Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

ALC-Review

August 20, 2019 ·1:30 PM ·Room A, MAC ·2:10:03
Video Transcript 7 documents

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 8, 2026

B. Department of Transformation and Shared Services, Office of State Procurement 10:08

The subcommittee was briefed that, under Act 419, any rule issued by the OSP director does not become effective until this subcommittee reviews it and the full Legislative Council subsequently approves it; the rule in question was deferred from a June hearing, the law took effect on July 24, and it was placed on today’s agenda for review. [10:16] [10:36] [11:10] [11:41] [12:13] [12:24] [12:30] [12:41] [12:47] [13:00]

Staff analyst Joy Leonard confirmed that the proposed rule R8 1911-230 does not directly conflict with Act 419, though it expands beyond the act in areas such as pre-award discussions, negotiation procedures, competitive-range criteria, and best-and-final-offer (BAFO) processes, and the rule’s text was presented by Ed Armstrong and Rep. Jeff Wardlaw. [14:38] [15:11] [15:28] [15:39] [15:47] [16:13] [16:21] [16:27] [16:37] [16:56] [16:58] [17:34] [18:07] [18:40] [19:14] [19:47] [20:30] [21:01] [21:35] [21:40] [22:02] [22:34] [23:07] [23:38] [24:09]

Committee members questioned whether the rule’s definition of a “competitive range” might exceed the statutory requirement that each “responsible and reasonably susceptible” offeror be considered; after the discussion the chair noted no objections and moved that the rule be considered reviewed and referred to the Rules and Regulations Subcommittee of the Legislative Council. [39:56] [40:08] [40:42] [40:52] [41:02] [41:05] [41:12] [50:15]

E. Services Contracts for Legislative Review 54:05

Speaker 121 presented the batch of contracts slated for legislative review, walking the committee through the construction-related agreements (Arkansas Tech, ASU-Jonesboro, SAU Tech, etc.) on pages 2-8, the intergovernmental contracts with the Health Department and UAMS on page 9, and the out-of-state contracts covering janitorial services, health-department surveys, DHS Medicaid pharmacy, military department programs, state-police services and UALR strategic planning on pages 11-14. [54:24] [54:56] [55:27] [55:58] [56:56] [57:01] [57:40] [58:09] [58:46] [59:19] [59:53]

Representative Charlene Fite raised constituent complaints that the DHS-Optum independent-assessment contract is producing poor, untimely assessments and denials, prompting DHS officials Mary Catherine Williams, Paula Stone and DeAnn Vaught to outline the contract’s history, acknowledge timeliness penalties of roughly $200,000, describe a corrective-action plan, explain volume-driven cost growth to an $86 million projected total, and detail process changes to improve phone-call outreach and caregiver interview procedures. [1:00:07] [1:00:26] [1:01:03] [1:01:05] [1:01:10] [1:01:26] [1:01:33] [1:01:44] [1:01:53] [1:02:01] [1:02:05] [1:02:14] [1:02:18] [1:02:41] [1:03:38] [1:03:45] [1:03:52] [1:04:25] [1:04:55] [1:05:31] [1:06:03] [1:06:35] [1:07:01] [1:07:05] [1:07:09] [1:07:41] [1:08:12] [1:08:43] [1:09:14] [1:09:45] [1:09:58] [1:10:19] [1:10:25] [1:10:28] [1:10:36] [1:10:44] [1:10:52] [1:10:57] [1:11:03] [1:11:27] [1:11:46] [1:11:52] [1:12:01] [1:12:04] [1:12:31] [1:13:05] [1:13:36] [1:14:06]

Senators Hammer, Stubblefield and Rice questioned the existence of contract violations, the rate of assessment denials and the agency’s exit strategy, while Senator Jim Hendren asked whether the independent-assessment program for behavioral health was actually improving service delivery and warned that the contract expires on August 30, leaving the state potentially without the program; staff indicated that a three-month extension is technically possible but no motion was adopted during that segment. [1:10:28] [1:10:36] [1:10:44] [1:10:52] [1:10:57] [1:11:03] [1:11:27] [1:15:21] [1:15:45] [1:16:18] [1:16:23] [1:16:50] [1:16:53] [1:17:09] [1:17:12] [1:17:19] [1:17:27] [1:17:58] [1:18:06] [1:18:15] [1:18:20] [1:18:34] [1:19:03] [1:25:35] [1:25:39] [1:26:14] [1:26:54] [1:27:25] [1:28:00] [1:28:23] [1:28:30] [1:28:32] [1:28:38] [1:28:53] [1:42:12] [1:42:48] [1:42:52] [1:42:56] [1:43:02] [1:43:05] [1:43:23] [1:43:26] [1:43:35] [1:43:42] [1:43:53] [1:44:16] [1:47:26] [1:47:37] [1:47:46] [1:47:52] [1:48:12] [1:48:15] [1:48:44] [1:49:14]

Ms. Paula Stone and Representative DeAnn Vaught explained that the assessments reduced unnecessary prior authorizations, targeted counseling to those who truly needed it, generated cost savings for Arkansas and enabled the state to pursue a 1915(i) waiver for supportive services, and Representative Matthew Shepherd together with Rep. Vaught outlined the contract’s performance indicators and penalties, noting that fines have already been imposed for timeliness failures and that quality-assurance metrics are being closely monitored. [1:44:25] [1:44:56] [1:45:07] [1:45:27] [1:45:58] [1:46:05] [1:46:30] [1:46:33] [1:46:46] [1:46:57] [1:47:52] [1:48:12] [1:48:15] [1:50:07] [1:50:38] [1:50:52] [1:50:57] [1:51:13] [1:51:47] [1:51:52] [1:52:06] [1:52:14]

Senator Hendren moved to extend the contract review through August 31 2020 with a requirement that DHS provide monthly reports and hard data before any decision on a new RFP; after an amendment aligning the timeline with a June 30 deadline, the motion was adopted unanimously with no opposition. [2:01:27] [2:01:33] [2:01:56] [2:02:32] [2:02:36] [2:02:40] [2:02:46] [2:02:56] [2:03:05] [2:04:32] [2:04:43]

F. Reports and Communications 2:08:35

Speaker 121 presented the June emergency transportation report, pointing out page 7’s professional consultant services contracts under $50,000, page 8’s technical and general services contracts under the same threshold, and page 11’s summary of an 800-page cooperative agreements spending report from OSP with a link to the full document. [2:08:38]

He indicated that the complete reports are available in the meeting attachments for members to review. [2:09:13]

Chair Representative Andy Davis asked for any questions, received none, and formally recorded that the reports were reviewed and the meeting was adjourned. [2:09:21]

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 8, 2026
Unknown speaker 0:00
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 4 6:30
If you'll find your seats, we're going to get started in just a minute.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 7:00
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 12 8:30
Thank you.
▶ Play
All right, let's try this again. John, if you'll find your seat, we're going to get started. All right. Guest, I'd like to make a quick announcement. We had a sign-up sheet out front. The sign-up sheet to speak to the committee, two people signed up. This is to speak on the OSP rule only. This is item B-1 on our agenda today. There will be no public comment on contracts today. So if you signed up, just know that's only for the OSP rule. All right, members, welcome. we'll go ahead and get started call this meeting to order senator flippo you have any comments all right we'll move on to item b1 procurement rule members mr jill thayer will explain to us what
▶ Play
Speaker 20 10:16
we're doing here thank you mr chair jill thayer bureau of legislative research and this is the first time that the subcommittee is going to be reviewing a rule of osp so the chair's asked that I'll just quickly explain to you your process for this. As some of you will remember, out of the procurement study last biennium, several acts were passed. One of them was Act 419, and that act states that a rule of the OSP director that is under the Arkansas Procurement Law is not effective until it receives review by this subcommittee and then the full legislative council and its administrative rules subcommittee. so the rule has to be heard by you first. You adopted rules in your May meeting that puts a process in place for this and that's what you're operating under today. This rule that you're going to hear was actually on the administrative rules subcommittee agenda in June. It was asked at that meeting that it be deferred to be heard until August and that then placed it with legislative council after the effective date of Act 419, which was July 24th. As such, it had to be put on this agenda before it can be heard by rules. It is on the rules subcommittee agenda for tomorrow. Under your rules, you state that public comment may be allowed on these rules. It is not required, so that's going to be up to your chairs. As Representative Davis said, a sign-up sheet has been put out, and so I believe they're going to allow that today. Public comment will be allowed at rules tomorrow. That's required by the law. And then your action today is just review. Only the rules subcommittee and the full legislative council have review and approval authority. Yours is simply either to review it or not to review it. And then whatever you determine will be immediately reported to the rules chairs for their meeting tomorrow. This is similar to what happens when a standing committee hears a rule such as public health. And so it's a recommendation to the rules subcommittee as to what action you feel should be taken but not approval so with that i'll take any questions miss
▶ Play
there if you would just clarify um because i think this is a little bit confusing the rule was before rules committee in june it was deferred to august and in july law went into effect it states that we must review any rule that affects the procurement
▶ Play
Speaker 20 12:47
Is that correct? Yes, sir. Any rules promulgated under the Arkansas Procurement Law and brought by the OSP director shall not be effective until they are reviewed by this subcommittee and then receive review and approval
▶ Play
by the full legislative council. Okay. But if you will, please clarify, what act is
▶ Play
Speaker 20 13:06
this rule the result of? This rule, I believe, is coming to you from a 2017 act, not one of the current acts. But it also does pertain to some of the BAFO requirements that were in, some of the procurement rules or procurement acts passed in 2019.
▶ Play
Okay. Thank you. Representative Orlau, is your question for Ms. Thayer or Mr. Armstrong? You recognized? Thank
▶ Play
you. and she just touched on my question being that this rule is from a 2017 act does it conflict in any way with the acts that we passed in 2019 or do you do does our staff know or have we looked at it
▶ Play
Speaker 20 13:48
legally we have done a review of that um we enjoyed leonard actually what is the staff person who conducted that room review would probably be better able to speak to it than i can mr chair with your joy will you join us please thank you
▶ Play
Speaker 39 14:31
Joy Leonard, Bureau of Legislative
▶ Play
Speaker 41 14:38
Research. So I did review the rule against Act 419, which was passed in 2019. And although it doesn't address everything related to negotiations and baffos that was in Act 419, there isn't anything in the rule that's being looked at today that I would say directly conflicts with Act 419. There are some parts of the rule that don't necessarily conflict with Act 419 but may go a little bit further than what 419 does on its face and that address some of the things that the review subcommittee discussed during the procurement study and that the legislature consider during the session in addressing these acts mr chair i just want to reserve the
▶ Play
fact asked question to procurement after they explain their rule on the grounds in which mr leonard just touched on we'll restart the queue and procurement joins us members anybody have a question for mr or
▶ Play
miss leonard all right saying none thank you you ladies. Mr. Armstrong, would you please come explain the rule. You gentlemen will introduce yourself to the committee for the record and then proceed, please. Mr.
▶ Play
Chair, thank you. Ed Armstrong, Office of State Procurement. David Withrow, Office of State Procurement. Mr. Withrow is General Counsel for the Office of State Procurement, and I'm acting as the State Procurement Director. And I brought Mr. Withrow up here because our general practice has been when rules were presented that counsel would go ahead and read the summary of the rule and then if there were questions beyond what was covered in the summary typically then I could answer them or he could answer them depending on the preference of the asker. Very
▶ Play
Speaker 52 16:56
good. Well good afternoon thank you for giving us some time today and this rule would be numbered if promulgated as R8 1911 1911-230, 1911-230 being the competitive sealed proposal statutes or the solicitation vehicle being the request for proposal or RFP. And as was touched upon a moment ago, during last year, 2018, during the procurement study that was conducted here, we were evaluating the laws, the rules and found that the rule was lacking and was not aligned with law and so that was the genesis of this proposed promulgation of the rule and being that it is fairly lengthy as director armstein just mentioned i will without objection read over a summary of what we're proposing rule 8 1911 230 subsection a is being added to clarify the discussions may be conducted with responsible offerors during a request for proposals in order to clarify a proposal or the terms of a request for proposal and for negotiations such pre-award discussions should be conducted in a manner that supports public confidence in public procurement and ensures fairness. Subsection B is being added to elaborate upon pre-award discussions conducted for clarifications, namely that clarifications can be sought in areas of ambiguity, miscommunication, misunderstanding, but that such clarifications should be documented in the procurement file. Subsection C is being added to elaborate upon pre-award discussions conducted for negotiations and provide guidance on how such negotiations should be conducted. For example, provisions for how negotiations might occur should be in the relevant request for proposals. There are no minimum or maximum number of rounds of negotiations other than what could be and should be set forth in a request for proposal. Negotiations may be conducted with a group of responsible offerors identified based on an identified competitive range or just a highest-ranking responsible offeror. During serial negotiation with the highest-ranked offeror, the procurement agency may only abandon negotiation with that highest-ranked offeror if it determines in writing and for identified cause that the offeror is not responsible or is otherwise not reasonably susceptible of being awarded a contract. Negotiation may be limited to cost only and shall be documented in the procurement file. Subsection D is being added to define the criteria for competitive range, namely that such criteria should be established on a rational basis. It may include price, cost of ownership, responses that provide the best value based on evaluation criteria, responses most likely to provide greater value after negotiations and evaluation scores. Subsection E is being added to provide guidance on how the state may establish a minimum score requirement for offerors to be in the competitive range, such minimum score not being unreasonably high. Subsection F is being added to provide guidance for how the state may elect to negotiate with a single offer or versus a multi-party negotiation. Elaborating on factors the state may use to reach a decision, such being the expected dollar value of the award and the length of contract, the complexity of the acquisition, and the variety and complexity of offered solutions, the resources available to conduct discussions versus the expected variable administrative costs of those discussions the impact on lead time for award versus the need for timely delivery the extent to which discussions with additional offerors would likely provide diminishing returns the disparity in pricing between the lowest price offeror and the other offerors the disparity in Pricing between the highest rated offeror and the other offerors. Subsection G is being added to establish the rules by which the state may conduct best and final offer, or BAPFO.
▶ Play
Can you just summarize this section, please? Yes, sir.
▶ Play
Actually, if you don't mind, David, I'll go ahead and summarize the remainder of the rule and its overall intent. we have in the past and for years in our statute we have a provision that references best and final offers as far as I can tell although it's been there since 1979 when I was a little bit shorter and a little less grayer we have never used it I wanted to make sure that we could take advantage of all of the flexibility that is there in the law so that we can make strategic decisions And if we had two offers that came in close, or three offers that came in close, I would like to be able to go out and ask those three on the short list to resubmit their best and final offers so that we can negotiate with more than one person at a time. The current negotiation rule only allows for negotiation with the top-rank vendor in a serial fashion, starting at the top, working your way down. If you can't negotiate a contract with the first one, you go to the next one. I thought that wastes a lot of time. And also, if you get back all the proposals and you look at all of them and you realize, whoops, we made a mistake somewhere in our requirements. Maybe our requirements aren't the best. When we read the proposals, we realize we could probably tinker and make a better one. Or if all the proposals come in high, we had no mechanism in the past, really, for effectively just saying, okay, we're going to amend and we want to hear proposals back, other than canceling the solicitation and redoing it. This gives us flexibility to have the people submit their proposals, and we can rank them. and the agency has to identify in advance in the RFP pursuant to this rule whether or not they're going to allow baffo negotiation it makes sense for example in a case where you're going to have a complex service to maybe dedicate time to talk to two or three vendors simultaneously it makes less sense if we're talking about a more simple transaction like janitorial services maybe under those circumstances and if you don't have a lot of time you just need to award it's not that complicated you don't make a really complicated process so this rule gives us that flexibility it identifies some of the words that have appeared in the statute for years for example reasonably susceptible being awarded a contract that's language that appears in the statute it's never been defined it's not defined in the statute this rule defines what that means and that's basically identifying the people on your short list but you have to identify them based on the criteria that's laid out in your RFP for purposes of transparency. Is that a
▶ Play
conclusion of your summary, Mr. Armstrong? That does, sir. Thank you, Chair. Representative
▶ Play
Wardlaw, you are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Armstrong, when we went through the procurement process for a year and a half or whatever it ended up being, we went through this short list. I mean, there was actually a bill drafted and passed and now is an act about BAFOs and how we wanted those offers and how we wanted the procurement office to communicate with those bidders. And in that, it did not, if my memory serves right, it didn't close that loop down to a certain top three or top five. It left it open to everybody that submitted a legal bid, and a legal bid being my terminology, not the correct terminology. So why would we want to shorten that down to two and throw out those other folks that bid if we don't have to? And if I read this correctly, you're shortening that down, and that's where it's kind of going above the law we just passed. Well, Representative Wardlaw, thank you very much for the question. let me allow to clarify that i believe your understanding is incorrect and if you go to the actual statute you can see one of the terms that has been there forever is that the definition in subsection a of 1911 230 it says what competitive sealed proposals are or rfps are and in subsection three it says discussion with responsible offerors whose proposals have been determined to be reasonably susceptible to being selected for a ward. That doesn't say discussions with all offerors. It says discussions with responsible offerors. Those two words together have a definition in the law. That's what I said by legal bid.
▶ Play
Speaker 63 26:10
It means that their bid is a proper bid for that particular RFP. That's one component, Representative. And
▶ Play
then the other part is... I wasn't wrong, so go ahead. Well, we're not done. There's a two-part analysis here. They have to be responsible. That means they've met the requirements and they have been determined. So there's a determination that's being made to be reasonably susceptible to being selected for award. What does that mean? Well, that's what this rule defines. Reasonably susceptible to being selected for award is a lot different than just making an offer that's legal. There's some reasoning that goes in, a determination is made as to who is qualified, who's on the short list. For example a really simple example if you have 10 vendors submit a proposal and three of them are far and away ahead of the pack they have high scores that are above the mid mark there's other scores that are legal they're responsible they meet the bare minimums but they're not in the same league there's a widespread in the points are we going to go through a bureaucratic process and say that we have to every time ask everybody to submit all the proposals because evaluation takes time mr. chair if uh if those top three have all been in litigation and other states we've we've sat through this all year then yes we should have went through and asked all 10 because then we've just disqualified the top three so i mean we we have sat here all all year two different instances if i can remember correctly where the top bidders got kicked out for either legal issues or other issues that were found out after the fact so yes, we should have had all those bidders up to date so that we could pick a fourth or fifth or whatever has to happen. Well, that is what we're trying to do is actually in the past that happened because it always went to the next person in line. We would like to say, oh, we've got two really close bidders or two good proposals, three good proposals. We want to focus on those three. They're reasonably susceptible of being awarded. These other people, their points are so far, they're so inferior after we spent maybe a month or two months having demonstrations and evaluations that we've already identified the top three in the past we didn't have that we identified one and that's why people if you were number two or number three you were highly incentivized to try to get number one disqualified because then you'd move up whereas if we had this rule we could go ahead and say oh well it looks like these are our top three contenders we can go ahead and ask all three of them to submit a best and final and we can have discussions with all three of them that's what we're trying to do we're trying to avoid the situation where it's an all-or-nothing a zero-sum game and you have to be the top person in order to have a discussion if you're in that competitive range we would like to be able to talk with everybody in the competitive range that makes sense I hope it works out the way you just
▶ Play
explained them. All right. Thank you, Representative Warwell. Representative Dotson, you're recognized. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Armstrong, if if what I'm hearing you say is correct, you're not limiting it to just three. It could be more. It could be anybody who is actually within that competitive range that meets the qualifications. So it could be five or ten even if if there's that many that are in that and then you're submitting it for a best and final offer to all of them before they know who what order they're ranked in
▶ Play
yes sir that's the flexibility we want is to be able to when we have some people who look like they've made an interesting offer it's within our budget it meets our requirements and they look like they have the level of quality that we might be interested we want to give
▶ Play
agencies that flexibility to do so is is there does it happen often or in your experience where we've had more than one or two or three that uh would would be within that range that we would send things out to
▶ Play
yes i mean we have had since i've been here in 2016 a couple of solicitations where it would have been nice to have had the option to have discussions with the top three vendors simultaneously and to get an offer a best and final offer from the top three or the top two follow up mr.
▶ Play
chair go ahead so i guess when you're making that best and final offer request that's purely a negotiation for the most part over pricing not so much over changing the scope of the work where it might allow someone who is lower ranked and outside of the scope of competitiveness to raise their score so to speak to be within that range well you have
▶ Play
to understand that there is sorry to introduce nuance and complexity but I want to make sure that I give you an accurate picture. There are some things we buy where the state should have a very clear picture of what it is buying. For example, a commodity. We're buying a computer. We're buying a fleet of vehicles. We should be able to identify with a lot of clarity what exactly it is that we want and we specify. And in those types of solicitations, we would likely do an invitation for bids, and then negotiation would be pretty much just price we're not going to go back and change the specifications on that type of a bid this is the rfp rule and in those situations sometimes we have something where we don't have an absolutely clear idea of what we need we have a general idea but we're not professionals with that same level of expertise in the area for example let's say developing some it software we know what we need it to do maybe the federal government has told DHS we need it to do ABCD and see appendix 200 and so we know what we need it to do but we don't know how to build that software or we do it maybe you know and so instead we can identify to the vendors we need this we need it to meet these criteria but you tell us in your proposal how you would do this how will you have something that meets these requirements by this date and so there is some flexibility and proposals that you don't have in IFBs and so sometimes there's going to be some proposals that they're going to have an innovative approach that maybe some of their vendors don't the other ones and so although they're delivering within the same scope of what we want done they might have a radically different notion about how they want to deliver the services and so I don't want to make it seem like it's price only they might be talking about other things beyond price if we're talking about something really complicated where innovation in service delivery might make the difference and
▶ Play
I hear what you're saying there my largest concern though is if if you go back out and you have something that's other than a best and final offer on price where you're you're really defining it down after you've got all of the criteria set for whatever the RFP was and you introduce a new component based off something you liked with this proposal and it wasn't in this proposal and you don't make that available to everyone who's bidding because you've kind of changed the scope of the original RFP if you will that's where my concern is with with this well yes if there is what
▶ Play
you just identified is if we make a change in what we want now that we've let's say we've gained some knowledge we've read these proposals and go oh that's interesting oh we hadn't thought of that maybe we made a mistake that's where we would clarify and if we need to make an amendment to the rfp that's one thing then everybody can get a chance to respond to an amended rfp so that would be available to all right that's available an amended rfp is available to everybody but what we're talking about is once we've received proposals we've already put out the RFP we received proposals and we want to start talking to people about one to get clarification to have discussions and to do negotiation which can be limited under this rule it can be limited to price discussion let's say you have the agency has defined with great clarity what they need and there's not a lot of room wiggle room for variation well then that's a case where price negotiation alone might be a appropriate. If it's an area where we have allowed a lot of room and latitude for the offerors to tell us how they're going to get our needs met, then we might be having discussions about things other than just price. But the parameters of the discussion and the negotiation have to be identified in the RFP. That's one thing this rule says, and that's consistent with the statute. It says, as provided in this law and under rule, and that's what we're keeping to, is that agencies are going to have to think it out ahead of time if they want to baffle they're going to have to identify what the parameters are they're going to have to identify how they're going to select and if a vendor reads it and doesn't think it's fair under our law they can protest that before they submit a proposal and say hey we don't think this is fair for x y and z reason and so there'll be an opportunity for them to bring it to our attention if they think that there's something that's unfair and we can think about it you know but that's not meaning that we're going to allow vendors to necessarily dominate what the agency is telling us that they need but we're going to at least give them an opportunity to you know to bring something to our attention and then once that's already in there so everybody knows the rules of the game before they start to play before they submit their proposal they can read and have an idea of how the negotiations will be conducted whether or not baffle will be permitted how the reasonably you know how the shortlist basically the reasonably susceptible people will be selected all that it has to be laid out and so they're gonna they're they're gonna be able to look at the RFP and have an idea then and be able to build their proposal based on that
▶ Play
thank you I think representative Dotson seat 56 I think it's representative Rye you recognized yes sir
▶ Play
thank you mr mr. chairman uh eddie in a situation where you in most cases you take the lowest bid because that's better for the taxpayers of our state but if you actually had a situation that came up that you were taking something other than the lowest bid would you bring it back in here and show us what's going on i'm sorry i'm not sure i well well you know The thing of it is, the people out here expect to know how their money is being spent and if it's spent right. In most cases, the lowest bid is what we have always went with. Now, if something happened and you had insight, knowing something that we may not know, would you not think that we might need to open that up and
▶ Play
Speaker 85 37:41
be transparent with how we're handling that?
▶ Play
Absolutely. Will all of our services contracts over the threshold get submitted here for review? so there will be that opportunity for review and discussion even the contracts that are merely reported can be elevated to the status of review so there's our transparency function but I do want to clarify too that there are two primary mechanisms they're not the only ones but the two primary procurement procedures and there is a big difference that's 1911-229 that is our IFB or competitive sealed bid statute and that's the one where we go with the lowest bidder of the lowest responsible bidder the lowest bid the rfp statute is different it allows for evaluation factors other than price and in fact the evaluation factors can be up to 70 percent of the total consideration of what we're looking at beyond price and so in those types of cases you know we don't always go with the lowest price it goes with the highest level of quality and again that's usually with professional services and I'll give you an example if you were to go get brain surgery tomorrow would you want the cheapest brain surgeon money could buy or the best when you have a complicated service like delivering you know some software that can determine who is entitled to benefits making sure that benefits are delivered keeping track of really important things. If there's a lot riding on this, sometimes quality matters more than just the lowest bid. And that's what an RFP is for. You got a follow-up,
▶ Play
Representative Rye? All right, make it quick,
▶ Play
please. Okay. Eddie, one more time. If that situation does occur, we're going to be able to see that situation in black and white within this committee is that not
▶ Play
right if there is a services contract at the threshold or higher it will get reported
▶ Play
here for review thank you and thank you mr chairman all right thank you represent right mr armstrong my concern with this rule is uh with this competitive range because that's not mentioned in the law it Seems as though, if I understand right, you've taken this reasonably susceptible of being awarded language and created this range out of that language in the bill, but in the same sentence in the act, it says that each responsible offer, which would be a legal bid, would be considered. if somebody falls just outside of your range and then they challenge and say i was a responsible offer and the law says each of them will be considered how do you defend that and i think represent war law wants to continue along that line is
▶ Play
that right all right i'm gonna let represent war law take over well no it actually if i'm if i'm reading correctly the provision
▶ Play
Speaker 94 41:02
that you're talking about is e2a
▶ Play
is that right as the statute is currently codified e2c i'm over here e2 section 9
▶ Play
e2c line 35 section 9 ci yes 19-11-230 yes so even in e2c in every instance it says for example in this one before issuing the notice of award of a contract the director or the agency procurement official may request a best and final offer from each responsible offeror that is reasonably susceptible of being awarded the contract. So it is each who is responsible and reasonably susceptible. You have to be both. The and is a conjunction and it makes both of those equally applicable. We're agreeing, but what we're saying or what I hear representative davis saying the same thing i'm saying it when it says each responsible that's everyone that met the criteria of the bid regardless of any criteria that you would set forth to kick them out whether they're ten thousand dollars off and a thousand dollar bid or a hundred thousand dollars off or or so forth they would still have to have notice or be involved in baffle because the law says each it doesn't leave room
▶ Play
Speaker 100 42:20
for you to set a parameter well it specifically says each responsible and reasonably
▶ Play
susceptible so you have to take those there's no there's no and between each responsible and reasonably each responsible that is reasonably susceptible there's no reasonably susceptible modifies the each responsible offer or so i mean that otherwise that that is reasonably susceptible of being awarded the contract has no meaning. And I'm not making this up, by the way. You can go and Google it or go to the National Association of Procurement Officials or Tennessee Procurement Law where this is pulled from. This is standard practice. Arkansas is just way behind the curve that this seems new to us. It's been the Model Procurement Code language since 1979. It is the way BAPHOs are generally done is that you identify your short list or your competitive range. And in some cases, it can be everybody. If you identify in your RFP, for example, everybody who gets a score over 500, there's 1,000 points available. Everybody who gets a score over 500 is reasonably susceptible of being awarded a contract. Well, let's say people submit their contracts and they're all legal and you get 10 offers, but only five of them score at 500 or higher. and then you've got some people who just barely made it you know maybe they get 20 points out of a thousand what we're saying is well if you've identified what is the reasonable basis and you've given people a chance to protest that because that's in our law when you put out your you know rfp if you've identified a reasonable basis for having a cutoff that we should only have to make the best and final offer to everybody who's hit the cutoff it's not to try to eliminate competition What we're trying to do is increase competition from where our current rule has it We want to increase competition, but we also want to be efficient and effective. We why Resubmit it To everybody even the people who scored so poorly that we know that they're not reasonably susceptible of being awarded a contract Mr. Chairman, I have one follow-up unrelated to the BAFO, but it's related to the rule
▶ Play
All right, let me make one point on that before you move on. I spoke with Ms. Leonard, and she says that it's within our authority and rulemaking to define something in a rule that is not defined in the act. Now, the way this rule is written, this is not a definition. So it may be doable. I mean, it's our call on whether or not we want to accept it. Representative Wardlaw, you recognize?
▶ Play
My follow-up question, and I had it earlier and lost my
▶ Play
train of thought when I was speaking untruths. They were accused of that. Just an error, not an untruth. What about, I
▶ Play
was told two months ago when this rule came to council the first time, and we asked for it to go through after July 24th because when the new laws took effect, it just had to do with e-procurement. Can you tell me what part of this had to do with e-procurement or any? this uh just has to do with proposals rfps e-procurement is going to be um different e-procurement is going to be the electronic processing of bids and proposals as well as just transactional purchases that but what i was told then was you needed this through because you were in negotiations with an e-procurement contract and i need to know what part of this okay so where that comes in is we currently right now have a solicitation for e-procurement that has been initiated the state has looked at it however we are in a position where right now under our current rule we would only be able to initiate negotiations with the top-ranked vendor if we were to proceed with the BAFO rule we would have the flexibility to talk to the top three ranked vendors for example or the top two ranked vendors or the top four ranked vendors and that is some flexibility we would like to have because that's exactly the type of a complex service that there's lots of things about it that the vendors know more about than we do with respect to how it's going to be delivered we know what we want and what our expectations are, but it would be most time effective if we could have that authority, not just for that one, but also generally speaking, any complex RFP, it would be good for the state to have the flexibility to look at the top vendors instead of just having to start from scratch. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Representative Wollong. Last question, Mr. Armstrong.
▶ Play
By my calculations, it took nearly 22 months for this rule to make it to BLR after the law went into effect. Can you explain to me why it takes 22 months to write this
▶ Play
rule? It does not. The rule actually came here in February, and it's languished since then. Okay, 19 months.
▶ Play
It's a 2017 act. I haven't read it. Well, I could. Oh, and
▶ Play
the model procurement law language goes back to 1979.
▶ Play
Okay, but this goes into effect, let's say July, August 17. Why are we just now seeing it in
▶ Play
2019? that's a really good question and so I came in in 19 I'm sorry 2016 we had negotiation on the books but we didn't have an effective rule and we didn't have a culture of doing it so I started pushing we have lots of things lots of opportunities for improvement throughout and we've been focusing on those now this one when it came to my attention was when we had a couple of these big RFPs and there were protests and I started realizing wow this is incredibly ineffective that we have these proposals and some of them look like I would like to or I think the agency should have the opportunity to talk to a couple of them but I had to look at our rules and I realized wow our rule says that you can only start with the top and so there was a process of time where I identified it and made a proposed change last year we had a big segment of rules that we submitted to make corrections and cleanups for rules that some of my predecessors had made that hadn't been properly promulgated so we had a lot do you remember how many david i mean excuse me i would say there's probably 30 to 35 rules separately that were so we had a lot to do we had 30 to 35 rules um that we were doing house cleaning on if you will and trying to set a firm foundation for improvement this was identified as a priority and we submitted it and we got the bull rolling rolling last year to get it changed and to get the osp rule changed so that we could better realize the intent of the statute and we went to the model procurement code i looked at at the notes i looked at some other states laws and saw how they were doing it and put something together and we wanted to be thoughtful because it's not something that has been done before in arkansas even though the law has the words best and final offer and has since about 1979 so we took a thoughtful approach and then of course there's the levels of review within dfna at the governor's office and then here okay i think i think i made my point i hope we get the rules for 2019 legislation a lot faster we do and we hope that we get a quicker turnaround as well I think
▶ Play
we will all right members any final questions on this rule saying none without objection this rule is considered reviewed members that just means that it will go back to the rules and regs subcommittee of ALC all right moving on next agenda item methods of finance item
▶ Play
Speaker 121 50:30
C1. Ms. Schmidt. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. In your packet, your agenda packet, item C, page one, that's the letter from DFA Office of Accounting. They have one method of finance that they sent over for review. On page two of that packet is a method of finance from Ozarka College for Ash Flat Technical Training Center to $775,000. They note that they have plant fund reserves, bank loan, and Ozarka College Foundation funding to cover that expense. That's the only method of finance
▶ Play
on today's agenda. Any questions? All right,
▶ Play
Speaker 121 51:14
saying none, this item is considered reviewed. The next item are discretionary grants. Item D1 is on page one of that packet. These are from the Arkansas Department of Health. They are both amendments to grants to provide implementation of the Arkansas Partnerships for Colorectal Screening Project, to collect and report project data, implement at least two evidence-based interventions, and to provide patient navigation and outreach for colorectal cancer. Again, that's from the Department of Health. On page two is a grant from Workforce Services. This is for $68,923. 923 it's federally funded for supervised living services it is for transitional living for women with disabilities which includes room and board assistance assisting them from transition from supervised living to independence after establishing stability which may include employment and then we also have from the Arkansas Department of Higher Ed we have the AmeriCorps grant programs the discretionary grants. These were moved from DHS to higher ed. This is over two million dollars in funding for AmeriCorps programs. These grants are for service opportunities. The programs include such things as Arkansas Reads, which is tutoring adults and developing literacy skills. Two academic learning programs for boys and girls clubs, programs to address food insecurity and nutritional education, Central Arkansas Boys and Girls Club program to improve academic engagement and interest in school. There is one for Camp Alliance to help military youth by preparing for and leading camp activity workshops for youth, tutoring and mentoring services, Girl Scout leadership experience, job placement services, nutritional and agricultural education in school and community gardens to address food insecurity, increase economic stability of low-income individuals and families through local support and online resource directory, and providing free tax services, planning grants for working with Arkansas's 25 and over who do not have a diploma or GED, teaching literacy skills for preschool children using the Jump Start for Young Children curriculum, tutoring and mentoring programs, food recovery and gardening programs, literacy and math tutoring, Smart Start Literacy and Math Tutoring, and Future Teacher Initiative for Tutoring Target at-Risk Preschool Students. Those are all the discretionary grants on today's agenda.
▶ Play
All right, any questions, members? Okay, seeing none, this item will
▶ Play
Speaker 120 53:57
be considered reviewed. Section E,
▶ Play
Speaker 121 53:59
these are our services contracts. On page one of that packet is the letter from Office of State Procurement, part of the Department of Transformation and Shared Services. They are now sending over services contracts that are over $50,000 a year, and this letter addresses the fact that the contracts that appear on today's agenda are considered to be legal contracts. On page two of this section are the construction-related contracts. The first one is Arkansas Tech. This is an original contract for a little over $3.8 million for New Student Recreation and Union Center. Next, we have ASU Jonesboro. This is for continuation of their centennial expansion project. This is funded with their Red Rule Wolves Club donations. Then ASU Jonesboro on page three of this packet for on-call engineering services. Career Education Rehab Services has two on-call contracts there. On page four of packet E, you have ADEQ. Then they have three contracts for design professional services related to suspected or confirmed releases from underground storage tanks and certain above-ground petroleum storage tanks, emergency containment, hazard mitigation. And, again, that's three contracts. They're like on-call contracts for them. Number nine is SAU Tech. They have a contract for construction of a dorm. That's for the Arkansas Fire Training Academy. On page 5 of this section, we begin contracts for Southern Arkansas University. They have contracts number 10 through 20 are all their own call contracts. On page 7 of this packet, State Police has a contract there for architect services for Troop L headquarters. This is in Lowell, Arkansas. And then the next contract, number 22, at the bottom of that page is the architect and engineering contract for the construction of the other four sites that are all being done for the state police. On page 8 is UA Fayetteville. This is an on-call architect contract, and that is all of the construction-related contracts
▶ Play
on today's agenda. Representative Fayette, is that
▶ Play
you? yes thank you mr. chair my question is item number seven under the out of state contracts is that where we are not
▶ Play
yet not yet thank you all right so we're still on item d is that correct yes sir all right e1 we're on item e1 construction related contracts any questions there members seeing none this item is considered reviewed moving on item
▶ Play
Speaker 121 56:56
e2 intergovernmental contracts these are begin on the packet marked item e page nine these are intergovernmental contracts these are contracts between that are procured using the intergovernmental procurement method the first one is the health department with uams for diabetes management and prevention program number two health department again with uams for chronic disease prevention and control continuing education and number three health department still with uams for trauma image repository those are the intergovernmental contracts on today's agenda all right any
▶ Play
questions on those saying none this item is considered reviewed item e3 out of state contracts these
▶ Play
Speaker 121 57:40
begin on page 11 of the e packet the first one is ASUBB. This is for their janitorial services, and this is adding additional money to that part of the contract for providing the janitorial services at their Searcy campus. Number two is Crime Information Center. This is Justice Exchange. Number three, DFO Racing. This is for veterinary drug testing services. Number four and number five are both for the health department the first one is behavioral risk factor surveillance system survey services and the second one is the cancer registry certification for tumor tumor register services number six is dhs it's on page 12 of this packet this is for the arkansas medicaid enterprise pharmacy system for the data quality improvement initiatives on page 13 is dhs with optum this is an amendment to the existing contract that they have for funding for performance and to replace their performance indicators for DHS independent assessment and transformation support. Number eight, DHS with youth law. This is for their compliance monitoring process to aid facility compliance with deinstitutionalization of status offenders. Number nine and number 10 are both for the military department. Number nine has to do with providing emergency management program coordinator services and number 10 is for their Arkansas National Guard anti-terrorism program coordinator. Number 11 at the bottom of page 14 of item D is for hosting licensing and technical support for the compass pension administration system. This is public employee retirement. Number 12 is South Arkansas Community College. This is for executive search firm for conducting a nationwide search for their college president. Number 13 and number 14 are both for state police. Number 13 is for transcription services. Number 14 is for a camera security system. That's for that troop L headquarters. Number 15 UALR. This is for strategic planning and those are the out-of-state contracts on today's agenda. All right, thank you, Ms. Schmidt. Now, Representative
▶ Play
Feight. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have
▶ Play
had more phone calls and emails and texts complaining about the Optum contract than I have any other item, I think, in my time in the legislature, and I just would like to get some information on how this is being corrected. All right, can we have some representatives
▶ Play
from DHS join us please this is item 7 this is item 7 in your packet e where we out here miss Schmidt item e page 13 yes you all will introduce yourselves for the record please we'll just go ahead and just go ahead and
▶ Play
introduce all three of you please sure mr. chairman kelly link legislative intergovernmental affairs if I could take just a moment to it like to introduce the lady at the far end of the table is Mary Catherine Williams as most of you know Sarah lineman unfortunately was headhunted by secretary key and has gone over to education but the great news is we should have seen that coming yeah you know we tried tried to head it off but Mary Catherine we're very very fortunate to be able to hire her with her experience she's three years of chief counsel with with our own state procurement office and so this will be her first meeting I want to give that introduction for her and and before before it may get contentious
▶ Play
Speaker 138 1:01:44
in here while we're still in a good
▶ Play
mood good afternoon my name is Paula Stone I'm the deputy director with Department of Human Services Division of Medical Services and Mary
▶ Play
Catherine Williams chief procurement officer can just turn your microphone on please I apologize I thought I had it on Mary
▶ Play
Catherine Williams chief procurement officer all right thank you miss williams all right please
▶ Play
proceed or representative fight would you like to start with a question yes please um specifically i have had constituents more specifically their families contact me and say that these assessments have been very poorly done that people who have spent down their money and gone into an assisted living facility are being told that they no longer qualify based on very poor criteria criteria for example they're calling their rooms two or three times if they don't answer then they are being sent a letter that says that they fail to respond and so they no longer qualify where we know these are people with impairments who have probably been told by their families don't answer the phone and talk to people that you don't know. We have had people that are not able to care for themselves their families know this and yet someone will come into their room and assess them and just ask them a series of questions and they will answer maybe trying to make themselves sound stronger and healthier and better than they are. Their family is not interviewed, their caretakers are not interviewed, and that's not right. If
▶ Play
Speaker 146 1:03:29
you'd like to respond, go ahead. Sure. Okay. We recognize there's problems. we recognize there's and
▶ Play
it'd be best maybe if I go through some of the timeline and explain when this contract and and the folks you're referring to right now represent if I it sounds like it's probably all in in more in the long-term care scope so there's really four buckets to this and and these folks on my left know so much more about this but I'll kind of go over briefly there's really four buckets to the optimum contract and who they do it independent assessments for whom they do it's this whole contract started in June 2017 and we first started doing independent assessments for the behavioral health world and then and then the DD developmentally disabled world both of those started off with problems DHS owns a portion of the problems because we have to give good direction to the company and go from there this is all of our first time into this world this is our first time in this world for independent assessment with behavioral health or DD and thanks to y'all for helping us move in this direction. It's a great thing when we get there. There's growing pains of getting there. We had problems with both of those worlds and Optum worked with us to correct those and we made the corrections. We then went into personal care world and y'all came with us in that. There was not as many problems there. Of course, it's also a very small population. The largest challenge has been in the long-term care scope if you will and and again part of that is DHS giving directions so that this all started January the long-term care assessments which is our choices and our living started January of this year of 19 and that's when your phone started ringing I'm sure is probably about eight months ago we at DHS had to develop a I think it's called a tool within MN choices so we have to put the information in there as to what how the assessments done what what questions they ask and how those questions factor into all this this was our first time also to do this if you will to load up the minute mn choices and get it off the ground we had some challenges in that because we didn't weigh some things as heavily as we could and came back on other things right now we feel like we have made a lot of changes both to that tool and Optum has made a lot of adjustments in what they're doing and we've also have asked we've also put Optum under corrective action plan as far as the amount of time it's taking assessments to be completed to be done the three phone calls and you're out thing we had to have some sort of a rule we had to give them some sort of a guideline is how to you know how much time and effort into making an appointment that is one of the biggest complaints I hear and and I'm not sure what adjustments we can really make to that or have made to it, but I agree that it's something, we need an adjustment there to contact these folks or have a better way of getting a hold of them, because so many people don't answer the phone if they don't recognize that number. I agree with that. I feel like most other parts of this have been either addressed in the corrective action plan or addressed in our own way that we're doing things as far as the putting information into the tool the criteria by which these these folks are measured for their assessment and I talked a lot more than I plan to but and see what Paula wants to add to this so
▶ Play
when you have a contract of this magnitude and it we've completed or Optimus completed over a hundred thousand assessments and and periodic reassessments of all of those populations that Kelly described and and as Kelly also described every time we stood up a new population and started assessing that new population, we experienced, we learned from things that happen. And so we have determined that it falls into several different buckets. So either there's a process issue going on, and the two things that you identified are process issues. Both of those are process issues. So they're either process issues, there are issues with the way we develop the tool and customize it for Arkansas, the way it's been customized, so that's called the logic model, or there are issues with actually with the assessors. So there's an issue with the assessors, either they were not trained properly, they're not going to be able to be trained, there are issues there. So the two issues that you described, both the not receiving the assessment due to not answering the phone, and the one where they've interviewed only the beneficiary who is not a good reporter of their issues, and that could be for a number of reasons, we are addressing. We addressed these two issues on the behavioral health side, and we stood up behavioral health by scheduling assessments using providers that were providing the service to help us schedule those assessments. So we can do that here. As far as the only interviewing the beneficiary, we also experienced that on both the behavioral health and the DD side, and we're using some of those lessons learned here. So obviously if it's an independent assessment, we were very concerned about the people who are providers providing the information for the independent assessment. But in this case, the providers are caregivers. So one of the ways we found to address that issue we did on the DD population, which is if the caregiver is an employee of a provider, but they don't have a financial stake in the company, we would allow that caregiver to provide that information to the assessor. Or we also did an activity on the behavioral health side where we developed a supplemental information form where additional information could be provided by a provider that would go with information that's provided directly by the beneficiary. So we will look at both of those things to help correct those problems, those process issues that you described.
▶ Play
Okay, now it's on. I'm not a member of this committee. If I were, I would recommend that this contract not be reviewed. I think there's just been way too many problems with it. We've talked about it. We talked about it in Aging Children and Youth for two hours. and I'm still getting phone calls about major problems with it all right thank
▶ Play
you representative fight members we have several of you in the queue go through you as quick as we can senator hammer you're recognized thank you mr. chair have you
▶ Play
assessed any penalties against opt-in to date for violations of the contracts or terms of the contract so we have asked
▶ Play
for corrective action plan and assess the penalty for timeliness. How much does that equate to? I don't have the exact total, Senator Hammer, but I know it was about $200,000 was the penalty we assessed for
▶ Play
timeliness issues. And in lieu of that, do you have a list of contract violations? Because somewhere, if these, and I've been involved in a lot of discussion, I know y'all have really worked hard as an agency, okay, but do you have a list of contract violations because somewhere the scale is going to tip to where this is not going to continue and add on to that, what's your exit strategy in the event this doesn't get corrected?
▶ Play
So as I stated, the issues were around timeliness and so one of the things that we did in this new contract has measured the timeliness in a different manner. We had the contract that we rolled out, and we rolled this contract out in 2017, so we've been at this for two years now. And again, it's been a massive project to have a face-to-face independent assessment for this many people, and particularly these types of populations that often have caregivers or may not be good reporters of their own needs. But with that, one of the things that we determined when we wrote the original contract, or actually when we wrote the original RFP, was that we were measuring timeliness of assessments from the time that Optum got the referral for the assessment to the time that the assessment was completed. What we found in all of that is there are many points in time during that timeline that there are, that if a beneficiary doesn't respond to a phone call, or if they do respond to a phone call, but they respond after the assessment is being held open, or the referral is being held open, that it really throws off the timeline. And so the timeline is being extended, not due to the fact that they didn't have an appointment and weren't able to schedule an appointment for an independent assessment, but because there was no response. So we've rewritten the contract deliverables, the PIs for that contract. So we can very clearly measure both Optum's performance in two places. One in being able to make the phone calls in a timely manner. So that's the three phone calls on three different days. And then a second place where Optum offers an appointment for the assessment once the person actually either answers the phone or calls them back. And then we're also measuring the points in time in between that to see if we have issues on our side that we need to correct for. And some of those issues that we would need to correct for would be if people aren't responding to phone calls, is there another way to do outreach to them? One of the things that we have done is done block reassessments and used those blocks as being able to offer assessments at a specific time, at a specific location, and then people come, so then you're not just dependent upon phone calls. That seems to have worked. So, we have another set of PIs to then be able to measure that. So I think that, I don't know that that completely answered your question, because I think the second part of your question was, if this contract is not reviewed, what is our backup plan? So our backup plan would have to be, we have written all of the independent assessment language into our eligibility language with CMS. So that is, for many of our programs, their ability for them to receive those services that are in that program. So what we would have to do would be to go back to CMS and remove that as an eligibility standard, which takes quite some time, to then have a successful standard in place by which we could determine eligibility either for the program or for Medicaid with another type of eligibility determination and then we would have to implement that so I think knowing that either that or we would have to go back out for a bid which would be starting with a new RFP for a contract for an
▶ Play
independent assessment entity. So we're kind of over a barrel because if you don't have a plan to go back out and you're talking about getting rid of the tool we're talking about getting rid of the contractor because if they've got two hundred thousand dollars worth of fines assessed against them and you're having to and you know and you're having to rewrite the deliverables on the timeline which we all have personal stories but I sat at one location for four hours because I wanted to see this the process firsthand they had a letter that said the assessor would be there and the assessor never showed up they had the actual letter so i i guess i think we need to get started at finding another contractor getting that rfp in place because otherwise it seems like we're held over a barrel and and we're the the the borrower is servant to the lender and so that's my two cents on that one
▶ Play
thank you all right thank you senator hammer senator teague you're up well double field thank
▶ Play
you mr chairman i'm sorry about that no i have a question uh first of all i made a couple of calls because i've received i've received a number of these calls myself from individual in fact i talked to kelly not long ago but never got a response back from dhs couldn't get anybody to call me back uh out of these hundred thousand denials uh i mean how these hundred thousand assessments how many of those what percentage of those were denials denied services. So Senator Stubblefield you probably have a missed call or two
▶ Play
on your phone from me as I did try to reach back out especially on that veteran. We looked at that a lot and I'll talk to you offline about that whenever we get that chance. I don't know that I have the number of the hundred thousand because that includes all assessments and do you have that Paula? I don't I don't know that I do. I did not
▶ Play
bring that with me but I know we compiled that information? So
▶ Play
what I did compile, Senator Stubblefield, so it's not direct answer to your question, but I think it's more to the point of most people's concern in here right now is more in the long-term care world, and that's where that's where the most issues seem to be that everyone wants to address. So during 2019 we had a total of 320 appeals from our Choices clients, 71 appeals from Living Choices, and 185 appeals from Personal Care. Of those appeals that have gone to hearing and received a decision corrective action has been ordered in seven our choices cases three living choices and seven personal cases that'd be 17 of the 320 appeals that have been the appeal has been withheld I guess would be the right term in other words that the appeal was
▶ Play
Speaker 174 1:17:58
considered is there is there financial incentive for for
▶ Play
this company to to deny some amount of services? No, sir. So the more they deny, they don't save
▶ Play
money? No, sir. They're paid to do the assessment. It doesn't matter the outcome of
▶ Play
the assessment. Well, I have one more statement that I've done, Mr. Chairman. The individual I'm talking about was a 97-year-old World War II veteran who lives by himself, never was married, was getting limited services from Curem, and he was told, not in a letter, not in a phone call, but by the assessor, that he would no longer receive any services. This is a 97-year-old World War II veteran who was living by himself, very independent, was getting limited services, and was denied. To me, that's unacceptable. And I agree with some of my constituents that this company, this contract, should be eliminated.
▶ Play
Senator Stubblefield, I certainly won't talk about an individual case at the table, but all of the story that you have may not be full or correct, and that's why I want to talk
▶ Play
to you offline, but we will do that. Okay.
▶ Play
I appreciate it. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Senator.
▶ Play
Representative Vought, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. um so i i totally understand that we could have growing pains and we could have problems but when we bid the rfp at 25 million we knew we had to build a tool as uh representative link said we knew we had to build that so did we dramatically underbid knowing that we were going to come back and ask for a tune of almost $60 million to help this company get their assessments all done. And not only that, we don't even know if they're truly doing a good job from everything we've heard here and from our constituents. So, Representative Vaught, I think what you said was $16.16, right? Well, the total says $86 million. It says $86 million. It was started off at $25,000, and it says total projected would be $86 million. I know right now we're talking about $16,000, but essentially we could be talking about $86. Okay, so let's talk about why additional money, where that additional money has come from. As I said, we pay per assessment. A number of reasons, a number of things occurred that caused there to be a lot more assessments than we projected there would be. We first thought there would be about 35,000 going to the PASS program. There's been about 45,000, so that certainly didn't make up all the difference. If you'll remember, at this time last year, we were held by the courts from doing assessments in the long-term care world. Those assessments should have been done, if you will, by us, by DHS, but they were all pushed past January. That was 2,000 long-term care assessments that then fell into this contract. We certainly couldn't see that coming to project that. There's been a number of reasons that there's been a lot more assessments. And then secondly, what we had in mind, so the tool for the long-term care was actually developed well after this RFP was out. Because the assessment started in the behavioral health world, as I mentioned earlier, in 2017. The long-term care assessment started in January of 2019. and as we've tweaked that as we should because there's a number of problems that we found the time to do that assessment has increased significantly what we thought would be I don't know the times we'll say one hour assessments become more like a two hour assessment and that's that's the main reasons for the additions of the money to this contract it's not that optimists coming back saying we can't do this for the money that we bid we're asking them to do number one more assessments than we first thought we projected and some of the assessments are taking a lot longer and i think i think paula probably has details
▶ Play
on exactly how that money breaks out so for optum they don't get paid unless they complete an assessment and so for the other populations for the behavioral health population and the dd population we did not ask for an increase in the amount per assessment. The only increase is because there are more assessments being completed than were anticipated back in 2016 when we wrote the RFP and that's just the volume. So they won't get that money unless they actually complete the assessment. I think also important to note is the only other place where we ask for any additional funds other than the funds that would be used to just pay for the assessments themselves would be again for that aging assessment which is an increase in cost to the aging assessment because at the time that we put the RFP out we did not know the extent to the the requirements for the number of hours it was going to take to do that aging assessment back to what Kelly says the only other place where we asked for any additional funds for this contract was because they send out a notice with the full results and of the independent assessment. We started out with just a notice that said your independent assessment is complete and here's your tier score. One of the things we determined to be able to provide that information to our beneficiaries is we wanted to send out the full results package, which ends up being about 50 pages. So they got some additional funding to be able to send out 50-page documents to all of the beneficiaries who received that independent assessment. So those are the only places we ask for additional funds. Follow-up, Mr. Chair? Thank you.
▶ Play
So this $86 million that's the total projected on here, on this sheet, is that where we're going to? Are we going to go from $25 million to $86 million, and are we going to go above
▶ Play
that? So this is the request for year three. I'm assuming, I'm looking at Mary Catherine, that that would be over a life of a contract. Yes. so that that's not it
▶ Play
Speaker 197 1:24:31
would be total projected cost over seven years my understanding is that
▶ Play
on a for like the next year this is actually lower than we've been in the past
▶ Play
is that correct so i think we've had two years where we were you know we had two years before we came back and asked for additional funds because it took some time to get all of those assessments done And so this is the first time where we've come back and asked for funds in year three to continue the contract as it stands and then add the small amount of additional funding for the increased volume as well as the increase in that per assessment cost for the aging assessment. Representative Vaught, are you
▶ Play
good? We got a lot more in the queue. All right, Senator Rice, you're recognized. thank
▶ Play
you mr. chair I appreciate mr. link starting this was saying that that some of the responsibilities with DHS and and some with the contractor but the problem is I think had there been more discussion as simple-minded as I am I i think some of these questions could have come up and we're dealing with a population here mostly elderly fragile that when you shake their world up their health can go down tremendously the ones that have contacted me and the ones that the family has contacted me that i know something about has been very concerning to me because i just don't feel like they should be put through this I don't want one side or the other to have an advantage as far as their providers being able to overbear one way or opt them to be able to view the other way. What I want is a fair evaluation, and they could go in and talk to the patient, but then allow somebody that knows something about that patient, their medical history, all the things that they've gone through, is part of their case. And what I've been told is that's not being allowed. And I've talked to, and I'd say most everybody in here, and Representative Fite mentioned it. This is from a generation of people that are proud, independent, that worked their lives to be self-sufficient. And when you ask them how are things, the first thing they're going to tell you is everything's great. My back hurts a little bit, but everything is great. That's their mindset. For us not to have built that in, this, and I don't think we did, because we've not allowed other things to happen, this is a faulty program to start with is it true that what was reported in the I believe either in the paper or something that I read it that a blind man was turned down for assistance had
▶ Play
Speaker 202 1:27:56
been getting it I didn't dream that I
▶ Play
don't think I don't I don't think you did dream that I think it and again don't want to talk too much about individual cases but I think there was a case of that I've not looked I've looked at that case a little bit Senator Rice and I've asked I've questioned that several times too and to my knowledge it's still open if you
▶ Play
will okay there is supposedly a 10-day assessment window is there not has that been changed now so
▶ Play
I think that's back to that that piece of information of that there are timelines for assessments and so those timelines really should be that once that person returns the phone call or asks for that assessment then they do have 10 days in which to schedule they should have an assessment time offered in those 10 days so that
▶ Play
is accurate does your agency have a a percentage that that's been met or what's not been met? Y'all
▶ Play
have that? So we did, as Senator Hammer described, we did send out a corrective action plan on timeliness, but we also are measuring that in a different way. I think we've learned that is that the measurement that we use from the time the assessment was referred to this time the assessment is complete is not the best way to measure that. So we have a different measurement in place. So we have gone back and looked at the timelines, the timeliness on those. And have a better way to measure and I do want to I'm sorry if I if I may go back to your statement about the medical pieces of this being added and so I just want to Describe the eligibility for for the aging program and for other programs as well, but it's a medical Eligibility a functional eligibility and a financial eligibility that has to be determined for that aging waiver program and so Optum does the functional piece of that and we have aging nurses that are doing the medical piece of that or I shouldn't say that things sound like nurses that are aging which we all are but those are nurses that are those are nurses that are employed by DHS so I think that is another one of the things that we have corrected in the implementation of this tool for the aging population is looking at making sure that we are reviewing all things we're not just reviewing or we're not just taking the results of a functional assessment they're also using the medical criteria I think an example of that is there was logic that was not put into the tool for dementia and that has been corrected so we've gone back in and put in additional logic so that if a person has dementia that it does impact the score and so you're not just measuring the functional piece of that but that's something that was just recently done after implementing the aging. But
▶ Play
these people that initially met the criteria, all the criteria, they wouldn't be
▶ Play
Speaker 212 1:31:08
in the program to start with,
▶ Play
correct? So the individuals if you're talking about the aging so at one point they did meet eligibility criteria in all three of those areas the functional area in the medical area may have been assessed differently
▶ Play
in the percentages that that I'm saying that are not from what I just in my head you were saying that they've been cut off and a certain portion has come back on a lot of them didn't get back on maybe some of them may be still in process but my point is if you don't have the right information and we're paying a company to get the information and it's not been up I don't think there's any way they can justify a lot of things and just the contact alone if you're some of the people I've talked to somebody ought to have enough sense no you're not they're not going to answer a phone and you ought to have an alternate number to call and set up a time. And again, it's been mentioned here before. People I've had that's been set up for an evaluation and nobody shows up, nobody calls. Whose fault's that? It's not theirs for not answering the phone because some of it's been a good contact. So I'm relying for what I've been told. So I've got deep concerns if we need to keep going down this road with this company there there's got to be a better way thank you mr. chair so
▶ Play
some if i can center us a little bit about on on the on the three calls thing one of the things that's helped with that is a number of providers have started helping um with the phone call if you will in other words that they they they can help set up that appointment at the time that that the um i guess the assessment is ordered that may be the wrong terminology but therefore they're right there with the the beneficiary and that's that's cut down a lot of that issue instead of just sending them home saying somebody will call you and i'm not saying it's a complete fix but it's stopped some of that or helped with some of that i
▶ Play
Speaker 214 1:33:25
just wish we would have thought of that before because it's a pretty simple thing to think
▶ Play
of thank you all right members i'll apologize to non-committee members we still have action to take so i'm going to go to committee members some questions from this point forward that means representative Richmond
▶ Play
you are recognized thank you mr. chair a few minutes ago you stated that the contractor doesn't get paid unless they complete an assessment so if there's three phone calls attempted and those phone nobody answers is that considered completion of assessment no okay the assessment is
▶ Play
not considered completed until it's actually completed and then the results are transmitted to DHS so they do not get paid unless they have transmitted the results of the independent assessment to DHS okay so
▶ Play
that because my concern is based on that they don't get paid that that the incentive that we're providing the contractor is more towards volume and timeliness and less towards accuracy of the evaluation that hey get this in here that's how we get paid and and I don't know if that is the case or not but I would be concerned about that just well based on on this criteria and based
▶ Play
on what you're hearing yesterday that I could see where you would get that but we do also have quality assurances in place and and there are quality measures which after it's part of the performance indicators has been talked about um and secondly there's just i mean there's x number of clients out there it's not just open world i mean there's only there's qualifications before an independent assessment can be ordered if you will so it's not just the entire population of arkansas or whatever that you can go assess
▶ Play
i realize that and i appreciate the fact that you guys are you know you're in the hot seat right now this is a tough deal but just like senator rice said what i have heard what i've spoken to these individuals i'm extremely concerned and i'm not very pleased with the performance of this particular contractor at this time because there's people out there that uh that are having their whole life disrupted and a lot of times they are fragile folks that this has a severe health impact on them as well
▶ Play
again thank you mr chair all right thank you representative representative
▶ Play
eubanks You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. What kind of assurances can you give the committee that these problems are being dealt with? And because of the length of the time that it takes to issue an RFP, at what point do you start moving in that direction hearing what you've heard today? And I was also wondering how timely are your reviews of the vendor? so that you know whether they're moving in the right direction? Are you staying on
▶ Play
top of it? So beginning with an implementing program, which we've been in implementation, and usually that's about the first six months with a new population, we are reviewing performance either weekly or a lot of times daily. So I know each of the divisions that have beneficiaries that are being independently assessed by Optum have a weekly phone call with Optum and a weekly meeting with Optum. We also get a monthly report and we are reviewing items as they come up if there are issues around appeals, around timeliness. We're looking at making sure that if a population, if we have a deadline, that those things are happening. So, we are constantly, particularly in implementation period, looking at our rollout of the program and then adjusting both internal processes and external processes with Optum regularly. A
▶ Play
follow-up, Mr. Chair? We've been hearing a lot about long-term care. What about behavioral health, are we, how is that working?
▶ Play
So we started the behavioral health independent assessment process in 2017. We actually started that in June, and our first behavioral health assessment occurred in August of 2017. So we've been at that with new beneficiaries to behavioral health that need home and community based services for a functional deficit. So we've been at that for almost two years now. So we are continuing to do assessments of new people that have been identified in the community, and then we've done reassessments. So we've started our, because the reassessments for that population are annual. So we have the similar challenges on being able to find people and make sure that they actually call in and make their appointment, but with the reassessment process, those individuals are all members of a pass and so the care coordinators are working on that because they're the ones that have the most contact with those beneficiaries so we've completed the most independent assessments on the behavioral health
▶ Play
side and reassessments representative vaught
▶ Play
thank you thank you mr chair um so i'm gonna see if i can get all this right we have a corrective action plan already in place dhs is reviewing denials and overturning them before appeals even happen so we're doing a double duty here and uh i mean i know dhs likes comes with this big doomsday the sky's fallen kind of scenario, but to Senator Hammer's point, why didn't we rebid this before this contract expired, or why didn't we come with a three-month extension until we could, because we know there's problems, and you can't say that you've not known there's problems because lots of people have gotten a hold of you and said there's problems, so why haven't we already gone toward that correctiveness of rebidding this out and getting somebody in there who knows what they're doing as I as I pointed out represent a lot some of the corrective need to be on our side too we needed to get the right tool in place for them to be using we had to get our act right once we did that's when the corrective action plan went out top them because we had to share in the responsibility of getting things right we feel like that DHS has a lot more right now and we're going to hold them responsibility for their timeliness with corrective action plan there will be more if if there are more issues but going back to kind of what paula said two years ago and and even up to just a little over a year ago we were having a great deal of problem with the behavior health assessments and and with our with our contractor we worked through those problems and got it to where they're you don't hear that now it's no longer a problem we can do the same with this population i know that's vulnerable i know it upsets lives and that's not anything that's taken lightly and i assure you when we when we talk about oversight it is daily as paula mentioned it's not like let's check in on them once a week or once a month this is a daily issue at dhs and we know the importance of it we we take the population seriously we take the problem seriously throwing out this contract right now the repercussions are much larger than just the population to which we're speaking it would it would disrupt the entire past system it would disrupt i mean the entire behavior health world which we have got kind of more stabilized than what we've seen in a number of years this would be a much bigger deal than just this portion of the population as i mentioned earlier there's four buckets and this is the bucket in which the problems are occurring and as i promise you we are on this daily trying to get these problems resolved Okay, so did the contract, is the contract expiring
▶ Play
on 8-30? We have an option to renew up to seven years. Yes, Representative, yes.
▶ Play
Okay, thank you. So could they do a three-month extension and come back and us do an RFP, Mr. Chair, where we start this bid process over. My biggest problem with this whole thing is that we're fixing to give more money to something that we already know is failing. It's already failing our citizens. It's already failing our constituents. So is it something that could be done, then come back with a three-month extension and us open up a bid process and try to get somebody in there who knows what they're
▶ Play
Speaker 240 1:42:48
doing? ma'am it's an extraordinary it's possible representative
▶ Play
it's my understanding from staff is that it's possible so i want to know
▶ Play
if i can make that a motion i'd ask you not to at this time okay at a proper time mr chair you want to respond to that well not to whether she can make a motion or not i certainly wouldn't speak to that no sir but uh three months question about extensions she uh three months would not be an amount of time in which we could get a bid out receive bids and go through the process that's more of an eight month
▶ Play
process okay let's wait if we get that motion later, then we'll have that discussion then. Senator Hendren, you are recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And Mr. Link, I know you'll remember we spent about two years reviewing health care reform, and particularly with regard to behavioral health, a key component of that was independent assessments. So all we hear about is the failure, the failures of the assessment system, but we don't hear anything about the successes. So I guess I'd ask you guys, are there successes in the sense that people were improperly assessed and receiving benefits that were not appropriate because that were determined and rectified because of the assessment process. And I'll speak to that from
▶ Play
the behavioral health perspective. So I know we worked on behavioral health. I was with the Division of Behavioral Health Services before I went over to the division of medical services and I'm also a long-term LCSW so I was a clinician and worked out in the field for many years and before I came to the state and so one of the things that we knew about the behavioral health population and the behavioral health system is that we had a 30 year old system in the RSPMI program and one of the things and because I worked out in the in the field and worked with behavioral health providers and for behavioral health providers for years before I came to the state I know that one of the things that happens is when somebody comes to the door of a behavioral health provider you would offer all of the services that you had to provide and that was not related to and sometimes was not related to what the person actually needed so that was one of the reasons that we launched the independent assessment for the behavioral health population to say that not everybody needed that. One of the things that we saw with the behavioral health population as we rolled out this assessment is we really looked at the data of the individuals who were receiving services and using the prior authorization process which is what the provider had to do is ask the person came in they would ask for a prior authorization from a vendor to make that determination if that person got that. So what we saw in that is that about before we started the independent assessment about 80,000 people came to the front door of a behavioral health provider in any given year. Of those most of them were had a prior authorization at any given time but as you looked at it over the year only about 30,000 people in any given month actually had that prior authorization which shows you there was a huge churn in the behavioral health population. So only 30,000. Of those when we started looking at actual claims data even though they had a prior authorization for services they were only receiving only about 17,000 at any given time if you just pulled it up on any day or actually had actually received a service that they had been prior authorized for. So one of the functions of the independent assessment was to say for people that are not coming for services and not showing up for services or just need counseling services, we were able to say then just give them counseling services and don't refer them for an independent assessment and only use the independent assessment for those individuals who really need the services are coming back over and over and we're showing a functional deficit. So it really was a tool that we used, one of the tools, it wasn't the only tool. It was that we used to transform the entire behavioral health system, making those services available to those, and it allowed us to then go to CMS and apply for a 1915 I, which provides more of those supportive services instead of the program that we were using. I know that was a really long answer, so I'm sorry. I apologize. It's really long. I'm not sure it's an answer.
▶ Play
So what I'm trying to get, though, is the reason for putting in the independent assessments was to make sure that appropriate services were given to the appropriate people and my question is is it is it working are we getting better delivery of the appropriate services to the right people as a whole than we were
▶ Play
before yes we are we and part of the independent assessment is is rather than just really one bucket in which we put most all behavioral health folks it opened it up to where we can assess them to the exact tier of services they've need and it has helped not only people get the right services but it's helped savings for the state of Arkansas which is again part of the the the purpose of trying to slow down the growth of Medicaid is to get the right people in the right care okay and again that's the
▶ Play
point I'm trying to make here is you know whether we need to fix it or rebid it at some point I'm understand you know open to that but the idea that we're going because as the healthcare reform task force reviewed the methods that we were used for dispensing services prior to this it was the fox guarding the hen house and it was it was no surprise that there was all kinds of abuse and the costs were getting out of control so it is also no surprise to me that there's some pushback from the independent assessment program that we're putting in place so I guess I kind of stepped out when you answered this question earlier but I think I got most of the answer about what would happen if we did not and I guess based on what the chairman said this contract expires the 30th of August so the testimony here is basically we would have no independent assessment program after that which as you said would put the past system and not just behavioral health but all the other systems into turmoil so I guess to me the question that's just not acceptable the question is are we going to fix it or are we going to begin the eight-month process or however long it does to to redo it we're
▶ Play
absolutely going to fix this we've fixed it when we had the trouble with behavioral health we fixed the small problems we had with developmental disabled and we will fix this population as well where it's getting daily attention from us we're making changes
▶ Play
it's getting better and we will fix it okay thank you
▶ Play
speaker shepherd you're recognized Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This is for DHS. With regard to this contract, it sounds like both from what I've heard from back home and then from various members, we've got a number of issues, many of which have been acknowledged today and at other times, and that there have been steps taken to try and correct and address issues as they are identified. my question is what under the contract what type of penalties exist for any kind of failure to perform or meet the expectations of the state or of DHS throughout the performance of the contract are there penalties in place have there been penalties levied and is there the possibility of strengthening those penalties to ensure that compliance, I know everybody wants to comply and wants to perform and meet expectations, but to maybe further incentivize the efforts to comply with the expectations that maybe we have and that DHS has? Yes, sir. Performance indicators
▶ Play
is to what you're referring of assuring that performance. As I've mentioned, and not to sit here and throw ourselves under a bus, we had to get our plan correct to them before we could hold them responsible for what's going on. And now that we, again, on the timeline, this is the first fine that we have levied, because that's not on us. That's no longer on us. There's other issues that we're fixing within DHS, and as we do that, we see the performance increase on the other end. But, yes, there's many performance indicators in place. There's quality assurance, and we're watching closely on this contract to be sure that Optum does the job they're required to do for all of us, for the state of Arkansas, so that we can keep these programs in place, have the right people getting the right care in all four buckets.
▶ Play
But in terms of not just the performance indicators, but in terms of
▶ Play
actual penalties. Yes, sir. The performance indicators are, and Mary Catherine can speak to this, but if not meeting performance indicators, there is teeth in the contracts to which we can levy. And have those teeth been utilized? They have for timeliness, yes, sir. And they have been utilized in other contracts at
▶ Play
other times as well. Has there been any discussion about strengthening or developing additional indicators based on the feedback of members and constituents?
▶ Play
so what's before you and again mary catherine can elaborate on it but what's before you has other performance indicators added thank you all right senator
▶ Play
rice you're very nice thank you mr chair and and let me
▶ Play
just follow up with my summation and i'll be quiet what i'm looking for is results yes sir a lot of what y'all said today sounds good and I appreciate and I know it's not a perfect world but what I see in results we've already gone through some bad stuff we're not we're not fixed it we really don't have an option what you're saying without eight months or more of getting ready for another one as I've dealt with different issues the opioid crisis where we listen to people testimony and somebody sitting in the chair you're sitting at that if she's still alive I'll be surprised from what she looked at that day and people that all I asked was what's the option for these people that were doing things they were told to do that were legal to do that were checked on and in criteria met and yet some of them turn i'm told to suicide street drugs you know now we're dealing with a lot of population not all but a lot of the population that i talked about before that this is impacting them greatly we've got to fix this we've got to get into it's never going to be perfect we've got to get an acceptable level are you committing today if this contract goes through that when there's a review needed it will be reviewed optum will be you'll be looking over their shoulder i hope you have been but if there's criteria uh that i don't i don't know that they did that much wrong i think it was just they didn't have all the parameters in there that they needed maybe would that be fair to say that is partially fair
▶ Play
Speaker 169 1:54:34
to say yes sir and you think they're they're in there now so
▶ Play
it's i believe that yes sir that that's all i'm asking for is results we we've got to have changes and we we've got that and i'm for efficiency i appreciate the health task force but i'm not for disrespect through our actions of our aging population that that's got to change from what i've seen and and the way state of arkansas the federal government everybody spends money and a lot of it we know is wasted i don't want to do it on this population i wasn't raised that way and i'm not going to sit still for it so i would appreciate any and all that you can do to make sure you're you're listening and changing to a corrective action thank you senator rice if
▶ Play
i make a very brief comment on behalf of all of us we realize that every action we take at dhs affects a person at least every time we do something and it weighs heavy on us i assure you i assure this entire committee we want this to work we know what's at stake it's not just the money at stake sure there's money at stake we deal with that daily we also know we're dealing with lives every day and and any mistake or any mistake made on us or behalf of our contractors affects them and it weighs heavy on
▶ Play
us i assure you thank you thank you senator rice all right representative dalby was alternate for senator uh for representative bragg version dalby you still over there it's here okay Senator Bledsoe, you're recognized.
▶ Play
All right. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just one thing I'd like cleared up, please. some have said that Optum almost forces people into the nursing home that some of these people that have been in home health care because of all that has gone on end up in a nursing home when really and truly they prefer staying at home and can stay at home would you just kind of speak to that and to tell me if your numbers of nursing home placements have gone up since some of this has started.
▶ Play
I don't have the numbers of nursing home placements but the state helped build the tool. So the tool existed but then you have to customize the specific tool which is the men choices for the policy of the state. So if during this implementation period if people were receiving a score on the functional assessment that took them out of their homes when they were receiving care in their homes that's something that's been gone back and looked at to see if we can align the logic model and make sure that the questions are being scored in a way that does not cause people to go into nursing homes unnecessarily. I'm sorry Senator Bledsoe
▶ Play
at the wrong button you'll have to request again.
▶ Play
So you had to your knowledge you have not seen any evidence of that? I'm because
▶ Play
I haven't been daily involved in the aging independent assessment we would need to go back and look and see the scores on the tools and if those were held steady because that because the assessment occurs and they're given a tier but then the DHS nurses make the final eligibility determination and so we would have to go back but we could gather those numbers for you and let you know what we've done to change that if there was a
▶ Play
problem. I can say that Optum is placing between one and two percent in nursing homes and there's not a rise in nursing home population. All right thank you but
▶ Play
I would like this number. Yes ma'am we'll get Thank you, Senator Bledsoe.
▶ Play
Members, staff, I have a request of a list of the corrections that have been made. It was mentioned earlier in Senator Hammer's questions. Staff, you can get with DHS on that list of corrections and then provide it to committee. I would appreciate it. Representative Fein, let's take one question, please, and then we have a motion. All right. Thank you so much.
▶ Play
As you know, my committee had voted to review this contract. that's aging children youth committee and we deferred doing that or passed on doing that because we knew it was coming up in august and we couldn't do it before then so i appreciate you're taking my question i had suggested back in our june meeting uh mr lynch that we do some kind of grandfathering for the time being with people who have previously been qualified to receive services they've spent down their money to go into assisted living facilities, and now we're scaring them to death, literally some of them, by telling them that they may not qualify anymore. Can we not grandfather them into some kind of quick assessment to see if they are worse and need more help, and otherwise leave them alone?
▶ Play
We certainly cannot grandfather any population into any tier, any program at all. That's CMS, Center of Medicaid and Medicare Services, that's part of the federal rules. It simply can't be done. An assessment has to be done yearly. Are you asking us more like an expedited assessment? While we're looking at this and you're saying that we're over
▶ Play
a barrel, we have to keep this contract, that would help greatly in the time being if we just leave these people alone and do the assessments for the new people coming in.
▶ Play
We have to do a yearly assessment. Could it not just be a
▶ Play
quick, are they any worse? that's pretty much what the
▶ Play
assessment is it's it's not I mean it's a I won't say that it's a quick you walk in and ask a person if you're any worse but it's not as we have to do the assessment we have to the full assessment if you will there's not an abbreviated version that we could do thank you all right thank
▶ Play
Representative Feit. Senator Hendren you're recognized for a motion. Thank you Mr.
▶ Play
Chairman and I think again with consultation with the speaker and the House members and several on this side let me just echo I think we all share the same concern that this needs to be fixed. Now you've committed that it's going to be fixed but the fact is we have a oversight responsibility. I think we also realize that not reviewing this contract and which would basically scrap the independent assessment process the end of this month is not really a path we want to take either so I think all of us really need to realize this reviewing this contract is a one-year extension basically which would take us through August 31 of 2020 so I would move that we review this contract through that period with this stipulation that DHS will report back to this committee uh prior to the end of this year with the steps that have been taken to improve the program and address the deficiencies and then at that point this committee will make a decision about whether or not the the rfp process will be begun for the subsequent contract which would give us the eight months required to uh to go through that process uh adequately so that'd be
▶ Play
my motion. Senator Hinger, I'm going to ask Ms. Schmidt just to clarify some of the
▶ Play
Speaker 121 2:02:46
timeline for us, please, on the contrary. The Amendment 3, which is before the committee today, is adding 16, a little over $16 million, and that amendment is scheduled to end June 30th, 2020. So that would be what would be required by this amendment if you're reviewing it. Let me just amend my motion
▶ Play
to adjust that timeline. If it's through June 30th, I would like to provide the eight months necessary if we make a decision to go through the RFP process, which means we're going to have to have a decision made sometime in October or November. So again, my motion is to review the contract with a stipulation that DHS will report back monthly so that we can make a decision in sufficient time to begin the RFP process prior to the subsequent contract of the next year. Give me a report back to this committee.
▶ Play
All right, members, that's a proper motion. We'll move to discussion. Representative Vaught, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. On the motion, could you have that they bring back true data to us, like hard numbers of this, this, this, and this, and not just this is what we think? Could that be in your motion, please? I'm fine with that being included in the motion. And again,
▶ Play
I'm an engineer and I understand true numbers, and that's part of what I was getting at is we sometimes focus on the one percent I want to see the entire totality of what this program has accomplished with real numbers the successes the failures the numbers so I think we need to we all need to be and that it's trending in the right direction that the changes you're making are fixing those problems so I'd certainly be agreeable to that amendment thank
▶ Play
you you know the discussion on the amendment all right seeing none all those in favor say aye aye any opposed no motion passes okay any questions on any of the other out-of-state contracts seeing none those items will be considered reviewed members we still have agenda items in front of
▶ Play
Speaker 121 2:04:54
us item e4 in-state contracts mr. chairman the in-state contracts begin on page 17 of item e agra for harvesting services of hardwood and pine seedlings correction department has a contract amendment for pest control services two of them there development finance authority has one for systems integrator for data center optimization dfa building authority for janitorial services for the justice building dfa child support for process services for custodial and non-custodial parents through the Office of Child Support, DFA Racing for experience counsel to deal with racing commission, racing laws, janitorial services for DFA revenue services. Education School for the Blind has two for charter bus services and for security guard services and then Education School for the Deaf has the same things for charter bus service and security guard services. Health Department has one with Arkansas foundation for medical care this is for colorectal cancer screening it's done through a special procurement by approved by osp it's in your salmon colored packet pages one through four that special procurement states that this is the only vendor originally it was done as a sole source osp has approved the special procurement for the term of the grant funding which ends june 29 2020 20. So that's what the approval is for. DHS, Ozark Guidance Center, Therapeutic Foster Care Services, Physical Therapy Services for Southeast Arkansas Human Development Center. You've got two there for, or one there for Insurance Department on page 21 for Navigator Assistance. That one also is done as a special procurement. It also is with Arkansas Foundation for Medical Care. The special procurement letter on pages five through six in your salmon packet is for Arkansas health insurance marketplace duties were transferred to the insurance department in March of this year. Marketplace had this as a contract in place. OSP approved special procurement until March 2020 when insurance can competitively bid these same services. Oil and gas for well plugging services. State Police has one there for administration of their health plan benefit. UA Fayetteville has one for Principal Fellows Program. UALR has one at the bottom of page 22 for Arkansas Prescription Drug Overdose Prevention Program. UALR on page 23 has a sole source justification for a contract number 21 there with Arkansas Foundation for Medical Care. It's for risk factor data book and providing behavioral health information, a picture of that for the state. In their sole source justification, they note that this agency has been doing the data collection for many years, and it's named in the federal block grant program to do that. Numbers 22 through 34 are all for UALR. these are all for professional comprehensive alcohol and drug abuse prevention services in Arkansas communities that takes you through to number 35 this is UAMS for legal services required for utility litigation matters and then you have number 36 the VA this is for housekeeping services for the VA at Fayetteville and those are all of the in-state contracts any questions on
▶ Play
these items saying none this item is considered reviewed
▶ Play
Speaker 121 2:08:30
the only remaining items mr chair are the report f1 in the item f page one is the medicaid non emergency transportation the report that we get monthly this is the june report then on page seven of the reports we have the executed contracts uh professional consultant services contracts under $50,000. On page 8, you have the report of technical and general services contracts as executed under that threshold. And then on page 11, we have one page of an over 800-page report from OSP. This is the cooperative agreements spending report, and there's a link provided in the attachments if you wanted to see this full report. Those are all the reports on today's agenda. Any
▶ Play
questions on the reports, members? Seeing none, those reports are considered reviewed. Seeing no other business, we're adjourned.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 2:09:49
You
▶ Play

Agenda

A. Call to Order - Comments from Chairs

9:29 - 10:08 4 segments 1 speaker

B. Department of Transformation and Shared Services, Office of State Procurement

10:08 - 50:28 168 segments 12 speakers

The subcommittee was briefed that, under Act 419, any rule issued by the OSP director does not become effective until this subcommittee reviews it and the full Legislative Council subsequently approves it; the rule in question was deferred from a June hearing, the law took effect on July 24, and it was placed on today’s agenda for review. [10:16] [10:36] [11:10] [11:41] [12:13] [12:24] [12:30] [12:41] [12:47] [13:00]

Staff analyst Joy Leonard confirmed that the proposed rule R8 1911-230 does not directly conflict with Act 419, though it expands beyond the act in areas such as pre-award discussions, negotiation procedures, competitive-range criteria, and best-and-final-offer (BAFO) processes, and the rule’s text was presented by Ed Armstrong and Rep. Jeff Wardlaw. [14:38] [15:11] [15:28] [15:39] [15:47] [16:13] [16:21] [16:27] [16:37] [16:56] [16:58] [17:34] [18:07] [18:40] [19:14] [19:47] [20:30] [21:01] [21:35] [21:40] [22:02] [22:34] [23:07] [23:38] [24:09]

Committee members questioned whether the rule’s definition of a “competitive range” might exceed the statutory requirement that each “responsible and reasonably susceptible” offeror be considered; after the discussion the chair noted no objections and moved that the rule be considered reviewed and referred to the Rules and Regulations Subcommittee of the Legislative Council. [39:56] [40:08] [40:42] [40:52] [41:02] [41:05] [41:12] [50:15]

C. Methods of Finance

50:28 - 51:14 4 segments 2 speakers

D. Discretionary Grants

51:14 - 54:05 7 segments 3 speakers

E. Services Contracts for Legislative Review

54:05 - 2:08:35 298 segments 23 speakers

Speaker 121 presented the batch of contracts slated for legislative review, walking the committee through the construction-related agreements (Arkansas Tech, ASU-Jonesboro, SAU Tech, etc.) on pages 2-8, the intergovernmental contracts with the Health Department and UAMS on page 9, and the out-of-state contracts covering janitorial services, health-department surveys, DHS Medicaid pharmacy, military department programs, state-police services and UALR strategic planning on pages 11-14. [54:24] [54:56] [55:27] [55:58] [56:56] [57:01] [57:40] [58:09] [58:46] [59:19] [59:53]

Representative Charlene Fite raised constituent complaints that the DHS-Optum independent-assessment contract is producing poor, untimely assessments and denials, prompting DHS officials Mary Catherine Williams, Paula Stone and DeAnn Vaught to outline the contract’s history, acknowledge timeliness penalties of roughly $200,000, describe a corrective-action plan, explain volume-driven cost growth to an $86 million projected total, and detail process changes to improve phone-call outreach and caregiver interview procedures. [1:00:07] [1:00:26] [1:01:03] [1:01:05] [1:01:10] [1:01:26] [1:01:33] [1:01:44] [1:01:53] [1:02:01] [1:02:05] [1:02:14] [1:02:18] [1:02:41] [1:03:38] [1:03:45] [1:03:52] [1:04:25] [1:04:55] [1:05:31] [1:06:03] [1:06:35] [1:07:01] [1:07:05] [1:07:09] [1:07:41] [1:08:12] [1:08:43] [1:09:14] [1:09:45] [1:09:58] [1:10:19] [1:10:25] [1:10:28] [1:10:36] [1:10:44] [1:10:52] [1:10:57] [1:11:03] [1:11:27] [1:11:46] [1:11:52] [1:12:01] [1:12:04] [1:12:31] [1:13:05] [1:13:36] [1:14:06]

Senators Hammer, Stubblefield and Rice questioned the existence of contract violations, the rate of assessment denials and the agency’s exit strategy, while Senator Jim Hendren asked whether the independent-assessment program for behavioral health was actually improving service delivery and warned that the contract expires on August 30, leaving the state potentially without the program; staff indicated that a three-month extension is technically possible but no motion was adopted during that segment. [1:10:28] [1:10:36] [1:10:44] [1:10:52] [1:10:57] [1:11:03] [1:11:27] [1:15:21] [1:15:45] [1:16:18] [1:16:23] [1:16:50] [1:16:53] [1:17:09] [1:17:12] [1:17:19] [1:17:27] [1:17:58] [1:18:06] [1:18:15] [1:18:20] [1:18:34] [1:19:03] [1:25:35] [1:25:39] [1:26:14] [1:26:54] [1:27:25] [1:28:00] [1:28:23] [1:28:30] [1:28:32] [1:28:38] [1:28:53] [1:42:12] [1:42:48] [1:42:52] [1:42:56] [1:43:02] [1:43:05] [1:43:23] [1:43:26] [1:43:35] [1:43:42] [1:43:53] [1:44:16] [1:47:26] [1:47:37] [1:47:46] [1:47:52] [1:48:12] [1:48:15] [1:48:44] [1:49:14]

Ms. Paula Stone and Representative DeAnn Vaught explained that the assessments reduced unnecessary prior authorizations, targeted counseling to those who truly needed it, generated cost savings for Arkansas and enabled the state to pursue a 1915(i) waiver for supportive services, and Representative Matthew Shepherd together with Rep. Vaught outlined the contract’s performance indicators and penalties, noting that fines have already been imposed for timeliness failures and that quality-assurance metrics are being closely monitored. [1:44:25] [1:44:56] [1:45:07] [1:45:27] [1:45:58] [1:46:05] [1:46:30] [1:46:33] [1:46:46] [1:46:57] [1:47:52] [1:48:12] [1:48:15] [1:50:07] [1:50:38] [1:50:52] [1:50:57] [1:51:13] [1:51:47] [1:51:52] [1:52:06] [1:52:14]

Senator Hendren moved to extend the contract review through August 31 2020 with a requirement that DHS provide monthly reports and hard data before any decision on a new RFP; after an amendment aligning the timeline with a June 30 deadline, the motion was adopted unanimously with no opposition. [2:01:27] [2:01:33] [2:01:56] [2:02:32] [2:02:36] [2:02:40] [2:02:46] [2:02:56] [2:03:05] [2:04:32] [2:04:43]

F. Reports and Communications

2:08:35 - 2:09:27 3 segments 2 speakers

Speaker 121 presented the June emergency transportation report, pointing out page 7’s professional consultant services contracts under $50,000, page 8’s technical and general services contracts under the same threshold, and page 11’s summary of an 800-page cooperative agreements spending report from OSP with a link to the full document. [2:08:38]

He indicated that the complete reports are available in the meeting attachments for members to review. [2:09:13]

Chair Representative Andy Davis asked for any questions, received none, and formally recorded that the reports were reviewed and the meeting was adjourned. [2:09:21]

G. Other Business

2:09:27 - 2:09:28

H. Adjournment

2:09:28 - 2:09:51 1 segment

Speakers

Speaker 4
1 segment
Speaker 12
1 segment
Representative Andy Davis Chair Unverified
69 segments
Speaker 20
11 segments
Representative Jeff Wardlaw Unverified
100 segments
Speaker 39
1 segment
Speaker 41
2 segments
Speaker 52
9 segments
Speaker 63
1 segment
Representative Jim Dotson Unverified
9 segments
Representative Johnny Rye Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 85
1 segment
Speaker 94
1 segment
Speaker 100
2 segments
Speaker 121
31 segments
Speaker 120
1 segment
Representative Charlene Fite Unverified
14 segments
Representative DeAnn Vaught Unverified
71 segments
Speaker 138
1 segment
Paula Stone Unverified
77 segments
Representative Chris Richey Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 146
1 segment
Senator Kim Hammer Unverified
6 segments
Senator Gary Stubblefield Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 174
1 segment
Speaker 197
1 segment
Senator Terry Rice Unverified
21 segments
Speaker 202
1 segment
Speaker 212
1 segment
Speaker 214
2 segments
Representative Marcus E. Richmond Unverified
6 segments
Representative Jon S. Eubanks Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 240
1 segment
Senator Jim Hendren Unverified
16 segments
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 169
1 segment
Senator Cecile Bledsoe Unverified
4 segments