Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Judiciary Committee

March 13, 2018 ·Committee Room 130
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026

HB 1006 4:11

Representative Wardlaw introduced House Bill 1007, explaining that it simply codifies the existing ADEQ Reg 5 permit review process by preserving the public comment and 30-day appeal periods while preventing new challenges after a permit is issued, and asserted that it does not affect the C&H hog farm issue. [9:00] [9:33] [10:05]

Committee members and stakeholders-including Rep. Ladyman, Rep. Love, and ADEQ’s Michael Group A-questioned whether the bill applied to Reg 6 permits, to C&H’s pending Reg 5 application, and whether it would retroactively limit appeals, receiving clarification that the legislation only affects permits already in good standing under Reg 5 and does not alter ADEQ’s enforcement authority. [13:46] [14:21] [14:51] [15:27] [15:58] [16:36] [17:12] [17:43] [18:19] [18:52] [19:22] [19:53] [20:24] [20:57] [21:30] [22:01] [22:33]

Testimony from Gordon Watkins of the Buffalo River Watershed Alliance warned that the lack of distinction between Reg 5 and Reg 6 could make the bill retroactive and jeopardize due-process rights, urging language to limit it to prospective Reg 5 permits, while the Arkansas Pork Producers Association’s Jerry Masters supported the bill as protecting existing producers. [23:05] [23:39] [24:15] [24:47] [25:21] [25:54] [30:54] [31:34] [32:08] [32:39] [33:13] [33:46] [34:16] [34:51]

Representative Gonzalez moved to pass the bill, and it was adopted without recorded opposition, as indicated by the unanimous “aye” vote. [40:42]

Bills discussed (3)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1001 Act 222 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB 1001”
AN ACT FOR THE ARKANSAS HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES OF THE NINETY-FIRST GENERAL ASSEMBLY APPROPRIATION FOR … House Management Notification that HB1001 is now Act 222
HB1006 Act 131 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB 1006”
AN ACT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION - DIVISION OF RACING APPROPRIATION FOR … Joint Budget Committee Notification that HB1006 is now Act 131
HB1007 Act 216 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “The only item on our agenda this morning is House Bill 1007. Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized. Thank you, Mada…”
AN ACT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION - REVENUE SERVICES DIVISION APPROPRIATION FOR … Joint Budget Committee Notification that HB1007 is now Act 216

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026
Unknown speaker 0:00
. . . . . Thank you. . . . . . . . . . . . Members, I see a quorum, so we'll go ahead and get started. I'm going to turn it over to Representative Ferguson. The only item on our agenda this morning is House Bill 1007. Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair. committee this is a pretty simple bill it's got a lot of uh bad rumors out there and i'll go ahead and address those straight off the bat this bill absolutely does nothing to help to harm to affect cnh hog farm at all um what this bill does do is put the current process that aedq practices today when they review and take up a reg 5 permit and puts it in black and white ink there was one little loophole in their process that wasn't clear if you'll follow me to section 2a this bill makes that very clear on location issues they would still have a comment period where they collect public comment those public commenters will still have a appeal process for 30 days after a decision is being made and they'll no longer be able to bring up those issues once those issues are settled which is the current practice adq has today and i have with me today mr michael group a from adq to answer any questions so i'll open it up for questions other quay representative hammer recognized thank you madam chair because it specifically states on line 31 that is in good standing i'd like to hear from michael and because it was brought up about the hog farm are they in good standing as of this moment they do not have a reg 5 permit so to be in good standings with a reg 5 permit they would have to hold a reg 5 permit and so go ahead okay yeah i just i want to tell the committee i you know we we don't want to let this degenerate into a discussion about the buffalo river and the hog farm because this bill doesn't have anything to do with that it's it's about other existing permits so I mean I think that's a bigger discussion but if you have questions on the bill that's fine but let's not degenerate into other areas representative love you're recognized . . Thank you. . uh representative ladyman you're recognized thank you madam chair mr i'll try to put this in a question but i'm really trying to understand why we're doing this i think i know but i want to clarify it um so when someone applies for a permit whether it be this particular instance or any permit that you all approve uh there's a set process there's 180 days then they have to supply the permit it's reviewed goes through the 90-day process a review or a 30-day review and through that extensive process there are people who invest in this business and once that process is complete all involved parties think this is a good operating business the finances are safe and this will go on for years and they'll get a return on their investment There are organizations in this state and outside of this state that look at businesses similar to these where they may have environmental issues that arise, and then they would come in and make a complaint, and that might reopen issues, which would put financial organizations at risk. So what this does is protect those investments. You've gone through that extensive process. everything looks good and we don't want someone coming in and upsetting that and causing a financial institution and a business to go under lose all their investment lose their employees and so forth is that a correct assessment or not that is a perfect assessment and you're not taking away any public comment period you're not changing any of those periods on the front end but you're saying after that has taken place which is the way the practice is today that you're not changing any of the practices today that AEDQ follows for a Reg 5 permit. You're just putting them in black and white ink. So you're saying once that process takes place, you're not going to come back at a later date and bring up a new reason. You can only address issues that you brought up in the comment period, just word for word in the bill the way it's worded. And you can't sit there and dream up new things to keep coming after a permit once it's issued. And that's going to settle the minds of the financiers in the state that finance these operations. representative hammer you're recognized thank you michael can you just tell me are there any and reading offline 3031 an existing state permit for liquid animal waste management system that is in good standing are there any now that are not in good standing that this would have a negative effect on i don't believe there's any liquid waste issues in this bill all right thank you uh saying no further questions oh i'm sorry representative love thank you so let me get this correct if there's if there's um a business in which they there's issues raised in a public comment period and you have i guess just say two or three issues raised are you saying after that period that a third party can no longer come and challenge that permit is that is that what we're saying um because you said that it's deemed i mean i'm just reading through the bill if it was deemed in good standing it is not subject to review or third party appeal for a sitting or a sitting or location issue so is that what we're trying to do is we're are we trying to take away that that appeal process? No, sir. Okay. No, sir, but Representative Love, if you were in a public meeting and you brought up a concern about the foundation that the forum was going to be built on, and we had all the technical data, geotechnical surveys, drillings, et cetera, that proved beyond a shadow of a doubt that your concerns were addressed and that there was no issue, then that would be a closed case because the formation is not going to change underneath your farm ten years from now somebody else can't come along and do the same challenge that you have done because it's already been proven that's what we're saying that way because if there are people against where your farm is located it doesn't matter whether it's true or not they can continuously uh bombard you with suit after suit and address and make you address over and over again the same issue okay all right thank you uh representative ladyman you're recognized thank you madam chair uh just as clarification we're talking about things in the permitting process here and i think there may be some concern that if something goes wrong in during the operation of these businesses, and there's violations or there's some type of contamination to the environment, that that may not be covered. But the inspection, they have a permit, they have limitations that they have to meet, and if they find that they are in violation, or if it is found that they are in violation of these permit requirements, that they still can be addressed through the normal inspection process that you all use. Oh, yes, sir. This does not affect that process. Representative, yes, sir. What this does is it doesn't affect our authority at all. We go through the public comment period. If everything meets the strict requirements of the Reg 5 siting area and they're given a permit, we provide continual inspections on a scheduled basis to ensure that they're operating correctly. And if we find that they're in violation, then we work out a consent order agreement for them to get back into compliance. And if they don't get into compliance at some point, then we go to court and we close them down until they get back into compliance. Are there any further questions from the committee? I did want a clarification. The C&H hog farm on the Buffalo does not have a Reg 5 permit. Is that correct? That is correct. Okay. So before we go to the public comment period, I want to make it clear, if you're speaking for or against, that you make sure that your comments are applicable to this bill and not to the greater issue of the C&H hog farm. If y'all will hang around to respond, that might be helpful. I just have clarification because I hear you continuously refer back to C&H Hog Farm and a Reg 5 permit. So I'm going to ask for clarification from ADEQ. Mr. Grape, can you come back to the end of the table? I just want clarification now. C&H Hog Farm has a Reg 6 permit. C&H Hog Farm has a Reg 6 permit, correct, at this time? They did have a Reg 6 permit. They're operating currently under the Reg 6 elapsed permit until we get through with the assessment and the hearings. Okay, so they're applying for a Reg 5 permit, though? That's correct, and they were denied that permit. So for the record then, Madam Chair, then if someone is going to come to talk about C&H Hog Farm and they're applying for a Reg 5 permit, then they should be permitted, I would believe, because now C&H Hawk Farm is going to a Reg 5 permit or applying for a Reg 5 permit. Is that not correct? No, sir, Representative Love. It's a good point. However, this bill addresses current. You have to have a Reg 5 permit in good standing in order for this bill to be effective for you. The C&H Hall Forum does not have a current Reg 5 permit. Are they applying for one? It doesn't matter if they're applying for one. No, wait a minute. Hold on, hold on. Don't tell me what does and what doesn't matter. I ask you, are they applying for one? Yes, sir, they are. Okay, so therefore that it is relevant to the conversation because they're applying for a Reg 5 permit. That is relevant. They have been denied a Reg 5 permit. Okay. All right, thank you. I think he's saying these this only applies to people who currently have one correct Not not going forward. It's just retroactive to people who currently have one It's retroactive to people but moving forward if they got a reg file permit would not these This bill would apply to them correct Yes, it would okay. Sorry Thank you, Representative Ferguson. Okay. Representative Wardlaw, did you want to further comment? Okay. Okay. The first person is Gordon Watkins that I wanted to speak against. Thank you, Madam Chair and members of the commission for hearing me out today. And I will try to abide by Madam Chair's instructions and refrain from addressing the 800-pound hog in the room and limit my comments to the bill, to the language in the bill. And I have concerns specifically about what Representative Love has just addressed, that being that there are two different regulatory programs for permitting liquid animal waste systems in the state of Arkansas. There are Regulation 6 permits for liquid animal waste. There are Regulation 5 permits for liquid animal waste. This language says only an existing state permit for liquid animal waste. It doesn't distinguish between Regulation 5 and Regulation 6 permits. Now, I understand that Regulation 6 permits are under the NPDES program as described by EPA, but the state is administering those permits. So it could be argued that those permits are state permits as well. And as has been mentioned, CNH is operating under a lapsed Regulation 6 permit. And so I think the general rule is that legislation only applies prospectively unless the legislature states that it applied retroactively. But there's an exception, and that is if the legislation concerns procedural matters. And there are precedents to support that, that if procedural matters are addressed, then it can be claimed that it replies retroactively. We're concerned that the whole operation that shall go unnamed could claim that this bill concerns the procedural aspects of how ADEQ is to process application for modifications to an existing state permit for liquid animal waste management system and does not affect the substantive vested rights of the permit applicant. Under that theory, the bill, if it becomes law, would apply to CNH's current situation. And if so, it would interfere with the appeal that's currently underway and could deny due process to my organization, the Buffalo River Watershed Alliance, which is an intervener in that appeal. And it could be deemed to be special interest legislation. Now, that concern could be addressed with two simple words. If this bill included the language that it was prospective only, in other words, that it was not retroactive to existing operations, or as an alternative that it applies only to existing Regulation 5 permits only, those two simple changes in this language would address our concerns about how this bill is currently written. So I'll leave it there, and I'm happy to answer any questions you might have. Are there any questions from the committee? Representative Leidyman, you're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair. Mr. Watkins, if this bill, you just made the statement, you would be okay if it was for future permit processes. If it is good for people applying new, why would it not be good for people that have already gone through the same process? Our concern is that if it could be applied retroactively and it could be applied under Regulation 6 permits, as I mentioned, this makes no distinction between Regulation 5 and Regulation 6 permits. If it could be argued that this could apply retroactively to Regulation 6 permits, then it could be claimed that the appeal currently underway was moot. and that would deny the due process of us following through with that appeal and would essentially revoke the denial that ADEQ has chosen to give to that permit appeal. So we're concerned that it could be argued that it applied to Regulation 6 as well as Regulation 5 permits because it does not distinguish between the two. It simply says state permits. any further questions committee representative gonzalez thank you madam chair is it not true the reg 6 is a federal permit the state does not have any say in and how those things are issued i mean that's why it didn't have a a public comment period through the reg 6 so therefore that is not a state permit would not be applicable applicable under this law that's an arguable point Certainly, and I've heard that stated that emphatically that this only applies to Regulation 5 permits, and I appreciate that, but I would also appreciate if that was made clear in the language of the bill. Now, the distinction between a federal permit and a state-administered federal permit, that's an issue that I think is maybe up to the courts to determine whether that's a federal permit or a state permit. it's it's a hybrid actually it's it's a federal program that's administered by the state well i i don't i kind of disagree with you i think the adq handles many things that are federal permits that aren't state regulated but they they do go through adq that i don't think will qualify as a as a state-ran permit and if so i think we ought to look at changing some of those Thank you. Representative Leidyman? Isn't it true that a process where the state applies to administer a federal program such as the NPDES program, they go through a process where they have to submit to the federal program how they're going to implement that. That is basically controlled by the federal requirements, not a state, not this group or a state requirement. So they have to implement that program based on the guidelines that they submit to the federal EPA. If they do not follow those guidelines, there have been lawsuits submitted by Arkansas ADEQ and by the Dallas region EPA when those steps are not followed. So my point is, isn't this process completely controlled between the two agencies? I think you're mixing apples and oranges. Is that not true? It's controlled through the federal agencies, and they have to meet specific requirements that they put in the application to be able to administer those programs? My understanding, sir, is that they may meet or exceed the federal requirements. The fact that they're allowed to exceed those federal requirements does give the state some latitude, therefore some control over those. Now, I don't know in this case if the state actually did exceed those federal requirements, but in my mind that does give the state some latitude and some control over how those permits are written and implemented. A follow-up, please. Yes, go ahead. But when they talk about exceed, it normally means that the permitting process is more restrictive, not less restrictive. Is that not true? Yes, sir. Seeing no further questions. Oh, I'm sorry, Representative Boyd, you're recognized. Can you even apply for Reg 6 anymore? That's a good question. It's in the regulations. The Regulation 6 CAFO section remains in the regulations now, but there's been an administrative decision not to accept applications under that. and instead defer those applications to Rec. 5. But that language describing the Regulation 6 liquid animal waste permitting program under NPDES remains in Regulation 6. Okay. No more questions, committee? Okay. Thank you, Mr. Watkins. Thank you. To speak for, we have Jerry Masterson. if you would recognize yourself and tell us who you're with I'm Jerry Masters I'm the executive president for the Arkansas Pork Producers Association I think there's a little confusion here about the Reg 6 and the Reg 5 Reg 6 is a federal permit that was overseen by ADQ And I'm going to have to mention CNH, so please let me do this. When CNH had a Reg 6 permit, it has a five-year expiration date. When their expiration was up, they submitted the Reg 6 permit and the Reg 5 permit at the same time to ADQ. ADQ returned the Reg 6 permit to them, telling them they were no longer going to do Reg 6 permits in Arkansas. That was the only Reg 6 permit that was issued in the state of Arkansas, even though ADQ did try to get several different operations, poultry and swine, to get Reg 6 permits. But CNH was the only one that did that, and now that is no longer a permit that's issued in the state of Arkansas. So the only permit that you have to worry about on liquid animal waste systems in Arkansas is Reg 5, which is addressed in this bill. We do support this bill, even though I will tell you we wish it went a little farther in protection. The reason that it does protect our existing producers is because when ADQ reviewed the Reg. 5 permit of CNHs, in my opinion, they went over and above any other recommendations that have ever been put on any other applicant for Reg. 5. so the reason for this protection is because the other reg 5 permits did not have to go through the scrutiny that cnh had to to get their reg 5 permit even though these operations have been in operation for many many years we want to make sure they are protected so that no one can come back in on them later on and say that they didn't comply with their permit conditions that ADEQ gave them. Representative Hammer, you're recognized. Mr. Masters, being that you're involved with the population that's going to be impacted by this bill it is specifically stated on line 31 the reference to those that are in good standing to your knowledge from your industry's perspective is everybody in good standing or is this either going to adversely or positively affect anybody at all in this moment of time to my knowledge we have no one that is not in compliance with the reg 5 permit and we monitor those farms our field managers do. We want them to be in good standing. We expect them to be in good standing and that's how we want our operations to operate. Follow up, Madam Chair? Yes, go ahead. And so for where we are in this moment of history being made, this should at least take care of any issues out there here and now and then anything else can be looked at when we get into January of 19 based on how you said you wished it would have went a little further. Is that a fair assessment? That's a very good assessment. Thank you. Thank you. Representative Love, you're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair. I think ADQ may need to come back to the table, but I am going to address this question to the gentleman at the end. What is the difference between a Reg 6 and a Reg 5 permit? I will tell you right now, I'm not very technical in nature. A Reg 6 permit was issued by the federal government for that where you could get a liquid animal waste permit. The Reg 5 permit has been in here since 1992. We developed Reg 5, and that has been our state regulation for liquid animal waste systems. There are some differences in applications, in public notices, things like that. there are some differences. Basically, they do the same thing in protection of the waters of the state and the waters of the United States. Did I answer your question? I'm sensing a follow-up. Do you want Mr. Grape to come back to the table? Michael? Michael Grape, ADQ. Representative Love. Why did we stop doing Reg 6 permits? Originally, Reg 6 permits were the federal program, and it was very general, sort of like when you build a McDonald's, you build the same McDonald's in every place. Shortly after they started that program, they realized that you can't build these facilities anywhere. So they abandoned that program. Is a follow-up, Madam Chair? Go ahead. Is a Reg 6 permit more stringent than the Reg 5 permit? No, sir. The Reg. 6 permit this CNH was permitted under required no public comment, and the siting requirements were minimal compared to the more stringent Reg. 5 permits that we enforce. Okay. All right. Thank you. Yes, sir. No further questions. Thank you. No further questions for Mr. Masters from anyone. We also have someone else to speak against, David Peterson from the Ozark Society. You're recognized. Please introduce yourself. As you can tell, I'm a novice. So it's a privilege here to speak before this committee. And the Ozark Society is an intervener in the ongoing case with litigation for Reg 6 permit and application at Reg 5. And I've been really well informed today as to what the committee really thinks and other people say. This bill has had many forms, and I'm sort of reacting to what spontaneously showed up here. And our position is that we want the hog farms clearly a focus despite everything else. We want the current appeal process that's going to be heard before the Arkansas Pollution and Control and Ecology Committee to proceed. Anything that would intervene in that, we would think would be detrimental to the legal proceedings, that's all. And I've heard lots of comment today that reassure us that the bill that's before us only applies to current Reg 5 holders, and I don't think we have any trouble with that at all. It's just that we'd like to hear that strength and that's all so that we know that the legal proceedings will go through and carry out to its finality. Any questions from the committee? If not, thank you. Representative Warlaw, you want to close for your bill? Thank you, committee, and thank you, Madam Chairman. I will tell you guys, I always want to sit down here and have controversial bills. this is fun I will tell you what the gentleman just said is very true this will not intervene in any way in the current appeal process this will not change in any way the public comment or the appeal process is currently being practiced at AEDQ this only puts the current process in black and white on paper to make it clear we were asked by the financial institutions to make this very clear so that they would feel comfortable in loaning these people millions of dollars to make these investments in our state we have groups of people looking to move to our state at the moment to farm more animals and would that would hold reg 5 permits and with that going on we needed to make this process very clear that is all this bill does doesn't help CNH doesn't hurt CNH doesn't affect CNH because they do not hold a Reg 5 permit the one guy said that he wasn't clear that we were either addressing a Reg 5 and Reg 6 Representative Gonzalez hit the nail on the head we cannot legislate here federal legislation a Reg 6 is a federal permit we can only legislate for our permits which is a Reg 5 is a complete state permit so with that I'd appreciate a good vote and I'd make a motion do pass okay I have a motion do pass is there any discussion on the motion all in favor say aye all opposed your bill is passed representative for law there's no further business we're adjourned . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . You
▶ Play

Agenda

Call to Meeting

0:36 - 1:08 1 segment

HB 1001

1:08 - 4:11 6 segments

HB 1006

4:11 - 49:23 84 segments

Representative Wardlaw introduced House Bill 1007, explaining that it simply codifies the existing ADEQ Reg 5 permit review process by preserving the public comment and 30-day appeal periods while preventing new challenges after a permit is issued, and asserted that it does not affect the C&H hog farm issue. [9:00] [9:33] [10:05]

Committee members and stakeholders-including Rep. Ladyman, Rep. Love, and ADEQ’s Michael Group A-questioned whether the bill applied to Reg 6 permits, to C&H’s pending Reg 5 application, and whether it would retroactively limit appeals, receiving clarification that the legislation only affects permits already in good standing under Reg 5 and does not alter ADEQ’s enforcement authority. [13:46] [14:21] [14:51] [15:27] [15:58] [16:36] [17:12] [17:43] [18:19] [18:52] [19:22] [19:53] [20:24] [20:57] [21:30] [22:01] [22:33]

Testimony from Gordon Watkins of the Buffalo River Watershed Alliance warned that the lack of distinction between Reg 5 and Reg 6 could make the bill retroactive and jeopardize due-process rights, urging language to limit it to prospective Reg 5 permits, while the Arkansas Pork Producers Association’s Jerry Masters supported the bill as protecting existing producers. [23:05] [23:39] [24:15] [24:47] [25:21] [25:54] [30:54] [31:34] [32:08] [32:39] [33:13] [33:46] [34:16] [34:51]

Representative Gonzalez moved to pass the bill, and it was adopted without recorded opposition, as indicated by the unanimous “aye” vote. [40:42]

Back from Recess

49:23 - 1:08:28 38 segments

Motion to Expunge Vote

1:08:28 - 1:09:01

Adjourned

1:09:01 - 1:09:33 2 segments

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers