Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Public Health, Welfare, and Labor Committee

February 24, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (4)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1363 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…epresentative Copeland, do you want to run your bill today? House bill 1363. Pardon? Yes. Oh, yes. Oh, yes. Please come to the end of t…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1407 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Okay. Representative Hammer will present House Bill 1407. you are recognized when you're ready thank you Mr.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1067 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1067”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1378 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1378”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
In the back of the room, please limit your conversation. Okay, we have Representative Collins. Are you ready for us to hear your bill? Okay. We have a special order of business to hear Representative Collins' bill, House Bill 1067. Thank you, Madam
▶ Play
Chair and members of the committee. I am excited to be at the end of the table today because it's not often that you get to talk about a bill that could do a whole bunch of good things and is very limited on the risk side. And that's what I think this bill could do for us in Arkansas. What I'm intending to do this morning is actually walk through three things. First is describing the problem that the bill is designed to help address. Second is describe what the bill does. And then third is to describe how the bill is going to go about doing it. But given that we're talking about watersheds, we're talking about environmental policy, and what I'm going to call pretty weighty issues, I want to start off by alleviating any preconceived concerns you might have by telling you a couple things that the bill does not do. Number one, it does not reduce any existing regulation at all. Number two, it does not mandate any behavior by anyone at all. In essence, what the bill does do is enable us to add more tools to our toolbox of improving the nutrient levels in our watershed. shed. So what is the problem? What are these things called nutrients, and why do we have to deal with them? Pollution is something I always think about as being harmful, like choking to death on carbon monoxide fumes or something of that nature. But there's actually another kind of problem that can be caused by good things, things everybody needs, things plants and animals need called nutrients. If you get too much phosphorus or nitrogen or carbon in a watershed, all of a sudden something like algae may grow out of control. When the algae grows out of control, then all of a sudden it's negatively affecting the water quality. It's negatively affecting the fish life. It's negatively affecting a lot of things. So in addition to monitoring and reducing pollutants in our watersheds, we also monitor and reduce our nutrients. And the current tool that we use is primarily reducing at the point of entry into the water. So if you're a wastewater facility, for example, owned by a municipality, you're going to have regulations on how much the rate of nutrients can be that goes into the watershed, and that's really where we measure it. However, as we all know, what we're really interested in is what is the overall level of these nutrients in the watershed. So we can measure that, but it's very difficult to say, here are all the different sources or causes for the nutrient level to be higher than we'd like it to be, since the only thing we can measure readily is the wastewater and other source points, that's really where our regulations are focused. What this bill does is enable us to add other tools to the toolbox besides just regulating what comes out of the point sources. Now, the bill operates in a win-win-win type of a fashion, where people would voluntarily get together to agree to do things because everybody gets more benefit than the cost to them. The easiest way for me to understand how this can work is to give you an example. Let's say today you're a municipal wastewater treatment plant and you've currently got a regulation which says you're only allowed to put in 0.1% phosphorus into the wastewater system and you've spent a lot of money to get your plant to be able to operate at that level. And when you look at the amount of wastewater you're putting into the watershed times your rate you're allowed to put in, let's say you put in 10,000 pounds per year into that watershed and that's your current regulated level. The fact that maybe five or ten years ago you were actually discharging 100,000 pounds, so 10 times as much as you are today, frankly is irrelevant because the money you've spent to get down to 10,000 pounds is good, but there's still concerns that maybe there's more nutrient of that type in the watershed than you'd like. Let's say that they're in that same watershed as a landowner who is concerned about his or her soil erosion off of his or her land that's also going into the watershed. Let's say that there's also an environmental group that is very concerned about beautification of this watershed. Here are three completely unrelated parties that all have an interest in the watershed, and what if they got together and said, maybe we can do something to improve the overall nutrient level in the watershed, make this a better place, and save money at the same time. How might that work? Well, if you're the wastewater treatment plant and you've spent $20 or $30 million to get yourself down to 10,000 pounds per year, and you're looking at potentially where the regulations might be three, five, or seven years from now, and you're saying to yourself, my goodness, if I have to get down to 5,000 pounds per year, that's going to cost me another $20 million. I wonder if there's a way for me to stave off that potential new regulation. Well, what if a scientist says, we've got a plant that is native to the region that is a very high consumer of phosphorus. This is a plant that eats a lot more phosphorus than most other plants do. And, oh, by the way, its root systems are very good for holding soil. So now maybe the environmental group and the wastewater treatment plant and the landowner get together, and the wastewater treatment plant says, I'll put $2 million into the pot to buy the plants and pay workers from the environmental group or some other place to go on this landowner's property, plant these vegetation, which will then, after we measure it, withdraw 20,000 pounds of phosphorus from the watershed. Now we've got a wastewater treatment plant that's spending one-tenth the money. We're getting three or four times the benefit, and we're also getting ancillary benefits like beautification of the watershed and minimizing land erosion. That's just one form of solution that this bill would allow. The bill would also allow groups of wastewater treatment plants and other producers of these things to get together in an association and have perhaps a permit that affects all of them collectively. So if one of the operators on a given day had a higher level and another operator on that same day had a lower level, then neither operator would be punished and that type of an arrangement could be made. And then beyond that, there are even more ways this could come to life. Now, the bill itself does not do any of those things. The bill itself allows the regulators to do those things. So how does the bill do that? The bill really has two key elements to it. The first one is it enables the Arkansas Pollution Control and Ecology Commission, which is the group that is over ADQ regulations and all those types of things, to adopt regulations and specify requirements, standards, and procedures governing the establishment and implementation of nutrient water quality trading programs. So this legislation enables our existing regulator to do those types of things. The second thing the bill does is it establishes a nutrient water quality training advisory panel. Now the advisory panel has no authority over regulations. It has no authority over the existing regulators. It is merely a partner, and a partner that would be made up of experts who would be able to provide input, provide ideas, help identify some of the individual participants in different things, and basically assist, but the bill is written very specifically so that the advisory panel does not have any authority over our existing regulators. The reason the advisory panel is so important, and frankly that it's as large as it is with nine members, is because whenever you hear something's too good to be true, as I'm suggesting this might be, people get very skeptical, and I would too. So for example, there are two spots on this panel for members representing the interests of environmental organizations. There's a spot on the panel for members representing the forestry backgrounds, and so on. And what I would submit to you is the way the enabling legislation is designed is such that we'll be able to anticipate and deal with the problems as they arise, if problems arise, but at the same time be able to implement things that could really make a difference in our watersheds. The final point I would make before opening this up to questions and bringing one of the experts to the table so that when you guys take me deeper than I can go, I've got some help, is to suggest that this puts Arkansas in the position of being a regional leader in environmental policy. The first places that these types of solutions have been brought to bear in the country is in the Chesapeake Bay Area. As many of you know, that's a very important water area in our country, and there have been some significant problems there, and that's really where they started these types of things. There are also a couple other nutrient trading types of programs in operation, none of them in our region. The sense of urgency we have is particularly the Illinois River watershed where Arkansas and Oklahoma have had some challenges. Beaver Lake Water District is another area. This is a bill that the mayor of Fayetteville has called me and asked me to support. So Mayor Jordan and I don't agree on everything, but this is one that we agree on wholeheartedly. And with that, I'll be
▶ Play
happy to take questions. Committee, do you
▶ Play
have questions? Representative Love. Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Collins, I just had a question in regards to the advisory commission or panel. Usually when we establish panels such as these, they can receive a per diem or some sort of travel expense. Is that the case with this panel? And if so, where will the funding come from to do that? That's an excellent
▶ Play
question. In fact, Mr. Benefield and I talked earlier this week, and he shared with me that he really supports the concept. He supports the bill. One of his concerns is that the per diem doesn't get out of hand. The way this bill is structured, these people can receive per diem, and it says if the money is available. And I've assured Mr. Benefield that if we have a problem with that, that we will absolutely fix it. And by having, if the money's available, I'm confident that we'll be able to manage that without a big problem. This is not a trick bag to try and fill somebody's coffers with per diem. In fact, there's specific language in the bill that people would be able to attend these meetings via phone calls and other technology to try and reduce any problem there. We're probably talking numbers on the order of $4,000 or $8,000 a year if it gets out of hand. And so while I'm answering that question, Representative Love, the other thing I want to just cover is, you know, what could go wrong with the advisory panel is that it doesn't go anywhere. Obviously, this requires work and effort from people. And, you know, if the panel does not have good projects, if they don't go anywhere, then you have the opposite problem, which is there are not meetings where people are bringing solutions to the floor and all these good potential ideas that I've just talked about never get off the ground and this idea withers and dies. So that's a related potential negative. We don't think that's going to happen, but obviously at this point can't guarantee it. But I do think the per diem dollars are
▶ Play
manageable. Are there other questions from the committee? I did have a question. Is this going to be any administrative burden for
▶ Play
pollution control? If they do set up a trading program, then there would be administrative costs associated with that. The way the bill is designed is they would, I mentioned if you're somebody being regulated today and you would invest X amount of dollars, this bill allows them to charge user fees so that it doesn't cost the government any more money, but that the participants in these programs actually fund those costs
▶ Play
as well. Okay. Seeing no other questions, we only have four people signed up to speak for the bill and no opposed. Do you want to have people speak for your bill? Well, what I'd ask the
▶ Play
committee is, Does anybody feel like there are questions where we need the experts to go through things? We've got many people that have come here to talk about this. That's why we set it up as a special order of business. I've kind of shared with them that sometimes you can buy it back, so they're willing to stand down. But if you need them, they're absolutely here and ready to go through all the detail.
▶ Play
Does anyone, I mean, if they want to speak, certainly they're welcome to. Yes, Representative Sullivan.
▶ Play
Yes. Thank you, Madam Chair. Who can't wait for this bill to be passed? Who's excited about us moving forward with
▶ Play
this? The mayor of Springdale, the mayor of Fayetteville. I've heard other mayors are also very excited, and also the people that are regulated and are spending tens of millions of dollars to meet the point source distribution requirements because they believe if they can get out in front that they're going to be able to show the watershed levels going down and that that will stave off future regulations, which would force them to go from, say, 0.1% phosphorus in the discharge to 0.05% or lower, and their hope is that they can avoid massive cost increases in the future in the wastewater systems. Thank you. Thank you,
▶ Play
Madam Chair. I guess I would just ask, are there members of the audience
▶ Play
who are signed up that want to speak for? What I'd appreciate is if we close for the bill and see if we can get a motion.
▶ Play
Okay. What's the pleasure of the committee? Okay. Representative Henderson has a motion due pass. Is there any discussion on the motion? If not, all in favor? Aye. All opposed? Your bill is passed, Representative Collins. Thank you. Thank you very much, Madam Chair, and thank you, committee. I guess it's Representative Mayberry here. She was first on the agenda. I don't see her. Let's see. Yeah, Representative Gonzalez, he's not here, Representative Copeland, do you want to run your bill today? House bill 1363. Pardon? Yes. Oh, yes. Oh, yes. Please come to the end of the
▶ Play
Speaker 29 17:31
table okay members I spoke with representative letting and
▶ Play
Davis and of course my bill all of those we're not going to hear today they're not ready to be heard okay representative Colin Copeland has house bill 1363 please you're free to
▶ Play
present your bill thank you lady chair madam chair thank you committee for hearing me. Obviously, we've already extended the private option from the previous legislation that's been passed. It will end December 31, 2016, and so I felt like it was only right that we send notification to all of those that are presently signed up and then those that will sign up in the future, that they be notified that the program ends December 31, 2016. If you'll notice in the bill, it's a very simple bill, so there's no fiscal impact. We made sure that at renewal, I don't think that's the technical term, but reevaluation annually, that is when people will be notified, and some of those are staggered, but they will be notified that the program is ending. So it's simply a notification to everyone that is presently on the plan or on the private option and will in the future that the program will be ending per the private option bill that was passed in the House and the Senate. And I'm welcome to take any questions. Representative Hamer, you're recognized.
▶ Play
us representative Copeland I think it's it's a great thing that we're going to you know let people know so they can have plenty of advanced time I'm just curious I'm trying to see where in the bill if this scenario plays out how it would how it would fit in if the task force comes together and I really think they'll probably have an alternate plan available before the budget hearings in the fall at least I hope they do so we can have that information when we go into the fall budget hearings, and then we roll around to the fiscal session, which is in all maybe a probability or earliest that we would deal with this, and something comes out of the fiscal session that is going to replace the private option, what do we do in that case if the private option actually ends before December 31, 16, because we as legislative of body have determined there's another way to handle the needs so could you kind of talk me through that and help me understand how all that would blend together yes sir Representative Hammer thank you that's a great
▶ Play
question I think either way if the task force comes up with another plan obviously the private option is going to end we've been told and rightfully so that there needs to be a wind down period and it just seems like everyone has agreed that December 31 2016 is given plenty of time. So whether the task force came back with an alternate plan, that's going to end the private option. Whether we continue down the path we're on right now, we've already said that it's going to end 2016, December 31. So either way, it's going to end. And this is just simply giving notification. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair.
▶ Play
Do we have other questions from the committee? I might if we could have if Mr. Seeley is here just to address how it might you know work with DHS and what the process would be oh I'm sorry just could you address how if this is going to be a difficult process for DHS or how that might work. Yes, ma'am.
▶ Play
Speaker 38 21:38
I'm John Seedy, director of DHS. I was trying to pull the bill up. I couldn't do it that quickly. In general, what Representative Copeland's bill does, we're in agreement with we would want to notify clients in advance that this will end on a particular date. I mean, it's the right thing to do is to give them notice. When I looked at an earlier version of the bill, and it may not have changed, I think it asked us to start notifying them now that it's going to end, and basically, as soon as the bill is effective, that it will end December 31st. Is Is that what
▶ Play
Speaker 39 22:08
it still does? That was the last bill, had
▶ Play
Speaker 38 22:11
a notification process. Okay. So I just need to ask because I don't have them in front of me. At what point does this bill ask us to begin notifying them? At renewal or whatever. At renewal, okay. My only concern would be, for example, if we renew somebody, let's say, April of this year, that their coverage is going to end December of the following year, their coverage could actually end before that if their income changes, if the following renewal. My preference, I think, would be to notify them at renewal in 16 or no later than July of 16, in other words, so they don't get confused thinking they've actually got longer coverage than we want them to have. I don't want anybody to think, for example, in April of this year that they're guaranteed coverage until December of next year if, in fact, something changes and they're no longer covered. It's not a huge point, but I think we could work through it. It would just be for us a little cleaner if we didn't start that notification until 2016 so nobody thought they had more coverage than they did.
▶ Play
Representative Meeks, you're recognized. Thank you, Director. Again,
▶ Play
that would be kind of where I was going at. Could you still do that anyways to say your coverage could end sooner if your income changes or whatever? This wouldn't prohibit you from being able to do that, correct? Yes, sir. That's right. We could do that. Okay.
▶ Play
Speaker 38 23:30
Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. I mean, we're okay with this bill, at least the version I saw. I don't think it's changed. And I think Representative Meeks makes a good point. We could do that, and that would probably
▶ Play
help clear up any confusion. Representative Love. Mr. Selig,
▶ Play
I want to be clear. Are you saying this is a governor's stance on the bill that he has no issue with it? My
▶ Play
Speaker 43 23:56
understanding is he's not concerned about the bill. Okay. All right. Thank
▶ Play
you. There's no one signed up to speak for against the bill. Do you want to close for your bill,
▶ Play
Representative Copeland? I would just like to say, just clarifying one thing. One, there wasn't another bill. That was a totally separate bill that was actually repealing the private option. That failed in committee. It had a notification in there that 90 days afterwards. So that was a totally separate bill. That was mentioned by Mr. Seeler a couple of times. So there's no confusion. There's not another version of this present bill. Secondly, to Mr. Sealy's point about notifying people and them getting confused, if you look at the language of the bill, it is not about their coverage. It is about the program. So you could have something in there that said your policy, those policies are annual. So this is about the program. It's not about their particular coverage. It simply says, if you look at the language of the bill, that you have until December 31, 2016. This program ends December 31, 2016, which is right in line with the legislation that was passed. Thank
▶ Play
you, Representative Copeland. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Lundstrom has do pass. I move we do pass. All in favor? Aye. All opposed? No. I move the motion passes. You've passed your bill, Representative Copeland. Thank you, committee. Thank you, Madam Chair. It's Representative Gates here to run his bill. Let's see, Representative McGee, you're not running yours again today. Representative Boyd, yes, House Bill 1378. you're recognized representative boy thank you mr. chair thank you colleagues I had hoped that
▶ Play
the board of pharmacy executive director would be here to help me with this but I really think I can move on and present it so at the current time what happens is if you're a pharmacist or a pharmacy technician, and you're licensed by the Board of Pharmacy, and you actually plan to practice physically in the state of Arkansas, then you have to have a state and federal background check. And since you have ready access to controlled substances, and we have a significant prescription drug abuse problem, and one of the ways that prescription drugs wind up on the street is through theft those background checks are very important so what this bill does is in the past there has been in the bill has said that you may background check pharmacists that are that are going to be arkansas licensed but physically present in another state so in in essence the best example i can think of is with a mail order facility so what the state board requires is that if you're going to mail prescription drugs into pharmacy residents in this state, so a pharmacy that is located physically out of the state, and they're going to mail prescription drugs into this state to our residents, then two things have to be in place. One, that pharmacy has to have an Arkansas license, and two, there has to be at least one pharmacist on staff there that is an Arkansas licensed pharmacist and then that pharmacist takes responsibility for any of the, so if there's a mistake that, you know, the wrong prescription is mailed in, then that pharmacist that is the Arkansas licensed pharmacist is on the hook for that. So what has happened is there have been some cases as these people have come and applied and they've not had the background check through just interviewing or what have you, there have been some issues where they found some felons and other things that otherwise would not. So basically this would extend the same requirement that all pharmacists that are Arkansas licensed pharmacists have a background check. I mean, basically it levels the playing field between our state and the other state. That's one way to look at it, but more importantly, these people are delivering medications into our state. Members, I think you've
▶ Play
heard an explanation of the bill. Any questions? Representative Lundstrom, you're recognized for a question. Okay. No one signs up to speak for or against this. Anyone for the audience want to speak for or against it? Seeing none, Representative Lundstrom, what is your motion? So we have a motion due passed from Representative Lundstrom. Is there any discussion of the motion? Seeing no discussion of the motion, all in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, your bill has passed. Moving on down to, let's see, 1394. I don't see Representative Fied in here. 10-08, don't see Representative Murdoch Representative Meeks Seems like I heard Representative Pitts say he wanted to present this but I don't see him in the room Hammer, you want to do yours today? No, that's right, that's special order I'm sorry, I don't see Representative Sablin Representative Bentley I think is over in revenue tax I don't see Representative Harris Representative Tucker Moving on, let's see, Stephen Meeks was going to do, he's over revenue tax, Murdoch. I thought we had Senate bills. We don't have any Senate bills in here. Are we done? We're done. Person of Hammer, you have a reason we're not done? There's no one to ask a question of, sir. 14.07. No, I didn't. And I looked at you, but I thought that's not the one that's on special order, is it? Would you like to run that? We can do whatever you want to do. If you're not ready to present, we sure don't want to hear it yet. Okay. Representative Hammer will present House Bill 1407. you are recognized when you're ready thank you Mr.
▶ Play
Chairman basically what this bill does if give you a minute to pull it up and before and while you're pulling it up is House Bill 1407 while you're pulling this bill up I want to just let you know that as far as the folks that are neutral or don't oppose this bill would include the Arkansas and Bulmers, the Hospital Association, those folks involved with medical waste providers, funeral home providers, and the Department of Health who are either neutral or do not oppose this bill. And basically what this bill does is that it says that in the case of which a baby is stillborn or premature birth or prior to a baby drawing its first breath, his or her first breath, what this bill would do is require that the remains of the baby, and we can use the legal term that's in the law fetus but for personal reasons I'm going to use the term baby that the baby final disposition would either be to allow the parents to make the decision there are some cultures that like to take their unborn babies with them or it would the baby would be buried or the baby would be cremated or incinerated, which basically are the two same things. What this bill would eliminate is the ability for that baby to be autoclaved so that it would be mixed in with all the other medical waste that occurs in a hospital, oftentimes which results in being sent to the landfills. So this is going to bring a higher level of dignity in treating the remains of the unborn that do not get born prior to drawing the first breath. When they draw their first breath and if the baby dies, then there's an actual death certificate that is issued and then it is handled in a totally separate manner. So what this is going to do is just establish the fact that final disposition will either be burial turned over to the parents for final decision, or cremation, which are the recognized methods of final disposition. There was a concern that was raised as far as did this interfere with any option of medical facilities as far as what they can legally do with experimental situations in cases like this. It does not interfere with that at all. In fact, what this does is actually strengthen putting the parent in the position of having the final say as far as what the final disposition is. And I'll be glad to answer any questions. Representative Hammer, what's this do for an abortion clinic? An abortion clinic would be held to the – in fact, I'm glad you asked that question. I should have noted this. In checking – and I don't think she's here today or maybe she's sitting behind me. I didn't see her. But we actually crafted this law along the lines of what all the hospitals in the state of Arkansas do currently in situations like what this bill covers. And so we're bringing the abortion clinics to the same standards as all of our licensed hospitals that have to account to the Department of Public Health. Final disposition would be that the baby would either be buried, the parents would take control of it, or cremation. So it's going to add a cost. Going to add a cost? Well, I'd say it add a cost. However, the hospitals currently are providing that and doing that now. It's part of what they do in providing services to those that are in that situation. If a parent currently at a hospital doesn't want any of those three choices, what happens? Currently, the hospital will take charge of it, and the hospitals have a method in disposing, I'm sorry, poor choice word, in taking care of the baby's remains with dignity. They separate it out from the medical waste, and it goes to cremation or incineration, which is recognized as a final disposition of the body. So the hospitals wouldn't – are you giving the parents more choice then? I mean, I'm
▶ Play
not – can it continue going as it is now, or is there going to be more burden upon the hospitals, more burden upon the abortion clinics, more burden upon the parents?
▶ Play
They will probably, if there was an audience that was going to have, if there was a group that was going to have more of a burden, it's going to be whatever abortion clinics there are in the state. But as far as removing from the parents or the mother the right to be able to say, this is how I want my baby's remains to be handled, no. In fact, if anything, it just, you know, it protects it that much
▶ Play
more. Representative Love, did you have a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. I guess that was on the same lines of I'm thinking. I'm trying to figure out what would we
▶ Play
Speaker 64 36:15
be doing differently than we're doing now if your bill is passed. What
▶ Play
it would do primarily is it would secure that any unborn babies that are born, whether in the hospital setting or in any other clinics that are licensed by the state of Arkansas through the Department of Public Health, that the remains of those babies would have final disposition of either being buried, cremated, incineration is the option. Because currently what can happen in certain settings, although it doesn't happen in any of our hospitals, but in certain settings what happens is the remains of the babies are mixed with the other medical waste and they can be autoclaved, and the final disposition is not necessarily burial or cremation or incineration.
▶ Play
So basically, I mean, if we're just talking, basically this is a bill for abortion clinics to do or bring them in line to whatever the hospital is doing. Is that what you're trying to, is that what you're saying? I mean, I guess I'm trying to really understand, are we not doing this already? In the hospitals, we
▶ Play
are doing this. But also one thing, and that's why it's modeled after what the hospitals do. St. Vincent does a great job because there's bereavement that's included in the follow-up and everything. And I will tell you just from a personal perspective, my daughter, you know, went through the traumatic effect of a stillborn birth. and she had to go through the full delivery. We chose and had the option to have our baby, our grandbaby, buried. That option still remains a viable choice to the parents if they want to do so. What this bill does is simply makes sure that unborn children, whether born in the hospital or born in an abortion clinic, are all held to the same value of dignity and treatment of remains in that the final disposition is going to be burial, cremation, or incineration, which is basically the same thing as cremation. Okay. All right. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And if I may, Mr. Chair? Yes, sir. Thank you. Right now, there's a double standard, and depending on where an unborn child is born determines or gives extra options as far as how the remains of the unborn children are treated. I work in the hospice world, okay, and I think that when it comes to the end of life, one of the things that we try to do is to maintain dignity of the remains. I don't think that it's any less for unborn children, whether it be in the hospital setting or whether it be in the abortion setting. That's a different fight, but when it comes to the remains, we need to give them all equal treatment. My opinion.
▶ Play
seeing no further questions anyone in the audience signed up speak for against this we don't have anybody members you've heard an explanation no further questions what's will the committee I'm sorry you'd like speak for the bill and if you would go then the table and tell us your name, and you'll be recognized to speak for the bill. I'm Nancy Emmons, and I'm from Hot
▶ Play
Speaker 71 39:38
Springs Village. And many of you who know me know that my passion is children. One of the things that was not brought out in this conversation is that the fetus many times are sold. And they're used for other things. And that baby deserves the right to have some dignity. Whatever the situation was for the mother, the disposing of the baby is very important. It is unthinkable that we would let someone sell our babies. They don't have a voice. and we need to really really be human about this and that's all i've got to say members any
▶ Play
questions okay saying none what's will this committee represent meeks i think represent miller you you had a motion all right represent i'm sorry i've been represent miller has a motion do pass any discussion on the motion itself seeing and hearing no discussion on the motion itself all in favor say aye any of those opposed say no and the ayes have it congratulations representative hammer your bill has passed and i see representative murdoch came in the room or no okay he came in and talked to us but he's not here all right i see no further business before this committee we're adjourned till Thursday
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1067

4:02 - 17:57 38 segments 6 speakers

HB1363

17:57 - 26:46 30 segments 9 speakers

HB1378

26:46 - 31:08 9 segments 2 speakers

HB1407

31:08 - 41:12 28 segments 5 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Deborah Ferguson Chair Unverified
18 segments
Representative Charlie Collins Unverified
32 segments
Frederick Love Unverified
5 segments
Representative Dan Sullivan Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 29
1 segment
Representative Donnie Copeland Unverified
8 segments
Representative Kim Hammer Unverified
19 segments
Speaker 38
7 segments
Speaker 39
1 segment
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 43
1 segment
Representative Justin Boyd Unverified
6 segments
Chair Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 64
1 segment
Speaker 71
3 segments