May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
SB498 Irvin TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "HEALTHCARE PAYOR"; TO PROHIBIT WAIVER OF ALTERNATIVE PAYMENT SYSTEMS BY CONTRACT; TO PROVIDE A LEGAL ENFORCEMENT MECHAN… 6:23
Speaker 20 (David Ivers) presented Senate Bill 498, explaining that it amends Act 902 to prohibit health-care payors from waiving penalty-protection provisions by contract and to authorize enforcement by the insurance department or penalized physicians.
[6:56][7:10][7:19]
Representative Les Eaves asked why Pulaski County Circuit Court was listed first in the enforcement language, and Speaker 20 clarified that the reference was borrowed from the Administrative Procedure Act and has no substantive significance.
[7:19][7:29][7:32]
After the chair confirmed there were no further questions, a motion to pass the bill was made and adopted unanimously.
[8:01]
HB1900 Bentley TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING DRIVERS EXCLUDED FROM A MOTOR VEHICLE INSURANCE POLICY; AND TO IMPOSE CRIMINAL LIABILITY ON THE INSURED DRIVER AND T… 10:19
Representative Mary Bentley introduced an amendment to HB 1900 to provide lifetime insurance coverage for prescription-only metabolic formulas needed by patients with rare inborn errors of metabolism, noting the high cost of these products and the potential long-term savings from keeping patients healthy.
[10:20][10:36][11:03][11:11]
HB1753 Collins TO CLARIFY THAT THE SUBROGATION AND REIMBURSEMENT RIGHTS OF PARTIES TO AN INSURANCE CONTRACT ARE TO BE DEFINED BY THE INSURANCE CONTRACT. 22:15
Morrill Harriman, an attorney for the Mitchell-Williams firm, presented the amendment to HB 1753, explaining that it would replace the bill’s original “all-or-nothing” subrogation scheme with a proportional formula that splits third-party settlement proceeds between the insurer, the injured party and, where applicable, the attorney (e.g., the insurer and claimant each receive roughly one-half when medical costs exceed the policy limit).
[23:21][23:37][24:10][24:41][25:17]
Committee members raised a series of questions-Representative Murdoch asked why the injured party would not receive the full award, Representative Payton queried how attorney fees would be treated, and others probed the impact on under-insured coverage-prompting Harriman to clarify that the amendment caps the insurer’s recovery at one-third (or one-half in certain scenarios) and allocates the remaining portions to the claimant and attorney, thereby ensuring the claimant receives some recovery even when the policy is insufficient.
[27:04][27:18][27:24][27:35][27:57][28:31][28:34][28:40][28:55][30:25][30:49][31:22][31:34]
Chair Representative Charlie Collins moved to adopt the amendment, the committee voted “aye” with no recorded opposition, and the amendment was formally adopted, allowing the bill to proceed in its amended form.
[31:34][49:59][50:02][50:10]
SPECIAL ORDER OF BUSINESS - Wednesday, March 22, 2017 1:09:55
Representative John Maddox explained that, although he had originally opposed the measure, his review of how other states (notably Texas) handle the issue led him to view the bill as a fair compromise.
[1:10:21][1:10:33]
The vote failed to reach the required 11 ayes (recorded 9 ayes and 5 nays), so the amendment was not adopted.
[1:12:08][1:12:38]
A motion to expunge the vote was made and carried, after which the chair returned to the agenda and listed several pending House bills (HB 2102, HB 2193, HB 2212, HB 1840) for consideration.
[1:12:38][1:13:09][1:13:36][1:13:40]
HB1840 Johnson CONCERNING THE APPLICATION OF INSURANCE PROCEEDS RESULTING FROM FIRE DAMAGE TO PROPERTY COVERED BY PROPERTY INSURANCE. 1:14:35
Representative Bob Johnson introduced HB 1840, describing it as a bill that would require insurers to retain 10 % of fire-damage proceeds until the property lot is cleaned up, a practice intended to offset municipal cleanup costs.
[1:14:45][1:15:16][1:15:50]
He noted that the problem affects multiple cities and offered to amend the bill to limit its application to first-class, second-class, and incorporated towns.
[1:16:32][1:16:53][1:17:08]
Ryan James, the Insurance Department’s public information officer, testified that the bill conflicts with existing policy law (2288-101), would impose an arbitrary hold-back on total-loss claims, effectively turn insurers into code-enforcement agents, and increase paperwork and filings.
[1:19:51][1:20:05][1:20:35][1:21:12]
After hearing the testimony, Representative Johnson opted to withdraw the bill for further study and consider re-introducing it in the next session.
[1:21:42][1:21:48][1:21:58][1:22:06]
Ladies and gentlemen, the first bill on our agenda today is House Bill 2048, Representative Rushing, you're recognized to present House Bill 2048, if you would like to do that at
Representative Rushing, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And for Les Warren, Representative Warren's sake, it's House Bill 2048. He's over here asking, so. This is just a mortgage lien protection policy, and it is raising the amount of protection from $100,000 to $250,000, and it just goes into what the federal law now allows, and it's for a secondary loan, for like a home equity loan or a line of credit on a piece of property that you already own. All right. Representative Rushing has
explained the bill. Are there any questions from the committee? Seeing none, is there anyone here to speak against the bill? For the bill. Representative Rushing, would you like to close for your bill? I am closed for my bill. What is the will of the committee? Representative Lowry, moves do pass. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Rushing. passed your bill. Thank you, and thank you, committee. The next bill on our agenda is House Bill 2102. Representative Lemons, are you here to present House Bill 2102? Representative Lemons, are you here to present House Bill 2102? The next bill on our agenda is House Bill 2193. Representative Representative Hammer, are you here to present House Bill 2193? Representative Hammer. The next bill on our agenda is House Bill 2212. Representative McGee, are you here to present House Bill 2212? The next bill on our agenda, House Bill 1840. Representative Johnson, are you here to present House Bill 1840? Representative Johnson. The next bill on our agenda is House Bill 1900, Representative Bentley, are you here? Representative Bentley, are you here to present House Bill 1900? The next bill on our agenda is House Bill 1958, Representative Gray, are you here to present House Bill 1958? Representative Gray. The next bill on our agenda is House Bill 2054, Representative Hammer, are you here to present House Bill 2054. Representative Hammer, are you here to present House Bill 2061? Representative Hammer. The next bill on our agenda is House Bill 2135. Representative Sabin, are you here to present House Bill 2135? The next bill on our agenda is House House Bill 2251, Representative Gassaway. Are you here to present House Bill 2251, Representative Gassaway? The next bill on our agenda is Senate Bill 498. I'm going to present that. Representative Lowry, would you be willing to come up and be the chairperson while I I present Senate Bill 498.
committee. And what I'm going to do is I'm going to let David Ivers introduce himself and who he's with, and then I'm going to turn it over to him to present Senate
Bill 498. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. We have David Ivers with Mitchell Blackstock Firm, and we worked with Senator Irvin in drafting Senate Bill 498. What the bill does is what we're calling a clean-up, a couple issues that arose after the passage of Act 902 in 2015. What Act 902 says is it deals with the episodes of care under the Arkansas Health Payment Improvement Initiative. And so if you have providers such as physicians in hospitals in an episode of care and at the end of the period the payer determines whether they have met, exceeded or not met their savings targets, then the payer penalizes or rewards the providers based on their performance. So if they did not meet, for instance, they exceeded their benchmark in terms of costs over the episode, then the payer will penalize the provider based on how much they went under the benchmark. So what happened is that we found out a number of physicians are being penalized based not on anything they could control in terms of the episode of care, but based on some contracts that were negotiated between the payers and the hospitals. So what Act 902 said is if it's not within the physician's control, then you can't penalize the physician for it. So then this bill simply amends that act to do a couple things. One is to say that the provisions of the act that were passed in 2015 cannot be waived by contract. In other words, a health care insurer defined as a payer in the bill cannot require that in order to be part of our participating provider network, you have to waive the protections of the act. And then the second thing it does is who can enforce it. And the insurance department or a physician who's been penalized in violation of the act could enforce it. And that's the two things that it does. Members,
Eves? This is probably a dumb question, and it likely won't be my last one, but why is Pulaski County Circuit Court listed first? On the very bottom of the second page, I
guess it is. These things we just are talking about on the enforcement part? Correct. is because we just borrowed from the Administrative Procedure Act on that part as to where it could be enforced. It really has no special significance about first or second or anything like that. It could be where the physician resides or it could be in Pulaski County. We just borrowed it from the Administrative Procedure Act. Thanks.
Any other questions, members? is there anyone in the audience here to speak for or against the bill seeing none we have a motion from representative payton of do pass all those in favor say aye all those opposed say no your bill passes thank you very much mr. chair and committee
What we're going to do without objection is move back up to House Bill 1900. Representative Bentley, you're recognized to present House Bill 1900. And we have an amendment for House Bill 1900. So Carol is getting that amendment ready now. Representative Bentley, if you're ready, you can present your amendment for adoption, as well as have the guest at the end of the table introduce herself and who she's with. Will do. Thank
you, Chairman. Thank you, committee. I appreciate the time this morning. The amendment of this bill simply takes Medicaid out of the bill. We have colleagues that are working with Medicaid trying to accomplish the same thing through rules. So at this point, at the request of DHS, I'm taking Medicaid off of the bill because, like I said, they're trying to do the same thing, another route through rules, and we don't really need them on this bill. So that's what the amendment is, and I'll let my esteemed colleague
Arkansas Children's Hospital. All right, members, we've heard a presentation on the amendment. Are there any questions on the amendment? Seeing none, is there anyone here to speak against the amendment, for the amendment? Representative Bentley, would you like to close for your amendment? I have. Thank you. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Henderson? The motion do pass. Representative Henderson moves that we adopt the amendment. Any discussion on the motion? All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Bentley. The amendment is adopted. You're now recognized to present the bill as
amended. Thank you so much, Chairman and colleagues. We'll bring forward to you a bill today that will help constituents in our state to be able to stay healthy, stay out of the ER, and actually, I believe, will definitely help us save costs in the long run. I'm going to let our nutritionists hear from Children's Hospital. I had the opportunity to work at Children's for 14 years. And I know all of you know that nutritionists over there are a key element for those kids to do well. So I'll let her explain what
we're wanting to do here today, and we'll answer questions. Thank you. Expanded newborn screening finds infants that have rare metabolic conditions that can be treated. With treatment, these children become adults that can lead full and productive lives. Without treatment, very vast things can happen. Many of them have long-term consequences, and some have short-term consequences. that will end them in the emergency room in the ICU. So what we are wanting to do is to provide coverage at the beginning of the diagnosis and throughout their lifetime through these rare metabolic food products, formulas that are by prescription only, that must be administered under the direction of licensed health care practitioners and dietitians. One of these products given to the wrong child could end that child in an emergency room or in an ICU, or even worse. So we do these rare diseases that many people have never heard about, and we are trying desperately to keep these children healthy and able to live long and productive lives. Without the products, again, these children will end up in the ICU. They will have very expensive health care needs throughout their lifetime. The most predominant and prevalent of the disorders that we're talking about is phenylketonuria, PKU, and you may have heard of that one. and it affects about one in every 14,000 live births in Arkansas. And with PKU, the danger of non-treatment is a profound mental incapacity. With good treatment, these children go to college. They become productive members of our society. Without treatment, and most, we have success in finding treatment for them up until they are in their teen years. When they become adults, treatment goes away. The insurances have not been providing treatment for our adults. Those adults are ending up in psychiatric wards of the hospitals and are costing somebody a lot of money because the primary problem is not being treated. Their PKU is affecting their brain. It is a, phenylalanine is a toxic component to the brain, and they cannot function as healthy adults and develop profound symptoms and, like I said, end up in the psychiatric wards of hospitals for extended stays. They end up in jail. And so we're simply wanting to be able to provide coverage for these patients throughout their lifetime to keep them healthy and productive members of society. This affects roughly 100 patients in Arkansas right now, and that is if we pull all of our patients out of the woodwork and provide coverage. This pulls out patients that have lost coverage, that are not on coverage now. Um, if we, uh, and then as we continue to have newborn screening in the state, we continue to bring these children and, um, want to keep them healthy. And I just want to give a brief overview. The
reason that we're, we're bringing this forth right now, um, this is, if you're a state employee, this is covered. Uh, if you're on Medicaid, Medicaid A, this is covered. So we have the group of folks that are working, that are paying for their own insurance, but unfortunately it's not covered. And it can cost these folks up to $10,000, $20,000 a year for this formula. It's just not something cheap. They just can't afford it. We have people that are leaving the state and going to states where it is covered because they cannot afford to be here. So we have that documented as well. So we simply want, whether it's through a GT tube or my mouth, for this formula that has to have a prescription in order for the patient to receive it to be able to get that formula covered through their insurance, just like you would get any other prescription covered. We want this prescription covered as well. I think it's 17 other states have passed this. Something like that. Yeah. And I'm sorry, Dr. Shaver could not be here right now from Children's, but at this present time, 17 other states have passed this. And I think it's, in the long run, we'll save us money if we can keep our Kansans healthy and active and not with brain damage. Okay. Any questions you guys have?
We're talking about for life, for infants, toddlers, children, adults. The metabolic conditions do not go away. They're a lifetime diagnosis. But the bill does not
it's just the formula. It's not the food that they would buy groceries. Right. It is not groceries. And to be clear, these patients with the disorders of protein metabolism, because this bill covers other metabolic diseases that are not protein metabolism, it also affects some fatty acid oxidation disorders. But within the protein disorders, those patients do need low-protein foods that are purchased from specialty food products. But at this time, we have other coverage for that with some of our patients. May I ask a follow-up? I guess I'm trying to figure out, are we talking about things like celiacs as
Just to follow up on that, I was initially picturing this only affecting infants, toddlers, but you still say it only affects 100 people in the state of Arkansas roughly right
now? Right now, I looked at our numbers this morning, and at Arkansas Children's Hospital right now we're treating around 70 patients, again, through Arkansas Children's Hospital, that have inborn errors of metabolism that need a special formula like this. There are a few at UAMS as well. I do not have UAMS's numbers. Dr. Schaefer was going to have that. But knowing, because those patients used to be my patients, just knowing who's there and knowing who has had insurance in the past and who hasn't, I cannot imagine that it would be more than 30 people there. So under 100 persons in Arkansas right now that we're talking about. However, there are, again, those patients out there that we do not know where they are. They've fallen through the cracks. They have not been treated for 20 years, and they're the ones that are showing up in the jails and the psychiatric wards that we get random phone calls for. So there may be up to 20 of those out there, too.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. So does the health department already have the appropriation to provide that $1,000 reimbursement if the patient exceeds that $2,400 tax credit? Is that money already appropriated?
that question, but I believe that money is in a fund that is with the newborn screening program. That's what it looks like. I just wanted to clarify. The
questions from the committee? Seeing none, is there anyone here to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Bentley, would you like to close for your bill?
Colleagues, I appreciate the time, and I know that we don't like to add unnecessary cost to insurance, but I think in the long run, this is something that will definitely decrease costs. because it will keep patients healthy and not with brain damage. So I would appreciate
a good vote. Thank you. Representative Hodge, is you recognized? We've got a do pass as amended recommendation motion. Is there any discussion on the motion? If not, all in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Bentley.
Colleagues, thank you very much. I appreciate your time this morning. The next bill on our agenda is House Bill 1271, Representative Hammer. Are you here for 1271, Representative Hammer? The next bill on our agenda is House Bill 2209, Representative Gray. Are you here for 2209, Representative Gray? The next bill on our agenda is Senate Bill 683. That's Senator Sanders' bill. Is there someone here to present Senate Bill 683 for Senator Sanders? The next bill on our agenda is House Bill 1753. I'm going to turn the chair over to Representative Lowry, and I'm going to present an amendment first, and then 1753.
asking Mr. Harriman to come up and introduce himself again as we get ready to present this amendment. What I'm going to do is just give some background to kind of level set us and then turn it over to Mr. Harriman to talk through the amendment. So as I'm sure you recall, a couple weeks ago we presented this bill with a goal of preventing double benefits for one thing. So if somebody had medical coming out of a claim, then the insurance company would pay the medical for example and then in a judgment the person would receive money to cover that same claim in effect having the potential to have that happen twice there were several concerns about that expressed by members of the committee one of the concerns which I thought was especially salient is well what if somebody is in a scenario where perhaps they're underinsured now all of a sudden you know they wind up in in what could almost be conceived a negative situation. Anyway, some of you on this committee, particularly Representative Maddox, was very involved in working up this amendment, and I believe it's a pretty good solution to that so that we can be fair to all involved. So what I'm going to do is turn it over to Mr. Harriman to explain the amendment and how it significantly changes the bill, and then hopefully we can adopt
and you're free. Yes, Mr. Chair, and thank you again. My name is Morrill Harriman. I'm an attorney with the Mitchell-Williams firm here in Little Rock, Arkansas. I'd like to start with somewhat echoing what Representative Collins said. I would like to personally give my thanks to Representative Maddox. He's worked very diligently with us to resolve some issues and problems that several of the members had. Mr. Payton, Mr. Armstrong, Mr. Chair, you actually had concerns. about uh the bill as well and i will i will try to be fairly brief and succinct as representative collins said there was there were some problems with a situation where assume a person was injured by under insured driver whatever the situation that caused the injuries there was a possibility we think it was remote but there certainly was a possibility that under the bill as it was presented last time the insurer the insurance company could have possibly received all of the proceeds from the third party wrongdoer and the injured party would not have received any proceeds in doing research on the matter Texas has adopted somewhat a proportional statute in that situation and we think it will work well here in Arkansas and that's the amendment that representative Collins has just presented best way to give you an example let's assume again that there is a situation the motorist has 25,000 minimum coverage there's 50,000 in medical bills so the coverage is not going to pay those even though the insurance medical coverage may have paid that entire 50 thousand dollars they will only be with they will only be allowed to recover half of the 25,000 liability coverage from the third party wrongdoer in other words the person that was injured gets half the insurance company gets half another situation there's 25,000 coverage there's 5,000 medical I could
just interrupt just to make sure that I signify the difference in your example between the bill as originally presented and the bill as it would as this amendment would change it in the original presentation given that the insured's total receipt was less than the medical costs in that situation the insured would walk away with nothing in the new version in the example that you used given the proportionality, it would be half for the medical bills and half for the insured. Even though the insurance company is nowhere near the full $50,000 they paid for the medical bills, this would still be a fair situation from the standpoint of making sure that the person that was injured walked away with something, even though the medical bills were more than the total damage. And then there's a proportionality scale in here based on the amounts and the particular situation. so that the insured never walks away with nothing. Is that an accurate statement?
That would be an accurate statement. It's a good situation. The only time that the insurance company would basically get what we call wholly made whole, again, the situation, there's $25,000 of liability insurance. There's only $5,000 of medical that the company had paid. Yes, they get their $5,000 back, but the injured party gets $20,000 in that situation. And that's a pretty brief explanation, but that's basically what the bill does, and I will be glad to answer any questions on the bill itself. Members, you've heard the bill. I know that
Mr. Vice Chair Lowry. Mr. Ehrman, Representative Collins, we asked this question, I think, Representative Farrar specifically. Could you backtrack this a little bit? What's currently already being done, and what does this do to change what we're trying to implement? Is this already
in some way? You currently have a lot of situations where the subrogation, to be honest, Representative Armstrong, is agreed to at the time of the settlement itself. You have the situation where basically there are liens filed against the proceeds that are obtained from the judgment which the attorneys for the claimant, the injured party, must recognize and pay those. What we actually think this will do, and it's actually been the case in Texas, is this gives a much more streamlined, sure, and definite understanding of who is able to recover what. But in that situation where there is an underinsured, we hope that's a situation that, you know, doesn't come up all the time, but it does come up. It arises. And if it does, we now have a definite statutory formula as who receives what amount of the proceeds.
so now if the insurance company is going to get to receive half of the settlement, would the insuree, would they be able to get half of the premiums they paid back over the years? No, sir. They would not. That answers
my question. And just to make sure that when we talk about half the settlement, it all depends on the particular. So an insurance company would have the settlement in a scenario where, let's say, they paid $50,000 in medical bills, but then the jury award or the judgment was for something noticeably less than that. We're talking about $25,000 in this example. So the insurance company has paid $50,000 in medical bills, and then the award is $25,000. So under the way the bill was originally presented, since $25,000 is less than $50,000, the insurance company would have got all 25, the person that was injured would get nothing, and the insurance company still is out an extra 25K. In this rendition, the insurance company would get 12.5, so they're now out 37.5, but the person that was injured would get 12.5, so he or she would still get some of that award so that we don't have a scenario where a person goes through this injury process and due to the fact that their medical bills were more than the award, they wind up with nothing, which was what so many people had expressed concerns about. And it's not just a half. There's a formula in here based on what the numbers are, so it's not just arbitrarily one half, but it's more rateable than that based on the specifics of the situation. This is where Representative Maddox, his insights were helpful. We have a question now from Representative Payton. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. So I'm quite sure I prefer the amendment, but just to be clear, the attorneys always get paid and made whole first before anybody else. So if the insurance company is getting half and the attorney gets half, that still leaves the claimant with zero. Can you explain how the attorney fees and court costs and all of the things like that
are going to affect the settlement? Yes, sir. Actually, there is language in the amendment that also covers the situation where an attorney attorney is present and, again, where you have an underinsured situation. In that case, the insurance company is only allowed to recover one-third at a maximum, again assuming an underinsured situation. The injured party is allowed to recover a third, and the attorney is allowed to recover up to one-third of the settlement proceeds. In that situation, there's, again, a proportional payout of the proceeds from the settlement itself. The amendment in front of you, Mr. Payton, specifically sets
still have several questions. Representative Murdock. Thank you, Chairman. So along these same lines, and I do appreciate Mr. Harriman for talking with me offline on this and helping me with this and some others, I still have the fundamental problem that the little guy in this equation is the guy that's at risk, most at risk, and seems to be, in my opinion, he's the creator of this in that he's paying the premium, he or she is paying the premium. And then they're paying the premium for in case something happens. Then when something happens, they are now put into this quandary of how they get made whole. And they have to be sophisticated enough. They have to go and get an attorney possibly to deal with a third party part of this. And everybody else that's involved becomes okay. So I just have a fundamental problem with the legislation that's being created to seem to protect the insurance company and make sure that they get what they need to get, or they get some level of fiscal satisfaction. So my concern is, as we look out for the speechless in this particular case, those that we represent, I think that I think I like the amendment, although it's six pages, I haven't read all of it. But it seems like the amendment is a little better than where we were. But still, I think it falls short of the threshold of making it a good piece of legislation for the one part of the equation that we really need to be trying to help. You know, the insurance companies are the big boys here, and attorneys are, you know, They're okay, but it seems to put too much responsibility and too much risk with the insured. I would submit
to you that one of the challenges whenever we're looking at these things is where are the leakages? And I would submit, Representative Murdoch, that when people write insurance for driving, for example, They're rating all the risks associated with the potential you're going to crash, that there's going to be bad weather that's going to make crashes more likely, and the value of the car is going to be a certain thing, and all of those factors. I'm not sure when insurance companies are setting insurance rates that they're pricing in a double benefit to X percentage of people that are receiving money from the insurance company for something and then also receiving it again in a separate situation. So the reality is insurance premiums, if this goes in place, should reflect that. And if it doesn't go in place, it should reflect that. And the insurance premiums for everybody in the state of Arkansas will see an effect one way or the other. Now, it's true somebody might say, well, gosh, why wouldn't the insurance company just pocket as much money as they possibly can? And I would submit to you that they do. They're just like you, they're just like me, and they're just like everybody else. They'll pocket every last nickel they can get. But the problem is there's another insurance company that will see inordinately high profits in the insurance market in Arkansas, and they will race in here and undercut the price so that they can make a good profit but not an over-the-top profit until you wind up with insurance rates that reflect the actual costs of insurance people, insuring people, plus a normal profit. it. So I would submit to you that the little guy and the little gal that we're helping are all of the people that are paying insurance costs every day. They're truly silent and they truly have nobody because for them it may be $20 a year, $40 a year. So the odds that they're going to write each one of us a letter and things of that nature are very low. But the truth is those million paper cuts are the reason, in my view, one of the reasons that it's so tough for us to move off the bottom in so many arenas because we've got so many of these types of things that add $20 a month here or $20 a year there. So I hear you on the little person, and I believe this actually helps
the little people of Arkansas. Well, and if I can, please, well, and that's, and we're probably conceptually different on this in that, you know, the concept that the big guy, when they're enriched and they make it better for the smaller guy in terms of whether it's a trickle-down economics or in this particular case, trickle-down policy or premium reduction at the end of the day. And I don't know that I agree with that concept at all. I think rich get richer, and they continue to enrich those that are on their team. So in this particular case, I think if we do the opposite of that, Chairman, then we make sure we take care of those that we're concerned about because they pay the premiums. And then what this bill is saying is that if there's a third party involved, when those dollars are realized, then that money is going to be used to go back and make the people they paid the premiums to whole or a percentage of whole. And that's on the small guy. And the small guy shouldn't be in that fight. The small guy paid the premium out of his meager earnings, he or she's meager earnings, then they should realize the benefit from that at the time of occurrence of an accident. So the made whole part for the insurance company should be a matter of them going and taking care of that business themselves.
about insurance premiums, the insurance premiums that I pay are not with the expectation that I'm going to pay X dollars a month and I'm going to collect $1 million in insurance payments. The insurance premiums I pay plus the insurance premiums you pay plus the insurance premiums of everybody else, as you know, create a risk pool. And the money that flows out of that risk pool to any one of us, God forbid we should have a tragedy. I had a neighbor that was in a car crash yesterday. She's having surgery today on her spine in the hopes that they'll be able to save the use of her legs. So obviously these are tragic scenarios. And that insurance pool, when it pays out money, has to raise rates on everybody. So this is not about one individual little guy or one individual little gal. This is about all of the little guys and all of the little gals that are paying into this pool and making sure that we're looking out for and taking care of all of them, not just the ones in the accidents that may be in a situation where they can get paid twice for the same action. And that's all that this does. And now that we've got this amendment, I believe we're making sure that that individual is not going to be left with no cash coming out of a settlement, even if his insurance was not enough to cover the actual medical benefits. It seems like it's the right balance to me, sir.
cover that as well. I guess my only other question, and I am not an attorney, and I know very little about personal injury, so I'm kind of struggling with this. It seems like a really, really long amendment. Are the people who would be opposed to this, have they seen the amendment for this morning?
I can only surmise that possibly they have. Again, we tried to get Representative Maddox. In fact, I think we did furnish him with the amendment last Friday so they would have the weekend to look over it. The only thing we have done since then, there were some technical errors which we have corrected within the amendment itself. But, no, we have tried to make sure that other committee members have certainly seen the amendment before just bringing it here today. Let
me clarify for members. We do have someone signed up to speak against the bill, and since the amendment is so substantive, we'll allow them to speak against the amendment. when that time comes, if they so choose. Representative Eves, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr.
Chairman. Representative Collins, you see things from a 30,000-foot viewpoint that maybe I can't get to yet, and I'm probably not as smart as you as far as insurance and things go, and I'm trying to understand what we're doing here. I kind of think I get it, but in the example you gave earlier about the $50,000 in medical bills and then an award of $25,000, why would the injured party not get all of the $25,000 that was being awarded? Or did I misunderstand? So let's say you
go to a jury and you say, I was injured. And then they say, well, what do you mean you were injured? And you say, I had $50,000 in medical bills. And the jury says, well, you know what? We think that since you did this, that, or the other, whatever reason they come up with, that we're going to give you $25,000 against your $50,000 in medical benefits, right? I'm making this specific example. It could be very different. They could say, I'm going to give you $25,000 in medical benefits, and I'm going to give you $200,000 in pain and suffering or whatever else they might say. But let's just use that as an example. The insurance company has already spent $50,000 on your medical benefits. So the insurance company has spent $50,000 to fix you up. The jury just said, I'm giving $25,000 to fix you up. You've now been paid $50,000 by the insurance company to fix you up, where they actually fixed up your literal medical benefits. And then the jury just said, here's $25,000 to do the same thing. So the way the bill was originally written, since the $25,000 is less than the $50,000, then the insurance company gets the whole $25,000. The way the bill is written today, the person would get half of it, even though they're still far and away below paying off the medical benefits. So the concept is you're just not allowed to collect twice for the same thing. The jury doesn't say, hey, we're going to give you $25,000 for the medical benefits. Since the insurance company has already paid that, we're going to count that as the benefit. What's been happening is people have been getting these things twice. And that's what this is trying to reduce. And when you pay people for things twice, what happens is you wind up raising everybody's insurance rates. And that's when people talk about what is the legal climate in a given state look like and why do businesses not say, I can't wait to go there. It's these kind of double jeopardies, and we have them in
Arkansas. Okay, thanks. That clears it up a lot. And to use your example of the injured party being paid twice, would the insurance company now be being paid twice as a result of receiving premiums and now also getting part of this
settlement? The premiums are based on an absolute risk pool. So what happens is in Arkansas, if somebody says, because it's Arkansas, whenever you write driver's insurance because of the laws in Arkansas, the way people drive, the condition of the roads, their tort system, and all these other things, we're going to make you pay for a 45-year-old driver with no points who's driving a brand-new Lexus X dollars per month, and that's your insurance bill, and everybody gets those bills every six months. I've never heard anybody say, doggone it, my insurance rates are so low, I can't even believe it, right? This is one of the reasons they're not lower, and what happens is when you have to price in double benefits for folks, then the insurance rates have to go up. So what will happen here is, to the extent this is prevalent, right, and I'm not enough of an expert to say this is going on to the tune of $50 million a year or $10 million a year or $1 million a year, our insurance rates reflect that. And what will happen is, to whatever extent that's going on, insurance companies will compete and bid down insurance rates, and that's essentially what the outcome would be.
go down? I can guarantee that they will be less than they would otherwise be if this bill did not. That is a guarantee. Thank you. Representative Rushing, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just have one question. On page two, on the amendment, it says on page two, delete line 29 and substitute the following. And then in that, if you flip the page on the amendment, the number two, it says this subsection does not apply to any claim for property or material damages. And you just said that a few minutes ago that it would take care of material damages such as a car or something, but maybe this is referring to something different. I just need a little bit of an explanation of what the difference is.
And that's a fair question. and amendments are tough to read, and the reason that the bill actually and the amendment are so long is there are two different really parts of the bill, one covering medical injury, one covering property. And what you're going to see is a lot of repeats, so one basically will cover property, one aspect of it will cover medical, but that is a confusing part of the amendment. There are two different sections.
Representative Rushing, do you have a follow-up? Representative Murdoch, I believe you were wanting to ask another question. Okay, you'll save it. Any other questions, members? As I mentioned, since the amendment is substantive, if the person who signed up to speak, who is Mr. Jesse Gibson, wants to speak against the amendment, he may do so at this point.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Again, my name is Jesse. Yes, go ahead. Sir. My name is Jesse Gibson. I'm a solo practitioner here in Little Rock, and I handle a lot of personal injury cases, but I also handle commercial litigation, represent some small businesses. Last week, I drafted a wheel on a trust, so I wear a lot of hats, and I understand that as an attorney who handles a lot of personal injury cases, I might be as popular as a skunk at a picnic, But I think in this particular instance, I've got some insight, because after listening to the questions, both this time and the first time this bill ran, I think a lot of your instincts are correct. I'm here to speak for the little guy, people that don't have someone to represent their interest at the Capitol, because I do think there's going to be some winners and some losers if this bill becomes law. So I want to start out by saying that I can understand this matter is quite complex because you have an intersection between centuries-old concepts of made whole, subrogation, and equity, and how they interact with the Arkansas Insurance Code, which is by comparison very new. But it really, a complicated situation like that boils down to very simple values judgment, and I can tell by your questions you've put your finger directly on it. Because what the citizens of Arkansas do when they buy insurance and they put their cash on the barrel head is they're, and it gets lost sometimes, but they're paying for a promise. It's not just a theoretical exchange. There is a consideration that's exchanged, money on the form of premiums, and a promise that if the what if happens, if something bad would occur, we will be there to pay up to the policy limits to you for your benefit. Now, what we have here is you have a value judgment. Is it more important that the insurance company can get your premiums and then reach over here and get your money back, or is it more important for the individual, the small person, actually everyone in this room, could be made whole for what could be a serious injury? And it's really that simple. Which side do we come down on, and you'll say so with your vote? Now the question or the issue I've seen raised a couple times is about this double dip. Let me assure you, that does not happen. And the reason that does not happen is that the made whole doctrine specifically prevents it. You get one recovery. So when you hear this double dip argument, let me just inform you, you can't get away from the preamble to this bill where it says it wants to overturn the case of Ryder versus State Farm. That case, which came out 10 years ago, was about PIP benefits or MedPay benefits, a $5,000 no fault policy. This is mentioned in the text of the bill, not to be codified, but it stares you right in the face. In that case, State Farm was wanting to get back these benefits, these $5,000 no-fault benefits that their insureds had paid for if they had the audacity to file a third-party claim. And the court said no. But here's a mechanism that you can use to prove made whole. It gave them the outline of how to do that. You file a simple motion, and you ask the court for a made whole ruling. Point of order, please. Are we
Okay. We have a motion to pass on the amendment. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed say no. No. The amendment is adopted. You are now free to present the bill as amended.
Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. So obviously we've just talked between the prior discussion and this discussion. We've talked through how this will help make our state more job-friendly by taking and moving us toward a scenario where we are lowering the cost burden on individuals from an insurance standpoint. And we're doing it in what I believe is a fair and measured way. Uh, the, the reason I say that is because when somebody is in an injured situation and they get a, uh, an award, a judgment, the, the award is allocated in such a way that they're not going to be getting, uh, paid two times for the same thing, but we're doing it with this amendment in such a way that that is not going to negatively impact an individual who may be uninsured, i.e. purposefully or not purposely, chose to underinsure himself and not pay the level of premiums that are required for the level of coverage that that individual needed for this particular situation. That's really the scenario that we're talking about where an individual is going to get some fraction where in the original bill they wouldn't get any. The second thing that I would emphasize is there's no such thing as free money. As the gentleman that just spoke said, there are winners and losers. Winners and losers come from a point in time. You are in a point and you're winning or you're in a point and you're losing. And I would just submit to you that for too long, we've insisted that the little guy in the little gal in Arkansas is put under a burden of a system that is keeping him or her from doing the things he or she was created to do because there's absolutely no reason for Arkansas to be last or near last in nearly every important quality of life measure. There's no reason for us to be near last in median income. And things like this that unfairly push costs onto insured individuals make paying for your insurance more expensive than it would otherwise be. I think this is a step in the right direction, and I'd appreciate your support. We have a question from Representative Payton. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
And Representative Collins, you may need Mr. Harriman back at the table to help answer this. As I said, I prefer the amendment. That doesn't mean I don't still have some concerns. One thing I think we've failed to address is if I'm that injured person and I chose to pay a higher insurance premium to include uninsured, underinsured coverage so that if I was damaged by somebody who was underinsured, I've paid a higher premium already to protect me from that. How does this bill, as amended, affect that situation? I have to
agree with Representative Collins. The way that it should affect it and the way that I truly believe it will affect it is that underinsured premium that you are now paying should at least remain steady or drop or not see as big an increase in the future. For the underinsured coverage right now in Arkansas, there is no chance whatsoever for particularly any subrogation claim. And the gentleman speaking on the amendment is right. The made-whole doctrine has been out there for the last 10 years. I challenge anyone in this room to find a court that's allowed subrogation to take place
these limitations we're putting on the insured's ability to be made whole will still affect his ability to be made whole even if he paid a higher premium by electing to get the uninsured, underinsured coverage. And I wanted to make sure and get this out there so the gentleman speaking against the bill would have an opportunity to address this. So I want to make sure you address this wholly because he's going to be coming back to the table to speak against the bill. And if I'm choosing to pay a higher premium to cover me from an underinsured person, this bill still restricts my ability to be made whole?
The thing that we talked about when we use these different examples is somebody's insured to a limit, $300,000, $100,000, or whatever the limits are. As you know and I know, we have different limits that we can choose to insure itself up to. The insurance department has a minimum limit that we must insure ourselves up to, and then there are higher limits that we can choose to insure ourselves. And then there are, of course, people that violate the law and do not have insurance at all. So there are all these different scenarios. The particular element of the insurance policy, whichever line that is out of the dozen lines that have different amounts associated with them that you're pointing out, I believe, is a mandatory, almost an add-on, for anyone that has an insurance policy in Arkansas, if I'm not mistaken. Everybody has to have an uninsured motorist coverage. No, it's an elective. No, is it? No. Okay. So what you're saying is if you don't have uninsured motorist coverage, that's not a mandatory element of the coverage that we have here? Okay.
If I could follow up, that's correct. When I buy an insurance policy, I choose to pay a higher premium if I want to be covered in the situation I'm damaged by underinsured or uninsured. Just like
you choose different limits along the way? Yes. You're saying, if I choose that limit versus higher limits for liability versus these other things, how does that vary based on how much insurance that I've chosen to pay for, right? Is that the question?
that situation. Yeah, I don't think it waives the coverage. It certainly wouldn't waive your coverage. And again, Mr. Payton, you are certainly paying for un- or underinsured. You are, to some extent, making sure that you've got an umbrella coverage in the situation whereby if I hit your vehicle and I've got $25,000 coverage, you've got $150,000 in damages, then certainly there is no chance whatsoever that that $25,000 coverage is going to make you whole. Therefore, your underinsured then picks up with that risk, and they insure you up to that amount for an additional $125,000. You are paying for the additional risk of an underinsured motorist causing you damages in excess of the minimum $25,000 coverage. Yes, sir, you're paying for that risk, but again, they're going to pay you in return for your premium payments should that situation arise.
That does help. Representative Payton, you've had several follow-ups. I don't have anyone else, but I want to make sure everyone gets a free opportunity. I will come back to you if you'd like. Anyone else have questions? Okay. Representative Payton indicates that he's through with his questioning. I believe at this point we can take testimony from anyone who is against, wishes to speak against the bill. I apologize for going out of
turn. I was trying to follow the instructions from Representative Lowry. To answer Representative Payton's question, Mr. Harriman said that it would not waive your coverage, but it sure would change who gets it. If you're paying for UIM coverage, and I've not seen all the amendments, but what it will would change who gets it. If you want to pay an additional amount of money for not only underinsured, which the table is correct, it is not required to have underinsured or uninsured. It does change who gets it. It won't be you if the medical bills are substantial enough. If you buy that higher coverage, it'll go to the insurance company if they have a subrogation claim. Now, to one of Mr. Harriman's claims that in the last 10 years, there's been no court award a subrogation, there's a really important separation to make there. The Rider court said, here's the procedure, insurance company, if you want to make a subrogation claim, file a simple motion and bring it before the trial court, and they'll make a determination. And in the 10 years since that case, I've handled a lot of personal injury cases. Do you know how many times insurance companies have filed those claims? Zero. Do you know how many cases from courts of record in the Court of Appeals or the Supreme Court that have addressed this issue where they've attempted that? Zero. Water cooler talk? Is there any people that I know that have ever had one of those? Zero. The procedure is there. It's always been there. So if there is any way to do this, it's already been there. So what they're wanting to do with this bill is, in effect, jump to the front of the line. You have a basket of damages, right? It could be mental anguish, pain and suffering, lost income, all these things that make up your basket of damages. What they're wanting to do is if you get any third-party award, we're going to earmark that as to what we paid and get basically a preferential treatment. In a court of law, under the made whole, they can't get that. So let's change the rules. Now, let's talk about double dipping. the real double dip comes from the insurance companies they get your premiums every month that's the first dip they take all of our premiums and they roll them together and invest them in markets make money that's the second dip if you have a third party claim under this bill they'll reach over there and get that money back that's the third dip and oh by the way insured you do that for free you're an indentured servant almost you have to go get their money back that's the the fourth did. So what you have here is it's a windfall of the insurance companies. Now, I know in a lot of these bills, you want to incentivize good behavior and disincentivize bad behavior. And I didn't want to give you examples because I think we get in the weeds a little bit. But here's one I think you need to really think about. I think we'd all agree that having insurance is good. We want everyone to be insured out the wazoo. And having no coverage is bad. It's risky. People can get hurt that way. Let's take two people, Representative Collins and myself, that have the exact same injuries, let's say $100,000 in medical bills, hit by a drunk driver. Representative Collins is a responsible individual and has health insurance, maybe a short-term disability policy, a pit policy. And I am a ne'er-do-well who says, no, I don't need any of that. I'm going to risk it. I'm going to drive and not have any insurance. But we both are hit by a drunk driver with $25,000 limits. Regardless of the amendment, for his responsible behavior, Representative Collins gets less than I do for being irresponsible. So what you're doing is incentivizing someone to be risky and dangerous and penalizing someone who is trying to be responsible. I don't think that's good policy. Now, I said earlier about the PIP case, the State Farm case, that this is trying to overturn. And a lot of times, you know, they're saying in the law, you know, read the darn statute. I think it's helpful in this case, read the darn bill, is to understand that's what it's trying to overturn. Now, it's hard for me to say what the intent of this law is, but I can tell you what the result will be. That case, that State Farm case dealt with those no-fault $5,000 policies. If there's 5,000 of those in the state a year, I don't have to get my calculator. That's $25 million that will flow to the insurance companies from their insured. Now, there are winners and losers, and it won't be the people. And I can sense from a lot of the questions that you can see that. The amendment, as I understand them, I haven't been given a copy of it, nor have any, certainly any insureds. But it's a matter of degree. It's a matter of, it'll be done on the back of the insureds of the state of Arkansas, your constituents. It's just how high up their back we want to let them go. I think it's a bad bill. I think it will hurt people and hurt the least of us, as I even heard Representative Collins say from the chairman's podium last week, that we're here to help people. I don't think this will help people. I think it will hurt them. I'd ask for a
no vote. Members, does anyone have a question for Mr. Gibson? If not, Mr. Gibson, thank you for your testimony. Is there anyone in the audience who would like to speak for this bill? Anyone else to speak against? For? We have a speaker who would like to speak against. Please go to the end of the table and identify yourself. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Thank you, committee members. First of all, I need to make clear that I'm speaking as an individual as opposed to the representative of my employer here. For
yourself with a record. Oh, I'm sorry. I'm Patty Julian. Forgot that part. For a number of years in my life practicing law, I ran the subrogation division for Arkansas's largest health insurer. And as such, I negotiated claims for people who had been injured and received third-party reimbursement for the insurer's subrogation claims. And I will just tell you one case that I think illustrates why this is not a good bill. There was a young man who was the son of our insured who was at the local swimming pool. It had been serviced, and they had neglected to put the grate back over the pump system. The young man's arm was sucked into the pump, and before they could get the pumps turned off and get the child released, he had suffered brain damage. He was to spend the rest of his life on a ventilator. The local pool had about $100,000 in liability insurance. By that time, my employer, the insurance company, had paid about a quarter of a million dollars for this child's care under a policy that had a $1 million limit on it. Under this bill, that family would only have received $50,000 of that settlement, as I understand the amendment. That child was going to require a lifetime of care. His family took him home on a ventilator with no respite care, no nothing. And when they hit the million-dollar limit on their health insurance policy, they were going to suffer devastating economic loss. They'd pay their premiums, they'd done everything they were supposed to, and I grant that this was an unusual but extremely catastrophic case. The made whole rule kept my employer from taking their $100,000 back. And I will tell you that insurance company or no, they knew that was only fair. And I
Julian? Thank you very much for your testimony. Is there anyone else in the audience who would like to speak for the legislation as amended? Anyone wants to speak against? Representative Collins, you are free to close. Thank you very much, Mr.
Chair. So a couple of points I want to make. The first one is that there are no subrogation requests that have been filed with the court since they said we're going to make rules to allow you to file for these subrogation requests. Well, it's a lot like the Fox Garden of Hen House. The rules are such that if you go through the process, it's virtually impossible for them to ever come to fruition. And so that's why nobody has ever filed for those. The example that the gentleman gave about how, you know, he was a ne'er-do-well and I paid all my insurance and maxed out all my payments, and yet, you know, when this all happened, he would get more money than I would, well, that's what the amendment does. So he acted like he didn't understand the amendment or hadn't had a chance to read every jot and tittle of the amendment, but he got the essence of it. That's exactly what the amendment does. Somebody that pays all their insurance and does all those things under the original, you know, if the injury was more than these other pieces, would be paid the amount above and beyond what they'd already received. But if somebody is, in his lingo, a ne'er-do-well and didn't pay anything and hence didn't have any insurance, under the amended version, even that individual with all that bad behavior is still going to get a payout. That's what the amendment does to make sure that if somebody has the misfortune of having some type of an injury, Even if they've done none of the appropriate or proper steps to prepare themselves for those types of things, they're still going to get cash. Here's the bottom line. Here's the bottom line. We take our people, 3 million of them, and we're killing their potential and their future by a death of 1,000 paper cuts. This is the kind of thing that we have in our state that other states don't have to this degree. And it's here, there, it's so many places that makes it very difficult for us to create the kind of burgeoning, good job environment that will really help our future. And I understand there are a lot of people that have a very strong vested interest in keeping the status quo. And I also understand there are a lot of individual cases that we all know of individual tragedies. And it always seems like, it just always seems like there's some big guy out there we ought to stick it to. But the bottom line is when you stick it to the big guy, he or she invariably passes those costs on, 10 cents at a time, $10 at a time, to the rest of our citizens. And that's what's been happening. So with that, I'd appreciate
your support. Members, you've heard the testimony and presentation. What is the desire of the committee? Representative Maddox, you had your hand raised.
entertain a motion. Thank you. Is there a motion from the committee? I move do pass as amended. You have a motion before you do pass as amended. Now would be the time for any discussion. Representative Maddox. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. I just want to briefly say that at the last meeting when this was addressed, I was probably most adamantly opposed to it and had the most questions. So what I did after that is I went and looked at how different states and how each state handles this issue. Some states have the pure, strict, full subrogation. They just get it. So I looked at each one, how it handles it. Texas, I think, had a good model, and that is what this is based off of. It's a compromise. I think it's fair, and I think it's a good bill. Thank you. Thank you. Anyone else wish to
discuss the motion? All right, we'll go to a vote. All those in favor, say aye. All those opposed, say no. Say the ayes have it. We have two hands requesting roll call. We will
Yes. Representative Lowry? Yes. The bill falls short of the needed 11 votes, 9 voting aye, 5 nay. The bill fails. Mr. Chair, I move that we expunge the vote. We have a motion. All those in favor of expunging the vote say aye. Aye. All those opposed say no. No. The motion passes to expunge the vote. Thank you very much, Mr.
Chair. All right, committee, we're going to pick back up on our agenda. We're going to go back to the top and give everybody a chance, another chance. So we have HB 2102, Representative Lemons. There's Representative Lemons here. HB 2193, Representative Hammer. There's Representative Hammer here. HB 2212, Representative McGee. There's Representative McGee here. HB 1840, I see Representative Johnson. Representative Johnson, you're recognized to present. HB 1840.
Thank you, Mr. Chair, committee. I have someone from the Municipal League is supposed to be here, and I'd like to call him up and come and help me. Did I what? Okay, again, thank you, Mr. Chairman, committee. House bill 1840 is a bill dealing with insurance, of course, and It came about a my mayor and I were talking and I had a new roof put on my house this year What what this bill does? Let me explain the bill for what this Bill does it holds 10% of the proceeds of when the house is burned out Until the lot is cleaned up now in your insurance policy It says you're supposed to clean up the lot, but there's no penalty if you don't. So what's happening is cities are having to go in and spend $3,000, $4,000, $5,000, $6,000 to clean up a lot after a house burns down because the owner just takes money to leave. It was a rent house. They don't care anymore, and I don't necessarily blame them for that. But it's a problem in cities, and so my mayor asked me, I brought this bill down here, talking municipal league uh they're on board with it and the idea came from when i had my new roof put on my house they gave me eight thousand dollars and when i put on the roof they gave me eighteen hundred more because i did what i was supposed to do so it's not something that's unheard of an insurance business uh that they hold back a little bit till the job's done so uh with that i would entertain and i'd like for my speaker to to tell me tell y'all what he thinks about the bill Sir, if
be recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Jack Critcher, Arkansas Municipal League, and I have to confess this is not my committee, and Mark Hayes had sent me a text a few minutes ago and said, will you run over to Insurance and Commerce because he had to be somewhere else? But I think Representative Johnson explained the bill accurately, and I don't think there's a whole lot I could add to that. And it's not a problem that's just in Jacksonville, it's in
Little Rock, it's in Fort Smith, it's in Corning. I talked to Blake Johnson, who's probably going to carry it in the Senate for me, and he says, yeah, it's not a major problem here, but, you know, it's something that needs, it's a health hazard when they don't clean it up, and it's a burden to the cities. So I would entertain any questions if I could.
Representative Payton, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. and Representative Johnson, we're not all city dwellers. Correct. And this bill, the way I read it, would affect people other than just inside the city limits. And that was
not in my intent, but I would be happy to amend it and limit it to citizens. And I thought it was in the original one, but limit it to citizens in first class, second class, and incorporated towns. Well, that would help
me. And I'll give you an example. Maybe you could address this a little bit. But, you know, about four years ago, I had a hay barn blow down in a windstorm, and I've got a very minimal settlement out of my insurance company on it. I live on 300 acres, three and a half miles east of nowhere, and I have not cleaned up the hay barn yet because I'm actually robbing tin off of it and boards off of it as I need it to build things. and the roof was laying on top of some hay that it was still sheltering. So I didn't rush to clean it up, but I sure wouldn't have appreciated my insurance company holding back 10% of the, I think it was $2,300 that they paid on the hay barn. So would your bill affect that? I
didn't intend for it to be limited, and it's only fires, but it's supposed to be limited to first-class, second-class, and incorporated towns. So I will make that amendment in there. Thank you. I'd appreciate it. Because in the county, you don't have code enforcers. You don't have people. The county doesn't go tear it down. They don't care that it sits there burned. You can keep burning it until it's all gone, if that's what you choose. And that's the reason people live in the county is they don't want those rules. But in the city, it's becoming a problem. Are there
any other questions from the committee? Seeing none, is there anybody who would like to speak for the bill? Against the bill? Representative Payton? Excuse me. Johnson. Does anybody have any questions from Representative Johnson? Sorry. I knew there was one coming. Representative Johnson, have you talked
we've not gotten to the speaking for and against yet. We're still asking questions, right? We did, but that's okay. Oh, my bad. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Representative Lundstrom, I'm going to shut up and turn the chair back over to you.
Are you speaking for or against? Well, I'm trying to answer your question about the Insurance Department opinion on that. Thank you. Good morning, committee. My name is Ryan James. I'm the Public Information Officer Legislative Liaison with the Insurance Department. The department takes an unfavorable view on this piece of legislation. chiefly being that it is in direct conflict with the valued policy law, which is 2288-101. HB 1840, as written, would require an insurer to hold back an arbitrary 10% of the claim until a new condition is met under current law in the event of a total loss. An insurance company is obligated to pay the liquidated value without condition. This would add a condition to that. Again, total loss. The example that Mr. Johnson, Representative Johnson offered, is not an example of a total loss. So this would change that. We have concerned over the fact that it would potentially turn insurance companies into code enforcers. And we have some issues with that. And, of course, the increase in filings and also the paperwork issue that insurance companies would have to overcome in terms of the forms that they file with us, in terms of reflect the fact that this would add another condition to what their contract normally is in the event of a total loss. Are there any questions for Mr.
Ryan? Seeing none, is there anyone that would like to speak for the bill? Is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill? If not, Representative Johnson, would you like to close for your bill? I
think after hearing this information and this, I would like to maybe just put this on our study and see if we can make it a good bill for next session. Yes, sir. All you need
Interstate. That would be wonderful. All right. Thank you very much, sir. Does the committee think that's a good idea? Great idea. Okay. See, we all agree on something. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. And I certainly tell everyone I didn't ever want to do it. All
right. What I'm going to do is I'm going to make a last call for anyone that had a bill on the agenda today that may be here now that wasn't here earlier. Is there anyone that has a bill that's on the agenda that they would like to present? Seeing none, without objection, we are adjourned.
SPECIAL ORDER OF BUSINESS - Wednesday, March 22, 2017
1:09:55 - 1:03
Representative John Maddox explained that, although he had originally opposed the measure, his review of how other states (notably Texas) handle the issue led him to view the bill as a fair compromise.
[1:10:21][1:10:33]
The vote failed to reach the required 11 ayes (recorded 9 ayes and 5 nays), so the amendment was not adopted.
[1:12:08][1:12:38]
A motion to expunge the vote was made and carried, after which the chair returned to the agenda and listed several pending House bills (HB 2102, HB 2193, HB 2212, HB 1840) for consideration.
[1:12:38][1:13:09][1:13:36][1:13:40]
HB2086 Sabin TO PROTECT THE PROPERTY RIGHTS OF CITIZENS; TO PREVENT THE ABUSE OF THE POWER OF EMINENT DOMAIN BY PRIVATE PIPELINE COMPANIES; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
REGULAR AGENDA Subtitle Sponsor Number
HB2048 Rushing CASUALTY CONCERNING INSURANCE AND COVERAGE LAW TO THE AMEND MORTGAGE LIEN PROTECTION.
HB2102 Lemons CONCERNING THE RESULTING LIABILITY UNDER A WARRANTY DUE TO A BUSINESS NAME CHANGE.
HB2193 Hammer TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING DRIVERS EXCLUDED FROM A MOTOR VEHICLE INSURANCE POLICY; AND TO IMPOSE CRIMINAL LIABILITY ON THE INSURED DRIVER AND THE EXCLUDED DRIVER IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES.
HB2212 Magie TO PROHIBIT THE USE OF AN ALL-PRODUCTS CLAUSE IN A HEALTHCARE PROVIDER CONTRACT; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1840 Johnson CONCERNING THE APPLICATION OF INSURANCE PROCEEDS RESULTING FROM FIRE DAMAGE TO PROPERTY COVERED BY PROPERTY INSURANCE.
1:14:35 - 10:19
Representative Bob Johnson introduced HB 1840, describing it as a bill that would require insurers to retain 10 % of fire-damage proceeds until the property lot is cleaned up, a practice intended to offset municipal cleanup costs.
[1:14:45][1:15:16][1:15:50]
He noted that the problem affects multiple cities and offered to amend the bill to limit its application to first-class, second-class, and incorporated towns.
[1:16:32][1:16:53][1:17:08]
Ryan James, the Insurance Department’s public information officer, testified that the bill conflicts with existing policy law (2288-101), would impose an arbitrary hold-back on total-loss claims, effectively turn insurers into code-enforcement agents, and increase paperwork and filings.
[1:19:51][1:20:05][1:20:35][1:21:12]
After hearing the testimony, Representative Johnson opted to withdraw the bill for further study and consider re-introducing it in the next session.
[1:21:42][1:21:48][1:21:58][1:22:06]
HB1900 Bentley TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING DRIVERS EXCLUDED FROM A MOTOR VEHICLE INSURANCE POLICY; AND TO IMPOSE CRIMINAL LIABILITY ON THE INSURED DRIVER AND THE EXCLUDED DRIVER IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES.
10:19 - 1:58:38226 segments28 speakers
Representative Mary Bentley introduced an amendment to HB 1900 to provide lifetime insurance coverage for prescription-only metabolic formulas needed by patients with rare inborn errors of metabolism, noting the high cost of these products and the potential long-term savings from keeping patients healthy.
[10:20][10:36][11:03][11:11]
HB2054 Hammer TO REPEAL THE ARKANSAS HOUSING TRUST FUND ACT OF 2009.
HB2061 Hammer TO MODERNIZE THE FIRE RATING SYSTEM IN ARKANSAS; AND TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS FIRE RATING BUREAU ACT.
HB2135 Sabin TO CLARIFY THE OBLIGATIONS OF RESIDENTIAL LANDLORDS AND RESIDENTIAL TENANTS; AND TO REQUIRE MINIMUM HABITABILITY STANDARDS FOR TENANTS OF RESIDENTIAL REAL PROPERTY.
HB2251 Gazaway CONCERNING THE PERSONAL INFORMATION PROTECTION ACT; AND TO DEFINE "ENCRYPTION" IN THE PERSONAL INFORMATION PROTECTION ACT.
SB498 Irvin TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "HEALTHCARE PAYOR"; TO PROHIBIT WAIVER OF ALTERNATIVE PAYMENT SYSTEMS BY CONTRACT; TO PROVIDE A LEGAL ENFORCEMENT MECHANISM TO ENFORCE ALTERNATIVE PAYMENT SYSTEMS.
6:23 - 22:1555 segments9 speakers
Speaker 20 (David Ivers) presented Senate Bill 498, explaining that it amends Act 902 to prohibit health-care payors from waiving penalty-protection provisions by contract and to authorize enforcement by the insurance department or penalized physicians.
[6:56][7:10][7:19]
Representative Les Eaves asked why Pulaski County Circuit Court was listed first in the enforcement language, and Speaker 20 clarified that the reference was borrowed from the Administrative Procedure Act and has no substantive significance.
[7:19][7:29][7:32]
After the chair confirmed there were no further questions, a motion to pass the bill was made and adopted unanimously.
[8:01]
HB1271 Hammer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HEALTH INSURANCE INNOVATION ACT OF 2017; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB2209 M. Gray TO CLARIFY THE USE OF AN ALL-PRODUCTS CLAUSE IN A HEALTHCARE PROVIDER CONTRACT.
SB683 D. Sanders TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS HEALTHCARE TRANSPARENCY INITIATIVE ACT OF 2015.
HB1753 Collins TO CLARIFY THAT THE SUBROGATION AND REIMBURSEMENT RIGHTS OF PARTIES TO AN INSURANCE CONTRACT ARE TO BE DEFINED BY THE INSURANCE CONTRACT.
22:15 - 1:22:36182 segments24 speakers
Morrill Harriman, an attorney for the Mitchell-Williams firm, presented the amendment to HB 1753, explaining that it would replace the bill’s original “all-or-nothing” subrogation scheme with a proportional formula that splits third-party settlement proceeds between the insurer, the injured party and, where applicable, the attorney (e.g., the insurer and claimant each receive roughly one-half when medical costs exceed the policy limit).
[23:21][23:37][24:10][24:41][25:17]
Committee members raised a series of questions-Representative Murdoch asked why the injured party would not receive the full award, Representative Payton queried how attorney fees would be treated, and others probed the impact on under-insured coverage-prompting Harriman to clarify that the amendment caps the insurer’s recovery at one-third (or one-half in certain scenarios) and allocates the remaining portions to the claimant and attorney, thereby ensuring the claimant receives some recovery even when the policy is insufficient.
[27:04][27:18][27:24][27:35][27:57][28:31][28:34][28:40][28:55][30:25][30:49][31:22][31:34]
Chair Representative Charlie Collins moved to adopt the amendment, the committee voted “aye” with no recorded opposition, and the amendment was formally adopted, allowing the bill to proceed in its amended form.
[31:34][49:59][50:02][50:10]
HB1751 Cozart TO CLARIFY THE RESPONSIBILITIES OF AN INSURER FOR APPLICATION OF INSURANCE PROCEEDS FOR ROOF REPAIR; AND TO PROVIDE FOR PROPER ALLOWANCES ON A ROOF REPAIR INSURANCE CLAIM.
HB1838 S. Meeks TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE HEALTH SAVINGS ACCOUNTS OF CERTAIN STATE EMPLOYEES.
HB1890 Tucker TO ESTABLISH AN ARKANSAS CROWDFUNDING OPTION; AND TO REGULATE EXEMPTIONS UNDER SECURITIES LAWS.