Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Revenue and Taxation Committee

March 28, 2017 ·Committee Room 151 ·1:01:31
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026

HB1681 Jett TO AMEND THE DEFINITIONS UNDER THE ARKANSAS TAX PROCEDURE ACT; AND TO PROVIDE THAT ERRONEOUSLY PAID REFUNDS ARE CONSIDERED UNDERPAYMENTS OF TAX AND… 0:09

The committee heard Paul Goering, Assistant Revenue Commissioner, explain that the Senate amendment to HB 1681 simply adds language confirming that if the Department of Finance and Administration (DFA) is solely responsible for an erroneously issued refund, the state will waive any interest and penalties on that refund. [1:10] [1:39] [2:04]

Representative Bob Johnson asked for clarification on how taxpayers would be treated if they spent an erroneous refund, and Goering confirmed that DFA would work with taxpayers to recover the funds but would not assess interest or penalties when the error was DFA’s fault. [2:17] [2:35] [2:41] [3:13] [3:41] [3:48] [4:19] [4:25]

After a brief question from Representative Kim Hendren, the chair moved to close the amendment, a motion to pass was made and adopted unanimously, and the committee noted that Senate Bill 657 would be considered next. [5:26] [5:56]

SB657 J. Cooper AN ACT TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DISCOUNT AVAILABLE TO TAXPAYERS FOR PROMPT SUBMISSION OF SALES TAX RETURNS AND PAYMENTS. 6:09

The amendment to SB 657 was described as reducing the sales-tax prompt-payment discount cap from $5,000 to $1,000, phased in over five years. [6:33] [7:04]

Representative Kim Hendren argued that the lower discount would hurt business bottom lines by forcing firms to either absorb the loss or raise prices for consumers. [7:29] [7:35] [8:09] [8:52] [9:11]

Testimony from the Association of Counties, the Municipal League, and a Walmart representative explained that the change was negotiated with major retailers and would affect roughly 160 businesses, with an estimated $2.57 million impact on local sales-tax revenue once fully implemented. [9:26] [9:55] [10:01] [10:14] [10:33] [12:13]

The committee then moved a motion to pass the bill as amended, which carried without opposition. [12:44] [13:16]

SB140 Files TO PROVIDE FOR THE COLLECTION OF SALES AND USE TAX RATHER THAN USE TAX ON SALES BY CERTAIN REMOTE SELLERS. 15:11

Committee members debated an amendment to SB 140 that would earmark $25 million of anticipated internet-sales-tax revenue for programs such as pre-K, after-school, and rural fire and police departments; the amendment was ultimately rejected in a roll-call vote (5 yes, 6 no). [15:13] [15:43] [15:45] [15:47] [15:55] [15:58] [16:17] [16:24] [17:23] [17:57] [18:27] [18:59]

Representative Dan Douglas argued that without the bill Arkansas would lose roughly $30 million in internet-sales revenue and that out-of-state retailers were creating an unfair tax burden on local businesses. [19:39] [20:10] [20:44] [21:21] [21:56]

Representative Kim Hendren and public attorney Josh Waters raised concerns that the bill was constitutionally suspect under the Commerce Clause, that it duplicated pending litigation in South Dakota, and that it could open the door to broader extraterritorial taxation; Waters also requested a roll-call vote. [24:56] [25:04] [25:37] [26:08] [26:40] [27:11] [27:47] [28:22] [28:30] [28:55] [29:26] [29:37] [29:56] [30:40] [31:05] [31:40] [32:12] [32:44] [33:19] [33:49] [34:21] [34:57] [35:30] [36:01] [36:32] [37:03]

A motion to pass SB 140 as amended was made and, after debate, was defeated by a 9-6 vote. [50:26] [50:33] [50:56] [51:29] [52:00] [52:27] [52:33] [52:56] [53:03] [53:33] [54:03]

SB505 J. English TO EXPAND THE INCOME TAX CREDIT ALLOWED FOR EMPLOYING AN APPRENTICE IN AN APPRENTICESHIP PROGRAM OR WORK-BASED LEARNING PROGRAM. 55:15

Senator Jane English presented SB 505, which expands the existing $2,000 state income-tax credit for hiring apprentices by extending eligibility beyond ages 16-21 to include older workers. [55:15] [55:24] [55:31] [55:36] [55:49] [55:57] [56:02] [56:08] [56:22]

Clarifying questions from Representative Bob Johnson confirmed that the bill would remove the upper-age limit, allowing apprentices up to age 25 or 30, and emphasized the goal of creating better-skill jobs. [56:02] [56:08] [56:22] [56:31]

The chair moved to close the bill, a motion to pass was made, and the committee approved the measure unanimously. [56:40] [56:52]

SB754 J. Hendren TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING THE COLLECTION, DEPOSIT, AND USE OF GAS ASSESSMENT FEES; TO DESIGNATE CERTAIN GAS ASSESSMENT FEES AS GENERAL REVE… 57:13

The committee was presented with Senate Bill 754, introduced by Representative Joe Jett and presented by Duncan Baird of the Office of Budget, which simply amends the date to continue redirecting half of the gas assessment fees to general revenue for an additional two years. [58:05] [58:09] [58:20] [58:37]

Representative Bob Johnson asked how much money would be transferred to the General Fund, and the chair estimated the amount at roughly $2.9 million annually. [59:03] [59:09]

No member voiced opposition, and after Representative Jett’s closing remarks the committee moved to pass SB 754, which was adopted unanimously. [59:20] [59:30] [59:39]

The committee then proceeded to address other pending business before adjourning the meeting without further debate on the bill. [1:00:22] [1:00:52] [1:01:22]

Bills discussed (51)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB140 · 5 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ou're in the room. Representative Douglas, you ready to run Senate Bill 140? Yes, sir. Members, we're taking a look at Senate Bill 140.…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1681 · 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…down to the end of the table. We're going to start off with House Bill 1681. It's concurrent in the Senate amendment. DFA, if you don't…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB657 · 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…endment is passed, Representative. Say, are you going to do Senate Bill 657? Yes, sir, thank you, committee.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1388 · 2 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…be killed. Also, this committee in the House already passed House Bill 1388, which is a separate bill that would, as you know, would re…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1028 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1028 Lemons TO EXEMPT CERTAIN BUSES, COACHES, AND OTHER MOTOR VE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1037 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1037 Wardlaw TO REGULATE THE SALE OF TAX-DELINQUENT PROPERTY; AN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1225 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1225 Magie TO REPEAL THE EXEMPTION FOR AND REQUIRE THE DISCLOSUR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1227 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1227 Farrer TO REDUCE INCOME TAX RATES IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES;…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1252 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1252 Rye TO AMEND THE INCOME TAX DEDUCTION ALLOWED FOR MEDICAL A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1253 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1253 Wardlaw TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT THAT CERTAIN RETAILERS PR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1263 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1263 Jett TO CREATE A SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTION FOR PARTS FOR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1395 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1395 Leding TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR TAXPAYERS THAT EM…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1396 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1396 Leding TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR TAXPAYERS THAT EM…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1397 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1397 Leding TO EQUALIZE THE SALES TAX TREATMENT OF DUES AND MEMB…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1399 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1399 Ballinger HONOR ARKANSAS VETERANS ACT OF 2017.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1409 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1409 House TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION FROM THE INCOME TAX FOR SERVIC…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1412 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1412 Ballinger TO PROVIDE FOR A PARTIAL PROPERTY TAX EXEMPTION F…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1449 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1449 Dotson TO AMEND THE ANNUAL FRANCHISE TAX FOR CORPORATIONS T…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1512 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1512 Davis TO REDUCE THE INCOME TAX RATES APPLICABLE TO INDIVIDU…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1531 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1531 G. Hodges TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR EDUCATIONAL LO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1535 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1535 K. Hendren TO AMEND THE DISTRIBUTION AND USE OF SALES AND U…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1565 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1565 Jett TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE ISSUANCE AND EXPIRATIO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1582 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1582 Dotson TO EXEMPT CERTAIN ELECTION EQUIPMENT FROM SALES AND…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1647 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1647 C. Douglas REBATES MOTOR ON THE FROM VEHICLES MANUFACTURER…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1684 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1684 Jett TO EXTEND THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS FOR DETERMINING T…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1693 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1693 Rye TO AMEND THE DISTRIBUTION AND USE OF SALES AND USE TAX…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1788 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1788 Dotson TO PHASE IN AN EXTENSION OF THE NET OPERATING LOSS C…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1789 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1789 Dotson TO AMEND LAWS CONCERNING THE CORPORATE FRANCHISE TAX…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1790 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1790 Dotson TO AMEND THE INCOME TAX PROVISIONS CONCERNING THE AP…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1795 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1795 Gates TO EXEMPT CERTAIN DONATED ITEMS FROM SALES AND USE TA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1796 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1796 Gates TO AMEND THE TIME LIMITATIONS FOR TAX ASSESSMENTS, CO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1824 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1824 J. Williams TO ALLOW A PROPERTY TAX EXEMPTION FOR DISABLED…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1845 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1845 Richey TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX EXEMPTION FOR TEACHERS EMPLO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1850 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1850 Leding TO CREATE THE STRONG FAMILIES ACT; AND TO CREATE AN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1853 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1853 Ladyman TO AMEND THE DEADLINE FOR ASSESSING TANGIBLE PERSON…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1911 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1911 Bragg TO CLARIFY THE APPLICATION OF THE INCOME TAX CREDIT F…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1965 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1965 Jett TO REPEAL PROVISIONS REGARDING THE USE OF SALES AND US…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2009 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2009 Sturch CONCERNING THE REMITTANCE OF INSURANCE PREMIUM TAXES…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2062 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2062 Hammer TO EASE THE BURDEN ON TAXPAYERS; TO OFFSET EXCESS RE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2066 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2066 Hammer TO PROVIDE FOR A PARTIAL REBATE OF DISTILLATE SPECIA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2068 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2068 Hammer TO RETURN EXCESS FEDERAL GRANT FUNDS TO THE UNITED S…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2100 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2100 Jett TO AMEND AND MODERNIZE THE LAW CONCERNING THE APPORTIO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2256 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2256 V. Flowers TO ALLOW AN INCOME TAX INCENTIVE FOR CERTAIN FIT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2276 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2276 Gonzales TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND ADMINISTR…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB120 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB120 J. English TO AMEND ARKANSAS TAX LAW CONCERNING INCOME TAX,…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB40 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…oth in agreement that mathematically the odds are higher if SB40 140 passes, even without your amendment, and that's all I w…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB450 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB450 Hester TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE SALE AND REDEMPTION…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB505 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB505 J. English TO EXPAND THE INCOME TAX CREDIT ALLOWED FOR EMPL…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB663 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB663 Files TO CLARIFY THAT AN ACCOMMODATIONS INTERMEDIARY IS REQ…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB754 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB754 J. Hendren TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING THE COLLECTION, DEP…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB9 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB9 A. Clark TO ENCOURAGE CHARITABLE GIVING AND ELIMINATE PERVE…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
We're going to call this meeting to order. I'm going to go down to the end of the table. We're going to start off with House Bill 1681. It's concurrent in the Senate amendment. DFA, if you don't care, make your way down. Paul, if you don't care, to help me out down there. Representative Douglas is going to share this for the first two bills. It's going to be House Bill 1681.
▶ Play
Representative Jett, you are recognized to present your concurrence incentive amendment on House Bill 1681. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman. Members, House Bill 1681 come back out of the Senate with an amendment, and I've got a very smart gentleman to
▶ Play
Speaker 12 1:10
my right who's going to explain the amendment. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Paul Goering, Assistant Revenue Commissioner, Policy and Legal. Go ahead. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Over in Senate Revenue and Tax, an amendment was put onto one of DFA's housekeeping bills. The amendment essentially added some additional language pertaining to the erroneously issued refunds. This was a request that was made on the House floor when this bill was voted upon. Essentially what the amendment does is just adds in some additional language that says if DFA was the responsible party exclusively for issuing an erroneously issued refund, we would defer to existing law in Arkansas that provides that DFA can waive all interest and penalties associated with that erroneously issued refund. Okay, is that
▶ Play
it? That's it. Okay. Members, you've heard of explanation of the bill. Are there any questions? Representative Johnson, you're recognized for a question. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. Okay, kind of break this down into simple words that a CPA could understand. DF&A issues a refund on income tax? Is that what we're – and then I get charged interest and penalty because you sent me a check? And that was the whole
▶ Play
Speaker 12 2:35
purpose of the amendment was just to clarify that what is already our existing practice, practice. If DFA makes a mistake that's exclusively ours, we are not going to cause that taxpayer to be charged any interest in penalty. What may happen is that the error may have been noticed that it was DFA's sometime after the fact that the erroneously issued refund was made. So we just wanted to make sure that the taxpayer understands and knows that we are going to defer to our existing law to make sure that there are no interest in penalties when it's entirely our
▶ Play
error. Okay, and does the taxpayer have any follow-up, sir? Follow-up? Go ahead. And will the taxpayer have, say I got a check, didn't know why I got it, went and spent the money, don't have it to give it back to you. Are we allowed to make payments? I mean, what kind of, you know, you send me a thousand dollars and I go buy me a new set of tires because the roads are bad and make my tires pop. So, I mean, are you going
▶ Play
Speaker 12 3:41
to give them time? I just need to know how to address it with my client. Absolutely. We understand that mistakes do occur, and certainly, you know, we understand that sometimes if an individual receives a check from the state that maybe they don't make any inquiry as to why the check came. They deposit the check, they buy groceries, They put tires on their car, and then they get a notice from DFA, this refund was issued in error. We need that money to be paid back to us. We're certainly going to make every effort to work with the taxpayer to make sure that they can return the money to us.
▶ Play
Okay, thank you. And it's not just IRS does this, too. They send checks, people go spend the money, and
▶ Play
Speaker 12 4:25
then they want me to fix it for them. So I understand. And just for a point of clarification, generally speaking, these erroneously issued refunds and the purpose of the bill are primarily as a result of fraudulent returns that are filed by taxpayers. But we do recognize that we are human. DFA is certainly capable of making a mistake and issuing a refund that should not have been issued. But certainly we do everything that we can and use a high level of diligence in order to avoid that circumstance in the first place.
▶ Play
Thank you very much. Members, any other questions? Representative
▶ Play
Hendren. Yeah, I wouldn't listen to this because Representative Ease has been distracting me here. But just a bottom-line question, does this bill, is this another bill we got down here to extract some more tax money from the voters in Arkansas? Just a yes or
▶ Play
no? No, absolutely not. Okay, members, any other questions on the concurrence in Senate amendment? Okay, anybody from the audience speak against the bill or the amendment? Anybody for the amendment? If not, Representative Jett, are you closed for your concurrence and Senate amendment? Yes, sir, I am, and I appreciate a good vote, committee. Okay, committee, any discussion? Okay, do we have a motion? We have a motion due pass. All those in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye. Opposed, nay. Your amendment is passed, Representative. Say, are you going to do Senate Bill 657? Yes, sir, thank you, committee.
▶ Play
Members, Senate Bill 657 is a bill that passed out of committee last week, I believe it was, and when we got it out and got it to the House floor, then that's when we realized that there were a few problems from some manufacturing, I'm sorry, from business owners across the state of Arkansas. And so we come back, and then the bill sponsor decided that he wanted to address some of the issues that were raised. And so this is the bill that had the cities and the counties on it. And then some business entities that worked together. Basically what, we already passed it out once, but what come on this was an amendment was engrossed into the bill. And it started out as a cap of $5,000. And then we're taking off deduction of $1,000 per year, all the way down to $1,000. And that's the main basic change of what this bill was when we passed it out and had debate on it last week. And to my left, I have a couple pretty smart cats that can ask any questions, answer
▶ Play
Speaker 33 7:15
any questions, maybe. Would you all recognize yourself? Good morning, Chris Felines with the Association of Arkansas Counties. Mark Hayes with
▶ Play
the Arkansas Municipal League. Okay, members, any questions? Representative Hendren, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Okay, let me ask this simple question. That's the only kind that I can understand the answers for. And I've looked at this bill, this reduces the amount of discount or whatever you could call it that a business remits to the state. And a lot of us have had businesses. And any business I've run, it's a bottom line. And so if I send this tax money to the state that I've collected off with the taxpayers that buy my product and I'm able to keep $1,000 or $5,000 or whatever this leaves here, then that goes to my bottom line in my business, which then I use to calibrate the cost I'm going to be selling to my customers. At least that's the way I've always run a business. Now, and with that kind of logic, whether I'm a big guy, whether I'm Walmart or whatever it is, or Target, whoever I am, whenever I send more, let's just take $1,000 to the state of Arkansas in more remitted tax money, that reduces my bottom line income. And so if I'm going to retain my bottom line income in that whatever business it is, I either eat that additional $1,000 that I've just sent to the state of Arkansas for the taxes, or else I raise the price on my product or my services to my customers to maintain the same bottom line. Now, so with that logic, my question to you is this. Basically, the way I'm talking about I'd run my business, then what I'm going to collect from my customers, whatever additional that I have to remit to the state of Arkansas. Is there something wrong with that logic? Because that's
▶ Play
Speaker 33 9:11
the way I've always run my business. Whoever wants to answer that down there? Representative Chris Falines, again with the Association of Counties. basically this affects 160 retailers more than half of the money that would be impacted by that cap comes from one retailer Walmart and we have sat down at the table with Walmart and talked with them and that is where the idea for phasing in this cap came into play so it is an agreed upon bill with them and they seem to be okay with this language I can't answer to their business practices as far as the bottom line goes, but we did do what we could to work with them and have come to a solution between the two of
▶ Play
us on that. You're recognized for a follow-up. So if Walmart takes this money from their stockholders that they're remitting to the state now instead of their customers, then, but somebody's, this $1,000 has got to come from somewhere, and my question was,
▶ Play
Speaker 40 10:14
where does it come from? Mark Hayes, again, with the Municipal League. Let me kind of back up for just a second and note it will whittle down to $1,000 over a period of five years. That's the same $1,000 cap that exists on state general taxes as well. So it simply makes it consistent with what the practice is for state sales tax right now. But we still haven't found out where
▶ Play
the money is coming from. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Okay, any other questions? Representative Johnson, you had a question, sir? You're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. So the $5,000 change that we're doing, it affected 160 businesses at 1,000. At 5,000, does it still affect 160?
▶ Play
Approximately, yes, sir. It's in that range. Okay, thank you. Okay, any other questions, Committee? Seeing none, is there anybody in the audience that wants to speak against the bill, for the bill? If not, Representative Jett. Oh, excuse me. You're recognized, Mr. Lindsey. Please sit down and introduce yourself. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Speaker 43 11:35
So the committee, Michael Lindsey, Director of Public Affairs for Walmart. And like Mark and Chris said, this is something that they were willing to sit down with us last week to discuss a phase in, which helps us, the company for sure, find this as a more acceptable bill and something that we support. So we appreciate their willingness and the sponsor's willingness to work with us on this bill. So I
▶ Play
just wanted to add that comment. All right. Thank you, sir. Any questions for Mr. Lindsay? Mr. Johnson. It's really not
▶ Play
for him. I was just wondering, all in all, what will be the net impact that the state will receive or the cities and counties?
▶ Play
Speaker 12 12:13
Do we know the dollar figure? Paul Gehring with DFA. We did issue a revenue impact on the originally filed bill as well as the bill as amended. At the point that is fully implemented, it's $2.57 million in local sales taxes. And in the first year of implementation, it's 392, and it works its way up to that 2.57 million
▶ Play
figure. Okay, thank you. Okay, any other questions, committee? Okay, is there anybody speaking against the bill, for the bill? Representative Jett, are you ready to close for your bill? I'm closed, sir. All right, members, the question before the committee is the passage of Senate Bill 657. Is there any discussion? That's as amended, sir. As amended? No. Nope. It's already engrossed. It's already engrossed. Thank you, sir. Okay, so we don't have to amend it. Thank you, sir. All right, members, all in favor, signify by motion. You going to make a motion, Representative Jett? Yes, sir, I will. Okay. Motion do pass. Okay, motion do pass. All in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye. Opposed, nay. Motion passes. Your bill is passed.
▶ Play
Speaker 53 13:29
Thanks, sir. Thank you for your meeting. The chair will be
▶ Play
back in just a second and carry on.
▶ Play
Thank you, committee. Representative Bragg, we're passing over your bill, is that correct, sir? Is Senator Hester in the room? Representative Fowles, you're in the room. Representative Douglas, you ready to run Senate Bill 140? Yes, sir. Members, we're taking a look at Senate Bill 140. I think we've been down this road once or twice, or maybe three times. Senate Bill 140, Representative Douglas is recognized. I'm sorry, Representative Gray. Okay, Representative Gray, it does have an amendment. Is the amendment passed out? It's on the tablets. On the tablets. Representative Gray, will you go down to the end of the table, please, and let's work through your amendment.
▶ Play
Just recognize yourself, sir, and feel free to proceed when you get ready. Mr. Chairman, thank you, members of the committee. I won't belabor it. We have seen this discussion before. What we're, this amendment proposes to do is to take 25 million of the expected revenue and distribute it in a proportionate manner to the developmentally disabled waiting list. Pre-K and after school programs and grants for
▶ Play
rural fire and police departments. Is this the same amendment we've
▶ Play
offered up before, sir? It is the same amendment that we've
▶ Play
heard before, yes sir. Okay, are you done, sir? I'm
▶ Play
open for questions, yes sir. Thank you. President Collins, you're recognized. Thank you very much. Representative Gray, let's say this amendment does not pass again. Do you believe your chances of having more money for these programs you prioritize in that case is higher or lower if we pass SB 140, even if it does not have your amendment on it? Representative Collins, I would hope that it would be higher,
▶ Play
but I've seen in my three years here that what we're talking about hasn't been a priority and it needs to be raised to
▶ Play
the level of priority, and I think this amendment would do that. And again, it's not to dispute that point, but I think we're both in agreement that mathematically the odds are higher if SB40 140 passes, even without your amendment, and that's all I was going for. Thank you.
▶ Play
Thanks, sir. Any other questions, members? Anybody from the audience want to speak against the amendment, for the amendment? Representative Gray,
▶ Play
are you closed for your amendment? If you'd allow, Mr. Chair, I appreciate the opportunity, the question for Representative Collins. I would just say to my colleagues that this is a very small drop in the bucket of what could be potentially income in the new revenue for the state. I'm just asking to make sure that these particular issues are addressed on the front end of that. With that, I'm closed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, sir.
▶ Play
Members, you've heard the discussion. Do we have a motion? Do pass. I have a motion from Representative Murdoch, do pass. Any debate? No debate. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? No. I'm going to say the noes have it, sir. The amendment does fail. Roll call. We do have a roll call. Go to the seat and call the roll, please.
▶ Play
Speaker 68 17:57
Representative Warren. Representative Warren. Representative Watson. Representative Gray. Representative Flowers. Representative Johnson. Representative Ferguson. Representative Eves. Representative Hendren. Representative Douglas. No. Representative Hodges. Yes. Representative Sabin. Yes. Representative Bragg. No. Representative Armstrong. Yes. Representative Dotson. Representative Dotson. Rep. Bultz. Rep. Bultz. Representative Murdock. Yes. Representative Collins. No. Representative Letting, Representative Farrar, Representative Farrar, Representative Jett. No.
▶ Play
Sorry sir, your motion fails. Representative Douglas, you
▶ Play
feel free to proceed. Thank you, Mr. Chair of the Committee. Thanks for your indulgence on this. We've been down the road before. I think we all know what the bill does. It says that out-of-state retailers with no fiscal presence in the state will collect and remit sales tax on money collected or on products sold within the state of Arkansas. all. We don't need to beleaguer this a whole lot. We've been down this road. We all know what it does. I just want to say this. There are no deals on the table. This is an up or down vote right here. It either lives or it dies in this committee. And it's over today. And we can either put the money in the general revenue and fight over it then, or we cannot have the revenue from this. It's up to you all. It's up to this committee. I would remind some of us that there was a vote taken yesterday to fund highways using internet sales tax. You all know who voted for that. Well, without this bill passing, there will be no Internet sales tax. Yes, we will have Amazon that has voluntarily agreed to collect and remit. That might be $30 million. Might be. And 15 of that, according to the bill that passed yesterday, goes to the general fund or general revenue. So they believe $15 million for highways, that would build one mile of interstate highway. That's really going to move the state forward. We need to look at what we're here for, and that is doing the business of the state of Arkansas and enacting our laws in a fair and equitable manner. And we have retailers, we have businesses that are the backbone of our economy in this state that are suffering due to an unfair competition with online retailers that are not collecting and remitting sales tax. It's time that we do what we were sent here to do to represent the people the state of Arkansas and be fair and equitable and save our Main Street businesses and make sure we have the money to balance our budget.
▶ Play
And with that, I'd take any questions. Thank you, sir. Representative Collins, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Douglas, do you think the biggest online retailer in the world who has heretofore been avoiding remitting and collecting sales taxes in Arkansas would have chosen to do that two days after a light was shined on the issue by the legislature if it was not true that these taxes are in fact and have in fact been due for decades. Would they have agreed to voluntarily begin to collect and remit if this was not a legal obligation of the purchasers of Arkansas for decades? No, I do not
▶ Play
believe they would have agreed to do that voluntarily, Representative Collins. Sales and use tax has been in law in the state of Arkansas since the 40s. They would not have elected to voluntarily collect and remit the taxes if they did not know that they were in violation of the law and know that this is coming to an end. The South Dakota bill that this bill is mirrored after is on its way to the Supreme Court. It's at the Supreme Court of the state of South Dakota currently. It will head to the United States Supreme Court, ultimately, where Justice Kennedy has asked states to challenge Quill v. North Dakota, to the bill that set the precedent on out-of-state retailers not collecting and remitting sales tax. That will likely be overturned. And whenever it is, unless we have the laws in place, we will be one of the few states that is not collecting and remitting because we are not asking or telling retailers that they have to when the Supreme Court changes its decision. So we can leave the state of Arkansas behind or we can get with the program and do what's right for the future of this state and the future of our retail businesses. Thank you, sir.
▶ Play
Representative Hendren, you're recognized. Yes. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
I want to frame exactly just a moment why I'm asking this question and why I'll frame it this way. I've asked, as you know, whenever you made your presentation, you said the choice on this bill is either to pass this out of here or forget it. And, of course, as we know, and I think that Representative Douglas, you put this on our desk. Yes, sir. The record of the vote yesterday on Johnny Rye's bill. And I see that you and Mr. Collins voted against it, and of course, a number of us here voted for it. But my question is this. One of the reasons that Mr. Rye's bill and others have said that is why not use this $40 to $150 million additional tax being paid by the people of Arkansas to apply to our roads or this other amendment which was just defeated? And that's essentially what Rye does as he heads that direction. Now, and I frame this this way, what bothers me about that, and I think you'd get support in here completely if we'd do something like Johnny Rye is suggesting. But I noticed, and I've asked several people this, why won't we use this money from the Internet bill to support the highways? And then it's not really technically a tax increase. It's shifting it over, which I think people could support. Finally, I've had at least two lobbyists answer that question this way. They said, we need this money, and I can get specific. I'm not going to go here, but you know me. I don't blow smoke. I can give you the names. I've had people tell me we've got to have that money, that $150 million or what it is, to go into education so we can build facilities and so forth. Now as I was reading the Northwest Arkansas Democrat Gazette this, and I'm going to get specific, this is not going to make me popular, but colleagues, you need to know this because your people are going to know it sometime back home. Is the city of Pea Ridge, the school of Pea Ridge, which is my adjacent district, used to be part of ours, is now, I got a proposal to build a $20 million new high school, $20 million. They're proposed to have a vote to raise their millies by 5.1 mills to 50 mills, the highest in the state of Arkansas, which will be for if you've got anything for $100,000, market value it's going to cost you $1,000 for each $100,000 total. This adds $100 to it to pay your taxes. You're going to be renting from the state the rest of your life, whether it's your chicken house or a business or a car or whatever. So my question, and then here's what really bothers me about this And what directly speaks to your bill, Mr. Douglas, or Dan, is that they're going to—that millage they're going to raise, according to the paper, raises $8.9 million for that school. So that's not $20 million. To get $20 million, they're going to have to get $10.1 million out of the state of Arkansas facility funds. Now, that bothers me, and that's where that $150 million they're talking about would go in to help Peeridge, Arkansas. And I love Pea Ridge because I've got friends there to build a $20 million school when they're based on their taxes will only support $10 million, according to the paper. And what really bothers me about this is there are schools in southeast Arkansas and southwest Arkansas with minority students and so forth that don't have near the facility that we in Gravit and Pea Ridge have right now. And it just bothers me to put 13 cents a gallon, to begin with, on gas tax that those people down there are going to pay so that we can put $10 million into an additional high school building in Pea Ridge. Now, my question is, how can I support that, Representative Douglas, and go back and answer that to my constituents? Well,
▶ Play
Representative Hendren, Kim, you can go back and tell them that you voted on a bill and you helped pass a bill out of the House of Representatives to use it on highways. You've already done that. You've already spent this money. It's already been spent in the House of Representatives. It was yesterday. We can't have our cake and eat it, too. We can't spend it there if we don't pass this bill here. I don't know how to answer that any other way. Could a follow-up? And let me add this. Let me add this. We have the opportunity. We have the obligation. We have the duty each and every session, whether it be the general session like we're in now or the fiscal session, to come back and look at the balance sheet of the state of Arkansas and decide where that money goes. And we might put more to highways. We might put some to some of these special projects that was in this amendment. Or we might decide to give a tax cut on the income tax back to the citizens of the state of Arkansas. But we can't do a damn one of them unless we
▶ Play
pass this bill. Well, Mr. Chairman, just a response, and then I'll shut up about this. But what we can also do is to fund that $20 million school for a $10 million facility. That's all they can afford. My question in follow-up is this, is that this—I've just been told here this morning that Mr. Rye's bill is in the Senate. They're going to kill it in committee, and that's why they tried to offer this other amendment this morning. So what you just said, that I voted—yes, I voted for a bill, but we all know full well they're fixing to kill it over the Senate, so it's not going to go anywhere. And I just think the people of Arkansas need to know this, and then it's up to them ultimately to make the decision whether my vote or your vote or my colleague's vote was right. And so I just appreciate you listening, thank you. Welcome sir, any other questions, members?
▶ Play
Speaker 80 30:19
Anybody in the audience want to speak against the bill? Yes, sir, Mr. Waters.
▶ Play
If you don't care, recognize yourself when you get down
▶ Play
to the end of the table. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, my name is Josh Waters. I'm an attorney for political strategies and Conduit for Action is our client. I won't go into depth about what I've already spoken about. I just wanted to give a few highlights of our arguments against SB 140, this internet sales tax bill. First, I wanted to respond to some arguments that were presented in favor of the bill. The first was that this money talking about how it would go to highway funding. And it's already been mentioned. Amazon has voluntarily agreed to start collecting the sales tax online. And so that's money that could be used if that bill passes. It sounds like it might be killed. Also, this committee in the House already passed House Bill 1388, which is a separate bill that would, as you know, would require the disclosure statements be sent to the purchasers. And they would then have to, they would at least be on notice that they owe the money. And so I expect there's some money that will come in from that. So there is money that should be coming in if that bill by Representative Roy goes through. Also, one thing that came up from Representative Douglas, he mentioned that Justice Kennedy has urged people to challenge this. Well, I want to point out that when he wrote that, that was in a concurring opinion. That was not the majority opinion. That's a concurring opinion. And when he wrote that, it was actually in the Colorado case that House Bill 1388 was based on. And in that Colorado case, when it came to the Supreme Court, it was in Direct Marketing Association versus Brault. And he said, hey, challenge this. That is correct. But, one, that's a concurring opinion. It's not the majority of the Supreme Court, so there's no weight of law. But in that same opinion, if I can read to you, the majority opinion of that court stated, But under our negative Commerce Clause precedents, Colorado may not require retailers who lack a physical presence in the state to collect these taxes on behalf of the department. That's how this bill is different. This is SB 140. They told Colorado, make this argument, and then denied cert when they made that argument. So I'm not sure that when the South Dakota litigation all settles out that this is going to be overturned. And I think to pass law hoping that the U.S. Supreme Court is going to maybe a year from now change the law, I don't think that's the right way to go about this. So I wanted to respond directly to that. And then my other comments along that, this bill is still unconstitutional. It basically admits it in the bill in the intent section. section, it basically admits that in the legislative impact statement that the commerce clause because only commerce can regulate interstate commerce. I think it's very clear that this is unconstitutional and this would serve as a test case. When we already know in South Dakota there is a test case going forward. This would be a duplicative test case using taxpayer money when we already are going to get a decision out of South Dakota. And it goes through the federal courts, South Dakota and Arkansas are in the same federal circuit, the Eighth Circuit. So any decision that comes down in federal court from South Dakota will be binding here in Arkansas. So to go forward with another duplicative test case, I would urge for you not to pass the bill, because that's what will happen if this bill is passed. um i've already mentioned before benton and washington county republican committees have passed um resolutions in opposition to the internet sales tax um one other point that i've mentioned previously and wanted to highlight is this bill really opens up um you know a lot of things that could could be to come taxing beyond our borders i think is very dangerous today it It might be the physical products, tomorrow it could be data usage, streaming usage on Netflix. If we start allowing and hoping to change the law to where we have taxing and regulatory authority beyond the borders of our sovereign states, I think we're really opening up a can of worms there, and I would argue that SB 140 does that. I also wanted to share some poll numbers that I have not shared previously. This was a poll conducted by Mercury on behalf of R Street, a free market think tank. I believe each of you received letters from them and some other organizations who opposed this bill. And this was their poll who polled Arkansas likely voters. And when they asked voters of Arkansas, should the internet remain as free from government regulation and taxation as possible, 74% agreed. 88% of Republicans agreed. 78% of independents agreed, 59% of Democrats agreed. When Arkansas voters were asked, do you favor or oppose federal legislation that changes how states collect sales tax from Internet purchases? 74% opposed this, 78% of Republicans opposed this, 79% of independents opposed this, and 66% of Democrats opposed this. When they are asked, and I think this is what this bill does, would you favor or oppose new federal legislation that changes the system by allowing states to make online retailers collect and process sales tax on Internet purchases based on where the customer is located? Fifty-nine percent of Arkansas people said that they opposed that. Sixty-seven percent of Republicans. Sixty-seven percent of independents. if you heard when I said that they didn't mention the word federal legislation so that might be an argument well that's federal the fed's telling us what to do but I think it's fair because this bill is unconstitutional and to ask people state legislation when state legislation currently would violate the constitution I think that's why the federal versus state question was in there and just to be honest this was a poll conducted by Mercury It has a margin of error of 4.9% among 400 likely voters, and it was taken June 1st through 2nd in 2014. So I wanted to share those poll numbers. I'm going to ask, I'm asking the committee to vote no, but I specifically want to ask the committee for a roll call on this vote. I'm afraid what's going to happen is that we'll go through this process, and a voice vote will be called, and there might be six or seven audible yeses when it takes 11 votes.
▶ Play
Excuse me, sir. Excuse me, sir. Now you question my integrity of this committee. I'm not going to allow that to happen. If you're going to sit down at the end of the table, you discuss the bill, discuss the merit of the bill, it's important for this committee to have the integrity of everybody's honest opinion. But when you start questioning my integrity, I'm going to shut this thing down. I know a... That's what you just did, sir. You questioned my integrity. And I assure you, Democrats and Republicans, both on this committee, not one of those folks all session has questioned my integrity. And I'm not going to have you sit down at the
▶ Play
end of the table and start doing that. That was not my intention. I apologize. That's the way I took it. Okay. I apologize. My argument for the merits of this bill, though, is that a bill this important, I believe the taxpayers who will be paying this tax deserve a roll call vote on this. Sir,
▶ Play
you mentioned the word roll call one more time, and I'm shutting you down. That's the chair's prerogative. Okay. That's the committee's prerogative. If the committee members want a roll call, all they got to do is ask for a roll call, they're going to get it. That's, yes, sir. All
▶ Play
right, I'll move on. And I expect you to be brief from this point forward. Thank you, sir. I'll just close and ask that you vote no on this proposal. And I appreciate your time, and I in no way was intending to attack your integrity, in no way meant that. I just know this is a very important vote. So I appreciate your time. I appreciate you letting me speak on the bill. Thank you.
▶ Play
Welcome, sir. Anybody in the audience want to speak for the bill? Anybody in the audience want to speak against the bill?
▶ Play
Representative Douglas, are you closed for your bill, sir? Mr. Chair, I'd like to make just a couple of comments. Mr. Waters said that this is an unconstitutional bill, and it is. And at the present time, due to the Supreme Court decision in 1992 of Quill v. North Dakota. But there's also another law that the Supreme Court wrote a decision on. It's called Roe v. Wade. And every time we pass an anti-abortion bill out of here, this building, we are passing an unconstitutional law. Hold on a second, Representative Douglas. Representative Armstrong. Point
▶ Play
of order, just stick to the bill,
▶ Play
Speaker 78 40:04
Representative Douglas. I was just making a point, Representative.
▶ Play
Members, you know what this bill is. This is it. We can either fund the future of Arkansas. We can either take care of our Main Street businesses, or we can just say to hell with it. So this is your choice. And with that, I move a do pass. We do
▶ Play
pass as amended. Hey, Mr. Chairman? Yes, sir. Could we take a three minute recess before we have discussion on the motion?
▶ Play
We can. Thank you, sir. Members, out of objection, we'll take a three minute recess. Thank you.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 41:18
.
▶ Play
Speaker 97 41:48
Thank you.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 42:18
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. The table.
▶ Play
Speaker 100 44:18
Members, everybody
▶ Play
Speaker 97 44:35
don't care, start making your way back
▶ Play
to the table.
▶ Play
Speaker 96 44:48
Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 17 45:18
Hey, members, members, we've got to go. We've got
▶ Play
members got to run other bills and other committees. I am, but I'm trying to give latitude to work through a very
▶ Play
Speaker 109 45:55
difficult issue. Members, y'all grab your seats.
▶ Play
We're going to start. We have a motion on the table for a due pass as amended. Many of y'all have had five minutes. We agreed for a three-minute recess. Yeah, just grab your seat, Representative Armstrong. We have a motion on the table for due pass by Representative Douglas. Any debate?
▶ Play
Mr. Chair, I'd like to request another three-minute recess. Yes,
▶ Play
sir, Representative Hendren. Well, Mr. Chair, I didn't take part in this first recess, and I don't plan to take part in another one. I have been in recesses down here, and in those resources, in my experience, sometime I have personally been told to go out of those recesses and tell the press if they ask me that we talked about something we did not. And frankly, to me, this is not the way we were sent down here to do the public's business. And you may take another recess, but I ain't coming.
▶ Play
Mr. Chair, I'd like to ask you if you would give another three-minute recess. I realize is that I'm asking a lot, we've been down here for X number of months. This bill has been out there for a long time. The way things work in life is you get toward the end and people start thinking a little harder. And we need three more minutes to think a little harder, sir. Members, we've
▶ Play
heard without objection, we're going to do three minutes and the clock starts now. Three minutes, we're going to take, we're going to- Thank you,
▶ Play
Speaker 48 47:41
Mr. Chair, thank you. The clock starts now. .
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 48:16
. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
We're going to start just here shortly. Members, everybody start making way back seats, you've got 30 seconds. We're going to
▶ Play
Speaker 86 50:11
call a vote. You can't tell time. I appreciate you, buddy.
▶ Play
Okay, we have a motion on the table, do pass as amended by Representative Douglas. Any discussion or debate? Representative
▶ Play
Collins. The first thing I'd like to say is, the third richest person in the world, Jeff Bezos, is no dummy. He didn't get to be the third richest person in the world by locating in a high-tax state, Washington State, zero-income tax. He didn't get to be the third richest person in the country collecting taxes that were not due. So any notion that this is a tax increase and not a tax enforcement action is balderdash. Balderdash. Number two, there are many priorities for the money. Some people think highway funding, some people think pre-K, some people think tax cuts, all wonderful ideas. There's no way to divide the pieces if we don't have the pie. This is the hard part, and I would encourage a good vote.
▶ Play
Thanks, sir. Representative Johnson, you're recognized. Thank you. And I just wanted to bring up Amazon, who we think is our new hero. and explain what they are and are not doing. They, if you buy, I bought a computer from Amazon. They charged me sales tax, Amazon was selling it. I bought a toner, they didn't charge me sales tax, because it's from a third party sales. So not all sales going through Amazon are currently taxed. And this will change if this bill passes, I presume.
▶ Play
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Hendren, you're recognized. I didn't recognize the gentleman that Representative Collins quoted, but let me quote somebody that I think we'll all recognize, and that's Jesus Christ. Love your neighbor as yourself, and do unto others as you'd have them to do unto you. And frankly, I think that's better than whatever that big shot was that was quoted here. I think that's a better rule, and that's all I'm asking me to do and other members of this
▶ Play
committee to do. Thank you. Any other debate? All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, no. No. Ayes have it. Roll call. Call the roll call, Ms. Eden.
▶ Play
Speaker 68 52:56
Representative Warren. Yes. Representative Watson. Yes. Representative Gray. Aye. Representative Flowers. Representative Johnson. Representative Johnson. Representative Ferguson. Representative Ferguson. Representative Eves. Representative Eves. Representative Hindron. No. Representative Douglas. Yes. Representative Hodges. No. Mr. Representative Sabin. Yes. Mr. Representative Bragg. Yes. Mr. Representative Armstrong. No. Mr. Representative Dotson. Mr. Representative Dotson. Mr. Representative Bolts. Mr. Representative Bolts. Mr. Representative Murdoch. Mr. Representative Collins. Yes. Representative Letting? Yes. Representative Farrar? Yes.
▶ Play
Representative Jett? Yes, sir. By a count of 9 to 6, the motion fails. Thank you, committee.
▶ Play
Speaker 127 54:37
We're going to move on, we have, is Senator Hendren in
▶ Play
the room? Is he running the bill, am I running the
▶ Play
Speaker 97 54:45
bill? I can run the bill. Yeah, yeah, I'll tell
▶ Play
you, Duncan, you've got just a minute, we've got a couple of, I know Senator English has been down there for a little bit. Senator English, you want to run your bill? Yes. This might not be a good day to run it, ma'am.
▶ Play
Expunge it. Motion. Morning, folks. Jane
▶ Play
Speaker 86 55:24
English, Senator. Senator English, hold that thought just a second. Can I hear your motion? I move to
▶ Play
expunge the vote of the previous bill. I'm not sure I'm going to
▶ Play
take that right now, Representative Murdoch. Senator English, feel free to proceed. Thank you. This bill is a law that's already on the books that gives a $2,000 state income tax credit to companies that take on an apprentice. This only expands the bill out from youth to adults.
▶ Play
Sorry, ma'am. Are you finished? Yes. Representative Johnson. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. Senator, so this exists up to age 21? No, the bill, the law
▶ Play
as it is right now, is age 16 to 21. What this does is it removes the 21 years old, so it could be some age 25 or 30.
▶ Play
And follow up please. Yes, sir. And so what you're encouraging is careers taking on this and encouraging people to do that. We're encouraging businesses to take on apprentices, so that all of
▶ Play
our folks can get much better jobs, have better skills. Thank you. Welcome. Members, any other questions? Anybody in audience want to speak against the bill, for the
▶ Play
bill? Senator English, you want to close for your bill now? I'm closed for my bill. Do we have a motion? We have a motion to do pass for Senator Johnson. Any debate? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, ma'am, you passed the bill. Thank you. I appreciate your patience this morning. Okay, Duncan, okay, members, we're gonna move on. We're gonna run Senator Jim Hendren's bill, that's Senate Bill 754. Representative Collins, will you sit in my seat, please, sir?
▶ Play
Representative Jett, when you get to the end of the table you'll be recognized to present the bill. Mr. Duncan, if you'd like to, excuse me, Mr. Barrett, if you'd like to go ahead and introduce yourself and who you're with for the record, we'll have that
▶ Play
as he sits down. Duncan Baird, Office of Budget, Department of Finance and Administration.
▶ Play
This is Senate Bill 754. And I'm
▶ Play
Representative Joe Jett, and we're running Senator Jim Hendren's bill. And Duncan's going to present the bill. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
It is a simple bill, it only makes a date change. The background on this, there's a gas assessment that goes to the oil and gas commission for the last two years. Half of that has been redirected to general revenue as part of the governor's balanced budget. This bill will simply continue that redirect for another two years. It is a revenue source that has been in the governor's balanced budget since November, so it's a critical component to the budget. So with that, I'd be happy to answer any questions. Representative Johnson, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question? And I would just add, members,
▶ Play
this is a very critical component to the budget. So just keeping that in mind as we go forward.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. So how many dollars are we talking about going to the general fund?
▶ Play
It'll be around 2.9 million annually. That's the estimate that we've made. Okay, thank you. Are there any other questions from the members? Seeing none, is there
▶ Play
anyone here to speak against the bill, for the bill? If not, Representative Jett, do you want to close for your bill? Yes, members, I'd just say that if you
▶ Play
look on the back page of the RSA schedule, you'll actually see this listed on the very bottom of the RSA when it gets laid on the table, see how important this is. I'm closed.
▶ Play
What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Ease moves do pass on Senate Bill 754. Is there any discussion on the motion? All in favor? Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Jett, you've passed the bill. Thank you, members. Thank you.
▶ Play
Is Senator Clark in the room? Senator Clark, are you in the room? You may have finally gone to the judicial. Members, just hold tight. We're working through a couple of other members' bills to kind of see where they are here real quick. Okay, we're just going to go through the list again one more time. Make sure nobody's here. Representative Bragg, we're passing over yours for sure, is that correct, sir? Yes. Okay. Senator Hester, are you in the room? Senator Fowles, are you in the room? Senator Clark, are you in the room? Members, I think what we're going to do is we'll probably have one more meeting. We'll come back Thursday, and that will probably be our last meeting. Without objection, this meeting is adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

CONCUR IN SENATE AMENDMENT

HB1681 Jett TO AMEND THE DEFINITIONS UNDER THE ARKANSAS TAX PROCEDURE ACT; AND TO PROVIDE THAT ERRONEOUSLY PAID REFUNDS ARE CONSIDERED UNDERPAYMENTS OF TAX AND ARE SUBJECT TO ASSESSMENT.

0:09 - 6:09 21 segments 5 speakers

The committee heard Paul Goering, Assistant Revenue Commissioner, explain that the Senate amendment to HB 1681 simply adds language confirming that if the Department of Finance and Administration (DFA) is solely responsible for an erroneously issued refund, the state will waive any interest and penalties on that refund. [1:10] [1:39] [2:04]

Representative Bob Johnson asked for clarification on how taxpayers would be treated if they spent an erroneous refund, and Goering confirmed that DFA would work with taxpayers to recover the funds but would not assess interest or penalties when the error was DFA’s fault. [2:17] [2:35] [2:41] [3:13] [3:41] [3:48] [4:19] [4:25]

After a brief question from Representative Kim Hendren, the chair moved to close the amendment, a motion to pass was made and adopted unanimously, and the committee noted that Senate Bill 657 would be considered next. [5:26] [5:56]

RE-REFERRED

SB657 J. Cooper AN ACT TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DISCOUNT AVAILABLE TO TAXPAYERS FOR PROMPT SUBMISSION OF SALES TAX RETURNS AND PAYMENTS.

6:09 - 15:11 28 segments 9 speakers

The amendment to SB 657 was described as reducing the sales-tax prompt-payment discount cap from $5,000 to $1,000, phased in over five years. [6:33] [7:04]

Representative Kim Hendren argued that the lower discount would hurt business bottom lines by forcing firms to either absorb the loss or raise prices for consumers. [7:29] [7:35] [8:09] [8:52] [9:11]

Testimony from the Association of Counties, the Municipal League, and a Walmart representative explained that the change was negotiated with major retailers and would affect roughly 160 businesses, with an estimated $2.57 million impact on local sales-tax revenue once fully implemented. [9:26] [9:55] [10:01] [10:14] [10:33] [12:13]

The committee then moved a motion to pass the bill as amended, which carried without opposition. [12:44] [13:16]

REGULAR AGENDA

HB1911 Bragg TO CLARIFY THE APPLICATION OF THE INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR WASTE REDUCTION, REUSE, OR RECYCLING EQUIPMENT USED FOR WOOD AND WOOD FIBER.

SB450 Hester TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE SALE AND REDEMPTION OF TAX-DELINQUENT PROPERTY.

SB663 Files TO CLARIFY THAT AN ACCOMMODATIONS INTERMEDIARY IS REQUIRED TO COLLECT AND REMIT THE SALES TAX AND TOURISM TAX DUE ON ARRANGEMENTS THE ACCOMMODATIONS INTERMEDIARY MAKES FOR THE SALE OR USE OF AN ACCOMMODATION.

SB140 Files TO PROVIDE FOR THE COLLECTION OF SALES AND USE TAX RATHER THAN USE TAX ON SALES BY CERTAIN REMOTE SELLERS.

15:11 - 57:13 127 segments 19 speakers

Committee members debated an amendment to SB 140 that would earmark $25 million of anticipated internet-sales-tax revenue for programs such as pre-K, after-school, and rural fire and police departments; the amendment was ultimately rejected in a roll-call vote (5 yes, 6 no). [15:13] [15:43] [15:45] [15:47] [15:55] [15:58] [16:17] [16:24] [17:23] [17:57] [18:27] [18:59]

Representative Dan Douglas argued that without the bill Arkansas would lose roughly $30 million in internet-sales revenue and that out-of-state retailers were creating an unfair tax burden on local businesses. [19:39] [20:10] [20:44] [21:21] [21:56]

Representative Kim Hendren and public attorney Josh Waters raised concerns that the bill was constitutionally suspect under the Commerce Clause, that it duplicated pending litigation in South Dakota, and that it could open the door to broader extraterritorial taxation; Waters also requested a roll-call vote. [24:56] [25:04] [25:37] [26:08] [26:40] [27:11] [27:47] [28:22] [28:30] [28:55] [29:26] [29:37] [29:56] [30:40] [31:05] [31:40] [32:12] [32:44] [33:19] [33:49] [34:21] [34:57] [35:30] [36:01] [36:32] [37:03]

A motion to pass SB 140 as amended was made and, after debate, was defeated by a 9-6 vote. [50:26] [50:33] [50:56] [51:29] [52:00] [52:27] [52:33] [52:56] [53:03] [53:33] [54:03]

SB754 J. Hendren TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING THE COLLECTION, DEPOSIT, AND USE OF GAS ASSESSMENT FEES; TO DESIGNATE CERTAIN GAS ASSESSMENT FEES AS GENERAL REVENUE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

57:13 - 55:15

The committee was presented with Senate Bill 754, introduced by Representative Joe Jett and presented by Duncan Baird of the Office of Budget, which simply amends the date to continue redirecting half of the gas assessment fees to general revenue for an additional two years. [58:05] [58:09] [58:20] [58:37]

Representative Bob Johnson asked how much money would be transferred to the General Fund, and the chair estimated the amount at roughly $2.9 million annually. [59:03] [59:09]

No member voiced opposition, and after Representative Jett’s closing remarks the committee moved to pass SB 754, which was adopted unanimously. [59:20] [59:30] [59:39]

The committee then proceeded to address other pending business before adjourning the meeting without further debate on the bill. [1:00:22] [1:00:52] [1:01:22]

SB9 A. Clark TO ENCOURAGE CHARITABLE GIVING AND ELIMINATE PERVERSE AND ABSURD TAXES AND DISINCENTIVES ON CHARITABLE GIVING; AND TO EXEMPT CERTAIN WITHDRAWALS OF STOCK FROM THE SALES AND USE TAX.

SB505 J. English TO EXPAND THE INCOME TAX CREDIT ALLOWED FOR EMPLOYING AN APPRENTICE IN AN APPRENTICESHIP PROGRAM OR WORK-BASED LEARNING PROGRAM.

55:15 - 1:01:27 28 segments 6 speakers

Senator Jane English presented SB 505, which expands the existing $2,000 state income-tax credit for hiring apprentices by extending eligibility beyond ages 16-21 to include older workers. [55:15] [55:24] [55:31] [55:36] [55:49] [55:57] [56:02] [56:08] [56:22]

Clarifying questions from Representative Bob Johnson confirmed that the bill would remove the upper-age limit, allowing apprentices up to age 25 or 30, and emphasized the goal of creating better-skill jobs. [56:02] [56:08] [56:22] [56:31]

The chair moved to close the bill, a motion to pass was made, and the committee approved the measure unanimously. [56:40] [56:52]

DEFERRED BILLS

HB1028 Lemons TO EXEMPT CERTAIN BUSES, COACHES, AND OTHER MOTOR VEHICLES FROM SALES AND USE TAXES.

HB1225 Magie TO REPEAL THE EXEMPTION FOR AND REQUIRE THE DISCLOSURE OF CERTAIN OF CERTAIN ADVERTISING AND PROMOTION TAX RECORDS UNDER THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967.

HB1252 Rye TO AMEND THE INCOME TAX DEDUCTION ALLOWED FOR MEDICAL AND DENTAL EXPENSES; AND TO REMOVE THE THRESHOLD FOR CLAIMING AN INCOME TAX DEDUCTION FOR MEDICAL AND DENTAL EXPENSES.

HB1263 Jett TO CREATE A SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTION FOR PARTS FOR AND REPAIR OF AGRICULTURAL EQUIPMENT AND MACHINERY.

HB1227 Farrer TO REDUCE INCOME TAX RATES IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES; AND TO REDUCE INCOME TAX RATES BASED ON THE GROWTH OF INCOME TAX COLLECTIONS.

HB1399 Ballinger HONOR ARKANSAS VETERANS ACT OF 2017.

HB1409 House TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION FROM THE INCOME TAX FOR SERVICE PAY AND ALLOWANCES OF FOREIGN SERVICE PERSONNEL.

SB120 J. English TO AMEND ARKANSAS TAX LAW CONCERNING INCOME TAX, SALES AND USE TAXES, AND THE SOFT DRINK TAX; AND TO SUPPLEMENT TE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TRUST FUND TO OFFSET DECREASED DEPOSITS FROM TAX REVENUES.

HB1037 Wardlaw TO REGULATE THE SALE OF TAX-DELINQUENT PROPERTY; AND TO PROHIBIT OWNERS OF TAX-DELINQUENT PROPERTY FROM BIDDING ON OR PURCHASING TAX-DELINQUENT PROPERTY.

HB1253 Wardlaw TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT THAT CERTAIN RETAILERS PREPAY SALES TAXES.

HB1412 Ballinger TO PROVIDE FOR A PARTIAL PROPERTY TAX EXEMPTION FOR DISABLED VETERANS IN PROPORTION TO THE EXTENT OF THE DISABILITY OF THE VETERAN.

HB1395 Leding TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR TAXPAYERS THAT EMPLOY A RECENTLY RETURNED VETERAN.

HB1396 Leding TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR TAXPAYERS THAT EMPLOY A RECENTLY RETURNED VETERAN.

HB1397 Leding TO EQUALIZE THE SALES TAX TREATMENT OF DUES AND MEMBERSHIP FEES FOR CERTAIN CLUBS AND FACILITIES; AND TO LEVY A SALES TAX ON DUES AND MEMBERSHIP FEES TO CERTAIN FACILITIES AND CLUBS.

HB1449 Dotson TO AMEND THE ANNUAL FRANCHISE TAX FOR CORPORATIONS THAT ARE IN THE PROCESS OF LIQUIDATION.

HB1531 G. Hodges TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR EDUCATIONAL LOAN PAYMENTS FOR QUALIFIED INDIVIDUALS AND EMPLOYERS OF QUALIFIED INDIVIDUALS.

HB1512 Davis TO REDUCE THE INCOME TAX RATES APPLICABLE TO INDIVIDUALS, TRUSTS, AND ESTATES USING REVENUES DERIVED FROM SALES AND USE TAX FROM SELLERS THAT DO NOT HAVE A PHYSICAL PRESENCE IN THE STATE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1684 Jett TO EXTEND THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS FOR DETERMINING THE CORRECT AMOUNT OF TAX DUE IN RELATION TO CERTAIN AMENDED RETURNS OR VERIFIED CLAIMS FOR CREDIT OR REFUND.

HB1790 Dotson TO AMEND THE INCOME TAX PROVISIONS CONCERNING THE APPORTIONMENT OF BUSINESS INCOME; AND TO REPEAL THE THROWBACK RULE.

HB1693 Rye TO AMEND THE DISTRIBUTION AND USE OF SALES AND USE TAX REVENUES.

HB1788 Dotson TO PHASE IN AN EXTENSION OF THE NET OPERATING LOSS CARRY-FORWARD PERIOD FOR CALCULATING ARKANSAS INCOME TAX; AND TO MAKE TECHNICAL CHANGES.

HB1789 Dotson TO AMEND LAWS CONCERNING THE CORPORATE FRANCHISE TAX; TO REPEAL THE ARKANSAS CORPORATE FRANCHISE TAX ACT OF 1979; TO MAKE CONFORMING CHANGES.

HB1845 Richey TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX EXEMPTION FOR TEACHERS EMPLOYED IN CRITICAL TEACHER SHORTAGE AREAS.

HB1850 Leding TO CREATE THE STRONG FAMILIES ACT; AND TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR EMPLOYERS THAT PROVIDE PAID FAMILY AND MEDICAL LEAVE FOR CERTAIN EMPLOYEES.

HB1582 Dotson TO EXEMPT CERTAIN ELECTION EQUIPMENT FROM SALES AND USE TAXES; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1824 J. Williams TO ALLOW A PROPERTY TAX EXEMPTION FOR DISABLED VETERANS WITH A ONE HUNDRED PERCENT (100%) TOTAL DISABILITY THAT MAY NOT BE PERMANENT; AND TO CLARIFY THE REQUIREMENTS FOR ESTABLISHING ELIGIBILITY FOR THE EXEMPTION.

HB2009 Sturch CONCERNING THE REMITTANCE OF INSURANCE PREMIUM TAXES.

HB1535 K. Hendren TO AMEND THE DISTRIBUTION AND USE OF SALES AND USE TAX REVENUES.

HB2100 Jett TO AMEND AND MODERNIZE THE LAW CONCERNING THE APPORTIONMENT OF INCOME DERIVED FROM MULTISTATE OPERATIONS; TO CHANGE THE METHOD FOR SOURCING OF RECEIPTS FOR SERVICES AND INTANGIBLES.

HB2066 Hammer TO PROVIDE FOR A PARTIAL REBATE OF DISTILLATE SPECIAL FUEL TAXES IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES; AND TO CREATE THE DISTILLATE SPECIAL FUEL TAX REFUND FUND.

HB2068 Hammer TO RETURN EXCESS FEDERAL GRANT FUNDS TO THE UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT; AND TO ENCOURAGE RELIEF OF THE NATIONAL DEBT OF THE UNITED STATES.

HB2062 Hammer TO EASE THE BURDEN ON TAXPAYERS; TO OFFSET EXCESS REVENUES AVAILABLE TO THE STATE; AND TO AMEND THE USE AND DISTRIBUTION OF CERTAIN REVENUES.

HB1647 C. Douglas REBATES MOTOR ON THE FROM VEHICLES MANUFACTURER EXCLUDE TODEFINITIONS USED FOR PURPOSES OF DETERMINING SALES AND USE TAXES.

HB1965 Jett TO REPEAL PROVISIONS REGARDING THE USE OF SALES AND USE TAX REVENUES FROM REMOTE SELLERS; TO DEPOSIT SALES AND USE TAX REVENUES FROM REMOTE SELLERS INTO A FUND TO BE USED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1565 Jett TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE ISSUANCE AND EXPIRATION OF GROSS RECEIPTS TAX PERMITS AND THE COLLECTION OF UNPAID TAXES UPON DISCONTINUATION OF BUSINESS.

HB2276 Gonzales TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION TO REPORT THE REVENUE IMPACT OF EACH TAX AND EACH TAX CREDIT, DEDUCTION, AND EXEMPTION.

HB1795 Gates TO EXEMPT CERTAIN DONATED ITEMS FROM SALES AND USE TAXES.

HB1796 Gates TO AMEND THE TIME LIMITATIONS FOR TAX ASSESSMENTS, COLLECTIONS, REFUNDS, AND PROSECUTION; AND TO LIMIT THE TIME AVAILABLE FOR A TAX AUDIT.

HB2256 V. Flowers TO ALLOW AN INCOME TAX INCENTIVE FOR CERTAIN FITNESS AND NUTRITION EXPENSES.

HB1853 Ladyman TO AMEND THE DEADLINE FOR ASSESSING TANGIBLE PERSONAL PROPERTY.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Joe Jett Chair Unverified
46 segments
Representative Dan M. Douglas Chair Unverified
34 segments
Speaker 12
8 segments
Representative Bob Johnson Unverified
9 segments
Representative Kim Hendren Unverified
20 segments
Speaker 33
3 segments
Speaker 40
2 segments
Speaker 43
1 segment
Speaker 53
1 segment
Representative Charlie Collins Chair Unverified
17 segments
Speaker 68
6 segments
Speaker 80
1 segment
Josh Waters Unverified
16 segments
Speaker 78
1 segment
Speaker 97
3 segments
Speaker 100
1 segment
Speaker 96
1 segment
Speaker 17
1 segment
Speaker 109
1 segment
Speaker 48
1 segment
Speaker 86
2 segments
Speaker 127
1 segment
Senator Jane English Unverified
5 segments
Chair Unverified
4 segments