Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Aging, Children and Youth, Legislative & Military Affairs

March 18, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (8)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1284 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…e will ask Representative Whitaker, are you here to present House Bill 1284?”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1904 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…epresentative Saban, are you prepared? it. It's going to be House Bill 1904. Representative Saban, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Ch…”
Pre-2017 bill
HR1039 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ight. Representative Broadway, you're recognized to present House Resolution 1039.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1947 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…y, we're going to recognize Representative Meigs to present House Bill 1947. And as soon as it pops”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1587 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1587”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1762 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1762”
Pre-2017 bill
HR1041 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1041”
Pre-2017 bill
SB760 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB760”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
Okay. You've heard from Representative Sturge. Is there a motion? Representative Broadway? Motion to accept amendment. Okay. We have a motion to accept amendment. All in favor, vote aye. Aye. Opposed, your amendment has been adopted. Thank you. Representative Meeks, are you prepared to run 1677? No, Mr. Chair. Okay, all right. Representative Broadway, you're recognized to present House Resolution 1039.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. Colleagues, I am pleased to bring you House Resolution 1039. And until this session, I did not know that Paragould is quite a historic place. I'm asking you all to recognize the 85th anniversary of the meteor hit in Paragould, Arkansas. On February 17, 1930, in the middle of the night, or actually in the middle of 4 o'clock in the morning, a meteor hit Paragould, Arkansas. There were three sonic booms and the largest meteorite is over 800 pounds. The second one was more than 70 pounds. Today it is known as the Paragould meteorite. It's the largest meteorite at the time to have ever been seen falling into the earth's atmosphere and recovered. It's the largest stony meteorite in the world at the time. The meteorite was sold to Mr. Stanley Field, where the meteorite was housed in the Field Museum in Chicago for many, many years. In 1988, it was moved to the University of Arkansas and resides at the University of Arkansas Center for Space and Planetary Science. there are pieces of this meteorite that are in the Max Planck Institute in Germany the Smithsonian, Harvard, the National Museum in Washington D.C. and the American Museum of Natural History in New York this is something that my constituents are very proud of and have asked me to come to you today with this resolution and with that, that is the bill I would appreciate a good vote, and I'm happy to entertain any questions, but I've told you pretty much what I know about the
▶ Play
meteorite. Thank you. Are there any questions for Representative Broadway? Yes, Representative Vaught, you're recognized. Okay. Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for or against this resolution? If not, are you closed for your resolution? I am. Thank you, sir. Representative Vaught, you're recognized. We have a motion to pass. All in favor, vote aye. Aye. Opposed? You've passed your resolution. Thank
▶ Play
you. Thank you. And you'll make many members of the Paragood community very happy. Thank you. Okay.
▶ Play
At this time, Representative Saban, are you prepared? it. It's going to be House Bill 1904. Representative Saban, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Chair, with your permission, can
▶ Play
I have Paula Shelton join me here to present the bill? Yes, Ms. Shelton, if
▶ Play
you would, state your name and affiliation for the records, please. My name is Paula McCauley
▶ Play
Shelton. Okay, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
This bill before you, House Bill 1904, is a bill that I've been working on for, I guess, about a year. And the way it came about was I was contacted by Ms. Shelton, who's with me today, because her son, Kieran, who's back there, was conceived nine months after the death of her husband. And she learned after that that Kieran really didn't have any rights to inherit any property or really be recognized as the son of his father under the current statute. And so we worked together. We also worked with representatives of the Bar Association, and we came up with this statute that's agreed-upon language that, as far as I'm aware, there are no objections to. And with your permission, I'd really like to let Ms. Shelton tell her story because what she'll tell you is the reason why I decided to pursue this legislation. Thank you, Michelle. You're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Representative Sabin. Please excuse me. I'm really nervous. My husband, John, and I were married for two years. I met him a little later in life, and he was my soulmate, my best friend. He was everything to me. and we were in the process of trying to start a family when my husband went to a football game, watched a football game at a friend's house and suffered a grandma seizure. And shortly after that, he was diagnosed with brain cancer, which has a dismal survival rate. We had the wonderful advice of a nurse after my husband had brain surgery who recommended that if we wanted to have children, we needed to freeze a sample of John's sperm because once he started chemo, it would likely make him sterile. And so that is what we did. And it was really difficult because he was still recovering from surgery. And in the process of doing that, John ensured that I would have rights to use his genetic material to conceive a child by signing a legal document that was provided by the fertility clinic to give me those rights. My husband passed away in February of 2009 and after I had somewhat recovered from his death, well not really, I still really haven't done that, but I started in vitro treatments and And nine months after John passed away, I conceived my son here in John. And when he was about three months old, I went to the Social Security's office and I applied for Social Security death benefits for my child. And initially I was told that, yes, absolutely, he was eligible because of the language of the law. And when I heard back from my first application, it was denied. So I filed an appeal, and I've continued to go through the appeal process because the law as it stands in Arkansas hasn't addressed this specific issue. I mean, really, frankly, I think at this time there aren't very many children conceived this way. I don't know what the future will hold for that, but the law has not addressed this issue. So I contacted Representative Sabin and asked him if he could help me change this law so that my son could receive the benefits that I know his father would want him to have. My husband worked in the summer when he was 16. He worked his whole life. He paid taxes, and he paid into these benefits, and I know that he would want his son to have these benefits. So, you know, my son deserves it. My husband and I had an opportunity to start in vitro a year after his diagnosis, and we were getting prepared to do that when his tumor recurred. I made a decision to focus on caring for him rather than going through a very difficult fertility process. And in me making that decision, I didn't know at the time that I was basically deciding that my son was not going to be eligible for these benefits it's because I put off conception of him to care for my husband. So as a mother, I feel obligated to try and rectify this situation and not only provide for my child but for other children that will find themselves in a similar situation in this state. There have been laws passed in at least 21 other states that I'm aware of, Texas, Louisiana, that provide Social Security death benefits for these children. So I would just ask that we do the same for Arkansas. Thank you. Okay. Thank you. And I'll just say right before we
▶ Play
have questions that, you know, obviously, as Paula indicated, Social Security Administration isn't opposed to doing this. It's just that they need the authority in our own statute here in Arkansas in order to offer those benefits. And also, you know, we had something similar already in statute, but because it was so specific about the technology, it didn't take into account that technology changes, you know, methods of these kinds of reproductive-assisted processes, you know, didn't keep track with the language. And so this merely updates our language so that the intent still remains the same. And with that,
▶ Play
I'll be very glad to answer any questions. Okay, thank you. Any questions from
▶ Play
Committee Representative Soutman, you're recognized? Thank you, Mr. Chair. On page 2, in line 35, it says consent of the decedent. It lines out husband, and so I'm assuming that when it lines out husband, it's referencing a legal binding relationship. And by replacing that with decedent, are we impacting the legal, I mean, how the court's going to decide if it decides to make this agreement between people that aren't legally married, I guess is my question. Does this allow for a person, a man and woman who are not married, or other, I guess, who are not married to exercise the rights under this law?
▶ Play
That's an excellent question. I'm just, you know, I'm looking at the bill right now because I'm not sure that we really discussed that aspect of it. And I just want to make sure I answer your question accurately. So, you know, in the previous line, line 32 on that page, it does talk about the surviving spouse as it does in line 28. So I think we are, in the previous language, ensuring that the child is the result of a legal marriage as recognized in the state of Arkansas.
▶ Play
Follow up, Mr. Chair? Yes, go ahead. I'm just wondering if we are keeping, and I see that language in a couple of other places also, I'm just wondering what the unintended consequences may be if in one place we're saying surviving spouse and the other place, which would recognize a legally binding agreement, and in another place we are striking that legally binding contract, marriage contract. Are there unintended consequences that by passing this bill we're setting a precedent, I guess?
▶ Play
Well, I'll say this. I mean, you know, certainly that was never the intention, never anything we ever talked about throughout the course of this. Also, as I read the bill, the first kind of instance of this that you mentioned, line 35, is a subsection of, you know, that previous section in section 2, which means that it kind of proceeds from the understanding that we're talking about a marital relationship, that there's a spouse involved. So just striking the word husband in that doesn't negate the overall intent that I think is spelled out pretty clearly. This is a child produced from a married relationship. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Representative Vaught, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. He might have answered my question. I just
▶ Play
want to make sure that this would not affect someone that's a sperm donor to someone else. No, and we did talk about that. You'd hate to open up that bucket for somebody who's just a sperm donor, and you'd hate to try to find that person and make them be liable for. I'm going to let Paula, I know she wants
▶ Play
to talk about it, but we did talk about that part, so go ahead.
▶ Play
My husband had to give legal consent for me to be able to go forward with the in vitro because the doctor would not have done that if he hadn't signed the document that gave me the legal rights to his genetic material. Yes. To that, Representative Vaught, I mean,
▶ Play
we definitely didn't want to create a situation where people could go off creating kids that then would, you know, I think that it's very clear that the intent of this is for a child conceived, you know, within the context of a relationship where, you know, consent is granted. And I think, you know, we were working with the Bar Association and others to make sure that, you know, the structure of that is very clear and very tight. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Representative Brown, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
thank you Mr. Chair but my question has been answered thank you Representative Tucker you're recognized thank you Mr.
▶ Play
Chair thank you Representative Saver for bringing the bill and I just want to commend your courage just to let you know when I sit at the end of the table I'm nervous too so don't feel bad about it just to address Representative Sullivan's question when I read that language in the bill that struck husband and replaced it with decedent the way that I read it was probably when the bill was written And it was only conceived at the time that the husband would have, the father would have died. And so this was changing it to either gender because obviously the mother plays a much more integral role in the pregnancy than the father. But with surrogacy and technology, it was just creating that possibility instead of just having it be in case the father passed on. So in any case, that might be an interpretation of that change. I think,
▶ Play
Representative Tucker, you might have done a better job answering the question than I did. But you're
▶ Play
the lawyer, and I'm not, so thank you. Please don't tell anybody.
▶ Play
I just wanted to chip that in. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you.
▶ Play
Thank you. Any more questions from the committee? Representative Sullivan, you're recognized. Just one more. In page 2, line 1, it strikes him or her and puts the person. And I'm just wondering, is that just cleanup language from BLR to make that read smoother? I'm just wondering why. Yeah, and in fact, I mean,
▶ Play
I'm almost glad Representative Tucker just said what he said because I think, again, it speaks to his point that maybe it was meant to be either gender neutral or to be cleanup language because, again, I don't know. That's not something that we focused a lot of attention on. Okay. Probably just cleanup language. Yes, sir. Thank you.
▶ Play
Are there any more questions from the committee? If not, is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for or against this bill? If not, Representative Saban, you're recognized too close for your bill.
▶ Play
I'd just like to thank the committee for your attention and your questions, and I appreciate a good
▶ Play
vote. Thank you. Thank you. Chair, it's open for a motion at this time. Representative Scott, you recognize? I move,
▶ Play
do pass. And thank you. This is a wonderful bill, in my opinion.
▶ Play
Don't you agree? Thank you for your motion. We have a motion, do pass. All in favor, vote aye. Aye. Opposed, you passed your bill. Thank you very much. Thank you, Mr. Chair and members of the committee. Thank you. This time, we will ask Representative Whitaker, are you here to present House Bill 1284?
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair, and good morning, committee. I bring before you today House Bill 1284. It is perhaps one of the most amended one-sentence bills in the history of this house. I had no idea until I was contacted by one of my directors of parks and recreations that you could pick up a phone and call them and ask for and receive the team rosters of all the children who play in city leagues along with their names, direct contact information, dates of birth, et cetera, et cetera. The information that these departments are legitimately collecting to be able to contact the children about practices, et cetera, physicals, all the other things that we associated with sports leagues and activity leagues. They had received a request. As it turned out, it was fairly innocuous. The lady involved was wanting to market sports fundraising kits to these teams and leagues. But it shocked the director so much that she contacted me and said, really, that you can just call up and get these children's information? And over the years, it simply was just never, nobody noticed. You'll notice that the bill has narrowed very specifically on this information, very specific information, controlled by city or county parks and recreation leagues. We did this to differentiate it from information held by schools, which is already protected under FERPA. So that may have been one of the reasons everybody thought, well, this stuff's already protected. We don't need to talk about it. The language has been vetted now with Axiom, LexisNexis, the Arkansas Attorney General's Office. Many of the words in the three amendments came from those folks, and we worked together to build this thing so it would be narrowly focused to exempt only the information that needed to be protected and in the specific instance where it needed to be protected. We believe that bill now does that, and I was happy to bring it for you. I'll take questions and would hope
▶ Play
for a good vote. Okay. Thank you. Are there any questions from the committee? Seeing none, is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for or against this bill? If not, Representative Whitaker, would you like to close? Just with my thanks again for your hearing my bill and a request for a due pass. Thank you. Representative Gates, you're recognized to make your motion. Motion due pass. We have a motion due pass. All in favor, vote aye. Aye. Opposed? You passed your bill.
▶ Play
Thank you. Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Committee. Thank you.
▶ Play
Okay, we're going to recognize Representative Meigs to present House Bill 1947. And as soon as it pops
▶ Play
Speaker 72 22:07
up, there is actually an amendment to this bill. Mr. Chair? Okay, thank you. I'll go ahead and explain the amendment. It kind of has something to do with the bill itself. One of the concerns that people had is that we would be the only state to do daylight savings time. So basically what the amendment does, it would keep us from adopting year-round standard time unless another state that borders us did it first so that we would not be the only one. From what I understand, Texas has a bill filed to go standard time year-round. So if they did, then we would also do it as well. So with that said, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair, I'll be glad to take any questions on the amendment. Okay. Any questions on the amendment? If not, is there a motion on the amendment? Motion to pass the amendment. All in favor, aye. Aye. Opposed? The amendment is passed, and you may proceed. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 72 23:08
you, Mr. Chair. Daylight savings time is just one of them kind of weird things that most people don't even necessarily think about. We've been doing it for so long. But when I was in the military, I was stationed in Arizona, and Arizona did not switch. They stayed on standard time year-round. And, you know, I thought that was kind of interesting, but I guess they've been doing it for a while now. Hawaii is another state that does not do daylight savings time at all. And so, of course, on Sunday when we had to switch our clocks forward, I just posted something on Facebook, and I said, what are your thoughts on us keeping standard time year-round or us keeping one time year-round? And overwhelmingly, people said that we need to stop doing daylight savings time or we need to stay year-round. and so I ended up filing the bill and interestingly enough this bill has generated probably the most emails to me versus any other thing that we've done so far this this year amazingly most have been positive most have been for it but basically the federal government in its wisdom or maybe not so much in its wisdom gives the state the option to exempt itself from having to move their clocks forward because some people said well why don't we just stay on daylight savings time well it's because the federal government says you can only exempt yourself from it and stay on standard time which means you wouldn't have that extra hour in the evening there have been a lot of myths about daylight savings time you know it was for the farmers or if it it was to save electricity and from what I understand neither of these two groups really care about it farmers they don't care what what the clock says they just go by the sun you know they're up before the sun rises and they're usually out in the fields until you know the sun after the sun sets so it doesn't really matter whether it's six o'clock or seven o'clock to them and because now of our technology and our advancements in our electrical grid there's not really any kind of you know concerns about what it might do to, you know, your electric bill or anything else because, again, people are there. Again, the two concerns that I've had that were valid concerns, number one, we would be an island, which is why we did the amendment, so that we would have to have another state that's bordering us actually do it. The other concern, which is a valid concern, is there's a lot of folks that say I work, I get off at 5 o'clock, and, you know, there's that extra hour that I can have family time outside or whatever the case would be and you know I kind of understand that but then again there are people who are morning people and they would have that extra hour uh you know maybe in the morning as well and then the other concern uh that this would help is when we switch in March and we go forward um you know there were parents that said they liked it like my bill because it would keep their kid from getting on the bus when it was dark in the morning so you know I guess there are pros and cons and uh you You know, just whatever you feel or whatever your constituents want you to do, but I figure we would put it out there and, you know, let the legislature make the decision since we have that power to be able to do so. So with that said, committee, I'll be glad to take any questions.
▶ Play
Representative Brown, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Thank you, Chairman McGill. You know, I am really glad that you brought this bill because I was listening to the news on Sunday morning and some medical doctors were speaking, And they said that when the time changes, that there are more traffic accidents. And I believe the other thing was violent crime. But, you know, I guess it only picks up like that for a short period following the time change, and then everything settles down. But I really find these time changes to be very frustrating for me to change my body clock. So I am, wouldn't you agree? Yes, Representative Brown, I would agree. And I didn't mention
▶ Play
Speaker 72 27:21
the health studies because, of course, you can find people that will say that, you know, again, like you said, that there are more traffic accidents or, you know, there are health issues because of the change and everything of that nature as far as your body having to adjust. You know, some people have told me that they want us to stay on standard time because for a few days afterwards their kids are more cranky because their bodies are adjusting, you know, more as far as that's concerned. So you can find those studies. You could probably find studies that disagree with you, but, you know, I would agree with you that it seems that that time change tends to cause, you know, some issues with your body having to adjust. One follow-up? Yes. Just to
▶ Play
add to what you said, I want to correct what I said. It may not have been violent crimes. I'm pretty sure it was heart attacks when you mentioned health issues. That reminded me of what it was. So it wasn't violent death. It was just death.
▶ Play
Speaker 84 28:22
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Petty, do
▶ Play
you reckon I have a question? Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. The only thing that I think about, you say another state has to do this, so I'll be close. With my other job, I fly everywhere. So I just think about us being in, like, this central time, and do you think that will affect anything for people just getting confused about time? Yeah, and, you know, again, I think if you have
▶ Play
Speaker 72 28:55
another state that does it with us, that that will help to alleviate the problem. You know, as far as travel is concerned, you know, we have these things now. Most everybody that flies is going to have one of these things. And whenever you land, they automatically will set to the cell tower, which will give them the correct time. You know, there is a concern, of course, if they're doing like a meeting and it's Skype or something like that or having to make a phone call that they might not realize it. But I think, again, once you do this, that everybody will adjust. And you've got to remember this is only going to be happening during the summer months because the winter months will be on standard time like we normally are. and so this will only, I guess, present that issue only seven or eight months out of the year, I guess, whenever we're on daylight savings time, which is most of the year, but still it wouldn't be a year-round type deal.
▶ Play
I just wanted to say quickly, follow up a bit, thank you very much. I have had constituents that really, really like this idea, too, so thank
▶ Play
you for bringing this. Thank you. Representative Fyde, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm old, so I remember when Daylight Savings Time came about, and I thought it was a silly idea at the time. So I actually like this bill. I was wondering, Representative Mix, have you had people from neighboring states contact you and say that they are also interested?
▶ Play
Speaker 72 30:21
Other than, like I said, other than I know Texas has presented a bill, I don't know of anybody else right offhand. To be honest with you, I've been so busy with other bills and everything. I haven't really put much research into this, other than the fact that people said they want it and thought
▶ Play
it was a good idea. Representative Sullivan, you recognize? Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm a little confused. Just help me understand. All this bill does is exempt us from
▶ Play
Speaker 72 30:49
the requirement, correct? Yes, correct. So basically what it is is if we were to pass this bill today, we would stay on daylight savings time, and then October or the first week of November, I can't remember now, we would fall back and then what would happen is is next march instead of going forward again we would just stay on the same time and again that is predicated on another state actually passing it and let's say you know texas doesn't pass it until next year again we would stay on daylight savings time until we fell back in in november and then instead of the next year instead of moving forward we would just stay on the same time and then we would stay on the same time Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Vaughn, you're recognized. Okay,
▶ Play
thank you. Representative Scott, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Well,
▶ Play
first of all, Representative Meeks, you Meeks brothers can pull some bills out of boxes that the rest of us never think of, and I appreciate that. May even be learning from it a little bit. and also another note if this bill does pass my 84 year old mother will come to little rock and personally give you a hug because she hates changing her clock she she just it it it just messes up her entire schedule now i'm one of those i depend on the clock for the time so when everyone says we lost an hour we gained an hour i never feel anything from that maybe the pacemaker I have keeps me going, and I don't think about it. Maybe I'm just different. However, I am concerned about one thing. At the Missouri-Arkansas line, we have so many folks who come into Walmart, Tyson, J.B. Hunt to work, and if we could get Missouri on board with this, then I would be 100% for it. Like you said, we also have other states, but that Missouri, Missouri the state of Missouri would really really have to be on board for me and I hope you understand that. Well I would hope Missouri might be
▶ Play
Speaker 72 32:52
the one state that that does it and and triggers it but I can tell you this you know there are a lot of states that already have an issue with you have eastern time zone going into central time zone or you know mountain time zone going specific time zone you know the thing that I can think of is even Florida you know they have part of Florida that's in the eastern time zone and the other part that's in central, Tallahassee I think is in the eastern time zone and Pensacola is in the western and so those folks have learned to adjust to those differing type deals and I believe that Arkansas, Arkansans would be able to adjust to it rather well and I'm hoping that Missouri, if they're not the ones that trigger this bill that they would also be, again be able to adjust to it
▶ Play
Thank you Are there any more questions from the committee? If not, is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for or against this bill? If not, Representative Meeks, you're recognized to close. Member, I
▶ Play
Speaker 72 33:56
just think it's a good idea. My constituents think it's a good idea, or most of them do, and I would appreciate a
▶ Play
good vote. Thank you. Chair is open for a motion. Representative Brown, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you. Motion do pass. We have a
▶ Play
motion do pass. All in favor, vote aye. Aye. Opposed? No. Ayes have it. You passed your bill. Are we finished? is there anyone in the audience or any member that has a bill before this committee that I may have overlooked ok
▶ Play
Speaker 72 34:54
you recognize members I'm presenting house resolution 1041 by representative hammer and what it does is it recognizes the Boys and Girls Club of America in Bryan, Arkansas. I think everybody kind of realizes what the Boys and Girls Club do. We have one there in Conway that serve the children of our community, provide many different services like after-school programs, and I know that the one in Bryan probably is just like the one in Conway where they do a good job serving the needs of children in their community and on behalf of Representative Hammer and even myself, even though this is specifically stating Bryant, I would appreciate a good vote on this resolution. Okay. Are there any questions from the committee?
▶ Play
Anyone in the audience that would like to speak for or against this resolution? If not, the chair will entertain. Would you like to close? I'm closed. Okay, very good. Chair will entertain a motion. Representative Vulture recognized. Motion to pass. We have a motion to do pass. All in favor, vote aye. Opposed, you pass that resolution. Thank you. Representative Smith, you recognize to present your bill. This is House Bill 1762.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair and Committee. I'm carrying this bill today for Representative Mary Bentley. She came to me several weeks ago and asked me to do this, and I told her yes, I told her no, I told her yes, and then I said, let me think about it, and I finally, after going home over a weekend and sitting and watching a movie with my granddaughters, I just thought I needed to do this for the little girls in our state. And so it relates to the act to create the offense of female genital mutilation. And so the thing about this bill is a lot of people have asked me questions about it. Is this a problem in Arkansas, or do we really need to do this? It's already federal law. We just simply have not made any kind of a policy statement in the state of Arkansas. In some of the research that I did, I discovered that it really is a women's rights issue. It is also a child protection issue. The World Health Organization says that there is no health benefit, and it only does harm. Female genital mutilation, according to the Center for Disease Control out of Atlanta, estimates between 150,000 and 200,000 young girls between the ages of 2 and 9 are at risk in the United States. On the promise of anonymity, I've talked with some medical professionals, and they have indicated to me and shared with me, just pulling me aside, that we do have this problem in the state of Arkansas, but it's one of those dirty little secrets that we don't talk about. In New York City, there are documented cases of between 800 and 900 emergency room visits where this procedure was performed in the back bedroom of somebody's apartment, and those little girls, if they hadn't been rushed to the emergency room, would have bled to death. And so I'm asking you today to just let's do something for these little girls before we have to deal with it on a much broader level, and I'm open for questions. Thank you. Are there any questions from the committee? Yes,
▶ Play
Representative Petty. Is this not already a salt and battery?
▶ Play
I mean, are we putting more? Well, there are
▶ Play
laws on the books to protect children as well as adults. We know this. But there is nothing specific in the codes that address this specific issue. And so while it is a federal law, there is a federal law actually saying this is illegal. We need something in the state of Arkansas. but
▶ Play
i don't feel like you answered my question i mean would this be considered assault and battery
▶ Play
anyway i'm not a lawyer so i don't know what the terminology would be i just simply know that if if assault and battery covered this we probably would i wouldn't be sitting here today But because I am sitting here, there seems to be a loophole or a gap in the way our codes are written. Thank you. Okay. Representative Brown, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I think we're all aware that this is a practice of a religious group, Maybe more than one faith group, I don't know. And it may just be something that some people do who are just mean. But is that your understanding, Mr. Smith?
▶ Play
Well, I mean, I'm sure it is practiced. And predominantly it's practiced in North Africa, the Middle East, certain tribal groups in Africa. but as our immigrant population grows, even at the federal level, we're recognizing that this is a practice that is barbaric and should not be tolerated in the United States. Without a statute or code on our books in the state of Arkansas, what we're also seeing is, and it's been reported to me that a lot of families actually take their children, their daughters, out of the United States, back to a country of origin, have this procedure done, and then they bring them back. That is if they live through the procedure. And so it's just something that we need to take a stand for as being against and set the record straight for Arkansas. Thank you, Representative Smith. Thank you. Representative
▶ Play
Sullivan, you recognize? So if someone takes their child out of the country and comes back in, would they
▶ Play
have committed a crime then? To my understanding of what's happening with federal law, yes. It's a class C felony. And we're just tightening up the gap in our own
▶ Play
local state law. Just to make sure I understand. So if someone takes a child, a healthy child, or takes a person to Great Britain, performs one or several of these practices, they perform that, when they reenter the U.S., they'd be arrested?
▶ Play
Well, I mean, I wouldn't know how would we know unless there's a physical examination, which I can't envision us pulling people out of, you know, immigration lines or reentry. But, I mean, that is what we're trying to do is say whether you do it here or you go out of the country, out of the state, and you come back, if there's knowledge of this, you're guilty of committing a crime. This is protecting our little girls, not just a person,
▶ Play
but a little girl. Follow up, Mr. Chair? Yes, you may. And to follow up on the earlier question, and again, I completely understand and sympathize with the protection. and as I read through this list of what's going on here am I correct in saying that this is allowable all these are allowable right now that one wouldn't be prosecuted if one did all this now I'm looking at page 2 at lines 1 through about 10. And
▶ Play
those can legally be done now? To my knowledge, yes. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Representative Gage, you recognize for question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
I guess this is my question, and I'll start it out and sound like a statement, But I know some prosecutors, if it's not spelled out, if somebody makes the claim we do this as part of our religious practice could bring in some confusion with some prosecutors that want to make sure they're because they believe there's a separation of church and state, don't want to infringe on their religious beliefs. This just spells out that religious beliefs are not this practice is going to be prosecuted. Is that
▶ Play
correct? could you could you repeat
▶ Play
that one more time this gives would you say that this bill would give the prosecutor the determination if somebody claimed we do this for religious practice would give that prosecutor the definition that basically takes it out of a religious defense? I think so, because what we're trying to say is you
▶ Play
can bow your knee to any god that you choose to worship. That's not in here, but we have that freedom in our country and the state of Arkansas. But you do not have the right to start cutting on a child between the ages of two and nine and call it a religious practice. It's barbaric. And some of the photographs that I reviewed through open source research just showed little girls thrown on the floor holding popsicles with blood just all over the floor. And I thought, we can't let this happen, not only in the United States, which federal law prohibits, but in the state of Arkansas. So we're bringing clarity to the law and setting the parameters for our
▶ Play
prosecutors. Representative Petty, you're recognized. So this is not a problem in Arkansas? No, it is a problem in Arkansas. And you've actually seen the pictures
▶ Play
of girls in this state? No, I've had, Representative Petty, I've talked to medical professionals who have dealt with some of these while they're limited in scope at this point through emergency room visits to stop hemorrhaging. These are not medical procedures done in a sterile, clean environment. Most of the time this is similar to a midwife type person going to the home of someone who wants this done to their children, to their little girls, in the back bedroom. or on the kitchen table and then the payoff is here's a popsicle that's what i've been hearing and seeing but some of these medical providers told me they said representative smith we've seen it we've we've encountered this but at the risk of losing our jobs and some of the hipaa laws that are involved we can't really come out against this but we're proud of you for trying to
▶ Play
run this Bill. Representative Brown, you're recognized. You just happened to mention the word two years of age to 18. Was that just, are you talking about all minor
▶ Play
females? Well, it's all minor females, but according to the CDC, that those are their age numbers. And what we're talking about is pre-puberty little girls and and if you dig further into the whole practice the the reason or rationale for doing this is to ensure that that little girl cannot enjoy sex or will not have sex until her marriage and so it is punishment predicated on the fact that they can't control their sexual urges and so we're gonna we're going to do this to these little girls to make sure most cultures that practice this are male dominated cultures it is a me first male run society women are considered cattle and breeders and so and having lived in that environment for six and well 65 and a half months I can tell you that this is a protective measure that
▶ Play
sends a message. The question I asked was, does this apply to all female minors, not just beginning at age
▶ Play
two? Yes. Thank you. Representative Wallace, you're recognized. Representative Smith, I appreciate you being here. A question I've got for you, just to clarify in my mind, if this happened today in the state of Arkansas and if the authorities were aware of it there's laws on the books that would punish an individual that did
▶ Play
it it is happening today but we have no law on the books right now to say this is illegal in the state of Arkansas at the federal level it is illegal but we need to bring state law and federal law together to provide the clarity for our prosecutors so we can move forward. Thank you. You're
▶ Play
welcome. Thank you. Representative Johnson, you recognize for question?
▶ Play
I appreciate. I'm sorry. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I appreciate what you're bringing, and I think Arkansas should be in compliance with federal law, but I'm really struggling with the idea that if somebody commits a crime, on foreign soil, we're going to prosecute them here, no matter what the crime is. I don't know. We might not let them in the country for whatever they've done or whatever reason, but I'm not sure I want to prosecute people for crimes that they committed in regards to what they are, robbery, murder, whatever. I don't know if it's our place to prosecute crimes that are committed in
▶ Play
a foreign country. Well, let me respond to that. but right now it already is a federal crime to go outside the continental United States or out of the U.S. to do this procedure. What we're saying now is let's just make the law uniform across the board. But, again, as these people return to the United States, I don't know how we would detect it unless they were boasting and bragging that they did this because we don't typically, I mean, TSA has been accused of pretty aggressive pat-downs, but I don't think we've seen this kind of thorough examination conducted, and I don't suspect we will, but it's a protection issue. That's what it is.
▶ Play
Thank you. Representative Petty, you recognize for a
▶ Play
question? I'm sorry. I'm struggling with this. Would a doctor that saw this in the state of Arkansas not have to report that as abuse? I mean, because you take a child into an ER and they're mutilated, wouldn't a doctor have to report that? You say that you're seeing all of this, or they are seeing this, and it came to you. But I just feel like that by state law, they would have to report that anyway.
▶ Play
I would hope they would report it. I don't know that it's been reported. but this is just going to add that extra layer of this is what we do in these cases yes
▶ Play
and I know you said you weren't an attorney but with that not already be assault and battery especially onto a child I just feel like that we're trying to put more I mean when we're we they would be charged with this anyway if a doctor had to report that I think this goes a
▶ Play
It's a little beyond our traditional thinking and definition of assault and battery. This is a new low. Are
▶ Play
there any more questions? Representative Brown, you're
▶ Play
recognized for question. Thank you, sir. this is currently not not listed as a child abuse I'm asking and this simply is in my I'm asking this sort of warning to people who might do this not to do it in Arkansas and and as you said to give clarity and specifically call out this crime because we've never really needed to call this out in our history. Correct. It
▶ Play
does bring clarity. It sets some guidelines for potential prosecutions down the road. Follow up? Yes. If
▶ Play
this bill passes, then these doctors that observe these mutilations would not be hesitant to report them. They would have legal coverage to report them. That's correct. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Gates, do you recognize a question? We passed a bill out of the House that basically restricted, oh, I forgot what it's called, your Sharia law that basically said American laws for Americans because it seems like there are some judges that have confused that law with American law and have basically said, we recognize that you come from another country and this is your standard practice, even though it was, you know, they were basically in an American court judging that. I understand where you're going with this and I support it. I think part of the concern is well shouldn't they already be prosecuting this i agree they should the problem is somebody brings up a religious practice from where they're from and they're not american citizens but they practice it here this would basically tell every prosecutor you cannot overlook this because this isn't some obscure federal law this is an arkansas law and i think that's the thing of trying to strengthen it to make to codify into arkansas law will actually bring hopefully even some recognition that we do have a problem with this.
▶ Play
Thank you. I agree with you. Representative Johnson, your recognizable
▶ Play
question. We've passed some mandated reporting laws already out of this committee. I mean, I think it definitely qualifies as a reportable offense, and that child shouldn't be with those parents anymore if done what we already have in place. Am I correct in that, that you go to the hospital, the doctors, we've said that in here, and then child services come in and the child's not with the parents anymore? I
▶ Play
think the gap that I'm hearing in your comment is we'd like to stop this practice before it happens, not report it after the fact. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Representative Sullivan, you recognize. Call
▶ Play
the question, Mr. Chair. Okay, what's your question?
▶ Play
Maybe I'm saying that wrong. Immediate consideration, Mr. Chair. We have a prepared motion.
▶ Play
Representative Gates is going to make a motion. But at this time, are there any more questions from committee? If not, are they, yes, Representative Tucker, you're recognized for a question. I don't have a question, but after the questions
▶ Play
were over, I was just going to make a comment about some of the interstate issues, which would be free legal advice, which is worth exactly what it costs. But I was just going to try to clarify that, but I was waiting for the questions to be over. So anyway, I'll go with the will of the committee, but I was going to offer a comment on
▶ Play
that after the questions were over. Okay. Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for or against this bill? Representative Tucker, you're recognized to make your
▶ Play
comments. Just to try to clarify the interstate issue a little bit. I'm not a criminal lawyer, and again, this is free legal advice, but basically the federal government can't prosecute behavior that takes place within one state, And so that's why murder is a state crime, because murders almost always take place within one state. What they can prosecute is if you cross state boundaries with the intent to commit a crime. And so if someone traveled from Arkansas to Tennessee with the intent to commit murder, then that crime would be committed as soon as they cross the state boundary, regardless of whether or not the murder actually ends up taking place, because the crime was crossing state lines with the intent to commit murder. And then the murder that took place in Tennessee would actually be prosecuted by the state of Tennessee. And so anyway, to the extent that helps clarify, Arkansas can govern criminal conduct that takes place within the state of Arkansas. I'm not sure that Arkansas can govern criminal conduct that takes place outside of Arkansas, but that conduct would be covered by the federal law. That's just my opinion of the situation. I just thought I would offer that to help clarify any questions that members had about that.
▶ Play
Speaker 139 58:09
Okay. Thank you. Would you like to close
▶ Play
for your bill? Okay. Representative Gates, you're recognized. A motion do pass. We have a motion do pass. All in favor, vote aye. Aye. Opposed, you've passed your bill. We've got the ayes. I see one hand. That bill has passed. with the committee's indulgence I'm going to run Senate Bill 760 for Senator Fowles Representative Miguel,
▶ Play
you're recognized to present your bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Madam Chair. Let me get this in front of me. Thank you, Madam Chair. Committee, I bring to you Senate Bill 760 by Senator Jake Fowles, and this kind of leans toward what we were just talking about. What this deals with is making sure that in suspected cases of maltreatment that everyone understands that there should be an investigative review. And he's added language to amend the current law to, if you'll look at on line 31, he's added language that reads, this involves current and past health care providers when the allocation of child maltreatment was reported by a health care provider. Basically, this was brought to his attention because there was some suspected child maltreatment, but they had difficulty getting the interviews with the health care providers, and this law is kind of clarifying that language on what they're to do in cases where there may be maltreatment. With that, I'll try to answer any questions that you may have. Are there any
▶ Play
questions by members of the committee? Representative Meeks.
▶ Play
Speaker 72 1:01:17
Thank you, Madam Chair. So, I'm trying to wrap my head around this. I guess it doesn't matter which health care provider this allegation was made against. Let's say you had a doctor that the allegation was made against, and they were in an office with several other ones, then those other providers in that office could also be interviewed. Is that the way I'm reading
▶ Play
this? if somebody else wants to come up. The way I'm reading it does say the current are past health care providers so that could mean anyone that was present at the time would be required to have a discussion concerning the maltreatment. Representative McGee, would you like for me to recognize
▶ Play
Ms. McGee to come to the table with you? Yes, please. She seems eager to do so. Yes. Thank you for being here. Would you please introduce yourself to the committee? Lisa McGee, I'm
▶ Play
an attorney with the Department of Human Services and Senator Foss came to us with his constituent issue and we helped him draft this bill. And his concern is when a healthcare provider makes the hotline report, he wants to ensure that when the investigation is conducted that the person who's doing the investigation goes and talks to the person who's the health care provider who made the hotline report. So that's what this is mandating. It's adding to the statute that we talk to the health care provider if they made this hotline report. Okay, so it wouldn't cause them to
▶ Play
Speaker 72 1:02:57
have to look at other doctors potentially? No, no. So if you're the
▶ Play
nurse, the nurse practitioner, the doctor, the health care provider and you call their hotline and said, I've got a kid here, I need to make a hotline report, here's what's going on, then when the investigator does the investigation, they need to go back and talk to that health care provider and get
▶ Play
information. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Johnson. And I guess your intent here is even if that person is not in the medical profession anymore, they've changed professions, they've retired.
▶ Play
Is that, it says. Well, current or past. Right. So when we go to this health care provider and they say, well, you know, this is the second time this child's had this injury, this other doctor had it, then we've got to go back to the other health care provider as well. So once we get the allegation from this health care provider, we've got
▶ Play
to go backwards and look back to see this child's history. Okay. Past provider meaning past provider for that
▶ Play
person. Okay. Past health care provider. Representative Gates. are they not already required a health care provider not already required to report
▶ Play
yes health care providers are already on over on our list of mandated reporters but what this is curing part of when we're doing their maltreatment investigation we're supposed to ascertain current injuries or past injuries so that's already in the statute but what has happened in central falls area is that a health care provider made a report and they were not interviewed as a part of this so what this amendment will do is it goes over to where in the section of the maltreatment act called investigative interviews and now it's mandating that the investigator has to go interview that health care provider and then also look at past health care providers and interview them as well so follow
▶ Play
up so really the problem is not the reporting it's the questioning and getting the information from the very one that we've required to investigate that we're not even doing due diligence to do follow-up. Thank you.
▶ Play
Madam Chair, at this time I would like to recognize Senator Files who has arrived for any comments he
▶ Play
Speaker 168 1:05:22
may have. Welcome Senator Files. Thank you Madam Chair, members of the committee. I'm sure Representative McGill explained this but this was a
▶ Play
Speaker 169 1:05:30
passionate emergency room nurse. We're having trouble
▶ Play
Speaker 168 1:05:32
hearing you. Could we get your mic? This was a passionate emergency room nurse that called me in despair when this situation came up and really was searching for ways where they could be more included. And, you know, when they make a report, my wife's a nurse, and she was talking about this process. She said, when we make a report, it's hard for us to be in and out of what we're still supposed to be doing, but yet we know we're required to report, and then to not get followed up with and not go through those processes just was burdensome. And then to see that same situation come back with a death and other heinous acts was just almost more than this lady could take. And so I'd appreciate a good vote on this bill.
▶ Play
Any more questions from members of the committee? Is there anyone in the audience who would like to speak for the bill, against the bill? Representative McGee, would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed. Excuse me. Miguel. I'm sorry. We're closed. Thank you. What is the pleasure of the committee? Representative Meeks. Motion to pass. We have a motion to pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Against? You passed your bill.
▶ Play
Again, I must reiterate, we have some of the greatest staff people in the world. Thank you. I should be giving you a standing ovation, you know that. reminder before we adjourn our tonight at Wyndham we'd love to see all of you there certainly if you have more important commitments take care of those but we'd love to see you tonight at 6 p.m. if there's nothing else
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1587

0:22 - 0:57 1 segment 1 speaker

HR1039

0:57 - 4:14 11 segments 4 speakers

HB1904

4:14 - 18:15 43 segments 8 speakers

HB1284

18:15 - 22:51 12 segments 4 speakers

HB1947

22:51 - 35:38 42 segments 8 speakers

HR1041

35:38 - 36:44 2 segments 2 speakers

HB1762

36:44 - 59:13 79 segments 11 speakers

SB760

59:13 - 1:08:14 30 segments 8 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative George B. McGill Chair Unverified
46 segments
Representative DeAnn Vaught Unverified
6 segments
Representative Warwick Sabin Unverified
13 segments
Paula Mccauley Unverified
11 segments
Representative Dan Sullivan Chair Unverified
11 segments
Representative Clarke Tucker Unverified
9 segments
Representative Sue Scott Unverified
4 segments
Representative David Whitaker Unverified
6 segments
Representative Mickey Gates Chair Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 72
26 segments
Representative Karilyn Brown Unverified
11 segments
Speaker 84
1 segment
Representative Rebecca Petty Unverified
8 segments
Representative Charlene Fite Unverified
6 segments
Representative Brandt Smith Unverified
33 segments
Chair Unverified
3 segments
Representative Bob Johnson Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 139
1 segment
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 168
3 segments
Speaker 169
1 segment