May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
HB2086 Sabin TO PROTECT THE PROPERTY RIGHTS OF CITIZENS; TO PREVENT THE ABUSE OF THE POWER OF EMINENT DOMAIN BY PRIVATE PIPELINE COMPANIES; AND TO DECLARE AN E… 0:51
Representative Warwick Sabin introduced HB 2086, explaining that it was intended to protect Arkansas landowners from private-pipeline eminent-domain abuse by adding a 30-day notice requirement, requiring both PSC and ADEQ permits, and setting compensation rules for affected property.
[1:04][1:35][2:06][2:37]
HB1753 Collins TO CLARIFY THAT THE SUBROGATION AND REIMBURSEMENT RIGHTS OF PARTIES TO AN INSURANCE CONTRACT ARE TO BE DEFINED BY THE INSURANCE CONTRACT. 2:09:06
All right, members, where you're going to hear special order of business, HB 2086, Representative Saban, are you? Yeah, there you are. If you'll take a seat at the end of the table and recognize yourself, and you are recognized to go. Okay,
Warwick Saban, State Representative, District 33. First of all, I'd just like to begin by thanking the committee for allowing me the accommodation of a special order on this bill. There are quite a few people who wanted to testify and they have to come from quite a distance and take time away from their work and their homes. And so I do appreciate the accommodation. I also wanted to thank Representative Pilkington in particular for co-sponsoring this bill with me. I did bring a similar piece of legislation two years ago and bringing it back now because the issue continues to be relevant. So the The legislation that you have in front of you, obviously, is really about protecting the property rights of citizens, especially in terms of the exercise of eminent domain by private pipeline companies. And I'm going to do pretty much a quick summary of the bill, and then kind of get into sort of the background and the reasons behind it. If you're looking at the legislation, you'll see that Section 1 is really about the purpose of this act, and it mentions specifically that it's intended to empower landowners who are facing the seizure of their private property by a pipeline company using the power of eminent domain. It's also intended to bring accountability to the process by which a pipeline company uses the power of eminent domain to prevent a pipeline company's abuse of the power of eminent domain and ensure that the taking of private property by a pipeline company occurs only to further the public good. And then as you go through the bill, and like I said, I'm going to summarize pretty quickly. Section two is really just to establish that in order to be given the right to exercise eminent domain in the state of Arkansas, a pipeline company must be a natural gas public utility or must be exercising the right of eminent domain in connection with the operation of a common carrier facility. And I worked with the Public Service Commission on this section of the bill. John Bethel is here to answer some technical questions about section two, if that would be helpful to the committee. But moving on to Section 3, it would require pipeline companies to provide 30 days' notice of intent to property owners before exercising eminent domain on private property. Section 4 would require pipeline companies to obtain an order from the Arkansas Public Service Commission and a permit from the Director of the Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality before exercising the right of eminent domain, and it also establishes criteria for each entity to examine and verify before issuing a permit or in order to a pipeline company. And finally, the last section would outline rules for compensation for damage to property surveyed, used for maintenance, or not acquired. And again, I'm sure you all might have questions about the technical parts of the bill. But again, I just want to kind of give you the background of this. You know, obviously, we're aware of the diamond pipeline in particular that's transferring oil across our state. The oil is actually coming from outside of our state, coming from our Oklahoma border, and the intention is to bring it to across to our eastern border on the other side of the Mississippi River where there's a facility in Memphis that I guess will distribute and refine, process the oil. And so it's cutting through a large swath of the state, going through a lot of rural communities, in some cases transmitting across reservoirs and other very important, you know, natural parts of our state. And obviously these are, you know, resources that if they're damaged or hurt, you know, we could never get back and could also, you know, impact the economic development, the community development, the health and the quality of life of those communities. So you know, it's important as we're kind of considering, you know, how this pipeline is going across the state, what impacts it could potentially have, and obviously just to make sure that we're protecting those natural resources. But this bill is narrowly tailored, of course, to really address the issue of eminent domain. And I think we all know what the purpose of eminent domain is. It's a significant power that our government has to obviously be able to acquire property when there's a significant public interest or a public good that would be achieved by doing that. And so we usually are pretty strict about how we allow that law and how that power to be employed. You know, it's again has to be for the public good. And so what this bill intends to do is really ensure that if we're going to take a significant power of the government like that and transfer it to a private entity, allow a private entity basically to have this kind of power that, you know, they need to show that there's some public good being achieved in utilizing that. And you'll be hearing from some people, Arkansas citizens, who will be testifying here in favor of this bill simply because in a lot of ways they didn't understand their own rights in this situation. They didn't feel like they were properly noticed. They felt like in some cases they were intimidated or bullied and forced apart with their property. And again, you know, as I think about, you know, all of us here in the legislature, I mean, we're here obviously to protect the people that we represent. Um, we're here to ensure that the law is being employed in the best way possible for the maximum benefit of our citizens. Um, and I think we all agree that, you know, private property rights in America are sacrosanct and we need to do everything we can to ensure that, you know, if, if, you know, we're going to employ any kind of government power, uh, that could possibly take away people's private property that we're doing it in a very conservative and in a very careful and very thoughtful way. And so, again, this bill is intended to very narrowly define how that power could be used by a private pipeline company. This is not an abstract issue. This is the result of real things that are happening to real people right now in Arkansas. I'll say that the city of Clarksville has actually passed a resolution to endorse this bill. The Arkansas Municipal League has endorsed this bill, and you'll hear from them today. And the Farm Bureau, while it hasn't officially endorsed this bill, has given me permission to say that they certainly support any efforts to protect private property and restrict the use of eminent domain. And so there's quite a bit of consensus, at least on this subject. I would be glad to, of course, answer any questions from the committee about the technical aspects of this bill and those I can't answer. Like I said, I think I've got some backup in the room. But otherwise, you know, I think it'll be important for everyone to also hear from the citizens and others who have come to testify today.
Thank you. Thank you, Representative Sabin. This pipeline comes right through my district, so I've been getting a lot of calls from concerned constituents on this, and I'm glad to hear some of this. What does your bill actually change for the oil companies or the pipeline companies to do? What's it
going to do different than they do now? Well, it really does enhance the notification requirements and puts into statute some more definition about what property owners' rights are in these kinds of situations. And And then it does increase the standard through which they would have to achieve permits from the regulatory agencies that I've mentioned before, again, just to ensure that when we're allowing them in a domain to be utilized, that we're protecting the natural resources of the state. Thank you. Do we have any questions
Mr. Chair. So I'm trying to figure out, if you could, what are you wanting to change about the current eminent domain laws in Arkansas? What is it that you think
is the issue here? Well, I think the issue, again, is that citizens don't feel like that they're being notified, first of all, of what their rights are and, you know, what they can do when someone is exercising the power of eminent domain. Sometimes I mentioned they feel threatened or intimidated or bullied. They don't understand the law. They feel like they're forced to sell their property at oftentimes below market rates. They don't understand why a company should be able to come in and do this. And I think that this bill clarifies how eminent domain should work in these kinds of situations. And like I said, you know, they're unusual situations, you know, normally, you know, a private company, if they want to come and, you know, have some right to your property or to purchase it, I mean, would have to negotiate with you, and it's sort of a fair, equal transaction. Everybody, you know, is on a level playing field. You're not forced into selling, you know, if you don't want to. Clearly, this is a little bit uneven. I mean, one party in this transaction has more power than the other, and I think what What we're trying to do is level the playing field for citizens. So I mean, that's what this bill does. And again, you know, there are a lot of, you know, technical aspects, especially in terms of, you know, how the Public Service Commission would define, you know, the utility aspect of this. But again, I think that's important because this is supposed to be exercise for the public good. And so it makes sense that, you know, if we're going to grant this kind of power, that there There needs to be some public good that's achieved through
part of it. But also, I mean, they're not sort of noticed about it as well. I mean, the playing field really isn't level if you consider that you've got big companies with lots of attorneys showing up unannounced, you know, to someone's doorstep. and people aren't prepared to respond, they are given kind of a short time period within which to respond, it comes out of the blue, and they oftentimes don't have the money or the resources to hire their own attorney. So again, when you think about, you've got the power of the government behind a very big company showing up at someone's doorstep who's not prepared or equipped to go up against I think, you know, it's our role here at the legislature to make sure we're ensuring a level playing field for the people we represent.
Representative Payton, you have a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Sabin, I understand what you're saying about notification, education, and does this bill give them resources or representation or increase their rights in the negotiation on the property involved? Well, no, and we can't do that.
I mean, that's something that we can't do. But again, if you look at the bill, I mean, just as an example, I just turned to page four, and this is section four, and basically these carriers have to have a detailed explanation of how the project meets the definition of a common carrier, which is basically, you know, the idea of what a public utility does. They have to, you know, prove that a notice of intent to exercise a right amendment domain has been given. There needs to be a hearing. There needs to be notice sent by certified mail with return receipt requested to all owners of real property along the route of the pipeline. And so, you know, these are things that are just, you know, real basic steps that ensure that people are at least given a chance to understand what their rights are. It doesn't ensure the outcome. It doesn't put the government necessarily all the way on the side of the property owner so that we're subsidizing their side of it. If anything, we're just really making sure that we're the referee, and we're making sure that it's a fair negotiation. MR. If I could
follow up. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So on the property owner's side of it, we're trying to ensure earlier notice, more opportunity to negotiate and object and educate their self, but we're not providing representation or increasing their rights. On the pipeline side of it, are you doing anything that is going to make it to raise Is the threshold that they have to meet to get granted the status where they can use
eminent domain? MR. I mean, just a very little bit. It doesn't change it a whole lot, but I mean, the permitting through ADEQ as well as through the Public Service Commission, I mean, does slightly raise that standard. I would say it creates a minimum threshold to ensure that this project or a project complies with what would be, I think, commonly understood to
then, what ways you're raising that threshold? I'd appreciate it. Sure. Well, you know, basically, the permit for ADEQ, you know, establishes that the requirements must be necessary or desirable for whether the permit should be granted. It ensures that, you know, the permitting process includes a description of the project, width of the corridor, that a hearing be held before the director on the application and that any objections to the applications are filed within 60 days of filing the application, that there's reasonable notice, again, sent by certified mail, you know, it includes a procedure for filing the written objection with the director. Again, you know, it lays out all of these different requirements that you would assume that are already being kind of complied with, but at least, you know, we're establishing in statute these basic requirements so that when a power as significant as an eminent domain is being exercised, that we've ensured our citizens that we've basically done our due diligence. Are you done? Yes, thank you. Okay. Representative Brandt, do you have a question? Or Smith? Sorry, Brandt
very much, Mr. Chair. Representative Sabin, you talked about ADQ. As I understand, ADQ has already charged Diamond Pipeline $123,000 worth of permit fees and $200 a pop. If the passage of this bill, if we pass this bill, what impact is it going to have on the Diamond Pipeline right now?
Well, the truth is I'm not sure it's going to have that much of an impact on the pipeline. And I've said that from the beginning, and I think we all acknowledge that. I mean, that horse is, you know, way out of the barn. on the projects in play, so I'm not certain that this does anything to stop that, nor was it the intention to stop the project. I also want to add to this that it's not in any way a judgment on the oil industry or the virtue of oil as a source of energy for our country or any of that. This is truly about just the property rights of our citizens, and we learned more about how eminent domain is exercised by virtue of what we've been experiencing with the Diamond Pipeline. I mean, that's what's brought the issue to the fore. That's why Representative Ferrara is getting phone calls. That's why many of you may also have gotten phone calls and heard from constituents. I've certainly heard from a lot of people around the state about it. And I think what we're trying to do is say we understand that eminent domain is a big deal. It's a very, very significant government power. And we want to ensure the citizens of Arkansas that if someone shows up at your doorstep and says they have eminent domain for a project and they are trying to force you to part with your property, that we've at least laid out some criteria to ensure that it's a project that meets that standard of public good and that, again, our citizens know what their rights are to the greatest extent possible that we can ensure. Thank you, Representative Saber. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Sorry, Mr. Richmond.
Mr. Chair. So I understand, you know, a big portion of your objective is to protect the property rights of those whose property would be demanded by eminent domain. But some of your, some of the language in this bill is like running ads in the newspaper about public meetings. I mean, that's not just the property owners. I mean, I would argue that the property owners can be much better represented if they are in a meeting with the government and the pipeline without a lot of input from outsiders.
Well, and this doesn't prevent those private meetings from happening. But again, if by virtue of eminent domain being exercised, we're saying this is in some way a public project. there's some public use involved. Otherwise, you couldn't use eminent domain. Therefore, a public notice of that project seems to me reasonable. I mean, for a community to know that something's happening. I mean, it may not be on your property, but it might be running right behind you, you know, on the other side of the fence from your pasture or, you know, your home. And, you know, again, it's one thing if, you know, the company said, hey, this is a private deal. I'm doing it myself. I'm using my own money to do it. I'm showing up at Representative Richmond's house, and he and I are having a man-to-man negotiation, and that's fine. But that's not what's going on here. They're using eminent domain. They're using a public government-issued power to do it. So I think the threshold needs to be a little bit higher for them to
be able to exercise that. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Any more questions? Seeing none. We have people speak for and against the bill. First for Emily Lane. Would you like to come down? Ms. Lane, if you'll take a seat and recognize yourself, and you are
recognized. Thank you. I'm Emily Lane. I'm a lifetime resident of this great state, and I teach in Conway at UCA. I'm here today, of course, to speak in favor of this bill because I think it would be unwise and unethical of us to allow private interest to have more rights than our property owners. I love this state. I'm from here. I love all Arkansans, and I consider all Arkansans to be my neighbors. This sense of responsibility that I have for my neighbor led me to work in Mayflower after the oil spill in 2013. My colleagues and I did quite a bit of work in the community volunteering our free time to help, and time and time again, we heard the same thing from residents there. They were sick, and they were scared. They felt helpless, and every time I went to visit Mayflower, I would get a headache, and I'd have to drive by the school and see the kids outside playing at recess, breathing in the same air that was making me sick. so it was no surprise to me that a few weeks after the spill teachers were demanding that students come indoors for recess because enough of them were getting sick and so were the teachers so needless to say people in the community were feeling pretty helpless were hurting and they were worried and still today four years later I get calls from people in Mayflower who are still sick, still scared, still feel hopeless about the situation. Some have certainly moved on. Some, you could say, are okay, but some have been permanently damaged from this disaster. And this is the risk we're taking with every pipeline when we approve them. There are 2.7 million miles of pipeline in this country and about 528 inspectors to oversee all of those pipelines. That's about one inspector for every 5,000 miles of pipeline. To give you some context, there are 5,000 miles is roughly twice the length of the United States from the East Coast to the West Coast. So even when we're trying to prevent these disasters, as we all are, it can be next to impossible. It can be a godly, a task of godly proportions, and we are not God. Pipelines spill, plain and simple. So we really need to think long and hard about how, if and how we're going to allow private companies to take property from hardworking Arkansans. Some of these folks have been on their property their whole life. It's been in their family for generations, and the last thing they want is for their hard-earned property to be taken from them and to be potentially spoiled irreparably from a pipeline spill. So if you support eminent domain for private use, you're really saying that people in Arkansas who own property and who work hard for that property don't have any rights. I am in support of this bill and encourage you to support it as well, because then you'll be making the statement that hard-working property owners in Arkansas do have rights. They have a right to protect their property against private interest. This is a nonpartisan, bipartisan issue, in my opinion. It's a human rights issue, and it's about my neighbors and your neighbors. So support this bill. Thank you. Thank you, Ms. Lane. Will you
you mr. chairman my name is Alan Perkins I'm an attorney here in Little Rock with PPGMR law firm I'm here on behalf of a pro the Arkansas independent Producers and Royalty Owners Association and the Arkansas Petroleum Council I in just a brief note about my background I've been practicing law for 26 years now in Arkansas I went to law school here in Little Rock I do a lot of oil and gas law and for the last several years I've taught oil and gas law at the UALR Bowen School of Law as an adjunct professor I have also been two out of the last three years recognized as the environmental litigation lawyer of the year here in Little Rock in Central Arkansas so enough about my background this this bill HB 2086 and representative Sabin mentioned to you that that it was all about property rights and and it's been subtitled the Property Rights Protection Act but in reality when you review it and and what the bill actually does and tries to do it might be more properly called the try to regulate pipelines out of existence act the pipelines are an important part of our economy our society and it's very important to oil and gas producers here in arkansas but let's just click through the bill uh quickly uh before a company a pipeline company can even think about um using eminent domain under this bill the first thing they have to do of course is is plat and uh plat a map and and describe the project that's that's not any large new requirement they have to file a copy in each county that's going to be affected And then they have to send a notice by certified mail with all of that information and a copy of the statute to every landowner who might be affected in the path of the pipeline. Pipeline projects take a long time to develop. They oftentimes change in their specific route or there may be alternative routes that are changed as the project moves along. It's a huge, expensive process to notify every single landowner by certified mail on the front end before the company even knows if they're going to obtain a permit. The next hurdle placed on the companies by this bill is a brand-new program, a regulatory program with the Public Service Commission, whereby the company has to apply to the Public Service Commission and receive a verification or a certification that they will, in fact, operate the pipeline as a, quote, common carrier. This is a completely new program. There's a 90-day period then between the application, there's a public hearing, and there's a second round of certified mail notices to every single person whose property lies within the potential route of the pipeline. After the 90 days, there's a public hearing, another 45 days for the PSC to issue its order. And unfortunately, that entire process is completely unnecessary. Our Arkansas Constitution and our current statutes right now today require that for any pipeline company to be able to utilize the power of eminent domain, it must, not may, not probably will, it must be operated as a common carrier. There were three Arkansas Supreme Court decisions in 2010. All three were somewhat related. Linder v. Arkansas Midstream Gas Services Corporation was the first one. There were two other cases. They were all heard together before the Arkansas Supreme Court. This very issue was discussed, and the Supreme Court said, pipeline companies are required by law to carry for all alike and not at their option the definition of the common carrier public purpose. So even if they wanted to operate it somehow privately only for themselves they could never use the power of eminent domain and if they did they could be stopped by anyone who objected to it because today the law of Arkansas says you can't do that. So, step two with the Public Service Commission, brand-new regulatory program, completely useless. The third and probably most significant hurdle that this act places as a roadblock to every pipeline project is another completely new regulatory program to be assigned to the ADEQ. uh this this program under a brand new set of regulations that that will have to be drafted after the bill is passed so we don't know what those would be like how stringent they would be how extensive they would be among other things requires that the pipeline operator again before they ever get a permit or know if they're even going to be able to do the project they have to conduct an environmental impact statement study environmental impact statements are incredibly expensive all of the ones that i've ever seen on the low end and it's unusual cost 50 to 100 thousands of dollars a large one for something like the diamond pipeline that representative payblah sabin mentioned would cost multiple millions of dollars to conduct a true environmental impact study for the entire length of the project and so one one effect there is that small projects would just never happen it would be prohibitively expensive and while uh representative sabin talked about the diamond project because um you know that's in people's minds and and evokes some strong emotions and i'm sure others will speak about that as well this kind of program this kind of bill would also affect small independent oil and gas operators for example you know if you had xyz drilling company in fort smith arkansas and they were going to go out and drill a gas well somewhere in the arcoma basin they never build the pipeline before they drill the well because they don't know if it's going to be productive so they drill the well and if it is productive and hopefully it would be they would then plan and construct and obtain the right-of-way to connect that well to a receiving pipeline because you can't sell natural gas without a pipeline it's not economical you can sell oil you can put tanks on your property and collect the oil and a truck can come and pick it up but we can't transport natural gas and trucks it's not it's not economical at all so in that scenario for a small independent gas company in Fort Smith Arkansas before they ever drill a well then what they'll have to do now is send a certified letter to everyone who might be along a pipeline that they might have to build if the well is is successful and then they'll have to go to the PSE and then they'll have to do an environmental impact statement and get a permit from the adq and then they can drill their well and if it's productive um they would uh they would have their project um the the fact the reality is that that pipeline companies do not like to use eminent domain um they rarely use it as a percentage it would be very small and i i can give you one very specific example The subsidiary of Southwestern Energy Company, DeSoto Gathering Company, LLC, which builds pipelines for their natural gas wells in the Fayetteville Shale, has constructed about 2,045 miles of pipeline to connect their wells up with the interstate pipeline system in the Fayetteville Shale. and they have never condemned a single acre of property under their power of eminent domain. However, pipelines, highways, telephone lines, electric transmission lines are what we call linear projects. That just makes sense. You all know what that means. It has to go from point A to point B. If you get 99% of all of the people to grant a voluntary easement and that one critical person holds out, you might have to use eminent domain because a chain with one link missing is worthless, and that's the way pipelines are, of course. But it is not a rampant problem. But the bill would affect all of the operators, all of the pipeline companies, large and small, not just the keystone pipeline type companies or the diamond pipelines, but also the very small independent oil and gas producers in this state that require the ability to to construct pipelines to get their products to market and to pay royalty owners to the landowners whose property they are producing the minerals from. I just want to finish up real quickly with a couple of other notes. Pipelines are already highly regulated. They don't just happen. And depending on, depending on the size and location of the pipeline and whether it's an interstate or intrastate pipeline, there are different levels of regulatory programs already that govern them. On the federal level, the Environmental Protection Agency, Corps of Engineers, the Department of Transportation, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, and the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, or FERC, in the case of interstate pipelines, have direct regulatory authority over the construction and siting and the environmental aspects of pipelines. FERC, for example, their program requires an environmental impact statement already, has to go through that project in order to receive FERC approval. FERC can specify the construction of the pipeline and even change the route of the pipeline. So, again, let's superimpose that on this program. let's say a pipeline company goes through the entire Arkansas set of hurdles and gets its final approval from the ADEQ and then FERC changes the route of the pipeline they have to go all the way back to the beginning because remember the very first requirement is that you send certified mail notice to every party who might be affected in the pipeline route and every step after that requires that you have completed that first step correctly so if the route has changed you have to start over next under the national environmental policy act that's the the federal law that requires environmental assessments and environmental impact statements on a whole host of different federal projects or projects that require a federal permit that comes into play no matter where the pipeline is so under the other laws for the for example the next one the Federal Water Pollution Control Act or the Clean Water Act as we usually call it it would require a pipeline company to obtain a section 404 Clean Water Act permit from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and the EPA prior to impacting or crossing any wetland or waterway in the state of Arkansas or anywhere in the United States, attached to that permitting process is another environmental assessment and environmental impact statement requirement depending on the scope of the project. Next, the Endangered Species Act comes into play. every pipeline project has to comply and protect any endangered or threatened species in their critical habitats. Under the Clean Air Act, there are a number of provisions of the Clean Air Act that are triggered by a pipeline project, particularly in relation to the compressor stations that are required to operate the pipeline. It can trigger requirements including new source review, prevention of significant deterioration, and the permitting program for major stationary sources under Title V of the Clean Air Act. All of those requirements and environmental checks and safeguards are already in place. The Natural Historic Preservation Act protects historic and cultural resources. Those requirements come into play. The Natural Gas Pipeline Safety
getting to the close. All right. Well, just real quickly in closing, the Arkansas eminent domain laws have operated well for over 100 years. They were first passed in 1873 as applied to railroads, telephone, and telegraph companies in 1921. They were made applicable to pipelines. The Supreme Court has reviewed, clarified, and enforced those laws a number of times, and as I mentioned earlier, several times just as recently as 2010. But the original purposes of facilitating these linear projects that are considered to be important and useful to modern society still exists. You can't build a pipeline and leave one link out. Um, and in those limited instances where it's necessary, eminent domain, um, is an important tool to have in the toolbox. So, uh, the, uh, APRO and the Arkansas Petroleum Council, um, oppose the bill. Okay. Thank
you, Mr. President. I heard you say one thing. Would you mind taking questions? I would be happy to. I think we have some questions. All right. Would you say one thing? Would this bill prevent, in your opinion, uh, gas drilling in Arkansas? It would in a number of instances, yes. Okay. Could you
be a little bit specific how? Yes. And it's because a natural gas well can't operate without a pipeline hookup. And so for the smaller projects where a well might only produce a few hundred MCF or maybe 1,000 MCF million cubic feet per day, those wells are not going to produce a lot of money. So the cost of this project would be prohibitive to those in the event that they need to use eminent domain. And because they don't obtain the pipeline right away until the well is drilled, it creates this huge economic problem for them in deciding whether to even
We have a motion to limit debate. Any questions? To limit the debate for each person. Three minutes. I'm sorry. Limits after Mr. Perkins. Yes. We'll limit three minutes per person. All in favor? Aye. All against? Okay. We'll limit debate for three minutes after Mr. Perkins is done.
the queue? Yes. Okay. So as you articulate the rights of those that's trying to install the pipeline, you said that the bill would prevent. The chairman asked you a question about what this prevent. You said yes. Drill down a little bit more for me on how you're saying it would prevent. As I read it, it just gives the rights to the property owner as it must be adhered to, but it does not prevent it just make you have to consider the rights so if
you can drill down on that i agree with that and what i think i said is it would prevent it in some instances by making it economically unviable so for a small natural gas well that's not going to produce a lot of money but is still economical in the current environment if they had to spend thousands and thousands of dollars on notices and environmental impact statements and so forth, just to determine whether or not they could build a pipeline to sell their gas, it's going to limit those smaller projects. It's going to make them economically unsuccessful. A
quick follow-up, please. Well, so if we go to the rights of the property right owner, if you think about that and use yourself maybe to make you really feel it, is if someone is going to acquire a piece or part of a property that has either been in your family, that you've bought and developed to whatever extent, then whatever they have to go through for you all to get to a satisfaction, a good agreement, I think it becomes part of the cost of doing business in that area. You make a choice to do business in that manner. But you want to be fair to the people that currently reside there or the current property right owners. So I think though we're not trying to be business unfriendly, we're trying to be also respectful of the current property owner and their rights. So I think it's a two-way, and I think what generally happens in these cases is you have to get full agreement, and that chain that you talk about with those links, those links are individuals with individual investments, individual families. They are all individual cases that has to be respected and duly dealt with by the prospective business owner. So I do agree that due diligence and the length and breadth of this is probably arguable to some degree, but it's necessary. So each individual property right owner has their rights. That's what I get from this. So I don't see it as a prevention. I just see it as a consideration and part of the
process. Thank you, Chair. Members, any more questions? Seeing any. Mr. Perkins, thank you. Thank you. All right, members, I want to let the real chair take over, and we'll go back to my seat. Okay, I
understand we have an Allison Millsap that would like to speak for, and I would remind you to keep your comments, not to repeat. Three minutes. Could you introduce
yourself for the record? Hello, my name is Allison Vilsaps, and I'm a landowner's advocate in the state. Thank you for letting us come today. I would like to say first that eminent domain is something that was kind of in my peripheral vision, like for many people, until it became my own personal experience. Two years ago, I sat before this committee, and I testified about my mother-in-law and her experience with Diamond Pipeline and with eminent domain. And I talked a lot about what it felt like, um, the loss, the loss of control, uh, the heartbreak, the just feeling of, um, isolation. Um, I talked about what it was like to deal with the land agents. And while, um, Mr. Perkins is correct that we actually did experience that in a domain. They, they took our property, um, for a temporary condemnation. They do threaten it a lot. So I just want to make that clarification. Anyway, so I talked about all those things, and unfortunately the bill failed. So today I'd like to talk a little bit more about places that have stronger permitting requirements than Arkansas does. While we're here today, Diamond Pipeline is at work, and I know this because they come by my house all the time. And they seem like nice guys, and I'm glad that they have jobs. So I want to make it clear that this is not about being anti-pipeline, and it's not about being against economic development. This is about bringing balance and accountability and transparency to a process that doesn't have those things at the moment. Sorry. I had this all planned out, and the three minutes kind of threw me. So I have handed out, if anybody is interested, I've handed out kind of an information sheet about the Dakota Access Pipeline, which I'm sure most of you have heard about. And Dakota Access Pipeline had to go through state permitting requirements in four separate states. They went through North Dakota, South Dakota, Illinois, and Iowa. And as you look, you'll see that they had much stricter requirements for what the pipeline had to do in terms of mitigation, in terms of reaching thresholds of voluntary easements before they were allowed to use eminent domain. so it was just a more robust process than the one that we have in Arkansas right now we need for this body to do something we need you guys to do something because right now landowners are left alone and HB 2086 really is a a step in the right direction.
you, Madam Chair, and thank you for the opportunity and the committee the opportunity to address it. My name is Michael Callen. I'm the current president of Arkansas Independent Producers and Royalties Association. I also am vice president of Stevens Production Company in Fort Smith, Arkansas, an independent natural gas well driller in the state. Very quickly, I would tell you that the requirements of the bill, while I understand the reasoning behind them, they are so extensive that there will be times where natural gas wells that are planned for the state of Arkansas will not be drilled if these requirements are put into place. The current regulatory scenarios that we go through in Arkansas are very strict. I'll give you an example. If we drill a well on the national forest land, the pipeline route is predetermined off of the forest property. At that point in time, we're required serially to purchase pipeline right away from each successive landowner. In my 33 years in the natural gas utility and production business, I've never seen a court own an eminent domain proceeding award less than fair market value for the property. All the requirements when eminent domain is used as far as notice to the landowner and always the effort to negotiate a private agreement with them are exhausted first. So that's the perspective from the company that I work for. by increasing the cost of drilling a natural gas well, there will be wells which will not be drilled, thus depriving not only the company but also royalty owners of the proceeds from the sale of natural gas from those wells. Thank
you. Thank you. Any questions from the committee? Seeing none, thank you, sir. We have speaking for Dana Schmidler. Snyder. All of the above. If you'll introduce yourself, we'll get it right.
Good morning. My name is Dana Snyder, and I am a member of the Clarksville City Council. And I'm going to read mine quickly. So if I go too fast, I can slow down a little bit. First, let me say that HB 2086 is not an anti-oil or an anti-pipeline legislation. It is pro-property rights, pro-transparency, and pro-due process. In the case of the Diamond Pipeline, their use of eminent domain, they had contracted land acquisition agents that went across the state purchasing the easements prior to applying for a permit. And the stories of harassment, intimidation, threats, and belittling were heard by me from many of the property owners. Almost every property owner was afraid to speak publicly about their experience for fear of retaliation by the pipeline company. The situation was deemed serious enough for Clarksville City Council to pass two resolutions, which you have before you, and the Johnson County Quorum Court also passed a resolution in support of this legislation. The good citizens of Arkansas were lied to by a private company about their rights. Some were told that fighting the relinquishment of their property would result in them receiving no compensation at all. These are stories that we heard from property owners. They were threatened with condemnation, and I believe in one case that did take place. They were deceived into taking less than market value for their property. They were threatened with disrespect and then forced to sign non-disclosure agreements. It is no wonder we could find no property owners that would be willing to come and speak to you today or even to speak publicly. The importance of HB 2086 is first and foremost so that private citizens will be educated on their rights and understand why their property might be acquired for private use. But just as important is that municipalities and residents in the path of the next pipeline can be involved in the process to educate the company itself as to the obstacles that they might encounter along the way. You will hear from Clarksville Light and Water General Manager John Lester who will explain to you what happened in our situation in Clarksville. If planes had seen the map that you have before you that shows the watershed, they would have known that they were going through what was considered a critical watershed for light and water. And they told us that they had not seen that map, and there's really no reason for them not to have done so. Had we had open communication with the public, They would have known that their 50-foot easement was going to cut underneath the foundation of a home, which was threatening the mortgageability of that home by the bank that held the mortgage. Is that my time? Yes, ma'am, if you could close, please. Yes, ma'am, I will do so. Eminent domain should be reserved for projects that benefit a community, not solely the benefit of a private corporation. It is indeed a common carrier. Land taking is never popular, but it should be used for the ultimate good of a community or state. Almost half of the states in America have already passed property rights legislations. This is about citizens of our state having some say in what affects their daily lives, or at least being informed. Thank you. No questions?
sorry committee i believe we have randy sook to speak for the bill and then we have three other people that are still on the four side if you want to get together so that we don't repeat the same
the bill i'm sorry i stand corrected First of all, I'd like to thank you very much for the opportunity to speak on this issue. I'll be very brief. I think I'd like to address just the common sense and the economics of this situation. We find ourselves today as the United States leading the world in the production and the refining of oil and natural gas. This is an enormous change in the world markets and the economics of fossil fuel production. This has certainly resulted in positive benefits for American consumers by driving energy costs down, enhancing our national security, as well as providing benefits to our environment. A robust infrastructure system is essential to ensuring reliable delivery of natural gas, oil, and other petroleum products to consumers where and when it is needed. Altogether, more than half a million miles of pipeline make up the energy superhighway system that spans the U.S. Our pipeline and infrastructure system is the critical connection between supply basins and demand centers. In particular, pipelines play a critical role in delivering energy to the citizens of Arkansas and on behalf of the citizens of Arkansas. The opening last year of the Magellan Midstream Partners Pipeline brings over 75,000 barrels per day of gasoline, diesel fuel, and jet fuel into the Little Rock market as well as directly into the Little Rock Air Force Base, assisting in the long-term viability of that base while also providing a vital link to Gulf Coast and Midwest refineries. It would take over 350 tanker trucks a day hauling 9,000 gallons of fuel each to supply the same amount of product to the Little Rock market. Think of 350 more trucks, and it's actually 700 round trips or total trips on I-40 between Oklahoma and Arkansas. It would take almost 1,000 trucks a day to deliver the same amount of product as the 200,000-barreled diamond pipeline. This is an enormous economic and safety concern. Whenever a company is considering where to place a new pipeline, it works closely with local officials and landowners to minimize the impact to the community, the environment, and historical or cultural resources. Once a potential route is established, the companies enter into written contracts to pay landowners if pipelines cross their land. Pipeline owners prefer to reach agreements with landowners along the route and seek eminent domain authority only as a very last resort HB 2886 singles out pipeline common carriers for requirements beyond those in place for other entities with eminent domain authority and submits pipeline pipelines to enter additional regulatory burdens which we believe would have a negative impact on non-utility development and lead to significant delays in costly litigation we urge you to vote no on 2086. I'd be happy to take any questions.
a question? Thank you, Mr. Zuck, for being here. Good to see you. Good to see you. Question I asked earlier in trying to do the same thing I'm sure you try to do in our state is to bring us together and not leave a big loser in the situation. As we talk about protecting the rights of private homeowners, the same question becomes of how we determine that the process, because of the good, that all that you talk about from the business standpoint, what it does, the global vision, we love all of that. But to the private homeowner, how do we square that with that property owner that's being felt unjustly treated in this? And we have to treat each individual individually. We can't put them in a class, so to speak, because that's theirs. So in your opinion, how can we make this all work for both sides? How can this work?
Well, I think Representative Sabin in his opening statement really addressed, you know, are we delivering a public good? And I think that's absolutely the case in this instance. I mean, we're actually trying to isolate this to Diamond. Diamond is already a done deal. It's going to be built. That route is set. It's been adjusted in response to pressures from different landowners and communities. That route is set. The pipe is being put in the ground. I had a personal experience just recently with Eminent Domain. Actually, it wasn't Eminent Domain, but it was the highway department taking 82 and a half acres right out of the heart of our farm coming into Shea County. I'm thrilled that I-69 may, in my great-great-grandchildren's lifetime, get built across DeShea County, and maybe we'll sell a corner to Walmart or Exxon or somebody. But in the meantime, we're messing up about 900 acres of really good soybean and corn land. We'll mess it up with a highway coming across it. So eminent domain is always painful or any public good like a highway or a utility line or a pipeline or whatever it happens to be. But at the end of the day, safer, lower-cost transportation of fossil fuels is vital to the health of our economy. That pipeline that came into Little Rock, I promise you, is saving Arkansas or Little Rock area consumers at least a nickel, maybe as much as $0.07 or $0.08 a gallon in transportation costs. It's safer. It's cheaper. You know, it's the safest, cheapest way to transport fluids like jet fuel or diesel fuel or gasoline that's available to us, and we need to maximize. But it's ironic that at a time in Washington when we're doing everything we can in the new administration to reduce regulatory burden on businesses and utilities and oil and gas producers, we're contemplating increasing that burden. We're kind of going at cross purposes here with this bill, and that's why we urge you to vote against it.
Okay. I apologize for my ignorance. I have a quick question. Eminent domain, it does give a consideration to the property owner. They do get some value for the acquisition of their property through that. That is, there is some value, correct? Absolutely. They get the market value. I apologize for that. They're kept hold.
They're kept hold. Now, is it painful? Sure. No question about it. You know, am I going to be happy the day I see those trucks start ripping the guts out of that field into Shea County? No. But, you know, at the end of the day, we've got the
questions from the committee? Yes. Representative Farrar. Thank you. And you may not know this, but when you put a pipeline through, okay, they repair the ground back, they pay for the prime, you have an easement, yes? And you cannot, now, what's the restriction? You cannot build over the pipeline or is it you can't do? Kind
of tell me what's going on. Well, look, I cross the Fayetteville Express pipeline at Ball Knob. Every time I go home to Melbourne, you turn off a 67 and turn up there at Ball Knob, there's their office. The pipeline itself is running across the highway at just about that point. I can't tell where the pipeline is. There's a sign every now and then identifying the right-of-way, but it's being farmed, it's being used, it's being driven across, it's being hunted, it's being fished, or whatever it happens to be. So the use of the property with pipelines especially is minimally disruptive compared to like a utility line where you've got a pole sticking up in the middle of a field or a highway in the case of, you know, just a barrier to getting across the property. So a pipeline of all the eminent domain entities and devices, a pipeline is, at the end of the day, after the project is completed, is the least obtrusive. Well, like Representative Saban
said, you know, I have this going through my district and I'm getting calls. And it seemed like the most calls and the problem I get, they have the inflexibility of the pipeline company to do anything. The last one I have, they were building a road to get to the pipeline, and it was 50 feet from Mr. Gentleman's back porch. And he said, I've got property over here. Just go this way. Mr. Senator, we're not going to do that because we're going to go right here, but this is because this is what we planned. I think the property owners in my area are just because the company is just inflexible of changing things when the opportunity is there. I mean, he didn't mind the pipeline going through there. He didn't have a problem with it. But just the road, the gravel road going right by his house, and that was his problem. And I know probably there's probably no fix to that. But what I'm seeing is not based upon my mind. It's just the fact that getting to the program is what the problem is. And the inflexibility of the company to work with these people. So I know that's not a question, but that was just
a statement. Thank you. That's okay. Any other questions? Representative Richmond, I apologize for missing you on the last one. Don't worry about it. She's long gone. All right. Anybody else? Any other? I do know your name. Thank you, Representative Fielding. All right. Any other questions for Mr. Zook? Thank you, Madam Chair. All right. We have three other witnesses. Have you all gotten together, and are you ready? We have first John Lester. Please remember not to repeat anything that's already been said so we can keep it on track, sort of. I will absolutely do my best.
Thank you, Mr. Lester. Please state your name for the record. My name is John Lester. I'm the general manager of Clarksville Light and Water. Thank you, sir. I have been the general manager since July of 2013. As a municipally owned utility, we have one of 14 systems in the state that own electric utility, water, and wastewater utility. Not only do we serve water to the people of Clarksville, a population of about 10,000, but we also have eight wholesale customers, other cities and water districts around us. We basically serve most of the southern part of Johnson County, which totals about 28,000. Uh, in addition to those particular individual customers, we also have some very large industrial concerns that are heavy water users. That would be Tyson and Haynes brand. In fact, years ago, it was the addition of a second intake, uh, across Piney Bay that basically opened the door for Haynes brand to come in to the community to employ additional people. So this goes beyond just, uh, jobs related to a oil pipeline or the oil industry, but it actually impacts industrial customers. your big water uses as well. I do have a long written testimony. I'm going to scan through it really quick. Uh, ultimately the question is why would I be here talking about this particular, um, issue, um, on this house bill? Uh, I'd like to say up front, I'm not anti oil. I'm not anti energy. We own an electric utility. I totally understand that we need to develop our domestic energy resources. I'm not against eminent domain. In fact, because of the oil pipeline and some of the things that we're going to have to do to protect ourselves from that, I'm probably going to have to use eminent domain against the same property owners that the oil pipeline crossed. So I understand the sensitivity of it. What I want to do is I want to share with you the particular experience that we've had. I'm not going to name names or companies or anything of that sort, but and I'm going to give you a once-over. The only way I learned of this particular project was a phone call from the Arkansas Department of Health, and their question was, were you aware? My question was, absolutely, I'm not aware. In fact, they asked me if I knew what the route was, and I said, I have no idea what the route was. I'd have been at Clarksville Light and Water for about nine months. So they started to share with me the processes that they knew, even though they hadn't been formally notarized, and I asked them to share maps with me. When I looked at the maps, and I've got those as exhibits, not only was this proposed oil pipeline crossing one of our watersheds, but both of our watersheds. So as I talked to the Department of Health, they recommended I call the Corps of Engineers. I called the Corps of Engineers and actually talked to them, and they said, well, we really can't discuss the topic because they haven't formally sent in their application for the permit. So I said, okay, I sent a letter of concern that I wanted to be involved in the process, and I falsely assumed that I would hear back when that application come in. They did acknowledge they had talked to the pipeline on a preliminary basis. Well, it was approximately a year later that Dana Schneider, the city council person, asked me. Anyway, here's an interesting thing. Well, sir,
you have any questions? All right. Thank you, sir. I believe we have two more folks. Where did that sheet of paper go? we have two people left could you raise your hand ma'am if you would come down if you could identify yourself and remember those three minutes go quickly I'm taking it. You're Katie or Emily. I'm Emily Harris, Arkansas landowner for
over 30 years. Thank you. I'm public health educator, safety officer for the National Disaster and Medical System and graduate field researcher for University of Central Arkansas. I'm here today to speak in favor of this bill. Currently, Arkansas eminent domain law allows for the path of least resistance to the highest corporate profits, with little concern to individual property owner rights and community health and safety. If given the opportunity for input, many landowners could identify less disruptive routes through their land, such as not through the middle of their best hayfield, across stock ponds, or blocking their front door. Municipalities, given the opportunity, could identify known areas of concern or areas that produce safety risks that could be avoided. Redirecting in the path of a proposed pipeline corridor away from essential services such as emergency medical, fire, police, hazardous materials response, and governmental offices allows for these necessary services to remain functional in the event of an accidental release. Public drinking water sources, including water intake locations, processing facilities, and distribution pathways require protection to ensure quality and safety of drinking water for our entire state. Schools, hospitals, and senior citizen centers house our most vulnerable populations and should not be submitted to the extra and unnecessary burden of hazardous materials running nearby and beneath their facilities. Tourism brings important dollars to our state. Our beautiful but sensitive recreational areas, wildlife management zones, and our beloved ability to hunt and fish depend on those areas remaining accessible and intact. and pipelines both have a limited lifespan, but just like people don't come stamped with an expiration date, neither do pipelines. Well documented problems with construction, anomalies in the pipeline itself, weldings and connections, technical issues such as equipment sensors and shut off valve failure combined with the factors such as high rate of earthquakes, tornadoes and floodings result in all too often devastating effects on the community following the accidental release of toxic pipeline contents. these circumstances require reevaluation of the power and privilege bestowed through the eminent domain that circumvents land over rights and the sensibility of local jurisdictions. As respected stewards of the people of the Great Start
of Arkansas, I implore you to pass this bill. You're very good. You've got 32 seconds left. That was impressive. Thank you. Committee members, any questions? Seeing none, thank you for your time. I believe we have one more. Thank you. Please come to the end of the table and identify yourself.
Hi, my name is Katie Bodenhammer, and I'm an attorney with the Arkansas Municipal League. Just very quickly, the league supports this bill. We feel that it's a good bill, and that it strikes the correct balance between property owners' rights and the businesses that are trying to put in pipelines. It takes into consideration environmental concerns, it gives property owners adequate notice of eminent domain, and it requires that those businesses who want to put in those pipelines to do so, to achieve a public good. And with that, my remarks are concluded, and we'd appreciate your support.
would, Madam Chair, and I also appreciate the committee's indulgence and the time we've spent on this issue. I'll make my close very, very brief. Mr. Perkins, when he was talking, I talked long and about a lot of things. I just want to kind of zero in on a couple points. Number one, you know, he'd mentioned how this could impact small projects, but, you know, I would kind of argue back to that, that there's sort of a lot of, he conflated a lot of things It's sort of in his remarks because he was talking about small projects which most of the time I assume wouldn't use eminent domain. And then he went through the long list of federal regulations which also wouldn't pertain to small projects. I mean, the kind of federal regulations that we're talking about are really for a project like the Diamond Pipeline that's an interstate project. And that's why it's federally regulated, which speaks to the reason why it's important for us here in the state of Arkansas to have our own protections for property owners and speak to that. But the main issue I just want to zero in on right here is, you know, when we're talking about eminent domain, you know, we're talking about the public good. And Mr. Zook, you know, used his highway example, but I think it's, you know, a lot easier to comprehend what the public good is for a highway project that Arkansans themselves are going to drive on, you know, locally or to transit the state as opposed to a pipeline that's taking a product from one state to another state and just happens to be crossing Arkansas. I mean, you have to really stretch your logic to argue that that's a public good for the citizens of Arkansas and deserves the power of eminent domain that's granted by our government. You know, I understand why companies want to use eminent domain and why they are here to protect it. All of us and all of our businesses, as I look around this table, would love to be able to use eminent domain. But most of us don't have that luxury. We have to, you know, assemble whatever projects that we're trying to assemble, one-on-one, or working collaboratively with a lot of different people through negotiation. That's what free market capitalism is. And you know, again, for the government to take one side in a sort of private business negotiation I think is dangerous. I think it, again, upends our feelings about free market capitalism. And I think in this particular case, it undermines those rights to private property that we all think are so important here in this country. And so, again, our job is not to ensure the success of any particular company. There is not a company in America that wouldn't love to use eminent domain to make the cost of their product cheaper for the consumer or to more efficiently transport their product around any particular locality or across state lines. So let's remember who we're here to represent. Let's keep in mind the values that we uphold, free market capitalism, private property rights, and being conservative and very careful about exercising the power of eminent domain. And with that, Madam Chair, I'm closed. Thank you, Representative Sabin.
What is the will of the committee? Motion to pass. All right. We have a motion to pass. Discussion. Representative Rushing, I believe you had a question. Yes,
I just did have one question that I didn't get answered, and I'm sorry I did come in a little bit late before you had finished speaking. But I wanted to know, do we have a physical impact on what the cost to the ADEQ and the Public Service Commission would be for any increased regulation? Maybe you might have already answered that. I don't know. Like I said, I missed part of the discussion
i'm sorry representative rushing you're right that is a good question unfortunately we're in discussion among committee members so if a committee member has that information that would be great the impact statement
wasn't going to be able answer it, but I'll just say we didn't do a fiscal impact statement. I'm not certain that that's something that we do for bills like this where we are simply, you know, I guess in this sense, you know, putting in a regulation of some sort. I mean, if we did that, we'd need
I appreciate that question. Representative Richman. I might be able to contribute just a little bit about that. As I said earlier, ADQ thus far as collected $123,000 worth of fees because every time that the pipeline, any linear project that goes across a stream or ditch or a low place, they have to do an environmental watershed study on it. And so I know they've got that many, that much fees off of, and I suspect that they would make considerably more money once, uh, if
this bill passes. Any other questions or discussion from committee members. We have a Representative Murdoch, did you make a due pass? I did. Okay, we have a due pass. What is the pleasure of the committee? All those in favor? Aye. All those opposed? No. I'm sorry, Representative Saban, your bill has
today. Thank you very much, everybody. I know we spent a lot of time on the special order of business, but given that this is likely the last day for House bills, we're going to try and get through the calendar, the entire calendar, so buckle up as we start going through these. The first thing I'd like to do without objection is remove House Bill 2193 from the deferred list and put it at the bottom of the agenda. Again, I'd like to ask Carol to do that without objection. Then I want to go to the top of the calendar, HB 2102. Representative Lemons, are you here? Representative Rushing, you're recognized to present House Bill 2102. Thank you,
Mr. Chair and committee. Please forgive me on not having a lot of information on this, but Representative Lemons had an emergency had to take care of today and email me this morning to run this bill for him. Basically this bill, he describes it as the best as a consumer protection act. In the past, some companies would change their name and or incorporate themselves under another name to avoid warranties. Just for an example, a company would be named ABC Construction and then they would change their name to ABC and Sons, and this would allow them to not honor the warranties under their first name, but yet still practicing the same business and doing the same activity. So this bill closes this loophole, and when a company changes its name and the principles and services are the same, the warranty transfers to the new company. And that is about all I know, but I'm open for questions. Is there any questions from the committee?
Seeing none, is there anyone here to speak against the bill? For the bill. Representative Rushing, are you closed for your bill? I am closed for my bill. Would you like to make a motion? I would like to make a motion due pass. We have a motion due pass on the table. Is there any discussion? Seeing none, all in favor. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Rushing. You've passed Representative Lemon's bill. The next bill on our calendar is House Bill 2212. Representative McGee, are you here? Representative McGee, are you here to present House Bill 2212? The next bill on our calendar is House Bill 2054. Representative Hammer, are you here to present 2054? 2054? Representative Hammer, 1271, that's the next one on the calendar. Okay. Representative Gray, are you here to present House Bill 2209? Representative Gray, are you here to present House Bill 2209? No? Okay. The next bill on the agenda is Senate Bill 683. Is Senator Sanders here? Senator Sanders, I think, was going to present Senate Bill 683. Somebody do me a favor and text him, just so he knows that we're doing this and we'll come back up to it. House Bill 1753 is mine. I'm going to pass over that. The next bill on the agenda is House Bill 2251. Representative Gassaway, are you here to present House Bill 2251? Seeing as he's not here, the next bill is Senate Bill 522. Senator Cheatham or somebody for Senator Cheatham to present Senate Bill 522. Representative Gray, what bill are you here to present a bill? So what I'd like to do is, without objection, I'd like to remove House Bill 1958 from the deferred list and put it at the bottom of the agenda. So that means that we're going to go to House Bill 2193, Representative Hammer, you're here to present 2193, and I think we have an amendment for that bill. And then Representative Gray will do House Bill 1958. is going to pass out the amendment now to House Bill 2193. Is there anybody else that's looking at a bill that's currently on the deferred list that they want to present today? If so, please come up here and let me know. Now, Representative Hamer, you're recognized to present the amendment for House Bill 2193.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. This agreement is going to be an agreed-upon amendment from all parties that have anything relevant to it. What it does is actually goes in and addresses the issue of people that have uninsured motor situations, and so the bill's been modified to represent what I think is a better way of moving forward. And it is agreed upon by all parties that I've worked with to get it to this point as far as out in the audience. Is there any
questions from the committee on the amendment? Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak against the amendment, for the amendment? Representative Hammer, are you closed for the amendment? Appreciate a good vote. I move that we adopt the amendment to House Bill 2193. Any discussion on the motion? All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Hammer. The amendment is adopted. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You're recognized to present the House Bill 2193 as amended. Thank you. Could I invite a
couple people to come to the table just to support me in the presentation? Yes, sir. And I'll have them identify themselves when they come if they—Walter and State Police,
for the record. I'm Walter Inger, I'm the commissioner of revenue for DF&A. My name is Sean Garner. I'm a deputy director for the Arkansas State Police Overfield
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm bringing this bill on behalf of working with state police and part motor vehicles. One of the big issues out there is people are supposed to have insurance when they drive their vehicles. A lot of times people will get their insurance for the purpose of being able to get their tags and other things, and then they'll drop their insurance. And when a trooper or somebody stops, somebody in law enforcement stops a vehicle, one of the disadvantage is the ability to look at real-time information to determine if indeed that insurance is in place or not. What this bill does is something that's been trying to be worked on for some time, and that is it would allow the trooper to be able to have immediate access from the vehicle or the police officer and others that have access to ACIC, I believe is the correct acronym, be able to determine if that insurance's deed is in force at the time that they are stopped. There is no, I understand, no revenue impact in that the cost of this can be, you know, absorbed. But before I go any further with that, what I'd like to do is yield to the two people sitting at the table with me maybe
to give comment. You're recognized. The current process right now is we have a database that is at least 30 days old. when, um, they call in to check the insurance information, um, somebody in order to get their tags can get insurance and then immediately cancel it. So, um, the information that the state troopers and the police are getting is, is at least 30 days old. Um, this would give a real time and they, and they would know right away whether the, especially in, um, accidents, some people may have a card, and it may not be valid. This way, they can get to the insurance companies and know for sure whether there's valid insurance. Morning, Mr. Chair and committee members. I can speak for this bill in two regards. One is as a victim, and another is a law enforcement officer. In 2015, I was involved in a motor vehicle crash. I was in the city of Hot Springs and was traveling westbound. I was attempting to make a left-hand turn, started that left-hand turn. This was about 1030 at night, and I was struck broadside by a vehicle that was traveling with no lights. At the time of that crash, Hot Springs Police Department officer, as we typically do, wanted the registration, driver's license, and insurance. The other party involved in this crash had a card that showed that they had valid insurance. This was on a Friday night. Monday, I attempted to file a claim against that party's insurance and was informed that their insurance was not valid. They had paid it for a period of one month. The next month, they made their payment. The subsequent month, they failed to make a payment, which the insurance then lapsed. Fortunately, I had full coverage insurance and uninsured motorists. A lot of people do not have that. So speaking from the law enforcement perspective, we deal with individuals that are involved in crashes that come back in later and find out that the other party did not have insurance. However, we did not cite them at the time of the crash for not having that insurance. This bill, I submit to you, would close that loophole. So we would have real-time data at the time of the crash or time of the traffic stop of whether that individual had current insurance on that vehicle or if they had it elapsed. Thank you very much for any question.
I love the idea of trying to make sure everybody maintains their insurance, but I've got a couple of questions about logistics. I think currently, if you don't have your card and you argue that you've lost it or misplaced it or whatever, I mean, they give you a ticket, right? But they don't impound your automobile? Yes, sir. That is correct. So on this, are we going to be trying to impound
the automobiles or are we going to be giving them a ticket? They would be issued a ticket. However, if that person had been subsequently issued warning citations in the past or citations in the past for no proof of insurance and they're caught driving again, it would be at the discretion of that law enforcement officer at that time to impound that vehicle.
Okay, if I could follow up. So the first time basically would be a ticket and not an impound? That's correct. The way you understand. All right. Lean holders, of course, are very concerned about when the vehicles become impounded and you have a tow bill and you have several days of storage. gentlemen, could you review the rules on notifying lien holders when a vehicle's been impounded?
Yes, and that is something that the wrecker companies are tasked with, is to obtain that lien information at the time that the vehicle is towed. Law enforcement does provide them that information on a tow slip, and then that process is followed through by the towing companies. Representative Ferguson, you recognize for
I wouldn't characterize it like that because I think that's already required by law anyway. And as a victim of three accidents presented previously in testimony, I would appreciate it if everybody else had insurance like I did. Mr. Chair, may I point out one glaring difference about this bill as other bills that have been run in the past? Certainly. Previously, with other attempts to do this, it was reliant, and correct me if I'm wrong, Mr. Anger, it wouldn't be the first time I've been corrected, that it was reliant upon a data dump of information, whereas this is an access to real time. And that's one of the big glaring differences between previous attempts to deal with this is it's direct access. Are there any other questions? You are correct. Seeing none, is there anyone here to
speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Hammer, are you closed for your bill? With that, yes, sir, I am. I'd appreciate a good vote, and it'll make it better for
all folks that carry insurance. Representative Farrar, you're recognized for a motion. I do pass. We have a do pass motion. As amended. We have a do pass as amended.
Motion on the table. Is there any discussion? Seeing none, all in favor? Aye. Is there any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Hammer. You've passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. Representative Gray, you're recognized to present your amendment on House Bill 1958. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. This is the amendment that I spoke about on the House floor yesterday that would put a cap in place for CSOs. So if I could get the amendment adopted, I would explain the amendment in relation to the entire bill. Is there any questions on the
Chairman. Thank you, Chairman. So this puts the total possible fees or whatever you want to call it, at the 17 percent, which matches the amendment. Is it 94, 89, whichever amendment it is? It's amendment 89.
Okay. Yes, it does, and I'll explain a little bit better when I'm able to explain the whole bill, but yes, it does. Okay. Thank you, Chairman. all right
uh we've got a we've got a motion to adopt the amendment is there uh any discussion on that seeing none all in favor uh any opposed we've uh congratulations representative gray we've adopted your amendment you're now recognized to present house bill 1958 as
amended thank you mr chair all right colleagues so i had this bill out there um for a while and essentially was wanting to put some more definitions in place regarding CSOs. And CSOs, credit services organizations, it's an act from 1987 is what we're looking at changing. They put some more defined definitions in place and put a consumer protections clause in there. um after running deceptive trade bill i decided that i didn't think that there was no one really wanted to discuss this issue so i was not going to run this bill and then this is just me being completely honest in the air of transparency so then senator ray burt and representative house ran the bill yesterday on the house floor to um essentially completely do away with this line of business it completely struck all language from the cso act of 1987. And in talking to a few other legislators, kind of what we, what I decided to do to give this a shot was to run this bill that puts definitions in place, consumer protection in place and puts a cap on it to essentially allow this business, this line of business to stay in business, at least for the next two years, because we have asked, Senator English has asked for an AG's opinion. That was approximately nine months ago as to whether or not these businesses are operating lawfully as they are operating and charging fees outside of, and Representative Murdoch, this is where outside of the 17%. So currently their fees are outside 17%. So what you have is a borrower who can't get a loan from a bank because their credit's not good enough from a lender. So they will go to a credit services organization who essentially co-borrows, uses their credit to help that borrower get a loan with the lender. Now the loan with the lender is going to be at close to or at that 17% just because of their bad credit. But that credit services organization, because they are the co-borrower, helps them actually secure that loan. So any fees they charge are outside of that 17%. So you have 17% that the bank, the lender is going to charge. And then the cap that we were looking at putting in place was $17 on 100, which if paid out over a year would be annualized to 17%. So total, we're looking at 34. So you've got the 17% that the banks charge. And then you have this additional that the credit services organizations charge. So you'll hear testimony against the bill here just a little bit about how this is. And Senator Raypert and I kind of had some words yesterday about this as well, you know, about how it's 250 percent interest. It's 400 percent interest, whatever it is. If you take that $100 and you paid it out over a year with the $17 cap, that's 17% interest. If you take it and pay it out over six months, then your APR goes up, what you see on paper. If you pay it out over two months, it goes up to 200% is what it looks like on paper. But it's still $17 on 100. So I'm actually to the point of getting frustrated that everybody wants to use this APR just to essentially make sure that all money stays with banks. That's where I'm frustrated. We're using this APR to confine business to banks and outside of this space of a service that I feel is needed. And that's when I was in college and I needed money, my parents, they don't want to give me money. I don't live in a rich area. What if my parents don't have the money to give me $400 for a new set of tires? I can't get to work. I've blown my transmission. I need a place to go. I have a very rural, poor district. They need something like this. At least let us keep this for two years. Let's don't do away with it, and let's wait for an AG opinion. Let's wait for that court case to come through and see where they land. Think about it like this. I've got $100,000 mortgage. Now, annualized, it's 5% interest rate. But over 30 years, I've paid an additional $200,000 in interest. That's, what, 200% more than what I borrowed. So $100,000, 30 years later, I've got $300,000 in that. On paper, it looks great, 5%. But I've paid twice as much as what it's worth. If I equated that to this, I'd be charging $200 for every $100. that I offered this service for. Take bank fees. Bank of America, $6 to cash a check. $100 check, they're charging a $6 fee. Overdraft fees, $35. $100 check, I'm paying a $35 overdraft fee. Every time, Bank of America, I can do four a day. It's $140 a day. So it's funny how when we want to call them fees, we're calling them fees. And when we want to call them usury APR, we're throwing them in under usury monthly fees Bank of America charges $12 a month unless you're checking balances over $750 who does that hurt middle class low-class people the kind of people that need this loan when they go to a bank they're getting hurt by the banks anyhow I can't know if you can tell I'm actually I didn't actually intend to run this bill but I'm to the point of getting pretty passionate about it yes we need consumer protections in place to make sure that they're not, my constituents, the people that need this service, aren't getting hurt or abused or in Senator Rapert's words, raped, which I didn't appreciate that in our conversation yesterday. We need consumer protections in place, but we also need a place for people to go that are down on their luck and need a service like this. These CSOs aren't lending the money. They're offering their credit as a supplement in order for these people to get a loan from the bank. So what I had asked and what I testified to yesterday on the House floor was let's don't pass Senator Raypert's bill that totally shuts these people down. Let's pass something that a little more narrowly defines what they're allowed to do while we wait for an AG opinion, and possibly a court case. I also expect that this will get challenged in a Supreme Court case. I fully expect it to get challenged, but you know what? Then we'll have our answer. Representative Ferrari, you're recognized for a
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yeah, you need to take a breath. I do. I know. I'm getting passionate about it. Calm down. I can tell. Your person wants to borrow $500 from the bank. Your CSO charges them too. to borrow the $500, is the interest charge on the $200 also? Or is it just on the $500? It's on the entire amount. So the $500. You're paying interest on your
wouldn't be $200. Okay, all right. But you have a fee. Now you're paying interest on your fee. Is the limit of 17% on your fee also? Yes. So you're paying $17,000 on all the total. Okay. Yes. Okay. What is it? Can I have one more follow-up? Okay. What is the average length of the loan on this? What are they? What's the? I
know it's not years, but I just. No, no. From what I was told, it's like six weeks up to six months. And what we're talking about in statute already, it's only up to $1,000 loan. So it's not like they could go get a $10,000 loan that they couldn't pay back. It's a
very small dollar loan. I understand. So six weeks, and you're still in it, and $200 on a six-week loan, and you're charging 17% on both. A six-week, maybe six months. Yes, so
going to ask for a question. Thank you, Chairman, and thank you, Representative Gray, for bringing this, because there is some need, probably, for this, and I understand your passion, certainly. Let's go back and separate a couple things that you testified. one, fees versus interest. Interest is relative to time and money. So when you talk about when you equate or put in the same pot fees and interest as a similar conversation, they're different because of interest relative to time. So just in the fee situation, if the legislation is going to limit this to a short-term, a very short-term exposure, then that makes it more, I mean, but what makes this very depressing, in my opinion, is the, well, people are obviously in need in this situation, and they are desperate many times, so therefore, you have them where you want them, if you will, and we need to make a good choice on how we help them above the banks being able to do it. So I'm interested in it, but I don't know that I'm interested in it as opening it up to a whatever timeframe and whatever loan amount. I think there needs to be some reasonable borders put here, fences, to protect those that we're trying to help. Because they probably won't be in a position to protect themselves, and the CSO would be in the position of maximizing profit, which is what we all do in some situations for our businesses. So as a legislator and making law, we should be, I think, reasonable in how we frame this for the people we're trying to help. I agree with you that we need to try to help the unbankable at that particular point, but I think we need to put some fences on it because I think that would be necessary. Representative Murdoch, was
I could actually respond. And I do agree, and I feel like the cap does that to some degree. There's already a limit of $1,000 is the max. That's not in this bill, Representative. It's just already in the statute. Okay. At least that's what I'm being told. If not, we'll amend it and put that in there. But what I've been told is the $1,000 cap is already in a statute. It's just not in the part I'm changing. What about the term? The term. To my knowledge, the term is not in statute anywhere. And I think I want this right. So I think if that was something that we needed to look at, problem is we're not, this is the last state to run house bills. We could amend it, I suppose, on the Senate side and concur because we'll have to meet again to concur in things. So I want it right. Um, the cash max is who they're going to, you know, we'll be talked about. They want it right. They in the, what I've been told, so it depends on case law. What you look at, um, is whether or not that fee is considered to be, whether it should be part of usury or not part of usury. And so that's what I'm proposing is let's railroad them in. Let's wait for an actual opinion, whether it's a Supreme court case because we get sued on this, or whether it's an AG opinion that says this fee is separate, which is the model they're operating under right now, or whether it should be included underneath that 17 percent. In which case, because the banks are going to charge close to the 17 percent, there is no room left for a CSO to operate. There is no money left. There's no room for them to operate, and they would leave the state.
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. If I've got my math right, if you have a $1,000 maximum loan, or whatever they call it, you have the 17% fee and then you have 17% interest on all that. So that would be to borrow $1,000, you would have to pay back $1,368.90. Does that math sound about right? That sounds fair. Okay. And that would be whether you take it out for six weeks or six months. It'd be
close to that. The interest rate would be you'd pay a little bit less in interest because you were doing it over a lesser amount of time. But I'd be in complete transparency. That fee of $17 per 100 by the CSO is set. That's set,
but the interest rate may be lower if you pay that over six weeks. That's correct. Now, getting to the real meat of it, what is the penalty if you do not pay it back in those six weeks? This is not a collateralized loan, correct? That's correct. It's not collateralized. So there's not any collateral that can be attached. What is the penalty if you do not either in a timely way make your payments or you just don't make the payment?
I do know the default rate is rather high based on what I've been told. Now the CSO, because they guarantee it, they will pay the lender back. So the lender gets paid. The CSO then takes the debt and has to try and collect the debt from the customer if that makes
That I do not know. Okay, thank you. I think, Representative Lowry, if I could interject, I think it follows all of the other collection laws inside, so whatever fees would be associated with those I think would apply here too. So it's almost like if you think about you've got a prime borrower, you've got the United States Treasury that borrows with its credit ratings and low interest, You've got a prime borrower borrows at a rate. Then you've got a subprime borrower borrows at a rate. Then you get all the way down to the bottom, the people that are like Fancy's mom from Reba McIntyre's song, who don't have a lot of access to credit. They don't have as many options as some of the others, and then they pay these higher amounts. Representative Henderson, you're recognized for
a singer, isn't she? She looks good, too. But anyway, going on. I do appreciate what you're trying to do, Representative Gray. There's just a few things. When you talked about like a check cashing, you know, you get charged a fee for cashing check. That's a fee to me is a point in time. You know, when you get into APR, that's when you, if you're borrowing money and you're stretching it out six months, you have to annualize that to actually get your APR to make sure that you're keeping apples to apples when you're looking at interest rates. So I guess that's what I'm a little confused about because your interest rate is. Your APR, if you're charging $17 per hundred and you let it go six months, your interest rate is not going to be 17%. It's going to be something in the shorter of the time because to really keep apples to apples, you've got to use an APR to let that go. And that's, there's a question there somewhere. And I understand what you're saying.
And when you talked about a fee is a certain point in time, and that's when I responded to Representative Lowry, it doesn't matter if it's a six-week loan or a six-month loan. That fee is exactly the same, $17 on $100. It doesn't change. The interest rate that the bank charges will still be the 17%, but if you pay it back over a lesser amount of time, then the true annualized percentage rate does go down just a little bit. but the actual fee is set in stone, and it does not change no matter what the payment period is. It's still the same fee, and that's why essentially that's how they do it now. They used to have a higher fee, but that's why they think that they can operate outside of Amendment 89 is because it's a set-in-stone fee. Just like if you go to an attorney, they're going to charge you a fee for their service, a physician, an electrician, a plumber. This is a service to help them get a loan, And so it's a
fee at the time of service. Follow-up. And I really do understand that. Okay. But when you're talking about a fee, I mean, you can't, and I'm saying this as a banker's perspective, you can't charge a fee and then have it paid out over time with interest. Does that make sense? Because that gets back to borrowing money. You know, whether you're borrowing money, if you're borrowing $100 here, say, or $117. Okay. You know, it would be more.
Representative Henderson. Go ahead. As I listen to your question, what I'm hearing you describe, and correct me if I'm wrong here, is the notion of financing the fee. So you walk in and say, I'd like to borrow $100, and then you have to pay $17. You don't have the $17 either, so they say, look, I'll allow you to borrow the $17. So now you're going to borrow $117, and on the $117, you're going to pay 17% interest on the $117. I think your point is, do these people allow you to finance?
but that gets back to the point where a fee is paid at a point in time that's what i said when we when we looked at your cashing a check and paying a fee that really is a fee but now then if i cashed a check and paid it out over six months because i cash that check then it would be more interest than i'm paying and i
guess mr chair i just disagree to me it's a fee at a certain set in time whether you are paying that fee off over six months six weeks or six minutes to me to me it's still a fee and i mean when i financed i'm actually getting ready to finance my house i'm financing my closing costs with my house okay i can't do that anymore i think they're told i'm in trouble then aren't i I'm about to start saving some money. Yeah, meet
question. Yes, okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. One question on a CSO. If the borrower will pay on time, does this help them in regards to establishing their credit? I'm going to answer that with about
90% certainty and say yes. And there also are no penalties for paying it back early. You know, and that's actually, if you go look at the websites, it talks about paying back early, and they encourage that type thing.
Representative Payton, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Gray, I'll try to be real careful on how I word this question, because I know we're trying really hard to stay away from the term. But... Put it out there, you're fine. Well, predatory lending. But anyway, so here's the thing. We have recognized in the past that people willing to make loans to people who are in dire need took that opportunity to exploit the people in need and basically create indentured servants. This model that you have here that we're trying to deal with is some middle ground or gray area, but the banks operate under the usury law. If Arkansas banks were allowed to charge more than 17%, they would make riskier loans to people who had weaker credit. So why not just address this through a change in the Arkansas usury law to open up this field to where legitimate banks and savings and loans and credit organizations can participate and make these loans. When their hands are tied at 17% and we allow this business model to come as a backdoor effort to get around the 17%, it doesn't matter to me what middle ground it is. So why don't you take your passion and your effort, and I guess this is a qualifying question, and make the argument to let the legitimate lending organizations service this market at a 25%, 30%, 40% rate. But this business model seeks in its fees and its late charges and its default remedies. I mean, they will reduce this to a judgment. They will guarantee their wages. They are very good at collecting. That's how they can participate in this high-risk market. so i i just implore you to take your passion towards changing the usury law for short-term notes maybe and
and representative payton had this not all happened the last week of bills that might be something that we could have looked at and it's uh and i could be wrong on this but if we're looking at amendment 89 to the constitution that's a much bigger undertaking and changing that And I agree, we could do it once, but I can't do it the last week while I've got Representative Raybert trying to shut business down. Senator Raybert, if I have to, Senator Raybert, shut business down. So that's why, yeah, he had fun on Twitter with me last night too. But that's why I'm doing this at the last minute. It's essentially saying, give us two more years to work on this. Don't shut a line of business down that's needed without opening up something else that constituents need. So this is up to you guys.
question that may hurt, but I mean, two weeks ago, you brought to me a packet to look at, and you knew zero about what this is all about. And I should have spent more time talking to you about it. I wish I had. But do you feel confident with your depth of knowledge in two weeks to challenge other representatives of the people who have been involved in this subject for a much longer period
of time? I feel confident enough in my ability to quickly understand the facts, learn the business, to at least keep another person from shutting down a line of business without the proper debate and the proper authority, such as the Attorney General's office, the Supreme Court, weighing in on it. I do feel confident enough in that. Yes. All right.
Are there any other questions from committee? Seeing none, we've got two people signed up to speak against this. So Mr. Klein, Hank Klein, has signed up, and then also Ron Herrod has signed up. So if it's okay with you two gentlemen, well, you know what? We're doing one at a time. All right. So we've got Hank Klein first. Mr. Klein, you recognize. And we've had a lot of discussion so far. So what I'm going to do is just let these folks say their piece. But if it starts going long, I'm going to interrupt and see if we take a motion to limit debate. But let's see how this goes first. Mr. Klein, if you would introduce yourself and who you're with for the record, you'll be recognized.
Thank you, Chairman. My name is Hank Klein. I'm a resident of Sherwood, Arkansas, and I'm a volunteer with AARP. And I'm here this morning to speak against House Bill 1658 because this bill would do a lot of harm to consumers in our state. This bill would allow Cash Max Loan Services, who currently operates in North Little Rock and Hope, to continue to make high-cost predatory loans. They currently make $300 loans with an interest rate of 280% using the Arkansas Credit Service Organization model, CSO. CashMax also makes these loans in Texas and Ohio where high-cost payday loans are not legal. Instead of making payday loans, directly they make high-cost predatory loans using the Credit Service Organization installment loans. CashMax arranges with a company called NCP Finance out of Dayton, Ohio, to fund their loans in Arkansas at an interest rate of 17% on top of CashMax charges a fee for arranging the loans of 283.82% for a total interest rate of 280.82% on a $300 loan paid in four installments over your next four paydays. The owner of Cash Max operated a similar organization, CSO Loans, in eight Cash Now stores here in Arkansas from April through December of 2008. After Attorney General Dustin McDaniel ordered all payday lending stores to close in March of 2008, their Cash Now stores converted their eight stores in Arkansas and one was on JFK Boulevard, just across the street and down a little bit from where the current store is. But they were finally closed down. They converted to the CSO model. Attorney General finally closed them down on December the 15th of 2008, and now they're up to their old tricks again, except this time their loans are even more expensive. Amendment 89 in the Arkansas Constitution limits interest on consumer loans to no more than 17% per annum. Cash Max charges 16 times that. I have the Cash Max website here, and I have the amendment here. And I will tell you that it will be less expensive than people are currently paying. $17 per hundred for a $300 loan, 17 times 3. is $51. Currently, they're paying a CSO fee of $81. $600 loan. 17 times $600 is $102. Presently, they're paying $268.50. So the interest rate, instead of being 280.82%, would just be a little over 100% annual percentage rate. Annual percentage rate is set by the federal government, The Federal Truth and Lending Act. It's been out since 1968 to make sure that all loans, no matter whether they're 30-year loans or a two-week loan, are all talked about on an annual percentage rate so we can all figure out what we're paying for our loans. Can I ask you a question? Yes, sir.
So let's say you were the individual that was going for this terrible deal because the federal government borrows at 1%. Wouldn't you agree? the federal government borrows at one percent the united states treasury borrows at one percent wouldn't you agree yeah okay so other people borrow at rates that are higher than that so this individual that can't get a loan for 12 percent or 13 percent and you're and i understand you're saying boy these rates are really high right and i agree with you they're high they're terrible rates okay so what would you tell the person who needs three hundred dollars for their alternator, what would you say? What are they supposed to do if we put these people out of business? What are they supposed to do? That's the part I keep asking folks that nobody will
answer for me. What would they do? Sir, I have helped over 50 consumers who got caught up in payday lending. I started the Arkansans Against Abuse of Payday Lending coalition of 40 different groups here in Arkansas that eventually got payday lending shut down. I personally have helped more than 40 people get out of the trap of payday lending. I contacted a number of those people a couple years afterwards to find out, Keisha, how are you doing now that you don't have the payday lender anymore to fall back on? And what Keisha told me was three things. Keisha said, number one, thank you, Mr. Klein, for getting rid of the payday lenders. I no longer have them to fall back on, and I got in so much trouble when I got with those people, I could never get out of what I had with them. Thank you for helping me get out of that, and thank you for getting rid of them. I said, that's fine, Keisha, but what are you actually doing? She says, I'm saving money now. I realize that I have emergencies. I have $500 saved. I I said, well, over the last two years, certainly you've had some kind of emergency. What have you done? And what she told me was, I went to my parents. Yes, I did have an emergency. Something did happen with my car. I went to my parents, who I wouldn't have gone to if the payday lender was here. I would have went to them, but I went to my parents. Thank you for answering my question.
sir? Yes, I would just tell you that our Constitution is very clear. 17%. In 2008, we had three Supreme Court decisions, and the Supreme Court decision said that the General Assembly did not have the authority to determine what was or was not interest. That was up to the courts, and they said that the Check Cashers Act that had been in place and said these various fees were not interest, that was outlawed, and you guys have taken that away. In 1952, installment lenders tried to come into our state. In fact, did come into our state. They got a law passed in 1952. Back then, the interest rate in our constitute was 10%. They said they were charging 10% plus this fee, this fee, this fee, and this fee. If you added all those fees up, the interest rate was 36%, which seems tame today. The next year, 1953, there were three Supreme Court decisions, and the Supreme Court said the very same thing. The legislature cannot determine what is and is not interest that's up to the courts. They threw the cases out, and those installment lenders left our state. And if you guys approve this, if the governor signs this, and he's already stated that he would not allow predatory lending to return to our state, but if that happens, the Supreme Court will decide that all of this is interest, and 100% interest is too much for consumers to pay in Arkansas when our usury rate, and the banks are not under the usury rate, by the way, and the usury rate is 17% in our state.
Representative Herod, Mr. Herod, you recognize I speak against the bill. I had the privilege of being involved in the passage of Amendment 89. Y'all may, most of you, I guess, know Senator Cheatham. He was in the House then, and he agreed to take our bill, and we were one of those three amendments that was referred to the people, and it became law. It became Amendment 89. Before Amendment 89 was passed, you wanted to buy a refrigerator. You had very few ways that you could buy it in Arkansas because they didn't finance them where they sold them. You could put it on a credit card, or you could pay cash, or you could rent to own. Those were the only methods if your refrigerator went out. This thing raised, Amendment 59, 89, raised that to 17%. That is law. And what we learned in that fight is that the Truth in Lending Act, through the Supreme Court's decisions is the determining factor on how many fees are charged as interest. They all charge as interest. I want you to know that from a very young age, I understood from reading the Bible that overcharging your neighbor was wrong. And I want you to know, I believe that's why Christ was so angry when he went into the sales in the chapel and ran those people off and one of the things it refers to is money counters, you know, money traders. I believe those were predatory lenders and I hope y'all keep them out of Arkansas. Thank you so much. And I'll answer your question if anybody has any. Seeing none, is there anyone that would like to speak for the bill? Anyone
just to close? Yes, you may. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I understand the arguments that are being made. All I'm saying before we shut down a line of business that our constituents, my constituents might need to use is that we give it time, two years, put them in some parameters and wait for the AG's opinion, Supreme Court, whatever it is, and we don't know how the Supreme Court, I mean, we just heard testimony that the Supreme Court would rule a certain way. That's up to the Supreme Court, how they decide they want to rule on that. A Federal Reserve study from 2015 shows that 47% of Americans say that they don't have enough money to cover a $400 emergency. That's almost half of America. All I'm saying is if we're going to shut this down, where are these people going to go. That's my biggest concern. I don't care what the business model is, and I've come to terms with it being a fee. As long as we feel that we're not essentially letting businesses take advantage of our constituents, we have to help them, give them a place to go when they need money to cover an emergency so that's with that I'm closed and it's I'm closed thank you all right what's the will
of the committee I'm excuse me representative civilian recognized for motion we have a do pass motion on the table is there any discussion on the motion seeing none all in favor aye any opposed I'm sorry Sorry, Representative Gray, the bill as amended fails. Thank you, Mr. Chair and colleagues. Bye-bye. All right, Representative Gazeway, I know you've been waiting patiently. You're recognized to present House Bill, I think it's 2251. Representative Gasway, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Members, House Bill 2251 is a bill that came to me from the Attorney General's office. and basically all the bill does is it provides a definition for the word encryption for the Personal Information Protection Act. The Personal Information Protection Act is an act that the Attorney General uses to prosecute and file civil cases against individuals or entities who for negligent handling of sensitive data and data that's supposed to be encrypted. And so the encryption needed a different definition in this particular act than it's defined in other places because of what this act applies to, the type of conduct that it applies to. And so it's the attorney general's job to protect the consumers and to get restitution for negligent actions for companies that collect data. And therefore, the definition for this act has to be different to reflect the type of cases that the attorney general's office pursues. And so that's what the bill does. I'd be happy to answer
any questions. Seeing none, is anyone here to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Gassaway, are you closed for your bill? I'm closed for the bill. I move do pass on, or Representative Henderson moves do pass on House Bill 2251. All in favor? Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Gasway. You passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, members. I'm going to come back to the agenda one last time before we close this, because for House bills, this is probably the last day where there's any realistic chance a House bill could make it through to law. So if you're on the agenda and you're here now and didn't get a chance to present earlier, going once, going twice, gone. We're probably going to have a meeting on Monday. I'm just anticipating that we're going to get Senate concurrence needs coming back when we come back on Monday. So I'm anticipating a meeting at 10 a.m. on Monday. I'm going to go ahead and just set that but recognize the focus is going to be Senate bills and house bills coming back for concurrence. And with that, ladies and gentlemen, without objection, we're adjourned.
HB2086 Sabin TO PROTECT THE PROPERTY RIGHTS OF CITIZENS; TO PREVENT THE ABUSE OF THE POWER OF EMINENT DOMAIN BY PRIVATE PIPELINE COMPANIES; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
0:51 - 2:09:06372 segments36 speakers
Representative Warwick Sabin introduced HB 2086, explaining that it was intended to protect Arkansas landowners from private-pipeline eminent-domain abuse by adding a 30-day notice requirement, requiring both PSC and ADEQ permits, and setting compensation rules for affected property.
[1:04][1:35][2:06][2:37]
HB2102 Lemons CONCERNING THE RESULTING LIABILITY UNDER A WARRANTY DUE TO A BUSINESS NAME CHANGE.
HB2212 Magie TO PROHIBIT THE USE OF AN ALL-PRODUCTS CLAUSE IN A HEALTHCARE PROVIDER CONTRACT; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB2054 Hammer TO REPEAL THE ARKANSAS HOUSING TRUST FUND ACT OF 2009.
HB1271 HammerTO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HEALTH INSURANCE INNOVATION ACT OF 2017; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB2209 M. Gray TO CLARIFY THE USE OF AN ALL-PRODUCTS CLAUSE IN A HEALTHCARE PROVIDER CONTRACT.
SB683 D. Sanders TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS HEALTHCARE TRANSPARENCY INITIATIVE ACT OF 2015.
HB1753 Collins TO CLARIFY THAT THE SUBROGATION AND REIMBURSEMENT RIGHTS OF PARTIES TO AN INSURANCE CONTRACT ARE TO BE DEFINED BY THE INSURANCE CONTRACT.
SB522 E. Cheatham TO CONTINUE TO REQUIRE HEALTH BENEFIT PLANS TO PROVIDE COVERAGE FOR THE TREATMENT OF MORBID OBESITY; AND TO EXTEND THE PILOT PROGRAM ON COVERAGE FOR MORBID OBESITY DIAGNOSIS AND TREATMENT.
DEFERRED Number Subtitle Sponsor
HB1751 Cozart TO CLARIFY THE RESPONSIBILITIES OF AN INSURER FOR APPLICATION OF INSURANCE PROCEEDS FOR ROOF REPAIR; AND TO PROVIDE FOR PROPER ALLOWANCES ON A ROOF REPAIR INSURANCE CLAIM.
HB1838 S. Meeks TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE HEALTH SAVINGS ACCOUNTS OF CERTAIN STATE EMPLOYEES.
HB1840 Johnson CONCERNING THE APPLICATION OF INSURANCE PROCEEDS RESULTING FROM FIRE DAMAGE TO PROPERTY COVERED BY PROPERTY INSURANCE.
HB1890 Tucker TO ESTABLISH AN ARKANSAS CROWDFUNDING OPTIONS; AND TO REGULATE EXEMPTIONS UNDER SECURITIES LAWS.
HB1958 M. Gray CONCERNING THE CREDIT SERVICES ORGANIZATIONS ACT OF 1987.
HB2061 Hammer TO MODERNIZE THE FIRE RATING SYSTEM IN ARKANSAS; AND TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS FIRE RATING BUREAU ACT.
HB2135 Sabin TO CLARIFY THE OBLIGATIONS OF RESIDENTIAL LANDLORDS AND RESIDENTIAL TENANTS; AND TO REQUIRE MINIMUM HABITABILITY STANDARDS FOR TENANTS OF RESIDENTIAL REAL PROPERTY.
HB2193 Hammer TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING DRIVERS EXCLUDED FROM A MOTOR VEHICLE INSURANCE POLICY; AND TO IMPOSE CRIMINAL LIABILITY ON THE INSURED DRIVER AND THE EXCLUDED DRIVER IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES.