Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Agriculture, Forestry and Economic Development

March 4, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (5)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1569 · 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1569”
Pre-2017 bill
HR1023 · 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…1493 for today. Representative Lampkin is going to present House Resolution 1023 for representative bill while she's making her way down the…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1464 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1464”
Pre-2017 bill
SB183 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB183”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1493 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…the Committee. All right. Next up, we're going to pass over House Bill 1493 for today. Representative Lampkin is going to present House…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
All right, let me remind everybody, if you want to speak for or against the bell, please sign in here. This meeting of the Ag Committee will now come to order. First item of business, Representative Kelly Link is going to present House Bill 1464, an amendment to it, I believe you have, Representative Link. Yes, sir. I think everybody has an amendment. I don't know
▶ Play
if it's on the tablets or not. Do you know that, Mr. Chair?
▶ Play
Hold on just a second, Representative Link, and we'll get that loaded up. Okay, the amendment should be on your tablets, members. Representative Link, you are recognized for your amendment, sir. Yes, sir. When we
▶ Play
were specifying parts of the bill, we left out a couple industries that we think was important to add in there, one of them being the cable providers or cable TV, and the other one is more Internet-specific. And when we get into the contents of the bill, that will make more sense. But we need to come back and add those two industries specifically.
▶ Play
So I'd appreciate a good vote on the amendment. Okay. Any questions for Representative Link? All right. Anybody speak for or against the amendment? Seeing none, Representative McElroy, you're recognized. Motion do pass. Motion do pass. All in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. Opposed? Representative Link, your amendment is passed. You may proceed, sir, with your amended bill. Yes,
▶ Play
sir. Thank you, members. Over the years, as we try to select, or as the governor tries to select members of a commission, in this case the State Parks Recreation Travel Commission, we've kind of come back and put in different language over the years to try to help industries. I mean, this thing started off when radio and newspaper were just about the only ways to do marketing. And over the years now, there's been other ways of marketing. And so we've tried to amend in cable providers and television and so on and so forth. And now we need to come back and add Internet. So what we decided instead, and this is agreed upon with Parks, Recreation, Travel, Director of Parks and Tourism, and also with the Governor's Office, we worked together in kind of putting this together. Rather than amending in specifics like that, we decided to kind of open this up so the Governor can make determinations, maybe who knows what in 10 years from now might be the new hot thing and we need a member from that industry. as you read in there it also opens up to where we can have members to the commission that are just we'll say a user group if they're an advocate of say canoeing or whatever that industry may be we can have someone that represents that and we think it diversifies the commission a little bit there's no sitting commissioners that will be affected by this so if you have a commissioner in your district or a friend of it no one's going to be kicked off the commission everybody who's currently on the commission qualifies to remain on there. So it shouldn't cause any heartaches at all. It's just going to open it up where the governor can be a little more flexible as we move forward in selecting the right commission members to help this industry move forward. And
▶ Play
I'm happy to take questions. Members, are there any questions for Representative Link? Representative House, you recognize?
▶ Play
Mr. Representative, a few weeks ago we passed, and I think it's already been signed into a law about limiting the number of commissioners for life, MRI-D, does this affect that in
▶ Play
Speaker 20 4:12
any way? This does not affect that. That needed to
▶ Play
be done because, well, numerous reasons, as was explained to this committee at that time. But this does not affect that at all. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Any
▶ Play
more questions for Representative Lent from the committee? All right. Anybody speak for or against the bill? Seeing none. Representative McElroy? Motion do pass as amended. Okay. Representative Link, are you closed for your bill? Yes, sir. Okay. Motion do pass, members. All in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. Opposed? Representative Link, your bill is passed as amended. Thank you, sir. Thank you, sir, Chairman of the Committee. All right. Next up, we're going to pass over House Bill 1493 for today. Representative Lampkin is going to present House Resolution 1023 for representative bill while she's making her way down there though i do want to take the opportunity to welcome a group of visitors we have here we have a group from the rice land in depth program it is a young farmer leadership development program would you all stand members of that group thank you all for being here we appreciate y'all Okay, Representative Lampkin, you are recognized for your
▶ Play
Speaker 28 5:35
resolution. All righty. Thank you, colleagues. I'm here today to present House Resolution 1023. This is one that's been in the making for a while when the 4-H was here, but the weather has kept them from being here, so our intent today is to go ahead and pass a resolution, and then when the weather gets better, we'll be ready to present it to them when they can come. So I give today House Resolution 1023 to recognize the positive impact of the Arkansas 4-H program on our youth and to celebrate 4-H Day. And that's basically my bill. It is my bill. Okay.
▶ Play
Members, any questions for Representative Lampkin? Anybody speak for or against the bill or resolution? Seeing none, was it all right? I recommend a do pass. Okay. Do pass. motion. Members, all in favor signify by saying aye. Opposed? Representative Lampkin, your resolution is passed. Thank you, ma'am. Thank you. Next up, we have Senate Bill 183 by Senator Eddie Williams. Representative Ballinger, you're going to be running this bill? You are recognized, sir.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. This bill is actually a fairly long bill, but relatively simple. Most of you all are aware and have probably heard about the Rule 111-D, proposed Rule 111-D on the promulgated based on the Clean Air Act, and basically the impact that it's likely to have or could have on Arkansas, asking us to reduce our CO2 emissions by 40 percent over a relatively short time period, which is one of the hardest and the most significant reductions that are asked of any state. I think we have the fifth most stringent requirement. So what this is is that if we're going to promulgate a state plan, it needs to be done in a way that is not going to have a detrimental impact on Arkansans, on the ratepayers, and on business in Arkansas. One of the great things that we have in our state is affordable energy. Probably the thing that attracts business more than any other single thing that we have as of right now is great people and affordable energy. So what this would do is help reduce the impact of that and basically provide us with information to know what the impact is going to be and then also have some oversight on how the state plan is actually implemented. So having said that, I'll be happy to take any questions that there may be from the committee. Committee
▶ Play
members, any questions for Representative Ballinger? Representative Mates, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I really
▶ Play
like what you're doing, Representative Ballinger, with this bill. Kind of the question that I have, and maybe you can go into a little more detail, is what kind of input or authority or approval would this body have if we were to implement something like this? Would we be able to say, you know, no, we're not going to do this to the EPA, or can you kind of go into that a little bit for us?
▶ Play
Okay, so there's a couple questions. One is if it's a federal rule, there's a question of preemption. Now, the issue of that is actually going to be settled hopefully in court relatively quickly. So there's a lawsuit right now that they're saying outside the fence they can't regulate, and so that's going on right now. So the answer completely to that question will be it depends. But if it comes down and it's upheld in court, then we'll be obligated to create some sort of rule. So what we'll have as a body is we'll have an oversight as to the plan. So the plan is put together. It's going to be presented to ALC. ALC would look at it and approve it. If we get to the point where we can't approve something, we don't have something that's agreeable that they come to us and it's going to have a fairly significant impact on rate payers or whatever we ask the Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality to go back reassess it, do a new plan and they come back. Eventually the governor can actually approve the state plan. So that's also written in here. However under issue one we're in a pretty good shape that however it's implemented they have to come through us to approve it so I think that we're going to be we're going to have a good chance to have real oversight of how this plan is not only promulgated but implemented. Okay so long and short is
▶ Play
we will have to have a plan of some sort but we'll have input into how that plan Well it depends.
▶ Play
If the court case comes down that we don't have to have a plan you know rule 11 D is thrown out then we won't so. Alright thank you. I've got a motion And there's nothing in this bill that actually requires us to put together
▶ Play
a plan. Now federal law may require that. Okay motion at the proper time Mr. Chairman Any other questions for Representative Bell? Anybody speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Meeks, you're recognized for your motion. Motion do pass. Committee, all in favor signify by saying aye. Opposed? Motion carries. Your bill is passed. Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Committee. all right next up we have house bill 1569 a rather non-controversial bill here hope everybody's signed up um let me say this to members in the audience i know this is a controversial bill uh we want to hear everybody's input from it we need to do everything with due respect. Everybody's here to try to solve a problem. We don't want anybody to be injured, but we have a problem to discuss, so we will try to be civil and keep things moving here. Representative Vaught, you are recognized to present House Bill 1569. Good morning. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. Before you, you have a couple amendments that we need to look at and do you want me to hand out the sheet to the
▶ Play
committee members? They're already passed out. Members, and I misspoke. She's recognized to present her amendments. They should be on your tablets. If they're not, let
▶ Play
us know. Go ahead with your amendment, Representative Ball. I need to amend out Representative Richmond's name from a sponsorship and will you pass those down please I'm sorry One
▶ Play
amendment at a time please representative
▶ Play
But it's two and one Sorry I'm sorry Mr. Chair and then delete the subtitle in its entirety and substitute to require that captured feral hogs be killed to provide for the disposition of fees and fines related to feral hogs and to provide for a resident deprivation permit to hunt and trap feral hogs.
▶ Play
And that's the First Amendment. Okay, that's First Amendment. Members, any questions on the First Amendment there? Representative Jean? Ms. Kendrick, could you get one more copy of the amendment, please? Members, I'll give
▶ Play
you just a second to... Here you go. I have one. Representative House. Pass. And here's this one, too. That's the first one. That's the
▶ Play
second one. Okay, members. Everybody got the amendment? familiar with it. Representative House, you're recognized.
▶ Play
I'm sorry, Mr. Chair. There's amendment S1 on the tablet and then there's one that's just been circulating. Can we, the amendment identified on the tablet just add Senator Fowles as a co-sponsor, so I'm trying to make sure. Are you on mine? That's
▶ Play
not mine. beg your pardon can you make this present itself thank you and also I need to take off Senator
▶ Play
Rice as a co-sponsor one amendment at a time ma'am that's all three on the first amendment oh they're all on the amendment ok alright does everybody got the right amendment alright All right. Hopefully we're on the right amendment here. Any questions on the amendment, members? Okay. Seeing none, anybody speak against the amendment, for the amendment? Representative, would you close for your amendment? Yes, sir. Okay. Representative Eubanks, moves due, pass. All in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye. Opposed? All right. Representative Vaught, does that take care of your amendments? I've got another amendment. All right.
▶ Play
Let's hear your other amendment. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Being that the tagging system had only been in place for six months and some were concerned that we were taking out the tagging system a little too quick because of lack of tags getting to some of our guys who like to transfer pigs or feral swine to some of the facilities that like to hunt, We decided that we could Admin that back in But if they aren't in compliance At the end of two years Then we can re-look at this Because we really want to stop The illegal transfer of Feral swine To different places of the state So they'll have to follow the rules and regulations From their pens all the way down to how they are Transferred And if not then they will be in compliance Okay Any
▶ Play
questions from the committee on the amendment Seeing none, anybody against the amendment, for the amendment? What was the pleasure of the committee? Do pass. Representative Ratliff, moves do pass. All in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. Opposed? Representative, your amendment is adopted. You are now recognized to present House Bill 1569 as amended. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. Good morning, committee. I come before you today with an industry-driven bill. Two years ago, we passed a bill, but we really left no one in charge of taking care of the illegal transporting of feral swine. And this is still going on today quite regularly. So this bill will put back in a little bit of teeth in helping us control the problem. But first of all, I want to say that I did not like the felony that was there. I felt like that was a little too harsh, so we decided to take off the felony and get rid of it and take a little bit easier of a step of one to five years of losing your hunting license instead. This law that we're looking at, this bill that you're looking at, in no way discourages hunting of feral hogs. We want all the feral hogs dead that we can get dead. it does nothing to hurt dog hunting at all it is actually just another step another way to help us eradicate these nuisance animals um i want to give you a little stat because i know some people in the room don't believe that trapping works and so uh in 2015 January to February in 2014, there was 275 hogs trapped when the hunting could still take place in your WMAs. Today, January to February 2015, 674 have been killed by using the trapping system that they like to use in the WMAs. So that does show a significant increase in how the trapping can really be another facility to help out with this problem that we have in the state. When we did take away the felony, we tried to collaborate and think of different ways. We left the $1,000 per head fine in there because we felt like that was an adequate fine for someone who is illegally transporting feral swine. The feral hogs can be attributed to more than $1.5 billion worth of damage in the United States, and $300 million of that is agriculture in itself. As a farmer in southwest Arkansas, I can attest to the damage that feral sows can do in just two nights. They destroyed 80 acres at our house. So they do cause lots and lots of damage. I've heard of graveyards being destroyed by these animals. So I just, there is a huge problem that we have. And I feel like we could stick our heads in the sand and say, oh, this is going to work. But it continues to multiply and multiply and multiply. A feral sow will have between, will have it on average 2.7 litters per year. they will start they will never go without sucklings on them also so say they have five gilts those five gilts will start having sucklings at the age of six months and again they will continue to have 2.7 litters per year so you can see how this can escalate so quickly this is not just a problem for farmers it's a problem for timber it's a problem for row croppers it's a it's a problem for lots of industries in the state of Arkansas all I want to do is help find a way to eradicate these nuisance animals from our state and with all of that said that's not even my biggest fear my biggest fear is that we will lose our pseudo rabies free state and if we do that will shut down all poultry I mean all um swine production in the state of Arkansas. We are Cargill growers. We sell our piglets at the age of 17 days. They do not stay in the state of Arkansas. They go across state lines. That will completely shut our business down if we lose our pseudo-rabies-free state. And with that said, I would appreciate a favorable vote. And if any questions, can they recognize themselves for questions, Mr. Chair? whoever we need
▶ Play
to talk to we'll talk to have questions
▶ Play
Speaker 129 20:55
for Jerry Masters executive vice president Arkansas Pork Producers Association
▶ Play
Speaker 80 20:59
I'm Bruce Holland director of Arkansas Livestock and Poultry Commission Mike Knadel director
▶ Play
of the Arkansas Game and Fish Commission and I'm Jeff Pitchford Arkansas Farm Bureau well we've got a who's
▶ Play
who of something down there don't we Hey, if I've got them all at
▶ Play
the same table, isn't that a good thing, Mr. Chair? That's a good thing. All right, members, any questions about this bill? Representative Bates, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
And I'm going to direct this at Director Holland since he's been at this table before. It seems like, you know, obviously no one disputes that this is an issue that needs to be resolved and needs to be looked at. And my concern is it seems every two years when we come down here we've got another feral hog bill that we're looking at. As you recall last go around there was a lot of discussion, a lot of back and forth, and a lot of work went into coming up with the current law that the compromise for the guys that are making their livelihood with the hog farms and with the hog hunts and so forth. So from where you're sitting, can you talk to us a little bit about the what does this do that either improves on that or changes that? My concern is we worked out this agreement last go around, but yet it looks like we may be changing that agreement up again and changing that. Talk to us a little bit about that from that perspective.
▶ Play
Well, I think the task force was formed. We've been talking about this for a few weeks now. And the problem is the feral hog population is not decreasing. It continues to increase. And so we've had our discussions with Representative Vaught and other representatives here at this table, Game and Fish, Farm Bureau, pork producers, timber folks, trying to find a solution. And we believe that trapping is the best solution. Now, I was handed this amendment a couple of minutes before I sat down at the end of the table here. There's a lot of, if we were going to continue to tag these animals and continue the program kind of as it is, just kind of tighten up some of that, there's a lot of things that need to be addressed with that system. For instance, there's a lot of hunters that are getting 10 tags, and then they get 10 more tags, and they never turn in that they've killed a hog. So that brings up the question, why did they need more tags? Is someone tagging a hog, moving it somewhere else, cutting the tag out, turn it loose? We don't know. We need a better system if we're going to continue to do what we're doing. And we've got some of the stats here that I can tell you. There's been 182 hogs that have been taken by hunters that are certified, licensed to hunt. Those 82 have been taken by nine hunters out of 32. There's been 730 tags issued. And no hogs have been reported killed at the terminal facilities. So there's 182 hogs that have been delivered, and none of them have been killed. And are they
▶ Play
required to report that? Yes. OK. And the other concern that I've been getting emails about is that we're creating a new fee or a new license where you've got guys that can automatically go out and just hunt now, and evidently there's a new license that's going to be required. Can you
▶ Play
Speaker 80 24:54
talk to us a little bit about that? I think that's more of a game and fish issue. Representative Meeks, that has been struck from the bill. There was original discussion about generating some revenue to subsidize the eradication program as in selling a $25 permit. permit you know then we would turn around and with that subsidization and give to the cooperative extension service buy some traps so that local landowners could lease these traps if they had hog problems on their private property but what we were looking for the original thought was to generate some income to purchase these traps so it doesn't have to come out of general revenue. Okay, but that part has been struck, though. It has, yes. All right. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Gene, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative DeVault, I appreciate you amending this, but on your original bill, it looked like to me, and I'm going to be quite up front about this, I think there's three hog hunting ranches in this state. One of them is in my district. they bring people from all over to kill these things they trapped on my property I'm a cattle rancher and a timber and captured 86 this past year and I killed and my neighbor killed 35 so we're killing them they are a nuisance I do agree that we need to stop the people that are picking them up from one part of the state or out of the state and bringing them in and drop on the open land but uh on your original bill it seemed like the the bill was trying to do away with these hog hunting ranches because that's what the legislation
▶ Play
would have done actually i feel like if there have i mean i feel like you can facilitate within yourself actually because you grow i just said that a sow will have six point two point seven litters per year they will essentially their guilts will start having pigs at six months i did strike that to give the benefit of the doubt that the farms that we have are abiding by the law that's what we want is people to abide i have to follow regulations every day in my business we have a dairy a hog and chicken houses and i have to comply with law or i'm shut down and that's what we want we want them to comply with law follow the law do the law to the t and that's all we're asking and that's not asking too much actually because every farmer that's in this room or every business owner they all have laws in which they have to abide by so but i'm giving them the benefit of the doubt that they are abiding by the law and that's why we changed it
▶ Play
you recognize for follow-up represent and i'm We'll have much debate, and I'll get back into this later on, but the statement I want to make in a question is that people that come hunt these, they come far away from Iowa and Minnesota down to hunt, stay in our motels. They don't want to kill a piglet. They want a big hog. They want one they put their rifle on and put their foot up on to get a picture made with. So they want bigger hogs, and you've got to trap them and bring them in these facilities.
▶ Play
Well, I even have something for that. I think my husband had an amazing idea. So all the hunters that like to hunt so much, why don't they start guides? And they start taking them out in the wild, which is a true hunt, and hunt them. They would probably make more money that way. Well, they're going to have to get permission to
▶ Play
get on private land. Well, that's right. You have to do that now. You have to do that now. They can't hunt them on public land. And you have to do that now. That's already law. That's already law. They can bring them into these hunting facilities, which are 200 acres or so, and, you know, they can kill them pretty quick and then get out of there and they feed them
▶ Play
and they have a big time. But it's more and more cumbersome. I understand what you're saying, but, again, I want to emphasize, we are talking about people losing parts of their land, being destroyed by these nuisances. I would like to, again, reiterate, if pseudo-rabies free is taken away from us in this state, it will shut down my pig farm and lots of pig farms in the state of Arkansas, which essentially could move to cattle, chickens, and everything else because we all cross state lines in this state with our
▶ Play
animals. Well, as we get on this debate, and this is my last statement, then I'll let some of the people testify. I would like to know from game and fish or livestock and poultry what these ranches are not doing to comply and the proof. But I know we're going to have testimony later on,
▶ Play
but I'll yield, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Representative Jane. Representative Pitch, I believe you had a question. I think this is
▶ Play
for Director Knadil. In researching this problem that we're facing, we aren't the only state facing this. We have surrounding states, some of which have been very successful, some of which have been not nearly as successful. We aren't creating the wheel here. We think we're patterning after a wheel with this bill. And I'd like you to tell us what your perceptions of your research and your department, what you've found.
▶ Play
Speaker 80 30:22
Well, thank you, Representative Pitch. That's a great question, and you are exactly right. The surrounding state, this is not a problem that's unique to Arkansas by any stretch of the imagination. But we've, you know, Tennessee, they've been pretty successful. Kansas has been pretty successful. But what they discovered after many, many years of dealing with hogs and the hog issues over in the crop lands and everything, they still can hunt somewhat but it's very restrictive and what they found was is that as long as and everything that I read the director of Tennessee has been there 44 years I tried to have him here because he's been down this road we're on now but you know he told me he said as long as you incentivize something with these hogs you can better bet they're going to keep coming and originally there was some discussion about putting a bounty on them, and I know Representative Vaught and I had this discussion very early on because I got really excited one day when I got a call that said we were going to ask to pay the bounty on the hogs, and I said, well, wait a minute, Game Fish never owned one. We never turned one loose. But to get to the point of the matter, Fort Benning, Georgia, they had a tremendous hog problem. They put a $45 bounty on hogs, $45, and they run this thing for two years, and when they got through, they found out they had more hogs when they started. So you see when you put an economic value on these things, who has the incentive to shoot the last one in the head? Follow-up?
▶ Play
Certainly. Can you give some specific numbers? You say Tennessee has almost eradicated it. Do you have anything that supports that? I mean, and what their plan was. I think they're very geographically close to us. I think when you look at Kansas and other places, they're different. Yes. But their methods and how close to true
▶ Play
Speaker 80 32:30
eradication they've come. Well, I don't think anybody knows that. The statistics show that you need to take out 70% of the population just to stay, you know, level in line. But I do know that trapping, after many, many years, trapping was the most effective way to do it. And one thing that I want to mention while I'm here is Game and Fish has no, in no form or fashion, want to get rid of dogs. That's out there. We're not here to put people out of business. But my job is I'm tasked as director of this agency to protect our state's natural resources. And these hogs are competing for our native wildlife. You want to talk about a business? The Arkansas Game and Fish business is $2.2 billion a year. That's what it brings to the economy of the state of Arkansas. So when something starts putting that, yes, I take that very serious. So to get back to Tennessee, I know I'm jumping around here, but trapping was the most effective weapon. Dog hunting was the least from everything that I read, and I know that's not popular with the dog hunters, but we need all the weapons we can get out there. I want people shooting them. I want people hunting them with dogs. I don't want to do away with dogs. I'm not against the hog ranchers, but I do believe, and this is a personal note from Mike Naila, the director, that the hog ranchers should have to comply with the same rules and regulations as the commercial pork producers. And that was my understanding when we left here a session ago that that was going to happen. And maybe some of them are, but I know some of them aren't, and
▶ Play
that's not fair. Any other questions from the committee?
▶ Play
Speaker 112 34:30
Representative Ratliff? This question about, I think livestock and poultry would answer this. You said a while ago something about they wasn't reporting how many hogs they were killing. That's correct.
▶ Play
We don't have any record of any hog being killed, one of the tagged hogs being killed from a terminal facility.
▶ Play
Speaker 112 34:49
Have you all been out and inspected any of those facilities? I have not personally, but people have. Okay. That's why I was wondering if they'd inspected. Okay. And I've got to follow up. I had a call last night, Director, about making this a competition. Some hog hunters called me, and they said, Why don't we, on these WMAs, after they get done trapping, why don't we have a statewide hunt and have little trophies, and the one that kills the biggest hog gets a trophy, and the one that kills the most hog gets a trophy, and said, Let's have about 36-hour hunts on these WMAs, after we get done trapping, of course, and see if we could have – let them turn loose in there and see how they could do one weekend and then wait about three weeks and then try out and compare notes. Having the
▶ Play
Speaker 80 35:40
– spent most of my career in south Arkansas, I can tell you if you allow that to happen, you're going to bust up those sounders. You're just going to disperse. They will kill some hogs. There's no doubt. But you're going to bust up those sounders that we're trying to catch and pretty much make trapping ineffective for a pretty good while. And I appreciate you asking that question because I've taken a lot of grief over us closing our wildlife management areas to hog hunting, and it's not against the hog hunters. Matter of fact, we used to put out pamphlets and try to encourage them to come on our WMAs and hunt, and it's kind of like Fort Benning, Georgia. What we discovered is we ended up with more hogs than what we started with when we'd done this on public ground because that way they don't have to – people that are violating this, and I don't want to paint everybody with the same brush, but those people that are relocating these hogs, that's very lucrative for them to do it on public ground because that way they don't have to lease, they don't have to pay any money to be there. So that's the reason for us closing the WMAs. It's not against hog hunters, but we're trying to trap them. And I'll tell you, I have to brag on my staff, and I don't know what the numbers are today. I know we caught like 28 last night, but they're getting the hang of this. J.P. French is our feral hog coordinator, and they're doing some damage. They're catching some hogs. Thanks,
▶ Play
sir. Okay, any other questions from the committee? Okay. If not, at this time we'll recognize people to speak against the bill. First we have Mr. Davis. Don't go far. Mr. Davis, are you here? Representative Beck, did you have a question? I motion to limit debate to 20 minutes on each side. Members, there's been a motion to limit debate on 20 minutes on each side. That is non-debatable. It takes a two-thirds quorum. All in favor of limiting debate to 20 minutes on each side, signify by saying aye. Opposed? No. I think the ayes have it there. Debate is limited to 20 minutes on each side. Mr. Leonard, could you start the clock, please? Mr. Davis, you're recognized. Please go ahead, sir. Give your name and who you are and where you're from. and let us know what you
▶ Play
Speaker 122 38:22
think, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Chaz Davis from Ashton, Arkansas, and I know Deanne real well. But I'm a big pecan farmer, and hogs, that messes me up pretty good. You know, you can't harvest pecans after hogs have been there. And, yes, trapping is effective. The dogs are effective also. You know, I'm not saying that the bill has changed now to where it's the amendments. If it goes like it is now, you know, I think most of the people will agree that that's good. The couple issues I have is the tagging system just got started six months ago. That's when we got our tags because I'm, you know, I have a permit and I got tags. I think it's working. Is there some problems? Yes. You know, I was just telling the game ranch that I sell to, you know, that the way this process is supposed to work, the bill did not clarify that. You have to go into Arkansas Livestock and Poultry, then go to the federal swine regulation, then go all the way through it for these guys to be in compliance. And they didn't know that. They thought they were whatever the bill was passed last two years ago, that was what they were supposed to do so yes they're going to get in compliance now since when they know what they're supposed to do and if they don't find them i hear there's a game ranch that's got holes in his fence why ain't he shut down you know let's enforce the law that with the bill that we have because if we don't enforce the law that we have it's as good as not even being there so you know that was my biggest for take on it but you know when I first had a hog problem in Little River County and I'll always have a hog problem no matter what y'all do because I border Texas hogs come across Red River every day they're crossing it right now you won't ever stop it they'll always cross that river back and forth but you know when I ended up on the hood of a tractor working in a pecan orchard you know I told my dad I said hey we got to take a different approach i'm trapping them i've got about eight corral traps set and about six portable traps i got about ten thousand dollars or more invested in dogs and equipment that still ain't good enough so my biggest deal was to miss vault was to please don't limit us to the resources that we have to get rid of these things so myself we went and bought a thermal scope and ar-15 six thousand dollars i got invested right there you know it it takes every bit of it to control it in my opinion so you know i know there was some stuff with the dog hunters and i tried to speak up and say that you know they're not trying to take that away from us gaming fish is not trying to do this You know, Deanne don't want the dog hunters put out of business. That wasn't what this was about. But what I did tell her was that if you do shut down the transportation and all, yes, that will limit some of the dog hunters and put them out of business. You know, they're steadily declining right now as it is. And this is not a – me and Mr. Canadi have talked several times. This is not a business to make money. It's not about that. But does it offset some of the costs for some of these people? Yes, it helps. So that's all I have if there's any other
▶ Play
questions. Any questions for Mr. Davis? Representative Eubanks? Yes, sir. Did you tag all the ones that you trapped? Yes, sir. Every hog that I
▶ Play
Speaker 122 42:19
have, I have tags. and every hog when I had tags and I will admit and that's the problem that I have and we're working on it to get better but my local game warden called me and he said hey I got a picture of you transporting a hog without a tag and sear I said yes sir you're correct I'm waiting on tags from livestock and poultry I said but as soon as I get them I'm fixing to put them in it because all of my hogs go to a holding pen that they cannot get out of and they go across a set of scales and I weigh them because they all of them go to rolling our ranch the terminal facility but not a hog has left my facility alive or without a
▶ Play
tag Thank you Any other questions for Mr. Davis? Mr. Davis thank you for your testimony sir appreciate you being here Alright next we have to speak for the bill Rick Evans Mr. Evans, if you will introduce yourself and who you're with, you're recognized,
▶ Play
Speaker 129 43:26
sir. I'm Rick Evans. I'm general manager at Calhoun Lumber Company. Calhoun Lumber Company is a hardwood manufacturing facility in Union County. It's a family-owned company, and we own 43,000 acres of timberland in Union County, Calhoun County, and Worshaw County. And thank you so much for allowing me to come and express my concerns on this hog issue this morning. In my industry, there's no doubt about it, the hogs have had and will continue to have an impact on our reproduction of hardwood timber. Like I said, basically 90% of our lands are in hardwood timber, not pine. And in areas where we have cut timber, we don't do a lot of clear cutting, hardly any at all. We do thinning, select cutting, and we kind of depend upon natural reproduction from acorns being placed in the ground by whatever means, mostly by animals, and growing, right? What we have found is in areas that we had heavy or moderate to heavy hog populations in these sections that we cut timber on. When we went back to look at our reproduction, we were not finding any regeneration in our hardwood forest, in our oak species. It's a problem. It's costing us thousands of dollars just in that of potential timber that we could harvest. We've actually, at one point, we tried planting some acorns, and they rooted them all up. It was a failure. We just quit. We said, we can't do that. That doesn't work on our lands. I leased to 65 hunting clubs, 65 on the 43,000 acres. I have complaints from these hunters about hogs. um all of all of my land uh all the clubs don't have a hog problem and what happened was was that i had i had my own people that were leasing for me i found out were taking the hogs off of this section or this club and moving them to this club where they would have hogs to hunt. So I was having hogs transported on my own lands for recreational reasons because they loved to hunt hogs. And it is a great sport. It is a sport. It's fun. I've been out there with these guys. I hunt with them. I'm for dog hunting. I'm for hog hunting. It's a fun thing. I like dogs. I like people that hunt with dogs. It's very important, and in no way would I support, you know, something that would deny that opportunity. I don't think it's necessary. But what does concern me here is when we identify this problem and this invasive species, this feral hog, is like any other feral animal that's reintroduced. That's why they're feral. Domestic animal reintroduced always impacts the resource, whether it be feral dogs, feral cats, feral hogs. They're going to impact the resources, the natural resources that are out there. The native species like Mike was talking about, the deer, the turkey, the ground, like hogs. I've had my hunters in my hunting club say, Rick, he said, you know, well, we have hogs. We had turkeys. Now we don't have turkeys. A hog is just a hog. He's just an opportunist. He doesn't wake up in the morning looking for a turkey nest to rob, but if he comes across one, he's going to eat it. If you come across a mud hole that's got a cotton mouth in it, he's going to eat that snake. He's an opportunist. It's not his fault. He's trying to survive. That's what he is. He's a survivor. And he has no natural enemies, none. And you can't poison him. We pour diesel fuel on our corn to bait to keep the deer and turkeys from eating our corn, and the hogs love it. Seriously. I've had my timber guys change oil in the skidder out in the woods and let some oil get on the ground. The hogs come water in that skidder. It's an attractant. These hog owners will tell you that. They all know these stories. But we have a problem. Now, it's like having a hazard that you're dealing with, and you have this hazardous item. You better be careful how you handle it. Don't spill it, because it can cause a lot of people a lot of trouble. It's going to cost you a lot to clean it up. That's kind of where we are with this. And for us to take this hog thing lightly for the sake of some opportunity, we need to examine that, the value of that. What do we want to risk to provide that for someone? It's not a small item here. We're not talking about we don't need to take this lightly. So I was thrilled to death that our representatives and senators drew up a bill to address this problem two years ago. I was very excited about it because I was at the point, and I had a half a million acres of land committed, that we were going to stop hog hunting on these lands. It was going to be over. They weren't going to hunt them by any means. It's our right to do that. I have a right to say
▶ Play
what goes on on my lands. Mr. Evans, if I can interject here, we have several more members. Could we make a point
▶ Play
Speaker 129 50:14
here? I'll wind it up. That's why I'm in favor of this. anything that you can do to further take care of this problem by transporting this virus all across this state would be appreciated by landowners like me. It's a
▶ Play
serious problem. Thank you very much. Representative Meigs, I think you had a question,
▶ Play
sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Just a real brief question. You've made a good point as to why they're bad, and I don't think there's any dispute about that. But the one thing I did not see your addresses. What specifically in this bill do you think is going to help with the problem? What new benefit is going
▶ Play
Speaker 129 50:56
to come by having this law that we don't already have? The benefit of this bill is to stop the transporting of hogs by any means to anybody, anytime, anywhere. That's what's so important is that there's no guarantees that a tagging system is like a deer tag or a turkey tag there's always a way to get around that tag you take the tag out you you get down the road with it when you get to the point take the tag out reuse it there's ways to get around this it's it's good in that we're doing something we're making an effort to abate the problem but why not just why not just say let's let's really go for this, and let's do this. We can't do a whole lot about the existing problem, but we can certainly keep our neighbors from getting hogs dumped on them. Why would we want to do that?
▶ Play
That's my question. Any other questions? All right. Next we have to speak against the bill. Let me look. Jeremy I'm sorry, I probably pronounced your name wrong, sir. Between your handwriting and my eyes, I'm not getting this too good. Please introduce yourself, and you're recognized to speak against the bill. Thank
▶ Play
you. My name is Jeremy Sullivan. I'm the president of the Arkansas Dog Hunters Association. I would like to say that I like the amendments to the bill, all except for the one about having to have a, it says a depredation permit. I need to know that all of my hunters are going to be able to get one of those depredation permits. Is it something that we're going to have to apply for and then we have to be accepted to get it? Or is it something that you just give $20 for and you get the permit? I would also like to say that the Dog Hunters Association realizes the critical problem that we have with Farrell Hall. in no shape or form? Do we condone any kind of releasing of feral hogs? But I think there's a lot of ways to go about getting rid of a lot more feral hogs than what we're doing at this point. We are modeling this legislation from Tennessee, from Missouri, and from Kansas. These states do not have the problem that we have. And I understand that these guys are able to control the feral hogs, but I would like this state to look at the state of Texas. In the state of Texas, it's wide open for feral hogs. There are USDA slaughter facilities in the state of Texas that would receive 5,000 head of feral hogs from the state of Arkansas every month if they could get them. There is money to be made to be generated in the state of arkansas from feral hogs i am conducting a federal uh feral hog is called the razorback roundup that starts at 1201 tonight i've got people coming in from south carolina i've got 105 hunting teams or hunters in this in this hunt last year we killed 83 hogs in 72 hours i've got people from out of state that comes in i offer the the winning team this year we got 26 teams 105 hunters we donate all the meat to hunters feeding the hungry in the state of texas they can offer fifteen thousand dollars for the winning team here in arkansas i offer them fifteen hundred dollars and the reason they can do that is because you have these buyers from usda facilities that donate this money because they know as soon as those hogs come across that scale they're going in a semi truck and they're going to slaughter and these guys are making a lot of a lot of entrepreneurial money off of these feral hogs and what i see happening is we're limiting people to to actually eradicate feral hogs i mean i understand the transportation of these hogs is terrible and and if if a person is caught transporting reporting a feral hog then he he should be you know dealt with but there are a lot of ways that we can go about uh getting rid of a lot more feral hogs than what we're doing, and we can make the public involved. The public will take care of the feral hog problem if there's some incentive.
▶ Play
That's it. Okay. Any questions for Mr. Sullivan? Seeing none, sir, thank you for your testimony. You bet. Next up, we have to speak for the bill, Mr. John David Neely. Sir, you are recognized. Please introduce yourself. Good
▶ Play
morning. My name is John David Neely, and I'm speaking on behalf of myself as a landowner, but also as a consulting forester in Camden, Arkansas. Our firm manages about 200,000 acres for about 300 landowners from northeast texas all the way to the to the eastern mississippi delta as a forest manager as rick evans talked about the problem and i know we've y'all heard a lot about the problem and i'm not going to get into it just in depth but a tremendous uh challenge for us as foresters and as forest managers with the hog depredation not only in in the hardwood side of things but also in pine plantations and damaging our our seedlings and depredating our survival rates. Tearing up our forest roads a tremendous problem. Thousands of dollars have to be spent fixing these roads. As Director Knadel mentioned too, one of the biggest resources we have in this great state is our wildlife. The amount of billions of dollars that are brought into this economy. And as managing the forest for landowners and managing leases on all these properties, hunting is a big business. And for our landowners, that's good revenue. Hunting lease revenue is important. And if we have good hunting populations of deer and turkey and squirrels and rabbits or whatever, native game species, we're going to be better off hogs are a problem they don't coexist well where we have hogs you're going to see these populations go down i can tell you personally on on our camp uh where we have uh about 4 500 acres used to we had i thought some of the best turkey hunting in south arkansas and good deer hunting and the hogs moved in a few years ago and our hunting has gone down now we hardly have a turkey on the place. And the deer hunting has suffered as well. Y'all have heard all this talk before. I'm just going to say, and I'll wrap up, you know, we have got to have strong laws like this in place that continue to improve the regulations, the teeth into the transportation of hogs to limit it. personally I think trapping has worked better at our place than dogs we've had both through the years I've had a lot of hog dog guys come on our place and and as someone had mentioned earlier about the sounders getting moved off and that that does hurt the trapping after you do have a dog operation come in for a while they're extremely smart unfortunately we're dealing with a species that's smarter than most of us. It's really one of the smartest species out there, and they quickly adapt to things that threaten them. They know how to evade people, to be nocturnal. So we've got to be creative. I guess that's about it.
▶ Play
Any questions? Any questions for Mr. Neely? Sir, thank you for your testimony. All right. Next up against, we have Gil Temple. Jill. Jill, I'm sorry. You're the prettiest trapper I've seen here today, so go ahead, Jill. I appreciate your
▶ Play
Speaker 140 59:41
testimony. Thank you, Chairman. I'm going to be brief so that we can get to the others, but I just wanted to second. It sounds like we're all on the same page, that the hogs, they are a problem. And I would like to go with the first person who spoke, that let's just strengthen the first bill, The first bill is perfectly fine. It's against transporting hogs. It allows hogs to the terminal facility. Those three terminal facilities can allow 15 trappers. You're looking at 6,750 hogs that can be transported to these facilities if we would allow that. So I just say strengthen the first bill. I didn't introduce where I was from. My family, they trap as well as travel to private property and help eradicate hogs any bill that adds fines penalties and licensing you're going to minimize the number of people eradicating the hogs so if eradicating the hogs is the goal and not profit let's let as many people in as possible and just strengthen the first bill any questions for mr. Jill
▶ Play
Thank you, ma'am. Appreciate your testimony. All right, now we have a go for again. Mr. John Vaught, you're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chairman. My name is John Vaught and happen to be married to to Deanne Vaught, so there may be a little conflict of interest here, but to kind of to summarize, I think, what I've heard here, and I think the amendments that's been put on this bill satisfies most of the dog hunters from what I've talked to, and actually, I've probably spent about 12, 13 hours on the phone in the last 36 hours talking to several of them, and they were all real congenial with me. Some of them wasn't so congenial with my wife and didn't really like that, but most of them, I think, understood what she's trying to do. She's not trying to shut y'all down. The government doesn't want y'all shut down. Y'all are part of the process of eliminating these things. But at the same time as a dog hunter, if you eliminated them, then what are you going to do? So there's a little bit of a conflict of interest in saying the dog hunters can do it because if they eliminate feral swine, then they don't have feral swine to hunt. No, you're right. It will never happen. But we have got to stop our national hog debt from going up. It's ticking up, ticking up, ticking up. And we've got to see that flat line and then start it back south. I mean, that's just the nuts and bolts of it because there's too many dollars at stake from the domestic side of the swine industry, the timber industry, all of that is jeopardized by the diseases that these things carry. A lot of these hunters have explained to me that they give meat away to people. I trap hogs on my own place, and I used to do that. I will not give one away. I think it's 15% to 18% I've been told are tested positive for pseudorabies, and another 15% to 18% are testing positive for swine brucellosis. That is two diseases that humans can contract from feral swine. And I told the guys that I talked to on the phone, if you want to give them to people, that's fine, but you're risking everything you own by doing that because if they get sick, they could see you. So the ones we trap on my farm now are destroyed on the farm and left on the farm. But this bill, I think, with the amendments that's been added, I think satisfies the sport hunters. I think it satisfies the game ranches. I think it puts some penalties in there for the ones that's not following the letter of the law. And I think it takes out the license they had to purchase. You know, some of them I told them, explained to them how I read the bill. and I told Mr. Davis a while ago he was right on one of the issues he and I had talked about. I was wrong on it, and I told him, I said, you was right, it was a separate license. But I think the way the law is written now actually strengthens what we have on the books. It puts Game and Fish as overseers of it, if I understand it right, and I think it'll get to ship a captain and we'll head in the
▶ Play
right direction. Okay, any questions for Mr. Vaught? Thank you, sir. I appreciate your testimony. All right, next to speak against the bill, we have on our list Mr. David Richardson. David, would you come introduce yourself and address the committee? Hi, my name
▶ Play
is David Richardson. I own the rolling... You missed the best part of my testimony. him. I would like to address a couple things. I wasn't aware, and I will throw myself on the mercy of the court, I wasn't aware that we were to report the number of hogs killed on our operation, and I don't know if the other guys were or not, but I can tell you We have killed 287 last year, and we've killed 71 year to date. We do track every hog that's killed. We weigh every hog that's killed. We have the name of every person that killed every hog. I wasn't aware that we were to report that. It's not a problem to do that, so I do apologize. There have been many hogs killed on the game ranches. Also, as far as the game ranches, it was brought up that somebody had some holes in their fence. And, you know, I think it should be – I think it's criminal that somebody knows that there's a hose in one of our fences and nobody reports it to that landowner to fix it. I hired a man that walks my fence every day to make sure we don't have those type of issues. But if I had a neighbor that knew that I had a hoe and took pictures of it and didn't report it, he's a criminal. So I just want to say, you know, you're part of the problem if you see stuff like that and you don't address it. The Game and Fish has been to my place many times. We have a great relationship with them. They've been an ally. They haven't been a problem. We've had one of the commissioners for the state Game and Fish hunt on our place. We've had one of the directors of the FBI hunt on our place. And we also had hunters from all over the world, including the groundskeeper for the Queen of England, hunt on our property. So it's not just a local business. We bring in people. In fact, most of our customers from out of state, most of them stay in hotels. We do two-day hunts, and the only thing that limits our ability to hunt is the ability to get hogs, and since our last legislation, that has gotten much, much harder to do. We have initiated a growing program. We're trying. Unfortunately, Finally, as Mr. Lane-Jean said, they're small. I've probably got 100 footballs running around on my property, and it's going to take another year to get them to shoot in size, and I've got to feed them all that time. In the meantime, in order to be able to pay the feed and the taxes and the upkeep on the fence, and for my employee, I have to buy hawks from the outside. So I depend on the trappers. Dog hunters, man, that is a generational thing that's been passed down from generation to generation to generation. I love those guys. I appreciate them, and they're very good friends. Most of the hogs that we catch near my ranch will use traps. What isn't addressed is how many hogs we lose that are tagged that die before they get to my place. A lot of times the stress of being caught, a hog will just die. And my growers continually talk to me about, hey, you need to be buying this dead hog because I've been feeding it for two weeks waiting on you to come get it. So, I mean, there's a lot of issues going on. There's a lot of cost involved. But we do, and I'm talking about my ranch specifically, we do a tremendous amount for our community. We're part of the Chamber of Commerce. We do wounded warrior hunts. We're a ministry. and we do a lot of good and we have a lot of support. The only thing, I've had a very short time, like Mr. Holland, to look through this and I haven't got to look at it very well. My only concern is the permit to kill like you would get for deer. I mean, I don't know how that would work, if that would affect us. So, I mean, there's a lot of good things I'm saying, and I appreciate Leanne trying to work with us and everybody. But it is a very big industry. There's a lot of people that affects. There's a lot of ministries from my end that would be affected if you shut us down. And we are trying to be in compliant. And I can tell you that I personally bought the licenses and the tags for my trappers so that I knew they was doing it legally. So, I mean, we're trying to do everything we can now. Like I said, there was that part of the law I did not know, and none of my guys are all shaking their heads. They didn't know about it. It's not a big deal to report that. One last statement I would like to say. I noticed you had a fine committee of people here that were looking into this problem before this came into effect. half the committee was missing the ranches and the trappers were not asked at all until this point what our opinion was we called you when we found out about it we found about it on monday and we've been on the phone non-stop until today but we would very much like to have input and and give introduce our ideals and help to eradicate this problem and control it and and you can regulate us out of business and still have a hog problem so we would like to be involved we agree there's a problem we would like to help address that problem cooperatively and so okay thank you very much all right representative
▶ Play
jane i think you have a question a couple if i can get them
▶ Play
in real quick get after mr richardson who's your ranch at harrison arkansas harrison arkansas Have you ever been visited by game and fish or livestock and poultry and written up for
▶ Play
any violation? No, sir. I have been visited, but I have
▶ Play
not been written up. Okay. Do you have hoes in your fences? Not that I know of, no. Okay. How many hogs do y'all kill a year on your facility? Our goal is 300 a year. How many do you kill? Well, last year we killed 287. Okay. Thank you. Appreciate it, Mr. Chairman. Okay. Any other
▶ Play
questions for Mr. Richardson? Sir, thank you for your testimony. Appreciate you being here. Thank you very much. Okay. Mr. Timekeeper, give us a
▶ Play
Speaker 160 1:11:19
little countdown on where we're at here. Yes, sir. We have 15 minutes and 5 seconds
▶ Play
on against, 13 minutes, 40 seconds, 4. Okay. Okay. and got five minutes against and about six-and-a-half minutes, four. Representative Hutchison, or Hendren, I'm sorry, runs in the family, doesn't it? You can call me Ray
▶ Play
and you can call me Jay, but you better not call me that anymore. It would help this guy. Now, the only Razorback we know about up there is those guys that try to play football and basketball at Fayetteville. So we don't have that problem yet. But what would help me, Mr. Chairman, is a guy that's sat here and listened to it and trying to understand what we're talking about. Some of these people are saying they're for it. Some are saying they're against it. And I don't know why they're saying each side. It'll help me some. This last fellow that Gene asked those questions, he's got a hunting place in Harrison, right? That's what he said. And I think he was saying he's against the bill or for the bill. He was speaking against the bill. And I'd like to know why he's speaking. What does he say is wrong with the bill? That's what my problem is, because I think I'm going to have to vote here in a minute instead of him, and I'd like to know what I'm voting about. It might be a change
▶ Play
around here. Okay, we will ask the members or the speakers here to point out why they're against the bill whenever they come up and why they're for the bill. So right now we have Mr. Jason Green here to speak for the bill. Yes, sir, I won't pass my term, Mr. Chairman, and you might not have the next person. To who, sir? On to the next person. On to the next person. Okay, let's go down the list here. We have Darwin Hendricks to speak for the bill. and so there's about six and a half minutes six minutes and twenty seconds left to speak for the bill
▶ Play
Speaker 164 1:13:25
thank you Mr. Chair can I pass some photos around please certainly thank you for allowing me to address you again concerning the problem that I have with feral hogs as a landowner and a sportsman These photos that I've passed around shows recent destruction to my land. Some of these photos show hay meadows that I've had to rework time and time again in the past 10 to 15 years. And as you on the committee know that are involved in agriculture, you know how expensive that can be. We know that the hogs like to eat Johnson grass and Bermuda grass roots. So when they're searching for food, that's a very convenient thing for them to root your land up. Two years ago, I brought pictures that showed one of my grandchild, and she was in a hole, and the hole was up to here on her. On our bottom land that overflow during the rainy season, it washes our topsoil away to the Gulf of Mexico. Since the 1st of December, I have, with the help of Scott Cagle, caught about 100 hogs on my land and an adjoining landowner, and we are still seeing more on camera. I have raised hogs for personal consumption, my family has, and we know how domestic hogs react when the actual kill takes place. I say this because I have caught wild hogs that react in the same manner as domestic hogs. If any of you have killed hogs in a pen, the feral hogs, they will actually bounce from fence to fence until you get them killed. In the beginning of my control efforts, I did use hunters with dogs, and I enjoyed the sport, but we simply moved the hogs away from our place after we caught three or four hogs. As a sportsman, consider, Mr. Gene, Representative Gene, consider what 30 to 40 hogs do. as they come across the acorns in the woods that deer, squirrel, and turkey live on. If we do away with the turkey and the deer and the squirrels, which I have lost a tremendous amount of turkey on our place due to these feral hogs, imagine what they do to a turkey nest. I urge you to pass this bill and will be happy to answer
▶ Play
any questions. Okay. Any questions? Representative makes. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm going to
▶ Play
get back to Representative Hendren's point. I've heard you reiterate that there was a problem with feral hogs, and no one here disputes that. But what I've not heard you say is, what in this bill specifically do you think is going to address that problem that is not being done now?
▶ Play
Speaker 164 1:16:26
Well, one thing, there's been a couple of amendments that I didn't think needed to be added to this bill. Another is permission to hunt on my land. They have to have my permission now. to hunt on my land i can't control all of our land and make sure that they're not hunting on our land the tag system seems like might be a way to go but a hog doesn't care if it has an ear that ear can be cut off and the hog's just fine i just think there needs to be something done to eliminate the transporting of these feral hogs more so than is being done now okay so
▶ Play
So the thing that you like about the bill is that we're eliminating the transport of hogs altogether,
▶ Play
is that? Okay, all right. No, we're not. Okay, any other questions? Sir, thank you for your testimony. All right, next we have to speak against the bill, Mr. Travis Thunderbird. All right, thank you, sir. That will go down to our next one, Mr. Lee Kendall, or Kirkendall. I'm sorry, sir. Please, sir, try to tell us what's bad about the bill that's going to make things worse. I will.
▶ Play
Speaker 171 1:17:45
Thank you, Mr. Chair, Mr. Vice Chair, Committee. Please recognize yourself and where you're from, sir. I'm Lee Kirkendall. I live in Hot Springs, and I'm here today. I want to go over a few numbers. I'll be as brief as possible. Thank you for allowing me to speak today. We've heard a lot of different numbers today. We've already, in a nutshell, we've got a bill in place. The requirements of that bill, if it's not being policed, that doesn't mean that we're going to get this bill out there and solve that problem. In 2005, a little bit of background, I was invited to participate in an eradication program and actually helped write the protocol for the eradication program for the state of Missouri. Since then, I have taught and instructed all their trappers, especially in the southern part of the state where their problem is. They have a very small problem now. Since that time, I have personally, myself, harvested over 5,000 head of hogs. I've blood tested myself closer to 10,000 head of hogs, and all those records are written down and free for anybody to look at. So having said that, I'm very concerned in this amendment. I've read over this. I'd like to get some clarification on this amendment here where it says depredation permit to hunt and trap. We all know that most everybody has a hunting license and goes out into the field. you know that everyone here has a hunting license okay as far as a depredation permit to hunt and trap i'm not real clear on that i'd like to have somebody clear that up for me we all know how much money that the gaming fish commission receives every year we know that their state money allotted and we know that the usda also has a program to help farmers they have presence in almost every county in the state matter of fact they do have a feral hog program they do some trapping help a tremendous amount of people i've actually worked with the department of agriculture in about three different states helped them trap and and actually gave instruction having said that this nuisance animal i can't see anybody in the state paying to hunt a nuisance animal so this i'm very concerned about this bill uh i'm gonna go ahead and close make it quick i can't see anything in this bill that's going to help eradicate feral hogs we all want feral hogs eradicated okay we've got something in place in closing i'd be happy to take
▶ Play
some questions okay we've got a couple questions here representative pitch you are recognized first sir thank you mr speaker i'm from missouri yes
▶ Play
sir does missouri allow transportation of feral hogs do they allow transportation? No, sir. Thank you. Okay. Representative
▶ Play
Makes, I thank you. Had a question, sir?
▶ Play
Yes, sir. And I appreciate you getting to the parts of the bill that you're concerned with. It seemed to me that the main sticking point that you have right now is that we're going to require a new license in order to hunt the hogs. Do you believe that having this requirement is going to worsen the problem, make fewer people want to go out and hunt the hogs? In your opinion, do
▶ Play
Speaker 35 1:21:21
you think it's going to make much difference? I'm alarmed about a
▶ Play
Speaker 171 1:21:25
depredation permit. The way a depredation permit, and I'd love to be corrected if I'm wrong, the way a depredation permit works is you apply for a depredation permit. You don't just go to the Walmart and buy a hunting license. You have to apply. What's going to keep our people that are killing hogs and trapping hogs from being turned down on an application. I don't want to apply and pay to kill a nuisance animal in this state. And to be honest, that's my
▶ Play
one concern, a big sticking point with the bill right now is that the point, and maybe the sponsor might address that as we get further along. Thank you
▶ Play
for your question. Thank you, Mr. Speaker, Mr. Chairman. Okay, any other
▶ Play
questions? Representative House. this bill has an amendment that reduces it from a felony to a misdemeanor rather substantial misdemeanor um we can't hardly keep the robbers and the rapists locked up and i agree uh misdemeanor seems more appropriate you know what missouri is doing in that regard what they're what they're
▶ Play
Speaker 171 1:22:30
doing on their transportation now when i asked your question a while ago missouri still has terminal kill facilities but they have a system set up very similar to ours and and they've not had a problem matter of fact they have less hogs now than when they than when they started they have a great program a really good program um the the transportation uh there again in in bill 1478 that was passed last session all this this tagging system everything is you know we don't want to we want to let one bad apple mess up the whole thing. That's with everything. We've got, you know, bigger fish to fry. I can't see this bill.
▶ Play
Okay. Any other questions? Thank you, sir. Appreciate your
▶ Play
Speaker 171 1:23:18
testimony. Thank you, Mr. Chair and Vice Chair. Thank you, committee, and I'd appreciate a no
▶ Play
vote on this bill. Director Canaito you're recognized here
▶ Play
Speaker 80 1:23:32
do you have some input you want to share to address representative Meeks and several folks today the depredation permit seems to keep popping up here and when we met originally we put in the night hunting clause in there which was very important to the Arkansas game of fish we were losing a tremendous amount of night hunting cases if we weren't catching people with deer in possession of deer at night the attorneys and and i won't pick on all the attorneys in here but they figured out pretty quick all they had to do is say they were night hunting or uh hog hunting while they were at night so we started losing a lot of cases because of this because there was not a law against hunting hogs at night So with this depredation permit, that's another way to enforce. A private landowner can go out and hunt hogs at night. We encourage them to do that in a safe manner, of course. But a leasee can do that. But if a person just wants to go, some of these folks here today, it's very important to us to know who's out there shooting at night. And that would be a case where we would issue a depredation permit to somebody that wanted to go at night where we can – it's kind of a controlled atmosphere beyond the private landowner, if that makes sense. No cost.
▶ Play
Representative Shepard, I think you had a question.
▶ Play
Speaker 179 1:25:01
Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Knadil, just a few questions, if the chair will allow me. Lawyers. There's been a lot of discussion in here And I'm really, quite honestly, I'm not sure what the issue is I mean, first off, last session, the law was put in place It was a step, I think, all believed to be in the right direction I recognize nobody was particularly happy But it was a step in the right direction And everybody understood that there was going to have to be probably some further looking at this issue. It's a huge issue. I mean, it's probably one of the biggest issues we deal with, and there's no way to really get your arms around it. But to be clear, in this bill, after the amendments that were put on it, the transport of hogs is not prohibited because of the amendment that was placed on it. Correct? Correct. Okay. Now, the punishment was changed. It was taken from a felony to a misdemeanor. But on the other side of it, there's a potential for losing your hunting license for five years, correct? Correct. Additionally, one way that some additional teeth was added to this bill was the fact that now it specifically states that all law enforcement officers can enforce the law, which has been a problem, correct? Correct. Because in the past, the game and fish didn't want to deal with it because it's a non-native invasive species, and that's really outside of y'all's purview, correct? Correct. Mr. Chairman, will you allow me just, I'm trying to hopefully clarify if you don't mind. I think you're doing a good job of clarification. Please carry on. Okay, so it gives all law enforcement the ability to enforce the law. Correct. So livestock and poultry, under the direction of Chairman, now Director Holland, will continue to regulate these hog farms. Is that correct? That's my understanding, yes, sir. So, and then finally, you just spoke related to the depredation permit, which you've just explained to the committee, correct? Yes, sir. That's what this bill does. So I'm trying to understand why I can understand landowners potentially not being happy with the bill Because it doesn't go far enough And I think it remains to be seen But there may need to be further changes made But I guess I don't understand why individuals who are wanting to preserve the hog farms Or the hunting of hogs are against this bill with the amendments because it largely does not change anything other than allowing additional agencies the ability to enforce the law, which I think all should be in favor of that. And so I'm wondering if you can help me understand. I just don't really understand why we've talked about this for an hour and a half because after the amendment, not much has changed other than we've given law enforcement additional tools to make sure that the law is enforced. uh representative
▶ Play
Speaker 80 1:28:13
shefford i will tell you this we've kicked the can a little further down the road uh that that's what i can say but i i do feel better that the hog ranchers understand what's expected of them and and i want to make myself clear once again game of fish has nothing to do with the hog ranchers i'm not trying to put anybody out of business um but they they need to be sure that they're reporting correctly last time last session when this was addressed i remember distinctly me testifying that sitting in that chair right over there that what they were doing was violating livestock and poultry regulations if you go back and look at the minutes you were there and everybody said oh okay yeah we're yeah we'll get in compliance well that's that's really I hadn't seen that happen. So hopefully this is the mechanism to start the protocol to get them in compliance because they are an important tool, in my opinion, of eradicating hogs if it's done right. I heard the gentleman a while ago, he was throwing some figures out there of how many hogs they could. But to your point, I can tell you, as I said a while ago, besides the night hunting thing, you didn't mention that uh when you were talking which is very beneficial to our agency and that was something that i wanted uh very much um we have just kind of kicked the can down the road a little bit but hopefully we're moving in the right direction and nibbling away at this what one final question
▶ Play
Speaker 179 1:29:50
if i may where is where is the prohibitional night hunting i mean yeah it's the depredation part but it's is it specific it's not it's not specifically in the is it in the last bill should be in the
▶ Play
Speaker 80 1:30:21
last bill what are you wanting to explain tell you what the depredation part is is just a tool, if you will, Representative Shepard, where people that can't use this as a viable defense, if they don't have that depredation permit, they can't use it as a viable defense if they go to court for out there hog hunting at night. That's what the depredation permit is all about. No cost, nothing like that. We just want to be able, one of the things as a long-term wildlife officer, if I'm on one side of the county that I work and somebody calls in shots fired on the other side of the county it's a and I'm working on a legitimate complaint and I drive all the way across the county just to find out that some yahoos over there shooting hogs in a pasture it's aggravating and that happens a lot under the old law and
▶ Play
Speaker 179 1:31:14
it looks like that may be actually in rules or regs as opposed to yes that's correct thank you Mr. Chairman for your leniency with me
▶ Play
well I was glad to I see a lawyer getting tripped up on the word depredation there. But anyway, not quite like adjudication, but getting close there. Okay, Representative Gene, you had a question, and then Representative House. Director, and I'm
▶ Play
going to ask this, and to Director Holland also, any of these ranches, has there been a reported violation? Have you all had a problem with them? And just yes or no? Yes. To my knowledge, no, but I've only been on the job a month here. I understand that. But the problem I had, and I appreciate Representative amending this bill, there was an assault on these ranches before this, and if we do anything down the road, I would encourage you all to please bring them in to the discussion prior to the legislation, and that's all I have to say. Representative
▶ Play
House, you were next with a question. uh
▶ Play
director canada would you ask the commission if they would consider a methodology of getting that depredation permit either online or a phone call yes sir and i mean just like if you're going to burn clear clear burning if you just call the fire department let them know they don't get too upset exactly and that seems where you're trying to go with
▶ Play
Speaker 80 1:32:38
yes commission consider that yes sir we've been doing this for years representative house With deer, it's not uncommon for deer or whatever, we get a call that they're out eating soybeans. Our biologists would go out and look at it. They would verify the damage. They would issue that farmer a depredation permit. I know there's been a problem with that word this morning, but it's a depredation permit to allow them or some of their designees to shoot, you know, to protect their crops, their property. and it's the same premise here with the
▶ Play
Hawks. All right. Members, well, Representative Pitch, just motion at the proper time, Mr. Chairman. Okay. Well, members, I think we have rooted this thing around. Nobody understands. I'm sorry, I just couldn't resist it. We've rooted this thing around enough here. In the rules, it's not in the bill. So, Representative Vought, are you closed?
▶ Play
I'm ready to close, yes, sir. Close this thing out. Let's get it done. Thank you, Mr. Chair. First of all, I want to say again, we are huge hunters in my house. We love to hunt. I love to hear the dogs run. That's not the problem. We want to find a way to help everybody eradicate these, and we feel like the trapping system is a great way to begin to help even the dog hunters in eradication of these feral nuisances. Also, someone brought up the fact that the cost. As farmers, I think we all understand the cost that we bear every day to prepare animals on our places to be used for consumption here in the United States. We can either do, it's not always right, it's not always easy to do something right, but I feel like this is the next step in doing the right thing to help eradicate these hogs. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Okay, members, representative is closed for her bill. it's time to vote on this thing all in favor signify by saying aye aye opposed dang I'm sorry let's back up we can't do that I'm sorry members we didn't have a motion it's a proper time it's past time go ahead and make your motion Mr. Chairman do pass motion do pass sorry members All in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. Opposed? Motion carries. Your bill is passed, Representative Vaught. And let me make this statement right now, but before anybody leaves the room, I feel like it was an oversight to not include the hog hunters and ranchers in the discussion of how to handle this problem. And going forward, if this issue is brought up again, I would encourage whoever is chair of this committee or members to do so. That was oversight, and I apologize to all of you gentlemen for that. But anyway, all right, at this time, members, we're going into, I don't see Representative Fyatt here, Representative Ratliff, or do you want to run your bill today? Okay, and I've got a couple bills. Representative Hammer is not here. I'll tell
▶ Play
Speaker 54 1:36:15
you what, we've got a motion to adjourn. We're adjourned.
▶ Play
Speaker 198 1:36:33
Process is working. Thank you.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1464

1:07 - 5:16 16 segments 4 speakers

HR1023

5:16 - 6:47 3 segments 2 speakers

SB183

6:47 - 11:27 16 segments 4 speakers

HB1569

11:27 - 1:37:14 243 segments 23 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Dan M. Douglas Chair Unverified
66 segments
Representative Mark D. McElroy Unverified
8 segments
Representative Douglas House Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 20
1 segment
Speaker 28
2 segments
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
8 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
14 segments
Representative DeAnn Vaught Unverified
28 segments
Speaker 129
19 segments
Speaker 80
28 segments
Bruce Holland Unverified
5 segments
Representative Lane Jean Unverified
11 segments
Representative Mathew W. Pitsch Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 112
3 segments
Speaker 122
10 segments
Jeremy Sullivan Unverified
9 segments
John David Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 140
2 segments
John Vaught Unverified
7 segments
David Richardson Unverified
12 segments
Speaker 160
1 segment
Speaker 164
8 segments
Speaker 171
10 segments
Speaker 35
1 segment
Speaker 179
10 segments
Speaker 54
1 segment
Speaker 198
1 segment