Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Insurance and Commerce Committee

March 8, 2017 ·Committee Room 149 ·1:55:47
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (34)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1594 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1594 Sabin TO REVISE THE DEFINITION OF "PAID SOLICITOR" AS IT RE…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB369 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…Representative Collins, you're recognized to tell us about Senate Bill 369.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1166 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…presentative Sabin. Thank you. The next bill on our list is House Bill 1166, Representative Rushing.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1448 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1448 M. Gray TO INCLUDE FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS INSURED BY THE NA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1742 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1742 Rushing CONCERNING A CIVIL ACTION INVOLVING A DECEPTIVE TRA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1752 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “We'll go to Representative Collins for House Bill 1752. Oh, so you do want to run the next one. All right. Represe…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1145 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1145 C. Douglas TO RESTRICT A JOINT TENANT'S ABILITY TO SEVER A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1750 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1750 Cozart TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE NOTICE OF A LIEN UPO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1751 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1751 Cozart TO CLARIFY THE RESPONSIBILITIES OF AN INSURER FOR AP…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1753 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1753 Collins TO CLARIFY THAT THE SUBROGATION AND REIMBURSEMENT R…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1799 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1799 Lundstrum TO AMEND THE UNIFORM MONEY SERVICES ACT.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1800 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1800 Lundstrum TO AMEND VARIOUS STATE SECURITIES LAWS; AND TO RE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1801 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1801 Lundstrum TO AMEND THE FAIR MORTGAGE LENDING ACT.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1828 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1828 Warren CONCERNING THE ARKANSAS TITLE INSURANCE ACT; AND TO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1838 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1838 S. Meeks TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE HEALTH SAVINGS ACC…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1840 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1840 Johnson CONCERNING THE APPLICATION OF INSURANCE PROCEEDS RE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1890 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1890 Tucker TO ESTABLISH AN ARKANSAS CROWD FUNDING OPTION; AND T…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1900 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1900 Bentley TO AMEND THE REQUIREMENTS FOR HEALTH INSURANCE COVE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1958 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1958 M. Gray CONCERNING THE CREDIT SERVICES ORGANIZATIONS ACT OF…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2042 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2042 Drown TO CLARIFY PROVISIONS CONCERNING REAL ESTATE LICENSE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2043 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2043 Drown CONCERNING THE REGULATION OF TELEPHONIC SELLERS.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2044 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2044 Drown TO MODIFY THE REGISTRATION OF CHARITABLE ORGANIZATION…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2054 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2054 Hammer TO REPEAL THE ARKANSAS HOUSING TRUST FUND ACT OF 200…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2061 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2061 Hammer TO MODERNIZE THE FIRE RATING SYSTEM IN ARKANSAS; AND…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2086 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2086 Sabin TO PROTECT THE PROPERTY RIGHTS OF CITIZENS; TO PREVEN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2087 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2087 Sabin TO OPEN ADDITIONAL BUSINESS OPPORTUNITIES TO COOPERAT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2135 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2135 Sabin TO CLARIFY THE OBLIGATIONS OF RESIDENTIAL LANDLORDS A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2139 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2139 D. Whitaker CONCERNING FRAUDULENT TRANSFERS AND VOIDABLE TR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2213 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2213 Henderson CONCERNING ARKANSAS PRICE DISCRIMINATION; TO ALLO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2240 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2240 Gonzales TO EXEMPT DIRECT PRIMARY CARE AGREEMENTS FROM INSU…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2249 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2249 Gazaway CONCERNING FRAUDULENT TRANSFERS AND VOIDABLE TRANSA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2251 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2251 Gazaway CONCERNING THE PERSONAL INFORMATION PROTECTION ACT;…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB421 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB421 Rapert TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS BUSINESS CORPORATION ACT OF 19…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB422 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB422 Rapert O AMEND CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS BANKING C…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
today. So what we're going to do is we're going to start at the top. We're going to move expeditiously through the numbers. I do not envision us getting back to the top again if we wind up passing over a bill during this period of time because there are so many on the list. I'm considering doing a meeting after session today, so we'll assess that based on how the day goes. The first bill on our calendar is House Bill 1594. Representative to save, and you're recognized to present House Bill 1594. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
And with your permission, I'd like to bring up a couple of people from Heifer International to help me present the bill.
▶ Play
Yes, they're welcome to come up, and then they can just introduce themselves and who they're with for the record, and then they'll be recognized to speak as needed. You're
▶ Play
Speaker 8 0:51
about to say your names and who you're writing. Good morning.
▶ Play
Chad Avery, General Counsel with Heifer International. All right. Good morning. My name is Chris Morgan. I'm
▶ Play
associate counsel at Heifer International. And Mr. Chair, basically this bill makes some pretty, I think, just clear and straightforward changes to the definition of a paid solicitor for the purpose of fundraising. And this issue was actually brought to me by these fine folks from Heifer International, which is, of course, an international nonprofit organization based here in Little Rock. And I thought it would be most helpful, since they're the lawyers and they're the ones who asked for this, if they could just simply explain what we're trying to do and why we're trying to do
▶ Play
Speaker 8 1:29
it. So go ahead. Thank you. Glad to. Good morning and thank you. As the representative said, this statute regulates the solicitation. Could you just
▶ Play
introduce yourself and who you're with for the
▶ Play
Speaker 8 1:38
record, please? Yes, sir. Chad Avery with Heifer International. I'm general counsel there. Thank you. You're welcome. This statute regulates the solicitation of charitable donations by paid solicitors in Arkansas. So it protects donors and it protects the charities by making sure that donors have confidence whenever they donate to the charity. And, of course, we fully support that. All of our paid solicitors register under this statute. But when it was drafted, I believe it was accidentally drafted in a manner that was overly broad. It's meant to ensure that paid solicitors register and post a bond and pay a fee, which is appropriate. There's a second piece of the definition that sweeps in anyone who has care or custody of funds. So it accidentally, for example, would include a school that's collecting donations for the Red Cross or a company that sponsors a charity and collects donations over the holiday season. So our intent is to remove that second part of the definition so that it only regulates paid solicitors and not individuals who simply have care custody of funds. All right, it makes sense to me. Is there
▶ Play
anybody in the committee that has any questions? Representative Lundstrom, you're recognized for a question. Does this impact campaign finance
▶ Play
any? This change should not, to my knowledge,
▶ Play
Speaker 8 3:11
no, ma'am. Thank you. Are there any other questions from the committee?
▶ Play
Seeing none, is there anyone that wants to speak against the bill? And I think we've got some people signed up to speak for the bill. But I think where we are right now is a place which is pretty good for the bill. So you're going to be recognized to speak for it, but just remember, it is possible to buy it back. Did you all sign? Just the ones that are already down there? Okay, all right. So, is there anyone that would like to speak for
▶ Play
Speaker 21 3:49
the bill? Representative Saban, are you closed for your bill?
▶ Play
Yes, I'm closed, thank you. I move that we pass House Bill 1594. Is there any discussion? All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Sabin, you passed the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I apologize that the people that were signed up were already down at the end. That was my mistake. I apologize. Thank you. Thank you. Congratulations, Representative Sabin. Thank you. The next bill on our list is House Bill 1166, Representative Rushing. Is Representative Rushing here to present the bill? She's not here. Now, what I'm going to do is I'm going to turn the chair over to Representative Lundstrom. And I'm going to do
▶ Play
Speaker 28 4:35
369. So that I can do 369. Wait
▶ Play
till you get to the end. And then just keep going because I think she may be gone. All right. Representative Collins, you're recognized to tell us about Senate Bill 369.
▶ Play
If you could recognize your guests. Oops, Mark Whitmore, Association of Arkansas Counties. Thank you very much, Madam Chair. So Senate Bill 369 is a clarification bill. We currently have associations for local governments, municipalities, that are providing services to the individual counties or individual cities, and legal services is an example, et cetera. And what we want to do is, even though they've been operating under a belief If that they're within the confines of the law, the law is somewhat unclear. And so what this bill does is clarifies that those associations have no legal issues with providing those types of services to their members. So that's really what this business does, and I've got Mr. Whitmore here to answer any questions if we have any. Does anybody have any questions?
▶ Play
Seeing none, do we have anybody that would like to speak for the bill? Against the bill? Representative Collins, you're recognized to close your bill. I'm closed, Madam Chair. Members, Representative Jett has given a due pass. Those in favor? Aye. Those opposed? Congratulations, Representative Collins. You've passed your bill. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you. Next up, we have Representative Gray with House Bill 1448. Representative Gray, we're going to pass over. All right. We'll go to Representative Collins for House Bill 1752. Oh, so you do want to run the next one. All right. Representative Gray, you're recognized. For 1742. With the chair's
▶ Play
permission, I'd like to ask that Kevin Kras be up here with me. Thank you.
▶ Play
Folks, it's 1742. She's running it in place of Representative Rushing. Representative Gray? Yes, thank you. So it's
▶ Play
House Bill 1742 and Representative Rushing. I'm on the bill with her, but she had a special order in another committee, so she wasn't able to be here. So what we are doing with this bill is making some changes to the Deceptive Trade Practices Act. A few things that we're doing, we're making it so that for someone to file a claim under class action. I'm sorry to interrupt. Do you have an amendment we need to hear first? No, not on this particular bill. All right, thank
▶ Play
Speaker 59 8:18
you. Let me, Will, if there are amendments, I would. I think
▶ Play
Speaker 61 8:23
we do. I don't know of any. I don't know of any.
▶ Play
Speaker 62 8:27
Let me just double check because we, you know, filed
▶ Play
Speaker 66 8:30
500 bills the other day. Let's get it right. That sounds great. I do. I do. All right. Thank you. All right. All
▶ Play
right. This amendment, what it does, it essentially adds one word to the bill that the Attorney General's office had asked for, adds the word specifically to the bill. All right. Thank
▶ Play
you. I forgot about that. Motion. I recognize Representative Vought. Thank you. We have a motion to pass. All in favor? Aye. Thank you. Representative Gray, if you
▶ Play
could continue on. All right. Let's see if I can talk and sign at the same time. But this essentially says that a person who wants to file a claim under the deceptive trade practice has to have an actual financial loss in order to do that. And then as I reach over, it's just a two-page bill, essentially says that...
▶ Play
Speaker 62 9:22
All right. Thank you. Do I get the
▶ Play
Speaker 73 9:27
key point? I'm going to take that one that you just
▶ Play
signed. Thank you. Okay, now we're good. I think we're cooking. I may have to start over. Okay, and it essentially says that to prevail on a claim brought under this subsection, a claimant must prove individually that he or she suffered an actual financial loss based on his or her reliance of the use of a practice declared unlawful under this chapter. So essentially what it does, representative actions involving the Deceptive Trade Practices Act can be brought by the Attorney General. Right now, they're allowed under this. With this bill, we're saying they can be brought individually. Or if they want to be brought as a class action, it will go through the AG's office. So it doesn't prevent it. It just limits it. Class action lawsuits are very easy to certify here in Arkansas. So we're just trying to get a little better control on that. So they must show actual financial loss. They must show that they relied on deceptive advertising. And just to clarify, we put in the bill that the right to a jury trial is no way affected by this. We actually put in the legislation that a right to a jury trial is still available. And so what I want to do, I've got Kevin Crass here, and he's going to kind of explain the history of how this bill or how this act came to be and kind of what's brought us to where we are and the need that we have today for this bill. Thank you, Representative Gray.
▶ Play
Madam Chairman, my name is Kevin Crass. I'm sorry, sir. Hang on just a second. We have a couple of folks that want to ask
▶ Play
Speaker 87 11:10
questions before you address this. Representative Lowry? Representative Armstrong? Thanks, Madam Chair. Mr. Crass, could you, in your explanation, we've got a payday lending venue in North Little Rock that constituents have battled for some time to try and remove how this may impact those that are trying to seek attorneys for these cases that may not take them on because the amount of reward par se to the attorney will be so minimal.
▶ Play
Could you- I'd be happy to do that, Representative Armstrong. It might be in the context later, but I'll be sure to address that. As I said, my name is Kevin Krass. I've practiced law for about 33 years with the Little Rock firm of Friday, Eldridge, and Clark. I head up our group internally at the firm that handles class actions and business litigation. I've handled a number of class actions on the defense side, a couple on the plaintiff's side. So I'm fairly familiar with the class action practice in this state. You're here though to consider an amendment to the Deceptive Trade Practices Act, and I'd like to just share briefly a little history of that. When that law first went on the books, it only allowed the Attorney General to bring a claim for deceptive trade practices. Now, if you look in the statutes, there are a number of other statutes that deal with unfair and deceptive trade practices with regard to specific businesses, whether I'm looking at the index, credit card solicitation, employment offices, foundation repair work. There are a number that catch specific industries. This one though was very broad when it was passed and it was strictly giving the Attorney General the right to to enforce these deceptive trade practices. There was a very small exception to that for elderly, but it's not really relevant here. And sometime in the 90s, the legislature amended the Deceptive Trade Practice Act, and it had a dramatic change because it kept the power of the Attorney General to bring a claim, which he or she continued to do throughout this bill's existence. But it also allowed a private citizen to bring a claim in the event they had suffered damage by way of violation of the act. The problem with that when it was passed, and I doubt anybody foresaw it, is what the Attorney General has to prove to recover what the state's purpose is and what a private citizen has to prove can be very different. And so what this bill is trying to do is to create a balance where it defines the actual damage, because there's been a lot of litigation about, well, what damage has to be the result of a violation for a private citizen to recover? Secondly, there was a significant omission, I believe, in the act as it applies to a private citizen's claim, where the private citizen had to prove that he or she had relied upon the misrepresentations or unfair trade practice. Simply stated, if I were a wireless telephone company, I used to do a lot of work for Altel and they'd get sued, and class actions of the deceptive trade practice for some ad that they had run. Well, most plaintiffs had never even read the act, or the ad. They certainly didn't rely on something they didn't read, and yet they had a claim under the Deceptive Trade Practice Act. So that's the Deceptive Trade Practice Act. What has to be considered in the context of this bill is the Arkansas law on class actions. In 1994, there was a professor at UALR that wrote a law review article. And these are his words, not mine. He described the Arkansas class action law as the most liberal in the country. Now, if it was the most liberal in the country in 1994, it'd be interesting to see how he would describe it in 2017. Because since 1994, I was on a panel one time at an Arkansas Bar Association on class actions, and a plaintiff's lawyer said, if you can't get a class action certified in Arkansas, the plaintiff's lawyers committed malpractice. That's a pretty bold statement, but so what does it mean when there's a class action? It means one person can represent hundreds, they can represent thousands. Some of those people don't think they have a claim, don't want to participate. And it creates a tremendous leverage against businesses. As I say, I've probably been involved in over 50 class actions on the defense side. I've probably been aware of hundreds of them. I can only think of three that actually went to trial after certification, which is pretty routine in this state, because companies cannot risk. You read recently about the case against Philip Morris and smokers. They just can't risk a billion-dollar judgment. You think, well, a billion-dollar judgment wouldn't happen in Arkansas. In fact, it has within the last few years. Fortunately, the Supreme Court reversed it. So what this combination of the deceptive trade practice and the class action law has in my view, and again, I make a living defending class actions. There are some who would say, why do you want to stop class actions under the Deceptive Trade Practice Act? But it's not fair to the defendants, it's not fair to the businesses of the state. And it's not going to take away the right of plaintiffs to seek recourse. And to Representative Armstrong's question, you know, plaintiff's lawyers very effectively use the class action tools to go after payday lenders. I would say with all due respect to my friends at plaintiff's lawyers, they didn't shut them down. The Attorney General shut them down. This body shut them down. And the fact that now a class action can't be brought by a private citizen under the Deceptive Trade Practice Act is not going to result in payday lenders proliferating this state. And to me, it's sort of a false argument that you should be opposed to this because you're opposed to payday lending. There are other remedies. What you're dealing here is with the balance of you've put the businesses in this state and the businesses from out of state that want to do business here in a very unfair place because it's difficult to defend. And, you know, you hear a lot of crazy examples. I tell people a limit on the class actions theory is limited only by a good plaintiff's lawyers' vivid imagination. You know, we've got one in the office right now where the class consists of state inmates who claim they were overcharged for calling cards. maybe there's a lot of sympathy here for calling cards sold in state prisons but that was a that was struck me as sort of an abuse of the system you could give more examples but you know put aside the abuses my contention is this is a chance to it's not so much tort reform and i was asked by the american tort reform association to come here it's really litigation reform and it's pro business and I believe it, uh, uh, is the right thing to do. So thank you. I'd be happy to answer any questions. I believe we do
▶ Play
have questions. Representative Lowry. Thank you, Madam Chair.
▶ Play
I understand, I understand your position that you, you want to, um, uh, protect businesses from being treated unfairly, but you know, I, my, my issue here is that, you know, I don't care if If a business is doing something unlawful, we don't need to protect them. And this actually does do that, especially if you're talking about an unlawful, deceptive practice that an individual may only have a small loss that they can prove under this bill. They're not going to be able to go to it. They don't have the deep pockets. They've already been cheated. they're not going to be able to go to an attorney and get an attorney to take their case on a contingency basis if you're only talking about a loss of $300 or $400. But that $300 or $400 could be critical to that individual. So my question is, why are we disallowing then the ability for citizens to be able to go after a business that is doing a deceptive practice? Representative Lowry,
▶ Play
I've not done a very good job, I don't think, of emphasizing that this would not prohibit that consumer who had a $300 or $400 loss from filing a class action on other bases. And the deceptive trade practice is usually one of about five legal theories that a class action is based upon. What I'm contending here is that the way this law was written and piecemealed together with the original act giving it to the Attorney General and the amendment given to private citizen, that it's created an environment that's just not a fair resolution of that dispute. Now, let me be very clear if I haven't been. That consumer who's got a $300 claim can still go file a class action. He's probably going to get it certified in this state until this body or the court changes the class action rules. So they're not being kept out of court. It's just saying this particular statute is not being applied the way it should be applied.
▶ Play
And if I might follow up on that, too, I mean, it allows that consumer to file a complaint with the attorney general's office. and the Attorney General's office can proceed with that class action lawsuit, which is the way this act was originally intended to be done until it was changed in the 90s to allow private lawyers in the mix. So it doesn't hinder class action lawsuits at all. It just limits them to the Attorney General's office. Do you
▶ Play
need a follow-up? Follow-up, please. Okay, so it was amended in the 90s, so we've come at least 20 years since that amendment was taking place. So what is the, I mean, if it's such a dramatic drain on business or an undue hardship on businesses in the state of Arkansas, why did it take 20 years to bring this before the
▶ Play
legislature? I don't think this is the first effort that's been made to bring this before the legislature. This is the first time we've gotten it to a committee. Not yet. Oh, is
▶ Play
Speaker 106 21:39
this a Senate bill? It said gotten it to a committee. Oh, to a committee. To
▶ Play
a committee. I got Ms. Chickens before that. Okay. No, Representative Lowry, it's been an issue that I've identified for when people talk to me about, you know, what needs to be done in the area of litigation reform or tort reform. This is the one I pointed to for years.
▶ Play
Speaker 110 21:57
Okay. Thank you, Ram. It's not a Senate bill, so just don't kill it because it's
▶ Play
a Senate bill. No, no, no. It's not a Senate bill. I just, I mean, you know, it's not that difficult to file a bill and get it to committee and be heard. And so I'm just wondering, again, because I've been on insurance and commerce. I've never heard in previous session this type of legislation brought before. So I'm just wondering, what is the emergency now or the exigent situation where it's something that we're now dealing with and it's been out there for 20 years?
▶ Play
To kind of address that, I started working on this and brought Representative Rushing in as of more recently. But I've been working on this with them for six months, just trying to get the wording right, trying to understand, make sure that we were doing the right thing. um, what the recourses were. This is a, it's a, it's a difficult issue. And I've put a lot, I've invested a lot of time and effort and I don't, maybe in the past, someone's not wanting to put that much time in. Um, we also have a different atmosphere in the legislature as of the last session or two than we've had previously, um, with, with regard to this, but I mean, we've got examples and I could go through them, but like in 2013, um, we had the subway, a lawsuit where a teenager in Australia posted a picture of a foot-long sandwich that was only 11 inches and something. It went viral. We actually, in Springdale then, had someone on January, a Springdale resident, filed a claim under the Deceptive Trade Practices Act. He went and bought a sandwich on January 24th, and then his lawyer filed a class-action lawsuit on January 25th. And then he filed a two-page complaint seeking recovery of up to $5 million. And this is in Arkansas. It's not like this is happening in some other state. This was Arkansas. Subway eventually decided to settle in the midst of a media frenzy. So under the agreement, which got final approval last year, in February 2016, the handful of lawyers who brought the class action received $520,000 for their fees and costs. The 10 class representatives, those that were named as plaintiffs, would receive $500 for their involvement. and the consumers would receive zero, not a penny. And so that's a main part of what the issue is, is the plaintiff attorneys are making all the money, while those that are trying to recover their damages get next to nothing. And so with the Attorney General's office being able to take these cases on, we would see the plaintiffs actually receive their actual costs coming back to them. It's more friendly to the consumer and not so much to the attorneys. Essentially, this is changing who receives the
▶ Play
damages. Okay, I believe we have a couple more
▶ Play
questions. Representative Collins. Thank you, Madam Chair. So two things. In my experience working with trying to get clarity in the law on other bills that I've introduced multiple times that have been killed in multiple sessions over multiple years, what I discovered was words that make common sense are exploded into oblivion and turned into words that become fishing expeditions for money. So if I was to say to somebody, what are your actual damages in a financial transaction? About 98 out of 100 people would define those financially. But what we've discovered is the abuse of the system has gotten to the point where that doesn't always come to fruition. And so what I see here is simply a definition of what it is we're talking about, which are financial losses for these types of offenses. Isn't that merely what we're doing? just adding all kinds of clarity so people that actually have damages can go sue
▶ Play
for those damages? That's certainly the import of the first two sections. Obviously, the issue on individual actions is different. But yes,
▶ Play
and that's currently the way the law stands right now. They don't have to, the plaintiffs don't have to prove any financial loss before they can be certified for a class action lawsuit. So what this says is you have to actually prove that you were damaged in the certification process. All right, members,
▶ Play
we have a few more questions. Representative Lowry. Thank
▶ Play
you, Madam Chair. Is it not enough for a citizen of the United States to sometimes want to stop a deceptive practice or a fraudulent practice just on principle? I'll give you an example. When I was in college, I used to work for an audio and video store, and they'd run a full-page ad advertising some great special on a tape deck. And the manager would tell us, we don't have any of these in stock. Your job is to steer them towards another tape deck that we have a higher profit margin on. Now, in those cases, if the salesman sold it, there was no loss to that individual, But there was still deceit. And I think in this case, even the subway case, I don't think anybody, the plaintiffs or the individuals expected that they were going to collect a whole bunch off of that one inch of sub that they were cheated on. But they should still have the right to sue on
▶ Play
principle, should they not? Well, that really goes to the point I'm trying to make where the statute was piecemealed together in a way that just confused that. But clearly, a citizen had the right under the original Deceptive Practice Act to do that through the Attorney General. The Attorney General had the right to file an action and actually enjoin that sort of behavior. When the provision was added in the 90s to give the citizen the right to file an action, it was limited to recovery of damages. They didn't give, the legislature then didn't give the citizen the right to enjoin the activity. So that citizen that you say wants to act on principle can get the Attorney General involved and get an injunction. And this law, this proposed amendment would not change that in any way. Representative Payton, you had a question?
▶ Play
Thank you, Madam Chair. I'm very sympathetic to the objective here on the frivolous and nonsensical lawsuits that seem to pile up in the class action. But, you know, I agree with the first part of the bill, which, you know, tries to define a financial loss. But my question is, how broad a net are we throwing? Because let me give you an example. The Fayetteville Shale is in my area, and two years before they came in to lease up all the mineral rights at a fair market value, there were companies that obviously found out what was going on and came in ahead of them and lied to landowners and leased their mineral rights at an extremely low value, $25 an acre, by misrepresenting what the state law was. And so 10 of those landowners could get together and approach the company with the threat of a class action suit. Would this prevent those 10 or 12 landowners from getting together and bringing a class action suit against the company for deceptive trade practices? Well, it would prevent them from
▶ Play
bringing them under this act. But this act would not apply to that kind of transaction because this act is limited to consumer transactions. So in an ordinary mineral lease situation, that is an arm's length business transaction to which this act wouldn't apply at all. In fact, this act. Are you referring to the Deceptive Trade Practice Act? It does not apply to non-consumer transactions. Well, it certainly worked. I'm not familiar with the, I know there were class actions filed. I'm very familiar with that. I cannot sit here and tell you today that it included a claim for deceptive trade practice. It could have included all kinds of claims for that wrongdoing. I mean, you've got to understand, when we say we're taking this particular act away, we're not taking away the rights of good lawyers to come up with good theories to represent plaintiffs who need them.
▶ Play
Okay. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you. Does anyone else have a question they wish to ask? All right. I believe we have some folks in the audience that would like to speak for and against. First up, we have Hank Klein. And then next is Kevin Crass. I would remind everybody we're on a time frame, so please don't repeat anything that's already
▶ Play
been said. My name is Hank Klein. I'm a resident of Sherwood, Arkansas. I'm here this morning to speak against House Bill 1742. The bill would be harmful to consumers. The bill would prohibit class action lawsuits by private attorneys and require showing fraud for individual claims. The Deceptive Trade Practices Act has been used very successfully in the past by private attorneys to sue payday lenders in our state. If this tool is taken away, it would be very difficult for private attorneys to sue predatory lenders like Cash Max Loan Services that's already operating in North Little Rock, Arkansas, and Hope, Arkansas. They're charging borrowers 280.82% on loans, on their installment payday loans. Businesses that engage in deceptive practices like Cash Max will have little concern about a few individual lawsuits. Victims will almost have to prove actual fraud instead of just showing that the fee was unlawful or usurious based on Amendment 89 of our Arkansas Constitution, which sets the maximum interest rate in our state at 17% for consumers. Most states have deceptive practice statutes that allow civil penalties. Ours simply provides a mechanism to let victims take their claim to court. They still have to prove actual damages. If the DTPA is gutted to prevent individuals from joining together in class action lawsuits, it becomes pretty meaningless and will allow businesses like Cash Max to continue unchecked, making usurious loans in Arkansas. Thank you.
▶ Play
I believe we have a couple of questions. Representative
▶ Play
Collins. Thank you very much, Madam Chair. So I just want to make sure I understand what you're saying. First of all, you're accusing a company here of being guilty of committing fraud in the way they operate. So wouldn't that be something that they would be put out of business for as a fraudulent company? And so the fact that they cheated, according to you, a million people or 100 people, the way you get rid of a fraud is not to go compensate each of the individuals one at a time, but to do both things. To bring a suit against them or accuse them of fraud and throw them in jail for being fraudulent. Isn't that the way that you solved the problem that you've designed? Again, presuming you're right, and this company is criminal as
▶ Play
Speaker 141 33:47
you describe them. Well, they're certainly operating against the Arkansas Constitution. But if you take my
▶ Play
question at face value, wouldn't it be true that you would go after the company and say this company's behaving fraudulently and criminally and put them out of business and put the fraudsters in jail? Isn't that the true way to deal with the situation you described?
▶ Play
I'm not an attorney. I don't know. I do know what happened with the payday lending here in Arkansas. And I do know that a local Arkansas attorney filed many class action lawsuits against payday lenders because consumers would come to them with a $300 loan and an attorney just can't afford to take on a $300 loan individually on itself. And that's what's going to happen here. Individuals will have to go and find an attorney who will take a case for a $300 loan which costs the consumer about $90 in actual costs. That far exceeds by 16 times our Arkansas Constitution. We have a follow up. As a follow up to that, let's just take a
▶ Play
mob with a loan shark. So the way we would deal with the mob and a loan shark would be different than what you're describing. And I'm just saying that any company that's behaving like the mob or a loan shark would be treated the same way. So in terms of solving the problem that you're describing, wouldn't you agree that the way to do it is to have the FBI or whoever it is investigate find these people that are cheating, whether it's a loan shark or this company you mentioned, and put the people that are running this ring in jail? And that's the way that we solve that problem.
▶ Play
I would love to see loan sharks be put in jail, but that is not what has happened here in Arkansas. What's happened in Arkansas is the same attorney that I mentioned, after suing and suing and suing for nearly 10 years, finally ended up, was successful in getting three cases to the Arkansas Supreme Court. The Arkansas Supreme Court made opinions on those, that the law that this assembly had passed was unconstitutional, didn't muster up to the Arkansas Constitution. And then the Attorney General took action and closed them down. No one went to jail that I'm aware of. Okay. Any other questions? I'm not saying they shouldn't. I'm just saying that's the way it worked in that case that I'm very familiar with over the last 10 years.
▶ Play
All right. Any other questions for Mr. Klein from the committee? Seeing none, thank you, sir, for being here today. Next, we have Kevin Kress with the Friday
▶ Play
Speaker 57 36:25
Law Firm. That's Kevin. Mr. Crass was the one who was up here with me, so we'll pass over that. We'll pass over that. Any discussion by the committee? Seeing none, what
▶ Play
is the pleasure of the committee? Would you mind to allow me
▶ Play
just to close for this? Yes, I'm sorry. Please do. I just wanted to address the gentleman's concerns that were up here. You know, he referenced payday lenders such as CashMax. CashMax is not a payday lender. I've actually been doing quite a bit of work on this over the last few weeks. They're a credit service enhancement agency. It's completely different than payday lending. This, what we're doing, would still allow the AG's office to bring suit on them if they did find that they were operating outside of Amendment 89. Currently, based on some of the case law around Amendment 89, It's unclear at this point in time whether or not this company is supposed to be operating within Amendment 89 or if they're allowed to operate outside of Amendment 89. And Cash Max actually has a suit that they brought themselves to try and get clarity from a judge as to where they fall. They've been in business less than a year here in the state of Arkansas are and are actually looking at possibly having to leave the state, um, based on what this ruling shows. So I just wanted to clarify the whole cash max as not being a, could I request that the gentleman please be removed from behind me? Sir, if you could take your seat. I don't get the rebut. Thank you. And this, this, this act the way it currently reads never, um, never allowed the plaintiff attorneys to shut a business down or to adjoin is the legal word that we used. The AG has to do that anyhow. It was never allowed to be done in the first place. They were only allowed to seek financial compensation for it. So essentially, all we're trying to do is rein this practice in here in the state of Arkansas. Class actions can still be brought under a variety of different legal areas, just not under deceptive trade. They can still be brought individually or by the Attorney General's office, which is what the practice that's been done in the past. So with that, I thank you for your time. I know it's a difficult issue and I would appreciate a good vote. Okay, what is the pleasure of the committee?
▶ Play
Do pass as amended by Representative Henderson. All in favor, sorry, we do need to have some discussion, I believe. Representative Payton, do you want to kick that off?
▶ Play
Yes, thank you, Madam Chair. Members, I mean, I hate the frivolous lawsuits. I really do. But there are some legitimate lawsuits out there that require class action. And I don't think that the current environment of frivolous lawsuits is there because of our law. I think it's there because of companies like Subway settling instead of going to court. When these frivolous lawsuits are brought, these insurance companies and companies tend to settle out of court. Everybody gets, all the lawyers get paid, when if they had went to court, they could have beaten the lawsuit instead of settling. And, you know, instead of changing the law, what should happen is those companies that are sued unjustly should fight it and cause those attorneys that are pursuing that to have their own losses.
▶ Play
But anyway, I'm going to be voting against the
▶ Play
bill. All right. Any other discussion? Representative Lowry? Thank you, Madam Chair. I know that we've heard that it still leaves in place the ability for the Attorney General to be able to bring these class action lawsuits. And, you know, and what I'm going to say is certainly not meant to be any kind of disrespect to our current attorney general. But sometimes, I mean, I just can't see the attorney general wanting to certify a class action over one inch on a subway. But it's still a deceptive practice. And there are a lot of other things that may not rise to the level of being huge economic losses. But statements have to be made. And sometimes, unfortunately, the statements that can be made are made over issues that the average person would look at and go, well, that's not a big deal. But deceit is deceit, and we've got to call it down. And I think any resource, any tool in the toolbox, as Representative Collins will refer to, any tool that we have to make sure that businesses operate with integrity, we ought to keep those tools in place. So I would be opposed as well. Representative
▶ Play
Collins, I believe you had a
▶ Play
comment. I believe that our world is one of balancing competing, wonderful principles. On the one hand, we have the principle of proper behavior by anybody all the time. On the other hand, we have the principle of not abusing businesses and others. And the question is, where are we in that balance? Do I think anything will be perfect? No. Do I think anything will get us there perfectly? No. Do I think over time things will change and perhaps this pendulum can swing the other way? Possibly it can. But where we've been for 50 years in this state is moving down, down, down. We're near the bottom in so many things. And our litigation climate is terrible. It's one of the things people point to when you ask them, will you move your business to Arkansas? It's just not good relative to everyone else. And I am confident, confident, confident if what we're finding is we're getting more bad deceptive practices in Arkansas, that we will be able to swiftly fix this, because our state is populist-oriented. And when little guys start getting hurt, we will snap to attention, I promise you. I think this is the right thing for us to try now. I believe Representative
▶ Play
Ferguson also had a question. Yeah,
▶ Play
I just think this is actually a great consumer bill. I think instead of all of the settlement going to attorney's fees where the consumer gets nothing, it actually will adequately compensate them for their loss.
▶ Play
Any other comments? All right. We ready to vote? All those in favor? Aye. All those opposed? No. The ayes have it. Congratulations, Representative Gray. You've passed your bill. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 161 43:13
you, Madam Chair and committee. Okay.
▶ Play
I believe we have 1752, if you can pull that up. Representative Collins, you're recognized to run 1752. Thank
▶ Play
you very much, Madam Chair. We talked earlier about a bill for the auditor's office and reclaiming property. And as you recall, most of that bill was taken away because it didn't comport with the financial industry. So what we did do to try and help in that scenario was extend by two years, the amount of time before property becomes abandoned. This is another idea which is designed to just help in that process, to help consumers not lose their property. And all it does is merely delay how quickly that fine the owner happens. So today, it's 60 to 120 days that the property owner must be looked for. And we're extending that to 90 to 180 days, just to give people a better chance to get their property before it's turned over to the state.
▶ Play
And I'm happy to take any questions. Members, are there any questions? Do we have anybody in the audience that would like to speak for the bill? Against the bill? Discussion? What is the pleasure of the committee? Due pass. We have a due pass from Representative Warren. All those in favor? Aye. All those opposed? Congratulations, Representative Collins, your bill is passed. Would you like to present
▶ Play
1753? Yes, Madam Chair, and I'd like to call up Mr. Moral Harriman, to the chair with me, and as he works his way up, he'll be able to help me with any specifics. But what this bill does, it uses some fancy words like subrogation, but the bottom line is, what this does is, if an insurance company insures a loss and they pay the loss, in other words, the owner is paid the loss by the insurance company for the lost property or whatever it is they lost, and that is complete. And the owner also gets reimbursed from some other venue for the same property, from a court or some other venue. Then the insurance company is entitled to then get reimbursed back for that so that nobody can get double payment for the same loss. That's essentially what this does, because the practice that we're seeing now evolving in our state is, you file the insurance claim, and you get reimbursed for the insurance company, and then you find some other venue to get paid again, and you get paid twice for the same loss of property, and the insurance company does not get reimbursed from that, even if that process happens. So that's what this bill does. Okay, I believe we have some
▶ Play
questions from members of the committee. Representative Lowry? Madam Chair, I'm going to ask Morrill Harriman
▶ Play
to introduce himself and who he's moved for the committee. Yes, I'm sorry, Mr. Harriman. Thank
▶ Play
you, Madam Chair. It's a pleasure being here. Maurel Herrman, I'm an attorney with the Mitchell-Williams firm here in Little Rock.
▶ Play
Representative Lowry? Thank you, Madam Chair. I'm looking, and your explanation makes perfect sense, but I'm looking at the bill, and I don't see anything in here that refers to the insured already being paid for their claim by their insurance company and then potentially receiving double payment from the third party. I just don't see that in there. I see that it says that an insurer's share of the cost of collection and attorney's fees, it talks about that. Can you point me to where it is specifically saying that that's what we are preventing is a
▶ Play
double payment? Representative Lyle, if you actually look at the markup on the bill, What may surprise you is to see that a lot of this is just additional language to statutory requirements that the General Assembly had already passed back in the early 90s as far as right of reimbursement. It's the term right of reimbursement that's the catch word. Insurance companies had always assumed that the Arkansas legislature had taken care of that and that there was a right of reimbursement if it was part of your contract of insurance. However, in 1997, the Supreme Court relied upon an old common law doctrine known as the made whole doctrine. It is a common law doctrine from the ecclesiastical courts of England. And basically stated that, again, they were going to apply the made whole doctrine before any right of subrogation or reimbursement could exist since that time. There basically has been almost an impossible right to recover for reimbursement cost itself. So let's say a lot of this language is attempting to clarify language, which everyone thought was already the law. But again, because of that decision, it's not there. You will see the language in there that, again, the right of reimbursement attaches only when it's paid. You'll see that's when
▶ Play
it attaches. Representative Lowry, that's on page 3 in section 3. you'll see that they've added a little bit of tweak to paragraph 1A1, but then it adds a 2 and a 3 to clarify. But the fact that nowhere in the law does it say you're allowed to cash in twice. They can't just remove the go ahead and cash in twice. That was some twist that's been put into what was intended
▶ Play
to be, you get one reimbursement. Follow up. Yes, thank you. Well, I guess my main question would, and I understand that the first section is to not be codified. But it clearly states that the intent of this is to override the made whole doctrine. And I know Mr. Harriman, you referred to this as an old doctrine. But it is a doctrine that is still in place in a large
▶ Play
number of states, correct? It is, and it's not our intent to override the made whole doctrine as a whole. It is our intent to override it to the extent that the Supreme Court interpreted that doctrine to override Arkansas statutes passed by this General Assembly. Again, we have a lot of the common law doctrines. We have repealed a lot of the common law doctrines. The one universally known is the common law marriage. We don't accept that in Arkansas. It's specifically prohibited in Arkansas. And all we are saying is the method by which the Supreme Court interpreted that doctrine from a modern standpoint, prevents any right of reimbursement that the companies have, because they many times will use a universal made whole, maybe for non-economic damages or other type of damages. It's much more of a subjective type of process. Here, it's very objective. If I hit a rear end, Representative Collins, he's hospitalized. The med pay of his insurance, or maybe his medical insurance, pays for those injuries. They have a right to receive that back from me or my insurance company, instead of him being paid twice for it. That's simplistic, but that's exactly what this bill does. Can I follow
▶ Play
up? I believe Representative Payton, did you get yours? Did you have a question? All right.
▶ Play
Thank you, Madam Chair. Okay, so for those of us that are not lawyers, would you explain your interpretation of the made whole doctrine and how that differs from the Supreme Court's interpretation?
▶ Play
The made whole doctrine can get very complicated and you can see a 15 page law review article. But bottom line, it says this, you must recover all aspect of all damages and be placed back in exactly the same position that you were in prior to the injury taking place, okay? That could be lost wages, that could be again non-economic damages for pain and suffering, could be loss of consortium, that could be payment for a vehicle. Might be payment for property damage to a home itself. It's to reimburse you for medical injuries that were caused and had to be again paid for due to injuries, personal injuries that were received. That you had to consider all of those documents. let's assume a court didn't feel like that you were totally reimbursed for a loss of consortium. I just used that term for non-economic damage. Then under the current status of the law, the insurance company that paid for the medical, although it was my fault, would not even have a right to recover the medical bills paid on behalf of Mr. Collins, although again caused by my fault, which I had insurance to cover. And again, we would be asking that my insurance company reimburse Mr. Collins' insurance company because they had paid for damages which my company was liable for. Follow up.
▶ Play
Okay, so you're saying that a court of law would determine that you had not yet been made whole. So how does that equate to getting paid double or getting paid twice as what's been referred to
▶ Play
several times here? Because, again, you would still be, again, Mr. Collins' company would have no right to receive a dollar until the court found that the entire universe of made whole had been met. So, again, certainly he has a right to recover damages for me, the wrongdoer, and for me and for my insurance company. So part of those damages are going to be his medical bills, his medical injuries, damages to his car. Deductibles? Again, he might have a deductible. There would be no deductible on my liability insurance. So again, then my insurance
▶ Play
company would pay him. If I could just interject in there. So let's say it was a $5,000 amount and there was a $500 deductible. The individual paid $500 and the insurance company paid $4,500. And the court gave the individual $5,000. The insurance company would only be reimbursable up to the 4,500, not the 500 that the member paid. Nobody would be talking about taking money that the insurance company never paid out to the member. That literally came from the member's pocket from moment one, and that would be his or her personal loss. And that's totally correct.
▶ Play
Speaker 177 54:04
Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. I
▶ Play
believe Representative Maddox, you had a question? Yes, thank
▶ Play
you, Madam Chair. I apologize, first of all, I didn't really read this bill until last night around 1030. But I have some concerns when I look at it, Mr. Harriman. For instance, like in my district, most people, they carry just 25 or 50 in insurance proceeds. That's all they have. Correct. I live in a poverty-stricken district. But if someone has, during an accident, there's $50,000 or $25,000 in medical expenses, under this bill, the insurance company would come in and take the full insurance proceeds and the victim would receive no recovery?
▶ Play
Only if the victim had not already been paid. If the victim had not, but the victim... But, again, if the victim had $25,000 in medical injuries, is that the example? Yes. Then at that point, the victim's insurance must have paid that $25,000. Correct. Before that they could recover from the liability carrier itself as far as the subrogation. Now, again, if the victim had underinsured coverage, yes. But your example could be a situation where it could be conceded. It could be correct. We deal with that issue really a lot as far as undercoverage. This just seems pretty, frankly,
▶ Play
pretty harsh to those, and those are the most common situations. For instance, in my experience, I don't even do this type of work, but the people never have personal assets to pay in. It's the liability coverage, and that's it. If it's 25 or 50, that's all you're going to get. So if there's 25 or 50 in meds, like in my example, there's going to be no recovery.
▶ Play
For the victim. Again, there would be no double recovery for the victim. You're correct. Well, but they're not actually
▶ Play
getting any money. Their insurance bills are paid. Excuse me, their medical expenses are paid. But they're not getting money,
▶ Play
correct? If they've got, let's assume it's a med pay. That med pay is going to continue to cover and would have to cover that victim's injuries itself. But the maximum they would be reimbursed, the medical pay, even if it was $100,000 for the victim, then again, the only thing the company would be reimbursed for is, yes, the $25,000. Madam Chair, I apologize. I've
▶ Play
taken some latitude here, but that will follow up. That's okay. Let's do one more
▶ Play
follow-up, and then we have some other folks that need to ask questions. I
▶ Play
apologize. Yes, but to be clear, there will be cases, like
▶ Play
I described, where there will likely be no recovery. There would be no additional recovery. I mean, that would be the term I would like to add is no additional recovery.
▶ Play
Correct. Thank you very much. We will come back around, Representative Maddox. I believe Representative Lowry, then Ferguson and Farrar. Yes. Representative
▶ Play
Lowry. Thank you, Madam Chair. I'm looking at on page two, lines 24 through 26. Stand alone paragraph doesn't apply back to anything else. It specifically says the right to reimbursement arises and attaches at the time of the first payment of any benefits or provision of services to a covered person, any benefits. So that actually even refers to your insurance company paying a benefit. For instance, if you are hurt, you are damaged by another individual. It's clearly their fault. Third party, their insurance company is going to be paying. But you've gotten a rental car from your insurance company. That immediately triggers right there the reimbursement, the fact that you got the rental car payment from your insurance company, that when the third party pays, and they may be underinsured, you're going to lose out at least the amount of
▶ Play
that rental car. That's true, and Representative Lowry, bluntly, that's the purpose. But you would lose out only assuming you do get that additional recovery. You won't be paid for the rental car
▶ Play
twice. Okay, I understand that. But if you're talking about a third-party insurer that is underinsured on the accident, they were at fault. So you have not even come close to being made whole because they're underinsured. And you have underinsured motorist coverage, okay? But your company is saying, well, we're going to rake back reimbursement from the less than optimum payment that you got from the third party before we even look at your underinsured motorist coverage. No, sir. Again, what this would do when
▶ Play
it says it attaches, it does mean that at that point you've got a right to recover at the end, if there are additional payments made by a third party, the benefits that you have paid. There was a rental car at the first. Eventually, there's a settlement with the liability company for the person who caused the damage. At that point, yes. The company that's already paid for the rental car could get repaid that
▶ Play
Speaker 188 59:35
since they were not the wrongdoer. Even if you have not been made whole by the third party insured? Again, you would
▶ Play
have to give me your definition of made whole. If you're talking about that, and that's a respectful response
▶ Play
to you. Let me try and answer and do some of the same thing. Let's say somebody got in a crash, and they crashed their car. They lost six months worth of work, and they had medical bills, and they had emotional pain and suffering. So there are four different elements to the award of money for this individual. $5,000 is making up for the car, $5,000 for the lost work, $10,000 for the medical. and $10,000 for pain and suffering, whether they were over-insured or under-insured, if the one insurer did both the health and the car, and I know that's not realistic, then out of that total of 5 plus 10 plus 10 plus 10, the paid amounts to fix the car, the paid amounts for the medical would go back to the insurer, and the individual would get the paid amounts for the work they lost, the paid amounts for the pain and suffering, the paid amounts for any deductibles, and they would be physically made whole after the medical, and they would be property-wise made whole with their car being restored. So in that scenario, they would walk away, and then they would be made whole in terms of their work. Now, where it gets difficult or is let's say somebody has a permanent injury and now it gets more complicated, but the same principles would apply. If the court said your non-economic damages or treble damages times, you know, $250,000 or whatever it is, the car $5,000 would still go back to the insurance company if the award was for the car $5,000. And I think that's the key element of this is the linkage between what is being reimbursed and who paid for it. And that's the key as I understand it. Representative Ferguson, I
▶ Play
believe you were next. Yeah.
▶ Play
And I mean, that was you started to address my question, which is if you have permanent medical injury. That's my real concern. Okay. So you settle with the person. And they have ongoing medical cost and medical care. How are they, then can the medical insurance company use that as a reason not to pay ongoing medical expense and say it was related to the initial injury? No, ma'am. They
▶ Play
have a contractual obligation under the medical insurance to make those payments. Subrogation or no subrogation, they have that obligation. If there's a third party wrongdoer, and let's say that there's not sufficient funds to cover that, that's too bad the medical still is required to pay for those injuries themselves. Their obligation to pay for those injuries in a medical setting, hospital setting, physician's fees, is not contingent upon whatever status you found the wrongdoer in. Can I
▶ Play
ask a thought? Yes. I guess I'm trying to help understand this. So I get a settlement for medical, and obviously they figure in, you know, your permanent injuries and lifetime, you don't think that the medical company can ask to be reimbursed for that ongoing?
▶ Play
I'm a little confused about the law. For the ongoing, again, that would be part of the settlement agreement. More than likely, that would be settled in a lump sum because, again, the future medical costs would be ongoing. That would be part of the settlement negotiations. There might be a sum set aside for future medical. There often are in these particular situations themselves. But again, bottom line, the person needing the medical care, it's going to be paid for from one pot or the other. It's not going to come out of their pockets.
▶ Play
But it's also true that you're not going to have, if the insurance company is obligated to pay for a lifetime of care, and let's say that's $10,000 a year, and the person also gets a settlement that says, this is for your ongoing care, and let's say it's also $10,000 a year. The person is not going to get $10,000 for their care, and then an additional $10,000 above and beyond that every year, that would be used to offset. So in that sense, the person does not get to collect double, but this does nothing to impinge on that person's award and continued medical care through permanence into the future. In other words, this does nothing to detract from the fact that they will be taken care of with a permanent injury, but it does and it would come into effect if the medical insurance was paying the liability because of the medical insurance and then the jury said, well, we're going to give you lifetime medical care. You wouldn't get both. You'd get one and then the insurance company would get the money back for the insurance they're paying. And then obviously all the other benefits, which are separate from that, have nothing to do with the insurance company. as they're supposed to. That's why the court separates these things out. They have your property. They have economic, non-economic, punitive. All of these are separated out because the idea is the jury or the judge or whoever's making the decisions is allocating things properly. The abuse comes when somebody says we got the non-economic and we got the punitive and we got all those, but when we're done at the end of the day, hey, let's go catch twice for the car. Let's go catch twice for this. And I get it. I would do the same thing. I said, look at me, I got a new theory, I'm a smart guy, yada, yada. We will really stick them. Plus,
▶ Play
we all hate insurance companies anyway, so it's easy. Yeah, I mean, I'm sorry, but I guess I'm just trying to understand if it's deemed the liability insurance is responsible for ongoing health care. And that doesn't turn out to cover it. Would it work like health care where you had two policies where your health care would pick up the copay? I mean, the difference would act as a secondary insurance. I mean, if you're giving the patient, I mean, I hate to say this, but if you're giving the patient a lump sum, it's not likely they're actually going to have the money
▶ Play
to pay their medical bills when the time comes. They're going to spend it. Correct. And again, unless the insurance company, the medical insurance company, had fixed its right of, if any, future subrogation rights, that has to be settled at the time of the settlement of the matter itself. So that has to be entered into and agreed upon at that time. You know, the best, it's hard for me to really get much better than what Representative Collins said. Again, can you recover twice? No. If you've got deductibles that are there, no, that should be paid by the wrongdoer and by the third-party liability. And again, the insurance company is not going to ask you for that money back, your health insurance company itself. Uh, that's not money they paid out. But again, all they are seeking to recover is monies actually paid on your behalf. But because of another person's negligence. Um, Representative Farr, you're next. Thank you,
▶ Play
Speaker 198 1:07:12
ma'am. Sure. This is pretty similar. We're doing this now, aren't we? Usually, yes. Uh, because I know in my business, I mean, when I have a patient that comes from a motor vehicle, I've built their insurance. The motor vehicle comes back from the insurance company. So what are we trying
▶ Play
to do any different? Basically, if it involves a complex matter with litigation themselves, usually this is where the issue comes up itself. You're totally right. You see the cases now where most of the cases now medical liens are filed. Right. We fought one of them. Yeah. In the case itself, just to make sure the attorney is notified. In this case, if I was representing the injured party, I would be notified that ABC Hospital has outstanding claims that are pending. They may be notified by others that their claims are pending as far as the injured party's concerned. What we're basically trying to do is to make sure that, again, in those situations where there are issues involved, that the legislature has said we are renewing the right of subrogation and reimbursement, reimbursement of monies paid because of the fault of a third party. Right. Follow-up. Again, I'm sorry. But, again, I want to
▶ Play
Speaker 198 1:08:32
ask you, we're doing that now. Yes. Okay, thank you. Representative Armstrong, I believe you had a question.
▶ Play
Speaker 87 1:08:41
Thank you, Madam Chair. So I do have a series of them, if I can just repeat. That's fire. Shoot them away. So if we are doing this now, and Representative Lowry, who just had to leave to run a bill, Representative Collins, he stated that this was basically piling on to SJR 8. And can you attest to that to say yay or nay one way or the other? And then my second to that is a question regarding what if the person dies? Does the
▶ Play
insurance get the money back? So this is unconnected to SJR 8.
▶ Play
Speaker 87 1:09:12
Not connected to it, but in the season of the red door being wide open across the country,
▶ Play
I mean... Oh, you're saying politically would this be killed if it was in the old days in the legislature? In my hypothesis, this bill would not do well in the legislature that I came in with. Nor would SJRA. Yeah, I agree with that as well. But that's a separate point. What I would submit to you is what this bill actually does is closer to what Representative Farrar said. But the intent is clear. You should get paid one time. And when things are not complex, even the wiliest cannot conflate them to such a degree as to create confusion. But when things get more complex, then the wily can conflate. and all of a sudden it becomes unclear when you add enough complexity to a situation that you're really laying out the common sense reimbursement for one time for one loss. And the reason that these losses are segregated and segmented is so that they can be properly allocated. The non-economic damages, the economic damages, punitive damages, property damages, they're all designed to be specific. specific. And if a court says you do deserve reimbursement for the car because the car was improperly or whatever it is, but you don't get punitive damages or whatever, you don't get to say, well, I'm going to reshuffle that up and I want to pretend that I was awarded these punitive damages because I was really looking for more money. And I understand the desire of a person that's filing a lawsuit or their attorney. I totally get why they'd want to do that. But the problem comes from the fact that the rest of us all pay higher insurance rates in order to undercut what the courts have decided. So the courts decide that you get this much for your car because you need to have your car taken care of, and you get this much for this and this much for the other. The court makes that decision. So does it privatize the gains? It doesn't privatize the gains at all. It just ensures that what people are being insured for and the risk that the insurance companies are taking on is accurately assessed in the premium. If they have to assess in the premium risks for claims that go far beyond the fact that you've crashed a car, now the rest of us pay higher insurance rates, one of the things that makes it tougher to have a quality of life in Arkansas. Two more follow-ups. Does
▶ Play
Speaker 87 1:11:34
this take away from likely a lot of my constituents, the little guy, and really looks after protecting big insurance? And then the second part to that is does it take away from the death and injury of the victims and, as I mentioned, give the money back to the insurance? I'm trying to make a distinction. I understand what you're saying.
▶ Play
What I would tell you is it does not give anything to the insurance companies. And you say, well, how do you know that? What is it about insurance companies? How do you know that that's the case? And the answer is if you look, you can follow all their financials. Most of them trade on Wall Street. And you can find out what the profits are and everything. But here's what insurance companies do. Warren Buffett writes about this every year in his annual letter. And one of the reasons he's not really writing much property and casualty insurance as we speak is because the insurance business model is based on taking money today called premium float and then paying it out in expenses and in liabilities to the insurance costs in the future. And when that balance, when the premium and the expenses gets out of whack, the prices have to go up or the insurance companies go out of business. The prices have to go up. So any time that you inaccurately put your thumb on the scale and make the expenses go up, the insurance company can do it by paying their CEOs too much money and things of that nature. So that individual insurance company's expenses goes up. So their individual company's rates go up. So they come into your neighborhood or mine and say, I'm selling you homeowner's insurance. And you look at them and say, hey, you idiot, your prices are a lot higher than the other insurance company. And that CEO either has to be really slick or has to take a more reasonable pay. And that's how the industry naturally regulates itself. Because they're all greedy. It's true. They're all greedy. They have one thing in common with all of us. We're human, so we're greedy. So they always want to try and get more money. But the fact they have to compete with other insurance companies prevents them from the inordinate profits.
▶ Play
Madam Chair, may I respond to Mr. Armstrong's question also? Yes. Mr. Armstrong, again, it's a very valid question, and I certainly can't wax economically as eloquently as Representative Collins can. But I would argue with you it's just the opposite effect. If you've got the small consumer who's got $2,500 worth of property damage or $500 worth of medical bill, and your insurance pays for it, that's really you're paying for it. Why should you have to pay for damage that I caused to you because of my negligence, Or why should your insurance company have to pay for it and then, in turn, raise
▶ Play
Speaker 87 1:14:10
your premiums? Not twice is what you're trying to clarify, but isn't that why
▶ Play
we get insurance anyway? It is why you get insurance anyway, but insurance is to cover you when there's no other party responsible or when you really have no other recourse. In this situation, we're only talking about where you, any of us, have other recourse. And that there are other funds out there to pay for the injuries that you have been caused. why should, again, your insurance company pay for my wrongdoing and increase your premiums when it's my responsibility? And, again, I believe that's a very, very fair, real-world answer for you. Thank you, Madam Chair. You're welcome. Any other questions by
▶ Play
the committee before we open this up for for and against? All right. Do we have anybody that would like to speak for the bill? against the bill.
▶ Play
Please identify yourself. Madam Chair, my name is Mike Boyd. Thank you. Thank you, Representative Collins, members of the committee, Madam Chair. Again, my name is Mike Boyd. I'm from Magnolia. i am city attorney there and i'm practicing attorney i have what i'd call a small town practice i represent folks from all walks of life all kinds of problems when you're in a small town it's pretty much what you do whether you're the dentist or the doctor or the lawyer that's what you handle i do that and i got into this profession to try to make a difference and that's why i enjoy it, and that's why I'm here today. I had some things to say, and some of that's been altered by what I've already heard here, but I'll try to keep this as simple and brief as I can. First, the current law does not allow for double recovery. It does not exist. The current law only allows the individual that's harmed to receive one complete recovery, and when they have reached one complete recovery, anything beyond that would get reimbursed to the insurance company for anything they have paid. It is that simple. What this does, what the law or this bill before you does, is that it actually is, and it's one thing I can agree with the proponents of this bill, I do not believe on either side of this coin that there should be a double recovery or a double dip but that's what this bill does for insurance companies you and i pay insurance premiums on a monthly basis we pay that to cover us insurance essentially a wager it is a wager between the insurance company and yourself as to whether or not some calamity will befall you you wager that it might and they wager that it won't and that's all taken into calculation of the premium that you For me, fortunately, up until today's date, I have not personally caused my insurance company losses. Even though I've paid them premiums for many, many, many years, and that's okay, because I know it's there. But I pay them, I pay those premiums with the expectation of, when that calamity does find me, that that insurance company will cover my harms and my losses. And it will do so to the extent of my insurance coverage. As Representative Maddox pointed out, in Arkansas, in my experience, and I don't handle a ton of these cases by any stretch of the imagination, but I do handle enough of them to know. Most of the insurance coverage that you find is $25,000. It is primarily minimum limits. That is the limit this legislature has set. It's been that way for many years, and that's what we live with. So in the example that Representative Maddox gave, and he was 100% correct, That if you have an instance in which an individual has $25,000 in medical expenses, which, by the way, would probably represent a surgery of some type, which means that person has lost wages, which means that person has lost time with their family, means that person probably has scarring, means that person probably has some type of permanent injury. So they have a whole panorama of losses, harms and losses, that they're trying to recover. In that instance, the insurance company under this bill would get all of the money from that settlement. They would get every dollar, and that individual with all those losses would walk away with nothing but the medical care, and if it was their health insurer, they would still have 20% of their bill left to pay to all their medical care providers. What you're doing is flipping this. This bill flips the balance. And Representative Collins was correct, and I agree from a lawyer's perspective in looking at some of these things, that you must balance the principles. This is flipping it and putting the insurance company in front of that individual, that constituent of yours, your family member, your friends. They are now behind the insurance company. That insurance company gets that money, and it's returned to them. Will you get your premium back? all the money that you paid them for that coverage? And the answer is, you will not. So I would encourage you to think of it in those terms. And a couple other quick notes, because I felt like it needed to be responded to here. In a court setting, if I go to a jury trial, that judge in 99 cases out of 100 is not going to break down in that verdict what my damages are. I get one global number. The same is true in a settlement case. You get one global number. There's no number that prioritizes, well, first we'll allocate $25,000 or this portion of $25,000 to your medicals, and then we'll allocate it to this number, and it doesn't work like that. You get one number for all of your damages. So I ask you, why is it fair to move the insurance company's reimbursement right to the front of that line when that person who's the primary breadwinner in their family and has to support their family cannot recover their lost wages and cannot recover their out-of-pocket expenses, whatever that may be, or all their permanent losses. So I would ask you to analyze it from that standpoint and ask yourself, if there's a double dip here, who's really double dipping? Now, this law has been in effect for 20 years. And if you read that Franklin case that's referred to in here, it perfectly lays out this imbalance that exists. And that imbalance begins from the moment you buy your insurance contract. It's not my experience, but if you think you can walk into your insurance agency and say, I don't like this phrase, I would prefer for you to take this out of our insurance contract, That will not happen. You decide to buy it or not, but the insurance policies are all the same. That court recognized that there is a bargaining imbalance that already exists. And so you do buy your insurance and you have to accept whatever those terms are. And that court saw that in equity, in fairness to that person, in that particular case was a prime example of how these things occur whenever there's medical expenses that far outstrip the potential recovery that's available. So I guess in the end, I believe that your constituents, citizens of this state expect you to do two things. One is to make improvements for them in their life, and I know you work hard every time you're up here trying to do that. But the second thing is to prevent negative things from happening. expect you to hold the line whenever it comes to them, and that's what I think this bill represents as an opportunity for you to hold that line. It will not be the last time that you're asked to do that, because it's just as sure as flowers bloom in the spring, insurance companies ask for made whole to be abolished. So this won't be the last time, but I do ask for you to take that consideration and vote
▶ Play
against this. Question, Madam Chair? Yes. So let's take this total lump sum. Where do the contingency fees come? Do they come after all the liens and these other things are paid, or do they
▶ Play
come off the gross? Well, contingency fees typically come off the top. I'm not sure how that impacts in any way this particular bill. I was just clarifying what comes off the top. Well, actually, a lien comes off the top. For instance, if a medical provider, a physical therapist files a lien in a case, and it's a valid lien, and they've taken care of their end of the bargain, then that lien actually must be paid. It has to be paid. The lawyer has to honor that, or the medical provider can report them to the professional conduct committee and potentially file a lawsuit against them.
▶ Play
Members, does anybody else have a question? All right. Seeing none. Thank you, sir. Thank you, Madam Chair. Do we have anybody else in the committee that was for or against in the audience? All right. Seeing none. Discussion amongst the committee? Can I close, Madam Chair? Hang on just a second. Any other discussions or questions? All right. Seeing none, you're recognized or closed. Thank you, Madam Chair.
▶ Play
So I agree that this can get complex. In reality, life is not a casino where we're taking bets. We're purchasing insurance because we're pooling our risk. We have court cases to settle wrongs. It's not a casino. When we talk about the benefits being paid and what does it mean to be made whole, And the concept of how you define that is really what's very much in discussion here. This gentleman, for example, said it's one number. You get one number. Contingency fees come off the top, and then after that, or liens and contingency fees come off the top, and then after that you have to think about how it's divided. I think most of the time, and the reality and the goal and the intent is to allocate by category what the damages are for. We just had a big debate. Representative Armstrong brought up SGR-8, and we had a big debate about that. And what we talked about were categories of damages. And all of us treated them significantly different in our own mind. In certain cases, they would be unlimited. In other cases, you could have two times. In other cases, they were limited a different amount, because based on the category, it drove the thinking. It's clear that the intent of the law, as Representative Farrar said, is if somebody, an insurance company, or somebody pays the damages, and the courts award against a wrongdoer for those same damages, that the payer, the original payer, is reimbursed. It's very clear that's the intention. But in more complicated situations, some of the decisions that have been made by the court have allowed that to become muddied. And what this bill simply does is seeks to clarify that. So in these individual court cases, people will have the right standing to be able to go with the intent of the legislature in those cases. And with that, I'd appreciate a
▶ Play
good vote. Members, any discussion? Motion by Representative Farrar? Motion to pass. We have a motion to pass. All those in favor? Aye. All those opposed? No. I think we'll have to have a roll call vote then. Representative Murdoch?
▶ Play
Speaker 224 1:26:58
Representative Murdoch, Representative Lowry, Representative Lowry, Representative Ritchie, Representative Armstrong, Representative Jett, Representative Farrar, Representative Ferguson, Representative Payton No Representative Eves Representative Eves Representative Hodges Yes Representative Rushing Representative Rushing Representative Henderson Yes Representative Servillo Yes Representative Vaught? No. Representative Richmond? Representative Richmond? Representative McCollum? Yes. Representative Maddox? Representative Maddox? Representative Warren? Yes. Representative Lundstrom? Representative Collins?
▶ Play
Yes. I'm sorry, Representative Collins, we needed 11. Okay, thank you, Madam Chair. Eight to five. Representative Collins, do you want to run Senate Bill 421? Yes, ma'am. You are recognized
▶ Play
to run Senate Bill 421. Thank you very much, Madam Chair and committee. Senate Bill 421 is fairly straightforward. It deals with the Arkansas Business Corporation Act, and all we're doing is modernizing. When the act was written, they didn't have things like e-mail, et cetera. So we're basically changing the communication for a corporation to give them the option to how they want to reach people and changing the word mail to furnish. And then on the back page of the bill, it gives the company the opportunity to ask a shareholder for their email records and then give them the flexibility together to decide whether to go email or hard copy mail. And that's all SB 421 does.
▶ Play
Thank you, Representative Collins. Any questions from the committee? We already have a motion due pass. Anybody speak for or against from the audience? Seeing none, Representative Collins, or any more discussion from the committee? Representative Collins, are you closed for your bill? We have a due pass. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Congratulations, Representative Collins. You passed your bill. Well, Representative Collins, do you want to run SB 422? And I think if the committee can stay with us, we just have a few more technical corrections bills that we can get off the mat today.
▶ Play
So hang with us. Thank you, Madam Chair. Yes, I would like to run SB 422. Floor is yours. So this bill is longer and it does more things. What I want to give as background is, for those that are not involved in the banking industry, there are different ways to charter banks. It's the Arkansas Banking Act that we're affecting. Federal banks can do many things because the federal charter laws have been updated to a different degree than the Arkansas charter laws. So this bill modernizes the Arkansas Banking Act so that Arkansas corporations can do a lot of things which are typically done by public corporations and by banks that have charters either in different states or federally. One of the benefits of this is for, especially as we see in Arkansas, our banks are expanding. We have a concept known as the bank holding company. A bank holding company has different restrictions than an individual bank. And one of those issues, for example, is that a bank holding company cannot purchase another bank holding company directly if it's chartered in Arkansas. So I'm going to go through a couple of the key changes in SB 422 that are associated with this. But basically, we're modernizing the Arkansas charter banking laws so that we can keep our banks chartered in Arkansas and also hopefully even attract some new ones. The risk we run as our banks get bigger is that our more archaic laws are going to cause some of them to change their charter and move it either to another state or federal. So what are some of the things that we're talking about doing in addition to this largest thing, which is enabling holding companies to purchase other holding companies versus having more complicated structures? One of the things that this bill will do is it will allow Arkansas banks to repurchase shares, to repurchase stock shares. Obviously, we hear about companies doing that all the time. Another thing is change the shareholder vote requirements. Today, the way the banking law is written, shareholder votes are a simple majority for every decision. This would allow Arkansas banks, like many other companies have the option to do, to place higher than majority thresholds on certain votes, kind of akin to how we do things in the legislature. We have a 75-vote threshold on a budget bill, for example. Another thing that this bill does is simplify the ability of the bank to react to market conditions in the issuance of preferred stock. There are three primary ways of funding a business. One is common equity, another is preferred equity, and the third is bonds. Preferred equity is a hybrid type of security. It acts and has characteristics of both stock and bonds. So in these businesses, it can be a very desirable security. As a quick FYI, when Warren Buffett steps in, he usually has companies issue him preferred stock. Today in Arkansas, this must be done by shareholder votes. And what this bill would allow is for the shareholders to give that authority to issue previously approved preferred stock to a board of director decision. There are two or three other related and similar types of changes. Obviously, they're in the bill. We can talk about them if you want to. But they're all the types of things that make Arkansas banking laws and Arkansas banking charter comport much more to what contemporary banking laws are like and charters in other places, which makes us friendlier for business.
▶ Play
And I'm happy to take any questions. Members, do you have any questions for
▶ Play
Representative Collins? Representative Payton? Thank you, Madam Chair. Chair, if I read this bill right, would you agree that it creates more flexibility in structuring the ownership and in transferring ownership, and that it preserves the capitalization and may even incentivize better capitalization of a bank? Yes, sir, I would. Thank you. Any other members?
▶ Play
Okay, anybody in the audience wish to speak for or against? Seeing none. Any other discussion by the committee? I'm closed for the bill, Madam Chair. All right, all those in favor? Aye. All those opposed? Congratulations, Representative Collins, you passed your bill. Thank you very much, Madam Chair. We're going to switch chairs, and I'm going to run down, and we have three bills coming up.
▶ Play
Thank you very much, Vice Chairman Lundstrom. I appreciate you sitting in for the majority of this meeting while we did those different bills. We're currently on House Bill 1799. Representative Richmond, are you going to present House Bill 1799 or Representative Lundstrom? I'm going to start and then head to rules. All right. So you are recognized to present House Bill 1799. I have some guests here that would
▶ Play
like to be recognized first, that I would like to recognize first. Those guests can come to the
▶ Play
end of the table and sit down. While they're doing that committee, what I'm thinking, and you can mull as well, is we've got a lot of bills on our list. I don't know how many people are still going to be here for them. I'm thinking we kind of go to like noon-ish and then think about meeting 15 minutes after adjournment. That's what's in my mind to try and give people that haven't been able to be here this morning an opportunity to come this afternoon. So just think about that, and later I'll test the waters and see if you like that idea or not. At this time, Representative Lunchtime, if you'd like your people to introduce themselves and who they're with, you're recognized to present
▶ Play
1799. Thank you. Mr. Smith. Well, first of all, we have our commissioner, Edmund Waters, is here today. But I'm general counsel. My name is David Smith. Edmund
▶ Play
Speaker 239 1:37:29
Waters, Securities Commissioner. This first bill is
▶ Play
a Uniform Money Services Act. This is updating. um if mr smith could just give us a thumbnail overview i think
▶ Play
uh what representative lundstrom said she just about described this bill and that i would characterize it as uh just uh an update or cleanup mostly cleanup language or housekeeping changes. Uh, a couple of the items in here included, uh, we're, we're changing from a requirement that filings be made, uh, to a calendar year, uh, from, uh, they've been all over the board with fiscal year. So it'll just bring all the, all those registrants in line where we'll get our filings at the same time. And another example is the surety bond requirements. We're just bringing those in line with other statutes that we regulate so that those surety bond requirements are all the same for us to look at. Are there any questions for members? Seeing none,
▶ Play
is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak against the bill? For the bill, Representative Lundstrom, are you closed for your bill? Yes. I move do pass on House Bill 1799. Is there any discussion? All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Lundstrom. You've passed House Bill 1799 and you're recognized to present House Bill 1800.
▶ Play
This is just amending Arkansas securities laws and updating their transactions. Do you want to give a quick overview?
▶ Play
Are there any questions from the committee? Is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Are you closed for your bill, Representative Lundstrom? Yes. I recommend do pass on House Bill 1800. Is there any discussion? All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Lundstrom. You're passed House Bill 1800. Thank you, Chairman. You're recognized to produce House Bill 1801. This is to amend and update the
▶ Play
Fair Mortgage Lending Act. Are there any questions?
▶ Play
Representative Payton, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lundstrom, I noticed that you're adding the requirement for fingerprints, and I was just wondering if you could explain the necessity of why we would
▶ Play
add the requirement for fingerprints. This is on. Again, with the fingerprint requirement, those are currently required for the loan officers, and there is an additional requirement that principals from the company provide fingerprints. But it's really a slight change. The majority of our registrants are the loan officers themselves. If I could follow up. Yes, your recognition.
▶ Play
Okay, you're saying that it's already done, but I'm looking at language in this bill that adds it. Exactly. It's this
▶ Play
Speaker 247 1:40:57
line that you're welcome. All right, let's see.
▶ Play
Speaker 251 1:41:05
Lines one, two, and three on the second page, 36. It's this one. That's right.
▶ Play
it's the bottom of page one top
▶ Play
of page two right i'm i'm looking above that for the for who
▶ Play
Speaker 257 1:41:35
it is that has to to give that um i don't know if ms mcdougall has anything to add
▶ Play
Well, I guess it would be the loan officer, mortgage banker, mortgage broker, mortgage servicer. All of them would have to. Mrs.
▶ Play
McDougal has been a little more intimately involved with this, so let me have her come to the
▶ Play
Speaker 259 1:42:00
table and introduce herself. Thank you. I'm Ann McDougal. I'm currently the Deputy Commissioner for the Securities Department. Actually, the provision for the loan officers is in a different section. We're just adding it in this section for the managing principal who's responsible for supervisors. And it's so that when they answer the questions on their applications of have they been convicted of any felonies or misdemeanors involving financial transactions, that with a background check we can ensure that those are truthful answers.
▶ Play
if i could follow up i mean i'm uncomfortable with just you know gathering fingerprint information on as many citizens as we can without knowing that they have created you know committed a crime and how many people are in this class that would be fingerprinted we
▶ Play
Speaker 259 1:42:50
have approximately We have only 400 companies, so each company would have one person. The majority of those individuals reside out of the state. We only probably have about 30 companies that actually are domiciled here. So the majority of these people we're checking on are out of state people.
▶ Play
Okay, thank you Mr. Chair. Representative Ferguson, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
If they're out of state and other states are already requiring this criminal background check, Will you accept that, or did they have to go through the whole process?
▶ Play
Speaker 259 1:43:21
Excuse me. It's all done through a national database, so we all share that information. Okay. So
▶ Play
most of them probably already have it. They're already providing
▶ Play
Speaker 259 1:43:28
it to other states. Okay. Thank you. Are
▶ Play
there any other questions from the committee? Does anyone like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Lundstrom, do you want to close for your bill? I'm close. Thank you. I move to pass on House Bill 1801. Is there any discussion? All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Blundström. You've passed your bill. Representative Warren, you're recognized to present House Bill 1828. So here's what I'm going to propose is after this bill that we will end and then come back 10 minutes after session today and give the people, because I want our House members to get a chance to get their bills out of committee in the middle of this week and at least start them in through the House so they get some more time in the Senate. So does the committee have a positive or a negative reaction to the idea of coming back 10 minutes after adjournment? I see thumbs up. I don't see any thumbs down. So then without objection, we will come back after this bill, 10 minutes. Carol, how much time do you need? Do you need 10? Is that enough? Okay, so we'll do ten minutes after adjournment. Representative Warren, you're recognized to present 1828.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. First of all, I want to begin with full disclosure here. I am president of Hot Springs Title Company, so I am presenting a bill that deals with my industry. But I wanted to do that because sometimes this industry is misunderstood and I felt like I would be able to answer any questions and give detail on this that maybe someone else presenting it would not. The purpose of this bill is to make it where a title company and an agent or closer is not subject to negligence or action for negligence in performing their duties. Let me explain to you how a title company works. A title company does not insure title to real estate. We secure underwriters who insure the title. For example, I use Chicago title. Some use Old Republic, Fidelity National title. there are multiple underwriters out there. You go through the underwriters as a title company and as a closer, you are simply acting as an agent for these people. You are not insuring the property on your own. The reason that I wanted to do this is because I want you to understand that as a title company, you don't operate alone. You have to have underwriters in order to be in business. And the way that you keep underwriters is by not having claims. If you have claims for things that you continuously miss, you are going to lose that underwriter. You lose your underwriters, you're out of business because you don't self-insure. So we have incentive as a title company to make sure that we're minimizing any mistakes that we make because they're costly if we make them. So in addition to our underwriters, we also have to carry an E&O insurance for a million dollars. So a person that comes in and does a transaction with us, they have a right to make a claim against the underwriter on any insurance that they're given that's that's what their insurance is for is any fault that was made or any problem that occurs with their real estate they have the underwriter to go to and make a claim to make it right in addition to that if there's something that's not covered by the underwriter there's an errors and emissions insurance policy that is also there but this policy all this bill is doing is saying that your claim is against the underwriter it's not going to be against the company or the agent who did the closing i'll be glad to take any
▶ Play
questions uh representative eaves you're recognized for
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:48:24
a question uh representative warren so this section e1 it says the cause of action for negligence does not exist by an insured um for lack of reasonable care and searching and disclosing so is that just saying if i don't do if i'm a title agent if i don't do my job well you still can't have a cause
▶ Play
of action against me it can only be against your um my underwriter underwriter because the it's all going toward the title insurance. The title insurance is our product. I mean, is there any
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:48:56
danger that, I mean, you know, you have to have some responsibility to do your job properly as a title agent. So this is saying, it doesn't really matter what I do. You can't do anything to me. You've got to go to them.
▶ Play
I mean, I understand what you're saying, but the bottom line is that if we don't insure that property correctly, we're out of business.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:49:20
Because you can't get underwriting. That's correct. Okay,
▶ Play
thank you. Related to that question, because I want to make sure again we've got a clarity. You as a title insurance agent can get sued for lots of bad behavior. You can get sued for misrepresenting. You can get sued for gross negligence. You can get sued for all kinds of things. What this is saying simply is if you did all your due diligence and did everything properly and the underwriter went out of business or whatever, you don't have a liability on that. If they have reinsurance, fine, but you don't automatically become their reinsurer. Is that essentially what we're saying here, or
▶ Play
does this go further than that? No. It's saying that the person still has the underwriter to go to. That's who we are simply representing the underwriter. Hot Springs Title Company is not your insurer in my case, nor is Beach Abstract here or anyone else. It's who the policy is written through is all that we are simply agents for that company. Representative Payton, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Okay, I think I heard you mention that you had errors in omissions insurance. That's correct. Okay, that is there, in case you make mistakes, to cover your liability. That's correct. If this law relieves you of that liability, when would that insurance ever step in to pay anything?
▶ Play
This is just stating that if we're with relationship to the real estate property, the closing for that, if we have done something that is not covered by the underwriter, something outside of that, the E&O kicks in. The E&O
▶ Play
will never kick in if Arkansas law does not recognize your liability. Okay.
▶ Play
Can I ask a question, Representative Warren? So are there not two types of liability in an insurance business? One type of liability is a liability that all business owners have to manage their business properly, and especially when it's a technical or an administrative-oriented business like yours or mine, frankly, as an executive search business, it is possible for us to make errors and omissions, and we are liable for those, and we have E&O insurance for those things. There's a separate set of liability which goes with is a given title properly researched, et cetera, et cetera, And an underwriter specifically, narrowly, and only insures that risk. So if you are a shoddy, crappy title insurance agent, they cannot sue the underwriter to get any recompense from your shoddy work. And likewise, if the underwriter for some reason goes out of business or doesn't have proper reinsurance or whatever, you cannot be sued for that. And you're just clarifying that element. that you're not giving yourself some kind of immunity. Is that essentially what we're doing here? That's correct. Other questions from the committee? Representative Payton,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question. Thank you again, Mr. Chair. But you do recognize in this bill that the person who we are relieving in this bill of liability is an agent of
▶ Play
the insurer. Let me give you a case of what's happening and what we're trying to prevent here. When someone has had a claim on a policy, they have included the agent and the company in their suit. The person that we have contracted with to do that is our underwriter. But yet a closer is being brought into the suit individually. And she's had to rely on the researcher who did all the work, passed on to her, the information that was given to her by the mortgage companies for payoff, insurance companies for quotes. She's gathered all the information. She's done the job that she was supposed to do. that she's being brought into a lawsuit individually because she was the closer. Could I
▶ Play
follow up? I mean, I don't manufacture automobiles, but I've been named in the suit where a vehicle was substandard in its manufacturer. And because I sold that vehicle, you know, I'm named in the suit. That doesn't make me liable just because I'm named in a suit. So my question is, if the person that you're wanting to exempt from liability is an agent of the title insurance company, then I don't see how we can exempt them from liability. They're acting as an agent of that company that is
▶ Play
Speaker 272 1:54:41
liable. Can I make a suggestion, Representative Warren?
▶ Play
I would be open to a suggestion. My suggestion would be, with the number of people in the room here, and I'm seeing the questions in the heads, the way they're rolling, nothing can get out of the committee unless we agree. So what I would recommend is let us recess now, and then when we come back this afternoon, we'll pick back up with House Bill 1828, and that gives you an opportunity to have some conversations and see if we can work through this
▶ Play
or if we need an amendment or something else. Well, and let me ask you this, because a surprise to me today was that my expert witness is in Florida, so... Well, you can call
▶ Play
your expert witness in the intervening hours as well if you'd like. You got a lifeline. Okay. If you're amenable to that, we will recess at this time, and we will reconvene at 10 minutes after adjournment. I'm going to gavel us out for the people that are filming. Thank you.
▶ Play

Agenda

REGULAR AGENDA Sponsor Number Subtitle

1:43:46 - 2:31

HB1594 Sabin TO REVISE THE DEFINITION OF "PAID SOLICITOR" AS IT RELATES TO SOLICITATION OF CONTRIBUTIONS FOR CHARITABLE PURPOSES.

Sabin

2:31 - 7:31 17 segments 7 speakers

HB1166 Rushing TO CLARIFY THE OBLIGATIONS OF RESIDENTIAL LANDLORDS AND RESIDENTIAL TENANTS; AND TO REQUIRE IMPLIED QUALITY STANDARDS FOR TENANTS OF RESIDENTIAL REAL PROPERTY.

SB369 Rapert FOR 16-22-211 AN OF INSTRUMENTALITY UNDER CONCERNING § EXCEPTIONS GOVERNMENT AND GOVERNMENTAL SELF-FUNDING GROUPS AND SELF-INSURANCE RISK POOLS.

HB1448 M. Gray TO INCLUDE FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS INSURED BY THE NATIONAL CREDIT UNION ADMINISTRATION AS INSTITUTIONS ALLOWED TO SERVE AS DEPOSITORIES OF PUBLIC FUNDS.

HB1742 Rushing CONCERNING A CIVIL ACTION INVOLVING A DECEPTIVE TRADE PRACTICE; AND TO DEFINE THE MEASURE OF DAMAGES IN A CASE INVOLVING A DECEPTIVE TRADE PRACTICE.

M. Gray

7:31 - 42:31 105 segments 17 speakers

HB1750 Cozart TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE NOTICE OF A LIEN UPON RESIDENTIAL REAL ESTATE; AND TO CLARIFY THE MEANING OF A DIRECT SALE.

HB1751 Cozart TO CLARIFY THE RESPONSIBILITIES OF AN INSURER FOR APPLICATION OF INSURANCE PROCEEDS FOR ROOF REPAIR; AND TO PROVIDE FOR PROPER ALLOWANCES ON A ROOF REPAIR INSURANCE CLAIM.

HB1752 Collins TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING NOTICE REQUIRED FOR ABANDONED PROPERTY.

Collins

42:31 - 44:31 10 segments 4 speakers

HB1753 Collins TO CLARIFY THAT THE SUBROGATION AND REIMBURSEMENT RIGHTS OF PARTIES TO AN INSURANCE CONTRACT ARE TO BE DEFINED BY THE INSURANCE CONTRACT.

Collins

44:31 - 1:28:31 129 segments 13 speakers

SB421 Rapert TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS BUSINESS CORPORATION ACT OF 1987; AND TO AUTHORIZE CORPORATIONS UNDER CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES TO PROVIDE ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS TO SHAREHOLDERS BY ELECTRONIC MAIL.

Collins

1:28:31 - 1:30:31 5 segments 2 speakers

SB422 Rapert O AMEND CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS BANKING CODE OF 1997; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

Collins

1:30:31 - 1:36:31 14 segments 3 speakers

HB1799 Lundstrum TO AMEND THE UNIFORM MONEY SERVICES ACT.

Lundstrum

1:36:31 - 1:38:51 9 segments 4 speakers

HB1800 Lundstrum TO AMEND VARIOUS STATE SECURITIES LAWS; AND TO REGULATE SECURITIES TRANSACTIONS.

Lundstrum

1:38:51 - 1:41:31 14 segments 6 speakers

HB1801 Lundstrum TO AMEND THE FAIR MORTGAGE LENDING ACT.

Lundstrum

1:41:31 - 1:44:31 17 segments 6 speakers

HB1828 Warren CONCERNING THE ARKANSAS TITLE INSURANCE ACT; AND TO CLARIFY THAT NO CAUSE OF ACTION EXISTS FOR NEGLIGENCE BY AN INSURED AGAINST A TITLE INSURANCE AGENCY OR AGENT FOR LACK OF REASONABLE CARE IN A TITLE SEARCH.

Warren

1:44:31 - 1:56:12 36 segments 5 speakers

HB1840 Johnson CONCERNING THE APPLICATION OF INSURANCE PROCEEDS RESULTING FROM FIRE DAMAGE TO PROPERTY COVERED BY PROPERTY INSURANCE.

HB1890 Tucker TO ESTABLISH AN ARKANSAS CROWD FUNDING OPTION; AND TO REGULATE EXEMPTIONS UNDER SECURITIES LAWS.

HB1900 Bentley TO AMEND THE REQUIREMENTS FOR HEALTH INSURANCE COVERAGE FOR MEDICALLY NECESSARY FOODS USED IN THE TREATMENT OF INBORN ERRORS OF METABOLISM..

HB1958 M. Gray CONCERNING THE CREDIT SERVICES ORGANIZATIONS ACT OF 1987.

HB2042 Drown TO CLARIFY PROVISIONS CONCERNING REAL ESTATE LICENSE EXEMPTIONS; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE INVESTIGATION OF COMPLAINTS BY THE ARKANSAS REAL ESTATE COMMISSION.

HB2043 Drown CONCERNING THE REGULATION OF TELEPHONIC SELLERS.

HB2044 Drown TO MODIFY THE REGISTRATION OF CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS BEFORE SOLICITATION; TO AMEND ANNUAL FINANCIAL REPORTS AD FISCAL RECORDS REQUIREMENTS OF CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS; AND TO AMEND REGISTRATION OF PAID SOLICITORS.

HB2054 Hammer TO REPEAL THE ARKANSAS HOUSING TRUST FUND ACT OF 2009.

HB2061 Hammer TO MODERNIZE THE FIRE RATING SYSTEM IN ARKANSAS; AND TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS FIRE RATING BUREAU ACT.

HB2086 Sabin TO PROTECT THE PROPERTY RIGHTS OF CITIZENS; TO PREVENT THE ABUSE OF THE POWER OF EMINENT DOMAIN BY PRIVATE PIPELINE COMPANIES; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB2087 Sabin TO OPEN ADDITIONAL BUSINESS OPPORTUNITIES TO COOPERATIVE CORPORATIONS AND ASSOCIATIONS; AND TO PROMOTE THE PURSUIT OF CAPITALISM IN STRUGGLING COMMUNITIES IN ARKANSAS.

HB2135 Sabin TO CLARIFY THE OBLIGATIONS OF RESIDENTIAL LANDLORDS AND RESIDENTIAL TENANTS; AND TO REQUIRE MINIMUM HABITABILITY STANDARDS FOR TENANTS OF RESIDENTIAL REAL PROPERTY.

HB2139 D. Whitaker CONCERNING FRAUDULENT TRANSFERS AND VOIDABLE TRANSACTIONS.

HB2213 Henderson CONCERNING ARKANSAS PRICE DISCRIMINATION; TO ALLOW RETAILERS TO OFFER DISCOUNTS TO CUSTOMERS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB2240 Gonzales TO EXEMPT DIRECT PRIMARY CARE AGREEMENTS FROM INSURANCE REGULATION.

HB2249 Gazaway CONCERNING FRAUDULENT TRANSFERS AND VOIDABLE TRANSACTIONS.

HB2251 Gazaway CONCERNING THE PERSONAL INFORMATION PROTECTION ACT; AND TO DEFINE "ENCRYPTION" IN THE PERSONAL INFORMATION PROTECTION ACT.

HB1145 C. Douglas TO RESTRICT A JOINT TENANT'S ABILITY TO SEVER A JOINT TENANCY WITH RIGHT OF SURVIVORSHIP IN REAL PROPERTY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1271Hammer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HEALTH INSURANCE INNOVATION ACT OF 2017; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1838 S. Meeks TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE HEALTH SAVINGS ACCOUNTS OF CERTAIN STATE EMPLOYEES.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Charlie Collins Chair Unverified
87 segments
Representative Warwick Sabin Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 8
7 segments
Chris Morgan Unverified
1 segment
Representative Robin Lundstrum Chair Unverified
44 segments
Speaker 21
1 segment
Speaker 28
1 segment
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
23 segments
Speaker 59
1 segment
Speaker 61
1 segment
Speaker 62
2 segments
Speaker 66
1 segment
Speaker 73
1 segment
Speaker 87
5 segments
Kevin Krass Unverified
23 segments
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
21 segments
Speaker 106
1 segment
Speaker 110
1 segment
Representative John Payton Unverified
21 segments
Hank Klein Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 141
1 segment
Speaker 57
1 segment
Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 161
1 segment
Morrill Harriman Unverified
35 segments
Speaker 177
1 segment
Representative John Maddox Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 188
1 segment
Speaker 198
2 segments
Mike Boyd Unverified
17 segments
Speaker 224
3 segments
David Smith Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 239
1 segment
Speaker 247
1 segment
Speaker 251
1 segment
Speaker 257
1 segment
Speaker 259
5 segments
Representative Les Warren Unverified
16 segments
Chair Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 272
1 segment