Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Public Health, Welfare and Labor Committee

February 17, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (7)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1311 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1311”
Pre-2017 bill
SB4 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Thank you, Mr. Chair. Today, I present to you SB 4 for your consideration, and I believe this bill is somethin…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1120 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1120”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1355 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1355”
Pre-2017 bill
HR1019 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1019”
Pre-2017 bill
SB153 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB153”
Pre-2017 bill
SB53 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB53”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
I want to, if we could, I'd like to hear from the Surgeon General Bledsoe. Are you ready? Would you like to, he would like to address this committee, and I would like him to address this committee. We've been talking a little bit about some of the bills we've got coming up here, and I think that he can give us some insight. The scope of practice bills get confusing, burdensome, and almost a little bit scary. So if you would, introduce yourself for the record, and you're recognized to address this committee.
▶ Play
Can you all hear me? Okay. So I'm Dr. Greg Bledsoe, the Surgeon General for the state, and I appreciate the chairman asking me to come and just do a very brief overview. In discussions with a number of stakeholders and in discussions with the governor himself about these expanded scope of practice bills, we've come down on the side of, we believe that we do need to work to help our underserved areas, but we also need to do it in an appropriate way with appropriate oversight. And for that reason, we are going to be supporting Dr. McGee's bills, the one that was already passed through committee, and also the anesthesia assistant bill, but the others we won't be supporting. We feel like it gives too much autonomy to the nurse practitioners and the nurse anesthetists. So that's a short summary. Any questions for me?
▶ Play
Representative Payton, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Dr. Bledsoe, just to make sure I heard you right, the bill that we already passed out that Dr. McGee or Representative McGee ran is something that you're comfortable with. Yes, sir. Before the meeting, I thought you had mentioned the local paramedics or something like that? Yes, sir. That's the other one. Is there another one that you may be?
▶ Play
Yes, sir. And that's, I'm not exactly sure how to classify that. It's sort of an expanded scope of practice bill, but that's one I'm very much in favor of. I've talked to a number of the health care leaders around the state that represent other entities, and they're also very excited about it. We think that that bill will be very good for our rural hospitals in particular because it allows a way for them to monitor patients who are in the community who maybe were recently discharged from the hospital or have needs. They can use the paramedics and the EMS providers to check on these folks and potentially keep them from bouncing back to the hospital. With the Affordable Care Act, one of the things that's really impacted our rural hospitals is you get penalized if a certain number of patients bounce back after a hospital admission. So you admit them, you discharge them, and if they bounce back to the hospital, you can get penalized for that. The role of these paramedics with this community paramedic program we think will be very helpful and protective of our rural hospitals to keep these folks from bouncing back unnecessarily. So we're very much in favor of that. Yes, sir. Thank you very much for your insight and
▶ Play
information. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Bentley, I've got you next.
▶ Play
You're recognized. Yes, ma'am. Dr. Bledsoe, thanks for coming.
▶ Play
If we could talk just a minute about the Nessus Assistance Bill. The district that I cover is very rural, Dardanelle, Danville, Moralton, just rural small hospitals, and none of those hospitals have an anesthesiologist on staff. They all have CRNAs on staff. So I'm not sure where we see the need for that. Do we see that in our large hospitals that we want these necessary assistants or what? Can you broaden just a little bit on that
▶ Play
subject just a little bit? Are you talking about Dr. McGee's bill? Yes. So I think this is a good example of how we can possibly expand care in an appropriate way. The anesthesiology assistant bill, from my understanding, is sort of like working as a physician assistant. When you talk about folks that have more training than a nurse but have a little bit less training than a physician, these mid-level providers, nurse practitioners and physician assistants, are used almost interchangeably in a lot of hospitals. The CRNAs are used in this fashion in the operating room under the guidance of anesthesiologists. An anesthesia assistant is sort of like a physician assistant that works in the operating room much like a CRNA. So that's an appropriate opportunity for us to, in theory, expand access to care by providing a way of allowing these folks to work in our state but still maintaining oversight in an appropriate fashion. So we're in favor of that bill.
▶ Play
Any other questions for our Surgeon General? Yes, Representative Bragg, you're
▶ Play
recognized. What's the difference in the training and qualifications between the AA and the... I don't know the specifics. I think they're very similar is what I've been told. It's sort of like when you look at nurse practitioners and physician assistants, there are some specifics that are different, but the overlap is tremendous. And so they're used interchangeably in the health care system. And what I've been told in the reading I've done, a CRNA and an anesthesiology assistant are very similar in training enough to where they're used interchangeably. Okay. At some point I'd like to see some
▶ Play
details on that. I think we will when the bill comes up. There will be a lot of people speak for it against that, even on a snowy, icy day if we run that today. I'm sure there will be a lot
▶ Play
of people for that and against Representative Hammer. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Sergeant General, I was wondering, as far as all the scope of bill practices and how you had mentioned about rural hospitals a while ago, as far as expanding services into the rural parts of the state, do you feel that they all give a good blanket to address the issues that are out there? And if not, what's some of the proposed solutions that you might bring that would help address those issues of making sure all the rural areas of the state are covered with essential
▶ Play
services? Well, I appreciate the question. The underserved areas of our state are an important issue, and we do want to expand coverage when we can in an appropriate way. But by short-circuiting the process and making our nurse practitioners or nurse anesthetists too autonomous, I have some problems with that because I think it could short-circuit quality and end up harming rather than improving the situation. I think there's a lot of things that are being discussed in this session that we can talk about, about improving access to care in these rural areas. I think telemedicine, for instance, has a big opportunity there. I've been in some discussions with others about some of the bills that are being presented and some of the other ideas that haven't even made it into legislation yet. So I think that has a lot of opportunity. The general principle is that we absolutely want to expand access to care, but we want to do it in a methodical, systematic, and appropriate way with appropriate oversight so we don't end up causing more problems than solving them. Follow up,
▶ Play
please. When it comes to underserved areas, I think there's two definitions. There's the federal level and then there's the state level. Could you speak to that so we know when we use the term underserved areas what we're talking about exactly or what your frame of mind is about underserved areas? Sure.
▶ Play
I'm sure there are people who would know those better than I, so I don't want to get into the weeds on federal versus state because I'm just not an expert in that area. But, you know, I think in general if you're having, if people are having access to care issues with regards to physicians, hospitals, or appropriate providers, those are what I would call underserved. Now, the legal specifics of that I'm not an expert on, so I'd let someone else comment about
▶ Play
it. Okay. And the task force that is going to be established as far as, you know, dealing with the private option and transitional and everything, Do you anticipate that any of these scope of practices, or would you want to participate in any discussions regarding scope of practices as it might overlap with that task force, or do you have any thoughts on that?
▶ Play
Yes, sir. I think the health care task force, the role is to look at ways to improve the overall health care system for the state. Everything is on the table. Having spoken to the governor at length about these expanding scope of practice issues, I sincerely doubt that we would be incorporating any of the expanding scope of care with regards to nurse practitioners or nurse anesthetists that are being debated today or in this session, but I do think it needs to be discussed, and I think we need to look at novel ways of improving access to care, and that will be discussed in the health care task force, I'm assuming. Okay, thank you. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. All right, seeing no further questions, Mr. Surgeon General Bledsoe, Thank you very much for coming and addressing some of our concerns. Was there any? I think Representative Sullivan, did you have? I guess not. Okay. All right. All right. Thank you. All right. First up, it's going to be not seeing Representative Letting in here. Senator Cooper is here, and I think that Representative Lundstrom, are you running this bill with or for him or however you all are doing this? All of the above. All of the above. All right. Well, you're both recognized to present your bill, and I believe that there are two amendments that we're handing out by paper because we could not get them on the tablets. So you've got two paper amendments coming out. We will take one amendment at a time. We will address those first, and then we will address the bill. So if you all give us just a second to get these passed out, then you're recognized to begin whenever. Thank you so much.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 10:08
Thank you.
▶ Play
I believe everyone has a copy of the amendment, myself included. So which one would you like to address first? Perhaps, let's see, amendment number, I can't tell which one is. Let's address one that adds Senator Rappert. Any questions on the amendment that adds Senator Rappert as a co-sponsor of the bill? Motion do pass. All those in favor? Aye. None opposed? Okay, we have added this amendment. And now if you would address the second amendment, if you would explain that one. Okay, first of all, to
▶ Play
give you a tiny bit of overview, and then I'll turn it over to Senator Cooper. This bill actually allows a terminally ill patient to experiment, to use an experimental drug that's already made it through the first level of testing. What I love about this bill, when Senator Cooper first told me about it, I thought this seems so obvious. And then I started reading it, and I thought, oh, I want to be a sponsor of this, because not only does it give a terminally ill patient the right to try, it also gives them the opportunity to save their life. With that, I'm going to
▶ Play
turn it over to Senator Cooper. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Committee. The amendment, the second amendment that we want to add here is to strike some language at the recommendation of the attorneys. It's just removing duplicated information from this. It's not necessary, and they wanted that removed. So that's basically what it amounts to. This is a member's own amendment, so I appreciate a good vote.
▶ Play
All right, you've heard an explanation of the amendment. Any questions on the amendment? Seeing none, Representative Wardlaw, did I hear a motion do pass from you? I thought so. All right, we have a motion. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all those in favor? Aye. Any opposed? All right, we have adopted both amendments. If you would, present your bill now.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Today, I present to you SB 4 for your consideration, and I believe this bill is something that we all should be happy to support. This legislation is designed to give terminal ill patients what could very well be the last hope and attempt to saving their own life. Currently it takes about 15 years for treatment to make its way through testing and what a terminally ill patient does not have is time I believe that it should be the policy of the state of Arkansas that a terminally ill patient should have the fundamental right to make a decision in consultation with their physician to access treatments that might save their life This bill gives a terminally ill patient the right to request and be given access to experimental treatments and such treatments must have been successfully completed through at least phase one testing of the FDA and remains in the clinical testing pipeline. In addition, the treatment must be prescribed by a licensed physician in Arkansas and the physician is granted protection from sanctions by licensing boards for participation. So also are hospitals and hospital employees that may consult in some form or another on the case. Insurance companies are not required to provide any coverage. However, if they do, it would be strictly up to them and they would do so on a voluntary basis. However, this is generally not the way things are done and there would not be any charges for that on a normal case so that's just in there if it would be needed As a matter of practice now the coverage for expenses are borne by investors and by the pharmaceutical company themselves No Medicaid money would be spent on providing these experimental treatments. For participation, the patient would give informed consent that they understand that they're receiving treatments that are still considered experimental and have not been fully licensed for commercial use in the United States. The manufacturer, farmer, developer can provide these treatments on a voluntary basis. They can recover costs. However, I don't think that that will be a matter of actual practice that they would do so. I know of no case in which farmers currently charges for the use of experimental treatments because the primary reason for these experimental treatments is to develop treatment and to do research. We're not the first state to pass this. There's been, we'll actually be the sixth. Five states has passed it before us. Four states has done it unanimously in both houses of their legislature. In total, this legislation has only had two votes grand total against it in the other five states. So I'm very happy to bring this to you today. and this is a tremendously popular piece of legislation with the public and with other legislators across the country where it's been presented so far. I'd be happy to
▶ Play
take your questions. Members have heard an explanation of the bill. Representative Hammer,
▶ Play
you're recognized for the first question, sir. Thank you. Senator Cooper, did I understand you say there wouldn't be any charge for these drugs that are going to be covered under this bill, or would you restate that, please? These are treatments that normally the way that the clinical trials are done, they're provided by the manufacturer or the provider, the pharmaceutical company, and normally this is not something that's paid for either by insurance, and this would not be charged to Medicaid or any insurance that would be publicly funded. Okay, and can you tell me about if, because it's dealing with terminally ill, which most times terminally ill patients are a lot of times are on hospice care, so can you tell me about the complications that if these drugs are used with somebody who is on hospice care, how is that going to blend together and not cause problems? Any insurance that they have currently would not be interfered with. They would not be taken off for this. If there was somebody that is currently receiving treatment and those treatments could be totally unrelated to this, that they would still be able to access those existing insurance policies and treatments through. Okay, well, sometimes it's not only the policy, but it's the diagnosis that is used, and Medicare is really clamping down on who can stay on hospice based on Medicare guidelines. So is there a chance that a hospice patient would be removed from receiving care, not necessarily because of the money but because of the diagnosis and the treatments that are recognized for that diagnosis? Or do you know in the other states that it exists, that that's been a problem or any issues with that? I don't think that would be the case, and I don't have any history of anything like that occurring. So I think I could say confidently that it wouldn't be a problem. Okay.
▶ Play
All right. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yes, sir. Representative Meeks, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator Cooper, thank you for presenting this bill. My question is, as we know, the FDA has a lot to say as far as drugs are concerned, and I know that sometimes in other countries there may be a drug available that may not be approved here in the United States by the FDA. will this allow patients to use those drugs or is there still going to be some FDA approval necessary? The way that works
▶ Play
is there's a lot of drugs in the pipeline in other countries and some of those have already reached approval stages and they may be ahead of us in this country. We may still have something in the process here that's been fully approved somewhere else. The way that sometimes happens now is people that can afford it or have means to do so travel outside the country to access those. And I think this will streamline the opportunity here in this country for people to have some access to those drugs that may already be approved. Also, there are drugs that are approved for one use and be approved, And then as those treatment availabilities, it seems that a drug might be usable in another area, that it goes back through testing again for a different use. And so it's possible that some of this would already be approved under one use and be back in clinical testing for a second use, and this could also help access some of that.
▶ Play
Speaker 60 20:09
Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Members, for an explanation of the bill, Representative Boyd, you're recognized. Do you have a question? I do. All
▶ Play
right. Are you recognized for a question? Senator Cooper, I've asked you this already, but I want to clarify. Has marijuana gone through phase one studies from
▶ Play
the FDA? There was a movement to add that to this bill, which I rejected because this is a bill that is narrowly focused on saving lives. I didn't want this bill to be sidetracked on being used for pain relief or nausea or anything like that. Any of that legislation needs to be done under separate legislation, not my legislation. So that, you know, there may be some testing. I'm not sure what might be tested in the FDA for that, but that's not a part of this legislation. So to
▶ Play
your knowledge, there's not a way that this legislation could be used as a backdoor to get socially controversial drugs?
▶ Play
No, this is defined in the bill that it is for terminally ill patients and must be prescribed by their physician.
▶ Play
Thank you. Thank you. All right, members, seeing no one from the audience signed up for or against this bill, hearing no more questions, seeing no more questions, what's the will of this committee? Representative Meeks. We have a motion to do pass. As amended, as amended twice. Yes, twice. Okay. Motion to do pass as twice amended. Any discussion on the motion itself? Seeing none, all in favor, aye. Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Senator. Representative, your bill is passed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. All right. Still not seeing Representative Letting in the room. We move down to Representative Gates, House Bill 1311.
▶ Play
You recognize, present your bill, sir. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Committee, this is a bill that basically ends the enrollment process into the private option. Right now, private option is scheduled to end December 31, 2017. Insurance, most insurance companies in a free market, they will sell policies up until the very last day and take the premium and cancel the policy the next day. All this does, it calls for an end of the enrollment process so that insurance companies are not selling policies to people that cannot continue to be fulfilled through private option. It recognizes that we're under a federal waiver. It will then require our seeking the federal government. But the difference is we do now have a plan to – we have an exit strategy out of private option, and this seeks an agreement with the feds to allow us to amend our current waiver. Congressman Westerman has spoken to me. He's agreed to help on the D.C. end to help present this to the powers to be in Washington. That's basically what it's doing. It calls for an end of it, and when the private option ends, we know this just calls for an end of the enrollment. And I'm open to any questions. Members, have
▶ Play
an explanation of the bill? Any questions? Representative Sullivan,
▶ Play
you're recognized. more out of just caution i'm just so so we're passing this um then which the purpose is just in ending enrollment at this date i'm trying to figure out what it is this bill does that we're not already doing well under the
▶ Play
current law under the current waiver we cannot stop enrollment all the way up till the day before private option ends insurance companies can sell policies the most the most profitable end of an insurance policy is on the front end the longer policy goes the more likely there is likelihood there is to be a claim and so this stops it this stops the enrollment the other great thing it does is the task force that's fixing to be put together one of the things is this will give us a definite number of how many people are on private option if we don't that the task force is going to be looking at a moving target and will continue to move until
▶ Play
Speaker 88 25:10
12-31-17. So this bill just stops that and
▶ Play
Speaker 89 25:12
gives our governor an opportunity to request a waiver? That is correct. An exemption to the current waiver. That is correct.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I am trying to be sure I understand. I've read this a couple times. I've heard your explanation. And everything that we've talked about, I believe, leading up to this, Representative Gates, and tell me where I'm wrong, and I'm very likely can be, but would this not kill the Health Care Independence Act immediately because we're stopping enrollment?
▶ Play
No, we're not stopping enrollment. If you will look in Section 1C and 1D, it says that we have to seek approval. The seeking approval under a contract, if both parties agree to amendment of that contract, we can't just arbitrarily decide we're going to change the contract, the waiver, on our end. It seeks approval. That means the federal government has to be willing to say, because you have a plan to end private option, we're going to allow you to wind down the process. And it's subject to their approval. Okay.
▶ Play
So what we're doing now is we're, and I'm seriously not being facetious or anything else. I'm just making sure I'm clear. So this is an argumentative, Representative Gates. I want to make sure I'm clear and this committee is clear so we can move forward. What we've done is we've gone and verbally asked, can we do this? And they said, no. What you're trying to do is ask us to formally go with a waiver, a separate waiver, and say, okay, we want to submit this waiver that would allow us to wind down the health care independence act
▶ Play
Speaker 88 27:01
or private option correct in the previous questions was the question was under
▶ Play
our current contract can we cap enrollment the answer to that under our current waiver is no you cannot what we're saying now is because we have a why we have a end date we would like to be able to slow down the process by it by camping that enrollment the you know it's oftentimes framed differently if if you go use the analogy if you ask if a little kid goes and asks mama can I have ice cream she says no if he goes and asks dad would you like me to get you ice cream well most certainly mom dad's eating ice cream can I have some ice cream too so I can be like dad it's oftentimes how the question is framed in this case it is not framed under the current waiver can we do. It is can we amend our current waiver because we have an end date of 12-31-17. We would like to amend our current waiver. It seeks that authority from the feds and like I said before, Congressman Westerman has already agreed to go plead our case before them also, which I don't think we had in the previous discussion
▶ Play
with them. Okay. Hi, members. You've heard, I think, a little better explanation of the bill now. Any questions? Seeing none, there's anyone from the audience speak for or against this? Representative Hammer, you have a question. Yes, sir. You're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Gates, do you know what the time frame, or is there a time frame when this would
▶ Play
come back? Well, if you look in Section 1B, it says 10 days on passage, but again, it requires we can pass it on this end. It will not stop the enrollment until the federal government agrees to the inclusion of this in our current waiver. So the request would have to be made
▶ Play
10 days from the passage of this bill signed by the governor. It's got an emergency clause on it and then when it gets in the hands of CMS we don't really control what their answer is going to be. We're just basically putting the issue before them, before the December 31st, 16th deadline and if they came back and said yes you could then we would have to adjust to that decision. Is
▶ Play
that a fair assessment? That is a fair assessment. Then we actually could start the one. Under our current agreement, we cannot stop. They could actually sell policies the day before the policy expired, thus profiteering off of the front end of a policy. This would keep the profiteering from happening.
▶ Play
Okay. Okay, and if the cap did go in place, then we'd be, between whatever that cap was and the December 31st, people would not be able to enroll, is that correct? But if they were already enrolled, they would be covered until the December 31st deadline. That is correct. Okay, thank you. All right, what I'd
▶ Play
like to do is ask Mr. Sealy of Department of Human Services, kind of give us, we're a bunch of amateurs, quite honestly, y'all. We study this as hard as we can, but this guy lives it and breathes it, So I'd like him to give us his view of this. Morning. Mr. Seelig, if you would introduce yourself for the record,
▶ Play
Speaker 101 30:14
and you're recognized. Morning, Mr. Chairman. I'm John Seelig, Director of the Department of Human Services. And I've not had a chance to visit with Representative Gates about this. As I read the bill, I see where in Section C it says we'll ask for approval. Section B is a separate section from Section C. Section B says we will stop enrollment. Then Section C says ask for approval. Well, I think, in my understanding, you have to read those separately. We have to stop enrollment, and then we can ask for approval, but we would have already stopped enrollment at that point. I think to do what Representative Gates is talking about, you'd have to say in Section B, subject to federal approval or something, that we'll do that, that we'll stop enrollment. I don't think it can stand like it is. And then I would just note, we haven't really discussed this portion, On Section A3, where it says that people who were enrolled in Medicaid will be re-enrolled, it's kind of a technical point, but we actually can't do that. We would have to determine their eligibility again because there will be many people who are enrolled prior to 2013 who, for whatever reason, won't be eligible again. So this would tell us to enroll them regardless. Again, it might take some wording change. I think I understand the intent was if people who met certain criteria, that those criteria would be restored. It's just not what the bill says now. Very good. Representative Hammer, do you
▶ Play
have a question for Mr. Sealing? Yes, sir. Thank you. John, let me ask you, just put you on the spot, but if he worked on that language to get to what you just said, would you have a problem with this bill and us putting CMS in a position to say whether or not we could do this, if nothing else, to benefit what future discussions may be, or can you give us some thoughts? Representative Hanna, I would
▶ Play
Speaker 101 32:03
want to discuss it with the governor, and we've not had a chance to do that, or his staff. My understanding from the governor was he wanted to keep the existing program in place subject to the task force, having a chance to determine what to do next. This would not keep the existing program in place and that it would stop the program for anybody who hasn't applied already. But do
▶ Play
you think it would serve any value or purpose to test the waters with CMS to see what their reaction is going to be? because if the task force comes back with something and the timing of all this comes together, it may provide them the opportunity to know kind of what the waters will be like with CMS or do you think it's just a futile effort? Well,
▶ Play
Speaker 101 32:43
I mean, the Secretary was very clear when the governor was up there with Representative Link and others that they would not approve something, they would not approve a stop in the enrollment. So I'd be very surprised if they changed their position. I guess the risk of testing the waters is if they said yes and this went into effect, it would contradict, I believe, what the governor had asked, which is to keep the existing program in place as it is until the task force has a chance to look at it. Okay, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative
▶ Play
Payton, did you have a question? Yes, sir. You're right, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Selick, if this were to pass, would you be inclined to lobby CMS harder for a wind-down agreement that would allow us to continue the program and limit enrollment, or would you feel that it would be a futile effort and they've already said no and we're just going to take them at their word? Representative Payton, I work for the governor, so I do whatever he asks me to do. Would you be inclined? That's why I didn't say would you do it. But would you be inclined, in other words, to be trying to get on the phone, go visit them or whatever, to ask, or would you just feel that they've already given their answer and it would be a futile effort? Yes, I'm really not trying
▶ Play
Speaker 101 33:58
to be cute, but I would talk with the governor about it and see what
▶ Play
he wanted me to do. Okay, thank you. Hi, members. You've heard explanation. You've heard Mr. Segal kind of give an explanation as well. Seeing no members. Seeing no one in the – oh, Representative Lundstrom? I'm sorry. Just motion at a proper time. Seeing no one else, the audience speak for or against this, what's the will? Representative Lundstrom, what's your will? Do pass. You have a motion, do pass. Members, I want to bring something up before we get to discussion of the motion and voting. I do not, it's very hard to hear up here. If you're going to vote with your microphone on, I'm just going to call a roll call. So let's not do that anymore. It's hard to figure out what's going on up here without amplification. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all those in favor? Aye. All those opposed? No. The no's have it. Roll call. Sorry, Taylor. I have one roll call. Do I have two? Representative Bentley. We're going to call the roll. Representative Sullivan.
▶ Play
Speaker 118 35:25
Representative Henderson. Representative Boyd. Representative Bentley. Representative Lundstrom. Representative Payton. Representative Fite. Representative Bragg. Representative Womack. Representative Miller. Representative Miller. Representative McGee. No. Representative Ritchie. No. Representative Overby. No. Representative Meeks. Yes. Representative Branscombe. No. Representative Hammer. Yes. Representative Wardlaw. No. Representative Love. Representative Love.
▶ Play
All right, we have, in roll call vote, we have seven yeas, 11 nays, one not voting. Your bill has failed, Representative Gates. All right, members, next up. I don't see Representative Davis. I don't see Representative Miller. Representative McGee, did you wish to run yours today? All right, Representative McGee, you're recognized for House Bill 1120. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. I'm pleased this morning to bring to you House Bill 1120. This is an act which is going to establish anesthesia assistance here in Arkansas and briefly place them under the medical board for their certification and their licensure. What I thought we might do is just spend a couple of minutes talking about the different levels of providers into anesthesia and why I think that anesthesia assistants are capable of performing their duties and why I think it's a good thing for patients here in Arkansas. So typically there are three different groups that provide anesthetic services and are part of the anesthetic care team. MD, medical doctor, anesthesiologist, they've been to medical school and then did generally a three-year residency program in anesthesiology. You have certified registered nurse anesthetists. Those are registered nurses that after their year of, after their bachelor's science in nursing, they typically spend a year or two working in intensive care units, and then they're accepted to nursing anesthetist schools, two of which we have here in Arkansas. And then the third group of anesthetic providers are anesthesia assistants. The concept of anesthesia assistants were started in about 1969 by a group of anesthesiologists at Emory University. And since that time, they've grown to approximately 10 training programs that are associated with medical schools or collaborate with medical schools for their training. We'll get into that in their training in a little bit. But so there are 10 programs that train these individuals, and then there are about 17 states in the District of Columbia which licenses or recognizes anesthesia assistance. The Representative Bragg asked earlier about a comparison, and I do have a sheet, if the chair would like, I can have a copy of that and pass it around for members to look at, that talks about anesthesiology assistance and nurse anesthetists and what their level of trainings are. I'm sorry, Representative McGee, can you get that sheet for us so we can make some copies? This is it. Okay. Mr. Price can take care of that. Thank you, Mr. Price. So the bottom line, the history of the anesthesia assistance programs in the early 1960s, there were leaders in the anesthesiology community that recognized staffing shortages and to meet growing needs and all. They developed these programs starting at Emory University to train in anesthesiology assistants. They're now certified by the National Commission of Certification for Anesthesiology Assistance, and that group creates a national certification process. In realistic terms, I guess to kind of get to the bottom line, in realistic terms, these individuals function after appropriate training. They function training and testing and certification and all. They function under the direct supervision of an anesthesiologist, unlike a nurse anesthetist. Now, many nurse anesthes that we know function in hospital settings, particularly in the urban areas, under the direction of anesthesiologists. In the rural area, many nurse anesthes function almost independently, but they still are under the supervision of the operating surgeon that's there. So they really perform the same function. And in my conversations with people in states where they're already practicing anesthesiology assistance and certified registered nurse anesthetists practice side-by-side in the same group settings and perform the same functions, the real reason that I think this is a good program is there are people that this affects that are Arkansans. There's, I know of one individual that lives in Bentonville whose husband works for Walmart who was transferred to Bentonville. They came from Georgia, where they are approved. She's capable of working. She no longer can work in our state because we don't have a classification or category for them. I know of an anesthesiologist that trained at UAMS, did his anesthesiology training, moved out of state and married an anesthesiology assistant. They can't come back to Arkansas because his wife can't practice in the state of Arkansas. So the bottom line is, I think, professionally, I think that their training is adequate. their testing is adequate, what they do for their continuing medical education, to keep their certifications is adequate, and they're recognized in 17 states. I think that they could be in addition to the anesthesia team. The anesthesiologists in the state of Arkansas support the concept. The American Society of Anesthesiology, which is the national group that most anesthesiologists belong to, is supportive of anesthesiology assistance. and are making all their efforts to get them approved in other states. So I guess I can open it up to questions. They are passing out a little sort of little bullet point list of the training of both anesthesiology assistants and certified registered nurse anesthetists. I'm open to any questions. We'll start with Representative Hammer,
▶ Play
and we'll go Representative Payton after that. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Would you run over the list again of who you said was supportive of
▶ Play
this bill, Dr. McGee? Well, you heard earlier from our Surgeon General that the governor's office is supportive of it. The American Academy of Anesthesiology, I think it's called the American Society of Anesthesiology, ASA, supports it. The local anesthesia groups here in Little Rock support the concept. Okay, and the only reason I brought
▶ Play
that up, well, one reason I brought that up was because I've gotten several calls from anesthesiologists that do not support it, so I wonder if the association and their support of it reflects the opinion of all anesthesiologists or for the ones that have been calling me saying they oppose it. I mean, could you give me some insight to that? I couldn't speak for the organization, but I
▶ Play
think there may be someone here from the state society that may speak to that in a minute. Okay. Mr. Chair, I've got about two or three. Can I
▶ Play
just continue on, or do I need to ask each time? Or you want to cut me off? Let's see. Go ahead and get your second
▶ Play
one in, then we'll move to Mr. Pratt and then come back to you.
▶ Play
Okay. Or whoever's next. Is there a shortage now, and is that what reflected on the sheet is an identification of areas where we have a shortage now of individuals that are capable of performing what would be offered under the creation of this new opportunity? because one of the things I got from those that called in opposition was saying there's not a shortage now that we're covered, so why create a new class? So could you speak to that, please?
▶ Play
Well, my understanding is there's not a shortage of anesthetic providers. That's not really been an issue on the table for me as to whether or not there was a shortage or whether or not there was an oversupply of providers. My issue is that these individuals are trained. They're trained as well in many instances or better than certified registered nurse anesthetists, according to what I've read in some of their literature. Now, they're accepted by the American Society of Anesthesiology, and they promote their use. They're accepted in 17 states. It's not really an issue of whether there's shortage. I think this is an issue of allowing someone to practice to the level of their certification in a state that doesn't currently recognize them. And it also, you know, even though there's a shortage, some people are going to perceive this as their competitors to certified registered nurse anesthetists. Well, they are competitors. They may compete for those jobs. I've always been taught my grandfather taught me years ago you want your competitor right next door because that's going to make you do a better job and deliver better service so if there's competition in the marketplace I think that's a positive for everyone involved that helps lower cost, creates a better environment and creates better health care for our patients I'd just like to
▶ Play
come back Mr. Chair at the chair's discretion please Alright, Representative Payton, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question Thank you Mr. Chair Representative McGee I probably could have let Representative Hammer continue. He was covering some of the ground. As we deal with these scope of practice bills, it's a little hard for me to get my head around where we currently are. And some of what you said, do we currently have these assistants operating in Arkansas or is this going to enable them to operate
▶ Play
in Arkansas? This is enabling legislation to allow them to be licensed by the
▶ Play
State Board of Medicine. Okay. But part of your bill towards the end of it, if I remember right, has a grandfather clause for those that have operated for the past year in the state of Arkansas to automatically be licensed under this new provision. So if there's not any currently operating, why would we have a grandfather clause to bring them in? Good question. I'll have to ask the people that wrote the bill. If I could continue one more question maybe? Sure. You're on a roll. So this is creating a new class of licensure, in your opinion, that we don't currently have in the state of Arkansas and would allow your friend to come back that's happened to operate out of state. But basically we're setting up new rules and guidelines and licensure for a class that is not currently operating. Current law, these individuals are
▶ Play
not allowed to practice in the state of Arkansas. What this
▶ Play
will do is this allows those that are certified and passed all the appropriate examinations and their boards and all the things that they do, they will fall under the state medical board. The medical board will promulgate rule and regulation concerning how they function and where they can function and that sort of thing. But the key to this is these individuals always work under the direction of an anesthesiologist. So it's not like we're setting up another group of providers that are going to go out and independently provide anesthetic services. These individuals won't go to Lake Village, Arkansas, and practice anesthesia unless there were an anesthesiologist there. So that's the difference. These individuals will function much like physicians' assistants do in physicians' offices now. Thank you. If you could come back at some later point. Yes, sir. I'm going to take a couple questions myself before I move on to the next one, Dr. McGee, or Ripson McGee. Tell me, first off, who made this for us, the comparison? That comparison was what I took offline. You know what website they came from? You can get this off the Anesthesiology Assistance website. Okay, so it's the AIA website. All right, this puts the new class, the AIAs, how is that for an acronym? I'm using one. Under the, is it the State Medical Board? They would fall under this, the bill that we have before us, they would be subject to rule and regulation by the state medical board. And where are the CRNAs? How are they? What board are they under? They're under the board of, I believe they're under the board of nursing. Okay. Why not put both under the board of nursing? Why did you choose, or whoever wrote the bill, why did you choose to go under the state medical board? Well, I chose under the state medical board because anesthesiologists are medical doctors who are sanctioned by the State Board of Medicine. So if I have an assistant as a physician, if I have an assistant that is recognized by some national organization that's going to come in and work for me, that individual would fall under the same board that I do. There are collaborative agreements, supervising agreements that are executed between the anesthesia, the MD anesthesiologist, and the anesthetic assistant, those are reviewed by the – they have to have somebody to review them, so those are reviewed by the medical board, filed with the medical board. Any changes in those agreements are always reviewed and approved or disapproved by the medical board. Okay. All right, Representative Sullivan, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. In the scope of practice, and I think some of the examples you gave were setting a precedent of people moving from one state to another and another license does that. The other point you made about a person is better trained in their specific field than someone who is generally trained in a specific field. And I know we're going to come up with several of these scope of practice bills, one of them that deals with Schedule II drugs, and we're looking at a saying someone who's more specifically trained that has value. Is that the same rationale you're using here to authorize this better-trained expansion of services based upon their training? Well, I don't quite
▶ Play
Speaker 157 51:30
follow that. Well, yeah, I didn't follow it either.
▶ Play
We're having several scope-of-practice bills that say someone who has specific training, we ought to allow that to occur. That seems to be the example you're using here, that they have specific training and they should be allowed and that other states recognize that. And I know we're going to face that in this Schedule II issue with nurse practitioners. So I'm assuming you'll apply that same precedent as we move forward?
▶ Play
the way that i view these issues are when there's when their scope of practice issues if if there's a group of providers an anesthesiologist a medical doctor provider and he has the opportunity to apply to employ someone as part of an anesthetic team whether that's a crna or an anesthesia assistant then that's his prerogative to employ those people. And as long as they fall under the appropriate boards for rule and regulation and to protect the public, the medical boards here to protect the health and welfare of the public and the state, as long as those individuals fall under the appropriate board and that board then directs what they can do and what they can't do, then I don't have a lot of problems with expanding scope of practice. If in some of the instances, for instance, you mentioned Schedule II drugs, in some states, well, we'll probably all not get off on that whole issue, but some states do allow nurse practitioners to do that. But what you also have to realize is some states put nurse practitioners under the medical board. They're practicing medicine. They're not practicing nursing. They're practicing medicine when they start prescribing those drugs. So it's just the level of authority of the medical board gives a value to individuals when they're under those boards. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Sir, Representative Hammer, we're going to come back to you, sir. Yes, right now. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I recognize. Dr. McGee, I sure am
▶ Play
glad you went first, brother. That's all I've got to say. Here's a couple things I wanted to ask you about. But so do they have their own governing board now, or would a new board have to be created with this enabling legislation? No, they would
▶ Play
fall under the present state board of medicine. Okay, so that would be a new
▶ Play
governing board, no. Okay, so that's going to put
▶ Play
them under the medical society then? No, no, the medical society and medical board are two separate. The medical society is the professional organization for physicians in the state. The medical board is appointed by the governor, and they're the 12 people that sit around the room and take care
▶ Play
of bad doctors. All right. Sorry about the confusion on the terminology there. In the other states where this exists, then, are they under the medical board, or is there any cases where they are under their own board or different boards being created? I don't know. Okay. And is there currently a training program that's offered in the state for those
▶ Play
that might want to pursue this? We don't have a training program per se that's real interesting. The training programs for AAs are always directed by an MD anesthesiologist, and they're all associated with major medical centers or have collaborative agreements with major medical centers. We don't have a formal training program. We do have students that come from one of the anesthesia assistant programs who rotate on the clinical rotation through Arkansas Children's Hospital. Okay, so are
▶ Play
we going to have to develop a new program through UAMS or one of the universities, or how are we
▶ Play
going to deal with that? That would be something that would be nice to do in the future, but we're not
▶ Play
addressing that here. Okay. And do they have to have currently what I would refer to, and I think you alluded to this while ago, a collaborative agreement with somebody above them that actually signs off for their work, or are they going to be functioning independent? Could you talk about that? They
▶ Play
have a collaborative agreement signed by them and by their supervising physician that is then approved by the medical board itself. Okay, and at no time are they
▶ Play
able then to break out on their own? They cannot practice
▶ Play
independent of an anesthesiologist. Okay, and I noticed
▶ Play
on the handout that you gave that it said under clinical education a minimum of 2,000 clinical hours under the AA column. that 2,000 clinical hours, is that after they've received the degree and before they could start to practice, they would have to have 2,000 clinical hours, or could you elaborate on that? I would assume that what
▶ Play
that means is there are 2,000 clinical hours during their training. They spend program lengths of a year to year and a half or so, 24, 28, 30-month programs, and my assumption would be is that 2,000 hours is probably the last year of their training in their clinical rotation, such as the student that's at Arkansas Children's Hospital now. Okay, and these individuals be
▶ Play
able to practice anywhere in the state, not just underserved areas, but wherever they could go and secure business? Wherever there was an anesthesiologist that they could practice under.
▶ Play
Does that anesthesiologist have to be in an immediate location or
▶ Play
could he be on the other side of the state or out of state? It has to be immediately available. but there's currently no shortages now for any of those now for the anesthesiologists that they
▶ Play
would have to work on. I couldn't comment as to the number of anesthesiologists in the state and whether there's a shortage or not a shortage. Okay all right thank you. Thank you Mr. Chair. All right
▶ Play
Representative Payton you're recognized. Thank you Mr. Chair and thank you Representative mcgee for taking so many questions i'm looking at this grandfather clause at the end of your bill and i was trying to figure out why if there's none operating in arkansas we would have a grandfather clause to bring them in after one year but it's not limited to just the state arkansas the way the language is written here if they've practiced it says if they've been engaged in anesthesiology work for at least one year i would assume that means anywhere it doesn't even restricted to the United States so they're going to be grandfathered in and given a license they're
▶ Play
still going to have to be the way I would understand that and interpret that is they would still have to meet all the requirements that the state medical board would require of them before they would practice well they would
▶ Play
have to meet the application requirements but it says that they shall be granted a license if they've been engaged in anesthesiology work for at least one year. It doesn't even narrow it down to the United States. So I don't know how you could be comfortable with, but are you telling us you're comfortable with the guidelines that they're working under in all other territories? Well, I'll tell you what we'll do. If you pass this out of here and we pass
▶ Play
it on the floor, I'll get that taken out and send it in. Okay. Well, that's good enough. I appreciate it. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right. Representative
▶ Play
Meeks, you're right and I ask for a question. Thank you. Representative McGee, were you aware that Louisiana has actually barred these anesthesiology assistants? They have statute
▶ Play
that does not allow them to practice in the state of Louisiana. That's true. Do you know why they have barred them from being able to practice in the state? I suspect that probably happened at a legislative level, and there were a lot of testimony that was given at the time, but I was not privy to that information. But what I will say is they are allowed in Oklahoma. They passed in Oklahoma several years ago. They're allowed in Texas. They're allowed in Missouri. They're allowed in Kentucky. They're allowed in Alabama. They're allowed in Georgia, Colorado. There are 17 states that do allow them, and I think it's time that Arkansas expand and allow them to come into our state. Okay. And then I
▶ Play
guess a follow-up question, if I may, Mr. Chair. Yes, sir. is the education level of the deal. Just, again, from talking with some of the nurse and also doing some research, on your sheet there it does say master's degree, but it's my understanding that anybody can go and easily get the master's degree, meaning you don't have to have a medical background like me. I have a degree in pastoral ministries, but if I wanted to be an anesthesiologist, and all I would have to do is go get the few hours that I need for my master's degree. So it doesn't have to be a medical field completely all the way. And that gives me some concern. I've
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:00:25
seen that issue raised, and they're giving you some misinformation. And, for instance, when you apply to medical school here at the University of Arkansas, you could have an English degree. You could have a theology degree. You could have any degree and get into the University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences and become a physician in four years. But you still have to have about 90 hours of prerequisite basic science clinical work before you're going to get in. So you have to have two years, you know, a year of organic chemistry with laboratory, a year of physics with laboratories, calculus. You have to have all the sciences to be even considered for application. The anesthesia assistance programs take people. They only take people that have premedical backgrounds when they apply to the schools. Also, the average grade point average, the average college grade point average of those that go into anesthesia schools is 3.5. So they pick the best and the brightest of people that have taken the premedical sciences. They could have a degree in anything, but they still have to have all of those pre-medical requisites that you have to have to go to medical school. Well, I mean, that's
▶ Play
the University of Arkansas. But, again, we can go to any college in the nation to become an anesthesiologist. And, again, I haven't done a study to see what other colleges, if it's something that's across the board required or if I went to another university in another state somewhere, you know, would I have to have these other
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:01:59
prerequisites to get in? All of the anesthesia assistance programs are accredited by whatever it is, some acronym, Joint Commission of Allied Health Personnel. And they all, all of them, all of them require the same pre-medical background before they go to an anesthesia assistance school. All right. So these are sharp individuals, may have good grade points out of college when they particulate into anesthesia assistance school. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lundstrom, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. I have two questions, actually. One of them, how does this help rural hospitals when we already have certified nursing assistants in those rural hospitals doing this job? It doesn't help rural hospitals. This is not about rural hospitals. I understand that. But if you need an anesthesiologist assistant has to have a doctor present when they do it and there isn't an anesthesiologist in
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:02:53
those rural hospitals. Anesthesiology assistants will not practice in a situation where they don't have an anesthesiologist present So in rural Arkansas, in many hospitals, there aren't anesthesiology present But there already
▶ Play
are certified nursing assistants with bachelors and masters that are competent in doing this type of care That's right Okay, and then my other question was, in this, the last line, it says A person who is engaged in anesthesiologist's work for at least one year before the effective date of this chapter is entitled to receive a license without
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:03:25
examination. That's to Representative Payton's point. If that's an issue, we'll take that out on the Senate end.
▶ Play
My follow-up to that is a certified nursing assistant, somebody who already has their bachelor's and master's who's practicing, has a license, has the exams, they're doing the job. This seems to dilute it. I'm not getting
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:03:45
it. I understand your concerns. And like I said, that will be gone. All right, members, seeing no further questions, we have some people from the audience signed up to speak for and against. The first person signed up is for us, Dr. Joshua Chance. If you would come to the end of the table, introduce yourself for the record, and
▶ Play
you're recognized to begin testimony. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. I apologize for my attire as I kind of came straight over from the hospital after I was relieved from my duties. I'm not expecting necessarily that we would be hearing or talking about this today. I am a physician anesthesiologist here in the state of Arkansas. I practice here in Little Rock. I am the president of the Arkansas Society of Anesthesiologists, and as a society, have written in support of this bill from our society. A question was raised earlier about individuals in the state perhaps disagreeing with the bill. I've reached out across the state and have not had any particular member that has gotten with me to suggest that they disagree with the society's viewpoint. There are a few points I think that are important to make about anesthesiologist assistance, And that is, one, they are subjected to extreme educational background that's needed to even become a physician and get into medical school. They do have to have the prerequisites, as indicated earlier, to apply. They are subjected to the medical college admissions test, the MCAT, which is the exact same test that an individual wishing to attend a medical school has to take, and they are often needed to get into most of these programs, and an average score above 25, 26, which is the score that many physicians must have for medical schools to really consider them to be admitted. than they are then they do receive 24 to 28 months as indicated earlier of clinical background with approximately 2,000 hours of clinical work. The 2,000 hours of clinical work is that equivalent to a nurse anesthetist often in their training. This is not to establish that an anesthesiologist assistance is in any way better or supreme to a nurse anesthetist. You would never get an anesthesiologists that would just stand up and tell you that this offers the opportunity for another mid-level provider for groups across the state that have anesthesiologists to hire or employ individuals to work in their practice equivalent to that of a nurse anesthetist. The American Society of Anesthesiologists recognize the training of both anesthesiologist assistants and nurse anesthesiologists and recognize them as being of equal stature. This, as indicated earlier, the nurse, the anesthesiology assistants have been around since the 1960s. It was written in their charter when they started that they would perform all actions under an anesthesiologist. So I think that that's why we would never come across any issues of independent practice. But that was specifically, it's my understanding, that was specifically put in there by those individuals that began or started the first program there at Emory. So the American Society of Anesthesiologists obviously supports the addition of the anesthesiology assistant as another mid-level provider equal to that in nurse and nurses. The Arkansas Society of Anesthesiologists has written in support of this being instituted here in Arkansas, at least the licensure, in that what we have allowed over the years is many Arkansans have left the state to seek higher education and then even return to the state to be trained at Arkansas Children's Hospital, yet they must leave the state again to find employment. And I think that we have had more and more of those individuals leave over the years. Dr. McGee alluded to an individual anesthesiologist that actually was trained here, and he's actually my best friend, Dr. Meeks. He was from Springdale. He was trained here with myself at the university, and he elected to leave and get further training. I mean, he has married an anesthesiology assistant and currently reside in Missouri where they do allow anesthesiology assistants. But he has indicated at times, sure, he would like to come back to the home state, but I don't foresee that as a possibility. So I think, as I said, more and more individuals have moved over the years. I mentioned the organizations that support it. also as a board member, I sit on the board for the Arkansas Medical Society, and the Arkansas Medical Society also supports this initiative in our state for hiring, or at least licensing, I mean, anesthesiology assistants, and again, offering that second level of that mid-level provider. I'm happy to take questions.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:09:33
Representative Bragg, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. When we talk about Under supervision of a physician, could you explain what that means? Like an assistant, do they have to be in the physical presence of a physician in the operating room? No, much like nurse anesthetists, we either bill for a nurse anesthetist under direction versus supervision. To bill for supervision of a nurse anesthetist and have Medicare, We have to meet seven steps that Medicare requires that we meet in order to bill under that. That's the same as for the anesthesiology assistants. I'm present at critical portions of anesthetic delivery, primarily any critical event that may happen intraoperatively as well as times of induction and meeting sleep as well as emergence as the patient awakens. An anesthesiologist's presence during those time periods covers supervision. Okay, so there's not a real difference in the supervision level between these two categories? Correct. And in many states that have anesthesiology assistance, they're trained by the anesthesiologist to do many of the same things such as line placements as a nurse anesthetist is trained in those situations or resident anesthesiologists are trained in those situations. Okay. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. Representative Hammer you have a question
▶ Play
thank you Madam Chair I haven't heard anybody yet substantiate that we have a shortage in the state that would make this essential to providing good quality health care and the idea of introducing a mid-level provider so I'm trying to get my mind around and maybe you can help me if we don't have a shortage we're introducing another mid-level provider, and what is it that they're going to be able to offer that makes this necessary then? Could you
▶ Play
speak on that, please? Yes, I can try. The addition, I believe, of another mid-level provider allowing groups of anesthesiologists across the state the opportunity to employ can drive cost. That cost can drive the decrease in health care costs as there's competition, and I think that we would all agree competition drives or can and is able to drive cost. Perhaps it could be seen as if the groups of anesthesiologists hired anesthesiologists in light of hiring nurse anesthetists, then perhaps nurse anesthetists become more readily available to move to the rural areas if they so wish to be supervised by the surgeons in those areas. I'm glad to hear you say that
▶ Play
because if it drives them to the rural areas and that's the motive, then I would hope that would set the trend. Just last question, maybe Dr. McGee can answer this when he comes back, But did this bill originate from your organization then, and are you all the ones that are driving this piece of legislation then?
▶ Play
No, sir. The Arkansas Society of Medical, our anesthesiologists are not the driving force. Though we have had members, and when it was mentioned that Dr. McGee would be proposing this bill, and I heard through it, through my connections as a board member on the Arkansas Medical Society, I did begin to reach out to
▶ Play
our members in support of this bill. But this bill will give you an opportunity to be able to extend your services, but you'll be billing indirectly through the AA, is that correct? Or once the AA bills, that eliminates your ability to bill them as the supervisor over them.
▶ Play
I'm not sure I follow your question. I think as of right now, payment is the same. whether I am delivering the anesthesia myself or whether or not I am delivering or overseeing more than one room in which I may have two or multiple nurse anesthetists in those rooms. The billable difference is in direction versus supervision. And again, Medicare, I believe, without knowing exactly, offers more dollars if an anesthesiologist physician is able to meet all seven steps that they dictate must be met. Okay, thank you. Thank you,
▶ Play
Madam Chair. Representative Sullivan, you're recognized for a question. Yes,
▶ Play
will this drive up the cost in the state for additional licensures and examinations and things like that? I know we talked about the opportunity to decrease the cost, but is there an opportunity to drive up the cost through some of those things? I don't know
▶ Play
what it costs the state now for me to get my license. I know that I pay a fee every year. So I don't know the exact answer to that question. I know that I'm sure that they're asked to pay just as any other
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:14:48
service is asked to pay for
▶ Play
their licensing. Thank you. Representative Payton, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Sir, in my profession, I love hands-on experience and on-the-job training, but I may not be comfortable with it in your profession. Are you familiar with the licensing requirements and restrictions and regulations from all the other territories that allow the AAs to operate? Because it seems to me that we're going to open the door to invite them to get a license in Arkansas. And is there a standard or a uniform licensing code out there
▶ Play
for these people? It is my understanding that they're held to a national standard, just as I'm, as a physician, held to a national standard as well. And obviously there could be individual state regulations within the medical board themselves. But again, they're held directly to what the medical board establishes as needing to be met, the requirements needing to be met to receive a license. It was asked earlier about why not having them licensed from another state. Again, it's my understanding that it was written in their charter from the very beginning that they would always be governed by the medical board in each state, and I don't know of any states that currently license them outside that. Excuse me
▶ Play
for a minute. When you say in their charter, are we talking about a trade
▶ Play
association or what? That's the verbiage that I've only heard when they were established, and so I don't know that answer. I mean, I'd have to go back and look.
▶ Play
I don't understand. What's the title of
▶ Play
the organization you're talking about? They use an acronym of Quad A. It's A-A-A-A. It's the American Association of Anesthesiology Assistants. So it's a trade association. I guess just as the American Society of Anesthesiologists. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Bragg, you're recognized. I heard some more terms here. I need clarification on what's the difference between directed and supervision? So that really pertains to how, again, how we're able to bill anesthesia services. Primarily, if I'm working with a nurse anesthetist, the case can be billed as medically directed or medically supervised. And again, in order for me to, and this stems from Medicare verbiage, But in order for me to bill a supervision of the nurse anesthetist, then, again, I have to meet all seven steps that Medicare has dictated I meet in order to bill that. And a lot of times that's not necessarily the case. You may miss one of the seven steps, and then it's automatically billed as
▶ Play
Speaker 188 1:17:38
medical direction versus medical supervision.
▶ Play
But, I mean, functionally, is there a difference? The medical direction allows for areas in which there's nurse anesthetists and physician anesthesiologists, but not enough, meaning I cannot medically supervise, I believe, more than three nurse anesthetists, but I can medically direct four to six. and I give the example of one of my members in Paragool. He's a sole anesthesiologist, but I believe he has six nurse anesthetists that often work there as well. He's not able to medically supervise any of them because if there are four or five operating rooms going at once in his area, then he can only medically direct them. Okay.
▶ Play
Thank you. Vice Chair Ferguson, you're recognized. And you might clarify, in addition to your supervision, there's always going to be another doctor present, a surgeon, I assume.
▶ Play
Correct. That's what allows the nurse anesthetist in the case to be medically directed outside in the rural areas at hospitals in which an anesthesiologist is not present. But this would not allow, anesthesiologist assistants are not allowed to work under that model of not having an anesthesiologist present. So it's just two tracks to
▶ Play
get to the same, sort of the same place, other than CRNAs can work without the supervision of an anesthesiologist. I guess I compare it to you can go to an allopathic medical school and be an MD or you can go to osteopath school and be an osteopath and you're still board certified by the medical board. Is that a good analogy? Yes, that is a good analogy. All right,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:19:28
members, seeing no further questions, Dr. Chance, thank you for testimony and being patient with so many questions. Thank you. Obviously, we care. All right, thank you. Try to make the right decision. Next up is to speak against or testify against this bill is Ms. Lori Cole. And if you would follow the same routine, introduce yourself for the record, and you're recognized to give testimony, and you might want to pull that microphone
▶ Play
up. Make sure you're close to it so we can hear you. Well, good morning, everyone. My name is Lori Cole. I'm a CRNA, certified registered nurse anesthetist from Pine Bluff, Arkansas. and there's a couple of things that I hold sacred in my life. One is my off days and another is my marriage. And today is my 31st anniversary and my off day. And this bill is very important to me to pull me out of the arms of my very handsome husband and on my off day to drive up from Icy Pine Bluff to be here to speak against this bill. It's very important to me because it's scary to me. This bill has got some kind of scary, reckless language in it. I'm not afraid of the competition from AAs. I think there is a reason that there's only 17 states that do allow them, though. That says something for itself. America as a nation is not slow. We're not ignorant. But there are only 17 states that allow AAs for a reason. in my practice down in Pine Bluff I've been doing anesthesia for 10 years I think if I had been allowed to be out there after just one year I think I would have made a whole lot of mistakes I think there says something to have a nursing background being allowed to sit at a bedside to watch trends and blood pressure and trends and responses. It means something. And as a nurse, I got to do that at a bedside in critical care, in the emergency room, in intensive care units. And it teaches you something. It gives you a calm confidence. And it makes me nervous that someone with a general bachelor's degree with two years of training would be allowed to do anesthesia in this state, especially since there's not a need for more anesthesia providers. We have two very good programs. We have Texas Wesleyan, which I'm an alumni of from Fort Worth, Texas, as well as ASU's program in Jonesboro that's putting out about 40 CRNAs a year. The program in Texas Wesleyan provides about 20 CRNAs that are local to Arkansas. And I think those people in majority have had to take jobs outside of Arkansas. Last year, everyone that I worked with coming through Jefferson Hospital took a job outside of Arkansas. This year, it may be a little bit different, but not much. Most of the interviews that they're going on, they're going out of state. They're not finding anesthesia employment in Arkansas. So I think it's important for us to take care of Arkansas' zone. Even if the AA bill were to pass, what would keep other AAs from other states to come fill those positions that we're going to allow? I think we should take care of Arkansas' people first. I take any
▶ Play
questions. Representative Hammer, you're recognized. Can you speak? Thank you for being here, first of all, on a day that you mentioned. It's important. Are there enough CRNAs to fulfill the need of Arkansas currently, or can you speak to do we have areas that are short, or can you speak to that, please, to
▶ Play
your knowledge? To my knowledge, we do not have any anesthesia shortage.
▶ Play
In the CRNAs? In the CRNAs. Okay. Why are you in Pine Bluff? Because if I remember, I think that's a medically underserved area, so why are
▶ Play
you in Pine Bluff then? Palm Bluff is my home. Okay, very good. So you went home then? I stayed home. I did have to go to train in Texas. We did not have an anesthesia program established in Arkansas when I was interested in it. Did the distance learning option through Texas Wesleyan for one semester, but it was very nice because I had four children at the time, husband, and it allowed me to do my training at Baptist Hospital here in Little Rock. Very good. And what
▶ Play
about the rate that you bill when you provide services for anesthesiology? What's your bill rate? We've seen some numbers, I think, floating around of what AAs would charge or others. So can you talk about that? I can't talk on the billing.
▶ Play
I have an office that does our billing. Okay, but you don't
▶ Play
know whether it's less equal or greater than? I don't know. Okay,
▶ Play
all right. I would imagine it would be more with an anesthesiologist assistant because you have to have a doctor there. You have to have an anesthesiologist on board. that's more cost. I know that reimbursement during this time has not been outstanding for the medical field and it's just added cost. You have to pay for two anesthesia providers instead of one. And with you, you only have to pay for you? You bill for
▶ Play
one. Yes, sir. All right. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Scherr. Representative Beeks, you're recognized. Thank
▶ Play
you. I appreciate you taking your day off and everything to come in. Just trying to clear up some things on education, I guess in your case, you had to go through more medical education. You have more medical training to be able to do the job that
▶ Play
you actually are doing. Is that correct? Yes, sir. I did four years doing my bachelor's in nursing. Also, I worked in the open-heart CVICU, ICU, ER for approximately eight years, again, an invaluable experience that you couldn't put a price on it. You have to learn to be cool in crazy, chaotic situations. That's where you cut your teeth. That's where you get out of being so green. You've got to be put in those situations where you have to be cool, calm, and collected and make a good judgment call. And coming from a background of a bachelor's in literature or a bachelor's in, no offense, pastoral studies, you don't get that. You don't get that. I think the good foundation necessary has got to be in the hospital.
▶ Play
You've got to get it there. Thank you. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. Representative Boyd, you're recognized. Are you aware of any patient safety issues like is there literature that you're aware of that shows that where anesthesiology assistants are used that patient deaths go up or other harm to patients happens in those 17 areas where they're allowed? I have not heard of any of those
▶ Play
studies. All right, members seeing no further questions.
▶ Play
Do you have a question? Vice Chair Ferguson has a question. You may not be able to answer this, and I don't know if there's someone from the nursing board here. I guess part of my problem with the CRNAs and the APN is the makeup of the regulatory body of the nursing board who oversees you. And it's my understanding it's mostly RNs and LPNs, and there's only one APN. Is there even a CRNA on the nursing board
▶ Play
that oversees your profession? I don't believe there is a CRNA on the board. There is an advanced practice nurse on the board. Yeah, just
▶ Play
one out of 13, I believe. Yes. And that's my real issue. That's why I like this group, because you actually have anesthesiologists and people that understand the issues and are more well-educated to oversee the scope of practice and all of those kind of issues for the group. It concerns me that the nursing board is overseeing the CRNAs, and there's not even a CRNA on the
▶ Play
board. It does not disturb me at all. The foundation of nurse anesthesia is nurse. I'm a nurse first. I do anesthesia every day, but I still regularly, I take people to the bathroom. I put people on the bedpans. If I need to be a nurse, I'm a nurse. I'm a carer.
▶ Play
I'm a nurturer. But if there's disciplinary control, my contention is they know nothing about what you're doing and to properly assess that. The literature and the scope
▶ Play
of practice, it's thorough, and it's effective. Representative Hammer, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you. Do you know how many CRNAs have been disciplined, let's say, in the last year because they failed to do their duties when functioning as under the anesthesiologist duties? Do you know if there have been any that have been sanctioned or that doctors or anybody that they've worked with have filed complaints? And if you don't know the answer to that, I think that would be a good thing for somebody to bring to the table to tell us if there have been any complaints or sanctions. Do you know of any? I do not know of any. Okay. And if the AAs come in, then what is the future role of CRNAs when it comes to that? Do you feel that it's going to be that you will be replaced by the
▶ Play
AAs and that CRNAs will be pushed out of the picture? I don't believe that. I do believe that there would be some competition again, which is, that's fine. but the thing that I'm concerned about is small hospitals it would not be affected but the only place that AAs would have a role will be in large learning institutions like here in Little Rock perhaps Fayetteville maybe Jonesboro and it's just an added cost. My main objection is the cost, the safety and there's not really a need for AAs at this time. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Madam Chair.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:29:53
Alright, seeing no further questions, thank you for testimony, Ms. Cull. Thank you. And happy anniversary. Thank you. Alright, we have no one else signed up to speak for or against this bill. Representative McGee, I think you'd like to close for your bill, and traditionally we don't ask questions during the closing, but I think some questions were asked that you may want to address during that. Well, thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee, for your indulgence. I think this has been a very informative discussion, an educational discussion for all the people on the committee because this is an important issue. And if there are questions that you have, and the chair, with the chair's indulgence, I'll answer some more questions if we need to. But just to finally close, I think, you know, the issue comes down to we have a group of individuals that are, I would say, no better or no worse than each other. We have anesthesia assistants. We have certified registered nurse anesthetists. Both of them, both groups perform in the settings in which they work. They work side by side under supervision. and you heard Dr. Chance talk about direct supervision and that sort of thing, of an anesthesiologist. So I don't want to degrade or say anything negative about the nursing anesthesia people that are here in our state. They do a great job. They deliver a great product, taking care of all of us. And if tomorrow they had to put me to sleep to do a surgery, I'd let a CRNA put me to sleep. I'd also let an anesthesia assistant put me to sleep under the direction of an anesthesiologist. These are educated individuals that have spent the time, have developed the skills, have the expertise to be part of the anesthetic team. They're not independent contractors. They work for anesthesiologists. The comment was made about the cost where they would cost more money. I don't think that's true. I think actually with competition, they'll lower cost. Competition for the job positions, they'll lower the overall cost. The costs are dictated by the procedure, and as Dr. Chant said, seven different things they have to go through to justify for Medicare, what they bill and all of that. That doesn't matter if there's an anesthesiologist or a nurse anesthetist or however it works because typically two or three different people are not going to get paid for doing the same thing on the patient. For instance, if I have an eye surgeon that I do and I have three eye surgeons in there, only one of us is going to get paid. I mean, that's just the way it works, guys. I can have all this. If I'm a general surgeon and I do your gallbladder and I have an assistant surgeon, only one of us is going to get paid, and that's just the way the world works nowadays. They don't pay for, quote, assistant surgeons, although in many cases we still use them. Cardiovascular surgeons, a lot of times they'll do heart surgery and have somebody harvesting veins, and, you know, one gets paid. So I don't think the costs are a big issue. I think this is a fairness issue. We have a group of individuals that are trained in university settings. All of these programs are in medical school, university settings. I'd like to see at some time in the future, I'd like to see our University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences develop an anesthesia assistant program and train those people. They come out accredited by their joint commissions. They undergo rigorous testing. We put them under the medical board, a board that has more expertise than them, that has anesthesiologists on the board of medicine, that will make sure that they're doing the right things and they're delivering good health care to the citizens of our state. So I don't see them as that much of a direct competition. They're not really, realistically, there are not very many anesthesia assistants in the whole world. I mean, there's like 2,000 in the United States, and there's 40-something thousand certified registered nurse anesthetists. So I don't think that you're going to see a move for every anesthesia assistant in the world to move to Arkansas and take over all the jobs. I just think this opens an opportunity for Arkansans that want to pursue this career, that this is their lifelong career that they want to do. It gives them the opportunity to go off to school, make the grades, get the training, and come back to Arkansas and practice. And we heard of a couple of instances where there were people that didn't come back to Arkansas to practice. And we want to encourage that. We want to encourage people to come back. It's not about over-regulating the system. It's, you know, we have to have these people under a board for licensure and to develop rule and regulation that we all will at some point review when they do that. But with that, I'm open to any questions. If there are no further questions, as a committee member, I'd ask for a due pass. All right. Is that a motion due pass? Unless there are other questions that I can answer first. I see no further questions. It's a motion due pass. All right, members, we'll have a motion on the floor. Is there any discussion of the motion? Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? No. Chair, rules and no's have it. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Thank you. All right, next up. We're going to keep going, y'all, while we're on a roll. Representative Baltz made a member's own. He's not going to be able to run that today. Representative Hammer, I'm guessing you're not going to be ready to run
▶ Play
yours today, are you? I'd like to make a request to the chair. Yes, sir. I'd like to have this as a special order of business on Thursday the 26th, please, at a time to be set to your
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:36:03
convenience. Thursday the 26th, the special order of business. We will do that at, let's do it at 10-15. All right, thank you. We might have a resolution or something in front of us. So we'll set that for the 26th at 1015. Thank you for that consideration, too. Representative Ferguson, is today your day to run this? I think you said no, right? No, no. No, okay. I don't see Representative Gonzalez in the room. Representative Fite, where are you at with your bill? We're going to pass over that. Representative Vladimir, are you here for fluoride? And we have some handouts, I think. I think this yeah. Representative Vladimir you're recognized to introduce your bill and what let's see what number is that 1355 members
▶ Play
1355 thank you Mr. Chairman committee House Bill 1355 entitled local control over fluoride levels is a very short and simple bill. What this bill does is provide local control of fluoride addition to drinking water. It does not address the science of adding fluoride or the benefit of fluoride reducing cavities. There are many, many studies out there on both sides of this issue, So this bill does not address that. It does give local boards, cities, quorum courts, rural water systems the right to consider the science and to make a decision locally on whether or not they want to add fluoride to their water and at what levels they want to add fluoride to their water. uh basically the bottom line here is i feel that uh the people who drink the water should vote on or decide what they put in the water the water uh quality varies from place to place so when you're when you're requiring a chemical addition to water statewide, the chemistry is different in different areas. So I think local people should look at that and make that decision. I say that based on my background as a water treatment professional. I've been over water treatment systems in Jonesboro, Fayetteville, Elkins, Little Rock, so I know the science of water treatment. So I really feel like that we should give local communities the opportunity to vote on this. That basically is the bill. I take any questions. Members have an explanation of
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:39:01
the bill. Representative Hammer, you're first for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. A couple things. Number one, what
▶ Play
this bill is proposing to do is to put it at the local level for each city or municipality or water work system to have a decision over whether they put fluorine in their water or not. Is that
▶ Play
Speaker 43 1:39:24
a fair assumption of the bill? I
▶ Play
think you said chlorine fluoride. Or fluoride, sorry. Yes, whatever the local entity is, whether that's a municipal system, a rural water system,
▶ Play
Speaker 213 1:39:35
whatever that local entity is, yes, that's correct.
▶ Play
All right. And but they will all have to function according to what the state or whoever governs this puts out as far as the amounts. And, I mean, there's really no, there's not anything that's going to hurt anybody. It's just we're going to let the local level decide whether or not they want to do this or not. Is
▶ Play
that correct? That's correct. The Arkansas Department of Health has recommended a level. What this bill would do would be would allow the local entity to add fluoride from zero up to that recommended level. So there would be a maximum level, yes.
▶ Play
Okay, final question. And then how are the citizens that are part of a water system going to have a fair voice in deciding whether or not that fluoride is put in the water or not? Are they going to have to have an election process? Is it going to be determined by the board or the governing body of that water system? Can you tell us how the citizens are actually going to have input to that that would make this bill do anything different than currently
▶ Play
what is being done? Thank you. Yes, Representative Hammer, that's a very good question. and I thank you for asking that. Sticking with the theme of this bill of local control, I felt like it was better not to put that into this bill and complicate the issue even more. I believe if we're going to give the people at the local level the right to vote on whether to put fluoride in there, then they should determine how they do that. So it would be up to the local entity, whatever that is, a board, a city council, they could choose at the local level how they would like to do that. That is something that could be added to the bill. But, again, if it's local control, I believe the local entity should decide that. Do I have any more questions?
▶ Play
Representative Feit, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Leitemann, since you're an expert in this area, I get a lot of email about this, and I've always wanted to ask. If I do not have fluoride in my water system, I can add that in my home. Is that correct, that there's a way that I could add fluoride to my water? But if fluoride is in my water system, I have no way in my home to remove it. Am I understanding that correctly, or could you help me there? Well,
▶ Play
you could add it in your home. I mean, there is a way to do that. You could actually take it out in your home, but it would be very expensive to do that. But, yes, that is possible. Again, based on my background, the delivery method of fluoride through the water treatment system is not a good system. Think about it. In the state of Arkansas, with the law as it stands, we are treating 100% of the water that goes to a water system that serves more than 5,000 people, all the water systems, 100%. Do you have an idea how much of that water is used for actual drinking water and brushing your teeth? Does anybody have an idea? It's probably around 5%. So we're treating 100% of the water for an act, drinking water, brushing your teeth, which actually only uses 5% of the product. My background in business is that that's not a good delivery system. There's much better ways, more economical ways to do that. As you said, you would have to, it would be very expensive for you to take that out at your point of use in your home. Did I answer your question? You did.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:43:21
Thank you. Hi, members. We have numerous people signed up to speak. I think everybody's against this bill. Dr. Lindy Bolin, is that right? If you would come to the table, introduce yourself for the record, and you are recognized to begin testimony.
▶ Play
Speaker 245 1:43:41
Thank you, Mr. Chair and members of the committee. I'm Dr. Lenny Boland, the Director of Office of Oral Health at the Department of Health. With me is Dr. Nate Smith, the Director of the Department
▶ Play
of Health. Dr. Nate Smith, Director of the Arkansas Department of Health. I figured you'd probably want to hear from us together rather than have to hear from us separately. you bet that's fine thank y'all I think I'll start out I want to say the Arkansas Department of Health is is is strongly opposed to this bill although it's a short bill it would have a very large impact fluoride is a naturally occurring element it's present in essentially all drinking water sources If those concentrations are too high or too low, they have adverse health effects, particularly they harm the oral health of individuals drinking the water, especially children. And that's why health authorities in virtually every jurisdiction have either recommended or set both a maximum and a minimum concentration for drinking water sources. This bill would allow local water operators to, you know, continue to abide by the maximum, but it would allow them to ignore that minimum. And that would result in harm to oral health, particularly oral health of children, which is why the Department of Health is opposed. And Dr. Lindley, our state public health dentist, can answer specific questions on those benefits. and harms thank you specifically when he's talking about harm to the oral
▶ Play
Speaker 245 1:45:29
cavity when the fluoride levels is too high of a concentration it can lead to a problem called dental fluorosis which actually are small white specks that you'll see on the developing teeth but this has to happen when the levels are far too high the levels that are recommended is at 0.7 parts per million not exceed 1.2 parts per million. This is the level that we have found that helps to strengthen the enamel, makes it more resistant to the acids that are forced upon the teeth, and it has shown that it greatly reduces the incidence of decay, especially in our target populations where they don't have the services. Members, any questions?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:46:18
you have a question as most
▶ Play
of you know I'm a dentist and would you not agree that this has been one of the most important public health initiatives of the last 50 years in terms of reducing cavities in children to almost what 40% reduction in cavities just as a personal point of privilege I'm a dentist and West Memphis had fluoride in the water and I would see kids from surrounding smaller communities and there was an appreciable difference in the cavity index and cavities is one of the main reasons that kids miss school and, you know, you can say this is about local control but, you know, you weren't for local control when you wanted cursive writing and discrimination. That's a question.
▶ Play
Speaker 250 1:47:08
Point of order. Point of order. I don't think
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:47:13
we had a question in there. Yeah, talk about the health benefits. There's more debate on the
▶ Play
Speaker 245 1:47:20
motion, if there is one. Thank you. As far as your mention of the benefits, the CDC even says that water fluoridation has been one of the top ten public health measures done in the last century. As far as the effect of greatly reducing decay among children, I myself have witnessed that in children that are in areas without fluoride when they are in areas with fluoride. I'm sorry, we've got
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:47:48
a couple questions if y'all would like to address those. Representative Hammer, do you have a question for these? Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. When it comes to the fluoride, let me ask you first of all, do you know how many water systems currently are utilizing fluoride, or they're all having to use the fluoride in the water now because of state law. Is that
▶ Play
correct? For all those that serve populations of 5,000 or greater, yes. Okay. And has
▶ Play
the health department received any requests for those that are 5,000 and above that are under your jurisdiction that they want to pull out from doing the fluoride? Have you received any requests for that? Yes, sir. Do you know about how many? i'm only aware of one currently and who is that if you don't mind me asking that is a mayor of
▶ Play
eureka springs and we have offered to bring that before the board of health in their
▶ Play
april meeting okay and is this about the cost of i mean from what are you hearing from your position is it about the cost to do it or is it just uh you know an issue wanting to keep the decision at the local level or can you share any to your level that you can
▶ Play
without violating confidence can you tell us something? Certainly. It's not about cost. Although there is a small cost to adding fluoride to water systems where the fluoride levels are below the recommended level, the addition of fluoride in drinking water to bring it up into that range is cost-saving. Communities that don't fluoridate pay far more in cost in terms of dental care, and also there's a strong connection between oral health and other general health conditions like cardiovascular disease. So no, the question is never cost because fluoridation actually saves these communities money and improves their health, not just oral health but also general health. The question is not super clear in this case, and I think it probably has to do with more control and, you know, beliefs about fluoride that aren't directly connected with the science. All right. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. President Sullivan, you're recognized. Thank you,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:50:10
Mr. Chair. So Representative Ladyman
▶ Play
said that this wasn't about the science of it, and you seem to be making the science argument, and you seem very confident in your argument, and you have stats. Why are you opposed to making this
▶ Play
a local issue then? Again, Florida, naturally occurring, and there's both an upper limit and a lower limit that are required for optimal health. And this bill would allow local water operators to ignore the lower limits, and that would put those communities at risk of lower health. Children born in those communities would have poor health just because they happen to be born in that community. The science doesn't really change from locale to locale. The public health effects are going to be there and those we can determine once and they don't have to be renegotiated at every locality because the science remains the same when it comes to the public health effects.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:51:30
All right, Representative Meeks. Recognize for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And this is kind of following the lines of Representative Hamer because I think the bill that we passed, I can't remember, I think it was probably four years ago, was contingent on funding, and I know that there were some groups that were going to be responsible for the funding. Do you know where we stand on that? Did all the communities over 5,000 receive the appropriate funding to be able to put fluoride in their water, or are there still some systems that do not have fluoride because of lack of funding?
▶ Play
There's not a lack of funding. There's a process that each of them have gone through, and not all of them have completed that process, but there's no lack of funding to complete
▶ Play
Speaker 245 1:52:17
that. I don't have the exact number, but all the systems have been in touch with various grants to go through that process. We have several that are already coming online, and within the next 18 to 24 months we'll have three more larger areas coming online.
▶ Play
Speaker 176 1:52:34
And a follow-up question, if I may, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. Yes, sir. I know Eureka Springs voted at least twice to say we don't want fluoride in the water. Do you know of any other municipalities that have fought against this because their constituents or their city council have said no. I know that a number of them didn't do it just because they didn't have the funding, which apparently now they're going to get the funding. But do you know how many municipalities besides Eureka Springs said, no, we don't want Florida in the water because of various reasons?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:53:04
None that have come to my attention. So it's just Eureka Springs
▶ Play
at this point? To my attention, yes. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Fyke, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My background is not in the health field, so if you will help me out, just a couple of my constituents have contacted me and said that they have thyroid problems that they feel are exacerbated by having fluoride in the water. Would you please speak to that so I can allay their concerns? Go ahead.
▶ Play
That would not be a concern at the recommended levels, levels recommended by Arkansas Department of Health. That's it. That's correct. Much, much higher levels of fluoride obviously can cause harm, not to just those with thyroid problems, but at the recommended range, both the upper and the lower limit, there's not going to be a problem for someone with thyroid disease.
▶ Play
Representative Boyd, you're recognized. Representative, if I just
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:54:14
ask my question. Good deal. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Bragg. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Are there other sources of fluoride? Is it possible to get it through toothpaste or
▶ Play
Speaker 245 1:54:26
other treatments? Fluoride can come through toothpaste, rinse, and even from professionally applied gels, varnishes, or rinses. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Seeing no
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:54:38
further questions, we're going to call our next two people up. If we might do it at the same time, kind of like we did this, if that's all right, that would be great. and if you would both introduce yourself for
▶ Play
the record and you're recognized to begin testimony it'll be short my voice is not not here today my name is rosie smith i'm with arkansas children's hospital and we have we supported the bill that mr meeks referenced it passed in 2011 in 2007 we started a program natural wonders it's a convening of groups that would look at children's health and well-being overall. And one of the areas that we looked at most closely was oral health. That's when we started doing mobile dentistry. We've done school programs where we do fluoride varnishes and sealants. I do apologize for not having one of my dentists here today to explain all this more readily than I do. And we also started the mobile dental vans with Delta Dental, with Tyson's, with Ronald McDonald House. We have three out there. All of those are treating kids that need the treating need treating they go to schools where the children have they have the highest number of free and reduced lunch kids so we can treat them there but nothing can do the same as preventative medicine and that's what fluoride and water does for children prevents them from cat tooth decay it makes them healthier we hope that it will make a bigger difference when it's all fully implemented and we hope we get the chance to do that thank you Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 268 1:56:14
you. I'm Marquita Little, the Health Policy Director with Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families. And so I'll just, I'll be brief as well and just echo many of the things you just heard from Rozzy. We also supported Act 197 as well, in addition to continuing to support the work of Children's Hospital and many other partners through Natural Wonders Group. And again, many of the things you've heard today. But our primary concern is basically maintaining the health and well-being of children. Pediatric dental disease or childhood tooth decay is one of the most common childhood illnesses, and it is preventable. With regard to this particular bill, we are concerned that it does not establish basically adequate levels to prevent tooth decay. although it does allow for a maximum, it does not adhere to those guidelines for what adequate levels would be. We also know that based on the research that water fluoridation really is the safest, most cost-effective and healthy way to prevent tooth decay. I know the cost came up a few times and so just to share a few statistics on the cost, studies show that for every $1 that we invest in community water fluoridation, it results in about $38 in savings to dental treatment. We also know that the national average, when you look at those costs for filling one cavity is about $145, which is about twice the cost of actually providing fluoridated water to individuals. So again, just to kind of speak to what others have said today, we would be opposed to this bill specifically for the reason of ensuring that we are taking proper preventative measures to preserve what is a preventable issues with children and certainly it also does affect adults as well.
▶ Play
Representative Hammer, are you recognized for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Regarding the efforts that are being done in schools to help identify 2K and other dental issues, can you speak Can you speak to that and also maybe tie that in with the increased number of visits to the doctor, to the dentist, I'm sorry, with the changes in the recent health care laws and kind of wrap all that together? And if I allow a follow-up short question, I'd like to.
▶ Play
I wish I could answer that, Mr. Hammer. I can get some more information for you. I can't do that off the top of my head. As I said, I wish we could have had
▶ Play
our dental and oral health specialist here today, but I wasn't able to. Okay, and do you know how many under 5,000 water systems there are and how it correlates to the, is there any correlation between those kids that live in those areas that aren't currently getting treatment in their water and the number of visits to the dentist or problems, you know, oral problems? Is there any way to match those two up to see if there's a correlation? I'm looking at the health department because they have more of those
▶ Play
numbers data than I do. Okay. Okay, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Dr. Lindy will
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:59:35
look into that. All right, members, seeing no further questions. Representative Vladimir, you're recognized to close for your bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. again as I said when I started to discuss the bill this is not about the science this is about local control I will address a couple things that were brought up they are absolutely right fluoride is a naturally occurring element as a lot of other things are you know strontium and atomic metals all those things are naturally occurring in the ground and the water that's another reason for having local control because the water systems And I can say this from experience, from being over water systems in Jonesboro, Fayetteville, Little Rock, and actually in other states, New York, Florida, California. The water is different everywhere. There are different levels of fluoride in the water. So you need to look at it at the local level. The other thing that I want to address, it does not set a minimum in my bill, but it does not eliminate that either. In other words, the local decision could be a minimum. That could be set at the local level. Again, I'm not talking about the science. I'm talking about who's going to make the decision. As you can see, there are no groups or agencies here with me to present this bill. This is presented because I had constituents contact me and local water systems and talk about they want local control because they have concerns. So that's why I brought this bill forward. It's for the constituents, for the local people to have a say in the water that they drink to make that decision. That's pretty much it. Again, the bill is for people who drink the water to vote on what goes in the water. That's my only proposal here. I would appreciate a good vote.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:01:32
Members, what's will of the committee? Representative Bentley? We have a motion due pass. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing or hearing none. all in favor aye all opposed chair rules the eyes have it roll call please do we have to I'm sorry you're right we had one have another roll call web to thank you would start with the freshman representative Sullivan representative
▶ Play
Speaker 118 2:02:10
Henderson. Representative Boyd. Representative Boyd. Representative Bentley. Representative Lundström. Representative Payton. Representative Fight. Representative Bragg. Representative Womack. Representative Miller. Representative Miller. Representative McGee. No. Representative Ritchie. No. Representative Overby. No. Representative Meeks. Yes. Representative Branscombe. Yes. Representative Hammer. Yes. Representative Wardlaw. represent board law representative love representative love
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:03:33
All right, we have, with roll call, we have 11 yeses, 5 nays, and 4 non-voting. Is that right? Yeah, it'd be 4 non-voting. So congratulations, your bill has passed. All right, up next is Senator Hester.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I hope this bill is easier than the past. It is yet to receive a no vote. What this does is this is a bill about upward mobility, in my opinion, that allows hardworking Arkansans the chance to better their lives without necessarily having to go to college. And today we're talking about workforce development and tech training. That's what this bill does. in Arkansas currently, if you are an apprentice plumber, you have to train with a journeyman or a master plumber at a one-to-one ratio. What I'm handing out to you is that shows what the states around us do, and that's just for kind of a barometer, that most of the states around us, they're unlimited on the ratio to train plumbers. Oklahoma's one to three, and Louisiana's one to two. And this just gives our plumbers the ability to train more young guys that are maybe coming out of high school that can train more guys at one time. And I think it's a really great bill, and I'd be happy to answer any questions.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:05:08
Members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Representative Hammer, you're recognized for a question. I was looking over my emails real
▶ Play
quick, and I haven't had one from a plumber. Is this going to blow up our emails if we pass this out of here? How are the plumbers feeling about this? Because if it flows the wrong way, we've all got a problem so can you tell me where you are with all the plumbers
▶ Play
sure well I can tell you I ran this for some plumbers in our area you know northwest Arkansas is growing and we simply they need to train more guys to be able to keep up with the demand I will tell you I met with the pipe fitters union on this they had some concerns we tried to work through them and ultimately they may be here they chose not to oppose it on the house on the senate side I think at the end When you see what the ratios are around us, it's kind of a reasonable bill. And what ratio did you
▶ Play
say you're expanding it to? From one to one to
▶ Play
one to three. So a master or journeyman plumber can train up to three apprentice plumbers at one time. And what's the UL mean and the others? Unlimited. Okay, thank you.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:06:10
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Seeing no further questions, no one is signed up to speak for or against this bill. What's the will of this committee? We have a motion to do pass. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing no discussion on the motion, all in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations. Thank you, Senator, for your patience, and your bill is passed. Senator Irvin? And it looks like Representative Mayberry will be joining you as well. And this is what Senate bill is this, 53? Senate Bill 53. Senate Bill 53, committee. And you're introduced or recognized to present your bill.
▶ Play
Thank you. This is the Senate bill that is identical to Representative Mayberry's bill that this committee has passed out which requires a physician to be present when a chemical abortion is being performed. You've heard this bill so I can answer questions from the committee but it's identical to Representative Mayberry's bill. Members have heard an explanation of the bill. Any questions?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:07:14
and seeing no questions we have a motion we have a motion do pass we'll let Representative Henderson make that motion Representative Wardlock because you get all the glory we have a motion do pass do we have any discussion of the motion hearing none all in favor aye all opposed and congratulations the bill is
▶ Play
passed thank you Senator I also want to say thank you to Representative Tommy Wren who co-sponsored this bill with me two sessions ago that we weren't able to get it passed. So I just wanted to mention that, and I appreciate his service to our legislature. Thank you.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:07:54
Representative Bentley, you have a resolution. Is that right? Is it today a day to run this? You know, members, I'm already hungry. We might as well get how long. This isn't like, okay. I believe we have a handout. Is that right, Representative?
▶ Play
Yeah, we've got a little handout just to correlate what I'm going to read to you, but it's a very simple resolution that we're going to honor the crisis pregnancy centers across the state. We have 46 crisis pregnancy centers that do a great service for free to our communities, give pregnancy tests, ultrasound tests, parenting, teaching, and just a great volunteer organization that I'm honored to work with in Moralton. Just a great group of ladies that I would just like to honor what they do for our state. So if anybody has any questions, there's a little sheet going around to say some of the things that these groups do. And just really honoring all the service they do as volunteers across our state. That's what the resolution's about. Members,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:08:57
prepare an explanation of the resolution. Is there any questions? Seeing no questions, do we have a motion? We'll have a motion. We have a motion due passed by numerous members of the committee. We'll give this one to Representative Lundstrom. I think she was the first one that wanted to do pass. Members, any discussion of the motion? Hearing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations. Thank you, Representative Bentley. Your resolution is passed. Members, we are done for the day.
▶ Play

Agenda

Surgeon General Testimony

3:50 - 12:28 28 segments 5 speakers

SB4

12:28 - 22:34 34 segments 6 speakers

HB1311

22:34 - 37:22 47 segments 9 speakers

HB1120

37:22 - 1:37:16 217 segments 16 speakers

HB1355

1:37:16 - 2:04:47 91 segments 19 speakers

SB153

2:04:47 - 2:07:07 9 segments 4 speakers

SB53

2:07:07 - 2:08:53 5 segments 3 speakers

HR1019

2:08:53 - 2:09:28 3 segments 2 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Chair Unverified
132 segments
Representative Ken Bragg Chair Unverified
52 segments
Representative John Payton Unverified
19 segments
Representative Mary Bentley Unverified
3 segments
Representative Kim Hammer Unverified
85 segments
Representative Robin Lundstrum Chair Unverified
7 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
12 segments
Speaker 60
1 segment
Representative Justin Boyd Unverified
4 segments
Representative Mickey Gates Unverified
14 segments
Representative Dan Sullivan Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 88
2 segments
Speaker 89
1 segment
Speaker 101
8 segments
Speaker 118
4 segments
Speaker 157
1 segment
Representative Deborah Ferguson Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 188
1 segment
Lori Cole Unverified
23 segments
Representative Jack Ladyman Unverified
14 segments
Speaker 43
1 segment
Speaker 213
1 segment
Representative Charlene Fite Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 245
7 segments
Representative Karilyn Brown Unverified
13 segments
Speaker 250
1 segment
Speaker 176
1 segment
Rosie Smith Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 268
5 segments
Senator Bart Hester Unverified
5 segments
Senator Missy Irvin Unverified
3 segments