Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Education Committee

January 20, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (1)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1051 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…presentative Hendren, you are welcome to present your bill. House Bill 1051 Thank you Mr.”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 16, 2026
The audience today introduced themselves, so I said I would do that last time, so we're going to take a little bit of time here, and if you will look on your desk, you have a packet from Tony Wood, Commissioner for Arkansas Department of Education, and it will have all the pictures and a little bio of the people that work under him, and so you can take that with you keep that get to know them and at this time I don't even know where to start but what I would like to see is a department head or the person that's in charge of whoever's here if you have extras with you if you would just go to the end of the table and introduce yourself and then have people stand up and introduce them from where they're they're seated and that'll that'll save us some time we don't need everybody to go to the end of talk so I'm going to start on the front row on this end and we'll just go down and as we get on the other end we'll just come back so that should make it simple we'll go down and back so on a row and if you're standing up here you get to start down the other table thank you Rich just please when you sit down introduce yourself say who you're with And then who's with you? Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Speaker 6 1:36
I'm Rich Nagel, Interim Executive Director with the Arkansas Education Association. And with me is AA President Brenda Robinson. Thank you. Next. Anybody, as you go down, just
▶ Play
if you want to do it, you don't have to. If you don't want to go to the table, you don't have to introduce yourself. you just nobody will know who you are so we have a lot of new committee members this year so it would be good for anyone that's in this row to please
▶ Play
do that so thank you mr. chairman i'm gary newton with arkansas learns we're a an alliance of parents employers and citizens dedicated excellent education for all students thank you thank you next yes all the way down
▶ Play
and as soon as she's through please next one get up and head that away it'll just expedite things thank you i'm michelle
▶ Play
Speaker 13 2:39
kitchens with arkansas farm bureau thank you okay if
▶ Play
you have anybody with you just please tell us who they are and have them stand
▶ Play
Speaker 14 2:57
Thank you. Bill Abinathy, Arkansas Rural Education Association, and this is my staff out here. And Bill is also
▶ Play
a former chairman of this committee. How many years ago, Bill? I think this is
▶ Play
Speaker 17 3:20
the third term out. Third term out. Thank you, Bill. Good morning, Mr. Chairman and committee. It's a delight to be before you today. I'm Henry Hank Wilkins IV, former state senator, former member of the House. Delighted to see all of you. And unlike Bill, this is not my staff. I don't have a staff, but I'm with everybody here who loves the Lord. Thank you very much. Thank you. Anybody else on that row?
▶ Play
Okay. hi good morning everyone my name is sheena lewis i'm the president of lux public relations firm and then also i'm representing the city of little rock i'm also the commissioner and a chair for the commission for children youth
▶ Play
and families thank you we'll start with tony down that
▶ Play
Speaker 23 4:21
way tony wood commissioner of education we've got a number of our staff and as mr hudson already referenced in regard to the information we've tried to provide you, but I still will just briefly recognize Michelle Griffin, I think, is in the group, back in the back, Legislative Service Director, Susan Harriman, Policy and Special Projects, Greg Rogers, Chief Physical Officer, Kimberly Freeman, Communications, Cody Decker deals with research and Technology, Jeremy Laster, General Counsel, Debra Jones, Assistant Commissioner for Learning Services, Annette Barnes, Assistant Commissioner for Public School Accountability, Eric Saunders, Dr. Saunders, Assistant Commissioner for Physical and Administrative Services, Ivy Pfeiffer, Assistant Commissioner of Human Resources and Education and Effectiveness, Mike Hernandez, Deputy Commissioner and certainly of importance Deborah Coffin who is our chief of staff she does the best she can keep me straight and we don't have to give anybody a tardy slip or anything today because all of our people came to join you for a few minutes thank you thank you we'll start I guess we'll
▶ Play
Speaker 32 5:40
start back up here again if
▶ Play
Speaker 34 5:55
you want to start on this end Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm Richard Hutchinson. I'm here representing the Arkansas Public Policy Panel and an education coalition called the Arkansas Opportunity to Learn Campaign, which is a coalition of a number of grassroots and policymaking organizations in the state interested in making sure that all children, regardless of where they live, have access to a quality public school education. Thank you. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 37 6:34
you. Good morning. I'm Jerry Dorlikowski. I'm with Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families. We're a group that represent the interests primarily of low-income children in the state. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 39 6:45
Good morning. Sandra Porter, Interim Deputy Director for Career Ed. Our new director, Dr. Sharice Childers, was unable to be here this morning, but she asked me to read a short statement for you. Chairman Cozart, Vice Chairman Lampkin, and members of the committee, Thank you for the opportunity to address you today. I would like to have been here in person, but I am attending a special called meeting at the State Board of Career Education. I am honored to be selected by Governor Hutchison as the Director of the Department of Career Education. I look forward to working with all of you and the members of the Senate Education Committee as we improve the career and educational services that prepare our youth and adults for jobs while meeting the needs of our business in Arkansas. Most importantly, I appreciate you for your service in the Arkansas General Assembly and your commitment to education in Arkansas. Our agency is available at any time, and my door will always be open. I also have with me today Sonja Wright-McMurray, Associate Director for Arkansas Works. Thank you. Thank you. Good morning.
▶ Play
Speaker 41 8:06
I'm Tanya Williams, Director of the Division of Child Care and Early Childhood Education at the Department of Human Services. Look forward to working with you.
▶ Play
Speaker 43 8:20
Don't be bashful. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Tony Perthrow, Director of the Arkansas School Boards Association. I have several with us here today. First, I'd like to introduce the point person for our legislative team, who is our advocacy director, Mr. Boyce Watkins, if you'd stand. Beside him is Jennifer George, our communications director. And on the front row, we also have Lucas Harder, who is our policy director. And then beside him, you may have formerly known her as Kristen Gould. She has since married and is now Kristen Garner. She'll answer to just about anything, as long
▶ Play
Speaker 45 9:11
as it starts with Kristen. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm Richard Abernathy, and I'm Executive Director of Arkansas Association of Educational Administrators, sometimes just known as school superintendents and school personnel. But we have several that are with me today and a couple of new faces. Mike Mertens, he's the Assistant Executive Director, and he's certainly not new. He'll be over here all the time and visit with many of you as we've gone forward. Two new positions, Robin King. And Robin King is our financial consultant. She works with school districts. She works with superintendents. She works with CFOs of schools, and especially regarding finance and coding to make sure that it's coded the way our legislature expects. Mitch Walton. Mitch Walton has just added, matter of fact, a couple weeks now. He's a former superintendent. He works with our principal groups, and we certainly welcome him aboard and look forward to working with you in the future. Good morning. I
▶ Play
haven't had the pleasure of meeting all of you yet. I'm with the governor's office. My name is Sarah Moore, and I am serving as education policy advisor and liaison in that role. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 50 10:30
Good morning, I'm Rosalyn Middleton with the Arkansas Attorney General's Office, and I will be serving as the educational attorney for both the House and Senate, and I'll also, for my backup, I have with me today Amber Schubert, who's also an Assistant Attorney General. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 52 11:06
Good morning. I'm Scott Smith with the Arbindsville Public School Resource Center. With us today is Christy Campbell with our Teaching and Learning Unit, Katie Clifford with the Communications Office. Also working in this committee is Tripp Walter with our Legal Counsel, and I don't believe he's here Bobby Davis many of you know I'm Dr. Davis with our school finance office and Barbara Hunter Cox and we serve school districts charter schools and educational cooperatives all over the state. Thank you Last roll
▶ Play
Speaker 56 11:40
Good morning, Mr. Chairman and members. My name is Jim Hall. I'm the Executive Director for Northwest Arkansas Community College Government Relations. Thank you for the opportunity to introduce myself. I do represent a growing college up in Northwest Arkansas. I look forward to getting to know all of you and telling you the wonderful things that we do at our college and what other two-year colleges do across the state. Thank you very much. Thank you,
▶ Play
Speaker 58 12:26
Mr. Chair and committee. I'm Lance Taylor, and I'm with the Arkansas High School Activities Association. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Chuck Welch.
▶ Play
Speaker 62 12:46
I'm the president of the Arkansas State University System, and I have with me today two employees, our executive vice president, Julie Bates, and he may introduce himself in his current role, but our soon-to-be vice president for governmental relations. Did Shane walk out? There he is, Shane Broadway, so you all know, I think. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 64 13:12
Hi, I'm Elaine Wooten with the Office of Education Policy at the University of Arkansas at Fayetteville. We do policy research on K-12 education issues. Good morning, Mr. Chair, committee. My name is
▶ Play
Diane Zook, and I'm on the State Board of Education. Thank you, Mr. Chairman's Committee.
▶ Play
Speaker 69 13:48
I'm Mitch Luella, and I'm an attorney from Fort Smith. I represent the Alamo. Turn your mic on, please. Does that work? I'm Mitch Luella, an attorney from Fort Smith. I represent the Alamo, Van Buren, Fort Smith, and Greenwood School Districts. I'm proud
▶ Play
Speaker 68 14:11
to have with me today the superintendent of the Alamo School District, Mr. David Woolley. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 73 14:19
Did that work? Try again. Mark
▶ Play
Speaker 69 14:22
tells me try again, so since he's a major demo here, I'll try again. Mitch Llewellyn, attorney from Fort Smith. I represent the Alma, Van Buren, Fort Smith, and Greenwood School Districts. I'm proud to have with me today Superintendent David Woolley from the Alma School District. And don't believe anything John Walker tells you about me. Thank you. Mr. Broadway.
▶ Play
Speaker 76 14:57
Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. I'm Shane Broadway, currently the director of the Arkansas Department of Higher Education, and I have with me today our deputy director, Harold Criswell, and our chief counsel, Janet Lawrence, and we are here to assist you in any way that we can. I'm going to say, y'all in the back of the room, start making your way
▶ Play
kind of towards the end if you want to. If you want to speak, if you don't, then that's fine, too. Good morning, Mr. Chair and members.
▶ Play
Speaker 80 15:27
Good morning, Mr. Chair and members. I'm Michelle Lynch. I'm the Executive Director of the Arkansas State Teachers Association, and we serve and support teachers and other school employees all across the state, and we look forward to
▶ Play
Speaker 84 15:46
working with you. Good morning, Mr. Chairman. Johnny Key with the University of Arkansas System. My colleague, Melissa Rust, is out with a phone call, but you'll see us here working on behalf of all the campuses of the University of Arkansas system. I also want to introduce, if they would stand, Randy Massinelli is with the Fayetteville campus, Joni Lee with UALR, and Dr. Elizabeth Underwood with the University of Arkansas Fort Smith. Mr. Chairman, members of
▶ Play
Speaker 85 16:19
the committee, I'm Bill Stovall, Executive Director of Arkansas Community Colleges, and you'll probably be seeing me or three of my colleagues, none of which are with me this morning for me to introduce.
▶ Play
Speaker 86 16:31
Thank you for the opportunity. Hello, I'm Breanne Davis with Arkansas Tech University. With our Russell campus and the ATU Ozark campus, we are the third largest university in the state of Arkansas right now with over 12,000 students. Thank you.
▶ Play
Good morning. My name is Stacey Tatera. I'm representing the Arkansas School for the Deaf, where we are proud to serve deaf and hard of hearing kids throughout the state. And we look forward to working with all of y'all. Thank
▶ Play
you. Anyone else? Going? Going? Gone. Again, welcome to everyone. I would like now to introduce my vice chair, Sheila Lampkin. And Sheila, do you have anything you'd like to say this morning? I'm just honored
▶ Play
Speaker 91 17:31
to be here and honored to be working with all of y'all, and I look forward to an exciting session. Thank you. All
▶ Play
right. I guess we're ready to get down to business. We have one bill that we'd like to run this morning. Representative Hendren, you are welcome to present your bill. House Bill 1051 Thank you Mr.
▶ Play
Chairman I left at 4.30 this morning was on my way down here attending my own business and I get a telephone call from the chairman and he said you prepared to introduce your bill and I said probably about as prepared as I am for anything but you didn't have nothing else or anything else to do this morning so that's one of the reasons I sometimes get called into action i i was just thinking mr chairman as you all introduced all these people thank the lord i didn't have this many constituents or supervisors or lobbyists as i was trying to build fence this weekend or i wouldn't have got anything done i am kim hendron and i represent 30,000 people now like the members of this committee and all the hundred of us in the house do and so what i told the chairman what i wasn't prepared to do this but what i what i want to do is to at least preliminary thing because my fault i have not worked this committee i do not work committees that's not my style uh i pre lay it out there if it's a good deal fix uh make it better and fix it if it's a bad deal throw it in the trash can that's how in my opinion we serve the state of arkansas that so the chairman was good enough today to let me i doubt we'll ask for a vote because what's happened even today uh there are other members that have similar bills that they want to uh maybe we'll assimilate and put together dealing with this particular issue there are other members that have asked to become co-sponsors or on the bill and and i don't care who sponsors it i don't worry about that but if you're what we need to do is to get a consensus if it's a good deal let's do it if it's not us don't do it so what what i want to do here this morning is just go down through where this came from and why it's here and then what suggestions you may have as to how it could be made better maybe it shouldn't be done at all but whatever So what it is, as you see the title, is to establish the public school efficiency and evaluation task force. Let me say right at the outset, I hate task force. I'm not too excited about big government at all, but I am excited when constituents, and by the way, any bills I bring before this committee or any other committee are not just ideas that I've had out there pounding a fence post or picking up dead chickens. It's a constituent that's come to me with a problem or with a suggestion that the government, which is you and I ought to deal with and try to make better or fix or do away with something. This bill today has to do with paperwork with public schools. Probably these big shots in these colleges, probably the same thing there. Anytime they're charging us $20,000 a year to go to college, we ought to see what we can do to make that more efficient, but that's for another day. But what this does, I read an article in a gazette the other day, and I hope you saw it. If you don't, we'll get it out. You need to read it because it will give you some of the background for this bill. Some professor or somebody at the University of Arkansas had done a study on reports and tests. This is not primarily to do with testing, but reports that teachers and staff and perhaps even administrators have to fill out. And what he did is he studied that. You fill these out, send them somewhere. They probably go on somebody's desk and get stacked 15 feet high so they can't do anything else. That's not a bomb, is it? What he had done is do a study of what was happening, what tests and paperwork teachers were having to do in our public schools. Then he followed that up. Isn't that an amazing thing to give a test or get a report and then follow up and see if it did anything? Well, he happened to do that, and he found out in that study, that article as I recall it, that the ones who did it and the ones who didn't do it, there was less than 1% difference in the performance of their students. Now, I'll tell you, the way we run things around our place, if it ain't doing no good, then quit doing it, especially unless you can do it for free, and I don't know of anything that's free. So when I read that article, and then I've had other public school people and public education people come and say, why don't you just let me teach kids what two times two is and how to write with cursive writing. Sorry, Mr. Chairman, I just had to get that in there. But why don't you let us teach these students instead of filling out this paperwork, unless the paperwork makes us a better teacher or makes a student a better, about, I just got a call from a guy today that runs a sale barn. He went to Sonic the other night, and the gal tried to, the kid came out to make change. He gave him, I think his $6 for a couple of drinks. I thought that was kind of high, but $6 and something for his, now they're soft drinks. He got these two drinks, but he gave this young person a $20 bill, and after she had thought, I don't know whether he or she had thought a minute, this waiter at Sonic, my heart goes out to him, gave him back $21. somebody got that at least one of us so they but what what the point is here is a teacher would rather be teaching a kid how to make change than to fill out a report that doesn't do any good so as you go down through this and as i say i don't like task force i don't like committees i don't unless they do something and we accomplish something line 25 section a the chair of the house committee and they're going to point these things down through here but let's see what they do here where does it start down here actually well to read this bill probably before we passed it hadn't we uh let's see what here it is number line 23 of page 2 uh section d the purpose of this task force is to now this first one i thought this might just be thrown away most of you know when we have an idea for a bill down here at least the way i think it works you call up this lawyers down here and they draw you up a bill and but sometimes they don't know sometimes we don't know what we're talking about sometimes they don't know what we're talking about so they bring it out and then we we in committees here we work it over and make it to be what the people of arkansas want us to want to happen and i know that's true because i had a bill the other day and the guy said i ran your i've read the 45 pages of your bill and i said i didn't talk 45 pages that yeah i changed to make one sentence i said if you want to know who's responsible for those other 44 pages look in the mirror it's us guys down here that keep adding some stuff but if you look at that Line 25, 24, the purpose of this task force is to, one, study state and federal regulations that are applicable to public schools. And I almost circumvent that ought to go out of there because you could study those until kingdom come and never get the answer. But I think if you look at items two, three, and four, you need to know a little bit about this to see what we're doing, what's required. Line 26, number two, review the data and reporting requirements of the Department of Education and local education agencies. What are the requirements? What are the requirements? Number three, identify areas of law or rule that can be modified or, here's a key word, eliminated to improve the efficiency of public schools. And that's why I say, man, from K through college at six or eight years or whatever it is, that thing could apply. But this is just the public school section. Number four, to make recommendations to the General Assembly. And that's you and I, ladies and gentlemen. It's our responsibility to represent those 460,000-so school kids in this state as well as the 3 million people that sent us down here. And we do it with input from these folks here, absolutely. But more than that, it's input from those guys back at home today are working and sent us down here to do this. So basically that's what the bill does. Now there's one or two members on this committee that have ideas. And what I'm going to suggest, what we're going to suggest, Mr. Chairman, is that maybe we combine their ideas with this bill and whoever wants to sponsor it, I don't care, but refine this thing to make it do what we're wanting it to do, to see if it needs to be done, if it's helping the students, if it is, let's keep doing it. But if it's not, let's get it out of there and make it more efficient. thank you are
▶ Play
you through presenting I reckon I'm getting ready to take questions I'm going to remind y'all one question then ask for a follow up and then we will continue to the next person if you don't have a follow up that's fine we'll just continue on so I
▶ Play
think we have Representative Lowry you're recognized yes thank you Mr. Chair Representative Hendren I appreciate the theme of what you're presenting to us in terms of efficiency and streamlining so my question would be would it not be more efficient and streamlined to use the current committee structure that we have i.e. we have a subcommittee on k-12 education could that subcommittee not perform the duties of this task force without us adding another layer of maybe
▶ Play
inefficient governance yes they could but But my answer, based on what I'm seeing, the staff out there are not doing
▶ Play
it. So follow up, Mr. Chair. So you'd be satisfied if the current chairman, for instance, were to utilize the subcommittees? And I know that having been on education one term before, I know subcommittees are used very seldom. If we could energize the use of those subcommittees to do the very work that you're talking about,
▶ Play
that would satisfy you? Oh, absolutely. If there's anything, I don't want more government, but I tell you what, the government we've got ought to be doing their job, and it's not being done on this one based on that item that I talked about, plus just the empirical evidence is you go talk to
▶ Play
the teachers. If it can be done,
▶ Play
Speaker 101 27:19
absolutely, but how do I know it's
▶ Play
Speaker 108 27:27
going to be done? All right. Thank you, Representative Hendren. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Douglas. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I would make a commitment to you, Representative Hendren, as the K-12 chair, to take this on and work with the education, you know, chairman to develop a format for this under your guidance and maybe loop in these other bills that you're talking about. And the reason I think this is important is because every time I have spoken on a legislative panel, one consistent question that we get is, you know, how can you deregulate our lives so that we can better teach the kids? So I see this as an issue that needs to be explored. And if that's the way the chair would like to handle it, I would be very open to that and would attack that with passion and take the time to do a good job on it. Absolutely.
▶ Play
And as I said before, I'm not looking for more government, regardless of what some people may think about that. But if we'll do it and get the job done, I'm for it. And so my question, Representative, is to you, is that how do we hold ourselves accountable to get this done? I'm ready to pull the bill down, bail the bill down. Maybe that's a good word for it. When you get my age, sometimes you misspeak, so I hope you'll give me some allowance. I'm ready to pull the bill down, provided, Charlotte, that we do something about it and we get a report in the time frame here. But as I said, and with all due respect, up to now it
▶ Play
hadn't been done. You're recognized. Do you have a follow-up? No. Okay. Representative Murdoch, you're recognized. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman. I don't have a question as much as I wanted to join the discussion. And to get a good understanding, what we're talking about is deregulation or what are we getting back in terms of reports or assessments for what's going on. And I think maybe we will need to hear from the people that will be ultimately producing these documents, which is the Department of Education, because now I'm sure what they're trying to do is produce what we've asked them to this point. So maybe we could hear from them and ask them how we can maybe even formulate this legislation that helps them to deliver for us what we want from them as information so that we can make the good decisions. So maybe they need to be included in the
▶ Play
conversation as well. I think you're correct, and I think that's where they would be looking for this information.
▶ Play
I agree with that. Thank you, Mr. Murrock. You would agree with that too, right? Yes, sir. Thank you. What
▶ Play
is your will to do? I think that this is off to a good start, having your first bill thrown in the trash can. But really, if we'll get it done, let me tell you something. If we don't do it, I'm going to be screaming again, and the public are going to be screaming. We just need to get it done. We need to get an answer. This has a date of by the end of 2016. That's next year, and I'm assuming this is what committee. Who's going
▶ Play
to do this? I mean, we talk about somebody who's going to do it. Well, who is it? We have subcommittees, and Representative Douglas is the chair of the K-12 and vote technical subcommittee, and they meet mostly during the interim, but we are trying to use them to discuss some of these bills during the session also. So they will be working on that. So her committee from her
▶ Play
and for you, Mr. Chairman, we'll accomplish what this task force asked for and do it by the end of 2016. We will try to all of our
▶ Play
duty to do that. I'll pull the bill down. Thank you. I believe that there are no more bills on the table. What I would like to also do is make another announcement. Since we do have a new committee, we have freshmen on this committee, a lot of the groups that are before us in the audience today use acronyms to describe some things. We would like for you, if you come to the table to describe something and you use an acronym, please tell them what that means. Not everybody, not even myself. I mean, as a lot of them, I don't have a clue what you're talking about. So if you would, any time there's something that comes out there, tell them what that means. And we will be asking you, if you say that on the end of the table, I may stop you and please tell them what that means, what is the actual wordage for that. So any other questions or anything from the committee? I need a motion to adjourn. Motion to adjourn. All those in favor say aye. Motion. We are adjourned. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1051

18:06 - 32:31 43 segments 7 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Bruce Cozart Chair Unverified
21 segments
Speaker 6
1 segment
Gary Newton Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 13
1 segment
Speaker 14
1 segment
Speaker 17
2 segments
Sheena Lewis Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 23
3 segments
Speaker 32
1 segment
Speaker 34
2 segments
Speaker 37
1 segment
Speaker 39
3 segments
Speaker 41
1 segment
Speaker 43
2 segments
Speaker 45
3 segments
Sarah Moore Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 50
1 segment
Speaker 52
1 segment
Speaker 56
2 segments
Speaker 58
1 segment
Speaker 62
1 segment
Speaker 64
2 segments
Diane Zook Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 69
2 segments
Speaker 68
1 segment
Speaker 73
1 segment
Speaker 76
1 segment
Speaker 80
1 segment
Speaker 84
2 segments
Speaker 85
1 segment
Speaker 86
1 segment
Stacey Tatera Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 91
2 segments
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
23 segments
Chair Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 101
1 segment
Speaker 108
3 segments
Representative Reginald Murdock Unverified
3 segments