May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 8, 2026
The committee was called to order, adopted the minutes, and filed the agenda reports by unanimous consent.
[0:00][0:44]
The chair noted that the meeting was light, with nine reports on the agenda, seven of which contained no findings.
[0:30]
The first report with findings concerned the Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality (ADEQ) audit, which identified three deficiencies: inadequate cash-transaction controls, improper use of a deputy director’s P-card, and illegible or missing canceled-check images.
[1:01][1:10][1:42]
ADEQ’s director, Becky Keogh, testified that the agency had made personnel changes, placed a chief compliance officer over fiscal and HR functions, and instituted new internal-control procedures and staff training to address the audit issues.
[2:48][3:21][3:57]
Senator Jimmy Hickey questioned how ADEQ corrected the cash-control problem, and the agency explained that it separated check-signing and reconciliation duties among designated employees, which satisfied compliance requirements.
[4:41][4:59]
Hickey also asked about the missing check images, and ADEQ confirmed it was working with the bank to obtain proper statements.
[5:15][5:52]
The committee then moved to the Southeast Arkansas Economic Development District report, which contained a single finding of a federal procurement violation that raised approximately $150,000 in questionable costs from a $3.1 million grant.
[6:13][6:46]
The district’s executive director, Patricia Hargrove, said the procurement process had been revised and that they were collaborating with the Department of Workforce Services (DWS) to resolve the issue.
[7:38][7:56]
DWS’s internal-audit director, Tanya Plunkett, explained that staff were reviewing 2014-2015 expenditures to separate eligible federal costs from administrative expenses and to determine the final amount owed.
[10:06][11:38][11:55]
Senators Hickey and Garner pressed for clarification on whether the $150,000 would need to be repaid, and DWS indicated that a resolution was pending and that they hoped the amount could be mitigated without repayment.
[8:27][9:41][13:03]
The committee adopted a motion to follow up on the SE Arkansas district issue before the next meeting scheduled for September 12 and to file the reports as presented.
[15:39][15:59][16:09]
The meeting concluded with a moment of prayer for the late Senator Linda Collins-Smith and recognition of John Moore’s retirement after 38 years of service.
[16:09][17:10][17:14][17:48]
we're going to call this meeting to order the adoption of the minutes do i hear us okay cecile a second okay all in favor say aye any opposed the review of the reports mr tom i thank you madam chair
We've got kind of a light meeting today. We've only got nine reports on the agenda today. Seven of those reports don't have any findings, and they're listed starting on the audit summary beginning on page
Thank you, Madam Chair. Our first report with findings is the Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality June 30, 2018 report, and this report has three audit findings. The first finding, the agency had inadequate control over cash transactions. Specifically, there was one employee who's the primary writer and signer of checks who also reconciles the bank statements, while there was another employee who signed checks and also reviewed and approved the monthly reconciliations. The second finding, a P-card that was issued to a deputy director was improperly checked out and used by various employees while the deputy director was employed at the agency and after she took another job. And the third finding, according to Arkansas Code, canceled check copies or digital images of financial transactions must be legible and show both the front and back of the checks. If the financial institution provides a canceled check images on paper, the images must be of such clarity and size that the details may be read without a magnifying glass. Bank statements for the AC's impressed account included only the front images of the checks, and these images were smaller than original size and not easily legible. Bank statements for the AC's special account did not include any images of canceled checks. And that concludes our findings for environmental equality.
Sure. This is Becky Keogh. I'm Becky Keogh. I'm the director of the Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality. Good afternoon. I've got Michael Bynum, our Chief Compliance Officer with us, and Michael Grape, our Special Projects Manager, who works with you often on legislative affairs. So just wanted to briefly let you know, we have reviewed these audit findings and take them very seriously. We've taken deliberate and quick corrective actions to resolve any of these findings. What you may not know, ADQ has made some personnel changes related to that, including putting Michael Bynum in place as our chief compliance officer, moving our fiscal and HR teams under Michael with his knowledge. And we are transforming our fiscal and procurement processes through his leadership to ensure that we do remain compliant with all our state fiscal laws and generally accepted accounting principles. ADQ reorganized this team through his leadership and through my direction and has emphasized the importance of not only DF&A regulations but other regulations or federal restrictions that we work under with our financial dollars. The fiscal team and management have been strengthening internal controls as described here in process through additional staff training and implementation of several new processes, as well as having frequent consultation with DF&A through this process. And with any, if you have any specific questions about that, we can ask Michael to respond to those questions, or I'll
Mr. Hickey. Yes, just, oh, I was planning number one. How exactly did y'all correct that? I heard you say that you ought to put some measures in place, but how did you make it so that those employees would be not so that you wouldn't have the same issue?
Sure, I'd be glad to answer that. We have designated employees who are authorized to approve and to sign checks. We then have separate designated employees that perform the reconciliations and the review of those checks. Okay. And that was enough to make you compliant for the
next one with audit? That's exactly the way you needed to do it? Yes, Senator. Yes, sir. All right. And then as far as the copies of the checks, was that because of the bank statement that you had? They were just giving you the printout of what it was but was not actually giving you the copies. Is that correct? That's correct. Okay. Have you already discussed that with the bank just to see if you're going to be able to get that type of
statement? Yes, sir. we are starting to get those statements now okay that's all i thank you i believe you miss okay any other questions do we have a motion to file this okay okay all in favor or do you have a second i'm sorry we need a second okay and all in favor aye any opposed okay thank you
All right, thank you. Our next report is the Southeast Arkansas Economic Development District, June 30, 2018 report, and this report contains one finding. I'd also say that this report was audited by a private CPA firm. Legislative audit did not perform this audit. An ongoing investigation by a state agency, in this case I think it was Department of Workforce Services, was monitoring the Workforce Innovation Opportunity Act federal program for the 2014 and 15 program years. And they had a finding in their report that there was a violation of federal procurement requirements resulting in question costs totaling about $3.1 million. And our discussions with the Department of Workforce Services during this process come to find out that the $3.1 million, I believe, and the AC can kind of allude to this when they come up, but I believe the $3.1 million was the whole grant. There was really about $150,000 of question costs involved in that, and that concludes
table? Give us your name, please. Good afternoon. I'm Patricia Hargrove. i'm executive director for southeast arkansas economic development district and i have peyton burgess he she is our director of finance and h and hr for the district um yes we have put in place um some procurement what we have changed our procurement process this is something that happened years ago prior to us being at our positions We are working with ADWS on correcting this issue. In fact, they were in our office yesterday, and will be back in our office tomorrow to go over the expenditures. So we think we're going to have a quick resolution on this.
um we heard there that the actual amount in question is 150 000 is that correct yes okay in your conversations are you going to have to pay that back or is there going to be some resolution so that you do not have to pay that money
back since it's in question or what where we at with that part of it i think it's going to be resolved i think in their reviewing that information the expenditures in relationship to that 150 um that it was um there were costs that were were just they weren't um hopefully we will not have an issue with that 150 000.
process of them reviewing our information. And hopefully that will not take place, but what if it does? Do you have the cash available, or how would you do that
have you asked that question no i have not i have not senator hickey we have people from dws i'm going to call to the table i think we'll be able to answer this a little bit more detail they're the one who did the audit and are working with the planning district thank you senator with With the representatives from DWS, please come to the front, please.
the record. Yes, I'm Tanya Plunkett, and I'm the Director of Internal Audit and Financial Monitoring at DWS. We are currently, as Patricia referred to just a minute ago, the Executive Director, we are working with them to arrive at the amount. Yesterday, we had two staff down there, and they're going to be there in the morning to try to segregate these calls back in 2014 and 2015.
question it? Uh, there was, um, one, one of the officials was too closely involved in the procurement of the one-stop. Okay. And so, therefore, we're trying to separate out those costs to mitigate this down. We did go ahead and question the full amount, but we're trying to decide what was actually eligible expenditures that were federal monies that were actually spent for all the participants and what was admin. Okay. We're having a hard time hearing you. Can you
or what? No, they helped. This is brand new where the procurement of a one-stop operator, this is new with the new Workforce Innovation Act and Opportunity act and this was brand new that they had to procure the services and he was very closely involved with right helping write that up okay that was the issue that arose okay are they in danger of having to pay this back or do we know that yet have we got that far
Chair. So it sounds like to me that y'all are having negotiations right now on the number and trying to get this fixed. And you anticipate that between both
Representative Richardson. Thank you, Madam Chair. Just clarity. The dates that the amount is in question was before you guys were in position, correct?
I'm not aware if they are or not. I don't know that we've checked on that. Since it was a private audit, we really didn't have any names that we could really follow up
anything personally? No. thank you no it was just the involvement and it was this was also brand new and you know that he should not have helped write this that then they turned around and okay i just wanted to make 100
it would have to be with non-federal funds okay okay thank you representative sorella um thank you madam chair um you said mitigate are you trying to mitigate all 150 are you are you um confident that that
for that just uh and we can do that just kind of before we have our next meeting in september we can kind of follow up and see what the resolution was and just share that with the committee if that's what you'd like to do if you make a
motion to that effect we'll do that okay i'll i'll make that motion okay it sounds like we have a motion it's all okay all in favor okay no other questions we thank you coming okay we'll make a motion to file this okay second all in favor okay that we have our new business we will not be meeting until September the 12th and I I want to take this, at this time, a time for our Senator Linda Collins-Smith and her death. We take a few minutes just to pray for her. Okay. Silence. This concludes our meeting. Okay. Sorry. I'm sorry. Don't need to turn it back. Okay. Tom. Mr. Tom. Thank you, Madam Chair. I'd just like to take this moment to recognize if any
of you were in the executive committee tomorrow, you all know that John Moore will be retiring after 38 years with audit, and he's been doing this committee for about eight years or more, a long time. He had some of you as his chairs when he was here, and he's done a really great job, and I'm hoping I can follow in his footsteps and