March 19, 2019·15 Minutes Upon Adjournment·Room 130·2:42:15
VideoTranscript
Summary
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 10, 2026
HB1775 Bentley TO CREATE THE EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES FOR ABLE-BODIED ADULTS ACT OF 2019. 0:50
Representative Mary Bentley introduced HB 1775, explaining that the bill would expand work-requirement and mandatory employment-training provisions to able-bodied SNAP adults with school-aged children in order to lift families out of generational poverty and create new jobs.
[1:38][2:06][2:39][3:12][3:44]
Department of Human Services Director Mary Franklin clarified that the current SNAP work requirement applies only to childless adults and that participation in employment-training is presently voluntary, answering Rep. Kenneth Ferguson’s questions about how the bill would make the training component mandatory.
[4:14][4:58][5:31][5:48][5:55][6:02][6:09][6:51][6:57][7:20][7:25][7:40][7:50][7:53][8:05][8:24][8:56]
Following testimony from both opponents (Arkansas Hunger Relief Alliance) and supporters (Nick Horton), the chair moved to adopt the amendment and then to pass the bill as amended; both motions carried unanimously and the committee reported HB 1775 passed.
[1:20][1:34][34:39][34:43]
HB1710 Perry TO CREATE THE TASK FORCE ON TRANSPORTATION OF NON EMERGENCY BEHAVIORAL HEALTH PATIENTS. 35:44
The bill was introduced by Representative Mark Perry, who explained that HB 1710 would create a cost-free task force, coordinated through the health department, to address non-emergency transportation of behavioral-health patients.
[36:12][36:23][36:57][37:28][38:02]
Representative Karilyn Brown testified that EMS agencies are strained by improper non-emergency transports, lack police authority to retain patients, and risk losing critical emergency resources, underscoring the need for statewide protocols.
[38:39][39:24][39:55][40:29][41:00]
HB1719 M. Gray TO UPDATE THE MEDICAID FRAUD ACT AND THE MEDICAID FRAUD FALSE CLAIMS ACT TO ADDRESS FLAWS IDENTIFIED IN RECENT INVESTIGATIONS AND CHANGES RELATE… 51:14
Representatives Kenneth Ferguson and Brad Nye presented HB 1719, noting it updates the Medicaid Fraud Act, the Medicaid Fraud False Claims Act, and adult-abuse penalties, and expands record-keeping requirements to include managed-care entities.
[51:28][51:56][52:02][52:34][53:13]
Testimony highlighted specific changes such as broadening “health care provider” language, adjusting civil-penalty ranges, and permitting the state to reimburse managed-care organizations when they are innocent victims of fraud.
[53:52][54:13][54:34][54:47][55:02][55:21][55:45]
Representative Jeff Wardlaw asked whether the bill would reinstate a controversial contractor contingency-fee provision; staff clarified that the legislation does not create such fees.
[56:18][56:29][56:58][57:02][57:29][57:36]
After brief discussion, the committee moved a motion to pass the bill as amended, which carried unanimously.
[58:59][59:10][59:18]
SB3 T. Garner TO REQUIRE ADDITIONAL REPORTING REQUIREMENTS BY CERTAIN PHYSICIANS AND HEALTHCARE FACILITIES FOR ABORTION COMPLICATIONS. 59:58
Representative Lee Johnson introduced SB 3, proposing that schools be permitted to stock albuterol inhalers under the same protocol used for epinephrine pens to treat asthma or allergic-related bronchospasm.
[1:00:19][1:00:26][1:00:44][1:00:52][1:01:24]
A motion to pass the bill as amended was made and approved by unanimous voice vote.
[1:02:37][1:03:02]
HR1047 Watson TO RECOGNIZE THE IMPORTANCE AND NEED FOR QUICK ACCESS TO AUTOMATED EXTERNAL DEFIBRILLATORS. 1:09:16
Representative Danny Watson presented HR 1047, a resolution urging greater awareness and access to automated external defibrillators (AEDs) in schools, citing survival benefits and a recent local incident.
[1:09:19][1:09:59][1:10:29]
After brief supportive comments and no questions from the chair, Watson moved to approve the resolution.
[1:11:14][1:11:36][1:11:41]
The motion was seconded, passed unanimously, and the resolution was adopted.
[1:11:59][1:12:06]
HB1568 L. Johnson TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS ADVISORY COUNCIL OF HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONS WITHIN THE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH. 1:12:55
Representative Lee Johnson described HB 1568, which would establish an Arkansas Advisory Council of Healthcare Professions within the Department of Health to gather scope-of-practice information and facilitate stakeholder dialogue, include a sunset provision in 2021, and incur no additional cost.
[1:13:16][1:13:51][1:14:09][1:14:26][1:14:41][1:15:02]
Committee members queried the cost and the role of the Surgeon General; staff confirmed funding would come from existing appropriations and the Surgeon General would serve as a non-voting, unbiased member.
[1:15:44][1:15:50][1:15:58][1:16:01][1:16:05][1:16:13]
With no further testimony, the committee moved a motion to adopt the amendments and pass the bill as amended, which carried unanimously.
[1:16:39][1:16:54][1:17:13][1:17:23]
HB1309 S. Meeks TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS NIGHTTIME ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION ACT. 1:18:06
Representative Jeff Wardlaw presented HB 1309, proposing to rename the Shielded Outdoor Lighting Act as the Arkansas Nighttime Environment Protection Act, update definitions, replace the 150-watt standard with a 1,800-lumen threshold and require new bulbs to be 4,000 K or warmer to curb blue-rich light exposure.
[1:18:24][1:18:56][1:19:26][1:19:56][1:20:31][1:21:04][1:21:40]
He detailed revisions to exemptions-including a cost-prohibitive benchmark, adding watercraft and highway construction lighting, removing school exemptions, expanding corrections and historic-monument allowances, and initially retaining a billboard provision that he later agreed to withdraw.
[1:22:11][1:22:47][1:23:18][1:23:51][1:24:22][1:24:54][1:25:28][1:26:03][1:26:35]
Committee members queried the grandfather-clause extension, energy-savings potential, compatible bulb types, and enforcement mechanisms; Wardlaw answered that changes would be phased in, could save municipalities hundreds of thousands annually, and would be enforced by local code officers.
[1:27:21][1:27:37][1:27:45][1:28:07][1:28:34][1:28:39][1:28:43][1:28:49][1:29:01][1:29:12]
HB1803 F. Allen TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS BLUE RIBBON PANEL ON PEDIATRIC CANCER RESEARCH. 1:39:42
Representative Fred Allen moved an amendment to HB 1803 creating the Arkansas Blue Ribbon Panel on pediatric cancer research, adding specific members, duties for the Department of Health, and provisions for staff and funding.
[1:39:51][1:39:58][1:40:04][1:40:25][1:40:32][1:41:11]
The amendment was seconded by Representative Payton and adopted without debate, as recorded by the chair.
[1:41:37][1:41:41]
Testimony from Michael Keck of the American Cancer Society explained that the panel would coordinate state efforts with the federal STAR Act, work with UAMS, and help secure future grant opportunities.
[1:43:05][1:43:19][1:43:50]
HB1801 L. Johnson TO REQUIRE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO COVER AN ADDITIONAL ALBUTEROL INHALER FOR CERTAIN MEDICAID BENEFICIARIES. 1:50:35
Representative Lee Johnson introduced HB 1801, which requires Arkansas Medicaid to provide an additional albuterol inhaler each August for children under 18 who already have a prescription, to ensure a spare inhaler is available at school.
[1:50:57]
No members sought further discussion; the chair called for a motion, Representative Johnson moved to pass the bill, and the motion carried unanimously.
[1:51:29][1:51:49][1:51:52][1:52:06]
SB273 Bledsoe TO CLARIFY THAT AN EXPERT WITNESS ACTING ON BEHALF OF A BOARD OF ANY PROFESSION OR OCCUPATION CLASSIFIED UNDER THE LAWS OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS … 1:52:54
Representative Lee Johnson presented an amendment to SB 273 clarifying that expert witnesses testifying before a professional board receive the same immunity as board members, after consulting with attorneys to refine the language.
[1:53:09][1:53:42]
The amendment was seconded by Representative Boyd and adopted without opposition.
[1:54:07][1:54:15]
Following additional explanation of the bill’s purpose, the committee voted to pass SB 273 as amended, and the motion was carried unanimously.
[1:54:49][1:55:20]
SB190 G. Leding TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS GENETIC COUNSELOR LICENSURE ACT. 1:55:40
Representative Lee Johnson introduced SB 190 and its engrossed amendments (SB 190 S1 and S2) that clarify genetic-counselor responsibilities and exclude nutritionists, and the chair adopted the amendment after a motion by Rep. Deborah Ferguson.
[1:55:51][1:56:22][1:56:56][1:57:09][1:57:27]
HB1761 Crawford TO CREATE THE EGG PROVIDER PROTECTION ACT. 2:26:48
Rep. Cindy Crawford introduced HB 1761, the Egg Provider Protection Act, which would prohibit payment for unfertilized human eggs while permitting reimbursement for reasonable expenses, requiring physician-performed retrievals, and preserving fertility-treatment donations.
[2:26:50][2:27:28][2:27:59][2:28:31][2:29:01][2:29:33]
During debate, Rep. Kenneth Ferguson argued that the ban on compensation ignores donors’ costs and hardships and urged allowance for research-related payments, and Rep. Mary Bentley, a surrogate mother, also opposed the bill on the basis of the procedure’s difficulty.
[2:31:23][2:31:46][2:32:34][2:33:07][2:33:12][2:33:22][2:33:34][2:33:40][2:34:12]
HB1827 D. Ferguson TO REPEAL THE LAW REGARDING THE ARKANSAS NEWSPAPER RECYCLING ADVISORY COMMITTEE. 2:38:04
Rep. Kenneth B. Ferguson presented HB 1827, which would repeal the Arkansas Newspaper Recycling Advisory Committee, noting the board is no longer used.
[2:38:07]
A motion to do pass the bill was offered by Rep. Wardlaw, no members spoke for or against, and the motion carried unanimously, resulting in the bill’s passage.
[2:38:25][2:38:38]
HB1856 Dotson TO PROHIBIT STATE AGENCIES FROM ENGAGING IN THE DECISION-MAKING FOR AN INDIVIDUAL IN THE CUSTODY OF THE STATE REGARDING THE TERMINATION OF A PREG… 2:39:26
Rep. Jim Dotson introduced HB 1856, amended to prohibit state agencies from funding or assisting a person in state custody or guardianship in obtaining a pregnancy termination, adding language to align with federal law.
[2:39:31][2:39:38][2:39:47][2:40:20][2:40:24][2:40:40][2:40:59]
The committee adopted the amendment without objection after a motion by Rep. Wardlaw, then moved to do pass the bill as amended; that motion also carried unanimously, leading to the bill’s final approval and the committee’s adjournment.
[2:40:24][2:40:40][2:40:59][2:41:30][2:42:01]
Chair sees a quorum. If there's anyone here in the audience who wants to speak for or against the bill that's on the agenda, please come up and sign up to speak. Members, the food will be here at 5.30. So what we're going to do is around that time we'll call a short recess for you to get up and get your food, come back to your seats, and then we'll continue on. So that should be around 5.30. So we're going to go ahead and get started. And Representative Bentley, are you ready to run HB 1775? You're recognized. Thank you, Chairman. We do have an amendment on
Is there a motion on the amendment? Representative Coleman, motion do pass or do adopt the amendment. Any discussion on the motion to adopt the amendment? Seeing none, all in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. Motion carries. Your amendment is adopted. Present your bill as amended. Thank
you, Chairman. Thank you, Committee. Colleagues, currently in Arkansas, more than one in four children are living in poverty. More than half of our counties have persistent poverty. My own county, Perry County, has 70% of its residents on some type of government assistance. Too many of our families are trapped in poverty for generations, and I believe it's time for us to take a hard look at what we can do differently so that we truly are giving folks a hand up and not just a hand out. Work requirements are a proven way to help individuals increase their incomes and improve their lives, and that is why I bring you HB 1775 today to employ its enhancement opportunities for able-bodied working-age adults that are on SNAP. If you guys look at the bill, Arkansas has made great strides in promoting work for able-bodied adults across public assistance programs. Arkansas could continue those initiatives by further creating opportunities and spurring economic development through workforce. Currently, Arkansas provides SNAP benefits to 123,000 able-bodied adults without young children. Under federal law, Arkansas has the opportunity to increase employment and training programs without applying for an extra waiver. right now we have 32,600 open jobs and this next year 2019 we're projected to create 166,000 jobs is my intent with this bill to increase employment and self-sufficiency among able-bodied adults who are receiving SNAP benefits and to pull all of our families out of generational poverty if you look at this bill it's going to take three years from now I've been working with DHS extensively on their to they're putting in a whole new SNAP program so when working with them and giving a three-year time limit to implement this. And what we're doing now in simple terms, if you do not have any, if you have an able-bodied adult receiving SNAP benefits and you do not have any children, then you're required to go to employment and training. This simply says if you're a parent who has children that are school age, that we're going to also ask you to go to employment and training and get yourself a job and help you to get a job through those activities through employment training and workfare. So it's increasing the amount of folks that will be apply to those. Right now it's a volunteer. They can do it as well. But now we're just saying those kids, people that have children that are school-age kids, they're not at home. They're not preschoolers that they would go into work training through employment and training. So if you guys have some questions on that, I'll be happy to take
Ferguson, you're recognized. I guess, is there someone from DHS here? I thought we already had a work requirement in SNAP. I'm sure Mary Franklin's here, yeah.
Please identify yourself. Good afternoon. I'm Mary Franklin with the Department of Human Services, Director of the Division of County Operations. And yes, Representative. Yeah, explain the existing program. The SNAP program has a work requirement component at this time, and it applies to able-bodied adults without dependents. And what that means is able-bodied adults without dependents must be working or compliant with the work requirement, or they will lose their benefits. So they have three months in a 36-month period to not be compliant, and then after that three months, they are ineligible to receive SNAP for the balance of 36 months unless they become exempt or they go to work or come back into compliance with the program, and then they can come back to the program. So that's how the program works now. And we do have SNAP employment and training as a part of SNAP now, But participating in SNAP employment and training is not mandatory. It's voluntary at this point. So those able-bodied adults who have a work requirement, they can choose to meet it by participating in SNAP employment and training, or they can do other things. So that's the difference that's here. So I guess I'm confused.
to say? So this bill would make participating in SNAP employment and training mandatory. There will still be a work requirement, but participating in SNAP employment and training will also be required. May
I ask a follow-up? Yes, you can have a follow-up. Okay, let's go back and enlighten you a little bit. When you implemented the work for SNAP, what, a couple years
ago, how many participants did you lose in the program? we implemented the work requirement in SNAP in beginning in January of 2016 I don't have specific numbers of how many we lost to specifically to work requirement in SNAP what I can tell you is that we average about 4,000 a little over 4,000 able-bodied adults without dependents in any given month in SNAP at this
Thank you, Mr. Chair. So we have a work requirement now, and what we're adding to this is also an employment and training program is it my i'm a little confused if you're not working we want you to try to
go to some employment and training there's a lot of different options in there or work fair so if you're working then you're not required to go to work you're not going to try to do employment training
you're not working? I guess I'm confused if we already have a work requirement. The work requirement stands alone, separate from SNAP employment or SNAP education and training. The work requirement, it requires us to keep track of able-bodied adults without dependents and whether or not they are working or have an exemption that allows them not to work and receive benefits at the same time. And the way that works is they have three months to not be in compliance or meet an exemption out of a 36-month period. That's how the federal rules work for SNAP work requirement. SNAP Education and Training or Employment and Training is a program that exists to assist SNAP recipients to increase their education and skills and their training so that they can attain better jobs or obtain a job if they don't have a job because they've increased their skills and education. So SNAP employment and training is available now for able-bodied adults to use to help them do that, to help them meet the requirement. In fact, participating in SNAP employment and training, it meets the requirement for the SNAP work requirement. That's one way someone who can meet the requirement in addition to being employed and other things. What this would do is make participating in SNAP employment and training also a requirement. So there would still be a work requirement, but this would also be a requirement for people to participate in our program to help them increase their skills and improve their education and training with the ultimate goal of helping them to become more self-sufficient. Even if
Brown, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just want to make sure I understood what you said already. You said prior to the work requirement, if I'm understanding correct, that we had 20,000 able-bodied people receiving SNAP benefits every month, and now we have 4,000 able-bodied. We're just talking about the able-bodied population. Okay, thank
The SNAP Employment and Training Program is administered through DHS. We have several providers that actually provide the services that we contract with or sub-grant to. So we would make referrals to those providers who would provide the employment and training services. Like, I mean, give me an example. Who are they? Department of Career Education is one of our providers. Our house here locally is a provider. Northeast Arkansas Community College. We have some others that don't necessarily cover the entire state, but parts of the state. But career education serves the majority of our counties in our current program. Well, I
mean, everybody's for personal responsibility and putting people to work. But my concern with all this, particularly SNAP from the beginning, is that DHS has seemed incapable of administering and facilitating the work aspect of this program. I guess I need some assurance that some of that's changed since 2016. Explain to me how this is going to make things any better and we're going to actually facilitate helping
people get jobs. I think that's why we're giving this a three-year time frame because they're working on redoing their whole entire system. And so that's why they're going to give to us here, to our committee, reports annually on how they're progressing in the next three years to get themselves ready to
um representative bentley yes now we're talking about 4 000 able-bodied people or 20 000 able-bodied people would be applicable to your bill anybody there's i don't even know the exact
number because i'm not working in the department but there's those that are currently able-bodied adults in and there's lots of exemptions that I'm not privy to, but those that are able-bodied adults with school-aged children are the ones that we're talking about with this bill. Okay. Let me have
one follow-up, and I'll go back in the queue, Mr. Chair. Now, for those individuals under 60, as I understand the bill, if they do not qualify in terms of the training programs, they would lose their SNAP benefits. Those are people under 60 who have dependents? Yes. Okay, so if that's the case and they lost the SNAP benefits, the dependents would also lose the benefits, too? I can
answer that question. No, the benefits would be reduced for the adult who was not cooperating if SNAP employment and training becomes mandatory. Okay. And the balance of the benefits would still go to the rest
of the members of the household. Okay, thank you. I'll go back in the queue, Mr. Chair. You recognize we don't have any other. Okay. One final question. In terms of the training program, so I think I heard someone mention 4,000 able-bodied. Okay. So those 4,000 able-bodied individuals would qualify for the training programs that you now have. And if those 4,000 individuals would be required to go into that training program, so we would be able to accommodate them?
This bill would expand those who were required to participate in employment and training beyond the 4,000 able-bodied adults with the work requirement. It would expand the employment and training requirement to include people who have dependents age 7 and older, as well as people who are age 50 to 59. So it would increase the number of people who, if they were not otherwise exempt or already employed, would be required to participate in SNAP employment and training. And our estimate, based on a point in time look at the enrollment, was around 50,000.
Representative Ferguson, that's why we're given a three-year implementation program. And they're going to report to us each year on how they're progressing and getting ready. Representative Deborah Ferguson,
you recognize me. Like I said, I mean, everybody certainly wants to facilitate people going to work, but I guess I also need to understand how these people are going to report these work requirements because, I mean, that's been the disaster of the Arkansas Works program. How are you going to facilitate the reporting of this work requirement and make it easy for people to actually report what they're doing and not lose their SNAP benefits?
Part of what we did as we implemented SNAP work requirement back in 2016 is we started working to expand our SNAP employment and training from 13 counties originally into now we have statewide coverage. Part of that process has been to develop an employment and training management information system that the providers can use to communicate with us and we can communicate with the providers. So basically, the information for SNAP employment and training would be facilitated through that system and with the providers. I guess I still, walk me through,
So if employment and training, if you're required to participate in that, we will make a referral to a local provider in your area, and that provider will start working with you. We'll send you an appointment for an assessment. We'll set up an employment plan for you with steps. And as long as that provider tells us that you're cooperating with your plan, that's all we need to know. So we would get that information reported by the employment and training providers who are working directly with the recipients.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Let me get this straight. So I'm 55, SNAP recipient, no GED. So this program will help me first get a GED. Yes, sir. and then connect me with a provider that will train me in something? Yes, sir.
That would be what employment and training would do. If education was one of your needs, then the provider would help you with the educational needs. If training was a need, a specific type of training to do work that's in demand in your area, then they would refer you
for that training. Just one follow-up, Mr. Chair. Okay. And so as long as I am working with the provider after I have gotten my GED, and as long as I'm working with my provider on a particular skill that that provider is assisting me in training, I'm good.
you, Mr. Chair. Deborah Ferguson, you're recognized. Yeah, I had another question. Okay, this morning when we talked about SNAP, they said that people tended to only be on it for 10 months. So it's probably people in transition between jobs. I mean, how many, if the average is 10 months, do you have a breakdown of how many people are sort of permanently on SNAP? How many are, is it transient? I mean, if they're only on it 10 months, that's not going to be much time to actually barely get them to refer and try to get into training if it's just some kind of transitional
food help in between jobs. Representative Ferguson, I am aware of that statistic that F&S has provided based on their analysis of Arkansas SNAP program. But I can't tell you, I don't have the data to tell you today how many people are on longer than that average. I don't have that information today, but I have seen that same data that you're referring to.
And I guess how much is it going to cost DHS to implement these additional programs? How much are we spending on consultants now for those? We're contracting with them. Are we paying them, or they're already in place
and we're just referring to them? So we are paying them. The SNAP employment and training works. The providers that we work with actually fund part of the activities. and then we use federal funds for the match for that activity. And we are spending about $238,000 in state general revenue to support the program today for transportation and child care reimbursements because our current program allows people to volunteer for employment training today. And we did do estimates. What we know from working with the people we do, there's about 20% of them request those reimbursements. So we did a fiscal impact that using that $50,000 number, if 20% of those, if they all participated and 20% of them requested reimbursements, as is our current rate, that how much additional funding we would need to support the transportation and child care support for those individuals. And our analysis came to 3.4 SGR, and the rest would be provided by the feds. And that's maximum liability if every one of those people participated in the program, and about 20% of them needed that reimbursement. Representative Payton, you're recognized. What's your
for closing. It's a valid motion, non-debatable. All in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. Motion carries. So we're limited to 10 minutes per side and three for closing. We do have two people to speak against and one to speak for. And remember, it's limited to 10 minutes per side. So I shouldn't know how to pronounce your name now, but I'll probably mess it up.
Tomiko Townley. You did a good job. Okay. Thank you so much, Mr. Chair and members of the committee. My name is Tomiko Townley, and I work with the Arkansas Hunger Relief Alliance. Okay. I want to start out by saying that SNAP is a food assistance program. SNAP is not a work program. The Arkansas Hunger Relief Alliance is opposed to HB 1775 because it will take food off the tables of families in need and resources away from families with children. SNAP helps families afford food through the end of the month. When underserved families have financial supports for food, money is freed up for necessities like cough syrup, child care, toilet paper, utilities, and financial emergencies like flat tires. Arkansas already enforces strict time limits on unemployed or underemployed SNAP participants who are childless adults age 19 through 49 that don't meet the requirement and are not exempt or participating in an employment and training program or a workfare program. We have since 2016. Arkansas has some of the harshest time limits under SNAP in the nation. I also have to add that much like the Arkansas Works program, the SNAP work requirement is really a reporting requirement and a time limit on vital supports. Taking food assistance and access to medical care away from people does not help them find a job or stay employed. This bill would expand time limits to parents with kids over the age of 6 and under 18 and other adults up to 60 years old. These are veterans, parents, and people doing everything right, but through no fault of their own can't find and keep a job that offers them 80 hours a month or meets one of the requirements or the exemptions. This bill assumes people are choosing not to work, when the truth is employment opportunities are not equitably available around the state. The number of people requiring job training or workfare slots far exceeds current job training programs in the state of Arkansas. There are only 33 employment and training sites in the state. Under this proposal, the state would have to identify a workfare program statewide. Establishing workfare slots throughout the state would be extremely difficult. Many nonprofits have limited capacity to supervise volunteers in more populated areas like Little Rock and Fayetteville. So Workfare opportunities would be impossible to find in more rural areas of the state that have few or no nonprofit organizations. In addition, Workfare has proven to do little or nothing to improve a participant's skills, overcome their barriers to employment, and enable them to secure and retain jobs in the private sector. Helping people who can get good-paying jobs and succeed in today's economy is good for families and overall public health. This proposal would not make that happen. It would make it harder, and the thousands of people that would be impacted by this would see their food budget go down. I don't know where the numbers are coming from for the additional 166,000 jobs that will be created in 2019, but the folks who were pushed off SNAP the last three years are often underqualified for skilled labor or unable to consistently keep a job due to lack of transportation, housing insecurity, and untreated physical or mental illness. I know from working with individuals who have lost their benefits under the current time limits and concerns shared by colleagues that work with homeless resource centers that parents are often underemployed or unemployed for reasons out of their control. These include the outrageous cost of child care and after-school care, the time it takes to take public transportation to attend appointments and turn paperwork in, the sheer unpredictability of parenting. It's often not financially feasible or accessible to find employment that perfectly matches with their children's school schedule, especially with the understanding that children living in poverty struggle with more medical issues and mental health issues. So sick days are important for parents to be able to take. If the goal of passing this bill is to get more people into jobs, this bill will not succeed. I believe the goal of this bill is to perpetuate a false narrative about SNAP participants and push people off a food assistance program that helps vulnerable families keep food on the table through the end of the month. Underserved people in your districts deserve better. We all need access to food in order to succeed. I believe a household that qualifies for SNAP is truly vulnerable. SNAP needs to be strengthened to allow more eligible people to get the help they need. Also, I want to answer the question about how many people were pushed off the program. I know in 2016 it was 24,063, and then in 2017 it was 11,787. So I don't have the numbers for 2018, but it does result in people losing their benefits. Thank you very much for
Horton. Please identify yourself. Yes, sir, Mr. Chairman. My name is Nicholas Horton, and I'm a senior research fellow for the Opportunity Solutions Project. in 1942 Clarence Horton collected his young family of eight and moved him from gun town Mississippi to western Kentucky with not much more than the clothes on their back they uprooted and went for one reason work he got a job with the Tennessee Valley Authority and would work for the next several years building the Kentucky Dam he understood the importance of doing whatever it took to provide, even on the heels of the Great Depression. And he passed this work ethic on. One of his sons, Nick, went to work at a young age. Over his career, he worked as everything from a milkman to a carpenter to ultimately building a locksmith business that he owned and operated for more than 30 years. He turned 81 a few weeks ago, but still goes into the shop every single day and works the counter. If he was here today, he would tell you that work is what keeps him going, and he passed that on. One of his sons, my dad, went to work at just age 12. I remember for most of my life, he worked multiple jobs. For years, he would wake up at 2.30 in the morning to go load trucks and then work construction all day. Growing up in rural White County, we never had much, but dad always made sure we had enough, and he didn't work this hard so we could drive Cadillacs or wear nice clothes. He worked his heart so we could eat. We drove old beat-up vehicles and wore hand-me-downs. We ate simple cheap meals. In fact, a real treat was a five-dollar pizza from Little Caesars that we split six ways. Some of my fondest memories as a kid are going to work with Dad. I was homeschooled until junior high, so a lot of days I'd wake up early, eat breakfast, and then we'd hop in his truck and listen to Paul Harvey on the drive in. I'd do my schoolwork in the morning, eat a tuna sandwich with dad for lunch, and then follow him around the job site for the rest of the day, handing him tools and trying to help him out. I was seeing firsthand what hard work looked like. And I remember on those hot Arkansas summer days, dad telling me time after time, Hortons don't cheat, Hortons don't lie, Hortons don't steal, and Horton's work hard. And he passed that on to me. Not counting the free labor for my dad, my first job was when I was 12, mowing lawns for a neighbor down the street. And I loved it. I loved being outside. I loved seeing the finished product. And I loved getting paid because I was saving up all summer to buy myself a TV and a video game system. And I did. I love the work so much, I grew it into a larger business that supported me all the way through grad school and at one point after graduation I was working three jobs myself. I guess you could say it runs in the family. Now as I raise my almost two-year-old son right here in Arkansas I'm going to do everything I can to pass these values on to him. Here's the point. It's not just about me or my family. Hard work is hereditary. It gets passed down. The values that I saw in my dad, that he saw in his dad, that he saw in his dad, will now be passed on to my son. And as a result, a family, the Horton family, that was on a path to generational poverty is now on the path of generational work. But not everyone has three generations of hard workers to look up to, and that's why I believe this bill is so important. It represents an opportunity to break the cycle of dependency for many Arkansans and put them on that same path to a better life. We've seen it happen time and time again, even right here in the state. Thanks to the existing work requirement and food stamps, Arkansans have seen their incomes more than double on average in just the first year after leaving welfare. And after two years, their incomes more than tripled, leaving them better off than they were before. This bill is a chance to build on that success. More than 60,000 able-bodied Arkansans stand to benefit from this bill and the work and training that it would provide. Children growing up in these Arkansas households need that example that I had and my dad had and his dad had. By getting these Arkansans into employment and training as set forth in this bill, we can help them and their children build a better future I know what it's like to be poor in Arkansas and that's not the future I want for any single person in this great state but I also know what it takes to change course it takes work thank you for your time and for your hard work on behalf of our great state and I'd
Rep. Brown recognized thank you Mr. Chair so you I would say that this opportunity that's being afforded through this bill is a benevolent thing to help people actually realize that they can work and earn their own money and help set a good example for their children. I think so, and I think
that's something that I've experienced and a lot of us have probably experienced as well, watching our parents work. And I think that we need to make sure that that opportunity is there for all
our Kansans. Thank you, Mr. Horton. Thank you. Do you have any information on jobs available? I heard people say that there aren't jobs. I know in my corner of the state, they're begging for people. There's work signs out all over the place. Sure. And, I mean, a lot of them are entry-level jobs. I know at the Human Development Center there in Jonesboro, they beg for people. I don't know about the rest of
the state, but do you have any numbers or data on that? Sure. The 166,000 jobs that Representative Bentley mentioned, those numbers come from DWS, Department of Workforce Services, projected jobs to be created in Arkansas this calendar year. And I would also just point out, obviously the goal is to get everyone into a real good-paying job, but as required under this bill, simply requires employment and training. So if there aren't jobs available, they can go to Workforce Center, Career Center, get that education, employment, and training so that they are job ready when those jobs become available.
Any other questions? Seeing none, thank you for your comments. Thank you. Okay, signed up to speak against the bill, Paul Atkins. He's not here? Okay. All right, that's all we have signed up to speak. Are you ready to close for your bill? You have three minutes.
Thank you, Chairman. Colleagues, I appreciate your patience today in getting this done. If anybody that you know me, I'm a very compassionate person, and the goal of this bill is not to get people off of SNAP. The goal of this bill is to get work training available across our state and to get people to work. I know that my parents have had me working the whole time, I mean, the best example for a child to see is their parent getting to work. And too many Arkansans don't think that they're able, and this bill will help them to do that. So with that, I would make a
motion due pass. I have a motion due pass as amended. Is that correct? As amended, yes, sir. By Representative Bentley. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. No. The ayes have it. your bill is passed. Congratulations. Okay, committee, Representative Warren, are you in the room? He's not going to run it. Okay. Senator Irvin's bill, SB 339, is anybody prepared
Affairs Chairman for the Arkansas Ambulance Association. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The House Bill 1710 is to form a task force on non-emergency transportation of behavioral health patients. And I attended a meeting two or three weeks ago where we had several of the group that were going to be in here. We had ambulance, we had law enforcement, we had hospital. And me being an outsider, listening to their concerns of how to actually efficiently do this really brought light to the subject. You know, when I dial 911, I want to make sure someone shows up. But, you know, for some reason, if my limited resources in my community are out of pocket because they're delivering or they're transporting a patient to a facility out of the area, that prohibits or prolongs the response time of the service. And listening to this group of people and professionals that do this day in and day out and they see the trials and the tribulations that they encounter is the reason that we came up with this task force. And asking for your permission to form it and we'll facilitate it through the health department. It will be an efficient and really no-cost task force. I know a lot of people hate task force due to the expense. But all of the professionals who are willing to serve will have a senator and a representative local, which would not require any per diem. I've actually offered to serve on it, which I'm local, so there wouldn't be a cost to it. And that's it in a nutshell. Mr. Kelly will expand on some of the concerns that they have and express this point of it.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. And Mr. Perry, thank you for that introduction. First of all, we are not here today talking about not responding. I represent ambulance providers across the state, everything from small volunteer to public to private to hospital to all forms of entities. And we're all facing this same challenge. When EMS is called to respond, we do respond, and we will continue that as part of the public safety net. However, over the last three to five years, we've seen a burdening trend in our industry in which it's not the emergencies that we're having trouble responding to. It's the improper utilization for non-emergency transport, particularly in those situations where we're having to travel from corner to corner and border to border across the state, transporting patients that need some alternative form of transportation, Not necessarily a community's only valuable emergency medical services asset, which may be a basic life support, or in many cases, because you only have one advanced life support ambulance covering a rural community, it may take that valuable resource out. And as our state system of care with our trauma system, our stroke, our STEMI heart attack systems have expanded, the importance of keeping those emergency resources in those communities is even greater today than it was just a few years ago. So we're not here talking about reimbursement. We're not here talking about a responsibility to not care clinically for patients. However, when we convened this group, we found several issues that are lacking from emergency medical services standpoint. One is we lack police powers in many cases to control these patients that if they're not under a court order, their voluntary commitments going to inpatient treatment facilities, we have no obligation to retain those patients during transport. So if they want to leave the ambulance and depart, we have to let them out on the side of the road. Of course, we contact law enforcement, and we have great partners that work with us in all of our communities. However, that puts EMS in a serious jeopardy and liability. In other situations, we find that many of these transports are occurring at peak hours when system demand is the greatest, and it's important that our hospital partners have throughput in their facilities to take care of more serious medical emergencies, and so we understand that they have needs in which to have throughput through their facilities. So it's a combination of problems, and we've had great conversations. The Arkansas Hospital Association and the Department of Health have been very supportive in understanding our challenges and trying to help us find ways, but we keep running into roadblocks in which to develop protocol, in which to interpret legislation that already exists in Arkansas. So we're not looking, I don't think, to pass new legislation, but it's just to help us develop protocols and procedures, procedures that will provide the clinically accurate care for patients suffering behavioral health emergencies and also to preserve the critical emergency response resources through our community. So I'd be happy to answer any questions you may have before the committee. I do think that this is an efficient way for us, and we have established a brief period of time in which to conduct our task force work. At emergency medical services, we get the call, we respond, we triage, and we treat the patients, and we will treat this task force with similar urgency in which to address the needs for the state of Arkansas.
Thank you very much. Representative Brown, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Okay, so you're in ambulance service and you handle emergencies, typically. And so if somebody's having a behavioral health emergency, So that means that they might be acting in such a way that it would be difficult for someone to accommodate their needs.
Yes, ma'am. So that's why you're called? The ambulance services in the state of Arkansas, we provide a variety of emergency and what we call non-emergent services. Emergency services are certainly those situations in which there's a threat to life or serious harm for the patient or others. And those situations, yes, we respond to those. In many cases, that is along with our law enforcement partners that help control those situations who may have the police powers to restrain the patient, and then they often accompany us. The non-emergency aspects of it, though, are where the crisis for the patient may have been resolved. However, they need to go to a different treatment facility for long-term treatment. In many cases, that may be a 72-hour hold or it may be a longer-term treatment program. The non-emergency transportation is where we often are in EMS are left to act on our own. We don't always have law enforcement present. We may not have the clinical protocols to treat the patient during that long transport time. And in some cases, these transports are not, you know, just down the street to the hospital. These can be three- and four- and five-hour transports going from Texarkana to Jonesboro in the middle hours of the night. And we don't have the clinical protocols to maybe sedate the patient, to provide medications in many cases, and certainly don't have the physical restraints. So more of the issues are not whether it's responding to an emergency. It's more the non-emergent that we're most concerned about. Inner facility type transports. Thank you. Representative Ward-Law, you're recognized for a question. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. It sounds like a broken record from where I'm sitting, but it's another task force. And I've sat here all session and spoke against them, so I'm not changing now. And, Ken, you know I've always been supportive and still am. I'm just lost in why we couldn't do this with public health. I mean, why could we not have these people come to the public health committee? They meet every month. They could have a place on the agenda for these different folks you list out through here, whether it's Department of Health, Department of Human Services, a provider-led person from the passes. is how come we couldn't take that testimony in this committee or why do you guys not come up with a bill and pass a bill to address this issue this session? I mean, is it you don't have a solution
for the problem or I'm lost? I think, Representative Borla, I think that's exactly correct is we don't have a definitive solution today. Many of the issues that we've worked with the health department and the hospital association on address many of the clinical aspects of how we best provide care to those patients. I think the real roadblocks that we're facing is getting all of the partners together at one time. And there's just so many nuances that we felt like that if we could convene a task force, it would put some teeth into the request. We've had numerous meetings over three years that have involved one or two or three elements, and then you're always missing an element. There's just always a missing element. And we're looking to this body to give us guidance and assurance that as we commit as a state to improve behavioral health, we involve all these partners in an organized and consistent way. Representative Wardlock, can
I add to that before you ask your next question? You can. You know, that's the whole point is being able to get them together and come back to you next year, fiscal session. We calculate we're going to do it in four meetings. We want to be quick, like Ken said, quick and efficient, come back and report, and that way if there's legislation that we need to do, maybe we can promulgate it in rules, we can get it done, but, you know, something we can take care of and serve the people better. Did you have a follow-up?
second. Representative Deborah Ferguson, you're recognized for a question. Yes, is someone from DHS here that deals with non-emergency transportation or any?
DHS? I know there's been some federal movement to get waivers and state plan amendments for non-emergency transportation. Have you all looked at this at DHS and thought about options? Well, I will say we
looked at this bill when it was filed. I mean, it caught our attention because it actually caught my attention because I heard of this issue back when I lived up in North Arkansas in my district because it's a three-hour trip to Little Rock, and sometimes an ambulance would be used to haul someone who made it be didn't need the health care of the ambulance or whatever. At DHS, I don't know that we've looked at this situation of using non-emergency transportation NET, if that's what you're asking. I know Janet's here, and she's kind of saying, no, we've not specifically looked at this.
think it would be something interesting to look at because, but again, typically those non-emergency transportation vans are used in a region, not necessarily crossing, you know, going entire state. I mean, they can take someone out of region, but it's not normally used for, but it would be a waiver. So, yeah, it'd be a demonstration waiver, perhaps. I don't know. I mean, it's something we could look at.
Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized. I had a question for Mr. Lee, Mr. Chairman. So you say that. I mean, do we need a task force for you guys to look at this, or could you all agree to get these players in the room? I mean, when I look through this list, there's only two people in this list that don't come here every month as it is, and that's the Sheriff's Association and the Chiefs, and they've been here before, by the way. I think they use the same lobbyist Mr. Ken uses. But so could this not be handled without four meetings of this task force, Mr. Link?
We could certainly look at it. We meet with these guys anyway, you know, so they know where our office is, and we could certainly sit down and talk about it with or without a task force. We're glad to do it either way. Follow-up? Yeah, you can
you could report back to public health that those meetings had taken place and what had resulted from each one of those meetings you would have, right? Yes, sir. Any other questions?
Seeing none. No one else has signed up to speak for or against the bill. So what is the will of the committee? I'll make a motion due pass. All right. I have a motion do pass by Representative Perry. Any discussion on the motion? Representative Johnson, you're recognized. I
just want to add a little testimony to the fact that, I mean, I know we recognize this as a problem, whether the task force is the right way to address it or not. We do have a problem in our state with emergency transfers in addition to the non-emergency transfers. We're a state that is short on specialists, and even our more urban areas, Fort Smith, Texarkana, Jonesboro, these communities rely on emergency medical transport vehicles to transport non-behavioral issues, and that puts an increased burden on the transportation of these folks that are behavioral. And so it really is a serious issue that needs to be addressed, and I appreciate the concerns and y'all bringing it to us today. I understand the issue with the task force, but in some way we need to find a way to get these people at
recognized. Representative Johnson, Dr. Lee, I totally agree. This is an issue. I didn't realize how big it was until I talked to DHS during this meeting. I mean, it is a major issue tying up our ambulances for these type transports. I mean, I heard some examples when I was talking to them about patients showing up to the door with a suitcase. They're ready to go for their week. and you tie up this ambulance for six hours to run halfway down the mountain from North Arkansas to Little Rock over this, I mean, it's a huge problem. But to tie up a whole task force for it, I mean, I understand getting them to the table. I think we've got an agreement from DHS that they're at the table now. I mean, I'm not against filing a bill to change the way it's paid for and the way it's done, but I don't know that a task force is the answer. So for that reason, I'll be voting
no. Any other discussion? Seeing none, the motion is due pass. All in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. No. The ayes have it. Your bill is passed. Congratulations. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Okay, committee. Next, we're going to hear HB 1719. HB 1719. Representative Ferguson, you're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. Would you have your guest introduce herself, please? Yeah, hang on. This is actually Representative Gray's bill, so y'all don't give me a hard time. It's a bill that the Medicaid Inspector General and the Attorney General's Office have brought to clean up some language and make some changes. And I'll let them introduce themselves, and then we'll... Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee.
Donna Galloway, Senior Assistant Attorney General with the Attorney General's Office. And I'll just kind of walk... It's a long bill. It's 14 pages, and most of it is just... On page two, if you need to ask questions, I hope they'll answer them, but it enhances a couple of misdemeanors for adult abuse that already exist. And then on the second page, it seems to add managed care organizations to the group of providers, and it clarifies what records they must keep. Then in other places, instead of physician, it just says a health care provider or a managed care company. Then on page 8, it talks about independent contractors and if you've been accused of fraud. That's the main changes, I guess. And then it talks about it changes the fine from $5,500 to $500 to $10,000 on page 13. It changes some of the violations for them, and it talks about seizures. So if you have questions, I'll let you ask them. Any questions from the committee? It's a long bill if y'all need time to look. Give everybody a
let Brad address that. Sure. Yeah, you're right, Mr. Chair. Thank you. The bill is mostly clean up. There are some updates to the Medicaid fraud and the Medicaid Fraud False Claims Act that stem from a combination of efforts between our Office of Medicaid Fraud Control, MFUQ, and the Office of Medicaid Inspector General, OMIG. over the course of the last couple of years with some investigations we had conducted and then with the advent of the new managed care-like PASS program at DHS, we identified some issues with the statute that we thought could be addressed early on to get ahead of any fraud issues that we might see coming down the
pike. Representative Payton, did you have a question? Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair. So my question is Section 5, page 5. 1B, we're adding language that says that when permitted by contract or rule, the department may return all or a portion of the restitution to a managed care organization or any similar organization that suffered a loss due to the Medicaid fraud. That seems to be some precedence that hadn't been set before. Can you
enlighten us on that? Yes, that's a great question, Representative Payton. I appreciate that. This actually is language that's found in many states that have managed care organizations. I think you all know, being public health, that managed care is a global payment that's paid out to providers once they bill for that global payment for services. And so in instances when that managed care organization is innocent, we have the ability to make them whole under certain circumstances, because we're going to go after the bad actor, the provider, to recoup the monies. So we basically, we don't want to recoup from a provider and then leave the managed care company holding the bag. It would be essentially double dipping by the state. If I could have
a follow-up. And I'm pretty sure I understand and would agree with that premise. I just want to make sure we don't have an obligation to make them whole unless we're made whole in that situation.
Right. And this language there on line 10 just explains that by contract or by rule we would have the ability to do it. It doesn't mandate it. It just gives us the ability down the road to look at putting that into
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. A few sessions ago, I ran a bill to keep us from paying those contractors by a continuancy fee. So if they found $100, they get to get 25 of it. And I think 25% was the going rate at that time. Does this go back and undo that and allow you guys to hire them on that percentage fee for finders? Because what we were finding back then was a lot of them were finding technical errors, and the state was losing that 25% over those technical errors, and we were actually paying the provider in the long run. So I don't want to see us losing taxpayer dollars on an illusion that we're actually taking something back we're not taking back. No, and that's a
wonderful question, and I might have to defer to Donna on that momentarily. But this isn't a contingency fee basis. This is just in the event a managed care organization has made the global payment, we catch a provider who's a bad actor and fully recover the taxpayer dollars that went out, we can turn around and reimburse that managed care company for that global payment. So it's just a make them whole in the event that we can recover from the provider that's the bad actor. So there's a follow-up, Mr. Chair? Yes, you recognize
No, Representative. Thank you. I have a question. On page 13 there on line 6, where you change the limits for civil penalty, it looks like you just tweaked those. Can you kind of expand why those are changing? They don't change that
much, but why was that necessary? The reason why the language was slightly tweaked, Representative, is because it added a penalty that was disproportionate to the amount of restitution, potentially, that could be lost in the Medicaid program.
Wardlaw was questioning. And Representative Payton, I appreciate that question. Let me differentiate the language on page 7. It talks about our office recovery fees for the cost of the investigation and the cost of the prosecution. So it's a little different than the situation with a contingency fee situation with a contractor doing recovery outside the state. Okay, thank
since she couldn't be here. Do you have a motion? A motion do pass. I have a motion do pass. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. Motion carries. Congratulations. Your bill is passed. Okay, the next bill on the agenda, SB 3, Senator Garner. Is there anyone here that's going to run Senator Garner's bill? Next week, okay. Senator Johnson, HB 1745, are you prepared to run that one?
just as a co-sponsor. And it is on the tablet. I have a motion from Representative Wardlaw to adopt the amendment. Any discussion? Seeing none. All in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. Motion carries. Your amendment has passed. Thank you. You may present your
bill as amended. Thank you. So this is a bill that a few years ago the legislative body enacted the ability for schools to stock epinephrine pens in a way of guarding against allergic reactions that might occur at a school that was done under physician protocol. The physician then provided a certificate to people who might administer that. It provided immunity for all members of the school that would be administering that epinephrine. Albuterol is an inhaler that we use to treat bronchospasm. It's a relatively benign medication that can be life-saving in the situation where a child is having a bronchospasm that could be related to an allergic reaction. This provides a pathway for schools to stock this albuterol inhaler under the same language that we use for stocking epinephrine and would provide the ability for these employees to administer the inhaler in addition to administering the epinephrine injector, which they have now. And I'd be happy to answer any questions about that if the committee has any.
the bill. Margo Bushmeyer. She was here this morning. She's with the Little Rock School District. She was going to answer any questions, but she's not here today.
make a motion to do pass as amended. I have a motion to do pass as amended. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. Motion carries. Congratulations. Your bill is passed. Thank you. Okay. Are we ready with the food? All right. Let's move on. We're checking the pizza list
this right. Okay, Representative Flowers is not here. Representative Fielding, not here. We're good. Okay, what we're going to do, folks, is we're going to take just a short recess, and people in the audience, bear with us. We're going to let people get up and get their food. It's only going to be about five minutes. So we'll get right back to this. But y'all go ahead and get up and get your food. There's drinks in here if you need it, and then we'll come right back.
all are. Oh, come on out. We saw each other on it. So he was surprised to get on it. He did take the back of it, and we've got more. I think you understand what the
trend is. I heard that education was a lot of nobody's pizza with y'all. You know what happened? Education done? They lied to you. You brought something different.
Okay. Representative Watson, are you prepared to run H.R. 1047? I am, Mr. Chair. All right. You're recognized. No. 1047. It's a health resolution. Oh, it's
a resolution. You're recognized, Representative Watson. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This will be real quick. House H.R. 1047, sudden cardiac arrest is the leading cause of death in the United States, so everybody in here be really careful when you're eating here, as well as the foremost cause of death among young athletes. More than 356,000 out-of-hospital sudden cardiac arrests occur in the United States each year. Sudden cardiac arrest is often survivable if treated within the first five minutes with cardiopulmonary resuscitation and the use of an external defibrillator. The likelihood of survival from sudden cardiac arrest is reduced 10% for each minute defibrillation or compressions are delayed. And the American Red Cross states that improved education and access to automated external defibrillators could save 50,000 lives each year. The purpose of this legislation, a school district in my district, the superintendent had an episode with a student two weeks before school was out last year. And he asked me, Representative, would you bring awareness of the importance of defibrillators? As everybody in here knows, each school district, each public school district is required to have a minimum of one in the district. just like a fire extinguisher or other things. They have to be certified and calibrated and all that kind of stuff once every 12 months. And naturally, the administration has to be trained, and that's all done by the Department of Education. Again, my point is to make sure we don't take it for granted, to make sure that everybody is aware of the defibrillator. Do not let it just sit up on the side of the wall and collect dust. I know we have several here in the Capitol. With a favorable vote, and this passes and gets to the House, I'm going to do my best to have the surviving young man who is 13 years old, who now has a pacemaker, and he is able to talk about this now. And I'm going to have the four personnel from the school district who administered this device to save his life. I'm going to try to recognize all of them from the gallery next week. I'll close at this, and appreciate your favorable vote if there are
any questions. Well, Representative, I'm glad you brought this forward because, you know, I've worked with some people out in remote areas, and we had these in our service trucks, actually, because timing is critical. The quickest you can get there, the better off you are, the less damage there is. So I appreciate you bringing this forward. Would you agree? I very much agree.
Anyone? Representative Boyd, did you have a question? Okay. All right. Nobody signed up? No. No one signed up? So are you ready to close? I'll close, Mr.
Okay. Representative Boyd made a motion. Do pass. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none. All in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. Motion carries. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Your bill is passed. Committee, before we get to the next one, I do want to thank you all for pitching in. We got plenty of money to pay for the food. Appreciate that. I appreciate Deborah Ferguson for ordering the pizza. So if you didn't get what you wanted, it's not my fault. No, I appreciate you, Representative Ferguson, for doing that. Okay, let's move on to next on the agenda there is Dan Douglas, who's not here. Representative Johnson, we're down to another one of your bills. Are you ready to run HB 1568? Yes, sir. You're recognized. Thank
you, Mr. Chairman. I might ask Ann Purvis with the Department of Health to come and join me at the table. Okay. So, first, we have some amendments. This is a bill that I presented in committee last week. There was brought up a couple of things that we want to try to amend, try to address some concerns of the committee members. One amendment has to do with the notification of the committee, the public health committee, with regard to when these meetings were going to take place and also the ability for the public health committee to request interaction with the health care advisory council. We also made an amendment to make the Surgeon General a non-voting member in the effort to make him an unbiased participant and moderator of any activities that happened. The other thing we did is we put a sunset clause in the amendment. So in other words, this would be a process that would last through January of 2021. At that point, if we give the legislative body a chance to reevaluate that process, see if this has been an added value to the process to look at these scope of practice issues. So I'll be happy to answer any questions about those amendments, and I have Ann Purvis here with me who helped me on those
amendments, if anybody has any questions for her. The amendments should be on the pads. Yes, sir, I believe they are now. Any discussion on the amendment or motion? I have a motion by Representative Bentley to adopt the amendment. Any discussion on the motion to adopt the amendment? Seeing none, all in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. Motion carries. Your amendment's been adopted. You can present your bill as amended. So as we
discussed the last time this was presented, the goal of this council would be to establish a process pre-legislative session to do two things. One would be to collect information regarding the scope of practice issues, And the second thing would be to put the parties in the same room together that are having issues on both sides of the scope of practice request. I don't know if everyone was here before when we presented this. Ann and I have worked on this together. This would be something that would be administered through the Department of Health. It's modeled after some things that are done in other states, Connecticut, Iowa, Virginia all have a process of screening these scope of practice issues through an unbiased body to collect information. this body would then give a report back to the legislative committee prior to the session. And again, if there are any questions about that, I'd be happy to answer them, or if you have any questions, direction for the Department of Health ends here
as well. Representative Bentley, you're recognized. Thank you, Chairman. Representative Johnson, I'm looking through here. Is there going to cost the state anything to run
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Is the Surgeon General usually a physician? Yes, sir. Follow up. So do you really think that they would have an unbiased opinion when it comes to these
scope issues? My hope is that they would. I mean, it's an appointment from the governor's position. This would also be a non-voting member. So my hope and intent is certainly with the current Surgeon General, I feel pretty confident he would stand as an unbiased individual. Again, this would be something that was sunset in 2021. If there were problems or issues with it, we could look at changing the composition of that advisory group, and I'd be open to that.
Any other questions from the committee? seeing none we have no one signed up to speak for or against the bill are you ready to close for your bill yes mr
chairman i'd just like to say that you know this process i think the way we do this here it could be improved i'm not 100 positive this is the right improvement but i think it's a good step in trying to do something positive to put these parties together and collect information. It's a no-cost intervention, and it's something that if it looks like it's not working or adding value, it's something we don't have to renew next session. If it does, it's something we can come in and tweak and renew. So with all that said, I'll make a motion
due pass, and I appreciate a good vote. I have a motion due pass as amended by Representative Johnson. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, the motion is due pass. All in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay? No. Motion carries. Ayes have it. The motion carries. Your bill has passed. Congratulations. I'm going to skip over my bill. Representative Meeks, are you ready to present HB 1309? Yes, sir. Are
Chairman. First off, colleagues, thank you for the dinner. It encourages me to come spend even more time with you all. So anyways, House Bill 1309, what I'm trying to do is I'm trying to modernize and clarify existing law to try to help expedite things, because I know your time is tight in this committee. Each of you on your desk should have a synopsis. I'm just going to run down the synopsis real quick and then try to answer any questions that you might have. Essentially, what I'm starting off is I'm wanting to change the title from the Shielded Outdoor Lighting Act to the Nighttime Environment Protection Act to just create a better description of what the purpose of the act is, update the purpose, try to modernize the definitions on the synopsis that you've received. You can see the definitions that we're trying to include and modernize. I'd like to spend the bulk of the time looking at the regulations. So under the current law, it says that if you're going to install an outdoor lighting fixture, if it's going to be more than 150 watts incandescent or 70 other source, it has to be fully shielded. As you may know, Congress outlawed the 150-watt incandescent bulbs many years ago, and we no longer measure lighting by watts. We use lumens. So what I'm doing is I'm essentially taking that 150-watt standard, and I'm converting it to lumen. So that's where the 1,800-lumen standard comes from. And it says, as the current law does, we're going to keep it fully shielded. And the only real regulation that I'm adding is in Section B, where it says that the new bulb has to be 4K or warmer. And where that comes from is there's a lot of emerging science that says blue-rich lights at night are harmful both to humans and to wildlife. And the recommendation from the American Medical Association is that lights at night stay at about 3,000K or less. Just to kind of help you put that in perspective, when you're driving down the road at night, the typical headlights we see on cars, roughly around 4,000K. Every once in a while, you'll come across those halogen lights that are very blue-rich and harsh. So it's that blue-rich color is the color that we would be outlawing in this bill. So we're going to say basically from the middle of the spectrum, from kind of yellowish back towards the red based upon that recommendation. That's the standard that the U.S. Highway Department uses as well. So we would be meeting that federal highway regulation as far as that goes. and hopefully we would be protecting our cities because a lot of cities before this came out installed a lot of the blue rich lights and they're having to go back and replace them with the ones that are not so blue rich and if you have any questions and would like to delve into that later when we get to the question section i'll be happy to to expand upon that if you go to the next page current regulations says it talks about mercury and landfills those lamps are no longer produced So we're eliminating that. That's being repealed, updating the grandfather clause from 2005 to this year. And there's a prohibition against the installation of mercury vapor lamps. That prohibition is no longer required because those lamps are no longer, so we're getting rid of things that are no longer needed. Under the exemptions, currently, under the current law, city or county can exempt themselves from the law if they just pass an ordinance that says that it's cost prohibitive. But there's no guidelines as to what is cost prohibitive, what needs to be included in that ordinance. And so it creates a lot of confusion. I had the attorney general look at this, and she said that, yes, there's no guidelines here for the cities. And so the city of Little Rock actually took this to the extreme in 2006, shortly after the first law was passed. They passed an ordinance that said it's too expensive and we're going to exempt ourselves from this law in perpetuity. And to this date, they've essentially exempted themselves from the law. So what I'm doing with this is to clarify that we're creating the cost exemption at 125% for excessive costs. And we're just saying that you have to show your work. Show us why or how it's cost prohibitive and what fixtures that you're talking about. So it just creates some clarification there. Under the exemptions, right now, navigational lighting systems for airports are exempt. I'm adding watercraft to that as well. There's an exemption for lighting for workers' safety on farms in industrial settings. However, there's nothing about highways and other temporary nighttime construction. So where this can become an issue, all of us have been driving down the highway at night. They're doing road construction, those portable floodlights that they use. If those are automatic, those are actually a violation of Arkansas law as it stands right now. So one of the things I'm correcting that is in this bill. The other thing that in Section 4 there under current law, there are six entities that get complete blankets from this. Those include the public schools and higher education. I'm removing that exemption so they have to follow the same rules that everybody else does. I've talked with higher ed folks, and they're perfectly fine with it. As a matter of fact, some of the lobbyists have come to me and bragged about how they're already implementing these changes. So I've been very encouraged by that. We are expanding some exemptions for the Department of Corrections. Under the old law, the Department of Corrections had an exemption, but it was just for the buildings themselves. And they asked that we include the grounds and the roads leading up to the facility, so that's included in here. And then we're going to add lighting for monuments and historic buildings. So, for example, under current law, if you're not one of these six entities as a state agency, you have no exemption. So the globe lighting around the outside of the Capitol, if those went out, it would be a violation of state law for the Secretary of State to fix that. I heard from the city of Hot Springs. They're wanting to do some lighting on some of their monuments and stuff. The old law wouldn't allow them to do that unless they pass the ordinance and so forth. This takes care of that so they can do that. Sporting facilities, same thing. If, say, the State Parks Department wants to install lighting for a ball field and that lighting is automatically controlled, it would be a violation of state law. So we're fixing that. Lighting of the U.S. flag. If the state police want to light the U.S. flag at night and they're using a bulb that's greater than 70 watts, that is a violation of Arkansas state law right now. So we're including that exemption to fix that as well. And then we've got the excessive costs that we looked at. On private businesses, under the current law, utilities are the only businesses that's really affected. What I'm doing here with private businesses, utilities, they would be required to meet that same 4,000 Kelvin requirement on area lights. The only exception would be if the property owner decides they want to put up something and light up their property like the Taj Mahal, they can supply those fixtures and the utility can do that for them. So we create that for private landowners. If a contractor is going to install streetlights and those streetlights are going to become the property where the city has to take care of them, I think it's only right that they should be conforming so the city's not going to have to go back and fix it. Billboards is the only other industry that's mentioned. And speaking with the billboard association, They came to me a couple of years ago and asked me to include the language that's in the current bill. I was under the impression that it was non-controversial and everybody was happy because they were trying to create a uniform standard not only across the state but across the country. And as of last week, as I understood it, everybody was still in agreement. However, as these things are apt to occur, two hours ago I heard from somebody else in the billboard industry that that's not essentially the case. So what I'm going to do is the billboards was really beyond the scope of what I was trying to do. It was a favor that I was doing for the billboard industry or so I thought to the billboard industry. And so if you all see fit to pass it out of here, what I'm going to do just to avoid the controversy, I'm just going to pull that section out of the bill down in the Senate. So we won't have that in the bill. So the only businesses therefore affected would be the utilities which are publicly run monopoly as you all know. And then if a contractor is installing street lights that a city is going to be responsible for. Other than that, that's the only businesses. No private individuals are affected by this. Enforcement would just be local law code enforcement, which is what you would expect. And other than that, that's what the bill does.
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm looking at your handout, Representative Meeks. Yes, sir. If you go to the second page, you're moving that grandfather cause to 14 years down the road. Correct. Is that not unfair out there? Is that not going to affect a lot of people by moving that? No, no. Are you pointing that to me, and is everybody in the industry and cities fine with that? Yeah, well, it actually helps them because right now any lamp installed before 2005 had to meet the requirements. And so what I'm doing is I'm bumping that up to modern. So, for example, the city of Little Rock may have installed nonconforming fixtures over the last 15 years. This just allows them to be grandfathered into what we're doing. Okay. That makes sense? It does. And I would also say that the changes that I'm asking for, this is not going to require any city to go out tomorrow and change all this stuff out. It's as it comes time to replace these things that we replace them in a manner that is in accordance with, you know, what we're trying to do here. Essentially what we're trying to do is we're trying to start to eliminate some of that blue rich light, which that's the light that is, you know,
harmful to the human eye at night. So the bulbs that would meet that requirement, that Kelvin requirement, other requirements, what types of bulbs that are on the market now would
of. So they would be available to these cities and other places. And there's substantial energy savings for these new lights, right? Correct, yes, sir.
The LED's fixtures that cities are beginning to install are up to 75% more energy efficient, and the fixtures themselves can last up to three times longer. So, for example, the city of Little Rock, I looked at their spending on streetlights. They spend about $1.2 million a year on street lighting. If something like this gets implemented, and again, it won't happen tomorrow, But over time, as this gets the city of Little Rock alone could save hundreds of thousands of dollars a year.
recognize? Just to clarify, I don't completely understand this, but, you know, utilities are publicly owned monopolies. If all of a sudden a city starts spending a whole lot less, Are the people who haven't updated going to spend a whole lot more in order to adjust things? No. Now,
I'll say, yes, so, you know, like in the solar, when you're putting solar panels out, the concern is that the people with the solar panels are going to be subsidized by it.
That's not the case here. Representative Perry, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Meeks, are you aware of the energy audits that are available
on a residential and a business to come out and analyze your utility uses and usage and recommend new lighting and the credits and the rebates you have available? I'm
introduce yourself and who you represent. Good afternoon. I'm Jasper Burton. I represent the Mid-South Sign Manufacturers Association. I'm also president of Cured and Sign Company in Conway. We have problems with this bill. It's effectively trying to regulate all signs. Whether it's billboards or not, it will affect all signs. That's a lot of appliances out there. I think some, we would have liked to have provided some input. Understand Representative Meeks contacted the outdoor advertising industry. I represent small manufacturers, you know, 10 to 20, if they're lucky, 20, 30 employees. We deal with these things on a local level. We get permits at every city that we put up a sign in. And that product is regulated by the cities, and this is a local issue. It shouldn't be dealt with the state. Little Rock's not like Greenbrier. I mean, they're different, and local communities are doing this now. They're regulating signs in compliance with us and lights. I guess every planning commission I've been to, they say don't allow light trespass. This is something that's out there now. This is really tough to determine. Can somebody tell me what is glare? And how much is excessive glare? I mean, too much is too much. How do you know what too much is? It becomes a nuisance. and virtually every city in Arkansas has a nuisance ordinance, and it's used. This will regulate every sign, and it's just not enforceable. I don't know if you've ever had to call your code enforcement officer. Those guys are swamped, and we're going to pass this, And I'd like for somebody to tell me exactly how that guy's going to go out and measure the light, or is it going to be up to me to measure the light? I don't see. It just says it's got to be done. So I think that this is an unenforceable law. It's ambiguous. It should be handled on a local level. I mean, because every town's different. I did have a question, and I wasn't sure under item 6 on page 9. Remote sensing equipment shall not be installed on a sign for the purpose of personalizing advertisements displayed on the electronic message center. I'm not sure how that's going to affect light or light pollution or has any place in this ordinance
but it's attacking the one tool that the small businessman man uses to attract business, and that's his sign. I'm not sure how bright 3 Lux is, so that may be blinding, but I couldn't tell you. I don't know if anybody else here knows how bright 3 Lux is. But I think it's something that's important and should be considered. I'm not very good at public speaking, and I apologize for my notes and my stammering and stuttering, but I think this is a bad bill, and I think
it should not be passed. I thank you for your time. Do you have to deal with local city ordinances? Have you run into cities across the state where they have a local ordinance that controls the amount of lumens from a light source? Have you run into that? Typically,
local ordinances and the sign industry works in foot candles. And, yes, there are some cities that do enforce that. But they're measured in foot candles. How do you determine whether
So they have a device that they measure that with? A light meter. Light meter. Okay. Thank you. Representative Penzo, you're recognized for a question. Yeah,
I just have a question more directed towards Representative Meeks. You just mentioned you were pulling out the section of the bill that had to do with signs. Yes, sir. Are his concerns all addressed if that section is pulled out? Yeah, all the concerns that he talked about,
that's the whole, he was the one I spoke to earlier about that had raised the concerns that I thought everyone was from the billboard. So I thought that part had been settled and everybody was good with it. I've since learned that that is not the case and as he has brought out, there are some things that are maybe beyond the scope of what I've been doing. So that's why I told the committee, if you pass it out today, I'm just going to pull that entire section out of the bill. So that should address Mr. Burton's concerns. Thank you.
Just wanted to clarify that. Any other questions? Seeing none, thank you for your comments. Thank you. Seeing no further questions, no one else to speak for against the bill, are you ready to close? Yeah. Again,
Motion do pass. I have a motion do pass by Representative Brown. Any discussion? I would like to make a comment. I appreciate you bringing this bill forward. I think it's a good bill for energy savings is the reason I like it. And I know in Jonesboro, in my city, the local utility there has voluntarily implemented something very similar to this. I don't know whether it's identical. In a subdivision. And it's gone very well. And their savings have been realized. It's been going on for quite a few months. and they realize savings and they're going to move that forward on a voluntary basis. So it has been tried in some areas. Any other discussion? Seeing none, the motion is due pass. All in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. No. The ayes have it. Your bill is passed. Congratulations. Thank you, committee. I think that's a little late, but I guess I'll take it. Roll call. Yeah, there was two hands. Representative Johnson. Wait just a minute. I already said it passed. I'm going to say that that was too late on the roll call. So we're going to move on. Representative McCulloch, are you ready to run HB 1806 on Passover? Okay. Representative Allen, is Representative Allen? Yep, there he is. Are you ready to run HB 1803? Yes, sir. Yes, sir. Okay. There is an amendment, and it's on your table. Uh, committee, there is an amendment and it's on your tablet. Representative Allen,
you're recognized to present your amendment. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members. With the, uh, permission of the chair, I would like for Rodney Smith to come to the table and, uh, or either Michael Keck to come down and, uh, have to explain this.
amendment first yes yes sir this is an amendment to create dark and saw blue ribbon panel on pediatric cancer research what we did with on page 1 line 30 we deleted a represented and three representatives and on page 1 line 36 we substitute the following with coalition page 2 we deleted live for and substitute the following upheld and G we added three representatives of the Winfrey P Rockefeller Council Institute appointed by the director of Arkansas Children's Research Institute and we go the line page 2 lines 22 through 23 where we did we at 6 we added 6 a Department of Health of its or its designees shall provide staff materials in a meeting place for the panel and be the apartment may designates its duties under supervision subdivision c6a of this section of the intended entity volunteering to take on the due to include without limitation of private entity. Is there a motion on the amendment? Representative
Payton has made a motion to adopt the amendment. Any discussion on the amendment? Seeing none, all in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed say nay. The ayes have it. The motion carried. Your amendment's been adopted. You may
present your bill as amended. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you, members, for adopting. As you know, cancer is on the growth not just in the state of Arkansas but throughout the country. And if you look at pediatric cancer here in the state of Arkansas, nothing has really been done over the past, what, 10 years or so with pediatric cancer. We have a pediatric cancer awareness month. But other than that, we haven't set out any real parameters on how to address this disease. So one of the things that this panel does, it advance pediatric cancer research and advance pediatric cancer treatment, improve childhood cancer surveillance, and support resources for pediatric cancer patients and survivals of childhood cancers. So, this task force is dealing directly with pediatric cancer, and I'm going to ask Michael Keck to say a few words if it's okay with the committee and the chairman. Yeah, you may proceed. Thank you, Mr.
Chairman. I'm Michael Keck, Government Relations Director for the American Cancer Society's Cancer Action Network. In the last session of Congress, it was the STAR Act, the Childhood Cancer Survivorship Treatment, Access, and Research Act was passed. This act enjoyed unanimous support of our congressional delegation. It advanced, this bill advances pediatric cancer research, childhood-focused cancer treatment, and provide resources for survivors and their families. I think it's important for this commission to be established to help position our state as we pursue opportunities to receive federal funds as they become available as the STAAR Act is funded. And it's also important for this to work in concert and in collaboration with UAMS as the ANCI is pursued. This will provide a better outcome and care for the pediatric cancer patient as we build on the excellent care that's been offered at Children's Hospital and at UAMS. And we fully are in full support of this and appreciate your support. Thank you.
Mr. Chair. So you brought up the National Cancer Research Institute that we're doing for UAMS. It's like $20, $30 million a year that we're talking about there. and it was supposed to make them eligible for these federal grants. Are we going to create something here that competes for those
grants? No, sir. No, this is something completely different. The STAR Act is a different category of funding and research. It would simply be something that would be done in collaboration and coordination, but not in competition with or in separate. It's a completely different line within the National Cancer Institute. to. It's not a competitive type deal. If I could have
matching, where's that funding stream going to come from? Well, again, those haven't been established, and I think those have to be identified through Children's Hospital as they become available. Children's Hospital has a foundation that does research as well. But again, many of those that come forward are based upon the research that's taken place in that institution, and it's collaborated there. If there is anything additional that would have to be added beyond that, it would have to come to the state and ask for those requests for those additional funds. This is not anything that's established or set up in that regard, it's simply to make sure we are prepared to engage in those opportunities as they come forward. It's not something that would be, it's not the intent of this to be set up to pursue. It's simply to prepare us for those opportunities. Thank
worked at Children's Hospital for 14 years, I'm certainly concerned about pediatric cancer. I just have a couple of concerns, so maybe you can talk to me about it. So under this line, too, they can solicit and receive donations and grants. So how are those grants going to be monitored, and how is that funding going to be monitored? You know, is this through Children's Hospital, or are we?
Whatever, I don't think, well, if grants become available. I don't think your mic's on. Oh, it was red. Now it's green. Okay. That's the colors. The grants that we're looking, that are referred to in here would be through, we would administer them. There would be no cost to the state. We have a research institute that works on pediatric cancer. I worked with David Becton, Dr. Becton, who's head of the hematology oncology unit at our hospital that's been working on this sort of thing for a while. He'd be involved in this. Does that make sense? So it would pretty much go through children's hospitals. That is what you're saying to me. Any other
questions? Seeing none, are you ready to close for your bill? Okay, what's the will of the committee? Representative Kenneth Ferguson made a motion due pass as amended. Due pass as amended. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. No. I'm going to have to say the no's have it. Roll call.
2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11. Congratulations, Representative. Your bill has passed. Okay, Representative Johnson, you have another bill, HB 1801. It did. It passed. Representative, you're recognized to present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
This is a straightforward, simple bill. What it does is it requires Medicaid to provide for one extra inhaler for a child under 18 who is already prescribed an alberol inhaler. This will be provided annually in the month of August. The intent of this bill is for that extra inhaler to be one that the kid could take to school and keep at school, in addition to one they could keep on their person. That would be one that they could have at school for the school year. And that's the straightforward intent of the bill, and I'd be happy to answer any questions. Any questions from the committee?
and make a motion do pass. I have a motion do pass by Representative Johnson. Any discussion on the motion? seeing none all in favor signify by saying aye all opposed nay the ayes have it congratulations your bill has passed representative johnson while you're down there do you want to go ahead and run you've got another bill bill 273 uh no senate bill 190 that's senator
You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. So this is a bill that came before this committee and was discussed at some length regarding extending immunity to expert witnesses that would be commiserate with the immunity that... Yeah, I'm sorry. There is an amendment. I think it's... It's, it
Does everyone have the amendment? Okay, so there was some question about the language here as to how it might apply to an expert witness and how that immunity might be conferred. We pulled the bill down and we visited with several different attorneys and also other colleagues from within the assembly. And what we tried to do here was clarify the fact that the expert witness could be testifying either on behalf, instead of being testifying on behalf of the board, was just testifying before the board. So if a person had been called to question and they brought their own expert witness, This immunity that now conveys to the board members would convey to the expert witness, regardless of which side they'd been called to testify. There was some concern that there was potentially some bias there in the way that language was written. And so we changed that language to try to provide for that same immunity for an expert witness testifying on anyone's behalf. I'd be happy to answer any questions about the amendment. Any questions on
the amendment? Representative Boyd, you recognize? I have a motion to adopt the amendment by Representative Boyd. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. The ayes have it. Your amendment has passed. You can present the bill as amended. So,
again, this is a bill that we discussed at some length before. I'd be happy to answer any questions. The intent is just to convey the same immunity to the expert witness that happened to be testifying is that it's already there for the board members, and we did spend some time vetting this with some attorneys and feel like we've got a good bill now that does what it's intended to do.
And, again, I'd be happy to answer your questions. Representative Wardlaw, do you have a motion? I have a motion, do pass. I have a motion, do pass. As amended. As amended, correct. As amended. Okay, any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. No. Ayes have it. Motion carries. Congratulations. Your bill has passed. Thank you. So now you're going to run a
bill. Yes, I have. I mean, I'm at the will of the committee. I have three things in a row here. I have Senate Bill 443, Senate Bill 190, and House Bill 1841. Well, Senate Bill 190, do
you have an out-of-town person here? I do, and that would probably be the right one to present. Yeah, let's run that because we have someone here from out of town. So, Senate Bill 190.
So, we have amendments with Senate Bill 190, some of which have been engrossed. All but J and B 405 have been engrossed. so I'll present the amendments first if I can. Okay, you may proceed. So as we went through this bill in this initial form, we reached out to the physician community. There's a physician at UAMS. He's the state's only adult geneticist physician. We reached out to him to seek his input on this bill, and he had several recommendations that went back and forth about language regarding responsibilities of a genetic counselor and how we would define that. These amendments just clarified that language to the extent that it made parties on both sides of the issue happy. That would be the engrossed amendments, which are SB 190 S1 and SB 190 S2. The J and B 405 amendment, that specifically addressed a language issue that came up this morning from a group of nutritionists who do some nutritional genomics, wanting to make sure that they were excluded from the licensure requirement, and so we made a slight change to the language there to ensure that they were not rolled into the group of people that would need to be licensed as genetic
counselors. Is there a motion on the amendment? I have a motion from Representative Deborah Ferguson to adopt the amendment. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. The amendment's been adopted. You can present the bill
as amended. So currently in Arkansas, there's no pathway for a genetic counselor to become licensed to practice in the state of Arkansas. This is a relatively new field. The field of genetics and how we approach that in medicine is expanding very quickly. And as we've expanded, the training as to what we call a genetic counselor has changed over time. There are people with different levels of training that are labeling themselves as genetic counselors. Other states have looked at licensing certain individuals as genetic counselors. The intent of this bill would be to create that licensure pathway and place these genetic counselors under the state medical board for oversight. It's a fairly lengthy bill, and what I'd like to do if I can is turn it over to my person that's holding my hand through the process. Let her introduce herself, and she can tell you some about her profession and why she thinks this is needed. You may proceed. My name is Courtney Cook, and
I'm an oncology genetic counselor here in Arkansas. So first of all, thank you guys for having me today. It's really a privilege and an honor to speak in front of you on behalf of the genetic counselors in our state and on behalf of our patients. I would like to preface my statement by saying that all cases are presented with consent of the patients, and some identifying factors have been changed to protect their privacy. Amanda was a vibrant young woman when her world turned upside down. She was finishing up her undergraduate degree in education, was getting ready to start student teaching, and was pending engagement to the love of her life. She woke up one morning and noticed that her skin and the whites of her eyes were turning yellow and that her urine was distinctly orange. She went in for evaluation and was found to have multiple tumors along her liver, gallbladder, and pancreas, the largest of which was 13 centimeters, and for reference, a baby's head is 10 centimeters. Amanda was subsequently diagnosed as having stage four metastatic malignant neuroendocrine tumor of unknown origin. Her skin and eyes were yellow and urine was orange because these tumors were shutting off the common bile duct in her liver and bile was backing up into her system. No treatment was possible. She was only 23 years old. While speaking with her oncologist, Amanda mentioned that her mother had passed away when Amanda was only three years old due to complications with childbirth of her younger siblings. Upon autopsy, her mother was found to have colon polyposis or hundreds of precancerous polyps within the colon. Amanda's oncologist then referred her to genetic counseling. The genetic counselor evaluated her personal and family history and helped order appropriate genetic testing. Amanda was found to have a hereditary genetic condition called FAP, or familial adenomatous polyposis, the hallmark of which is having hundreds of colon polyps, along with a high risk of developing other GI cancers. This genetic diagnosis not only explained her mother's colon polyposis, but also why Amanda developed such a young, rare cancer. The recommended age of genetic testing for FAP is young childhood, as cancers can develop by the age of five. Why, then, had no one recommended genetic testing to any of these children after their mother passed away? Amanda's genetic counselor dug deep into the family, conducting genetic testing on all of her siblings, aunts and uncles, and grandparents. Unfortunately, Amanda passed away in October of last year, at the age of 23. And two of her younger 20-year-old siblings, Raven and Regan, were also found to have FAP via genetic testing two weeks later. Raven and Regan immediately underwent colonoscopies and were found to already have hundreds of precancerous colon polyps. To say this was a devastating, terrifying time for the family was an understatement. However, the genetic counselor walked this family through the risks of FAP and made a care plan for the younger siblings in accordance with national guidelines. The first recommendation is prophylactic removal of the colon, as the risk of colon cancer is virtually 100% if it's not removed. Reagan recently had this procedure, and Raven is up next. They will also undergo extensive screening for other GI cancers for the rest of their lives, so if these cancers do occur, they will likely be caught at an early stage where they are most easily treated. The family would not have known that they were at extremely high cancer risks, and especially would not have known how to be proactive if it weren't for a genetic counselor. I am familiar with these cases, the patients, their families, and the long road it took to finding answers because I was their genetic counselor. I earned my Master of Science degree in genetic counseling from the University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences in Little Rock. My primary focus is oncology, and I have created and developed two oncology genetic counseling departments during my career thus far. One of these departments is at the University of Tennessee Medical Center in Knoxville, and the other is at Highlands Oncology Group in Northwest Arkansas. I am nationally board certified by the American Board of Genetic Counseling, and I hold a genetic counseling license currently in the state of Tennessee. While I have spoken from my realm of cancer genetics today, genetic counselors do exist in many different specialties, such as pediatrics, high-risk pregnancies, cardiovascular disease, and neurology, just to name a few. The overarching standard of genetic counseling is making sure that the right patient gets the right test at the right time. We are trained to identify which patients need testing and which do not. And then we have the specialization to determine which test is appropriate for each patient based on their personal and family histories. As you can tell, this is not a straightforward process. Genetic counseling appointments often last one to one and a half hours to ensure that the genetic counselor has discovered all of the pertinent information and so that the patient and their family is fully educated about the benefits and limitations of genetic testing. In the cancer genetics field specifically, it includes not only genetic testing for predispositions to develop cancer, but we also now have targeted chemotherapy drugs based on genetic factors. This is not the wave of the future. It is happening now. Genetic counseling licensure in the state of Arkansas ensures that Arkansans are getting state-of-the-art care by state-recognized health care providers. It ensures that we as providers meet certain requirements, like board certification and maintenance of continuing education activities, in order to actively practice genetic counseling at the top of our scope of practice in this state. It increases access to genetics care, not only from a cost perspective to patients, but also because licensure attracts more genetic counselors to want to work in the natural state. I am currently the only cancer genetic counselor in a three-hour radius, which covers a population of about 500,000 people. Access to top-tier genetic counseling services is a major priority amongst the genetic counselors and medical geneticists in Arkansas. So I've presented a lot of complicated topics today, but I will leave you with this straightforward thought. One in two men and one in three women will develop cancer in their lifetime. One in two men, one in three women. So look to your left and look to your right. Someone in here probably has already had this battle themselves, or you at least know someone who has. So heaven forbid that day ever come for you, or your spouse, or your parent, or your child. But if it does, wouldn't you want the most comprehensive medical team in the state? Wouldn't you want targeted treatment based on your own specific DNA? Wouldn't you want to know whether your family is at risk to develop the same type of cancer that you have? Wouldn't you want your family to have a chance to be proactive? And if the answer to all of these questions is yes, then wouldn't you want not only a genetic counselor, but a state-licensed medical board-recognized genetic counselor in your corner to help walk you and your family through the nuances of diagnosis, treatment, genetic testing, and future management? I know I would. Thank you for your time. I'll take questions. Representative Warlow, you're recognized for
Yeah, so currently that's complicated. There are currently three insurance companies nationwide that do reimburse for the genetic counseling appointment itself. So if you think about whenever you go to a physician for a doctor's appointment, you pay not only to see your doctor, but then you pay for whatever tests he or she might order. So currently, Aetna, Cigna, and UnitedHealthcare do reimburse the genetic counseling appointment under very certain circumstances. So your family history has to meet certain requirements, like you have to have a certain number of cancers in your family. They have to be under a certain age. That's what I figure out. So we don't really know if your insurance is going to pay for your appointment until you get into the session. So other major insurance payers, though, such as Blue Cross and Anthem and things like that, they don't necessarily pay for the genetic counseling appointment because they do not reimburse for non-licensed providers. So since we're not licensed, because there is no license, they won't pay for the appointment. Now, on the flip side of the genetic testing, the genetic testing is very much covered. It's way different than it used to be. A lot of times, as long as you meet those certain criteria to undergo genetic testing, insurance does cover it. And if it doesn't, out-of-pocket costs are much lower now, a couple hundred bucks. So to point blank answer your question, for the most part, the patients are paying for the appointment if it's denied by insurance. And then usually insurance still pays for the test.
Follow-up, Mr. Chair? Yes, you recognize. So passing this bill is somewhat of a leader into the fact that you're going to be coming here in two years and asking us, just like we've had for Blue
Cross and others already, for them to pay for this service. Potentially. So we've already been in discussions with Blue Cross. Their major hang-up is just not having a license in Arkansas. There's also federal bills going on right now to try to get Medicare and Medicaid to cover genetic counseling and call us medical providers at the national level. So hopefully in two years there's a little bit of a difference going on there. Yeah,
you can have one more. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So at that point, I talked to DHS a few minutes ago, and they're neutral, but they don't see an increase to cost because you're not really asking for them to pay for it yet. So the financial impact of this bill has the potential of being a positive hit or negative hit to the budget, however you want to look at it, because you're going to come back after you get the license.
Of DHS? Is that what you said? Medicaid. Okay. You know, I don't know the answer to that. But what I do know is right now it's negatively impacting patients. And so I'm a patient advocate. So if you had to go to your doctor's office and you were told at the door it's 250 bucks because we know your insurance is not going to pay for this, that can be an issue for patients. So the thing about licensure, though, this is not only about cost. This is about maintaining a higher standard, not only for our profession, but then also making sure that patients are protected as well because we're at a higher standard. Therefore, patients are getting the
a question. Thank you. Mr. Representative Wardlaw stole most of my questions, but that will save me having to ask him. I guess one of the questions most would have was about insurance, but how many people are actually practicing in the state of Arkansas right
state. Okay. Okay. Follow up. Yes. Do you, uh, are you like, are you familiar with MTHFR mutations and things like that? Yes. Okay. Okay. You out of Fayetteville? I'm in Northwest Arkansas. Yeah. Thank you. Representative
I don't want to paraphrase, but I'm going to try to say back to you what I think I heard. It sounds like the market is demanding these credentials, this licensure, rather than, say, the legislature. So is this request really to accommodate the market, or is this request to protect public health? I believe that I am the one
that brought this up, and I don't identify with the market. So I've been leading this effort with Senator Leading for the last 17 months, and I approached him. So from a genetic counseling standpoint, this is about public health. I'm a patient advocate. I advocate for my patients, and I know that working at a place where genetic counseling services were not part of the bundle was like a very large financial burden on my patients. So I really would like to see this in the state become a higher level of care, higher level of practicing. So I guess it does kind of come from the market as well, but it's protecting patients. You don't want to have just Joe Blow off the street being able to set up shop on the corner and say, I'm a genetic counselor because he can because there's no legislator saying that he's not.
Yeah, if I could address that too. In discussing this with the geneticist that I've interacted with at UAMS, the physician geneticist, he explained to me there's different levels of education, and it's pretty broad, the different levels of education of people that are calling themselves genetic counselors. Some of them have had a full two-year master's programs. Others have gotten a license, I mean, a certificate of a year's completion of education and training. So there's sort of a broad range in which these people are working under the auspices of genetic counseling. So to say you're now a licensed genetic counselor would differentiate you by these criteria from anyone who's just a genetic counselor. And also some of these services that are being mentioned as a result as to charges, people are getting these services, they're just getting them in charge under a physician as opposed to directly charged under a licensed genetic counselor. So these things are being obtained and paid for through physician services, physicians using a genetic counselor as an extender. That still has a caveat for this in this bill. There's still going to be genetic counselors working under physicians, but this would be a separate caveat for people that are licensed genetic counselors to be able to do those services away from the
physician. You're recognized for a follow-up. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So just briefly, what I thought I heard you say was Blue Cross Blue Shield and Anthem demanded this of you in order to create a I did not say that, no. Okay.
Representative Brown, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So would you need this licensing, or would there be a benefit to the licensing for, let's say, if this counseling is not just generally known or available, perhaps individuals, whether their insurance covered it or not, might want to have it. would you, so being licensed would lend credibility to those people who just want to pay out of pocket? They would feel like they were actually getting a bona fide individual who knows what they're doing?
Yes, that's correct. Another thing, too, if you have a license within a state, again, in order to practice within that state, you have to meet certain standards. So a big thing in the genetics world right now is telehealth. So technically, any genetic counselor in any state could provide care to Arkansas residents via telemedicine, and there's no regulation there because there is no Arkansas license. So they don't have to be licensed in this state in order to still provide that care. Sorry. What
you. So please clarify for me because I specifically thought I heard you say you couldn't get reimbursed or patients couldn't get reimbursed through insurance unless you were licensed. Was that not what I heard?
No, not every. Okay, so I'll re-clarify. So there are certain insurance companies that reimburse for genetic counseling services. They're very specific companies, and you have to meet certain requirements. What I said was there are a couple insurance companies that do not. So it's saying that this would help everybody. So just because you only have, like in the state of Arkansas, if patient A has insurance number one and patient B has insurance number two, patient A doesn't get their service paid for, but this one does. Like it just kind of evens the playing field for all patients. Representative Gonzalez,
did have a question, I guess, of Representative Johnson. I thought that we, the group, I think you work for an oncology group in Fayetteville, is that right? I did until last
thought they were under the misconception that they could not bill for the genetic counseling with Blue Cross Blue Shield, but did we find out they could?
memory and understanding, yes. So the clarification to that is we, so Representative Johnson was saying a lot of the genetic counseling services in Arkansas right now are being billed incident to a physician. So you're still billing underneath the physician's name, and so you're an extender of that physician. So where I was previously practicing, that's what they did not understand, was that we could still bill incident two. Licensure, in general, allows you to not have to meet those incident two requirements, and you could bill specifically in the name of the genetic counselor for that service. So in order to bill incident two, the physician has to previously establish care, and they have to be on the premises while the appointment is taking place. So if I'm talking to a woman who has no personal history of any sort of cancer, yet she wants to come in for a genetic counseling appointment, and I was only billing incident two, then she would have to previously establish care with an oncologist, even though she's never had cancer, and then she would have to come back a few days later to see me, and that oncologist would have to be on the premises at the same time. So it's just kind of the nuances like that, which don't really make that feasible for every patient. I guess my question was, did the oncology group finally
Representative Payton, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Johnson, at what point will we need a genetic counseling board, and will they have a seat on your
new scope of practice committee? That's an excellent question, Representative Payton. Under the present bill, it would be the medical board, so it'll be a while hopefully before we establish a whole brand new board, but I could see that coming in 25, 30 years.
you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Boyd, you're recognized. Thank you for accommodating me one more time. I'm going to try this one more time. So is it the insurance market that is, in essence, demanding this
bureaucracy? I mean... I would say that this is an access issue. So there's currently a pathway to bill, as she was trying to say, But that pathway requires the presence of a physician and initial evaluation of a physician. If we create a licensure pathway, it allows for a licensed genetic counselor to intervene, interact with the patient without the physician having the initial encounter or without the physician being present. So this is a way of extending access for these counseling interventions and allowing a pathway to build for that separate and apart from a physician. seeing no more
are you ready to close for your bill yes sir I understand the problem with creating seemingly more regulations and more boards and more oversights medicine is an evolving thing and this is something we didn't need 10 years ago The genetics field is evolving quickly, and this is the training that goes along with that is evolving quickly. And this is an effort to keep up with that training. So I think it's a good thing for us as a community to be able to establish these bona fides for the people that are going to enable themselves as licensed counselors and provide that service. So with that said, I'll be close for the bill and make a motion do pass. Appreciate
you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Committee, we sit here over and over again, and they want us to pass more ways to bill insurance, more ways to bill Medicaid. This bill is only a path for them to do that in two years with this very service. I agree genetics is a key component to health care today. There's genetic tests you can take to see how to metabolize different medications out there. Very well needed, but doctors are able to do that now. Doctors are able to find these people. Patients are not going to be able to pay this high price for this service. They're going to have to have insurance payment, and they're going to come sit in front of this committee in two years if this bill passed and ask for us to pass that. And for that reason, I would say no. Any other discussion on the bill?
Representative Penzo, you recognize. I guess my thoughts on this are currently a lot of doctors, no offense, Dr. Johnson, don't understand a lot of these genetic diseases or genetic predispositions to disease. I know that my mother has the BRCA gene, so even I went and got tested for it. If she hadn't had breast cancer, that's something that we would have never even heard of. I'd asked her about the MTHFR. You wouldn't believe how many doctors I've asked if they know about that genetic mutation. A lot of doctors don't know about this. There are a lot of preventable diseases, a lot of things that could be altered in lifestyle that could affect these genetic mutations, and if people knew about them, I disagree. I think that we should have more awareness out there on this topic. I understand not wanting to have another licensure with a potential board and that, but I do think that this is probably something that's important to have in treating people for diseases. And there's just not an awareness. I know a lot of people that go to Missouri to naturopaths to get educated on this stuff instead of being treated in northwest Arkansas. It's really probably mind-blowing that people drive to Joplin and other places in Missouri because this doesn't exist in Arkansas. So I'm a big fan of this, and I'll be supporting it. Representative Boyd, you're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. So just in case anybody knows, health care is not a free market, but it's a market nonetheless. And sometimes that market dictates things that are necessary in order to get payment, and this is one of those issues. And I think that if we want to have these services, we're going to have to accommodate the insurance market. Thank you. Any other discussion? Seeing
none, the motion is due pass. Is that correct? Okay, the motion is due pass. All in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. No. I'm going to say the ayes have it.
Congratulations, Representative. Your bill has passed. Okay, committee, Representative Crawford has been waiting. You ready to run your bill? Yes. This is H-Bill 1761. I hope you got some pizza while you were waiting. I did. Okay. Can I have Mrs. Stiffman? Yes. Yes, please introduce yourself and who you represent.
Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair and Committee. Cindy Crawford, State Rep. And I have with me Cherise Dean, Family Counsel. Okay, committee, I know you guys are tired at 7 o'clock, so am I at the Agriculture Committee by chance? I don't think so. Okay. Well, this is an Egg Provider Protection Act, and the first time it went there, and it had to be rerouted here. I just want to give you a little humor so you guys will loosen up a little. Hopefully, I'm your last one. House Bill 1761 addresses commercial egg harvesting in Arkansas. It provides companies and individuals. Did I say that right? It prohibits. I'm tired. Excuse me. It prohibits companies and individuals from paying women for their unfertilized human egg. The bill contains exceptions for reimbursement for time and trouble that are typically paid to research subjects. It does not affect fertility treatments, and it does not prohibit women from freely donating their fertilized egg, their unfertilized egg. Under the current law, Arkansas law does not prohibit companies from paying women large sums of money to harvest their unfertilized human egg. The Arkansas Anatomical Gift Act, which is 2017-01, generally prohibits Arkansans from buying or selling human organs, but this law does not apply to human eggs. The Arkansas Anatomical Gift Act permits charging for reasonable expenses related to the removal, storage, transportation, implantation, or disposal of a body part. What HB 1761 does is address commercial harvesting of human eggs from Arkansans. It restricts the sale or purchase of human eggs in much the same way that the Anatomical Gift Act restricts the sale of purchase of other human body parts. It prohibits companies and individuals from paying women for their eggs, but it does permit egg donations. It requires donated eggs to be harvested by a physician, which is very important, in a hospital, clinic, or other medical facility that meets state health department licensing standards. It requires individuals or companies that harvest eggs to give the woman important information regarding the procedure, including a summary of drug or hormone treatments involved. Excuse me, just a minute.
signed up to speak is there anyone here from the public that wants to speak for against this bill. Does that address your point of order? Representative Boyd, I know you want to say something. What is it? A motion of immediate consideration. We have a motion on the floor of due pass. Okay, we have a motion of due pass. Is there any discussion on
the motion? Representative Deborah Ferguson. you're recognized. Yes, I have great concerns about this bill. Certainly I don't think we ought to be paying people exorbitant amounts for eggs, but there was a lawsuit and it pretty much established that $5,000 is what you could pay a woman. This compensation that says that you can only pay them for research, that doesn't even compensate. If someone, I have had friends who donated their own eggs so that they could have IVF, you know, treatment when they had trouble getting pregnant. It's an arduous process. I mean, you have to go through hormone treatments and you have to, you know, go in and have your eggs and sometimes they can't harvest enough and you have to go back through it and you have to go three months of abstinence. It's a process, and it's a huge medical procedure, and these women, if they're willing to help infertile couples have babies, they deserve to at least be compensated for those procedures that they're having done. I mean, they at least deserve, this bill does not allow that. This bill says, I was trying to find it where it says they're allowed to be paid the amount that a researcher would be paid. This bill in no way allows them to be compensated for their time and effort and medical procedures and all of those types of things. I think this is a really slap in the face to infertile parents who are trying to have a child. I am not paying an exorbitant amount of monies for egg donation like has been done in the past at other places, but I am very opposed to this bill and the restrictions that it has.
motion, and you're not members of the committee, so you can't participate in the discussion. Okay. Representative Bentley, you're recognized. Colleagues, I just want you to
know that I will be voting against this as well as being a surrogate mother and being involved with this. It is an arduous deal. And if some folks don't have family members that want to donate eggs, and it's sad to say, but anyway, I will be voting against this bill because I've been involved in the process, and it is arduous, and it is actually a living hell to go through the shots you have to go through for that. And I'm sorry that I have to experience it again, but I have experienced it. So I think that we should allow these women that want to help infertile parents be parents because it's one of the most wonderful things on earth to be a parent, and I would want to not block it. So I'll be voting against it.
Any other discussion? Seeing none, the motion on the table is do pass. All in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. No. I say the ayes have it. Roll call. Call the roll. Representative Johnson.
7, 8, 8, 8, 4, 5, 6. Sorry, Representative, your bill has failed. Okay, committee, I know it's getting late. I did want to ask if there's anyone on the committee that has a bill that you want to run. It's a little bill. We would do that. Does anybody got one you want to run that's a small bill? If not... Do you have a bill?
Sure say Wardlaw and Womack are going to love this bill. We're getting rid of a board. This repeals and gets rid of the Arkansas Newspaper Recycling Advisory Committee that's part of ADQ. That's it. They don't use it anymore. Motion. I have a motion by Representative Wardlaw. What is your motion? Has
No. Motion do pass. I have a motion do pass by Representative Wardlaw. Any discussion? Seeing none, all in favor signify by saying aye. All opposed nay. Motion carries. Congratulations. Your bill is passed. Okay. I think we're about wore out here. Representative Dodson
Yes, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. The amendment is a language that DHS asked me to include in the bill. So it kind of fills out the bill a little bit more than what the original bill had in there. And so it includes the word guardianship. If you look at the first line of the bill, in custody of the state, it says in custody or guardianship of the state. and adds in or federal law, so things as required by federal law. So it fills out the bill a little bit more.
I have a motion by Representative Wardlaw to adopt the amendment. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. Motion carries. Your amendment has been adopted. You can
present your bill as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members of the committee, HB 1856, as amended, now says that on the first line of the amendment, it said consent to or approve the termination of pregnancy for a pregnant woman in the custody or guardianship of the state. So, this is laying out requirements that any state agency shall not basically pay for or help someone who's in the custody or the guardianship of the state to make a decision to terminate a pregnancy or pay for the termination of a pregnancy. I think that's pretty much it in a nutshell. I'll try to answer any questions.
Any questions from the committee? I have a motion by Representative. Is there anybody to speak? Yes, this one. There is nobody from the audience to speak for. Yes, so I have a motion by Representative Gonzalez. Do pass. As amended. As amended. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. Motion carries. Congratulations. Your bill is passed. Thank you. Okay, committee. You know, I keep saying this and bragging on you all, but I noticed there's only three empty seats. You all came back until 6.30, so thanks again for all your hard work. Appreciate it. We are adjourned. It's 7.30, honey. It's 6.30.
HB1731 G. Hodges TO REQUIRE COOPERATION BETWEEN CERTAIN STATE AGENCIES REGARDING SUPPLEMENTAL NUTRITION ASSISTANCE PROGRAM ELIGIBILITY.
HB1743 Bentley TO PROMOTE THE PURCHASE OF HEALTHY PRODUCTS WITH SUPPLEMENTAL NUTRITION ASSISTANCE PROGRAM BENEFITS.
HB1775 Bentley TO CREATE THE EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES FOR ABLE-BODIED ADULTS ACT OF 2019.
0:50 - 35:44119 segments15 speakers
Representative Mary Bentley introduced HB 1775, explaining that the bill would expand work-requirement and mandatory employment-training provisions to able-bodied SNAP adults with school-aged children in order to lift families out of generational poverty and create new jobs.
[1:38][2:06][2:39][3:12][3:44]
Department of Human Services Director Mary Franklin clarified that the current SNAP work requirement applies only to childless adults and that participation in employment-training is presently voluntary, answering Rep. Kenneth Ferguson’s questions about how the bill would make the training component mandatory.
[4:14][4:58][5:31][5:48][5:55][6:02][6:09][6:51][6:57][7:20][7:25][7:40][7:50][7:53][8:05][8:24][8:56]
Following testimony from both opponents (Arkansas Hunger Relief Alliance) and supporters (Nick Horton), the chair moved to adopt the amendment and then to pass the bill as amended; both motions carried unanimously and the committee reported HB 1775 passed.
[1:20][1:34][34:39][34:43]
HB1642 Warren TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING COSMETOLOGY AND OTHER RELATED OCCUPATIONS; AND TO REMOVE THE CERTIFICATION FOR NATURAL HAIR BRAIDING.
SB339 Irvin TO PROHIBIT THE REQUIREMENT OF, BARRING OF, AND DISCRIMINATION AGAINST A PHYSICIAN FOR HIS OR HER DECISION TO NOT PARTICIPATE IN MAINTENANCE OF CERTIFICATION.
SB446 G. Leding CONCERNING STEP THERAPY REQUIREMENTS FOR CERTAIN PRESCRIPTION DRUGS TO TREAT METASTATIC CANCER.
HB1688 M. Gray TO ESTABLISH COST-REPORTING FOR ASSISTED LIVING FACILITIES TO THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES AS A CONDITION OF PARTICIPATION IN THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM.
HB1265 M. Gray TO AUTHORIZE FULL INDEPENDENT PRACTICE AUTHORITY TO ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES WHO MEET CERTAIN REQUIREMENTS.
HB1710 Perry TO CREATE THE TASK FORCE ON TRANSPORTATION OF NON EMERGENCY BEHAVIORAL HEALTH PATIENTS.
35:44 - 51:1447 segments11 speakers
The bill was introduced by Representative Mark Perry, who explained that HB 1710 would create a cost-free task force, coordinated through the health department, to address non-emergency transportation of behavioral-health patients.
[36:12][36:23][36:57][37:28][38:02]
Representative Karilyn Brown testified that EMS agencies are strained by improper non-emergency transports, lack police authority to retain patients, and risk losing critical emergency resources, underscoring the need for statewide protocols.
[38:39][39:24][39:55][40:29][41:00]
HB1719 M. Gray TO UPDATE THE MEDICAID FRAUD ACT AND THE MEDICAID FRAUD FALSE CLAIMS ACT TO ADDRESS FLAWS IDENTIFIED IN RECENT INVESTIGATIONS AND CHANGES RELATED TO THE IMPLEMENTATION OF MANAGED CARE; AND TO UPDATE THE ADULT ABUSE PENALTIES.
51:14 - 59:5832 segments7 speakers
Representatives Kenneth Ferguson and Brad Nye presented HB 1719, noting it updates the Medicaid Fraud Act, the Medicaid Fraud False Claims Act, and adult-abuse penalties, and expands record-keeping requirements to include managed-care entities.
[51:28][51:56][52:02][52:34][53:13]
Testimony highlighted specific changes such as broadening “health care provider” language, adjusting civil-penalty ranges, and permitting the state to reimburse managed-care organizations when they are innocent victims of fraud.
[53:52][54:13][54:34][54:47][55:02][55:21][55:45]
Representative Jeff Wardlaw asked whether the bill would reinstate a controversial contractor contingency-fee provision; staff clarified that the legislation does not create such fees.
[56:18][56:29][56:58][57:02][57:29][57:36]
After brief discussion, the committee moved a motion to pass the bill as amended, which carried unanimously.
[58:59][59:10][59:18]
SB3 T. Garner TO REQUIRE ADDITIONAL REPORTING REQUIREMENTS BY CERTAIN PHYSICIANS AND HEALTHCARE FACILITIES FOR ABORTION COMPLICATIONS.
59:58 - 1:09:1633 segments13 speakers
Representative Lee Johnson introduced SB 3, proposing that schools be permitted to stock albuterol inhalers under the same protocol used for epinephrine pens to treat asthma or allergic-related bronchospasm.
[1:00:19][1:00:26][1:00:44][1:00:52][1:01:24]
HB1745 L. Johnson TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING PRESCRIPTION ASTHMA INHALERS IN SCHOOLS DISTRICTS AND PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOLS; AND TO AUTHORIZE ACQUIRING AND STOCKING ALBUTEROL FOR ADMINISTRATION IN CERTAIN SITUATIONS.
HB1771 V. Flowers TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS LITTER REDUCTION AND DEPOSIT BEVERAGE CONTAINER RECYCLING ACT; TO REQUIRE THE LABELING OF DEPOSIT BEVERAGE CONTAINERS SOLD IN ARKANSAS; TO ESTABLISH THE DEPOSIT BEVERAGE CONTAINER RECYCLING PROGRAM.
HB1783 Fielding TO MODIFY LABELING OF PRESCRIPTION DRUGS; AND TO REQUIRE PHYSICIANS TO PROVIDE ADDITIONAL COUNSELING WHEN PRESCRIBING MEDICATIONS.
HR1047 Watson TO RECOGNIZE THE IMPORTANCE AND NEED FOR QUICK ACCESS TO AUTOMATED EXTERNAL DEFIBRILLATORS.
1:09:16 - 1:12:5512 segments4 speakers
Representative Danny Watson presented HR 1047, a resolution urging greater awareness and access to automated external defibrillators (AEDs) in schools, citing survival benefits and a recent local incident.
[1:09:19][1:09:59][1:10:29]
After brief supportive comments and no questions from the chair, Watson moved to approve the resolution.
[1:11:14][1:11:36][1:11:41]
The motion was seconded, passed unanimously, and the resolution was adopted.
[1:11:59][1:12:06]
HB1536 D. Douglas TO CREATE THE COMPASSIONATE CARE END-OF-LIFE OPTION ACT; AND TO EXEMPT THE COMPASSIONATE CARE END-OF-LIFE OPTION ACT FROM THE DEFINITION OF "PHYSICIAN-ASSISTED SUICIDE".
HB1568 L. Johnson TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS ADVISORY COUNCIL OF HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONS WITHIN THE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH.
1:12:55 - 1:18:0619 segments6 speakers
Representative Lee Johnson described HB 1568, which would establish an Arkansas Advisory Council of Healthcare Professions within the Department of Health to gather scope-of-practice information and facilitate stakeholder dialogue, include a sunset provision in 2021, and incur no additional cost.
[1:13:16][1:13:51][1:14:09][1:14:26][1:14:41][1:15:02]
Committee members queried the cost and the role of the Surgeon General; staff confirmed funding would come from existing appropriations and the Surgeon General would serve as a non-voting, unbiased member.
[1:15:44][1:15:50][1:15:58][1:16:01][1:16:05][1:16:13]
With no further testimony, the committee moved a motion to adopt the amendments and pass the bill as amended, which carried unanimously.
[1:16:39][1:16:54][1:17:13][1:17:23]
HB1650 Ladyman TO AMEND CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF THE WORKERS' COMPENSATION LAW THAT RESULTED FROM INITIATED ACT NO. 4 OF 1948; AND TO REVISE THIRD- PARTY LIABILITY IN THE WORKERS' COMPENSATION LAW.
HB1309 S. Meeks TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS NIGHTTIME ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION ACT.
1:18:06 - 1:39:4267 segments9 speakers
Representative Jeff Wardlaw presented HB 1309, proposing to rename the Shielded Outdoor Lighting Act as the Arkansas Nighttime Environment Protection Act, update definitions, replace the 150-watt standard with a 1,800-lumen threshold and require new bulbs to be 4,000 K or warmer to curb blue-rich light exposure.
[1:18:24][1:18:56][1:19:26][1:19:56][1:20:31][1:21:04][1:21:40]
He detailed revisions to exemptions-including a cost-prohibitive benchmark, adding watercraft and highway construction lighting, removing school exemptions, expanding corrections and historic-monument allowances, and initially retaining a billboard provision that he later agreed to withdraw.
[1:22:11][1:22:47][1:23:18][1:23:51][1:24:22][1:24:54][1:25:28][1:26:03][1:26:35]
Committee members queried the grandfather-clause extension, energy-savings potential, compatible bulb types, and enforcement mechanisms; Wardlaw answered that changes would be phased in, could save municipalities hundreds of thousands annually, and would be enforced by local code officers.
[1:27:21][1:27:37][1:27:45][1:28:07][1:28:34][1:28:39][1:28:43][1:28:49][1:29:01][1:29:12]
HB1803 F. Allen TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS BLUE RIBBON PANEL ON PEDIATRIC CANCER RESEARCH.
1:39:42 - 1:50:3535 segments7 speakers
Representative Fred Allen moved an amendment to HB 1803 creating the Arkansas Blue Ribbon Panel on pediatric cancer research, adding specific members, duties for the Department of Health, and provisions for staff and funding.
[1:39:51][1:39:58][1:40:04][1:40:25][1:40:32][1:41:11]
The amendment was seconded by Representative Payton and adopted without debate, as recorded by the chair.
[1:41:37][1:41:41]
Testimony from Michael Keck of the American Cancer Society explained that the panel would coordinate state efforts with the federal STAR Act, work with UAMS, and help secure future grant opportunities.
[1:43:05][1:43:19][1:43:50]
HB1801 L. Johnson TO REQUIRE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO COVER AN ADDITIONAL ALBUTEROL INHALER FOR CERTAIN MEDICAID BENEFICIARIES.
1:50:35 - 2:26:48117 segments17 speakers
Representative Lee Johnson introduced HB 1801, which requires Arkansas Medicaid to provide an additional albuterol inhaler each August for children under 18 who already have a prescription, to ensure a spare inhaler is available at school.
[1:50:57]
No members sought further discussion; the chair called for a motion, Representative Johnson moved to pass the bill, and the motion carried unanimously.
[1:51:29][1:51:49][1:51:52][1:52:06]
HB1796 Della Rosa TO REQUIRE AN APPLICANT TO NOTIFY ADJACENT PROPERTY OWNERS OF PERMIT APPLICATIONS AND MODIFICATIONS BEFORE APPROVAL BY THE ARKANSAS DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY.
HB1761 Crawford TO CREATE THE EGG PROVIDER PROTECTION ACT.
2:26:48 - 1:52:54
Rep. Cindy Crawford introduced HB 1761, the Egg Provider Protection Act, which would prohibit payment for unfertilized human eggs while permitting reimbursement for reasonable expenses, requiring physician-performed retrievals, and preserving fertility-treatment donations.
[2:26:50][2:27:28][2:27:59][2:28:31][2:29:01][2:29:33]
During debate, Rep. Kenneth Ferguson argued that the ban on compensation ignores donors’ costs and hardships and urged allowance for research-related payments, and Rep. Mary Bentley, a surrogate mother, also opposed the bill on the basis of the procedure’s difficulty.
[2:31:23][2:31:46][2:32:34][2:33:07][2:33:12][2:33:22][2:33:34][2:33:40][2:34:12]
SB273 Bledsoe TO CLARIFY THAT AN EXPERT WITNESS ACTING ON BEHALF OF A BOARD OF ANY PROFESSION OR OCCUPATION CLASSIFIED UNDER THE LAWS OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS AS A PROFESSION OF THE HEALING ARTS HAS IMMUNITY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
1:52:54 - 1:55:4011 segments3 speakers
Representative Lee Johnson presented an amendment to SB 273 clarifying that expert witnesses testifying before a professional board receive the same immunity as board members, after consulting with attorneys to refine the language.
[1:53:09][1:53:42]
The amendment was seconded by Representative Boyd and adopted without opposition.
[1:54:07][1:54:15]
Following additional explanation of the bill’s purpose, the committee voted to pass SB 273 as amended, and the motion was carried unanimously.
[1:54:49][1:55:20]
HB1815 Perry TO AMEND THE DEATH CERTIFICATE REGISTRATION PROCESS FOR THE SIGNATURE OF THE MEDICAL CERTIFICATE OF DEATH.
HB1696 Gonzales TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS CLEAN INDOOR AIR ACT OF 2006; AND TO ALLOW PRIVATELY OWNED BUSINESSES THE OPTION TO PROHIBIT SMOKING.
HB1727 Dotson CONCERNING COVERAGE BY AN INSURER FOR INTRAOPERATIVE NEUROPHYSIOLOGICAL MONITORING.
SB504 Irvin TO EXTEND THE EXPIRATION DATE FOR THE PALLIATIVE CARE AND QUALIFY OF LIFE INTERDISCIPLINARY TASK FORCE.
SB456 Irvin TO AMEND THE EDUCATIONAL LICENSES ISSUED BY THE ARKANSAS STATE MEDICAL BOARD.
SB190 G. Leding TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS GENETIC COUNSELOR LICENSURE ACT.
1:55:40 - 2:38:04126 segments18 speakers
Representative Lee Johnson introduced SB 190 and its engrossed amendments (SB 190 S1 and S2) that clarify genetic-counselor responsibilities and exclude nutritionists, and the chair adopted the amendment after a motion by Rep. Deborah Ferguson.
[1:55:51][1:56:22][1:56:56][1:57:09][1:57:27]
HB1841 L. Johnson TO CREATE THE OSTEOPATHIC RURAL MEDICAL PRACTICE STUDENT LOAN AND SCHOLARSHIP; TO CREATE THE OSTEOPATHIC RURAL MEDICAL PRACTICE STUDENT LOAN AND SCHOLARSHIP BOARD; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1840 D. Douglas TO INCREASE THE NUMBER OF PERSONS SERVED UNDER THE ASSISTED LIVING PROGRAM TO ONE THOUSAND FIVE HUNDRED FIFTY (1,550); TO REMOVE THE LIMIT ON THE NUMBER OF PERSONS SERVED AT A TIME IN THE PROGRAM; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1827 D. Ferguson TO REPEAL THE LAW REGARDING THE ARKANSAS NEWSPAPER RECYCLING ADVISORY COMMITTEE.
2:38:04 - 2:39:267 segments6 speakers
Rep. Kenneth B. Ferguson presented HB 1827, which would repeal the Arkansas Newspaper Recycling Advisory Committee, noting the board is no longer used.
[2:38:07]
A motion to do pass the bill was offered by Rep. Wardlaw, no members spoke for or against, and the motion carried unanimously, resulting in the bill’s passage.
[2:38:25][2:38:38]
HB1823 Ladyman TO REQUIRE EMPLOYEES OF FOOD SERVICE ESTABLISHMENTS TO BE IMMUNIZED OR VACCINATED AGAINST HEPATITIS A FOR THE PUBLIC HEALTH, SAFETY, AND WELFARE OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS.
HB1821 Murdock TO PROVIDE FOR MEDICAID REIMBURSEMENT RATES THAT ADDRESS THE MINIMUM WAGE INCREASES; TO PROVIDE FOR IMMEDIATE AND ONGOING REGULAR REVIEWS OF MEDICAID REIMBURSEMENT RATES AND METHODOLOGIES; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
SB448 G. Stubblefield TO REQUIRE PHYSICIANS TO HAVE CERTAIN QUALIFICATIONS TO PERFORM ABORTIONS; AND TO REPEAL THE PRESUMPTION OF VIABILITY OF A FETUS AT THE TWENTY-FIFTH WEEK OF PREGNANCY.
SB398 Rapert TO MODIFY THE STATUTES CONCERNING THE OPERATION OF A FUNERAL ESTABLISHMENT.
HB1257 Boyd TO AUTHORIZE AND CLARIFY THE METHOD OF RELEASING CLAIMS AND ENROLLMENT DATA BY HEALTH INSURERS THAT PROVIDE HEALTHCARE COVERAGE TO ELIGIBLE INDIVIDUALS IN THE ARKANSAS WORKS PROGRAM.
HB1850 McCollum TO ESTABLISH THE EMPOWER INDEPENDENT CONTRACTORS ACT OF 2019; TO AMEND PORTIONS OF THE LAW IMPACTING INITIATED ACT 4 OF 1948; AND TO AMEND DEFINITIONS OF "EMPLOYEE", "EMPLOYMENT", AND "EMPLOYMENT STATUS" WITHIN TITLE 11.
HB1856 Dotson TO PROHIBIT STATE AGENCIES FROM ENGAGING IN THE DECISION-MAKING FOR AN INDIVIDUAL IN THE CUSTODY OF THE STATE REGARDING THE TERMINATION OF A PREGNANCY AND FROM EXPENDING STATE FUNDS FOR THE PURPOSE OF TERMINATING A PREGNANCY.
2:39:26 - -223:14
Rep. Jim Dotson introduced HB 1856, amended to prohibit state agencies from funding or assisting a person in state custody or guardianship in obtaining a pregnancy termination, adding language to align with federal law.
[2:39:31][2:39:38][2:39:47][2:40:20][2:40:24][2:40:40][2:40:59]
The committee adopted the amendment without objection after a motion by Rep. Wardlaw, then moved to do pass the bill as amended; that motion also carried unanimously, leading to the bill’s final approval and the committee’s adjournment.
[2:40:24][2:40:40][2:40:59][2:41:30][2:42:01]
HB1857 Womack TO INCREASE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM BENEFIT LIMIT FOR DIAGNOSTIC TESTING.
HB1860 D. Ferguson TO REQUIRE REPORTING TO THE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH OF PATIENT TRANSFERS FROM A LAY MIDWIFE.
HB1864 D. Ferguson TO AMEND THE PRIOR AUTHORIZATION TRANSPARENCY ACT; TO PROHIBIT PRIOR AUTHORIZATION FOR MEDICATION-ASSISTED TREATMENT; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
SB278 G. Stubblefield TO AMEND LAWS CONCERNING ABORTION FACILITIES AND ABORTION REPORTING; TO AMEND THE BORN-ALIVE INFANT PROTECTION LAWS; AND TO REQUIRE AN ADDITIONAL ACKNOWLEDGMENT UNDER THE WOMAN'S RIGHT-TO-KNOW ACT.
SB377 Irvin TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE COLLECTION AND DISTRIBUTION OF SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL AND TRANSPORTATION FEES.
SCOPE OF PRACTICE BILLS
HB1282 Lundstrum TO REMOVE THE REQUIREMENT FOR A MANDATORY COLLABORATIVE PRACTICE AGREEMENT FOR AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE TO HAVE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY.
SB184 G. Stubblefield TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF CERTIFIED REGISTERED NURSE ANESTHETISTS BY REMOVING SUPERVISION REQUIREMENTS.
HB1323 D. Douglas TO REQUIRE THE OFFICE OF LONG-TERM CARE NOT TO ADOPT RULES OR STANDARDS THAT ARE STRICTER THAN THE FEDERAL MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS FOR CERTIFIED NURSING AIDES OR ASSISTANTS AND CERTIFIED NURSING AIDE OR ASSISTANT INSTRUCTORS.
HB1334 Maddox TO INCREASE THE NUMBER OF PERSONS SERVED UNDER THE ASSISTED LIVING PROGRAM; TO REMOVE A LIMITATION ON THE NUMBER OF PERSONS SERVED AT A TIME IN THE ASSISTED LIVING PROGRAM; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1232 Lowery TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING AUTHORIZED PAYROLL DEDUCTIONS OF UNION DUES FOR PUBLIC EMPLOYEES TO ALLOW DEDUCTIONS ONLY FOR FIREFIGHTERS, POLICE OFFICERS, AND EMERGENCY FIRST RESPONDERS; AND TO PROHIBIT DEDUCTIONS FOR TEACHERS.
HB1102 Sullivan TO ADDRESS THE UNDERSERVED STATUS OF A COUNTY AS A REQUIREMENT FOR LICENSURE AND CERTIFICATION OF CERTAIN PROVIDERS.
HB1528 Womack TO INCREASE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM BENEFIT LIMIT FOR DRUG TESTING AND X-RAYS.
HB1164 Pilkington TO AUTHORIZE A PHARMACIST TO DISPENSE ORAL CONTRACEPTIVES WITHOUT A PRESCRIPTION.
HB1252 Magie TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS ANESTHESIOLOGIST ASSISTANT ACT; AND TO PROVIDE FOR LICENSURE OF ANESTHESIOLOGIST ASSISTANTS.
HB1253 Magie TO AUTHORIZE A LICENSED DISPENSING OPTICIAN TO REFRACT EYES AND DISPENSE EYEGLASSES IN CERTAIN CONDITIONS.
HB1283 Gonzales TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "PRACTICE OF CERTIFIED REGISTERED NURSE ANESTHESIA"; TO CLARIFY THE SCOPE OF PRACTICE OF A CERTIFIED REGISTERED NURSE ANESTHETIST; AND TO REMOVE SUPERVISION REQUIREMENTS.
HB1284 Gonzales TO AUTHORIZE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO RECOGNIZE AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE AS A PRIMARY CARE PROVIDER.
HB1274 Pilkington TO AUTHORIZE AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE WHO HAS SERVED A RURAL COMMUNITY TO PRACTICE WITHOUT A COLLABORATIVE PRACTICE AGREEMENT.
HB1060 Lynch TO ESTABLISH AND REQUIRE CONTINUING EDUCATION FOR HEATING, VENTILATION, AIR CONDITIONING, AND REFRIGERATION LICENSEES.
HB1275 Richey TO CREATE THE COMMUNITY HEALTH WORKER ACT.r
HB1649 Sullivan TO PROVIDE FOR OPPORTUNITIES FOR PATIENT CHOICE AND PROMOTE QUALITY OF CARE AS A REQUIREMENT FOR LICENSURE AND CERTIFICATION OF CERTAIN PROVIDERS.
HB1451 A. Collins TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING THE SUPPLEMENTAL NUTRITION ASSISTANCE PROGRAM; AND TO EXCLUDE CHILD SUPPORT PAYMENTS FROM GROSS INCOME USED FOR ELIGIBILITY DETERMINATION.