Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

State Agencies

March 1, 2017 ·Committee Room 151 ·31:59
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (4)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB273 · 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB273 PERMITTING ACT 309 INMATES IN THE CUSTODY OF THE DEPARTMENT…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB373 · 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB373 TO EXEMPT ATTORNEY-CLIENT COMMUNICATIONS AND ATTORNEY WORK…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1728 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1728 TO REPEAL THE COMMUNITY SERVICES ADVISORY COUNCIL.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1736 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. House Bill 1736, this goes back a couple of years as far as the history whe…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
We're going to start off with Senate Bill 273, Representative Brown, if you want to take the end of the table. Before we get going, let me tell you what I know that we're taking up. We're taking up this Senate Bill 273. If Representative Davis gets back soon enough, we'll take up Senate Bill 373. If not, I may help him with running that. and I'm not sure. Are there any other bills that we know of? You have one? Okay. 1736? Okay. So 1736, and then Jack, you've got one. Yeah. 1728. Okay. All right, so that's what we'll be handling unless somebody else shows up. Representative Brown, you are recognized to run Senate Bill 273.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair, committee. What we have here is an issue. Many of you know the 309 program if you're from a small community. You see the guys, they're 309s, I guess you could say, from the county jail. The sheriff receives those inmates to work in good faith around the county. You've seen them at the county courthouse. You've seen them at the county fairs. You've seen them working to keep up the grounds at the volunteer fire departments. But the problem is they've been used in this capacity all these years, and somebody, I think it was, I think it was Batesville filed a, wanted a attorney general's opinion on it as to whether or not those 309s could be used for a nonprofit. And they came back, and based on the ruling, it changed everything, and the Department of Corrections had no choice but to say they had to stop using them in that capacity. So what we have here is language to codify that they can be used, and the Department of Corrections is on board. They were going to be here, and they got tied up down at the prison system in Pine Bluff and couldn't come back this afternoon. But that's pretty much all I have on that. If there's any questions, I'll do my best to field those. Representative Hamer, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. With the implementation of this law then, does that satisfy what the Attorney General stated? And first of all, is that going to take care of that then? Yes, it will take
▶ Play
care of that. Department of Corrections says that they're good with it, and it'll go back to the way it's always been. Follow up, Mr. Chair. You're recognized.
▶ Play
What type of nonprofits are going to be able to be used? the 309 is going to be able to be used for, because nonprofit can apply to churches, it can apply to, you know, a lot
▶ Play
of different entities. So could you clarify that, please? Based on my understanding, and of course, I was handed this bill and got a quick gloss over, but the Department of Corrections used the example today that if the VFW wanted to use them to help in the putting out of some ceremony that required the placing of a lot of flags, that they would be able to do so. And I know traditionally in Pope County, I've seen the 309s working in like at Fall Fest for Russellville, for the city. They've been at different veterans organizations, events there. They were sponsored by a lot of times by a church. So I think as long as it qualifies as a nonprofit based on the language here in this proposed legislation, that that would be justified. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Okay. Any other questions from the committee? All right. Seeing none,
▶ Play
Representative Brown, you're recognized to close for your bill. I just recommend do pass. Okay. We have a motion on table, do pass. Any discussion on that motion? Representative Hendren, you're recognized for discussion.
▶ Play
Since I know less than I usually know in here, since I just came in
▶ Play
the door, what bill is it? Okay. This is Senate Bill 273. That's one dealing with three. I could just go ahead and vote like I do most of the time and make people think I'm 273. Yeah, 273. It deals with trustees, 309 inmates. Well, the bill doesn't do nothing, right? Well, it probably does. It just gives them more flexibility from what I understand. Any other discussion on the motion? Okay. We have a motion do pass on the table. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed, say nay. All right. Congratulations. Representative Brown, you passed your bill. Okay. Let's see. Next on the list, Representative Leidyman, are you prepared to run HB 1728? Yes, I am. Okay.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. House Bill 1728 is not really a clean-up bill, it's a clean-out bill, if you want to look at it that way. If you look at that bill, it eliminates everything in the bill except the title. So this is one of those regulations that we're taking out that's not needed anymore. What the bill is, is it repeals the Community Services Advisory Council. This council has not met in a long time, they really haven't done anything. It's under DHS, so DHS approached me to run this bill to take this council out of regulation. So I'd take any questions. Okay. I see no questions from the
▶ Play
committee. You're recognized to close for your bill. Just recommend do pass. Okay. We have a motion to pass. Any discussion on the motion?
▶ Play
Okay. Representative Hammer, you're recognized. I should have asked you, and I apologize, maybe somebody from the Department to clarify, are there any funds attached to this commission sitting in an account somewhere, or
▶ Play
do we know? Let me see. Is there someone from DHS here that might answer that? David?
▶ Play
I've got some notes here, but I'm not sure if it pertains to this
▶ Play
bill, so let me take a look real quick. I don't know whether we can find this, but to my knowledge, the discussions I've
▶ Play
had, there are no funds associated with it, but that may not be the case. That's my understanding as well. Basically, this particular entity was set up some years ago. As far as we can tell, we can't find any minutes from the last time they met. We've looked back on a lot of research trying to figure out when they last met, and as far as we can tell, the present governor nor the previous governor ever made any appointments to it. We can't figure out when they meet or where they meet or anything like that. We've talked to some of the other people that are mentioned in it. They don't know anything about it as well. So I think we can't find any information on it, and I don't think there's any budgetary, any money sitting around for it either.
▶ Play
All right. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Okay. Any other discussion on the motion? Okay. We have a motion on the table. Do pass. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed, say nay. All right. Congratulations. Representative Ladyman, you passed your bill. Thank you, committee. Representative Hammer, are you prepared to run 1736? You're recognized to run 1736, Representative Hammer.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. House Bill 1736, this goes back a couple of years as far as the history when Senator Hickey and I ran the procurement bill last time. One of the things that we've seen with it now being two years, or a little less actually, but with it being in application and use, we were approached by some of the entities, one of them being one of the schools in higher ed, and there was no minimum threshold that was placed into the procurement bill as far as the responsibility to report. And just to give you a quick scenario how that would play out as it is right now, and This is pretty extreme, but just gives you an idea. If stapler, you know, some smaller items came up according to the way the law is written, if you took it to the letter of the law, they would have to report that, and that created a lot of undue burden on legislative audit and also on the entities themselves. So what Senator Hickey and I are proposing is that we would set a threshold of $1,000, which we feel would be, you know, a good starting point. We can kind of measure this as it goes along. What it will do is minimize us showing up in leg audit meetings and having a finding for a box of staplers not being able to be found, and it just makes it a little more efficient for leg audit and for the entities. And with that, I'll be glad to take any questions. Any questions from the committee? All right.
▶ Play
Seeing none, you're recognized or closed for your bill. Representative Hammer? Thank you. I'm closed, and I'd make a motion to do
▶ Play
Speaker 21 9:53
pass. All right. We have a motion to do pass. Any discussion on the motion? Representative Hendren, you are recognized.
▶ Play
Well, I just would like the sponsor to assure me that this is not loosening anything up. I just found out at Kiwanis last Friday morning and up in Benton County, somebody stole over a million dollars, and we hadn't found it with an audit and so forth. And so I'm sure you're going to assure me that's not a step to help that get done any better.
▶ Play
What this is going to do is allow them more time to try to find that million dollars instead of going after some of the things. And a dollar is as valuable as a million dollars. I understand that principle and everything. But because it was, in my opinion, not realistic good use of resources of legislative audit, that's why we set the threshold. That's also the reason we set the threshold so low was just to make sure there's a buffer so we could identify it sooner than later. Okay. Any other questions or any comments
▶ Play
on the motion? All right. Well, we have a motion on the table. We'll do pass by Representative Hammer. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? All right, congratulations, Representative Hammer. You have passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. Representative Davis, are you prepared to run Senate Bill 373? I can't do
▶ Play
Speaker 50 11:16
it. Okay. It didn't sound real confident. Yes. All right, it looks
▶ Play
like we have an amendment. You are recognized to present Amendment No. 1 to Senate Bill 373.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Members of the committee, this amendment adds the word privileged to the bill so that we are speaking about privileged communications in terms of protecting that
▶ Play
communication from FOI. Okay. Representative Davis has presented his amendment. What's the privilege or the pleasure of the committee? All right. We have a motion to adopt the amendment. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Okay. You have adopted your amendment. You are recognized to run your bill.
▶ Play
Representative Davis. All right, committee. It's the same bill we heard this morning. Just literally changed, added the word privilege, so we're talking about a record that constitutes an attorney-client privileged communication and exempting that from FOI. I believe the gentleman to my right can speak to the meaning behind including that word privileged.
▶ Play
You're recognized. Introduce yourself, if you would, for
▶ Play
the record. I'm Brad Phelps, general counsel for Arkansas State University. I believe this morning during the committee discussion there was a bit of concern about the phrase attorney-client communication. I believe someone indicated they were concerned that that could literally touch every communication sent to or from a lawyer, and we wanted to address that concern by inserting the word privilege to make sure that we're limited, we're not making it too broad, which was the concern earlier. That was not our intent, but I believe this language does address that concern and should narrow it significantly. Okay, thank you. And Representative
▶ Play
Hendren, you're recognized for a question. Not that I unnecessarily distrust
▶ Play
lawyers, because I've got a family full of them, but I would like to, and maybe you're going to do it here in just a minute, I've been told by some folks already that this solves a problem on the FOI. And I'll feel good about it when somebody that's not a lawyer that's in the press that comes down at the end of the table and says that, in their opinion, this solves it. Is there
▶ Play
going to be somebody to do that? Do you know, Mr. Chairman? I don't have anybody signed up to speak for or against this bill, so at this point I don't know if anybody has any intention
▶ Play
to speak to it. Well, do the opponents know what we're doing? The ones that were here this morning, do they
▶ Play
know that we're amending it, about ready to pass it? Well, yes, sir. In fact, we discussed it before we adjourned to go to lunch. So they knew that we were coming back upon adjournment.
▶ Play
I just have a problem with that because I would like to, if a person speaks out against the bill and then we amended here. I would like to know that they're satisfied with it, but if they're not here, they're not here. Well, we have some people who
▶ Play
are here. I don't know what their intent is as far as speaking for or against this piece of legislation. But you're welcome to come to the end of the table if that will help Representative Hendren. Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, I'm Tom Larimer.
▶ Play
I'm the executive director of the Arkansas Press Association. I think we're pretty clear in our concerns about the bill this morning. This is the first I've seen of the amendment. I don't know if it fixes it or solves our concerns or not. You're adding one word, privileged communication, and what I would
▶ Play
say, I guess, is in order to avoid the discussion at the other end of the table and try to clarify, for Representative Hendren, what we've done is the concerns that were mentioned in particular by the attorneys who were here earlier was that we were going further than just what would normally be attorney-client privileged information, and somebody who is sending an email could just copy an attorney on an email and therefore it be described as attorney communication. Well, that wasn't the intent of the legislation. The intent of the legislation was trying to make it fair, whether you're in the private sector or a public government attorney, and be able to protect what typically is considered to be privileged information. And so inserting the word privilege would narrow it down to the same attorney-client privilege that I possess with the clients when I'm representing them. And so that's the idea. It still is an exemption from FOI, so if somebody is fundamentally opposed to any exemption for FOI, then I could see that. However, this is a more narrow exemption that just applies to what would be attorney-client privilege if we were dealing with the private sector. Does that answer your question, Representative?
▶ Play
You're recognized for it. It helped me a little bit. I guess if I'm having a board meeting, a school board's having a school board meeting, and I've got my lawyer there, and we're talking to them, and then we do some stuff, does that make it attorney-client? I'm paying my lawyer $250 an hour, and I
▶ Play
hope it does. Yeah, that doesn't, because specifically what would happen was, I mean, that is, you're not even allowed to have a closed meeting with your attorneys, from what I understand with school board meetings. It's kind of a different, there's a different statute that would deal with this, and this wouldn't address that at all. So where it would is if you had a, probably a better example is if you had a superintendent meeting with the attorney for the school district and they were communicating, and really what we're talking about is written communication because you can't FOI something that's not written. So if they were writing back and forth about a potentially pending case or trying to avoid going to court over something, that could be considered attorney-client communication. And if he, you know, if the attorney sent an email to the superintendent and said, hey, let's go play golf tomorrow, that's not attorney-client privilege, and that would be subject to FOI. Does that make sense, Representative Hendrick? Well, I guess that's how you see it, and
▶ Play
I guess if you're right about all that stuff, I guess that's right, but I'm not sure you are. Well, I've
▶ Play
been wrong about as often as right. Any other questions from the committee? Okay, seeing no other questions from the committee, anybody at the end of the table, I know that we don't have anybody to sign up to speak for or against, I'm pretty casual.
▶ Play
Speaker 70 18:03
Representative Greenberg, you're recognized. Or Mr. Greenberg. Well,
▶ Play
I'm a free man. I'm not a representative anymore. But would it be out of order for me to speak briefly against this,
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman? No. I mean, the answer maybe is yes, it's out of order, I don't know. But at this point, we've kind of lost all orders, so you are
▶ Play
recognized to speak against this piece of legislation. So here is the problem. It's going to be possible under this exemption to create a fairly large zone of what you might call protected discussion among government employees. And I think it's easy to exaggerate the scope of these things. It's easy to minimize the scope of these things. But I'm just trying to kind of lay it out there in a neutral way. It's going to be, in my view, a little bit too easy for government employees to create this zone of privacy when they're essentially making government plans between themselves and to shield that under attorney-client privilege. And so I really fear that this is going to be the exception that swallows the rule. I appreciate that there are many states that have some form of protected attorney-client privilege under the FOIA. There are also many states that do not. The problem is if we put this into Arkansas's code, Arkansas is going to go from one of the best FOIA laws to one of the worst FOIA laws. Arkansas's FOIA law works very well compared to many other states, and one of the reasons is we don't have this broad attorney-client exemption. And so I really do feel that this is, as put, very broad and provides for a very large shield with respect to the citizen inquiring into government
▶ Play
conduct. Okay. Representative Hammer, are you recognized for
▶ Play
a question? Thank you, Mr. Greenberg. You're speaking as a private attorney who is on that side of the line, but earlier, I think you were in the room when you heard the concerns about how, in an example, I think a UAMS or ASU, they were disadvantaged in that the private attorneys could have direct access to what I would, you know, term as inside information because of the way the law is set up now. So what would you propose as a resolution in order to bring a standard of fairness to where that's not possible? Well, in
▶ Play
my opinion, FOIA has worked pretty well in Arkansas for the last 50 years without a broad attorney-client exemption. I think it's possible for me to, you know, think about, you know, given a little time, it might be possible for me to think about some very narrow exemption, but it's going to be hard for me to do it in the next five minutes. So I just can't answer this question right now, but I think it's going to be considerably smaller than what's proposed here today. Any
▶ Play
other questions from the committee? Anybody else to speak for or against this bill? Okay. Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker 74 21:02
Chair, Mark Hagemeyer with UAMS. One of the reasons that we took the break and inserted the word privilege is there is Supreme Court case law on this particular issue. There is a test that attorneys are having to utilize all the time in order to make a determination whether something falls in or out of FOIA. It's been my experience, my experience alone, that, well, privilege and FOIA. I mean, we are always having to make a determination whether a particular document that is requested falls inside or out of an exemption to the FOIA law. This is another one of those exemptions. There is a test, and I think the privilege, the utilization of that word, gives lawyers a much better idea of what they should be looking to in order to make that determination. I think previously there was a lot more wiggle room. I believe always the FOIA law allows for the requester to go to court in order to have a judicial determination if the lawyer who has responded on behalf of the governmental agency has provided the correct documents or not. I personally, after 25 years of government public service, I think this strikes a pretty fair balance and puts government lawyers on an even footing with lawyers in the community. All right. Any
▶ Play
questions from the committee? I appreciate
▶ Play
– oh, Representative Gonzalez, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Could we just send this to the judiciary and let the
▶ Play
lawyers argue about it? I may be for that at some point. Representative
▶ Play
Hammer, you're recognized for a question. You know, you brought up an interesting point that since we took this break, so of everybody sitting at the end of the table knowing that we're going to take the break and come back with this, who was in the discussion, who was in the circle of
▶ Play
discussion bringing back this proposed amendment? Representative Hammer, I was given notice of the proposed amendment, but the amendment was proposed by Mr. Phelps and Mr. Hagemeyer. Is that
▶ Play
fair? I think, Representative Hammer, I think for the most part the discussion was in the last time, and then they took what we discussed and then went over there. So the primary concern that I expressed to them even after the committee and even in the committee, the primary concern that was expressed was the idea of communications. I mean, we talked about CCing somebody, carbon copying somebody on a communication, and then exempting that out because it said attorney communications. And so what they did is they said, no, what we really meant is anything that would fall specifically into attorney-client privileged information. And so that's where the amendment came from, is adding just the word to make sure it's attorney-client privileged communication. Is that fair? That's a fair assessment. And that's where the amendment came from. Pretty straightforward. All right, any other questions from the committee? Okay, seeing none, I appreciate the testimony of all the individuals. You're recognized, Representative Davis, to close.
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman, I think Mr. Hoggard would like
▶ Play
to say. Mr. Hogger, you're recognized. Well, first of all, I'm going to express my appreciation to the committee. You're here at four in the afternoon listening to lawyers talk about what lawyers can and can't do. So you have great forbearance, and I appreciate that. So let me see if I can put this starkly. I think Mr. Greenberg did a very good job of that as well. You're going from a situation where absolutely everything an attorney had in their representation of a government entity was subject to FOIA. That's the law right now. to what this amendment will do and this bill will do, as I understand it, to where nothing that a lawyer has that is considered to be privileged will be applicable to FOIA. And from my point of view, I oppose that because of two very simple points. As Mr. Greenberg said, it is too broad an exception. There's got to be some room in the middle as opposed from all to nothing because that's what we're going from. Well, from nothing to all would be probably more appropriate. And I think there's some middle ground, and I wish we had some time to work on that. The second problem I've got with this is, as you pointed out, Chairman, there's no single definition of privilege anywhere. Mr. Hagermeyer is referring to a Supreme Court case, which is, as you all know, quite subject to change. We've got three separate sets of rule, all of which have some definition of privilege within them. And so I would like to see there be some definition of the word privilege, not just the insertion of the word privilege, because we'll spend a lot more time arguing about what it means and what we can and can't do. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank
▶ Play
you. Okay, Representative Davis, you're recognized to close for your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Members, I think we could probably debate this for a long time, but I think there is a problem there. We need to address it one way or another. I'd be happy to work with any of the gentlemen at the end of this table if they've got additional concerns that we could address through separate legislation, we could do that. And with that, I appreciate a good vote. And I move
▶ Play
to do pass as amended. We have a motion to do pass. Any discussion on that motion? I just want to say that, you know, from my standpoint, it does seem reasonable that, and before I got into government, I would have assumed that attorney-client privilege and within an agency would also be protected. It does seem like it would be really hard if I were an attorney representing UAMS to be put in a position where my notes, the attorney-client work that we've done would be FOIA'd right before trial or right before depositions or whatever. There are exemptions already, and for the AG's office, this seems kind of reasonable. I think that about everybody has presented things that are reasonable objections. The question is, how far is this going to go? Is it going to go too far? And at this point, I don't know the answer to that. But if there are safeguards, I think, like Representative Davis said, you could probably do it through other legislation. But any other discussion from the committee? Okay. Representative Hammer, are you recognized?
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And part of the complication of this one, and I'm speaking to myself, being a layman, I've got lawyers on both sides of this issue that I trust and respect. And so just trying to get to that common ground where I can move on with a clear conscience as far as I vote. And maybe the Chair could give me clarification on this. If we do this, and what happens if an attorney, and I'm just going to say UAMS because they've been speaking in the table, what if one of those attorneys representing UAMS purposely hides something under the protection of what this bill is going to allow them to do and then later it's determined that that was misused? What is the appropriate action that can be held against an attorney like that? Would it be a bar association or would it be something civil that could be done or what's the appropriate form of punishment in the event the entity that the lawyer is representing or the lawyer themself do something inappropriate as a result of this bill we're about to pass?
▶ Play
I think the answer is all the above. So the bar association, there could be ethics violations just like anyone else. But what I'd say, I mean, we've been around long enough to know that when you have somebody from an agency that's not acting right as the legislators, we have the ability to kind of address that. So if it's something that brought to our attention that some agency is over utilizing their FOIA exemption in this case, then usually you call in the agency head or one of the attorneys for the agency. You sit down and you talk to them. You let them know that you've got concerns about that, and usually they're fairly responsive
▶ Play
and it's addressed. May I? Yeah, yeah. You're recognized. You're recognized. That sounds good, but what's the teeth in it that cost that individual something? Are they able to be charged with a misdemeanor of felony? It's just left up to the Bar Association to sanction them. What is the real fear that's going to be in the heart of an attorney that may use this as a cloak of coverage in order to do something
▶ Play
inappropriate with it? There may be somebody who can answer more specifically. There are sanctions that It could come from the ethics violation,
▶ Play
Representative Davis. Mr. Chairman, if it pleases the committee, I know normally a discussion on the motion is limited to the committee, but we have
▶ Play
some lawyers down here and I'd be happy to answer that. Okay. People
▶ Play
who actually have to deal with FOIA probably know the answer to that. Representative Hammer, in response to your question, a violation of the FOI is a misdemeanor. Your actions would also subject your agency to civil liability and that they would be paying attorney's fees for the thing that you did wrong, which you'd also be subjected to, I believe, personnel action by your employer. And also, using your facts, if you were to intentionally withhold a document in response to a lawful request, I believe that would put your license in jeopardy as well. But the immediate impact as a violation of FOIA is still a criminal offense, and that does not change with this bill. covers the entire scenario. Mr. Greenberg.
▶ Play
But I would add to that that no such penalty is ever likely to happen because the initial review process is such that the lawyer himself or herself is going to make the decision as to whether to disclose that document. So any kind of violation of the kind that you're talking about, Representative Hammer, is unlikely to happen because you'll never have another party see that a mistake or an intentional error has been made. And this is the reason why these broad exemptions to FOIA are so dangerous, because there is no umpire, there is no second party that looks at these things to determine whether wrongdoing has ever occurred. I
▶ Play
would say that, you know, that is part of the, one of the reasons that you have some concern. However, if you're going to violate FOIA, you violate FOIA, it's kind of hard to prove anyway. So if you're out there destroying documents, hopefully we're hiring very few of those people to represent our state. Any other comments on the motion? All right, we have a motion on the table. Do pass as amended. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed, say nay. No. The ayes have it. Congratulations, Representative Davis. You pass your bill. Thank you, committee. Okay, is there anybody else has any bills that they want to run today? I do have one bill that has been asked to be placed on special order for next Wednesday at Senate Bill 341. Without objection, we'll place that on special order for next Wednesday will be first up. All right. Seeing no objections, so ordered. Any other business for the committee? Okay. Seeing none, we are adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

SB273 PERMITTING ACT 309 INMATES IN THE CUSTODY OF THE DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION WHO ARE HOUSED IN A COUNTY JAIL TO WORK FOR LOCAL NONPROFIT ORGANIZATIONS; CONCERNING ACT 309 INMATES; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

0:12 - 5:26 15 segments 5 speakers

HB1728 TO REPEAL THE COMMUNITY SERVICES ADVISORY COUNCIL.

5:26 - 8:11 9 segments 4 speakers

HB1736 TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE REPORT OF A LOSS OF PUBLIC FUNDS.

8:11 - 11:21 11 segments 5 speakers

SB373 TO EXEMPT ATTORNEY-CLIENT COMMUNICATIONS AND ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT FROM THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967.

11:21 - 31:57 78 segments 11 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Bob Ballinger Chair Unverified
44 segments
Representative Karilyn Brown Unverified
5 segments
Representative Kim Hammer Unverified
17 segments
Representative Kim Hendren Unverified
8 segments
Representative Jack Ladyman Unverified
4 segments
David Sterling Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 21
1 segment
Speaker 50
1 segment
Representative Andy Davis Unverified
5 segments
Brad Phelps Unverified
5 segments
Representative Lane Jean Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 70
1 segment
Dan Greenberg Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 74
3 segments
Chair Unverified
2 segments
Glenn Hoggard Unverified
5 segments