House Revenue & Taxation Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (2)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1132
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…take up, without objection, members, we're going to take up House Bill 1132 this morning. It'll be the only bill that we'll be hearing…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1178
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1178”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 16, 2026
There, find a seat. We're going to get started. The chair sees a quorum. Anybody? We're going to take up, without objection, members, we're going to take up House Bill 1132 this morning. It'll be the only bill that we'll be hearing this morning. Without objection, this will be taken up out of order for the committee. Anybody signing up, anybody's going to speak for or against the bill, please sign up, sign in on the sign-in sheet.
Representative Pitch, are you ready to run your bill, sir? I've got the wrong one. My apologies. 1178. But you can run the 1131 if you want to, Matthew. I was frantically looking for that bill, Mr. Chairman. Well, I know this is your first one. You know, I'm just going to let your conscience be your guide.
All right. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and committee. As you said, this is my first bill.
This bill came out of the governor's task force in the 89th General Assembly as a recommendation. Act 690 was a state statute in 1997, which allowed for the formation of regional intermodal transportation authorities. They're called RETAs. As a state, we have four of those, with four more trying to get ready, up and running. This statute, ask for what you see here. So everybody probably says this is a clarification bill, but this truly is a clarification bill.
The Attorney General was asked for an opinion. He came back with the comment that I know you think you did that, but you didn't quite do that. And so he's given us most of the wording you see here. It was scored as revenue neutral by ADFA, and they gave a 50-mile limit clause that was added as well. And I think that pretty much defines what we're trying to do here. So I would hope for a good vote, as they say. So open for questions.
Members, are there any questions? Representative Ease,
are these four RETAs that you're talking about? Well, there are four that are in existence. There's a Western Arkansas Rita in Fort Smith. There's a Southeast Arkansas Rita, which is home to the Representative John Lipton, who crafted the very first legislation, Act 690 in 1997. Batesville, Northeast Arkansas, has a Rita that's just starting to get some traction.
And then there's one in the southwest part of the state that's kind of a startup as well. we've heard from four other communities who are seeing the impact of RITA's that are starting to form them so thank you members are there any other questions
I'm not seeing any other questions does anybody in the audience want to speak against the bill have you signed in ma'am no ma'am
well if you want to sign in you want to speak from you have sign? Are you Ms. Sellers? You're recognized ma'am to go to the end of the table and speak. We're going to have to recognize you at the end of the table and just recognize yourself and you're free to speak. How are you? Please recognize yourself for the please recognize yourself for the record please.
My name is Diana Sellers. I am a retired Army Captain with my last duty station being an instructor at the United States Military Academy at West Point. Additionally, I am a supply officer, an ammunition officer, and a transportation officer. uh the previous speaker mentioned a rita in southwest arkansas but not did did not give a
location and i didn't want that uh second of all where are these other four rita locations trying to start up what what rivers because this has to do with river and rail third of the four ritas are they privately owned? And of the four upcoming RITAs, will they be privately owned? Or will they be state owned?
I'm very concerned about the United States in a lot of ways. And the budget is up there in the top five. I would like to know the answer to these questions because if these are private companies and I know Arkansas is trying to get companies coming into state from out of state and giving them tax reductions or no taxes at all to start up
but is that for just a start up period and then they get taxes or is that through infinity I don't get that People should pay taxes on what they earned based on
the income tax statutes, period. Yes, ma'am. I certainly appreciate your comments, and I appreciate your service to the country. I certainly recognize our veterans and what they mean to us, and when Representative Pitts closes for his bill,
then he can address some of your concerns if he so choose which, too. So thank you very much, ma'am. So anybody here want to speak for it? Mr. Gene Higginbotham, you're recognized, sir. And
Speaker 23
6:08
please state your name, please. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Gene Higginbotham. I'm director of the Arkansas Waterways Commission, speaking on behalf of the bill. I can answer some of those questions for you. The Southwest Arkansas Regional Intermodal Authority basically is a public entity.
It consists of Clark County, Pike County, Montgomery County. Nevada County was a part of it. I think they just removed themselves. Dallas County as well. So it's a multi-county organization. It's basically headquartered in Arkadelphia. All of the regional intermodal facilities are public entities. They have scheduled meetings that any member of the public can attend.
So they do work with private entities to help create jobs inside the state of Arkansas using these regional intermodal authorities. One of the things that we're trying to do, in particular with the commission, is we're trying to create partnerships between ports and intermodal authorities that actually aren't adjacent to a river. So we can take advantage of those partnerships and creating more job opportunities by helping those ports and intermodal authorities work together through marketing agreements.
As a member, I'll say this, I was a member of the task force. This was one of the tools that the intermodal authorities came to us with. I mean, they're in desperate need of tools to help them recruit more industry increase more jobs in their particular areas of the state. As far as future Rita's, I've been working with one in particular in the Conway area that's basically a combination of Faulkner, Perry, and Conway counties. So they're moving forward with theirs. There's also another group in
Russellville that's also planning an intermodal authority as well. The Northeast Arkansas Regional Intermodal Authority is basically based in Pocahontas, Pico Foods, and the jobs that are created there basically through the work of that regional intermodal authority up there. So we've got even though some of them are basically just starting up, we're already starting to see some successes out of this regional
intermodal authority group. But this was a tool that those intermodal authorities asked us for, and we wanted to see if we couldn't give them that help. Representative Meek, do you want a
question? Yes, sir. Thank you. I had a couple questions, and of course I've kind of worked with you a little bit on the Conway one. I have kind of a question and a concern about this that you may be able to answer. What kind of leasees would you expect
to come into these intermodal transportations? It
regional intermodal transportation authorities, per the question that was asked, deal with five areas. It's not just river. It's water, obviously, but it's railroad, highway development, airport development, and a fifth category called economic development. If RIDAs by Act 690, almost 15, 16 years old now, is allowed to own properties,
and if they were to own properties next to a river, I could see a port operator. If they were as southeast Arkansas as RIDA, they wanted to build a spur on a railroad, then you'd have a railroad might be a leasee to it. So it varies in nature, but it is a tool that was originally intended with Representative Lipton's bill. And, again, we're not dealing with RITA's here. We're dealing with the clarification of what was written in the first law. Right. And I guess
my concern is, and either one of you may be able to answer this,
is that in the Constitution one of the things it talks about when dealing with taxes is that they be fair and uniform across the board. And could we end up with situations where we create an unfair advantage to those that are businesses that are, say, whether it's in the Conway area or Fort Smith area, where you've got one business competing directly with another business and the one business is located within the RITA and they get a tax break that the business that's outside the RITA doesn't? Is that a potential scenario that could be an unintended consequence of this?
Well, in scoring it with ADFA, one of the clauses that they were concerned, and they might want to talk to it here too, but the only concern they really voiced with the original intent of Act 690 was someone who would become a REEDA leasee for the sole purpose of getting the sales and use tax around the state at other venues. Thus, you see the one clause that ADFA requested was put in here, the 50-mile radius. They need to be on that spot. So I think ADFA felt fairly, I don't want to put words in their mouth, Representative Meeks,
but I think they felt fairly comfortable in the application of this. Okay. And
maybe, Mr. Chair, at the proper time, I'd be interested in hearing kind of their thoughts on this and addressing this concern to make sure that we're not creating this unfair tax situation for competitors. Okay. We'll have
Tim and his folks come down to the end just here shortly. Are you done, Representative Meeks? Yes. Thank you. Representative Collins, you're recognized. Motion at the proper time, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Representative Collins.
Speaker 34
11:59
meeting, but I'd like to confirm with you, Mr. Higginbotham, while I have the chance, is it your understanding that the
Little Rockport Authority is unaffected by this bill? Yes, sir. That's correct. It is.
Thank you, sir. Members, any other question? I'm sorry. Representative Hendren, you're recognized. Just very quickly, I think the captain's question was, at least I can understand it, this bill, does it exempt sales taxes from any private entity or are they all public?
The readers are all public. Who the leasee might be is yet to be determined by that scenario, but they would be a leasee on a public entity's property. So if this leasee is
a for-profit corporation such as I might own that I wanted to operate there, then this would let me buy tools and stuff without taxes on it? That is correct. Does that have any effect on affecting the competitiveness of whoever is competing with them?
It's hard for me to answer that without knowing who might be a leasee, But I do believe that their sales and use tax on the port would be a transportation venue that serves the community. I guess the best example I can give is if someone was to lease land on a harbor owned by Rita, Rita being a public entity, that harbor would not be used for company leasees strictly business. It would have to be utilized in a public way for the community's deals.
So it's hard to answer the, is it fair, are they doing business for themselves or are they doing business for the community to be on our properties as Rita's land? They would be doing stuff for the community. I see, Mr. Chairman,
I see Tim Leathers sitting over there, and when the state pays him these big bucks to answer questions like this, so at the proper time, could we get him to answer that question if he would? Sit here. Mr. Chair,
members of the committee, my name is John Tice.
I'm with the Department of Finance and Administration, and Mr. Leathers, in his high-paid position, delegated that responsibility, so I will see what I can do to help.
top of the food chain. It is. DFA did review this bill in advance of it being filed. We did give it a zero revenue impact because there are currently no businesses physically located at one of these RITA's for which the sales and use tax exemption would apply.
We did raise the concern that a business located near the RITA could close a facility and physically move it to the RITA solely for the purpose of getting a sales tax exemption for that for-profit business. In result to that concern, the sponsor did add a provision that you didn't get this sales tax exemption if you physically closed or ceased operations or dramatically reduced operations within a 50-mile radius of the RITA to get the exemption.
Are there any other questions that Captain raised a minute ago that you could answer
right there for us? I'm trying to remember what the questions were, but I
don't believe so. Representative Meeks, you're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Just to follow up on the question that I had is, could you create a situation where you've got two competitors in the same field, or one's within the RITA and one's outside the RITA, and be giving an advantage to the one business because of the taxes? I mean, based upon the nature of what the RITA does, is that unlikely?
What's your thoughts? Representative Meeks, I don't believe that is a concern because the constitutional provision you were referring to regarding equal taxation throughout the state is a property tax concept and relates only to property taxation. This is a sales and use tax exemption, and there's no similar limitation. Okay, but, I mean, just in the
concept, could you have two businesses competing where one's paying the sales tax and the other one's not? Do you foresee that as becoming an issue?
I want to make sure there's no unintended consequences. I'm not against the tax cut. I just want to make sure that we're not harming one business and helping another business. I want to
make sure that. It is not a legal issue. Whether it becomes a political issue or something down the road, that's a different question. But legally, we do that under current law with economic development incentives and with other types of tax statutes. Okay. All right. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Lemons, please.
Quick question. If you have two companies, A and B, A moves within the 50 miles, becomes part of the RITA, and let's say that A and B are in competition, is there any exclusionary measure that would keep B from also coming into
the RITA if they so desired? any company could come into the Rita and qualify for the sales tax exemption as this bill is written. The only thing this bill prohibits is closing or substantially reducing operations at another location within a 50-mile radius of the Rita solely to move to the Rita to take
advantage of the sales tax. But otherwise, any business could physically locate within the Rita and qualify for the exemption. So we could
have two competing businesses within the same Rita? you could or you could
are any other questions we're with just a second we're working through an issue right here
representing flowers you are recognized now
thank you I just want to clarify it's the southeast location in Warren.
Speaker 23
18:01
Yeah, the southeast location is a combination of basically Warren and Monticello. It's actually located between the cities of Monticello and Warren. Okay, thank you. Any other questions, members? Representative
Pitch, are you closed for your bill? You want to make a
closing statement? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. We're in brief. We are dealing with a clarification. This
This is not how RETAs work or don't work, and those RETAs that are in existence have been a real tool for communities. I will not take time in this committee. I'd be happy to outside to explain the return on that investment that has occurred over the last five years, but this is a clarification of the original author's intent. And if you have questions, I think what you're looking at is a good bill. It's a revenue-neutral bill, and I'd appreciate a good vote.
Members, you heard the closing statement. What's the will of the committee? Have a
motion, Representative Collins? Yes, Mr. Chair. I move do pass on House
Bill 1178. Motion from Representative Collins, do pass. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, say no. Ayes have it. Congratulations, Representative Pitch. You passed your first bill. Thank
you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you to the committee
also. With that objection, this committee meeting is adjourned.
Agenda
HB1178
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Joe Jett Chair
Unverified
Representative Kim Hendren Chair
Unverified
Representative Lance Eads
Unverified
Diana Sellers
Unverified
Speaker 23
Representative Stephen Meeks
Unverified
Speaker 28
Speaker 33
Speaker 34
John Tice
Unverified
Representative Tim Lemons
Unverified
Representative Vivian Flowers
Unverified
Representative Charlie Collins
Unverified