Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Boys State 2017

June 2, 2017 ·House ·2:41:57
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026

Representative David Whitaker opened the session by asking members to settle in, distributing informational packets, conducting roll call for House officers and members, addressing a brief messenger-assignment confusion, and noting the limited time available. [0:00] [0:36] [1:13] [3:03] [3:06] [3:40]

Parliamentarian Buddy Johnson welcomed the delegates and explained chamber protocols, including hand-signal recognition, microphone activation, and the prohibition of food and drink on the floor. [8:06] [8:39] [9:09] [9:44] [10:19] [10:51] [11:25]

The Chair led the opening prayer by Chaplain Jared Turner, the Pledge of Allegiance, and then confirmed a quorum of 100 members. [15:15] [15:44] [15:48] [16:29] [16:59] [17:08] [17:21]

Two committees were appointed-one to notify the Senate and another to notify the governor that the House was organized and ready for business. [17:29] [17:59]

The House then considered House Bill 1002, the “Smart Weed Act of 2017,” which proposes a 2.9 % sales tax on medical marijuana to fund industry regulation and allocate revenues 60 % to education, 30 % to drug-prevention programs, and 10 % to disaster relief. [19:01] [19:06] [19:29] [19:48] [20:03] [20:34]

Representative Campbell explained the bill, while members such as Rep. Sturge suggested diverting some funds to road programs and Rep. Rushing defended the education allocation. [21:38] [22:02] [22:13] [22:45] [22:54] [23:22]

After debate, the House passed House Bill 1002 by a vote of 71 yeas to 26 nays. [35:16]

The next item, House Bill 1003, sought to redirect existing auto-related sales-tax revenue to a state-aid road program, prompting extensive questions about fund allocation, oversight committees, and potential impacts on education and other services. [36:12] [36:38] [36:54] [37:15] [37:45] [37:57] [38:04] [38:24] [38:53] [39:01] [39:13] [39:32] [40:03] [40:07]

The road-tax bill was defeated, receiving 17 yeas and 80 nays. [56:04]

House Bill 1004, proposing concurrent college or vocational credit for high-school students, was introduced with arguments about cost, access, and state funding, eliciting mixed testimony from delegates. [56:57] [57:09] [57:21] [57:53] [58:25] [58:43] [58:49] [58:57] [59:01] [59:22] [59:33] [59:42] [59:51] [1:00:02] [1:00:05] [1:00:15] [1:00:37] [1:00:43] [1:01:10] [1:01:16] [1:01:32]

The bill failed by a vote of 50 yeas, 47 nays, and one present. [1:06:20] [1:06:27]

An amendment to House Bill 1001 adding a requirement for athletic trainers (one per 50 athletes in small schools, one per 100 in larger schools) was debated, with discussion over appropriate ratios and the financial burden on schools, and the amendment was defeated by a vote of 32 yays, 57 nays and 10 presents. [1:10:17] [1:10:29] [1:10:52] [1:10:57] [1:11:05] [1:11:26] [1:11:35] [1:11:51] [1:12:07] [1:12:19] [1:12:33] [1:12:38] [1:13:02] [1:13:08] [1:13:25] [1:17:57] [1:18:31] [1:18:55] [1:19:04] [1:19:23] [1:19:35] [1:19:49] [1:19:54] [1:20:15] [1:20:19] [1:20:57] [1:21:27] [1:22:01] [1:22:39]

Representative David Whitaker explained the procedural rules for amendment debate, voice votes and machine votes, noting that a failed amendment means the original bill proceeds unchanged. [1:22:51] [1:23:15] [1:23:47] [1:24:21] [1:24:55]

The chamber then debated House Bill 1001, which would require an athletic trainer in every public school; proponents argued that volunteer nurses or physical-therapy students could fill the role at no cost to the state and improve student safety. [1:25:25] [1:25:33] [1:25:46] [1:25:55] [1:26:26] [1:26:58] [1:27:27] [1:27:29] [1:27:53] [1:28:05] [1:28:14] [1:28:20] [1:28:37] [1:28:46] [1:28:50] [1:29:11] [1:29:32] [1:29:44] [1:30:16]

Opponents raised concerns that the bill’s loan-forgiveness funding mechanism was unclear, questioning how trainer salaries or debt-repayment would be financed if no state funds were allocated. [1:31:55] [1:31:58] [1:32:18] [1:32:26] [1:32:44] [1:32:59] [1:33:20] [1:33:27] [1:33:34] [1:34:07] [1:34:18] [1:34:47] [1:35:15] [1:35:20] [1:35:44] [1:35:53] [1:36:06] [1:36:41] [1:36:51]

After extensive discussion, the House passed House Bill 1001 by a vote of 56 yeas, 34 nays and 7 presents. [1:40:26]

The session moved to Senate Bill 2, proposing a water-conservation task force to study alternative irrigation; supporters cited Arkansas’s agricultural reliance and existing federal grant opportunities, while critics warned of added bureaucracy and uncertain funding. [1:41:11] [1:41:27] [1:41:33] [1:42:01] [1:42:33] [1:42:52] [1:43:05] [1:43:07] [1:43:13] [1:43:49] [1:44:04] [1:44:09] [1:44:17] [1:44:20] [1:44:24] [1:44:53] [1:45:20] [1:45:24] [1:46:00] [1:46:21] [1:46:33] [1:47:11] [1:47:19] [1:47:25] [1:47:34] [1:47:46] [1:48:20] [1:48:30] [1:48:36] [1:48:54] [1:49:32] [1:49:35] [1:49:39] [1:50:10] [1:50:27] [1:50:35] [1:50:45] [1:51:03] [1:51:18] [1:51:25]

Senate Bill 2 was approved by a vote of 55 yeas, 37 nays and 6 presents. [2:02:56]

Senate Bill 4, which would mandate standardized ACT preparation beginning in eighth grade, sparked debate over redundancy with existing programs, funding sources, and the necessity of early testing, leading to opposition that the requirement would waste resources. [2:03:22] [2:03:29] [2:03:45] [2:04:00] [2:04:32] [2:04:40] [2:04:53] [2:05:04] [2:05:14] [2:05:20] [2:05:25] [2:05:37] [2:05:57] [2:06:03] [2:06:10] [2:06:19] [2:06:32] [2:06:41] [2:06:47] [2:07:10] [2:07:13] [2:07:23] [2:07:31] [2:07:41] [2:07:47] [2:07:56] [2:08:07] [2:08:12] [2:08:17] [2:08:49] [2:08:59] [2:09:27] [2:10:03] [2:10:22] [2:10:27] [2:10:38] [2:11:06] [2:11:09] [2:11:22] [2:11:41] [2:12:03] [2:12:14] [2:12:25] [2:12:51] [2:13:11] [2:13:31] [2:13:34] [2:14:05] [2:14:40]

The House rejected Senate Bill 4 with 39 yeas, 54 nays and 5 presents. [2:16:58]

Procedural remarks followed on the rapid passage of hundreds of bills, the rarity of floor amendments, and the process for sending legislation back to committee for further changes. [2:17:54] [2:17:59] [2:18:05] [2:18:30] [2:18:49] [2:18:57] [2:19:02] [2:19:24] [2:19:32] [2:19:36] [2:20:02] [2:20:16] [2:20:19] [2:20:29] [2:20:35] [2:20:44] [2:21:06] [2:21:39] [2:22:01] [2:22:16] [2:22:50]

Members were advised to direct detailed questions about legislation to the bill’s sponsor or the relevant committee before it reaches the House floor, though sponsors may not anticipate every query and may need to follow up later. [2:23:01] [2:23:23]

Representative Gates noted that prolonged debate can cause bills to die and suggested using motions to speak against a measure until specific questions are answered, while the Speaker may sometimes limit further inquiries. [2:23:57] [2:24:29]

Representative Lemons explained that each legislator serves on two “A” and two “B” committees, which can create scheduling conflicts when a sponsor must present a bill in multiple committees, often requiring a leave of absence or a co-sponsor. [2:24:45] [2:25:05]

The committee system is portrayed as essential for managing the 75-day session, preventing endless floor debate and allowing more efficient legislative work. [2:26:11]

Committee hearings permit expert testimony, charts, and graphs, whereas floor proceedings strictly forbid visual aids, require legislators to present arguments themselves, and enforce a dress code that includes a tie and generally bans jeans except on designated charity days. [2:28:04] [2:28:20] [2:28:52] [2:28:57] [2:29:02] [2:29:16] [2:29:21] [2:29:25] [2:29:55]

Bill ideas typically originate from constituents’ concerns, district-specific interests such as agriculture, input from interest groups like farm bureaus, and requests from the governor or state agencies, with legislators often specializing in particular policy areas to handle these proposals. [2:30:33] [2:31:09] [2:31:36] [2:31:41] [2:32:13] [2:32:29] [2:32:44] [2:33:20] [2:33:53]

The House schedule alternates “A” and “B” committee meetings each morning with floor sessions in the afternoon, and a bill must appear on the calendar for two days before a vote, resulting in varying bill volumes per committee (e.g., education may handle about 200 bills versus transportation’s 100). [2:34:42] [2:35:02] [2:35:34]

In closing, Lemons highlighted the chamber’s diversity and camaraderie among the 100 members, and Representative Meeks moved to adjourn the session for lunch, a motion that was unanimously carried. [2:36:06] [2:36:37] [2:37:07] [2:37:33] [2:37:39] [2:37:49]

Bills discussed (2)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1002 · 3 mentions in transcript
Matched: “House Bill 1002. House Bill”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1001 · 2 mentions in transcript
Matched: “Members, we're going to pass over. House Bill 1001.”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026
Y'all get settled in and there's a packet of materials on your desk if you want to start looking over it. It'll give you an idea of what's going to happen today. We need the officers of the House. That's the speaker, Speaker Pro Tem, Chief Clerk, Sergeant at Arms, Parliamentarian, Chaplain, Reading Clerk. Come down here and report to the Chief Clerk. Where is he? Okay, good. Okay, we need a speaker of the House to start off with. I'm going to start calling off names. If I do, y'all come on down here. Zion Sane, speaker. Adam Hagler, I think Mr. Gates has already got him. Okay. good, thank you. Jared Mattson, Aaron Mann, Max Sutton, Jared Turner, Logan Meyer, Cole Irwin, Daryl Wilson, DeMond Johnson, Xavier Childs, Trillian Williams.
▶ Play
Speaker 16 1:56
Okay, so you're Connor Carpenter? Yes. Okay.
▶ Play
Speaker 537 2:09
Okay, you need to be
▶ Play
a messenger to
▶ Play
Speaker 26 2:18
the House
▶ Play
Speaker 29 2:26
and are you going
▶ Play
Speaker 31 2:29
to the Senate?
▶ Play
Speaker 537 2:36
Okay, messenger to the House, we don't
▶ Play
Speaker 33 2:38
really get out of the Senate because we have a messenger to the Senate. Go down there, okay?
▶ Play
Speaker 35 2:44
Yeah. Messenger to the House. So I
▶ Play
Speaker 33 2:53
sent him to the Senate. He was a messenger to the House, so I sent him to the Senate. Hopefully that's where he belongs. Gentlemen, we're
▶ Play
going to get started here in just a few minutes. While we're waiting, there's a packet of materials on your desk. If you would look over it, I think it would give you an idea about what we're going to be doing here this morning. Gentlemen, y'all come on in and have a seat. We're waiting, looking for the Speaker of the House, Zion Sane, Adam Hagler's already here, Jared Mattson, Aaron Mann, Max Sutton, Jared Turner, Logan Meyer, Cole Irwin, Daryl Wilson. Daryl's already here. DeMond Johnson, Xavier Childs, and Trillian Williams. Do you need these down here, too?
▶ Play
Speaker 44 4:03
Or just in the room? Do you need Adam down here?
▶ Play
Speaker 47 4:11
Or in the seat? No, he
▶ Play
needs... Adam? Yeah, he's going to be sitting up there. We have an extra desk chair up there. up there I'm Buddy Johnson nice to meet you why don't you go yeah going up there there's a speaker will be in the middle chair if you would sit in the chair on that side now come on in I think your governor
▶ Play
we're looking for the you the Speaker, buddy Johnson. Nice
▶ Play
Speaker 26 4:49
to meet you. If you would
▶ Play
go up there and sit
▶ Play
Speaker 537 4:56
in the middle of the street. I
▶ Play
Speaker 61 5:00
think maybe some of your people
▶ Play
just got here. Okay. Jared Mattson, Aaron Mann, Max Sutton, Jared Turner, Logan Meyer, Cole Irwin. I didn't realize there was two here. Aaron Mann, Sergeant at the Arms Department. You are Paul Irwin. Get with our chief clerk.
▶ Play
Speaker 74 5:56
You're Sergeant at
▶ Play
Speaker 75 5:58
Arms. Mr. Williams, okay. You're with him. Williams, okay. You
▶ Play
Speaker 537 6:12
need to go with him.
▶ Play
Speaker 80 6:18
We're missing Logan Mayer.
▶ Play
Speaker 537 6:26
Logan Mayer. Logan Mayer. Does anyone know Logan Mayer? Does he exist?
▶ Play
Speaker 87 6:40
How do you know him? Okay, do you
▶ Play
Speaker 91 6:50
have his phone number?
▶ Play
Okay. We understand Logan is here somewhere. Logan Meyer. Looking for Logan Meyer.
▶ Play
Speaker 97 7:32
Well, I'll tell you what. We're waiting Logan
▶ Play
Speaker 99 7:46
Meyer. Okay. We're waiting one more
▶ Play
Speaker 86 7:51
officer of the House. Meanwhile,
▶ Play
let's go ahead and get started because our time is limited today. I'm Buddy Johnson. I'm the parliamentarian for the House of Representatives. I want to welcome you to the House chamber. This is a very special place. It's been used since 1911 for lawmaking in Arkansas and aren't very many people have the opportunity to come on to the floor to participate in something like this as you are doing today. Before we get started, I want everybody to take a deep breath and look up at the ceiling because there's not many other cooler ceilings anywhere than what we have here, so make the most of it. Once we get started, during the proceedings to be recognized to participate, the recognition will come from the Speaker of the House, Design Sane, and when we get started, he'll be doing that. He'll be calling on you according to the name on your desk. So become familiar with that. When he does call on you, that's the name he'll be using. So for the purposes of what we're doing here today, for instance, you're Mr. Shepard, you're Mr. Hendren, you're Mr. Whitaker, et cetera. if you wish to be recognized just like in your school classroom you raise your hand usually you hold up your microphone that tells the the speaker or the parliamentarian that you you would like to be recognized if you're in debate if you want to speak for a bill if you could just indicate to the speaker or the parliamentarian that you want to speak for the bill give a thumbs up if you want to speak against the bill, thumbs down. If you want to make a motion or something, just get their attention and just make eye contact. A lot of communication is done out here just through eye contact and hand signals. If you recognize during debate, if you want to speak for or against the bill, you will come to this spot in the chamber. This is called the well of the house you don't debate from your desks you can ask questions from your desk and you can make motions from your desk but during debate to speak for or against the bill you'll come down here if someone is down here speaking the speaker can't and won't accept motions made from the floor because the person down here literally has the floor with during debate if you asked to be recognized, please don't hit the microphones. There aren't switches on these microphones. They're all activated by our sound clerk, Mr. Garrett Wilkins, up here. And he activates the microphones once you're recognized by the speaker. And so if you would just be patient, the microphone will come on eventually, and you don't need to bang on it. When you're using the voting machine, and there's a voting machine or buttons at each desk, The green button means yes, red button means no, yellow button means present, white button means request to speak, and we don't use that button in here. So you can punch it all you want, but nothing will happen. And we also ask that delegates not have any food or drink on the floor. So if you have water or something, if you just tuck it away, that'd be great. We were very protective of this chamber and of the desks in it. So at this time, again, welcome to the House chamber, and I'd like to turn over to the chair of the Boise State delegation, Representative Tim Lemons.
▶ Play
Well, welcome to Boise State, and thank you for participating in this remarkable journey that you're on. I, too, was on this journey back in 1979, way too many years ago. But I never knew when I was in Boys State that I wouldn't end up in the House of Representatives. So chase your dreams. That's what this is all about. I'd like to recognize some of our House members that have been helping with Boys State this week. We have our Vice Chair, Mr. James Sturge. Representative Steve Hollowell. the back. Representative Austin McCullum. Representative Stephen Meeks, who I would like to point out is number one in seniority in this house. So he has, he's She's number one. The most righteous and honorable ex-county judge, State Representative Mark McElroy. Representative Andy Davis. Representative Monty Hodges. Representative Mickey Gates, Representative Rick Beck, Representative Erin Pilkington, Representative Les Warren, and just joining us just a few moments ago, the most wonderful Representative Carlton Wing. As the parliamentarian spoke just a moment ago, you are somewhat on what we would call sacred ground. Please understand that to be here, to be in Boyce, that is a privilege. But to be in this chamber is also a privilege. The only people that are allowed on this floor are the representatives, the staff, and pages. Every two years when we get sworn in, we're allowed to bring one family member onto this floor. Besides that, no one else is allowed within this room. So you're definitely, this is a privilege. So as Buddy said, make sure you get a good picture of the fixture up top because very few people get to see it from this angle. And looking out at this crowd and being in your committee meetings yesterday, Arkansas's future looks very bright. You are the cream of the crop, and we're really excited about our future just seeing what we saw yesterday. And one last question. Is there anybody here from Cabot? From Cabot. Outstanding. Get with me before you leave today, please. That's where I represent. I want to get a picture with you. Okay. Thank you so much, Mr. Parliamentarian.
▶ Play
Will the House come to order? I invite the members, staff, press, and guests in the galleries to stand and be led in the prayer by the House Chaplain, Jared Turner, and to remain standing for the Pledge of Allegiance to be led by Representative Christian Bocats. by your heads close your eyes
▶ Play
Speaker 118 15:44
dearly father thank you for this day thank you for letting us come here and look at a great opportunity for all of us in this room give us strength give us guidance help us lead us in the right direction and hope that we can be better citizens as we get out of Lord, in Jesus' name we pray. Amen. Amen.
▶ Play
Members, please indicate your presence by pushing your yellow present button. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk.
▶ Play
Right here, yep, there you go. And then, so, you're gonna be greeting who are
▶ Play
Speaker 129 17:08
still waiting on Murdoch. Murdoch, Murdoch, Murdoch, Murdoch. Cast up the ballot, Mr. Clerk. With 100
▶ Play
members present. With 100 members present, the chair sees a quorum. The chair appoints the following committee to notify the Senate that the House is organized and ready for business. Chapman Campbell, Hayden Couch, and Will Dean. The chair appoints the following committee to notify the governor that the House is organized and ready for business. Sullivan Sulhurst, Tate Hill, and Marcus Pillow. If the committee will please deliver those messages. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 141 18:27
Members, we're going to pass over. House Bill 1001.
▶ Play
Is that it? We're going to
▶ Play
pass over House Bill 1001. Without objection, we're going to pass over the Bill 1001. Okay. Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker 106 18:51
Clerk, please read... Yes,
▶ Play
Speaker 148 19:01
House Bill 1002. House Bill
▶ Play
Speaker 152 19:06
1002. House Bill 1002, Smart Weed Act of 2017.
▶ Play
Representative Campbell, you are recognized to explain the
▶ Play
Speaker 161 19:48
bill. Good morning, gentlemen. The Smart Weed Act of 2017 is made to implement a sales tax on the sale of medical marijuana. Currently, Arkansas has no funding. Well, it costs $3 million a year to fund and regulate the sale of medical marijuana because it's an entirely new industry that we didn't really account for. So that's $3 million that the state's losing every year. To make up this, we're trying to implement a 2.9% sales tax on the sale of medical marijuana. This includes sale from the cultivator to the distributor and then from the distributor to the consumer. And so the first $3 million of that will be used to cover the funding of regulating the medical marijuana industry. And then the rest of that will be given back to funding for important things in the state. So the remainder shall be distributed as follows. 60% to the Department of Education to be used for kindergarten, through grade 12 education, 30% to drug prevention programs in education, and 10% to a fund for disaster relief. And we know that disaster relief is important, as we've seen some of the flooding in northeast Arkansas. So the Smart Weed Act really has no drawbacks. It'd be great for the state, and it would help to cover the costs of this new industry, and it would give back
▶ Play
to the people. Representative Campbell has explained the bill. Would anybody like to speak against the bill? Representative Sturge, for what purpose? Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Guys, I
▶ Play
Speaker 164 22:02
just kind of want to show you how this is done in the process. So when after a speaker presents his bill, you will have an opportunity to come down here and either speak for or against the bill. As long as he was in the well, you could have asked a question of him. And so I'm using this opportunity to bring up a point that I did not see in House Bill 1002. I applaud Representative Campbell's efforts. I applaud his division of the funds. But I would also like to see money diverted to our road program. Because, as you know, roads in this state are at a critical time, and we need money diverted to them. We're already giving almost 60 cents out of every dollar to public education and higher education. I'd like to see some of this money to the road. So I'd ask you to please consider that when you're voting on
▶ Play
this bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Would anybody like to speak for the bill? Representative Whitaker, for what purpose? You are recognized.
▶ Play
Although the roads are in bad condition, as you said, public education is a big part of the future of Arkansas. And this money should be used to further education so that more solutions and more problems can be fixed. Coming from a small school, I can see that public education is underfunded and there is major improvements that could be made. Thank you.
▶ Play
Would anybody like to speak against the bill? Representative Rushing, you are recognized, please speak against the bill. Please
▶ Play
Speaker 146 24:21
admit the delegation from the Senate.
▶ Play
Speaker 180 24:29
You are recognized. The Senate, where each member is recognized as, sorry, the Senate, where each member approximately represents 90,000 citizens, as opposed to you guys representing 30,000, is ready for business. So, let's put that out there. Ready to get started?
▶ Play
Okay. Representative Russian, you
▶ Play
are recognized to speak. Though this bill does have a lot of potential, I think that it should go towards the roads. But also, we've seen how drugs can affect families, and not just families, but individuals. that level. So I think that that should somehow fund towards not only the education but the rehabilit- rehabilitation of those who have been previously addicted to drugs like that- like that of marijuana. Representative Hendren for what purpose? He's left the well. He has left the
▶ Play
well would anybody like to speak for the bill Rick the representative Jett you are recognized to speak for the bill
▶ Play
Speaker 200 26:33
I do agree with the allocation of funding to public schools because we all know how underfunded rural schools are and the teachers of the state are completely underpaid. So I do believe that even though we do send a whole lot of money to public education, That is the most important part of the bill,
▶ Play
public education. Would anybody like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Representative De La Russo, you are recognized to speak for the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 205 27:17
I believe that the 30% that goes towards drug prevention programs would be enough. I don't think that the rehab programs are necessary in this situation because it is something that's been voted on and approved by the state and gone through a process so so that it is, has been recognized as safe and allowed for medical use. Thank you. Would
▶ Play
anybody like to speak against the bill? Representative Tosh, you are recognized to speak against the bill. Representative, if you would like to speak against or for the bill, please stand so you can
▶ Play
Speaker 209 28:15
be recognized. I would like to make the case against the bill that there should be more funding for the drug prevention because it's not just preventing marijuana use. You'd be going for opium and heroin and cocaine and all that. And so I think those drugs, they do need rehabilitation. So I think maybe instead of 30 percent, increase it to 40 percent of the bill's funding to go to drug rehabilitation and prevention. Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 132 28:51
Burchey has left well. For the bill. Against.
▶ Play
Representative Ballinger, for what purpose? Question about the use of the 40% on the drug prevention program, where would that money come from? There's no one in the will, so no one can answer the question. Alright. Representative Campbell, would you like to close for your bill?
▶ Play
Speaker 161 29:45
So the Smart Weed Act of 2017, it seems that everybody's on board with spending money to cut the deficit that we have on the regulation of medical marijuana because we're losing $3 million every year that we don't tax the industry. It just seems that people are disagreeing on what we should spend the remainder on, but I promise that the programs we've chosen to invest in with the remainder of the money will benefit the people of Arkansas, and they are good for the citizens. and this bill could bring a lot of good things to Arkansas it could break because not only would it not only would it help with education it also helped to prevent drug abuse it also helped to prevent natural disaster or to help natural disaster relief so I would encourage each and every
▶ Play
one of you to VOTE FOR THE BILL. REPRESENTATIVE GRAY FOR WHAT
▶ Play
PURPOSE? USE YOUR MICROPHONE. AS YOU JUST SAID THAT 60% OF THE TAX WILL GO TO THE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION AND I JUST WANTED TO KNOW WHAT IN PARTICULAR WOULD IT BE USED FOR THROUGH OUR PUBLIC SCHOOL SYSTEM?
▶ Play
Speaker 161 31:12
Um, it'd just be used to go to the public schools and the Department of
▶ Play
Education could use it from there,
▶ Play
Speaker 222 31:29
however they see fit. Representative Wardlaw, for what purpose? Um, I would just like to, well, good morning everybody, I'd just like to know, um, is the, um, oh, question, question, question. You're recognized. Okay, so the remainder of the money is spent based on importance or personal choice? Oh, excuse me? Is the remainder in the proceeds, is it based on personal choice or importance? Based on the schools, the drug prevention programs, and the flood, is it based on importance or personal choice?
▶ Play
Speaker 161 32:04
Well, I guess it's based on a little of both. all of us are high school students, so I guess the problems that we see the most of would be problems with education. So that played a factor in allocating the funds. And I'm from northeast Arkansas, so I've seen some of the flooding, so that played a part in choosing to send some funding there. And the drug abuse, I figure if we're having a law that involves drugs, we should
▶ Play
also be having a law that helps to prevent drug abuse. Representative Speaks, for what purpose? Question. You are recognized. How will we know that this money goes towards the public school programs and it's not spent on other things through the Department of Education?
▶ Play
Speaker 161 32:56
Well, the Department of Education spends money on public schools, so we'd expect them to spend them on public schools. I hope we can trust
▶ Play
the Department of Education. Representative Gates, for what purpose?
▶ Play
Speaker 232 33:14
Question. You are recognized. Why a 2.9% tax? Why not any higher? Why not any lower? Well, when
▶ Play
Speaker 161 33:23
drafting this bill, we looked at what other states who have medical marijuana laws have done. And Colorado, who's most well-known for their medical marijuana laws. They have a 2.9% sales tax, and it has only been beneficial to the state. So we figured we would
▶ Play
emulate their success in that. Representative Miller,
▶ Play
Speaker 236 33:52
for what purpose? Question. You
▶ Play
Speaker 205 33:54
are recognized. Will this marijuana be grown inside of Arkansas,
▶ Play
Speaker 161 33:58
or will it be imported? So, the tax on the cultivators' sale to the distributors, that comes from the five cultivating facilities that we will allow in Arkansas with the recent medical marijuana bill. And along with the five cultivators, there are, I believe, 32 distributors across the state. Those will be all the
▶ Play
questions. Representative Campbell has closed for the bill. The question before the House is the passage of House Bill 1002. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everybody voted? Has everybody voted? Cast up the ballot, Mr. Clerk. By vote of 71 yeas, 26 nays, and zero presents, the bill is passed. members we do not usually clap when there is a passage or failure of a bill Clerk, please read House Bill
▶ Play
Speaker 152 36:12
1003. House Bill 1003, to create a state and local road partnership by dedicating the sales tax revenue created from the sale of certain auto-related goods to the state aid program by representatives H. Wilson, W. Schwartz, E. Daugherty, by Senators H. Harrison and C. Brown.
▶ Play
Representative Wilson, you are recognized to explain the bill. This bill is designed to help improve the roads in rural areas that tend to be neglected and just help to maintain them in the future. The Chief Fiscal Officer of the State shall certify to the Treasurer of State each month the amount of available net general revenues for the immediately preceding month that are attributable to the collection of sales taxes derived from auto-related sales, including without limitation to all parts placed on or used by a motor vehicle. The Treasurer of the State shall deposit the amount of net general revenue certified each month under subdivision of this section into a fund to be used for the State Aid Program with an emphasis on connecting vital infrastructures between population centers representative speaks for what purpose question you are recognized most of the roads in rural areas are maintained by the county and city how would we know that the money is going to be used towards the roads instead of being used towards a county jail or other purposes there there will be a committee appointed to for the purpose of making sure that all the funds are spent correctly within the counties and to ensure that not only are the funds spent the way they're supposed to be spent but also to minimize the cost to the state as that will maximize the amount of money that the county is spending that they already had representative gates for what purpose you are recognized you spoke of a
▶ Play
Speaker 232 39:01
committee who would be on that committee who would consist of being on
▶ Play
the committee where would they come from well the way I would think of it is that the committee would be composed of representatives and senators that mainly represent either rural areas or the areas where the money is going like for example if some if there was some rural district the representatives for that district that are for the dish for the representatives whose district or whose district would be would have the county within it they would be on definitely on the county or on the committee to ensure that the funds are well spent representative jet for what purpose you are recognized the
▶ Play
Speaker 200 40:07
bill does not specify what the tax is what percentage would the tax
▶ Play
be the tax is it's an existing tax that's already on all automobiles and automobile parts and what we would be doing is taking the existing tax and redirecting it to the roads as opposed to the general fund that we've had it for already. Representative Davis, for what purpose?
▶ Play
You are recognized. Do you know exactly where you're taking
▶ Play
these funds from? From just the general fund, which encompasses many different things, such as education and general maintenance and things like that. Representative Nix, for what purpose? Question. You are recognized. What is the expected amount of revenue
▶ Play
Speaker 266 41:06
that this tax will bring in?
▶ Play
Well, we're not quite sure yet. to depend on just the sales of automobiles and automobile parts as far as the tax itself is concerned, but in the future, after the improvement of the roads from the tax, we would expect that it would bring in more revenue through transportation of goods and such because the shipping of trucks and all that would be easier representative Ballinger for what purpose question you are recognized so the tax would the tax money be given back to the county where the purchase was made or would it come back to the state and the state divided up to each county it would be divided up the way that the existing gas tax is divided which is between which is 15% of it goes to the city 15% of it goes to the county and 70% of it goes to the state Representative Lundundstrom, for what purpose? You are recognized. Okay, so
▶ Play
do you know how much the existing tax already
▶ Play
is? I do not. Representative Wardlaw, for what purpose? Question. You are recognized. Could
▶ Play
Speaker 222 42:55
you give a general estimate on how long construction will take?
▶ Play
Well, it all, of course, depends on the road that is being repaired and the severity of the damage to said road. But the average should be anywhere from about four days to a week. representative de la rosa for what purpose ask a question
▶ Play
Speaker 192 43:27
you're recognized i was wondering
▶ Play
Speaker 205 43:30
what you would use to uh determine what is an auto-related good um would that have to do with motorcycles and mopeds as well and also would that have to do with things like air filters and like oils, or would it only have to do with
▶ Play
parts? Of course it would, like you said, have to do with parts for automobiles, mopeds, motorcycles, just about anything that would be street legal in traveling on the road, but that it would include things such as oil and all that because there's already a gas tax which goes to the roads even though sometimes people get gas and it's not for their car representative gray for what purpose question
▶ Play
you are recognized what would be the process in which roads are chosen to get aid from this
▶ Play
tax well the roads that would the goal is to now obviously we can't fix all the back roads in Arkansas because that was there's too many of them but the goal would be to get a majority of the moderately traveled rural roads that tend to fall into decay would be to be fixed and take care of but what we would do is most likely take complaints from citizens and whichever ones are reported to be the most severe we will look at and if it is determined that they require a large amount of upkeep they will be taken care of first and then it will just go from there from the most destroyed to the least Representative Gazeway, for what purpose? Question,
▶ Play
Mr. Speaker. You are recognized. Just to be clear, this bill is
▶ Play
focused on rural roads. Yes, the focus is concentrated more on rural roads because those are the ones that tend to fall into the most disarray because of the lack of upkeep on them due to the fact that they're not extremely widely traveled, but traveled just enough to where they get worn down. But any road that lacks consistent upkeep and is in need of massive repair would be open to the funding from this bill. There will be no more questions. Representative Wilson has explained the bill. Would anybody like to speak against the bill? Representative Rushing, you are recognized. Within
▶ Play
this bill, it takes the money out of the general fund. This general fund goes towards things like education, which is a major factor, in my personal opinion, of the next generation, our future kids that one day we will have. Now, if we put that towards the roads and we take it out of this fund, we lose that potential income, that potential revenue that could be used towards the further education and the further enlightenment of our fellow citizens as well as generations to come. Representative De
▶ Play
La Rosa, for what reason? First of all,
▶ Play
Speaker 205 47:53
I'd like to point out that it does not add any taxes. It replaces, you know, it changes where those taxes are allocated. Secondly, I would like to point out with education, we just passed a tax that would greatly add to our Department of Education. That's all I have to say.
▶ Play
Would anybody like to speak against the bill? Representative Ballinger, you are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'd like to oppose this just because on the fact that I come from a more highly populated area where there is a lot of construction on the roads. This budget will take away from all the construction we are doing for highly populated areas such as Little Rock, Northwest Arkansas, and it's giving it to other counties which could hurt our infrastructure because there's so much traffic due to all the construction going on in our area. It would be hard to do any business getting to or from in these highly populated areas. I see the need for it in rural areas, but you're taking away the opportunity for people to do business in these highly populated areas. but also, like my fellow representative said, it's taken away from the general tax. Yes, we did pass a bill that helped the education system through taxing medical marijuana, but with this add-on in education, we might be able to help these rural areas with their education and possibly get them jobs to advance the income in those areas to build up the infrastructure. So, thank you. Representative Boyd, for what purpose?
▶ Play
Speaker 296 50:31
Let's hear your motion. To limit the debate to
▶ Play
two minutes. On each side? Total. So one minute on each side? Yes, sir. That is a proper motion. It's not debatable. The question before the House is to limit debate to one minute on the side. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed say no. No. Ayes have it. The debate is limited. Would anybody like to speak for the bill? representative Saban for what you are you are recognized
▶ Play
Speaker 302 51:40
yes I would just like to say that first of all this bill does not take away any funds that are currently in the road system for highly populated areas. It simply adds more funds to the improvement of our infrastructure. And also, you talked about taking away the funds from the general fund, which would take away funds from education. But improving our overall infrastructure would therefore increase commerce, which would mean more funds, revenues coming into the government, into the general fund, which would then go to education.
▶ Play
Would anybody like to speak against the bill? Representative Tosh, you are recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 209 52:46
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Well, I would like to say this bill has a good idea supporting the roads and I think taking away from the general tax wouldn't be such a bad idea, but I don't think the bill is well thought out enough. There are certain details that haven't been addressed, such as I don't think it was well unexplained how the committee would be selected. When he was talking about the construction and how much of the tax is already there, those are unanswered questions, I feel like. So I think this bill needs some work still. This is a bill that I think is a good idea, but not a bill that I would, as of now, put into law. Would anybody like to speak for the bill? Representative Warren, you are recognized. There are just a few seconds left.
▶ Play
Speaker 309 53:47
I would like to point out that this bill is greatly needed for the infrastructure of the southern half of the state. If you look at the wood on these desks, that was most likely provided by a sawmill from the southern half of the state, such as where I come from, Spartan. There are three major sawmills there. One of them is the third largest sawmill in the state next to GP
▶ Play
and Rogers Sawmill. and that is all the time for the bill would anybody like to speak against the bill representative Ferguson you are recognized that's McNair my apologies I'm against
▶ Play
Speaker 311 54:45
this bill because you'll have to turn around, especially with the construction being, he said, from four days to a week. I feel as if it would be poorly constructed, as if they wouldn't tear up the roads and do it over again. And if it's a heavily populated back road, it would draw back to the community from getting
▶ Play
to work. Thank you. We have a few seconds left. Would anybody like to speak against the bill? Representative Fielding, you are recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 313 55:34
I see there's a need, but I think the bill is too early in the stage. I think that there are some more details that need to work out. And also, I think that instead of taking away from the education, if you can take part... That
▶ Play
is the time. The question before the House is the passage of House Bill 1003. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everybody voted? Cast up the ballot, Mr. Clerk. By a vote of 17 yays and 80 nays and zero presents, the bill has failed. Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1004.
▶ Play
Speaker 152 56:57
House Bill 1004, to provide for current college or vocational credits for high school students by Representatives T. West. Representative
▶ Play
T. West, you are recognized to explain the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 320 57:21
Good morning gentlemen. This bill was designed to be very straightforward and what we discussed about was trying to get it to where every high school student had the opportunity of enrolling in concurrent classes where they can either take academic or vocational classes to steer away from the negative connotation that jobs like plumbing or electricians aren't good careers because those blue-collar jobs are looked down upon, but they can easily make up to $80,000 and $90,000 a year. And also, we feel as if college, it's a very time-consuming process, and this could expedite that process by making a four-year bachelor's program turn into three. Instead of having senior year kind of being that blow-off year, they start taking college classes earlier in advance. And that kind of saves money and time. Yeah, so thank
▶ Play
you. representative Williams for what purpose ask your question you are recognized okay so
▶ Play
Speaker 324 58:49
how would this part how would the concurrent credit be like given to the students would there have to be like classes offered and if so how would you fund those classes funding
▶ Play
Speaker 320 59:01
well I'm from Fayetteville high school and what we do is you have to actually pay for your classes like I'm signed up for composition too so it's like a $200 class and it's through our NWAC community college so I feel like it's your responsibility to pay for that
▶ Play
because nothing in life is really free. Representative Hendren for what purpose? We're taking questions now.
▶ Play
Speaker 310 59:33
Representative Walker, for what purpose? Question. You are recognized. How do you plan to pay for this,
▶ Play
Speaker 320 59:42
for these classes? I just kind of answered that in my previous statement, that it's kind of your responsibility as
▶ Play
Speaker 327 59:51
nothing in life is free. That
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:00:02
there is my question. Representative West has explained the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Hendry, you, we have recognized. In the bill, it says
▶ Play
that it would like to provide each student the opportunity to get it, And so when it says provide, I believe that that means that it'll allow them to pay for it. And so I don't think that in public education we have the funding to provide each student that opportunity. I think that each school district in the state should be free to choose whether they would like to offer that, and that's what I
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:00:43
have to say, thank you. Would anybody like to speak for the bill? I would like for this
▶ Play
Speaker 336 1:01:10
bill to be passed because as of right now I'm only taking one class next year in high school. And if these classes were passed, I would be able to get more college credit and not have to spend so much time in college when I finish
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:01:32
high school. Thank you. Would anybody like to speak against the bill? Representative Gray, we have recognized you.
▶ Play
Looking at this bill, I don't really see, with all due respect, I don't see the point of this bill if the schools are going to offer college credit, but then the high school student has to pay for it, and so honestly, I just think it would be a waste of legislation if the student can afford it. They would go ahead and take these college credits themselves, and we shouldn't make the public schools we shouldn't force it upon the upon the schools to make them
▶ Play
Speaker 337 1:02:20
offer these college classes thank you wouldn't
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:02:24
would anybody like to speak for the bill Representative Gonzales, we have recognized. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Speaker. If these classes were to be offered in high school, high school students would be relatively guaranteed basically the first year of their college year. So if So if you were to go to a two-year vocational college, if you were to take that first year in high school, you would only have to take one and instantly be in the job a year later. Whereas if you were, or if the school were to not have these classes, it would still have, it would take longer for you to be in these jobs. Or it would take longer to go to school, or it would take, yeah, it would take longer
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:03:36
to go to school, yeah. Oh Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Bentley we have recognized you we have already recognized the next speaker I would just like to point out that in college different classes give you different number of our credits so I'd like to point out that it would vary like very widely depending on which classes are offered and also you can take four hours worth of classes one year and like six hours of worth of classes the next year so what exactly I identifies as one year of college. Representative Hillman, for what purpose? Because, because I don't
▶ Play
Speaker 345 1:04:38
believe that, oh, I'm sorry, motion? Let's hear your motion. Immediate consideration.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:04:56
That's a proper motion and it's not debatable. The question before the House is immediate consideration of House Bill 1004. All in favor say aye. Aye. All in favor, all opposed say no.
▶ Play
Speaker 537 1:05:26
No. I heard, I heard, I heard, I was happy. I was
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:05:40
happy. I was happy. I was happy. The question before the house is passage of House Bill 1004, prepare the machine clerk.
▶ Play
Speaker 351 1:05:48
Thank you. Has everybody voted?
▶ Play
Speaker 187 1:06:20
48. Has everybody voted? Cast up the ballot,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:06:27
Mr. Clerk. Cast up the ballot, Mr. Clerk. By vote of 50 yeas, 47 nays, and one present, present, the bill has failed. Representative Wilson moves that we place House Bill 1001 back on second reading for the purpose of amendment. Without objection, read amendment number one, Mr. Clerk. Amendment
▶ Play
Speaker 248 1:07:34
number one by Representative Allen.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:07:45
I recognize Representative Meeks to explain what is going on. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Okay,
▶ Play
gentlemen, what we're doing is we're getting ready to amend a bill. When a bill is first introduced, the Constitution says it has to be read three times. The first time, basically, is when it's read is when it's filed. It's read a second time. After it is read the second time, it's assigned to a committee. If it passes the committee, it comes back, and then it's read the third time across the desk before the House takes action on it. In order for a bill to be amended, it has to be on second reading. When the bill's on the third reading, it's considered that's the final form of the bill, and it can't be amended on the third reading. So what we just did is the Speaker said, without objection, we're going to put the bill back on second reading for the purpose of amendment. If anybody objected, then the House would go into debate about whether we were going to put it back on second reading. Generally, nobody ever does that. So the bill is back on second reading now for the purpose of amendment. And here in a minute, the amendment sponsor is going to come down and talk about his amendment. Now, when he comes down and talks about his amendment, he has to focus on the amendment only. He can't talk about the merits of the bill. So if he starts talking about the merits of the bill, someone jump up and call point of order on him. when he explains the amendment then it will go into the normal debate like we've just had you can speak for and against the amendment sometimes the bill sponsors okay with the amendment and wants the amendment to take place because it makes it a better bill sometimes the bill sponsor does not like the amendment and will speak against the amendment so the bill sponsor I don't know that'll be up to you to decide what to but you will debate that amendment if the amendment passes then what would happen in the real world is the bill would be sent to what's called engrossing. So there would be no further action taken on it today. That amendment would be engrossed into the bill and then it would come back tomorrow for us to take up as a whole bill back on third reading. If the amendment fails then we would just continue business as order. You go into the bill and discuss the bill and continue normally. So, with that, Mr. Representative Ladyman? Representative Wilson, you have
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:10:01
been recognized to explain the amendment, House Bill 1001. Amendment. Okay, so is he doing the amendment or is he doing
▶ Play
Speaker 367 1:10:10
the amendment? He's doing his
▶ Play
Speaker 369 1:10:17
amendment. Okay, okay. Thank you, Speaker. The amendment is for Bill 1001. What it would do is, for the smaller schools, which is 3 a.m. below, it will require one athletic trainer for every 50 students, every 50 student athletes in the school. And for every school that is a high population school, 4 a.m. or above, it will require one athletic trainer for every 100 student athletes representative de la Rosa for what purpose ask a question you
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:10:52
are recognized why do the schools
▶ Play
Speaker 205 1:10:57
have a different ratio of athletes to trainers the reason they have different ratios is
▶ Play
Speaker 369 1:11:05
because a three a school such as the one I go to we may not have a hundred student athletes in a school because most of the people that play play multiple sports so we may not have a hundred student-athletes so we may not be required
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:11:26
to have even one athletic trainer he has explained representative Wilson has explained the amendment would anybody like to speak against the amendment Representative Warren, we have recognized you. In the bill it
▶ Play
Speaker 309 1:11:51
was said that there would be one trainer for every 50 student athletes. Well there are some schools that do not even have 50 student athletes total, such as schools like Sparkman, Taylor, Emerson, Bradley, 1A schools, even schools like Harmony Grove, which they are, although a bigger school, their football team has about 30
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:12:19
people. Would anybody like to speak for the amendment? Representative Whitaker we have recognized. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Speaker. As of right now, athletic trainers are shared at the smaller level between the schools. Usually three or four schools will share a one athletic trainer. This in turn means that an athletic trainer cannot make every single event, which is a problem. And for one school, if they cannot have an athletic trainer present, this bill would help correct
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:13:02
that and that's it when anybody like to speak against
▶ Play
Speaker 376 1:13:08
the amendment representative Ballinger we have yeah
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:13:25
Thank you Mr. Speaker. I disagree with the 50 athletes to one trainer. I'd set different ratios based on the different classification of the school. If we lowered it, I go to 7A school so we'd be hiring a bunch of athletic trainers to match the lower ratio or even the 50 to one student athlete ratio. So if we could come up with a more proper ratio to fit different classifications, for example, lower 1A schools to have a better ratio between athletes and athletic trainers compared to a 7A school who has a whole lot more athletes, so the ratio can be changed. that's why I'm asking for for you guys to consider because the pay that you have to pay for these athletic trainers would be more more of a burden on these higher schools that need to focus more on education for thousands of students not just athletes so please consider that when you're voting would anybody like to speak for the amendment Representative Farrar, you have been recognized. Alright,
▶ Play
Speaker 161 1:15:02
so speaking back on his statement right there, he said that the money would be more for teachers, which we need, but if you look down on the bill a little farther, it's going to be an incentive to people that are in physical therapy school or medical school and they will use their volunteer hours to get a percentage off or use it as like a teacher when they have to shadow to get a certain amount of hours. So it would be no cost to the education pool. Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 306 1:15:36
Richie, for what purpose? Oh, well, he's left a pit hole.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:15:48
Would anybody like to speak against the bill? Representative Donston, we have recognized
▶ Play
you. Thank you, Speaker. I believe that all the money should be going going to things like teacher salaries. We're adding more employees, but our teachers are not getting paid enough. So why would we put money in more employees when we're not already paying our teachers enough? We need to focus on them so they can pour into the students.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:16:33
Thank you. Would anybody like to speak for the amendment? Representative McElroy, we have recognized you. To address what the former representative just said, if you look at the actual bill, you'll see that the funds would definitely not be coming from the schools. So the pay from teachers would not be diverted at all. The bill in question offers funds for the Department of Education to local college students who are studying physical therapy. It offers them payments towards their student loans. Representative Taj, for what purpose? In order,
▶ Play
Speaker 209 1:17:36
what we're talking about right now, the most conversation has been about the bill, not the amendment. The amendment is talking about the ratio of 1 to 50, or 1 to 50 for 4A, or no, 1 to 100 for 4A above and 1 to 50 for 3A above, and that should be the discussion, or the topic of the discussion.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:17:57
Speakers, please keep your remarks to the amendment. Okay, I'm finished then. Would anybody like to speak against the amendment? Representative Hodges, we have recognized you.
▶ Play
Thank you, Speaker. I feel like these ratios aren't justified because 4A schools are a lot different than 7A schools, and I feel like that each classification, they should have a specific amount of trainers. So like 1A schools, they would have a specific amount, 2As, 3As, 4As, 5As, 6As, 7As, and I would like you all to take that in consideration.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:18:55
So, thank you. Would anybody like to speak against the amendment? Representative Jett, we have recognized. While there is a
▶ Play
Speaker 200 1:19:23
need for athletic trainers, specifically trainers at higher levels, smaller schools like 3A, 2A, 1A, they can probably get by with just having a coach or multiple coaches for that matter taking athletic training well training in the summer times and being certified trainers so then you don't have to divert funding from anywhere you just have the coaches there that already know
▶ Play
Speaker 391 1:19:49
the kids are already close and are already
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:19:54
on staff would anybody like to speak against the bill Representative Gassaway we have recognized you let's hear
▶ Play
your motion sir my motion is for immediate consideration of the
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:20:19
amendment that's a proper motion and is not debatable the question before the house is immediate consideration of house of amendment number one to house Bill 1001. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed say no. The ayes have it. The question for the house is passage of amendment 1 to House Bill 1001. All in
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:20:57
favor say aye. Opposed say no. The no's had it.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:21:27
I see more than five hands question for the house is passage of amendment 1 to House Bill 1001 prepare the machine mr. clerk Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? cast up the ballot mr. clerk by vote by a vote of 32 yays 57 nays and 10 presents the amendment has failed I recognize the proletarian. Mr. Johnson. Representative Johnson. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker. Men, I wanted to kind of explain what just happened here, and it goes to why we passed over House Bill 1001 at the very beginning. When you're doing amendments, it can get complicated, And during the debate, the point of order was made when the discussion went beyond the amendment itself. It was a proper point of order because the debate should have talked strictly about the amendment. And since the debate happened, the vote was taken, the first vote was taken was a voice vote. And it wasn't clear what was going on, but when we vote on amendments up here, we often just use a voice vote. The state constitution requires that the yeas and nays be recorded on the passage of bills in certain resolutions. But on amendments, that's not a requirement. So the speaker will often do voice votes on amendments. But if there's five hands that dispute the outcome of that vote, It will be put on the machine, which is what happened, and that's what the result was. Okay, the amendment failed. So now we're in the posture, as Mr. Meeks explained a while ago, we immediately take up the bill as originally written. So it is as if amendment number one doesn't have anything to do with the bill anymore. Had it passed, it would have become part of the bill, and during a real legislative session, when a bill is amended, it goes to engrossing. And that's the process of taking the amendment and merging it with the bill and producing a new version of the bill. And that won't be voted on until it comes out of engrossing and the members can actually read the bill and know exactly what they're voting on. So I don't know if I've made anything clearer, but the bottom line is amendments can be complicated. and if we get Senate Bill number one over from the Senate later we're going to take up another it will have been amended so we won't have to deal with the amendment over here. So thank you.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:25:25
Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1001.
▶ Play
Speaker 152 1:25:33
House Bill 1001, to protect the health of student-athletes by requiring an athletic trainer in every public school, by Representative Allen.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:25:46
Representative Allen, you are recognized to explain the bill.
▶ Play
how you all doing okay well the problem at hand is not every school around the state of Arkansas have an athletic trainer and an athletic trainer's job is to treat athletes when they are hurt prevent some maintenance from getting them hurt and diagnose things when they are hurt and it is dangerous to have coaches out there diagnosing you know I'm saying players without athletic trainers and and it would be we would do this bill by okay here we go nurses it will be all volunteer work nurses like it says right here in a it says receive a credential in the program to study for athletic trainers for a similar program of study that leaves the person being qualified as athletic trainer and it continues to be employed in public schools as an athletic trainer. It will be nurses or people who are in graduate school to get volunteer hours, or it will be like a debt forgiver for people, like a year for a year, if you stay there for a year, then you get the debt off of you, something like that. I'm telling you guys, it is so dangerous to have your coach sit there and diagnose something for you when you can have someone professional there, and it will cost no money to the state at all. It's
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:27:27
just volunteer time. Representative Davis, you are recognized.
▶ Play
For what purpose? Question. You are recognized. The amendment says if the funds are available, that they will be help with student loans from the Board of Education or the Department of Education. If the funds aren't available from the Department of Education, will they still be required to employ trainers? And if so, where will the money come from? Well, I
▶ Play
didn't type that up. It was not originally supposed to be any funds at all. It was supposed to be all volunteer from nurses and nurses who wanted to be nurses or people who were nurses trying to get their debt paid like a debt forgiver. So
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:28:14
that's where I was. Representative Gray, for what
▶ Play
purpose? Question. I was just wanting to know if there was a minimum or maximum salary that athletic trainers had to be paid, and if so, would it differentiate between each size of the school?
▶ Play
That's a great question, and if you read the bill, it says that
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:28:46
no one's going to get paid
▶ Play
Speaker 324 1:28:50
as all volunteer. you representative Williams for what purpose question you're recognized how important is it to have is it to have a athletic trainer on the spot when a student athlete gets injured and why is a couple of 1a schools using the same trainer not sufficient may you repeat the question I didn't the first part. How important is it to have a physical trainer? How what? How important is it to have a physical trainer at the time of an injury and why is a couple of 1A schools sharing one athletic trainer not sufficient? It is extremely
▶ Play
important for a school to have an athletic trainer. Being an athlete myself we at my school we do not have athletic trainer and it costs the school more money not having one because when the player gets hurt and the coach doesn't really know what to diagnose then now the school has to spend money to send this player to go get an x-ray or something or the coach diagnosed something and it's actually more than what it is now the school has to spend money because it's more than what it was it's extremely important because that's a professional and your coach isn't, no matter how many classes he takes. And you said about 1A schools. What about 1A schools? 1A schools is what?
▶ Play
Speaker 324 1:30:16
I asked why it's not sufficient to have a couple
▶ Play
of 1A schools sharing the same trainer. If that's, well, we can't talk about the amendment, but that was what the amendment was about. Y'all took it as if, like, 50, that was no one 250 so if your school had 20 that would be in that 20 and if a couple 1a schools is in that area that trainer will be with those schools also they will all fit in with that one trainer or a trainer you know what i'm saying representative house
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:30:53
for what purpose question you are recognized would there be
▶ Play
Speaker 417 1:30:59
a trainer for each sport in case like two sports are going on at the same time
▶ Play
yes volunteers yes it should be represent De La Rosa for what purpose
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:31:16
to ask a question you're recognized what about the
▶ Play
Speaker 205 1:31:23
athletic trainers who currently have jobs through the school system okay will they will they retain those jobs yes
▶ Play
if your school wants to keep his athletic is is obligated for the school to have an athletic trainer this is just a program if your school wants to spend their money on the athletic trainer then they can as they will but this is for the schools who don't necessarily you know what I'm saying Representative Smith, for what purpose?
▶ Play
Speaker 421 1:31:55
You're recognized. Not all schools or
▶ Play
not all students that are going to be athletic trainers might want to participate in volunteer service, but the bill still requires that each public school that offers athletic programs shall employ a trainer. So, will they be forced to hire one, and where will those additional funds come
▶ Play
from? No, people are going to volunteer because of their debt. In local hospitals, nurses are going to volunteer. It's volunteer where people volunteer. They're going to volunteer for it. Representative Mahindran, for what purpose? Question.
▶ Play
question you're recognized you said that people would volunteer to because they have debts as I understand volunteering means you don't get paid so how am I gonna pay off my debts if I'm just volunteering it also states in the bill
▶ Play
one for one one year for one year of your debts I think that's what it says in here if I think he wrote it down he was supposed to write it down or type it You know, we're supposed to say
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:33:20
one for one. But yeah, that's how we'll go, one year for one year. Representative Ballinger, for what purpose? In section, I think it says 1B, 1B, it says if funds are available, the Department of Education shall provide payments toward the student loans of in-person employed as an athletic trainer by public schools if the athletic trainer receives credentials in Part A, but it also says continues to be employed by the public schools. If this is volunteer work, why are they receiving funds? Because that makes them an employee at that time. And then where will that money come from? Will that come from the school board having to rearrange the budget? Or will the government have to take taxes out of some other place to pay for these athletic
▶ Play
trainers? I believe someone over here already asked a question earlier, and we were like, that was a mistype. it will be all volunteer well I'm done with questions
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:34:47
representative Allen has explained the bill would anybody like to speak against the bill represent gas away we have recognized
▶ Play
you why this bill has a good concept there are some problems with the execution of the bill, mainly just the whole funds going towards the particular volunteer's student loan debt. Where would that money come from? I don't see any funds being available, so. Representative Nix, for what purpose?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:35:44
let's hear your motion
▶ Play
Speaker 125 1:35:53
hey limit debate to two minutes each side that's a problem that's a proper motion
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:36:06
and that's a proper motion is not debatable the question before the house is to limit the debate to two minutes on the side all in favor say aye all opposed say no the the eyes have it I recognize Representative Sturge. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Guys, this time
▶ Play
Speaker 164 1:36:51
won't count against you or for you. Just a quick observation. What's in this bill today before you is not exactly what was talked about in our committee yesterday. This actually does happen to us even sometimes as authors of the bill that we think we had put something in there or that it should have been this way and it doesn't get translated just right. So a lot of the questions that you're asking, I think that's where a lot of the confusion was. This was my committee that I worked on yesterday, and we did talk about both a loan forgiveness program and a volunteer service credit program. So if you were working at a hospital or if you're working at a higher ed institution like for college and you needed service hours or volunteer hours, you could be employed as the athletic trainer or help out with athletic training, and that would take care of your service hours. So a lot of the confusion I keep hearing about is because there was supposed to be a section in there that's not in there. But there was supposed to be a volunteer service hours and a loan forgiveness program. So I just wanted to make that clarification for you.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:37:55
Would anybody like to speak for the bill? Representative Fielding, we have recognized
▶ Play
Speaker 313 1:38:20
you. I would like to say that this bill is for the trainers. It's not that if you already have a trainer, if you have already like high springs, we already have a trainer on staff. We want them to stay on that staff. This is for more like the lower A schools like 3A and under that do not employ an athletic trainer. So we're trying to get where we're making sure protecting our health of our athletes that we try to get that the colleges, we're going to try to go where we get them to partner up with certain different schools that are struggling to get them where we're ensuring the health of our athletes. Thank you. Would anybody like
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:39:08
to speak against the bill? Representative Birch,
▶ Play
for what purpose? I want to make a motion for immediate consideration.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:39:28
That's a proper motion. It is not debatable. The question before the House is immediate consideration of House Bill 1001. in favor say aye. Aye. All in favor say no. No. The ayes have it. The question before the house is the passage of House Bill 1001. Prepare the machine Mr. Clerk.
▶ Play
Speaker 537 1:40:06
Has everyone voted? Has
▶ Play
Speaker 241 1:40:13
everyone voted? Cast up the ballot, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:40:26
Clerk. By vote of 56 yeas, 34 nays, and 7 presents, the bill is passed. Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Bill No.
▶ Play
Speaker 152 1:41:11
2. Senate Bill 2, to study and create alternative irrigation methods to conserve water. Sponsored by C-Swears.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:41:27
Representative Swears you are recognized to explain the bill. What this bill was meant for is what a lot of people don't realize especially with the flooding this year is Arkansas's water deficit underground is becoming where it will be in the same shape as the state of California is if we don't do something about it now. The state of California already has laws in place that what it does is they can only pump so much out of the ground. And not only will that hurt our state's economy, because one in four jobs here in this state relate to agriculture. Agriculture is the biggest industry here in this state. What this bill was meant to do is it's to create alternate water sources. And the way it's going to do that is it's going to create a commission board, which will also partner with the University of Arkansas Division of Agriculture, which will not only make the bill come back, hopefully, but it will also have conservation so that when we have children someday they won't have to worry about the water situation here in the state of Arkansas representative swears has explained the bill would anyone like to speak against the bill representative Whitaker for what purpose question you are
▶ Play
recognized where would funding come from to support the study and the development of this water irrigation? The
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:43:13
University of Arkansas Division of Agriculture has a lot of programs, and this could also be one of their programs. But if you'll also think of it, there's a lot of federal funding. The United States Department of Agriculture, the Natural Resource Conservation Services, and also your USDA, all of it has grants. And like the NRCS, which is your Natural Resource Conservation Service, they've started on this project long ago because they've seen the bigger picture that we're fixing to run out of water. And they're already offering grants, but it's not helping fast enough. We need to make it where everybody's aware that we have a problem with this state's water. Representative Wardlaw, for what purpose? You're recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 222 1:44:09
While it is a unique concept, are the steps attainable for achievement? Are
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:44:17
you asking, can this be achieved?
▶ Play
Speaker 222 1:44:20
What are the steps for achievement,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:44:24
basically? what would have to happen first is after the committee is elected they would have to also appoint people and that's where the division of agriculture can come in with their research facilities if you've never seen them the division of agriculture in the state has some of the best research facilities in the nation we lead here in the state of ardensoll the rice research That would be a perfect place to start for water conservation services. I spoke with some gentlemen yesterday during the meeting who said that drop irrigation is what used to be used, which if it could be fundable to the farmers, it would be an excellent program, but the only way you could see how it would react would be to have it tried. Trod. Representative De La Rosa, for what purpose?
▶ Play
Speaker 205 1:45:24
To ask a question. You're recognized. First of all, you kind of described the bill as something that would create better infrastructure to do with water. But from what I've read, it's only about the Water Conservation Task Force itself, the creation of that, right? okay and so this would have like our our say in this would have nothing to do with actual research right so so this is just about the the delegation of responsibilities so that we can have an opportunity to get this early right the
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:46:00
bill was also supposed to include which I the more I've read it does not but it's also supposed to include or it actually does say the study of it and that's That's where your water conservation task force would come in, and they would help lead the
▶ Play
Speaker 205 1:46:21
studies, which would then report it back. Okay, and so with that, how is that going to help? So this task force is there in order to provide ideas?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:46:33
Is that what this is? They're going, the task force is going to, from my perspective, would create ways and with the water engineers and everybody on the task force, then they would know, they would have an insight, like they're going to be farmers on this that know the water struggles here in the state of Arkansas. And I come from a farm family, so I can tell you firsthand there are water struggles here in this state. The task force would be the one to, they would run the research side of it, and with that in mind, it would bring back the information that the public could use. Thank you. You're welcome. Representative Gray, for what purpose? Question. You're
▶ Play
recognized. So how much capital would we need to create this organization, and then how much would
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:47:34
we need it to fund it yearly? There's really not on the funding. The farmers itself can apply for grants through your NRCS, your USDA, your FSA offices. They can apply for the grants that would fund it on their part. The research itself would come from, like, the University of Arkansas Division of Agriculture is part of your land grant college here in this great state. That would allow for, your land grant college is already state funded, and they have many, many programs. We are, my dad's farm is in one of the programs they have. This could just be another program that they offer in order to try to save the state and make it better for everyone representative Miller for what purpose question
▶ Play
Speaker 205 1:48:30
you're recognized okay so you keep using the word problems can you elaborate on what type of problems
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:48:36
are you talking about the water problems or yes like five years ago we had a well in front of my house it was pumping 1300 gallons a minute, which is a lot of water. Last year when we turned it on, it was only pumping 700. The underwater aquifers are slowly depleting to the point that they're going to be nothing one day. And when that happens, we'll be in the same shape as the state of California, who is always on the noose because of their water crisis. Why not do something about it now when we still have enough water that we can contribute to this and make it better so that we won't run out of water one day. Representative Gates, for what purpose?
▶ Play
Speaker 232 1:49:32
You're recognized. You've referred to the study numerous times. How much money would that study cost?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:49:39
How much money would this program cost? the study the study i truly believe that the studies um really wouldn't have to cost any money because of the fact that it could be implemented like um in stuttgart there's the ardenso ross research center which it leads the ross and it um research i believe it could be implemented down there which is already state funded so you wouldn't have to move any of the funds around and with the money they already used all you'd have to do is just use the same money for the same purpose representative douglas for what purpose your question um you're recognized So you
▶ Play
Speaker 161 1:50:35
mentioned that states like California have this problem as well, and they create task force like this that research the same problem. So my question would be, do you really find it necessary to create our own task force when we can just look at the research and solutions that task force in other states have done and get immediately to solving the problem rather than studying things that have already been studied? Arkansas
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:51:03
is a very unique state and you can't compare it to any other state we're one of a kind so I truly believe it needs its own task force in order to make it unique like we are and representative Douglas for what purpose you're recognized so my question is where will
▶ Play
Speaker 470 1:51:25
your allocation of money be like what percentage will go to the farmers and the engineers and what percentage will go to the actual research or review of agricultural irrigation methods? I don't believe
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:51:41
I understand your question. Okay, so
▶ Play
Speaker 470 1:51:44
with the funding that you do receive, how much will actually go to the task force and how much will go to research and review?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:51:56
The task force would be a group of volunteers just like you can volunteer for a lot of different communities throughout your community. There are several communities, like on Ardenstall Farm Bureau, that don't have pay rates, but you're still part of the committee. There really wouldn't be any money raised. It would just be the fact of you're taking the money that's already being used, and you're using it for purposes that would not only conservate the water here in the state, but would also make the state better. I would appreciate a yes vote on this. The state has a problem that a lot of people aren't knowing of, and I'd appreciate your vote. Thank you. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Whitaker, you are recognized, or for what purpose? Motion. We're
▶ Play
not taking motions at this
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:53:13
time. We want to give someone the opportunity to speak against the bill. Representative Sorvillo, you are recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Speaker. To my understanding, this bill will create a new task force. I would like to vote no on this bill today and send it back to the committee, have it rewritten so that we assign these responsibilities to an existing agency as opposed to expanding in the bureaucracy. Thank you. Mr. Whitaker, for what purpose?
▶ Play
Speaker 475 1:54:04
To limit debate to two minutes. That's
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:54:08
a proper motion, and it is not debatable. The question before the House is to limit debate to two minutes on the side. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, say no. No. The ayes have it. Would anyone like to speak for the bill?
▶ Play
Speaker 309 1:54:39
Representative Warren, you are recognized. okay this would put us in the lead for basically making our own efforts towards conservation of the water and really i think what he was trying to say was that we can't really follow someone else's lead because it is a very, very different situation. California didn't take steps in advance to prevent it. We are trying to prevent it, and as with the farmers, the costs could be covered by agencies such as Farm Bureau, Farm Credit, who are basically insurance agencies for the farmers. They help them out in times of need, and as far as the cost for the study, Southern Arkansas University is an agricultural college mostly. So they would be glad to do a study on this, University of Arkansas would very gladly accept a study on this, and this could be one of their programs that we would not have to pay for as a state, as taxpayers, we would be paying the same taxes for the same
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:56:10
universities. Thank you. Representative Payton, for what
▶ Play
Speaker 480 1:56:26
purpose? No one is at the stand.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:56:43
Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Representative Smith, you are recognized. Thank
▶ Play
you all. My dad worked for a guy that drilled wells in South Arkansas for a while. And recently they've been having to go around and lower those wells so that they can reach the water table that we have. This is a different water table than is in California. We have different crops that are grown in California. The corn and rice here, as Governor Hutchinson said yesterday, we grow 50% of the nation's rice. So we have a very different problem than California does. So we have a need to have research specific to Arkansas, and that's what this bill would do. It would give us what we need to preserve our economy, to preserve our agriculture and preserve our land. Thank you. Would anyone like to speak against the bill?
▶ Play
Speaker 161 1:57:55
Representative Douglas, you are recognized. So water conservation is a problem across the world, not just in America. Every nation faces droughts. And because of this, there have been numerous studies on how to conserve water and new irrigation methods. And because of this, I don't feel that it's necessary for us to explore something that there have already been solutions to and that we know how to fix. We just have to implement a cause to fix it. So this task force is unnecessary because we could just go straight into implementing ways to help solve the water crisis instead of creating some sort of a committee to research problems that we already have research on and have solutions to. So I would encourage you to not vote for this bill.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:59:01
I need to interrupt for a moment. Is leave granted for the governor to be admitted to address the House? Please submit the governor.
▶ Play
Speaker 484 1:59:38
Governor, you are recognized. To the speaker and everyone in the house, thank you for this opportunity to speak before you right now. I hope you guys are just enjoying yourself. I hope you're having a good time. I hope you're actually doing stuff, though. So I'm not going to be before you long. We're already late for appointments. But basically what I want to say is, don't forget what got you here. You're sitting in these seats now. You're seeing what the actual system is like. Don't forget what got you here. Think together. Use your head. And work together. Don't be separated, no matter where you from or what you do. Be together. Let's work together as a coalition. That's all I got to say. Thank
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:01:04
you. Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Representative Birch, for what purpose?
▶ Play
Motion to limit the debate to two minutes. Representative Birch, for
▶ Play
Speaker 222 2:01:37
what purpose? Let's hear your motion. All this talk about water is making me pretty thirsty. Can I have a motion to recess? Let's see your motion. Motion to recess, get
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:01:47
some water. We're not going to set that up this time. Representative Hendren, for what purpose? Motion.
▶ Play
Speaker 421 2:01:55
Let's hear your motion. For immediate consideration.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:02:00
That's proper motion, and it is not debatable. The question before the House is immediate consideration of Senate Bill 2. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, say no. All opposed, say no. The ayes have it. Question before the House is passage of Senate Bill 2.
▶ Play
Speaker 476 2:02:26
Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:02:56
Cast up the ballot, Mr. Clerk. By a vote of 55 yeas, 37 nays, and six present. The bill is passed. Mr. Clerk, please read Senate
▶ Play
Speaker 152 2:03:22
Bill number four. Senate Bill four, to require standardized college entrance exams and exam testing. Sponsored by S. Sellhorst. Representative Selhorst,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:03:45
you are recognized to explain the bill.
▶ Play
As high school students in Arkansas, we take one test in the 11th grade year. That is, for many students, the first and last ACT that they take. This bill proposes that we have them take another test in their 10th grade year and take a course in their 8th grade year to prepare for these tests so they are less nervous and more prepared for the entrance exams for college.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:04:32
Representative Selhorst has explained the bill. of Hendron for what purpose? You're recognized. Why do you see that
▶ Play
it is necessary to have other opportunities to take this test when some kids don't even plan on going to college, they would rather go to a trade school or a technical school? I
▶ Play
feel that the option to go to college should always be open, and we should give as many opportunities for the people who do and even the people who don't. For if their first test doesn't go well, then their second test goes much better so that that may persuade
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:05:14
them to go to college representative sabin for what purpose question you recognize uh yeah why is the um preparation the the class
▶ Play
Speaker 302 2:05:25
why would that be eighth grade instead of ninth grade closer to to their high school years?
▶ Play
To, when taking it in eighth grade, if they are very adamant about doing well in this test, they can take the things that they learned within the eighth grade and then practice them throughout their ninth grade year and even enhance the learning from the eighth grade class in their classes in the ninth grade year and focus on what they
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:05:57
really need to know. Representative Bentley, for what purpose? you're recognized why do you feel that it should be required for someone have to take the test in the eighth grade when it's early as the seventh grade there's already opportunities through the dip Duke tip program so if kids want to take the ACT test early they can the eighth grade is
▶ Play
that what you said seventh grade so did you ask me if they can take it in the eighth grade I must have misspoke. They can take it in the 10th grade and take it in the
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:06:32
11th grade. Does it require 8th grade students to complete one semester of college entrance test preparation? So why do you feel that it's required for them to take this preparation when in 7th grade they can already take the ACT if they really want
▶ Play
to? The Duke DIP program, as you and other programs, only are offered to a select group of students. But we want to offer this to all of the students that are interested in taking exams later down their career in school. Representative Shepard, for what purpose? Question.
▶ Play
Speaker 501 2:07:10
You're recognized. Would this test be paper or digital?
▶ Play
It would be the ACT, which is
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:07:23
paper. Representative Lowry, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized. Where would we get the funds to pay for the ACT test that will be administered in
▶ Play
the 10th grade? We have just passed a tax to go to education. We can use those funds and allocate there. but did
▶ Play
Speaker 504 2:07:56
it pass in the Senate? That's a good question. I don't know. But I'm just, it's
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:08:07
a school board, I guess. I don't
▶ Play
Speaker 506 2:08:12
know. Representative Fortner, for what purpose? Okay. You're recognized. What would you have in the preparation classes
▶ Play
for the ACT? Well, I believe that we would focus on all the things that they need to know, focus on the math equations that they need to know. We would have them practice reading because speed and pacing on the ACT is a big problem that we have. And we would try and prepare them mentally for the tasks that they will need to take.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:08:49
Representative Sorvillo, for what purpose? Question? You're recognized. The ACT as a college
▶ Play
entrance exam is pretty complicated as far as some of the content goes. Would this class be more along the lines of general test skills or would it be more formatted to the actual content of the ACT considering that the math can be fairly advanced as well as well as, excuse me, as well as the other subjects?
▶ Play
The majority of the math on the ACT is, there's a very small portion that is calculus. And you can, without taking calculus you can mainly do all of the math except for the calculus questions on there but i i feel that a large part of the test is is knowing what types of questions they're going to ask how to eliminate answers from those questions and i'm learning how to pace yourself on those questions representative davis for what purpose question you're recognized
▶ Play
uh from my experience there's a lot of redundancy forcing students to take classes they don't care about so would you consider making the class not required but offered at
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:10:22
every school? I would consider it. Representative Birch for what purpose? You're
▶ Play
recognized. So it's to my knowledge that in 2A it says just in ACT and I believe in SAT is also a college test. My question is why is that not in
▶ Play
the bill? In our committee, we did talk about this, and we did not put the SAT in there, but the college preparation classes would, can be geared to focus to the SAT or the
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:11:06
ACT, whichever. Representative Selhorst has explained the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Hendren, you're
▶ Play
recognized. So this bill has discussed offering eighth grade preparation classes and then taking the test in 10th grade and 11th grade we already take it in 11th grade and throughout the 11th grade year it is required that your class or your teachers in each like science math English they have to give tests that are preparation or that are preparing you for the ACT and so I feel that offering a eighth grade preparation class would be a waste of time and just would be repeating itself and something that we already do in 11th grade. Would anyone like to
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:12:03
speak for the bill? Representative Sturridge you are recognized. Okay, I don't see you, like you, 11th
▶ Play
Speaker 512 2:12:25
grade, yeah, we take the ACT, but I believe that we should take it or start preparing for it around 8th and 9th grade, like the ASFAB test, and previously before we had the benchmark test that we had to take every year in middle school and it was like preparing us and then for the kids that like the younger generation that didn't have to take it then they're not having any like they take the ASVAB test but that's just the ASVAB test but the benchmark was like preparing us for these kind of things that's why most of us do good on our ACT. So let's go for this bill.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:13:11
Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Ballinger, you are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'm against this bill because of the lack of in-depth detail especially about funding for this he said the school board will pay for it where in most cases some districts some school boards don't have enough money to keep afloat all programs and are suffering in some yes we need to take the ACT more often it will help us but I don't think you should require kids to take it if they really want to be successful there's online tests there's classes some schools offer ACT prep for kids that want to do well different methods different styles to be successful so forcing kids to do something that they already have an option of doing would be very harmful to them because they wouldn't want to take it seriously and if putting money that we haven't even found a way to get into the system, that would just be a waste of it. Thank you. Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Representative McNair, you are recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 311 2:15:17
Thank you Mr. Speaker. Now as we all know we go to school and I feel as if this is a great opportunity to be prepared in the eighth grade because this is what you work forward to getting out of high school and proving yourself to go to college and you want to have a high ACT score. I took my first ACT in the 11th grade, and I did fairly well on it, but I felt as if I wasn't prepared enough in the 11th grade. And if I would have had the preparation in the 8th grade working to 11th grade, I felt like I would have done better than I have already did. This is a great bill, and I say we pass it.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:15:57
Thank you. Representative Fortner, for what purpose? Let's
▶ Play
Speaker 506 2:16:09
hear your motion. A motion to immediate consideration.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:16:13
That's a proper motion and it is not debatable. The question before the House is immediate consideration of Senate Bill 4. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed say no. No. The ayes have it. The question before the House is passage of Senate Bill 4. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? has everyone voted cast up the ballot mr. clerk by a vote of 39 yeas 54 nays and five present the bill is failed Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 537 2:17:54
I recognize Mr. Lemons to the stage.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:17:59
Oh, podium. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. We have a couple other
▶ Play
representatives that are with us today that I did not recognize earlier. I'd like to take a minute to do that. Representative Charles Blake. Charles, that's what happens when you're late. We have with us Representative David Hillman. I think he stepped out. And also we had Representative Dan Sullivan. Dan here. We just gave you an
▶ Play
Speaker 111 2:18:49
ovation, sir. Thanks for being here. Representative Hillman. What we'd like to do
▶ Play
now, we're waiting to see if there's any more Senate bills coming forth. I think there may be one more. It may not be making it down here, but we kind of wanted to open it up a little bit to see if you have any questions about anything that you've experienced today. And I'm sure we have plenty of knowledgeable representatives here that would love to step forth and answer. Go ahead. Use your mic. Is
▶ Play
it common for these to get past this fast? Because it seems like it's flying pretty fast and we're limiting, like, the time. So is that pretty common for them to
▶ Play
get through that fast? Actually, you had quite a bit more dialogue today on the average bill than we have. because we vet these in the committee extensively before they get to the House, so a lot of the questions you're asking are handled in the committee. It's not uncommon for us to pass in a session of 75, 80 days, what, 700, 800 bills? And that does not include appropriation, does it? That's separate. 1,100, 1,200. 1,100 to 1,200 bills with appropriations, so we go through them pretty fast. And we've had some times we've had to stay up here until late to
▶ Play
Speaker 519 2:20:16
get it done. Yes, right. We
▶ Play
had 2,200 bills filed this past session. We passed 1,100 of them thereabouts. Any other questions? Yes, sir. So we
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:20:29
experienced some times where stuff wasn't in the bill, but we still voted on it. So in that case, does the bill have to be redrafted and then re-brought before the people, or can it be like a verbal agreement that that stuff is in the
▶ Play
Speaker 164 2:20:44
bill? What you would do in those situations, you kind of fill out what the rest of the body would want you to do. So a representative, if it's my bill, and I feel like there's something that should be in there that's not in there, and I come to present it for you, I can voluntarily pull it down and send it back to committee for purpose of amendment, or I can amend it and come back with an amendment for you to approve here on the House side. However, I have seen it done to where in order to get votes or have people who are kind of on the fence about it, in order to get their vote, what you would do is promise to have it amended on the Senate side. So say there's something in the bill that you don't like or that you wanted added in there, what you can do from this well is say I make a pledge or a promise to you that I will add this, this, or this on the Senate side. So when the bill goes to the Senate and gets in committee, you can amend it in the Senate committee with the Senate sponsor. That bill then would be voted on by the Senate, and then the amended version would come back to you, and you could pass that amended version. It just kind of depends on what the time frame is. So if you're wanting it to be done real fast, you would do it that way. The Senate version comes back here. Or you could do it yourself, and you could amend it back to committee
▶ Play
Speaker 205 2:22:01
and have it amended in committee. Next question. Yes, sir. Like, when dealing with a bill, is it often that people propose a motion to amend, or are they so specific and thoroughly vetted that it doesn't happen?
▶ Play
It doesn't happen that often, but each session there's always what I guess you would label a hostile amendment that might come up that happens on the House floor. We've had it happen a couple of times in each session, but it's very, very rare when you look at 2,200 bills. Usually by the time they get to this floor, for the most part, unless it's a real close vote, they're pretty well, you know, all the problems are worked out. Any other questions? Yes, sir. Say that I wasn't in the committee that was discussing the bill,
▶ Play
but I still have questions about it. Are those usually discussed among the representatives themselves? They just go ask the person in the committee, or how is
▶ Play
Speaker 164 2:23:01
that handled? Usually if you weren't on the committee, like say it's an education bill, but you serve on revenue and tax, and you want to know something about what's in that bill, usually you would go to the sponsor of the bill, or at least someone on the education committee that heard the testimony in committee that day, and ask them, I have a question about this, this, or this. Can you explain this to me? And they'll usually go ahead and do that before it ever comes to the floor. But even I've seen in my short time here that there are still questions. Like you had several questions about different bills because you weren't on that committee. And a good sponsor will try to answer as many of those questions as possible in their presentation. Now, are they going to be able to know what questions you're going to ask? Not when they get down here. So you may throw them for a curveball, and they may not know. So they may have to kind of either say, I don't know, or I'll get that answer to you. You know, but usually the respectful thing to do is to try to get to them and ask the sponsor of the bill before it comes on the House floor for a vote.
▶ Play
Mickey Gates is just dying to say something. Well, a lot of times also this, y'all saw some, some bills die because they kept talking and talking and talking. If you, if you support it and your teammates up here are promoting, you might kind of gently get them out of the well. But also to that end, there are times where the speaker leaves and doesn't want any questions. And you may vote for it if he could answer one or two questions. So you may motion, I want to speak against it and say, well, right now I can't vote for it. But if you can answer these questions, and then when they come up to close, if they want to address
▶ Play
those questions, then they can answer those questions at that point. One other thing I want to mention about committees so that you'll be aware, you do have potential conflicts from time to time. This past year, I was on city, county, local, and I was also in transportation. Every member gets two committee appointments, and so you have five A committees and five B committees. A lot of times you will be in one A committee, but you've got a bill that you are the sponsor that you need to address to the committee to answer questions that is going on at the same time that you're supposed to be in your other committee. So a lot of times you either have to take a leave from your committee to go present it, or you have to find a co-sponsor that will speak on your behalf. So it begins to be a little bit of a timing issue from time to time. Do we have another question? Yes, sir. I'm sorry. We'll come to you next, sir.
▶ Play
Speaker 537 2:26:04
You know, what you're going through today about asking your questions from
▶ Play
the House floor, that's what it would be like if we did not have the committees. So you can imagine, we're in session for 75 days. We would never go out of session if we didn't have committees. So they do definitely serve a good use. I had a question over here. Yes, sir.
▶ Play
Speaker 161 2:26:33
For the most part, is the votes heavily one-sided most of the time on the bills, or is it usually pretty close?
▶ Play
Oh, there are a range. There are some times when Mr. Meeks
▶ Play
Speaker 537 2:26:53
is going to – if you want to address this, go ahead. Come on. The only need can hear me come over here. you can't bring charts, you can't bring graphs, you can't bring presentations, you can't have experts, you can have doctors, you've got to present them yourself. It's a good point. that's a personal opinion, that's not party line. There's about 5% of the bills are real big controversial ones that may divide us all party lines. Those are the ones that are closed public. That's 5% of the ones that you typically hear about on the news. But those are generally the majority of the bills that we focus on. The majority of the bills, post-reviews, And also, going back to one thing I want to add about committees is when we're
▶ Play
in committee, it is, we have certain protocol that we follow, but also it's not near as formal as it is in here. In committees, you can bring in experts to give testimony. People from the public can come and give testimony. Whereas here, when you come to this well, you better have all your questions answered. You better be prepared because no one gets to come up here but you. Now, I'm going to play a little quiz right quick for my fellow legislators. When you come up to the well, you can have paper. Can you have this? Thank you. We're not even allowed to bring these to the well. I mean, it is you get to bring your presentation material, and that's it. No charts, no graphs. Yes. Yes, sir. Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 89 2:28:57
Hodges. Microphone. Attire. The attire. Is anybody wearing blue jeans that's
▶ Play
on the back row standing up? Oh. I'm talking about, Mr. Blake, do you have jeans on today? Okay, just want to make sure.
▶ Play
Speaker 534 2:29:16
Anyway, the attire in here is
▶ Play
you are not allowed to come to the well to present a bill to speak for or against. You can't come up here if you don't have a tie. You must have a tie. And blue jeans are prohibitive, except for typically one day we'll have a blue jean day. And if you give like $20 to a charity that is selected by the members, then you're allowed to wear blue jeans that one day. But you still have to wear a tie. even when you're wearing blue jeans and you must have a jacket must have a jacket yes sir how do you come up
▶ Play
with ideas for bills I'm sorry say that again he was whispering in my ear how do you come up
▶ Play
Speaker 61 2:30:22
with ideas for bills can y'all hear him they can't hear you over here you're gonna have to pick up
▶ Play
Speaker 488 2:30:28
a microphone or come down here i'm gonna you're in charge
▶ Play
yummy okay well most of your ideas for your bills will will come from your districts people in your district. And you're usually related to what, you know, something of special interest to your district, like agriculture or maybe you're a rural versus a non-rural district, those type of legislation. And that's what you'll see. Legislators, the legislation that they bring forward will kind of reflect the makeup of their districts that they come from. One other point, and I'll just quickly make this point, is on the typical day, you understand that we're not just in this chamber. We usually don't get here until about 1.30 or so. So what's going to happen in the morning is we're going to have committee meetings in the mornings and sometime after we adjourn here. So you wouldn't actually be in this chamber. You'd come in, you'd do your A or your B committee and all that goes on in the committees. And then we would come up here to the actual floor.
▶ Play
Another answer to that is when you campaign for office, there are going to be points that you're advertising, that you're campaigning on saying, this is what I want to go do. You'll also have constituents that say, hey, we want you to pass a law that says every fence in Arkansas has to be blue or brown. And we want you to sponsor that. And you're going to look at them and say, you're crazy. I'm not going to do that. And you're going to have people that, you know, that campaign for you, that donate money. Some of those people want you to sponsor legislation that you can agree with or not agree with so those are the way most I think legislators come up with it you're also you have farm bureaus those of you in ag areas the farm bureau is very active they come up with legislation there's times that you pass a bill one session and two years later you find out things in it that really unintended consequences you got to go fix your own
▶ Play
bill I'll just kind of piggyback on that also sometimes you know the governor has his agenda the governor can't file or pass bills so sometimes the governor or state agencies will come to you with issues and they have to get a lawmaker to sponsor a bill because without one of us even the governor can't get a law passed. The other thing that we find is that as lawmakers we each have to get an area that we specialize in because it's impossible for you to know everything. So for example I specialize in the technology and budget and energy and those are things that interest me so a lot of times i will see issues in those areas and will sponsor legislations based on on that whereas uh you know representative gates may be i don't know which committees you're on um okay so he may be an expert in the education field so he may sponsor uh legislation on education and because i might not be an education guy if i see an education bill I trust him because he and I vote the same. We have the same beliefs. I might go to him and say, hey, what do you think about this? Or if there's a bill on the insurance industry, I don't know anything about the insurance industry. So I'm going to find somebody who I trust that knows a lot about the insurance industry and get their opinion which way they feel on a certain bill. So a lot of times we have to develop trust with each other in order to get the state's business done because we can't all be experts in all areas of
▶ Play
state government Stephen don't leave I want you to conclude us today the way you do every time
▶ Play
Speaker 514 2:34:05
so we got one more question though representative McGee you're
▶ Play
Speaker 550 2:34:10
recognized sorry okay so y'all said Johnny so y'all said y'all meet in this chamber of 70 something like 72 days or so do y'all meet in y'all's committees every single time and like how like how many bills do y'all like create in those committees on average like can you repeat the first part of your question um so y'all said that y'all y'all meet in the chamber about like 72 days or so um do y'all meet with those committees every single day that y'all meet and like how like how
▶ Play
Speaker 164 2:34:42
many bills on average do y'all think y'all like create for each committee i i'll try and do my best it's a complicated answer okay but for those 80 days or so we have committees in the morning and then session in the afternoon but we alternate each day so we have like he said a committees and b committees so on mondays and wednesdays i'll have state agencies and governmental affairs on tuesdays and thursday mornings i'll have education committee and then every day i'll have session and in the house we have a couple of rules that deal with the calendar so a bill has to be on the calendar for two days until we vote on it so say on monday we have a bill in education or state agencies that gets passed it won't be until two days after that that it actually comes to the floor so it kind of to answer the other part of your question it kind of depends on the committee itself how many bills that committee is assigned education this year was my first year to serve on education and we had twice as many bills as the transportation committee that I just come off of had just because of you know the funds that go to it the different programs that are a part of it, you know. So not every committee, there's not an average, you know. But basically you could say that education may have 200 bills that are filed that pertain to it, whereas transportation may only have 100 bills that pertain to it. It depends on the committee itself. And
▶ Play
so, all right. Before I turn it over to Representative Stephen Meeks to adjourn us, I want to just say a few words. First, thank you for taking part in this exercise. I hope you learned something. I hope it is something that you can build on. I'm quite confident. Representative Hillman, we're fixing to take a picture. Can you wait just a minute? Thank you, sir. Anyway, sorry, I didn't mean to interrupt. But I hope you have learned something. One thing you'll find out about this body down here, we're 100 different people. We're 100 different people that have real lives back home. When we come up here, and we're all from different backgrounds, different races different creeds different everything different religious views when we walk in this house it's amazing the camaraderie that you develop you might argue against your seatmate on a bill at three o'clock in the afternoon and get very heated except for mr beck and then later that evening you'll go to dinner together so i mean there is i'm so glad that we bring those different views in here so that we can come up with a a plan for the state of Arkansas that is good for everyone. But thank you for being here. Now, every session or every meeting that we have here in the House, it is concluded by the senior member doing what Mr. Meeks is fixing to do. So, Mr. Meeks, would you please adjourn us? Thank you, sir. It's been an honor to
▶ Play
be with you here, gentlemen, here today. And with that, Mr. Speaker, after the announcements, reading of the bills, transferring of the bills, placing the calendars on the desk, members amending their own bills with their own amendments, members withdrawing their own bills, finalizing resolutions, reading communications, and any remaining committee
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:37:49
reports, I move that we adjourn for lunch. Proper motion. Not debatable. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Those opposed, say no. Okay, motion carried. House is adjourned.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 2:38:09
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. You
▶ Play

Agenda

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative David Whitaker Unverified
33 segments
Speaker 16
1 segment
Speaker 537
12 segments
Speaker 26
2 segments
Speaker 29
1 segment
Speaker 31
1 segment
Speaker 33
2 segments
Speaker 35
1 segment
Speaker 44
1 segment
Speaker 47
1 segment
Chair Unverified
211 segments
Speaker 61
2 segments
Speaker 74
1 segment
Speaker 75
1 segment
Speaker 80
1 segment
Speaker 87
1 segment
Speaker 91
1 segment
Speaker 97
1 segment
Speaker 99
1 segment
Speaker 86
1 segment
Representative Tim Lemons Unverified
29 segments
Speaker 118
2 segments
Speaker 129
1 segment
Speaker 141
1 segment
Speaker 106
1 segment
Speaker 148
1 segment
Speaker 152
7 segments
Speaker 161
20 segments
Speaker 164
14 segments
Speaker 146
1 segment
Speaker 180
1 segment
Representative Laurie Rushing Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 200
5 segments
Speaker 205
12 segments
Speaker 209
5 segments
Speaker 132
1 segment
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 222
6 segments
Speaker 232
4 segments
Speaker 236
1 segment
Representative Andy Davis Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 266
1 segment
Representative Robin Lundstrum Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 192
1 segment
Representative Jimmy Gazaway Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 296
1 segment
Speaker 302
3 segments
Speaker 309
6 segments
Speaker 311
4 segments
Speaker 313
4 segments
Speaker 320
5 segments
Speaker 324
5 segments
Speaker 310
1 segment
Speaker 327
1 segment
Representative Kim Hendren Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 336
2 segments
Speaker 337
1 segment
Representative Justin Gonzales Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 345
1 segment
Speaker 351
1 segment
Speaker 187
1 segment
Speaker 248
1 segment
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
11 segments
Speaker 367
1 segment
Speaker 369
3 segments
Speaker 376
1 segment
Speaker 306
1 segment
Representative Jim Dotson Unverified
2 segments
Representative Monte Hodges Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 391
1 segment
Representative Fred Allen Unverified
16 segments
Speaker 417
1 segment
Speaker 421
2 segments
Representative Brandt Smith Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 125
1 segment
Representative LeAnne Burch Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 241
1 segment
Speaker 470
2 segments
Representative James J. Sorvillo Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 475
1 segment
Speaker 480
1 segment
Speaker 484
3 segments
Speaker 476
1 segment
Representative Mary Bentley Unverified
12 segments
Speaker 501
1 segment
Speaker 504
1 segment
Speaker 506
2 segments
Speaker 512
2 segments
Speaker 111
1 segment
Speaker 519
1 segment
Representative Mickey Gates Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 89
1 segment
Speaker 534
1 segment
Speaker 488
1 segment
Representative Rick Beck Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 514
1 segment
Speaker 550
2 segments