Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Public Health, Welfare and Labor Committee

March 10, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (11)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1452 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1452”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1008 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1008”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1160 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1160”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1192 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1192”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1276 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1276”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1407 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1407”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1466 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1466”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1497 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1497”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1533 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…y Representative Douglas. And then the third order would be House Bill 1533 by Ferguson. and I think all three have people coming in fr…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1747 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…to be in. I mean, the order as people asked. First would be House Bill 1747 by Representative Sullivan.”
Pre-2017 bill
SB101 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “in 2013 Act 1453 and as appropriated for in this year's Senate Bill 101. And if you don't have that bill, I have hard copies of it,…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
Unknown speaker 0:00
. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. We've got a bunch of organizational stuff to do before we get started. Hi, members. I see a quorum seated already. We've got some organizational things to do. I want to go over with you. When we say without objection, if there is an objection, I'm welcome to hear it, but I don't know why we would. We want to set three special orders of business for Thursday. In this order, this is the order that people asked to be in. I mean, the order as people asked. First would be House Bill 1747 by Representative Sullivan. Isn't that right, Representative Sullivan? Okay. Okay. So the first order of business on Thursday, again without objection, is 1747 by Representative Sullivan. The second special order of business is 1142. That's by Representative Douglas. And then the third order would be House Bill 1533 by Ferguson. and I think all three have people coming in from distances far, far away in order to testify, and that's the purpose of this. It's not that they're highly controversial necessarily. It's just that they've got witnesses coming from a great deal of distance to be here, and considering the packed agenda we have, it's easy to get run over if you don't set a special order of business. We're going to set those three without objection in seeing none to special order of business on Thursday. Also, Representative Murdoch has requested that his bill 1009 be removed from deferred, so we will move that into the active calendar, and I'm sure we will hear that on Thursday. First order of business, Representative Hammer, I think you're at the end of the table. You need to concur a Senate amendment on 1407, and then we will hear your bill 1160. So, Representative Hammer, you are recognized to tell us the amendment on 1407, or, yeah, for concurrence. Thank you, Mr. Chair. If I'm not mistaken, that amendment... S1 and S2 Alright, there are two amendments that we're concurring Representative Hammer, they're on your tablet S1 and S2 And I'm trying to pull them up myself right now It looks like we said Added Senator Cooper as a co-sponsor That's on S2 No, I'm sorry S1 And S2, it looks like we added Hmm Looks like they both say that we added Senator Cooper. We're looking to see if that's right. We only need one. We'll hear your one amendment, which is 1407-S1 on the tablet, and that adds Senator Cooper as a co-sponsor of the bill. so I guess I've explained your amendment any questions on Representative Hammer's amendment? I have a question yes sir I'm not surprised appreciate a good vote yes sir seeing no questions seeing no one from the audience to speak for or against the bill do concur the amendment, the Senate amendment all those in favor, aye any opposed congratulations we have we have done that now you're one one six zero your bill that you're going to present you're recognized thank you mr. chair mask a point of clarification sure is this the final time for this bill to be heard your bill is not had a vote yet this would be if we vote on it today would be the first vote so it can be heard twice you can you can have two votes in a committee thank you what I'd like to do mr. chair is I have a statement prepared and then at the discretion chair however you'd like to like to proceed I'd like to begin by dispelling a rumor that has been brought to my attention by actually a couple individuals but specifically yesterday I was approached by one legislator that said that he or she had heard that my intent for running this bill was because I have some immediate family members that are in the nursing field I'd like to dispel that publicly and say that my motivation for running this bill is not for personal gain. I do not have a nurse in my family. My daughter was in nursing school, but she has taken a step aside in order to have our fourth grandchild do not have a doctor in the family. So if you've heard that rumor, you can dispel it and consider the source of it to be inaccurate and false and should not be given any merit or credit. Actually, the reason this bill is being run is for the citizens of the state of Arkansas that exist in counties that have been recognized in law as being a medically underserved area. The amendment that was added to this bill addresses some of the concerns expressed, including identifying the specific counties recognized as underserved areas established in law in 2013 Act 1453 and as appropriated for in this year's Senate Bill 101. And if you don't have that bill, I have hard copies of it, and you'll find that actually there are some individuals that are members of this committee that sponsored that back in 2013. Also creating a subcommittee of the Arkansas Board of Nursing comprised of five APRNs that will make recommendations to the full board for approval of permits to address the concern about those that have the authority and the level of expertise in order to grant those permits. It also allows APRNs who are willing to make a commitment to go to the medically underserved area the ability to be grandfathered in should the county be removed from the list, which should be the goal of all reasonably-minded health care providers. at the same time stopping permits from being issued once the county is removed so that this would not be a constant movement. On the basis of trying to provide an accurate snapshot of both past history and current trends, I've asked legislative research to affirm the key critical information that reflects whether or not we are giving medically underserved areas the full resources they deserve to provide fair and equitable access to all citizens. This included expanding the snapshot of the number of physicians in each county listed in the bill from a two-year window to a five-year window and also an area to consider of one criteria is that the eligible to be federally designated as a health professional shortage area if the county has fewer than one primary care physician for every 3,500 people. In 2013 there were 10 counties with county-wide ratios of fewer than one primary care physician per 3,500 people. Eight of these are in this bill and two are not. The two that are not are Newton and Perry, and the eight counties that fit this designation of one physician per 3,500 people include Cleveland, Grant, Izzard, Lafayette, Lincoln, Marion, Poinsettia, and Prairie. The majority of the rest all fall under other criteria that show that the needs exist to improve accessibility. The numbers support that the trend is not for physicians to move to these underserved areas but to gravitate toward the more populated areas, even in the counties that are listed in this bill. It is my belief that we should not limit, let alone deny the citizens of Arkansas, especially those who lived in medically underserved areas, full access to competent and licensed medical professionals in order to meet their medical needs. Our decision should be driven to provide the consumer the opportunity to select who they want to provide their medical services within the scope of practice defined in the law. In the past week, we passed in this committee without opposition a bill that allows paramedics to offer face-to-face services to those individuals in their community that have already a history of serious illness, serious enough to have been hospitalized and now are at home, and those medics, which are going to have to meet a higher criteria of scope of practice, are going to be offering face-to-face to those patients. A move that was presented on the basis of reducing re-entries to the ER hospital, providing face-to-face environment, and save the hospital's money. So it begs the question, so why would we want to prohibit APRNs the same opportunity to operate up to the level of their scope of practice and be financially rewarded? APRNs who have already proven their ability to function safely within their scope of practice and are competent enough to be employed by physicians for the purpose of being able to offer greater accessibility. and APRNs who, with the amendment represented in this bill, have to be recommended to a committee of peers equivalent to their level of training. It should also be noted that the U.S. Supreme Court decision, North Carolina State Board of Dental Examiners v. Federal Trade Commission, affirmed that the state regulatory boards are not exempt from federal antitrust suits. The ruling upheld the FTC's previous stance that the dental board's actions constitute an illegal suppression of competition. It should also be noted that in over 29 states currently, APRNs have 100% full reimbursement. In this committee, we passed a bill to allow medical students who cannot find internships the opportunity to utilize their skills up to their level of training. And we just passed a law that would allow a task force to come together to determine what is the best way for us to meet all the medical needs of the state of Arkansas. We should give them that option in their consideration. and on no less than two occasions in testimony that was given at the last committee meeting physicians who made statements that they would no longer offer particular services under their scope of practice for reasons not stated but the statement was made nonetheless. So why should there be a choice to discontinue services but an option for others who want to offer services up to their scope of practice be denied that ability? In fact, I would point out to you that in the bill that was passed back in 2013 on the last page it actually has an escape clause for physicians that no longer want to practice in those particular areas that they could be released without any penalty. Let me bring my comments to an end by asking you to consider the following when you vote. This is not a matter of pitting two occupations against each other, but instead an opportunity to give the consumer a choice and giving the providers the opportunity to offer their scope of practice with ample accountability built in to assure competent care is given and equality for pay is rendered. We have a long established history of having medically underserved areas in the state. What is one of the main contributors that has caused us to retain 39 counties mentioned in law to be recognized as medically underserved areas so much that they, for two years, have been identified that way in statute? It's because of limited medical personnel to meet the need is a main contributor. Does anyone at this table really believe that if the private option of the Affordable Care Act goes away or if we take on any more citizens in the state, that we're going to be able to supply the need, especially if the private option goes away, and then who will be the ones that will be available to offer them services. I've not tried to influence any of you with false claims or misrepresentations, but instead my push has been because there is an underserved population that does not need to be denied access to care because at the end of the day, not only does the individual who cannot gain access pay, but we all pay as the citizens of Arkansas in higher insurance premiums and more taxes. One of the stated fears that has been expressed through emails and verbal comments is that medical students will be discouraged from entering the medical field and their ability to pay for medical school will be threatened. My response to those fears are this. We have to be aware that consumers should be in control of their choice. They pay the premiums, they invest in the health account savings, and also the state subsidize those costs. Is the number of medical students choosing to enter family practice that is the most equal of comparison to the role of APRN increasing or decreasing? Is the number of medical students who graduate and choose to go into practice in medically underserved areas increasing or decreasing or flat rate at best? And if physicians can bill 3.5 times as many billing codes as available to nurse practitioners, which equates to APRNs billing 2,683 codes to 9,361 codes for physicians where it's disparity. And then finally add to that the fact that physician assistants are able to bill at 100% rate. If you believe in equal pay for equal skills then you should vote for this bill. And if you believe there should not be a double standard that allows for a person to be competent enough to work in one environment and billing being charged to the full rate for those services but that same person not be able to go out and offer their services on their own and bill for them at the full rate, then you should vote for this bill. To say that I have doctors who are angry with me for even proposing this legislation would be an understatement. And to say that I have doctors who have talked to me and said that they do not feel threatened by this legislation is not an overstatement. To say that every APRN is going to rush out to these underserved areas is no more realistic than to think that it is the desire of every medical student standing in this room today is going to go out to practice in all 39 of these medically underserved areas. But finally, we should be able to say to the citizens that you have a choice to choose who they want to see for their medical needs up to the scope that one is allowed to practice is a right that we should give to the citizens and reward those who financially are willing to invest in those medically underserved areas because when we do, we all win in improving Arkansas health care. We're going to step on the floor this afternoon. We're going to introduce a nurse of the day and the doctor of the day. If I was to have a heart attack on the floor, each one of them would be competent in order to be able to come and render aid to me. If I had to have further such as surgery beyond that, my APRN wouldn't be able to do that, but my doctor would. All I'm asking is that up to the ceiling that they have the full right to operate within their scope of practice, that we pay them equally, and as a result of that, we're going to make a better Arkansas because we're going to make a more healthy Arkansas. And with that, Mr. Chair, I would ask for a good vote, and I do introduce a motion, do pass. May I be sure an explanation of the vote? Bill, Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a question. thank you Mr. Chair my question is this I think you mentioned in other states that APRNs are allowed to do what you're proposing to do can you tell me the good and the bad of what other states have experienced with allowing this to happen I don't know that I could specifically get to the weeds and the detail but I guess I'd answer your question by this way the growing trend is to allow APRNs to have more access to the population in order to be able to offer care I think if it was a bad experience in going in the wrong directions, the numbers wouldn't be going up. Okay, and follow-up, if I could, Mr. Chair. Yes, sir. And my follow-up is this, and you may have addressed this and I may have just missed it. What happens if you have an APRN in a county, you know, doing what the bill is proposed to do, and then that county comes off the medically underserved list? What happens to that APRN? Yes, sir, and that was actually a concern that Representative Payton had mentioned, and I addressed that through the amendment. What would happen is in these medically underserved counties, this bill is able to get through and get voted into law. If an APRN goes into that county and it comes off that designated list, there would be no more permits for APRNs to be able to function in that county, but they would be grandfathered in and be able to remain in there. So our goal and objective is that if we do see a surge of APRNs who want to move into those counties, we want to get all those counties off the list, and that will resolve this issue. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yes, sir. Representative Brant is going to be recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative Hammer, has there been a physical impact on this bill? I mean, if this bill were to pass and then the APNs are bumped up to what the doctors are paid, I mean, it's got to be a tremendous impact on our Medicaid budget, I would think. Have you done any figures on that? No, sir, because I don't see the necessity for it driven out of two or three reasons that just pop in my head. Number one, if the physicians were going into those areas, we'd be paying that expense anyway, so what's the difference, number one? Number two, that we want that expense is going to be covered because the services ought to be provided now, but the problem is they're not being provided now, and so the expense ought to be covered in the budget anyway, So I really don't see the need for a fiscal impact because if the providers were there, the need would be taken care of. Well, I sort of disagree with that because if this bill would have passed, then an APN that's doing a service already is going to be bumped up to the doctor's feet. Is that not correct? Well, if the doctor goes out there and there's no need for APRNs to go out there, the doctor is going to bill at the 100% rate. So if the APRN is able to go out there and bill at the 100% rate because there's an absence of doctors, then it's going to be revenue neutral. The cost is going to be there regardless of whoever's fulfilling the position. I disagree with that. All right, thank you. Bobri, you have a question, ma'am? You're recognized. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. How many counties are you talking about here? I'm talking about the counties, and I have hard copies. if the chair would like to pass them out that are in the bill that was enacted in 2013. I just need to know how many. 39. And that's the same 39 that's in the bill, isn't it, Representative Hammer? I'm sorry, I stand corrected. 39 plus 1 because it was in the red chart and it was on the basis of being under the longevity of life number, and I think it was 74. I stand corrected, 40. 39 that are in the bill plus the 1. Representative Ferguson, you have a question? You're recognized. How many APNs are in those 39 counties now? Don't know. We're trying to gather that information, so I don't know. And then the question is, how many would go to that? If I knew that, I don't know how many doctors would go there once they graduate, but I don't know that. Hi, members. You've heard an explanation. I see no further questions. We'll have a couple people in the audience signed up to speak for and against. The first against would be David Roten. If you were to make sure that microphone is on and close to your mouth and you're recognized to testify. Here we go. My name is David Roten. I'm the Executive Vice President for the Arkansas Medical Society. Members of the committee, you heard the medical testimony last week or week before last from several physicians and medical students and residents in family practice. You heard their concerns. I'm not going to go over that again today. I do want to reiterate that we are opposed to this bill. We're opposed to it for several reasons. First and foremost, let me just say Percocet, Dilaudid, Oxycontin, methamphetamines, amphetamines. Those are all Schedule II drugs that are prescribed by highly trained physicians that have had four years of medical school and in primary care, a minimum of three years of residency training after that. They are allowed to prescribe those drugs today. This bill passes. In 39 counties, you're going to allow a whole new group of people to write those prescriptions that have never written them before, regulated by a nursing board that has never written them before. That gives us a lot of concern in an era where we are spending so much resources on reducing the incidence of prescription drug abuse. That's number one. Number two, this bill, it's not just Medicaid. It will require the private insurance carriers who have made a decision, a business decision, that the services of a physician based on their training and education is worth X number of dollars for a service and for an advanced practice nurse who has a fraction of the training and education of a physician to get paid a lesser amount in recognition of that. You're about to tell those private insurance companies what they must pay, a group of providers in this state. We've never done that before, to my knowledge, with private insurance. So, and then third, we've talked a lot. There's been a lot of testimony about the physicians or lack of physicians in these 39 counties. Well, the question came up, how many advanced practice nurses are already in those counties? The purpose of this bill is allegedly to provide incentives to encourage advanced practice nurses to go out into these rural areas. So it just goes to, it would make sense to know how many are already there. If those obstacles that the bill would allegedly resolve are not preventing advanced practice nurses from going there now, this committee needs to know that. so i went to the state nursing board's website and they put out an annual report every year the most recent annual report on the nursing board's website is 2013 there's not one for 2014 yet and in those 39 to 40 counties there are currently 625 physicians practicing and there are 346 advanced practice nurses residing in those counties so it wasn't an obstacle to get them to go to those counties they're already doing it under the current statute and the current rules they came to this capitol 20 years ago when we had nurse practitioners who were totally supervised by physicians and they said representatives if you will pass a law removing the supervision requirement and putting us under collaborative agreements with physicians we will go to the rural areas 20 years later they're back here saying we still can't go to the rural areas the data shows otherwise they are out there in those rural areas they're out there practicing they're out there practicing semi-independently independently in urgent care centers in physicians' offices and hospitals, they're out there. I would argue this bill is not needed to get them to go to rural areas. Thank you. Members, you've heard testimony. Representative Payton, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Roden, are you saying that under the collaborative agreements, they do not prescribe those drugs that you mentioned? They do not prescribe Schedule II's period, with the exception that if Dr. McGee's bill passes, Representative McGee's bill passes, they will be able to continue writing the hydrocodone combination products that they have written for the past 20 years. So currently under the collaborative agreements they don't prescribe it, but this bill would change that? Yes, sir. In fact, this bill would remove the requirement that they even have a collaborative agreement to write Schedule IIs. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yes, sir. Representative Sullivan, you're recognized. Yes, are these folks allowed in other states to prescribe those meds? There are some states that allow them to. There are other states that do not. There are some states that will allow them to, but it's very restricted. They must be under a supervisory agreement with a physician, under direct supervision. Some states, they will allow them to write a limited number of Schedule II drugs, like people that are terminally ill. They'll let them write drugs for those kind of folks. So it's all over the board. They've probably got better numbers on that than I do. Follow up, Mr. Chair. So how's that working in states where they're allowed, if this law passes, and other states that have the parallel to this law, how's that working? I mean, you seem to imply that if this happens, there's going to be a rash of prescriptions and usage that's unlawful, unethical, illegal, and unnecessary. How's that working in states that have this bill now? Is that occurring? Well, I can't tell you that, but I also want to reiterate, I never said illegal, unethical, or anything like that. What I said was, you've got these drugs that are highly controlled, and you're about to turn loose another 300 to 500 prescription riders that have no experience riding those drugs. And there's no evidence that that's being in other states. There's no evidence that you're aware of that that's not working in other states. I've seen no evidence either way. Okay, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members, seeing no further questions, Let's see. Yes, Mr. Roten, thank you for that testimony. Yes, sir. To speak forward will be Debbie Shelton. And, Ms. Shelton, if you would, make sure that microphone is on and speak clearly and introduce yourself for the record, and you're recognized to give testimony. Thank you so much. Good morning. My name is Debbie Shelton, and I've been a nurse practitioner since 1993. and I've lived and was raised in one of those counties, one of those 10 counties, Poinsett County. I grew up in Marktree, Arkansas, went to school in Arkansas State University, and this was the late 80s, and I knew I wanted to be a nurse practitioner. It was new talk then, but having grown up in Marktree when you had Dr. Smith and Dr. Swingle, and they were the only two providers we had in our town, and they're getting older, I knew that they were retiring and no one wanted to come. So I wanted to go to school, to come back, take care of the people in my county and my community. And I did that. As I was leaving my master's program, I got a call from Crittenden Memorial Hospital. And they had purchased Dr. Swingle's practice and wanted me to come work. So it was a dream come true. I got to do what I always wanted to do, go back and take care of the people that I loved. And I was so enamored by that possibility that I stayed in that clinic for 15 years. And little bitty three-by-five exam rooms, two of them, two exam rooms, saw 30, 40 patients a day and loved taking care of those patients. Independently saw patients, diagnosed, treated successfully. Great patient outcomes in 1998 through 2002. We did patient satisfaction surveys. 96% of the patients who visited our clinic loved our services and would come back to do that. But during that time, I had a lot of students coming through. I'm sitting in Marktree, Arkansas, so I'm equally between Memphis and Jonesboro. So I got a lot of UT students from the University of Tennessee, a lot of the University of Memphis, nurse practitioner students. And those students begin to say things like, I've learned a lot of things from you. Things are done differently here in your community than they're done other places. I don't understand the differences in the education. So I asked, well, what do I do so different than you see in downtown Memphis? And a student told me, well, Mr. Bird, he'd come in here for an incision and drainage for an abscess to his arm, and before you ever touched him, you made sure he had running water to clean it, you made sure he had money for his antibiotics, and you made sure he had transportation to come back to your clinic in two days when you needed to see him because you knew it took $20 to get him here from Torrell, Arkansas, to see you today. In Memphis, we would have opened it up, put a bandage on him, gave him a prescription, told him to come back in two days. Probably never would have seen him. Again, he shows up in the emergency room with an infection. So we do things a little differently in the rural, medically underserved areas. So I begin to get an interest in education, thinking when I leave Mark Tree, and my life is only going to be so long, is someone back there teaching students how to take care of this vulnerable, susceptible population are there are the new generation coming up do they know that and so in 2005 I went to work in at Arkansas State University teaching nurse practitioner students doing that to this very day and love that to keep my certification current I have to practice a day a week so in 2006 I went to work at Coast to Coast Medical Stop in West Memphis it's Crittenden County which is medically underserved as well but taking care of a different population of people I went to work doing occupational health, doing a lot of DOT physicals, a lot of workers' comp, and seeing only private-paid patients and self-paid patients. A lot of difference, where in Marktree Riverside Clinic, 66% of my practice come from either Medicaid, Medicare, or a combination of Medicare and Medicaid. I was truly convinced then. Hang on with me just a second. I need to recognize Representative Love. I'm sorry, but I've got a little, is it point of order Representative Love or what? Point of order? What's your point of order? Well, it's not actually a point of order. Well, it is, but I really would, I mean, we have gone through a lot of testimony on this issue, and I would like to limit debate for 20 minutes. Is that 10 minutes per side? That's correct. I think that's more than enough. But that's motion non-debatable. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? All right, thank you. We will start a timer as soon as Mr. Price is ready. Representative, we promoted you, too. you get paid less so hi ma'am if you would continue your testimony I'm sorry to interrupt that but we need to get that get that out of the way thank you okay thank you so much to wrap up I currently teach at Arkansas State University I looked at my numbers from 2009 to 2013 to see how many of my students were actually going to work in medically underserved areas and anywhere from 36 to 48 percent of my students that we graduate are going to work in medically underserved counties such as Poinsett, Cross, Prairie, Woodruff, Jackson. Those are the surrounding counties from our university. We just completed F&P interviews for the next class. We interviewed 30 students. From those 30 students, I hear comments such as, I only want to go back to work in Cave City. I want to go to work in Emboldon. I want to go back to Cherokee Village to work. So we have students out there who are willing to go through the educational process, put their lives on hold for three or four years, come back to school, do the clinical hours necessary to be trained to be a nurse practitioner to go to work. We have willing, competent providers in the stream who want to go to work in those areas. But we have a barrier that exists, and the barrier that exists is collaborative practice. I have 0.01%, that's 2 out of 122 nurse practitioners that we've graduated since 2009 who have opened their own practice, 2 out of 122. So I call each of those to see what are your biggest obstacles. And Sarah told me that she couldn't pay herself for the first year. She lived out of her retirement funds because she was paying $3,200 a month for a collaborative physician who come in and sign charts and never saw a patient. The other lady that I called said that she had to scale her practice down from five days a week to two days a week because she could only afford to pay her collaborative physician $1,500 a month. And so two out of 122 graduates are practicing in the rural health care settings as independent providers due to the barrier that still exists in the state of Arkansas for nurse practitioners. All right, members, you've heard a testimony. Any questions? Seeing none, thank you, Ms. Shelton, for that testimony. It looks like two more people to sign up to speak for this. They're going to come up together. It would be Sue Tedford and Fred Knight. I will remind you that your representative sitting next to you would probably like to close for his bill so you may want to leave him time but I'm sure you all can figure that out if you would introduce yourself for the record you're recognized to give testimony we've got about eight minutes thank you Mr. Chair and committee I'm Sue Tedford Executive Director of the Board of Nursing and with me is Fred Knight General Counsel And so since we're on a time frame, I'll make this brief and kind of address some of the issues that I've heard y'all's concern. As you sit here and consider this bill, one thing that's going through your mind, I know, is safety. Is this best for the public? The mission of the Board of Nursing is protection of the public. And I guarantee we would not be here in support of this bill if we did not feel these nurses were qualified and competent to provide this care. One of the things that are kind of brought up is scope of practice. When I listen to the medical board talk about scope of practice of physician, they have a very global view of scope of practice for a physician, where we look at it a little bit more narrowly and based on what is the training and education of the advanced practice nurse, or even our RNs and LPNs. An advanced practice nurse has very specialized education and training. They are taught physical assessment, comprehensive diagnosis, and prescribing. And then they specialize based on one of the six population foci. They're neonatal, they're pediatric, they're family, they're adult Gero, they're women's health, they're mental health. So they very specialize in it, and then their practice is based on that specialty. All of their training in their advanced practice program is based on that specialty. So they have the basic training of an RN, basic training across the board of an AP RN, but their clinical is very specialized. So when you talk about scope of practice of an advanced practice nurse, you would not have the women's health practitioner treating the six-year-old because that is not within their scope of practice. So they have to stick within what their training and education is. Now, all APRNs can do health assessments. All APRNs can prescribe medications. They have basic training in physiology, pharmacology, and those areas. there's not a single APRN out there that can do surgery there's not a single APRN out there that can set a broken bone so there's things that none of them can do then you have the other things that depends on their specialty as they get out and specialize they go back for additional training and education for example Botox and laser therapy are the new things for everybody so the APRN goes back and she gets trained in Botox laser therapy or whatever it is and that becomes within their scope of practice but to say that's within scope of practice of all the APRNs absolutely not they have to be trained just like a physician or anybody else now Mr. Roten brought up some issues with prescribing schedule 2 medications and APRNs in other states currently according to the DEA 43 other states allow Schedule II prescribing by APRNs. In the states that have allowed APRNs to prescribe, none of those states have ever rescinded that ability due to issues with prescribing. With the training of APRNs and Schedule IIs, they are trained in their basic educational programs of how to prescribe hydrocodone, the ADHD meds, the other Schedule II meds, that is part of their basic training. What is limiting the APRNs in Arkansas is Arkansas law. So it's not their education, it's not their training, it's the law that we have in Arkansas that limits their ability to prescribe Schedule IIs. I think that's the main points I wanted to make. Did you want to? My name is Fred Knight and I would just briefly state that, you know, I'm the one that prosecutes cases in our office when individuals have violated the Nurse Practice Act or any other state laws that impacts on their practice as far as that goes. And I can tell you unequivocally, when you look at the total number of advanced practice nurses practicing in the state of Arkansas since 1995, we've had very few complaints overall filed against APRNs. To give you some idea, this past year, we already have over 2,000 complaints filed against nursing as a whole. We've got 54,000 licensees in the state. So we deal with a lot of complaints. We have very, very, very few complaints from the public regarding APRNs and their practice. We've only had probably at best over the last 20 years, seven or eight year, seven or eight complaints, even remotely alleging that they may have prescribed beyond their scope or that they were overprescribing. One of those instances of where someone did prescribe a Schedule II that they were not allowed to do was an APRN that had moved here from, I believe it was the state of Wisconsin, where they had the total ability to prescribe all Schedule IIs in Wisconsin, and that particular nurse had been prescribing up there for several years, so she didn't quite comprehend when she got here that she was much more restricted in what she could do because of state law. As Ms. Tepard's already noted, most states the vast majority of states are allowing them to do it, have been allowing them to do it for years. Our state, our nurses in this state have the same education and training as APRNs in all the other states. They've just been limited simply because of the law. It's not a lack of training or that they don't understand the consequences of those Schedule 2s. They do very much. But I think that should be noted. representative hammer you have two minutes remaining okay one last point and then I will close a comment was made about by mr. Roten of where the APR ends are and he was looking at our annual report and that's based on residency we provided statistics last week a based on practice site of all of our APR ends and we have 317 nurse practitioners that are practicing in the 39 counties, and that's based on their practice site reported to us. And that's all I have, Mr. Chair, and I'll entertain questions. Minute and a half left, Representative Hammer. Mr. Chair, am I the last word on this, or is there anybody else lined up to speak against? No one else signed up to speak. Okay. Then let me wrap it up. No one else signed to speak up for or against. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Then let me just say this, if you would, please. As far as the fear of prescribing, and I think that point was hit on, one of the things that was mentioned was to instill a fear factor as to whether or not the APRNs are competent. I'd be open to a review of the history, as I think Sue touched on, the history of APRNs and their ability to control themselves versus other medical fields and what is their percentage of rate of having individuals that had complaints or maybe even licenses suspended because they couldn't take care of their own needs with regards to the drugs. And then finally, maybe just an old cliche, an honest day's pay for an honest day's work. If you've got somebody who wants to go out there and work hard and work on us, as we were giving testimony a while ago, why shouldn't they be paid to the full scope of their practice? And I want to focus on one other thing. The collaborative agreement can cost anywhere between $1,600 to $2,500 a month, which adds a substantial amount, not mentioning the overall range of $30,000. The money is pretty high for that collaborative arrangement, and that just finally transmits to the bottom line. And with that, again, I would ask for a good vote, and I make a motion. Do pass. All right, members, for an explanation of the bill and testimony, you have a motion on the table. Any discussion on that motion? Hearing or seeing no motion, all those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? No. I'm going to go ahead and call it no. I have one hand for roll call. I have two hands for roll call. Representative Love. No. Yes. Representative Wardlaw. Representative Wardlaw. Representative Hammer. Yes. Representative Branscombe. No. Representative Meeks. Yes. Representative, excuse me, Overby. Representative Overby. Representative Ritchie. No. Representative McGee. No. Representative Miller. Representative Womack, Representative Bragg, Representative Fight, Representative Payton, Representative Lundstrom, Representative Lundstrom Representative Bentley Representative Boyd Representative Boyd Representative Henderson Representative Henderson Representative Sullivan Vice Chair Ferguson 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 We have 8 yays, 6 nays, and 6 not voting your bill has failed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Point of order, though. It can be brought back up one more time. Is that correct? Yes, sir. You have one vote left on this. Thank you. Let's hope it doesn't take an hour. All right. Representative Murdoch, I asked you came in, but hang on just a second with me because Representative Bain has been waiting, and he says he's very brief. Is that acceptable with you, sir? Yes. Okay, good. I appreciate that because he's been in room for a while. Rep. Bain, I lost track of you, but you're in there somewhere. Oh, you're behind me. That's why. I'd make a terrible elementary teacher, apparently. I know I'm not funny, but humor's really falling dead today. It's late in the session. Rep. Bain, you're recognized to present House Bill 1452. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. 1452, back in my district, we were having an issue, and let me just lay it out real quickly, succinctly, what the issue was. We actually have a waste incineration company that does hazardous material days throughout the year for the community. Takes in a lot of household hazardous material waste and incinerates it right on site with all the commercial incineration work it already does. The sticky wicket issue is back in 2011 we passed a law that said that basically anybody that does that kind of work has to have a landfill operators permit. They do not have one because they do not operate a landfill. They actually incinerate on site. They don't store and they don't contain or they don't operate a landfill. So we were coming to an issue trying to identify what we could do to help them be able to not have to actually go out and contract to bring on a landfill operator permit individual, basically just to be out there and watch them take in materials. The landfill operator actually doesn't do anything except they're on site because they're complying with state law because it requires a landfill operator to be on site to help process in the material. What we're asking for is to give ADQ the ability to waive that requirement on those who do not operate a landfill. I wanted to make sure people understood this is not some backdoor process to let anybody operate a landfill or anybody skirt the landfill rules. This is simply to allow those who actually have worked with ADEQ that they actually do on-site incineration to actually incinerate on-site without a landfill operator permit. And ADEQ I know is here in the house. I've been working with them for probably about a month on this trying to make sure that We've got the cleanest and most straightforward bill. I'll also say I've never necessarily been a big fan or friend of ADEQ. I've been kind of watching like a hawk because I've got a lot of industry that doesn't always get along with ADEQ back home. But for the purposes of this, I would ask the committee to give us the leeway to allow ADEQ to waive in certain circumstances the use and necessity of a landfill operator permit. Members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Any questions? Seeing or hearing none. is there anyone like to speak for against this no one signed up no one coming forward what's will this committee i have motion do pass is there any discussion of that motion hearing or seeing none all those in favor say aye any opposed congratulations your bill is passed thank you represent bain thank you mr chairman thank you committee and represent burdock where'd he go oh there he is Representative Murdoch, that bill number is 1008 that you're presenting. There are, I see numerous amendments. Are they all engrossed? They are. They are all engrossed. Yes, sir. Very good. All right, members, all the amendments are engrossed. Representative Murdoch, you recognize the presentation bill. Okay, I was kind of working this. I have another bill, 1009 also, and I was really trying to not have to come back and see my good people, my good colleagues again, and do it all the same day. But the rules will preclude me from doing that, so I better run this through while I can. Thank you for the opportunity. Thank you, committee. This bill is a simple bill. is a bill to regulate the fairness and the bidding practices for the construction of publicly funded projects, specifically to modify the retainage laws of the state of Arkansas. And what it simply does is a friendly bill for the small business specifically in our state to perform work. This is just about retained. It just allows upon satisfactory performance that the retainage will be released at the levels mentioned. 95% after 50% of the work is completed. If the owner, say, is happy, if the design professional is happy, if everybody in the house is happy, then they'll reduce the retainage to zero at a certain point. And that's up to those three entities that will not hold any further retainages. It's that simple. But the key to it, though, is that everyone is happy. Everyone is satisfied with the work performance. There's no issues out there with the contractor or subcontractor in this case as well, I think. And so, just making sure that they're, just help them finance the project. Representative Love, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Murdock, did you say that there was no known opposition to this bill? No, no known opposition. We worked it out with ABA. We worked it out with the AGC. Just, we worked it out with everyone involved. Who'd you work it out with? ABA, the Arkansas Building Authority. Okay, and who's the other one? The Arkansas AGC, Association of General Contractors. Okay, thank you. No, no, I'm thanking you as well. Motion at the proper time, Mr. Chair. All right, Representative Payton, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Murdoch, I guess I may be the only known opposition, But at first glance here, I mean, you're talking about 50% through the contract. Everybody's satisfied. You said happy several times. But there could be a lot. I mean, if we're talking about a sizable contract, you could be advancing several hundred thousand dollars to bring it to the 95% paid when you're only 50% complete in the project. No. What am I missing? Yes, sir. I'm sorry. Let's put it on the presenter and not on the receiver. I take the blame for that. Let me try to clear that up. What we're talking about is when we're 50% through the project, we're entitled to 95% of the payment due, not 95% of the total contract. You're just getting paid up to 95% of what you have done. 95% of the 50%. There you go. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Actually, thank you for that question because I thought I was the other opposition in the room. All right. Thank you for the better explanation, Representative Murdoch. Any other questions? Representative Meeks. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mine is on page one where you've added, it says to furnish a performance, and you've added the word and payment bond. Can you explain adding those two words? Yes, that's a good question as well. The performance and payment bond is a general part of all Public Works contracts. That's a part of anything above $20,000 as a contract. the contractor must provide a performance and payment bond. That's the assurance or the surety bond that assures the owner that if this contractor fails to perform or pay, then the surety will have to take control of the project and finish it. So that's a further assurance. And I should have mentioned that in my presentation, actually, because that's a further assurance to the owner that they will have the completion of their work. Yes, sir. Seeing no other questions, anyone from the audience? speak for or against this bill. Seeing none, what's the will of this committee? We have a motion to do pass from Representative Love. Any discussion of that motion? Seeing or hearing none, all those in favor say aye. Any opposed? The ayes have it. Congratulations. Representative Murdoch, your bill has passed. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, committee and the presenter. Try to do a better job next time. We all have our days, don't we? We'll bring you back Thursday and let's try again. I know that representative Lampkin is coming in to present her bill shortly is everyone here to present Senator Wood's bill okay oh they are tied together well I text yeah you might we got the chair and vice chair of education want to present bills and we can't have them both over at the same time well so I've chaired judiciary one present a bill If you're familiar, head on down there. Okay. Representative Letting's not in here, is he? No? Good. The guy from the southeast-west district is going to be the main one that talks about it. y'all bear with me just a moment Representative Miller you're wanting to pass over yours today for sure I think you said I really thought Representative Murdoch was going to have opposition it would take a while so I didn't have other people in here yet Hey, Representative Lamkin, if you're ready, we're ready. We held up the entire show just for you, but that's because I got a jar of pickled beets last night. That's why. It worked great. I do take pickled beets as bribery, and you did a great job. You said that was your husband that made those beets, right? They were good. Representative Lampkin, you are recognized and introduced your bill, which is House Bill 1497. Oh, dear, I brought the wrong one. Okay. I have two in another committee, and I brought the wrong one. Okay, this is House Bill 1497, and it involves the Waste Tire Program. In fact, it says it's an act to clarify the law regarding applications, grants, and grant funds for waste tire programs. It starts off by describing or defining what a waste tire is by excluding products of beneficial use made from the process of waste tires. And we define a waste tire as a product of beneficial use derived from a waste tire which could no longer count against a tire recycling facility's permitted capacity. And this change will allow facilities to produce and store sufficient amounts of recycled waste tires to compete in the market. In some of the recycling districts, they have programs where they take in waste tires, and some of them are destroyed, but some of them are taken and repurposed, recycled. And that's what this bill deals with, the ones that were recycled. Only solid waste districts are eligible to receive a waste tire grant, and that's where they get their money to use to do this, a grant. Currently, each solid waste district must complete a waste tire grant application every two years. The bill removes ADEQ's retirement of a waste tire grant application every two years. They don't have to reapply as often. And it requires ADEQ to immediately disperse quarterly the tire grant funds to each applicant, solid waste district. This is a really good program that we have in southeast Arkansas and in several of the districts. And that's what we want to do, amend some of the rules to define what a waste tire is because at this point we're limited to how many they can keep on site. so they want permission to keep more on site so that they'll have a product when the buyer is requested. I'm going to turn that over to this gentleman and let him answer your questions because he's the expert and I don't even know how to take a tire off. If you have any questions. No. Could he introduce himself? Yes. Andrew Armstrong. I'm with the Southeast Arkansas Economic Development District and Regional Solid Waste District. Committee, do you have any? Oh, Representative Fite. Thank you, Madam Chair, and thank you for being here. Could you tell us some of the ways that tires can be used to benefit us, besides just making our cars go? But after they're no longer on our cars, how can they be used? Yes, ma'am. There are many products that can be made from recycling a waste tire. A major one, one of the easiest ones, is tire-derived fuel. We refer to it as TDF. It is used in a lot of the paper mills. You can make crumb rubber from tires. Crumb rubber can be used in lots of things. It can go into rubberized asphalt. It can go into ball fields, playgrounds. You can make rubber mulch that is paintable. out of tires, there's a myriad of products that tires can be recycled into. Representative Sullivan. Yes, I'm on page 2, line 25 and 26, where it says, distribution of grant funds shall be based upon the monies available in the funds and upon submitted quarterly financial and approved as stricken there. Can you tell me what difference that makes? That requires ADQ to give us our quarterly money upon the submission of the quarterly report. Currently, they can hold your money if they have questions about your quarterly report. Follow-up? And it's not a good thing? I mean, should they not be able to have questions with the report if it doesn't contain all the information or is inaccurate or is, you know, you're requesting money, they don't have to approve the money you're getting? All you have to do is submit the report? Yes, we still submit the report, and we would still have to have an accurate report, and we would work with them. This just ensures that we're not, that the money is not held up. We have bills just like a business every month, and if we do not get that quarterly receipt, then we cannot pay our bills. We cannot. Does that answer your question? Well, I'm afraid it does because I have a difficult time saying all I have to do submit a report to get the money with no approval or authorization that the product is is of the quality necessary to justify the expenditure that that is not in the report currently I think that represent Ferguson has kind of been involved with this a little bit and she would like to kind of give a little information on that if we are with you we have a task force that's not complete and I didn't know that representative Lampkin was going to bring the bill but you might just explain the whole funding process I know that ADQ gets the money for the two dollars per tire and then that they keep eight percent and they distribute it to the planning districts and you might explain it's really the hold up in paying you really is not based on you doing anything wrong but kind of explain that process for people who are not familiar with the Tire Recycling Program? Yes, ma'am. Thank you. There's an advance fee on every tire sold in the state, passenger and truck tires. That fee goes to DF&A, and then DF&A gives that to ADEQ. And the solid waste districts are currently tasked with operating a waste tire district that takes care of those tires. We, based on our grant applications, ADEQ has a formula, and we are allotted so much money of the receipts in each district. Does that help a little bit, Representative Sullivan? Not much. I still don't understand until we're submitting a report and we're getting our money, but nobody has to approve the report. I'm not familiar with that business process. You might explain, has there ever been a situation where the report was not approved and they didn't eventually pay you but really strung it out for a long time and then you had trouble paying your bills? Yes, ma'am, that's accurate. We allotted the money to do what we're tasked with, we recycle those tires. The quarterly report only is reporting to ADEQ the expenditures which we have made for that previous quarter. it's just reporting previous expenditures does that help it helps me understand it doesn't convince me but that's I guess that's my problem if you're understanding I can't go the other direction as long as you understand I'm happier then Representative Meeks you're recognized for a question thank you Mr. Chair mine is on the application part of it on I think it's page two starting with line 12 So it says the procedures of this section shall provide that a solid waste management district shall apply only one time for a waste tire grant under the subchapter. And my question is, number one, why do we need it in law versus policy? And a second question is, is what happens if or can that application be denied? And if that's the case, then how would they be able to reapply? If a new tire district reformed, they would have to submit an application. And, yes, it could be denied by ADEQ. The way this is written, all the solid waste districts already have a tire program, so we already have an existing program. And the previous applications that we have done would satisfy this requirement. Go ahead. You said that if an application can be denied, and if an application can be denied, and this right here doesn't seem like it would provide for them to maybe clean up or improve or do whatever they would need to do and then resubmit an application to be able to be formed. That is not the intent. Then is that something that I guess the sponsor then would maybe have to go back and amend to make sure, because you said that was not the intent, but that's what this bill does. According to the way I read it, I may be wrong, I'm not a lawyer. Okay, run that by me again, David. Okay, on page 2, line 12, it says that it only allows, because it's a shall, shall provide, shall apply only one time. And if that application is to be denied, then that's it. They would not be able to go back and fix whatever it is or improve and apply again to be able to form. I think that means it should be denied one time as is. and then it would be their responsibility to make whatever changes and they might reapply under a new application with the changes is the way I understand it. Now, I'm not a lawyer either. And I think ADEQ would agree that they would not turn down an application and not accept another one. The point to this was that the Waste Tire Program, each year we have to submit a biennial application. So every two years we have to do a completely new Waste Tire Grant application. we are the only entities that operate that program and we are trying to do away with that requirement Mr. Chair I would like some clarification because I don't want to get caught up in the fact of you know they apply once if that's denied then they won't be able to apply again because I mean it states that it shall only apply once so I'm not sure I'm kind of with you I get their point but I hear your point too so please thank you chairman i'm ryan benefield i'm the deputy director at the arkansas department of environmental quality so unlike a traditional grant program there's only they get this money by formula so um we wouldn't deny an application to a district because it's not like a normal grant call. They have the money allotted to them. The application in this case is actually more perfunctory than it is a true review because the law itself says that each district gets a set amount of dollars. Now, we do applications for supplemental grants, which is different, which is a more competitive thing, but because this is a perfunctory by law that district gets that amount, we wouldn't deny an application. If we found an error in it, which would be rare because there's not a lot that they have to do to form a tire district, we would simply have them amend that application. There wouldn't be a situation where the department would issue a true denial because, by law, they have this money allotted to them. Okay. Very good. All right. Next up, Representative Payton. And thank you, Mr. Benfield, for that explanation. It helps a lot. Representative Payton, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I guess my question is for the gentleman there. Yes, sir. As you were talking about the application and the payments earlier, the information, or not the application, but the quarterly reports, the information on the quarterly report in no way affects the amount of the payment that we're talking about? No, sir. So it's not so much per tire or so much per volume. The money is allotted and it's going to them, and what's coming on the report has nothing to do with like a billing statement or... Correct. it's just a past expenditure report yes sir thank you thank you Mr. Chair yes sir Representative Ritchie recognized thank you Mr. Chair I guess going back to Representative Sullivan's question he may understand now I still don't but so why is there I mean why are payments held up now I mean is there a reason why payments are held up is it just a paperwork deal I mean it doesn't sound like there's anything to do with the quarterly reports so I'm just kind of I'm curious so for what reason would there be a delay now that we would need to say that they've got to disperse it immediately several districts have felt in the past that that their payments were held up for no good reason maybe we need to ask a I'm sorry chairman but maybe a DQ maybe they could answer that one for me. I'm sorry to make you come back. Mr. Benfield, you're recognized. Thank you. And I will say, I hope everyone agrees, right now we are processing in about a day or two. With the way the statute reads now, having to approve the report, so if we review one and we find a mistake, then we have to let them know what the mistake is, they have to correct it, they have to get us a new report, and then we'd have to approve it like i said i think we've worked out most of the kinks in that process and we're approving them in day or two i don't i haven't heard a district you know in a while uh work about that but but honestly i think from our perspective is the tires keep getting generated whether we've approved that report or not so the district is continuing to get tires to have to be dealt with and withholding their funds you know while we're working out an issue on a report is actually causing probably more harm because you know the tires don't stop every day there's more tires delivered to the district, whether they're getting the money in one day or two weeks. Thank you. Hi, I'm Ambush for an explanation of the bill. Seeing no one signed to speak for or against the bill. I see one in the audience seeing none. What is the will of this committee? Representative Overby? Representative Overby makes a motion that we do pass this bill. Discussion on the motion? Kind of surprised. Hearing or seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. All right, the ayes have it. Congratulations. Representative Lampkin, you have passed your bill. Representative Shepard, Judiciary Chair Shepard, we'd like to get you in and out of here. So if you would, if you're recognized, present your bill, which is? Thank you. 1466. Yes, sir, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Members, House Bill 1466 is really just a clarification. A few years ago, we passed some legislation that restricted the sale of ephedrine and pseudoephedrine and gave really some discretion to the pharmacist. And some issues have occurred, and since filing this bill, I've actually heard more and more stories related to this issue. But some issues have occurred that I've become aware of where you have individuals who may be traveling outside of their community who on the weekend or during the holidays they go into a pharmacy usually a chain pharmacy they try and buy some type of pseudoephedrine and the pharmacist or the pharmacy says we're prohibited by law from selling to you because we don't know who you are you have no track record with our pharmacy you should go see a doctor and come back with a prescription which the problem is that many times this occurs over the weekend or during the holiday when there's really no way to see a doctor. This bill actually just clarifies to state that the law does not preclude that sale. The pharmacist still has the discretion and they still could decide not to sell it, but quite frankly, they're not going to be able to blame the legislature anymore after we make this change. And I've worked with the Pharmacy Association before filing it. They had no issue with it. They said the law, they believe the law already allows for this type of discretion, so it's a clarification, so they were fine with it. I've spoken with the Executive Director of the Board of Pharmacy about it, but I believe this is just a bill that is a clarification to allow the discretion to the pharmacist, which is already the case, but quite frankly, many times they've been blaming the legislature for precluding them from being able to sell. I'd be glad to answer any questions. Members, you heard an explanation. Representative Love, you recognize? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Shepard, is there any known opposition to this bill? I'm not aware of any opposition. Okay, motion at the proper time. Seeing no further questions, I'll take that motion, Representative Love. Motion to pass. With motion to pass, is there one from the audience, no one signed up to speak for or against, anyone from the audience want to speak for or against this bill? Seeing none, we have a motion to pass. Members, is there any discussion of that motion? Seeing or hearing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Shepard. You passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. Are you still meeting over there? Yes, we are. We're open for business. Good luck. Representative Letting, we could not look more forward to hearing your three bills. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and I think I might actually have four. First up is House Bill 1192, and you have an amendment for that. Is that right? There is. Okay. Let's see if it's on the machines here. It's just adding language. It's not replacing any of the language in the bill. members that amendment should be on your tablet 1192-H1 all right representative letting if you would present your amendment please it adds language thank you mr. chair and madam vice chair this amendment comes from the arkansas school board association it was just some language that made them feel more comfortable with the bill that they wanted to see add to make sure that we made sure parents weren't using this law as an excuse to send the family pet to school with little Susie members for an explanation of the amendment was will this committee representative Sullivan you move to adopt the amendment any discussion hearing none all those in favor say aye any opposed all right representative letting You are recognized, present your bill as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Committee, last fall I was approached by a gentleman from Benton County named Jimmy Davis. His wife, Sharon, is an Iraq vet. She served in 2008, and as a result of her service, she now copes with post-traumatic stress syndrome. One of the things she does to cope, they acquired a service animal, a chocolate lab named Coco. It was a rescue dog that they purchased and paid for the training, which can be quite expensive. and Coco's been working out great. The problem is Coco was a little bit of an older dog when they got him and so they have purchased a younger dog and he's going through training. And they encountered a problem at a local establishment last fall where a manager had some questions about whether or not they were actually allowed to have the training dog along with them. Mr. Davis thought they were covered because according to the ADA they should have been But when he looked at the Arkansas code, he saw that our code was out of date. So what we did this session was we worked to update our code. We've worked with a number of interested parties. I do apologize that this has sat on your calendar for so long, but we wanted to make sure we got the policy right. We have worked with the Arkansas Hospitality Association, Game and Fish, the Little Rock Zoo, the City of Little Rock, the Grocers Association, believe it or not, and also the Arkansas School Board Association and the other local schools. we believe we finally now have the bill in a place we know of no current opposition so basically all we're doing again is modernizing our laws regarding service animals members for an explanation of the bill Representative Fite you're recognized for the first question thank you and Representative Letting could you explain exactly how this would work with the schools what would happen how would this impact schools well hopefully it's not gonna necessarily have an impact unless there is a student or a staff member that truly does require a service dog that was the purpose of the amendment today was to provide a little more assurance again that parents weren't going to be able to use the the law as an excuse to send the family pet if Susie or Johnny just wanted to have the family dog with them so there should be no additional burden to schools in any way as a former classroom teacher I just cannot imagine anything more horrible than having 20 gerbils in the classroom that are therapy animals and so that's why I'm really concerned about this. It should that that is a fair point but we've not had that concern raised by it by anyone. Representative Sullivan you're recognized. Thank you Mr. Chair. Does this add or remove any animals that weren't service animals that are now? Are we excluding or including any new type gerbils? That's one of the reasons it took us so long. We did initially not realizing quite what I might be wading into. We wanted to see if we could expand it because there are an increasing number of animals that are being used and we wanted to provide some protection. That is a much longer project and I'm not sure if that's even going to be possible. So we scaled this back to focus on dogs. At one point we did have miniature horses included because ADA guidelines also include miniature horses. If you're curious, people use them for balance issues, but the Grocers Association was concerned that they might have horses in the produce department picking up apples. So we dropped the miniature horses and focused on dogs. And I'll tell you just a very quick story. The way it came to my attention that other animals are being used. My wife works for Crystal Bridges Museum. They had a patron come in one day who had a rat perched on her shoulder, and they understandably asked, why do you have this rat on your shoulder? And I forget the name of the disease, but I looked this up after my wife shared this story. It's real. She has some sort of disease where she starts to have these warning spasms, and if she doesn't take a pill soon enough, she can seize up and become locked up. It could take her hours or days to relax. But unfortunately, due to nerve damage over the years, she no longer is able to feel these warning spasms as they're coming on. The rat is trained to sense them, and when it does, it licks her neck, she takes her pill, and she avoids the muscle seizures. And so I'd already talked with Jimmy and his wife about visiting this legislation when this story came to my attention, so that's what initially prompted the idea that we would look at other animals, but the zoo was quite concerned about that, as were others, so we scaled it way back. short follow up Mr. Chair please do yes sir so I appreciate the answer so there is we're not adding new animals we're just dealing with dogs okay thank you okay representative there's no doubt you put more time in on this than probably I would have ever thought of doing myself so hats off to that I mean you're going to a long range on this the Americans with Disabilities Act the ADA doesn't supersede I mean how does that work I admittedly was a little confused when Mr. Davis brought that to my attention. They've got the ADA protections, the Arkansas Code not being up to it. I don't know why that necessarily presented a problem. Now, when he contacted the owner of that establishment, the owner understood and granted them the access they needed, but the manager was referencing the Arkansas Code, I guess not understanding the ADA, and so that was where they ran into the trouble. And so that's why Mr. Davis thought the Arkansas Code should be updated. It sure seems like it would have been easier to just call the manager and chat with him than do what you're doing. If I had known then what I know now, Mr. Chair. We all have our methods, I guess. Members, for an explanation of the bill, seeing no further questions from the members, we have one person signed to speak for this bill. That would be Mr. Michael Thornton. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and committee. My name is Michael Thornton. I'm a self-advocate for people with disabilities for acceptance of people with disabilities. Could you pull that microphone a little closer to you? It doesn't pick up much. I'm also the vice president of the board of directors for the Arkansas Disability Coalition. I'm here representing people with disabilities today. I have friends that have a service animal, a dog, who is for diabetes alert. And this animal, a few weeks ago, they had just received the dog and went to a restaurant. In the restaurant, the waitress misunderstood and was trying to ask them to leave. And they talked to the manager, and the manager said the dog is allowed. However, if the manager had not have known that the dog was allowed into the restaurant by the Americans with Disabilities Act, that waitress and my friends would have been asked to leave the restaurant. I also have other friends that have been asked in the past to leave, and they, by the manager of restaurants, and they were not welcome back without having to go through legal terms with the Disabilities Act. I would appreciate a good vote for this, and I'll be glad to answer any questions that the committee may have. Mr. Thornton, I mean, with this law, and I'm not arguing about whether it passes law quite honestly or not, but even with this law in place, you may still have those same arguments. Yes, you may, and I understand that. But I also understand with the law and with the Americans with Disabilities Act, you do have a little bit more leeway from reading the legislation that Representative Letting has written. I do appreciate it, and I do think that this just strengthens Arkansas' commitment to people with disabilities. And that would be my belief. Do you think this goes further than the Americans with Disabilities Act goes? No, I do not. But I believe the Americans with Disabilities Act goes above this, but this also gives Arkansas's commitment to people with disabilities. And as a person who has invisible disabilities, who may need a service animal at one point in the future due to seizures, I believe that if Arkansas does not say that we would, we We recognize that people with disabilities need more protection and additional effort to say that we are committed to people with disabilities, that it kind of would be, you'd have to go through the Americans with Disabilities Act also, and that's what I believe. I mean, and every one of us in this room on the committee and otherwise understand that one wrong footstep and every one of us may need a service animal we're all one footstep away from that we get that but I'm just wondering if we really really need this or if ADA already covers it Representative Hammer you're recognized for a question Thank you Mr. Chair can you tell me is there any requirement for the dogs to have any identifying marks or the pets the therapy animals to have any identifying marks on them such as a collar that would indicate they are specifically assigned for a specific need as far as as far as i know according to the ada there is not however i agree that there should be some protection for people who have legitimate service animals to have a collar or a leash or harness or something that says service animal please do not touch i know friends that even though they're not required have had to go through that to protect themselves, to get the service animal deals. I understand that there's ways to purchase online fake service animal things, but I believe there needs to be some way, and this would have to be addressed by the United States legislature for the ADA, some way to really, truly protect people that have legitimate service animals that there's some some some identifying papers that or something that shows that it's a true service animal and not someone trying to use a little Susie's family head okay all right thank you there Mr. Chair you're recognized for a question thank you Mr. Chair and we keep talking about dogs but as I read this on page two line 11 and 12 it just says service animal means an animal that's trained specifically. So we're not just talking about dogs. Is that correct or am I misinterpreting this? I believe Representative Letting says the ADA also allows for horses, but that would be something that if, say, the supermarkets or anybody disagree with, that would be something that they would have to do. I do understand that dogs are the main focus or service animals, that everybody understands that a dog is used most of the time. So that's my belief is that it should be mostly dogs. I know that horses are used for balance, as Representative Liding said, But I also know that there's other dogs that are big enough to use for balance is these two. Representative Womack, you're recognized. I think my question is for Representative Letting. On page 3, line 8, it says, A person who without just cause purposely kills or injures any service animal is guilty of a Class D felony. One question is who decides what just cause is. And my second, I guess, follow-up, kind of, or second part of that question is, why is that in here? And you're on page 3, I apologize. Page 3, line 8. That's actually original language, Representative Lennie. Yeah, that was already in the statute. Just out of curiosity, do you know who decides that? I would assume that would be a court. If an owner of an animal pressed charges, it would be in the hands of the court. Okay, thank you. You're welcome. Seeing no further questions from the committee, we have a person signed up to speak for, I'm sorry, against this bill now. That would be Mr. Paul Calvert. You recognize coming to the table. You probably know the routine. Make sure that light's on. Microphone's closed. Introduce yourself for the record, and you're recognized. My name is Paul Calvert. I'm not to throw water in your parade. to me this is kind of a property rights issue I think we need to respect people's property rights my sister has recently received a kidney transplant and while I was helping her out back a few months ago, maybe almost a year ago now I went into a clinic with her and somebody brought their animal in a dog and you realize that people with kidney problems I think you tend to have a reduced immune system so they're more subject to infections or whatever else And this person didn't take care of the dog very well. It was nosing us, I think, and licking and touching us and stuff. It's just dogs are dirty animals. They lick their backside. It's just kind of gross. And I think a private business owner ought to have the right to say no. And even though it might be unfeeling and unkind, I think a private business owner should have the right to say, no, I don't want animals in my business. And if it's a horse, that's awful. I mean, that hadn't even occurred to me. But a horse could be extremely destructive just from walking in a business. But to me, this is primarily a private property rights issue. And I don't think we should be mean to anybody. But the fact is that if someone doesn't want a dog in their business, I think they should have a right to refuse it. And it's just kind of where I'm at. I'll take questions if you'd like. Anybody have any questions for Mr. Calvert? Representative Miller, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And Mr. Calvert, I certainly sympathize with your sentiment concerning the dirtiness of an animal. But in a public place, say Walmart or whatever, do you believe, or is what you're saying, you believe that Walmart should have the right to deny access to their store for someone with a disability who is using a highly trained service dog? Yes, sir. Okay. I just wanted to clarify that. Just based on private property, I think that private property owners should be able to be mean if they want to. Be rude. I mean, I can tell people they can't come in my house for any reason whatsoever. Maybe they're wearing pink shoelaces. I agree, I'm rude all the time I was just curious about that Thank you Mr. Chair Representative Hammer, you're recognized Thank you Mr. Chair Paul, if you can't answer this, maybe somebody's following up I'm just curious that in that scenario that you mentioned a while ago that if that dog got in your space and you slapped that dog or you kicked that dog would you be liable for any charges and potentially be charged for a felony under that act that was mentioned in there and I would like to know the answer to that question. I don't know, but I did consider it. I find it pretty offensive for dogs to just lick me in general, even my own dog. I mean, it doesn't matter so much to me if I'm out in dirty work clothes and stuff like that, but if I'm clean, I'm taking my sister to a doctor's visit when she's in kidney failure, I don't want to be licked by a dog. I mean, maybe I'm just too sensitive, but I think that's fairly reasonable. Hi, members, you've heard a testimony against the bill. Next way, if someone else has signed up to speak for this bill, that would be Justin Nichols. Mr. Nichols, if you would, make sure that microphone is on. Introduce yourself for the record, and you're recognized to give testimony. Hello, my name is Justin Nichols, and I'm with Disability Rights Arkansas, and I'm here to talk in support of the bill. And one way to look at this would be to look at it as an individual liberty issue. All these people who have disabilities, they have equal rights as you and I do. I think that should be known. And the nice thing about the ADA, if a dog is out of control and licking a stranger, that dog can be asked to be removed from a business. So that wouldn't be an issue at all. We support this bill. It's a good way to help make sure everyone has equal access to businesses and public places. And according to the ADA, a service animal under the ADA is a dog. It's not necessarily a bird, even though, in our view, sometimes people might need other types of animals to help them. Say it's a soldier returning from overseas who has PTSD. Sometimes service animals can help them. Your opinion, does this bill go beyond what ADA already provides these businesses and these people? I'm not entirely sure, but I believe it does help more with issues like PTSD that ADA might not actually cover yet. And what is PTSD? Post-traumatic stress disorder. Okay, thank you. so you think that this bill helps with post-traumatic stress disorder more than what the Americans with Disability Act does I think so I don't want to go 100% on that I think what we're trying to establish here is whether we need to add more code to Arkansas law or if the Americans with Disability Act already covers it that's just my line of questions Representative Payton you're recognized for a question thank you Mr. Chair my question is we allow private property owners to deny people their Second Amendment rights by putting up a sign that says you can't carry on this property. Currently, is there anything that requires them to put up a sign that says no service animals or no dogs? Or is that just something you find out after you're in and they ask you to leave? Well, if it's a business, it's illegal to turn away any person with a service animal. Federal law, the ADA says it is. Already before we pass this law? Mm-hmm. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Seeing no further questions, we have someone else speak for. I'm sorry, Representative Lundstrom, you're recognized. OK, OK. We'll wait for Representative Lundstrom and come back then. Next to speak against this bill is Kevin Carr. And if you would. I'm sorry, we don't know if you're for or against that. I'm sorry. Just if you would, recognize yourself at the record. I'm Kevin Carr, Parks Administration for the Arkansas Department of Parks and Tourism we're not necessarily against this bill that some of the language in here does concern us I think was already raised earlier there's some ambiguous language on page two about the service animals just about everywhere else it does discuss service dogs and AD is very specific about service dogs and horses miniature horses being allowed but that language there leads us some leads us to some concerns that we might be opening ourselves up to other animals that aren't specified by the ADA. Okay, so your opinion this would go further than ADA and that would open it up to more animals than what the ADA currently allows? As it's currently written here, we are concerned that it will open us up to other animals that are not currently allowed under the ADA. Members, any questions for Mr. Carr? Seeing none, thank you for your testimony. Representative Letting, you're recognized to close for your bill. and probably if you would again typically closing there's not questions but I think there may be more questions if you'd be open for them. Right but I would like to address a couple of points just real quickly regarding the filthiness with all due respect to Mr. Calvert these animals are some of the best kept they're very expensive a service dog can cost $20,000 or more so I certainly don't think that they're going to be necessarily caked in mud and swarming with fleas when they come into establishment. And also, we were really only trying to focus on dogs. At one point, we did not have service animals in there. So I'm going to get back with our drafting attorney and follow up on that. I'm still happy to answer any questions, but I do think to make sure we address the committee's concerns and the Parks Department's concerns, because we had heard from them, too, about the service animals. Our intent was only to focus on dogs. So with the committee's permission, again I'm still happy to answer some questions, but I think we'll pull the bill down and make sure we take care of that language. Representative Lundgren, do you still have a question? You're fine now. Okay, so Representative Lundgren, I'm addressing myself in other ways up here. What was your final request? Were you wanting to pull this down and address those issues? To address the service animal issue, yes. Yes sir, we'd be glad for you to do that and your recognized presents your second bill? Which one? I don't know. I've got three more. Yes, you do. 1276, the right to know your pay act. Okay. This is an issue we've actually been working on since I got down here in 2011. There are a small number of employers, very small number of employers who occasionally will fire an employee or an employee will quit and the employer will fail to pay that employee wages that he or she has earned. One of the ways we're trying to address that with the Right to Know Your Pay Act, we're simply going to require employers of four more employees to provide a pay stub, a minimum of just once per month, that would list basic contact information for the employer, along with the wages earned during that period and any deductions. For most Americans, I think, and most Arkansans, a pay stub is the second most important piece of paper that they get in the envelope on Friday. They're more interested in the check, but if you're my wife, the pay stub is a very important part of your financial record-keeping. We just feel that if employees have a pay stub, it's one more tool that they can use if they do have a wage claim. Really, that's straightforward. Representative Beaks, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I know that a lot of businesses already potentially do that. It's not necessarily it's the pay period and then maybe a year to date, but I'm thinking that this is going to change it to let's see if total hours worked by employees. So can you clarify that as far as the total hours? I mean, is it year to date? It would just be for that pay period, a minimum of once a month. We did originally have it for each pay period, but Representative Bell made the recommendation that we only do it once per month, and we accommodated that request. There is a gentleman here from the Department of Labor, Mr. Faulkner, who might be able to better answer that question. Okay, and I do have a follow-up, Mr. Chair. Yes, sir, go ahead with your follow-up, then we'll break the line up. Okay, because, yeah, Mr. Faulkner may need to address this one as well, because it does say at least one time each month a pay stub, and I don't know if there is a legal definition for pay stub, because as you know, a lot of folks get something sent electronically, and it's not an actual paper type deal, so if you could address pay stub and if that would include electronic means of doing that. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Daniel Faulkner, Staff Attorney, Arkansas Department of Labor. This is not an agency bill, but we're neutral on the bill. It doesn't create any enforcement issues for us. Specifically, Representative Meeks, I think your question was about the one month. Currently, under state law, there's a semi-monthly payment statute that requires corporations to pay semi-monthly already, but there's some exemptions from that. So there already are employers that can pay once a month. I read this to indicate slack for those that can pay once a month because it does say in Section 4 here, identifies the pay period for which it's made. So the month, if you can pay by the month, I think that's how that would be read together. And your second question was with respect to, I'm sorry, I was paced up. I don't see a definition of pay stub in the statute. We would be very broad in our definition. Anything that indicates these factors listed in Representative Letting's bill we would take a look at, regardless of form. I don't see it restricted to any form. Yes, sir. Representative Payton, you recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Letting, my question has to do with the very last line where it says an employer who fails to provide a pay stub as required under this section may be assessed a penalty under 11-4-2-0-6. Could you tell us what penalties they're subjected to there? I can handle that, Representative Payton. 11-4-2-0-6 is the penalty attached to the Arkansas Minimum Wage Act. The penalty is standard with any civil penalty, as little as $50 up to $1,000 in the statute. But it does require willfulness in that statute, which typically how we've enforced this, I mentioned the semi-monthly payment statute earlier. It has similar provisions. Typically, we've enforced that if it's your second time to come to us, we can prove willfulness, or if we visited your business before and you have a poster indicating you know the law. The semi-monthly statute that exists right now, I've been with the agency 13 years. I don't recall a single penalty for that. Typically, those types of complaints are handled by visit to the employer, and many times the employer just doesn't know that's the case and it's corrected but the penalties are pretty broad as with any statutory scheme yes sir if I could have a follow-up yes sir my follow-up would just be what educational process there would be to try to make the employers aware of this change typically in the past our practice has been in conjunction with our investigators to do what we call a sweep we had a child labor bill in here recently if you recall that representative Lowry changed some child labor laws. There were some changes last session as well. We typically try to get out and inform the public about those through the posters, through our newsletter, and in some cases even investigators going out and personally visiting a business. But we can sure do some outreach and, you know, phase this in, so to speak, if necessary. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Sullivan, you recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So a contractor who has several jobs out there and they employ someone for a few days to work for them and then they leave and they have another job and they find another employee or two or three or more employees and then they go through 15 or 20 employees on a semi-cash basis in the course of that month. They're going to have to track each one of those employees, and who owns that responsibility? Is it the employer to find that person or the employee to go back to get the pay stub? I just think that seems very difficult for somebody who has a lot of employees that they go through in a month. I don't want to speak for the sponsor, but from our enforcement perspective, it would place the onus on the employer, just like other record-keeping requirements. So I would have to, if I have 30 employees that work for me this month and 30 next month, if I'm going through a lot of folks, I've got to find each one of those people and give them a pay stub for a few days' work. I would hope that they would have contact information for you, and it would be as simple as sending an e-mail or putting the pay stub in the mail. All right, members, you've heard the explanation of the bill. I'm seeing no further questions. I don't have anyone signed up to speak for or against this bill. Anyone from the audience to speak for or against? Seeing none, Representative Letting, are you closed for this bill? Yes. Representative Letting is closed for the bill. What's the will of this committee? Well, you're lucky I was about to call that one dead. Or I'm not lucky, I don't know which. Representative Love, what's your motion? Motion do pass. we have a motion do pass any discussion of that motion hearing or seeing none everybody in favor say aye everybody opposed chair of rules and those have it members we've got about seven minutes left I don't think that's enough time to hear another bill so we're adjourned
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1407

8:24 - 10:31 4 segments

HB1160

10:31 - 51:06 76 segments

HB1452

51:06 - 54:05 5 segments

HB1008

54:05 - 1:01:44 14 segments

HB1497

1:01:44 - 1:17:34 29 segments

HB1466

1:17:34 - 1:20:50 6 segments

HB1192

1:20:50 - 1:44:08 43 segments

HB1276

1:44:08 - 1:51:33 13 segments

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers