Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Revenue & Tax Committee

March 5, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (1)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1489 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1489”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
It simply does two things, changes the calculation for individual unemployment insurance benefit using the average highest employees of the last four quarters rather than picking out the single highest quarter in a year and reduces the maximum amount of benefits that you can receive from 25 weeks to 20 weeks. The average Arkansan is on unemployment for 14 and a half weeks. The maximum benefit that Arkansas unemployment pays is $451 and our minimum is $81. And the average Arkansas benefit is $289 and some change. With me is Mike Moore. I'll let him identify himself in a minute here to answer any technical questions. But this is to help stabilize this the years I have followed it in the legislature we've been real high on the balance we've been a bad negative this will bring in some more certainty to the fund and I can answer any questions but I'm gonna let mr. Moore identify himself who he's with and if he has anything to add then we'll we'll entertain any questions yeah
▶ Play
mr. Moore please identify yourself with record and you're free to
▶ Play
Speaker 4 1:23
proceed sir good morning thank you mr. chairman member of the committee. My name is Mike Moore. I'm a lawyer here in Little Rock and work with the state chamber and have been and I'm also on the governor's advisory council with the Department of Workforce Services. I have been involved in drafting this bill. I have obviously followed unemployment in Arkansas for a pretty long time and we have worked through the last several years There's, as most of you all know, I think, some significant problems with the Unemployment Trust Fund being in a negative balance for, I think, four years, maybe five, which cost employers in the last year of the insolvency $180 per employee in extra contributions. We drafted this bill to address two issues. The first is the maximum number of weekly, of weeks of benefits. And we have drafted this bill to reduce that from 25 to 20. As Representative Jean said, the average claim in Arkansas is 14 weeks. So this bill does not touch most of the people who get unemployment. Part of the reason for both of the things, both of the parts of this bill that we've got before you today is that the opponents to this bill will say that the trust fund is solvent. To the extent that the trust fund is positive, that's true. However, the federal government recommends, based upon the calculations that Department Workforce Services have received, that the trust fund should have $642 million in it to be considered solvent. They have the authority to designate what solvency is and penalize employers in the state of Arkansas if the trust fund does not meet those solvency requirements. The current positive balance in the trust fund is $232 million. The Department of Workforce Services projection is that the positive balance in the trust fund at the end of 2016, almost two years from now, will be $360 million. Now, that sounds like a lot of money, except the federal government says it ought to be $642 million. So we're going to have to find some ways to increase our trust fund balance so that we don't run the risk of a penalty with the federal government. And that penalty can be something in the neighborhood of the $180 per employee every employer paid so long as the trust fund was in a negative balance. There are a number of states, including Missouri and Florida, Georgia, South Carolina, North Carolina, and Kansas, that all have maximum weeks of benefit amounts below 20, some down as low as 14. And again, our average is 14.6, I think, weeks. The other portion of the bill is to change the way we calculate the weekly benefit. Currently, it's calculated as a percentage of the weekly wages in the highest quarter of the last four. In Arkansas, there are a lot of businesses that, while not technically seasonal, on a seasonal basis will have employees working a lot of overtime. What happens is the way the law is currently written inflates somebody's weekly benefits to a rate much higher than what their average is for the year. It allows them to get paid benefits on the highest quarter they got, even though most of the year they didn't make that much money. The big problem for us is that Arkansas, the percentage of the average weekly wage in Arkansas is almost 40%. In the contiguous states, the percentage of benefit to the average weekly wage is less than 30%. And in terms of percentage, we are far and away above everybody else, which puts us, of course, at a competitive disadvantage. And so when the unemployment compensation system was put in, it was the primary safety net for people who lost their job. Today, we have a variety of types of benefits that are available to employees. We believe that this change in the weekly benefit calculated based upon all the last four quarters, the base period, as they say, is a much fairer way for everybody and will bring Arkansas in line with the contiguous states for competitive purposes. And I'll be happy
▶ Play
to answer any questions. Mr. Moore, your testimony, you said federal government expects us to have $642 million in the unemployment trust fund. Is there a penalty? Because right now we're off $410 million. And just a quick math, is there a penalty
▶ Play
Speaker 4 7:10
on that from the federal government? Currently not. There isn't anything in place to require that penalty. This is where they're going. This is the suggestions they're making to all the states. Because of what happened in the Great Recession is that there were so many states that had to borrow a lot of money from the federal government. They're increasing their solvency requirements. We're not going to be penalized immediately. That's
▶ Play
their goal that they're telling us we need to see. Is this amount of
▶ Play
Speaker 4 7:44
one-size-fit-all, or is it they're working with each individual state? Each individual state. It's a percentage of claims and a complicated calculation to figure out what they're going to suggest. And it, frankly, has been rather a moving target for the last couple of years because they've been given some mixed signals as far as what's going to
▶ Play
be required. Okay. Can you give us a real-world estimate of somebody making, say, $500 a week based, just simple math, just shoot me a figure for the committee to see if somebody compare now to compare later based on these figures, the 126th of a percent or whatever it is? Well. What difference is somebody going to be making?
▶ Play
Speaker 4 8:28
The average weekly benefit that's being paid is $289.36 currently with a minimum of $81 and a maximum of $451. Our difference in the calculation, I can't give you a... It's going to affect different people differently. I understand. Because somebody who makes the same amount every week for the year is going to make the same amount. It's not, if I've got somebody who has steady earnings throughout the year, when they become unemployed, the second part of this bill that I just testified about will not affect them at all. Thank
▶ Play
you. Representative Meeks, you're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chairman. A question about the math on the calculation here Help me to make sure we're not about to make a major goof here. We're looking at the four quarters prior. Four quarters, it's a full year. That's 52 weeks. Now, according to the bill, what we're going to do is we're going to take their average over a year and divide it by 26. That's half of a year. So shouldn't we be dividing that by 52 instead of 26? is if we're just going to divide the average over a year by 26, we're in effect going to be giving them a check that's
▶ Play
Speaker 4 9:57
doubled every week. That's the way it's always been calculated is to divide it by 26. So we're staying with that formula. It's just what we're doing is catching more
▶ Play
Speaker 32 10:08
months of earnings there. Right.
▶ Play
I know we used to do 26 weeks, and I think that's why it was divided by 26. According to this, we're going to take, according to what the bill says, we're going to take the workers' weekly benefit amount shall equal 1 26th of the average of the entire year. So, I mean, if we're going to drop, I mean, either we need to make that 1 52nd to do a year, or if we're going to do 20 weeks, shouldn't it be 1, or maybe 1 20th? so I'm not understanding why we're staying at 126 I want to make sure I understand what you're trying to do I want to make sure the language in the law gets us to where we need to be but right now the way I read it and please correct me if I'm wrong is we're going to take 126 of their average for the year and that's how we're going to come up with a calculation so the net effect would be whatever their weekly in the $500 a week we would, in fact, be paying them $1,000 a week in unemployment
▶ Play
Speaker 4 11:16
benefits. No, we're actually going to pay them the same weekly
▶ Play
benefit. And I know that's the goal, but I'm reading what the language of the law is going to say.
▶ Play
Speaker 4 11:27
I don't know how you get to that. Because we have always determined the weekly benefit amount as a percentage of the 126th, this is going to keep that consistent. Okay, so the only difference in this calculation is going to be the number at the top of the equation. That's all we're changing. Then? Then the first part of the bill reduces the number of weeks you can receive that from 25 to 26. Right. And originally,
▶ Play
it was, before we came in last year, it was 26, which is where the 126th.
▶ Play
Speaker 4 12:07
It was actually 2011 that we went from 26 to 25. Right. And so the only thing, and I'll talk about the first part of the bill and the second part of the bill. The second part of the bill, the only change that makes is in
▶ Play
the top number of the equation. Okay, that's the main question I
▶ Play
had was that one. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. About as clear as mud. Okay. Representative McGill, you're recognized, sir. Do you have a question, sir? Okay. Okay. Representative Flowers, you
▶ Play
have a question now. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You bet. I'm wondering, just I guess I'm trying to figure out the justification and the basis that you explained, and And I'm wondering, if the goal is to get to the recommended amount in the trust fund, if growth in our economy remained the same, when would that happen? And how many other states fall below that recommended trust fund balance that the federal government recommends?
▶ Play
Speaker 4 13:23
I do not know that the Department of Workforce Services has calculated how long it would take without changes to the law to reach that suggested solvency level of the federal government. Obviously, if we stay as we are, we're less than halfway there by the end of next year. We don't know at what point in time they're going to put in required solvency levels that will trigger a penalty if
▶ Play
we don't reach them. Right now, they're
▶ Play
Speaker 4 13:56
not required, right? The penalties are not in place at this time. As far as other states, I'll say two things. I believe that most states would still be under what the recommended solvency levels are because almost everybody was so low after the Great Recession. Right. I do know that the states that have done the best for solvency change, the most positive change, are North Carolina, South Carolina, those states which have reduced their maximum number of weeks that a claimant can claim benefits. And remember, our average claim length is now 14.6 weeks. And so this will only affect a relatively small number of people at the top end of that curve.
▶ Play
Mr. Chair? You bet. So when we talk about averages, and you mentioned that the average number of weeks, so just in terms of the time frame of benefits that are allowable right now, You're saying that it's 25 weeks. The average is 14, which means that there still is a relatively significant proportion of people who need benefits and you take advantage of those benefits beyond the average. Do you have any idea what that percentage looks like? I don't believe that
▶ Play
Speaker 4 15:29
the Department has calculated for each week above that how many people drop out of the process. So, no, ma'am, I don't. Is anyone from the department here today? I don't think so. Do you have another question?
▶ Play
I do have more questions, but I just, I guess my great discomfort in this process here today is considering something so significant without the agency that it would affect being here to provide data I mean I'm hearing data in the affirmative for the bill but the agency that's responsible for for these dollars and for this program they aren't here to answer pertinent questions that I think we need
▶ Play
to hear to make this decision well I don't understand your concern ma'am but also I would say that you know we all knew that this bill was coming today to do our due diligence with this bill as well so I'm not trying to be belligerent to you, but that's how come we
▶ Play
put these out to everybody do the due diligence. I guess just as a matter of transparency, I mean, we all have it. We're all here, but we film our meetings for a reason so that the public can hear. Today is a snow day, so I imagine a lot of people who would normally be here aren't here, and maybe that includes workforce services. I don't know. So noted,
▶ Play
ma'am. Members, any other questions from the committee? Representative Tucker.
▶ Play
Speaker 54 17:09
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Is the primary impetus for
▶ Play
the bill the penalty from the federal government that you're concerned about, or is it something else?
▶ Play
Speaker 4 17:20
Well, the primary impetus for the bill is to ensure that we remain solvent and that we have the kind of trust fund balance that we need to avoid getting into the position we got into last time. I mean, the fear out there to be in a negative trust fund situation and for employers to have to pay what amounts to a penalty because the department has to borrow millions and millions of dollars is what we're driving at, trying to be financially responsible for the state.
▶ Play
You talked about where the trust fund is projected to be in the next few years by the Department of Workforce Services. I guess I'm just curious about I understand the Great Recession and every state had an issue there and I also understand that the way these trust fund balances work are they go down in times of recession and go back up in times of economic recovery which is what we're doing now and so I understand we're at a low point in 2010 But my question is how the current balance and where it's projected to be in the next two years compares historically with those sorts of economic ups and downs.
▶ Play
Speaker 4 18:40
The highest trust fund balance we've ever had, according to the information I have, is $265 million in 2000. The federal government says we need well more than twice that to be what they consider solvent. And while we are almost to that level now, I think that what happened is that the recession told everybody that their ideas of solvency were not correct, that it needs to be a much more solvent trust fund in order to survive what might happen.
▶ Play
So I'm personally not as concerned about the federal government penalty because it's a theoretical possibility right now at some point in the future when we don't know when that will be. And so I'm just kind of more concerned, as you said, the impetus for the bill is just having a solvent trust fund for our own purposes here in Arkansas. So my understanding is that our trust fund right now and where it's projected to be is a record all-time high in our state's history. Do I understand that correctly? Absolutely. And with unemployment going down and a solid economic recovery, are there concerns about
▶ Play
Speaker 4 20:01
it becoming insolvent for the rest of this decade? Well, I will tell you that the projections we have from the Department of Workforce Services or that in 2016, the stabilization rate tax that's currently in place will reduce the rate employers pay. So at some point in time in the next two to three years, contributions are going to go down if nothing changes. And so if contributions are going to go down and we don't make any corresponding reduction in benefits paid, our trust fund balance will go down even in a good time. Contributions from employers, is that right?
▶ Play
Yes, absolutely. I have a few more questions, but I'll let somebody else take a turn.
▶ Play
Yes, sir, Mr. Lemons. You recognize, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Let's go one step further with this. What I see this is an opportunity for Arkansas to be competitive. And from that, I'm a small business owner. I pay in substantially to unemployment insurance for my people. So, therefore, I'm paying it at a higher rate than a like firm that would be located in any other state. So I could see this as being in a roundabout way. This could be for job creation and make Arkansas more attractive when they compare
▶ Play
Speaker 4 21:41
us to neighboring states. Is that true? Absolutely. The percentage of the weekly earnings is, I was shocked when I saw that number, that we are that high above the median of the surrounding states as a percentage of weekly wages. We have low weekly wages and high benefits.
▶ Play
Follow-up? If you could, the only thing I have a problem with is, like Representative Meeks brought out, the 126 that's in the bill. I understand that's not being changed, but can you kind of take us through the calculation real briefly and kind of put our mind at ease on that? Hold
▶ Play
that thought just a second. I'm going to recognize Representative Collins. I think he has probably got his hands wrapped around this.
▶ Play
Thank you. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. And Representative Lemons, I think what Representative Meeks called out is a little bit of a question in some of our minds. And, you know, I'm not a lawyer. You know, I wouldn't claim to be an expert mathematician. But I'm confused enough to want to insist that people take a look at this. So here's what, and I guess this would be a question for Representative Gene since this is his bill, but hopefully, if this makes sense to Representative Gene, we may or may not need to tweak that formula because of the way the words are changed to make sure that we're delivering exactly what we intend. In other words, there may be a technical correction in the language that's needed, or there may not. The folks think they've done it right. Regardless, they're going to take a look at it and make sure. So if there's no change, everything just moves smoothly if we pass the bill out. If they do need to change it, they're committed to not having an incorrect formula. This would be a technicality that Representative Meeks caught. So that's why if we pass the bill out now, we don't slow it down. If it does need to be slowed down for an amendment, that would happen on the Senate side, different than other situations where we knew we needed an amendment, in which case we might as well go ahead and get it done here. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. I appreciate that. Representative Lane, if you want to think on that, fine. Or if you want to
▶ Play
answer, of course, it's your prerogative. I might have something else to say to that before we get to that point, if you don't care. Representative Lemons, are you done, sir? Yes, sir. Any
▶ Play
other members speaking for or against the bill? Go ahead. I appreciate your indulgence with me this morning. One just more question I have is about that federal number that you mentioned. If we make this adjustment, does that adjust from the federal government's perspective what our solvency number should
▶ Play
Speaker 58 24:12
be? No. It just gets us there faster. Can you explain
▶ Play
that? I just don't understand that because I just don't understand how it gets us to $642 million because the benefits will be less, right?
▶ Play
Speaker 4 24:30
The benefits will be less, and therefore we have more contribution and less payout. So we increase the trust fund towards that number. The trust fund, and I'll be honest with you, I can't tell you the formula that they use to determine what their solvency recommendation is, but it doesn't involve the number of weeks paid or the average weekly. It's more global. So we'll
▶ Play
Speaker 42 24:58
have more contribution from employers as a result of this? Is that what you're telling me? Ultimately, yes,
▶ Play
Speaker 4 25:04
but neither of these have to do with contributions. These have to do with the expense side to the business of the Department of
▶ Play
Workforce Services. You bet. Representative Meeks,
▶ Play
you recognize her? Thank you. Mr. Chairman, I'm going to ask a question that may kind of clear up what I was asking earlier. Using the example of someone who's making an average of $500 a week, What would their weekly benefit be expected to be typically under this formula? Would they be expected to make $500 a week or $250 a week roughly?
▶ Play
Speaker 4 25:41
No. I'm trying to remember the formula calculation because it's not that simple. There's another percentage that's added to it, and I don't have that in front of me, and I apologize. Okay. But just,
▶ Play
and I spoke with Mr. Zook a little bit ago, but the person making $500 a week is not going to make $500 a week. They're probably going to make close to that $250 mark.
▶ Play
Speaker 4 26:06
Right. Okay. I mean, I'll put it to you this way. The average unemployment as a percentage of the weekly wage is 40%. Okay. So on an average basis, somebody who's making $500 a week is going to make $200 a week. Okay. All right. And that's the formula
▶ Play
based on what we've got. The new formula, they would make $250 a week. So that sounds to be in line with where we need to be. So I think we're fine there. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Members, are
▶ Play
there any questions? Representative Cazales, you recognize her? Thank you,
▶ Play
Speaker 81 26:38
Mr. Chair. What did you say the maximum there
▶ Play
Speaker 4 26:42
ever had been in the trust fund is? The information I have is $265 million in 2000. And what's in there now? $232
▶ Play
Speaker 83 26:52
million. And at what point did it go bankrupt and we had to borrow money from the federal government? 2010? So
▶ Play
Speaker 4 27:00
that – 2008 we started. I think 2010 we were at the bottom and started our way back up. So that
▶ Play
Speaker 83 27:07
makes it hard to argue that the trust fund
▶ Play
Speaker 4 27:11
is solvent now? Well, the trust fund is not solvent.
▶ Play
Speaker 83 27:15
That's what I'm saying. You said at the start of this that some people would argue that the trust fund is solvent now. That kind of makes
▶ Play
it hard to argue that point, doesn't it? Yeah.
▶ Play
Speaker 4 27:36
Thank you. Representative Flowers, you recognize, ma'am. So just to clarify, what is solvent? Solvent is reaching a, according to the federal government, reaching a positive balance so that with a particular level of unemployment, you will still have money in your trust fund and won't have to borrow from the federal government. It's not a zero balance is not solvent, at least based upon what the Federal Department of Labor says. So we don't
▶ Play
have a zero balance, though, right? No, we don't. And we're not borrowing money from the
▶ Play
Speaker 4 28:10
federal government? Not this year, we're not. We have finally, and I believe it was October of last year, finally paid the last of that debt off.
▶ Play
So we paid the debt off from borrowing that took place in that last year or the borrowing took place back in 2008? We borrowed
▶ Play
Speaker 4 28:34
from 2008 to 2010, and it took us that long to pay it back. We were negative all that time. As a result,
▶ Play
though, of the Great Recession, like many other states. Yeah, we
▶ Play
Speaker 4 28:49
were not by any means the only state to be in that position.
▶ Play
And would you say compared to other states that we were probably in better shape? Oh,
▶ Play
Speaker 4 29:01
I think there were a lot of states in worse shape
▶ Play
than we were. Yeah. Well, I guess, and I don't even know if it matters, but the word solvent is being sort of thrown around as if we're not or we are, and I'm just trying to get clarity because it sounds like with the definition you gave, we're solvent, but we're not solvent at the level that's recommended.
▶ Play
Speaker 4 29:25
Well, solvency, some people would argue that solvency means we have a positive balance. But that's not, I don't believe that's the case, and the federal government doesn't believe that's the
▶ Play
case. I'm not, that's not my understanding. That's why I asked you the definition. And based on your definition, we are solvent and have been because we haven't borrowed since 2010. So we've been solvent and are solvent, but we have not reached the level of solvency that's recommended because we're not borrowing and we're able to pay out our unemployment and we have money in our trust fund,
▶ Play
Speaker 4 30:08
correct? We've been solvent for, I think, four months since we paid off the debt. I mean, we're just barely out of the debt situation. So we are solvent. Yes, but the federal government ultimately will decide how solvent we have to be. I just wanted to
▶ Play
clarify because it sounded like there was some confusion about whether right now we are solvent. We are solvent now.
▶ Play
Speaker 83 30:31
Okay, thank you. Reverend Gonzalez, you recognize her? Well, if your definition of solvency is that you have enough money in there that it will not go negative or hopefully will not go negative, then no, we are not solvent, correct? Because we had more money and we did go negative. If things turn around, we will be negative quickly. And we paid this money, the money that we borrowed, we paid back on the backs of our small businesses,
▶ Play
Speaker 4 31:00
correct? on the backs of all of our businesses and the employees. That was $180 per employee that couldn't be spent for somebody else's
▶ Play
wages. Thank you. Representative McGill,
▶ Play
you're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I appreciate all the information. My concern and question is, if we go to 20 weeks, impact would that have on and what number of our Arkansans that have lost a job or are unemployed what would that number look like
▶ Play
Speaker 4 31:35
I can't tell you the number of employees who are currently above 20 weeks I know that changes all the time obviously in the last two or three years our average weekly the average length of claim has dropped as employment has raised, and that continues to do so. And as employment continues to get better in Arkansas, the numbers of people who go 20 weeks drop.
▶ Play
And I guess that's my concern. As we get better, you talked about the safety net. this unemployment thing is a safety net for Arkansans that were once employed and doing good work but for whatever reason they're unemployed and Arkansas to me has always been a compassionate state and looked after those that were hurting in some form and unemployment is going to pay them $200 a week where they may have been making $700-$800 a week I like the idea of having a great safety net and we're doing things better the economy is changing again I'm just interested in what we do for those that could be impacted by this. Thank you Mr. Chair
▶ Play
Representative Tucker you're recognized sir one
▶ Play
more follow up question to something Representative Flowers raised earlier there's no representative from the Department of Workforce Services today and I just was curious whether you guys worked with that agency or with any other organization on behalf of employees and if you reached some sort of agreement or if you just collected input from people from a variety of perspectives on this before you
▶ Play
Speaker 4 33:34
brought it to the table. We have worked with the Department of Workforce Services and they did see and had an opportunity to comment on the bill as before it was introduced. And that's why the question about the 26, the 126, they've reviewed the bill, and I don't think there's a technical correction that would be needed because they didn't make a comment as to whether that needed changing. Any other questions, members? Anybody in
▶ Play
the audience want to speak against the bill? Mr. Allen Hughes please come to the table and recognize yourself Thank you Mr. Chair Excuse me a second Allen do you have a handout members we're going to pass out a handout for Mr. Hughes here and while they're passing it out go ahead and recognize yourself for
▶ Play
Speaker 103 34:30
the record sir Allen Hughes is it on Allen
▶ Play
My name is Alan Hughes, president of the Arkansas AFL-CO here in the state of Arkansas. Go ahead, Mr. Hughes, you recognize her. Representing workers in Arkansas, not all workers. I am over the unions, but we're usually at the end of this table speaking up for those that have trouble getting representation because they're not here. I was hoping to have a crowd of people here today to testify on how this would affect them. Workers are actually drawing these wages and what it would do to them as far as putting groceries on their table, paying their electric bills, they're taking care of their car insurance, house insurance. The main thing is taking care of their families. We believe House Bill 1489 is an unnecessary legislation that will harm employed workers and families and Arkansas business because we believe every dollar spent immediately goes right back in the economy twice. that's always been the history of this reduce unemployment benefits restrict informally to calculate workers' weekly benefits amount and two, reducing the number of weeks workers can draw benefits from 2025 will harm them. House Bill 1489 would reduce benefits to unemployed workers by $50 million you would be taking out of the economy right then without a justifiable reason, we believe. As of December 1, 2014, our employment trust fund balance was $236 million. Department of Workforce Services projects that our trust fund balance will increase to $333 million at the end of 2015 and $369 million at the end of 2016. With the exception of the current trust fund balance, The highest trust fund balance for the last 12 years was we got a number of $160 million in 2006. Our trust fund balance by the end of 2016 will be, like I said, $369 million or $209 million higher than the previous in 2006. Even unemployment trust funds in the country face solvency problems as a result of the recent recession. The Arkansas Trust Fund has returned sovereignty largely due to the direct cuts of unemployment benefits back in 2011, which at that time we always believe everyone should have a skin in the game, as we called it. You're talking about cutting benefits right now to workers, but we hear that their company side, business side's premiums are going to go down. Where's everybody having a skin in the game? It sounds like one group's having the skin in the game, and that's the unemployed workers at no fault of their own. I've been going around and talking to legislators and others, and I know in everything, I believe, there's a bad seat. Somebody says, well, they need to go to work. I'm going to ask you something. If you're in Crosswood, Arkansas, and you have a plywood plant shut down like it did, and you've got nearly 800 people employed there, and that affects other jobs in that town, How are you going to find unemployment for 700 to 800 people not counting the chain reaction coming up in this amount of time? It's not easy. That's rural areas. I can give you example after example. Go to Whirlpool. Look at the big layoff over there. They're all over the place. And there's still an amount of people there. You're giving the 14% or whatever it was a while ago. There's a lot of people that's going to be hit by this at no fault of their own. I wish we could come up with a cure if there's a problem that people feel like people aren't trying to get back in the workforce. I wish we had that golden egg that we could sit here together and deliver to you. But you're punishing the ones at no fault of their own, the ones that are out there trying to find work that are struggling. And I don't think it's right. Our people don't think it's right. Like I said, I was hoping to have some people here today to testify on these concerns. but think about it when you start talking about I've come we've come up with a number of like $21 is what it would affect them per paycheck take $21 off the grocery table trying to feed a family of four I've got a dog stepdaughter drinks two gallons of milk every week and it's nearly $3 or $4 eggs same way that's the necessities it's hard to do you're putting this burden on them the Act 861 was the blow that passed last time. We fought this battle. We pleaded and depleted, asking you not to do that. We're here asking you again today not to do that. According to Arkansas Hunger Relief Alliance, representing 400 food banks within our state, Arkansas has one of the highest rates of food insecurity in the nation. More than 28% of the Arkansas families with children experience food insecurity on a regular basis. of families without children, 19% may not know if they can obtain their next meal. Passage of 1489 greatly worsens the state's current food insecurity crisis. If you count the numbers that we heard a while ago, we paid, I think it was 200-something million dollars we paid off in that debt with no interest charged to us. I didn't know anything today about the 642 excuse me I'll talk with my hands we've always talked about trying to get that fund up to 500 million before this all occurred we've never been able to do it because cuts kept coming you look at the weeks I ask you these other states that are referred to are their wages higher than ours are their state wages higher maybe that's got a little bit to deal with about There's lower because they're drawing a higher wage or minimum wages or other areas. But I was doing the math a while ago, and if we're supposed to be up to $369 million at the end of 2016, you add a few more years and we're looking at growing at $90-something million a year, we're not that far off. So why would we turn around and try to do this now? we've been a lot lower unemployment's going down I believe we're in that recovery I'd love it if it was like Representative Meek said while ago that $1,000 I could go back to him and say I did good today guys but it's not there and I'm asking you to reconsider if you've thought about this bill and committed to it to reconsider and not do this to the unfortunate ones that are unemployed in the state of Arkansas I don't believe it serves the law there's a last piece of your pass out on the last page it's referring to an article and stuff talking about what the purpose of this was and I'd hope to have a legal counsel here today with us but he's not available because he's like a lot of the other others what we wanted was snowed in I ask you once again if you could please vote against this and reconsider not I mean if we're going to all have a skin in the game let's let everybody have a skin on the game Let's make sure everybody puts into this, make sure if we've got to get to that $642, it's done by everyone. I'll try to answer any questions if there
▶ Play
are any. Thank you, Mr. Hughes. Mr. Representative Meeks, you recognize,
▶ Play
sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just one question. On your handout here, you said that it would reduce unemployed workers by $50 million per year. Where did you get that number at? How did you come up with that calculation? I wish I had ESD here. Once again, we're
▶ Play
in the situation. I was hoping to have someone here could answer that for you today because our legal counselor that serves on the advisory committee was one to help furnish this. He represents us on that committee, and he's not able to be here today. I've got furnished this material from him. Okay, so he's the one
▶ Play
that came up with this number, and we don't know where he got it from. Well, it came from the cuts. If you're talking about
▶ Play
$21, I'm assuming. And I can't tell you that. I'd have to have him here. There's something to come
▶ Play
out of that advisory committee, and Mr. Moore might be able to answer this question. Yeah, I'm just curious. Thank you.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Members, are there any questions for Mr. Hughes? If not, anybody else is here to speak for the bill, against the bill. Representative
▶ Play
Lane, Gene, you want to close for your bill, sir? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members, you know, the testimony here today, and this is something that I don't take light, but I take the email that I got from Bubba Smith. He owns a lumberyard in Magnolia, employs about 65 people. This is going to help him with his insurance, unemployment insurance. And I think the state chamber's own numbers have shown since 2008, the state of Arkansas was down 60,000 private sector jobs, not counting the public, we're up on public sector jobs. This is to help the people that, in your community, the small business and the large, it helps everyone, the employers, the people that have payrolls, they are requesting this. It's a bill that I think has some reason in it. When you feel like that 14 and a half weeks is average unemployment, this is 20, much higher than the average and I would appreciate a good vote and I move do pass on this bill Members we have a motion
▶ Play
for do pass. Any discussion? Representative Lane Jeans made a motion for do pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed say no. No. Chair recognizes that the ayes have it. Congratulations Representative Jeans. You passed your bill. You bet. Members just kind of doing a little bit of housekeeping things. Next Tuesday, we're going to have a special order of business with Representative Charlene Fights, Bill 1412. Everybody, please understand that this will not be a motion made on this bill. This is going to be for educational purposes only. Speaker has indicated he still does not want to open up this committee for tax cut bills. So she wants to bring her veterans in to just discuss the bill. So when she gets here, please, nobody make the motion for a do pass or unattended consequences might prevail. So don't want that to happen. Also, next, what night is that? On the 10th will be a committee dinner at 6 o'clock at the Wyndham. So put that on your calendars also. Any other discussion, members? If not, this meeting is adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1489

0:36 - 45:49 167 segments 17 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Lane Jean Unverified
6 segments
Representative Joe Jett Chair Unverified
22 segments
Speaker 4
59 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
14 segments
Speaker 32
1 segment
Representative Vivian Flowers Unverified
18 segments
Speaker 54
1 segment
Representative Clarke Tucker Unverified
11 segments
Representative Tim Lemons Unverified
3 segments
Representative Charlie Collins Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 58
1 segment
Speaker 42
1 segment
Speaker 81
1 segment
Speaker 83
4 segments
Representative George B. McGill Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 103
1 segment
Alan Hughes Unverified
19 segments