Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Agriculture, Forestry and Economic Development

March 11, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (10)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1003 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Okay, next is House Bill 1003. Representative Meeks, you're recognized to present your bi…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1388 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1388”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1963 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1963”
Pre-2017 bill
SB403 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…llo is not here, so we'll pass over that. That brings us to Senate Bill 403, Senator Irwin. Anybody going to run that bill for her toda…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1564 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…Waiting on an amendment. Okay, waiting on an amendment. But House Bill 1564, Representative Fite, I don't see her here. House Bill 1582…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1582 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…House Bill 1564, Representative Fite, I don't see her here. House Bill 1582, Mr. Gossage, I don't see him here.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1620 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “House Bill 1620, Representative Civillo is not here, so we'll pass over tha…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1825 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1825”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1960 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1960”
Pre-2017 bill
SB554 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…Irwin. Anybody going to run that bill for her today? Okay, SB 554, Representative Sanders. I told you we were going to be fas…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
Unknown speaker 0:00
We'll clear the calendar. The first thing I'd like to do is introduce Dr. Robert Stack. And I'd like to recognize Representative Lampkin for the introduction. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'd just like to introduce Dr. Robert Stack from UAM. Sir? Star. Star, what did I say? Okay, Stark, I'm sorry. I have his email address and I missed that one. Dr. Robert Stark from UAM and his ag policy class from UAM. We're real proud of Dr. Stark and his department and what they do, and really proud of our students. How many of you are from southeast Arkansas? See, there you go. We're honored to have them today, to sit in on our session as much as they can, and to attend the session this afternoon and see their legislator at work. Like the legislature at work. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, ma'am. And, Robert, we did try to make you one of the untouchables, but other than that, we'll go with that. Okay, the first item on the agenda today is 1553. Representative Ratliff said he'd like to pass over that. Waiting on an amendment. Okay, waiting on an amendment. But House Bill 1564, Representative Fite, I don't see her here. House Bill 1582, Mr. Gossage, I don't see him here. House Bill 1620, Representative Civillo is not here, so we'll pass over that. That brings us to Senate Bill 403, Senator Irwin. Anybody going to run that bill for her today? Okay, SB 554, Representative Sanders. I told you we were going to be fast today. You know I'm here. I know you're here, but before we get to you, without objection, I would like to take a bill out of order. I know that Representative Eubanks is here, and he's got to catch an airplane. So, Representative, you are recognized for House Bill 1963. Thank you, Mr. Chair, committee. If you'll take a look at House Bill 1963, the purpose that I'm bringing this bill to you is I'd like to try to avoid litigation if at all possible. So in my experience as a poultry grower, there's been times when there's been a dispute between the grower and the integrator. And at one time, my integrator had a grievance committee set up where you could file a grievance and have an opportunity to present your case. And the makeup of that committee was part company people and part growers. and I actually served on that committee at one time. They did away with that and right now I don't believe the growers really have any kind of recourse other than going to court. And like I said, if at all possible, I try to avoid litigation if at all possible. So I'm proposing that this arbitration committee be set up at Livestock and Poultry and if you look through the bill, the governor appoints the members of that and he appoints three members from a list that's supplied by Farm Bureau of Current Growers and he appoints three members from a list supplied by the Poultry Federation and then he has one at large that is not associated with either. the purpose of this and if you go on and read they they have to in order to keep it from being trivial in nature they have to file they have to pay 250 dollar fee to the livestock and poultry in order to even go through the process and like there's other details in there they have to do it a timely fashion and that sort of thing. The findings are not binding in nature. We would certainly hope that whatever the findings were that the people, whichever party, would choose to do the right thing. But if not, then they can certainly use whatever the findings of the committee was if they choose to litigate it. a short version of it. I spoke with BLR. There are some existing laws on the book regarding arbitration, and they do single out different industries, you might say, where arbitration is allowed specifically for them. So are there any questions? Anybody have any questions? see none are you closed for your bill i believe somebody might want to speak against it though i think i think i might want to i might want to close after they say okay all right are there any uh anybody in the audience that would like to speak against the bill Mr. Childers, you are recognized identify yourself and you're recognized to speak against the bill. Thank you Mr. Chairman and members of the committee Representative Umanks did a great job explaining about arbitration and I want to say on the very front end the poultry integrators are not opposed to arbitration What I think I'm going to point out to you is... Marvin, would you, for the record, recognize yourself? I'm sorry. I'm Marvin Childers. I'm president of the Poultry Federation. We're not opposed. The integrators are not opposed to arbitration. But what I want to call your attention to is in 2005, the General Assembly, unfortunately I happened to be here at that time, And the General Assembly passed a law that said neither party shall be denied the right to go to court. Initially, all poultry production contracts had a mandatory arbitration clause in it. And I think Representative Eubanks will tell you that the growers, Representative Hinder will know, that the growers were absolutely opposed to being forced into arbitration as opposed to having the ability to file suit. So the law was changed to say both parties have a right to go to court. In addition, the current code says if a dispute arises and the parties then agree, they can go to arbitration. And, you know, what I'm suggesting to you is that this bill flies directly in conflict with 232.301, which says both parties have the right to go to court. in addition and this is something I mentioned to Representative Eubanks in addition in 1981 the Arkansas General Assembly adopted the Uniform Arbitration Act we have set forth in Arkansas Code 16-108-201 through 224 and that act sets forth all of anything that can where there's a dispute where you can go to arbitration this bill sets up a complete new tribunal at livestock and poultry it requires to the vice president of the division of ag to be a non or ex officio member it requires the director of livestock and poultry to be the secretary, and I just believe that it's, you know, it's duplicative of, you know, the current uniform act. Additionally, I think what happens or what the end result is going to be, as Representative Eubanks said, it's not binding, but the things that it does do, it says a A contractor can have an attorney present during the hearing, but the attorney cannot participate. So any integrator who goes to arbitration and takes a lawyer, the lawyer sits in the hearing but can't participate. And what I'm suggesting to you is nobody's going to arbitration. So basically what you're going to do is you're going to kill the opportunity that we currently have in Arkansas law. You're going to kill the opportunity for those growers to go to arbitration because no integrator is going to agree to do that. That's my opposition to the bill. It's not that we're opposed to arbitration. I think the current law already authorizes that. I'll be glad to answer any questions, Mr. Chairman. Okay, any questions for Mr. Childress? Mr. Hendon, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. To both of you gentlemen at the end of the table, Representative Eubanks, can you respond to what he just said? Because you've been a grower, and I still haven't been smart enough to get out of it yet, so we both look at this. What I understood him to just say is that if we pass this bill as a grower, I'm going to have less opportunity to take on Simmons or not Peterson anymore, Tyson or whoever, than I have now. Marvin, is that what you're saying? Yes, sir. I mean, I think when you say, number one, Tyson, take for instance, Tyson can have an attorney present, but they can't participate. I think that just totally eliminates the possibility of Tyson ever agreeing to go to arbitration. And if that's the case, then. So as president of the Poultry Federation, you're going to advise your members, if they can't take their counsel and participate, not to go to arbitration? I mean, you know, those companies are going to speak for themselves. But I can tell you, I've polled every poultry company in Arkansas. Nobody's going to go to arbitration if they can't take their lawyers and participate. In addition, the bill also, I think, violates Amendment 80 because it says you've got seven people who are going to be taking evidence. And that evidence or the findings from that arbitration panel, they're telling the court that that's admissible in a trial subsequent to arbitration. I mean, I don't think that'll fly either. And the way the law is now, they'd have to go to arbitration. No, the way it is now is the poultry companies cannot force you to go to arbitration, but the current law says if you and Simmons agree to arbitrate, you can, and you go under the Uniform Arbitration Act. A couple more questions, Mr. Now, to go to arbitration, the integrator would have to agree. Both parties have to agree under current law. And probably as their advisor, you'd say, well, don't agree then. No, I think you'll see, and I agree with Representative Eubanks, I think a lot of claims can be and should be arbitrated as opposed to tying up court time. And if I could ask Mr. Representative? Yes, sir. Go ahead. Representative Eubanks, would you respond to that right now, what difference it makes? It would help me. Thank you. Well, my understanding of the bill is it doesn't prevent them from going. litigation to resolve the issue. I'm trying to interject another means that maybe keeps that from having to go that far. And with regard to a couple other points that Mr. Trilders made, the Vice President of Agriculture or his designee is a member, and the reason that we put them on there is because they would have maybe some expertise with regard to some of these issues, especially with poultry issues particularly. But with regard to the attorneys, it states that that's the case with an informal hearing, that they may choose to call an informal hearing to see if they can work out those things beforehand, and that's where the attorney could be. That's where it specifically addresses that issue, where they cannot participate. As far as giving, I would say that direct participation refers to direct testimony. I don't think that means they can't be advising their clients in that. But I go back to my issue that I think this is a means that helps prevent litigation. It doesn't restrict them from going that route if they so choose. Okay. Other questions? Representative Meeks. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The one question that comes to my mind, and either or both of you gentlemen can answer this, is there that many issues or complaints within the poultry industry that it requires that we do this or that we have this avenue? I'm not a poultry farmer. There are a lot of issues that do come up, but for the lack of a reasonable avenue for growers to pursue, they'll make their case to their respective integrators and hope that they might look favorably upon whatever their issue is. Some of them are legitimate and some of them aren't. I was in the poultry business for 38 years, and there were many attempts to try to form associations. And what I found was usually the loudest complainers were sometimes the worst managers. So lots of times you just couldn't get together on issues because some people were expecting integrators to do things that are completely just unreasonable or things that are out of their control. but in your mind do you think that there is enough complaints or enough issues in the system that it warrants trying to do something like this I want the grower to have an opportunity to have some recourse and if they're going to have to make the decision whether they think it's important enough to go that far they're going to have to pay a $250 fee in order just to get it heard thank you Mr. Chairman other questions? Thank you, Mr. Childers. Is anyone here to speak for the bill? Anyone here to speak against the bill? Now, you may close for your bill. Thank you, sir. One of the other things that Mr. Childers brought up was about the arbitration law. This is modeled after an effective seed arbitration board that's set up at the plant board for row crop. And that was the model that we used. And they formed a committee, and we just went basically by the language that is already being used with regard to one agricultural practice. So I would hope that the committee would give this bill an opportunity to move through the system. And with that, I move to do pass. All right, we have a motion to do pass. All in favor say aye. Opposed, no. The chair rules the motion passes. Thank you, sir. Thank you, sir. Thank you, committee. Now we will go back to the regular order. Representative Waterlaw, you're recognized to speak on House Bill 1388. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. If you would indulge me, I'd like to bring Adam from the Cattlemen Association, please. Okay. Adam, if you would identify yourself and who you represent. My name is Adam McClung with Arkansas Cattlemen Association. Mr. Chairman, committee, this bill does something that the House floor asked for two years ago. It caps the cattleman $1 at $1. If everybody recalls two years ago, I know the freshmen wouldn't. This bill was ran, but it capped it at $2 and failed miserably on the floor because everybody was asking for the $1 cap. This bill does that. It also has an emergency clause in there so that if livestock and poultry sees the need to raise that fee, they can come to ALC in the interim or the budget in the session and ask for that raise. They only get to raise it for one year at a time and it goes back to the dollar. So with that I'll take any questions. Any questions? Seeing none, is there anyone? Okay. Representative Hendren, you're recognized. What's done with this fee that's being collected now And what's the fund balance? I don't know the fund balance, Representative Hendren. But if you remember, Representative Douglas, the chair of this great committee, came down here and changed the name of this fund until bovine disease. Am I saying that right? From the BANGS program. And all this does is cap that same fund that he changed the name. So it will go to help with cattle diseases throughout the state. And one of the reasons I asked that question is I know cattle prices are so low now that we need to reduce this. But if we have money in the fund we don't need, I can certainly understand that. If I could just a few comments. The numbers we've been shown by livestock and poultry are about $1.2 million that this fund needs to fund 32 field men. And it's a field man program is essentially what it is. The guys out in the field, they're doing the disease testing in the cell barns and so on. And there's a dollar a head collected on all in-state sold cattle. And right now, that's about $650,000 of that fund. We're about 60% of their workload, so we feel like that we're paying our share of that. And then those field men also work on, you know, other species, diseases, and outbreaks as well. I was just wondering if we might take this, if we left it where it was, and use it to help offset the loss in the scholarship lottery scholarships? I believe we're going to plead the fifth. Okay, other questions? Yes, sir. Mr. House, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I noticed it says that, you know, we changed the name from brucellosis to bovine disease, but the language of this says to be used for the brucellosis program. Do we need to fix that? No, sir. That was addressed by the wonderful Farm Bureau, and the lawyers in the Bureau said that we need to leave that the way it is because if we change it in this bill, it contradicts with Representative Douglas' bill, and they assure me that that needs to stay the way it is in the bill today. And when the codifiers, you know, when the bills pass and they go through and the governor signs them, they go over to the codifiers. When they codify it, it will be capping Representative Douglas' new fund. So they can codify it so it pays for the scholarship program that Senator had. That would be a negative. Thank you, Chair. Other questions? Is there anyone in the audience that would wish to speak against the bill? Anyone for the bill? Yes, sir. I've got a motion at the proper time. Thank you. Seeing no one in the audience that wishes to speak for or against the bill, would you like to close for your bill? We're closed, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Ratliff, you're recognized for a motion. Do pass. Motion do pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed, no. You have passed your bill. Thank you, committee and Mr. Chair. Okay, next is House Bill 1003. Representative Meeks, you're recognized to present your bill. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, committee. Well, if I thought I could get away with that, I would just say that this is a comprehensive technical correction, but I think we're going to probably need a little bit more explanation about this bill and what it does. You know, a lot of times we come down here to the end of the table, and we like to say we've got a little bill that doesn't do anything. And there was such a bill that was passed, and that's what I'm trying to correct. We had an outdoor lighting law that was passed 10 years ago that had good intentions, but unfortunately it's been of little effect, and a lot of the technology and terminology that's within the law is outdated. So what I want to do is I'm going to bring you a bill today that has the goal of trying to fulfill what the goal of that original law was and to try to update the law to make it a little more modern. As many of you know that have been around here for a while, this is a bill that I've been working on for four years. This is not something that somebody brought to me. This is something that I've developed with a lot of work, and this is probably one of the most well-vetted bills you will look at this session. because there's been well over a dozen agencies and organizations that have looked at this. So let me give you a little bit of background about why we need this kind of bill to begin with, and then we'll go into what the bill does. On the handout that I gave you, this is a map of the state of Arkansas, and it is the light pollution map that shows the outdoor lighting levels in our state at night. you can see quite clearly in the center you'll see the bright spot for Little Rock you'll see all of our major cities Conway, Fort Smith, Fayetteville, Texarkana down in the bottom left corner you can see the bright glow from Dallas and so forth and according to standards set by the International Astronomical Union and that's the body that is the international body that determines the standards in astronomy for example they're the ones who decided that Pluto wasn't a planet a couple years ago They set the boundaries of the constellations. And according to the standards that they have set, Arkansas, the natural state, has no place, there's nowhere in our state that you can go that the sky will get naturally dark at night. So in a state that prides itself on being the natural state, there's nowhere that you can go and find a naturally dark sky at night, not even in the Ozarks. It gets close, but it never does reach natural darkness. And this is typically caused by the misuse or misdirected outdoor lighting. So to kind of help to create an analogy that makes it a little bit easier to understand what's happening here, imagine driving into a subdivision where there are sprinkler heads that are placed besides the curb, and every evening the water comes on and is sent in 360 degrees away from the sprinkler head. such that some of the water goes into the street, some goes onto the sidewalk, and some of it goes onto the grass where it's actually needed. The portion of the water that's going onto the street is clearly it's wasted water. And it's not just the water that's wasted, it's the resources that took to get the water there in the first place that are also being wasted by this. There are also negative consequences of the negative of the water, you know, being on the road. You lose traction, you take chemicals that are being washed down into the gutter, So there's negative consequences to that. Now, if it was just one sprinkler, we probably wouldn't say much about it. But imagine if it was a whole neighborhood that was sending water or dozens of neighborhoods across the street. And that's analogous to what we're doing with some of our outdoor lighting, where we've got outdoor globe lights that send light off in every direction, like the water that's wasted going into the street, all the water that comes off those globe lamps. And if you want to kind of see what I'm talking about on the second page here, I'm talking about these kind of light fixtures. So a light fixture that's a big, giant globe, all the light that comes out of the top portion of that fixture is wasted, and so is the electricity. That's wasted electricity. Everything that's used to make that electricity is wasted. The dollars spent to buy that electricity, the tax dollars, are all wasted. Similarly, if we continue in our analogy, somebody that went jogging along the sidewalk where this water is coming out of the sprinkler head that was getting hit in the eye every time they passed a sprinkler head the same thing happens when you or i are driving down the road and we come across either a bright billboard or bright light that's shining in our eyes and that's called glare and that creates another problem so those are the two things that this bill is primarily looking at addressing so what are the consequences of the sky glow and the glare. Two years ago when I presented this bill and the health committee, the health committee was gracious enough to pass it out, but I had an economist from the Missouri State University. It was Dr. David Mitchell who specializes in the economic impacts of light pollution, and he testified that the state of Arkansas collectively waste, one little sprinkler head at a time, collectively waste $50 million a year. Now that's government, private, and businesses. That's everyone together. So we're talking about quite a bit of money here. This is not just a few dollars here and there. There are also ramifications of human health, which is why it was originally sent to the health committee. Light pollution has been shown to be a risk factor for certain types of cancer. Now, while at first it may seem funny that light can cause cancer, but I want you to think about whenever you go to the beach, you put on suntan lotion. Why do you put on suntan lotion? Well, it's not only to protect you from sunburns, but you also don't want to get skin cancer. The light that we're talking about here works in a slightly different way. When we go to sleep at night in the presence of light, our penile gland produces a hormone that's called melatonin. And melatonin has been shown to protect us against certain types of cancers. But when we're in the presence of light, melatonin is diminished. And so is our ability to fight off those cancers that melatonin protects us from. An Israeli study released in 2008, which compared the nighttime levels in 147 communities across Israel and related them to the incidences of breast cancer within those communities, found that there was a 73% higher occurrence of breast cancer in the brightest-lit communities versus the darkest communities. Much higher incidence of breast cancer, and it also translated into prostate cancer for men. So you've got higher incidences. Also, because melatonin's primary function within the body is to signal the day and night are circadian rhythms, with the reduction in melatonin, it disrupts the circadian rhythm and all the side effects that come as a result of that. Insomnia, diabetes, obesity, and cardiovascular health are also affected by this issue. And a lot of you probably know this from your own personal lives. Imagine, when was the last time you went outside at night and it was truly dark and you had to have a flashlight to see? Unless you live out in a rural area, it's probably been an extremely long time. Wildlife is also affected, sometimes tens of miles away from the city that's creating the glow. And just to give you a few examples, I know, for time. So, for example, nocturnal mammals that use the cover of darkness to forage for food at night become easier prey for predators. insects swirl under bright lights and suddenly they become easy prey for bats that are not adverse to the light so the bats that are okay with the light they can easily find the food but there are certain species of bats that are adverse to the light so it makes them harder to find food crows they like to roost in the presence of the light because that protects them from the owls and evidently and i find this somewhat comical evidently female frogs are less selective in their mating choices when they're exposed to light at night. So it's kind of counterintuitive. They can see the mate. They're less selective than if they could see it. Yeah, it seems kind of counterintuitive, right? Yeah. Songbirds are also affected. You may, you know, may even, from your own personal experience, you hear songs at night. Those of you that have been in the legislature for any period of time may remember a couple years ago, NCSL, we held our national convention up at McCormick Place in Chicago. Well, they had a study done. Evidently, the Chicago Field Museum, they would typically, in years past, whenever they needed species for their research of birds, they would actually have to go out and kill the birds and bring them in. Well, they started to actually go to the McCormick Place Convention Center because there was all sorts of dead birds being found there. During the study, when the convention center lights were on at night during the study period, they were able to collect 1,300 dead songbirds or migratory birds from the rooftops of the convention center. But on the night that the lights were not on at the convention center, the number of birds that they were able to find dropped almost 80% to under 200 birds. So light pollution has a major impact upon wildlife, and unfortunately, the full ramification of this issue are still being studied. Many of you know that my interest in this is related to the cosmos and notice up until now I've not mentioned it as a reason to do this but I've stood in the Arizona desert on a dark moonless night and have seen the glory of the Milky Way stretch from horizon to horizon and it was so bright that it was almost able to cast shadows. That's a view that would be visible every night from here in Arkansas except we mask it every night with light pollution. In 1994, some of you may remember there was an earthquake in Los Angeles that knocked out power to the city at night. Shortly thereafter, the 911 calls came in from people in the city who were concerned and frightened about a strange silvery cloud in the sky. And they were afraid that that silver cloud was actually responsible for causing the earthquake. Well, what they were actually seeing for the first time was the Milky Way. It's been estimated that two-thirds of Americans live in an area where it never gets dark enough to see the Milky Way. and almost half of American adults have never actually seen the Milky Way. One final point that I'll make and then I'll get to the bill is the issue of light pollution also is an impact on tourism. When people travel from large cities such as Dallas to enjoy the scenic beauty of our Ozark Mountains, one of the things that allures them there is the nighttime ambiance. Whether it's sitting on the porch on a summer's evening watching the firefly, seeing nocturnal animals, or watching stars in a meteor shower, the nighttime environment plays an important aspect of whether people choose to visit our state. If you're in a rustic mountain cabin, the last thing you wanted to do is see the bright glow of a city skyline. So let's talk a little bit about what the bill does. In your packet on the last two pages, I have the current law as it stands. And again, it was passed back in, I think, the 03 or 05 session. So this law has been around for approximately 10 years. So what the bill does is it seeks in a practical, pragmatic, and common-sense way over time, so we're not telling the cities or anybody to go out tomorrow and suddenly fix all this. We're saying as we move forward, when it becomes time to replace lighting fixtures that are ready to be replaced, that they need to use fully shielded lamps. And what we're talking about here is we're talking about lamps that direct all the light down. So we're not sending it off to the side. We're not cleaning glare. We're not sending the light off into space. We're sending all of the light down. Now, the current law already calls for that. If you look on the first page, it says no public fund shall be used to install an outdoor lighting fixture unless it's shielded. There are only two definitions in the law. It says shielded is a light that we're going to send all the light down. So the first thing that the bill does is it updates the definitions to more scientifically accurate definitions. We just have shielded. But there's a differentiation between partially shielded and fully shielded. There's also, within the law, it talks about using 150-watt incandescent bulbs. Well, 150-watt incandescent bulbs are no longer available. Remember, they were outlined by Congress a couple years ago. The brightest incandescent bulbs I think you can get nowadays are 60 watts. And then we have the new invention of the LED technology. A, you know, 15-watt LED bulb puts out as much brightness as a 60-watt incandescence as much as a 20-watt fluorescent. So basing the brightness of a bulb based on its energy output is no longer a good way to judge the brightness of a bulb. So one of the definition updates that I do is I change it over to the lumen, and a lumen is the scientific measure of the brightness of a bulb. So we're comparing bulbs apple to apples now instead of by whatever their energy output is. So besides cleaning up the definitions and cleaning up the intent of the law, I also update some of the exemptions. Did you know right now that based upon the law that we have that it is technically it is illegal for any city or county within this state to go out and put up a brand new flagpole and light it at night? It is against the law for any city to light the American flag at night because in the current law it says if they're going to use a light that's greater than 70 watts that it has to be fully shielded and shining down. So there is no allowance or exemption for lighting a flag at night. There is no allowance or exemption for lighting your courthouse or lighting monuments. Those are exemptions and things that I've added into the bill. There is also a current law that says that cities and counties, if they see that something is too costly, they have to pass an ordinance. How many cities and counties do you think have actually done that? I suspect the answer is probably close to zero. My bill takes that out of there, says they're no longer required to do that. but i put in a different um thing i say uh what what my current bill does is it says that if and when the resources become available you upgrade to this lighting unless you find it's cost prohibitive so one of the things the cities have been concerned about is great cost well that's not an issue if it becomes cost prohibitive they don't have to do it if there are structural issues uh for example the arkansas building authority brought to me the concern that if I currently have a wall pack that is shining onto a parking lot in order for me to become compliant with the laws that currently stands, then what they would have to do is go out and put up a big pole out in the middle of the parking lot and do away with the wall pack. I have allowances for structural modifications. I also have allowances for safety concerns. Those are not addressed in the current law. The other thing it does is, and the main focus is the cities and the government entities. The only major private business that is addressed in the bill is billboards. I've been working with the Billboard Association, and I think they may still be here in the room with us. They're still here in the room. They have graciously been working with me on this, and we've come up with some language that the Outdoor Advertising Association of America, they actually have this neat little brochure that they put out, They flew a representative down from Washington, D.C. to bring these standards to me to include into this bill. The issue is with these new bright LED signs that are coming out is different cities across the state of Arkansas are passing different levels of ordinances and are not necessarily based upon scientific research. And so what the organization did is they went out and they commissioned a group of scientists to come up with a standard, and that's the standard that we've included in the bill. So we're upgrading the standard to the scientifically researched standards. There's still one or two tweaks that we're trying to work out with them, but otherwise they are in support of the bill. The last item that the bill addresses, and this is something new, this is something that came to me at the request of the numerous Arkansans who have contacted me in support of the bill, and it's to try to address something that's known as light trespass. The concept of light trespass is simple. You know, your neighbor has the right to play whatever music they want in their house, but do they have the right to rattle your walls at 3 o'clock in the morning? You know, your neighbor has the right to, you know, dump whatever they want on their lawn, but do they still have the right to do it when it runs down into your yard? Your neighbor has the right to put up a light at night, but do they have the right to put up a light at night that shines into your bedroom window? And so what the bill does is, and I set a fairly high standard on this, but the idea here is, you know, your neighbor has the right, They can light their yard up like the noonday sun if they want, but do they have the right to light up your yard like the noonday sun if you don't want it done? So what I've said is that if your neighbor puts up a light, if it's within 25 feet of your property, and it has to be the property owner, so it can't just be any person out there who wants to do it, but if they put up a light within 25 feet, if it is objectionable to you, then it requires your neighbor just to shield it so that their light stays on their property. or if the ambient light on your property jumps above 50-foot candles. Now, the idea here is this. You may have a neighbor who is just being persnickety, and so what they do is instead of shining the light directly at your bedroom window, they shine it against a wall or something that reflects and still the net effect is that your bedroom window is being lit up at night. And this says that if it is above 50-foot candles. Now, to give you an idea where 50-foot candles is, it's roughly about 60 to 70-foot candles in here. So we're talking a fairly high threshold that they have to be adding to whatever the ambient light is on the property. So in a nutshell, that's what the bill does. And just to give you an idea who this bill has been vetted by, and then I'll finish with that and take any questions, this bill has been looked at by the Municipal League, the Association of Counties, the Department of Higher Head, the Arkansas Association of Educational Administration, the Highway and Transportation Department, the Building Authority, the Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality, the Public Service Commission, as I said, the Billboard Association here in Arkansas, Energy and the Electric Cohops have looked at this, Conway Corp has looked at this. The bill does have the support of the International Dark Sky Association, which is an international group based out of Arizona. The Arkansas Astronomical Societies and the Audubon Society contacted me this week to also express their support for the bill. So with that, Mr. Chairman, I will attempt to answer any questions that the committee may have. All right. Committee, you've heard Representative Meeks explain his bill. Are there any questions? Representative Hendren? I see you're back, Mr. Chairman. Welcome to the committee meeting. Thank you. I may not get recognized for a question now. A couple of questions. Representative Meek, you mentioned in here that I think part of this bill that says for a city or a county, when funds become available, they're to make adjustments to conform to this. Who determines whether they're available? What if I want to build another Broadway in my city, or I want to build another, I want to plant some more trees or build a bigger park or what have you, and I say I don't have money to do what you want to do, I want to build these other things. What happens then? Very good question. You build those other things. That's entirely up to that governing body. That's not the answer I wanted to that. Well, that's it. It's permissive language. If they see that they have the money to do this beforehand, then it asks them to try to move in this direction. If they don't, they want to use those resources for something else. In your opinion, that's why the Municipal League, you say, supports this bill? Well, I didn't say they supported it. Unfortunately, the cities tend to be the biggest offenders of this. Now, I will say that several of the cities have already started moving in this direction. Fayetteville has worked on this. Eureka Springs has worked on this. Well, you put two interesting examples there. Yes, yes, yes. I was going to say, even Conway, which is a more conservative city, The city of Conway is also working on looking at updating some of these lights. Because a lot of the cities that switch over to the LED technology of the street lights, now the bill doesn't say they have to do that. But the cities that are willing to make that investment, they will end up saving anywhere between 40, 50, 60 percent on their electric bills. So if you have a city like the city of Little Rock, they're spending over a million dollars a year to light up the streets at night. night if they were to over time to do this they could potentially be looking at saving 20 30 40 percent on the cost of those lights and that's you know that's real tax dollar money second question you mentioned this ancient bill 10 or 15 years ago and i'm sure i probably had something to do with that but i thought that we had dealt with this and you mentioned light trespassing here one of the things that that i'm interested what this deals with or not one of the things that really bothers me and bothers my constituents. You'll be driving down the highway, and maybe you have an outside storage building or whatever, and they will locate a light for that that actually shines against their building, but it also shines right down the highway. Right. And you can't tell whether that's a car you're meeting. Maybe that's because for older folks, but I think it's even for the younger folks. You can't tell whether that's a car coming down the road or some kind of a problem down there. Is there anything in this bill that helps control that? because you just don't have any business, in my opinion, shining a bright light down the center of a highway. Right. I would say yes and no. One of the things I've been cautious on this bill, because, you know, it's a good conservative and, you know, limited government, I've been very cautious to not apply this to local businesses or to personal property, except for the light trespass issue. But this bill gives guidance to any local city or municipality that would like to pass something along these lines because of the updated definitions and because I set that level at that 1,800 lumens level, that helps to create a basis so if a local city wants to pass something along those lines, then they can. So as far as you know, right now, if it's out in the country, and even the city or county doesn't have this, that I can pretty well shine a bright light down the highway. Unfortunately, yes. If I knew I could get away with it, I would include it in the bill, But I just don't think I could get away with it at this point. Okay. Representative Branscombe, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. When you were going over the list of all those entities that had vetted the bill, you had a long list. Were they for it or against it? Most of the ones that I had listed in just the vetted section were neutral on the bill. They weren't going to take a position either way. Like the transportation department, they were neutral. Energy, you know, they didn't care either way. the ones that I know that have come and said we are going to support the bill are those ones that I mentioned the Audubon Society the Astronomical Societies in the state and the Dark Sky Association since you've worked on this bill for several years and the research that you've done on it and what you've learned about it wouldn't you think that you'd probably know that most cities and counties and towns when they're replacing these aren't they going to the new efficiency standards anyway without this having to be mandated? Some of them are. Well, it's already mandated. It already mandates it. So, unfortunately, a lot of them are ignoring this, but a lot of them are, to some degree, naturally migrating along those lines. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Eubanks, you're recognized for a question. Representative Meeks, because of the way the lights are shielded, Would it require municipalities to put in more polls to provide the same amount of light for security reasons? Very good question. In some of the situations, depending on what is currently out there, that is a potential requirement that you may have to change the spacings on the poll, which is why the excessive cost and structural modification exemptions are in there. Thank you. Representative Whitaker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative, I have, first of all, a point of clarification on the handout we have here. Yes, sir. It's actually, if I'm correct, it's actually showing it in the negative. So the darker black is the brightest area. Correct. And the lighter are the darker areas. Yes, yes. And I did that as a good conservative to save a few pennies on ink to print out all the And I'm good with that. I'm good with that. I just wanted to be sure we were looking at the same map. Yeah, and on that map, I mean, you can see just the lights from Little Rock. They not only affect Little Rock, but it affects Faulkner County, White County, Yale County, Green. So, I mean, it's not just Little Rock. My question is, if this bill were to pass, would it preclude or preempt any lighting ordinances that may have already been, more stringent lighting ordinances that may already exist? No, no. There is a section that said that this is a cumulative and supplemental. So if any city or county already has something in place, then this would not usurp that now. Thank you. Okay. Hey, Representative Ratliff, you have a question? Yes, sir. Representative Meeks, have we got any idea what kind of impact it's going to have on the state and dollars? Well, ultimately, it should save us money. Save money? Save money, yep. So not only does it reduce light pollution, this pollution is kind of different than other pollutions that you'll find, like water pollution and air pollution. Typically, any effort to try to reduce those is going to cost money. This one is kind of unique in that efforts to reduce it actually saves money. Okay. Have one follow-up, please? I noticed that in all your list of folks in supporting us, the state police and the city police and the chief of police, none of them were involved. No, they have – I've not been contacted by any of them. Now, there is – one of the issues that are related to this is security and outdoor lighting, and that is a whole other topic, and I'm more than happy to get into it. But the long story short, studies have found that using light to reduce crime is not always about using brighter light, but about using light more wisely. In some cases, brighter lights actually increase the incidences of crime for various reasons, and it goes to if your property is very well lit, It's easier for the bad guys to see what you have there to steal. It's easier for them to see what security measures you have in place. It's easier for them to see ways to get in and ways to get out. There have been cities that, due to budget cuts, had to cut lights off in certain areas of town, and they found that the crime either stayed the same or went down. If you're talking about graffiti, evidently hoodlums don't like to hold a flashlight while they're doing their graffiti on a wall. They like the wall to be already well lit. So depending on what types of crime it is, crime can actually go up or down. It's not about using brighter, but using more wisely. Thanks, sir. I have a quick question along those lines there. Do you think the brighter light would cause more reflection to shine off Representative McElroy's head whenever he's sneaking around out in your yard at night? Could be. Could be. Well, what happens, and this may be beyond the scope of the discussion, but the way our eyes work at night, our eyes have a certain range of brightness that they operate in, and our eyes will always adjust to whatever the brightest light available is. And so if we're in a dim location, our eyes are going to adjust down here, and we're going to be able to see everything from the dim all the way to the darkest we can see. But if you put up a bright light, then our eyes are going to come up to that level, and that's why the problem of glare is created, because our eyes will come up to the level of that glaring light, and now everything down here is black and we can't see it and it creates shadows that bad guys can hide in or it makes it where we can no longer see what's ahead of us on the road. And that's what our eyes do with that. So that's why lighting, brighter lighting, can actually be a hindrance sometimes. All right, thank you. Representative Beck, did you have a question? Thank you, Chairman. As a representative McElroy's neighbor, I think this law will apply to me over here, right? Now, I share your – I had the opportunity to be out in New Mexico up on top of Mount Phillips, and the sky was absolutely beautiful up there. The concerns that I have, though, with the bill are this. I do some exterior lighting for another company, and, you know, some of my fixtures are provided by Intergy. And, you know, we have some fixtures that are ours, some fixtures are pole fixtures by Intergy. Intergy Corporation, and those really are a per month type of fixture. I pay per month for those fixtures. Is there anything in here that's going to allow me to, first of all, I'm assuming that they would be responsible for that upgrade, all right, and then second of all, if I'm upgrading to a more efficient light, is there anything in here that would require that as a customer, I would say a lower monthly rate or whatever. The first question is, and I've spoken with Energy, and they're fine with the bill. If you go to the page with these light fixtures, the light fixture that most of you are familiar with, the Cobra Head, is this one right here. And for them to stay compliant with the law, all they have to do is go from this drop-lensed Cobra Head to a flat-lensed Cobra Head. The cost to Energy is the same. You or I could go out on the web and purchase these. They're about $250, and it's the same cost. So the cost of the utility is basically the same. My hope is, and as energy goes before the Public Service Commission to establish their rates, that that would have to be taken into account. Thank you. Any further questions from the committee? Representative McElroy, you're recognized. Representative Meek, I appreciate you bringing it to me. You know, I was sitting there thinking, when I was a kid, we used kerosene lights. And I thought, and I never would have thought in a hundred years we'd be talking about light pollution because I was praying for something brighter than them things, especially on the way out to the outhouse. But, you know, we pass bills sometimes, pass laws here, without really giving them any teeth because, you know, nobody to enforce it. So who's going to be the one, the enforcer or the light police to say, hey, you're out of compliance? Okay, good question. The law, the way it currently stands, there is nobody. So that's part of the reason why this law is basically of little to no effect right now. And so what my bill does is right now, city council, they have to pass an ordinance. I take that away. And what I do is I say that if you have lights that are non-conforming fixtures, if you will, that once a year, whatever that city is, they would file a report with the Pollution Control and Ecology Commission that says that we've got this many fixtures that are non-conforming, and this is what, if anything, we're going to do to try to bring those into compliance. So it's kind of a once-a-year nag that the cities have to do to try to remind them. They no longer have to do the ordinance, but they just have to file this report that says that we're going to try to do this. Now, once they've come into compliance and they've got all the fixtures that they can get into compliance, because I know there's going to be some they can't, especially in the city, the Pollution Control and Ecology Board will say, you guys are good. You don't have to file the report anymore. So it tries to create accountability. The normal people that would do the normal enforcement would just be whoever the normal code enforcement folks are. OK, any more questions from the committee for Representative Meeks? Seeing none, I'd like to in the audience people to speak against the bill. We have Ken Wasson with the Municipal League. Ken, would you like to come up and give us your $0.02 worth, sir? Please sit down and recognize yourself, who you're with. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Ken Wasson with the Arkansas Municipal League. We have some concerns about this bill. We worked with, as Representative Meeks mentioned earlier in his testimony, that the Municipal League worked with Representative Ledbetter a few years ago in crafting the original bill. We were quite happy with it. I thought that it was doing the intended purpose of the bill, which, again, addresses some of light pollution as described in Mr. Makes' testimony. And from the years since the bill has passed, most of our municipalities have, again, tried to get in compliance with the bill and are definitely concerned and aware of the modern lights and ways to illuminate the areas and are doing their best to, of course, be in compliance and to be more energy efficient. Our concerns about this bill are really several. Number one, we don't know if there's been a fiscal impact statement drafted, so it's very difficult for us, after reading the 13 pages here, to determine whether or not how this is going to impact municipalities. We're very much concerned about that. You can read the bill. In some ways, it looks like it's going to be very expensive. Other ways, page another page, it's maybe not quite so bad. Regardless of that, we feel like this is an unfunded mandate and it's something that has solutions for this can be taken care of locally. We have some concerns about the security aspect of it. We get requests all the time from citizens asking for more lights in their neighborhood because of crime, because of intersections, because of safety, because of traffic. And so that's a concern that this, again, is regulating some of that or taking away some of the city's ability to regulate that. It, again, takes away the city's ability to want to upgrade and make more energy-efficient lighting in various areas. It was mentioned about the lights shining in people's eyes as they're driving down the streets or whatever. This can be taken care of, again, locally, local ordinances. This is a public safety concern. It's an issue that the local police department could easily get involved in and just say this is a safety issue. Let's get that corrected. The idea that, again, here we are at the state level trying to dictate some things that can be corrected and can be controlled at the local level is, again, something that we're very much concerned about. So we are obviously – well, and then the other part I was going to mention was the ability of – that was mentioned about neighbors lighting, going over into somebody else's yard. These are issues that can be taken care of locally. You know, you just call the local police department and say, look, my neighbors, lights are too bright. Again, it's a public safety, public nuisance issue. These are things that can be taken care of locally, and we don't feel like it needs to be a new state law passed to accomplish these things. Again, opposed to the bill because of additional unfunded mandate and, again, taking away a home rule, local control. So we're opposed to it. Thank you. Any questions from the committee for Mr. Watson? Representative Beck, you're recognized. And this may be for Mr. Watson, or maybe Representative Meeks might want to answer this. Since we enacted the rule, what was it, 2005 or whenever it was, is there any data that shows that that rule is working, that we've reduced the pollution? I don't have raw data to that effect. I would just say that, again, as Representative Meeks has so adequately described, the cost savings from the old lights to the new lights is pretty obvious. And so when municipalities are all about trying to save money, So when a bad light, if you will, goes out, they're going to require or try to encourage the energy or whomever to try to replace it with a more modern light, a more energy-efficient light. That just stands to reason. But I do not have – I can't give you the list, but that just stands to reason. Any other questions? Representative Meeks? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'll wait till I close for a lot of the things you said but the two questions that I have related to the cities is according to the law as it currently stands it is against the law for any city to erect an American flag well not to erect the American flag but to light an American flag at night with a bulb that's greater than 70 watts were you aware of that? No sir Okay well under current law it's against the law for any city or county as it stands right now to light an American flag at night with a bulb that's brighter than 70 watts. The other question I have is, according to the current law, it says that a city, if it determines that an outdoor lighting fixture, if it's cost prohibitive to make that upgrade, that a city or county has to, by ordinance, pass that it is too costly. Have any of the cities, to your knowledge, ever passed such an ordinance? Are you talking about existing law? Existing law. Existing law. Existing law says that for this section not to apply, any municipality or county must determine by ordinance that the cost of acquiring the fixture will be prohibitive. I don't have that data with me. What we're concerned about is when you took out that whole section that dealt with municipalities having the ability to determine or actually was exempt in which the whole purpose of the original law was to negotiate, and we came together with an agreement that would enhance and encourage municipalities to do that but not mandate it. Let's see if it's. All right. Any other questions for Mr. Watson? All right. Thank you, sir, for your testimony. Next up, to speak for the bill, we have Dan Shinneman. Dan, would you come up and introduce yourself, who you're with, and you are recognized to proceed with your testimony. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, Representative Meeks. My name is Dr. Dan Shinneman. I have a Ph.D. in ornithology, and for the last 10 years, I've been the bird conservation director for Audubon, Arkansas. And Audubon, Arkansas is the state office of the National Audubon Society, which is a non-profit conservation organization dedicated to protecting birds and their habitats. And Audubon, Arkansas supports HB 1003 because it aligns with Audubon's national initiative to create bird-friendly communities. Arkansas lies in the heart of the Mississippi Flyway, one of our nation's most important migratory corridors. across the u.s billions of birds migrate north in the spring and south in the fall and many migrate at night night migrating birds include ducks woodcock hummingbirds and also all songbirds like robins orioles and bluebirds and as they pass over the big cities on their journey they can become disoriented by bright lights and not just those up on the high buildings that are in their migratory pathways but even on lower single-story structures and this is especially a problem on foggy nights when the stars and the moon that birds use to navigate are obscured. It's estimated that every year between 365 and 988 million birds are killed by building collisions in the U.S. after being attracted to the bright lights like moths to a flame. Some are casualties of collisions with windows and others circle around the lights until they become exhausted and fall to the ground. By reducing the disorienting effect of light pollution, we can help provide those birds with safe passage between their nesting and wintering grounds. Excessive lighting can also affect the daily rhythms of birds. Maybe some of you have been bothered by a mockingbird singing all night long. Why is he doing that? Because all the artificial nighttime light is fooling his brain into thinking that it is still daytime or at least it's dawn and it's time to sing and this can have subtle effect on a bird's health studies have shown that the melatonin level in birds will increase when birds live near nighttime lighting versus birds that live in more dark areas so in conclusion audubon arkansas supports hb 1003 because it will make the natural state, a more bird-friendly state. Thank you. Okay, committee, any questions for Mr. Scheinman? Seeing none, sir, thank you for your interesting testimony. My pleasure. Thank you. Alright, next up to speak against the bill we have Mr. Tony Sullivan, the Arkansas Highway and Transportation Department. Tony, would you speak up, introduce yourself and who you're with, and speak to us. I'm Tony Sullivan. I'm the Assistant Chief Engineer for Operations for the Arkansas Highway and Transportation Department, and the director couldn't be here today we have in our commission meeting, so he had to attend that, so he asked me to come and speak about this bill. We're not totally against the bill as such. In fact, a lot of the provisions of the bill we already enact on our highway system, we allow roadway lighting systems to be installed by permit. Some of the cities and counties from time to time will ask to do that as a matter of public safety and to help increase the site distance at intersections and things like that. So we authorize them to install lighting systems in that manner. We also occasionally, not too often, install them on our freeway systems with the use of federal aid funds. I can tell you this. We don't install very many if we have to use state funds because we just don't have the money to do that. All of these lighting systems are maintained and operated by the cities and counties. We do not actually take over ownership of those in these more urbanized areas like Little Rock and Conway. They actually maintain, operate, and pay for the electrical power and do any repairs for those. So we're kind of out of that loop if a system gets installed. So we do, when we allow these by permit or install them ourselves, go by certain regulations that we have to adhere to with the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials. The roadway lighting systems have to be designed and installed so that all the roadway lighting goes to the roadway as much as possible. So we always use the cutoff or have in recent years the full cutoff fixtures where none of that light goes beyond the horizontal plane. None of it goes up at all. It's all directed down to the roadway. So we already adhere to a lot of these requirements that are in the bill. We do have some issues with some of the provisions in there as to when we can install lighting systems where it has to be some studies done, and we have to have already done some other more stringent measures as far as speed limits and things like that is concerned. We have warrants for particular type lighting systems. Okay. Okay, the copy I have still has it in there. Okay. Well, we don't have an issue with that then if we don't have to abide by those regulations to determine whether or not something is even warranted in the first place. We do have a little bit of an issue, and maybe this is not actually in the bill anymore, I don't know, but it requires the Arkansas Highway and Transportation Department, I guess specifically the director, to be an enforcement arm of the provisions of this bill. And we don't need to be concerned with anything off the highway system as far as enforcing the requirements to meet this law. I mean, that's just not something we need to get into on city streets and county roads and private property, you know, commercial entities. So if that is not the intent of the law, then we're fine with that. But we don't need to be involved in neighbor squabbles or anything like that on personal property, involved in enforcing that. We don't have the manpower or the expertise or the enforcement authority, I guess, to do anything other than the highway system. Now, Mr. Hendren mentioned something about lights from private property shining down the highway. That's certainly a concern of ours, not just from light trespass, but for safety reasons. And we don't have really the authority to tell anybody what they can do on their private property. But we have met with these folks, commercial or private people, and try to encourage them to shield those fixtures in some manner such that it doesn't create a safety problem. So we don't really have – we're not an enforcement-type agency, so we have issues if we're required to do something like that. But other than that, like I say, we, by permit process, adhere to all the light trespass-type issues and try to make sure that the lighting systems are safe and efficient for everybody traveling. That's the whole reason, really, they're out there in the first place. Any questions from the committee? Representative Gene, I think you had a question here first. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Sullivan, I'm trying to find somebody from Energy or Electrical Co-op, and I don't think they're here today, so you're it. I'm reading on page 5 where it says an agency and a public corporation, a county or a municipal subdivision shall not use public funds to operate, maintain and install or cause to be installed or new or replace permanent outdoor lightings unless they meet all these categories which is the shielded lights that direct the light downward and do you have any idea and I was Mayor of Magnolia for 15 years and we paid a per light on a light pole but we never had to pay for the if an eye went out on them or a ballast went out energy would always come in do you feel like the energy corporation maybe we need to get them in here will pay for this for these cities and counties or is this a cost they're going to have to share to replace these lights to be when they go out? Some of the cities, from what I understand, actually ask or have an agreement with Entergy to provide the fixtures there and replace them if necessary, and they pay a flat rate, I think, per month or per fixture. It's not actually a metered amount that they charge, And I think there's somebody from the city of Little Rock here today. They may be able to answer that question better. Okay. Maybe when they get up here, I'll get the answer. Okay. Yeah, we're not required to maintain or operate the system, so that's all turned over to the cities. Thank you, Mr. Sullivan. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Hendren, you had a question? Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Sullivan, it's correct to say that all state highways are actually under the control of the State Highway Department as far as how we do things, for instance, speed traps. If you all don't like a speed trap in a particular area that you think is being abused, does the State Highway Department have the authority to encourage the city or county to let the state troopers take care of that speed enforcement? There is a law that all the revenues and things like that from the cities has to be reported to the state police, I believe. And they have the authority to ask that or even allow enforcement on state highways in that jurisdiction. The reason I ask that question is that the lights I've noticed are on state highways. And sometimes not the primary state highways, but they are state highways. and then you address the because and we've talked about this before but from what you said I understand there is no really no mechanism right now for you all can just go out and say would you please turn that back and point it the other direction I guess that's basically all you can do now yes we don't have anything other than what's on the right-of-way you know we have jurisdiction there if it's a light fixture installed on the right-of-way that the city or county is maintaining then we have authority to tell them you know yeah you need to do something differently there and what we're talking about here is not just something some auxiliary light it's something exactly a spotlight or something that's actually shining down the highway that's what what i'm talking about at least well it uh there are laws that were they can't put any type of device out there that on the right of way uh but if it's on their own property control device you know like a traffic signal or anything like that they can't do that so i guess my question is depending on how representative meeks does with these bill here this morning it's too late to introduce a bill to give him authority to do that, but perhaps if we might amend this to do something with it. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. You're welcome. Any other questions? I have just one. From AHTD's standpoint, do y'all feel like this unfunded mandate of any kind, or what's your feelings there? If we're required to do any type of enforcement, you know, off the highway system. Now, we police the highway system already by permit process and anything that we allow as far as roadway lighting goes we're already in control of that we won't allow a city to put in something that would cause light trespass or cause a problem like Mr. Henry was talking about now we do have overhead signs that historically years ago were illuminated and they had signs under or lights underneath it that did shine up, but over the years we've replaced or done away with all the overhead roadway lighting because we've gone to a higher type reflective sheeting. Representative Makes. Thank you, Mr. Chair. If you allow me to address that, the enforcement section for the Highway and Transportation Department just says it's over the highway, street, and right-of-way lighting and signage which is already what they are. So they're not having to do city, you know, it stays which remain to what their responsibilities are. If there's concerns that we need to amend it, then I'm more than happy to work with them going forward. But it specifically states just the highways and whatnot. Okay. Thank you. If there's no more questions, Tony, thank you for your testimony. We appreciate you, sir. And anybody else speak for the bill? Against the bill, we have one more on here, I'm Mr. Ronnie Lowe with the City of Little Rock. Ronnie, do you want to speak here? Come on up, introduce yourself, and tell us all about it. Chairman, committee members, this is I'm Ronnie Lowe with the City of Little Rock, Assistant Director of Public Works. The city is opposed to the bill. While we understand the intent of the bill and appreciate what's been said about it, There are concerns with the funding of things like this. The first key issue is that in the existing bill, it gave the option for cities to opt out. City of Little Rock did that. We opted out so that we are in control of how those lights are funded. This does not give that option. It forces cities to be in the bill. The City of Little Rock has about 24,000 streetlights in the city. They are, the majority of those street lights are under a tariff with energy. As written, if these lights have to be converted over to be in compliance with this new bill, that's about a dollar or something increase per month for those lights, just for the monthly fee. If there's any fees that energy requests the city to pay for for changing out fixtures, that would be in excess of that. So with that, you're talking about a $26,000 monthly fee or unfunded mandate for Little Rock is about $316,000 a year just to keep the existing lights as they are. Additionally, this bill has an exemption in there. However, it requires extensive accounting and annual reporting as to why you're not updating or increasing those lights, for each city is going to have to maintain some type of accounting system and reporting system, and then they're going to report that to, I think the bill calls for it to go into the PC&E Commission, and so they're going to have people on that end that have to review those and keep up with that. There are things in there that says that existing lights are exempted. However, it says once they are repaired or replaced, they need to be updated. There's no definition in there that clearly states what that encompasses. Does that mean if the bulb goes out and you replace that, you've got to replace the entire fixture? The ballast in the fixture, is that considered maintenance, and can you just replace that? So we have concerns with even if it was to pass, how would any of that be regulated? you know it as was stated earlier most of these street lights they're put up because the public your constituents have asked for street lights for public safety issues so these lights have been put up you know at the request of citizens so if this goes forward and it it is an unfunded mandate and you put cities in the position of having to decide whether to put up more lights or not put up more lights or take lights down in order to keep the funding at the same level, then you're going backwards from what the constituents are actually wanting to be done. It does also create an issue with enforcement. It creates a nuisance issue with the light trespass. It's forcing each municipality, city, or the proper authority to be responsible for which creates an issue for their code enforcement officers or somebody has to be able to go out and measure light trespass now they have to be able to measure light trespass in a way that they can go to court and that can be upheld as a reason for and so you're creating just another system of how to deal with that that you know local municipalities should have the option to do that as they see fit and just one more point i'd like to make is the city of Little Rock is currently part of the U.S. Department of Energy Outdoor Lighting Accelerator. We are a partner in that program. We are providing upgrades and increasing efficiency of the outdoor lighting that we have through our system as the funds and technology advance and as it makes sense to do. If something like this was to go, that creates additional funding issues and takes away from our ability to do that, be a part of that program and be as efficient as we can and make as many replacements as we can. We talk about, there was talks about how if you put in more efficient lighting, then you reduce your cost. If you're under an energy tariff, that's not necessarily the case. If you put in LED street lights, your cost is going to go up almost two to three times what it is on the monthly cost because energy is going to recover their initial cost to go out and replace fixtures. So there is an upfront cost that has to be borne somewhere to change out fixtures. Even with what we're talking about with just going from regular cobra heads to shielded cobra heads, there's a cost, you know, there is some cost to energy to go out and put those in. There's an additional cost to those cities, like I said, for a dollar more per fixture just to maintain the existing lighting. so we feel additional mandates are an increased cost to municipalities and that they may result in fewer street lights which are at the expense of public safety which they were installed to maintain so we would be against the bill okay any questions representative hindron yeah some of us around here serve on the energy committee and what you you'd already said is going to cost a dollar a piece more for 24 000 units a month and that raised a flag with me right off because that's not the way it is around my place. If I put in a LED rather than a mercury vapor and so forth, I save money. But then here at the last, you opened it up. You said the reason that is some tariff agree with energy. That's correct. Well, now to me, that's kind of a bad deal that maybe needs to look at. Would you agree with that? If you're going to get more efficient light fixture, you're going to raise your bill a dollar a month. That's an issue with, you know, public service committee. We ought to have it, you reckon? I think that's, you know, we're agreeable to talking about that is energy going to testify here this morning for against this thing the issue with energy is that fixture cost initial fixture cost to go out and install an ld light this is more and so they have to recover that in the monthly fee that they get to install the light okay representative davis you had a question yes mr chair i think he just answered it but i'll ask it anyway several years ago the city Little Rock went around and, excuse me, you changed out all the traffic signals. You took out bulbs that were perfectly fine and burning well and replaced them with LED light fixtures. I assume that those are also under a tariff with Entergy. Yes, sir, they are. Was there a rate change on those? There was not. That was actually done through a partnership we did with Johnson Controls. They went throughout the entire city and looked at ways to save money, and that was one of the issues they found was a way to try to save money there. The city has not realized the savings that they projected we would realize with those streetlights or with those traffic signals, and they actually have to cover that cost as part of their contract. What did you all do with all those good bulbs you took out? I'm sure they were disposed of properly. Yeah, I understand. A follow-up question, Mr. Chairman? Certainly. You said in your comments that your partnership, I think USDA, something or other, working on energy efficiency, and that you are updating light fixtures to be more efficient as it made sense. Can you expand on that? When does it make sense? Well, with the existing energy system, it doesn't make sense to do it under the tariff structure. The city itself has about 2,000 lights that we own and maintain. They're especially lights that energy doesn't have under tariff. Those are lights we're looking at going in and spending capital money. We may spend $100,000 to replace 20 or 30 lights or 100 lights and expect and looking to get monthly savings to recover that cost. That's the type of things we're looking at. We're trying to replace the lights that the city owns that we have control of and we find funding to make capital improvements. We want to make those improvements and we'll take those lights off of energy tariff and make them into city-owned city responsibility to maintain them. But there's only about 2,000 lights that we actually own and maintain at this point. Part of that part of this lighting accelerator, though, is ways the city is looking at ways that other cities have taken over street lights, the way they have increased savings, and that's things we hope to learn from being a partner in this agreement. All right. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. All right. All right, Representative Beck, you got a question here? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Did you say the city has how many lights? 24,000 street lights. Street lights. But your lights, how many does the city have? About 2,000 that we own. It seems to me that the way to approach this external lighting then would be to approach approach it from a standpoint of going after energies, this tariff agreement with energy to make it more advantageous for them to put the more efficient lights in, as opposed to this. And I hinted at that earlier. It's whether or not energy was going to roll any of the energy savings back on these contracts, but I don't know. MR. Well, from our experience with the existing tariffs, no, it is a lose-money proposition for the city to go to more efficient lighting. Let me interrupt our members. Remember that the purpose of the bill is the shielded lights and stuff. Let's not get into energy efficiency on this other stuff. Let's keep it to the point here. Any other questions for Mr. Lowe? Seeing none, thank you, sir. Appreciate your testimony. All right. Anybody else speak for the bill, against the bill? If not, Representative Meeks, let's wrap this thing up. All right, committee, I appreciate your time, and based on our discussion today, you can see how I've been working on this for so long. This is what on the face seems like a pretty simple issue. It's actually a very complicated issue and has a lot of moving parts. I'm just going to address a few things that the opponent said, and then I will throw myself at the mercy of the committee. One of the things that you noticed, everyone that came up here said that they all agreed with the concept, but there was some debate over how we get there. And one of the reoccurring themes that you heard was that it was an unfunded mandate and that the city of Little Rock just said that if they were to do this, that it was going to cost them a dollar more fixture. Well, there's a provision in the law that says that everything they have out there is grandfathered in, and then there's another provision that says that if it's cost excessive, that they don't have to do it. So if they have to pay a dollar more, that's cost excessive, and they wouldn't have to do it. There's also allowances in there for security. They had mentioned that if your constituents had issues and we needed to put up more street lights in a neighborhood, that you can't. Well, you can. There's nothing that says you can't. This gentleman from Little Rock said that the city of Little Rock opted out of the law. There is no provision to allow the opt-out. And what would be the purpose of having the law in place if we just let everybody opt out? That seems counterintuitive. The local control issue, like I said, it's already in law, and I would buy into that a little bit more if the light pollution from Little Rock stayed within Little Rock City limits, but it doesn't. It spills over into Faulkner, White County. It spills over into many other jurisdictions. people from Greenbrier or from Perryville can't come to Little Rock and ask them to fix this. I have heard the issue with Entergy, and I think some of the problem lies there because there is no incentive for the city to go out and upgrade if Entergy is just going to keep the costs the same or increase the costs. So that is an issue that I'm going to definitely keep working on here. so with that I would ask that the committee to allow this to move forward to allow us to fix the problems with the current law to bring it into compliance or to bring it to modernize it and with that I will conclude and make a motion do pass okay motion do pass all in favor signify by saying aye opposed Representative Meeks, I'm sorry it's evident your motion failed. All right. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. All right. Next up, committee, let's entertain Senator Irvin here. Senator, if you would pedal right up there to the seat and tell us about your bill, please. thank you members of the of the committee and thank you uh mr chair for uh recognizing i appreciate that um my bill is very simple it creates the arkansas bikeways commission and i have a whole group of people with me today that are here mike van abel with um emba and uh bruce alt with uh and if they could join me i'd appreciate it if they could come over and join me. The purpose, I live in Mountain View, Arkansas, and we have one of the most incredible little gems in the state of Arkansas, which is called the Silamo Bike Trail, and it goes through the Ozark National Forest, and it's a mountain bike trail, and we have really focused on trying to clean up this trail, and I think one of them will speak a little bit more about that, but the reason I brought this, Bill, is because this is tremendously important to the tourism of the state of Arkansas, and the possibilities are really just unbelievable for us to be able to bring in and attract folks that are mountain bike riders as well as road bike cyclists and enthusiasts. There will be a convention in Bentonville, Arkansas. We hope and believe there's, I think, a 98% chance that that convention will be held in Bentonville, Arkansas in 2016. We wanted to put this Bike Ways Commission in place and really it's going to be housed in the Department of Parks and Tourism. I visited with Richard Davies. They're excited. They've got people that ride their bikes to work that are excited to take this project on. If you read the language of the bill, I made it extremely permissive and it's really at the pleasure of the Governor. Yes, sir. Senator Urban, can we have a little Order Committee here. We've got a bell being presented in place. Go ahead, proceed. Thank you. Just in respect of time, I'd have Bruce Ault, if he could come and kind of tell you what the project in the Silamo Bike Trail and what's happened there. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, and Senator Irvin. My name is Bruce Ault. I am the Executive Director of the Arkansas Society of Certified Public Accountants. but I appear to you today as the volunteer president of the Central Arkansas Trail Alliance, a non-profit organization dedicated to stewardship and outdoor recreation. We are a chapter of the International Mountain Bicycling Association, headquartered in Boulder, Colorado. The Silamo Trails that Senator Irvin has spoken of is 50 miles of trails in virtually a wilderness area in the Ozark National Forest, just north of Mountain View in Stone County. The trails were built to provide an abundance of outdoor recreational opportunities to both in-state and out-of-state residents. And right now, they're currently undergoing a renaissance. Very quickly, I'll tell you about that. After severe ice storm damage in 2008, the 50 miles of trails had become overgrown, hazardous, and were no longer being used to an alarming degree by riders, hikers, and equestrians. This had an immediate and dramatic impact in terms of a decline on tourism and economic development in Stone County, specifically in Mountain View. However, due to the collaborative and concerted efforts of County Judge Stacey Avey, Stone County's tourism and economic development communities, the International Mountain Bicycling Association, the U.S. Forest Service, and uniquely the Calico Rocks Prison, the trails are being restored to active use for a variety of outdoor recreationists, directly benefiting the local business and tourism community. One immediate and direct result, in mid-May, a brand new family event, the Silamo Epic, a race that will draw participants, hundreds of participants from other states, will be held in Mountain View. Now, the Bikeways Commission will directly benefit the entire state's tourism and economic development efforts as we seek to build collaborative, genuine, and similar efforts between multiple partners, such as federal and state land managers, bicycling advocates such as IMBA, and local business communities. I'll entertain any questions. I just wanted you to hear from him, and he eloquently states what's going on and outlines the project, and I couldn't be more proud of my community for stepping up to the plate. And also, just to point out, the work that's being done by the North Central Arkansas Correctional Unit, the prisoners that have come out and cleaned up this trail, is unbelievable. We should expand that program to every prison population in the state of Arkansas and understand and appreciate the work that they do. and they love doing it. Anyway, I could go on on that program, but I'm here to talk about the Boc-Ways Commission, and I think it's going to be a great thing for our state. So I appreciate any questions. Okay. Committee, questions for Senator Darvin on this bill? Senator Hender. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm not sure what page this is on, but somewhere down here in line 33, it says that the commission is going to educate the community on the important benefits and so forth, and then road and trail safety. And I just had to take this opportunity to ask this question. I guess you all are big deals in this thing. One of the biggest complaints, and I've got some bicycles and I've ridden bicycles, but one of the biggest complaints I hear up, and I guess we older folks in northwest Arkansas, and I understand you're coming to Bentonville, is getting on these two-lane highways where there's curves and crooks and so forth and getting a line of cars up behind you. Do you educate? I've had some people say we just ought to ban bicycles off highways. You've probably heard that before, and I'm not in favor of that. But I am in favor, and I want to ask if you all are doing that, is let them use some common sense if there's a show to use it and recognize when you line up traffic behind you, are you all educating folks to say that I believe, in fact, I believe highways are primarily for cars, not for bicycles, but I don't have any problem with using them personally, but let's use them responsibly. Do you all have a program that, I guess, is that included in this safety? Excellent question. And, yes, the Arkansas Highway Transportation Department does have a plan that is in progress right now to address exactly what you've talked about, and that's why part of the bill does talk about there will be input from the folks on the Bikeways Commission with the Highway Department to address exactly what you're talking about. And so this has been a collaborative effort, not just with Parks and Tourism, but also with the Highway Department. And we kind of went back and forth as to kind of where to house this thing. We wanted the primary focus to be on tourism, but you make excellent points and ones that I think the whole community, we all discuss that quite thoroughly, and that will be a big part of it as well. One of the things we've done up there, and we may have done it around the state, is make whiter highways with a pretty good 8- or 10-foot shoulder with a white line down it. And I think that's a real improvement, but some of these guys that ride these bicycles think that white line, I guess, is to put their wheels on, and I don't think it is. I appreciate that. Thank you. Okay. Next, I think we had Representative McElroy. You had a question? I have a motion at the proper time, Mr. Chair. Representative Meeks. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The question that I have, and I know you can appreciate this question, is we currently already have close to 230-some-odd commissions in the state. Is there not another commission, or could the Parks and Tourism Department not do this without creating another government entity and the cost that goes along with it? Thank you for the question. If you will read the bill, it is entirely voluntary. There is no reference in the bill to allowing for per diem or for travel mileage. It is entirely voluntary. In fact, even if the governor chooses not to spend the money to staff it, then there will be a member of the commission serve as the secretary of that commission, and they themselves will file the reports with the Department of Parks and Tourism. So the potential is that this will cost us zero money as the bill is written. Okay, which I like. To address the other part of your question, if you look at, you know, these are citizens. I mean, these are citizens of our state that care deeply and passionately about this sport. And they also see the great potential for our state. I could go on and on. We had a presentation in Mountain View that John Moran came and delivered, and it was in conjunction with what he had done and visited a convention and what the state of Oregon had done. And this is kind of patterned after that. And so I've worked on this for about four months now with them. But these are private citizens that really have a passion, and I just feel like it's, and I have worked through all those issues, Representative Meeks with the folks in the executive branch and within the agency that I don't feel like we need to disallow that input to occur. And one thing that I really would feel, look in the language of this bill, it requires that there's somebody on that commission that is above the age of 18 and below the age of 25. I don't know if we have a question.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1963

2:45 - 17:32 26 segments

HB1388

17:32 - 22:11 9 segments

HB1003

22:11 - 1:34:32 133 segments

SB403

1:34:32 - 1:53:48 14 segments

HB1825

1:53:48 - 1:58:03

HB1960

1:58:03 - 2:08:03

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers