The Claims Commission reviewed Cox’s estate claim for $1 million against UAMS and approved a settlement of $175,000, which was then referred to the General Assembly for review.
[6:36]
Chair Senator Bart Hester asked for any comments, received none, and moved to adopt the settlement; the motion was seconded and carried unanimously.
[7:01][7:06]
Tommy Mason’s $10,000 negligence claim against the Arkansas Department of Correction was awarded $175, and he appealed that award to the General Assembly.
[8:13]
Chair Hester called for discussion, received none, and moved to uphold the Claims Commission’s ruling; the motion was seconded and carried.
[8:25]
E. (Other) Denied and Dismissed Appealed by Claimant 9:22
The committee considered several denied or dismissed claims, beginning with Ellis Sloan v. APERS where the commission dismissed a $1.55 million claim and, after the Attorney General declined to opine, Senator Bruce Maloch moved to reverse and remand the case to the commission-a motion that carried.
[9:52][10:23][10:32][10:39][10:42][10:54][11:03]
The dismissal of Melissa Roth’s claim against the Department of Finance and Administration (originally $10,000 plus punitive damages) was affirmed by a motion that carried.
[11:07][11:26][11:45][11:58]
The dismissals of Kimberly Burks’s $3,055.25 claim against the Department of Transportation and Harvey Chennault’s $50,000 claim against the same agency were each affirmed by motions that carried.
[12:37][12:44][13:05][13:12][13:17][13:35][13:39][14:10][14:37]
The commission’s dismissal of Devin Wiggins’s $15,000 constitutional-rights claim against the Department of Correction was presented, and the committee moved to affirm the dismissal; the motion was seconded and carried.
[16:22][16:51]
just jump into the first item. Okay. We're going to start with the reissuance of warrants and unpaid bills. Okay. If no objection, I'll entertain a motion to batch items B1 through 3, the reissuance of unpaid warrants and unpaid bills. i got a motion and a second all in favor say aye opposed say no motion carries now that the items have been batched do i have a motion to approve items b1 through 3 i got a motion to approve items b1 through 3 and a second all those in favor say aye opposed say no motion carries We'll move on to item C, negotiated settlement agreement. Staff, please give a brief description of the
claim. Okay, this is item C-1, estate of S.E. May Cox via University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences. Cox's estate filed a claim against UAMS alleging medical negligence and seeking damages in the amount of $1 million. UAMS initially denied liability. On May 1, 2019, the party submitted to the Claims Commission a joint motion to approve settlement in the amount of $175,000. The Commission approved the settlement and referred it to the General Assembly for review and approval. Ms. Irby, does the Claims Commission
have anything to add? No, sir. Are there any questions or discussion from the members? Seeing none, do I have a motion? I have a motion and a second. All those in favor say aye. Opposed say no. Motion carries. Moving on
to item D1. Item D1 is an awarded claim appealed by the claimant, Tommy Mason v. Arkansas Department of Correction. On October 21, 2013, Mason filed a claim against ADC claiming negligence and seeking damages in the amount of $10,000. The allegations were related to an illness he claimed was caused by salmonella bacteria found in a food served at the Tucker unit of ADC in August of 2012. After a hearing, the Claims Commission entered an order granting an award in the amount of $175. Mason filed a motion for reconsideration requesting that the award be increased to $1 million. The Claims Commission denied that motion on April 1st, 2019. Mason now appeals the $175 award to the General Assembly. Ms. Herbie, does
the Claims Commission have anything to add? No, Senator Hester. Are there any questions or discussion from the members? No. Seeing none, I have a motion. Do I have a second? Second motion is second. All those in favor of upholding the ruling of the Claims Commission say aye. Opposed, say no. Motion carries. Item E1.
Item E1 is Ellis Sloan v. Arkansas Public Employees Retirement System. Sloan filed a claim against APERS on May 18, 2017, seeking $1,549,152 in damages. He listed two counts in his claim against APERS, promissory estoppel and constructive fraud. APERS moved to dismiss the claim for lack of jurisdiction pursuant to Arkansas Code Annotated 19-10-204B1A1D. which states that the commission shall have no jurisdiction of or authority with respect to claims arising under the Arkansas Public Employees Retirement System Act. The commission granted APER's motion to dismiss and subsequently denied Sloan's motion for reconsideration. Sloan appeals the commission's dismissal of his claim. Also, just a note that this claim was before the subcommittee a year ago, at which time it was remanded for an AG opinion. The claims commission sought that opinion, and the AG declined to opine on the matter.
Ms. Irby, does the Claims Commission have anything to add? No, sir. Members, I'll tell you, I was here and actually made the most of the sense of the AG. We're in a weird spot where the Andrews ruling from the Supreme Court says that sovereign immunity, they can't go there. The Claims Commission is saying they're not sure that they have authority to hear it. So it's came to us back to us. So we asked the AG for an opinion. They declined to give an opinion. So here we are. I personally, I feel like everyone deserves to be heard somewhere. I don't think this is the venue, but I do have a member that has a motion. If Senator Malik, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Is it your understanding that that
move that we reverse the decision of the claims commission and remand the case back to the claims commission for a hearing on the merits of the matter. I have a motion and a second.
Motion carries. Moving on to E2. E2 is Melissa Roth, the Arkansas Department of Finance and Administration. Roth filed a complaint against DFNA on May 18, 2017, alleging breach of contract and seeking $3,325.40 in damages. She subsequently amended her complaint to seek $10,000 in general and consequential damages, plus an additional $30,000 in punitive damages. DFA moved for summary judgment, and after a hearing, the Claims Commission granted the motion and denied and dismiss Ross' claim. The commission also denied her motion for reconsideration. She now appeals the dismissal of her claim to the General Assembly. Ms. Irving, does the Claims Commission
have anything to add? No, sir. Any discussion from the membership? Any motion? I have a motion to affirm the ruling of the Claims Commission. Senator Irving, do I have a second? I have a second. All those in favor say aye. Opposed say no. Motion carries. Item E3. Well, I can tell members of the audience that unless there are questions, we don't have anyone come up to discuss. Everybody's had their day in court with the Claims Commission. So unless members had questions or wanted to ask someone a question, we don't have them come up. Thank
you. Moving on to E3. E3 is Kimberly Burks, the Arkansas Department of Transportation. Ms. Burks filed a claim against the Department of Transportation on December 27, 2018, alleging negligence with respect to property damage allegedly caused by a raised drainage cover in the median of an intersection in Hot Springs. She sought damages in the amount of $3,055.25. since. The Claims Commission entered an order on March 11, 2019, granting the department's motion to dismiss. Burks now appeals the dismissal of her claim to the General Assembly.
Ms. Irby, does the Claims Commission have anything to add? Yes, sir. Does members have any discussion or questions on the matter? Seeing none, do I have a motion? I have a motion to affirm and a second. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed, say no. Motion carries.
Item E-4. E-4 is Harvey Chennault, the Arkansas Department of Transportation. This claim stems from an October 8, 2012 motor vehicle accident between Chennault and the department's employee, Christy Mott. Chennault filed this negligence claim on August 5, 2014, against the department as Mott's employer, seeking $50,000 in damages. The department then filed a motion for summary judgment, and the Claims Commission granted that motion. It also denied his motion for reconsideration. Chennault appeals the dismissal of his claim to the General Assembly.
Ms. Irby, do you have anything to add? I don't, but I'm happy to take any questions. Are there any questions or discussion from the members? Seeing none, do I have a motion? I have a motion to affirm and a second. All those in favor say aye. Opposed say
no. Motion carries. Item E5. E5 is Ken Berg, the Arkansas Department of Human Services. Mr. Berg, an employee at the Boonville Human Development Center, filed a claim against DHS on September 26, 2018. He alleged that another vehicle backed into his parked vehicle at the Development Center campus on August 1st, 2018, and he sought $1,690.65 in damages. The Claims Commission entered an order on March 15th, 2019, granting DHS's motion to dismiss and subsequently denied Berg's motion for reconsideration. Berg now appeals the dismissal of his claim to the General Assembly.
take any questions. Senator Rice, you're recognized. Thank you. In reading over this, I don't think I saw or clarified in my mind the other night. There wasn't or was there anybody that saw the accident or did he just come out and his vehicle was damaged? The only information we were given, Senator, was what was included in the complaint and the claimant did not respond to the motion to dismiss filed by DHS, so we don't have any other information. What I saw, you just said he parked by the curb and found damage, but nobody saw a claim. That clarified what I thought I saw. Thank you. Any other question or discussion from the
members? Seeing none, do I have a motion? I have a motion to affirm and a second. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed, say no. Motion carries. Item F.
Item F.1 is a corrections claim denied and dismissed, appealed by the claimant. It's Devin Wiggins v. Arkansas Department of Correction. Wiggins, an ADC inmate, filed a claim with the Claims Commission on June 4, 2018, alleging that he was subjected to inhumane conditions and that officers within his unit failed to follow behavioral control guidelines set forth by ADC, all of which he claimed violated the Eighth Amendment. Wiggins sought $15,000 in damages. The commission granted ADC's motion to dismiss, agreeing with ADC that Wiggins' claim was premised on an alleged constitutional violation over which the commission lacked jurisdiction. A motion for reconsideration was also denied in Wiggins' appeals to the General Assembly. Ms. Herbie, does the Claims Commission have anything to add? No, sir, but
I'm happy to take any questions. Are there any questions or discussion from the membership? I have a motion to affirm and a second. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed say no. Motion carries. Are there any? That's through our agenda. Any discussion? Anything anybody's got? Thank you for coming today. We are adjourned.
The Claims Commission reviewed Cox’s estate claim for $1 million against UAMS and approved a settlement of $175,000, which was then referred to the General Assembly for review.
[6:36]
Chair Senator Bart Hester asked for any comments, received none, and moved to adopt the settlement; the motion was seconded and carried unanimously.
[7:01][7:06]
Tommy Mason’s $10,000 negligence claim against the Arkansas Department of Correction was awarded $175, and he appealed that award to the General Assembly.
[8:13]
Chair Hester called for discussion, received none, and moved to uphold the Claims Commission’s ruling; the motion was seconded and carried.
[8:25]
E. (Other) Denied and Dismissed Appealed by Claimant
9:22 - 17:0135 segments4 speakers
The committee considered several denied or dismissed claims, beginning with Ellis Sloan v. APERS where the commission dismissed a $1.55 million claim and, after the Attorney General declined to opine, Senator Bruce Maloch moved to reverse and remand the case to the commission-a motion that carried.
[9:52][10:23][10:32][10:39][10:42][10:54][11:03]
The dismissal of Melissa Roth’s claim against the Department of Finance and Administration (originally $10,000 plus punitive damages) was affirmed by a motion that carried.
[11:07][11:26][11:45][11:58]
The dismissals of Kimberly Burks’s $3,055.25 claim against the Department of Transportation and Harvey Chennault’s $50,000 claim against the same agency were each affirmed by motions that carried.
[12:37][12:44][13:05][13:12][13:17][13:35][13:39][14:10][14:37]
The commission’s dismissal of Devin Wiggins’s $15,000 constitutional-rights claim against the Department of Correction was presented, and the committee moved to affirm the dismissal; the motion was seconded and carried.
[16:22][16:51]