State Agencies and Governmental Affairs
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (70)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
SB341
· 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB341 L. Eads TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING APPOINTMENTS TO BOARDS,…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2053
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB2053 Hammer TO TRANSFER THE ARKANSAS FAIR HOUSING COMMISSION TO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1792
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1792 J. Williams TO AMEND THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DELIVERY AND…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1004
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1004 Blake TO CREATE THE DEMOCRACY ACT; TO REQUIRE AUTOMATIC VOT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1005
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1005 Tucker TO REQUIRE REPORTING AND DISCLOSURE OF ELECTIONEERIN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1008
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1008 Tucker TO INCREASE THE PENALTY FOR TAKING CAMPAIGN FUNDS AS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1009
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1009 Leding TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING APPROVED POLITICAL ACTIO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1011
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1011 Sabin TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING POLITICAL ACTION COMMI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1012
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1012 Sabin TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING POLITICAL ACTION COMMI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1046
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1046 Tucker TO PERMIT PAID MATERNITY LEAVE FOR STATE EMPLOYEES.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1065
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1065 Watson PERMITTING THE ARKANSAS COMMISSION ON LAW ENFORCEMEN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1151
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1151 Davis TO REQUIRE THAT REGISTERED VOTERS BE NOTIFIED BY MAIL…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1179
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1179 Ballinger TO PROMOTE AND IMPROVE EFFICIENCY AND QUALITY IN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1207
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1207 Dalby TO AMEND REQUIREMENTS FOR CAMPAIGN SIGNS AND MATERIAL…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1270
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1270 Johnson TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ELECTIONS AND BALLOTS.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1289
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1289 Ballinger TO PROMOTE AND IMPROVE EFFICIENCY AND QUALITY IN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1386
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1386 Lemons TO REQUIRE THE FILING OF FINAL AGENCY RULES WITH THE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1440
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1440 M. Gray TO AMEND PROVISIONS IN THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1447
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1447 M. Gray TO TRANSFER THE STATE BOARD OF ELECTION COMMISSIONE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1570
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1570 Brown TO PROVIDE STATUTORY GUIDANCE CONCERNING INTERSTATE C…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1622
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1622 Johnson TO CREATE A PROCEDURE FOR ADDRESSING BURDENSOME REQ…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1623
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1623 Johnson TO AMEND THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967; TO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1675
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1675 Sturch TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1696
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1696 D. Meeks TO TRANSFER THE STATE CHILD ABUSE AND NEGLECT PREV…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1707
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1707 M. Gray TO AMEND THE DATES OF THE GENERAL PRIMARY ELECTION…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1725
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1725 D. Douglas TO TRANSFER VARIOUS STATE AGENCIES TO THE AGRICU…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1739
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1739 C. Douglas TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING PRIMARY ELECTIONS, R…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1741
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1741 Vaught TO ESTABLISH A BLUE ALERT NOTIFICATION SYSTEM; AND C…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1765
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1765 Holcomb TO IMPROVE ELECTION ADMINISTRATION TRANSPARENCY; AN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1766
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1766 D. Douglas TO CREATE "THE NONPARTISAN BLANKET PRIMARY ACT";…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1807
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1807 Collins TO ENSURE THE FUTURE FUNDING OF THE STATE HEALTH DE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1819
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1819 K. Hendren CONCERNING BALLOT TITLES AND POPULAR NAMES OF CO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1823
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1823 Collins TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS PAPERWORK EFFICIENCY AND TRA…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1832
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1832 House TO ALLOW THE EMPLOYMENT OF SPECIAL COUNSEL BY A STATE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1866
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1866 Lundstrum TO EXEMPT CERTAIN INFORMATION PERTAINING TO A LAW…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1892
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1892 C. Douglas TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING UNOPPOSED CANDIDATES…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1893
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1893 M. Gray TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS PROCUREMENT LAW; AND TO AMEND…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1931
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1931 Gillam CONCERNING THE APPROVAL OF BALLOT TITLES AND POPULAR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1932
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1932 Gillam CONCERNING THE REVIEW OF RULES PROMULGATED BY THE ST…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1944
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1944 C. Douglas TO ESTABLISH A GRANT ADVISORY BOARD; AND TO AMEN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1975
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1975 Dotson TO ADOPT THE COMPACT FOR A BALANCED BUDGET; AND TO A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1988
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1988 Lundstrum CONCERNING COUNTY JAIL REIMBURSEMENT FOR HOUSING…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1995
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1995 Della Rosa TO AMEND THE OFFICIAL HOLIDAYS; TO REFINE THE TE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2033
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2033 Shepherd TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND ADMINISTR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2035
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2035 D. Douglas TO AMEND THE DATES FOR PROCESSING ABSENTEE BALLO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2055
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2055 Hammer CONCERNING REMEDIES AVAILABLE TO PERSONS TERMINATED…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2065
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2065 Hammer TO REQUIRE STATE AGENCIES AND CERTAIN STATE-SUPPORTE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2074
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2074 Leding TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING INITIATIVES AND REFER…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2095
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2095 G. Hodges TO ESTABLISH VOTE CENTERS ON THE CAMPUSES OF STAT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2096
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2096 G. Hodges TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF PROCUREMENT LAW TO REFLECT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2162
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2162 Gonzales TO PROMOTE VOTER TURNOUT; TO AMEND THE LAW TO LIMI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2165
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2165 Tosh TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE STATE ATHLETIC COMMISS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2183
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2183 Lowery TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS WHISTLE-BLOWER A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2196
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2196 Henderson TO AMEND LANGUAGE CONCERNING THE SPORT OF PROFESS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2200
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2200 M. Hodges TO MODIFY THE DEFINITION OF "SMALL PROCUREMENTS";…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2242
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2242 Davis TO AMEND THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967 CONCE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2259
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2259 Walker TO REQUIRE THE PASSAGE OF THE CIVICS PORTION OF THE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2260
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2260 Walker TO REQUIRE THE PASSAGE OF THE CIVICS PORTION OF THE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2261
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2261 Walker TO REQUIRE THE PASSAGE OF THE CIVICS PORTION OF THE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2353
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Representative Hamer, you are recognized to run 2053, House Bill 2353. Thank you, Mr.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HCR1011
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HCR1011 Tosh COMMENDING DR. MARY PARKER-REED AND HER COMMITMENT AND…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HCR1014
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HCR1014 V. Flowers REQUESTING AND PETITIONING THE UNITED STATES CON…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HJR1001
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1001 Ballinger APPLYING TO THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS TO CALL A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB292
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB292 Maloch TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE TRANSFER AND INVESTM…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB373
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB373 Hester TO EXEMPT ATTORNEY-CLIENT COMMUNICATIONS AND ATTORNE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB377
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB377 Hickey CONCERNING THE ELIGIBILITY OF AN INMATE OF THE DEPAR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB38
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB38 A. Clark TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ELECTIONS AND BALLOTS.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB380
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB380 Hester TO EXEMPT CERTAIN COMMODITIES AND SERVICES UNDER ARK…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SJR7
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SJR7 Rapert AN APPLICATION TO CONGRESS TO CALL A CONVENTION FOR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SJR9
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SJR9 Rapert AN APPLICATION TO CONGRESS TO CALL A CONVENTION FOR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 13, 2026
All right, as I said, obviously we do have a long agenda today. What I'd like to be able to do is work right up until lunchtime, you know, as long as we continue to have the bills ready to run, and I expect that that'll be the case. And then at that point, we'll break, and we're actually coming back upon adjournment so long as there are bills that are still left to run, my guess is that there are. I'd like for the members to try to keep in mind that we do have a lot of work to do. I don't want to let anything out of this committee that's not been vetted, so we do need to make
sure that we're ready to ask questions, but make sure the questions are on the bill, about the bill, and, you know, there's information that we need to make sure that we pull out and just try to make it as efficient as possible as we do this work so we can get people in and out. Representative Hodges, you can go ahead and take the end of the table if you want. We have a special order for Senate Bill 341, and I want to go ahead and use this opportunity also is that if somebody has a bill that they want to run at a certain time, as long as the committee is okay with it, I'm great with setting things for a special order.
It kind of lets people know where you're at, and frankly, you can be guaranteed to be first up and get out of this committee if you've got something else to do. So we can set that, but we'll start off with Representative Hodges, and then Representative Williams after that, and we'll pick you up. But you are recognized, Representative Hodges, to run Senate Bill 341. Thank
you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, committee, for the special order and for working me in today. I appreciate it.
SB 341 is part of the governor's legislative package. It's his boards and commissions bill. It's the result of over two years of work by the governor's appointments office and the governor's staff in appointing various people to boards and commissions, taking notes, seeing what's working and what's not working, and which boards and commissions need to be either reformed or eliminated altogether. So this bill is really a culmination of that effort. It is a long bill, but just to sum up, I think we are eliminating 13 boards and commissions,
as well as reforming several others. And by and large, these are committees that have either outlive their original purpose when they were created, or they become redundant with some other board of commission that's been created. That's kind of the gist. But just to give you an example of a board of commission that's in the bill, the Arkansas Scenic Resources Preservation Coordinating Committee is one that we're eliminating. The last meeting that was on
file for this committee was over six years ago. Another example, the Distance Learning Coordinating Council. It's asked to be abolished, which the Commissioner of Education supports. It was created in 2005. It's fulfilled its purpose. And any issues that are relevant to this council have been taken up by other bodies, such as the Arkansas Broadband Council, Digital Learning Council, and things like that.
The commissions and boards that are being reformed, most of them are pretty straightforward changes. Just to give you one example, the State Board of Education, as it currently stands, the members are appointed from congressional districts as they were in 2007. So this bill just updates it to our current congressional districts. All of the changes are just changing it from some outside organization appointing members to the governor appointing those members with the consultation of those outside organizations.
And in many cases, adding in confirmation by the Senate. That's a lot of those changes to these boards and commissions. So with that, if there's any specific questions, I'm happy to take those. But really what we're trying to do here is help save the state a little bit of money and a lot of time. It takes a lot of time to take applications for these boards and commissions to find people who are willing to serve on them, especially in some cases these boards and commissions
have as many as 30 members. So we have people in our government working on these issues. It takes up their time. We would rather that be used for some of the other boards and commissions that are still active and still important to the functions of government. So I'd appreciate you joining us in this effort to reduce some waste in bureaucracy and focus our efforts more on other areas that are important. So with that, I would take any questions or any motions.
Okay. All right. Do we have any questions from the committee? All right. Seeing none, I don't think we have anybody signed up to speak for or against this. Nobody in the audience is here to speak for or against. All right. And I will hear your motion, Representative Douglas. All right, I have a motion to pass on the table. Anybody want to speak for or speak on that motion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? Congratulations, Representative Hodges. Your bill passes. Thank you, Chairman. Thanks, Committee. Good job, Committee, making that happen so quickly.
as well. Representative Williams, you are recognized to run HB 1792. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Hopefully
this one will be just as fast. Committee members, what I bring this one
to you, this is a request from election commissioners, and it involves election commissioners and treasurers. But this really very simply is that in the past, when a ballot was produced, it was produced
with a printed number on the ballot and on the stub, and they kept those two separate from one another. The belief was that that was done because of, you know, concerns about integrity of the election process. That's no longer the case. The ballot numbers are only printed on the stubs. There's no longer a requirement to have them stored separately and to have the treasurers be responsible for this. So I was reproached by one of the treasurers to see about just allowing those ballot boxes
to be stored with the Election Commission since, as I said, there's no longer any concern about any integrity or issues with that. I'll be
glad to answer any questions. All right, any questions from the
committee? Representative Hendon, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Can you assure us that this does not degrade the security, the integrity of our ballot system? I can. People say it's not happened. I have seen it happen in the past, both in the legislature and in school board elections.
And so the people that say it doesn't happen, they don't know what they're talking about because I've seen it. But my question to you is this bill, does this bill move away from the integrity of our ballot system? If it does, I ain't for it.
But if it is... It does not at all, since there's no way to be able to match the ballot stubs to the ballots themselves now. It doesn't. Back when they could, there might have been an issue, but since they're no longer printed on both ballot and on stub, there's no way to be able to use those for identification purposes. Well, why don't we
still print them on both the ballot and the stub? That's a question I can't answer for you.
I guess I'm too late to ask that
another day. Any other questions from the committee? All right. There's nobody signed up to speak for or against, what is the will of the committee? We got a motion from Representative Dotson do pass. Any discussion on the motion? All right. All in favor say aye. Opposed? All right. The ayes have it. Congratulations. Your bill passed. Thank you, Your Commissioner.
Okay. I know that Representative Douglas has a witness, but she is not in the room, So we'll pick her up with the next one. Is there any other members from outside the committee who are here to run a bill? No, I had been approached by a couple, all right. Then is there any members that are prepared to run a bill on the committee? All right, Representative Sturge, 1675, okay.
Speaker 33
8:36
Okay, you are recognized to run 1675, Representative Sturge. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Colleagues, this is a simple cleanup bill about the law enforcement memorial that we have on the Capitol lawn. It's been in place for several years now, so the funding is actually done by the Secretary
of State. This just updates the language on the committee that meets, that selects the names of the fallen officers to go on that memorial. Simple cleanup bill. All right. Are there any
questions from the committee? All right. Now, there's nobody signed up to speak for or against. Nobody in the audience here to speak for or against? All right. What is the pleasure of the committee? We have a motion from Representative Ferguson to do pass. Any discussion on the motion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? All right. Congratulations, Representative Sturge. You passed your bill.
Speaker 37
9:38
Representative Douglas, are you prepared to run your- Yes. Okay. Which one? 1892, is that the bill? Thank you.
Speaker 48
10:30
Thank you, committee. You're recognized around 1892. If I could have my county clerk, Mrs. Sharon
Brooks, to accompany me. Ms. Brooks, if you don't mind introducing yourself for
Speaker 49
10:49
the record, you'll be recognized. Good morning. Sharon Brooks, Sebastian County
Speaker 48
10:56
Clerk. Thank you for being here. Committee, as you know, in the past, we have passed legislation, which was, I believe,
Act 95, that addressed unopposed candidates. And since that time, we've realized there was another group of unopposed candidates that we could eliminate from the ballot, and that's what this bill does. It's going to save the county time. It's going to save them money. And if you have any questions about that, we'd be glad to answer them.
Okay. We have a question. Representative Dotson, you're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. It's my understanding that the offices that are listed out here, the mayor, governor, and circuit clerk, are they not used for tabulating petition gathering signatures
Speaker 55
11:45
and thresholds of what those? They're not eliminated. What those are supposed to be? They're not
Speaker 48
11:54
are left on the ballot. They are not eligible to be pulled from the ballot when they're unopposed. It speaks to that.
I guess I've misread it. I thought it was including those. Which group? If you'll look at
Speaker 48
12:11
B, the names of all unopposed candidates for the office of mayor, and then it underlines governor and circuit clerk shall be separately. So they still are on the ballot? Uh-huh, placed
on. Okay. Thank you. Okay, are there any other questions from the committee? All right. Seeing none, there's nobody signed to speak for or against this bill. You are
recognized to close for your bill, Representative Douglas. I'm
motion due pass. Any discussion on that motion? All in favor, say aye. Opposed? Congratulations, Representative Douglas. You passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have this
Speaker 48
13:03
second bill. Do you want me to wait? I could come back and be on the bottom of the agenda with this one later if you'd like. What's the bill number on it?
you. What I'd say is that if it is something that is, if you don't mind actually holding off on it, yeah, that way if there's some things that are not as, I don't know if that's going to be controversial or not, but if it's not controversial, then we can move
Speaker 48
13:39
on. I think that works for me as well, and I appreciate you allowing me to run this bill, and I'll come back for the other one.
Okay. Thank you, sir. Sounds good. All right, are there any other members from other committees who are in here to run a bill? All right. I know, Representative Hammer, did you have another bill that you had to go to another committee or are you here for the long haul now? I'll be glad to sit down and run all night in here. Okay. Okay. Well, Representative Hammer, what bill are you looking forward to running? We'll start with 2053.
2053. All right. I'm sure you can.
Representative Hamer, you are recognized to run 2053, House Bill 2353. Thank you, Mr.
Chairman, members of the committee. Everybody has, I think, had distributed to them some information that kind of sets the stage for why I'm bringing this bill before you today.
I think on the top of the handout that you have, you'll find that there was an article that was referenced from a news source that started after one of the last audit findings on the Fair Housing Commission. You'll notice at the bottom of the article, it has my name listed as a source of comment. So as far as my interest in this particular issue, it goes back as far as that legislative audit meeting. What I'm proposing is that we would merge the Fair Housing Commission into the Arkansas
Development Finance Authority. I've given to you a two-sheet handout that I've prepared that would have some of the reasoning behind why such a move would be in the benefit of the state of Arkansas and also the taxpayers. One of the things that I want to be sure to emphasize on the front is that this would not result in any loss of services. It would not result in any lost federal funding. Those may be two things, and in the last 24 hours, you may have heard if you've been approached by some that may
be against this, but I want to put your mind at ease, and I've given you the rationale spelled out in two pages so that you could see some of the arguments for and against. This move would actually create a savings to the general revenue of the state of Arkansas, approximately $271,000, and it would also bring more efficiency to the operation of providing these services to the residents of the state. There would be no loss of services. This is an example of what 80 percent of the rest of the states do as far as having these services combined or already existing in a division that is able to offer broader base support by giving more resources that currently, the way it's structured, are lacking.
In fact, if you look at the three audit findings and the reports that are attached in your handout, you will see that in 2010, 2012, 2014, one of the issues that is cited is the segregation of duty issues have been constantly under scrutiny and findings have resulted in each one of those three audit findings that you have provided to you. So this is a move where we could combine it, save $271,000 to the general revenue, and
be able to make the operations of what is intended in the way of services provided a much more efficient and effective manner. And with that, Mr. Chair, I'll be glad to answer any questions. Okay. Are there any questions from the committee? All
right. Seeing none, we do have an individual who signed up to speak on this bill. The first person, it looks like, is Ms. Carol Johnson with the Fair Housing Commission.
If you don't mind taking a spot at the end of the table, then if you would introduce yourself
for the record, you are recognized. Good morning. Thank you. My name is Carol Johnson. I'm the director of the Arkansas Fair Housing Commission, and I appreciate the opportunity to speak against House Bill 2053. We've had not a lot of time to get together to really discuss this. I do understand that this was not part of the governor's package to consolidate agencies.
Let me tell you why this bill is detrimental to the state of Arkansas and why it absolutely will create a financial burden to the state. First of all, this agency is the only civil rights enforcement agency the state of Arkansas has. And Arkansas is unique to that. A lot of other states have civil rights commissions that do not only housing, but they do employment, housing accommodations. but we're unique in the fact that we only do housing, and this agency was established for that purpose.
This act would eliminate the civil rights agency, enforcement agency that we have, would seize all of the assets that the commission has and bring them under the sole authority of ADFA. Now, you all, I'm sure, are familiar with ADFA, but ADFA is the Arkansas Development Finance Authority. It is basically the lender for multifamily housing developments and projects within the state of Arkansas. I don't know another state that has an enforcement mechanism like this in a lending institution.
Basically, it would allow ADFA to police itself. It would provide ADFA by virtue of its mission of providing these types of funds to housing developments and other types of multifamily developments in the state would have the authority to bring or not bring investigation suits or whatever into alleged fair housing violations. It also would provide that inherent conflict.
We do housing complaints based on a number of protected classes that are enumerated under the Fair Housing Act. And while some of those are obviously race and color and national origin, a lot of those have nothing to do with that. It's disability, religion, familial status, sexes, and gender. We have most of our funding comes in the form of federal funding. So that $271,000 that Representative Hammer mentioned that would be preserved, that is
We do get that amount in general revenue, but the majority of the $1.2 million I think right now that we have in our budget is all from federal funding and it's all from money that has been raised and collected by the work of the commission over the last several years. Representative Hammer also mentioned the segregation of duties. That has been an issue in terms of, and the segregation of duties is the fact that there are very few people.
We have a staff of less, well, actually now it's about 12. When I started at the agency, we had a staff of about three. Over the years, we have had a surplus in our federal funding simply because we have not been allowed the appropriation to spend that money that we have. That's why there's a surplus of federal funding in our budget, in our appropriation, and in our funding because we haven't been allowed to use that money to hire the staff that we need to really provide the services.
This bill would not only transfer all of those assets over to ADFA for their sole discretion and how to use, it would also eliminate the Housing Education Trust Fund that was enumerated in that statute. That money was there to provide education and outreach. They have eliminated that part of the statute as well. So there would be no obligation whatsoever to provide any education and outreach services throughout the state. So that is a very real and tangible thing that we would lose.
ADFA obviously has been, again, the inherent conflict in that they are a basic lender. They are a bank. They're not an advocate for civil rights. That is not their authority. the adjudication of claims, again, all of those things would be chilled. And the final point I would like to make also is that this is a conflict. We have spoken with several members of the community and also the attorney general's
office. We would most likely lose those federal funds if we moved this under the control of AFA Because of those internal inherent conflicts, basically you're going to put the fox over the hen house. Okay, we would, there's an inherent conflict there that we would most likely lose all those federal funding. So instead of this being additional revenue for the state in terms of seizing those federal funds that the agency has,
Um, probably in the future, the, the, um, state would have to bear the burden of funding the entire cost of it. That's why we believe that, um, uh, the House Bill 2053 is not good for the state of Arkansas. It's definitely not good for the citizens. We need to be allowed, um, to continue to protect people's fair housing rights, their fair lending rights and provide those opportunities that, quite frankly, I don't believe ACFA
has the, I just don't think they can do and I don't think they're ethically situated to do so. Thank you. I'm happy to answer any questions you have.
Representative Sabin, you're recognized for your question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just want to follow up on the point you made about the federal funds being in jeopardy if we make this move. Do similar commissions in other states reside within other agencies? I mean, are there any examples that we can point to to determine whether or not for sure
the federal funds would be in jeopardy if
this move was made? We absolutely thank you for your question. Most of the other states that have, and every other state except for one, I think it's Alabama, has these. And those agencies are separate entities. The only other states that I'm aware of that have it within other entities are with the Attorney General's office. So again, that would be another autonomous enforcement agency. But to place that enforcement mechanism with basically a lender, which is what AFA is,
that's an inherent conflict. And that would most certainly jeopardize our substantial equivalency with HUD. Follow-up, Mr. Chair? Yeah, you recognize the follow-up.
This is less of a question for the person at the end of the table than it is to wonder whether somebody from ADFA is here to respond to any of this, just to understand from their perspective, you know, whether they're prepared for this or have a response. In fairness, I have support for ADFA, but not in this area, and I'm not familiar
with this question in any way or shape of it. Okay. Thank you. Representative Ferguson, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This question is for Ms. Johnson. The funding for the Fair Housing Commission, is it directly from
the feds or does it go through a pass-through agency? Thank you for that question. Our funding comes directly from HUD, so it doesn't pass through any agency. It is directly funded to our agency from the federal entity.
One follow-up, Mr. Chair, if you please. You're recognized for follow-up. The other question, based on the amount of complaint that are filed and handled by your agency, are there certain funding given preferences as it relates to HUD based on those complaints handled? For instance, if you have, say, 50 complaints, are there any additional funding? Okay.
So, yes. So, um, thank you. Um, well, we do get, um, we get, uh, money for, for a number of different reasons. Some of that is to provide education and outreach. Some of that is, is based on the complaint processing. We do have, um, HUD requires the states, um, and the governmental agencies to look at every single complaint that comes into our office. Last year, we had, uh, almost 900 calls. Um, all of those obviously did not materialize in the fair housing complaints because they
They go through the intake process, and so some of them don't materialize into complaints, but they're concerns that people have. The state is paid from HUD based on a number of case processing criteria that they have. So yes, we do receive funds for that, and also for the education outreach, which is a very important component. Most people, and I have been here for a lot of years, almost since it started, a lot of people didn't even realize that these services were available for free to all the residents of
the state. And again, I mean, it's a benefit that we offer based on, you know, just the civil rights protections that we need to offer citizens as part of the, as part of, you know, state services that we offer. But yes, we do receive those funds directly from HUD based on case processing, based on education and outreach. We provide a number of different services. And also for ADPA participants as well. We provide training classes every few months for developers, site
engineers, architects. We train about fair housing and design requirements, do's and don'ts for housing providers. So we train on both ends in terms of whether or not you're a housing provider or you're a member of the general public who needs some protections or they believe their fair housing rights have violated. We act as mediators, conciliators, and again, not every complaint that comes through our agency materializes into a, you know, into a complaint that's filed. But we're here to assist all of them through that process.
And we've had a lot of success. We've had thousands of, since I've been the director since 2005, we've had thousands of complaints that we've been able to effectively resolve. Housing developers that come here, and obviously we have people that come here from across the country to build multifamily housing developments in Arkansas, they have had me go to their states to talk to their states. They have highlighted Arkansas as one of the best states in terms of fair housing education, enforcement outreach. There's no doubt that we provide a great and
beneficial service to the state. In terms of that extra money, we just need to be allowed to use it. I mean, we have not had the opportunity to spend down some of that fund balance that we have in our federal revenue simply because we haven't had the appropriation and the authority to fill positions. We've had vacant positions that have been there because we can't get the authority to fill those positions. I'll
I think that you, if you want to hold off, I can get Representative House, but there's not a whole lot of other
questions, so you're recognized, Representative House. Representative Hammer, glancing through the audit reports, and ma'am, we have heard you testimony in committee, and the audit findings continue and continue and continue, misapplication of public funds, and that continues to be a problem, according to the auditors.
But, Representative Hammer, I've got a question. In a Type II transfer, all duties, powers, authorities, budgeting, supervision, et cetera, et cetera, is transferred to the receiving agency, and a Type I transfer basically just transfers financial oversight. Is there a reason why you think it's better to do a Type II rather than a Type I? Because it seems like the objective is to get some financial management supervision in this case. Am I reading this bill wrong? Let me try to illustrate this way and see if it answers
your question. You've got an agency sitting over here by itself doing everything that's represented in the audit findings. And why would you not want to transfer to an agency over here that is able to do the same thing in all aspects? And I think it even says that it transfers the liabilities. So it's a complete transfer over underneath this agency over here. So the reason behind the rationale would be that take it in its entirety, put it over here in its entirety, and let all the responsibilities rest over here where you have the resources to do it effectively and efficiently.
I don't know if that answers your question, but
that would be my response. Representative Ferguson, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I think one of my questions may have been answered, Representative Howes, that was one of my questions. It was for Representative Hammer. But another question I have for you, Representative Hammer, will this eliminate the commission and also some of the staff members in this transfer? But what happened in
this is that there's a board that would be in place that would
assume those responsibilities to oversee, you know, the, you know, all the functions that are required. That's why this is a non-threatening move in that all the things are expected over here are still required over here because, you know, the ADFA receives the largest portion of HUD funding, number one. Number two, they still have to comply to all the things that are expected over here. This is why it's a move of efficiency that you can take this over here, put it over here. Now, as far as the staffing, I think that would be left up to ADFA,
But, you know, in the spirit of what we're trying to do in this legislative branch, I mean, in this legislative session, and that is look at areas of efficiency where we can combine as far as there would still be the board that would, you know, have some ultimate responsibility and accountability. So as far as the, you know, the fox watch and the hen house, I'm not sure that's a valid argument because you still have this board over here that oversees the, you know, the aspects of ADFA. As far as the employees, I don't really think it's our place to delegate that or be involved in that.
I would say this about AFA, though. They have run a real lean mean budget in the last year or two. In fact, they've cut their expenses. They have eliminated, I think, one position, and they are trying to be as efficient as possible. Would that happen? Would that occur? That would be up
to them to answer that question for sure. One more follow-up, Mr. Chair, if you please. So just for clarity, so the Fair Housing Commission would be eliminated under this bill, and the after board would take over, correct?
Basically, that would be correct. They would assume the responsibilities, and that's what keeps the fox from the hen house effect. You've got that board overlooking them, just like you have the board overlooking the commission. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. Representative Sturge, you're recognized for a question.
Speaker 33
34:42
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Hamer or Director Johnson, either one of you can answer this, but I guess I'm having a hard time figuring out what the relationship is now between ADFUD and Fair Housing, because both of them received money from HUD, and it was my understanding
that there was kind of a MOU between the two that ADFA was actually transferring money to Fair Housing already, so it already seems like you worked together
already. Can you explain that relationship a little more? Certainly. Thank you for that question. We have, over the years, we actually started an MOU with ADFA back in 2010, signed in 2011, before the new ADFA president even came. And that was to increase awareness with multi-family development housing people to make sure they
understood what the law was, because ADFA was being the subject of a number of fair housing complaints. People were filing fair housing and lending complaints against AFA, and we wanted to make sure that if they received public funds from AFA, from the state, from the federal government, that they were adhering to state and federal guidelines. So that is how this MOU arose. They wanted us to train their participants, and that's what we did. And since that time, we've trained hundreds of AFA participants. And as a matter of fact,
They made that as a condition precedent to receiving any federal or state funds from ADPA that they went through the training. That's how much they believed in our training and our education and outreach. That's how that MOU came about. And in terms of the staff, I mean, obviously, ADPA operates on three or four times the staff that we do. They've been able to hire staff. We have the funds. We just haven't been able to hire those staff. This bill is going to eliminate a necessary agency unnecessarily.
And again, there is an inherent conflict. The federal funds will not continue. The only money that ACFA will probably ever receive from this deal is whatever the Fair Housing Commission has in its bank account right now, because HUD is not going to continue to fund fair housing if it's inherently in a conflicted agency. And it is. I don't know of any other state that has this. Again, if they don't have a separate agency, which is really what you need, you need the autonomy in order to litigate that without fear of reprisal or whatever else there is,
it would be in the Attorney General's office. APFA is not
Speaker 33
37:12
the place for that. Follow-up, Mr. Chair. You're recognized for a follow-up. So, several minutes ago, you mentioned something about a trust fund, fair housing trust fund. What money is currently going to it? It was, in my understanding, it was, I can't even remember now, half a million dollars or so, I think, from GIF, and we all know that that doesn't have a bright future ahead of it. So what, I guess, what monies are currently going into it? What do you, what are you saying as far as, you know, the legitimacy of it if it's moved
into a merger? That actually is two separate things. That's the housing trust fund, and that's not related to us. We don't get any state funds. We're not getting any GR funds in our housing trust fund. That comes solely from conciliation agreements, monies that come in from fines that are levied, things of that nature. So all of that money in our education trust fund is generated by the agency. The only money that this commission gets from the state of Arkansas is that $271,000 a year.
And it's been like that for the past probably, I don't know, 10 years. So we don't get much. All that money that we have, that $2 million or whatever it is that we have in our, it's all federal funds.
All right, see no other questions on the committee. I appreciate your testimony for the committee today.
Thank you. Also signed up to speak against is a
Mr. Aaron with the NAACP. if you do not mind introducing yourself for the record yes sir you're recognized good morning
Speaker 119
38:57
pastor good morning sir i'm razelle aaron the president of the arkansas state conference of if you
Speaker 120
39:05
don't mind make sure your mic's on i'm sorry yeah you're fine thank you i'm razelle aaron the president of the arkansas state conference of the naacp the arkansas state conference has worked with the arkansas fair housing for a number of years many of the The complaints we receive at the NAACP in regards to discrimination in housing are referred to Arkansas Fair Housing for several reasons. One reason is the majority of the people that need that type of assistance cannot
afford to file civil action or litigation in civil court to defend themselves or to get relief. And the other issue is that with Arkansas Fair Housing partnering with NAACP, When those complaints are filed with Arkansas Fair Housing, they are primarily or by majority mitigated, which means they don't end up in court at all. When we talk about funds and saving funds, it may save the state a few hundred thousand dollars
in reference to eliminating fair housing. But it simply displaces the burden, the financial burden on the court system. Because now these people that would usually, we would refer to Arkansas Fair Housing, would now be referred to the court to file action against, to file civil action in the court system. Again, it would add to overburdening of the court system, but also it would add to costly litigation, which is now being avoided by sending or referring those complaints to
Speaker 121
40:33
Arkansas Fair Housing. Now, when we talk about how this impacts poor people,
Speaker 120
40:40
a lot of people have the misconception that the NAACP is about protecting black people, and that's absolutely not the case. It's about protecting people's civil and human rights, and that is all inclusive of all people. And the majority of people that are impacted or negatively impacted by discriminatory housing are poor people, poor defenseless people that have learned to trust in the fair housing and have confidence in fair housing,
taking care of their issues and mediating their problems. Another thing we have to also consider, of course, sitting next to Pastor, Representative Hammer, is that we have to consider the implication as we think about Arkansas and the Bible and Bible states and what we profess to try and protect. And that is the poor people and defenseless people. So it's not in the best interest of poor people, especially being down here in the Bible area, that we eliminate a commission or
the Fair Housing Commission that helps the very people that we tell God that we are going to help. And so I think it's in the best interest of the state of Arkansas to continue to retain the Arkansas Fair Housing Commission in its current form to eliminate, again, the overburdening of the civil court system. The possibility that poor people that are discriminated against will not get relief because they cannot afford relief. And also we have to consider the relationship as it relates to the outreach
program that Arkansas Fair Housing does, for the first time in probably 20 years or in its existence, the NAACP has partnered with Arkansas Fair Housing to travel the state in their outreach program to poor communities, communities that may not be able to receive this information otherwise or may need more time to be given a better understanding of what their rights are in regards to fair housing discrimination.
And so with being able to partner with organizations like Arkansas Fair Housing and Urban League and ACLU and LULAC, the NAACP now in the most recent couple of years, we've positioned ourselves to be able to not only assist people like organizations like fair housing, but also for fair housing to assist us in our efforts and our objective, which is to protect the the civil and human rights of people. And right now in the state of Arkansas, there is no renter's rights, so to speak.
There is no formal law here in the state of Arkansas that protects renters. As a matter of fact, there was legislation, I don't know what the status of it is, but to go back to making it a misdemeanor criminal offense if people are evicted from a property and don't leave that property. And so instead of going forward with being able to protect poor people in reference to discriminatory work practices, we're actually going backwards. We don't need to go backwards, especially as it relates to civil and human rights, because
one thing that I can assure you is that the NAACP will do everything we can using all of our resources to try and protect or regain those rights. And again, that means that we need to make sure that we stay on the right track, and that's the track of progression. So I appreciate Pastor Hammer's position in this bill. But again, the reality is that it's not beneficial to the citizens of the state of Arkansas.
If there are any questions, I
would be glad to answer those questions. Yeah, we do have a couple of questions. I have one.
Speaker 120
44:36
Have you seen the audit report findings for this agency? Yes, sir. Yes, sir. As a matter of fact, when I was the vice president of a political organization, the Black Caucus, there was an issue that came up that basically appeared to me to be a witch hunt, and I'll explain briefly why that is. The Arkansas Fair Housing has been partnering with political organizations, Republicans and Democrats, since I've known or since I've been involved anyway.
And at one point, the Arkansas Fair Housing partnered with the Arkansas Democratic Black Caucus to get information out to the public. Part of what the Black Caucus does is reach out to people that are in Hispanic and black communities and also poor communities. At that particular time, we had a website, we had radio advertising, we had program advertising, And Arkansas Fair Housing basically bought an ad, just a simple ad, with Arkansas Democratic
Black Caucus, which is also extended to the Republican Party. They just chose not to. But in that, there was a complaint, I believe last year or the year before last, against Arkansas Fair Housing in reference to basically saying or trying to say that they were supporting a Democratic or supporting a political party. The issue with that is that it was based on politics. You have a Republican legislator that wanted to go after anyone that wanted to support
what they thought were Democratic party issues, when in fact it wasn't a Democratic party issue. The issue was is Arkansas Fair Housing was trying to do what it is designed to do, and that's to reach out to people in the communities that we serve. And part of the community that we serve as the Arkansas Democratic Black Caucus is the community of black people, Hispanic people, white people, and poor people. And so it was an excellent opportunity that they took advantage of. As a matter of fact, I came and spoke in support of Director Johnson and the Arkansas Fair
Housing for what they had done. And what we did do is that to remove the burden from Arkansas Fair Housing, the Arkansas Democratic Black Caucus actually reimbursed those funds to the Arkansas Fair Housing. And so when you look at the audit, and I have not looked at it in detail, but I know based on my personal experience that Arkansas Fair Housing has done an excellent job under the leadership of Director Johnson. So your opinion
is that the auditors used their office to conduct a witch hunt?
Speaker 120
47:16
Not the audit office, but the legislator that was seeking to go after Arkansas Fair Housing Commission. So did the auditors have any findings of
Speaker 120
47:29
don't believe they did, but I can't be quoted on that. In that particular instance, I don't believe that
they did. Okay. Let's see. Representative Miller, you have a question? Yes, sir.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Sir, I caught something you said a minute ago that I would like for you to either clarify or back up and take back or extrapolate on or something.
That was, you were talking about tenants do not have, do not, in Arkansas, tenants do not have any rights. I believe you made that statement just saying, can you clarify exactly what you
Speaker 120
48:10
meant by that? Yes, sir. Certainly, I'd be glad to, and thank you for the question. When we talk about renters' rights, Arkansas, in comparison to other states in the United States, has limited resources to get relief for tenants that rent from landlords or property
managers. And I believe it was Jay Barth last year, year before last, and a committee that the governor had put together to study proposing a renters' right law. And Jay Barth came up with a comprehensive, very detailed document that laid out a plan to provide rights to renters, but also without eliminating or negatively impacting the rights of landlords and property managers.
Unfortunately, because due to the political environment at that time, the recommendation that Jay Barth and that committee put forth did not go anywhere. And so in comparison with Arkansas and other states in the United States, Arkansas, when we talk about renters' rights, there's no specific written rule or written law that says that if your landlord doesn't fix your, if it's 20 degrees outside and your landlord doesn't fix your heat, that you have a right to withhold rent, for example.
There's no remedy right now for tenants that allows them to get relief based on the repair, just simple repairs that have to be made on homes. And here's another example. In a housing development here, actually in North Little Rock, where there were issues with wiring problems and mold problems, and the city of Little Rock was coming in and and writing those people up and writing them up on numerous occasions, or the state of North Florida, excuse me.
And so the problem was is that because of the property managers and their position being out of state people and also that there were limited laws that could be used by the tenants. As a matter of fact, no laws that could be used by the tenants, to my understanding, to be able to force the property managers to make the corrections or repairs that were necessary. Some of these repairs were life-threatening when we talk about black mold and bare wiring and issues like that, fire hazards and health hazards.
And so when we talk about laws, Arkansas has no comprehensive law that protects renters from bad landlords or property managers. Yes,
sir. Follow-up, Mr. Chair? You're recognized for a follow-up. Thank you. And I understand. I can appreciate where you're coming from. I'm in the rental business myself. I do think some of the issues that you were talking about probably are best taken care of in capitalism and free enterprise, folks having the opportunity to rent from somebody who provides better property.
Now, that may not work in all situations, but I would also ask you this. Are you aware of the difficulty that landlords and property managers face when you have a tenant who refuses to pay rent for months at a time and the difficulty that one faces when trying to get them out? I mean, I understand where you're coming from, but I want to make sure that both sides of the coin are shown here in that sometimes, you know, landlords,
since the Supreme Court ruled a year or so ago that where sheriff's departments can no longer go in and physically remove somebody from a home, it kind of leaves landlords up a creek with actually being able to get someone out. And so are you all aware of that, and what's your position on that as far as taking care of actual property managers?
Speaker 120
52:01
Thank you for that question. That is certainly an excellent question.
Capitalism does not cure this problem. Capitalists, the theory of capitalism does not give relief to poor people if they are unable to get or access the resources that they need to make it to the level that other people are already at. And so when we talk about your question as it relates to both sides, Right now, only one side is protected, and that side is the landlord and property managers.
And so the only, and that's another, and so you make an excellent point, and that's another excellent reason or perfect point in maintaining the Arkansas Fair Housing Commission as it is because of the fact that landlords and property managers are protected and renters are not protected. And one of the only avenues or the only avenue they have in the state of Arkansas right now is the Arkansas Fair Housing Commission. Another thing we have to consider when you say that, and I'm glad you said it that way, is that if we're going to send renters to jail for not paying rent,
then we should send landlords to jail for not fixing property. Yeah, let's
keep it, you know, the applause and all that. Let's try to do business here. And let's also try to keep it to the legislation that's in front of us. All right. My apologies. No, that's all right. Seeing no other questions from the committee, I appreciate your testimony today. You're welcome, and thank you, Chair, and thank you, Pastor Hamm. Thank you. Reverend Smith, I'm sorry, I did not say your name on the list. Okay. Hopefully your question can get answered somewhere.
We still have one individual signed up to speak against, Ms. Annie Abrams, if you don't mind introducing yourself
Speaker 131
54:02
for the record. Good morning, thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Annie Abrams, and I happen to also historically at 85, been the first chairperson of the Arkansas
Fair Housing Commission when it was established after a vigorous, vigorous, vigorous struggle to get one here in Arkansas. Prior to that time, if a person had a concern about fairness as it relates to one of the basic things that we call the American dream is somewhere to stay, they had to go all the way to our original office in Texas. And that was an imposition on a lot of people. As I listened to the questions, and I'm sorry,
I know that I'm a southern bride. I didn't know pastor to say, Mr. Chairman, and then I didn't know to say pastor, and I didn't know to say that your legislation is awesome. Ms. Abram, if you don't mind. I know,
I know. I'm 85. I just have to do what I do. We'll give you a lot of grace. We're good on this in
the table, Mr. Chair. Do you just worry about your
Speaker 131
55:07
n-word? We've been neighbors from a common standpoint for a long, long time, Celine and Pulaski, so I know him and he knows me.
But I wanted to address a couple of things because of the history of this commission. When this commission, as I said, was established, there was a lot of collaborative reconciliation activities that went about to bring us to this point that we have one in Arkansas. That was the Realtors Association fought with us, but the initiation, the birth of having one here, came about from Little Rock, Arkansas, and it was the place where they had decided
first that they would take on this problem of discrimination based on the distribution of wealth. After they decided that it was such a statewide problem that we decided that they would come together, realtors, realtors, we didn't have a realtors association, we We didn't have a landlord's association back in those days, but we all came together and we fought in this participatory democracy of how to get this piece of legislation on
the books. The name of the organization, I think, is the most important thing about our legitimacy. That is Arkansas Fair Housing Commission. And we have been dealing with those classes that we knew were categories of where you could have discrimination, and most of us have done that education over the years to make sure that each of those categories, those classes that the federal government endorses
have been there for us to work with. The second thing is, as the evolution of any democracy is, we have had two other categories that have been discriminated against, and we've had to deal with the choices people have of their associations based on sex. And then the last one that we have entered into in our education of preparing for fairness in housing has been those who have to re-enter, re-enter from our prison system to get back
to a basic human right, that is the right to have somewhere to stay. Our education program is what has generated more information and more resources for us and more reconciliation than any other, I believe, commission. As we listen to the audit piece, we have not been penalized that we had to pay back. if you are in an audit that is severe, you have to pay back whatever you're supposed
to have misappropriated. We've never had to do that. The other thing is, if you have to prove that you are worthy for the taxes that come from all of us, this democracy, our taxes come from all of the people in the categories that we have a responsibility to try to make sure that they are treated fairly. In that category, We have found that because of our education program, and that's one of the things that I'm proudest, having been the first chairperson of this commission.
As a long time, since I was 16 years old, I've been working on this issue of trying to be fair to all of our citizens. And I find that we still have miles to go before we sleep, as Robert Frost talks about. In the banking aspect, bankers, it doesn't matter what kind, whether it's a credit union or whether it's Africa or it's any, they're in the business of making profit for their stockholders. Our stockholders in the Arkansas Fair Housing is everybody, regardless of your classification.
So I just wanted to let you know that in the Bible Belt, it's very hard, very hard for for us in our education program to deal with one of the most controversial issues that have been recommended that we would have at our next spring convention, where we brought last year some 68 consultants, speakers from all over the United States. And that one that we are going to have to deal with is bilingual education.
We have had to struggle with the Commission in trying to build our staff. What has happened in my history with this organization is that we train in our education program lawyers, landlords, realtors, homeless people on what their rights are. And as a result of that, we have been given accommodations all over this country. And I want to personally put in the record, I know how important it is in the record,
that this executive secretary of ours is one that has been sought by others that they wish they had won. So when you talk about doing away with a structural, institutional structure, it scares me to think that this bill to eliminate the conscience of right and wrong would be brought by a minister. Do unto others as you'd have them do unto you. So, I'm available for any questions,
and if I don't have it with me now, I'll have it back in 15 minutes on my iPad. I don't see any questions
from the committee. I appreciate you coming and testifying. Thank you. We don't have anybody else to speak for or against? I did not find it on my own seat. Yes, you may. If you don't mind coming and introducing yourself for the record. This is something that we do have a full agenda, so if we can try to keep it as quick as possible.
Speaker 141
1:01:19
If you would introduce yourself, you're recognized. I am Dr. Kermit Parks, Union County, Eldorado, Arkansas. I am a owner of rental property. I am a member of, I'm a commissioner on the Martin Luther King Commission. The statement made that renters have no housing rights or whatever. I think we need the Fair Housing Commission to have a small unit where we can address issues.
There are issues on both sides that I do not think that will be addressed in the larger unit as it's being expressed to right here. The biggest thing that hurt us as landlords and as tenants is when you can no longer go to the district court for an issue, what used to be called municipal court. That just killed us. And so I'll give you an example. I consider myself quite compassionate. I frequently give away a month or a month's rent.
But after I've given away three months' rent and I tell the person, well, I'm sorry you You haven't performed as you said, but you owe me 30 days. You can't throw me out. There are issues that need to be addressed that I think can best be addressed from the Fair Housing Commission. Thank you, sir.
Thank you. Seeing no questions, I appreciate your testimony. All right. Not having anyone else signed up to speak for or against, Representative Hammer, you are recognized to close for your bill.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. I'd like to point out some things that have been shared in the comments that have been given in the testimony. First of all, I don't know about you, but it has a little bit of a negative overtone to me that part of your funding source is that you are basically paid for the number of complaints that you receive almost gives the impact or the idea of a bounty hunter type situation that would cause you to think that maybe in similar fashion, like there
are certain speed traps around the state, there's that ultimate overall guiding goal to find the greatest number of complaints that you can because you know there's a dollar value attached to it. I've got a little bit of a pause concerning that thought. And as far as ADFA reports, I want to also point out that it is ADFA that reports to the Arkansas Fair Housing Commission. So as far as the, you know, Foxwatch and the Hent House, it seems to me like they are the point of entry where those complaints come.
Now, even since this bill came out, there have been sources like the Arkansas Times that states that AFA has been the subject to fair housing complaints themselves. But what wasn't mentioned in that fact and what's been overlooked in this conversation also is that AFA has their own fair housing officer. So one thing you want to, you know, you want to keep in mind is that as this would be moved over to this entity, there's no relieving of the responsibility for a process whereby complaints can be given. Really what it all boils down to is who can do the same job, but who can do it more efficiently,
and who has the greater number of resources in order to carry out the ultimate goal and objective of what's intended. ATFA already receives the largest amount of HUD funding, and yes, there is that aspect of them providing the low-income housing and everything else, but when you have the federal government looking over your shoulder, regardless of whether it's parked over here or over here, the same accountability factors are going to come into play once it's all said and done. Keep in mind also that we are one of a few states that have a separate entity functioning
over here in the capacity as we are currently arranged. So that tells me that it's worked in other states, the majority of other states. The question is, why are we still holding on to an old model that has been plagued not Not with one, not with two, but with three audit reports that have the same consistency which tells me that the problems exist but there's nothing being done in order to address that. So the question is, if we're worried about the poor and if we're worried about those that are going to benefit from this, why would you continue to allow an agency that has a
chronic history and it was implied that one legislator was on a witch hunt and used the arm of legislative audit to do this? You might get away with that once, folks, but as past House Chair of Legislative Audit, I can promise you, you're not going to get away with it twice, and you're sure not going to get away with it three times. So I think that argument doesn't hold water. Regarding the education of the poor, there may be a reason for why more resources have not been given to this organization in order to do that.
And I want to point out that, yes, I'm a pastor, but I did not bring that subject to the table. I want to point out also that as far as my intent for bringing this, I'm bringing it from the argument that this is an efficient move to preserve resources and give a greater opportunity to the people of Arkansas who need this for it to be handled by an agency that has proven through audit reports of their own with no blemishes that they are a much better vehicle to make sure these resources get channeled out to the state.
So there may be a reason for why these resources have not been given to this organization. Number one, three consistent audit reports, and then number two, the numbers don't lie. When you look at the productivity of each one and you lay them down beside each other and you ask yourself this question, who's doing a better job with what they currently have and who could do a better job moving forward to meet the needs, you have to look at the numbers and you have to look at the audit findings and you have to look at it from a business model as to which one is going to do the overall goal.
Regarding education, let me give you an example of what the concept of education is. If you look at the audit reports, you'll find that there's a trail and you'll find that there's a hint of how money has been spent at these educational conferences and some of the high ticket expenses that have gone with it. Now, I don't know about you, but in the area that I serve and the poor people that I work with on a daily basis who we have a good working relationship and if they have a problem they call me as a state legislator and I get them the solution
to their problems and lean on the people that I have to lean on in order to get it done because that's one of the powers and authorities that we have as a legislator but if you want to talk about taking care of poor people why do you take the resources that have been entrusted to you by the taxpayers the federal government and out of general revenue and why do you squander them in one area saying that under the pretense you're taking care of the poor when you're not doing a good job of managing the money that you have yourself. The argument does not align, and the philosophies do not match up. And with that, I just want to begin to close by just saying this,
that this is an example of how we can take a function of the state and we can merge them together, maintain a sense of independence through a board that will govern and oversee, being held to federal examples and also being held accountable to us as a legislative branch. And we can take more and do more with it if we just mesh them together. The histories of the organization stand on their own with regards to how finances have
been handled. And with that, as a member of this committee, I'll make a motion.
Mr. Chair, do pass. Okay, we have a motion on the table. Do pass.
Any discussion on the motion? Representative Sabin, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'd like to preface my comments by simply saying that I've actually voted for every efficiency and consolidation measure that's been introduced this session. My concern really right here is that we don't have anybody from ADFA represented in this
discussion who can competently address some of the concerns that have been raised. I think the question really in this instance is not whether consolidation and efficiency is a good thing, because I think it usually is and can be. I think the question is whether ADFA is the right agency. And I think some legitimate concerns have been brought up about the conflict simply because ADFA does finance housing projects, and when complaints are made and they're the No one is fielding the complaints about projects they financed.
That's clearly a conflict. The other thing is, I think there's a concern that's been raised about whether the federal funding could be put into jeopardy if the Fair Housing Commission is merged into ADFA. So I think we need to address that. The third concern I have about ADFA is not the competence of that agency, because I've dealt with ADFA, and I think they're competently managed. I think they do a great job with everything that they do. In my experience, they have a very small staff, and of course others could probably speak to that if they were here, but, you know, when you have a small staff and you're talking
about merging more responsibilities into an agency, I think that does create an issue of capacity and whether they could really fulfill the issues here. So I think we have heard from Representative Hammer that his goal obviously is not to hurt the Fair Housing Commission. It's not to, you know, eliminate it or to prevent its duties from being, you know, fulfilled. But, you know, we want to make sure, obviously, that those things don't happen if this consolidation were to take place. And so, therefore, you
know, I would just like, you know, an opportunity maybe to consider this legislation when ADFA can address the concerns, when we can understand whether, you know, maybe the Attorney General's office is a better place for the Fair Housing Commission since that was raised today as a place where in other states the Fair Housing Commission does reside. So let's look at those other states, let's see what's happened, let's make sure we're not putting the duties of this Commission into jeopardy through this consolidation. And so I would just simply ask that we either don't pass this today, bring it up for consideration
when someone from ADFA, the agency that we're talking about, can actually be here to answer questions, address concerns, and make sure what we're doing is the right thing. Thank you. Representative
Douglas, do you have a comment? Okay. I thought you'd take one. Anybody else want to speak on the motion? Mr. Chairman? Yes,
a member of this committee, but I'm also president. It's fair game. You're welcome to
speak on this motion. Okay. The one thing I'd like to point out with regards to why this will not threaten federal
funding. This isn't like we're a pioneer or the first time to one to do this as a state. This has been done in other states as well. And federal funding, to my knowledge, has not been threatened in other states. If we were the first time out of the chute, that might be a legitimate argument. But when you consider that the vast majority of states have this component wrapped into another agency that makes us pretty unique the way we exist, I think that kind of negates that argument. So that's one reason I would speak in favor of the bill. As far as ADFA
and are they experienced in dealing with fair housing situations, I think I've already made a good case for that, that they have that fair housing individual that is responsible for investigating those complaints. So I think that that function can continue. So those concerns might be expressed, but I don't know that the validity of them when you lay them against what other states have done and successfully done necessarily warrants voting against this. So I'd appreciate a good vote to get. Representative Howes, you're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm going to make a statement in the form of a question and a nod will confirm what I'm saying. The staff of the commission will also transfer over to ADFA. Is that a correct statement? So the people to do this are going to still be around. I don't know this,
Mr. Chair. I can just nod ahead and say that. So latitude to the chair. Yeah,
you've got – I think this is probably an appropriate time to have some of this discussion, so that's perfectly fine.
ADFA has operated and has shown in the past year that they've been able to perform their duties, do it very efficiently without compromising the quality of services that they offer. I have no reason to believe that their reputation would not continue. Could I sit here on their behalf and say that all their staff is going to transfer over and that they are going to be able to be guaranteed of their job? I don't know. But I would also want to say this. I wouldn't want to tie that agency like I wouldn't want to tie any agency's hand, that they would need to accept the responsibility for this, do a thorough assessment,
knowing that they're going to be held accountable to making sure that services are provided in a way that keeps us out of trouble with the federal government. I think that's been the general tone of our review of all agencies operating in an efficient manner, that they would be able to do, provide the services, but it's going to be left up to
them what they do. Okay. All right. Any other discussion on the motion? Okay. The motion on the table is do pass. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? Say no.
No. Ayes have it. Congratulations, Representative Hammer. you've passed your bill.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I know I've been down here
a long time. I've got two others. Well, yeah, let's, if you don't mind, let's get some of the folks from outside the committee who've been waiting patiently while we've listened to you talk, get them a chance to do it. Representative Murdoch, do you have a bill that you, that you came here to run? Okay. Well, I thought you were here first. That's why I wanted to make sure. All right. Is Representative Brown? Okay. There you are. You're recognized Representative Brown to run HB 1570.
And actually, I'm sorry. Before I recognize you to run this, we have just a real simple amendment.
And if Representative Womack, if you want to run it from right there at your seat, you're welcome. You don't necessarily have to go down the end of the table as long as the committee doesn't object. It's an amendment to Senate Bill 373, and you're recognized,
Representative Womack. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This amendment simply deletes Representative Davis' name as a co-sponsor of the bill and nothing more. And I know Representative Davis is
home taking care of his family, so we need to make sure we pray. I know that his dad is ill and probably is not going to make it, so make sure we pray
for his family. What's the will of the committee? Okay, we have a motion to adopt the amendment. All in favor say aye. Opposed? Okay, the amendment is adopted
Speaker 155
1:16:45
for your forbearance. Representative Brown. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Chairman Ballinger.
Representative Brown has asked me to accompany her to answer any questions.
My name is Dan Greenberg. I'm
with the Advance Arkansas Institute. Thank you, Mr. Greenberg. All right. You are
Speaker 153
1:17:06
recognized to run House Bill 1570. But I'm going to try to keep this as brief as possible since I presented the bill earlier and was asked to amend it, which I have done. This simply is a bill to provide assurance and guidance to any delegates that we may
elect or select to represent us at an Article V Constitutional Convention. They have an oath to which they are to adhere, and we have reduced the penalty from the amendment basically reduces the penalty from a felony charge to a misdemeanor if they do not. We felt that barring them from holding state office in the future and whatever else is included in that misdemeanor charge
was sufficient to get their attention, that we are serious about them following the advice that they are given to attend the convention. Okay. You've heard the presentation. Are there any questions from
the committee? All right. Seeing no questions from the committee, what is the will of the committee? All right. We have a motion from Representative Womack. Do pass as amended. Any discussion on the motion? Okay. All in favor? The motion is do pass as amended. All in favor, say aye.
Opposed? Say nay. All right. Congratulations. Your bill is passed. Representative Brown. Thank you very much. Thank
make clear that the motion was due passed since it was engrossed in it. So it has been amended, but it was already engrossed, so the motion is due passed. Thank you, Representative Brown. Thank you. All right. Representative Tucker, do you mind telling us which bill it is that you're running?
Speaker 168
1:19:14
No. Okay. Actually, I got two, but I'll just take the first one and see how
Speaker 93
1:19:21
it goes. Okay. We can kill them in whatever order you want. That's fine. It's fine with
me. All right, you're recognized to present House Bill 1005. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
It's always an honor to appear before the House State Agencies Committee. I know the keen minds will not hold back on the questions and everything that goes along with that. Yeah, hopefully
we'll have an open mind, but it's thorough vetting, I'm sure. So
this is a piece of legislation. It is, I won't convey it as a little old bill that doesn't do anything. It is a complex piece of litigation. Unfortunately, the devil's in the details, but the point of the bill, I believe, is very important, And it's to restore a sense of integrity to the political and democratic process for state
elections in the state of Arkansas. In order to see what I'm trying to do here, I think first I have to explain what I believe the problem to be, and that is the lack of transparency in elections and try to figure out what order to go in. So one way to express the problem is that in Arkansas right now, for candidates, if If we receive financial contributions to our campaign, we have to disclose every contribution of $50 or more and every expenditure of $100 or more. And the reason for that is because the people of Arkansas need to know who's financially
supporting us to get an office in order to either prevent corruption or the appearance of corruption. Similarly, if you engage in what's called, what is currently in the Arkansas Code in an independent expenditure committee where you support or oppose a particular candidate, you're subject to the same disclosure requirements. So if you give $50 or more, or more than $50 to an independent expenditure committee or an IEC, and every $100 expenditure they make, they have to file a report with the Secretary
of State saying what all those contributions and expenditures are. Now, the IEC code is limited to situations of express advocacy, and that's a legal term of art, but what it means is, essentially, is that you have to use the words vote for this candidate or vote against that candidate. And if you don't use those magic words, then there's no disclosure whatsoever. And I think we're all familiar with the political ads, whether they're in mail pieces or hit
pieces on TV that just berate a candidate for 28 seconds, and then for the last two seconds it says, please call this candidate and tell them to stand up for Arkansas. It doesn't say vote against this candidate because these organizations know if they use those magic words of vote against this candidate, then they're subject to full disclosure. And if instead all of the rest of the content of the ad is the same, if at the end they say, please call this candidate and tell them to stand up for the people of Arkansas, then you go from disclosure of every contribution of more than 50 to no disclosure at all.
And these organizations in Arkansas, I'll just tell you, you know, in the last cycle, we had two races for Arkansas State Supreme Court. And in one race, there were $600,000 in TV ads spent. The people of Arkansas have no idea where the sources of that funding came from. And then in another race, there was a half million, $500,000 in dark money spent. And I can promise you these organizations that are spending upwards of half a million dollars, they don't have benign motivations. They have an agenda. And that's okay if you
have an agenda. That's why people support candidates for office. But the people of Arkansas need to know. If you think transparency is good for candidates and independent expenditures, then I believe you also have to believe that transparency is good for these situations. And so that's the problem in a nutshell. And so what this bill attempts to do is to require disclosure in those kinds of situations. It's important to mention that the framework of this bill is based on the McCain-Feingold
Act, which is federal law. And the bulk of this bill is the law in about 25 states. So we're not breaking new ground here. We're trying to make sure that really in states where dark money has become pervasive, those are the states where this type of legislation has been passed in order to address. And I should mention one statistic, it is a nationwide statistic, it's not specific to Arkansas, but there was a study that was conducted that in 2006, 76 percent of money
spent in campaigns was transparent, and in 2014, that number is 29 percent. So in eight years, we've gone from 76 percent to 29 percent. And so what this bill attempts to do is to require disclosure. So the federal law, this legislation is actually narrower than the federal law in a very important respect. The federal law applies to any, so it creates a term called an electioneering communication, and that's basically a political ad, and it has to deal with candidates.
It does not affect issues. If you're advocating for or against a ballot initiative, a constitutional amendment, or other issues, it only applies when you identify a specific candidate for office. And so with the federal law, it actually, the reporting requirement kicks in if you just identify a candidate period. And this language is actually more restrictive than that. The language is if the political ad, if the only reasonable interpretation of the advertisement or communication is that it is an attempt to influence a vote for or against a specific
candidate or a specific set of candidates. Now, I've been working on this for several years. I ran a similar piece of legislation in the 2015 session, and there were a lot of compromises made then and then in the interim. And so I think, you know, it's also important to say that, you know, this includes a lot of provisions that remove concerns that people had that I thought were legitimate. And so I made changes to the legislation. I'll give you an example. If, for example, an organization communicates in a candidate survey and gets their positions
on particular issues, and then they distribute that information to their members, that's not covered by this. So any communication from an organization to its own members is not an electioneering communication by definition, and so there would be no reporting requirement. Anything that you say on your own website or social media platform is not covered. So I mean, this is not an attempt to rein in free speech at all. These ads that exist that I refer to, and I'll just kind of, for the most part, stick
to the Supreme Court ads, I will say in 2014, it was prevalent in the Arkansas Attorney General's race. And I don't think it's fair to associate the other candidates with the dark money ads that came in. to create that implication because a lot of times they're, well, I don't know of any case where they're approved of by the other candidates, but in most cases I think they're not even aware of them. But I just wanted to mention I did have a couple. After the Supreme Court races in 2016, the governor, and I'm not saying the governor
supports this legislation. I frankly don't know what their position on it is. But after the election, the governor said, regrettably, a winner in yesterday's campaign was dark money. reason he made that comment is because in both of the races, in the $500,000 and $600,000, those candidates that had those dark money attacks against them lost. And so we don't know what the election outcome would have been without those ads. The outcome could have been the same, but we do know that in the last two cycles for three seats on the Supreme Court, there have been dark money ads, and those candidates
that were the victims of those ads, for lack of a better term, they lost each of those elections. So anyway, back to what the bill does. That's just so if anything on your social media platform, you actually have to spend money in order for this to kick in. So it's not any sort of attempt to rein in free speech. The actual ads that were used in those Supreme Court races, the content of those ads would not have to change at all. So you could still say whatever you want and you can spend however much money you want to say it. The only difference
is you would have to file a report with the Arkansas Secretary of State that's akin to the report we file to identify the sources of the funding for those ads. And there's no limit to how much you can spend or how much a person can do because that would violate Citizens United. One of the discussions we've had about this particular bill is that whether or not it violates the First Amendment. As of last week, there are now three Supreme Court decisions that affirm disclosure. And so what the Supreme Court found in Citizens United was, you know, that corporations can
spend money and there can't be a limit on that. And so there's nothing in this that affects that at all. There actually was a prior Supreme Court decision, McConnell versus FEC, where they challenged the McCain-Feingold Act. And in that opinion, the Supreme Court upheld disclosure. And actually, the Supreme Court said there are important governmental interests in providing the electorate with information, and those include deterring actual corruption and avoiding any appearance thereof. So that's the Supreme Court upholding disclosure. In Citizens United, the Supreme Court upheld disclosure again as constitutional.
And then just in the last week, there was a new challenge to the McCain-Feingold Act by an organization in Colorado, and they said, oh, Citizens United and disclosure, that only applied to C4 organizations, and we're a C3 organization. Well, they found at the lower levels of the courts that that challenge was unmerited, that disclosure is constitutional, and the Supreme Court felt it was such a simple issue, they did not even take the issue up. They just summarily affirmed that decision. They did not even feel it necessary because disclosure is constitutional.
I can also tell you that these laws in the other states that have passed have been challenged all over the country, and I'm not aware of a single one of the disclosure requirements that's been overturned by a court. And just to kind of show you, at least in my opinion, this is a nonpartisan issue, one of the organizations challenging a disclosure statute in another state in Connecticut was the Democratic Governors Association. So they wanted to overturn the disclosure law passed in the state of Connecticut. And the federal court in Connecticut upheld that law. So I think it's fair to have a policy debate on this, but I feel very strongly in the constitutionality
of it based on the guidance from the Supreme Court of the United States and federal courts all over the country in interpreting the First Amendment and upholding disclosure. So for what that's worth, the other general criticism that has come up is if organizations have to disclose their members, then their members may be subject to some harassment or abuse. And of course, you never want to condone that in any shape, form, or fashion. And the way that that has been addressed in other states and the way that I propose to
address it in this legislation is that your members only have to be disclosed essentially if they're willing to be. There's a mechanism set up in the legislation where if you set up a segregated account, a bank account, and I'll contend that anybody who's sophisticated enough to buy a TV or radio political ad is sophisticated enough to create a second bank account. And then that segregated bank account is set up solely for the purpose of electioneering communications or political advertising, then you only have to disclose the people who give
money to that account. So if you have ABC organization who buys political ads and someone wants to support that organization to the tune of a million dollars, they can still do that without having their name disclosed. They just give it to the general operating fund rather than to the political advertising account. Another change that I just recently made in an amendment is that the organization would only have to disclose the amount that they spent. So let's just say, hypothetically, that ABC Group has $100,000 in their political advertising
account, but they only spend $30,000 of it. They only have to disclose the sources for that $30,000, not for all $100,000. And there's a last-in, first-in accounting method that the legislation directs, and it essentially just says you go with the most recent contributions in reverse chronological order, starting with the most recent. So the idea simply is that if someone makes a contribution to us, they know that their name is going to go on a report filed with the Arkansas Secretary of State. And so by the same token, if you give money to an organization that you know is going
to engage in political advertising, then you would have the same awareness. And I know I'm at the risk of repeating myself just a bit. This law is essentially already in place in 25 states and in federal law. So it actually already is in place in Arkansas for races for federal office, so for congressional races and U.S. Senate races. And so if you hear, you know, about fears of what the impact of the disclosure might
be, just recognize that it already exists here for our federal races, and we haven't seen those impacts here. And so, you know, for those reasons, just to kind of sum up back with the bottom line, And we have a real issue of transparency and the integrity of our democratic process, the election process. And so this is an attempt to restore that and not to change what people can say, but just that you can't say it anonymously. And if you think anonymous internet message board commentary is high quality, I don't
see how anybody can think that based on what we see on the internet. but that's basically the level of discourse that our campaign political discourse has
Speaker 175
1:33:38
fallen to, and this is an attempt to help that situation. So I'd be glad to take
any questions. Okay, Representative Hammer, you're recognized for
a question. Thank you, Ms. Chair, one and a follow-up if allowed. And I want to go to something you just said. And what about, you're talking about, you know, entities having to identify themselves if if they give to, you know, political entities or, you know, and I don't think you said parties,
but I think you said entities or implied that. What if you're a state agency and you receive or you're a branch division agency component of the state and you receive money from general revenue and you are known or you have record of contributing to certain political aspects or groups, how would this bill affect that situation? I'm not totally
following your question, Representative, but I'll give it a shot.
And if I don't answer your question, then please follow up at the Chair's discretion. So this only applies to situations where you buy a TV ad or a direct mail piece or a radio ad where you're advocating essentially for or against the election of a candidate. So I cannot foresee a situation. I think it would be against the law for any state agency to buy political ads supporting the election or defeat of a candidate. And so I don't think it would ever apply to that.
Follow-up, Mr. Chair? You're recognized for follow-up. It may not be a political ad direct, but what if it was an ad that was purchased and placed in a, I don't know, a magazine or something where that particular entity that received that money would benefit? Would it apply in that scenario? Not an ad directly supporting the candidate, but you put an ad in their publication.
what you're asking? Or if the state agency bought an ad. Exactly. Yeah. If state agency or entity of the state who receives general revenue monies or any monies from the state does that, how would this bill affect in that scenario? So, you know, the
first thing is that it has to refer to a clearly identified candidate for public office. So if you're not a clearly identified candidate for public office or if it doesn't refer to any person in particular, then the act has no application.
The second thing is the only reasonable interpretation of the ad has to be that it's an attempt to influence a vote for or against a specific candidate. And I would strongly believe, although I can't say with certainty because I don't know with certainty, that state agencies aren't allowed to use general revenue to buy ads that are going to be an attempt to influence a vote for or against a specific candidate. If in the scenario that I can't imagine whatever happened, that that were to happen, then the state agency would say, you know, we get our money from general revenue that we bought
that ad with. All right. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Okay. Any other questions from the committee? All right. Seeing no question from the committee, we have one person who signed up to speak against Mr. David Ray. If you don't mind taking them to the table and introduce
yourself for the record, you'll be recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is David Ray. I work with Americans for Prosperity Arkansas, and I'm here today to speak against House
Bill 1005. As the representative just explained, this bill seeks to reclassify large amounts of issue speech as electioneering communications and require mandatory reporting of names and addresses of contributors to the government simply because individuals choose to support a cause that they believe in. And one of the primary reasons that we oppose this bill is because it would definitely have
a chilling effect on political speech, thereby discouraging many from making their voice heard in the policy arenas that affect each and every one of us in the state of Arkansas. And that is the intended outcome of this legislation. Senator Chuck Schumer is the sponsor of a federal version of this very idea. And here's what he had to say. He said, quote, I think it's a good idea when someone is trying to influence the government directly with ads and everything else to have a deterrent effect, end quote.
Keep in mind, Senator Schumer was referring to people trying to influence policy and government, not elections. And in a country where free speech is one of our cornerstone principles, the last thing that we need is a deterrent effect on free speech. And while this bill is supposedly about campaign finance reform, in reality it takes aim at individuals' private giving to charitable and nonprofit political organizations. This bill would trigger government reporting mandates, both for 501C3 and 501C4 organizations,
which include groups like the National Rifle Association, NAACP, ACLU, Right to Life, Family Council, all of those types of organizations, and it would have profound impacts on free speech in Arkansas. 501C organizations are not election focused. These organizations exist to promote the social welfare of all of our citizens, and many work to promote the social welfare by educating citizens on the issues and advocating for
policies that they believe would better citizens' lives. The forced reporting of private giving that this bill would trigger also infringes on the privacy of Arkansas citizens and could subject them to threats of harassment, intimidation, and bullying. And unfortunately, that is a problem we see across the country when people weigh in on the hot button issues of the day. You don't have to look much further than the Proposition 8 event out in California,
regarding the definition of marriage there. A lady by the name of Marjorie Christofferson was the manager of a small Mexican restaurant who donated $100 to the pro-traditional marriage Proposition 8 effort in 2008. And when her name turned up on the list of supporters who supported a cause that they believed in, she became the victim of harassment and intimidation. Her restaurant was boycotted for days on end and was picketed outside by protesters.
And ultimately, she was forced to resign from her job at the restaurant. This woman lost her economic livelihood over a $100 contribution to a cause she believed in. Unfortunately, there are dozens of other Marjorie Christoffersons out there who have been harmed when their right to privacy has been violated. The last thing I'll say is Representative Tucker mentioned many times that this bill is about transparency, but it's critical to remember that transparency exists so that
citizens who fund government actions and the elected officials' offices and salaries can know what government is doing with their tax dollars, not so that government can register and monitor the causes that citizens support. Transparency is for government, and privacy is for citizens. Every American and every Arkansan has the right to support causes that he or she believes in without fear of intimidation and harassment, and we hope that each of you will take a stand for a robust marketplace of ideas and vote against this bill.
And if anyone has any questions, I'd be happy to
take those. All right. Any questions from the committee? Okay. Seeing none, I appreciate you testifying, Mr. Ray. Thank you. Okay. We don't have anybody else who's signed up to speak for or against this bill. And so not seeing any, Representative Tucker, you
are recognized to close for your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'll be very brief. you know, for the record, it's not my intent to chill any speech. It's just to make the sources of those advertisements known to the public. And so I just want to say that, you know, this is my
bill. And so as far as my intent goes, it would never be to chill speech. I'm glad Mr. Ray was here so we could have a debate. I support good speech. And so I'm glad he was here to offer those comments. I just, the only other couple of things I would say are that I'm intended to say earlier is that the Bar Association and the Judicial Discipline and Disability Commission both support the bill so far as it relates to judicial elections, and their, you know, basically scope is limited to that area, and so they don't have a position on non-judicial
elections, but they do support it in so far as it affects judicial elections. And just, you know, the last line that Mr. Ray used, which I think is a very effective line that transparency is for government and privacy is for citizens, when it comes to political candidates and elected officials, you know, we are the government. And so the only way for us to be transparent is for the people to know who paid for us to get into these positions. And the point is to, as I mentioned, and as Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote in a Supreme Court
opinion, the point here is to avoid corruption and the appearance of corruption. And so I think But that sort of transparency for elected officials is necessary. And the last thing that I'll mention is Mr. Graham Sloan, who's the director of the Arkansas Ethics Commission, is here, and I just want to point that out for the members and thank him for being here. And if you all had any questions for him or if he wanted to add any comments, I know he would be willing to come to
the table. Okay. Appreciate your testimony. So the question is, what is the will of the committee?
Okay. We have a motion for Representative Ferguson, do pass. Any discussion on that motion? All right. Seeing no discussion on that motion, the motion on the table is do pass from Representative Ferguson. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed, say nay. Nay. The noes have it. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Do you think we got 15 minutes left? Do you feel like you can run your bill in the next 15 minutes? And for other folks, I know there's a lot of people who are waiting to run a bill.
We are meeting upon adjournment, so we'll be back at that point. I think I'll try it another time. Maybe I'll come back this afternoon. Okay. Thank you. We may be a lot nicer at that point. Okay. So let me say at this point, I think, yeah, Representative Douglas, if you want to take the end of the table, we'll see if we can get that one done. And I do, there's several other members of the committee that have, there's not any members who are from other committees here. I'm sure they're not at this point. All right.
Okay. Let me just say that at any point, if we're taking things out of order, any committee member can address that and object to that at any time. What I'm trying to do is be mindful of the members and what they have going on. Actually, and having said that, Representative Tosh, you actually have one that you've got somebody here to testify, don't you? If yours won't take very long, maybe we'll get to that one next, Will. Okay.
the queue ahead of me. I'm not sure that he was directly, but he may have been. But at this point, you know, we'll go ahead. You're down there. Let's get your bill
Speaker 48
1:45:45
moving if it's going to be. Committee, if you're looking at this bill, it is two pages. It has four sections. The change that we are looking at is in the first paragraph. Okay,
for the committee, just so that everyone knows. 17.
1739, House Bill 1739. Yes. The change that we
Speaker 48
1:46:04
are looking at, and we bring this to you for the county clerks, is in the last line of the first paragraph in B, line 27, where it changes it from three to four weeks. That is the change that we're going to make. In discussion with my county clerk this morning, Sharon Brooks, She asked us to strike Sections 2, 3, and 4 from the bill.
I would have to amend that on the Senate side, and I'm willing to do that. Let me say
this, that if that's the case, and it would be the will of the committee, yeah, if you already know of one amendment, go ahead and pull, my recommendation would be to pull it down, and then let's get that amendment done. And now, if you have somebody who's wanting to testify to the bill, if we want to go ahead and get that out of the way, that way you just run it next time. But if you have an amendment we know we're going to make, man, I just think it's going to be a lot easier to clear that up.
Speaker 48
1:47:09
I'm not going to amend it in committee. I'm just promising you I'm going to strike those four sections, and I'm just bringing to you the one change from three to four weeks. It gives the county clerks an extra week to
work on. Yeah, what I guess my recommendation is, though, if we know that we're going to be taking several sections out of this bill, then why wouldn't we just want to do an amendment and get it done? I don't think it's going to slow down the process any, seeing how it will have to be done at some point.
And I think that would be better to let a bill out of this committee that
Speaker 48
1:47:43
has got everybody's agreement on it. It was just a last-minute thing when she was here this morning, and I was going to try to get it by y'all. But if you want me to bring it back amended, then I'll honor
that. That would be my recommendation. Obviously, it's the will of the committee, but that would be my recommendation. Let's pass the bill out that you actually want to be moving. All right. I'll bring it back to you clean. Thank you. Okay. Thank you so much. Representative Tosh, I know that you actually have a couple things you want to get done. And as long as they aren't too exciting, then okay.
Representative Tosh, you have a Senate bill and a resolution. Which one do you want
to run first? We'll do the resolution first, Mr. Chair. Okay. If it's all right with you, I'd like to have join me here at the table with
the Department of Corrections. Yeah, if you don't mind introducing yourself for the record.
Wendy Kelly, I'm sorry. Okay. Thank you. Representative Tosh, you're
recognized to run HRC 1011. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is a House resolution to recognize Dr. Mary Parker-Reed. As all of us know, the Department of Corrections is an important part of our judicial system. It obviously helps our society to stay safe. And Dr. Parker-Reed, she has been instrumental in guiding the entire correction system for over 23 years.
It was her leadership and foresight that spearheaded the program requiring inmates to get a GED before leaving prison. She has been instrumental in changing the lives of so many. And this resolution is to recognize her and for her contributions to the Department of Corrections and to the state of Arkansas. Okay.
I appreciate your presentation. Any questions from the committee?
All right, not seeing any questions from the committee. You are recognized to close for your resolution,
Representative Tosh. Mr. Chair, committee, I'm closed. Appreciate a due pass. Okay,
so we'll take that as a motion. Do pass. Any discussion on the motion? All right, all in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? All right, congratulations, Representative Tosh. You passed your
resolution. Mr. Chair, one more thing. I've just handed a note. If you don't mind, as the chair, would you recognize there are a lot of the several board members from the correction,
Department of Correction is here that that support this resolution and we're here to testify if necessary. Could you recognize them? Sure. I have no problem. If
they don't mind standing up, so we'll we'll know. I appreciate you all hanging around as long as you have. Thank you. And we appreciate the work that you do. Okay, Representative Tosh, you want to run Senate Bill 292? Senate Bill.
Okay, so what House bill you got? 2165. Okay.
Okay, you are recognized from House Bill 2165. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Colleagues, this bill is to reduce our obviously regulations for small business.
It's a business-friendly bill. What this bill does is in a lot of our small towns across the state, there are venues where they have these wrestling events, and there's so many. They actually visited with the health department, and they're on board with this. As a matter of fact, they help us write the draft, the bill. What it does is that they were, the wrestling events, they were actually placed under combative sports, and anytime you're under combative sports, you are under a lot more.
more strenuous rules and regulations that you have to abide by, and we felt like it was actually placing an undue and unnecessary burden on these small venues across the state that were just trying to provide some type of theatrical entertainment, and so what this bill does, it reduces those regulations that's required of them. The Health Department and the Athletic Commission, they have, like I said, helped draft this bill. They're on board with it, and I'll give you one quick example. without belaboring the issue, and that is like in a small town,
if they have an event going on, they are required, they were required under the combative sports part of the statute, they had to have an ambulance on site, they had to have an EMT on site. In a lot of these small towns, it may be the only ambulance actually there, and if they had to leave and make a run, the event had to stop. They had to shut the event down, So it was just a lot of unnecessary regulations, and I really appreciate the Athletic Commission and the Health Department working to get them out from under the extraneous regulations
and let them be able to have a little entertainment, invite some fun in these small towns, and be able to do so and make a little bit
of money anyways. Okay. Thank you. Any questions from the committee? I just want to say my wife texted me and said how boring we are, and I don't know what's more exciting than providing
freedom to professional wrestling. And I might add this, Mr. Chair, one of the hardest things in presenting this bill was that I saw, I was really pleased. Sometimes when you tell some of the members that wrestling is theatrical and it's fake, sometimes they can get pretty belligerent with you.
So I appreciate nobody reacting in that manner. Okay. Representative Hammond, did
we induce a question out of you or do you just have a motion? I
just want to know if you think the legislative branch ought to be moved under the combative sports category or should we stay where we are?
It's moving more in that direction every day. Thank you. All
right. Okay, we actually have two people signed up to speak for the bill.
Okay, so it sounds like it's probably going pretty good for you. so there's probably no reason to testify. I appreciate the endorsement, though. All right, so not having anybody else who's signed up to speak against the bill, you're recognized, Mr. Tosh, to represent Tosh to close for your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
I'm closed, and I would ask for a due pass. Okay, we have a motion due
pass on the table. Any discussion on the motion? Okay, all in favor, say aye.
Aye. And opposed? All right, congratulations, Mr. Tosh. You, Tosh, you passed your bill. Okay, we have four minutes left. I'm going to say that's probably not enough time to do anything unless the committee can convince me otherwise. We do, you think you can get it done in four minutes? Yeah. All right, well, let's give it a try. He says one minute. Somebody, somebody start a timer. I think people are questioning whether your ability to speak in one minute is even possible,
Representative Hammer. Representative Hammer, what bill are you running? Mr. Chair, it is going to be 2065,
and if it hits noon and I'm not done, I'll stop. Well, that's what it
is. I bet we can finish it up. You are recognized to run House Bill 2065. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. Let me pull it up on the screen here real quick.
This bill comes as a result of having been the past House Chair of Legislative Audit and then sitting through the meetings the last two years. And one specific example comes to mind about a museum where the board members were not being provided regular monthly statements, and so it accumulated over a period of years, and it resulted in some theft charges and, you know, the director basically just keeping stuff from the board.
So what this bill does is states that any state agency or supported library or museum that has an executive board, they've got to be provided a monthly statement, and that would help for transparency and try to hopefully minimize some of these things that are occurring that are, you know, coming through the leg audit, and that's what it's all about. So I'll be glad to answer any questions. Okay. Any questions
from the committee? All right. Seeing no questions from the committee, then you're recognized to close for your bill. I'd
appreciate a due pass and did that in about two minutes for the record. I'd like that noted, please.
Okay. Motion on table is due pass. All in favor, say aye. Opposed? All right. Congratulations. You passed your bill. All right. I appreciate the work that this committee has done today. It's not been easy, and we've got a lot done. What I would say is that we are planning on meeting probably 15 minutes upon adjournment, so we are adjourned. You
Agenda
SPECIAL ORDER OF BUSINESS Subtitle Sponsor Number
SB341 L. Eads TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING APPOINTMENTS TO BOARDS, CERTAIN COMMISSIONS, COMMITTEES, AND OTHER ADMINISTRATIVE BODIES.
RE-REFERRED TO COMMITTEE TO CONCUR IN SENATE AMENDMENT Subtitle Sponsor Number
HB1440 M. Gray TO AMEND PROVISIONS IN THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING ELECTION RUNOFFS, INITIATIVES, AND REFERENDA.
RE-REFERRED Subtitle Sponsor Number
SB373 Hester TO EXEMPT ATTORNEY-CLIENT COMMUNICATIONS AND ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT FROM THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967.
REGULAR AGENDA Sponsor Number Subtitle
HB1622 Johnson TO CREATE A PROCEDURE FOR ADDRESSING BURDENSOME REQUESTS FOR DISCLOSURE; TO AMEND THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967; TO CREATE AN AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1623 Johnson TO AMEND THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967; TO AMEND THE LAW TO AND AN DECLARE GUIDANCE; INFORMATION CONCERNING PUBLIC FOR EMERGENCY.
HB1675 Sturch TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS' MEMORIAL.
HB1696 D. Meeks TO TRANSFER THE STATE CHILD ABUSE AND NEGLECT PREVENTION BOARD TO THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES THROUGH A TYPE 3 TRANSFER; AND TO ABOLISH THE STATE CHILD ABUSE AND NEGLECT PREVENTION BOARD.
SB292 Maloch TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE TRANSFER AND INVESTMENT DUTIES OF THE TREASURER OF STATE; TO AMEND THE TIME REQUIREMENTS APPLICABLE TO CERTAIN TRANSFERS OF STATE FUNDS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
SB377 Hickey CONCERNING THE ELIGIBILITY OF AN INMATE OF THE DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION TO PARTICIPATE IN A WORK-RELEASE PROGRAM OR UNDER ACT 309 OF 1983.
HB1707 M. Gray TO AMEND THE DATES OF THE GENERAL PRIMARY ELECTION AND PREFERENTIAL PRIMARY ELECTION; TO AMEND THE TIME PERIOD FOR FILING AS A CANDIDATE FOR A PRIMARY ELECTION; AND TO AMEND THE TIME FOR THE FISCAL SESSION.
HB1725 D. Douglas TO TRANSFER VARIOUS STATE AGENCIES TO THE AGRICULTURE ARKANSAS DEPARTMENT THROUGH A TYPE 4 TRANSFER.
HB1065 Watson PERMITTING THE ARKANSAS COMMISSION ON LAW ENFORCEMENT STANDARDS AND TRAINING TO MAKE ADDITIONAL SALARY PAYMENTS ABOVE THE BASIC CERTIFICATE LEVEL.
HB1570 Brown TO PROVIDE STATUTORY GUIDANCE CONCERNING INTERSTATE CONVENTIONS UNDER THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION, ARTICLE V.
HB1004 Blake TO CREATE THE DEMOCRACY ACT; TO REQUIRE AUTOMATIC VOTER REGISTRATION; AND TO AMEND AMENDMENT 51 OF THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION.
HB1207 Dalby TO AMEND REQUIREMENTS FOR CAMPAIGN SIGNS AND MATERIALS.
HB1008 Tucker TO INCREASE THE PENALTY FOR TAKING CAMPAIGN FUNDS AS PERSONAL INCOME; AND TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF ARKANSAS LAW RESULTING FROM INITIATED ACT 1 OF 1990 AND INITIATED ACT 1 OF 1996.
HB1005 Tucker TO REQUIRE REPORTING AND DISCLOSURE OF ELECTIONEERING COMMUNICATIONS; AND TO RESTRICT THE AMOUNT OF MONEY SPENT ON CAMPAIGN COMMUNICATIONS PRODUCED IN COORDINATION WITH A CANDIDATE FOR OFFICE.
HB1739 C. Douglas TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING PRIMARY ELECTIONS, RUNOFF ELECTIONS, AND SPECIAL ELECTIONS.
HB1741 Vaught TO ESTABLISH A BLUE ALERT NOTIFICATION SYSTEM; AND CONCERNING EMERGENCY ASSISTANCE TO LAW ENFORCEMENT.
HB1765 Holcomb TO IMPROVE ELECTION ADMINISTRATION TRANSPARENCY; AND TO RESOLVE A CONFLICT IN THE LAW CONCERNING PUBLIC NOTICE OF ELECTIONS.
HB1766 D. Douglas TO CREATE "THE NONPARTISAN BLANKET PRIMARY ACT"; TO INSTITUTE THE NONPARTISAN BLANKET PRIMARY ELECTION SYSTEM; AND TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS ELECTION CODE.
SB38 A. Clark TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ELECTIONS AND BALLOTS.
SJR7 Rapert AN APPLICATION TO CONGRESS TO CALL A CONVENTION FOR PROPOSING AN AMENDMENT TO THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION CONCERNING THE DEFINITION OF "MARRIAGE".
SJR9 Rapert AN APPLICATION TO CONGRESS TO CALL A CONVENTION FOR PROPOSING AN AMENDMENT TO THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION PROVIDING THAT EVERY HUMAN BEING IS ENTITLED TO THE RIGHT TO LIFE.
HB1792 J. Williams TO AMEND THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DELIVERY AND STORAGE OF BALLOT STUBS.
HB1807 Collins TO ENSURE THE FUTURE FUNDING OF THE STATE HEALTH DEPARTMENT BUILDING AND LOCAL GRANT TRUST FUND.
HB1819 K. Hendren CONCERNING BALLOT TITLES AND POPULAR NAMES OF CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS PROPOSED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY.
HB1823 Collins TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS PAPERWORK EFFICIENCY AND TRANSPARENCY ACT; TO PERMIT ELECTRONIC DOCUMENT SUBMISSIONS AND PUBLICATIONS; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE INSPECTION OF PUBLIC RECORDS.
HB1832 House TO ALLOW THE EMPLOYMENT OF SPECIAL COUNSEL BY A STATE OFFICIAL OR ENTITY IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES; AND TO REQUIRE SPECIAL COUNSEL TO OBTAIN APPROVAL BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL BEFORE ENTERING INTO A SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT.
HCR1011 Tosh COMMENDING DR. MARY PARKER-REED AND HER COMMITMENT AND SERVICE TO THE AND CORRECTION DEPARTMENT OF DEPARTMENT THE OF COMMUNITY CORRECTION.
HB1866 Lundstrum TO EXEMPT CERTAIN INFORMATION PERTAINING TO A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER FROM THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967; AND CONCERNING PUBLIC RECORD WEBSITES.
SB380 Hester TO EXEMPT CERTAIN COMMODITIES AND SERVICES UNDER ARKANSAS THE PROCUREMENT LAW.
HB1892 C. Douglas TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING UNOPPOSED CANDIDATES.
HB1893 M. Gray TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS PROCUREMENT LAW; AND TO AMEND THE VENDOR REPORTING REQUIREMENTS FOR STATE CONTRACTS.
HB1270 Johnson TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ELECTIONS AND BALLOTS.
HB1931 Gillam CONCERNING THE APPROVAL OF BALLOT TITLES AND POPULAR NAMES OF PETITIONS PRIOR TO CIRCULATION.
HB1932 Gillam CONCERNING THE REVIEW OF RULES PROMULGATED BY THE STATE BOARD OF HEALTH AND THE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH.
HB1944 C. Douglas TO ESTABLISH A GRANT ADVISORY BOARD; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DISBURSEMENT OF CERTAIN FEDERAL FUNDS RECEIVED BY THE STATE.
HB1975 Dotson TO ADOPT THE COMPACT FOR A BALANCED BUDGET; AND TO ADOPT A PROPOSED AMENDMENT TO THE COMPACT FOR A BALANCED BUDGET.
HB1988 Lundstrum CONCERNING COUNTY JAIL REIMBURSEMENT FOR HOUSING STATE INMATES.
HB1995 Della Rosa TO AMEND THE OFFICIAL HOLIDAYS; TO REFINE THE TEACHING OF HISTORY IN THE CLASSROOM; TO SPECIFY THE TEACHING OF CONTENT RELATED TO DR. MARTIN LUTHER KING JR. IN CONJUNCTION WITH THE CORRESPONDING HOLIDAY.
HB2033 Shepherd TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION TO ESTABLISH A CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECK POLICY FOR CERTAIN PERSONS APPLYING FOR OR OCCUPYING A POSITION HAVING ACCESS TO FEDERAL TAX INFORMATION.
HB2035 D. Douglas TO AMEND THE DATES FOR PROCESSING ABSENTEE BALLOTS.
HB2053 Hammer TO TRANSFER THE ARKANSAS FAIR HOUSING COMMISSION TO THE ARKANSAS DEVELOPMENT FINANCE AUTHORITY.
HB2055 Hammer CONCERNING REMEDIES AVAILABLE TO PERSONS TERMINATED IN VIOLATION OF THE ARKANSAS WHISTLE-BLOWER ACT.
HB2065 Hammer TO REQUIRE STATE AGENCIES AND CERTAIN STATE-SUPPORTED ENTITIES TO SUBMIT TO ITS BOARD A MONTHLY FINANCIAL REPORT.
HB2074 Leding TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING INITIATIVES AND REFERENDA.
HB2095 G. Hodges TO ESTABLISH VOTE CENTERS ON THE CAMPUSES OF STATE-SUPPORTED POSTSECONDARY AND HIGHER EDUCATION INSTITUTIONS; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING VOTE CENTERS.
HB2096 G. Hodges TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF PROCUREMENT LAW TO REFLECT THE IMPACT OF INFLATION ON THE COST OF GOODS AND SERVICES AND TO ENCOURAGE MORE PARTICIPATION BY SMALL BUSINESSES.
HB2162 Gonzales TO PROMOTE VOTER TURNOUT; TO AMEND THE LAW TO LIMIT THE DATES ON WHICH CERTAIN SPECIAL ELECTIONS CAN BE HELD; TO AMEND THE LAW THAT RESULTED FROM INITIATED ACT 1 OF 1942.
HB2165 Tosh TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE STATE ATHLETIC COMMISSION AND PROFESSIONAL WRESTLING.
HB2183 Lowery TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS WHISTLE-BLOWER ACT; AND TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "WHISTLEBLOWER".
HB2196 Henderson TO AMEND LANGUAGE CONCERNING THE SPORT OF PROFESSIONAL WRESTLING; AND TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION FOR CHARTABLE EVENTS.
HB2200 M. Hodges TO MODIFY THE DEFINITION OF "SMALL PROCUREMENTS"; TO INCREASE THE ABILITY OF THE STATE TO CONTRACT WITH CERTIFIED MINORITY BUSINESS ENTERPRISES; AND TO ELIMINATE BURDENSOME DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENTS.
HB2242 Davis TO AMEND THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967 CONCERNING DATA RELATED TO A PUBLIC WATER SYSTEM OR MUNICIPALLY OWNED UTILITY SYSTEM.
HB2259 Walker TO REQUIRE THE PASSAGE OF THE CIVICS PORTION OF THE NATURALIZATION TEST USED BY UNITED STATES CITIZENSHIP AND IMMIGRATION SERVICES BEFORE A MEMBER OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY MAY VOTE FOR OR AGAINST A BILL OR RESOLUTION.
HB2260 Walker TO REQUIRE THE PASSAGE OF THE CIVICS PORTION OF THE NATURALIZATION TEST USED BY UNITED STATES CITIZENSHIP AND IMMIGRATION SERVICES BEFORE A PERSON MAY BE ELIGIBLE TO SERVE AS A DIRECTOR OR HEAD OF A STATE AGENCY.
HB2261 Walker TO REQUIRE THE PASSAGE OF THE CIVICS PORTION OF THE NATURALIZATION TEST USED BY UNITED STATES CITIZENSHIP AND IMMIGRATION SERVICES BEFORE A PERSON MAY BE ELIGIBLE TO SERVE AS A CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICER OF THIS STATE.
HCR1014 V. Flowers REQUESTING AND PETITIONING THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS TO PROPOSE FOR SUBMISSION TO THE STATES FOR CONTINUED RATIFICATION AN EQUAL RIGHTS AMENDMENT.
HB1046 Tucker TO PERMIT PAID MATERNITY LEAVE FOR STATE EMPLOYEES.
HJR1001 Ballinger APPLYING TO THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS TO CALL A CONVENTION FOR PROPOSING AMENDMENTS PURSUANT TO ARTICLE V OF THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION.
HB1011 Sabin TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE CONTRIBUTIONS; AND TO PROHIBIT DIRECT CONTRIBUTIONS BETWEEN POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEES.
HB1012 Sabin TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEES; AND TO ACTION POLITICAL TO COMMITTEES DIRECT PROHIBIT FROM CONTRIBUTIONS CANDIDATES.
HB1179 Ballinger TO PROMOTE AND IMPROVE EFFICIENCY AND QUALITY IN THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES; AND TO REORGANIZE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES.
HB1009 Leding TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING APPROVED POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEES; AND TO PREVENT A MEMBER OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY FROM FORMING MORE THAN ONE (1) APPROVED POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE.
HB1289 Ballinger TO PROMOTE AND IMPROVE EFFICIENCY AND QUALITY IN THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES; AND TO REORGANIZE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES.
HB1386 Lemons TO REQUIRE THE FILING OF FINAL AGENCY RULES WITH THE ARKANSAS STATE LIBRARY; AND TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURE ACT.
HB1447 M. Gray TO TRANSFER THE STATE BOARD OF ELECTION COMMISSIONERS TO THE OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OF STATE; TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING COMPLAINTS OF ELECTION LAW VIOLATIONS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1151 Davis TO REQUIRE THAT REGISTERED VOTERS BE NOTIFIED BY MAIL OF THE DATES FOR CERTAIN SPECIAL ELECTIONS; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING SPECIAL ELECTIONS
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Bob Ballinger Chair
Unverified
Representative Grant Hodges
Unverified
Speaker 9
Representative Jeff Williams
Unverified
Representative Hendon
Unverified
Representative Kim Hendren Chair
Unverified
Speaker 24
Speaker 33
Speaker 37
Speaker 48
Speaker 49
Representative Jim Dotson
Unverified
Speaker 55
Speaker 64
Speaker 68
Representative Kim Hammer
Unverified
Carol Johnson
Unverified
Representative Warwick Sabin
Unverified
Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson
Unverified
Speaker 106
Representative Monte Hodges
Unverified
Speaker 119
Speaker 120
Speaker 121
Representative Josh Miller
Unverified
Speaker 131
Speaker 141
Representative Richard Womack
Unverified
Speaker 153
Speaker 155
Dan Greenberg
Unverified
Speaker 164
Speaker 168
Speaker 93
Representative Clarke Tucker
Unverified
Speaker 175
Speaker 179
David Ray
Unverified
Representative Dwight Tosh
Unverified
Speaker 113
Speaker 195
Speaker 135