Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

State Agencies & Governmental Affairs

March 15, 2017 ·Committee Room 151 ·2:34:45
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026

HB1047 Lowery TO REQUIRE THAT A VOTER PROVIDE VERIFICATION OF VOTER REGISTRATION WHEN VOTING; AND TO AMEND AMENDMENT 51 OF THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION. 0:42

Representative Mark Lowery explained that voters without photo ID could sign a sworn statement attesting to their identity, relieving the need for provisional ballots. [1:11] [1:43]

Chair Bob Ballinger noted two Senate amendments to concur in and moved a motion to concur in both amendments, which passed without objection. [2:12] [2:17]

Representative Warwick Sabin recognized the concurrence on Senate Amendment 1 to HB 1010, referencing its prior passage without dissent. [3:04]

HB1010 Sabin TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE FILING AND PUBLICATION OF CERTAIN CAMPAIGN FINANCE REPORTS; AND TO AMEND PORTIONS OF LAW RESULTING FROM INITIATED … 3:09

Representative Warwick Sabin described the Senate amendment allowing paper filing for voters lacking internet access and noted its unanimous 34-0 Senate approval. [3:20]

The committee moved to concur in the amendment, and the motion carried unanimously. [3:58] [4:01]

Chair Ballinger then closed the item and indicated the next bill would be taken up shortly. [4:24]

HB1765 Holcomb TO IMPROVE ELECTION ADMINISTRATION TRANSPARENCY; AND TO RESOLVE A CONFLICT IN THE LAW CONCERNING PUBLIC NOTICE OF ELECTIONS. 5:19

Representative Mike Holcomb outlined that the bill would require posting the date and location of early-voting official lists well before voting, addressing current one-day notice practices. [5:35]

Chair Ballinger asked for questions, received none, and called for a vote on the bill. [6:06]

The committee approved HB 1765 unanimously. [6:23]

Representative Jim Dotson presented the amended HB 1207, removing felony penalties, limiting violations to ethics offenses, and narrowing the scope to candidate-specific signage issues. [6:42] [7:12]

HB1207 Dalby TO AMEND REQUIREMENTS FOR CAMPAIGN SIGNS AND MATERIALS. 7:16

Representative Dwight Tosh confirmed that penalties requiring state employees to resign were eliminated, now treated as ethics violations before the Ethics Commission. [8:19] [8:50]

After discussion, a motion to pass the bill was made and adopted without opposition. [10:22]

Representative D. Meeks introduced HB 1696 to transfer the State Child Abuse and Neglect Prevention Board to the Department of Children and Family Services, citing inefficiencies and funding concerns. [11:21] [11:26]

HB1696 D. Meeks TO TRANSFER THE STATE CHILD ABUSE AND NEGLECT PREVENTION BOARD TO THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES THROUGH A TYPE 3 TRANSFER; AND TO ABOLISH TH… 11:27

Speaker detailed the board’s limited activity, excess appropriations, and the rationale for a Type 3 transfer that would retain programs while improving oversight. [11:57] [12:27] [12:58] [13:29]

The committee asked no questions and voted to pass the bill. [15:07]

HB1440 M. Gray TO AMEND PROVISIONS IN THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING ELECTION RUNOFFS, INITIATIVES, AND REFERENDA. 16:08

Representative Michelle Gray explained that HB 1440 needed a correction from “three weeks” to “four weeks” and added language to ensure constitutional publication of amendment texts six months before elections. [16:10] [16:29]

The committee concurred in the amendment, adopted it after brief discussion, and recorded the adoption despite a single objection. [16:44] [16:48] [17:17] [17:48] [18:05] [18:13] [18:16] [18:19]

A final motion to pass the bill as amended was made and carried unanimously. [19:02]

HB1270 Johnson TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ELECTIONS AND BALLOTS. 20:15

Representative Bob Johnson presented HB 1270, proposing low-cost private voting areas by placing simple tables to allow secret ballot marking without additional expense. [20:25] [20:56]

Chair Ballinger noted no questions from the committee and closed the hearing on the bill. [21:07]

The committee voted to pass HB 1270 unanimously. [21:27]

HB1622 Johnson TO CREATE BURDENSOME REQUESTS FOR ADDRESSING A PROCEDURE FOR DISCLOSURE; TO AMEND THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967; TO CREATE AN AFFIRMATI… 21:36

The committee first considered an amendment to HB 1622 that reduced the response deadline from a 45-day cap to 15 business days and added language for an affirmative defense, which Rep. Gray moved to adopt and was approved by voice vote. [23:52] [24:14]

Witnesses including Pulaski County Attorney Chastity Cypress, Sheriff’s Sergeant Doug Cunningham, public-policy attorney Dan Greenberg, former commissioner Stewart Sofer and others testified, arguing that the 15-day limit balances transparency with the burden of large requests while warning that eliminating the three-day rule could undermine citizens’ rights, prompting extensive debate and questions from several representatives. [23:12] [23:18] [23:38] [23:40] [23:52] [27:18] [27:38] [27:50] [27:56] [28:18] [28:55] [29:01] [29:09] [29:38] [30:10] [36:07] [36:21] [36:55] [37:00] [37:19] [37:29] [37:44] [38:00] [39:35] [40:09] [40:40] [41:15] [41:49] [46:02] [46:06] [46:46] [47:21] [47:52] [48:22] [48:55]

When the time came to vote on the bill itself, the committee lacked a motion to consider HB 1622 and the chair announced that the measure failed, ending the hearing without passage. [55:17]

HB2033 Shepherd TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION TO ESTABLISH A CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECK POLICY FOR CERTAIN PERSONS APPLYING FOR OR OCC… 56:20

Rep. Matthew J. Shepherd introduced HB 2033, which would require the Department of Finance and Administration to conduct criminal background checks for personnel handling federal tax information, citing compliance with a federal mandate. [56:25]

After brief discussion, a motion was made and passed unanimously, and the committee approved the bill, with Shepherd noting a possible future amendment to include another department. [56:56] [57:12]

HB1725 D. Douglas TO TRANSFER VARIOUS STATE AGENCIES TO THE ARKANSAS AGRICULTURE DEPARTMENT THROUGH A TYPE 4 TRANSFER; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY. 58:39

Rep. Dan M. Douglas introduced HB 1725, explaining that the bill would transfer the State Plant Board, Livestock and Poultry Commission, and Forestry Commission to the Arkansas Department of Agriculture while preserving their statutory powers, rulemaking authority, and fee-based revenues, and he argued the move would eliminate duplicated HR, procurement, IT, and CFO functions across the three agencies. [59:11] [59:42] [1:00:13] [1:00:46] [1:01:18] [1:01:51] [1:02:25] [1:02:56] [1:03:27] [1:03:58] [1:04:35] [1:05:15]

Secretary of Agriculture Wes Ward testified that these agencies have been part of the department since the 2005 “top-one” transfer, that consolidating support functions could save roughly $600,000 per year, improve emergency response capabilities, and would not result in job losses because staff would be reassigned at the same pay level. [1:06:05] [1:06:19] [1:06:51] [1:07:28] [1:07:58] [1:08:33] [1:09:03] [1:09:34] [1:10:04] [1:10:39] [1:11:13] [1:11:43] [1:12:14] [1:12:49] [1:13:20] [1:13:28] [1:13:51] [1:14:02] [1:14:21]

Committee members raised concerns about the projected savings, the absence of a formal financial impact statement, and the potential effects of the type-4 transfer and emergency clause; opposition witnesses such as Ray Vester and Kim Hammer warned that the bill could centralize control of funds and weaken the Plant Board’s independence, while supporters including Wes Higginbotham and Marvin Childress argued it would reduce duplication and preserve board authority, after which Chair Rep. Bob Ballinger adopted a motion to limit further debate to five minutes per side. [1:13:28] [1:13:51] [1:14:02] [1:14:21] [1:15:00] [1:15:04] [1:15:32] [1:24:58] [1:25:39] [1:26:11] [1:26:53] [1:27:26] [1:27:59] [1:28:30] [1:29:02] [1:29:34] [1:30:08] [1:30:38] [1:31:14] [1:31:45] [1:32:15] [1:32:46] [1:33:21] [1:33:51] [1:36:43] [1:36:48] [1:37:02] [1:37:29] [1:37:39] [1:38:10] [1:38:40] [1:38:53] [1:39:09] [1:39:11] [1:39:31] [1:39:43] [1:40:14] [1:40:40] [1:40:45]

The chair called for a motion to pass HB 1725, held a voice vote with no opposition and announced committee approval; Rep. Tucker then confirmed the bill’s number (1,005/1,008), noting that this version differed substantially from the one previously considered; finally Rep. (Speaker) 239 explained that the disclosure provisions had been removed, leaving the measure to focus solely on coordination issues in campaign-finance transparency. [1:50:21] [1:50:32] [1:51:09] [1:51:14] [1:51:22] [1:51:41]

HB1005 Tucker TO REQUIRE REPORTING AND DISCLOSURE OF ELECTIONEERING COMMUNICATIONS; AND TO RESTRICT THE AMOUNT OF MONEY SPENT ON CAMPAIGN COMMUNICATIONS PRODUC… 1:52:03

Representative Tucker explained that the bill would create a definition of coordinated political advertising as an in-kind contribution subject to the $2,700 contribution limit, noting Arkansas is currently the only state without such a rule and that the proposal places the disclosure burden solely on candidates, not third-party groups. [1:52:11] [1:52:47] [1:53:18] [1:53:49] [1:54:21]

David Ray of Americans for Prosperity testified that the bill’s definition of “political advertising” is overly broad, would capture ordinary issue-based speech by nonprofits, and gives the Ethics Commission unchecked authority to interpret “any other factor”. [1:55:32] [1:56:07] [1:56:40] [1:57:12] [1:57:47] [1:58:21]

Tucker responded that the definition is confined to the coordination section of the code, does not affect other campaign-finance provisions, and that the threshold for prohibited ads is limited to express advocacy for or against a specific candidate. [1:59:07] [1:59:27] [1:59:58] [2:00:32] [2:01:05]

Chair Bob Ballinger moved to pass the measure; after brief discussion the committee voted “no” and the bill failed to pass. [2:01:17] [2:01:34]

HB1944 C. Douglas TO ESTABLISH A GRANT ADVISORY BOARD; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DISBURSEMENT OF CERTAIN FEDERAL FUNDS RECEIVED BY THE STATE. 2:06:03

Representative Dan M. Douglas described the bill as strengthening an existing grant advisory board that reviews and advises on the administration of federal victim-service funds, emphasizing that the board would not have authority to direct DF&A spending but would provide oversight and input. [2:06:32] [2:06:41] [2:07:12] [2:07:48]

He raised concerns that the bill’s use of the term “review” could be interpreted as legislative-style review authority, prompting the chair to suggest amending or removing the word to avoid overstepping federal guidelines. [2:08:21] [2:08:53] [2:09:26] [2:09:35] [2:09:56] [2:10:27]

Testimony from Monty Johnson (Arkansas Coalition Against Sexual Assault) and Beth Goodrich (Arkansas Coalition Against Domestic Violence) highlighted past failures of the advisory committee to influence grant decisions, the need for a stronger advisory role, and fears of retaliation against agencies that raise concerns. [2:11:37] [2:12:00] [2:12:32] [2:13:03] [2:13:38] [2:14:09] [2:23:06] [2:23:37] [2:24:08] [2:24:39] [2:25:10] [2:25:22] [2:25:31] [2:25:41]

Committee members, including the chair and DF&A Deputy Director Paul Lothian, debated a proposed amendment that would insert a Webster’s-style definition of “review” to clarify it as non-legislative analysis, but no final vote was taken, leaving the amendment pending for later consideration. [2:18:28] [2:18:36] [2:18:38] [2:18:54] [2:19:08] [2:19:14] [2:19:59] [2:20:18] [2:20:56] [2:21:35] [2:21:45] [2:21:50] [2:22:05] [2:26:17] [2:26:42] [2:26:47] [2:26:55] [2:27:08] [2:27:23] [2:27:30] [2:27:38] [2:27:54] [2:28:18]

SB419 Irvin TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE CIVIL WAR SESQUICENTENNIAL COMMISSION, THE ARKANSAS NATURAL HERITAGE COMMISSION, THE PUBLIC ART PROGRAM OF THE ARKA… 2:30:39

Senator Irvin’s amendment, presented by Speaker 291, merely updates the bill’s title to reflect its actual contents and makes minor technical changes, such as allowing the Natural Heritage Commission to submit reports electronically and eliminating unused programs and boards (Public Art Program, Delta Cultural Center National Advisory Board, Mosaic Templars Cultural Center requirements). [2:31:07] [2:31:09] [2:31:26] [2:31:39] [2:31:45] [2:32:13] [2:32:43]

Representative Warwick Sabin asked why a member of the Humanities Council was removed from the Delta Cultural Center board; the answer was that the position had been vacant and the change eases staffing. [2:33:22] [2:33:40] [2:33:48]

The chair moved to adopt the amendment, the committee voted “aye,” and the amendment was adopted, effectively passing the bill as amended. [2:34:13] [2:34:19]

Bills discussed (71)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1010 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “to concur in Senate Amendment 1 to HB 1010. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Everyone at this committee may remem…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1270 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Okay. Without objection, we'll take up HB 1270. If the”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1696 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…Meeks, what is the bill number that you're here to present? House Bill 1696. Okay. Okay, you're recognized to present House Bill 1696.…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1047 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1047 Lowery TO REQUIRE THAT A VOTER PROVIDE VERIFICATION OF VOTE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1207 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1207 Dalby TO AMEND REQUIREMENTS FOR CAMPAIGN SIGNS AND MATERIAL…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1440 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1440 M. Gray TO AMEND PROVISIONS IN THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1622 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “right. We'll take up the amendment first on HB 1622.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1765 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “mutual. Is it HB 1765? Yes, HB 1765, and actually, essentially, it's just a clean…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1004 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1004 Blake TO CREATE THE DEMOCRACY ACT; TO REQUIRE AUTOMATIC VOT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1005 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1005 Tucker TO REQUIRE REPORTING AND DISCLOSURE OF ELECTIONEERIN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1008 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1008 Tucker TO INCREASE THE PENALTY FOR TAKING CAMPAIGN FUNDS AS…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1009 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1009 Leding TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING APPROVED POLITICAL ACTIO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1011 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1011 Sabin TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING POLITICAL ACTION COMMI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1012 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1012 Sabin TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING POLITICAL ACTION COMMI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1046 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1046 Tucker TO PERMIT PAID MATERNITY LEAVE FOR STATE EMPLOYEES.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1151 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1151 Davis TO REQUIRE THAT REGISTERED VOTERS BE NOTIFIED BY MAIL…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1179 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1179 Ballinger BENEFITS DEATH DESIGNATED TO PROVIDING TO PROVISI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1289 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1289 Ballinger TO PROMOTE AND IMPROVE EFFICIENCY AND QUALITY IN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1386 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1386 Lemons TO REQUIRE THE FILING OF FINAL AGENCY RULES WITH THE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1447 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1447 M. Gray TO TRANSFER THE STATE BOARD OF ELECTION COMMISSIONE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1623 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1623 Johnson TO AMEND THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967; TO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1707 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1707 M. Gray TO AMEND THE DATES OF THE GENERAL PRIMARY ELECTION…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1725 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1725 D. Douglas TO TRANSFER VARIOUS STATE AGENCIES TO THE ARKANS…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1739 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1739 C. Douglas TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING PRIMARY ELECTIONS, R…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1741 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1741 Vaught ALERT NOTIFICATION SYSTEM; ESTABLISH A BLUE TO AND C…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1766 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1766 D. Douglas TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING PRIMARY ELECTIONS, R…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1807 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1807 Collins TO ENSURE THE FUTURE FUNDING OF THE STATE HEALTH DE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1819 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1819 K. Hendren CONCERNING BALLOT TITLES AND POPULAR NAMES OF CO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1823 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1823 Collins TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS PAPERWORK EFFICIENCY AND TRA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1832 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1832 House TO ALLOW THE EMPLOYMENT OF SPECIAL COUNSEL BY A STATE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1861 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1861 Ballinger CONCERNING THE APPROVAL OF BALLOT TITLES AND POPU…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1866 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1866 Lundstrum TO EXEMPT CERTAIN INFORMATION PERTAINING TO A LAW…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1893 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1893 M. Gray TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS PROCUREMENT LAW; AND TO AMEND…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1931 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1931 Gillam CONCERNING THE APPROVAL OF BALLOT TITLES AND POPULAR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1932 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1932 Gillam CONCERNING THE REVIEW OF RULES PROMULGATED BY THE ST…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1944 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1944 C. Douglas TO ESTABLISH A GRANT ADVISORY BOARD; AND TO AMEN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1975 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1975 Dotson TO ADOPT THE COMPACT FOR A BALANCED BUDGET; AND TO A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1988 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1988 Lundstrum CONCERNING COUNTY JAIL REIMBURSEMENT FOR HOUSING…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1992 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1992 Lundstrum CONCERNING COUNTY JAIL REIMBURSEMENT FOR HOUSING…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2029 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2029 Sabin TO AMEND THE UNIFORM ATTENDANCE AND LEAVE POLICY ACT;…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2033 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2033 Shepherd TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND ADMINISTR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2035 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2035 D. Douglas TO AMEND THE DATES FOR PROCESSING ABSENTEE BALLO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2055 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2055 Hammer CONCERNING REMEDIES AVAILABLE TO PERSONS TERMINATED…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2064 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2064 Hammer TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE FILING DEADLINES FOR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2074 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2074 Leding TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING INITIATIVES AND REFER…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2095 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2095 G. Hodges TO ESTABLISH VOTE CENTERS ON THE CAMPUSES OF STAT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2096 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2096 G. Hodges TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF PROCUREMENT LAW TO REFLECT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2128 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2128 Lowery TO AMEND ARKANSAS LAW CONCERNING THE APPROVAL OF STA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2162 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2162 Gonzales TO PROMOTE VOTER TURNOUT; TO AMEND THE LAW TO LIMI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2183 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2183 Lowery TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS WHISTLE-BLOWER A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2195 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2195 Shepherd TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING INFORMATION FOR PUBLI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2196 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2196 Henderson TO AMEND LANGUAGE CONCERNING THE SPORT OF PROFESS…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2200 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2200 M. Hodges TO MODIFY THE DEFINITION OF "SMALL PROCUREMENTS";…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2201 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2201 Della Rosa TO DIRECT THE DEPARTMENT OF ARKANSAS HERITAGE TO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2242 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2242 Davis TO AMEND THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967 CONCE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2259 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2259 Walker TO REQUIRE THE PASSAGE OF THE CIVICS PORTION OF THE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2260 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2260 Walker TO REQUIRE THE PASSAGE OF THE CIVICS PORTION OF THE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2261 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2261 Walker TO REQUIRE THE PASSAGE OF THE CIVICS PORTION OF THE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HCR1014 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HCR1014 V. Flowers REQUESTING AND PETITIONING THE UNITED STATES CON…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1001 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1001 Ballinger APPLYING TO THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS TO CALL A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1003 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1003 Gillam AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNING…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB252 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB252 B. King TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES TO SUBM…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB373 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB373 Hester TO EXEMPT ATTORNEY-CLIENT COMMUNICATIONS AND ATTORNE…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB377 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB377 Hickey CONCERNING THE ELIGIBILITY OF AN INMATE OF THE DEPAR…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB38 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB38 A. Clark TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ELECTIONS AND BALLOTS.”
Pre-2017 bill
SB380 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB380 Hester TO EXEMPT CERTAIN COMMODITIES AND SERVICES UNDER THE…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB419 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB419 Irvin TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE CIVIL WAR SESQUICENTE…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB449 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB449 Hester TO CLARIFY THE RESOLUTION OF PROTESTED SOLICITATIONS…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB513 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB513 Hester FROM CONTRACTING WITH AND INVESTING IN TO PROHIBIT P…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB584 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB584 E. Williams CONCERNING THE QUALIFICATIONS OF THE DIRECTOR O…”
Pre-2017 bill
SCR9 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SCR9 E. Williams URGING THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS TO PROPOSE TH…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
Committee, we got a lot of fun stuff to take care of today. We have several people from other committees who are here to run bills. We'll start with the concurring and the Senate amendments and get those done real quick, and then we'll pick up some of you who've got other bills to run and move from there. So the first thing is we have a concurrence for Michelle. Is anyone here to run that? She's not here yet. We can come back and pick her up. Representative Lowry, you have a concurrence for HB 1047? You are recognized to concur in the Senate Amendment to HB 1047.
▶ Play
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, members. This is the voter ID bill passed out of the House. On its way to the Senate, I was offered some suggestions that I think made the bill much better. So the concurring amendment, in addition to some technical corrections that the Secretary of State's office helped us in making sure that we didn't violate the Voting Rights Act or anything, the main part of it is that if a person submitting an absentee ballot does not have a photo ID to send a copy of it, we are providing them on the form with the ability to sign a written statement attesting that they are who they say they are under penalty of perjury. The same thing is true that if you show up at the voting place and you don't have an ID, rather than having to cast a provisional ballot and then come back later to show your ID, you cast a provisional ballot, but you can cure it by signing the sworn statement. So this will help alleviate a lot of the concerns about votes being thrown out because they don't have ID. The option is also there for them to have the sworn statement. So I think this is a suggestion that came both from the ACLU and also from a Republican election commissioner. So I felt very comfortable adding it, and it really improves the bill. But we do have to go through the concurrence process. Okay. We actually have
▶ Play
two amendments to concur in, and without objection, we'll take up both of them. You've heard the amendments presented. Is there any discussion on the amendments? Any questions for the presenter? All right. I'm not seeing any questions. What is the will of the committee? We have a motion from Representative Sturge to concur in both Senate Amendment 1 and 2. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? All right. Congratulations. Thank you, members. Okay. Is Representative Sabin in the room? There you are. If you want to go ahead and concur in your amendment. You are recognized
▶ Play
to concur in Senate Amendment 1 to HB 1010. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Everyone at this committee may remember this is the bill that requires electronic filing for reports of political action committees, exploratory committees, and independent expenditure committees, passed the House without a dissenting vote. And over on the Senate side, they asked to add an amendment that would basically allow for exceptions for people who don't have access to the Internet to file a paper report if necessary. So, excuse me, a little out of breath, I came running in here. So that was the extent of the amendment. After that, it also passed the Senate 34-0. So I'd appreciate concurrence in that amendment. Okay. Any questions? All right.
▶ Play
You ready to close for your? I'm closed, Mr. Chair. Okay. What's the will of the
▶ Play
committee? You move to concur in your amendments?
▶ Play
I move to pass on the concurrence in the amendment. Okay. Okay, so the motion is to concur in the Senate Amendment to HB 1010. All in favor say aye. Opposed? All right. Congratulations. We've concurred. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Okay. I have promised Representative Holcomb. He's got, I think, what should be a fairly short bill to run his bill so he can get out of the committee real quick. And then after that, without objection, we'll take up Representative Dalby. She's been
▶ Play
back. Thank you, Mr. Chair, committee. Mr. Chair, if you don't mind, I'd like to have Stu Sofa from the Election Commission come up in case the committee has any tough questions this
▶ Play
Speaker 25 4:47
morning. That's fine. Hopefully that didn't kill your bill. Well, I was thinking the same thing, but I didn't know the feeling was
▶ Play
mutual. Is it HB 1765? Yes, HB 1765, and actually, essentially, it's just a cleanup bill with no price tag to it that improves transparency and correct submissions and oversights in the code. And it resulted from citizens' complaints to the State Board of Election Commissions from voters that were not aware election officials list or posted where and their right to review the list and challenge anyone appointed who is related to a candidate on the ballot or as a paid employee of political party campaign. The bill also requires posting of early voting election officials in sufficient time for candidates or voters to challenge either an election official or a deputy county clerk. Under the current system, the early voting list is posted only one day before early voting begins. The bill requires a date and location of where appointed elected officials list will be posted. And while the information is included in the running of the public office handbook that some candidates receive, the information is not generally available for voters. So that's it in a nutshell. If you have questions, we'll be glad to answer them. Any questions on the committee?
▶ Play
All right. Seeing none, you're recognized to close for your bill. I'm closed. Okay. What's the will of the committee? I have a recommendation for Representative Tosh to pass. Any discussion on it? All right. Nobody has signed up to speak for or against this bill. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? All
▶ Play
right. Congratulations. You passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Committee, appreciate your time.
▶ Play
Representative Dalby, is this 1207? Yes, Mr. Chair, it is. Okay. You are recognized to present HB 1207. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. Members of the committee, I'm hoping third time is the charm. This is the campaign materials that we have talked about before. There were some questions beforehand. I mean, the last time I was here, let me tell you what I have now done to amend this bill, which I think will address all of those issues. I have taken that section, remember there was a discussion that we were afraid that it had now put it into a felony position. We have taken that out, put it down into where it would just be an ethics violation, so there are no criminal penalties whatsoever, no barring from office. Then also there was a question as to the regard of letters. Somebody writes a letter and maybe on the bottom puts, I'm thinking of running for office. I have taken letters completely out, so you do not have that issue any longer. And I have narrowed the scope of this bill down to where it will only apply to those individuals running for office, so that we don't run afoul of any First Amendment issues regarding free speech. And then there is language in there that if you already have campaign signs, banners, et cetera, from a previous campaign, and you don't have the language of paid for by or sponsored by or printed by, those kinds of things, you're good to go. You can still use those campaign materials. And with that, I'll be happy to answer any questions. Representative Tosh, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Representative Dobbs, I really appreciate all the hard work on this. There's one question that we discussed this before, and I just want to follow up and make sure that this was addressed in your amendments. I believe it was testified to before that if someone that is a state employee happens to be running for office, if for some reason they violated some part of this bill, that somehow they would have to resign from their state.
▶ Play
Has that been taken care of? That is taken care of. That is no longer in there. We've taken any of those type of penalties out. We've simply taken this, moved it down to where it would simply be an ethics violation before the Ethics Commission. I really appreciate that. I thought that was really unfair to state employees to be under that
▶ Play
type of. And I agree. I agree with you. Okay. Thank you. Any other questions from committee? Representative Dotson, you're recognized for a question. Representative Dalby.
▶ Play
I, too, want to reiterate and commend you on the hard work you've done on this, and as one of the chief questioners of it before, I really appreciate what you've done with it, and I think it's probably a really good piece of legislation now, and wouldn't you agree? Thank you, Representative Dodson. And I couldn't have done it without your help and your whispering from the very beginning in my ear. So I've tried to really address the concerns, as I've stated before as I close for my bill, is that this is important not only to me, but I think it should be important to all of us that we want to be as transparent as we can in our campaign dealings. And with that, Mr. Chair, I would like to close for my bill, and I would ask the committee for a good vote. Let
▶ Play
me just make sure there's not any other questions. Oh, sorry. Are there any other questions from the committee? Okay. Well, we've got your close, if you're welcome to close after that. I'm good. Thank you. Representative Eubanks, you have a motion. What's your motion? All right. I have a motion to pass. Any discussion on the motion? But I'll just quickly say that, you know, this was a perfect example of how the legislative process is supposed to work, and Representative Dalby has been a trooper, and I appreciate her willingness to work with this committee. And anyway, so motion on the table is do pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? All right, congratulations. You finally passed your bill. Thank you, committee. I appreciate it. Okay, Representative Meeks. And then if there's any other legislators from other committees, make sure you either get with me or share and let me know that you're in here. I know Representative Johnson will get you next. But anybody else who's here from another committee, I want to try to get your stuff in and out so you can get back and get to work. Representative Meeks, what is the bill number that you're here to present? House Bill 1696. Okay. Okay, you're recognized to present House Bill 1696. Thank you,
▶ Play
Speaker 51 11:21
Mr. Chair. Members of the committee, House Bill 1696, what it does is it takes the Child Abuse and Neglected Prevention Board and moves it under the Department of Children and Family Services. This is not just an efficiency bill. This is not just moving a board to move it and to say that we've done something good. And there are reasons behind it. Last year when we were going through the budget hearings, this board came up, and what we found out was that the board in fiscal year 15 and 16 had spent a total of $198,283. The majority of that was on salaries and operating expenses. And they currently have a fund balance or excess appropriation of $2.176 million. And so to me, a board that is supposed to be preventing child abuse and neglect, and they have that much funding versus how much they're actually spending, that was an issue to me. And so we started to ask questions, and what we found out was, number one, the board only had three members on. I don't know if they've increased since then, but at the time of the budget hearings, they only had three members on that board. Also too, when we asked, that the board was supposed to meet at least twice a year, but again as of May, they had only met, the last board meeting was in July of 2015. And so as you can see, that also was an issue as well. So why are we going to move it under the Department of Children and Family Services? So, this is in line with strengthening and supporting families. This is something that, you know, came out a working plan from the director, Cindy Gillespie, and also Misha Martin, is that they were focusing on different areas, and this is one of the areas that they're doing to prevent child abuse and neglect with the demonstrated commitment to parental participation. So again, what this does is this will transfer this board, it's what it's called a Type 3 transfer. It does abolish the board, but it places all the duties, functions, records, responsibilities with DCFS. So again, everything that was under that board is going to be moved. The programs, the Children's Trust Fund, I know which is very important, that will be moved. The 1% to Succeed Fund is also going to be moved over as well. They're already doing home visitation, so again, that's already a plus to be in there. As far as federal revenue, because there are some concerns about federal revenue, we have checked with that and we believe that everything that they're getting as far as federal grants will fall in line with DCFS. Right now the board is funded by a $10 from each marriage license that will also continue as well. So those programs, the Children's Trust Fund, its focus will remain that. We haven't deleted anything, we haven't changed any of the requirements as far as how those grants are going to be handled. Also potential revenue, and again, this was another problem, heirloom marriage certificates. This has actually been in the law since 2001, and it's a special certificate that the state can do, can give out somebody, again, it's not a marriage license, but again, it's something that you can frame and have hanging on your wall. This has never been implemented. This has been a law since 2001. And so, again, we believe that the right thing to do at this point in order to get the most potential out of doing the child abuse and neglect is to take this board and its personnel, the staff that's on there, I think the two people that they have on staff, will be moved and will be under DCFS, and again, the board will continue as well. So, members, with that said, I'll be glad to take any questions.
▶ Play
All right. Any questions from the committee? All right. Seeing none, you're recognized. I don't think there's anybody here signed up to speak for or against that bill. So, okay, you're recognized to close for your bill. I'm closed, Mr. Chair, and I appreciate a good vote. Okay. What's your motion, Representative Dodson? I have a motion to do pass from Representative Dodson. Any discussion on the motion? All right, all in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? All right, congratulations. You pass your bill, Representative Meeks. Representative Johnson, let me have you hold on just one second. Let me have Representative Greg concur in her amendment, and then we'll get you next if that's okay with you. Okay, it's rumored you may also have an amendment to adopt as well, okay. So one trip through the Senate wasn't
▶ Play
enough for you. No, I like to keep going back, you know, take my chances. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So we will look at concurring in this amendment first. We just had one error. It's HB 1440, if anybody's wondering. bill 1440. We just had one error in the bill where we were changing the wording from three weeks to four weeks, and we did not get that done on page four, line 32. So it's just a quick change that Senator Hester did
▶ Play
on the other end. Okay. And so we're concurring in the amendment before we adopt the amendment. So you move that we concur in the amendment number one? Yes. Okay. So we have a motion to concur in amendment number one. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? Okay. We have concurred an amendment, so you're now recognized to present your amendment. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
So in House Bill, let me pull up the actual bill itself, and I can show you guys what we're doing. We tried to catch this on the Senate end before Senator Hester ran it, but I was unsuccessful in doing that. In the bill, I just want to find it. If I have the amendment, I can show you quick. here I'll just tell it off off my head so in the bill what we had done is we had changed essentially the wording for here we go thank you we had changed the publication of text provision to essentially say that it would be provided online in full text what ended up happening is I had someone an attorney with the Friday firm actually contact me and let me know that this was actually unconstitutional, that if we wanted to change this, we would have to essentially change the Constitution. And so that obviously is not our intent. I don't want this to be unconstitutional in any way. So what we've done is we've added publication of the complete text of an amendment proposed by the General Assembly shall occur six months before the election. So we had to come back in and change some wording to essentially make this bill constitutional. OK. All right. So you've heard
▶ Play
the amendment. Any questions on the amendment? All right, so you're recognized to close for your amendment. Thank you. I'm closed, Mr. Chair, and
▶ Play
I'm making a motion to adopt the amendment. All right, we have a motion
▶ Play
to adopt the amendment. Any discussion on the motion? All right, all in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? All right, congratulations, you've passed it. Thank you, Mr. Chair. With only Representative Wardlaw objecting.
▶ Play
Speaker 70 18:29
Oh, sorry. Representative Gray, we have to actually
▶ Play
pass your bill, too. Sorry. That is, if you want your bill to go on and continue the process. At
▶ Play
Speaker 72 18:48
this point, I'm not even sure.
▶ Play
All right. So is there any questions for her on the bill itself? All right. So you're recognized and closed
▶ Play
for your bill. Thank you. I'm closed, Mr. Chair, and I would appreciate a good vote. Make
▶ Play
a motion. Do pass as amended. So we have a motion on the table. Do pass as amended. Any discussion on the motion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. All right. Congratulations. You actually passed your bill this time. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Okay. Representative Johnson, you are free. Now, if anybody is here because of the speaker's resolution for the constitutional amendment, that is not going to be ran until Friday. So I don't figure that's what people are here for. But just in case, then you all don't have to be here and wait around. Which bill are
▶ Play
you running, Representative Johnson? Okay, I have three bills today. I'm not going to run 1623 today. Okay. We're going to define entity in the bill before we run it. Okay. I want to run 1270 and 1622, and I'd like to run 1270 first, if that's all right.
▶ Play
Okay. Without objection, we'll take up HB 1270. If the
▶ Play
committee remembers, thank you, Mr. Chair and committee, House Bill 1270 is about voting. And it's the one that I had seven words. Well, seven words wasn't near enough. So I've amended the bill. And at y'all's suggestion, it said shall proceed to. Now it says may, mark the ballot. And then, you know, at a voting booth, voting machine, or private voting place that allows the voter to mark the ballot in secrecy as he or she casts your vote. So it's just saying if you want to go sit at the big table and do that, you can. But there ought to be at least a place you can vote in private. If it just means there are sweetie boxes between you and the person beside you, it doesn't matter. It should be no expense. It's just providing a area for people to vote in private so nobody can see it. And obviously this is a problem in several places I've heard since this has been out here. So it's not saying spend a bunch of money or do anything. It's just take a card table and put it in the two corners, and there's private voting in those places. So that's actually all it says, and I'll be happy
▶ Play
answering questions. All right. Any questions from committee? All right. No questions from the committee, and nobody is here to sign up to speak for or against this bill? And you are recognized and closed for your bill. I'm closed, sir. All right. What's the will of the committee? We have a motion from Representative Saban to do pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? All right. Congratulations.
▶ Play
You passed your bill. Okay. So now I'd like to take up 1622, which had an amendment sent over here. Okay. All
▶ Play
right. We'll take up the amendment first on HB 1622.
▶ Play
And I'll give you a little history of the bill after I signed my name 100 times. Okay. Thank you. Uh, this was, uh, of course, the FOI bill for your bill that, uh, um, Plasty County brought it to me. Actually, we had it on a study, uh, interim study. And when we wrote this bill and we put it out there, well, of course, you know, you get called to the press association down there and you have to go meet with the press association and all the other third parties that are involved in it. And so we met. We had our meeting. The press association gave us this amendment. Basically, the wording in the amendment is from the press association. And so we amended to – we were going to – they had put a 45-day cap in there, and some of the third parties thought 45 days was too long, so we amended it to 15 business days. And I would like to introduce my two guests I have with me. We'll join us yourselves and who you're with. Yeah, if you would
▶ Play
Speaker 88 22:59
introduce yourself for the record. Certainly. Chastity Cypress, Pulaski County Attorney's Office.
▶ Play
Speaker 89 23:02
And Adam Fogelman, Pulaski County Attorney. Okay. And so
▶ Play
with that, I'm going to let them present basically what the amendment says or what they want to say about it. Okay. Right.
▶ Play
Speaker 88 23:12
We did meet with many stakeholders in trying to come up with a resolution for this bill. We've met with the press association. They made some suggestions. We agreed to those changes. We, again, met with some other stakeholders afterwards regarding bulk data requests, and I think this is an attempt to accommodate everyone. And at this point, we feel confident that we've met those requests and that there is no opposition at this point. Okay,
▶ Play
and so this is on the
▶ Play
Speaker 88 23:40
amendment itself? That is correct, and so we've amended it from a reasonable time to a 15-day period, 15 business days, and wrote in some language to accommodate an affirmative defense after that period.
▶ Play
Okay. All right. If there is, is there any questions for them on that? Okay. So you're recognized to close for your amendment. I'm closed for amendment. All right. So it's closed for amendment. What's the will of the committee? We have a motion from Representative Gray to adopt the amendment. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed?
▶ Play
Okay. So your, your amendment is adopted. Thank you. Now I'd
▶ Play
like to present bill 1622 as amended. You're
▶ Play
recognized to present bill 1622. Thank you, and and basically it's defining And and when we went to the meeting with the press association they told us we did a really good job of here And it's blaming what an overly burdensome FOI is so we have criteria we have to meet before we can get there and you also have if you send us an FOI Request we're going man. We can't do that in three days But we couldn't seven and we contact you and you agree to seven then everybody's happy and so there's no We are not trying to harm the three-day rule in any way, and that's what the Press Association wanted to make sure with their wording and their amendment that we didn't harm the three days. And so would you all like
▶ Play
Speaker 88 25:03
to add some stuff to her? Certainly, and happy to answer any questions that anyone may have. But basically this bill was born out of a need to allow for transparency but also allow for a little bit of leniency in order to allow elected officials to do the duties that they were elected to perform. and not incur unreasonable expenses regarding overtime or man hours in order to comply with FOIA requests that may be large or burdensome. So it was born of need, but I think we've been willing to compromise and come to an agreement regarding something that's acceptable for everyone. Okay. Are there any
▶ Play
questions from the committee? I do have one question. I've been contacted from folks in the title industry. My guess is that's maybe been the stakeholder that you all were talking about. And with the amendment of the 15-day instead of reasonable time, did that satisfy their concerns with
▶ Play
Speaker 88 25:56
that? That was one concern from bulk data collectors, which are those entities. And, yes, we agreed we worked with Bob Smith in order to come up with the 15-day language, but also they were agreeable to allowing us an affirmative defense on the backside. So I think it's a win-win for everyone. Yeah. I
▶ Play
mean, it's not typically a problem, But occasionally, in order to update your title plan or even to build a title plan, you're getting a lot of records. You are correct. All right. Any questions from the committee? You're recognized, Representative
▶ Play
Sabin, for a question. Is there anybody from the other side of the equation that's present in the committee room
▶ Play
that could testify to? We do. We've got a couple of people who are signing to speak against the bill. Thank you. Any other questions from the committee? All right. Seeing none, we do have individuals who are signed up to speak on the bill. The first one is Mr. Joey McCutcheon. Okay. It doesn't look like Mr. McCutcheon is no longer speaking on the bill. And then Mr. Tom Larimer. I'm sorry. I'm getting signals saying that Tom is not speaking. Is that what your signal is? Okay, he's neutral. Okay. Mr. McCutcheon, you're
▶ Play
recognized to speak on this bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And maybe this bill has been amended, but I'm here to talk about the three-day, the important three-day in which government bodies have to present records. And I want to start off by, I'm going to talk about the other bill, 373, today also. And this relates to this bill, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Sure, but Mr. McCutcheon, I would say keep it on this bill. Later on, we'll run 373.
▶ Play
At some point, you'll have a chance to speak on that. Absolutely. Absolutely. On March 3rd, 3,000 of last year, a nine-year-old boy was raped on an area agency van. And because of our strong FOIA laws, which Governor Rockefeller back in 1967 proposed and passed and signed, we were able to have not only records, but also a videotape. Later, an affidavit was taken which showed that this nine-year-old boy was not only forcibly required to give oral
▶ Play
Speaker 114 28:55
sex to an older boy.
▶ Play
Mr. McCutcheon, you may have to help me. How does this apply to the bulk data collection and the bill
▶ Play
as amended? Well, when was the bill amended? Just now. Just now. You know, it has to do with the people, because this is about the people. And this young nine-year-old boy was a person, and that's who this law is designed to protect, the people, not the government, the people. And because I was able to get those records within three days, we were able to protect the rights of this boy who was raped, and we were also able to get the video because of our strong FOIA laws. So, again, it's about the people. I mean, the people are here to speak today, but this bill has been amended, and I haven't even been able to see this bill on behalf of the people. And to me, that's disturbing. But I'm here to speak about the attacks on our freedom of information, particularly this subjective deadline. Is the subjective deadline passed now? can I ask a question? I'm sorry. It was. You know, I'm here today to speak after a tragic death of my wife last week. This bill means something to me. And for this bill to be amended this morning and and nobody had the chance to read it is a travesty. And that's that's one of the reasons that I'm here. Can you can you and we talk about a 15 day? I have no idea what we're referring to.
▶ Play
Mr. McCutcheon, I mean, and we all recognize your tragic loss, and that's a tough situation, but part of the committee process is that we come in and we do amend bills. So, I mean, this is only the first step of this bill. This still has to go on the floor and then has to go through a committee on the Senate end. I mean, that's part of the process is that we amend bills. And my hope is the amendment satisfies the Press Association, would satisfy a public transparency that we all ought to be concerned about. Well, okay, thank you. My concern
▶ Play
is, and I haven't had a chance to read this, but my concern is that it gives some kind of subjectivity to government bodies, whereas now we have a hard and fast three-day rule, which is the way it should be, that we, the people, should be able to get the records within three days. I haven't heard any testimony that there's ever been a problem with that. And when there is a problem, it's handled. It's handled through—because if these records aren't produced within three days, it's going to take us a little bit to get into court. And this bill is about the people, because this is not about the media. It's about everyday citizens. By the time they go out and hire a lawyer, if the claim is that there's an overly large or complicated request for public records, by the time they go out and hire a lawyer, spend multiple thousands of dollars to protect the rights that are here, it's it's an issue and so again it would be nice to be able to to see a bill before the committee but it looks like that this is subjective and looks like it gives the government the right to claim that something is overly complicated as opposed and now will place the burden upon citizens. Let me just briefly state what happens now in four-year requests, and that is a four-year request for records will be sent, and generally, the response will be that, number one, it's granted in full, and there is a release of the records. Sometimes, there's a grant in part or a release, and records are disclosed with the exempt portions. Thirdly, it could be denied entirely. Fourthly, the claim could be that the records are not in our possession, which, in fact, there's not going to be a criminal prosecution, and I'm wondering how many criminal prosecutions there have been. The other is to simply do nothing, which we've seen that with Ekklesia recently, that they just do nothing. They just blow off the period of time, which, in fact, then a lawsuit has to be filed. But if there is a voluminous request, it's very clear that what happens is that the government body will advise the requester within the three working days and give us time of how long it'll take to fulfill our request. And that's a workable solution. I'd like to see how many folks have been prosecuted. I haven't heard any of that testimony. Bottom line is, this is an anti-people bill. It's an anti-media bill. And I think it's sad when we're taking away the rights of the people and not protecting them. And I think that the bottom line is, with all these FOIA bills, that this administration is going to be known as the most secretive governing body in the history of our state. And with my Republican brothers and sisters who are now down here, I think that's a travesty. And I think the 10 bills, 57 parts of bills that destroy you, FOIA, is wrong, and it's anti-people. Thank you, sir.
▶ Play
It's Sergeant Doug Cunningham. Is he here? You're recognized to speak for HB 1622. If you don't mind with you to introduce yourself for the record. Sure. My name is Sergeant
▶ Play
Speaker 123 36:07
Doug Cunningham, Pulaski County Sheriff's Office. You are recognized. For nine years up until last year, I was a supervisor of the 911 center at Pulaski County Sheriff's Office. You're pretty much standard FOI request for, let's say, a 911 call, you want a copy of deputies recordings responding to one call is no problem getting that in three days what could be burdensome from us if we get here with an FOI that says I want a copy of all the 911 calls over the last three months because that's something we have to let them sit down and listen to basically live you know make sure we think we have to redact out we redact that out or if we get a copy of or an FOI that says I want a copy of all the you know deputies responding logs over a period of six months. It's just going to take time, and there's no way to get that done within three days.
▶ Play
Okay. We do have a question. Representative Dotson. You're recognized. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. So if you would, walk me through the process currently under current law. If that situation happens that you suggested where it's three or six months, a request comes in, and you have to listen to that live, and there's physically no way to get it done within three days. What happens at that point? Fortunately, I
▶ Play
Speaker 123 37:19
never actually had a situation for that long. I've had a federal case before I had to sit down and listen to over six hours. I was able to get that, you know, within the three days. If I ran across something like that, that's something I'd have to bring up, you know, with the sheriff, you know, and say, hey, you know, this is going to take definitely a lot more
▶ Play
than three days. It may take me 10, 15. Follow-up? You're recognized for a follow-up. So if it were to take 10 to 15 days or however much time it did take in an extended beyond that three-day time period, do you know what the process would be as far as, is there a current defense against violating that particular law? What I would do is notify
▶ Play
Speaker 123 38:07
whoever sent the FOI, it would take some time. Would that satisfy saying
▶ Play
that you're not held liable for not being able to physically get it done within that period of time currently? There's no defense. There's no defense. Okay. Thank you. Reverend Wardlaw,
▶ Play
do you still have a question? Okay. Any other questions from the committee? Representative Douglas, we recognize
▶ Play
for your question. So is there room in the law, this might be going to Representative Johnson for an appeals process, leave it at three days with an
▶ Play
Speaker 133 38:56
appeals process, Representative Johnson? Oh, I'm sorry. You're pointing.
▶ Play
I'm sorry. Well, I mean, what I'd say is that if this gentleman, if you have a question for him, let's get him out of the way, and then I'll let you ask
▶ Play
a question, Representative Johnson. Yes, if you could answer that. If not, then I would ask Representative Johnson. I
▶ Play
cannot answer that question. Okay. All right. Any other questions for this witness? All right. We sure appreciate you coming. Thank you. Thank you. All right. Representative Greenberg has signed up to, or Mr. I do that every time. I don't know why I do that. Mr. Greenberg, you are recognized to speak against 1622.
▶ Play
As I've noted before, I'm no longer representative. I'm a free man. You'd think I'd know that. So my name is Dan Greenberg. I'm a lawyer, and I run a nonprofit good government organization called the Advance Arkansas Institute. And it doesn't give me any pleasure to speak against a bill by Representative Johnson, who I served with before in the quorum court and whom I personally admire. But I just want to bring two small facts to this committee's attention. First, it's my opinion that the first part of this amendment where it says that there's no defense to prosecution if you can't comply with a FOIA request, I just think that's wrong. Impossibility is always a defense. If you have a duty to do something and you just can't do it, it's perfectly legitimate to argue in court. There's no possible way for me to do it, and if you can demonstrate impossibility, there's no way you're going to face any criminal offense. And I'd invite any of y'all, if you'll have any doubts about that, to call up the Bureau of Legislative Research and ask them if impossibility is an appropriate defense in this kind of action. And I certainly don't think that there's any instance in which anybody's ever faced criminal penalties for this sort of thing. I think there was one action brought for noncompliance with FOIA in my memory, and in that case, the jury wouldn't convict. And so I fear that this committee is being asked to create a solution where there's no real problem. And I would add, you know, the second point I want to make is that it appears to me that the dynamics of this change in FOIA law are basically this, that it allows public servants and public employees to make a decision kind of like this, which is that if I have anything better to do with my time, then I don't have to comply with this FOIA request. I'm allowed to place it at the bottom of my list of job duties, and those job duties could include reorganizing my office, you know, sweeping out the place. If I feel like I've got anything else I can do, then I can make a good faith choice to deprioritize this, and that in practice is a recipe for essentially delaying many FOIA requests long beyond what I would consider to be any reasonable limit. So I think I'm legitimately concerned that this really does weaken our FOIA law, and I think our FOIA law is more or less workable, and I think it helps the public, and I'd ask the committee to consider helping the FOIA to help
▶ Play
Speaker 143 42:00
the public, as it does now. Representative Wardlaw,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Greenberg, you and I spoke a few minutes ago. This FOIA law has been in effect since 1967. And how come now, almost 50 years later, or right at 50 years later, we're hearing this is a problem and not have addressed this before? And, I mean, is it because people are not complying with the three-day or need the extra time? You would think with the computer age, this could get easier to
▶ Play
comply with. I think as a general matter, we have a lot of resources that the government has already devoted to complying with FOIA requests. And I think public servants do a pretty darn good job of complying with FOIA requests right now. And that's a very important part of their job. and I hope you all permit that to continue. Does that speak to your question?
▶ Play
Any other questions from the committee? Representative Sabin, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and if it's all right, I might ask a couple in a row for your indulgence. Yeah, that's fine. No problem. Mr. Greenberg, in practice, normally the way FOIA is enforced is through sort of a civil action, a lawsuit by somebody who maybe thinks the FOIA hasn't been complied with in the correct way?
▶ Play
If somebody feels that the public servant or the government office hasn't complied with FOIA, then they got the option of finding a lawyer and suing. Yes, sir. Follow up, Mr. Chair. Yeah, you recognize. So, I mean, there's not like somebody
▶ Play
out patrolling this, that it really would be up to the person making the FOIA request to then, again, find a lawyer and sue? Yeah, it's supposed to be self-enforcing,
▶ Play
and it's not going to self-enforce very well if you have to write a check to a lawyer.
▶ Play
Yes, sir? Another follow-up? Yeah, and you're free. I'll let you
▶ Play
know when you've abused your discretion. These will be real quick in a row. So are you aware at all or have kind of a good guess at how often those kinds of lawsuits are filed on
▶ Play
FOIA? I mean, not often, pretty often. Well, you know, if you want to find out what your government's doing, it's free. And if you don't get satisfaction, then you have to write a check. And so not everybody's in the position when they can write a check. But I do think, I mean, I've certainly dealt with people anecdotally who are frustrated when they don't get what they see as sufficient compliance. And when I say, sure, just find a lawyer and write him a check for a couple hundred dollars and you can file suit, that's not the kind of self-enforcing system that
▶ Play
they're very fond of. You recognize? Yeah. So that's kind of where I'm heading with this. I'm just wondering if you feel like the burden is really more on the citizen or the taxpayer more than it really is on the entity which employs lawyers itself to actually ensure that FOIA is being complied with, and the idea that I know newspapers themselves oftentimes choose not to pursue legal action when their FOIAs have not been complied with simply because they don't have the
▶ Play
money to do it. Yeah, I fear that the average citizen is at a pretty serious disadvantage sometimes if they run into a government body which has a controversial or an unpleasant interpretation
▶ Play
of the FOIA. Sure. Any other questions from the committee? Mr. Greenberger, appreciate your testimony. Appreciate your time. All right. Nobody else in the audience has signed up to speak for or against this? Oh, I'm sorry. Yes. Stewart, Mr. Sofer, you're recognized. Speak
▶ Play
for 1622. Thank you. My name is Stewart Sofer. As a Jefferson County Election Commissioner, I am aware of FOIA. I'm aware of FOIA. I'm retired military, retired government service. I support FOIA. I'm an advocate of FOIA, but I have been on the receiving end of frivolous, intentional FOIA requests that I just couldn't possibly comply with. We received, I received a FOIA request from an attorney in Little Rock to a little-used Yahoo account demanding everything on my home personal computer to include communications with my wife relating to elections. And the request was received late in an afternoon on a Friday just by accident, three days after it was sent, where the prosecuting attorney, who was my attorney, cannot respond. And what I wanted to do was make a complete response, and I sent an interim. And even before my interim got to the person that did the FOIA, they had a lawsuit, criminal lawsuit, filed against me personally in Jefferson County Circuit Court. I gave them everything on my computer that was relevant. Now, I'm 75 years old. The grandbabies weren't there. Have you ever tried to take everything in your Outlook Express account and put it onto a CD or something? It's just not done easily. I am not doubting that we have some government entities that either do or will avoid a bona fide FOIA request. But I'm also sharing with you all that there's folks like me who are public servants, who are subject to FOIA, who don't have staffs, who don't have resources, that sometimes will need more than three days. Now, we had trial, ACLU got involved, it cost the county a lot of money, and essentially what the judge said, the judge recognized that these folks were just on the edge of their chair waiting to file the lawsuit. This is what folks like me need protection against. I agree with Mr. Greenberg that the public needs protection, but you've got a segment of the public, a segment of the people who just lay out there looking for excuses to drop a lawsuit or to burden a public servant. And that's all they want to do is harass. There was a subsequent lawsuit, excuse me, a subsequent FOIA request that in trying to completely reply, I managed to successfully delete everything in my Outlook Express account for the last 10 years, in the rush, the three-day rush. Sometimes the three days is just too darn soon, and I think folks like me need protection. I'll be happy to answer any questions. Any questions from the committee? I appreciate
▶ Play
your testimony, Mr. Sofer. Oh, I'm sorry. Mr. Sofer, if you don't mind answering the question, Representative Douglas, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Mr. Sofer, thank you. It sounds like from your explanation that you assume that your three days would start up on Friday and then you'd have Saturday, Sunday and have to turn it in Monday. But does the law say three business days or just three days? I honestly
▶ Play
don't know what the law says, Representative. But I do know that what happened was it was three business days since they sent it to the obscure Little U's Yahoo account that should have been deleted off of a website where they accessed it. Now, I will hasten to add they had. Okay, that answers
▶ Play
my question. And, you know, I don't know about that specific situation, but I didn't want to know whether the law needed to say business days. and I think we've looked it up, and it does say three working days.
▶ Play
If I may add one other thing. They had my SBC Global account. They finally sent it to my SBC Global account on the third working day after they sent it. So what I'm trying to say is you have these scrupulous individuals who will play games with the government entity just for the purpose of filing a lawsuit. Yes, I thank you. Yes, ma'am. Okay, seeing no
▶ Play
other questions, I appreciate your testimony. And there's nobody else who signed up to speak for or against Representative Johnson. You're recognized to close for your bill. I certainly
▶ Play
hope we can address a couple of these things real quick.
▶ Play
Well, you're recognized to try to do so. Thank you. The design of the bill is not to take away the three days. The three days remains to the extent that the resources of the office wouldn't be unreasonably diverted or unnecessarily diverted in order to make the response to the FOIA request. And a good example that we've experienced in Pulaski County was an individual who, in good faith, made a request for a week's worth of dispatch radio logs to the sheriff's office. And a week's worth of radio dispatch may not seem like much, but when you consider there are 22 dispatch channels, it calculates out to some 3,600 hours of audio that must be reviewed, redacted, and before being turned over. And those 3,600 hours are a difficult task to accomplish in only 72 working days. Thankfully, the requester in that situation, once they were explained, the volume, they backed away. But the state police wasn't so lucky in a case where they got sued over requests made for accident reports, which required the redaction of juvenile information. They weren't able, based on the staff that they had, to adequately respond to the requester's request within the three days. They got sued, and a circuit court here found that there was no defense, that they should have done better, even though they didn't have the resources to do better. So what we're trying to accomplish is not to take away the three days, but to recognize that in some instances, in rare instances, three days is simply insufficient without necessarily diverting the resources of the government body that's being requested to respond. And in a compromise, we've established a second deadline of 15 days, and if that can't be met based on the volume of records requested, there remains an affirmative defense. uh, that they have made a good faith effort to, to comply.
▶ Play
Thank you. Uh, appreciate it. Representative Johnson, you're recognized to close. All right. Thank you
▶ Play
very much. And, and just to, to go back, we wrote the bill. We went and met with the stakeholders, including the press association who I told them at that meeting, I do not want to harm the three day in the case of one accident or one specific event. I don't see any reason why that would never be within three days. And this is just dealing with super large, super big requests. And addressing 50 years, well, today things are different than they were 50 years ago. You have multitudes of records you would think it'd be easier, but people are requesting more and larger records that you're having to get. Some of them Some may be digitized, some may not, and so it can be overly burdensome. So we try to address specifically what is overly doodly burdensome request so that we know, and the people that are ministering the FOI, they know what they have to meet to even call and ask the people before that. So you've defined these things. We've negotiated with all the stakeholders. They seem to be okay with it. The Press Association, of course, they're not for it, but they are not opposing this legislation. And so I would appreciate a good vote. You look at Montgomery County, or some of these counties that have very few staff, you could shut them down where they can do nothing. And so I would appreciate a good vote.
▶ Play
Okay. What is the will of the committee? Okay, Mr. Johnson, I apologize, but your bill fails for lack of a motion. Thank you. Thank you, committee. Representative Shepard, you are recognized to present House Bill 2033. I'm rumored this should be a pretty easy one, so we're going to try to get him
▶ Play
out so he can get back to his committee. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. With the chairman's permission, I'd like Mr. Walter Anger, who's the Commissioner of Revenue with DF&A,
▶ Play
to join me at the end of the table. Absolutely.
▶ Play
If you don't mind introducing yourself for the record. Walter Anger, Commissioner of Revenue. Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, House Bill 2033 is a bill that the Chief Counsel of the Department of Finance Administration had asked me to carry. This basically brings DF&A into compliance with a federal requirement that is essentially If an individual is dealing with tax information, they're required to have a background check, and so we're simply bringing the law into compliance with the federal mandate, and Mr. Enger may have additional comments to that. No, he explained it really well. If we're
▶ Play
Speaker 176 56:47
handling federal tax information, then we're required to have background checks. Okay. Any questions from the committee?
▶ Play
All right. We know when signed up to speak for or against. Representative Eubanks, you have a motion. Okay, I have a motion due passed from Representative Eubanks. Any discussion on the motion? All right, all in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? Congratulations, Representative Shepard. You passed your bill. And could I say one thing? I believe
▶ Play
there may be another department that needs to be amended onto this, but I have not been able to track them down, so I want to go ahead and get it out. We may have to come back with an amendment later on, but I appreciate the committee's agreement to this bill. We'll try to accommodate when we do.
▶ Play
Representative Wardlaw, do you have something? Okay. Thank you so much. Okay. I know that Representative Dotson has somebody to speak towards a bill that you're working on. Are you prepared to run your bill? And do we have anybody else, any other legislators from other committees? Oh, I'm sorry. Representative Tucker and Representative. Okay. So we've got a bunch of really fun ones to deal with. So let me do this. I'm sorry, Representative Tucker. Let me get, I've visited with, represent, although I've visited with you too, but Representative Douglas, if you want to present your bill, if you're prepared to do so. You're recognized to present HB 1725. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Thank you, committee. and I guarantee you this one doesn't have anything to do with highways or tax increases today. It's just the opposite. Although I've had people say it's a power grab, it's trying to steal money, but it is nothing near that. The propaganda is rampant. This is an efficiency bill. This is to save the state money. This is to make government more efficient. It's a reorganization of the Department of Agriculture. Let me give a little brief history. In 2005, the Department of Agriculture was created. There were agencies that were put under the umbrella through a Top 1 transfer to the Department of Agriculture. The State Plant Board, the Livestock and Poultry Commission, and the Forestry Commission were all put under that umbrella. The legislative intent at the time was as personnel retired or left the service, there would be some combining of jobs. Well, as it all works out in government so many times, the intent is not what happened. So, we end up with three agencies there that each have their own HR department, each have their own procurement department, their own IT department, their own CFOs, and it's a duplication of services that is not needed. the governor has set forth a principle of trying to make government more efficient more responsive to the people and that's what this bill does through a process that was started over six months ago meeting with the agriculture department and senator caldwell and myself We started working on this. We then started bringing in the different affected stakeholders. We brought in Farm Bureau. We brought in the Ag Council. We brought in the Poultry Federation, the Cattlemen's Association, the Conservation Districts. We tried to be inclusive to get their input, and we listened to them, and we made changes in the bill. We made multiple changes in multiple meetings, and we came up with this bill. Let me explain what House Bill 1725 does. If you look on page one, it states in the first section, section one says do not codify. it transfers all these boards and all these agencies under the Arkansas Department of Agriculture. Then if you look on page two, you will see in section B, line one on page two, The boards, commissions, or other governing bodies of these agencies retain their current statutory power, their current rulemaking authority. So nothing changes on the power of the boards and commissions. If you look on down to line 8 on page 2, section C, number 1, this states that the boards and commissions are nominated. They are approved in the same manner they have always been. Down on line 23, Section D, it states that all records, personal property, and unexpended balances are transferred to the Department of Agriculture, and that is true. This is where one of those rumors or one of those conspiracy theories comes out that, oh, it's all about the money. They're trying to steal the plant board's money. They're trying to steal livestock and poultry's money. Well, the truth of the matter is the vast majority of the funds, I don't know the exact percentages, 90-95% of the funds are not general revenue, they are special revenue. They are dictated by statute that they are collected from fees. For example, the fees on fertilizer sales, there's a fee there that goes to run the soil test diagnostic laboratory. That money can only be used for the purpose set forth in statutes. It cannot be stolen and used for other purposes. For example, the brucellosis fund money cannot be used to fund the boll weevil program. doesn't work that way. There's statutes that states how the money is used, but what it does do, there are some equipment, say for example, if the plant board had 10 cars there not being used and livestock and poultry needed one for a day or two, currently they can't share, they can't use each other's cars, but now they could. It's called efficiency, making use of what you have. The next Section E goes on to state again that the boards and commissioners and the directors are appointed in the same manner that they have always been right down on page 2 section F this is some language that we amended the bill after one of our meetings there was some concern that it was all about the money and it just states out what is in current statute that all revenues including cash funds special revenues so on and so forth held in the accounts being transferred, including unexpended balances, can only be used for the purposes for which the revenue was collected as provided by law. So it's not a money grab. There's no way you can use it. That's the bill. That's what the bill does. Currently, according to the Secretary of Agriculture, we're looking to save money. We're looking to make the agency more efficient, make government more efficient. With that, I would like to ask Secretary of Agriculture Wes Ward to come forward and see if he's got any comments that I've left out here. Mr. Secretary? Mr. Secretary, if you don't mind introducing
▶ Play
yourself for the record. Yes, sir. Thank you,
▶ Play
sir, and thank you for members of the committee. My name is Wes Ward. I'm the Secretary of Agriculture for the Arkansas Agriculture Department, and I want to thank Representative Douglas for all of his hard work on this bill, and most of what he said, I'm just going to echo, and I'll try not to repeat myself or repeat what he has said too much. But I do want to say that there is a history with the department. Agriculture is our state's largest industry, but we didn't have an agriculture department until 2005. We are literally one of the youngest ag departments in the country. And to that end, 2005, when the ag department was created, it created through a top one transfer, brought over the plant board, the livestock and poultry commission, the forestry commission under the agriculture department umbrella. So since then, since 2005, both of my predecessors, Secretary Dick Bell and Secretary Butch Calhoun, both took efforts that they could, as much as they could, to try to move the department forward, to try to get the department operating as one unit, really an effort to try to make the Arkansas Agriculture Department mirror USDA and how they're set up and how they function. So both of my predecessors took the actions that they could to move forward. When I started in March of 2015, we continued that trend, and one of the first things we started doing was started the consolidation of the fiscal and HR staff, which we were required to do by Arkansas statute, but had not yet been done. Moving further, we worked, of course, with the governor's office and legislators and other organizations trying to find ways that we could increase our efficiencies. I learned very early on in the Marine Corps that you have always got to be looking for ways to improve. And I think that is true, not just from the military standpoint or a personal standpoint, but a business standpoint, a state agency standpoint. The day that we stopped looking for better ways of doing things, we're failing. The Ag Department exists to support the agriculture industry of Arkansas, and if we're not constantly trying to find better ways of doing things, we failed. We have failed the industry and we have failed the people that are putting money into special revenues and people that were using general revenues from all taxpayers. We have failed all of those. So continuation from there, December 2015, the governor directed every state agency to work with the policy foundation to help identify ways that we can increase our efficiencies in state government. Through that process, we've already identified over $600,000 in savings per year, and those are very simple, what I would call low-hanging fruit areas that really just make the Ag Department, saves money and helps the Ag Department work better. That includes simple things as phone systems. Currently, we're operating under multiple phone systems, even within the same building, multiple email servers within the same building, vehicles, as Representative Douglas mentioned, IT personnel are separate and they're all doing separate things. Across the board, every single one of these, everybody does their own thing. So when you look at our entire list of efficiencies of what we've identified of ways that we can better operate, every one of those have to do with personnel and property. And that really is the gist of this top four transfer. These agencies are already part of the Ag Department when it was created by that top one transfer in 2005, but to move forward, the top four transfer provides that better clarity and allows for the better management of those personnel and property so that the plant board isn't using a technology system that's completely separate from the Livestock and Poultry Commission and all the way around. One last thing I do want to point out on the efficiency side, it's not just, there are certainly some simple low-hanging fruit areas that are easy things that we can fix pretty quick, but it expands beyond that and expands to the agriculture industry itself, to areas such as high-path-aven influenza. And I know I saw former State Representative Nate Bell here earlier in a conversation we had had many times. You look at the poultry industry of Arkansas and its impact on our state. About 46 and a half, 47 percent of our state's cash receipts come from poultry. High-path-aven influenza, 2015, we were lucky we had one incident, which our Livestock and Poultry Commission responded to. They will very quickly tell you that if that had been more than one incident, we would have not had the personnel with Livestock and Poultry Commission to respond to that incident. That incident is what USDA calls the largest animal health outbreak in the United States ever. And we had one incident in Arkansas. We're very fortunate. The downside of that is that if we got hit with more than one incident, we would have had Livestock and Poultry Commission personnel responding to that incident, but we would have also had Forestry Commission district personnel right down the road. We would have had plant board inspectors right down the road, all part of one department, but unable to help each other out, unable to use the full weight of our personnel and resources to combat an issue that if we get hit as bad as Iowa did with 77 farms, our state would feel that economic impact. Agriculture is a $20 billion economic impact. We have got to be able to use the full weight of our personnel and resources to respond when emergencies right. So moving past that, that's really what the intent of the bill is for, what the top four transfer was for. But let me also say and echo what Representative Douglas said about what this bill doesn't do. It doesn't change the boards and commissions. They still have their full statutory authority, the regulatory authority. Those decisions will still be made by those boards and commissions. Their roles won't change. There's not an extra layer of bureaucracy. As I've said, these agencies already existed as part of the Ag Department since 2005. The directors will still be elected and nominated and appointed by the government in the same process that they have been. And as Representative Douglas said, the funds won't change. Those funds, as we've gotten in the language of the bill, still have to be used in the purposes that they were collected for and in accordance with the law. That's something that I hope people will actually read the bill and read the language and let facts and logic prevail. At the end of the day, I just want to stress again that agriculture is our state's largest industry, $20 billion economic impact. Our agriculture industry deserves the most efficient and productive ag department that we can possibly have. We would all agree, I believe, that we can get more done. We're stronger, we're better when we all work together as opposed to separately and independent of each other, and that's what this is intended to do. I want to say to close by saying thank you for letting me speak in favor of the bill, and would also like to add that this isn't a new thing that's just coming for me or for Governor Hutchison. Certainly he has the priorities for efficiency in state government, but as I mentioned, this is something that Secretary Dick Bell and Secretary Butch Calhoun were taking steps to accomplish. I have with me today a letter from my predecessor, Secretary Butch Calhoun, in support of the bill, in support of what we're trying to accomplish. So I have a copy of that for any member that would like to see that. But again, we'd just like to say thank you for the opportunity to speak in favor of it.
▶ Play
Thank you. All right. Any questions? Representative Leidyman, I know we have you, and
▶ Play
then Representative Hendren will get you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Secretary Ward, I just had a question or a thought. When you talked about efficiencies and improving efficiencies, and I totally agree with that, Do you have any comparison data to other states, like these commissions and boards that you are talking about moving? Does that put you in line with other states? Do other states do it that way? And then also, do you have any cost data that shows how we might stack up in Arkansas compared to
▶ Play
other agriculture states? I think I can generally answer that question, but probably not as specifically as what you would like. I would say the majority of states are structured that way, more in line with USDA. Very few of them have separate and independent state agencies under an ag department that they don't work together. Generally, across the country, the ag departments work as one team, not as four separate and independent state agencies. So I would say the vast majority, I just don't have the number, operate as one unit. To the cost savings of the comparison of that, I could only speak to the $600,000 in savings that we've already identified that we'll be able to accomplish per year through operating as one unit. How that compares to other states, I don't have a good figure to give you on that.
▶ Play
Representative Hendren, you are recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I notice here on our list, on most of our bills, if we save money or spend money, we request and require financial impact statements. And I see none on the document here today. And so I guess there's not. And I know Representative Douglas, as you began, you said this is an efficiency bill, and I can understand that. However, I didn't hear it until Mr. Ward came and began to testify a dollar figure. And I think you mentioned $600,000 a year, and I guess we're moving seven agencies as I count this over into this deal. And so the question I'd have is, how much do we save? And you've said $600,000, and I'd say, is there more than that? And to follow that question up, yesterday, we got into real trouble yesterday afternoon because we were trying to find $250 million. And I guess my question is, if we're going to save $600,000, which the figure used, and I'd hope it'd be that much, by less telephone systems and offices and so forth, can we take that $600,000, put it back into the general revenue, and help Representative Douglas with his bill to raise $250 million? Now, that's a little bit of a joke, but it's quite a serious question because that can be replicated across state government. And when you bring a bill that says we're going to be more efficient, why don't we take that money that we're going to save and not raise the taxes on people for other things? So the $600,000, what are you going to do with it?
▶ Play
Representative Hendren, that would be great. And if there's general revenue money, like I said before, the majority of these agencies' money is special revenue. There's very little general revenue. If there is general revenue savings, that could be a possibility. But the thing is, with special revenue, such as the fees on fertilizer that are charged to operate the soil testing laboratory, are special revenue. The only thing you can do with that is spend it on what it was intended for in the statute, or, and here is the good or, or reduce the fees that you charge to the producers and the individuals that are paying the fees in. And that's what we ought to be doing with some of this stuff. Leave it back in the pocket of the producers out there. Anything else you want to add,
▶ Play
Speaker 192 1:17:32
Secretary? Follow-up, please, sir. Do you
▶ Play
have a follow-up? Yes, you're recognized for follow-up, Representative Hendren.
▶ Play
I think you make a good point. Does that mean that you plan to follow with a bill to reduce the fees of $600,000 that you're going
▶ Play
to save if we pass this bill? I think it's something that we've got to look at. I think that there is, as you look at, as I mentioned, we have an emergency response capability, so there has to be a reserve balance of some sort to be able to respond to how pathogen influence or wildfires or any other disaster that could occur. But it is worth looking at, you know, how long has it been since we've looked at our fees and said, okay, this is the right fee amount, and that's across the board. We just, just this morning, sir, we sat through House Ag Committee meeting with another representative of Douglas' bill, went through a Livestock and Poultry Commission statutes and were able to eliminate 52 percent of them because they were old, archaic, and hadn't been used. Our next step with Livestock and Poultry is to go through our regulatory process and say, are our regulations correct? Are the fees correct? Are they where they need to be? I would say that's something that's needed, not just in the Ag Department, but probably
▶ Play
for every agency. So fees and tax cuts are
▶ Play
coming. Thank you, sir. Okay, Representative Wardlaw,
▶ Play
you recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Secretary, can you tell me what the mission is going forward, and is there a push here to move promotional and research, better known as a checkoffs, back under the Department of Ag as well, or what's the future
▶ Play
of this? Yes, sir. So the future of the Ag Department is really just to operate as one cohesive single unit. Livestock and Poultry Commission, Plant Board and Forestry Commission, all working together as one team as opposed to separate and independent of each other. This bill, if you look at the Arkansas Code that created the Arkansas Ag Department, specifically says that this bill, the Arkansas Agriculture Department, has zero impact. It does not change any of the research and commodity boards. There's six of them in Arkansas. This has nothing to do with those research and promotion boards, purely with the programs of the Plant Board, Livestock and Poetry Commission, and Forestry Commission. You're recognized for a follow-up. I totally
▶ Play
agree with you on that, but is there a future push to bring all
▶ Play
that back under the Department of
▶ Play
Ag? No, sir. Thank you. Representative Douglas, you're recognized for a question. Yes. Just in an overview of what we're doing here, we've had several bills come before us that try to, you know, that are combining agencies, and we keep hearing that this is the tone of this administration to bring efficiencies to state government. So, does this align with, you know, what we're seeing with other bills that are bringing these efficiencies as we, you know, combined agencies. If I might, Representative Douglas, sounds like I'm talking to myself. Yeah. I might ask Ms. Amy Fetcher to come down here and join us with the governor's Department of Efficiency. Ms. Amy? Ms. Fetcher, if you don't
▶ Play
mind introducing yourself for the record, you'll be recognized.
▶ Play
And for the record, I always try to get a good-looking woman
▶ Play
sitting beside me. Gosh. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is Amy Fetcher with the Governor's Office
▶ Play
of Transformation. Representative Douglas? Do I need to repeat that? I'm sorry. If you'd repeat your question. Yes. We're just seeing a lot of efforts to combine agencies, and we're hearing that that's going to bring great efficiency and cost-saving. and it looks like this is an overall theme for this legislative system, and I wanted to hear if this is in line with the governor's push to bring us
▶ Play
these efficiencies. Yes, thank you. This is very aligned with the governor's approach to state government. Through the administration since 2015 when he took office, there have been eight agency mergers or transfers, very similar to this, One that I can speak to personally is when AEDC took on Rural Services and the Science and Technology Authority. And to repeat what Representative Douglas and Secretary Ward have said, what we did there was we had three different commissions that are still intact today. It was the same fear then that they would be dissolved and not have any authority anymore. We've had $1.5 million in savings that we have turned back to the state since that merger. But what the governor feels very strongly about is that there's no staff that lost a job during that merger. They may have been reassigned to another area at the same pay rate they were making when they came on. So this is aligned with the governor's mission for finding efficiencies as we go forward, reducing silos in state government and finding savings and duplications of processes and bringing these agencies together. Thank you. Thank you very much. Okay. Representative Hendren, you're
▶ Play
right, can I answer your question?
▶ Play
Just a real quick one. I did some math here right quick, and it looks like to me with what you just said and what Mr. Ward just said and the other representative Douglas just said, we have found $2.3 million here today in savings in the last 30 minutes. That's $150,000 you just said, right? $1.5 million. How much? But that's already been turned back to the state. $1.5 million plus $800,000 is $2.3 million, right? Let's all say hallelujah.
▶ Play
Speaker 210 1:23:50
I find that's good government, don't you, Representative Henry? Put it in your bill, and we'll pass your highway program. All right. Any
▶ Play
other members have questions? Okay. Seeing none, we do have several people signed up to speak on this bill. So if you all don't mind making some room at the end of the table. Let me just say this for the purposes we are talking about efficiency. For the purposes of efficiency, we do have seven people who are signed up to speak against that bill. And what I would just say is that if what you have to say has already been said, would you would you just make sure that you keep it keep it short and I have people who are anxious to I'll wait to hear your motion so that's a good illustration I have people who are anxious to make a motion on this already I don't want to cut it off if we need to so just want to say that just keep it as short as possible and someone already said what you have to say just just let us know that all right so Ray Vester I'm not going to hear that motion yet So let's see how quickly we can get through this.
▶ Play
So I'm Ray Vester, a rice farmer from Stuttgart, Arkansas. I've had the privilege to sit on the State Plant Board for 18 years as a rice representative. I come to speak today in opposition to this bill. I want to thank Mr. Chairman and this committee for allowing me to be here today to speak to you. I have two specific areas in that bill I'm opposed to, and that's the type four transfer and the portion that talks about declaring an emergency. Type four transfers I've discovered through much talk to congressmen, more than one, and getting the explanation of that from a website, a Type 4 transfer transfers the money, and in this case it would be from the plant board into the hands of the Department of Ag. But if you read that bill, the only person who has authority to spend that is the officer in charge of the division that has it transferred in, and that's a big concern for me. The site plant board is 100 years old. It has faithfully served this state for 100 years, growing and expanding. It's not on its own by the fact that the state has brought to it other things they need them to do. This year, the budget of the state plant board is $10 million. Each year, each year, the plant board is appropriated $500,000. That's the only tax dollars we get. The rest of it is from fees and, let me see, seed inspections, licensing, permits, training, and such as that. We cover seed, fertilizer, chemicals, pest control, which is the termite people. We cover Bureau of Standards, and it goes on and on. That's funds that come into it from chemical companies who bring chemicals into the state to be approved. We also approve any chemical that's used in anybody's yard or in their home, and we train those people who apply it, and we license those people. So when you look at our impact to the state in cost, it's $500,000 a year. And the governor said we have 3 million people in the state. Well if that's the case, then the tax cost to the people to run the state plant board is 17 cents a person if you divide 500,000 by 3 million. The total cost of our budget is $3.33 per citizen of this state. The plant board and its fees and collections covers $3.16 of that, which is the 95% coverage without tax dollars. A little history of the plant board. In 1970, there was a black phy incident in southwestern Arkansas and Miller County. Black phy's were destroying the livestock herds. Plant board went in, took care of the problem, eradicated the black phy's, and set everything back to equal places. There were no funds appropriated. The plant board covered the funds in their fee system. And they weren't getting $500,000 a year from the state back in 1970. That's 40-plus years ago. In 1980, there was a gypsy moth outbreak in North Arkansas. Some of you may remember it. It destroyed thousands of acres of timber. The plant board had people in place up there, began the investigation immediately, and discovered that they could be stopped. They stopped that problem. In 1996, the plant board was still monitoring that, and by that time, the problem was over. State plant board took care of that. In 2006, there was a GMO problem with seed rice. Bayer Chemical Company had got their GMO rice mixed in with our seed. The plant board, in a heated debate because it pitted farmers against seed dealers who were going to lose money, but it was a tie vote. The chairman broke the tie, and the two seed varieties that were infected were banned by the state. And our standing in the rest of the country, the six rice states, once we did that, followed AFIS, which is a sampling group and regulatory group with the U.S. government, said we couldn't clean up the GMO problem. It would be impossible. The third year after we voted to stop selling that seed, we found no seed rice in the state infected with GMO seed. It was accomplished in two years. It was not paid for by tax dollars. It was not any tax money used. It was the farmers and the seed dealers who paid that price. The boll weevil eradication program, which has made this state free of boll weevils. We still monitor along the Mississippi River because Tennessee hasn't accomplished that yet, and we still monitor along the Texas line because the great state of Texas who can do anything hasn't accomplished it yet. All those monies that it took to accomplish that were paid for by farmers, it was administrated by the plant board, and the plant board provided the seed money to get it started. So that's our history of involvement. The other thing I have an issue with today is the emergency clause. In the plant board, an emergency clause is given, they have the authority if there is a disaster in effect that we have to attack and we have to move quickly. And by the way, we can't do anything without a public hearing, and a public hearing takes 120 days to accomplish. And once we have that public hearing, if the majority approve it, then the plant board once again votes to make that the regulation. But then the governor has the opportunity to decline that. To the governor, if he approves it, it goes to the Legislative Council or to the legislature to approve. We don't run free and wild. We take care of things as they should be taken care of. But with an emergency clause, I fear the only reason that was placed in, during the year last year, we banned a chemical from the state of Arkansas that was never independently tested as far as its ability or how dangerous it was. What tests we had showed that it was very volatile. It would destroy a lot of soybeans in the state, a lot of cotton that didn't have the GMO gene in it to protect it from dicamba. The state of Missouri didn't do that. They have a plant board or a regulatory agency very similar to the one that we're trying to develop here, not what we have here. The state of Missouri had destroyed a 900-acre peach farm, peach orchard, and now there's a huge lawsuit because nobody could do anything about it because the plant board, or what we call our plant board had no authority because you see it had moved from an independent agency funded by industry to an agency controlled by the governor of the state and when that happens you move from a agency that makes decisions on sound science instead of political science and that's what I fear here but this emergency clause if this bill passes and gets through the senate But when the governor signs it, the governor will be immediately able to call Monsanto and says, bring your chemical into the state. We need it. And let me tell you what will happen that day. If it comes into this state in time to be used this spring on soybeans, there will be devastation in the farmland. Ask the people in Missouri that lost several hundred thousand acres of soybeans because of the illegal spraying of that very chemical. In this state, last year, we had a lot of soybeans, probably as many as 50,000 acres, significantly damaged from dicamba that was sprayed illegally in the state. And it also went to the point that neighbors were in arguments with neighbors, and I don't know if you know about it, but a man was actually murdered by a Missouri farmer's employee because the neighbor came to complain about it. That's the reason that chemical was banned. That's the reason the governor didn't block that banding of that chemical. But there's great pressure in this state on the governor to bring that chemical into this state. And that's why that emergency clause is there. That's the only reason. I probably talked enough. Other people want to talk. Do you have any questions? Representative Hamer, do you still have a question? Okay.
▶ Play
One thing I want to say is that we are kind of pressed for time, and I'm about ready to take a motion to limit it. And if the members will remember that as well.
▶ Play
Representative Hamer, you're recognized for a question. Real quick question. I was like that $600,000 I thought we'd saved a while ago, and they had told, I'd understood up to now, Representative Douglas, that all this thing does is to put these fellows over in this other department, and you still had the same authority you didn't have before. Are you saying that's incorrect, and we
▶ Play
can't have the $600,000? No, I don't know. I tell you what we can have. The plant board, we've talked in the plant board, by the way, I'm not on the plant board anymore, But we've talked in the plant board that if that's needed, you can take the $500,000 from the plant board because we can fund our own sales from the industry in the state. And we will be in 18 months from now when you're running for reelection, you can say, look, this is what the plant board does, and they're getting zero tax dollars. And I believe that's a truthful thing. But in case there is an emergency like the avian flu or whatever, those funds are sitting there to be used in that situation. Our biggest concern is you can grant us all the power and authority you want to have, but if you don't have your money to take care of it, you have no authority. And once that money is moved from the possession of the state plant board, we may never see it again. disappear into that black hole of the state treasury.
▶ Play
I appreciate your testimony today. Thank you. All right. I kind of regret not taking the motion of Representative Douglas earlier. Representative Gray, for what purpose? A motion to limit debate. Okay. I'll hear your motion. I'd like
▶ Play
to make a motion to limit debate to five minutes per side with Representative Douglas to be given additional time
▶ Play
to close. Okay. You've heard the motion. Any discussion on the motion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. And opposed? Okay, your motion has passed. And, you know, one of the things is that, you know, I'm going to let you guys manage that, but, you know, one of the things is that the more time that you take, the less time someone else has to speak. So, and I apologize, but we do have people who have to do business in another committee, and we've got to get this done today. So, the next on the list to speak for is Mr. Wes Higginbotham from the Ag Council. If you don't mind introducing yourself for the record,
▶ Play
then you're recognized. WES HIGGINBOTHAM. Good morning, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. My name is Wes Higginbotham. I'm a farmer for Mariana, and I'm the current president of the Arkansas Agricultural Council. The Ag Council is a trade organization representing farmers, landowners, and agribusinesses across the state, and I'm here today to speak in favor of the measure under consideration by the committee. The aspects of the bill most important to the Ag Committee are the following. The plant board will continue to keep its independence as a board in regulations, rule making and enforcement. The plant board will continue to represent the industry and there will be no changes to the makeup or process of appointment to the board. The plant board will continue to recommend persons to serve as director of the plant board. The bill does not affect the plant act in any way and the bill ensures collections. The plant board will remain and be utilized by the plant board. The Ag Council will oppose any effort to use funds collected except for those purposes which they are collected for. The legislation limits the Secretary's rulemaking authority to marketing, promotion, and education, and the bill allows for better transparency on funding and budgets, which is also good government. It's the Ag Council's hope that the bill will allow for better synergies among the agencies within the Department of Agriculture, reduce duplication, and allow the Department to efficiently serve our state's top industry. I'll answer any questions. The committee may have. Okay. Seeing no
▶ Play
questions, I appreciate your testimony. Thank you. Okay. Next on the list to speak against is Mr. Terry Fuller. If you don't mind introducing yourself for the record, and just remember we are limited to five minutes per
▶ Play
Speaker 225 1:39:09
side. Terry Fuller, farmer from East Arkansas. I'd like to speak against this bill, but I'd like to defer to my side to let give up some other guys some more time. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you for committee, for hearing us today. Thank you, Representative Douglas, for presenting this bill to us. I appreciate
▶ Play
your courtesy. Speaking for the bill is Mr. Marvin Childress, if you don't mind introducing yourself for the record.
▶ Play
Speaker 226 1:39:43
you're recognized thank you mr. chairman i'm marvin children's i'm president of the poultry federation i'll be as brief as i possibly can i think what you need to hear is uh we are proud to be members of the livestock and poultry uh commission and we've been partners for over 50 years with the Cattlemen Association and the pork producers. So think for just a minute if you would how ridiculous it would be if we came in here and said we want our own poultry commission, the cattle guys want their own commission, and the pork guys want theirs, and we want our own buildings, we want our own vehicles, and our own employees. You would think we'd lost our mind, And you should. What this bill does is provide efficiencies with people, assets, and
▶ Play
Speaker 45 1:40:40
allows the state to save money. I'll be glad to take any questions.
▶ Play
We have one question. Representative Hammer, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you. I've got a bill up in my desk drawer. I wish I would have went ahead and filed after hearing this discussion because it would have required the boards and commissions in the agricultural field and others because they're carrying quite hefty cash balances, and it would have required them to limit three years worth of budget. So I'm just curious, is this going to, if we go through with this, is it not going to also help cut the fees to the people that are being charged for these individual agencies that are represented in this move and puts money back in their pockets?
▶ Play
Speaker 226 1:41:17
Representative Hammer, that's a great question, and as you know, you control the budget strings of members sitting around this table, and when it comes to appropriation, You'll have that prerogative. But there's no doubt that if the livestock and poultry funds are excessive, then sure, we could reduce fees to the producers. Mr.
▶ Play
Chairman, that total on that sheet was $54 million between 23 agencies that we could have returned money back to the citizens by putting a three-year cap on their budgets and requiring them to return. I wish to God I would have ran it. Thank
▶ Play
you. Okay, any other questions from the committee? Thank you. All right, see you now. I appreciate your testimony. Okay, Nick signed up to speak against is Mr. Wendell Stratton, if you don't mind introducing yourself for the record, and
▶ Play
Speaker 230 1:42:20
you're recognized. Sure. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and committee members. you for the opportunity to share a few minutes with you this morning. I'm Wendell Stratton, manager of our 69-year-old family-owned seed production, marketing, and processing company in Studgard. We also furnish crop protection, fertilizers, and consultant services to our farmer customers. I have worked in our business 47 years. I have managed our business for the past 36 years. And I'm fully qualified to sit here today in front of you and speak to this issue with knowledge and conviction of House Bill 1725. I'm not a politician. I'm a businessman and a farmer. I don't have a paid lobbyist here to represent me and speak for our interest. I'm here representing my peers in this industry. I'm not on the plant board, so I can freely say what I think without having to worry about being reappointed by the governor. Our business is associated with five separate plant board positions. That is Arkansas seed growers, Arkansas seed dealers, the Arkansas Plant Food Association, the Arkansas Crop Protection Association, and the Errol Applicators Association. Now, I appreciate some of the comments made earlier about reaching out to industry, but But I can assure you that in this process, none of our industries were included in that process. They mentioned Farm Bureau and mentioned a couple of others organizations, but it did not include industry. Industry is the one that is supplying the funds that fund this whole organization. We are totally in support of the plant board as it stands. Our plant board is recognized nationally for the professionalism and technical expertise it has in dealing with ag issues. It has done so for 100 years, and it's imperative that it continues to work freely without additional political influence. I spoke in opposition in 05 to the creation of a Department of Agriculture as I envisioned something like this happen. Who would have thought, 12 years later, here we are, coming back, trying to take more control of the best ag regulatory agency in the nation. Other states look at what we do and the way we do it. They respect us, and basically, in most cases, they follow our lead. The thing that upsets me in this case is under the current administration has wrongly taken control of many of the Arkansas State Plant Board functions without the authority to do so. Please listen to what I said. This administration has overstepped their authority under the law in the Department of Ag and needs this bill to cover what they're already doing. This bill gives them the authority and more as the state will then not only control the functions of the plant board, will have jurisdiction of the surplus funds that are needed when an emergency situation arises. The industry has provided these surplus funds and is dead wrong for the state to take these funds. As a matter of information, our company supplied right at $88,000 last year in fees and license and training and things through the Arkansas State Plant Board. It's a great investment in agriculture in our state, and we have no problem with that. But our funds and our contributions need to be left alone. Now, we are told that amendments are coming that will keep these amendments in place. That's fine. But Representative Douglas, I would ask, I have been told that you said you will not move from a Title IV to a Title I, that that's a no-brainer. So if in fact that's true, then why don't you allow it to stay as a title one? So we don't have to worry about the secretary of ag or the governor at some point taking control of these funds. We have had some great directors on the plant board in the past that I'm sure would be appalled to learn of the governor's attempt to control this agency. The plant board has a history of acting quickly when the need arises and has served ag industries in our state well for over 100 years, plant board employees need the freedom to operate without another level level of political influence that does not have the experience. This bill is not about saving money. It's all about control. But let's talk about money a minute, because that's been brought up several times already this morning. In 05, the initial the initial budget for the Department of Ag was $300,000 in a mid in visit with West Ward in January. Mr. Stratton, I'm sorry,
▶ Play
you have used all the time to speak against this bill. Can
▶ Play
Speaker 163 1:47:37
I make one comment, please? I will, without objection, allow you to make one comment, but please keep it short. Thank you. The
▶ Play
Speaker 230 1:47:43
current budget for the Department of Ag is $1.9 million. The initial budget was $300,000. There's your tax savings. And what has this Department of ag given this state other than another level of government and bureaucracy. There's your cost savings. Yeah, Mr. Stratton, I
▶ Play
apologize to Mr. Johnson that you didn't have an opportunity to have your voice heard. There is nobody else to sign up to speak for the bill. Representative Douglas, you are recognized to close for your bill. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. There's always controversy whenever you go to change, you know, there are several comments made. The plant board has done a great job, the livestock and poultry commission has done a great job, the forestry commission's done a great job, and why have they done a great job? Because of the makeup of the boards and commissions that do the rulemaking and regulatory authority, and they are industry driven. That's why they're good. That's why they're some of the best in the nation, and under this bill, that will not change. They will be appointed the same way. They'll have the same authority they did have before. We've explained the money. The special revenues come from statutory fees, and maybe there does need to be a little bit more oversight, because why is the plant board sitting on $10 million in reserves? Why is the Livestock and Poultry Commission setting on $7 million in reserves? Maybe some of those fees need to be lowered and more cost savings that could be done or spent on upgrading the laboratories or doing other good things. They've done a good job in the past, but we can do better. Four of the biggest fears to man are dying, conspiracy theories, change, and that's what this is. It's a little bit of change, and people are scared of change because you don't know what's going to happen. Under this, you do know what's going to happen because it's spelled out what can and what cannot happen and what can change and what cannot change. The fourth thing that man fears is a mad wife. But with that, I would appreciate a good vote, and thank you, committee, for your indulgence. Thank you. Representative Dotson, you have a
▶ Play
motion? Motion do pass. Okay, we have a motion do pass on the table. Any discussion on that motion? Okay, the motion is do pass. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. The ayes have it. Congratulations, Representative Douglas. You passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Sheriff. Thank you, committee. Thank you. Representative Tucker, do you want to wait or are you ready to do it? OK.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:51:09
Representative Tucker, you are recognized as
▶ Play
1,008. Is that right? Five. Five. 1,005. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This is the same
▶ Play
Speaker 239 1:51:22
bill number that I ran last week, but it's a vastly different bill for the committee. The bill attempted to address two separate matters of campaign finance transparency. One was about disclosure and one was about coordination. Disclosure is what we primarily discussed last week. The disclosure part is now out of the bill entirely. It's all about coordination. And I followed a, I see the former chair of this committee walking in the room now and he can testify to this, but I followed a similar path last year. I put both parts in the same bill in the last session two years ago. The disclosure part caused heartburn. I took it out and then I was able to pass the coordination part out and out of the House and the legislators down on the south side of the building had problems with it. So what this does is there's no disclosure left in the bill. This is about coordination between candidates and third-party groups. As I mentioned the other day, about half the states had passed laws about the disclosure, and we're virtually the only state that's left that does not have some rulemaking about coordination between candidates and third-party groups. And so that's what this seeks to address. The loophole here is primarily with a contribution limit. If, let's just say the issue is that someone wants to support me in my next race, you know, they could either give me $2,700 or I could work with them directly on a TV ad, I could work with them on the content, I could appear in the ad, I could say whatever I wanted in the ad, and then they could spend $50,000 or $100,000 or however much dollars they want to buy a TV ad here in Pulaski County to support my candidacy. And so that's the issue. Once again, it goes back to the words of express advocacy, those words of either please vote for or vote against this particular candidate. If we coordinate and they run the same ad and says, please vote for Clark Tucker, then it's prohibited. But if instead we run the same ad, I coordinate with them and they say, please call Clark Tucker and tell him what a great candidate he is, then there's no rule about that in Arkansas. And so, as I mentioned, we're virtually the only state that does not have a rule on that level of communication. So that high threshold, what this seeks to do is that high threshold of the express advocacy that please vote for or against, it lowers that just a little bit where the definition is the only reasonable interpretation of the ad is to vote for against a particular candidate seeking office. So that's what it seeks to do. The other major difference between what is in here now and what was in last week is there were obligations in the disclosure part on third-party groups. There is no burden at all on third-party groups in the current proposal. It's only on the candidate. This bill doesn't actually prohibit coordination. It just defines it as an in-kind contribution to a campaign. And so it would then be subject to whatever the contribution limit is at the time. Right now, that's $2,700 per race or per election. And so then at that point, it's just up to the candidate not to accept more than the contribution limit. And if the candidate does so, then they would be subject to ramifications with the Ethics Commission. But there's no ramifications at all for third-party groups. So that's what the bill does, and I'd be glad to take any questions. Okay. Are there any questions from the committee?
▶ Play
Okay. Representative Sabin, you're recognized for a question. I just motion at the proper time, Mr. Chair. Okay. Any questions at all from the committee? All right. Not seeing any. Hold on one second. Okay. Is anyone in the audience signed to speak for or against? Okay. We have one person signed to speak against. If you don't mind, you take the end of the table. If you would, Mr. Ray, introduce yourself for the record.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of this committee, my name is David Ray with Americans for Prosperity. I'm here again to testify against House Bill 1005, which would create an overly broad definition of political advertisements. I'd like to begin actually by thanking Representative Tucker for listening to the feedback and many of the concerns about the previous versions of his legislation. He's listened to our feedback about the potential harm to supporters of nonprofit groups from across the political spectrum, and that's reflected in the current version of this legislation. However, we are continuing to oppose this legislation, and the reason for that is because this proposal contains an overly broad definition of political advertisement. The handout that was distributed to the members of the committee from the Center for Competitive Politics outlines that, I believe, on the back side. This definition, as best I can ascertain, is the exact same definition as electioneering communications that was contained in the earlier version of this bill. And this amended version simply calls it something different. calls it political advertising. And that definition would still include speech that is not related to political campaigns. So for example, under this definition, political advertisements would include, quote, criticism or support of a candidate. This means that any communication criticizing or thanking a politician for their support of an issue that a nonprofit group deems important would be subject to this definition. And that is a technique that's essential for grassroots educational communications that nonprofit groups engage in routinely to keep the general public aware of issues of importance to them. Similarly, the timing requirements for when groups can engage and talk about these issues is similarly broad. It makes sense that when citizens are paying most attention to the issues, that that's exactly when groups would want to talk to citizens about those issues. And finally, the phrase, any other factor the commission deems relevant is troubling on multiple levels. It essentially makes the other criteria irrelevant because the commission could determine their own criteria. This broad language, in our opinion, undermines the rule of law and unnecessarily empowers the commission to further regulate speech. While we understand the definition of this bill would only apply to coordination and not to all nonprofits, we believe it is poorly constructed and overly broad, and the tendency would be for this definition to linger rather than to be amended into precise law. So based on the first version of this bill, it's not a stretch to see that putting this definition into statute could be further extended to apply to many more groups down the road where their consequences would be much worse. In essence, we view this as one part of a two-step plan, and based on that, we would respectfully ask the members of this committee to continue to oppose this bill.
▶ Play
Thank you. Any questions from committee? All right. Seeing none, I appreciate your testimony. All right. Anybody else has signed up to speak for or against, so you're recognized to close for
▶ Play
Speaker 239 1:59:07
your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'll just make two quick points. The first is that, yes, the definition is the same, but I did move it in the code. It's no longer in the definition section of the subchapter. It's now only in the proposed section on coordination, so it would have no application to any aspect of the subchapter dealing with campaign finance laws aside from the section that is proposed in this bill. It's restricted solely to coordination. The other thing that I would say is I actually was not aware of that handout until Mr. Ray just mentioned it, so I haven't had a chance to look at it or know what's in it or respond to it. But I would just say that so right now the threshold on coordination is as high as it can be. The only way the threshold, you kick in above the threshold is if you say vote for or against a specific candidate. And so right now that's why you see the ads that just say please call so-and-so and tell them to work for the people of Arkansas instead of vote against that candidate. And so what I'm trying to do is just catch those ads. And this proposal, I totally understand and respect Mr. Ray's point that his perspective is that it's broad. But as I mentioned, we're virtually the only state left that does not catch those ads. And this is the narrowest language that I have seen in any other state. Most other states' language is much broader than this. The language is that the only reason, well, first of all, you have to identify a candidate in the ad. And so if you don't identify a candidate, it doesn't kick in at all. But then the other language is that the only reasonable interpretation is to vote for or against a specific candidate. And so, you know, if during the session someone runs an ad and says, you know, thanks, John Doe, for voting for or against this bill, and it's 18 months before an election and they haven't even announced for re-election, then the only reasonable interpretation of that ad is not to vote for or against the specific candidate. If they run it the day before an election and, you know, it blankets the airwaves, then then I think it's reasonable to interpret that as a request to promote that candidate. So anyway, just a quick way to say that this is as narrow as it can be to catch the type of coordination that we're trying to catch, and it's much narrower than exists in most states in the country. So with that, I'd appreciate a good vote. Okay. Representative Sabin? Yes,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. I move to pass. Okay. We have a motion to pass. Any discussion on the motion? Okay. Okay. All in favor, say aye. No, say nay. The noes have it. Sorry, Mr. Tucker. It was a good try. That's all right. You worked
▶ Play
Speaker 239 2:01:34
real hard at it. All right. I do have the other bill.
▶ Play
I don't know if everybody's ready to go. That's fine. Well, we do have other people who are wanting to run bills. Let's move on, if you don't mind, and let some of the other bills get done. But we'll get you back. We'll be here upon adjournment, and I'm happy to hear you upon adjournment. I appreciate you waiting around all day long for that. Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized. And what is the bill number, Representative Wardlaw? Do you know? Senate Bill 380. Oh, yeah, you're going to start with Senate Bill 380. there is amendment to your bill you want to run the amendment yes we can okay okay and you know what actually hold on one second I don't see an amendment on my tablet here Okay, Representative Wardlaw, you have an amendment to add co-sponsors. So, you know, at this point, apparently it isn't your amendment, so we'll have to get a new amendment. I don't need it. We're not going to run the amendment? No. Okay,
▶ Play
all right, good. Then you just run the bill. I don't need amendments to co-sponsors. Okay, then you're recognized. This is a real simple bill for UAMS. What it does, it allows them to have freedom on the money that they collect from patients, not such freedom on money that they get from general revenue. And that freedom meaning that they can procure different things throughout UAMS just like any other medical clinic or hospital. Bill came through the Senate with no opposition. I'd be glad to answer any questions. All right. Any questions on
▶ Play
this, Bill? All right. There's nobody signed up to speak for or against this bill. You're recognized to close for it. I'm closed. Okay. So what is the will of the committee? We have a motion from Representative Lady Minowitz's motion. We have a motion due passed. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? Congratulations. You passed your bill. Do
▶ Play
you have another one to run? I do, I think. Okay. Maybe.
▶ Play
House Bill 1975. Okay. you're recognized to run House bill
▶ Play
1975 committee this bill we've we've voted out of here in numerous sessions prior this is the balanced budget compact bill and I won't spend hours debating it or telling you about it but I'll be glad to answer any questions it's a it's a good bill to control our national budget and here to answer
▶ Play
any questions okay any questions from committee seeing none represent Womack you okay we have a motion do pass there is nobody here to sign up to speak for against this bill any discussion on the motion there's motion do pass on the table any discussion on the motion okay all in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed, say nay. No. Ayes have it. Congratulations. You passed your bill. Thank you. Thank you, committee. Representative Douglas, do you want to run your bill? Which bill is it, Representative Douglas? 1944? Okay. You're recognized to
▶ Play
Speaker 254 2:05:17
of 1944. Take the end of the table.
▶ Play
Thank you committee. And I'd like to have the advocates from the victim's advocates that are here today, they're not going to all speak, but I want them to be recognized. And so if they would come and just sit in these chairs around me as we explain what this bill will do to strengthen a partnership that they have with the F&A. Yeah, that is fine if they want to have a seat. Yeah.
▶ Play
I appreciate you all being so patient to sit here all through this committee. Come on up. You don't want to?
▶ Play
Okay. Okay. Okay. I'm going to let them recognize themselves, and then there's others here that, you know, are not joining us at the table for different reasons. So go ahead, Amy. My name is
▶ Play
Amy Stivers, and I'm with Parents of Murdered Children. My name is
▶ Play
Beth Goodrich, and I'm with the Arkansas
▶ Play
Coalition Against Domestic Violence. My name is Monty Johnson. I'm the Executive Director of the Coalition
▶ Play
Against Sexual Assault. Appreciate you all being here. Yes. Committee, what this does is it strengthens the partnership that we have with DF&A who accepts all the money. They are the pass-through for all the federal money that comes to our victims' groups. And there is a board, an advisory board, that has been set up to be an overlook, an oversight for those monies. And we feel like that it just needed to be strengthened a little so that the decisions made about the money through DF&A would have an overlook by the victims' groups. The board was already established. We're not doing anything different with the board, but we're adding just some strengthening language, such as if you'll look, if you care to, on page 2, line 6, we're saying that we want the board to review and give advice concerning the processes and grant funding. We also want them to be able to review and give advice when rules are changed. A lot of times rules have been changed that have not agreed with federal guidelines, and that has caused some problems in the funding streaming to the advocacy groups. We feel like this will strengthen the money getting to the advocates and then being passed on to the victims in the state. Two things that we're very mindful of. One is that we do not want to overstep any federal guidelines by this review process. So if there's ever a conflict of interest, then we're sensitive to that. The other opposition that might be to this bill was on a definition of review. And the odd thing is, in the legislature, when we say something is reviewed by committee, that means we either passed it out or we didn't. But in the real world out there that exists outside of the government bubble, the word review simply means analysis, evaluation, assessment, appraisal, examination, investigation, inquiry, and I could go on. It's not a yes or no, it is a process of giving input. So I want you to know that Webster's definition of review is passing with this bill, not the legislative definition that we have developed in committee where we say it is reviewed or not reviewed. And so, with that, I would take questions and... Do you define review in this? No, I do not. I assume that the definitions in bills are according to Webster's. Well, that's... Is that
▶ Play
not a good assumption? Yeah, that would be probably an erroneous assumption when we are in the review, and I think that was a legitimate concern, that it would be kind of the review process like we do in rules and regs and everything else. And I don't know how that would be interpreted. And so it may be doing more than you really want to do. My recommendation would be, if that is an issue, then you probably need to put an amendment in here to define the review or just get rid of review altogether as a word in here. And I think that it would still probably cover your process. if what you're really wanting this to be is kind of an advisory board and not a governing board. But that's just kind of my opinion. We do have other questions. Representative Womack, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
I just want you to affirm that I'm correct or not in my understanding. This grant advisory board does not have any authority to tell DF&A yes or no, this money will not go there. It can't be
▶ Play
used. This is, if I understand what I read. Right. It's just advisory, and they want, the board just wants to review those decisions and review what is coming, you know, to the, you know, different advocates and have a chance to give input about what their needs are and where, you know, they think the money should go if there's ever, you know. Yeah, great.
▶ Play
Thank you for answering that. Representative Douglas, how would this be funded? Would there be any funding, or is it all volunteer basis? they pay their own mileage and per diem or whatever their
▶ Play
organizations would cover that, I guess. Yes, and I'm going to let Monty Johnson just give a statement about that, about how the advisory board has worked, and we're going to keep this very, very short. Okay.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:11:30
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and
▶ Play
thank you, Representative. Recognize yourself. Yeah, my name is Monty Johnson. I'm the director of the Arkansas Coalition Against Sexual Assault. I want to thank you for standing in the gap for your constituents because that's where I find myself today, standing in the gap for victim service agencies that are boots on the ground working with victims of crime. A lot of these people work 24-7. They hear stories of crimes against the human flesh that none of us really like to stand or sit in a room and hear, yet they do that on a day-to-day basis. I also want to acknowledge that we have been working with Paul Luthien at DFNA, and we recognize that he has been very helpful since he came on board about eight weeks ago, and we have seen a lot of changes, and it's all been for the positive. The reason that we brought this, that we want to bring this bill forward is to just give a little bit more oversight as to the things that are being done in the DF&A, IGS, victim justice part that oversees all of these grant funds that go to these victim service agencies. I represent the Arkansas Coalition Against Sexual Assault, and I represent those other victim service agencies. And I believe this is the responsibility that's given to the advisory board. This legislation will enhance the utilization and equitable distribution of these funds. The intent of this board is not to undermine or hinder the granting process as it flows through the Department of Finance and Administration. It is to provide much needed constructive and productive oversight from board members who are knowledgeable of both the federal rules and regulations and the needs of victim service agencies across the state. One of the purposes of the Arkansas Coalition Against Sexual Assault is to advocate for its member agencies. When I became the executive director of ACASA, I began to be contacted by members of agencies regarding issues with grant administration through IGS. Although the advisory Committee at that time existed, it was powerless to effect change. It is my experience while advocating for these agencies, their voices have not been heard nor respected. The Arkansas Coalition Against Sexual Assault believes that this grant board, which is made up of volunteers, will give those who are boots on the ground a voice and will improve distribution and monitoring of funds that provide victim services to all citizens of the state of Arkansas. I also have letters of support with me, and I would read those if you would like, but I also appreciate your time and don't want to overstep.
▶ Play
I would say that's up to you. However, I think that it probably would be wise. If you do have letters, something that you want to distribute to the committee, if you bring it up here, we'll distribute it. It may not be useful to read it, but that would be your discretion. Any questions for this? All right. So one thing that I would come back to as an issue and a question, I mean, it's clear that you don't want the review authority like we use in the legislature. So would you be amicable to amending that? And then an amendment that I think in every place, and you may have to correct me if you're wrong, But every place that you use the word review in here, you also say recommendations or you say advice. And so if all you did was do an amendment that struck the review, I think it would probably – I mean, essentially what this board is is just kind of a board of people, you know, stakeholders who would then have some, you know, codified authority to work with individuals who are transferring money that is associated with their costs, right? And so for the most part, the state agencies are probably already doing that, but this probably just makes it where
▶ Play
it's a little clear, is that right? We have struggled with that language and find that there needs to be some more strength in the language to give strength toward the board process. We see great movement in that direction, but we want this board to have the ability to give their say on where things are going to go and to be respected and listened to. We see that happening, we're moving toward that, but this needs to be codified so that that happens no matter who's in charge at DF&A. We have someone that's very willing to work with us now, but that may not always be there and we can't depend on this being an individual decision. Okay, so are you
▶ Play
saying that you want this board to have a review authority over the spending? Review as I defined it. Right.
▶ Play
Okay. So, but I don't... Again, federal
▶ Play
guidelines. All right. What I would say is that the bill is written, the easiest and best way to define it would be review authority like we use in every other area of the code. So if you want something less than that, I mean, you know, if they have the authority to work with DF&A to make recommendations, then you can take out the word review, and I think that you would still accomplish that same task. It's completely up to you. not telling you how to amend your bill. I would say that if you don't want review authority, then you should make sure that that's defined. And I just think that you're granting a lot of authority to a new board if
▶ Play
you're giving them the review authority. I would be glad to amend that definition end as we move toward the Senate end, but I don't want to slow this process down. And these women have worked for months with the FNA to come up with this language. And when we try to substitute any other word for that, it seems like it weakens the advisory board. Okay, so I guess what I
▶ Play
would say is that it probably would be productive for the committee to know what your amendment is going to be. If you're not sure about what your amendment would be, then my recommendation would probably pull it down and let's work on the language.
▶ Play
My amendment would be to add the definition that I gave you earlier out of Webster's of what review means. Okay,
▶ Play
so if you don't mind going over that definition again.
▶ Play
That would be review means analysis, evaluation, assessment, appraisal, examination, investigation, inquiry, probe, inspection, and study. Okay. and probably should include something to specifically say that it's not
▶ Play
the same review authority associated with reviewing rules and regs for any other agency. And so that would be your amendment that you're going
▶ Play
to do? I would, with my colleagues here, if they would, if they can make that decision quickly, I can say a yes as well. I think we're okay with that. Okay, where we are, we have made a collective decision. Okay, I don't think there is there
▶ Play
anybody else who's signed up to speak for or against the bill? Okay, we do have actually somebody who is here to speak against the bill. If you all don't mind making room at the end of the table.
▶ Play
Speaker 281 2:19:46
I would like to say as he comes to the table
▶ Play
that this gentleman has been over backwards to work with us on this, and his work at DF&A is admired by all of us, so I thank him for the time he has spent with us. Mr. Lothian, if you'll introduce yourself for the record.
▶ Play
Speaker 283 2:20:18
I'm Paul Lothian, Deputy Director, Department of Finance and Administration. I want to be very careful what I say because I do admire the people that work in this field and the work that they've done, and I appreciate what we've worked together for the last eight weeks to accomplish. And I want you to understand that regardless of how this works out, we're going to continue that. Our concern is that, as Mr. Chairman, as you've mentioned, is that the wording could be misunderstood or misused somewhere down the road. And also that we may have difficulty with the federal auditors if they come in and look at what the processes and procedures are for us administering these grants. I first brought up the concern about the word review. If you'll look on page two, there's also a statement there that is required that we look at rules and regulations. If they choose to ask us to do that, I believe that word required would also violate the guidelines that we would need to have for this grant. With that said, if we can remove that word and define review, I think we concur on this
▶ Play
legislation. Where is the line in page? Let's
▶ Play
Speaker 283 2:21:50
see. Line 14 on page 2 says within federal guidelines requiring and recommending. And then on page, I guess we need to look at page five, line two also, where it makes the statement that's subject to the review and recommendation, that we would need to remove that, the review from there also. But the concept is, Mr. Chairman, is what you brought to us in your comments. There has to be some lessening of that. We want to be inclusive. We want to have their input, their consideration, and their guidance. They're the people that do this every day. Our job is to facilitate that, to see that the money is put to good use, that we get all the money we can from the federal government and put it to use for the citizens of Arkansas. And I'm committed to doing
▶ Play
that. Thank you. All right. Any questions? I appreciate your testimony. I did see a hand go up of another person who had was, okay. You are recognized. Please introduce yourself to the record.
▶ Play
You're recognized to speak for the bill. Thank you. I'm Beth Goodrich, the Executive Director for the Arkansas Coalition Against Domestic Violence. And I just kind of wanted to say that, you know, regardless of going forward, whatever happens here, I think it's important for you to have some history of why we did this bill. What are we doing here? There is, unfortunately, a long history between service providers on the ground and the staff at IGS of non-cooperation. When there's an issue on the ground, those voices are not being heard. The advisory committee thus far has functioned with the language that we're talking about weakening it to as simply a token board. It's largely ignored. It's not listened to when we meet and we talk about questions we have and changes that we suggest to make the rules be more consistent with what we know to be federal guidelines. It's completely ignored. And so the push to have language in the law that actually forces people to listen to the advisory board, that is where that is born from. It's from a long history of being ignored. There's no process of appeal that programs are aware of on the ground. If funds are taken from them, there's a long history of people being afraid to question anything through this office because of fear of retaliation. and by retaliation, that means the loss of their federal funding. And so that's been a real concern. I don't have letters of support to submit to you because every single one of my people who have a complaint, and there are many of them, I represent 31 shelter programs, they are too afraid to assign their name to a complaint against DFNA because they are afraid that they will lose federal funding or face a significant reduction in federal funding for speaking out against the office. Now, going forward, I feel hope. You know, we've had communication that has been really good, but my concern is that if that is not in the law, that when different people come into those offices in the future, they will not have the interest of working with us to provide those better services and listen to, you know, programs that are on the ground. That is my fear because that's what we've been living with in this long history. I've worked in this field for 11 years, and it has been a struggle every single year that I have gone through that
▶ Play
grant process. I hope it is getting better. So is your position that you don't want to see the language change to take the review authority out? It's
▶ Play
kind of hard to decide. You know, I don't mind it being reviewed with her definition in there. I would support that because I feel like we've made other people aware of the issues that we've had. But I would prefer it to be that stronger language simply because there are other states that have done it. Oklahoma has done it. And as far as, you know, the states that haven't, they're not having the same issues that we're having between the people on the ground and the people in the DF&A office, equivalent in their state. So obviously it's my preference for it to be the other way. I don't feel like it's unproductive if we change
▶ Play
it now, but. And if you'll notice on page 2, line 14, we said, because we had this brought to us, within federal guidelines. We do not want to do anything to jeopardize the federal money coming to the victims. So we would be sensitive to the federal guidelines at all points and wanted that written into the bill. Okay. Are there any
▶ Play
other questions from the committee? All right, so seeing no questions, Representative Douglas, I guess let me, what is your intention now?
▶ Play
My intention now is to make the definition clear of what we feel like review is and to say that it is not the review authority given through the legislature. Now, one thing that I know that there's
▶ Play
been some discussion about doing an amendment. If you were to do the amendment, we're coming back upon adjournment, and, you know, we can, without the, you know, all the issues of running the bill, since we've all discussed it, you'll have the amendment. If you can get that done and get that back at committee this afternoon, we can still get the bill out today. Would you entertain doing that? I
▶ Play
would be glad to. Are you saying you would rather vote? Can we go ahead and have a vote now so that I can end this afternoon? We wouldn't be able
▶ Play
to amend it then, because if we vote on it and it votes out, it goes to the floor, and we wouldn't be able to do that. My recommendation is because of the fact that we can pick it up upon adjournment, that you circle the wagons, figure out what you can do, get an amendment, and bring it back. I'm not dictating that. We can have a vote here and just amend it on the bill you got. But if you are willing to amend it, my recommendation just from the chair, and I have no sense of what the committee is going to do at this point, But if you were to amend it and bring it back, I think that you would have a better chance of passing what you actually are wanting
▶ Play
to pass. I'm struggling with that because these ladies have worked so hard on this. I'd like to move forward with it, amend on the Senate end, since it is just a simple definition of the word review.
▶ Play
Okay. And that's fine. And if it doesn't fly, you can always amend it and come back later. All right. Any other questions from the committee? Okay. Representative Sturge, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Douglas, if we
▶ Play
Speaker 291 2:28:41
are going to meet in the committee this afternoon, it seems to be, and I don't know, it would be faster to have the amendment done today, go over to BLR right after we meet here, get that amendment done, bring it back to us this afternoon, and we'll get it due past same day, same time frame. That way you pass it on the floor tomorrow. It heads to the Senate. It doesn't have to come back to us. Would you be? I mean, I'm willing to vote yay either way,
▶ Play
but I'm just asking, I think it's the same time frame. If that's the will of the committee, I'm getting some head shakes that you're more comfortable with me doing it that way, and I don't want to jeopardize the bill. So I'll pull it down and bring it back this afternoon after session with a clean amendment, and I'll have this language in there, and that will hopefully bring a compromise to the table that we can all live with.
▶ Play
Well, we appreciate that very much. I think getting sent to the committee, I'd say that's probably a good idea. Okay. And we appreciate the ladies coming and testifying and the work
▶ Play
that you guys do. And I, too, want to recognize Doris Smith that came to the table from DF&A. She's the pass-through for the money. She works so very hard over there, and we wanted her to be recognized as well as a part of this discussion moving forward. Well, thank you very much, Representative Douglas. Thank you, committee.
▶ Play
Okay, are there any other members who are not part of this committee? Upon adjournment, I really want to try to focus on members' bills. Now, Representative Tucker had asked, so I'm going to let him run something if he wants to run it upon adjournment. But my plan really is to focus on members' bills when we meet upon adjournment. So if you have something that you want to run, we can work as late as we need to work in order to get that done. So I'm fine with that. Is there anybody else that has something that they want to run right now? Okay. Representative Serge, all right. Well, as long as the committee is still okay and we don't lose our quorum, then you're recognized. What are you running? Senate bill what? 419. 419, okay. I have an amendment, Mr. Chair. Okay. Okay. You're recognized
▶ Play
Speaker 291 2:31:07
to run the amendment. Colleagues, the amendment basically just changes the title. This is Senator Irvin's bill over from the Senate, and I believe the original bill had something to do with the Civil War 150th Anniversary Commission, but that was actually taken out of the bill, but the title wasn't changed. So we're just wanting the title to reflect what's actually in the bill
▶ Play
like good Republicans do. Okay. All right. So you've heard the presentation of the amendment. Are you closed for your amendment? Yes, ma'am. Excuse me. Okay. So I assume you make a motion of adopting the amendment. Yes, please. Okay. So you have a motion adopting the amendment on the table. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed?
▶ Play
Speaker 291 2:31:45
Okay. Your amendment has been adopted. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Chair, I also want to recognize Director Hurst from the Arkansas Department of Heritage, and she'll be with me to answer any questions. But basically, folks, my mama used to accuse me of being a clean freak when I was younger, I guess that's good because I'm always running clean-up bills for some reason or the other. But Representative Barker and Senator Irvin asked me to run it for them today. But this bill does four different things with different commissions underneath the Department of Heritage. One is amending the law concerning the Natural Heritage Commission. Right now, they're required to do a report every year to the governor by paper, and so we're just allowing them to do that on their website and electronically to the governor. The Arkansas Arts Council, this bill would abolish a public art program that was never implemented. It was supposed to be set aside funds to purchase or commission artwork for state buildings through levying fees, but that program was never established, and we're just cleaning up the language on that. Also amending the law for the Delta Cultural Center Policy Advisory Board, the Delta Cultural Center National Advisory Board. The bill would eliminate the National Advisory Board intended for the Delta Cultural Center. Originally, that board was to have a statewide and national, but the national board was never created. And so, basically, the bill is clean up given to us by the Department of Heritage. Like I said, Director Hurst can answer any questions that
▶ Play
you might have. Okay. Mrs. Hurst, I'm sorry, if you don't mind introducing yourself for the
▶ Play
Speaker 296 2:33:11
record. I'm Stacey Hurst, Director of the Department of Arkansas Heritage.
▶ Play
Okay. Any questions for Reverend Sabin, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just
▶ Play
a simple question, and I almost apologize for asking it. But in addition to the things that you had mentioned, I guess it also removes a member of the Humanities Council from the regular Delta Cultural Center Policy Advisory Board. I was just curious what the rationale behind that was.
▶ Play
Speaker 296 2:33:40
It hasn't been filled in a long time. It's just a difficult position to fill. Traveling to Helena is hard for some folks. So we just find it easier to be able to fill that body if we didn't have these various restrictions. We've also asked if we could remove the geographic requirement for the Mosaic Templars Cultural Center. And, again, that's an issue of just finding it makes it harder to fill the positions. Okay. I appreciate the answer. Thank you very much. Okay. Any other questions from committee? All
▶ Play
right. Nobody's signed up to speak for or against. Representative Sturge, you're recognized to close for your bill. I'm closed, Mr. Chair, and I move to pass. Thank you. Okay, the motion is do pass as amended. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? All right, congratulations. You passed your bill. All right, when I took up that bill, I got a little bit of pushback from my committee members. I can tell that they are ready to go and eat. So we're going to go ahead and adjourn, and then we will meet back here upon adjournment. So we are adjourned. Thank you.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1440 M. Gray TO AMEND PROVISIONS IN THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING ELECTION RUNOFFS, INITIATIVES, AND REFERENDA.

16:08 - 0:42

Representative Michelle Gray explained that HB 1440 needed a correction from “three weeks” to “four weeks” and added language to ensure constitutional publication of amendment texts six months before elections. [16:10] [16:29]

The committee concurred in the amendment, adopted it after brief discussion, and recorded the adoption despite a single objection. [16:44] [16:48] [17:17] [17:48] [18:05] [18:13] [18:16] [18:19]

A final motion to pass the bill as amended was made and carried unanimously. [19:02]

HB1047 Lowery TO REQUIRE THAT A VOTER PROVIDE VERIFICATION OF VOTER REGISTRATION WHEN VOTING; AND TO AMEND AMENDMENT 51 OF THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION.

0:42 - 3:09 6 segments 3 speakers

Representative Mark Lowery explained that voters without photo ID could sign a sworn statement attesting to their identity, relieving the need for provisional ballots. [1:11] [1:43]

Chair Bob Ballinger noted two Senate amendments to concur in and moved a motion to concur in both amendments, which passed without objection. [2:12] [2:17]

Representative Warwick Sabin recognized the concurrence on Senate Amendment 1 to HB 1010, referencing its prior passage without dissent. [3:04]

HB1010 Sabin TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE FILING AND PUBLICATION OF CERTAIN CAMPAIGN FINANCE REPORTS; AND TO AMEND PORTIONS OF LAW RESULTING FROM INITIATED ACT 1 OF 1990 AND INITIATED ACT 1 OF 1996.

3:09 - 21:36 63 segments 12 speakers

Representative Warwick Sabin described the Senate amendment allowing paper filing for voters lacking internet access and noted its unanimous 34-0 Senate approval. [3:20]

The committee moved to concur in the amendment, and the motion carried unanimously. [3:58] [4:01]

Chair Ballinger then closed the item and indicated the next bill would be taken up shortly. [4:24]

RE-REFERRED Subtitle Sponsor Number

SB373 Hester TO EXEMPT ATTORNEY-CLIENT COMMUNICATIONS AND ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT FROM THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967.

REGULAR AGENDA Subtitle Sponsor Number

HB1622 Johnson TO CREATE BURDENSOME REQUESTS FOR ADDRESSING A PROCEDURE FOR DISCLOSURE; TO AMEND THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967; TO CREATE AN AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

21:36 - 11:27

The committee first considered an amendment to HB 1622 that reduced the response deadline from a 45-day cap to 15 business days and added language for an affirmative defense, which Rep. Gray moved to adopt and was approved by voice vote. [23:52] [24:14]

Witnesses including Pulaski County Attorney Chastity Cypress, Sheriff’s Sergeant Doug Cunningham, public-policy attorney Dan Greenberg, former commissioner Stewart Sofer and others testified, arguing that the 15-day limit balances transparency with the burden of large requests while warning that eliminating the three-day rule could undermine citizens’ rights, prompting extensive debate and questions from several representatives. [23:12] [23:18] [23:38] [23:40] [23:52] [27:18] [27:38] [27:50] [27:56] [28:18] [28:55] [29:01] [29:09] [29:38] [30:10] [36:07] [36:21] [36:55] [37:00] [37:19] [37:29] [37:44] [38:00] [39:35] [40:09] [40:40] [41:15] [41:49] [46:02] [46:06] [46:46] [47:21] [47:52] [48:22] [48:55]

When the time came to vote on the bill itself, the committee lacked a motion to consider HB 1622 and the chair announced that the measure failed, ending the hearing without passage. [55:17]

HB1623 Johnson TO AMEND THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967; TO AMEND THE LAW TO AND AN DECLARE GUIDANCE; INFORMATION CONCERNING PUBLIC FOR EMERGENCY.

HB1696 D. Meeks TO TRANSFER THE STATE CHILD ABUSE AND NEGLECT PREVENTION BOARD TO THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES THROUGH A TYPE 3 TRANSFER; AND TO ABOLISH THE STATE CHILD ABUSE AND NEGLECT PREVENTION BOARD.

11:27 - 58:39 163 segments 22 speakers

Speaker detailed the board’s limited activity, excess appropriations, and the rationale for a Type 3 transfer that would retain programs while improving oversight. [11:57] [12:27] [12:58] [13:29]

The committee asked no questions and voted to pass the bill. [15:07]

SB377 Hickey CONCERNING THE ELIGIBILITY OF AN INMATE OF THE DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION TO PARTICIPATE IN A WORK-RELEASE PROGRAM OR UNDER ACT 309 OF 1983.

HB1707 M. Gray TO AMEND THE DATES OF THE GENERAL PRIMARY ELECTION AND PREFERENTIAL PRIMARY ELECTION; TO AMEND THE TIME PERIOD FOR FILING AS A CANDIDATE FOR A PRIMARY ELECTION; AND TO AMEND THE TIME FOR THE FISCAL SESSION.

HB1725 D. Douglas TO TRANSFER VARIOUS STATE AGENCIES TO THE ARKANSAS AGRICULTURE DEPARTMENT THROUGH A TYPE 4 TRANSFER; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

58:39 - 7:16

Rep. Dan M. Douglas introduced HB 1725, explaining that the bill would transfer the State Plant Board, Livestock and Poultry Commission, and Forestry Commission to the Arkansas Department of Agriculture while preserving their statutory powers, rulemaking authority, and fee-based revenues, and he argued the move would eliminate duplicated HR, procurement, IT, and CFO functions across the three agencies. [59:11] [59:42] [1:00:13] [1:00:46] [1:01:18] [1:01:51] [1:02:25] [1:02:56] [1:03:27] [1:03:58] [1:04:35] [1:05:15]

Secretary of Agriculture Wes Ward testified that these agencies have been part of the department since the 2005 “top-one” transfer, that consolidating support functions could save roughly $600,000 per year, improve emergency response capabilities, and would not result in job losses because staff would be reassigned at the same pay level. [1:06:05] [1:06:19] [1:06:51] [1:07:28] [1:07:58] [1:08:33] [1:09:03] [1:09:34] [1:10:04] [1:10:39] [1:11:13] [1:11:43] [1:12:14] [1:12:49] [1:13:20] [1:13:28] [1:13:51] [1:14:02] [1:14:21]

Committee members raised concerns about the projected savings, the absence of a formal financial impact statement, and the potential effects of the type-4 transfer and emergency clause; opposition witnesses such as Ray Vester and Kim Hammer warned that the bill could centralize control of funds and weaken the Plant Board’s independence, while supporters including Wes Higginbotham and Marvin Childress argued it would reduce duplication and preserve board authority, after which Chair Rep. Bob Ballinger adopted a motion to limit further debate to five minutes per side. [1:13:28] [1:13:51] [1:14:02] [1:14:21] [1:15:00] [1:15:04] [1:15:32] [1:24:58] [1:25:39] [1:26:11] [1:26:53] [1:27:26] [1:27:59] [1:28:30] [1:29:02] [1:29:34] [1:30:08] [1:30:38] [1:31:14] [1:31:45] [1:32:15] [1:32:46] [1:33:21] [1:33:51] [1:36:43] [1:36:48] [1:37:02] [1:37:29] [1:37:39] [1:38:10] [1:38:40] [1:38:53] [1:39:09] [1:39:11] [1:39:31] [1:39:43] [1:40:14] [1:40:40] [1:40:45]

The chair called for a motion to pass HB 1725, held a voice vote with no opposition and announced committee approval; Rep. Tucker then confirmed the bill’s number (1,005/1,008), noting that this version differed substantially from the one previously considered; finally Rep. (Speaker) 239 explained that the disclosure provisions had been removed, leaving the measure to focus solely on coordination issues in campaign-finance transparency. [1:50:21] [1:50:32] [1:51:09] [1:51:14] [1:51:22] [1:51:41]

HB1004 Blake TO CREATE THE DEMOCRACY ACT; TO REQUIRE AUTOMATIC VOTER REGISTRATION; AND TO AMEND AMENDMENT 51 OF THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION.

HB1207 Dalby TO AMEND REQUIREMENTS FOR CAMPAIGN SIGNS AND MATERIALS.

7:16 - 1:52:03 314 segments 38 speakers

Representative Dwight Tosh confirmed that penalties requiring state employees to resign were eliminated, now treated as ethics violations before the Ethics Commission. [8:19] [8:50]

After discussion, a motion to pass the bill was made and adopted without opposition. [10:22]

Representative D. Meeks introduced HB 1696 to transfer the State Child Abuse and Neglect Prevention Board to the Department of Children and Family Services, citing inefficiencies and funding concerns. [11:21] [11:26]

HB1008 Tucker TO INCREASE THE PENALTY FOR TAKING CAMPAIGN FUNDS AS PERSONAL INCOME; AND TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF ARKANSAS LAW RESULTING FROM INITIATED ACT 1 OF 1990 AND INITIATED ACT 1 OF 1996

HB1005 Tucker TO REQUIRE REPORTING AND DISCLOSURE OF ELECTIONEERING COMMUNICATIONS; AND TO RESTRICT THE AMOUNT OF MONEY SPENT ON CAMPAIGN COMMUNICATIONS PRODUCED IN COORDINATION WITH A CANDIDATE FOR OFFICE.

1:52:03 - 5:19

Representative Tucker explained that the bill would create a definition of coordinated political advertising as an in-kind contribution subject to the $2,700 contribution limit, noting Arkansas is currently the only state without such a rule and that the proposal places the disclosure burden solely on candidates, not third-party groups. [1:52:11] [1:52:47] [1:53:18] [1:53:49] [1:54:21]

David Ray of Americans for Prosperity testified that the bill’s definition of “political advertising” is overly broad, would capture ordinary issue-based speech by nonprofits, and gives the Ethics Commission unchecked authority to interpret “any other factor”. [1:55:32] [1:56:07] [1:56:40] [1:57:12] [1:57:47] [1:58:21]

Tucker responded that the definition is confined to the coordination section of the code, does not affect other campaign-finance provisions, and that the threshold for prohibited ads is limited to express advocacy for or against a specific candidate. [1:59:07] [1:59:27] [1:59:58] [2:00:32] [2:01:05]

Chair Bob Ballinger moved to pass the measure; after brief discussion the committee voted “no” and the bill failed to pass. [2:01:17] [2:01:34]

HB1739 C. Douglas TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING PRIMARY ELECTIONS, RUNOFF ELECTIONS, AND SPECIAL ELECTIONS.

HB1765 Holcomb TO IMPROVE ELECTION ADMINISTRATION TRANSPARENCY; AND TO RESOLVE A CONFLICT IN THE LAW CONCERNING PUBLIC NOTICE OF ELECTIONS.

5:19 - 20:15 49 segments 10 speakers

Representative Mike Holcomb outlined that the bill would require posting the date and location of early-voting official lists well before voting, addressing current one-day notice practices. [5:35]

Chair Ballinger asked for questions, received none, and called for a vote on the bill. [6:06]

The committee approved HB 1765 unanimously. [6:23]

Representative Jim Dotson presented the amended HB 1207, removing felony penalties, limiting violations to ethics offenses, and narrowing the scope to candidate-specific signage issues. [6:42] [7:12]

HB1766 D. Douglas TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING PRIMARY ELECTIONS, RUNOFF ELECTIONS, AND SPECIAL ELECTIONS.

SB38 A. Clark TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ELECTIONS AND BALLOTS.

HB1807 Collins TO ENSURE THE FUTURE FUNDING OF THE STATE HEALTH DEPARTMENT BUILDING AND LOCAL GRANT TRUST FUND.

HB1819 K. Hendren CONCERNING BALLOT TITLES AND POPULAR NAMES OF CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS PROPOSED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY.

HB1823 Collins TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS PAPERWORK EFFICIENCY AND TRANSPARENCY ACT; TO PERMIT ELECTRONIC DOCUMENT SUBMISSIONS AND PUBLICATIONS; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE INSPECTION OF PUBLIC RECORDS.

HB1832 House TO ALLOW THE EMPLOYMENT OF SPECIAL COUNSEL BY A STATE OFFICIAL OR ENTITY IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES; AND TO REQUIRE SPECIAL COUNSEL TO OBTAIN APPROVAL BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL BEFORE ENTERING INTO A SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT.

HB1866 Lundstrum TO EXEMPT CERTAIN INFORMATION PERTAINING TO A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER FROM THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967; AND CONCERNING PUBLIC RECORD WEBSITES.

SB380 Hester TO EXEMPT CERTAIN COMMODITIES AND SERVICES UNDER THE ARKANSAS PROCUREMENT LAW.

HB1893 M. Gray TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS PROCUREMENT LAW; AND TO AMEND THE VENDOR REPORTING REQUIREMENTS FOR STATE CONTRACTS.

HB1270 Johnson TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ELECTIONS AND BALLOTS.

20:15 - 2:06:03 310 segments 36 speakers

Representative Bob Johnson presented HB 1270, proposing low-cost private voting areas by placing simple tables to allow secret ballot marking without additional expense. [20:25] [20:56]

Chair Ballinger noted no questions from the committee and closed the hearing on the bill. [21:07]

The committee voted to pass HB 1270 unanimously. [21:27]

HB1931 Gillam CONCERNING THE APPROVAL OF BALLOT TITLES AND POPULAR NAMES OF PETITIONS PRIOR TO CIRCULATION.

HB1932 Gillam CONCERNING THE REVIEW OF RULES PROMULGATED BY THE STATE BOARD OF HEALTH AND THE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH.

HB1944 C. Douglas TO ESTABLISH A GRANT ADVISORY BOARD; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DISBURSEMENT OF CERTAIN FEDERAL FUNDS RECEIVED BY THE STATE.

2:06:03 - 2:03:24

Representative Dan M. Douglas described the bill as strengthening an existing grant advisory board that reviews and advises on the administration of federal victim-service funds, emphasizing that the board would not have authority to direct DF&A spending but would provide oversight and input. [2:06:32] [2:06:41] [2:07:12] [2:07:48]

He raised concerns that the bill’s use of the term “review” could be interpreted as legislative-style review authority, prompting the chair to suggest amending or removing the word to avoid overstepping federal guidelines. [2:08:21] [2:08:53] [2:09:26] [2:09:35] [2:09:56] [2:10:27]

Testimony from Monty Johnson (Arkansas Coalition Against Sexual Assault) and Beth Goodrich (Arkansas Coalition Against Domestic Violence) highlighted past failures of the advisory committee to influence grant decisions, the need for a stronger advisory role, and fears of retaliation against agencies that raise concerns. [2:11:37] [2:12:00] [2:12:32] [2:13:03] [2:13:38] [2:14:09] [2:23:06] [2:23:37] [2:24:08] [2:24:39] [2:25:10] [2:25:22] [2:25:31] [2:25:41]

Committee members, including the chair and DF&A Deputy Director Paul Lothian, debated a proposed amendment that would insert a Webster’s-style definition of “review” to clarify it as non-legislative analysis, but no final vote was taken, leaving the amendment pending for later consideration. [2:18:28] [2:18:36] [2:18:38] [2:18:54] [2:19:08] [2:19:14] [2:19:59] [2:20:18] [2:20:56] [2:21:35] [2:21:45] [2:21:50] [2:22:05] [2:26:17] [2:26:42] [2:26:47] [2:26:55] [2:27:08] [2:27:23] [2:27:30] [2:27:38] [2:27:54] [2:28:18]

HB1975 Dotson TO ADOPT THE COMPACT FOR A BALANCED BUDGET; AND TO ADOPT A PROPOSED AMENDMENT TO THE COMPACT FOR A BALANCED BUDGET.

2:03:24 - 56:20

HB1988 Lundstrum CONCERNING COUNTY JAIL REIMBURSEMENT FOR HOUSING STATE INMATES.

HB2033 Shepherd TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION TO ESTABLISH A CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECK POLICY FOR CERTAIN PERSONS APPLYING FOR OR OCCUPYING A POSITION HAVING ACCESS TO FEDERAL TAX INFORMATION.

56:20 - 2:30:39 265 segments 30 speakers

Rep. Matthew J. Shepherd introduced HB 2033, which would require the Department of Finance and Administration to conduct criminal background checks for personnel handling federal tax information, citing compliance with a federal mandate. [56:25]

After brief discussion, a motion was made and passed unanimously, and the committee approved the bill, with Shepherd noting a possible future amendment to include another department. [56:56] [57:12]

HB2035 D. Douglas TO AMEND THE DATES FOR PROCESSING ABSENTEE BALLOTS.

HB2055 Hammer CONCERNING REMEDIES AVAILABLE TO PERSONS TERMINATED IN VIOLATION OF THE ARKANSAS WHISTLE-BLOWER ACT.

HB2074 Leding TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING INITIATIVES AND REFERENDA.

HB2095 G. Hodges TO ESTABLISH VOTE CENTERS ON THE CAMPUSES OF STATE-SUPPORTED POSTSECONDARY AND HIGHER EDUCATION INSTITUTIONS; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING VOTE CENTERS.

HB2096 G. Hodges TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF PROCUREMENT LAW TO REFLECT THE IMPACT OF INFLATION ON THE COST OF GOODS AND SERVICES AND TO ENCOURAGE MORE PARTICIPATION BY SMALL BUSINESSES.

HB2162 Gonzales TO PROMOTE VOTER TURNOUT; TO AMEND THE LAW TO LIMIT THE DATES ON WHICH CERTAIN SPECIAL ELECTIONS CAN BE HELD; TO AMEND THE LAW THAT RESULTED FROM INITIATED ACT 1 OF 1942.

HB2183 Lowery TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS WHISTLE-BLOWER ACT; AND TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "WHISTLEBLOWER".

HB2195 Shepherd TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING INFORMATION FOR PUBLIC GUIDANCE UNDER THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967.

HB2196 Henderson TO AMEND LANGUAGE CONCERNING THE SPORT OF PROFESSIONAL WRESTLING; AND TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION FOR CHARTABLE EVENTS.

HB2200 M. Hodges TO MODIFY THE DEFINITION OF "SMALL PROCUREMENTS"; TO INCREASE THE ABILITY OF THE STATE TO CONTRACT WITH CERTIFIED MINORITY BUSINESS ENTERPRISES; AND TO ELIMINATE BURDENSOME DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENTS.

HB2242 Davis TO AMEND THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967 CONCERNING DATA RELATED TO A PUBLIC WATER SYSTEM OR MUNICIPALLY OWNED UTILITY SYSTEM.

HB2259 Walker TO REQUIRE THE PASSAGE OF THE CIVICS PORTION OF THE NATURALIZATION TEST USED BY UNITED STATES CITIZENSHIP AND IMMIGRATION SERVICES BEFORE A MEMBER OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY MAY VOTE FOR OR AGAINST A BILL OR RESOLUTION.

HB2260 Walker TO REQUIRE THE PASSAGE OF THE CIVICS PORTION OF THE NATURALIZATION TEST USED BY UNITED STATES CITIZENSHIP AND IMMIGRATION SERVICES BEFORE A PERSON MAY BE ELIGIBLE TO SERVE AS A DIRECTOR OR HEAD OF A STATE AGENCY.

HB2261 Walker TO REQUIRE THE PASSAGE OF THE CIVICS PORTION OF THE NATURALIZATION TEST USED BY UNITED STATES CITIZENSHIP AND IMMIGRATION SERVICES BEFORE A PERSON MAY BE ELIGIBLE TO SERVE AS A CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICER OF THIS STATE.

HCR1014 V. Flowers REQUESTING AND PETITIONING THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS TO PROPOSE FOR SUBMISSION TO THE STATES FOR CONTINUED RATIFICATION AN EQUAL RIGHTS AMENDMENT.

SB419 Irvin TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE CIVIL WAR SESQUICENTENNIAL COMMISSION, THE ARKANSAS NATURAL HERITAGE COMMISSION, THE PUBLIC ART PROGRAM OF THE ARKANSAS ARTS COUNCIL, THE DELTA CULTURAL CENTER AND THE MOSAIC TEMPLE CULTURAL CENTER.

2:30:39 - 2:35:16 15 segments 4 speakers

Senator Irvin’s amendment, presented by Speaker 291, merely updates the bill’s title to reflect its actual contents and makes minor technical changes, such as allowing the Natural Heritage Commission to submit reports electronically and eliminating unused programs and boards (Public Art Program, Delta Cultural Center National Advisory Board, Mosaic Templars Cultural Center requirements). [2:31:07] [2:31:09] [2:31:26] [2:31:39] [2:31:45] [2:32:13] [2:32:43]

Representative Warwick Sabin asked why a member of the Humanities Council was removed from the Delta Cultural Center board; the answer was that the position had been vacant and the change eases staffing. [2:33:22] [2:33:40] [2:33:48]

The chair moved to adopt the amendment, the committee voted “aye,” and the amendment was adopted, effectively passing the bill as amended. [2:34:13] [2:34:19]

SB252 B. King TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES TO SUBMIT MONTHLY FINANCIAL REPORTS TO THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL.

HB1386 Lemons TO REQUIRE THE FILING OF FINAL AGENCY RULES WITH THE ARKANSAS STATE LIBRARY; AND TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURE ACT.

HB1861 Ballinger CONCERNING THE APPROVAL OF BALLOT TITLES AND POPULAR NAMES OF PETITIONS PRIOR TO CIRCULATION.

HB2201 Della Rosa TO DIRECT THE DEPARTMENT OF ARKANSAS HERITAGE TO CONDUCT A FEASIBILITY STUDY CONCERNING THE ESTABLISHMENT OF A CIVIL WAR MUSEUM IN ARKANSAS.

HB2064 Hammer TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE FILING DEADLINES FOR ELECTIONS INVOLVING AN INDEPENDENT CANDIDATE.

SB449 Hester TO CLARIFY THE RESOLUTION OF PROTESTED SOLICITATIONS AND AWARDS UNDER THE ARKANSAS PROCUREMENT LAW.

SB513 Hester FROM CONTRACTING WITH AND INVESTING IN TO PROHIBIT PUBLIC ENTITIES COMPANIES THAT BOYCOTT ISRAEL.

SB584 E. Williams CONCERNING THE QUALIFICATIONS OF THE DIRECTOR OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICE OF THE COURTS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

SCR9 E. Williams URGING THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS TO PROPOSE THE REGULATION FREEDOM AMENDMENT TO THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION.

HB1992 Lundstrum CONCERNING COUNTY JAIL REIMBURSEMENT FOR HOUSING STATE INMATES.

HB2029 Sabin TO AMEND THE UNIFORM ATTENDANCE AND LEAVE POLICY ACT; AND TO PROVIDE FOR CAREGIVER LEAVE.

HB2128 Lowery TO AMEND ARKANSAS LAW CONCERNING THE APPROVAL OF STATE AGENCY RULES.

HJR1003 Gillam AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNING PROPOSED MEASURES AND CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS CONSIDERED BY VOTERS AT AN ELECTION.

HB1046 Tucker TO PERMIT PAID MATERNITY LEAVE FOR STATE EMPLOYEES.

HJR1001 Ballinger APPLYING TO THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS TO CALL A CONVENTION FOR PROPOSING AMENDMENTS PURSUANT TO ARTICLE V OF THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION.

HB1011 Sabin TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE CONTRIBUTIONS; AND TO PROHIBIT DIRECT CONTRIBUTIONS FROM POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEES TO CANDIDATES.

HB1012 Sabin TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEES; AND TO ACTION COMMITTEES TO POLITICAL DIRECT PROHIBIT FROM CONTRIBUTIONS CANDIDATES.

HB1179 Ballinger BENEFITS DEATH DESIGNATED TO PROVIDING TO PROVISIONS AMEND BENEFICIARIES OR SURVIVORS OF POLICE OFFICERS.

HB1009 Leding TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING APPROVED POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEES; AND TO PREVENT A MEMBER OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY FROM FORMING MORE THAN ONE (1) APPROVED POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE.

HB1289 Ballinger TO PROMOTE AND IMPROVE EFFICIENCY AND QUALITY IN THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES; AND TO REORGANIZE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES.

HB1447 M. Gray TO TRANSFER THE STATE BOARD OF ELECTION COMMISSIONERS TO THE OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OF STATE; TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING COMPLAINTS OF ELECTION LAW VIOLATIONS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1151 Davis TO REQUIRE THAT REGISTERED VOTERS BE NOTIFIED BY MAIL OF THE DATES FOR CERTAIN SPECIAL ELECTIONS; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING SPECIAL ELECTIONS.

HB1741 Vaught ALERT NOTIFICATION SYSTEM; ESTABLISH A BLUE TO AND CONCERNING EMERGENCY ASSISTANCE TO LAW ENFORCEMENT

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Bob Ballinger Chair Unverified
127 segments
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
3 segments
Representative Warwick Sabin Unverified
10 segments
Representative Mike Holcomb Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 25
1 segment
Representative Kim Hendren Unverified
8 segments
Representative Jim Dotson Unverified
11 segments
Representative Dwight Tosh Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 51
8 segments
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 70
1 segment
Speaker 72
1 segment
Representative Bob Johnson Unverified
19 segments
Speaker 88
8 segments
Speaker 89
1 segment
Joey Mccutcheon Unverified
15 segments
Speaker 114
1 segment
Speaker 123
5 segments
Representative Dan M. Douglas Unverified
62 segments
Speaker 133
1 segment
Dan Greenberg Unverified
12 segments
Speaker 143
1 segment
Representative Jeff Wardlaw Unverified
10 segments
Stewart Sofer Unverified
11 segments
Adam Fogelman Unverified
5 segments
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 176
1 segment
Wes Ward Unverified
20 segments
Representative Jack Ladyman Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 192
1 segment
Amy Fetcher Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 210
1 segment
Representative Kim Hammer Unverified
24 segments
Wes Higginbotham Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 225
2 segments
Speaker 226
3 segments
Speaker 45
1 segment
Speaker 230
13 segments
Speaker 163
1 segment
Chair Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 239
13 segments
David Ray Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 254
1 segment
Amy Stivers Unverified
1 segment
Beth Goodrich Unverified
8 segments
Monty Johnson Unverified
7 segments
Representative Richard Womack Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 281
1 segment
Speaker 283
6 segments
Speaker 291
7 segments
Speaker 296
3 segments