May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
HB1628 B. Smith TO CREATE THE HEALTHCARE FREEDOM OF CONSCIENCE ACT. 1:40
The committee first adopted an amendment to HB 1628 by voice vote, and Rep. Brent Smith introduced the bill, explaining that it creates a Health Care Freedom of Conscience Act that prohibits discrimination on the basis of a patient’s status or identity and provides “reasonable accommodation” for health-care workers with religious or moral objections, while expressly barring conscience claims to refuse emergency, life-saving care.
[2:15][2:34][3:08][3:43][4:18][5:44][6:15][6:50]
The committee then moved to limit further debate to 15 minutes per side with a two-minute closing, a motion that carried unanimously, and the discussion proceeded without a final vote on the measure in this segment.
[48:55][49:08][49:12][49:16]
HCR1012 J. Williams TO ENCOURAGE THE GOVERNOR TO SUBMIT A STATE PLAN AMENDMENT TO THE CENTERS FOR MEDICARE AND MEDICAID SERVICES TO PROVIDE ACCESS TO COVERAGE … 2:22:54
The resolution HCR 1012 was introduced by Representative Williams, urging the governor to request a CMS amendment that would restore Medicaid-like coverage for migrant children and pregnant women from the Compact of Free Association islands.
[2:23:07][2:23:38][2:24:17]
HB1716 Richmond TO CLARIFY SHORT-TERM ACTIVITY AUTHORIZATIONS; TO ESTABLISH CONDITIONS FOR WAIVING THE FEE; AND TO ALLOW THE DEPARTMENT TO MODIFY THE FEE FOR A… 2:38:02
Speaker presented HB 1716, which would permit ADEQ to waive 25 percent of its routine fees to counties and eliminate fees in emergency situations, thereby reducing the financial impact on local governments.
[2:38:21][2:38:57][2:39:28][2:39:50]
An illustrative emergency (flood-washed-out bridge) and the rising ADEQ fees-exemplified by the Diamond Pipeline project-were cited to show the bill’s practical benefits and the need for flexibility in fee assessments.
[2:40:03][2:40:31][2:41:08][2:41:38]
The committee moved to pass the bill, and with no opposition the motion carried and HB 1716 was approved.
[2:42:59]
HB1851 Hammer TO AUTHORIZE A REGISTERED NURSE EMPLOYED BY HOSPICE TO SIGN THE MEDICAL CERTIFICATION OF DEATH AND PRONOUNCE DEATH FOR A PATIENT WHO IS RECEIVING… 2:44:36
Representative Kim Hammer introduced HB 1851, allowing a registered hospice nurse to sign the medical certification of death and pronounce death for hospice patients who die in a hospital, addressing delays caused by awaiting a physician.
[2:44:50][2:45:20][2:45:50]
The proposal received bipartisan support, including endorsements from the Hospital Association and the Hospice Palliative Care Association, and no member voiced opposition.
[2:45:50][2:46:00]
A motion to pass the bill was made, the “aye” vote carried, and the measure was adopted as bill 2067.
[2:46:00][2:46:30][2:46:35]
HB2067 Hammer TO CREATE THE PALLIATIVE CARE AND QUALITY OF LIFE INTERDISCIPLINARY TASK FORCE. 2:46:35
Representative Kim Hammer offered HB 2067 to create a Palliative Care and Quality of Life Interdisciplinary Task Force, citing collaboration with the Hospice and Palliative Care Association of Arkansas and the American Cancer Society to improve statewide palliative services.
[2:47:19][2:47:36][2:48:09][2:48:12][2:48:21][2:48:48][2:48:57]
we're going to move House Bill 1809 and 1810 to deferred at the request of the sponsor with no objection that will take place and then we got a special order of business for House Bill 1815 for March 16th with no objection we'll put that on the calendar
introduce a few people for you we have some interpreters in the room today courtesy of Arkansas Rehab Services we have Cheryl Sugg and Leah Gray thank you guys for being here today All right, Representative Brant Smith. Brant Smith, I'm sorry. You ready? House Bill 1628. And I believe you have an amendment and committee. That amendment is on the tablet. And if you don't mind, let's take care
we'll take up a motion on it what we've done is on page 3 line 5 we've deleted the word public or and on page 8 we've deleted lines 13 and 14 and substituted the following B1, an individual association corporation and then on page 9 we've deleted line 1 and substitute the following phrase protection laws within the state and so with that I'd ask for a motion to consider our amendment. I got a motion to
pass from Representative Meeks for adopting the amendment. Any discussion on that motion? Seeing none, all those in favor for the amendment, say aye. Aye. All those opposed? Ayes have it. You are recognized to present your bill as amended.
Thank you very much. I apologize for a scratchy throat. I guess we've got pollen in the air today. This is House Bill 1628. It's generated quite a bit of discussion. I think we'll be able to alleviate some concerns. We've already done that with several different agency heads and entities. But we want to walk through as much of this as we can and help bring this bill before the House for a complete vote. But it's an act to create the Health Care Freedom of Conscience Act and for other purposes. one of the things that I would call to your attention in the policy brief has to do with the need for this bill a lot of times I've experienced conversations where people would say well aren't you looking for a solution to a problem that doesn't exist and in this case all this bill is trying to do is clarify what we mean by the right of a health care worker to express their concerns about certain procedures they may be asked to perform. We're giving them the opportunity under reasonable consideration or accommodation to ask for maybe a little latitude from their administrator or their supervisor. But let me read a couple of things for you. This bill, House Bill 1628, actually prohibits discrimination against patients. 1628 specifically prohibits discrimination on a patient's status or identity. That's broad, status or identity. This protects members of the LGBTQ crowd and others from discrimination. One of the things that I've repeated numerous times in my conversation with media, with other legislators regarding the protections within this bill is we know that we often have HR at various hospitals within our state, recruit, hire, and put to work physicians or people that may come here with skills that we need, but they come from other countries where their culture, their belief system, maybe their faith is so different from, say, mine as an Arkansan and specifically one of those good old Southern Baptist boys, all right? But here's the thing. I was talking to some members of our Muslim community, and I mentioned if you have a physician that is required to use a pig valve in one of the surgeries and he says or she says my faith will not allow me to touch that pig valve reasonable accommodation means they go to their administrator their supervisor and they simply say hey next tuesday i need to step away from that procedure and can you find a replacement for me or Dr. So-and-so has volunteered to take my place on that surgery. And so with reasonable accommodation, they step back and that substitute steps in to complete the surgery. The same could be said for any number of jobs where there might be a religious objection or a crisis of conscience based on faith or some other issue that would prevent them from wanting to be a part of that. And so we're trying to protect everyone, and I really want to underscore the word everyone here. But then also, 1628 does not let doctors, hospitals, or insurance companies use freedom of conscience as a grounds for withholding life-sustaining treatment or appropriate health care services. In those emergency situations, there is no reasonable accommodation. That medical worker will perform their duties, and this does not allow them to walk away from an emergency setting such as an ER situation or maybe an on-call, hey, we need you in the OR right now. And so we're not trying to make this as an, this bill does not create an excuse, but rather focuses on those opportunities for reasonable accommodation when there's time to do so. And so I'd also like to mention one other thing before I ask Luke McCoy of the Family Council to maybe pick up on a point or two and address it before we take questions. 1628 gives legal recourse to a doctor, pharmacist, counselor, or other healthcare professional or company who is discriminated against for exercising his or her rights of conscience. We have a lot of opportunity here to express in law support for those people that serve us in the healthcare industry. As we look at this bill today and you consider a good vote, I want you to recognize that we have addressed every concern and issue brought to us. That's why we needed to do several, do the amendment this morning. This is actually through BLR and Miss Jessica Beal, I think the third, maybe fourth amendment to make sure we got this bill right. addressed the AG's concerns and other agencies within the state so that we could present you a more complete bill. And I would mention, this is my second term, and I really believe the statement I hear quite often, there are no perfect bills, but we can get reasonably close. And I think that's what we've tried to do with 1628. And with that, I'd like to ask Luke McCoy to speak on behalf of this bill.
with Family Council. I'm a lobbyist here. Thomas Jefferson once said, no provision in our Constitution ought to be dear than that which protects the rights of conscience against the enterprises of the civil authority. I think if you look in the past several years, you'll see on the east coast and west coast, even as close as Oklahoma and Tennessee, in fact, rights of conscience have been trampled on. And so current Arkansas code includes very good conscience protections for providers, hospitals, but yet it doesn't necessarily include good conscience protections for other people in the health care industry, such as clinic staff workers, counselors, social workers, medical students, and so on. If you look at the definition of health care provider in the bill, you'll see some of those listed out. But basically what we're trying to do is bring everyone else up in the health care industry to some of the same good broad protections and specific protections that doctors, nurses, pharmacists, and hospitals have. Not only that, second, we want to give them protection from discrimination. So in other words, these people shouldn't be discriminated against for their conscience. And then last, we want to give everyone in the health care industry a specific legal recourse should their rights of conscience be
discriminated against. I'll also add one more point. Illinois and Mississippi have already passed similar laws protecting the rights of conscience, and so we're not plowing new ground on a bill like this. we're simply better defining what we mean with this conscience bill. And with that, we'll be happy to take questions. Representative Love, you're recognized for a question.
want to ask a fairly simple question, but this is kind of the first time I'm hearing about a rights of conscience. I mean, explain to me kind of like what we're doing, and what we're asking to be done, I guess, with this appeal, rights of conscience. Kind of walk me through that, please.
So people have deeply held beliefs. Companies operate with a mission statement, a creed, values, certain principles, ethics, and so do health insurance companies. So when someone wants to exercise their conscience, it's basically saying, I don't want to participate in that. I'll give you a really good generic example of something I wouldn't participate in. So say I'm at a party, and someone asks, and there's alcohol at the party, someone asks me to lift them up and take a cake stand. I'm not going to do that. I'm not going to help them do that. And so I'm going to exercise my conscience because I think it would be wrong for that person to take a cake stand. So you could fill in the blank a lot of situations, but essentially you shouldn't be forced to represent love to participate in certain actions or procedures or so on and so forth. We're basically wanting to give specific clarification in law with health care industry workers because we've seen it across the country, even as close as Tennessee, like I mentioned earlier, where rights of conscience have been trampled on.
You have a follow-up? Let me mention one more thing in conjunction to this. I'll reserve my follow-up. We're not talking about emergency settings. We're talking about decision-making that has some time built in so that reasonable accommodation can be made for that individual that's being asked or required to do something. And this bill basically will allow them to have a replacement for a specific situation at a specific time. Probably 90% of the time, you're not going to have a problem. But there are those occasions where there is a crisis or a conflict of conscience, and we don't want someone losing their job because or being unduly criticized for exercising their right to conscience. You got a follow-up, Representative Love?
Okay. I've got a question. representative smith if you look on page eight with me go down to line 25 i'll give you a second to get there you give me an instant some insight on why the amount of damages shall not be less than five thousand dollars for each violation can you give me kind of line thought of what you were thinking when that was put in there or why it was put in there maybe mr mccoy can answer
Sure. Let's say someone who's lost their job, someone who's been lost out on certain benefits and so on, the cost that they're going to have to take to retain a lawyer, to pay for the court cost and so on, probably going to come close to that amount. And so that's probably the reasoning behind that. I'm going to
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I know we spoke earlier, but I'm still concerned about a patient being able to get the health care service that they need in an emergency or life-threatening situation. Can you address that a little more? I know you mentioned this doesn't apply to an emergency situation, but really what I'm trying to figure out is where's the line that something goes from life-threatening to an emergency? It seems, I know there are certain medical terms that would define when that is, but if you have to deal with someone's conscience, how can you, can you
speak to that a little more? Well, I'll begin, and thank you for the question. A lot of this circulates around elective surgeries, And it may be a situation where someone, say a surgical tech or an anesthesiologist, sees on their calendar of what's coming up in the next few days or week that they, it could be something as related to a transgender reassignment surgery. and they're in the field, they're needed in that operating room, but they just simply say, you know what, my conscience and my belief will not let me provide this type of service. And so with that clause, reasonable accommodation, they can go and ask, would someone take my place during that procedure? And with adequate time, someone could fill in for them and they could move on to some other surgery, maybe something as simple as an appendectomy or a tonsillectomy. But when we talk about some of these social issues and issues that are real divisive in our culture, there ought to be some reasonable accommodation for that person that's working in the field, and that's what this is trying to do, not diminish the need for emergency services, such as a car accident or some maybe a cardiac arrest some kind of myocardial infarction or something like that that would occur you're on call you're an EMT that's your job you've got to do it stabilize these folks and then get them to a facility where they can receive further treatment but in the case of an elective surgery that's what we're talking about is reasonable accommodation i might also say that this bill isn't just for
today but it's also for the future and the medical industry is rapidly changing but let's say members in arkansas and i've visited with some of you about this example let's say euthanasia becomes legal in arkansas and let's say you're a physician and the patient your patient comes to you you're just a general practitioner or whatever and a state law would allow a general practitioner to participate in euthanasia but you've got deeply held concerns, principles, values, whatever, against us in ASIA. Patient comes to you who's terminally ill, you've been treating him for a while, says, I want you to help me in my life. I want to make this a much better process. But yet you specifically would have issues with that. This law would help protect that doctor should that patient sue the doctor, and it'll also give that doctor specifically a recourse to fight back. Because right now in current code, again, and like I said earlier, doctors, nurses, and so on, they have good conscience protections right now, okay? So we're trying to raise everyone else in the health care industry up to that same level. So, again, if euthanasia were to become legal, I don't think anybody would say that a doctor should be forced to perform that procedure. Not only that, again, this bill would help protect the doctor from discriminations from health insurance companies or providers or institutions and so on that would discriminate against him for not providing euthanasia and also give him specific legal recourse. There's a section, obviously, towards the very end of the page, though, Austin, that addresses that. We've put the language in the bill, and it's already in state code, page 7, excuse me, page 8, lines 1 through 4, and basically talks about does not condone, authorize, or approve withholding of appropriate provision of health care services or life-sustaining treatment to patients. So I think there's a clear line between emergent care and something that's elective. I'm
going to go back to my other question I asked a while ago. If you look on line 24, it says reasonable attorney fees. So you're already collecting that, and you're still setting a minimum at $5,000. And, Mr. McCoy, if I understood you correctly while ago, you said that the reason that minimum was at $5,000 is to sustain those attorney fees and cost. So it looks like that's above and beyond those costs and attorney fees. Can
you address that? Yes, I think that was language that was added by another entity before the bill was filed, so I don't have specific reasons for that. But I would say right of conscience is a First Amendment right. It is very important, so I would like to think it should be very much protected. That's all I can say to that.
you chairman um mr mccoy you mentioned tennessee twice i think in your uh testimony can you give me a couple of specific examples of what happened in tennessee to give us some more clarity thank you
sure at vanderbilt university uh there were some nursing students that had to take a pledge so i'll take uh read a few lines out of this vanderbilt university required applicants to its nursing program to take an abortion pledge and so after a complaint that was filed with the HHS for a violation of federal law, Vanderbilt changed its policy. What about if Vanderbilt didn't change its policy? And what if these nursing students were denied to take further classes and so on? And they've been out so much money and so on. I think we need to give them specific prohibitions against discriminations and also specific legal
for another question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And usually I try to stray away from this, but I think this has an application. So we've been talking about consciousness and we've been talking about deeply held beliefs. That's been the testimony, correct? So I'm going to preface this with racism. racism can be a deeply held belief you could just deeply believe that doesn't matter if it's black white hispanic or whatever you can have a deeply held belief that racism is your right that's fine how does this play into that when we start talking about denying people access to care I mean, that's what I'm really concerned about. Okay. Well, and let me just state right off the top, I have zero tolerance for bigotry, racism, discrimination of any kind. And then secondly, there are preferences that we may have on certain issues, but then there are deeply held convictions. Principles never change. Our principles are what make us the type of person we are. But if you – let me just read something here that is what I had mentioned earlier. but 1628 probably does a better job protecting all patients as well as service providers than anything we have right now, and that's why we're bringing it to you because previous law is kind of broad, but this narrows things down and actually defines not only what is in the conscience bill but who is protected. And so there is less discriminatory language here which supports not only the health care worker side but the recipient of services than perhaps any law that we now have on the books. Mr. Chair, I need to follow up. You're recognized. Thank you. But Mr. Smith, we are talking about deeply held beliefs. And if this is your deeply held belief that you shouldn't serve as a Hispanic or you shouldn't serve as an African-American or you shouldn't serve as a woman or whatever your deeply held belief is, this is what this act is saying, is that your deeply held belief trumps that. And I mean, I'm pretty sure, I mean, I'm the only African-American here, but that causes me concern if you're saying that this is a deeply held belief and I can act on it. And I mean, don't you, I mean, you can't you can't see what i'm saying correct i can see what you're i can understand and i i empathize with that line of thinking but i i think at some point we need to pull back a little bit from always defaulting to racism being a part of a no no hold on hold on hold on hold on I did not say that everything is racist. That's kind of the channel that a lot of this takes. I will service and work with anyone that needs help. It's just that I'm not in that field. In the last several weeks, I've met with numerous groups and opposition groups that try to alleviate concerns, but there's nothing in this bill that focuses or targets on any specific ethnic group or nationality. Representative Love, may I respond as well? Sure. You can. We've
put language in the bill to be proactive to make sure that doesn't happen. I don't know if this has come to your attention already, but page 5, lines 25 and 27 and so on, And also for institutions, the next page over, same lines. Same thing for health care payers, page 7, lines 24 through 29. We've basically said you cannot use conscience to deny a person because of their identity or status. That's not tied to civil rights law, federal or state. It is broad. It's open-ended. I can't deny you for any reason, your favorite football team, whether you're married or not, what kind of car you drive, the color of your skin, your race, religion, any of that stuff. You cannot refuse a patient based on their identity or status. However, you can choose not to participate in a medical procedure of which you have conscience objections to. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
always putting out a lot of bills now looking for problems that don't exist yet. And I understand where you're coming from. I mean, I also kind of understand where Fred's coming from. But can you give me an example? Has this happened to your knowledge? And so something has happened, and we don't like it, and now we're introducing this bill to try to fix a problem? Sure. So there are laws,
as I've visited with a few of you beforehand, where they're addressing future needs. And like I mentioned earlier, this bill is for today, but it's also for tomorrow as the health care industry changes. But I would say that just because we haven't heard about it on the news or so on doesn't mean it's not happening here. We do have a medical school, much like Vanderbilt University, offers a nursing program. We have other programs around the state, ASU and other colleges that have nursing programs. There are instances where the health care industry is a significant portion of the state of Arkansas's economy. This happens. We're just not hearing about it because it's probably not media-worthy. I think some of us can agree that obviously there are things that don't make the news that should and a lot of stuff that makes the news that shouldn't. Follow-up.
I probably would disagree with you that it wouldn't be media-worthy. I think probably if it has been happening that we would know it. And I'm not saying that it's not. I mean, I'm not disagreeing with you. But I think it's media-worthy, too. But as far as you know, I mean, this has not happened yet, and we're just trying to make sure it never happens. How would – follow-up? Is this kind of like the riots of putting it on a – like a baker's bill, if you wanted to? Would that be equivalent? I mean, it's a different level, but to make sure a baker doesn't have to bake a cake for, again, a lesbian couple, if they didn't want
to? It's only similar in the fact that a health care provider, which is defined not just as doctor, nurse, pharmacist, and so on, a health care company, and so on, and then also a health care payer, if they have their conscience, and it's based on relevant documents, conscience is defined in the bill, they can choose not to participate in that medical procedure and so on. And, again, these are not emergency treatments. These are elective treatments. They can be anything from euthanasia to a pig valve, like Representative Smith already alluded to, and so on. So I would say it's only similar to the fact that you don't participate in a
Representative Ritchie, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Can you give me some more clarification on the bottom of page six where it talks about health payers having the right to decline to pay for a health care service that violates the conscience of the payer? Are we talking about insurance companies specifically? Are we talking about individuals? Who is the health care payer, and can you give me an example of what you're talking about
that? Yeah, it would be insurance companies, but we don't want to limit it just to insurance companies. There are other companies out there that are involved in the health insurance payment, if you will, type transactions. And so whether it's a go-between, third-party administrator, insurance company, and so on, they may not specifically underwrite those policies. They might be, like I said, involved in the third-party type involvement in the payment of a health care service. So,
I mean, what would be an example of what we're talking about, I mean, where a health care insurance agency, I mean, they're usually pretty clear on what they'll pay for, well, sometimes you find out on the other end, but most of the time, I mean, it's in their policies what they will and won't pay for, so what specific things are we thinking that a health care payer would have a conscience violation and not want to
pay for? Well, currently, health care payers don't have any conscience protection in state law, so that's why we added them to this bill. But second, if you look at court cases and so on, companies have values. They have mission statements, creeds, and so on, bylaws, and so on. So right now, for example, QualChoice has listed on their website here in Arkansas that they will not participate in some abortion and contraceptive-type procedures. I don't know that that's just good enough for them to be able to post that on their website. I'd like to see them have something in state law specifically saying that they're protected and, again, also prohibit folks from discriminating against them and also give them a specific legal recourse should they be coerced into participating in or covering, excuse me, controversial
thank you mr chair i'm gonna i'm still needing some clarity so i'm at least gonna need one follow-up you might have to move me back that's fine all right so representative smith i just want to say thanks for having the courage to bring this today i mean this is a big deal you see the audience and there are a lot of people here that they're interested so um i do appreciate that uh and and so i i'm still not clear on some things so for instance one of the issues in my mind is this like the little sisters of the poor and hobby lobby where the government came in and said hey you're going to do these things and it violated deeply held religious beliefs or is this more okay well i have a deeply held religious belief and so i go to work and so i'm struggling with what are we trying to protect people from the government or we're trying to make sure that people have the ability to to exercise things so in other words should we be mandating this or should the market be determining this because i have a freedom i have the freedom to choose i go to work here i go to work there there's probably more than one question in there but if you could somehow walk me through some of that and then we go ahead and throw in the next part okay help me walk me through again the
difference between this and the religious freedom Restoration Act that we passed last time. All right I'll begin by just saying and when this bill was brought to me by family council I reviewed it and I thought you know this is something that probably needs to be presented during this legislative session. It needs to be broadly reviewed and of course as you mentioned there is a quite a bit of interest in it. I think sometimes we need to differentiate between a consistent value-based faith where over time we have been very consistent in what we do and what we don't do as opposed to a last-minute maybe I just don't want to do something Right now, I don't feel good about performing some kind of procedure, but you mentioned a couple of entities, and one of those was Hobby Lobby. And while the federal government did try to force them to go against their deeply held convictions, Hobby Lobby eventually won. And so that was based on their consistency throughout their business life. And I think you could trace that back to the Green family that owns Hobby Lobby and how consistent they've been with their values, their faith. And so in these cases that we're talking about now, yes, we may take a job, and most people will take a job that is consistent with their values. But over time, as processes change or services may be added, there develops conflicts. And when those conflicts present, we need to go back to that health care worker, that provider, and just say, where have you been the last year, two years, five years, or ten years? And there's probably a good record of how they function. And so at this point, we're saying, as Luke mentioned, this is not just for today, but this is for years to come that we can set people up to be protected and not discriminated against when they are challenged. And so I think that may help
The right of conscience has been around before the Constitution here in our country. The only reason why Hobby Lobby, Representative Boyd, was successful, part of the reason why they were successful, was because they were religious people. However, not everyone goes to church. Not every hospital or clinic or health care payer is affiliated with a church or a religion or something like that. And so we feel like we need something in state law that protects those folks that aren't specifically associated with a church and so on. So I hope that addresses some of the concern to piggyback off what Representative Smith said. I think you had some other questions, though.
I'm going to put you back in and come to you. I will remind the committee we still have a large queue for questions, But we also have a large amount signed up to speak for and against. So just keep that in mind. And we do have some more bills that we have to run, too. So Representative Miller, I think, is who, Peyton? Yep, you're recognized for
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm going to ask a question kind of in a form of a hypothetical scenario. This is hypothetical. Nobody can throw rocks or anything. Now, let's say I am a general surgeon at a rural hospital, and I'm the only surgeon on duty for this shift. And as a deeply devout Christian, conservative, whatever you want to call it, I have deep convictions against homosexuality. However, a gay man is brought into the ER in need of life-saving surgery. Does this bill give me the right, as the only surgeon on duty, to say, this goes against my beliefs, I'm not going to perform surgery on this man?
a question. thank you mr chair so i want to go back to the heart valve surgery picture i um you know you said you're talking about elective surgeries people could decide not to do something on an elective basis if against their conscience i would argue that the heart valve surgery pig valves are not elective surgery i mean you either have it done or you're going to die so so i'm a surgeon i go to the operating room i take care of a lot of patients i take care of a lot of AIDS patients. What is there in this to protect my patient from someone in that hospital deciding they don't want to be part of that surgery because that person contracted their AIDS because of their behavior? I mean, what's to protect my patient and allow me to continue to operate at that time when I need the whole team there? And I'll give you an example. I've had this happen, okay? I've had this happen in the operating room, particularly back before we treated a lot of AIDS patients when people used to get a lot of CMV retinitis. They had retinal detachments. We had to do a lot of surgery on those people. And people would use that and say, well, I don't want to operate on an AIDS patient because I might get a needle stick. Well, guys, I've had needle sticks from AIDS patients. You know, I mean, that's just part of the job. That's part of what you do. What's to say I'm a physician and I am assigned to work on a tuberculosis ward and there's an AIDS patient with tuberculosis in seclusion from the world because they have a resistant tuberculosis. What's to say that I can, as a doctor, say, well, I'm not going to take care of that patient because, one, I could get their TB, but, two, they have AIDS. this goes against the grain of what being a physician is all about we take care of of patients irregardless of what where they're from what their background is what they believe in what they don't believe in they're human beings and we deliver a service to them at the time of need in their life so I really think I would like you to comment I don't understand how you can use your example of a heart surgeon. If a heart surgeon doesn't want to do heart surgery, then he doesn't need to be a heart surgeon, and he doesn't need to be picking and choosing between patients because of some deeply held religious belief or conscious belief. You take care of patients. That's what I was taught in medical school, and that's what doctors are taught now. You take care of patients. Do you have any
comment to that? We agree. In fact, on page five is the section for health care, freedom of conscience for providers and so it would not be discrimination if that providers supervisor administrator the hospital in other words at the clinic to say hey look you need to provide we've provided you a job description written just written certification is the words in the bill basically like you're gonna be required to do these things now if we can accommodate you we'll try but in the event of a life-saving treatment especially but even if it's not if we can't accommodate conscience then it shall not be discrimination for that employer that hospital that clinic whoever's in charge of the supervisor that that heart doctor cosmetic surgeon or whatever basically say hey look we need you to do it we can't accommodate you and so on only that conscience is defined as if you look at the definition it's something that's that's established it's not just really nearly out of the blue and and like I told represent love that you cannot deny a patient on their identity or status I guess we'll have to keep saying that again and again but committee I've had a
lot of requests for the surgeon general's opinion on this and he has another meeting at 11 so if you don't mind I'm gonna go ahead and let him speak and then we'll go back into questions to the sponsor without further ado Dr. Bledsoe I'm gonna recognize you if you would introduce yourself for the committee and then you can give your statement Thanks, Mr. Chairman.
Greg Bledsoe, Surgeon General for the State of Arkansas. I appreciate y'all allowing me to speak. I just wanted to give a statement from the Surgeon General perspective. Most people recognize me as a physician, obviously, and as the Surgeon General, but I'm also a Christian and someone that has some very strongly held beliefs of conscience myself. And this bill concerns me for a couple of reasons. I think the first reason is that in doing my duties as Surgeon General and as an active member of a faith community, I know a lot of people who are both people of faith and then also people in the medical community, obviously. And over the course of the last two years doing my job, I've had not a single person tell me that this was something that they were struggling with. So I've never had a member of any faith community come up to me and say, you know, this is a problem. We need to do something about it. I've also never had any physician or nurse or medical professional come up to me and say, we need to do something about this. In addition to that, in my own personal experience, I've worked here in Arkansas as an emergency physician. I have a lot of friends and colleagues in this state. I've also worked in other states. I've worked as a physician in Maryland, Georgia, and Alabama. Never heard of this being a problem in any of those states with regards to matters of conscience. And I think the reason for that is is that within the healthcare community there's always been accommodation of things I'll give you a perfect example I have a colleague here in the state of Arkansas who has very very strong beliefs regarding abortion and one of the things that he has refused to do is he will not write for the morning-after pill he's a physician he works in an emergency department but one of the things that he was able to work out with his group is there was another member of his group that would write the prescription with no name in it, so it could be addressed to any other patient, and this other physician would sign these prescriptions and allow these prescriptions to be used if a patient came in that needed the morning after pill or requested the morning after pill, and my friend, who's a colleague of mine, refused to give it. So there are always accommodations when you have these matters of conscience that are respected in the health care community, and I haven't had any members of the health care community come up and say that they felt like their beliefs were trampled upon. So in my mind, this is probably a well-intentioned bill. I understand the intentions behind it, and I respect the sponsors and also the folks that are sort of pushing for it. But I think it's well-intentioned, but it's misguided. And the other thing that I think is really important is that especially because we don't see this as an acute problem right now in our state, we have to be very cognizant of the sort of message that a bill like this sends. So if you're a member of any sort of minority group, whether you're a Christian and you feel like your beliefs are under attack or you're a Muslim or you're a member of the LBGT community, all those communities, if you're a member of those communities, these sorts of bills send a message that threatens you. And it can be perceived that way even if it's not intended to be that way. So I am very sensitive to that as a member of the Christian community, and I think we need to be sensitive to that, you know, looking at it through the eyes of others who may see this as a threat even though it's not intended by the sponsors to be perceived as a threat. But it sends a message to some members of those communities that our state is insensitive to them and is proactively trying to preempt something against them, especially when there's not an acute need right now. So because of those reasons I'm speaking out against the bill, I think it's well-intentioned, but I think it's misguided, and I think it's the wrong direction for our state. So I appreciate you all listening to my perspective on it. I'm open to any questions, if anyone has any. Questions for the Surgeon General?
for the sponsor. It may have been answered, but I was reading through the bill, and I just want to clarify. this if if somebody presents to a physician or a provider hospital may express and it is a emergency situation this bill they would still have to treat the patient on the basis of the emergency for which they were presented
address that type of situation as well. One follow-up, Mr. Chair. You're recognized. In a case where a physician would want to have the opportunity to step away in a non-life-threatening situation, somebody presents to them at their clinic, wants something done that violates their conscience, this bill would allow that physician to step away from that and give them some legal protection in order to be able to do that and and not quite similar but along the same lines of which physicians may not want to take somebody in their clinic because they don't have a good enough insurance plan any money at all maybe their Medicaid and that physician is not taking Medicaid patients anymore because they can't afford to. Is there similarity between the two or are those just two opposite directions? I'd say they're different, but
basically because the bill says you can't refuse a patient because of their identity or status, that is open-ended. Their financial status, so I'd say they're different. I would say they are opposite. Thank you. Representative Boyd, you're recognized for another question?
I think it might have been answered. Thank you. Thank you. See you. No further questions. We're going to go to the audience. We have quite a few signed up to speak for and against. So if you guys would, I'm going to have you move over for me. I've got a Dr. Janet Cathy to speak against.
can motion to limit debate yes ma'am how long do you want to limit that 15 minutes per side. I'll take that motion. Limit debate to 15 minutes each side. Would that motion include the closing
closing. Okay. All in favor of motion, limit debate 15 minutes each side that includes a closing. After the motion's carried or failed, I'll offer the member to reserve how many minutes. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed? Ayes have it. Representative Brent Smith, how many minutes would you like to reserve to close? Two minutes. We'll hold you two minutes. Dr. Cathy, you're recognized to introduce yourself for the committee, and we'll hear your testimony.
Thank you. I'm Dr. Janet Cathy. I am a lifelong Arkansan and have practiced medicine in Arkansas for 30 years. And most of my remarks reiterate what Dr. Bledsoe and Dr. McGee had already said. And I just wanted to say that I've taken care of thousands of patients in the years that I've been in practice. And I've never considered their religion, their race, their sexual orientation, whether they were obese, drug addiction, their politics, nor any physical affliction or disability they had in my care. I mean, were there patients I didn't like taking care of? Absolutely. But would I ever consider not taking care of a patient? Never. I would not consider my own religious beliefs, my own conscience, to be a part of my care because I would consider that egregious. I think Representative Love is right when he says, what is the definition of a deeply held belief? You know, you have to understand that the practice of medicine is above, by any provider, by an MD or any provider, the practice of medicine is above my personally held beliefs. And I think Dr. McGee would agree with that. I mean, this is what I teach my medical students. And I think that this bill sends a message to students, it sends a message to people that there are some people that don't deserve care and that I won't take care of them, not because of who they are, not because of I can't take care of them, but that I won't take care of them because of who they are. And I think that it's important to address the payer. I mean, I think some of the examples given were observed. Well, let me give this example, that a payer can say, you know, obesity is self-inflicted. We're not going to take care of people with obesity. Our smoking is a self-inflicted illness. And as a payer, we consider that a, we're not going to cover that. I mean, there are certain moments in your life that are memorable because of the amount of pain they cause you, not just physically, but just heartbreak. And when I read this bill, I mean, it was one of those moments. It really kind of broke my heart as a physician that it would even be considered because I think that the heart of this bill is so unkind. You know, I serve as an example, as a role model, not just the medical students, but to the entire medical team. And my attitude and how I take care of them is going to determine whether that patient is cared for not just medically, but cared for compassionately. I mean, as a politician, perhaps you have the luxury of supporting an issue based on your moral or religious or matters of luxury, matters of conscience. As a physician, I don't have that luxury. I mean, I have a person in front of me, not the masses. I have one single real person in front of me that has a need. And anything I believe is their need is put above my belief. And if that's not what you believe, then you shouldn't be in medicine. And that's what I teach my students. if religion were to play a role in my care then it would be the story of the good samaritan and i would ask that before you vote on this bill i would say that your concerns should not be about protecting providers your concern should be about protecting patients i would ask that you consider the story of the Good Samaritan. I would say consider how you treat the least among us. I mean, we are all members of some minority. There's something about every one of us that offends somebody. Perhaps you just don't know what that is yet. I appreciate your time. Thank you. Hold your
claps. Keep the order in the room. Keep the order in the room. Next, we have Mr. Jerry Cox speak for the bill. Mr. Cox, if you would, introduce yourself for the committee, and you're recognized, speak for the bill.
I'm Executive Director of Family Council, and I'm here to speak on behalf of this bill. One of the points that I want to address to begin with is this whole thing of emergencies. There are an array of laws already on the books that say that no doctor can deny life-saving treatment to a patient. and this in no way trumps that and it in no way affects that so I don't care who you are what you are if you're if you need emergency treatment the law the doctors are bound by the law to render that and so are the nurses and everybody else and so really this discussion about emergencies it should be just off the table as far as this particular bill is concerned the next point I want to address is the whole racism part of the discussion and if you if you look at the bill it says in three different places the very same thing that is nobody can deny treatment to a person based on their status there I don't know that it specifically says race but it's all covered in that part ethnicity all of that's covered the way that's worded and so a person could not walk into you know a patient say oh you're the wrong color you're the wrong ethnicity you're the wrong religion you're the wrong whatever and I'm not going to treat you so really that discussion though it's a good one to have this bill just does not apply to that because you know what it applies to? Procedures. Procedures, not people. And so the way this works is, let me bring this. You know, all of us are familiar with conscientious objectors in the military during the draft that conscientious objector makes his objection known on the front end and he says I don't want to kill people and the military guess what they make accommodation for that and they say okay then you can drive an ambulance you can do these other things you still have to be involved you have set to serve but we're not going to we're not going to make you violate your conscience this bill would create discussions between employers of health care people individuals insurance companies all these others it would create it would create that situation where they would work that out ahead of time and the person would say you know what I don't do abortions you know what I don't do birth control you know what I don't do certain kinds of procedures but they would not be able to say I don't treat certain races or ethnicities or anything like that. In fact, I would maintain that this puts that in the law for the very first time in Arkansas that you cannot do that. And so it's not like you just walk in one day and say, oh, I suddenly have a brand new conscience objection. That all has to be worked out ahead of time, and it probably ought to be worked out between employer and health care provider and all the people concerned. And so you just can't pick and choose. So I think much of the concern about this bill is that people haven't read the bill, and they don't understand what it will do and not do. And so I would urge everybody to look at the bill and what it does, not what some people might think it might do. Thank you,
what line, in three places where that's in the bill? I don't have the bill right here in front of me, but maybe Rep. Smith can, but it's in there under the provider, under the payee, and under the part there about the hospitals. Mr. McCoy, I don't know if you can help. May he help with that, Mr. Chairman? Yes, sir. Mr. McCoy, if you would. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. If you
look at page 5, lines 25 through 27, specifically line 27, If you flip over to the next page, the same exact lines. I don't see. Do you want me to read it? Read it. All right, so page 5, lines 25 through 27 say this. This section applies only to individual health care services and does not authorize a health care provider to refuse to provide health care services to a patient based on the identity or status of the patient.
in this bill? It is not defined, and when I spoke to the Arkansas Hospital Association to give them credit in trying to make this bill better, they offered that language, and I asked Jodianne specifically, I said, please tell me this is open-ended, and it's not tied to the civil rights law, federally or in the state, and she said, correct. I also spoke with another attorney and said, what do you think? Is that open-ended? Is that any identity, any status? He also agreed.
Obviously, Mr. Chairman, we're not here to speak on behalf of the hospital association or anyone else, but do know this, that we consulted with a number of health care entities and individuals and attorneys and so forth as we put this together, and as the sponsor pointed out, it has been amended and was changed in draft form several times before we finally got to this point. So we tried really, really hard to cover all those bases. Seeing no further questions, thank
you for your testimony. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I have Dr. Teresa Daly testify against the bill. Dr. Daly, if you would introduce yourself for the committee and you're recognized to testify against
the bill. Thank you. I am Teresa Daly. I am both a physician and a priest, and I am also the parent of a gay child, and I am here to testify as all of those, and this is really what I want to say in its brief. In medical school, there were procedures that I did not want to participate in. I did not want to participate in an abortion. I was able to say that at a very liberal New England medical school. It was Yale, and I was able to say, I don't want to do that, and I did not have to. I feel in all my time as practicing as a physician that this has never been an issue for me. I have treated many people that I did not agree with. I have had to take care of families where there were child molesters, where there were abusers, where there were people addicted to drugs. Is that against my moral conscience? To do those things, yes. But this is what I want to say. As a physician, I think this bill is much more likely to hurt those who are disadvantaged, those who are on the margins of society, than it is to hurt someone like me. And besides that, perhaps down the road, could there be something that a physician might not be able to do, a place they might not be able to work because of what they refuse to do? Maybe, but you know what? Our fate also carries with it the possibility of sacrifice. And if we are not willing to make that sacrifice, How can we expect other people to sacrifice their well-being for our comfort? And I feel that that's a really important thing for me to say. I also want to say that I'm not sure that I do trust the intentions of this bill as a parent of a gay child. I know what it will signal to her, and it will signal that she is not worth what many of the people in this room are worth and that is incredibly painful to me as a priest who respects the dignity of every human being whether I agree with them or not as a parent who loves my child and as a physician who cares for the well-being of every person who walks in my office or has ever walked in my office thank you Dr. Daly
thank you doctor could you educate me on the Hippocratic Oath and what if you can recite it not a test question but if you can recite it or at least tell me about the structure of the Hippocratic Oath that you take and a follow up Mr. Chair if I may
You know what, I'm going to be honest. We kind of bear it down to do no harm. It's much larger than that. But for me, the spirit of the Hippocratic Oath is to respect the dignity of every person that comes before us. That doesn't necessarily mean doing every procedure that someone wants done, but it does mean making sure that they receive it if it's necessary for their well-being, making sure that they are referred to someone who can do it, making sure that they feel cared for and that they feel that their life is important. And I think that's the spirit of the Hippocratic Oath. And I'm sorry, I can't recite it. Follow-up, Mr. Chair. Do you reckon us?
I am not being insensitive, but you have publicly declared that your child is of a different persuasion. So here's what I want to ask you. Would your child be more likely to seek out treatment from a physician that she would know would be friendly to her lifestyle versus somebody who would not be friendly to her lifestyle in order to get her medical needs met? I also don't mean to be insensitive but I don't think that that's pertinent to
the reason I ask that is A you brought it up for public discussion but number two to set the stage that it's an individual's choice as to who they seek their physical care from and I'm going to go to a physician that I feel comfortable with and if I'm in front of a physician that I'm not, I'm not going to go back to them, and that's why I'm bringing it up, is that it's an individual's choice as to which physician they go to see get care from, regardless of whatever
their needs are. Would you agree with that? Not completely. I have worked in very small towns where there are very few physicians who are available, and I don't think that it's totally an issue of preference. I think oftentimes when you walk into the physician's office, you don't know the, you know, religious beliefs of the person who walks into the room to you. And above all, I believe that this bill is unnecessary, and that's the main point for me. I think it paints physicians in an unflattering light. and I also believe that at the end of the day it is more likely to harm those who are disadvantaged, who are marginalized, who are of a minority than it is to hurt, than the non-passage of this bill would be to hurt physicians. All right, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Seeing no further questions, thank you
for your testimony, Doc. uh we have no more signed up to speak for is there anyone in the audience to speak for the bill see you none we'll go to the next i got michelle plumbo and you have about four minutes left ma'am
i'll go fast under a minute i promise uh i am a resident of Little Rock. I'm a citizen of the United States. I'm also a trans woman and I've also have a very serious heart condition. I've had eight MIs. This is all part of public record. I own property. I'm a fairly large landowner in Fulton County and three times I was admitted to Fulton County Hospital. Very small county hospital. Anybody familiar with Salem and Fulton County would know that and as soon as it came to light that I was a trans woman the entire how do you want to say the conversation changed that's even before this law and the way I look at it this law is only going to give people license to treat me badly and I'll be honest with you that is of deep concern to me so I don't have a choice when I go into a small emergency room when there is one attending physician and two nurses on staff I do not have that choice I am there and whoever is on call treats me so I mean that's the end of my discussion and that's my testimony thank you
we do witnesses left table right we have a Reverend Peggy Cromwell speak against the bill. Cromwell, I'm sorry. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. You introduce yourself. You recognize speak against the bill. Yes. My name
is Peggy Cromwell. My concern for this bill is great. I have 31 years experience as a public school teacher where we welcomed and taught and did our best for every child, regardless of any kind of tag that came with them. I believe as a deacon in the Episcopal Church that my call is to recognize the dignity of every human being and work to alleviate whatever problems they may have. I am a caregiver for my partner of 14 years who has suffered with multiple sclerosis. My understanding of this bill as it is written is that although she has received treatment for years from a doctor. Now it might be more difficult for her to even get to the doctor if she runs into a receptionist or an insurance person or anything like that who might have a moral objection to the fact that I happen to be pushing her wheelchair. It's a very disturbing bill. I appreciate greatly the comments of Dr. McGee and Dr. Bledsoe and Dr. Kathy and Dr. Daly. And I strongly urge the committee to please listen to those experts.
Thank you. Thank you. Seeing no one else signed up to speak against, Representative Smith, you recognize a close for your bill. You have approximately 10 minutes to close your bill, about nine
Thank you, Mr. Chair. After, you know, the thing about listening in a room like this to all the concerns and questions demonstrates the quality and the kind of people we are. As fellow Arkansans, we're a caring group. We do care about our neighbors. We care about the health needs of those that are ill, those that need services, and we're compassionate to our people. this bill does not discriminate against the identity or status of an individual if you really knew me in my background and some of the things that I've been able to do for others you probably would champion some of those things that I've done And this bill simply protects the right of conscience for those individuals, we're not talking about mean-spirited, hateful people that simply have an issue maybe with a procedure. And so our fight today is not about an individual, a status, an ethnic group, but about procedures and whether that conscience, that issue of conscience can be accommodated. And I want you to focus on the words reasonable accommodation. I think sometimes we take our physicians, our nurses, our medical teams for granted. I mean, when we need them, they're supposed to be there. But when it comes to some of the elective surgeries that are not life-threatening, there are opportunities for health care workers to reschedule their work environment to accommodate their rational approach to what they can do when a conflict of conscience surfaces. Not our physicians prescribe opiates randomly. Or any number of patients might come in and say, I need more painkillers. I need more narcotic-style medications. and those wise physicians often turn those individuals down and they won't prescribe them because they know they do harm. And so when it comes to a health care worker simply saying, this is one procedure that I prefer not to be involved in, we should reasonably accommodate those people so that they're not themselves in jeopardy of losing their jobs. And with that, I'd ask for a good vote and for a member to make a motion for due pass. I had a motion due pass for Representative
Lundstrell, and I'm going to open it up for discussion. As amended. As amended, right, Representative Lundstrell? I'll open it up for discussion. Representative Love, I'm going to recognize you for discussion.
discussion but okay you're recognizing well i want to say first and foremost i mentioned the issue of race and it's not because i was calling any sponsor or anyone associated with the bill or racist that was not my point. My point when I mentioned racism is because it can be a deeply held belief in which that's what we were discussing. So if anyone took my comments to say that anyone associated with this bill is a racist, that is not the point that I was trying to make. I was just stating that it could be a deeply held belief. Secondly, when we begin to talk about this and the consciousness, it does scare me that someone could say, just say, for instance, and I'm thinking about the movie that just came out, Loving, about the case in which there was a Caucasian man and an African-American woman married, and they are to enter a room or enter a hospital facility. someone could use that as a deeply held belief to say I do not believe that an African American woman or Caucasian can be married and that could be a deeply held belief and so when we begin to when we begin down this road of consciousness I just want people to be aware that even though it may not be your intention that the bill be used this way it could be used this way whether it's an intended consequence or unintended consequence but it could be used this way and so I do take you at your point that you don't believe in discrimination, you don't believe in racism but you're not the one that this bill is going to be applicable to it's going to be applicable to everybody in Arkansas and so that's what I would like for you to consider And in that, Mr. Chair, that's what I would want the committee to consider when taking into account this bill and how it will impact not only minorities, I mean, it impacts everybody. It impacts everyone. And so with that, I would say I would hope that the committee would not pass this bill out because it has a detrimental impact to all Arkansans.
Chair. Representative Smith, I appreciate you bringing this because I appreciate the discussion this morning. It's been lively and informative for me. But a couple of things that worry me a little bit, worry me a lot about this other than what we've said. One is we talk about insurance companies, and so in their conscience, what if an insurance company in their conscience said a fetus at 26 weeks is not going to survive, so we're not going to cover treating them? It opens that door. It opens that, even though I understand where you're trying to go, that opens the door for them to do that, to deny some type of care. And it was mentioned earlier about the obesity problem where someone could say, well, we have a conscience against that, and we're not going to treat those patients. So I take a lot of issue with it. One of the things I would like to know is I'm a health care provider. I have not seen any health care group get up and testify for or against this. I've not seen any insurance company get up and testify for or against this. I don't know that this is really an issue at this time, and with that said, I would ask people to vote against it. Thank
Thank you, Mr. Chair, and I've tried really hard to be very quiet today. I'll just have to say, I mean, if I agreed with Representative Love and Representative McGee's interpretation of what this bill does and several of the people who spoke against it, I'd probably not vote for it. I just, when I read the bill and I see the line about, you know, you can't discriminate on identity or status, and that it's only about the procedure. I mean, I can understand a medical professional having a deeply held principle that they do not want to participate in some procedures. And I don't see that being translated in the bill to the identity of the patient or the lifestyle of the patient. I just see that a health care professional can say, this is a procedure that I don't want to do, and I have a reason not to do it. and I don't see how that correlates to the identity or the lifestyle or the practice of the individual in the bill. If I did, I would agree with you all, but I'm going to vote for it.
I like the bill, and there's a couple of different reasons. I love the fact that we would protect the Catholic hospital from having to do abortions or give out birth control or voluntary sterilization. They could say no. The only reason Hobby Lobby won is they were big enough to afford attorneys. This protects the little guy, the nurse. If in a time of crisis with our country we allowed soldiers to have a conscientious objection, surely we could protect nurses and people in the health care profession when it's not a time of crisis, when it's about a procedure. I'm for this bill, and I think it
you, Mr. Chair. Just one follow-up with that, Representative Lundstrom. St. Vincent's Hospital here in Little Rock is a Catholic-based hospital. Catholic Health Initiative runs the hospital. They do not perform abortions, never will. They do not perform sterilization. Catholic Church, you know, somebody asked me one time, asked my wife about what my stance was on abortion. She said, my gosh, we're Catholic. We don't even believe in birth control. So they don't perform any sterilization procedures, and they never will. They've chosen to do that. And the doctors that work at that hospital know that. And there's no one that's ever put them on guard and said, well, we're going to do this or we're going to challenge that. The physicians know that, and the physicians, the obstetricians, and the urologists that all practice there that do those procedures take the patient elsewhere to another hospital where it's allowed. So I haven't seen the hospitals association down here testifying against this. This doesn't affect them. I haven't seen doctors testifying against it. I haven't seen insurance companies testifying against it. I think it's a solution or whatever, how do they say that, a solution looking for a problem or a problem looking for a solution. So that's why I'm against the bill. I think it's a non-issue in the state of Arkansas. So thank you.
think we ought to have the same rights as maybe the Catholic Hospital does and protect everybody's individual rights. So we just agree to disagree. Representative Bentley, you're recognized for discussion. I
that folks took this as an affront to them or any – I see this as a bit of protecting everybody's rights, and I really feel bad that people feel that that doesn't do that. So I think, again, I just want to reiterate this doesn't say about people. I think this gives more protections to people that haven't had it in the past. I see it as really helping folks of every community to be protected. That's really what I read in the bills. I see people being more protected than they were before, and this is really about procedures, and I think that Dr. McGee, doctors and nurses, we do have some protections, but those people that are even small in the list that really have no voice to speak up to this point, it gives even people, workers in the clinic, whatever, that haven't had a voice before, it gives them a right to have that voice. And so it really gives me greater protection to people that haven't had it before, and it's really about procedures and not people. And I just hope it would read the bill.
I want to speak as someone who came in here not knowing which way to vote. Maybe that's a different viewpoint. And I got a call. Originally I was for this bill. I've been very busy, and I should have read it in more detail. But I got a call this morning from someone who I really respect and said, you really need to look at that bill. It might not be good. It might not be good for the medical industry, for the hospitals. And so I did. I listened intently to the discussion here. And as Representative McGee said, it's been a very interesting discussion and a very important question for all of us. But when I hear this and when I look at the bill, I think we have to zero in on what the bill says. there are a lot of people here that feel like this is going to affect them and in my opinion it probably does not affect them that's just my opinion so if we look at the bill i believe it does protect people that are not being protected now from discrimination and it gives them the right to speak up and to do what they think deeply is the right thing to do and not be reprimanded in losing their job. I understand there are a lot of protections in place now, but I think this gives more protection to people who work in the medical industry and who work in insurance. So for that reason, I've decided to vote for it. Thank you. Seeing no
further discussion, all those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? No. I have to rule the ayes have it. I've got two hands for a roll call. Mr. Price, if you would, call the roll. Representative Pilkington.
7, 8. With eight yeses and 11 noes, your bill has failed. Thank you. Let's keep the order in the room. We cannot have that. Keep the order in the room. Representative Pilkington, you recognize the run House Bill 1706. Question
of the chair. Yes, sir. Please advise to have this bill recalled for consideration in committee what the processes are, please. The bill previously run? The one that we just voted down?
Representative Pilkenen, hold on one second. Let's do that now. Let's concur and send an amendment first. We need to take care of that on the agenda. Representative Farrar, are you recognized to concur an amendment on House Bill 1016? Thank you, members. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thanks, Mr. Pilkington, for letting me do this. This will take me two or three seconds. What this is is a concurrent with the HP 1016, which is the DRG bill I ran way early this time. When it got to the governor's office, the DHS found out the date was not long enough to give them time to implement this program. So they asked me to change the date, so I did. We ran it back to the Senate, and it's back here to get a concurrence with, and I appreciate a good vote. I got a motion. Is there anyone in the audience to speak for or against this concurrence? Seeing none, Representative Ladyman, I'll take the motion to concur and send an amendment. Any discussion on the motion? All those in favor, say aye. All those opposed. The ayes have it. Congratulations, Representative Farron. Thank you, committee. Intercept you, Miller. There's always
present your amendment first, please. Okay. This amendment is simply changing some definitions that were at the request of some of the medical groups in Arkansas. We also added a consumer advisory board to the past as well. This was something a lot of patient advocates wanted, and I think it makes a good bill even better. Do you want to add
anything to the amendment? Maybe I can just grab this one. All right. This five pages of amendment actually represents input from legislators, from provider groups, from families, from advocates. So we've taken into consideration everything that was presented to us over the last two or three weeks, sorted through it, put in what we thought would improve the bill, and that's what you're seeing in this amendment.
Well, it's a pleasure of the committee on the amendment. I got a motion to do pass, Representative Boyd, on the amendment. Any discussion on that motion? All those in favor, say aye. All those opposed, ayes have it. You're recognized to present your bill as amended.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Before I hand it over to Dennis Smith, who can speak a lot more intelligently to this than I can, I'll just give a brief overview. I know we've been there a long time, so I'll try to be brief. What we have here in House Bill 1706, which is also known as provider-led organized care, is a completely unique model in delivering health care in the United States. No other state has a system like this. What essentially we're doing is we're bringing the level of coordinated care by letting providers in this state lead, communicate, develop organizations and networks in order to provide services to around 30,000 Arkansans. These are people who after the independent assessment will be ranked a tier two and a tier three. We also hope that through this we'll see savings that will be able to allow us to eliminate the disability waiting list over the next five years. And I know that's something that's been on a lot of our hearts this session is to do what we can to fix that waiting list. So that's a brief, extremely brief overview. But I'd like to turn it over to Dennis Smith from DHS right now. Thank you very much. Appreciate the time, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. This is a unique approach to bringing in a model of organized care. In Medicaid today, beneficiaries are in a fee-for-service system in which individuals with very complex medical needs, behavioral health needs, individuals with developmental disabilities in many respects are out there navigating a complicated system on their own. This puts these high-cost individuals really at the center of a new coordinated system in which an entity called a Provider-Led Arkansas Shared Savings Entity, or a PASS, will be held responsible and accountable for improving the health care outcomes for these individuals. We spend about a billion dollars on approximately 30,000 people with intensive behavioral health and developmental disability services needs. So it's a very small population but one that we believe would greatly benefit from this model of coordinated care in which this entity would become responsible for the entire array of services that these individuals need, their physical health care, as well as their behavioral health, substance abuse, and the specialty services of individuals with disabilities. There are certain populations that are exempted from this, because this proposal would be a mandatory enrollment of the individuals in which we consider to be the highest cost individuals. You've heard the expression tier two or tier three. The entire universe of people with behavioral health claims or claims related to developmental disabilities is about 150,000 people altogether in the state. So this is getting only at the very highest cost individuals, as I said, about 30,000 people. But in this, the pass would become responsible over time for the entire cost of their care. There will be a phase-in period in which the provider-led entities will begin forming these passes this spring and summer, starting enrollment October 1st of this year. But these entities themselves will not take on full risk until January 2019. So during this transition period, we will learn much more about the specific claims paid on behalf of these individuals. Again, on the developmental disability side of things, individuals who are already in waivers. The department knows already a great deal about the individuals in need of those services. But on the behavioral health and substance abuse, quite frankly, while we know the claims, we need more experience, we believe, in order to be able to eventually set actuarially sound rates for the passes. So we believe this transition period is a protection not only for the beneficiaries, but the providers and the taxpayers as well, so we have this claims experience with these individuals. The passes will be required to serve a minimum of 10,000 individuals once it is fully, once we get to full risk. So that means that there will be a limited number of these passes. We are hopeful, based on discussions that we have heard, that we'll have two or three passes. So we will have competition, which, again, I think is particularly good in terms of the quality of care for the individuals and for the taxpayers. This will be regulated as an insurance company, so it will be subject to the existing 2.5% premium tax on insurance companies. That tax we will use to be able to generate revenue from the federal government in which we will continue to reduce over time the waiting list for individuals waiting on the DD waiver and eventually, over time, eliminate the need for that. We've already made great progress in helping to reduce the waiting list, but this is an additional way to eliminate that even faster. The past must be owned. 51% of the ownership must be from the providers themselves. Again, this is a unique model, but we believe that after looking at other managed care, traditional managed care models around the country, we believe the uniqueness of this being provider-led and owned is a critical component of that. Governance board members must be Arkansas-licensed providers. We have added, again, additional providers to the membership. We've added the Community Pharmacy Enhanced Service Network providers, which again I think is a uniquely Arkansas-grown product in which our pharmacists have become more and more involved in the care of individuals. This is, there are beneficiary protections already built into the system as it is. This will be subject to the managed care rules at the federal level, which assures access to providers, network adequacy, freedom of choice. Again, Individuals will be attributed into a pass based on current relationships that they have with their providers, their specialty providers, but also other providers as well, their pharmacists, physicians, et cetera. But even after that attribution is made, individuals will still have 90 days in which to switch out of a pass and choose a different pass if they would like to. Underlying all of this are the federal regulations on grievances and appeals, all of which are backed by enforcement mechanisms in which if there's failure to perform, DHS has financial tools to enforce compliance. So those protections are not only there under the current system, but they will be reinforced in the certification application in which APAS must agree to all of these beneficiary protections and then at the end of the day, if it is necessary, we have the ability to sanction a provider for failure to perform. So again, I think this is uniquely targeted to the highest cost individuals who will gain the most from this system of coordinated care. We believe that it is an improvement for the beneficiaries. We believe that it opens new opportunities for providers in that they can get out of the Medicaid black box. All too often, providers are frustrated they do not get paid for things that they will be able to be paid for under the new model. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Payton, you're recognized for a question. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. Mr. Smith, there had been some talk about some protections for patients, the Patient Bill of Rights or something being written in. Was that part of the amendment that we adopted a while ago?
Don't we take the mic, Dennis? I know you trusted him, but I had mentioned it. Yes, in this amendment, we had created advisory committees for the passes in which patients are able to give their input. And I forgot to mention this. I was going to mention it in my closing statements. We are going to actually add a preamble to stating the intent, kind of layman's term language, to let them know that they are protected. I've told them as well that I filed a shell bill for a patient bill of rights, and I was happy to work with them on that as well. So we've addressed those issues that we keep on getting those emails about. The report on savings, that already is in there. And like I said, a lot of these protections, they want in the Bill of Rights, like Dennis said, already exist under federal law. But we're adding the preamble. We've added the advisory committee like they wanted, and we're working with them. So for what I understand right now, they are satisfied. We met with them this morning. We're all good. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Ladyman, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. You mentioned that this is mandatory for this group. And then you said, well, they can go to a different pass. I think I'm going to have a follow-up. But can you define for me what pass, what you're talking about there? You said
there might be three passes? Yes, sir. The pass would be the underlying entity, the organization that the members, as I said, would initially be assigned to, but then they could choose a different one if they so desired. These are created by the providers of Arkansas themselves and in which they will then also enter into agreements with qualified entities to do the back office business of processing claims, doing reporting requirements, et cetera. So it is the providers themselves and specialty providers as well as primary care providers have been in discussions over the last several months in forming partnerships among themselves and with a qualified business entity. So it is mandatory, though, for only this small population of 30,000 people. Could I have a follow-up, please, Mr. Chairman? You're recognized
for a follow-up. Thank you. So I guess the word mandatory bothers me in that it limits these individuals, and they are individuals, in their choice. And I guess I could use an example of, you know, a physician out of that group might prescribe a drug, and in many cases these people have drugs prescribed for them that have major side effects. And they might choose, maybe I'm getting too much in the weeds and I apologize if I am, but they might have major side effects, and the person responsible for these folks might say, well, you know, I don't agree with that. I mean, that discussion is available now. Would that still be available with this program?
you, Mr. Chair. I'm just trying to work out how does a provider become part of one of these risk-based provider organizations when I represent richie can you get closer
trying to figure out how a provider becomes part of one of these risk-based provider organizations and this you know where we get the minimum reserve of the six million dollars and things like that Because where I am, in a small rural part of the state and small providers, it just seems like those people are going to be left out. Can you give me any kind of assurance that they're going
to have a spot at the table? They will because of the network adequacy rules in particular. So all of these services will have to be covered, and patients will have to be able to have access to them of what's available in the local community. So, for example, it would be unacceptable for the network adequacy rules and time and distance requirements to say someone in Mississippi County has to travel all the way to Little Rock to get a therapy. So the independent providers, I believe, very much will, again, gain compared to the current fee-for-service system because they could be paid for additional time and efforts that they are making to serve these clients.
You have a follow-up with that? You recognize that. Thank you. Thank you. So I guess my question is I appreciate that answer, but even more so I guess I'm trying to figure out. So you have this provider organization, okay, then they're kind of setting the rules and running the show as I understand it. So how are these smaller providers going to be able to have input into that organization that's setting the rules, or maybe I'm misunderstanding this.
No, sir, you're not. So again, all different types of providers, every different type of provider, will need to be covered in this organization. So again, those discussions amongst the providers themselves have already been occurring for a couple of months now. They are the ones who decide who they choose to partner with in order to form then a business partner to do the back office operations. So we have had these discussions with providers. No single provider can do this themselves. You have to find a partner, and you have to find multiple partners to be able to be successful. Thank you. Mr. Smith, you and I had a discussion
earlier in the week, and we talked about these passes. I'd like for you to kind of talk to the committee a little bit about it. They can't form one that just services Little Rock or just services Northwest Arkansas. All these passes have to be statewide. Is that not true? That's correct. Can you kind of
expound on that a little bit? That's correct, Mr. Chairman. The requirement would be that you do have to operate statewide and not only operate statewide but have adequate network of providers statewide as well. Representative Ritchie,
I did that because of your question, but I want you to understand that I had the same concerns as well. Are there any further questions for the sponsor? Representative Payton, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. That comment that was just made, we've had some discussions about how hopefully there would be three passes It could possibly be two, but with the requirements in there about statewide, is there anything in this that would prevent there from being just one pass?
If we form only one pass, I would consider that to be failure. We want two passes at least. But there's nothing in this bill that would demand two? There is nothing in the bill as drafted that would require to, but CMS would look on that. CMS would not accept only one. If there were only one, then people would be able to choose to remain in fee-for-service. Okay, so can a provider? They have to have a
choice. So say you've got a very rural part of Arkansas, and we require the pass to have services in all parts of the state. Could a provider be a participant in both
question was triggered kind of by those questions as well. Because, I mean, really in Arkansas we're talking about one major company, that's Blue Cross and Blue Shield. When we're talking about competition, do you see other insurance companies being able to come in and compete and bid, or are we talking about where you might have Blue Cross and Blue Shield being able to form both passes, which would kind of, you know, have two different plans or two different passes? Or are you talking about Blue Cross and Blue Shield maybe having one and another insurance company having the second one? So could you clarify that or maybe expound on that? Yes, sir. Again, 51% has to be owned by the providers themselves. So in typical managed care, it comes from the top down. In this respect, it's being formed from the bottom up. So the providers have to go find the business partner from discussions that we've heard. Those discussions have been taking place for months, and there are a number of highly qualified carriers who are in discussions to be able to support the business side of the pass. So I believe we will have competition, and again, you need to be successful. To serve this population successfully and to be able to make this a successful model, this cannot be just a typical insurance model. You have to have the care coordination, You have to have the beneficiary support that is not present in just a regular commercial insurance product. Go ahead. And I apologize because I know that we've had discussions and all that, but I'm trying to wrap my head. So it has to be 51% owned. So can you tell me how that would work? I mean, are they going to partner with an insurance company like Blue Cross and Blue Shield? So how would that 51% work? Could you kind of further tell me how that would work? So let's say in this instance you have providers who partner with Blue Cross and Blue Shield. Tell me how that 51% works as they try to work together to form this network. Again, I think that these will be on the financial side of things. It will require providers, but providers of all shapes, sizes, to participate as the majority owners. So, again, we believe that these relationships, it does require capital investment, but from discussions that I've heard, there are some very solid business plans being put together. Representative Love. Thank you, Madam Chair, and actually, I want you to ask a question until Representative Meeks said something in regards to bidding, and I want you to explain that process because you came to testify before the Arkansas Legislative Black Caucus, and we got into a discussion about this is not going to be a bidding process, so can you walk us through that as well? Yes, sir. We will have a certification process, and again, this is how this very much differs than in other states running a traditional managed care request for proposal and bidding process. Under this approach, and we've had a draft certification out in the public for several weeks now asking for comments on that, and that walks through all of the requirements that an entity must be able to meet in order to be certified as a pass. But if you do meet that, that all those requirements, that you have to be statewide, that you have to serve a minimum number of people, that you will have to be able to demonstrate network adequacy. All of those things will be required to be certified as the pass. We'll have to meet the reserve requirements that the insurance commissioner will require. So all of those Those things have to be done, but if you can meet those, then you will be certified as a pass. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Payton,
percent of multiple passes? The legislation does not specifically address that. It's a hypothetical that I haven't really considered. That just came to me too. Thank you. But I know from discussions that providers are speaking to separate different partners to do the business processes.
Well, and if I may follow up, I mean, over time, that can change. I mean, if one provider, one non-provider decides to buy out the competition, so to speak, we could end up with the same non-provider owning sort of a monopoly, even
though it's only 49 percent of each one. Uh, again, my response would be that as long as the 51% is controlled by the providers themselves, the 51% makes the financial rules as well as the underlying medical, uh, rules, et cetera.
you latitude since I have no one else in the queue. Well, since this seems to be a new line of thinking that we're just considering, I just want to make sure you consider the fact that if you're the non-provider and you own 49 percent of the competition, that's going to
give you more leverage against the 51 percent of this entity. I see your point, and, again, just very candidly, it's not a situation that I had contemplated, and it's not a situation that the current environment is operating under. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Vice Chair. Just adding to that real quick, 51% is provider-owned. They still are in control of which way that pass goes. I mean, I would find it crazy for that 51% to say, okay, yeah, let's sell 49% or let's let that 49% go to our competitor. Let's not try to find someone else to come and buy. Yeah, you're right. They could constantly come in and take it over, but I would find it to be an
extremely rare circumstance. I think, oh, no, that's okay. I think it would be helpful because I'm getting some text asking if you'd clarify what you mean, who the provider is. Is that the behavioral health group? Is that the physician? Is it, you know, the nurse? Who
is the provider in this model? All providers are included within that definition. So it's the array of the different types of providers, whether it's a physician practice or a hospital or a pharmacist. So all of those providers are within that definition. Again, I think that based on discussions that I've heard about, which is very common today, in which there are different types of shareholders, different levels of equity that, you know, some people have more equity in a company than others do. So, again, in this respect, it is an economic model to be thinking about as well. Yeah, I mean, you're saying
I believe it'll be a combination of the, I believe the ownership itself will be a combination of different providers. Okay. Thank you. Seeing Representative Hammer.
Thank you, Mayor Scherer. Representative, could you tell me what are the built-in firewalls between the 49 and the 51 so that if the fear that's being expressed today should begin to happen? You know, we can vote for this thing, one thing, as a legislative branch, but as the free market takes place and everything begins to happen, are there any firewalls to stop it
from happening? Yes, sir. In the certification application itself, which will also have to be redone on an annual basis. follow-up mr. chair you're recognized who controls
see no further questions we'll go to the audience we have quite a few signed up to speak for the bill, and I've misplaced the piece of paper. Let's start out with Mr. Robin. One. Motion in. I'll take your motion. Representative Love, I recognize you. Motion to limit debate. Motion to
All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed. Thank you. Representative Pilkington, how much room do you need to reserve for closing? Two minutes. We'll hold you two minutes for closing. Mr. Robin Ravino? I did not pronounce that right, I know. I understand. We
there is others to sign up, so if you could keep your remarks to the point and brief. Thank you, Mr. Robin. Thank you. I'll be brief. Thank you. I mean, everyone introduce their sales for the record for me, please.
want to thank for the members and the chair for letting us talk. We want to support this bill. We worked hard with most providers together, collaborating, coming up with this bill. and I'm basically going to reserve my time for any questions anyone will have and let my colleague talk about the rest of this stuff. Thank you, Robin.
I was asked to speak more from a provider's perspective on this rather than as the Mental Health Council president. I also serve as the chair currently of the Behavioral Health and DD Provider Coalition that we've established, which involves six different statewide provider groups of developmental disabilities providers, mental health and substance abuse providers around the state. We do really believe that the provider-led accountable care model can be successful in reducing overall health care costs for our clients and improving the quality of their lives. As someone representing a provider agency, The things that excite me the most about this is that it's a chance to build a system of services and care delivery that we feel are important. It's a way to finally have true coordination of care for all of our clients throughout the state. It's an opportunity to implement new, innovative services, as Dennis Smith had mentioned, in our communities. And it's a chance to prove that we can improve the outcomes of our clients and do it in a cost-effective manner. I know the bending the cost curve, the Medicaid cost curve, is something that we've got to look at. We've got to take that into consideration. And I do believe that this can do that. But the other priority is making certain that the clients that we serve get the services that they need when they need them. And I think the key component of this legislation, of this project, is that it allows for care coordination on a statewide basis. of everyone so that if you're a DD client and you also have some mental health issues, you're going to have someone that's coordinating your care and maybe you also have asthma and some other physical health issues. You're going to have someone coordinating all of that care to make sure you get to your appointments, you stay compliant with your medications. So it really does involve the entire healthcare system to make this work. But I believe we can do that.
speak Mike or I would just point out too that because of this effort to try to put this together from a provider association standpoint that this is the first time that I know of historically that this number of provider associations have worked together to try to coordinate services and I think that that makes a very big deal in trying to provide the best health care possible for this population and will serve to provide better services for the future for all of these populations. And so I think that this bill is very important for improving the quality of care that we can provide as providers, especially from the substance abuse treatment providers' standpoint, where we've been limited in some of the access to services that we could provide to that population. I think this is going to open up doors for us to be able to provide the services that have been desperately needed over the years for Substance Abuse Treatment Provider Association. The DD Provider Association represents a large number, as well as some of the other associations of programs that are
relatively small, and we basically significantly regard the local service provision as being a key element. We think that it's important that people are providing those services, be people who are in the community, have boards from the community, and that's one of the things that we're giving careful thinking to in this process to make sure that that occurs. And again, the integration of the services is important. There's been a schism, particularly between individuals who receive DD services and also the behavioral health services they need also. So we're looking forward to integrating that
and also the flexibility and the efficiency that will be allowed through this process. Everyone has heard before the advantages to having managed care from the application of aligning financial incentives to integrating care, to creating greater accountability of care throughout a network. I think everybody's heard that and probably heard it too many times. But what I will say to you is that you have not seen the level of coordination and allegiance that has been formed by multiple provider organizations across the state in order to try to facilitate the development of this process. And I think that probably, among all the other things, is one of the more hopeful pieces of this, in that we have been able to bring DD and substance abuse, private providers, public providers, mental health counsel are all sitting at the same table right now trying to figure out a way to make this happen. And that, in my experience in Arkansas, is unprecedented. I think that should provide a great deal of assurance and hope to this committee that we have stumbled across a model that will give us the maximum opportunity to develop a value-centered project that will give us the ability to be flexible and provide services.
I've got to stop you right there. Yes, sir. That's the end of the time, and I've got two minutes reserved for the sponsor. All right. So that's all the time for the people speaking for. I have a Mark George to speak against. Mr. George, if you would, introduce yourself for
the committee. Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair. My name is Mark George, and I'm a parent of a child with a developmental disability. I want to start off and say I'm not necessarily against the concept at all, love the concept. My comments have to do with the bill itself, and not necessarily what's in the bill, but what's not in the bill. The bill tells you that the purpose is to administer health care services to individuals with developmental disabilities as determined by an independent assessment under criteria established by the department. What the bill doesn't tell you is that criteria is so narrowly defined that the only individuals that will be included in that group are participants in the ACA's waiver program. But it doesn't tell you that. The bill tells you that the managed care organization, or the PASS, will provide care coordination, which is defined as the coordination of providers for diagnostics, ambulatory care, and hospital services. The rare results of how the DD population is defined is essentially the management or provision of services under the waiver program will be switched to this managed care organization this bill says nothing about that the managed care company will be providing the types of services and supports offered under the waiver that are necessary for our daughter who you all happened to meet a couple of weeks ago when I brought her here yeah to some extent Tesla will be mandatory enrolled in this organization and it misses the fact that I carry private insurance on her. Therefore this you know she has coordinated care and she gets her services paid for. So in this model the past will be making global payments to somebody to cover the cost of services that they don't provide that somebody else is paying for and she doesn't need I think that needs to be clarified this bill tells you that the performance of the past will be measured by such factors as reduction in emergency room utilization hospital admissions and readmissions that has nothing to do with the waiver program It's about supported living, employment opportunities, assisted living, you know, community living. Those are the things that they will be providing. The bill tells you that residents of the HDCs are exempt from this model. Okay? The bill doesn't tell you is that having exempted them and some of their guidance from CMS about the management of long-term services support programs, you should have a structure that does not provide an incentive to the managed care company to shift high-cost patients back to an institution and away from community services. It should be exactly the opposite. They should have an incentive to provide community-based care as much as possible. There's nothing in this bill that would require the pass to both permit and facilitate the waiver participants' choice to self-direct their private or personal plan of care. That's a money saver. That is something that increases their independence and their happiness. That's something, you know, achievement of goals should be one of the measurements of the program. All I'm saying is that CMS, as Mr. Smith mentioned, that CMS has some specific rules applicable to managed care of the waiver program. And in many ways, they are different from the managed care rules applicable to the regular Medicaid program that they're talking about the state parent services of mental health and medical service they are different so all I'm saying is when I read this bill there's either a whole bunch of language in here is extraneous and not needed because DHS can handle it all the things about performance and what coordinated care is there's a whole lot language that is missing because there is nothing that is specific to the waiver program that's being taken over and I believe it should be in there so again I'm for the concept I love the idea of better care better coordination more services available I'm just saying if you're gonna write a bill make sure it covers everything that you're going to require the MCO to do I'd like to trust them. But my dad told me, you know, trust and verify. So with that in mind, you know, I would just say that as it is written, because of what's left out, I cannot support this
You're recognized. Close for your bill. Just very quickly, I think the gentleman is not correct that all the services are not included. All state plan amendment services and all waiver services are required to be covered by the pass. Thank you. In closing, I'd just like to say we've been working very hard with all facets of health care here in Arkansas to get everyone on board and to get us a plan that is truly provider-led in this state. You know, we, and this is across the country too, we spend more money and get some of the worst results in the United States here. This is an opportunity for us to break these patients, as a term David would say, out of the Medicaid black box. and to give them the freedom in their care to whether we can find better ways to serve this population that desperately need a better form for care. And so with that, I'll just ask for a good vote and a motion to do
pass. I got a motion to do pass. Representative Pilkington, as amended, right, Representative? As amended. Representative Meeks, I'm going to recognize you to start off discussion.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I appreciate this bill, and I like the framework. I like the concept, of course, with managed care. You know, we have to make sure that it is implemented properly, and so that's going to be the job of the legislature to help oversight and to make sure that we deliver on what is promised in this bill. Again, I support it because of the fact, again, I like the concept, but more so the fact that we are once again able to take some money and put it into eliminating that DD waiver list. And so that is appealing to me. I appreciate you all putting that in there. And so, members, for those two reasons, I ask that you would support this bill. Thank you. Representative Miller, do you have
Folks, I just want to say that for the last couple of years or more, I've kind of been adamantly opposed to this idea of managed care and all this stuff. I mean, it's just kind of left a bad taste in my mouth. mouth. I've looked at this concept, and I've come around a little bit. One of the biggest selling points on this for me is that the money that we're going to save and generate through this program is going to go back into helping resolve the waiting list for the developmental disability waiver. You know, that's something I've worked hard on and going to continue to work hard on. We may even be back. This session was something that can guarantee that. But anyway, for that reason, I am going to support this. I'm going to vote for it. And because I do think we consider the greater good. There's going to be some bumps in the road. There are going to be some individuals who, you know, it takes a little bit to get used to a new set of circumstances. But overall, when we have to sit in here and make decisions about what's best, I see this as a reasonable plan that's going to get services to 2,500 other people who right now have no idea when they're going to
recognize discuss the motion oh thank you mr. chair first of foremost I want to say thank you for bringing this bill as you know Monday the Legislative Black Caucus had a lot of questions and concerns and I do still have some of those questions and concerns I'm a little hurt that representative Miller left me out of that discussion because you know I used I'm working with them, I'm working with them hard, but it left me out, so, no, but I am in line with his thinking. If we could do something in regards to this disability waiver list, I think we need to do that, and I think this is a good step forward, and for that, I will be supporting you.
Thank you. Representative Boyd, you're recognized for discussion. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just want to say I have concerns, too, because this is big change. And any time there's big change, we shouldn't just step into that lightly. But every time I've asked a question, something I thought, there's no way there's an answer to, either it's been answered or people were up front and honest and said, you know, yes, we understand that, and that is a risk. So I do plan to support this today. Thank you. Thank you.
I will, in discussion, I want to commend the department because every time I've went to former Representative Link or Mr. Smith or Brian Bowen or Mr. Brader, those guys have went above and beyond to get the answers that we needed for our constituents on this issue. And I just want to take this time to tell you these guys have worked night and day to put this together in this short period of time because it was just a few months ago this idea started. So I will tell you, I support the bill wholeheartedly, and I want to tell you from the bottom of my heart how much I appreciate the work you guys have put in this for this great state of Arkansas. Thank you. And Representative Payton, I
want to recognize you for some discussion. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just want to let people know I'm on board on this bill for one reason. That's because it's provider-led. And I think 51% is a very, very slim margin. I would like to make sure that going forward, if this becomes law, we really protect the provider's ability to lead in this fight. One of my concerns had been brought up this morning about whether or not the providers wanted to lead or take their share. And I think the gentleman at the end of the table that spoke in favor of this bill proves that there is a strong desire among providers to fill their role in this model. if it gets amended or maybe two years from now we may want to put a little assurance in there that the same company can't gobble up the 49% of more than one pass but I'm going to support the bill appreciate a
good vote thank you seeing no further discussion all those in favor say aye all those opposed congratulations Representative Pilkington you now have Pilk care Representative Williams We recognize you to run Senate joint resolution If we could, let's keep the order in the room Show the next member the same respect I would remind the members I do have some food coming So you'll have some A snack anyway Thank you, Mr.
Chairman We're a working committee committee we're gonna stay here and get our work done okay this uh this resolution is a much simpler not as complex as the last two issues that we come back for what this resolution is is it really just cleans up some some issues that occurred back in 1996 that allows for the coverage of a group that was explicitly held back from this and it's just very simply that to allow the governor and the rest of the governor make this help provide coverage for this group. I'll answer any questions anybody might have. Any questions for Representative Williams? We have to speak up. I didn't
S-C-R. I don't know what it is. H-C-R, yes. H-C-R, I'm sorry. Yes. For some reason, I'm thinking of the Senate joint resolution. It's the House joint resolution. Thank you, Chairman. Yep. Oh, I know. I'm sorry. If you just give a second, we'll get that door back closed. We had to clear a couple hundred people out of here, I guess. representative williams if you don't mind introduce your bill for your house joint
concurrent resolution sure this is a house concurrent resolution 1012 what this is as i said earlier i know people may not have been able to hear this is really a fairly simple resolution that will go before the house asking for the senate to concur if we could keep that door closed please. Let's show the next member respect. Thank you, Representative Williams. Sorry to interrupt you. No, not at all. What this very simply does is it cleans up an issue that occurred back in 1996 that was now is allowed under a law that passed in 2009 and It allows us to provide coverage for a very deserving, very small group of individuals within the state of Arkansas, and I'll be happy to answer any questions any of the members may have.
I have a question, Representative Payton. I'll have to apologize for skimming over this so quick, but in this resolution, we're mentioning nuclear weapons and atmospheric nuclear tests and things. I mean, my initial fear is that somehow we're recognizing in a resolution that there were some bad acts or negligent acts. What exactly is all this about? Well, very simply what had happened
is that after World War II, the United States made a decision. The United States come under control of an area in the Pacific Island that consisted primarily of the Marshall Islands, the nation of what we've now recognized in Palau and the Micronesia. And we decided that that was a great area to do testing of nuclear weapons. And over a course of approximately 12 years, we tested 67 nuclear weapons in that area. The issue that, because we were new in this and not really understanding the issues that raised with this, it ended up causing a tremendous amount of radiation damage to the area and to the folks who lived on those islands. And that's the reason we point that out. It's to provide some history to understand what the folks of that area that lived in that area and that now reside primarily here in Arkansas do, how it occurred. Representative
Williams, on Representative Payton's question, you and I had spoken earlier this week. Can you elaborate more on these chronic health conditions these people have experienced since that took place and why this is needed to assure these people get the health care that they need and deserve from that?
Right. There are many. We have discovered, you know, since we began, the United States began its nuclear program, we have discovered a lot of chronic health issues that have occurred, which are actually listed, a few of them are listed in the resolution itself, that specifically with diseases that, higher rates of cancer that have occurred in that. Will, along with that cancer, talks about chronic conditions that have occurred. That is specifically outlined in page 3, starting at line 26. But these are just a few. There have been a very large increase in the rate of cancer that many have attributed to the radiation that have occurred because of the fallout from the nuclear weapons that we have tested. And what has occurred is that some of the issues that have occurred medically with those folks have been passed down from generation to generation due to that exposure that those folks have had. and we still see some of the medical issues that have occurred because of that exposure. It still exists within that community. It wasn't a big issue to Arkansas until a large part of that community, primarily Marshallese, began moving into the area. And then what happened was back in 1996, the federal government made a change to immigration policy that excluded this population from something that they had previously had covered. They previously had the opportunity to be covered under these programs, and people believe inadvertently, as with many of these federal programs, sometimes inadvertent things happen. And back in 1996, it was very much believed that inadvertently they were removed from many of these programs, which allowed for them to be able to be treated for many of their illnesses that were believed to be a direct result of this nuclear testing. And this just as simply as allows them to be able to be qualified under those programs once again. Like I said, this is not cutting edge. Since this was allowed, there have been 31 states that have specifically asked for these things to be reoccurred.
Okay, so this is not a bill that you have in front of us. This is a resolution. It's simply a resolution. So this resolution does not change the law or make them qualified for anything. It does not. So is it not already at the governor's purview to do this or not do this in the absence of this resolution? The governor
could make the amendment through CMS to do this of his own accord. What he just wanted to do, what was asked of me was to be able to present this resolution because once it comes back from CMS, there's going to be some necessary rule changes that are going to occur here in the legislature to make this still occur. and he wanted to see that both houses of the legislature were willing to support those rule changes or at least to be able to consider those rule changes once they come back. Representative Lundstrom, you're
Chairman Woodlaw. I'm a little bit confused, so help straighten me out. The feds, we brought these folks over here because of our actions, And my understanding was the federal government was going to take care of their health care as long as needed, not Arkansans when they moved
Right, when they should not have done it, they should have kept their word. So you're not saying the people of Arkansas need to pick up the tab. You're saying the feds need to go back and mop up their own mess. Yeah, that's exactly what we're asking them to do. We're not putting the governor or the state of Arkansas taxpayers' money at risk. We're just simply saying you,
the feds, need to finish the job you started. Correct. Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a question. Thank you. This is a follow-up to Representative Lundstrom's question, because on page three, starting with, I guess, basically line three, but it says allow states the option to obtain federal matching dollars to cover certain lawfully residing children and pregnant women. So that tells me that the state is going to have to put in some money in order to obtain, and I don't know if the regular Medicaid rate that we pay right now is 70-30 or if there's another special rate. So by passing this resolution, what you're telling me is that we're going to allow them to be covered, but the state is going to have some obligation to put forward some money, and if that is the case, do we know how much that is? The federal matching rate is 100% under this program. The state will be obligated, no funds. You recognize for a follow-up. Then why is it saying it allows states the option to obtain federal matching dollars? Well, because I think under many of the programs that exist, there are different matching funds, different levels of matching rates. And under this particular thing, if you want to call it the matching rate, it's 100% federal, 0% state. Okay. All right. Thank you for clearing that up. Representative Ladyman. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So do you know if some of these people are currently covered under regular Medicaid where we're paying 30% and it would go to 100% federal, or is that? This is only going to cover the part of the population that is currently, because when we say, you know, the Confederation Free Association, that's a big lump that occurred there. Many of the Marshallese children already that existed within the community may have health care through workplaces, things like that. So we're talking about a very small portion, But this will only be people who would qualify under every other rule that they still have to have. There's still income restrictions. There's still all sorts of the other restrictions. This will only cover just that small portion. But you don't know if any of these people are currently covered under the 730 rule and would go to 100% federal? None of the ones that we're talking about here are covered under any other programs. Okay. Thank you. Representative Love, did you have a question?
I'm going to make a statement. I think it's a little bit of confusion, and I've been in meetings with Representative Williams and Governor's Office and others on this issue, and I just had a brief moment with Representative Lundstrell. These people have the ability to come here and work because of these nuclear bombs that went off in the history. They're never declared citizens. So without this resolution and without this waiver, There's no way for the federal government to know where these people are located in the U.S. So you have to ask for this in order to let them know that you have a population of them here to get them covered. And we as citizens of the U.S., we didn't push the button, but the button went off on our behalf. So we owe them that much in my mind. And I should have done this in discussion on a motion, but I'm going to go ahead and do it. so that's where this resolution comes from it's to take care of a population that we nuked years ago that are still having health issues pertaining back to that issue so with that I recognize Representative Lundstrom for a question just a point of
clarification for those of you who may not know Springdale is the largest has we are the only embassy outside of the Marshall Islands and the largest population of the Marshallese folks live in Springdale and that's why this is coming up in Arkansas. So with that, does there
anyone in the audience speak for or against the resolution? Seeing none, Representative Williams, you're closed for your resolution? Closed. I got a motion due passed by Representative Meeks on the resolution. I got a discussion for Representative Payton. This
seems like an idea that I'd probably be in full support of. I just want to point out to the membership, this is a resolution, and to me it sure seems to rise to the level that it should have been a bill. If the governor has the authority to do this, he can do it, with or without the resolution, without us compelling him to. But if we're going to see a situation that needs to be done and try to compel something to be done, we should do that in bill form because my colleagues surely recognize that many times resolutions do not get vetted very well. And with all the confusion that happened on the bill right before this and everybody leaving, this one just almost sailed without anybody understanding its content because it's a resolution. And so, you know, I just, I don't like the fact that this is being done in resolution form. Other than that, probably fine with content.
Representative Meeks, you're recognized for discussion. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and I'm in support of this resolution. We've done it in the past. The only difference is that we send it up to Congress, we send it up to the President of the United States, encouraging them to do something. And I think for our Marshallese population, I think that this is the right thing to do. I think, you know, the governor apparently is either in support or at least neutral on this, and it gives him the ability to make sure that the legislature wants this to go through and so I think that in order to support this and in order to support our Marshallese people that we should go ahead and pass this resolution out and encourage the governor to follow
through on it. Representative Liedemann, you're recognized for discussion. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just a comment. I mean, we might not agree with the process or the procedure but as Representative Lundstrom said, there is a large population of Marshallese in Springdale. They do contribute greatly to the economy up there and all I hear is good things about that group, that population and it feels, it seems like we are partially responsible as a country, so I would recommend a yes vote for this. Thank you. Seeing
no further discussion, all those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed, congratulations. Your resolution has passed. Thank you, members. Thank you, Richmond you're recognized to run you got to remind me the bill number representing Richmond I think it's 1716 is that correct that's correct mr. chairman
with ADQ and the fees that are charged to our counties right now the ADQ whenever there is work that has to be done at a county such as cleaning underneath the bridge or other type of facility like that where there is water they charge the county for each time that they do it $200 also the State Highway Department gets charged the same fee personally I think it is not correct for a state agency to be reaching down into the pockets of our local government and take those monies which means so much because the counties are nowhere close as well-funded as what you have up at the state agencies. $200 is $200 to a county. Also I just returned from public transportation where we spent the whole committee discussing a tax increase that the people are going to have an opportunity to vote on in order to provide more revenue to the state highway department. It's hard for me to go home and explain to the people of my constituents that we need to raise taxes when we have a state agency that is also getting revenue from another state agency such as the State Highway Department. Now what this bill does is that, and it's a soft hit on ADEQ, that it says on page 3, subchapter 5, that ADEQ will waive 25% of those fees during a fiscal year timeframe. So if there's four events in a county where AEQ would normally charge $800 for, they would only charge $600. Also, if there is an emergency situation, then they will not charge any fees at all to the counties or the state highway department for going in and doing that work to take care of an emergency situation. Again, I have most of the language in this, and I'm trying to be brief here. Most of the language in this is AEQ language. The only difference, and I don't know if anybody's here to talk for or against, they have never contacted me saying they were against this bill since we parted ways, but the only difference is the 25% and the emergency fees being waived. And I did that because up to that point, they were basically giving me a bill that just simply authorized what they were already authorized to do. Anyway, I'm open for any questions at this point if you have
one that happened in my district several years ago same time that we lost our game warden and our county sheriff in that the floods come Fish Valley River it washed out and ended the Fish Valley River and at that point Basically, we were isolated because one bridge was completely under. The other one was washed out on that river. People couldn't get anywhere. Highway department come in, and then they had to have ADQ had to make sure that there was not going to be any kind of permanent damage or anything done to the environment. And so that's one incident right there. One of the things that ADQ has done that has hurt and caused them to get a little extra money is that they changed the formula on our state highway departments. It's used to the State Highway Department would submit a section of highway that was going to be operated on. They would get charged one fee for that. ADQ would come back then and change that formula so that they get charged for Evercrossing. The significance of that is what I have is some of the fees that we have right now is that in fiscal year 14, it was only $115,600, 15, $168,400 that was charged. Fiscal year 2016, $237,400. Part of that was because the Diamond Pipeline, which any time you have a linear project, the fees can run pretty high going across all the different rivers and things and creeks and whatever it might be. $123,000 of that came from Diamond Pipeline, and that's kind of a one-time deal. And I'm not touching the private industry in this bill at this time because I want ADQ to have the opportunity to get in the budget process in the future and be able to have that opportunity to address any kind of shortfalls that may eventually come to them because I don't intend this to be the last time you see this. If I'm lucky enough to come back in a couple of years, I intend to come back, and I've told ADQ as well that we're going to come back and we're going to revisit these fees, and that way they have a chance to get involved. And so far in fiscal year 17, as of December 12th, it's $62,800. Now, that's not a lot of money up here in the capital. It's not a lot of money for a state agency a lot of times, but it's a lot of money to a county, especially in rural Arkansas where they struggle for resources all the time. I hope I answered your question. Is there
anyone? Representative Coleman, you're recognized for a question. Am I missing something or on the wrong bill? But on my agenda, there's an amendment on here. Did I go to sleep and we discussed that? The amendment's already engrossed, Representative. They just let you know that he did amend the bill since it's been filed. I had
Seeing no further questions, anyone in the audience speak for or against the bill? I got a motion due pass. Representative Lundstrell, any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed? Ayes have it. Congratulations. Your bill has passed. Thank you, committee. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You should have already been at the other end of the table. I believe you have a special guest with
you today, Representative Hammer. Thank you, Mr. Chair, with a point of personal privilege, if I may. Yes, sir. I'd like to have my grandson, Braden Lawrence, sit here, and I'd like to have Eli, who is up here paging, sit with me, if that's all right with the chair. Very good. I think you have two bills. Can you tell me which one you want to go first? I'd like to do 1581, if I could, please. Yes, sir, 1581. All right, and this is Eli Kelly. His dad is Jason Kelly with the Boys and Girls Club of Saline County, my grandson to the left. These are non-controversial bills, so I would not put the members in an awkward position by emotionally telling me no or anything. Point of order. What's the number again? I've got 1851. 1851. Okay. You recognize. All right, thank you. What this bill does, and I'll give you a real-life scenario, As many of you know, I'm a hospice chaplain. I work for Selene Memorial Hospice, which is a division of Selene Memorial Hospital in Benton. I'll tell you, one of the most uncomfortable positions that you can find yourself in is being in the hospital where the patient is a hospice patient and the patient has passed away. And because of the way the law currently reads, the physician in the hospital, whether that be in the ER or whether that be the hospitalist, you have to wait for that physician to come up and pronounce that patient. It has happened on several occasions where I've been with a family, 2 o'clock in the morning, patient's passed away, family is processing, ready to go, but the ER doctor is tied up down the ER and cannot get out of the ER. The hospital's tied up on something. What this bill allows is to expand for the hospice nurse, providing the hospice service to that patient. If the patient passes away in the hospital, that hospice nurse would have the authority to make the pronouncement. That way we don't have to wait on the ER doctor. We don't have to wait on the hospitalist. And this is only for patients that are under hospice care. The Hospital Association is fully supportive with this. Also, the Hospice Palliative Care Association is fully supportive of this. And this in no way, shape, or form alters Representative Bentley's bill that she ran earlier other than it just adds and covers the hospital in that procedure as well. And with that, I'll be glad to answer any questions, Mr. Chair. Seeing
no questions, anyone in the audience speak for or against the bill? Hold on. Seeing no one. Seeing no one in this pleasure of committee. Do pass. Got a motion. Do pass. Representative Lundstrom, all those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed, congratulations to your bill. It passed. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. I'm waiting on him to give me the number. 2067. 2067. Mr. Chair, may I invite Lisa
Network. Go ahead. Thank you, Madam Chair. What this bill does is establish a palliative care and quality life interdisciplinary task force. I've worked with these two groups along with the Department of Health, ACHI, and DHS in order to get this bill crafted to where all parties are in agreement. What this task force is going to be charged with the responsibility to do is put a microscope on the palliative care stage of life, which typically precedes the hospice care time of life. There is much that we can do to improve the palliative care, which subsequently is also going to help with the cost management in areas such as Medicaid populations that need the palliative care services as well. And, Mr. Chair, what I'd like to do, with the Chair's permission, I'll just yield to each one of my guests to add some additional insight, if I may.
this without creating a new task force? Not to my knowledge. The health committee possibly could do it. However, this is going to be pretty broad, pretty deep, because there's actually a cost to providing health care. Might also add that there's no opposition to this from any entities other than maybe represented on this committee today. But even up to the second floor, there's no opposition because palliative care really needs to put the microscope because we could have some real cost savings when this thing is all said and done. But it's going to be a pretty intensive process to give
for you. Thank you. You'll be welcome to attend the meetings. Thank you. I would also echo, from my perspective personally, Representative Payton's concerns. I've voted against and stood in this committee on this same principle. The committees are here as permanent entities and can also serve and have the attendance of most of the people that are required to be on these task force and could achieve the same goal using the committee or the subcommittees of this committee. Representative Meeks, you're
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Page four, line 11 says members of the task force may receive expense reimbursement in accordance with 2516-109. And I'm not familiar with that particular statute, so could you explain that? Does that mean all members of the task force, to include non-legislative members, can ask for reimbursement? And if so, where would that money be
paid out of? One of the things that we tried to do was to make sure that this bill had actually started off with another part of it added to it, and we limited it down to just being able to look at the actual program aspect of it. And we did start off looking at the Department of Health that would be solely responsible. That's why we broadened it to include DHS to help cover the costs associated with this. But ACHI is one of the team members on here, and they are actually going to bring to the table some of the protocols and some other areas that they are experts in order to be able to contribute to this and it not be a cost shared by anyone. It would be spread out across. Mr. Chair, to the issues that have been mentioned, could I let Lisa and Michael speak to that as far as the necessity of the task force versus going through the public health committee? Yes, sir. Briefly. Chairman, palliative care is a form of health care specifically
focused on those. Can you get closer to the mic, Michael, please? My apologies. Is that? Yeah, it's on. Is that better? That's better. Thank you. Palliative care is a form of health care specifically focused on care for those with critical illness that have a long road to recovery or are anticipated to live a longer period of time with their disease. It works to improve the lives of patients by making coordination of their care the standard protocol during their treatment for cancer or other critical diseases. It helps people live a greater quality of life while they fight the disease by making certain that issues presented during their treatment are answered. In Arkansas, we are fortunate to have a few centers of excellence in palliative care. However, it is not readily available throughout all of our state. It is our belief that the Cancer Action Network, that by convening this task force, the state of Arkansas will improve the clinical cares of providers in palliative care, and by doing so, create greater access to palliative care services throughout the state. In addition, it is our desire to better educate the public on palliative care to create a a better understanding of this specialty and make known the benefits of integrating palliative care with specific disease-directed treatments for seriously ill adults and children. I appreciate the opportunity to speak today, and I also greatly appreciate the work of Representative Hammer in bringing this bill
forward. I have a little bit of data for you guys this morning because I know sometimes that helps you prioritize things, and we all have high feelings about, you know, things we want to see done, but approximately 90 million Americans are living with serious illness, such as cancer, heart disease, dementia, things like that. This number is expected to double over the next 25 years as the baby boomer generation ages. Recent national data shows that only one palliative care physician exists for every 1,200 patients living with serious illness, and that disparity is much larger in Arkansas. The most recent statistics that I have for Arkansas is we have approximately 25 board-certified palliative care physicians for the entire state. Recent studies indicate that by closely matching treatments with patient goals and improving their quality of life, palliative care can provide substantial cost reduction in the health care industry. The U.S. Senate Committee on Appropriations, the National Institutes of Health, and the Institute of Medicine have called for substantial investments in palliative care across the nation. The Centers to Advance Palliative Care have a report card rating that they do for every state, and currently there are seven states with a D report card rating, and Arkansas is one of them, and that's because of our limited access to palliative care. There are many areas in the state where individuals have no access to any type of palliative care treatment. Hospice is not the same thing as palliative care. Hospice is a form of palliative care, but palliative care can be offered much sooner than hospice care can. You don't have to be in your last six months of life to receive palliative care. So it's a much broader field. It can be offered to so many other individuals, as the representative and Mr. Keck have mentioned, anybody going through a serenous illness, cancer treatment, just things like that. Palliative care is a supportive layer that helps assist that patient, and it has also shown to reduce hospital readmissions when that palliative care team is involved. But our state has a long way to go in access to palliative care. It's just not widely out there available in Arkansas. So my association does support this bill and ask you guys to help us prioritize this for the state.
Representative Love. Motion at the proper time. What's your motion, Representative Love? Do pass. I'll take that motion. Representative Branscombe. Immediate consideration, please. I got a motion. Immediate consideration is non-debatable. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed. Aye. All those in favor of motion do pass. Say aye. Aye. All those opposed. No. Ayes have it. Congratulations. Your bill has passed. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. Seeing no further business, we stand adjourned.
Special Order of Business for Thursday, March 9, 2017
Number Sponsor Subtitle
HB1628 B. Smith TO CREATE THE HEALTHCARE FREEDOM OF CONSCIENCE ACT.
1:40 - 1:29:18244 segments20 speakers
The committee first adopted an amendment to HB 1628 by voice vote, and Rep. Brent Smith introduced the bill, explaining that it creates a Health Care Freedom of Conscience Act that prohibits discrimination on the basis of a patient’s status or identity and provides “reasonable accommodation” for health-care workers with religious or moral objections, while expressly barring conscience claims to refuse emergency, life-saving care.
[2:15][2:34][3:08][3:43][4:18][5:44][6:15][6:50]
The committee then moved to limit further debate to 15 minutes per side with a two-minute closing, a motion that carried unanimously, and the discussion proceeded without a final vote on the measure in this segment.
[48:55][49:08][49:12][49:16]
Special Order of Business for Tuesday, March 14, 2017
Number Sponsor Subtitle
HB1021 Love TO PROVIDE PAY EQUITY FOR WOMEN; AND TO AMEND THE WAGE DISCRIMINATION LAWS CONCERNING PROHIBITED CONDUCT AND REMEDIES FOR VIOLATIONS OF THE WAGE DISCRIMINATION LAWS.
CONCUR IN SENATE AMENDMENT
Number Sponsor Subtitle
HB1016 Farrer TO CONVERT THE HOSPITAL REIMBURSEMENT SYSTEMS UNDER THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO DIAGNOSIS-RELATED GROUP METHODOLOGY.
HB1653 Miller TO CREATE THE DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES WAIVER DEATH NOTIFICATION ACT; AND TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES TO PUBLISH CONCERNING THE WAITING LIST FOR THE ALTERNATIVE COMMUNITY SERVICES WAIVER PROGRAM.
HB1714 Petty ACT TO PERMIT THE OPERATION OF MOBILE SALONS; AND TO CREATE A LICENSING PROCEDURE CONCERNING MOBILE SALONS.
HB1706 Pilkington TO CREATE THE MEDICAID PROVIDER-LED ORGANIZED CARE ACT; TO DESIGNATE THAT A RISK-BASED PROVIDER ORGANIZATION IS AN INSURANCE COMPANY FOR CERTAIN PURPOSES UNDER ARKANSAS LAW; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1718 D. Ferguson TO CREATE THE PATIENT RIGHT-TO-KNOW ACT; TO PROVIDE FOR ACCESS BY PATIENTS AND THEIR PHYSICIANS TO CONTACT INFORMATION; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1731 Jett TO PROVIDE AMENDED UNEMPLOYMENT CALCULATIONS AND BENEFITS FOR CERTAIN AGRICULTURAL AND CONSTRUCTION EMPLOYEES.
HB1746 A. Mayberry TO CREATE THE DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES WAIVER LEGISLATIVE TASK FORCE.
HB1771 S. Meeks TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS NIGHTTIME ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION ACT.
HB1775 Johnson TO MANDATE THAT THE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH ESTABLISH AND MAINTAIN A SUICIDE PREVENTION HOTLINE.
SB206 Irvin TO AVOID UNNECESSARY EXPANSION IN MEDICAID COSTS AND SERVICES RELATED ITO REHABILITATIVE SERVICES FOR PERSONS WITH MENTAL ILLNESS; AND TO CODIFY THE REHABILITATIVE SERVICES FOR PERSONS WITH MENTAL ILLNESS MORATORIUM.
HB1182 Sullivan TO AUTHORIZE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO ALLOW AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE TO BE A PRIMARY CARE PROVIDER.
HB1809 Watson TO REFORM MEDICAID SERVICES FOR INDIVIDUALS WITH DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1810 Watson TO CLARIFY AND ESTABLISH AN APPROPRIATE MEDICAID REIMBURSEMENT METHODOLOGY FOR SMALL INTERMEDIATE CARE FACILITIES FOR INDIVIDUALS WITH DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1815 D. Whitaker TO CREATE A STATEWIDE ANTIMICROBIAL OR ANTIBIOTIC STEWARDSHIP POLICY FOR THE STATE OF ARKANSAS REGARDING HEALTHCARE SERVICES; AND TO REQUIRE HEALTH FACILITIES TO IMPLEMENT ANTIMICROBIAL OR ANTIBIOTIC STEWARDSHIP POLICIES.
HB1818 Gonzales TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF NURSING AND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY ADVISORY COMMITTEE.
HB1835 Dotson TO PROMOTE, RECRUIT, AND RETAIN A HIGHLY SKILLED WORKFORCE IN THE STATE OF ARKANSAS; TO ESTABLISH A SYSTEM OF RECIPROCITY FOR LICENSING, REGISTRATION, AND CERTIFICATION FOR CERTAIN PROFESSIONS.
HB1846 Collins TO AMEND AND CLARIFY THE MINIMUM WAGE ACT OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1851 Hammer TO AUTHORIZE A REGISTERED NURSE EMPLOYED BY HOSPICE TO SIGN THE MEDICAL CERTIFICATION OF DEATH AND PRONOUNCE DEATH FOR A PATIENT WHO IS RECEIVING HOSPICE SERVICES AND WHO DIES AS A HOSPICE PATIENT IN A HOSPITAL.
2:44:36 - 2:46:356 segments2 speakers
Representative Kim Hammer introduced HB 1851, allowing a registered hospice nurse to sign the medical certification of death and pronounce death for hospice patients who die in a hospital, addressing delays caused by awaiting a physician.
[2:44:50][2:45:20][2:45:50]
The proposal received bipartisan support, including endorsements from the Hospital Association and the Hospice Palliative Care Association, and no member voiced opposition.
[2:45:50][2:46:00]
A motion to pass the bill was made, the “aye” vote carried, and the measure was adopted as bill 2067.
[2:46:00][2:46:30][2:46:35]
HB1857 Magie TO PROHIBIT DISCRIMINATION AGAINST A PHYSICIAN FOR A DECISION TO NOT PARTICIPATE IN ANY FORM OF MAINTENANCE OF LICENSURE OR MAINTENANCE OF CERTIFICATION.
HB1865 Ladyman TO AMEND THE STATEWIDE FLUORIDATION PROGRAM; AND TO PROVIDE LOCAL CONTROL OVER FLUORIDE LEVELS.
SB335 Irvin TO PERMIT VOLUNTARY RESPITE CARE; TO CREATE A LICENSE EXEMPTION CONCERNING VLUNTARY RESPITE CARE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
SB351 B. Sample TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING COSMETOLOGY INSTRUCTOR TRAINING.
SB361 Flippo TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION FROM THE LAWS REGARDING THE PRACTICE OF PHARMACY FOR DIALYSATE OR DEVICES NECESSARY FOR HOME PERITONEAL KIDNEY DIALYSIS IN CERTAIN SITUATIONS.
HB1186 Brown TO REMOVE THE COLLABORATIVE PRACTICE AGREEMENT AS APPLICABLE TO ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES WHO MEET CERTAIN REQUIREMENTS; AND TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY FOR AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE.
HB1894 Gates TO REQUIRE THAT BIRTH CERTIFICATES LIST THE BIOLOGICAL SEX OF AN INDIVIDUAL AS DETERMINED AT BIRTH; AND TO PROHIBIT AMENDMENT OF A BIRTH CERTIFICATE TO CHANGE THE BIOLOGICAL SEX LISTED ON A BIRTH CERTIFICATE.
HB1903 Bentley TO CREATE THE ENHANCED ELIGIBILITY AND AUTHENTICATION ACT.
HB1916 Hammer TO REQUIRE ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES TO USE THEIR OWN MEDICAID PROVIDER NUMBER OR A MODIFIER TO A MEDICAL CODE WHEN BILLING THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM FOR REIMBURSEMENT FOR HEALTHCARE SERVICES.
HB1951 Collins TO AMEND CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF THE WORKERS' COMPENSATION LAW ENACTED BY INITIATED ACT NO. 4 OF 1948; AND TO REGULATE FINAL SETTLEMENTS OF CLAIMS INVOLVING JOINT PETITIONS.
HB1952 Collins TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING THE LIABILITY OF AN EMPLOYER FOR MEDICAL COSTS RELATED TO A COMPENSABLE INJURY; AND TO AMEND PORTIONS OF THE WORKERS' COMPENSATION LAW THAT RESULTED FROM INITIATED MEASURE 1948, NO. 4.
HB1953 Collins TO AMEND CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF THE WORKERS' COMPENSATION LAW THAT RESULTED FROM INITIATED ACT NO. 4 OF 1948.
HB1954 Collins FOR PLAN SAVINGS PROVIDER-LED MEDICAID THE TO PROGRAM A REQUIRE ORGANIZED CARE SYSTEM.
HB2001 Baltz TO ALLOW THE CONTRACTORS LICENSING BOARD TO SUSPEND OR REVOKE THE CERTIFICATE OR LICENSE OF CERTAIN CONTRACTORS.
HB2004 G. Hodges TO REQUIRE COOPERATION BETWEEN THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES AND THE OFFICE OF CHILD SUPPORT ENFORCEMENT REGARDING SNAP ELIGIBILITY.
HB2013 Lynch TO ESTABLISH AND REQUIRE CONTINUING EDUCATION FOR HEATING, VENTILATION, AIR CONDITIONING, AND REFRIGERATION LICENSEES.
HB2067 Hammer TO CREATE THE PALLIATIVE CARE AND QUALITY OF LIFE INTERDISCIPLINARY TASK FORCE.
2:46:35 - 2:22:54
Representative Kim Hammer offered HB 2067 to create a Palliative Care and Quality of Life Interdisciplinary Task Force, citing collaboration with the Hospice and Palliative Care Association of Arkansas and the American Cancer Society to improve statewide palliative services.
[2:47:19][2:47:36][2:48:09][2:48:12][2:48:21][2:48:48][2:48:57]
HB2071 Pilkington TO PLACE LIMITATIONS AND SAFETY GUARDS ON THE MIFEPRISTONE PRESCRIPTION FOR ABORTIONS.
HCR1012 J. Williams TO ENCOURAGE THE GOVERNOR TO SUBMIT A STATE PLAN AMENDMENT TO THE CENTERS FOR MEDICARE AND MEDICAID SERVICES TO PROVIDE ACCESS TO COVERAGE FOR MIGRANT CHILDREN AND PREGNANT WOMEN FROM THE COMPACT OF FREE ASSOCIATION ISLANDS.
2:22:54 - 2:38:0248 segments7 speakers
The resolution HCR 1012 was introduced by Representative Williams, urging the governor to request a CMS amendment that would restore Medicaid-like coverage for migrant children and pregnant women from the Compact of Free Association islands.
[2:23:07][2:23:38][2:24:17]
HB2000 Leding TO PROTECT THE RIGHTS OF EMPLOYEES AND APPLICANTS FOR EMPLOYMENT; REGARDING EMPLOYER USE OF CREDIT REPORTS AND BACKGROUND CHECKS OF EMPLOYEES AND APPLICANTS FOR EMPLOYMENT.
SB420 Irvin TO ALLOW INSURANCE CARRIERS TO OBTAIN PRACTITIONER AND DISPENSER INFORMATION MAINTAINED BY THE PRESCRIPTION DRUG MONITORING PROGRAM; AND TO ALLOW PRESCRIBER DATA TO BE USED FOR RESEARCH PURPOSES.
SB429 L. Eads TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECKS FOR MASSAGE THERAPISTS.
HB1625 Leding TO CREATE THE RIGHT TO KNOW YOUR PAY ACT.
HB2023 Fielding TO REQUIRE A FIRE EXTINGUISHER IN ALL APARTMENTS IN ARKANSAS.
HB2108 Johnson TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING WORKERS' COMPENSATION COVERAGE REQUIRED FOR A CONTRACTOR.
HB2109 Johnson TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING FINANCIAL STATEMENTS REQUIRED TO BE SUBMITTED BY A LICENSEE OF THE CONTRACTORS LICENSING BOARD.
HB2140 Rye TO AMEND CERTAIN PROVISIONS REGARDING ACUPUNCTURE AND EXEMPTIONS TO THE LICENSURE OF ACUPUNCTURISTS.
HB2145 Penzo TO CREATE THE MEDICAID PROVIDER-LED ORGANIZED CARE ACT; TO IMPOSE AN INSURANCE PREMIUM TAX ON RISK-BASED PROVIDER ORGANIZATIONS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB2148 Penzo TO PROHIBIT THE USE OF SUPPLEMENTAL NUTRITION ASSISTANCE PROGRAM (SNAP) BENEFITS FUNDS TO PURCHASE LUXURY FOOD ITEMS.
HB2149 Penzo TO REQUIRE A MERCHANT TO REQUEST A PHOTO IDENTIFICATION CARD BEFORE ACCEPTING AN ELECTRONIC BENEFITS TRANSFER CARD.
HB2150 Penzo TO PROHIBIT THE USE OF SUPPLEMENTAL NUTRITION ASSISTANCE PROGRAM (SNAP) BENEFITS FUNDS TO PURCHASE LUXURY FOOD ITEMS.
HB2176I McCollum TO ENCOURAGE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT BY FACILITATING EMPLOYMENT OF INDIVIDUALS; TO REGULATE OCCUPATIONAL BOARDS, COMMISSIONS, AND OTHER ENTITIES WHILE PRESERVING HEALTH AND SAFETY STANDARDS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB2177 McCollum TO CLARIFY THE PROPER ADMINISTRATION BY THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN TO REGULATIONS PERTAINING POST-ELIGIBILITY OF SERVICES THE FEDERAL TREATMENT OF INCOME OF INSTITUTIONALIZED INDIVIDUALS OF LONG- TERM CARE MEDICAID.
HB2216 McCollum TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE SOCIAL MEDIA ACCOUNTS OF CURRENT AND PROSPECTIVE EMPLOYEES.
HB2220 Davis TO AMEND THE PROCESS FOR PERMITTING NONMUNICIPAL DOMESTIC SEWAGE TREATMENT WORKS.
HB2245 Gazaway TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING INFORMAL DISPUTE RESOLUTION HEARINGS PERTAINING TO DISPUTE RESOLUTIONS FOR LONG-TERM CARE FACILITIES.
HB1716 Richmond TO CLARIFY SHORT-TERM ACTIVITY AUTHORIZATIONS; TO ESTABLISH CONDITIONS FOR WAIVING THE FEE; AND TO ALLOW THE DEPARTMENT TO MODIFY THE FEE FOR A STATE AGENCY, BOARD, OR COMMISSION OR A MUNICIPALITY, CITY, OR COUNTY.
2:38:02 - 2:55:3553 segments9 speakers
Speaker presented HB 1716, which would permit ADEQ to waive 25 percent of its routine fees to counties and eliminate fees in emergency situations, thereby reducing the financial impact on local governments.
[2:38:21][2:38:57][2:39:28][2:39:50]
An illustrative emergency (flood-washed-out bridge) and the rising ADEQ fees-exemplified by the Diamond Pipeline project-were cited to show the bill’s practical benefits and the need for flexibility in fee assessments.
[2:40:03][2:40:31][2:41:08][2:41:38]
The committee moved to pass the bill, and with no opposition the motion carried and HB 1716 was approved.
[2:42:59]
HB1160 A. Mayberry TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF A "SPECIALIST SIGN ELECTRICIAN".
Number Sponsor Subtitle
HB1624 Leding TO CREATE THE RIGHT TO WAGES EARNED ACT.
DEFERRED
Number Sponsor Subtitle
HB1040 Farrer TO LIMIT THE PRACTICE OF ATHLETIC TRAINING IN A NONCLINICAL SETTING.
HB1300 Miller TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES TO PRIORITIZE SPENDING WITH THE DEPARTMENT AND THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO FULLY FUND HOME- AND COMMUNITY-BASED SERVICES FOR INDIVIDUALS WITH DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES.
HB1255 D. Ferguson TO CREATE A TEMPORARY CHARITABLE DENTAL LICENSE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1439 M. Gray TO AMEND THE HEALTHCARE QUALITY AND PAYMENT POLICY ADVISORY COMMITTEE.
HB1502 S. Meeks TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION TO THE DEFINITION OF RESIDENTIAL CARE FACILITY AND THE DEFINITION OF ASSISTED LIVING FACILITY.
HB1237 Hammer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS SURGICAL TECHNOLOGISTS ACT; AND TO ESTABLISH THE REGISTRATION OF SURGICAL TECHNOLOGISTS.
HB1254 Magie TO TRANSFER REGULATORY AUTHORITY OVER ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES FROM THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF NURSING TO THE ARKANSAS STATE MEDICAL BOARD.
HB1204 Magie TO ALLOW PHARMACISTS TO MAKE BIOLOGICAL PRODUCT SUBSTITUTIONS.
HB1205 Magie TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS ANESTHESIOLOGIST ASSISTANT ACT.
HB1181 Sullivan TO CREATE THE TRANSITION TO PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY ACT; AND TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY OF ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES.
HB1228 Hammer TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY OF AN ADVANCED PRACTICE NURSE.
HB1551 Womack TO STIMULATE JOB CREATION AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT WHILE PRESERVING HEALTH AND SAFETY STANDARDS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1525 Magie TO REQUIRE THE ARKANSAS STATE MEDICAL BOARD AND THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF NURSING TO DEVELOP A JOINT APPLICATION FOR COLLABORATIVE PRACTICE AGREEMENTS BETWEEN COLLABORATING PHYSICIANS AND ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES.
HB1257 Richey TO CREATE THE COMMUNITY HEALTH WORKER ACT.
HB1664 Payton TO AMEND THE FEES FOR WASTE TIRES; TO REQUIRE PAYMENT OF WASTE TIRE FEES FOR NEW CAR TIRES; AND TO REQUIRE PAYMENT OF WASTE TIRE FEES BY DEALERS MOUNTING TIRES SOLD AT OTHER LOCATIONS AND FLEET OWNERS.
HB1504 Hammer TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTION DRUG MONITORING PROGRAM TO MANDATE PRESCRIBERS CHECK THE PRESCRIPTION DRUG MONITORING PROGRAM WHEN PRESCRIBING CERTAIN MEDICATIONS.