Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Judiciary Committee

February 17, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (1)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1197 · 7 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1197”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
We also have some handouts, so I'm going to wait just a minute to be able to allow staff a handout. If anybody wants to speak for or against the bill, now's your chance to sign up. We're not going to take anybody else if you don't sign up now. Sign on back before you. All pan out. Representative Lighting, you are recognized to present your
▶ Play
bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair and members of the committee. We appreciate everybody being here today. We know the
▶ Play
Speaker 6 0:41
weather has made it difficult. We've actually had three or four people who are supposed to be here today to testify in support who have not been able to make it. So the presentation will be a little shorter today than it would have been otherwise. We're still going to be respectful of the committee's time, and I'm going to be very brief. Currently, the United States is the only country in the world that sentences children to die in prison. Recent Supreme Court decisions have effectively ended that practice, but states are just now playing catch-up. And while this is not in any way a partisan issue, to date, conservatives and conservative states have led the way in ending juvenile life without parole. States like Alaska, Kansas, Kentucky, Montana, Texas, West Virginia, and Wyoming have all ended the practice. In fact, former Republican Texas Governor Rick Perry called the Texas State Legislature into a special session in part to end juvenile life without parole in the Lone Star State. Former Republican House Speaker Newt Gingrich has written an op-ed calling for California to end its practice there. The Pope has recently come out in support of ending juvenile life without parole, and the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops in December of 2012 decided it was also going to join the fight, saying that it cannot support policies that treat children as adults when it comes to their moral and cognitive development. Other churches, including the Methodist Church, also oppose juvenile life without parole. On February 9th of this year, the American Bar Association adopted Resolution 107 calling for an end to juvenile life without parole. ABA President William Hubbard said that the ABA has sent a clear message to the legal community and policymakers across the country that children should not be sentenced to die in prison. And just last Friday, the editorial board of the Arkansas Democrat Gazette wrote an op-ed in strong support of this bill calling for Arkansas to end juvenile life without parole. You should have a copy of that editorial on your desk before you. Also before you is a letter from Linda White. She had planned to be here today, but due to the weather, was not able to make it out of Houston. She is the mother of a victim. I had the honor of meeting Linda at a conference in D.C. last November. She has a very powerful story. We really wish she could be here today, but again, unfortunately, she was not able to make it, but I do encourage you to read her full letter. We also had Dr. Banks, a child psychologist who was supposed to have been here today, along with a couple of members of the local faith community. But again, the weather has prevented their absence. Senator Irvin was also going to be here this morning, but have not yet heard from her. So we do again appreciate all of you for being here. We do have a few people here to testify in support of this bill, the first of which is Mr. James Dold. Those of you who were here in the last session might remember Mr. Dold. He worked with Senator Irvin, I and other legislators to help pass a package of anti-human trafficking reforms that actually took Arkansas from among the worst states to the best states when it comes to fighting that particular crime. crime. So, Mr. Chair, that's all I have. With your permission, we can hear from
▶ Play
Mr. Dold. Mr. Dold, if you'll just let everybody know your name and what group
▶ Play
you're with, you're recognized. Absolutely. Thank you so much, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. My name is James Dold. I'm the Advocacy Director with the Campaign for the Fair Sentencing of Youth. The Campaign is a national clearinghouse and organization that works with crime victim family members, incarcerated youth, as well as family members of those currently serving extreme sentences across the country, to work on and develop a more age-appropriate and just alternatives to sentencing children to die in prison. We work closely with prosecuting attorneys associations in some states where they're supportive of these measures, as well as other folks in the law enforcement community where possible. We've had a lot of support in other states where we've had actually prosecutors testify in support of our bills. And so we try to, as much as possible, reach out and build bipartisan consensus around these issues. We work with policymakers across the aisle. We work closely with our sister organization, Right on Crime, a conservative think tank in Texas. It's housed at the Texas Public Policy Institute, which also supports these types of reforms. And so we're here today to talk a little bit about House Bill 1197. I think for some background, I think there's two major lenses to view this issue through. and to some extent there's a little bit of overlap. There's the legal lens and I'll be going through a little bit of the Supreme Court jurisprudence on this issue as well as the moral lens. From a moral standpoint the Old Testament in Hebrews chapter 13 verse 2 reminds us to remember those in prison as if you were together with them in prison and certainly nowhere is that more true than when we're talking about juveniles. Representative Letting mentioned former Speaker of the House Newt Gingrich in an op-ed that he wrote to Governor Brown in a paper in California calling for the passage of similar legislation. He said, I think that's something poignant that I think should be thought about here as we continue to go along. And Speaker Gingrich said that Jesus told us to do unto others as we would have done unto us. Shouldn't we give the kids and grandkids of others the same second chances that we would want for our own children? So today, as you listen to some of the testimony from other folks who have been impacted by these sorts of extreme sentences who have been given second chances, I would just ask that you pray and you think about this issue and think about it through the lens of if this was your own child, what sort of policy would you want in place if, in fact, your child was to end up in an unfortunate situation to commit a serious offense? Would you want them discarded for life or would you want them, if they showed that they were rehabilitated and they were capable of change, have a second chance. So pivoting real quick and starting to begin to talk about the Supreme Court decisions over the last decade, it's important at the outset to note that these Supreme Court decisions, it's important to read them together. There's three decisions that I'll highlight dating back to 2005, but they really build off one another. And so reading them together is central to understanding both the new and emerging jurisprudence in this area as well as where the Court is likely to be heading in the next couple of years. So the first case that came down in 2005 was a case called Roper v. Simmons. In this case, the High Court struck down the use of the death penalty for juveniles, finding it to be a violation of the Eighth Amendment's prohibition on cruel and unusual punishment. Central to the Court's decision was the underlying and emerging juvenile brain and behavioral development science that showed that juvenile brains are fundamentally different than adult specifically the prefrontal cortex, which is the part of the brain that's responsible for emotional control, impulse control, risk and rewards. Essentially, the decision-making functions wasn't fully developed, and children relied on a more primitive part of their brain called the amygdala to make these sorts of decisions. This left them more open and susceptible to peer pressure, and it also showed that children's brains and their personalities weren't as well fixed as adults in similar situations. situations. This drastically limited their culpability in comparison to adults who commit similar offenses. And central to the court's holding also was this notion that there needed to be a categorical rule, that it was almost impossible to determine at the outset that a child who commits a very serious offense was irreparably depraved. In other words, that they were a psychopath or could never be fixed. And that was central to the court, that it was impossible to distinguish at sentencing and make those sentencing determinations at that time because youth have this heightened capacity for change, their personalities aren't fixed, and youth is such a transient time. And so the court imposed this categorical bar on using the death penalty for kids. Five years later, in a case called Grand v. Florida, the court struck down the use of life without parole for non-homicide offenses. It's important to note at the outset, as well, that that decision had retroactive effect. It impacted 128 individuals across the country, including 12 here in the state of Arkansas. Specifically, the court held that the Constitution prohibits the imposition of life without parole sentences on a juvenile offender who did not commit a homicide. A state need not guarantee the offender eventual release, but if it imposes a sentence of life, it must provide him or her with some realistic opportunity to obtain release before the end of that term. And what's worthy of note here is that the court goes on to say that it is for the state in the first instance to explore the means and mechanisms for implementation. And so as I understand it, and we'll hear a little bit later on from some of the other witnesses, that in the absence of a legislative fix, attorneys have come up with using the process of habeas to actually try and address these issues and get these kids back in front of judges. But really, this issue is a moral one. It's a question of sentencing that really should be decided directly by the legislature, and that's one of the reasons for House Bill 1197 was specifically to address the Graham v. Florida issue and the fact that there are sentences on the books currently in Arkansas that if a child was to get a life sentence would be in violation of the Graham v. Miller decision. So in Arkansas, and how this implicates Arkansas law, So in Arkansas, a 16-year-old, any kid over the age of 16, can be tried as an adult and, therefore, given an adult sentence. 14 and 15-year-olds are also eligible for adult sentences if they've committed specified offenses, such as murder, aggravated robbery, rape, battery. There's a litany of types of crimes, including any crime where a firearm was used in the commission of a felony. So it's a pretty broad exception that would allow 14- and 15-year-olds to also be eligible for life without parole sentences for non-homicide offenses. The other important thing to note is that in addition to life without parole, which is a specifically authorized sentence for capital murder, life means life here in the state of Arkansas. So for class Y felonies, and there's a whole list of them, murder, aggravated assault, aggravated robbery, a whole list of offenses where kids could potentially get a life sentence. If that was imposed upon them, again, the sentence would violate the idea of grant because there's not really a legislative fix in place to grant them a parole opportunity. The other thing is that there's these de facto life sentences that haven't been addressed in the law either. And de facto life sentences are, in essence, a case where you have a kid who commits one single offense, but maybe there's multiple victims. And then the charges get stacked against them, and they end up serving what would be termed a de facto life sentence because they'll never become eligible for a release before the expiration of that term. A great example of this is we had this case in Virginia where a young man went into a house party with two adult co-defendants. They robbed the house party. Nobody was hurt. Nobody was injured, but they were armed. The young men were charged with 50 counts of kidnapping because there were so many victims, 50 counts of armed robbery. The two adult co-defendants pled out. They got 10 and 12 years, respectively. This kid went to trial, who was 15 years old at the time, and got six life sentences because the charges were stacked. And so this is the other issue that House Bill 1197 is trying to address. And so in section 11 of the bill, on page 6, it creates pro-eligibility for youth convicted of non-homicide offenses after no later than their 20th year of incarceration, including instances in which multiple sentences are to be served consecutively or concurrently. So again, it's addressing the issue of Graham v. Florida that requires a fix to be in place so that a kid can't get a life sentence that is, in effect, a life without parole sentence. The issue of de facto life sentences are being litigated across the country right now. The vast majority of courts that have taken the issue up also find that when you have a de facto life sentence, like the example I just mentioned, That is also a violation of Graham. And so this would address all of those issues together. So that's the Graham issue. The other issue in this third case that comes down in this trilogy of cases is called Miller v. Alabama. What's interesting about Miller is that there was a companion case called Jackson v. Hobbs, which many of you may also be familiar with. Jackson v. Hobbs originated here in the state of Arkansas. It involved a young man named Kintrell Jackson, who was 14 years old when he conspired with two other kids to go and rob a video arcade. Mr. Jackson goes with these two young men. On their way to the store, Mr. Jackson learns that one of them has a gun. During the entire altercation, Mr. Jackson stays on the outside of the store, so he doesn't go in. He has no intention of committing a homicide. But one of the kids on the inside does pull out the gun and shoots the clerk, and the clerk unfortunately dies. Mr. Jackson, even though he was 14 years old, even though he did not have an intent to commit a homicide, was still charged under Arkansas' felony murder rule, which essentially states that if you are in the commission of a felony, even as a child, even if you don't have an intent for anybody to be killed, you are just as culpable as anybody else who commits that homicide. So Mr. Jackson was ultimately sentenced to life without parole. And this was the case that was before the US Supreme Court in the Miller v. Alabama case. And again, building off of what the court had said in both Roper and Graham, the court highlights the importance that age is more than just a chronological fact. It's a point in time where kids are still developing. Their brains aren't fully developed. They're more susceptible to peer pressure. They're more likely to make really bad decisions. And the court goes on to invalidate not only Arkansas's laws on mandatory life without parole, but 28 other states, finding that it's imperative that a sentencer consider the mitigating factors of youth before imposing the state's harshest possible punishment. The state goes on to say that by making youth irrelevant to the imposition of the harshest prison sentence, such a scheme poses too great a risk of disproportionate punishment. Because that holding is sufficient to decide these cases, we do not consider Jackson and Miller's alternative argument that the Eighth Amendment requires a categorical bar on life without parole for juveniles. And this is the part that I think is really important. But given all we have said in Roper, Graham, and this decision about children's diminished culpability and heightened capacity for change, we think appropriate occasions for sentencing juveniles to this harshest possible penalty will be uncommon. That is especially so because of the great difficulty we noted in Roper and Graham of of distinguishing at this early age between a juvenile offender whose crime reflects unfortunate yet transient immaturity and a rare juvenile offender whose crime reflects irreparable corruption. And so the reason I highlight that language and I talk about sort of the uncommon and rare dynamic is because I think what you hear later from the Prosecuting Attorneys Association is that this issue of Miller and life without parole for juvenile homicide offenders was fixed in last year's legislative session. However, when you read these three opinions together and you look at the language of the court that says that these sentences should be uncommon and rare, one must ask themselves, can a sentence of life without parole be uncommon or rare if it's imposed upon a juvenile who does not kill or intend to kill, like Mr. Jackson? And so one of the elements of House Bill 1197 seeks to eliminate life without parole as a sentencing option for those kids who have not killed or intended to kill and make sure that they're eligible for parole after they've served a lengthy sentence of 20 years. Again, sort of reflecting their diminished culpability, the fact that they did not intend for anybody to actually be killed during the course of a particular type of felony. And of course, in the wake of these decisions, as Representative Vletting mentioned, several All states have moved away from the practice the American Bar Association just last week called for the end of life without parole sentences for juveniles. And so you have the legal community by and large standing up more and more to say that we should end this practice. Certainly the neighboring Texas did this, as Representative Laying mentioned. And so this is, you know, an important dynamic, not just because of what other states have done, but because of the juvenile brain of behavioral development science, where we know about kids and their unique capacity for change. And the fact that we have so much bipartisan support for this measure. House Bill 1197 does go a step further than Miller v. Alabama requires in that it eliminates life without parole as a sentencing option wholesale. Again, building off of and sort of looking into the crystal ball and looking into the future of what the court might do on this issue. And certainly when we look at Roper, when we look at Graham, we look at Miller and what the court was saying about how difficult it is to make a determination at the outset that a child is irreparably corrupt and that they are beyond redemption, it would stand to reason that the court is going to continue to move in this direction and certainly felony murder is probably next up on the chopping block for the court and looking further into the future, probably life without parole wholesale. Again, the court mentioned in Miller that it didn't get to the exact question of whether or not there was a categorical bar on life without parole sentences for juveniles because it decided on the more narrow ground, which is in the purview of what the court typically tends to do in any case, is to try and decide the case on the most narrow grounds possible. I'd be remiss if I didn't also mention the retroactivity issue, and the bill has retroactive effect and it would grant parole eligibility to those folks that are currently serving. It's important to note that the Graham decision was retroactive and so that there should be retroactive effect in for the cases of non homicides the court has not yet the high court has not yet weighed in on the retroactivity issue and there have been a couple of cases one was just dismissed because it settled out of Louisiana however of the nine states of the 13 Supreme State Supreme courts that have took taken up this issue nine of them including neighboring Texas and Mississippi and South Carolina have found that the Miller decision is retroactive in part of those decisions part of the rationale of those courts was looking at what the court did with Contrell Jackson's case. Contrell Jackson was on collateral review here in the state of Arkansas, which means that he had exhausted all of his direct appeal options. So essentially this was his last chance. And because the court granted relief to Mr. Jackson, the argument goes that it also intended for the decision to have retroactive effect because it was a substantive rule. And again, the court, the high court hasn't had a chance to weigh in on that direct question, but the majority of state Supreme courts who have addressed that issue have weighed in on it. And so the House Bill 1197 tries to address all of these issues to eliminate the specter of potential and future litigation that will inevitably come with the issue of juvenile life without parole. And it's important, too, from a moral perspective that, again, as I mentioned before, that it's important to ask the questions of if these were our kids, you know, what would we want done with them? child is born bad, and therefore they shouldn't be discarded for life. And the last thing I just want to mention before closing, and I'm happy to take questions, is that there's a couple of individuals here in the state of Arkansas where the parole board has actually recommended a commutation of their sentences to them, and I want to just highlight a couple of them that are still serving prison sentences here in Arkansas for crimes committed as youth who have made extraordinary efforts to turn their lives around. The first one that was recommended for commutation by the parole board was Laura Berry, who was convicted of first-degree murder at the age of 17. Laura has volunteered with children visiting with their parents in prison, spoken to teens to help them avoid the mistakes she made, helped other inmates learn to read and taught classes in HIV and AIDS awareness. She said that she would like a chance to live outside of prison, has never done as an adult because she was incarcerated since she was 17. She says that I know that I can and will be a productive citizen who has a desire to help others. And I haven't reached out personally to these folks. All this information is available online regarding what the parole board has recommended. But I also think it's important and I'd like to read just a portion of a letter that I found on the Facebook page of Dustin Vickers, who also was convicted of a first-degree murder at the age of 17. In 1991, I was a carefree high school student. I was quarterback of the football team, ran track, and helped my father with her family farm outside of Stugard, Arkansas. I also helped my mother around the house and with my two younger sisters. The most serious thing I had ever done wrong was stay out beyond curfew on the weekends. In 1992, at the age of 17, I was arrested for the first time in my life. I was tried and convicted and sentenced to life in prison for murder. I entered prison angry, confused, and unwilling to accept responsibility for what I had done. I was less than a model inmate during those first years. With help from my mother, grandmother, and the rest of my family, I began to grow and mature. I know that it was not the law that put me there. It was my own actions that put me in prison. It took a long time to accept responsibility for the pain and suffering that I had caused in other family, but when I faced this reality, it was no longer about me. I begin every day praying for forgiveness, for the pain I have caused another man's family. Every day I promise myself that I will live my life in a way that shows that I am sincere about what I say in this letter. I have completed several correspondence courses from the U of A in English, Math, and Chemistry. I read continuously and have studied computer science, architecture, accounting, and business. To the prison I have learned drafting, welding fabrication, electrical wiring, and livestock management. I have worked in maintenance and construction at several facilities with the ADC system. It has become my goal to learn the skills needed to be a productive member of whatever society I am a part of. There have been many times that I have thought I would not survive here, but with resolve and determination, I did make it through those days and nights. I have learned many skills and life lessons. The most important is that most young inmates almost never mature mentally or emotionally. These tools have helped me learn my role in society, and I use them daily as I mentor the newer and younger inmates. I know that I have changed. When I came here, I was a child and now I'm a man. I have a man's understanding of what is right and what is wrong. I know in my heart that I can look anyone in the eye and tell them that I was wrong and that I'm sorry. And when they look back into my eyes, they will know it is the truth. And I just highlight that because I have never been in touch with Mr. Vickers. I found this post on his Facebook page several years back before the Miller v. Alabama decision actually came down, before he actually even had any sort of hope that he might ever be released one day from prison. And I think it highlights the important dynamic that we're talking about here is that the children have this unique capacity to change and that given that opportunity, most of them can and do change. And so this bill is so important in that respect in that there are so many young people who have been discarded for life, over 113 here in the state of Arkansas, who, if just given the opportunity, can show that they have matured and changed. And again, this bill doesn't open the floodgates. There's still a lengthy term of years that anybody would have to serve even before they became eligible for parole. For a capital murder, you have to serve a minimum of 28 years before you're even eligible to go before the parole board. And again, it doesn't guarantee release. It just gives that opportunity there for the parole board to consider it. And given the nature of youth and what we know about children, we believe that this bill is important to find the moral center of Arkansas and really the moral center of the United States and how we're going to treat our children. And with that, ladies and gentlemen, I'll be happy to take
▶ Play
any questions. Thank you. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I appreciate what y'all are working on. In fact, I think smart sentencing may be the answer long-term in Arkansas. We incarcerate too many people. I mean, you look at it and you see that we're the highest incarceration rate in the country or one of the highest and so we probably need to find a way to get people out who need to get out one thing I do have a little bit of concern about is that this sets a number and I don't want to say arbitrary because 18 is the age of majority and that's the number that the state has said is the age of majority however you had mentioned that there's been some scientific study that shows how the brain develops and all that what I would say though is they don't it doesn't it's not a question of okay it doesn't they're not developed up till when they're 18 and then at 18 they're developed i mean you would agree that some people develop quicker and that their brain may be at 17 they're a lot further developed than somebody who's 23 the brain is developed and so the little bit of my concern here and i'm not even saying that i'm i'm going to vote against this bill but it is a concern is that the the trier of fact the the judge, the jury, who's sitting here looking at and communicating with them, we've removed from them the ability to decide whether this person really is adult in their development or not. And if you don't mind just addressing that.
▶ Play
Yeah, absolutely. So most of the juvenile brain and behavioral development science that's available today, I suggest that the adult mind doesn't stop developing until around age 24, 25. Again, looking back to the language of the Supreme Court cases, I think one of the things that was most concerning for the court is that even if you have the case of the 17-and-a-half-year-old, their brain still is developing according to the science, and it's not going to stop developing until they're in their mid-20s. And so to make a judgment call at that point to say that they're irreparably depraved and can never be rehabilitated and that this is just sort of who they are was counter to what what the science was saying, which is why, in Roper, you have the catecholical bar on the death penalty and life without parole for non-homicides in Graham. And so I think that's kind of, I think, at least where the science is at in brain development. Certainly, people do mature at different paces and different stages. And it doesn't mean that kids are incapable of making rational or responsible decisions. Certainly, there's a lot of kids out there that make good decisions. But I think when we look at this population, And that's the other thing to highlight, is that this population of kids tends to, as you might expect, tends to come from more impoverished communities. They tend to be kids who have had a lot of tragedy in their life. They've been abused. They've been neglected. And so this throws the world into turmoil in some ways and stunts their development in this way. Certainly, that's not all of the kids, but that's one of the dynamics. And I think when we're looking at juveniles, even though they develop at different paces, Generally speaking, what we know from the science is that their brains aren't going to be fully developed until they're
▶ Play
around 24 or 25. Follow-up question. If that's the case, then why isn't the age 24 or 25? I mean, if the science, if the reasoning for the science behind it is that they're not going to be fully developed until that age, I mean, obviously what I would assume is that you say that they get further developed, further they go along. Right. But I think that we're kind of removing ourselves from that courtroom where the judge has a chance to actually witness and see how the defendant interacts and hear the facts of the case and all those things and decide that, you know, somebody, I mean, and I hate to say arbitrary because I know it's not anyone's fault because that's kind of where we've said it, but when it comes to development, it is an arbitrary number of 18. Right, and
▶ Play
you're absolutely right, Representative Ballinger, in terms of what you're saying. I mean, the further along in the stages of development you go, the more able to make decisions. Certainly a 21-year-old is allowed to drink or do other adult-related activities that an 18-year-old isn't, and that's because we recognize that they're further along in their development. So certainly there is that developmental gap there that happens from age to age all the way up until people around the age of 25. But generally speaking, and I think this is why society has drawn the line at 18, is because we recognize that, by and large, that's where the overwhelming majority, 95 to 100% of 99% of kids are at in terms of their development is 18 years of age. And that's why I think with contracts, with decisions to marry, with decisions to join the military, decisions to buy and smoke tobacco products, engage in other adult-related activities, to work in certain types of industries, we've drawn that line at 18 because that's where the vast majority of kids are in terms of their development. Representative
▶ Play
Tosh, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Capital murder, you alluded to 28 years they'd be eligible for parole. Is that correct? Yes, sir, in the way that we drafted the bill, yes. Is that a 28 flat years, or is that also they going to be receiving good time or any other credits towards their sentence, or is it 28 flat? We tried to
▶ Play
draft a 28 flat, and I'll be honest, there's a little bit. I was going back through, and I was reading the statutes pertaining to good time, and it's not entirely clear how it might play out because there's not a lot of guidance from the statutes themselves. I had a couple of other litigators on our team take a look at that. The intention was to be 28 flat years. I think the language specifically that we were looking at in the bill specifically said that they have to serve a minimum of 28 years before they're eligible for parole. So this is in Section 11 of the bill. And A, subsection 2, a person who committed a homicide offense is eligible for release on parole no later than after his or her 28th year of incarceration. So the idea is that they would have served their 28th year of incarceration, and then they would be eligible for parole.
▶ Play
So are you telling me that it is a flat 28, or is
▶ Play
good time factored into it? Yeah, and I'm not entirely sure. Just the way the statutes are written here in Arkansas, there's the 70% rule for all these class Y felonies. And so at a minimum, they'd have to serve 70% of their sentence even before they were eligible for that. I read it to say 28 years. I think that the way that the other statutes are written, they're ambiguous, is what I'm saying, is that they could be interpreted in a number of different ways. And so that's why I'm sort of equivocating the answer that I'm giving to you. The way that we wrote the bill was to be, after 28 years, to be in line with the previous bill that was passed in 2013.
▶ Play
Representative Gray, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Thank you. Can you tell me approximately, I know this bill is retroactive. can you tell me how many people are incarcerated right now that this would possibly put on parole,
▶ Play
Speaker 6 33:15
early parole right now? Currently it's just 113. Despite being 32nd in population, only five states currently hold more individuals sentenced to juvenile life parole than Arkansas. Michigan, Florida, Pennsylvania, California, and Louisiana. But to be clear, it's not a guarantee that any of those people would actually get out. It's still entirely possible that their parole could be denied. It's still possible with the passage of this bill that someone would still serve
▶ Play
life without parole. I'll follow up. Could you tell me how many of those are currently serving for capital
▶ Play
murder? Do you know? Yeah, it's around, I want to say, 54 for capital murder. Then there's a substantial number that are first-degree murder. And then there's 12 that are for non-homicide offenses. The other thing is that because the bill would create eligibility after 20 years for non-homicides. And again, this data wasn't readily available from the Department of Corrections, but there's a number of individuals who would receive these de facto life sentences, not life in name, but like a 60, 70, 80 year sentence that could also possibly be eligible for parole earlier for the non-homicide crimes. Representative
▶ Play
Copeland, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Appreciate you being here today and giving us a lot of good information. I, one thing, the disparity between the 28 years minimum for murder and then 20 for other crimes, and I've talked to you about this personally, I feel like they're, you know, eight years is not much time for a life when you look at the difference. So maybe are you guys open to lengthening that murder, the longer sentence, and then maybe there being a little bit more disparity between the
▶ Play
Speaker 6 35:09
two? I suppose it is something we would be willing to consider. The way I look at it is I'm a few weeks shy of my 37th birthday. Had I been sentenced to a minimum of 28 years, I would still be eight years shy of even being eligible for parole. When you look at those years between 17 and 45, I'm not about to say those are the best years of anyone's life, but those are certainly some of the most important and most productive. That's one of the reasons it's at 28. It's just that we
▶ Play
feel like that is a substantial penalty. Follow-up. Representative Leavitt, I can tell you, It does go uphill from where you are, so. But one major, and I'm like Representative Ballinger and others have spoken here, you know, the plight is one that you definitely have compassion for. And, again, we all think about the victims, and I think we don't want that to be lost. and obviously a lot of these crimes are particularly heinous or they wouldn't probably be serving these lengthy sentences and again that's an assumption but my question is how can we ensure okay the courts have said a lot of other states even conservative states as Representative Letting has mentioned has had a turnabout or a change of heart on these issues how can we ensure someone like a Troy Kell in Utah, who's well-known, and other juvenile criminals that have been created, particularly heinous crimes, how can we, if they were released, do you have a mechanism, do you have an idea how society can be protected and see if they are making that development, or are we letting someone out that, you know, is going to do that? Because that's the worst nightmare, is we're showing compassion, then the same thing happens to another family. And so I know we can't guarantee that, but what are your thoughts there? Absolutely.
▶ Play
So there's two dynamics that we try to address in the bill. The one is that when you look at the language in subsection 11, two things are noticeable. One, in subsection A1, the last little section, it says including instances in which multiple sentences are to be served consecutively or concurrently. That language was intentionally left out of the homicide section. So if you have, for instance, a case where you have multiple homicides, for example, a really terrible case, the judge would still have the ability in that instance to impose what we term de facto life sentences. And so that would, in essence, be a life sentence so that individual couldn't get out. The other thing with, like, say, a singular type of offense, the parole board is actually in subsection B1 there. It's slated to look at certain dynamics, including the extent of the inmates' role in the offense and whether or not an adult co-defendant was involved. And so we do instruct that the parole board is meant to look at all of these factors, including the serious nature of the offense. And so, you know, if you have somebody who committed a very terrible crime who's clearly showed that they have not been rehabilitated and have not changed over 28 years, 28 years is a long record, too, you're going to be able to have to look at this individual to see if, you know, they have truly changed or if they haven't. And so that's the other thing there is that there is the protection because, you know, nobody wants, you know, I worked on human trafficking issues before this. Some members of the committee know this personally about myself. I was a victim of child sexual abuse and human trafficking when I lived in my home state of Nevada. And so, you know, I'm very sympathetic to victims. I've worked closely with them, and nobody wants anybody to be harmed by anybody. And so that's something that, you know, I personally take great pride in is to make sure that we work closely with victims and victim family members and to make sure that there are these protections in place because nobody wants anybody that potentially could cause harm out on the streets. And so we've tried to build those protections into that by making sure that the parole board does look specifically at the seriousness
▶ Play
of the offense. Representative House, you're recognized for a question. Representative Tosh, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You know, to me, there's a reason that the prosecutor has chosen to try someone as an adult. And obviously, they've reviewed the case file, and they understand what was involved, and there's a reason they made that decision. With that in mind, as I look at your bill, and I direct your attention to page 2, paragraph 5, and i read it it says youthfulness both lessons a juvenile's moral culpability and enhances the prospect that as a youth matures into an adult and neurological development occurs these individuals can become contributing members of society my question to you is this the victims of these horrific and brutal crimes will they ever have the opportunity to become a contributing member of society. Yeah, and Representative
▶ Play
Tosh, to your question, I mean, for some of those, certainly not, right, for the homicide cases. For the non-homicides, you know, we would hope, and we would hope that there are protections in place to make sure that they have the services they need to begin to rebuild their lives from what has happened. It's also why it's so important that we engage in what we call restorative justice practices, where we can help victims and family members of victims heal through that process. And I think Linda White's letter is an exceptional example of that, who had she been here today, she would have told you all the story of Gary, who was one of the juveniles who killed her daughter. She engaged in restorative justice practice in the early 90s, went and met with Gary, advocated for his release. He was released in 2010 on parole, and she remains in close contact with him. And so, you know, whenever these types of offenses happen, they're a tragedy. There's no doubt about it. I mean, a murder, somebody's gone. Their life is gone. They're not coming back. And then the question that we are left with as a society is what is our response to that when it's a juvenile who's committed that crime? Is it the response to, you know, also take that life away forever and say that there's no hope? Or do we say that there can be this possibility of hope and can we support the victims and can we heal as a community? And that's part of what this bill is about, is promoting healing, hoping that an individual who committed a terrible offense can repent, can become rehabilitated. And I think what you'll hear later on from a young man who was a formerly incarcerated youth is that you'll hear that oftentimes for the folks who have been rehabilitated, they dedicate their lives to their victims in their cases. And they advocate to make sure that other youth don't commit serious offenses and that there is this community healing. And so your question is a very difficult one, and certainly one that we're very sympathetic to. And it's really about trying to create a healing process and being supportive of the victims in the best way that we can. And certainly our organization tries to do that and to make sure they're involved in the process as well.
▶ Play
And so that's how I'd respond. Representative
▶ Play
Petty, you're recognized for a question. I'm just listening to you, and I appreciate everything that you're saying about the healing for the victims and trying to come together. But I know personally I've been a victim for 15 years. And if the guy that had murdered my daughter got out and everybody said it's all going to be okay, and I'm having real trouble with this. I mean, can you respond to exactly how you can help victims understand? Because that's a tough one. I mean, you can bring people in and talk about it, but how does that happen? Yeah, and I have to
▶ Play
say, you know, I am not, and, you know, It's hard for me to respond, because I've never had to go through that, of losing a child. And so we try and do it in the most compassionate way possible. First and foremost, we connect them with other victim family member groups. There's a lot of, as I'm sure you're aware of, family members that support each other. And so we try and just provide that supportive network for them. And then if they want to be engaged with the juveniles or work with us, I mean, then we have that process open for them. But for us, it's really about making sure that we at least recognize that pain and suffering and do what we can to be as supportive as possible. But it's definitely a difficult question that we continually grapple with. So, I mean,
▶ Play
you can't tell me exactly how. Yeah, so one of
▶ Play
the things that we do is we bring family members of victims together once a year at our annual conference in DC. So specifically for our organization, are you saying? We bring them together, and we have healing circles. We talk about law, some of the individuals that we have there. For example, and I'll just go through a couple of examples. Mary Johnson, her son was killed by a young man named O'Shea Israel, and it was her only son. And Mary, she's from Minnesota. She engaged in the process of restorative justice. She met with O'Shea when he was in prison, and they began a dialogue that way. And so we try and facilitate if the family members want a dialogue with the youthful offender, their engagement with them. If not, just trying to make sure that we connect them with those supportive groups that are out there and serving as a resource to other sorts of resources that victims could be eligible for through crime victim compensation funds and those sorts of things. And so that's kind of the process that we go through. We try to bring everyone together. that we engage in community conversations and make sure that, you know, we're sensitive to those issues and just provide whatever support that they may want or need in those situations.
▶ Play
One last time. And I mean no disrespect, but I have been through a lot of these healing groups and healing circles, and they're very painful. And I know a lot of these crime victims, families, I've worked with them for a long time. Sometimes it's just very painful. And I do appreciate what you're doing here, but I'm just having a hard time with this one.
▶ Play
Representative Copeland, did you have another question?
▶ Play
Yes. Okay, you're recognized. us. You included four success stories, and I think that's awesome. But isn't this change with long sentences for juveniles a relatively new phenomenon? Or maybe correct me on that, how long, maybe the state that the longest tenure that has made these changes, that's one. So I'm thinking this is a newer phenomenon. Secondly, mentioning Texas and some of the more conservative states, what are the stats? See these four success stories, and I'm very thankful for that, for these four young men. But what are the stats for those that have been released that were juveniles? Do we have stats on how they've fared after coming out of prison after committing serious crimes. Is it 50% make the turn, or could you speak to that, please? Absolutely. So I'll just the first part of your question first, Representative Copeland.
▶ Play
So to answer your question, you kind of have to go back in time about 25, 30 years. The law drastically began to change in the early 1990s, where states began passing laws that made it easier to transfer kids into the adult system. This happened on the heels of what termed the super predator theory where criminologists were theorizing that there was a new class of super predator children that were coming of age that were more violent and remorseless than ever before. Of course that never came to pass but as a result of that it made it easier to try kids in the adult system. Before that though a lot oftentimes kids were being handled in the juvenile system or if they were transferred the sentences weren't necessarily as harsh. So a lot of kids that we'll hear from and you'll hear from Xavier a little bit later on But he was sentenced in the 1980s, and so the laws weren't quite as punitive at that point. So it allowed some of these individuals, young men, to come out sooner. The other thing is that not every state necessarily imposed these harsh sentences, and that in some states, judges had a little bit more leeway, especially if the kids were kept in the juvenile system. So Charleston White, one of the young men, highlighted on that. He ended up being kept in the juvenile system for the homicide that he committed. And so he was able to come out at the age of 21 instead of being kept in the adult facilities, unlike the rest of the folks there. Others, Sarah Kruzan, for example, she was a child sex trafficking victim. She killed her pimp at the age of 16, was sentenced to life without parole in the early 1990s. Her sentence was commuted by the governor. Others of those folks, like Ralph Brazil, who's also on that page, he was a product of the Granby Florida decision. He received three consecutive life sentences for intent to manufacture and distribute methamphetamine and got three life sentences. And so his case was overturned by the Supreme Court. When he was resentenced, he was sentenced to time served and then released. And so part of it, it's a multitude of things. Sometimes they're commutations. Sometimes they're decisions that come down. Sometimes they were just sentenced at a different time or in a state that didn't allow such harsh sentencing. And that's the other dynamic that we wanted to highlight through those stories is that these kids, had they been here in Arkansas wouldn't have ever gotten the chance to get out and become productive members and do what they're doing now, which is mentoring at-risk youth, giving back to their communities. And then to the second part of your question, I apologize. There's not a lot of national data specifically on juveniles who were released into the system. We're just now getting states to get caught up with actually tracking kids in the system. Unfortunately, a lot of times kids go in and there's some states we work in where they don't even know how many individuals went in as children, and so we're still having difficulties just tracking, but there's the anecdotal evidence that we do have of those cases of other individuals across the country who are active with us and those who aren't active with us who are doing great things in their community. Very quick follow-up, if I may. This is the last question. Okay. Here we go.
▶ Play
Just because this is such a weighty issue, is there a way that we can get information before making a decision of this magnitude to see when we release previous murders back into society? You know, if it's 75%, 80%, is there a way to get that, or is that available? Yeah, I mean, I can definitely double-check
▶ Play
and go back and look into it. You know, I mean, the best stat that we have is that there's a national study that shows that, you know, Most kids age out of criminal behavior in that kids who commit serious, violent, serious offenses, only about 10% to 15% continue to recidivate after that. And so the recidivism rates of the studies that have been done, which are by no means comprehensive and they vary from geographic region to region, but that's sort of the best information that we do have available.
▶ Play
All right. Seeing no further questions, Representative Letting, do you have anything further?
▶ Play
Speaker 6 51:36
No, Mr. Chair. I believe we have some people who
▶ Play
have signed up to speak. Okay, thank you. We're going to go to the public sign-up sheet here, and the first person is Larry Jegley. Mr. Jegley, if you'll take a seat at the end of the table. If you would, state your name, who you represent, and then you
▶ Play
Speaker 58 52:13
may make your statement. I'm Larry Jegley, J-E-G-L-E-Y, prosecuting attorney for Perry and Pulaski Counties, which constitutes the 6th Judicial District of Arkansas. I'm here to speak on behalf of myself, as well as president of the Arkansas Prosecuting Attorneys Association. First off, I want to thank the members of the committee, because until the questions came out, I didn't hear anything about victims. And I want to thank you all for having the right perspective on it. Too often victims are forgotten, and just because someone is young, I get what 1197 is about, but the victimization is the same regardless of the age of the perpetrator and I feel very strongly about that. I've been doing this since 1991 and I've dealt with countless, countless victims and their families. It never changes. On behalf of the association, I want to point out that there are 28 elected prosecuting attorneys in the state of Arkansas. They're elected by the same, the exact same individuals who elect 135 members of the Arkansas General Assembly, y'all included. Prosecutors are entrusted by their communities to make the hard but right decisions day in and day out. And some of those hard decisions involve charging youthful offenders as adults because of the nature and seriousness of their crimes. All 28, all 28 elected prosecutors have registered opposition to this bill, all of us. Let me just tell you a few things. In 2013, Act 1490 passed, and that revised punishment is authorized for persons under 18 years of age who commit capital murder. I'm just going to read this. It's a lot shorter than it was. Thank goodness for the ice storm over the weekend. It kept me cooped up in my man cave, and I distilled it down from about 20 pages. It's only two and a half. This act made capital murder committed by persons under age 18 punishable by life without parole or life with parole after serving a minimum of 28 years. The act ensured that Arkansas was in compliance with the US Supreme Court's ruling in Miller versus Alabama, which simply prohibits mandatory life without parole sentences on offenders under the age of 18. The case does not prohibit life sentences. Only scenarios where life without parole is the only sentencing option. We're in compliance. According to this bill, it's the legislative intent to eliminate life without parole as a sentencing option for juvenile defendants and to create more age-appropriate sentencing options. That goes further than what's required by Miller. And I don't purport, despite the fact I've been a lawyer for a long time, to have a crystal ball about what the Supreme Court may or may not do or what direction they're going in. So I would invite you to disregard speculation as to what the law might be as a selling point for $1,197. The legislation duplicates the affirmative defense to capital murder that exists for all persons now charged with capital murder under 5-10-101C. Currently, current law provides an affirmative defense to capital murder which requires a defendant to prove they didn't commit or aid in the homicidal act. If this bill passes, it would require an interrogatory to be submitted to a jury on the subject of whether a juvenile defendant committed the homicidal act. Under current law, if a defendant prevails in their affirmative defense, The jury would then consider the charge of murder in the first degree, which has a penalty range of 10 to 40 years or life. There's no need for an interrogatory. No need. Leave the capital murder statute and its affirmative defense alone, as that does not address the stated legislative intent of the bill. Section 4 of the bill eliminates capital felony murder for all defendants under the age of 18. Again, this is cookie cutter. The age of 18, I understand why the law has to have some cookie-cutter type lines in it, like the age of 18. But the law also has to allow for some discretion, as well as justice and mercy. And that's what your 28 prosecutors are all about. This bill proposes to reduce the amount of time to be served before being eligible for parole from 28 years to 20 years for juveniles who are convicted of capital murder but did not cause or did not have purpose to cause the death of a person. The bill requires a defendant to only serve 20 years, only 20 years, talk to victims about that, if the defendant did not have the purpose to cause the death of the victim. Under current case law regarding capital felony murder, it's not necessary for the state to show that the defendant took an active part in the killing so long as he assisted in the commission of the underlying crimes. A defendant must only have the requisite intent for the underlying felony. That's current law. So if a defendant could convince a jury, and it's their right to do it, and I've seen it done, have the intent to kill the victim as part of the crime, then under this, the defendant would only get 20 years. Only 20 years. It's not a lot. Here's an example from my real life and my career as a prosecutor. Let's say a juvenile broke into somebody's home with the intent to commit a rape. The victim resisted and fought, and the defendant killed the victim with the purpose of getting victim to submit to the sexual assault. Under this bill, the defendant would only be required to serve 20 years. That's it. The bill would also be in conflict with sentences available under 5-10-102. The proposal specifically addresses sentences under capital murder, 5-10-101. Under 510-102, the state could charge a juvenile defendant with first-degree felony murder, and the juvenile defendant could be subject to a sentence of 10 to 40 years or life. And that's a jury's decision, ladies and gentlemen. Not mine, not the judges. That's a jury's choice, 10 to 40 or life. Obviously, this would have the unintended consequence, however, of making a penalty higher for murdering the first degree than for capital murder. Section 6 of the bill amending parole eligibility in capital murder cases, it treats all capital murder defendants the same, regardless of their criminal history and the nature of the crime they committed. Cookie cutter? Uh-uh. That's not what it's about. You don't treat all capital murder defendants the same. We don't do it. When they're adults, why should we do it as juveniles? Give you an example. Real world. Three 17-year-olds rob a restaurant. Happened right here. Defendant A shoots and kills the clerk with all intents and purposes of doing so Defendant B, who has an extensive criminal history shoots two people during the robbery of the restaurant but he didn't kill them The 17-year-old driver Defendant C, who has no criminal history shoots no one but he's an accomplice to the murder committed by Defendant A. B and C are treated the same. Is that right? Is that just? No. I tell you about that because if this bill were in effect in that scenario, which happened, an accomplice to capital murder could potentially serve less time than one convicted of murder in the first degree. Just a couple other things. Retroactivity. I've had a little experience with retroactivity. I had a pretty famous fight with former Governor Huckabee about some retroactive pardons, for lack of a better word. I had some murderers, had some rapists let out, and we had a big fracas and a big fuss about it. Retroactivity not only dishonors the victims, dishonors their families, but it also disrespects the fundamental element of our criminal justice system, and that is 12 members of the community picked at random who serve as juries. And in Arkansas, we're one of only a few states where the jury ascertains punishment. A defendant is given all free reign to put on all evidence that he thinks is relevant to his mental state, his condition in life, his circumstances, and a jury, 12 wise strangers to each other, determine punishment in Arkansas. And I tell you about that because with Governor Huckabee, when he pardoned certain individuals who had been convicted by juries in this community and others, I got calls from folks saying, wait a minute, why? We worked hard. We cried. I lost sleep over that sentence. And now he's out? don't disrespect the juries but more than that don't disrespect the victims and their loved ones don't do it because let me tell you something 113 out of say 16,000 inmates give or take I don't know what the math is on that but that's less than 1 100th of a percent I would think none of y'all would want to be sitting at the table when I or one of my 27 colleagues had to sit down with that family and they said, wait a minute you told us that they were going to be away for the rest of their life and now you're telling us they're going to get out it's not fun had to do it with people whose families were taken by folks who later got pardoned. Now, I don't doubt the motivations behind this. I do understand that people are different and kids are different from grown-ups, but as I think it was Representative Ballinger rightly pointed out, I got a son, and I think maybe at age 26, he's finally starting to grow up. His sister grew up a lot faster. I've seen other young men and women who have shown wisdom and maturity beyond their years before they got out of high school. Everybody's different. And I think to draw a line when it comes to heinous acts, we're not locking them up because of how old they are. We're locking them up because of what they did. And I'll tell you this, too, and I don't think any of my colleagues would disagree with me. We take our jobs very seriously as the conscience of the community, and I guarantee you in the juvenile justice system, even including some pretty horrendous crimes, there's lots of mercy to go along with the justice. And that's what we're trusted to do, and that's what I think that this bill would upset because it would impose more strictures than we need in order to address the problem of 113 out of over 16,000 individuals in our criminal justice confines. we'd ask for a no vote on this bill be glad to
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:06:29
answer questions Representative Armstrong you're recognized for
▶ Play
Speaker 76 1:06:32
a question thank you Mr. Chairman I've got three if that's okay thank you so much Mr. Jagley thank you for your comments as you know Representative Petty spoke about the victims I've had to serve at the helm I've been on the victim side of young, senseless teenage murders in my community and also serve on the side of trying to help some of these young men that seem to have no outlet and that have been sentenced to life. And all too often we get down here and we hear the for and against arguments. And I know that in your position you yield a great deal of power with those 27 other prosecutors. and I very seldom hear prosecutors or organizations like the one Representative Letting and Senator Irving have brought to our great state to try and find a solution, get to the table. And if you've been at the helm of this since 1991, can you give me at least three identified or maybe more opportunities where opposing sides have gotten to the table to find a solution to the small population of young people that may not have all their schools aligned right when they're that young and may do some stupid stuff like walk into a Burger King and shoot a clerk and come to school the next day and get arrested in our home economic class because they're just not thinking. And actually their families have failed them too because they have got to go that far. I'm just looking for, and it is in all intentions my hope while on this committee, that we get to a day that we're talking about solutions from the prosecuting side and organizations such as the one that's come from Washington that can help curb this overcrowding of our prisons, can help curb the fact that you have young people committing capital murder because they're lost or their communities have given up on them or their families have given up on them. I don't ever want to be the victim again, and I, quite frankly, don't like receiving the letters from some of my old buddies that are now doing life in prison for something that they made a stupid mistake when they were 14. But I'm in desperate need of trying to understand from your position and your organization, what are some opportunities for compromising solutions if this isn't one? And then number two question. You said that the bill only allows for a maximum of 20 years, and I've had the gentleman and Representative Letting and Senator Irvin explained this to me at least three different times and I don't find in the legislation anywhere that this only gives those that commit our most heinous acts of crime a maximum of 20 years and then they're off the hook par se. Number one question again is solutions to an all too often growing problem that no one wants to be the victim or on the other opposing side of a family member that's now losing a son to our justice system forever. What are you guys doing from that perspective from a prosecutor's association to work with attorneys, families, communities, organizations such as this to reduce the sentencing, try to curb these young people's lives, number one, and then number two, address the
▶ Play
Speaker 58 1:09:54
20-year maximum issue? The 20-year maximum, I used examples of that because it's theoretically possible and I think will practically come to pass that some people who are guilty of pretty heinous conduct only do 20 years under this bill. Now, Sam, I'll grant you, and I may have been remiss, would have to serve
▶ Play
Speaker 76 1:10:17
28. Mr. Chairman, could you ask Representative Redding or the other gentleman that testified on the bill? I just want to make certain it's absolutely clear to our committee where that is aligned or not so that we're not in the haze
▶ Play
Speaker 58 1:10:35
about that particular proportion? It's 20 years under some circumstances and 28 under others, under 1197's provisions. Okay, thank you. And there are some conflicts, like I told you about the restaurant robbery with three defendants. One of them was the wheel man with no criminal history. The other two, one kills, the other wounds. and yet the wheel man with no criminal history is held as culpable as the one that killed. So I just use that as an example of the slippery slope. What are we doing? We're all talking about endgame right here. The opportunities, and I appreciate you mentioning families. People ask me, what can we do? What can we do? I can't go inside the four walls of people's homes and make them better parents. Good gosh, it's hard enough being a parent. Anybody will tell you who is. But, yeah, there's a real failure in our families and our parenting. Mr. Jailes, so
▶ Play
Speaker 76 1:11:35
wouldn't you agree if there is a real problem with parenting and families then that when you've got these young people that come before your courts as opposed to prosecuting them to the maximum extent of a crime, whether it be a low-level offense like they're drug selling or I know you've seen them all. In the event that you've gotten these children, because they are children and they do do stupid things, I was once one of them, is there anything besides prosecuting them to the fullest extent that you guys are looking at to make probable solutions so that they can become productive or even have the potential to change their lives and become productive
▶ Play
Speaker 58 1:12:14
citizens? Well, as everyone knows, Arkansas was smart enough back in the 80s to have separate divisions of juvenile courts set up. We have three in Pulaski County, and I'll be honest with you, you can ask any of the folks in my office who have come up in my system, so to speak, that the emphasis is on rehabilitation. And that's what juvenile courts are all about, providing services, FINS petitions. Instead of charging as a juvenile, let's get a family in need of services petition. Working on things like that. I can speak for the organization of prosecutors that I'm representing here today and say that anytime somebody comes to us with a proactive front-end solution, the deed's done by the time we hear about it. We'll get involved in it. I'll speak personally to something that I'm a strong believer in. A lot of people don't know about it, and I've been involved in it since, gosh, back into the mid to early 1980s, and that's the Joseph Pfeiffer Kiwanis Camp here in Pulaski County. Anybody who hadn't heard of it, give me a call sometime after session's out. I'll take you out there while they're in session, and I'll show you something that can't be measured, and that is the work that they do with children who are at risk in our school systems here in Pulaski County. very, very few of them ever show up in the system at all. And I can tell you from my friendship with Sanford Tollett, the executive director of that wonderful program, that they struggle all the time. And they get asked by some of their benefactors, well, tell us how effective you are. Well, how do you measure a child who goes through that program who doesn't end up in the system? It's pretty tough. It's pretty tough. So I appreciate what you're saying, but what we're talking about in 1197 is it's not the kid involved with dope. It's not the kid who is stupid and steals a car or goes in the back door of a house. It's something far worse than that. And I'll be honest with you, it's not the age, it's the conduct. It's the conduct. And it's the results to the victims and their families that I think deserves, as well as almost demands, that we show some outrage at the results of their
▶ Play
Speaker 75 1:14:59
terrible choices, youthful or not. That's, I think, your opinion on conduct versus
▶ Play
Speaker 76 1:15:04
age. I wish you could just spend some time where I come from so that you could understand that it is not all conduct. It is age. It is a lapse of certain things. But my question I don't think we've addressed is, are there funds, are there programs, are there efforts being led by our Arkansas prosecutors in any way to try and curb what we know is a problem that will forever persist in our society. You've just got some people that are that heinous and will do crazy things, but I'm curious to know what our prosecutors are doing to try and meet us
▶ Play
Speaker 58 1:15:48
somewhere in the middle of the road. Again, whatever tools you put before us, the General Assembly sets up our system and our process and funds it. And I'll be honest with you, I think that our juvenile court system has come a long way in going there. Again, we don't get a hold of something on the front end. We don't get them in the third and fourth and fifth grades when they're really pliable, when they can really develop productive habits and stuff. We get them after a terrible thing has happened. We get them after something has gone down. But still and all, rather than charge them as adults, we charge them as juveniles as much as we can. But you cross the line with violence, you're talking something different.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:16:41
Representative Tosh, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. If you were to help the committee, would you as a prosecutor, when you receive a case file, when you review that file would you enlighten us as to what factors you use to help you determine whether you charge the individual as an adult or
▶ Play
Speaker 58 1:17:03
a juvenile well sure i mean i can categorically tell you that a murder is a murder and um there's no getting around it i don't care what impulse there was, what immaturity of the frontal lobes of the brain was going on, a deadly weapon against another human being that results in the death of that other human being, that's a place that you're going to see pretty much the full weight of the criminal justice system, at least in Pulaski and Perry counties. But backing on down again to talk about the nonviolent offenses, the offenses that may have involved even a threat of violence, and in some instances violence itself committed by individuals who are under the age of 18, just like with drug court, we will do everything we can to get you into drug court, to get you into veterans court, which we have in Pulaski and some other counties around, to get you into a sobriety court, which we have on both sides of the river in Sherwood and Pulaski County District Court. The analysis has always got to be, A, what's best for the community, B, can you do something that's less draconian than locking somebody up? And we only lock up 35% of the people we charge in circuit court in Pulaski County. 35 out of 100 actually get pen time. The policy is try to do something that is an alternative to incarceration if a person hadn't hurt another individual. Certainly the age of the perpetrator comes into play. Let me tell you this. We talk about 18, and again, I understand why we have to draw a line sometimes. But you get somebody who commits a crime, and they are two weeks away from their 18th birthday. We can't keep jurisdiction except in specific enumerated circumstances after they reach age 18 two weeks out. How are we going to help them if we put them in juvenile court? Now, if we can get extended juvenile jurisdiction under a law that the General Assembly wisely passed some time ago, that's a different thing. But you try to look at A, the crime, B, the victims, because the crime itself drives what your options are. B, the victims' wishes are paramount. C, the community, and D, the individual. And part of that equation is age, upbringing, family circumstances, education. All those things come into play when you're talking about what is the best thing that you can do for an individual. And the primary objective, contrary to a lot of popular opinion, is not necessarily to punish. It's to help.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:20:13
Representative Vines, you're recognized. I have a motion, Mr. Chairman. What's your motion? Limit debate, 10 minutes aside. I'll accept your motion. We have a motion to limit debate. Ten minutes aside, it's non-debatable. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Aye. Okay, ten minutes aside, and I would remind those who were speaking for the bill that that also includes Representative Letting's time to close for his bill, so you need to keep that in mind if you would like for Representative Letting to have an opportunity to close. Thank you. Going back to the questions, Representative House,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Prosecutor, thank you for coming. I pulled up Miller v. Alabama and Jackson v. Ray Hobbs, our former director's Department of Corrections. As I look through this case, experience and training, I try to remove the emotion from it Because while our hearts pour out for juveniles, they equally pour out for those who have been victimized by crime. I think of, read the decision, and I see that the court is more inclined towards a rehabilitative type prison sentence rather than the retribution or the revenge that every citizen has surrendered to the state to exercise. Now, laying aside all of the emotional arguments, as I read the Jackson case and the Miller case that involved the state of Arkansas, I am under the impression that we have been given a mandate to correct our law. Yet, I heard you say early on, our statute complies. Apparently, in the Jackson case, it does not. What is the answer, and that's the type of information I'm looking for. What do we need to do to get in compliance with this
▶ Play
Speaker 58 1:22:23
ruling? I think we are in compliance with it. The
▶ Play
Supreme Court's obviously said that's not so, so there we are.
▶ Play
Speaker 58 1:22:34
I don't think 1197's the solution on it. And again, I don't think that we're out of compliance with it, But I guess we disagree on that.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:22:44
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Petty, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Just a yes or no question. This bill basically ties the hands of
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:23:01
juries. Yes. Thank you. Okay, that's all the questions we have for Mr. Jegley. Thank you for your testimony. We're going to go back to the list. speaking for the bill Xavier McElrath Bay if you would take a seat at the end of the table state your name and if you represent any particular group
▶ Play
and then make your statement thank you okay sorry about that my name is Xavier McElrath Bay I'm a youth justice advocate with the campaign for fair sensing of youth I'm also a network coordinator, a national network coordinator called the Incarcerated Children's Advocacy Network. Currently we have 22 members as a part of this national network and these are advocates who go out and speak and they, for the most part, try to push legislators and other entities out there to be on board with age-appropriate and trauma-informed alternatives to extreme sentencing of America's youth. unique about this group, it's not just the nature of the advocacy work that they do, but also their backgrounds. If you look at the papers, the handout, if you look in front and back, these are just eight individuals. This national network has been in existence for the past, I think, eight, nine months. It's growing every day. We have a heavy social media presence. We have a lot of support. But it's also a project of the campaign. And As a project, the goal of this initiative is to amplify divorces of those who are directly impacted by extreme sentencing. Of the 22 members who are part of this national network, 20 were formally convicted as children for first-degree murder. Of the 22 members, nine were once sentenced to life without the possibility of parole, but have been either commuted, pardoned, or in a couple of instances were actually exonerated. This particular national network is important to me because I feel that it really reflects a much needed narrative. I feel like for the most part that children not only have been labeled as super predators and have been deemed as irreparable, but unfortunately I think that we've denied children the right to their own childhood. I have a three-year-old daughter, her name is Sophia. And there's nothing more that I've learned as a father is to be patient, loving, and understanding. I've also learned that as time goes by, she does start to pick up on certain things. And she wrote her name for the first time last week. I was excited. And I was mostly excited because I see every day she's becoming someone. She's becoming a person. But I still recognize that she's a child. And I also recognize that everyone in this room, we were once children. we were all children at some point and for me this is especially important because there was a time when I was told that I would never have a life I was told that I was given a 25 year sentence when I was 13 years old I was arrested charged and I was later convicted to serve a 25 year sentence for a first-degree murder I stood in front of a judge at the time unfortunately There was not much that they could say. It was positive about me. I was multiple times violating my probation and parole. I mean my probation. I had 19 arrests and seven convictions. My juvenile arrest record read everything from armed robbery, aggravated battery, aggravated assaults, weapon charges, multiple violent offenses. At that time, at the age of 13 years old, many would have assumed what was said about me, that I was incorrigible, that I was incapable of change. I remember my probation officer, when it came to time to make the decision, a discretionary decision, he decided to go against me, not to advocate for me. And there was no one there in the courtroom to speak on my behalf. But the unfortunate reality is that what was unspoken was what I experienced in my life growing up. I recently did a TED Talk. It's called No Child is Born Bad. And the reason why I titled it No Child's Born Bad is because I remember as a child growing up in an environment that was very unloving and not nurturing. I remember very early on, the first time I was placed in the back seat of a police car, my mother felt so hard to stop them from doing this. But my stepfather had physically abused me and my siblings. They put us in foster care. I was in foster care from the age of six until I was eight and a half years old. A child protective service that was intended to relieve us of that abuse unfortunately resulted in even further abuse by a very mean foster mother, Ms. Betterman. I will never forget she had locked me and my brother in our room often without toys and without entertainment, no television, no radio. I remember she had this one time chipping paint off the basement floor. I remember coming home after two and a half years of complaints when mother finally was able bring us home. And I remember meeting a man named Jose for the first time who we later referred to as our stepfather. He was very abusive. He had beat my mother every single weekend. He would come home and I would be able to witness his children and sad to say oftentimes when he didn't come into our room, we were simply happy not to have been harmed. Oftentimes he would come in, we'd get underneath the covers and we'd hide. But he would punch through the covers. And I say all that to say that, you know, many of the children that we meet in these courtrooms, it's not as if they woke up one day and said, I'm going to kill someone. That doesn't happen. Unfortunately, many of these kids grew up in very poor and disinvested communities. Many of these children, like myself, grew up in doing abuse and neglect, depraved of the emotional needs that we all deserve and are entitled to as children. And I think that this is what we ignore, unfortunately, when they commit a serious offense. It's almost as if we relieve ourselves of the responsibility of our kids the moment they do something that is so horribly wrong. And I feel almost as if we forget the fact that these were children, that they were victims also. When I was 11 years old, I joined a gang. And it wasn't because I had any ill intentions. I had no desire to harm or hurt anyone, strange enough. You know, you think, I had 19 of us in seven convictions, and you say, how is that possible? How could you say that you never intended to hurt anybody? The fact of the matter is I was motivated by the need for love and respect, the need for a sense of connection and belonging. By the time I was 11 years old, as soon as I learned my way around the block to get away from my stepfather, I was out in the streets. That same year, at the age of 11 years old, I was shot in my face at point blank range. And the sad reality is that when children come in contact with the system, these are things that are unspoken. When it came down to my sentence, my public defender, Michelle Charlotte Connors, she emphasized the importance that I was still a child. At the time of my arrest, I still remember, I was 112 pounds, I was 5'4". Today as a grown man, I'm 188 pounds, I'm 5'9". Not just physically different in terms of my growth, but also mentally and emotionally. As a child, I really didn't understand the words that were being spoken in the courtroom. As a child, I didn't really understand death, to be quite honest with you. I didn't understand that doing something could actually lead to someone's, the end of their life. And I think that's something that, you know, in terms of the victim of my case, I think back as an adult now, as someone, as a caring, responsible adult, as a father to a three-year-old child, it's incomprehensible to think that I would ever lose my child and I can only imagine the pain that would come from such a thing but given my experience, given what I've been through and what I've witnessed and seen with my own eyes the humanity in these very dark and desperate places to see the capacity for human change that exists within a child, that exists within every single child to see that if the person who took my child was a child I will be compassionate because I understand that I've been in those situations. I understand that as a child you're not fully formed. And we're not just talking about maturity in a psychological sense. We're talking about children being wired, developmentally incapable of making, yes, what may appear to be adult decisions, but when it comes to the human brain, we're talking about you know brain regions that are not fully in communication. We're talking about the people from a cortex that is still in the process of pruning and myelination, that we know through MRI readings that not only is it a physical lack of maturity, but it's also a functional lack of maturity. That through observation, through MRI readings, they came to find that very little signals were being sent in terms of decision making to the executive parts of the brain, which basically means empirically That children are not capable of making decisions or being able to bypass the more emotionally driven amygdala which seeks rewards of love and respect, the need for recognition and acceptance and belonging. And these are all very fundamental human needs that we all have as children. When I went in at the age of 13 years old, many thought I would never have a life. But as I grew and mature, as I grew up in prison, as I had time to reflect upon my decisions and through a growing sense of maturity and remorse, I came to dedicate my life to the victim in my case. He was the one that motivated me to become a better person because I reflect upon the fact that that was a human life. And although as a young child I didn't fully understand, as an adult I'm able to give back now, and that's what gives me my healing purpose. That's where I restorably am able to give back and make penitence to society. And for the past 12 years I have worked in various positions that were designed to keep children out of the criminal justice and out of the grave. For the past 12 years, I've worked as a gang intervention specialist doing violence prevention in the streets of Chicago and the south side of Chicago. I worked as a juvenile justice diversion program coordinator. And all this was possible because I had an opportunity. I had a light at the end of the tunnel. I knew someday I would be free. At the age of 13 years old, I didn't know where my life would be, but as time went by, I started to mature and I started to develop goals. I started to envision the future. I started to imagine the ability to come out and do right by my victim. And so with that in mind, I ended up getting an Associate of Arts, an Associate in General Education, a Bachelor's in Social Science, 4.0 GPA, was inducted into the Franklin Island Society. Then I went on to get computer technology certified. And this is before I even knew the internet was. And the point is that I'm trying to make is I was driven and I was motivated to make a change. And it was possible. And I am far from the exception. Just recently I worked a position prior to the
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:34:25
campaign. I'm sorry. The time is up, but we certainly appreciate your comments. Thank you very much. Okay. We're going to go back to the against side. There's just over eight minutes left on the against side. Cody Highland. Okay. If you would, take a seat, state your name, who you represent, and then you may make your statement. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is Cody Highland. I am the 20th Judicial District Prosecuting Attorney, which comprises Faulkner, Van Buren, and Searcy Counties in north central Arkansas. Here today to speak against the bill. Representative House, real quick, I'd just like to say Act 1490, I believe, last legislative session, should have addressed the compliance issue. That was post-Miller and post-Jackson. That's one of those things that I'm sure that we wouldn't care to get together with you and go through that and determine, and that's our position. Our position is that we are in compliance post Act 1490. But with that said, one of the things, and I'm hesitant to follow Prosecutor Jegley because he does such a good job with this, but one thing that I want to touch on is sometimes when government acts, we think we're creating a solution to a problem when, in fact, were creating unintended consequences elsewhere. Let me give you an example of that. After Graham, we no longer could charge folks with class Y felonies outside of homicides with life without parole. What we have seen, I'll give you one example. We have a 16-year-old that's currently in our court. He was recruited by a gang member because the gang member understood that this kid no longer had the exposure that other people did that were over 18. and so this kid was involved in an aggravated robbery and so what I'm afraid that we're going to do and not intentionally and I certainly respect Representative Letting and Senator Irvin and the motivation that they bring and certainly don't impugn any negative to that but I think that we're going to see some unintended consequences to acting. In particular what we don't want to do is to create trigger men, a pool of reserve that they can recruit to be trigger men for their crimes and murder. And we're talking about capital murder here. Somebody said earlier, you know, we're talking about releasing murderers back in the community. That's exactly what we're doing. And it's hard for me to believe, frankly, that we're here having this discussion. But I want to talk about Representative Armstrong brought up a good point, and I want to address that. I spoke to an FCLI group back home one day, and I was asked the question, Mr. Highland, what are you going to do to prevent crime and reduce crime? It's a good question to ask a prosecutor, right? And my response was this. In my mind, there are two ways to prevent or reduce crime. Number one, you have better people. Have better people, you don't have as much crime. And folks, here's my problem. If you want to have better people, if you want to transform hearts, you need to talk to the one who parted the Red Sea and fed the 5,000. Because I'm not him. And y'all aren't him. There's a reality there. I have seen God change hearts. I'm a Christian. I believe it. Absolutely. But as the state of Arkansas, the second way you reduce crime, and really the only way in my mind, is the deterrent effect. If we don't have the deterrent effect as a tool in our toolbox as prosecutors and as law enforcement, we will go nowhere as it relates to reducing crime. And I think that's where we're headed with this type of legislation, is reducing the deterrent effect. Now, you may say, but we're talking about children. We're talking about children here, not adults who need to have the deterrent effect. And we're talking about capital murder, premeditated and deliberate actions. There's often, I believe too often in our society, a situation where crime is sanitized. About two months ago, we had a young lady who was 12 years old that had cerebral palsy. And she had to testify in a rape case. And she stood up there with facing 12 strangers in a jury box, the judge and a defense attorney who was ripping her apart, and she absolutely melted down. But you know what? She had to do it because that's what our law requires. That young lady doesn't get to get up there and say, you know what? I was raped. That's not what she gets to talk about. She has to talk about details that would make any of us in a conversation between the two of us blush. And she's having to say it to everybody. Folks, when we talk about this issue, we're talking about it in the abstract. Let's talk about who is going to be released if we make this retroactive. Have we talked to the victims' families? Do we know what the circumstances are surrounding the conviction? We have to ask those questions. This blanket approach that reduces our ability to seek justice in the case is scary for us. the last thing we want to do is from a blanket approach be releasing people back into our communities without any idea about how they're going to react and I see a question from Representative Armstrong so I'll Representative Armstrong you're recognized for
▶ Play
Speaker 76 1:39:45
a question. Thank you I guess we're beating a dead horse and you're right capital murder is a completely inseparate issue that we should be taking up but I feel as though if we've got members that have done the due diligence to bring this forward and you all have the flexibility under the cover of the law. Why isn't the justice system, our judges, our prosecutors, our attorneys, to prevent the grief that Representative Petty had, prevent the grief that somebody like my family has been through and other victims, we're not Jesus, but we are kind of the Alpha and Omega of being able to say you're sentenced to 100 years or two years, and before we ever get to the point of sentencing them, I've still not heard anyone, even with as much strong opposition as you all have in the prosecuting group, all 28 of you, no one's brought forth the real silver lining of a solution. And that's so important, I think. If this bill dies or not, what's a
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:40:44
solution for tomorrow for these same young people that we're talking about? Representative Armstrong, you're absolutely hitting on it. I wish I had a silver bullet. and I'm telling you there are 28 of you I wish all 28 of us could come up with a silver bullet on changing behavior and that's what we're talking about if the law would allow you if the doors of our juvenile court system could swing open wide and all of you could go in and sit in that system you would see young men and women who are lonely they are bitter and they are angry because their parents have checked out because their own drugs are doing whatever immediate gratification they're satiating at the time and grandma and grandpa are doing their best to raise these young people and they're tired they're exhausted and we see it every day and it's frustrating because we are building a group that's going to go right into the system and they're going to be the ones committing aggravated robbery and joining our gangs and everything else the breakdown of the the family in this society has led to a lot of issues and if you could sit in our juvenile courts, you would see that. Representative Armstrong, I guess I'm failing you, is I don't know how to change that behavior other than the deterrent effect. A suggestion, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Speaker 76 1:42:04
Drugs and guns all around me from the ages of 11 until I was 21. Luckily, I got out of it. Small programs in my community that then-Governor Clinton, former state representatives, and others put together to keep us off the streets in the middle of the night summer youth development and enrichment programs life skills training and learning and some of our most dilapidated and ill-fitting communities where the parents may not be providing these young people what they need and in our rural towns and communities the list goes on and on of opportunities that are there funding resources from the feds and the state that are there but i still don't hear our local and i'm not trying to hammer on anyone but I'm still not hearing our local factions of elected officials, prosecutors that have a hard job talk about anything that's solution-based. Again, I'm maybe out of lane but thinking so pragmatic about something like that, but if it could save somebody like me, I know it could save kids that are ten times worse than me. One thing
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:43:11
that I'd like to hit on, too, one thing that this body and the public never sees from a prosecutor standpoint, I think everybody says, oh, they're tough on crime, they want to hurt folks. You don't see the decisions we make every day not to go forward, not to prosecute. Two weeks ago, I had a 43-year-old man that 23 years ago, or whatever time it was, several years, had gotten a felony conviction. He was there on a felony possession. He'd gotten busted. And we just non-prosted the charge because it wasn't just to go forward. And you never hear that from prosecutors. You never hear that coming out, and again, we have decisions that we make every day that we have discretion over as it relates to seeking justice, and that's our job is to seek justice, and I would suggest to you that as it relates to capital homicide and our victims, when you meet with these victims and their families, it no longer is in the abstract. It is a very real, very raw, very emotional thing. And so forgive us if we are somewhat emotional about this, but when I have a 12-year-old with cerebral palsy that has to get up and testify, and again, that's not related to a juvenile committing capital homicide, but if you have a drug problem, if your mother didn't like you, didn't raise you right, if you were kicked out of school, whatever the issue may be, once you decide to hurt someone else, it's time to face the consequences and protect society at that point. And that's where my line comes down. You know, with drug court and everything else, there are opportunities, but when you hurt somebody else, my job is to prosecute you to the fullest extent of the law. Thank you. And time is up for the against side. So now both Both sides have used their allotment of time. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Ballinger, what's your motion? Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
I think in general I feel like there's probably some good things that most people would support on this bill. And since the bill sponsor will not have a chance to sit down at the end of the table, I'd like to make a motion that we table this and maybe make some amendments and come back and
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:45:28
look at this later. okay we have a motion to table just a second okay that's a proper motion it's non-debatable all in favor say aye those opposed The bill has been tabled. With that, without objection, I'm going to set House Bill 1376 by Representative Bell for special order Thursday at 10 a.m. And given that we're approaching the noon hour without objection, we're adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1197

0:48 - 1:46:19 252 segments 14 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Marshall Wright Unverified
3 segments
Chair Unverified
38 segments
Speaker 6
12 segments
James Dold Unverified
79 segments
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
6 segments
Representative Dwight Tosh Unverified
6 segments
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
2 segments
Representative Donnie Copeland Unverified
10 segments
Representative Rebecca Petty Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 58
49 segments
Speaker 76
18 segments
Speaker 75
1 segment
Representative Douglas House Unverified
5 segments
Xavier Mcelrath Unverified
22 segments