Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Judiciary Committee

March 14, 2018 ·Committee Room 130 ·8:20
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026

SB4 Sample CONCERNING THE POSSESSION OF AN OPEN CONTAINER OF ALCOHOL IN A B. MOTOR VEHICLE; AND TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS NECESSARY TO AVOID FUTURE FEDERAL… 0:01

Representative Dwight Tosh asked whether Arkansas already had an open-container law and if the proposed SB4 simply brings state law into line with federal guidelines; the Chair confirmed the bill is “in complete compliance word for word” with federal law and does not expand the prior statute’s provisions, noting that the unattended-vehicle language from the 91st General Assembly is not included in the new bill. [0:40] [1:10] [1:31] [1:44] [2:05]

A motion to pass the bill was made by Representative Matthew J. Shepherd, seconded and adopted unanimously by the committee. [2:37] [2:45] [2:49]

SB5 J. Hutchinson CONCERNING THE WAIVER OF A PERSON'S OR ENTITY'S RIGHT TO A JURY 3:22

Representative Bob Ballinger presented SB5, explaining that it restricts the waiver of a jury right to lending transactions and that future amendments may be needed for other sectors such as automobile or insurance contracts. [3:48] [4:45]

Representative Carol Dalby inquired whether the bill would also cover pawn-shop loans and warned of a potentially broader interpretation; Ballinger replied that while it could apply, pawn-shop cases are typically small and unlikely to generate many jury trials. [4:20] [4:45] [4:51] [5:14]

Representative Clarke Tucker asked if a contract serving multiple purposes that includes a loan-related jury-waiver would extend the waiver to non-loan provisions; Ballinger indicated the waiver would likely be confined to the borrowing/lending portion and that broader issues could be addressed later. [6:19] [6:25] [6:32] [6:39] [7:05]

Representative Matthew J. Shepherd moved to pass the bill, the motion was seconded, and the committee approved it without opposition. [7:32] [7:36]

Bills discussed (3)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1006 Act 131 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1006 Ballinger CONCERNING THE WAIVER OF A PERSON'S OR ENTITY'S R…”
AN ACT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION - DIVISION OF RACING APPROPRIATION FOR … Joint Budget Committee Notification that HB1006 is now Act 131
SB4 Act 76 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…we're going to pass over house bill 1006 and we'll move to senate bill 4 representative pitch you're recognized and present senate b…”
AN ACT FOR THE AUDITOR OF STATE - CONTINUING EDUCATION OF LOCAL OFFICIALS APPROPRIATION FOR … Joint Budget Committee Notification that SB4 is now Act 76
SB5 Act 15 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB5 J. Hutchinson CONCERNING THE WAIVER OF A PERSON'S OR ENTITY…”
AN ACT FOR THE ARKANSAS BEEF COUNCIL APPROPRIATION FOR THE 2018-2019 FISCAL YEAR. Joint Budget Committee Notification that SB5 is now Act 15

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026
objection we're going to pass over house bill 1006 and we'll move to senate bill 4 representative pitch you're recognized and present senate bill 4 thank you
▶ Play
mr chairman committee same same bill you were the first ones to see it yesterday we didn't have any questions passed unanimously through the house floor it's senator samples bill same version so respectfully i'd ask if there's any questions. All right. Any questions? Are you? Motion. All right.
▶ Play
Representative Tosh. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Pidge, I apologize for not asking this question or these questions on the House floor this morning. You got, Yeah, I just wasn't fast enough, but I just want to make sure of a couple of things. I guess it's probably more for my information than anything else, but currently, do we not have a, we have a law already on the books here in Arkansas, an open container, is that correct? We do. Representative Wing passed that in the 91st General Assembly. Okay. Okay, the federal law that we are trying to align with, I just want to make sure the law that we, the law that we, that what you're presenting today, does it go beyond what the federal guidelines already are, or is it in complete compliance with that law? It is
▶ Play
in complete compliance word for word, so we didn't get contrary to them again.
▶ Play
Okay, and you correct me if I'm wrong, but there's one thing that I noticed in the current law that you're trying to introduce here, And it was my understanding that the language in that law said that if you observe if a vehicle or something is unattended and you observe an open container inside that vehicle, that that would fall under a violation of this particular law. Do you know if that's correct or not? I'm not familiar with that. That's not in
▶ Play
the changes we made to this law. That may have been in the 91st General Assembly, but this law did not deal with that.
▶ Play
Okay, I was just thinking that was getting pretty broad with the law, if that's the case. And I was just curious as to why we would have language in there that – If
▶ Play
that's in there, it was in there prior to this because this doesn't deal with that. Okay. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker 21 2:31
Chair. Any further questions? Representative Pitch, are you closed for your bill? I'm closed. All
▶ Play
right. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative, motion? Yes. I have a motion to do pass. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion
▶ Play
Speaker 2 2:49
passes. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. Next item is Senate
▶ Play
Bill 5. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized to present
▶ Play
the bill. Thank you Mr. Chair, thank you committee. One thing I know for sure is I know when I'm whipped. So we worked real hard yesterday, took a lot of your recommendations and you know one thing I've also learned is that you try to achieve as much as you possibly can achieve and that you can't do anything more than that. So essentially in this short time frame we don't really have the time to debate all the ins and outs and all those things. The immediate thing before us was an issue for the bankers. Several of you all said that you would support that legislation. So we went through, made the fixes, worked it through the Senate, and now we're back to you with the bill that you all said that you wanted. So essentially what this does is this narrows it down to just lending transactions. It doesn't go any further than that. I do believe that at some point we're going to have to try to fix it for, like, the automobiles, for the insurance companies, for everybody else. However, this is the immediate problem right in front of us. I'm happy to answer any questions that you have. Representative Dalby, you recognize for a question?
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Ballinger, thanks for redoing this after our concerns. I just want to make, this isn't just with banking and financial institutions. Could it, I'm just asking, would it also apply to like a pawn shop transaction because they're loaning money in regard to something that you may pawn And is it broader than just banking? Because I want to make sure I understand whether it's because it's
▶ Play
the borrowing. It's if you have a contract provision for borrowing or lending money. So I would see that it could apply. However, what we're talking about here is just waiving the trial by jury, not trial in general, and pawn shop transactions tend to be rather small transactions. So I wouldn't anticipate having very many jury trials based on a pawn shop transaction. So I really think that that's going to be a limited application,
▶ Play
if at all. Just one follow-up. But I just want to make sure. But it could be broad interpreted, and that may be something we need to work on
▶ Play
in the next session. Well, I would definitely be up to it all the time. So I've never passed a bill that I thought was above being tweaked and changed. So I would definitely entertain that. But my thinking, you know, obviously I came in here with the originally yesterday that I felt like two adults ought to be able to contract the way they want, right? So I would say that, you know, I don't think that it can be too broad as long as it doesn't put us back further than we were prior to the court decision. However, comma, I do understand that, you know, this system works a lot better if it's not all my ideas. So, you know, right now what I have before you is a bill that started off as something that did include some of my ideas that now includes a lot of your ideas, primarily, I think, mostly your ideas. But it is something that we need, and so hopefully this committee will agree and we'll get it passed out. Representative
▶ Play
Tucker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Ballinger, so if there's a contract that serves more than
▶ Play
Speaker 38 6:25
one purpose, and one of the purposes is to borrow or lend money and included a provision to waive a right to trial by jury. Would that waiver count for the other part of the contract as well or just for the part to borrow or lend
▶ Play
money? I think that probably a good attorney may be able to argue that it would not apply to other parts of the contract, that it only applied to the contract itself for the borrowing and lending of money. So if you have a contract that is some sort of Hybrid between the two I think that that that may be an example of something that needs to be addressed down the road Although like I said, you know, my hope would be that when we address it down the road We restore the freedom of contract, you know, that that's what would be my goal And so it wouldn't matter whether you're contracting for borrowing lending money, but other things However comment this time all we're talking about is borrowing and lending money So I would say it probably would only be the enforcement of the loan itself where you'd have the ability to waive the travel jury any further questions represent voucher are you closed for your
▶ Play
i am closed and i do move to pass all right we have a motion do pass is there any discussion all in favor say aye hope aye those opposed motion passes thank you mr chairman thank you committee All right, members, I believe that concludes our business for today. I don't at this point anticipate that there will be need for further meetings, but if the need arises, staff will let you know. I appreciate your good work during this session, and thank you very much. Without objection, we're adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

REGULAR AGENDA Subtitle Sponsor Number

HB1006 Ballinger CONCERNING THE WAIVER OF A PERSON'S OR ENTITY'S RIGHT TO A JURY TRIAL THAT IS CONDITIONED ON A CONTRACTUAL AGREEMENT OF THE PARTIES; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

SB4 Sample CONCERNING THE POSSESSION OF AN OPEN CONTAINER OF ALCOHOL IN A B. MOTOR VEHICLE; AND TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS NECESSARY TO AVOID FUTURE FEDERAL HIGHWAY SPENDING PENALTIES.

0:01 - 3:22 16 segments 6 speakers

Representative Dwight Tosh asked whether Arkansas already had an open-container law and if the proposed SB4 simply brings state law into line with federal guidelines; the Chair confirmed the bill is “in complete compliance word for word” with federal law and does not expand the prior statute’s provisions, noting that the unattended-vehicle language from the 91st General Assembly is not included in the new bill. [0:40] [1:10] [1:31] [1:44] [2:05]

A motion to pass the bill was made by Representative Matthew J. Shepherd, seconded and adopted unanimously by the committee. [2:37] [2:45] [2:49]

SB5 J. Hutchinson CONCERNING THE WAIVER OF A PERSON'S OR ENTITY'S RIGHT TO A JURY

3:22 - 8:16 16 segments 5 speakers

Representative Bob Ballinger presented SB5, explaining that it restricts the waiver of a jury right to lending transactions and that future amendments may be needed for other sectors such as automobile or insurance contracts. [3:48] [4:45]

Representative Carol Dalby inquired whether the bill would also cover pawn-shop loans and warned of a potentially broader interpretation; Ballinger replied that while it could apply, pawn-shop cases are typically small and unlikely to generate many jury trials. [4:20] [4:45] [4:51] [5:14]

Representative Clarke Tucker asked if a contract serving multiple purposes that includes a loan-related jury-waiver would extend the waiver to non-loan provisions; Ballinger indicated the waiver would likely be confined to the borrowing/lending portion and that broader issues could be addressed later. [6:19] [6:25] [6:32] [6:39] [7:05]

Representative Matthew J. Shepherd moved to pass the bill, the motion was seconded, and the committee approved it without opposition. [7:32] [7:36]

TRIAL THAT IS CONDITIONED ON A CONTRACTUAL AGREEMENT OF THE PARTIES; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair Unverified
7 segments
Chair Unverified
4 segments
Representative Dwight Tosh Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 21
1 segment
Speaker 2
1 segment
Representative Bob Ballinger Chair Unverified
9 segments
Representative Carol Dalby Unverified
3 segments
Representative Clarke Tucker Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 38
2 segments