May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 8, 2026
C. Reports of Executive and Standing Committees: 6:52
The executive committee report was presented by Representative Richard Womack, noting staff-review approvals for the Pharmacy Benefit Manager program and an audit of Covenant Keepers College Preparatory Charter School, and the committee adopted the report by unanimous voice vote.
[6:57][7:13][7:43][7:51]
Senator John Cooper reported that the Town of Sunset is in substantial compliance with the municipal accounting law and recommended notifying the state treasurer so the town may receive turn-back monies; he also summarized the handling of deferred and current reports, filing 161 reports and moving to adopt the committee’s findings.
[8:14][9:02][9:37]
During a brief discussion, Representative David Fielding and Senator Jimmy Hickey asked whether forfeited turn-back funds could be recovered, and staff counsel confirmed that the funds are forfeited and cannot be retrieved.
[9:52][10:07][10:16][10:22][10:32][10:40][11:11][11:20]
Reports on educational institutions by Representative Stan Berry and on state agencies by Representative Nelda Speaks were each adopted after motions and seconds from Senator Cooper, with unanimous aye votes recorded.
[13:27][14:01][14:32][15:04][15:28][15:34][16:09][16:43][16:54][17:09]
The audit staff presented the Marvel School District audit, noting two management-letter findings (an unregistered $200,000 modular-building contract and untimely federal tax deposits) and two financial-statement findings, including a repeat lack of segregation of duties that allowed the bookkeeper to issue 90 unauthorized checks totaling almost $472,000 and led the board to declare fiscal distress after a $1.6 million drawdown since 2016.
[19:01][19:35][20:05][20:39][21:14][21:49][22:23][22:57][23:27]
Representative Richard Womack moved that the Legislative Joint Auditing Committee conduct a legislative audit of the Arkansas School for Mathematics, Science and the Arts and any associated non-profits to review their financial transactions for compliance with state law.
[1:11:02][1:11:33]
Senator Jason Rapert called for a second to the motion, which was provided by Senator Johnson, and the committee voted unanimously in favor, with all members saying “aye” and no opposition recorded.
[1:11:42]
The motion was adopted, directing the audit and the preparation of a report to be presented to the legislative audit committee.
[1:11:42]
I want to thank everyone for being here this morning. Thank you for all the work of the committees yesterday. first order business for us would be adoption of the minutes of the May 10th 2019 meeting I have a motion I have a motion from Senator Cooper and a second from Senator Eads all those in favor say aye all opposed no the minutes are adopted and now we're at item C and I'd like to call on co-chair Womack for the executive
committee report. Thank you, Mr. Chair. The executive committee met Thursday, June 6, 2019. Staff reported to the committee the audit special investigative and shortage report scheduled to be presented to the standing committees and the full legislative joint auditing committee this month. The committee took the following actions. Approved a request for staff review and analysis of selected financial records and other documentation relating to the Pharmacy Benefit Manager Program as it pertains to public funds, and the committee approved a request from the Department of Ed for staff to perform the audit of Covenant Keepers College Preparatory Charter School for the fiscal year ended June 30, 2018, contingent upon the department obtaining the applicable financial records to conduct an audit. With no additional business to discuss, the meeting was adjourned. The next meeting of the committee will be held on Thursday, September 12, 2019. I move for adoption of this report. I have a
motion for adoption of the report. I have a second. I have a second for Senator Cooper. All those in favor say aye. All opposed, no. The report is adopted. Item two, I'd like to call on Chairman Cooper for the report on counties and municipalities. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
The committee, June 7, 2019, the committee adopted the minutes of the May 9, 2018 meeting. The committee discussed the status of the Town of Sunset and their compliance with the municipal accounting law. Staff reported that the town has made significant progress in their compliance with the municipal accounting law. There are a few issues left, but staff reports that they are in substantial compliance. The Standing Committee on Counties and Municipalities recommends to the Legislative Joint Auditing Committee that the state treasurer and town officials be notified that the town of Sunset is in substantial compliance with the municipal county law and that they are, again, eligible to receive turn-back monies. The committee reviewed 11 previously deferred reports, including one investigative letter. Eight of the reports were filed and three were deferred. Officials from six of these entities were present to discuss their repeat findings. The committee reviewed 165 current reports. Four of these were certified to the bond board, including one investigative letter. Eleven were referred to prosecuting attorneys. Officials from five entities were present to address the repeat findings in their current reports. The committee filed 161 current reports and deferred four. move for adoption of this report thank you mr.
fielding thank you mr. chair this might be a question to the chair during the bill and Senator Hickey is here to you you might be asking through Senator Hickey was the town would they be able to see retro funds back from when they was not compliant with the stuff from here on
you want you say you were addressing that to Senator Hickey did you say yes through the chair okay Senator Hickey I believe has rung in here so Center Hickey you're recognized I would want our legal counsel to
if i'm incorrect mr chairman frank airy legislative audit mr fielding my understanding is that the town of sunset was at that third and last stage at that stage according to the law everything that was was held back is forfeited all the turn back is forfeited to all the other municipalities so at this point they cannot retrieve what they lost going forward however they can start to collect turn back again okay
all right thank you thank you mr chair thank you representative fielding um i do have a motion on the floor do you have anything further i have a motion on the floor for adoption from Senator
Cooper. Ring back in there for me, Senator Cooper. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. We did discuss the lack of full compliance in this issue, and even though they're not in full compliance at this time, they haven't cleared everything at this point. But we determined that they were in substantial compliance at this point and did not think that it would be appropriate to continue to hold the turn back funds especially in light of the next opportunity that we had would have to review that would be
representative I'm here seat 21 okay thank you mr. chair I just want to ask do we have do we have a figure on how much turn back the city has has forfeited thus far Senator Cooper do you have
right thank you all right thank you members we do have a motion on the floor for adoption from Senator Cooper have a second have a second from co-chair here all those favor say aye all those opposed no the report is adopted and members we're now i want to recognize representative barry for presentation of educational institutions report as if he will ring in for us if you push your button Mr. Representative Berry you got to push the yellow button I think maybe there you go thank you Mr. Chairman finally got it now you're recognized okay the committee
reviewed 53 current school district audit reports three current educational cooperative audit reports four current open enrollment charter school audit reports three current higher education audit reports and one current internal control and compliance assessment report for the year in june 30 2018 representatives from the east end school district were present and answered questions from the committee related to findings contained in the district's audit report one of which was a repeat finding representatives from the arkansas department of education were also present on behalf of Rockbridge Montessori Charter School. The school's audit report contained repeat findings. The committee was informed that the school's charter was revoked effective June 30, 2018, and as a result, is no longer in operation. The audit report of the Gentry School District was certified to the Governmental Bonding Board. the audit reports of the cotter east end eureka springs mcgee and nettleton school districts were referred to the prospective prosecuting attorney the committee filed the 63 current audit reports and the current internal control and compliance assessment report that were brought before it Mr. Chairman, at this time, I move for adoption of this report.
All right. Members, any questions at all? Seeing none, I have a motion for adoption of the report. Do I have a second? Second. I have a second from Senator Cooper. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed, no. The report is adopted. And now I'd like to recognize Representative Nelda speaks for the
report on state agencies. Thank you, Mr. Chair. There were nine reports that were on the committee's agenda yesterday. Two reports where findings were presented. The Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality did not properly segregate duties over their bank account transactions, and the check images received from the bank were not in compliance with the state law. In addition, a former deputy director's P-card was used by various employees during the deputy director's employment as well as after she took another job. A private audit report was reviewed for the Southeast Arkansas Economic Development District. This report contained a finding that a review of a federal program at the district resulted in total question cost of over $3 million for 2014 and 2015. Various agencies, staff members were present to report on how the agency intended to address the audit findings and to answer committee questions. During the committee, during the meeting, the committee adopted a motion to file the nine reports. I move to adopt this report. Very well. Members, any questions
at all on the report? I have a motion by Representative Speaks for adoption of the report. Do I have a second? I have a second from Senator Cooper, who is our standing seconder this morning. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed, no. Thank you, and that report is adopted. Members now, I would like to recognize Roger Norman.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. It's my honor and privilege and also with a little sadness to present to you this morning John Moore, Deputy Legislative Auditor for State Agencies. This is John's last meeting with us. He's going to be retiring after 38 years. John, would you stand? John has done a tremendous job in all the positions he's been with with audit, but he's one that's never backed down from anything. We were talking, some people, they get ready to retire and they slow down. I think John is speeding up. We're working on a report on the PBMs, and I think he's, well, I don't know if he wishes he could stay and do that or not, but we were visiting this morning about that, and he's making plans and how we could do things and stuff, But John will be tremendously missed, and I just want you to know how much I appreciate and the staff appreciates John and his service to the committee, the General Assembly, and the citizens of the state of Arkansas. John. Thank you, John.
Very well said. The legislature joins you in that, Roger. thank you john for your service to this state members we're now to item e and we have an audit report for the marvel school district for the year ended june 30 2018 and we recognize miranda is that it ms mccoy for comments and the report
thank you mr chairman this presentation covers the audit findings for the Marvel School District audit for the year ended June 30th 2018 the Marvel School District located in Phillips County served approximately 366 students at two schools during the 2017 2018 school year the district participates in the community eligibility provision option which allows the nation's highest poverty schools and districts to serve breakfast and lunch at no cost to all enrolled students. We issued two management letter findings and two financial statement findings, one of which was a repeat finding. First, I will present the management letter findings. and an installment contract for the purchase of a modular building for over $200,000 was not registered with the Arkansas Department of Education as required by state law. Additionally, the district failed to make timely federal tax deposits for three quarters, resulting in penalties of just over $3,700. dollars. As previously stated, two financial statement findings were also issued. The first finding, which was a repeat finding, resulted because financial accounting duties were not adequately segregated among employees. Specifically, bookkeeper April Poore was responsible for receiving and depositing monies collected, maintaining accounting records, preparing and posting journal entries, and preparing bank reconciliations. The bookkeeper who processed and prepared payroll checks was also responsible for adding new employees, making changes to the payroll amounts, reconciling reports, and maintaining accounting records. Additionally, the bookkeeper was responsible for processing and preparing non-payroll checks, adding new vendors, receiving and maintaining accounting records. The bookkeeper had unrestricted access to the district signature stamp and was authorized to post journal entries to the general ledger without independent review. The failure to segregate duties resulted in the second financial statement finding which related to unauthorized disbursements. Our comparison of bank statements obtained from the bank to the statements on file at the district revealed that the bookkeeper issued 90 unauthorized checks to herself totaling almost $472,000. The bookkeeper recorded the unauthorized disbursements as payments to a utility vendor in the accounting system. changed the payee on the checks from the name of the utility vendor to her name endorsed these checks and provided altered bank statement copies to us for audit purposes this is one of the 90 checks that miss poor wrote to herself she issued checks to herself which range from just over one thousand eight hundred dollars to nine thousand five hundred dollars. This is the altered check image included in the bank statement provided by Ms. Poor to the auditors. The number sequence on the back of the check is missing the date. She used this particular back of check image for the majority of the unauthorized check images written in the fiscal year 2018. The district terminated miss poor's employment on january 17th of this year on march 29th miss poor was charged with five counts of felony theft of property and 90 counts of felony forgery additionally on april 12th the board of education voted to classify the district as being in fiscal distress due to the district drawing down its year-end reserves by 1.6 million dollars since 2016 as well as the theft of funds from of miss poor this concludes my presentation for the marvel school district audit the district officials are present to answer committee questions thank you
miss mccoy members do you have any questions do you have any questions you'd like to ask of the officials that that are here I have several that are coming in here now so the one that's first on list is representative
love thank you mr. chair to staff you said that they drew down 1.6 million dollars which put them in fiscal distress but there was only there was four hundred and seventy one thousand dollars worth the felony charges I'm I guess I'm trying I'm at a loss as to why they threw down 1.6 million dollars versus the four hundred and seventy one thousand
dollars so. Mr. McCoy. Thank you Mr. Chair. It's over it's not just the unauthorized disbursements that brought down their just their ending balance It's other expenditures throughout these years that as they were spending money, their revenue was not as, you know, they weren't getting in as much revenue as disbursed money. Okay. All right. Thank you. Mr. Norma, do you
just like to say that on both of these reports today, they've been referred to the prosecutors, and there are upcoming trials. and so I know we've visited with the prosecutors before and they know that we put people under oath here and they have a little bit of an issue sometimes with the officials giving testimony here and they would like to preserve the integrity of the trials and the testimony of the trials. So I don't think that there's a problem with bringing these officials forward but if we could direct those questions as opposed to the specific facts, I think the staff might can answer some of those questions. But as far as what the officials have done to correct the problems, I think those would be appropriate. But getting into the specific facts, I think those questions would probably be better fielded by the staff
further, Mr. Love? Well, I guess I want to ask, what have they done since they've found out about the missing $471,000? What controls have they put in place or have staff reviewed that
to see if the controls are now adequate? Yeah. With that, I think it would be appropriate. I know that I have at least one name here, Dr. Joyce Cottoms, the superintendent of Marvel. Ms. Cottoms, if you would please come forward. And if there is anyone else that is on staff that needs to join you, they're welcome to join you if they care to. If you'd please come forward. And members, of course, recognize what Mr. Norman has stated there to try to keep your questions within those parameters so that we don't impair anything related to the upcoming trials. I would like you to go ahead and stand, though, and our custom is that we swear you in for your testimony. And if you would, please state your name and your employer and your position for us, and then I'll administer your
Okay, thank you. if you would please both of you raise your right hand do you solemnly swear or affirm that the testimony you're about to give will be the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth all right thank you you may be seated and with that representative love it might be good for you to restate that question i
think which you wanted them to answer thank you mr chair so since since Since this event, what controls have you put in place to ensure that this doesn't happen again? Because I'm kind of baffled as to how one person could do this. So what controls have you
put in place? Well, we are segregating duties between the secretary who opens the mail and the bookkeeper who generates payroll checks and reconciles the bank statements. We require and will continue to require two signatures on all checks before processing. Those two signatures are the superintendent's signature and the vice president of the Marble E. Lane School District Board of Directors. No checks are signed by the bookkeeper or the secretary. Only the superintendent and the board vice president. The bank statements are reconciled and will continue to be reconciled on a monthly basis. The superintendent now checks all or approves all pre-Cal pay run reports and accounts payable bills. The superintendent now opens and reviews all bank statements first, had a conversation with the bank and ask them to bring the bank statements directly to me so that I could open them. The superintendent will periodically check all journal entries for approval. The superintendent will make sure receipts are being given for all monies that are receipted or turned in and also send the balances to activity sponsors or sponsors for agreement of the balance. okay and just recently I spoke with the energy with the facilities that we had several bills and asked them to do a collective billing and so they are working with us on that now okay now were you the the superintendent
you thank you senator hammer you're recognized sir thank you mr. chair we all in financial distress before this event over here to your to your left ma'am to your left ma'am there we go right here good morning were y'all in financial distress before this event occurred no okay any idea how long it will be before you'll be able to work your way out of financial distress I think
specific date that we can give it is just we're gonna have to watch revenues and expenditures um and it will depend some on if we can collect any of this money that was
embezzled okay and i want to ask a question to the chair staff please first mr chairman if i may yes go ahead do well or maybe they can answer the the bank at which the deposits were being made were they the same bank as the same bank that the school does business with yes and is that is that a local community bank
there in marvel yes mr i don't believe that i think there may be a misunderstanding that the checks that were being taken were not being deposited in the same bank as the school districts
recognized thank you mr chair my my question is more kind of a general question and can anyone tell me what what type of maximum sentence are we looking at for this person if there's five counts of felony theft of property 90 counts of felony forgery does anyone know
what Mr. Norman may want to comment on that. Obviously, you're talking about an answer from the judiciary. Right. And the other thing is this is a good time to point out that in pursuit of trying to make sure that nothing here interferes with the prosecution, we just make sure we don't get into some of those, the facts of some of that issue, talk about the process and what they're doing to rectify. but I think since the prosecution has made that known to us we need to be real careful but you have a good question Roger normal try to answer that I do not
you go okay there you go ladies a question for you um up until the situation that occurred here which is what about a three-year period something like that is about a three-year period some more four years four years is there some way that we could have grabbed hold of this situation earlier I think if someone
other than the person reconciling the bank statements would open them and review them as what they're doing now then that potentially could have prevented this from happening very good
question thank you representative right senator mark Johnson you should have it unless you yeah you should just punch your green button now go there there it is. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Chairman, I assume our
rules we generally use on the floor apply to committees as well. I do want to state a disclosure to the committee. Dr. Cottoms is a good friend of mine, a person of high integrity, and I was as shocked as she was when this was discovered with I think any of us that have ever worked with a trusted or someone, and this person I understand Dr. Collins was there when you took this job as superintendent, so she inherited this individual. She didn't hire them, and any of us have ever had someone that we trusted do the right thing, and they let us down. You know, it's a bad thing all the way around. I'm hoping that what we're here for is to not only solve the specific problem in the Marvillie Lane School District and their now partner, the ADE, but also to determine things that will stop things like this from happening in the future. But I just did want to disclose that I'm a longtime friend of Dr. Cottom's and that I know she's a wonderful person and she's going to do everything she can to make things right. And again, the fact that there is criminality involved, as you and Mr. Norman stated, I know we have to tread lightly, but certainly the long-term effect of this is that we can find some procedures and some checks and balances that keep one individual from being in a position to pull this off. We see this over and over again, both within state government and in the private sector, where when you only have one person that is more or less checking themselves, as long as they're honest, there's no problem. But when they're not, then a whole lot of dominoes start falling. So, Mr. Chairman, thank you for the opportunity to state that and my own confidence in her ability to try to move this thing forward as best as can be done.
it's been for several years I don't know how far back it goes but several years I would say probably at least five or ten or I don't know if we've ever not had that comment in that report what was the
make it better. Did these events occur after they were initially cautioned about failure or segregation of duties, so at the time that you first noticed it, there was no embezzlement occurring, but you did you notified them that there was a an issue of segregation of duties and then this embezzlement took place after that warning was that correct I would have to go back
and look at all the reports to see but I feel fairly certain that that comment has been in the report for many years and and this individual when did she go to work there you know 2012 I would I would venture that that comment has been in the report prior to her coming on board mr. chairman
mass superintendent question sure thank you so madam mr. superintendent excuse me the it sounds like there's a history of failure segregation of duties what was the school's actions once you were first notified of a failure segregation of duties and why were no changes made that might have otherwise prevented this from occurring
well in all honesty we had two individuals working in that district office and when I came in this person had one set of duties and this person had another set of duties and that's the way they worked I did attempt to try to get them to interchange so that when if the occasion happened that one was not there the office could continue to go on but what I was told was that we've always been found against doing segregated duties and we're not the only district other districts around us do it as well and so in all honesty I really did not know how to you know segregate duties between two people when you have one person saying I do this and I don't know how to do that and then you have the other person who's doing what she does
I'll leave it there mr. senator I just like to add that that's probably the one of the most if not the most common comment that we have in our reports particularly on the smaller school districts because it we have an obligation to point that out but then as far as some of these districts sometimes it just comes down to the practicalities and not having enough money to hire enough people to segregate it as it should be done right which
is a contributing a contributor to the problem is the lack of funding of the district to have enough personnel in order to be able to have that established segregation of duties through through two separate people what's your school enrollment over there 356 356 okay all right thank you.
All right, Senator Chesterfield. Thank you Mr. Chair and thank you for coming this morning. The department has now placed the district in fiscal distress, correct? Have you worked with them then on the appropriate way due to in spite of the fiscal constraints? Because we know they don't have enough money and our funding formula is not such that it provides funding for adequate funding for those school districts with less than 500 students is that correct so what are we doing in order to help train our superintendents in the smaller school districts and the board on how we can better segregate those duties because it is something that is pervasive especially among those small districts with less money at the moment
we have a consulting group that is doing part of the duties and we are in the process of trying to find someone that is qualified to be the business manager there and once we have that person in place we will train them and then we will divide the duties out where they will not have that audit finding and we may have to even move some of those duties over to like school level secretaries you know the review process entering some of the information so that one person is not in control of anything so we'll have several steps and it will involve several people and as it is in small schools people that don't normally do some of the business office work will have to step up and take on some of those duties
I see I want to thank the superintendent it was not that long ago that the education committee came to marvel yes and we saw that the community was rallying around the school district as far as its academics were concerned and you had these wonderful summer programs that were moving apace. Are you still able to do some of that? Yes. And we appreciate you very, very much for it. Hopefully this new formula as far as the facilities is concerned will help you as well so that Marvel will continue to move forward. And I know that that would be of extreme help to you. Is that correct? Yes, it will be. great
you were to us during our visit there and we wish you well as you work with the State Department of Education to correct these issues thank you all right members any
committee well I just like to say it is with regret that we're here under this situation we are working very closely with the department and they are very helpful to us we hope that well we will come out of this and when we do come out of this we hope that it will be for the best all right well
thank you for your comments and thank you for coming and presenting and members I just will say on this this is one of these where obviously we need to thank the work and the diligence of the auditors and all those involved to make sure the integrity of the system and even in our school districts are in place and hopefully the personal response will be brought to justice so thank you for being here today you're dismissed members we're now to another report this is a report regarding the Turtle Creek Volunteer Fire Association And for that report, I believe that Jimmy Locke on staff will be presenting to us today. Mr.
Locke, you're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. The prosecuting attorney's office for the 22nd Judicial District asked us to review selected transactions of the Turtle Creek Volunteer Fire Association. They had received some allegations of improper cash withdrawals and other possible improper spending by the fire chief. The association located in Saline County was established as a non-profit corporation in 1976 and became an improvement district in 1978. They provide fire, rescue, and emergency medical services for area residents and businesses and are governed by a five-member board. In 2018, the Saline County judge appointed a new board because the previous board had been inactive for several years and the association basically operated with no oversight. personnel consists of approximately 26 firefighters who serve in a volunteer capacity and they have a paid bookkeeper funding consists primarily of improvement district assessments state aid and membership dues the association maintains two bank accounts the general fund and the fireman's fund and during our review period the general fund was maintained by the bookkeeper, and the fireman's fund was maintained by the fire chief. And then when discrepancies were found, the board dismissed both the fire chief and the bookkeeper. Our review revealed improper disbursements totaling $327,531. This included $309,000 in undocumented disbursements, $16,000 in non-business disbursements, and $1,500 in other questionable disbursements and these improper disbursements are summarized in exhibit one which is on page three of the report the undocumented disbursements included $207,106 in either undocumented or inadequately documented wages that were paid to the bookkeeper based on the $13 per hour wage that she was paying herself, the amount that she received equates to approximately 52 hours of work per week, which according to association personnel was extremely excessive. There's also $40,175 in undocumented payments to the fire chief, $25,450 in undocumented cash withdrawals by the fire chief. And then there were $500 in undocumented checks which were made payable to cash and endorsed by the fire chief. The non-business disbursements included $8,868 in personal purchases which were made using the debit card. And then there was $722 for repairs to an all-terrain vehicle that was owned by the fire chief. It was his personal ATV. And they also spent five thousand seven hundred and seventy five dollars on Christmas parties we also discovered altered financial records. The original allegations only involved withdrawals from the fireman's fund by the fire chief, but I also requested the records for the general fund, which was maintained by the bookkeeper, and it took her about three months to get the records to me, but when she finally did, while I was reviewing the bank statement copies that she had given me, I found numerous check images in which the payee had been altered. And I identified 136 altered check images that total $71,449. Of this, $69,797 were checks paid to the bookkeeper, $850 were checks paid to the fire chief, and $802 were checks paid to vendors for personal purchases. this is an example of one of the altered checks the check on the left is the copy that the bookkeeper provided to me it shows that check number 3247 was a $455 payment to JJ's truck stop which is where the department purchases fuel however the copy on the right is the one i got from the bank which shows that the check was actually a payment to the bookkeeper samantha blair
this is another one more example of an altar check it's the same type situation the check on the left or well the check that's up there is the check that was provided to me it shows that check number 3154 was a 481 payment to metropolitan fire however the copy that i got from the bank shows that this check was actually paid to miss blair as well and as i said i found 136 checks that had been altered like this and they totaled a little over 71 000 dollars our review also revealed several internal control deficiencies financial records were inadequate the Association did not receive annual financial audits as required by Saline County ordinance financial duties were not adequately segregated and the board did not provide adequate fiscal oversight so in summary our review revealed improper disbursements totaling 327-531, altered financial records, and several internal control deficiencies. As I mentioned earlier both the bookkeeper and the fire chief were dismissed by the board in 2018. Our report was forwarded to the prosecuting attorney and on March 27th of this year the former bookkeeper Samantha Blair was charged with theft of property forgery and falsifying business records and the former fire chief Jimmy Cooper was charged with theft of property
the report on page four it talks about obtaining financial audits annually as required by the saline county ordinance that financial audit was to be conducted by who it would be bad CPA firm of their choice and and then is that a criteria required only saline county or is that adapted throughout all 75 counties involving financial matters or do you know is that unique to us in Saline County or is that across the board it
was when the department was set up that was one of the requirements specifically related to Turtle Creek Fire Department in its organization okay and it was it could be conducted by
done with this one for you adjourn us out please oh yes certainly thank you we do have a couple things to handle anyway so thank you senator hammer members are any other questions at all on these reports Senator Sample, who
is, so you're now in Senator Sample's seat, okay. Representative Love. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is to the staff, because we've just now witnessed two institutions that are having the false checks. um mr norman is this something that i mean number one did are you all catching this or are the cpa firms catching this and referring this i'm trying to figure i'm trying to figure out if the cpa firms are not doing a a good job or like why are they not catching this sooner well it
that's a that's a kind of a difficult question to answer i mean we do the the bulk of you know the state agencies, and we do all the counties, most of the school districts, and 500 of the municipalities. I think we do a very excellent job. I can't really speak to the private CPA firms, but we do get records directly from the bank. I'm not, to my knowledge, CPA firms generally do not do that. Several years ago, it was, we ran into this same situations before check imaging, and where you would the checks would come back used to on the old IBM Selectric typewriters I don't know if if you know you may not remember those things they had a little ball thing on them where they would type them and that's what a lot of the the districts or people did their checks with they did them manually and you could actually take double-sided tape and roll across that and it would take that ink up, and somebody could go back and put something else on there. So we would get microfilm from the banks, a sample on every audit that we did, and look at that. When checks started going away and they were not returned, we had several concerns. One, if you can't see the back of the checks, you can't see where it went, you can't see the endorsements. And so we worked with the General Assembly and got a check imaging law passed for public funds and we had to work with the bankers association but it requires all public entities to get if if they're going to get images to get the fronts in the back of all the checks and send them back and we we work very closely with them over the years in fact a lot of them we're converting now to where they don't even send that to us we have a direct link through the banks where we can look at the public accounts and look at them online and do that but to answer your question when we audit an audit is based upon samples we don't look at we can't not look at every transaction but we do I think we do a wonderful job of knowing what to look for to know the schemes that are out there and how people go about manipulating these and funds but do we catch everything no but do we do a good job I think we do a very good job
but Well, I wasn't questioning the job that the legislative item was doing. I was just wondering, I mean, are the CPA firms, I mean, because these entities are getting an audit each year. Not by legislative audit, but just by a CPA firm. And so I'm wondering if CPA firms are not catching these things and if they're going on for... I could not answer that.
They are subject to the same auditing standards that we are. We probably go a little bit overboard on a lot of things that we do, materiality and risk or functions that they look at, but it's just like the comments that we had on segregation of duties. If you do not have adequate segregation of duties, then it opens the doors for a lot of mishandling of data and financial records where you could misappropriate assets of entities.
Representative Love, I'm just sitting here thinking myself, you know, with entities that I deal with. if a cpa firm that's working with you is only getting the actual statement that they've got what this person was doing where they were altering the checks that you were you'd be hard to catch some of that so if with the technology that is internal to the banks that you have now where you can get online i think having those two checks where you're getting the printed statement but you also have the the online access obviously having having all of that material together could help them but the the bottom line is how do you stop a criminal from doing what they're going to do and they keep trying to find ways around that and so it's troubling i've got a bunch of people that have chimed in here we're at the end of this so i don't know what all these questions are but we're going to try to take them and you get one shot each okay Representative Rye, you're recognized, sir. Thank you so much.
And I want to say this much about Roger and the way that he operates his business. First of all, I don't see that it can be done any better than what it is. Now, saying this, there are a lot of different situations out there that we do not have enough help to actually do this and do it in a proper manner. You know, Roger, you and I have talked about this before. and we won't bring this up as far as who we're trying to nail but I'll say this much there are different agencies out there y'all that through the last 30 and 40 years have not actually given an audit report you know and that's a bad thing And the reason for that is not Roger's fault. It's because he does not have enough help to do these things that he needs to be able to do. So, I mean, I want to pitch that in because I'll guarantee you one thing. This man right here knows what he's doing. I appreciate
that, Mr. Rye. I'd just like to say of those entities that we are required to audit, I feel like we do a very good job. However, there are a lot of entities that are not subject to audit by us, and our manpower would have to be increased substantially if we looked at all the improvement districts and various other aspects of public or semi-public money in the state. Okay, thank you. Representative Kelly. Thank you, sir. Mr. Logg, this
question is to you. during the investigation during the audit did you was there any is samantha blair the bookkeeper and the fire chief jimmy cooper are they related
button and you should be able to go now okay sorry I see that I know that we there was something the the chief and the bookkeeper were held accountable but I also read in here where there was poor oversight by the board was there anything or any conversation any accountability held to the board who was supposed to provide oversight to the chief and the bookkeeper mr norman or lock
right there there was a board on paper but i think some of them i don't think are even living anymore so i mean they weren't they weren't meeting and there wasn't any control your ultimate yes man represented richardson until until the saline county judge appointed this new board and they're the ones that discovered there were problems and got the investigation started all right senator
frustrations on a lot of this. I had a conversation with Senator Cooper yesterday about this, and I used the analogy of if every now and then the state police didn't set a radar trap out on 630, people would be driving 100 miles an hour down that freeway. And I realize they can't catch every speeder, and they do a good job, and I think that's analogous to the job that Mr. Norman and his staff do, as well as the CPAs that are out there doing these audits but it is kind of a spot check but the fact that there's a chance that you'll get pulled over for speeding or chance you'll get caught like we've seen this criminality today is the real deterrent that that cuts us back the problem I'm concerned about and I don't have anything statistically when I first you know was assigned to this committee one of the first things I did was go talked to Judge Airy about how, I'm talking about Frank Airy, former Judge Airy, about how this was dealt with by prosecutors. And while I don't have a solution at this point, I do want to help us define a problem. A problem is if we call our prosecuting attorneys the radar police, then we don't have enough radar police pulling people over, writing them tickets. We need, we know everyone can't be prosecuted. We know every case can't be taken to the extreme, but if the criminals see other people doing things like this that are convicted and go to jail more often than we've seen lately or in the last few years, then we'll have, I think, a little bit better compliance. Now, I've used a thing that life's a series of incentives and disincentives, and that could be a major disincentive for people to do wrong. And I don't, again, I don't have an answer. Maybe we should speak to our prosecutor coordinator's office about some understanding of just like Mr. Norman would have someone spot check a particular situation. Well, then maybe they need to spot check some of these referrals and say, you know, this is not one we'd normally do, But this is a street that's got too many speeders, and we need to put radar out there every now and then. So that's really all I've got to say about that, Mr. Chairman. I have more
questions than answers, I'm afraid. Thank you. I'm going to take one more general question here, and then I'm going to recognize Senator Hammer. And we actually
do have an item under new business we need to handle, so please don't run off. Representative Servillo, you're recognized, sir. mr norman thank you mr chair mr norman how many of these findings come from whistleblowers and is there any incentives that could be given for um whistleblowers to be able to identify or at least let you know that there is an opportunity out there i obviously i think that uh if you if you have a whistleblower or some informant that's that's probably the the the best way it certainly saves us a lot of time um a percentage wise i i don't know i it would be less than half well less than half maybe 25 percent from something like that as far as a whistleblower there is a whistleblower law in the state it's my understanding that there's recently been some legislation dealing with that in the in the treasurer's office so I'm not for sure what impact that will have on the whistleblower law in the future and if that needs to be looked at Now, you just
It was a court action. That's right. Court action is what it was, dealing with the sovereign immunity. That's right. Well, that's something that we definitely look at. I will encourage members, if you haven't been to the Legislative Audit website, it does actually list the Whistleblower Protection Act. and that might be something nice to share with your constituencies just to let them know and encourage them that if they see something wrong there is protection there for them from punitive action against them if they are to report so that's a great question representative servilo senator hammer you recognize sir thank you
mr chair um we haven't voted to review this report right or actually it's not required for these required it's just filed yes sir it will be Okay, here's here's my question on the Turtle Creek Fire Department. That was a private audit and the question is why didn't the private auditor catch it and maybe you hit on this a while ago Miss Norman But then with the Marvel School District, that's an entity that's being audited by Legislative audit on an ongoing basis and I guess what amazes me is that that individual could You know embezzled nearly four hundred thousand dollars and get it in her personal account and that not come above the radar screen as far as Maybe being something that a sample should have caught Help me educate help educate me as to why in the Marvel School District the Legislative audit did not pick up the fact that that lady was writing the checks in her name and depositing them into her account and that wasn't detected sooner than it was given the course of time that it occurred over okay
going back to your your some of your first comments as far as the audit that was one of the problems with the Turtle Creek is they were not getting an audit by a private or anyone okay and so we were requested by the prosecuting attorney to go in and look at that okay all right as far as of on the Marvel School District again it did not come up in our samples that we were looking at if you looked at if you look it's like anything else if you looked at at the documentation that she had in there it all looked like it was legitimate however the only way you could catch it is to go back and look at the records at the bank right that was the only key that we had to to uh identify that we we uh uh some of our suspicions were raised and we dug in and and uh dug a little deeper and once we started pulling that and identified it then then we could see the scheme easily but unless it comes up in a sample unless you look at every transaction all the documentation was there and appeared to be correct the only way you could have called it is to go back and and look at the actual check that was being sent back from the bank because she was taking those images and manipulating them once they came back to the district if the bank statements were being opened by someone other than her then that should have sent up a red flag because there were checks in there that were payable to her for several thousands of dollars each time and and
not part of we do look at the bank statements these are the statements that it's just like on on your personal account if you get them if they get them back if the used to the banks and they still do on these entities they'll send them back so that's what we look at however we do sample we do a sample where we go in and look at the statements and and look at the the the records at the bank and compare those and this did not come up until this time once we i believe in this particular case this individual was out and the school district opened the bank statements and and saw that and that was one of the ways
that we called it okay very good members speaking of all the questions and prompting and when requests are made yesterday I received a letter from Senator Sample that he requests a legislative audit of the financial records for the Arkansas school for mathematics sciences and the arts at 200 whittington avenue in hot springs arkansas i consulted with co-chair and with the staff and we want to bring this before you today because as you see under other business we're not scheduled to meet again until september the 12th and 13th of 2019 or the call of the chairs being the case we wanted to bring this before you today and let let you know that this request has been made there's been some issues that's been brought forward and they would like to have this looked at and so I want to yield to my co-chair who actually had mentioned this issue to me previously and what we're looking for is a motion to proceed legislative audit to look into this matter. Thank you
Mr. Chair. I just wanted to mention the committee that I talked to several legislators from Garland County previously about this and I thought another one or two was going to be able to be here today to discuss this but for whatever reason that hasn't happened and there are a number of issues out there and it comes from several different representatives in several different parts of the country over there. So with that Mr. Chair I'd like to make a motion for legislative audit to review the financial transactions of the Arkansas School for Mathematics, Science and the Arts including any non-profits associated with the school if deemed necessary by audit for compliance with state laws and prepare a report to be presented to the legislative audit committee. That's a
proper motion to have a second. Second. Have a second. Senator Johnson. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed, no. Members, that concludes all of our business for today and make good note of that that September we have legislative conferences and we typically yield for July and August. Thank you for your time and your work and have a good afternoon. We're adjourned.
The executive committee report was presented by Representative Richard Womack, noting staff-review approvals for the Pharmacy Benefit Manager program and an audit of Covenant Keepers College Preparatory Charter School, and the committee adopted the report by unanimous voice vote.
[6:57][7:13][7:43][7:51]
Senator John Cooper reported that the Town of Sunset is in substantial compliance with the municipal accounting law and recommended notifying the state treasurer so the town may receive turn-back monies; he also summarized the handling of deferred and current reports, filing 161 reports and moving to adopt the committee’s findings.
[8:14][9:02][9:37]
During a brief discussion, Representative David Fielding and Senator Jimmy Hickey asked whether forfeited turn-back funds could be recovered, and staff counsel confirmed that the funds are forfeited and cannot be retrieved.
[9:52][10:07][10:16][10:22][10:32][10:40][11:11][11:20]
Reports on educational institutions by Representative Stan Berry and on state agencies by Representative Nelda Speaks were each adopted after motions and seconds from Senator Cooper, with unanimous aye votes recorded.
[13:27][14:01][14:32][15:04][15:28][15:34][16:09][16:43][16:54][17:09]
The audit staff presented the Marvel School District audit, noting two management-letter findings (an unregistered $200,000 modular-building contract and untimely federal tax deposits) and two financial-statement findings, including a repeat lack of segregation of duties that allowed the bookkeeper to issue 90 unauthorized checks totaling almost $472,000 and led the board to declare fiscal distress after a $1.6 million drawdown since 2016.
[19:01][19:35][20:05][20:39][21:14][21:49][22:23][22:57][23:27]
F. Other Business: The next meetings of the Legislative Joint Auditing Committee will be held on September 12 and 13, 2019, or at the call of the Chairs.
Representative Richard Womack moved that the Legislative Joint Auditing Committee conduct a legislative audit of the Arkansas School for Mathematics, Science and the Arts and any associated non-profits to review their financial transactions for compliance with state law.
[1:11:02][1:11:33]
Senator Jason Rapert called for a second to the motion, which was provided by Senator Johnson, and the committee voted unanimously in favor, with all members saying “aye” and no opposition recorded.
[1:11:42]
The motion was adopted, directing the audit and the preparation of a report to be presented to the legislative audit committee.
[1:11:42]