May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
HB1793 McCollum TO CREATE A PANEL ON DATA TRANSPARENCY; AND TO CREATE THE POSITIONS OF CHIEF DATA OFFICER AND CHIEF PRIVACY OFFICER WITHIN THE DEPARTMENT OF IN… 0:12
Representative Austin McCollum introduced HB 1793, explaining that it implements earlier report recommendations by creating a state data-transparency panel, a chief data officer, and a chief privacy officer within the Department of Information Systems to enable inter-departmental data sharing and a data warehouse.
[0:30][1:03][1:34]
Representative Stephen Meeks clarified that the two officer positions have already been established and their costs will be absorbed by DIS, so the bill would not draw on general revenue, and noted that the governor’s office supports the strategic approach.
[2:06][2:16]
After a brief Q&A, Rep. McCollum moved to pass the bill, the committee voted aye with no opposition, and the motion carried, resulting in the bill’s passage.
[2:59][3:01][3:09]
HB2099 S. Meeks TO AMEND THE TELECOMMUNICATIONS REGULATORY REFORM ACT OF 2013; AND TO MODERNIZE THE ARKANSAS HIGH COST FUND. 3:31
He then presented the full bill, outlining a reverse-auction grant to be administered by the Arkansas Economic Development Commission, clarifying that the High-Cost Fund would remain untouched and adding reporting requirements for the fund and the commission.
[5:55][6:18][6:52][7:26][7:57][8:32][9:03][9:33][10:04][10:38][11:08][11:45][12:20]
So we'll call the meeting to order, and I'll let Representative McCollum take the end of the table, and we're going to look at House Bill 1793. And, Representative, if you have anybody that you'd like to join you, you're more than welcome to have them join you. And when you get settled, if you would introduce yourself to the committee and you're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. So this, a lot of the language, at least the title, should look very familiar to you. Task Bill 1793. So this came from the report, I think it was either the first or the second meeting that we had on creating the panel on open data, and we had a pretty lengthy report that was given to us. We talked about it. We talked about the recommendations. So what this bill does is it takes those recommendations, and it puts them into action. The creation of a chief data officer, a chief privacy officer, and it creates a panel. All of the individuals are listed in the bill of the departments that would be associated with this panel, as well as two individuals from the private sector. This is just to refresh your memory in hopes of ultimately down the road having the ability for different departments and their data sets to come together to talk to each other, store in a data warehouse. We've listed the number of efficiencies earlier in different conversations that we've had that this would create. Ultimately, we strongly believe this would create a ton of efficiency for our state government and ultimately save money. So does anyone have any questions for me? Because I know there's another bill that probably a lot of people want to talk about. Isn't
it true, Representative McCollum, that the, just for the benefit of the committee, that the two positions have already been created and that the cost of those positions will be absorbed in DIS, so there will be no cost to general revenue
to get started with this program? That is true. That is the way we are going to set it up. We've met with the governor's office. They're on board with the strategic thinking behind this, and they're on board as to why we would want
to create such a panel. Okay. Colleagues, any other questions from the committee? Okay. Seeing none, we will go to the audience. I don't see anybody signed up. Is there anyone here that would like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Seeing none, Representative McCollum, would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed. All right. Thank you. With that, what's the will of the committee? Representative McCollum, would you like to make the motion?
I just want to make sure you support your own bill down there. All right. We have a motion to do pass. All in favor, please signify by saying aye. Any opposed? All right. Congratulations, sir. You have passed your bill. All right. All right, colleagues, we have an amendment to House Bill 2099. I'm going to pass the mic over here to my co-chair. I'm going to take the end of the table, and then I'll let Ms. Williams pass that out. And then that'll be the first thing we'll address, and then we'll get to the meet of
2099. Thank you. We're just going to wait for everybody to get a copy of the amendment and Representative Meeks to present the amendment. Okay, Representative Meeks, you're recognized to present amendment number two to House
Bill 2099. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The first amendment relates to the reverse auction. Basically what it does is it allows a right of first refusal to telecommunications that are already in an underserved area. Beyond that, I want to wait until we get to the heart of the bill. So with that, I would make a motion to
do pass on the amendment. Okay. We have a motion do passed on this amendment. Are there any, was there any discussion? I guess we, were there any questions? No questions from the committee. Is there any discussion on the motion? Okay, seeing no discussion, all in favor of the motion, please signify by saying aye. Aye. Opposed nay? The ayes have it. The amendment is adopted. Representative Meeks, you're now recognized to present House Bill 2099 as amended. All right. Thank you, Mr.
Chairman. Colleagues, as you know, about a year ago, the Speaker of the House charged this committee with looking at ways to improve broadband deployment within the state. The committee undertook several meetings to go around the state to look for ideas, concerns, so forth on how we might move forward on this issue. I was very pleased to surprise that there were not a whole lot of obstacles that were preventing deployment and that essentially it comes down to availability of money and resources to be able to get into the underserved and non-served areas. I've traveled to different states, looked at all sorts of different programs. And this idea that I bring you today in the form of House Bill 2099 is the culmination of that work. I will start by prefacing and saying this will not be the end. There's still much work that needs to be done in this area. Still a lot of input on this process and I want to thank a lot of the providers that are in the room. The Public Service Commission and many of you on this committee that have helped in this area. I know it's an area that a lot of us are very supportive of and would like to see our state move forward. So what we've done is what we're trying to do is on House Bill 2099, if you take a look at it, it's roughly a 15-page long bill. The vast majority of it is simply cleanup language. It doesn't change anything. It just clarifies that in this case, most of it talks about the high-cost fund and the Arkansas Public Service Commission. The bulk of what we're doing today is actually on page 15. What we're doing is, or what we're proposing, is that we create a reverse auction grant under the Arkansas Economic Development Commission. I know there's some concern among the providers in the room that this money is coming from the high cost fund or deals with the high cost fund. This money in no way, shape, or form touches or manages or does anything with Arkansas High Cost Fund. The Arkansas High Cost Fund is being left alone. Any money that goes into this program will be new money, which I'll talk about here in just a few minutes. Basically the concept behind a reverse auction is simple. If you have two providers that are looking to go into an area, they both come to the table and they say that I can add 100 customers for $100,000. If the one says, I can make a business case and I can go in there and I'll put in $80,000 of my own, so I need $20,000 to get me over to the top, business B comes to the table and says, my best business case for that is $50,000, so I need $50,000 to get me over the top, then what we're going to do is we're going to give the $20,000 to the provider who can get us the most new people added for the least amount of possible cost. As we go forward through time, once we get sort of the low hanging fruit, then the goal is that we get to more and more and more complicated areas that these funds would be able to help our carriers. The way the reverse auction is set up, I tried to be, I didn't want to create a whole lot of rules within the law to allow flexibility over at AEDC to administer the program. The only rules that we're putting in place in the law is that it's technology neutral, so that way we don't tie ourselves to a certain type of technology, that they don't establish a minimum matching amount. The idea behind that is if we say we want them to bring 20 percent, most of them only bring 20 percent, and that's it. We want them to bring as much as they possibly can. And then we delineate two different areas. The first area that we delineate is an unserved area. So that's an area that currently has no Internet access whatsoever. And we say that in order to be eligible for the funds, for somebody who has nothing right now, you have to be able to bring the area up to 10-1. Now why 10-1? Currently with fixed point wireless, you can get 10 megabytes into an area. Hard to get to that 25 range currently, but you can get to 10 megabytes. For somebody that has nothing, 10 megabytes is a game changer. Now, in an underserved area, that's an area that already has some type of Internet, we're saying if you want to have access to these funds, that you have to get up to at least 25.3, which is the current FCC definition. The amendment that I just added would imply that if you're already, say, providing 10.1 or 3.2 or whatever it is, that before state funds allow a competitor to come in and overbuild you, that you have the first opportunity to accept any funds. Once you've got an area up to the 25-3, then those state funds are going to help you to come in and overbuild a competitor because we don't want state funds to disrupt the free market. But, like I said, beyond that, the Economic Development Commission will develop the rules. Of course, those rules will then have to be approved by us. The other thing that it does is requires that the high-cost fund begin to submit a report to this committee on an annual basis. That's not being done. So part of us making good decisions on what, if anything, to do with that fund in the future begins with us having good information, and that's a good first step. And also, should funds become available for the reverse auction, that the Economic Development Committee would also report to us on the progress of how we're doing in this area. This morning, joint budget, they did pass the appropriation in AEDC to set the fund up. As far as where the source of funds would come, currently there is no source of funds. So essentially what we would be doing is in the event that a surplus develops within the state, it would allow some of those surplus funds or would allow the governor with his quick action closing fund, What should he see fit to put funds within this program in order to help with broadband deployment with the state? And with that, that's it in a nutshell. Basically we add two reporting requirements, create the reverse auction, and go from there. So with that, committee, I will open it up to any questions.
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Chairman Meeks, I just really have one question. I'm just a little curious that you've chosen the Arkansas Economic Development Commission over the Public Service Commission to administer this. Could you share with us your
rationale for that? Yes. And actually, I should point out that this was discussed between all three branches, myself, the executive branch, and the senators. And it was thought that the best people to do that would be the Economic Development Commission under the idea that we're trying to promote economic development within the state. The Public Service Commission or the High Cost Fund, just to be frank, we want to make sure that we're not allowing the politics of all the moving parts of this to get involved. We wanted somebody who could basically from the outside make determinations on what is the best possible choice or best possible investments, if you will, for the citizens of Arkansas. A lot of the complications are with this, you know, if you're going to lay fiber, if you go to lay fiber in the Ozarks, it's a whole lot more expensive than it is to lay fiber in the Delta, just because drilling through rock is a whole lot more expensive. And so we wanted to put it in an agency that, A, would have the flexibility to take all that stuff into consideration, and B, since they're the ones that are charged with the economic development of the state, they know sort of the projects that they're working on to promote that, things that they generally can't release to the public, so they can take all that into account as far as trying to direct these funds for the best outcome for our citizens. Are there any other questions from the committee? Representative Blake, you're recognized
Well, I know they're represented here. We have John Bethel, and I think I saw Amy Fetcher walk in earlier, but I could be wrong about that. Yep. I did see her. Okay. Great. If either of you want to make yourself available, I guess for a question from Representative Blake, is that right? Yes. Okay. Is your question for both of them or just one of them? I'll talk. AEDC first. Okay. Ms. Fetcher, if you would identify
taking a position on the bill. We feel that we're here to serve the state. So if this bill passes and there's a position, you know, we will carry out the duty in the legislation. We do support expanding broadband statewide. You're recognized for follow-up. Thank you. Can
here late. You may have already covered this, but I mean, this is a lot to read. But this is for anybody then at the table that can explain this to me. I'm seeing in here that the Arkansas Public Service Commission is getting tasked with setting up the regulations for the grant program, delegating, enforcing, yada, yada, yada. It all seems to be the Arkansas Public Service Commission getting the responsibility for setting all this up. And then suddenly we switch over and go, but the Arkansas Economic Development Commission will be the ones that decide who gets the money. Is that how this is working? Because that seems to be how it's written in the bill. No. So help me understand
that. Yeah, yeah, gladly. Most of that, the rest of the bill is essentially cleanup language. This section of the code deals primarily with the Arkansas High Cost Fund and how we deal with utilities that are regulated by the Public Service Commission. And under the current language, it basically just says the commission shall do this, the commission shall do that, the commission shall do the other. And because we're adding the Economic Development Commission duties in this section of code, if we just left it as commission, there would be confusion what commission are we talking about. So all that language does is it just strikes commission and puts in Public Service Commission. So we're not expanding or changing their duties. It's just making clear that we're not moving these duties to economic development. We're leaving those duties with the Public Service Commission as is.
Follow-up, if I could. You recognize for a follow-up. So then that just breeds another question, and that is if everything else in this code section is all being done by the Public Service Commission and the language for this fits in that code, it just seems odd to give it to a different agency than the Public Service Commission. I mean, I'm not following the thought process there. I mean, I understand economic development, but Public Service Commission has a different viewpoint, and we're trying to expand broadband, if I'm understanding this correctly. It just seems like that's something that would fit under their purview more
than it would economic development. And Director Bethel may want to jump into this. The purpose of the Public Service Commission is to regulate these entities, but not necessarily to promote these entities. And so Economic Development Commission, their job is to promote and to market. And so they're better equipped to promote the broadband and better equipped to know the areas of the state that might benefit from this better. The folks over at Public Service Commission, they regulate these agencies. And part of the concern is that you could end up creating a situation where you create a conflict of interest, because since they regulate these agencies, you don't want to put them into a position where they're also picking and choosing who gets this money because it could create, you know, we don't want to put them in a bad situation. So this relegates those duties between these two agencies so that they don't get put in a situation where, you know, someone's before them for a ruling at the same time they're also before them asking for support. and I think we could all see how that could lead to conflicts. And I don't know if Director Bethel has any other comments
on that. No, I just, we currently, we don't regulate any of the local exchange telecommunications companies, but we do administer the high-cost fund, and that's what this section that exists currently addresses, that we administer the high-cost fund. We have a contractor, the high-cost administrator, that performs that function for the commission and as instructed in the statutes for that. But we don't regulate broadband service itself, but that's not a regulated service, and so we don't have any regulation in that space. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Kavanaugh,
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Meeks, so AEDC is really just going to oversee the reversed auction grant. That's all they're actually going to do? That's all they're doing, yes. May I have a follow-up? You're recognized, yes. Thank you, Mr. Chair. The high-cost funds, you said that there's nothing changing in that. All we did was change the name from commission to public
service. Right. The only thing that's changing on the high-cost fund is now the law would say that they have to provide a report to this committee so that we know how those funds are being expended. We have, through this process, obviously been looking at the high-cost fund, But we weren't able to come to any consensus on how to modernize it. And so having that information will allow us as lawmakers to make better decisions on what, if any, changes that need to be made to that going forward. But as of right now, this bill does nothing to the high-cost fund. I'll
allow you one more follow-up, sure. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And this is for Amy. Ms. Fescher, is AEDC prepared? They're prepared to, if the money does come available, to administer this grant and be part of AEDC.
Y'all are comfortable with that. We see it as our role to serve the state. And if this passes, then we will promulgate the rules and regs and administer the program.
That's a polite way of saying that they're not allowed to take positions on all these stuff. But I will say that she and her agency have been involved in this from the get-go. So this is not something we're springing on them, surprise, last minute. They've been involved in this for, I don't know, probably a year or so.
Representative McCollum, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Meeks, have you consulted some of the providers in this state, the ones that
are currently? I think almost every single one. What have you heard back from them? I don't know if we have enough time to go into all the different feedback we've gotten. Um, the, um, as it relates to this bill, it's been, as it relates to what we're trying to do in this particular instance, with the high cost fund, there was a lot of concern back and forth, which is why we decided not to touch that at this point. Um, with this bill, there has, um, been some concern, um, and I think some of them are signed up to speak, so I'll, I don't want to put words in their mouth, so I'll let them, address some of their concerns with the committee. MR. Are there any
other questions from the committee? Okay, seeing none, we do have several members of the audience who have signed up to speak, and all four of them so far are against the bill. And I understand Mr. Vigno is not going to speak, so he was number one on the list, followed by Katie Burns. So, Katie, or Ms. Burns, you're recognized to come up. If you would, identify yourself for the
record, please. Good afternoon, my name is Katie Burns. I am the Director of Government Relations for CenturyLink Telecommunications. And while we appreciate the efforts of this body to move the needle forward on broadband, we are greatly disappointed that after two years, like Representative Meek said, after two years of working together and traveling around the state and following this committee, we saw this legislation for the first time when I printed it off the computer upstairs. We feel like we are an integral part of this process. We have been at the beck and call of anyone that has needed to talk to us about this issue and what we're trying to do. But like I said, we were not given the legislation or any time to kind of process the different stages of this along the way. So for that, like I said, we're disappointed. With such little time to review, obviously we are opposing the bill. And first and foremost, the reverse auction process, we feel like in Arkansas is very premature. There are federal funds that are pouring into the state right now. CenturyLink, along with AT&T and Windstream, have accepted those federal funds based off of certain criteria, a reverse auction process would go against a lot of that criteria. And in our minds, and I'll just speak for CenturyLink, could, if funded and the reverse auction began being funded, could actually jeopardize some of that federal funding coming into the state. We accepted CenturyLink alone, and just to tell progress, and I know that broadband, Everybody wants it now and fast, but just to kind of give you an idea of what CenturyLink committed to when we accepted the CAF2 money in Arkansas, we stepped up and committed $90 million, just CenturyLink, $90 million over the course of the CAF2 program that will be spent in connection with the federal money that's coming into the state, and we have committed to serve more than 45,000 living units in the state of Arkansas. The first year out of the gate in the program, we have upgraded or served in over 14,000 living units. So when we talk about broadband and doing it right and doing it fast, I think that for now, for us, this process and the federal process needs to run its course. We have federal money coming into the state to help promote broadband in Arkansas, and I do not want to jeopardize any federal money and then have the Arkansas taxpayers have to pick up the bill later. Another note, there are discussions on the federal level of a CAF-3 process, which would actually go even deeper in the weeds and take broadband further than even CAF-2 can do. Also, I know Justin Allen is here today on behalf of some of the small companies. They have accepted ACAM funding with a lot of the same criteria and requirements that we have in CAF-2 that will deploy broadband across the state even faster. But just to kind of give you an idea of amount and money, the amount that CenturyLink alone is spending during this CAF-2 process and our commitment to the state of Arkansas right now all in at $90 million, that's in addition to the CAF-2 funding. So we do not want to jeopardize any of that investment in the state. I'll be happy to answer any questions. Are there any questions from the
Thank you for coming. How will this reverse auction, how is it going to affect the federal funding you're talking about? You're talking about how it's going to affect it negatively. Yes, ma'am. How will
that happen? Okay, so what happens is when you have these, and I'll just speak to the CAF2 since that's what our company has chosen. When you have the CAF2 census blocks, there are areas in the state that were approved by the FCC as unserved or underserved areas in those CAF2 census blocks. So we as a company had to commit to serve a certain amount of living units within those census blocks. If a reverse auction of any kind is put beside or, well, and I need to mention the halo effect as well, but if any of those areas are also considered along in the reverse auction, then that census block would no longer be a valid census block, meaning we wouldn't get funding to serve there because the state would be providing funding to serve there. It would be duplicative. Um, and also I needed to mention as well, um, you know, I mentioned that we are going to touch 45,000 living units over the course of this program. That is just actually what the CAF, what CAF two can take responsibility for as a result of the CAF two funding. There's also a large halo effect, um, at least for, for our company. I'm sure the other companies can speak to that as well. We're probably actually going to capture an additional 40,000 living units in addition to the 45,000 we've committed to, and that's either upgrading existing customers to higher speeds or actually, you know, we just turned up, I think, 25 in Garfield, Arkansas, and then that was a huge CAF2 project that we did. So there is a halo effect to where that money will actually kind of go beyond. But to answer your question, there is serious concerns regarding the CAF2 census blocks that were very carefully chosen and approved by the FCC, and that money has to flow into those areas. areas that can't go outside of those census blocks. You're recognized for
a follow-up question. What about the areas that those census blocks that are not designated by you or anybody else, any other provider? I guess that's my question, you know, if you've got your census block, but there's, I guess, is 100 percent of Arkansas covered by these census blocks that could not benefit from this reverse grant? My
question. I know that, and Lisa, I may have to look to you, 130,000? Yes, 130,000 living units. Right, I'm sorry. I don't know if it covers the entire state, but I do know that this program alone, just with the three large companies, covers up to like 130,000 living units, which is quite a big impact on the state. But I don't have the census, the CAF-2 maps in front of me. I don't know if it covers everywhere, but I do know that the CAF-3 process, which is coming next, is also going to be bringing more money to
go into even the more remote areas. Okay, sure. As someone from rural Arkansas, I can say we must not be in your areas because we can't get anybody to come out. So that's what my question is. For people in rural areas where it's not viable for y'all to come, this might be an option to help us be able to get these to our, not only to our citizens, but to businesses that desperately need it. From someone who's sitting in an area that I can't get anybody to come out and look at putting in a broadband to my industrial park at our airport, you know, the reverse auction might work. So that's what my question to you is. We're talking about this halo effect and how many Arkansans are affected by this, but how many are not in your plans to be affected by that? And I
can, at another time, I would be more than happy to bring the CAF2 maps back. I do know that there are some areas actually in your district that I could probably show you offline. But that being said, I think that we're one year in. I think that we're one year into a six-year program, and I think that to take the risk of interrupting a program like that that's actually bringing federal money into the state, I don't think that would be good policy for the state of
Arkansas. Are there any other questions for Ms. Burns? If not, I have a quick question for you. Yes, sir. There was an article a few days ago in the New York Times about the use of the reverse auction in the state of New York as far as really extending improved broadband service to rural parts of the state that didn't have it. And I'm wondering if you know anything about that program and if they, you know, had put any of their federal funds in jeopardy as a result of that. I
don't know when you have time to read the paper. I haven't read the New York Times session started. I read it every day. I try. I do know that there are places where reverse auctions have been successful. I do not know about, I cannot speak to the connection to a state that's received money versus that hasn't. I can just speak to here. And it's a genuine
question just because it's hard for me to believe that the state of New York would have put their, you know, those kinds of federal funds in jeopardy by adopting a program like that.
Well, I think that there's a major concern for overbuild and a lot, too, like where we've already built out. There's concerns about overbuild, obviously. There's also, I think, quite a few instances where companies that are given money and kind of brought into a situation where it's okay, like Representative Mink said, if you can do it for $100,000 and you can do it for $70,000, then we'll kind of split the difference. There are a lot of fly-by-night companies that have come in and really caused states harm by saying they can do things and not being able to actually follow through with what after they get the money. I think there's some small companies from Arkansas that have also worked in Oklahoma that have cases that they can discuss to that. Okay, thank you. Are there any other questions
from the committee? Seeing none, thank you very much for testifying. Thank you so much for your time. The next person on the list to speak against the bill is Justin Allen. Mr. Allen, if you would identify yourself for the record, please.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman and committee. My name is Justin Allen. I'm an attorney here in Little Rock, and I'm here today speaking on behalf of my clients, South Arkansas Telephone Company in Calhoun County, Ritter Communications in Jonesboro, and Yelcott Telephone Company in Mountain View, all of which are telephone companies and Internet service providers. A lot of what I say will echo what you've heard from Ms. Burns, so I'll try to be brief. But as she stated, literally tens of millions of dollars in FCC federal money have begun coming into Arkansas and will continue to do so over the next six to ten years. You heard Ms. Burns talk about the CAF-2 money that's being made available to the large providers. The FCC has also moved forward what is called the ACAM funding model, which is Alternative Connect America Cost Model, ACAM. This is going to be about $1 billion nationally for rural telephone companies and Internet service providers to get broadband service out to the more rural places in the country. In Arkansas, there are five companies that are going to participate in that program, and those five collectively will receive about $11 million a year over 10 years to reach and get fiber and or broadband of some nature at least 10-1 out to the rural areas. Two of those companies are my client, one being Ritter, one being Yelcott, to give you kind of an idea of what they're going to be looking at and what they're obligated to do, in fact, by receiving the money, is Ritter will receive about $5.3 million a year over the life of the program and will be connecting up to 8,200 locations during that process. That will increase from their current customer base almost 50% of what they currently serve, At least 3,200 of those will be at 25.3 and 3,200 at 10.1. Yelcott will receive 2.5 million a year and will connect up to 6,000 locations. At least 3,700 of those will be 25.3 and 1,200 at the speed of 10.1. I say that to say in terms of House Bill 299, we are with Representative Chairman Meeks and what he's trying to do all the way. There's no question. And where there's opportunities to get additional funding to help deploy broadband, especially in rural areas, we're with it. But this bill, which, again, industry, or at least speaking for myself, I saw for the first time on Monday afternoon is extremely vague. There's a lot of uncertainty and questions. And what I don't want to do, Representative Kavanaugh, to your question earlier, is for this fund, if it is ever funded and started up, to be duplicative, to work contrary to all the millions of dollars in federal funding. Now, if there are some areas that aren't going to be touched by this funding, perhaps something like this is something that we need to look at. But we need to make sure that's what's going to happen, and we have no assurance in the current legislation that that's not going to happen. I would like to think that AEDC, through the rulemaking process and industry and interested parties weighing in, would try to make sure that's not the case. But I think that's a safeguard that the legislature probably should consider before it turns it over to an agency for rulemaking. And to give you an idea about the ACAM, my clients have ordered equipment. They're getting engineering designs. They're beginning to spend money. That ship is setting sail. So it is imperative that whatever we do here that we get it right. I don't want to say that outright that a reverse auction is a bad idea or isn't the way to go, but there are concerns with it. And I received a white paper this morning prepared by four national associations that are made up of rural Internet service and telephone providers, and I don't have a copy of it with me here. I will get hard copies and or e-mail it to you. in due course, and we'll send you a copy, but it notes problems with the process that's been used internationally, including examples of failure to attract bidders and default by winning bidders. And that raises an issue that I think the General Assembly might want to consider before turning it loose to rulemaking, is that's making sure you have qualified bidders. Just because you get the person that's willing to do it for the best price, and I know this is a discussion we have here at the Capitol in many contexts frequently, doesn't necessarily mean you're going to get what you want, and the money may go to waste. So it's important that we get it right. We support broadband deployment. We support working with the General Assembly, and we support having funding, but we need to get it right and make sure that primarily it complements the ongoing and forthcoming federal process, and with the bill we have here, we just don't know if we're going to be able to get it right. So with that, thank you, Mr. Chairman and committee.
I'd be happy to try and answer any questions. Thank you, Mr. Allen. are there any questions from the committee? Okay, seeing none, we appreciate the testimony. We've got one person left on the list, and that is Lisa Lake.
Ms. Lake, if you would, identify yourself for the record when you're ready. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Lisa Lake, and I'm representing AT&T. And I just want to say, We, too, appreciate the concerns about getting broadband out to all of the state of Arkansas. I mean, we think that is something that's very important and something that we continue to work to do in our areas. So, you know, the main thing is, and I just want to echo that, you know, I agree with a lot of the same things, and we have a lot of the same concerns that Katie and Justin both mentioned before I came up here. But our main concern, too, is all the federal funding that is coming into the state and where there might be overbilled. You know, there's just not only the providers at this point know exactly where that money is going to go. There is an FCC map that shows all of the eligible areas, but providers are working on their plans to be able to deploy and meet all of the FCC's requirements. So at this point in time, only those providers who have accepted the funding are in a position to know exactly what's going to get covered with those federal funds. Additionally, I think Katie and Justin both shared, you know, numbers about the amount of money that they've accepted. For AT&T, we're getting $21 million a year over the next six years. For CAF2, now Justin spoke to ACAM, but CenturyLink, Windstream, and AT&T are the price cap carriers, and what they accepted was CAF2 money. And that's $54 million a year coming into the state and federal funds over the next six years to deploy. And we have commitments to get that out to 130,000 locations. And as Katie said, there's going to be other areas touched as a part of that deployment, too. Another thing is 40% of that deployment is required to go active by the end of 2017. So I think you're going to see a lot of improvements all throughout the state. And in the FCC, this was addressing high-cost areas, what they've done so far. There is another phase where they're going to address extremely high-cost areas. And so there will be another process that will address that. So, you know, we are not opposed to there being some type of a state fund. We just feel with the language right now as it's being presented that there are too many unknowns and that it's going to take more of a collaboration from the industry with all types of Internet service providers giving input. We have had opportunities, you know, to speak before committees and with Representative Meeks, and, you know, we've talked about ideas and shared information, but we just don't feel like there's been enough collaboration to put together something like this reverse auction And there's just too many unknowns at this point in time that we don't think are addressed in this particular piece of legislation. So with that, I'd be happy to answer any questions if I could. Are there any
My question is, we've heard all the same concerns from the providers, that they're afraid that if we do this reverse grant that it's going to interfere with their federal funds. Is there some type of a, you know, commitment that AEDC can give that once they're doing these rules that y'all will look at that before you decide that you're going to do a reverse auction in that area that would jeopardize all their
monies? We would never want to jeopardize federal funds. I cannot say that I'm an expert on reverse auctions or that we are at AEDC, but we would try to ensure that we were not going to lose any federal funds
your bill. All right. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Committee. Colleagues, when I joined the General Assembly six years ago, there were discussions about broadband deployment in the state. You all know what came of it. Nothing. There have been broadband deployments. has been talked in the Connect America, we need to start moving forward on this. As you all know, Arkansas is near the bottom, and doing nothing is simply not an option. The providers that came up and spoke against the bill, first off, I do appreciate them being here and being part of the conversation. It gives you an idea of the complexities that we are working with. But you also noticed it was all the telephone companies that came and spoke against it. The The telephone companies are receiving money from the federal government. They're also receiving money from the Arkansas High Cost Fund. That's great. That helps to move the ball forward. But there are other Internet service providers that don't have access to any of those funds. There's a lot of small and medium-sized Internet providers across the state that $50,000, $100,000 can make the world of difference for them and for those communities. So what we're asking here is for the opportunity to be able to set this auction up, to have the potential to be able to help bring broadband Internet into parts of the state. There will be a rulemaking process that will go on. That rulemaking process will definitely involve all the providers, so a lot of their concerns can be answered. And before anything is done, of course, those rules have got to come back before the General Assembly, so they can't go off, they're not going to go off and do anything willy-nilly. So I would just ask, do not let fear of what might happen be the enemy of what good could happen in order to be able to provide Internet and the economic development that comes with it for our state. And so with that, colleagues, I would ask for a positive vote, and I will make the motion of do pass as amended.
Okay. Representative Beeks has moved do pass as amended on this bill. Is there any discussion of the motion, Representative Whitaker? You are recognized. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. Not so much discussion as a plea to Chairman Meeks. Could you take a moment at least to address their concerns about this loss to these federal
funds? Yeah, I think a lot of that concerns can be handled in the rulemaking process. The purpose of the funds and a lot of the concern that they had is, and I agree, if the federal funds are going to allow them to come and to build out an area, there's no reason for us to put state funds in those areas. I mean, that would be duplicative, it would be a waste. There's no reason to do that. I also agree that, you know, we don't want to give it to just any, you know, Joe who comes up and says, I'm an Internet service provider. You know, through the rulemaking process, we can set up precautions to make sure that, you know, whoever's receiving these funds has an established business and so forth. What we're talking about is areas where there's currently nothing, there's no plans for anybody to go out there, and we can either, you know, leave them abandoned or we can set up a way to potentially be able to get service out to those areas. And that's all we're asking for. Can I use
have a place at the table during rulemaking? Yeah, and these discussions are definitely not going to end with the session. As we go forward as a committee, I still want to continue these discussions. And, you know, we've got the high-cost fund that we're still going to need to look at And so, by no means is this the end of any decision that we make today.
Is there any further discussion on the motion? Okay. Seeing none. All in favor of the motion, please signify by saying aye. Aye. Opposed nay. I rule the ayes have it. Congratulations, Representative Meeks. Your bill has been passed as amended.
And as we go forward with this, the rules, obviously, that's going to have to come back before this committee, so we will definitely have input on this going forward. Colleagues, just a little bit of housekeeping. I don't know if Mr. Carlock has any last-minute words of wisdom for us, but the technology that we've been looking at over the last couple of weeks, as you all know, the goal is to try to end session next week. So over the next few days, he's going to come around and start collecting that equipment back up. Yeah, you've got to give the toys back. And then as we get into the interim, then we'll be able to provide him feedback on where Or we'll go forward with that, okay? Is there any other business coming for the committee? Seeing none, again, thank you for all your work. We are adjourned.
HB1364 K. Hendren TO ESTABLISH THE PUBLIC POLICY OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS ON THE USE OF ELECTRONIC DEVICES.
HB1793 McCollum TO CREATE A PANEL ON DATA TRANSPARENCY; AND TO CREATE THE POSITIONS OF CHIEF DATA OFFICER AND CHIEF PRIVACY OFFICER WITHIN THE DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION SYSTEMS.
0:12 - 3:3111 segments2 speakers
Representative Austin McCollum introduced HB 1793, explaining that it implements earlier report recommendations by creating a state data-transparency panel, a chief data officer, and a chief privacy officer within the Department of Information Systems to enable inter-departmental data sharing and a data warehouse.
[0:30][1:03][1:34]
Representative Stephen Meeks clarified that the two officer positions have already been established and their costs will be absorbed by DIS, so the bill would not draw on general revenue, and noted that the governor’s office supports the strategic approach.
[2:06][2:16]
After a brief Q&A, Rep. McCollum moved to pass the bill, the committee voted aye with no opposition, and the motion carried, resulting in the bill’s passage.
[2:59][3:01][3:09]
He then presented the full bill, outlining a reverse-auction grant to be administered by the Arkansas Economic Development Commission, clarifying that the High-Cost Fund would remain untouched and adding reporting requirements for the fund and the commission.
[5:55][6:18][6:52][7:26][7:57][8:32][9:03][9:33][10:04][10:38][11:08][11:45][12:20]
HB1410 S. Meeks TO AMEND THE TELECOMMUNICATIONS REGULATORY REFORM ACT OF 2013; AND TO PROHIBIT A TELECOMMUNICATIONS PROVIDER FROM RESTRICTING RESIDENTIAL INTERNET DATA USAGE.
HB2097 S. Meeks TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR A PORTION OF THE COST OF PROVIDING NEW INFRASTRUCTURE USED TO BRING BROADBAND INTERNET ACCESS SERVICE TO UNDERSERVED FOR UNSERVED SERVICE AREAS.