was the right thing because I knew that if I'd gone to court,
and I did go to court, and I tried to represent myself because I did not have the money to get the conservatorship or whatever it took to try to help my father. And he passed away suddenly in an isolated state. And at the end of it, he called me. He wasn't supposed to call me. She told me that I was going to have to have a restraining order, which I was actually, she was going to get a restraining order against me and my other siblings.
And I was happy about that because that would give me a chance to go to court and find out why she was doing this because there was no reason for her to stop any of us from seeing my dad. And so he passed away suddenly and unexpectedly. And it's so traumatizing. I don't know how to, when you can't, I'm sorry, it's unthinkable really
that you don't, that this kind of thing happens and I couldn't do anything about it. The police couldn't do anything about it. APS was on it with the help of Alzheimer's Association And he just didn't have enough time. And I lost my father like this, and she even cremated him so we couldn't have an autopsy. And I just knew that it wasn't safe to be old, to get old at that point. And I knew that the Alzheimer's Association was familiar with the situation because she made me do a report with APS.
She helped me to fill it out in San Diego about my father in New Orleans. So, you know, we need this bill. I needed it. It wasn't there for me, but people need this bill all over the nation. Thank you for your testimony,
and we are sorry for your loss. We have Donna Gay signed up to speak. Oh, I'm sorry, different bill. all right we don't have anyone else signed up to speak against this bill we have other people
signed up to speak for the bill and please keep in mind we want to hear from you but we are under time constraints so please if you have something that we have not heard before the committee that would offer a different aspect please be sure and bring that forward to us we have margaret Timbrough to speak for the bill.
Speaker 76
35:20
Hello, Madam Chair. May I have Carrie with me up here to talk? Yes. Thank you. I would like to thank Madam Chair, the committee, and Representative Beck for helping me along this journey supporting my mom in our situation. First of all, I had no knowledge of my stepfather acquiring guardianship.
Think of your lifelong best friend considered how much you enjoyed spending time with that person and all the memories you've made together. Now imagine that you were prohibited from seeing your best friend who is in a serious situation and is in grave need of your help by doing so. You can start to understand the story of my mom being isolated from me. I was devastated to learn that my mom had been placed in a nursing home. A doctor whom I
have never met, spoke to, evaluated my mom, the guardian had this doctor evaluate my mom, stated in a letter in 2013 that I should be limited to supervised visits for 30 minutes with my mom because of a certain false allegations against me. this also barred me from outings and visits with my mom and all holidays and special events
my mother and I have been isolated from each other for more than three years except my permission from the guardian she is still in the nursing home to this day she has not left the nursing home except for doctor's appointments and she is in a lockdown unit at the dementia Alzheimer's ward. Currently, the only chance I have to see my mother is on Sundays just to help her with lunch, and the guardian approved that. My mom nurtured me and loved me
growing up as a child and still does to the extent she can. It is my turn to do the same for her. This is my birthright. I have witnessed neglect with my mom having dementia. She cannot express it, so I am her voice, her eyes, and her ears. My goal is that at trying to pass the visitation bill, people in situations like mine gain access to isolated loved ones without
senseless restrictions. My parents taught me the difference between right and wrong. And to me, this, in my opinion, this arrangement is wrong. Just the thought of separating loved ones from each other needlessly is unbearable. The vulnerable need their family's love. Nothing can match the love of a daughter or son for her or his parent. Again I thank you for all your time and to please
consider this bill. Thank you for your testimony. Next we have Cole, oh excuse me were there any questions from the committee? Next we have Cole Tumburo to speak for the bill.
Madam Chair there is one thing she wanted to add is that okay? Yes, please. Her stepfather went to the courts and when they asked if he had any, if his wife had any children or any next of kin, he said, no, we have that here. He lied, so nobody was notified she was put under guardianship and where she went. So I just wanted you to know that.
Thank you for that information. Thank you. Mr. Tamburo. Would
Speaker 82
39:37
you please introduce yourself to the committee? Hello, my name is Colton Bureau. I am the son of Margaret Tamburo, and so thank you everyone for giving me this opportunity to speak. I'll be very brief, and I just want to corroborate with my mother's story and verify the absolute
pain and struggle that my family has been through with this situation and my personal loss of my grandmother and the awful disease that dementia is and Alzheimer's, I just want to briefly say that a bill like this needs to be passed, and it needs to be passed quickly because these people aren't, they're not always around for very long.
And I've witnessed my own grandmother turn into someone that I don't really know anymore. And so please take that into consideration. And please consider this bill. That's all I ask. Thank you. Thank you for your
testimony. We're sorry for the suffering. your family is experiencing. And our final, were there any questions for this witness?
Thank you. Our final witness is Kim Eubanks. And would you please introduce yourself to the committee?
Speaker 85
41:19
Thank you, Madam Chairman and committee. My name is Kime, K-I-M-E, Eubanks, everybody messes it up, don't worry, it's a strange name. I am from Benton, Arkansas, I have a master's degree in counseling and I'm also a grief
specialist, that's my business, but this is personal for me, 10 years ago, 2006, my wife passed away from gastric cancer, leaving me with three children, 12, 8, and 5 at the time. So I have been, for the past 10 years, their sole parent. We stayed in Benton to be close to my parents, who live in East End, but also her parents, my late wife's parents, who hadn't been married for years and lived separately in Benton.
One of those, of course, her mother. In 2013, her mother started to experience strokes, and so she wasn't thinking as clearly. We helped her through some of those situations. They were TIA strokes at first and weren't as severe, but eventually they became more severe. A woman, a notorious drug offender in Benton, found her way into her life, talked her into being her caretaker and living with her. eventually falsely obtained a power of attorney.
We were later, a lawyer helped her do it. We were later able to get that redacted. At that point, she separated Anita, my mother-in-law, from her grandchildren, my children, my three children. We weren't able to talk to her on the phone. We knocked on the door. The lady wouldn't let us in. We, of course, retained a lawyer and began to make moves to do something to change that. But as you know, the rules of justice go slowly sometimes.
Judge Hertzfeld was very helpful to us in Benton. But before we could get that finished, Ms. Sweeney, Anita Sweeney, went into the hospital without our knowing it. We knew she was somewhere. We weren't sure where. And before we could find out where she was, this woman had also become executor of her will. and was just controlling her life. Ms. Sweeney passed away in the hospital before we found her. Risk management caught on in the hospital to what was going on
and became involved, and they started looking for us, but before they found us, Ms. Sweeney passed away. So we found out that my children's grandmother passed away by reading it in the paper. We were able to attend the funeral. We sat in the back. We weren't a part of the process. We wanted to be, but we were shut out from that as well because we hadn't changed things yet. We since have, but in a nutshell, a bill like this would have given us visitation rights to talk to Ms. Sweeney.
The hospital found out she did want to see her grandchildren, but we didn't force our way in the home or couldn't, of course, make her talk to us on the telephone. A bill like this would have enabled that we could have done that and avoided all these other things. I agree with some of the concerns that other committee members have addressed today, and I share some of those concerns. I urge the committee to find a way to resolve those things and give people in Arkansas the basic right of being able to visit family members when someone is keeping them from
doing that. Thank you. Thank you for your testimony. Were there any questions from members of the committee for this witness? Thank you. All right, Representative Beck, did you wish to say anything in closing? We'll hear your actual closing of your bill when you come back to present it with
the changes. Thank you, Madam Chair. And I do appreciate the input from the committee, and I certainly encourage you guys to give me that input so we can make this bill even better.
And I look forward to bringing it to you guys next week. Thank you
question for you. Actually, just a point of personal privilege. Yes. Oftentimes when people bring compelling stories and people say, we're sorry for your pain, that can oftentimes be just sound like a sugar coat. We do feel your pain. And I think we're all in agreement. We want to do something. We just want to make sure we don't go too far to the other end
to those who have that responsibility. And so this is not a pushing off to the side that oftentimes people get from government. This is people wanting to make sure we get it right so that we can fix this for future generations. Thank you. Thank you for
those remarks. Representative Beck, this committee will not be meeting Friday. Next Wednesday we have a special order of business already arranged that may take some time, but we will hope to get to your bill next Wednesday.
If not, it will be next Friday. Thank you very much, Madam Chair. Thank you. Do we have anyone here to present for Senate Bill 268 for Senator Hutchinson? House Bill 1636, Representative Ritchie. Okay, Representative Ritchie, I understand that you have an amendment that we need to
adopt first. Yes. Representative Ritchie, you are recognized to present
your amendment. Thank you, Madam Chair. The amendment simply is something brought to us by the Department of Health to help offset the cost of handling these records because these records, a lot of them are stored off-site. and so they have to pay money to get access to them, so we just have a fee there of $100 to get access to those records
and then also that they can adjust that fee as they need to in the future. Hopefully, as things get more on digital records, those costs would be able to
go down. Thank you. Are there any questions from committee members about the amendment? All right. Okay, Representative Gray has moved that we adopt the amendment.
All in favor say aye. Opposed? No. The amendment is adopted. All right, you are recognized, Representative Ritchie, to
present your bill. Thank you, Madam Chair. Committee, House Bill 1636 is a bill that was actually brought to me by Representative Ferguson. She did a lot of work on this, but she knew my ties with adoption. Both of my sons are adopted, and so it's a personal issue for me
whenever you're dealing with kids that are adopted. And so the bill, the nuts and bolts of the bill, basically, is that this gives children who are adopted, adoptees, the opportunity to request their original birth certificate when they turn 21, that they can get a copy of that. And that it also gives birth parents the opportunity to have their names redacted from that birth certificate
if they desire to remain private and not have that information, their names given out, but also provides an opportunity for them to provide a medical history that that adoptee will have access to so they can know their medical, their family's medical history, their biological family's medical history, which is often very important. and so that provides that it also provides ways that the the birth parents can say if they would
like to be contacted if they don't want to be contacted or how they would like to be contacted different I think there's three different provisions there of means of communication so it protects their privacy and also gives the adoptees an opportunity to to have access to their biological history, and Shane Carter is here with me, and if it is okay, I'd like for him to give testimony. He's one that kind of had the heart of this bill and brought it to Representative Ferguson.
Thank you. Mr. Carter, would you introduce yourself to the committee,
please? Yes, ma'am. Good morning. My name is Shane Carter. I'm a resident of Little Rock. Chairman Fide and members of the committee, good morning, and thank you for this opportunity. I'm an adoptee that is here to testify in support of House Bill 1636. I've been researching the need for open records for the past five years. And there were other adoptees planning to be at this meeting on Friday, but with it being moved to today, there's one other adoptee here that would like to speak with you coming
up in a few minutes. We have 15 states, including Missouri, Tennessee, and Alabama, that have passed legislation similar to what is before you this morning. Arkansas adoptees are unable to access their original birth certificates, which denies basic biological truths. Adoption files were originally sealed with the intent to protect the adoptive family from public scrutiny. Original birth certificates became sealed from adoptees, and in doing so, any and all
information regarding an adopted person's birth, heritage, and name were permanently cut off from them even as adults. This was the beginning of unfair treatment and the denial of our human rights to our own identity. Arkansas was involved in a national trend in sealing records prompted by changes in social theory that adoption should be a complete substitute for a family by birth. The intent of adoption policies were to erase any tie between the baby and the birth mother
or birth family, which research has shown, there has been a lot of research over the past 10 years that has shown this to be extremely unhealthy. The approach was designed to ensure the adopted family there would be no interference from the birth family and was considered at that time the best way to ensure a successful adoption. I was adopted by loving parents who support this legislation. I'm very thankful for that.
And I would tell my birth mother, thank you for giving me life. Committee members, you have an opportunity this morning to right along and give a voice to adoptees and birth parents that we have never had. I will not go into a lot of the mechanics as I know Representative Ritchie has handled that and you may have some questions so I'll stop there. Thank you for your time and I'll be glad to answer any questions that you may have of me.
Thank you. Are there any questions by committee members? Representative Birch and certainly
certainly I appreciate this and love the idea behind it and I do have a couple question, so how would this impact DHS in my heart a little bit with regard to children that have been adopted through the DHS process, the entirety of that is sealed parental rights have been terminated the identity of the birth parents are not normally in that file but has been moved to the county clerk and sealed in the county clerk's files, how would
this impact a child that was adopted through the DHS system with getting those records my second
son is adopted through DHS so we went through that process and it's my understanding of the bill is that when he turns 21 he would be able to access his original birth certificate and I don't know about you know a lot of that stuff was given to us as the parent of the
adoptive parents we got records of his biological mom and all the things that had happened previously in his life and so we got all that so I don't know if that's you know if DHS always does that or not but I would think that would go see Shane
yes ma'am if I may the way this is written and it's modeled after the other states it's actually the Department of health that's involved, and I know Mr. Breck is here this morning, so the original birth
certificate and the adoption decree would be distributed if all of the process is handled the way that it's supposed to be set up. With that being said, you're going to have basic information there, but I think Mr. Breck could address that better. Were
there other questions? I'm sorry, excuse me Madam Chair, Mr. Breck said that he could address that, it doesn't
involve DHS, but from the Department of Health he could address that question, if that would help.
All right, Mr. Breck, would you please come in and identify yourself for the committee members?
Thank you Madam Chair, Robert Breck, General Counsel with the Health Department. we wouldn't have the DHS file we would have the original birth certificate because we would have to amend that and we would also have the court order that ordered that amendment so we wouldn't have a complete DHS file
and I believe the way this is drafted this would only access vital records that are handled at the health department so it is true that any adoption whether it was a DHS adoption or otherwise the child or the adult once they turn 21 they could get that original birth
certificate Thank you for that testimony. Any other questions from committee members for any of these witnesses? Representative Birch, did you have another question?
Representative Gates. Thank you, Madam Chair. my wife and her twin sister and brother are all adopted and have problems, not because they later found their birth parents, but her mother was adopted. And so there is no genealogy. There is no medical records. There's nothing to be able to find out if different diseases or anything else. Is the purpose of this is not necessarily to reestablish contact to do,
But for you to be able to know what genetics they have for your children, for bloodlines and everything else, is that one of the main purposes
in this bill? Yes, and that's at the heart of the bill is access to that kind of history. And that's why we have the provisions in there for the birth parents to have their names redacted or to line out what kind of contact they would be open to, if any contact at all. So if they don't want any contact, then they can make that clear.
Follow-up? Yes, you're recognized for your follow-up. And I think that's part of the concerns because I don't think we want to do anything that would cause people to not want to give, to later on have to deal with that issue. But at that time, that's 21 years later. That's a long time in which people, so this basically allows an adoptee to medical records, to genealogy to part of who their genetic code is and everything else, that is the purpose of this bill.
Yes, sir. And the future generations. Thank you. Were
there other questions? Is there anyone in the audience who would like to speak for or against the bill? We
Speaker 117
58:22
to the committee good morning my name is Wesley Ashley thank you for your time I'm here today in support of House Bill 1636 I'm a son a husband a father and an attorney
I'm also an adoptee a fact that has affected all other roles I play in life at a very young age I knew I was adopted my parents felt it was extremely important to be honest with me about that fact and to be honest some might say it was rather obvious my parents are black Arkansans they have a darker skin tone and kinkier hair than I do or at least did when I had hair I am a black multiracial Arkansan whose features lend to be interpreted as native to many different regions of the world I've gotten Cuba Persia Ecuador and even China I only recently became comfortable
adopting the term multiracial as a part of my identity for years I simply identified as a black Arkansan due to my environment and lack of genetic and cultural history. This lack of a definitive history has prevented me from developing a strong sense of self as a child and subsequently also left me feeling uncomfortable with my identity as an adult. As a teenager, I began discussing my desire to know more about my origin story with my mother, my adoptive mother, who I might add also supports this bill and was intending to testify Friday at this hearing.
After a very honest, awkward, and loving conversation, my mother gave me the only document she had pertaining to my biological parents. I believe these were the DHS files we were discussing earlier. These documents contained a questionable narrative about my teenage biological mother, explaining she only became aware of her pregnancy a few days before going into labor. These documents also detailed her family's composition. One military father, one stay-at-home mom, a little sister, all Catholic and Caucasian. The only information pertaining to my biological father is extremely limited.
He wore glasses, he did not smoke or do drugs, and he was, quote, black Hispanic. To this day, I often get lost in the mirror wondering where my particular shade of brown eyes came from or whose ears also have that funny crimp in the corner. I generally question any other feature I deem odd. I am extremely uncomfortable around new people because I fear I will be asked the one question I dread the most. What are you? This uneasiness is not due to the poor form of the inquiry, but instead reflects my discomfort in my inability to answer my own questions, let alone those of the stranger on the street
who feel entitled to an answer. The fact that Arkansas's laws treat me differently from other citizens due to a decision in which I had no voice only frustrates my attempts to feel comfortable in my own skin. With each visit to a new physician, Arkansas's adoptees face medical history questions in which they must repeatedly answer, unknown, adopted. This exercise in repetition drives home the point that Arkansas's adoptees are the only class of people who are legally prevented from knowing our most basic biological truths,
our origins. Access to adoption records in the adoptee's original birth certificate have not always been limited. In fact, preventing an adult adoptee is relatively new in the history of American adoptions. States across our nation, our laboratories of democracy, have realized preventing access to these records have actually done more harm than help to the children whose best interests are to be served. I support House Bill 1636 because it would refocus Arkansas's adoption laws on the best interest of the adoptee, both as a child and adult.
It would fairly balance the interest of the adult adoptee, the biological parent, and the adoptive parent, also known as the adoption triad. It would provide a system in which medical, social, genetic, and genetic histories may be updated. It would end the treatment of adoptees as a lesser class of citizen in Arkansas. I implore you to vote yes on House Bill 1636. Thank you for your time. Thank you.
Were there any questions from committee members? All right. I don't see anyone else in the audience who wished to speak for or against this bill.
Representative Ritchie, would you like to
close for your bill? Yes, Madam Chair, just to close, you know, with my two sons, it's very obvious, of course, that one is adopted, and he's African American, and the rest of us are all white, and so he knows very clearly he's adopted, but an interesting story about my older son as well, and it's an open adoption, so he knows he's adopted as well, but we were told before he was born that his dad was Mexican.
And so if you've seen my oldest son, with blonde, blue eyes, it came very evident very quickly that his biological dad was not Mexican. And so later his biological mom contacted us when she figured out who the father was and let us know his biological history. And so that's very important for us, very important for our kids and I just want other adoptees to have that same
opportunity. What are the wishes of the committee? Can we have a motion do pass from Representative Gates? Oh, excuse me, thank you for that correction. We have a motion do pass as amended. Representative Gates, did you wish to explain your motion? All right. Any discussion of the motion? All in favor say aye. All opposed say no. Congratulations your bill has passed. Thank you Madam Chair. Thank you
committee. Representative Gassaway are you ready to present House Bill 1530? If you will have your witness introduce himself to the committee, you are recognized. Thank
you, Madam Chair and members of the committee. My name is Doug Wood.
I'm a long-time member of the Civil Air Patrol in Little Rock and a former member.
Representative Gassaway, you're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair. members. I'm here today to present House Bill 1530, which is an act to clarify the law concerning leave and absence for certain training programs of the National Guard or of the United States Armed Forces. Basically, what this bill does is it adds two words and auxiliary branches
of the Armed Forces. Basically, what the bill does is it will allow members of the Civil Air Patrol, which is an auxiliary branch of the United States Armed Forces, to have the same leave, who are also members of the state government, to have the same leave as other members of the Armed Forces to attend training programs. And that's generally what the bill does. Representative Doug House asked me to run this bill, and I have Mr. Wood here with me
today, and he can further explain it. That, with the permission of
the chair. All right. Thank you. You're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chairman. Most people think of Civil Air Patrol as a flying club for old men. But we actually serve much more functions than a lot of people realize. While our primary mission is air search and rescue, that is whenever an aircraft is missing somewhere in the state of Arkansas, we are tasked by the Air Force to go and look for it.
As well, we also look for ELT signals that come off. They'll just come off, start up, batteries get low, and it'll start an airplane on the ramp. We have to go and turn those off to make sure that it doesn't interfere with another aircraft that might be lost. But in addition to air search and rescue, we also do disaster relief. If you'll remember the tornado we had at Bologna, our aircraft was up in the air at 8 o'clock the next morning taking video and photographs of the destruction path from an aerial point of view.
We also have a homeland security missions. We also fly earthquake routes. If we had an earthquake route in northeast Arkansas, it's a good possibility that the roads would be severed. So we have to train our people to fly up the roadways to see if their roads have been severed or if the bridges have been collapsed so that when you get all the massive supplies, they can get to the area that's affected.
During Hurricane Katrina, we launched aircrafts down there to shuttle medicines and couriers back and forth among the operation. One of the things we also had done in the past was we'd fly night patrol over El Paso, Texas, on the Rio Grande River to be sure that there wasn't anybody coming across the river at a point. One of the interesting missions that we have is we train the artillery batteries, battalions
that protect the nation's capital, Washington, D.C. Their final exam is at Fort Bliss, Texas, and our aircraft serve as targets for these radar operators to recognize whether the aircraft is friendly or not and what the do with it and how to do the procedures. It's their final exam before they take a tour to Washington, D.C. to guard our nation's capital. So we do a lot of functions. The only thing we have is our members are all volunteers. We have about 350 senior members and about 220 cadets, age 12 to 18.
Our state employees, we only have 11 volunteers who are state employees. and I don't want to give the impression they take all 15 days but we do have to train occasionally and keep these people in to do these missions to perform you just can't go hop in an airplane and go do it you got to make sure you're familiar with the radios how to communicate one interesting mission that we have and and we have not done it yet we got to do training for it is the health department gave us three airborne repeaters for the a wind system in case
of any kind of disaster, that we will launch our bird and we will be a relay so that anybody in Fayetteville can talk to first responders in Texacana. We don't have that capability except through repeaters, but if we have an emergency, that's what we'll be able to do for them, and that's all I have. Thank you. Are
there any questions by the committee? Representative Birch? Thank you. Thank you,
Madam Chair. How many days are we talking about?
Is this the 15 days? It's up to 15 days a year. That's what National Guard, the Air Reserves, and the other Armed Forces, Reserve Forces get. However, we don't use 15 days. I mean, it's just we've got to be eligible for any kind of leave. And I apologize that you probably
said that before. Is this evidence by an order so that the person will be on orders, they will provide that to the state of Arkansas? The state of Arkansas would continue to add up the number of days until it reaches 15. and after that they would need to take their own personal leave.
Correct. Thank you. Any other questions? All right, thank you. Is there anyone in the audience who would like to speak for or against the bill? Seeing none, would you like to close for your bill, Representative Gasoling? I think this
is a good bill. supports our armed forces and appreciate a good
vote what are the wishes of the committee okay we have motion do pass from representative Birch would you like
to explain your motion any discussion of the motion all right it's pretty self-evident all right we have a motion of do pass all in favor say aye against no congratulations your bill has passed thank you madam chair thank you members members
representative Birch would you say that into the microphone please I just I hear that
you're the father of somebody pretty important to this
committee it's been before us a couple of times did was that appropriately determined Jeff would lieutenant
colonel in the Jag Corps back here and he's a a former member of this august body. I was afraid he was going to speak against my bill for a little while. Thank you, sir. Well, we
of personal privilege, my son was a cadet for several years and gained a lot from that experience, so we appreciate what you do. Thank you.
Is anyone else here to bring forward a bill before us today? Okay,
Okay, Representative Birch, you're recognized to present House Bill 1059.
Thank you, Madam Chair. And, members, thanks for your patience. This is one that you may have seen before. It's been amended twice, so it's much better now.
Has the amendment been approved, Madam Chair? It's all engrossed. Yes. Thank you very much. Madam Chair, I'm going to request that Lieutenant Colonel Wood do a little bit more of the explaining. Basically, this is a very technical term, but it allows law enforcement to be involved and it involves the ability to have parity with out-of-state orders from another military that have been issued against a military or on behalf of a military person.
And it's a protection bill so that whenever a family member needs to be separated or the military member needs to be separated from the family, the military has already gone into the specifics. The commander knows better than anyone else the circumstances, and they've issued this order in the military. This is so that the military order would also be able to be fully recognized by state law enforcement. Should the military member particularly be living off post or the family be living off post to make it so effective?
And if I might, let Colonel Wood further explain the bill. Yes, please
introduce yourself to our committee. Thank you, Madam Chair. Lieutenant Colonel Jeff Wood with the Arkansas Army National Guard. And I also have with me Captain Adam Rose. He's a member of the Arkansas National Guard. He's here in a civilian capacity today. He serves as a special victims counsel for NGB. In the military now, victims of sexual assault are giving their own attorney to advise them throughout the process. And so just to give a little background, the reason we're here today is, you know,
the Arkansas National Guard is kind of caught between the civilian authorities and the way they do things on active duty. On active duty, any commander at any level is able to issue a military order of protection by his signature and filling out a form. Basically, that's the equivalent of what we have in the civilian world of an order of protection and judge issues. They also have MPs. They have a system to put that military order of protection into the federal system so that civilian authorities know about it, their MPs know about it, so everyone has knowledge of the situation.
You don't have law enforcement rolling up on a situation that's not aware of what's going on. Unfortunately for the Arkansas National Guard, we're now getting into the point of having to prosecute sexual assault cases. Most of the cases we get, the civilian authorities have deferred because we defer all rape and sexual assault cases to the civilian authorities in Arkansas because we don't have the criminal investigation division. We don't have MPs. We don't have the infrastructure to do it. So we defer to the civilian authorities. But what we've
seen happen a lot is either if it's at another post on a federal post or the state authorities for whatever reason if the victim doesn't want to cooperate with the local authorities cases are deferred to us to investigate and to adjudicate. Under current policy the Arkansas National Guard is not allowed to investigate sexual assault cases so we have to have NGB come down from Washington to investigate these cases which National Guard Bureau which takes some time. She reminds me I've got to spell out acronyms because we're used to saying them all
the time. These investigations can take anywhere from six months to 12 months. What that's left us in a position is there's not a lot we can do to protect the victim. Our commanders can issue verbal no contact orders, hey, don't email, don't go to this side of the post, that kind of stuff, but we've had two really egregious cases where the accused, because we don't live on post, Our individuals, even if they're full-time, go home at night. This individual looked our commanders in the eye and said,
Roger that. I won't do anything. Then once he left post, he was intimidating her. He was harassing her through email and everything else. And there was nothing that our command could do because the civilian authorities had no idea that our commander had issued this order. And so we already have an ACIC number due to our court-martial system. So what we drafted this bill to do is to give the military a way to be able to communicate with the civilian authorities to say, hey, something's going on out here. If this person, you know, if you get a complaint, this person is driving by this person's house
or harassing them, they need the same protections that we offer people in the civilian world that are, you know, have accused someone of, you know, sexual assault. So that was kind of the nexus of the bill because, you know, we had to look this young girl in the eye who was 19 years old. You know, our typical cases are 40-year-old full-time member assaulting either a recruit or a younger E-4, E-5, you know, traditional soldier, which means they only come in on the weekends. And so there's a lot of areas there where, you know, we just don't have the typical control the active duty does.
And, you know, it killed me to look this young girl in the eye and say, you need to go to civilian authorities. I know I'm wearing a uniform, but I'm fearful for your life. I mean, we woke up the next morning and tried to call her immediately and make sure she was still okay. We were that concerned. And there was nothing we could do because, again, there was no connection. So we structured this bill a little bit differently than the active duty. What we did is we made it a criminal offense on the civilian side for you to violate a military order of protection. And so what that does is that means it doesn't matter what duty status our soldiers are in, whether they're
in day or full time, we can issue one of these. We also limited it. Unlike active duty, we didn't allow every one of our commanders to issue these. We pulled it up to what we call the special court martial convening authority level, which means it's going to be an 06, it's going to be one of my one stars or a military judge. So we've got a very limited role, a pool of people who can issue these. Probably in the last two years, I would probably say we probably would have issued two or three of these. So it's not going to be something we do all the time. It's going to be in those egregious cases
where the, you know, just telling the soldier don't do this doesn't work is what we're going to do. Just another, not to get too far off in the weeds, but another issue we've had is we've We kept soldiers who we would otherwise fired on active duty because we were concerned if we fired them, we would have no control over them and they would go out and hurt these victims. So we were literally paying, using taxpayers' dollars to have someone sit at a desk over some other area because they had been transferred out of their unit, basically just doing odd jobs and everything else. These are usually E-7s, E-8s, so they're making $60,000, $75,000 to do nothing for us to wait
for the investigation to get done and other things. This mechanism would give us a tool where we could terminate these individuals and still have some protections for the victims. So I kind of… Trying to make it from their employment. Employment. Yeah, from their employment. And just kind of walking through the bill here, that first part is what sets it up that it limits the authority who could issue these. The second part basically says we're going to use the same active duty policies and procedures to issue these so we have some consistencies there. The rest of the bill goes down and basically gives law enforcement the authority to give
of these the same process they would another protection order. Another thing that's unique here is if you have a civilian order of protection, if the person's picked up for violating that, they go back before the judge that issued this. We worked with the administrative office of courts to amend ours that basically says if someone's picked up and confined for this, we have 24 hours to come pick them up. If we don't pick them up with that time frame, shame on us, the civilian authority's going to turn that person loose. And also, too, the military is going to cover that confinement for those two days.
We're going to put the individual on orders, and then we're going to address the misconduct. I'm trying to look to see if there's anything else in here that needs to be covered. I think that's an overview of the bill, Madam Chair, and
me and Captain Rose will be happy to answer any individual questions. All
right. Thank you. We have a question from Representative Gates. Thank you, Madam Chair. this only affects members of the military who, when they signed up, are already waiving certain rights and privileges
that a normal citizen would have. Absolutely, Representative. Yeah,
we waive our freedom of speech rights. They ordered me to take an anthrax shot that I didn't want to take, and I didn't have a choice, and so there's many, many rights, and this would be another one of those. Any other questions
from committee members? all right thank you is there anyone in the audience who wishes to speak for this bill against this bill would you like to close for the bill just just
make a motion do pass all right we have a motion do pass all in favor say aye Opposed, no. Congratulations. The bill has passed. Thank you, Madam Chair and members of the committee. I see no further business before this committee. Has anyone come into the room to present a bill? And I overlooked you. All right. We will not be meeting Friday. Next Wednesday, we have a special order of business, so be prepared for a long day next Wednesday. With that, we are adjourned.
Agenda
REGULAR AGENDA Sponsor Subtitle Number
HB1297 Farrer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS MILITARY HERITAGE PROTECTION ACT.
HB1475 K. Hendren TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE APPOINTMENT OF GUARDIANS AND THE REPORTING REQUIREMENTS FOR GUARDIANS.
SB268 J. Hutchinson CONCERNING THE TERMINATION OF A GUARDIANSHIP.
HB1445 Lowery TO CREATE THE PARENT-CHILD RELATIONSHIP PROTECTION ACT; AND TO PROVIDE FACTORS AND PROCEDURES FOR DETERMINING WHETHER OR NOT A CHANGE OF A CHILD'S PRINCIPAL PLACE OF RESIDENCE IS IN THE BEST INTEREST OF THE CHILD.
HB1530 Gazaway TO CLARIFY THE LAW CONCERNING LEAVE OF ABSENCE FOR CERTAIN TRAINING PROGRAMS OF THE NATIONAL GUARD OR OF THE UNITED STATES ARMED FORCES.
HR1025 S. Meeks RECOGNIZING THE CHICKAMAUGA CHEROKEE PEOPLE'S UNIQUE HERITAGE AND IMPORTANT CONTRIBUTIONS TO THE STATE OF ARKANSAS.
HB1636 Richey TO PROVIDE BIRTH PARENTS WITH THE OPTION TO REDACT THEIR NAMES FROM CERTAIN ADOPTION RECORDS DISCLOSED TO ADOPTEES AND THEIR RELATIVES; AND TO PROVIDE ADOPTEES AND THEIR RELATIVES WITH ACCESS TO CERTAIN ADOPTION RECORDS.
SB132 J. Hutchinson CREATING THE COMMISSION FOR PARENT COUNSEL; CONCERNING DEPENDENCY- NEGLECT REPRESENTATION FOR THE PARENT OF A MINOR CHILD; AND CONCERNING REPRESENTATION IN THE JUVENILE DIVISION OF CIRCUIT COURT.
SCMR1 K. Ingram IN RESPECTFUL MEMORY OF CORRECTIONAL CORPORAL BARBARA ESTER.
HB1678 Beck CONCERNING VISITATION WITH AN INCAPACITATED PERSON OR A WARD; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING DECISIONS MADE BY APPOINTED GUARDIANS ON BEHALF OF WARDS.
HB1059 House TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF VIOLATION OF AN ORDER OF PROTECTION; AND TO CRIMINALIZE THE VIOLATION OF A MILITARY ORDER OF PROTECTION.
HB1034 C. Fite TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING HEARING INSTRUMENT DISPENSERS.
HR1034 C. Fite TO RECOGNIZE THE MONTH OF MARCH AS NATIONAL COLORECTAL CANCER AWARENESS MONTH.
DEFERRED Subtitle Sponsor Number
HR1013 Sorvillo HONORING THE 308TH TITAN II STRATEGIC MISSILE WING AND THE RESPONSE TO THE 1980 MISSILE EXPLOSION AT DAMASCUS, ARKANSAS.
HB1381 Gazaway TO AMEND THE GROUNDS FOR DENYING PERMANENCY PLANS THAT PLACE JUVENILES IN THE CUSTODY OF A PARENT, GUARDIAN, OR CUSTODIAN..
HB1568 Rushing TO GRANT VISITATION RIGHTS TO GRANDPARENTS WHEN A PARENT OF A CHILD IS DECEASED, MISSING, OR IN A PERMANENT VEGETATIVE STATE.
HB1654 RushingCONCERNING THE RIGHTS OF GRANDPARENTS INVOLVED WITH FOSTER CARE AND ADOPTION CASES.
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Charlene Fite
Unverified
Speaker 7
Representative Carlton Wing Chair
Unverified
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Representative Rick Beck
Unverified
Representative LeAnne Burch
Unverified
Carrie Kasem
Unverified
Representative Jimmy Gazaway
Unverified
Speaker 57
Ian Daniels
Unverified
Speaker 76
Speaker 82
Speaker 85
Representative Mickey Gates
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Shane Carter
Unverified
Speaker 108
Robert Breck
Unverified
Speaker 115
Speaker 117
Doug Wood
Unverified
Speaker 78