House Revenue and Taxation Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (8)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1902
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…gies first for the committee. We're going to start off with House Bill 1902.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB332
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB332”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1745
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1745”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB801
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB801”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB802
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB802”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB844
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Senate Bill 844, in the 89th General Assembly, for those that were here are…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB1022
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB1022”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB8
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…start at 8.01 and move down. Members, we want to start off Senate Bill 8.01. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee.”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
Members, y'all don't care. Let's grab a seat and let's get started. Good. Chair sees a quorum. We're going to get started. My apologies first for the committee. We're going to start off with House Bill 1902.
I didn't shoot that out yesterday to you guys because Representative Saban is still working through his fiscal impact to get it revenue neutral. I'm understanding that he does have an amendment for that. Yes, sir. And we're bringing the amendment up now, members, on your screen. So it will be House Bill 1902 with the amendment when staff gets the amendment up. Somebody just yell at me, please.
Repetives, good morning, Repetives. Saban, you doing all right? I'm doing well. How are you? Good. When you get ready, just go ahead and proceed with your amendment.
Okay. We are ready? I'm sorry. No, hang on just a second. Staff's holding me up. Ignore the one on the screen. Okay, staff is saying ignore the amendment on the screen. There have been two amendments. We're passing out the hard copy of the correct amendment.
Sorry for the rage. Good morning. Good morning. Okay, the amendment on your screen should be taken away and we're going to go off the hard copy until we get this worked
out. Representative Saban, when you get ready you just go ahead and proceed, sir. Okay. Well, while the amendment's being handed, I'll just say that the amendment is designed to bring the fiscal impact of the bill to zero and we do have members from DF&A here who've said they're willing to testify to that
effect because we don't have a fiscal impact statement in writing, but obviously with everything going on at the last minute. You know, I brought this amendment basically at the request of the state treasurer's office to sort of simplify the intent of the bill, which is really just to make sure that our state employees know that these 529 plans exist for savings for college tuition for their children. And it now has the support of the treasurer's office and, like I said, the fiscal impact's down to zero.
Mr. Larry, Mr. Timmer, anybody from DFA want to speak to that? Are you guys good? You guys are good? John Tice shows us that he's good. Members, any questions on the amendment? Representative Collins, you're recognized, sir. Sorry, Mr. Chair, I was waiting for the bill. I've got a motion on
the amendment at the proper time. Thank you, sir. Any other questions? Anybody in the audience
want to speak against the amendment? for the amendment. Representative Collins, you're recognized for your motion for the amendment, sir. I move we adopt the amendment.
Motion for adoption of the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any no? Congratulations. Your amendment passed. You're free to proceed
with your bill, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And the reason why I brought this bill just so everybody knows is I was approached by state employees who didn't know that they had the opportunity to contribute to a 529 plan, and the fact is that the plan does exist, but I think everybody now acknowledges we need to do a better job to make people aware that it exists and to help them understand how it works in terms of the voluntary contributions
they can make out of their paychecks. And so really, if you look at the bill, we took out a lot of the language with this amendment we just adopted that maybe overcomplicated things. And if you look at the amendment and the language we added, I think you can see it's pretty straightforward in terms of how the participation in the program exists, that it's voluntary. I think there's pretty much consensus from everybody that the 529 plans are an excellent way to encourage people to save for their
children's college education. And so we just want to make sure people are aware of that opportunity. And
questions. Representative Collins, you recognize? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Sabin, I just want to make sure I understand what we're doing here. What we're doing is basically allowing an administrative animal. In other words, DF&A can administratively assist in this. But I just wanted to make sure one more thing that we may not also be, which would be nice, giving state employees an actual help.
529s are deferred tax benefits, right? So it's not like your pre-tax money goes in, i.e., if they put the money in now, then DF&A can also reduce their withholding. You don't really get that effect. All you really get is administratively you don't have to set up an ACH at your bank. You can just do it this way, and it really doesn't affect the tax. Okay, so it seems like a good help to people, in my view, as long as the administrators can do it. Thank
Mr. Chairman. This one may be a question for DF&A.
We've recently had discussions in budget about payroll slots, and there's only so many payroll slots available for these employee deductions. I just want to verify that we have a slot available, and if so, what slot that that would come out of. Mr. Chairman, Tim
Speaker 42
6:40
Leathers from the Department of Finance and Administration.
We would not have an issue of this if it was in the law with payroll slots, and we can pay this, actually administer, I think, through the Treasurer's Office, but we won't have any problems dealing with it. All right, thank you.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Motion at the proper time. Thank you, sir. Any other questions, members? Anybody nodding, just want to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Meeks, you're recognized for your motion, sir. We have a motion to adopt as amended. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Any opposed, no?
Congratulations, you passed your bill, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. You're welcome. Representative Jean, you ready, sir? Yes, sir. Do you have a preference of what you want to start off with? I want to start at 8.01 and move down. Members, we want to start off Senate Bill 8.01. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee.
I'd like to ask Mr. Danny Ferguson, if he wants to come forward, just be here. If you have any technical questions with Southwest Energy, come to the table. First off is Senate Bill 801. It's what this did. Many was here in the fiscal session 2014. we put an exemption on sand for drilling purposes, mainly to help out in the Fayetteville shale area, and all this bill does
is strike the language that was passed in the 2014 fiscal session and, by the way, this passed with 84 votes in the House and 34 votes in the Senate and replaced it with identical language in the 2015 session and answer any questions at this time. If not, I've got Mr. Ferguson here to answer any technical questions.
Members, any questions? Anybody in the audience want to speak against the bill? For the bill? Representative Meeks,
do you recognize to make your motion, sir? I have a motion to do pass. Representative Meeks has a motion to do pass. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed?
Congratulations. You passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, members of the committee this Senate Bill 802. This also is a kind of a cleanup bill that solid waste is defined. What we think of solid waste is stuff that goes like food, garbage, metal waste that
goes into a landfill. Somehow salt water got classified as solid waste. It never goes into landfills. It goes usually into re-injection wells and what this does is delete that from solid waste and it does have an exemption that is not taxed because none of this stuff ever goes to a landfill and Mr. Ferguson is here to answer any technical questions. Any questions members?
Anybody not just want to speak against the bill?
You guys are easy today. Anybody want to speak for the bill? Do we have a motion? Motion to approve. Motion for approval. Do pass. Representative Neal? I do
Speaker 57
10:03
have one question. I'm sorry. Go ahead. We passed this in fiscal session in 801, and then we're going to pass this in 802, and we're redoing 801 redoes what we did in the fiscal session. Is that right?
That's correct. Okay, are we going to have to come back in two years and redo this again because we're not following the law that we passed this time? Representative
Jean, can you speak? Well, I'm hoping that the ones that oversee the regulation of this law follow the law, and I don't anticipate that problem. Thank you. any other discussion members
Representative Lateman you're free to make your motion sir motion do pass motion do pass any discussion all in favor say aye any opposed
no resolution you pass your bill thank you Mr. Chair and thank you members of committee 683 you good we're ready to run 683 Mr. Ed Ellis if you come forward at the mic this is a broadband infrastructure incentive act and everybody knows we
need to do more broadband in the state and I'm going to introduce mr. Ed to identify himself and kind of give
Speaker 66
11:36
a brief explanation what this bill does I'm a consultant for working on behalf of AT&T this bill in a nutshell does a couple of things. Number one is it caps the amount of intangible assets that can be assessed by the Public Service Commission.
Another thing it does is it really mitigates an unfairness that's going on today in Arkansas in that companies that are assessed by the Public Service Commission have to be assessed and pay property taxes on intangible assets, Things like trademarks and copyrights and patents and things of that sort. No other companies have to do that. You know, Apple Inc. with their store out in Promenade in Chenal, they don't pay on intangibles.
But companies like AT&T that are involved in broadband infrastructure deployment do have to. thank you sir
members any any other questions anybody represent makes you recognize all right thank you
and this this may be have to be directed at DF and a but my understanding of current law is that they're not supposed to be able to and this is like a personal property assessment that's what we're dealing
with here? Am I barking up
ask another follow-up? Well, based on discussion we've had with assessors in past committee meetings, the taxing of intangibles is already supposed to be illegal. So I guess what I'm working at is that the purpose of the bill kind of in a nutshell is to make sure to clarify what the what these
businesses are being assessed at for personal property taxes is that kind of the
Speaker 66
13:40
goal it does in fact clarify that and there is an exception for companies that are centrally assessed by the PSC they do get assessed and have to pay on intangible so it's a little bit different than the normal statutes that govern ad valorem taxation. Okay, so we're not dealing with ad valorem taxation so much. We're dealing
more with rates set by the PSC. I'm just trying to get a handle of what the ultimate goal of the bill is trying to accomplish here.
Speaker 66
14:09
Well, the ultimate goal, Representative Meeks, is that going forward, the Public Service Commission would no longer include intangible assets that were added in the previous year to the calculation of the ad valorem taxes that would be due. So if a company was paying $100 for intangible taxation and they added $10 worth of intangible value next year,
that $10 would not be included in the calculation of what was owed or what was
assessed. Okay, so the ultimate goal here would be to reduce the fees to the company and ultimately to the customers because
Speaker 66
15:00
of the fees? The future prospects of those assessments is what it would affect. The business as usual, the intangibles that we're being assessed on today will continue just like today.
Okay, all right. Representative Collins, you recognize her?
is another way to phrase this to say if we cap the tax at the current level of intangibles it makes it more attractive for future investment in Arkansas by companies that are affected by this sir. That is very well said Members, any
other questions? Anybody in the audience want to speak against the bill? For the bill? Members, we have a motion for the bill?
Have a motion to do pass by Representative Ferguson, any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, you passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, members of the committee. Members, out of objection, we're going to take, I know you guys are not going to believe this, but I'm going to take one out of order without objection, Senate Bill 332. And do we have anybody from the chamber want
to go? Parker and Mr. Zook will come to the table.
Mr. Chair. Feel free to proceed. Okay. Colleagues, this is the act of amending the law concerning sales and use tax to partial replacement repair of certain machinery for parts. Having with me today is Randy Zook with the Arkansas State Chamber. Mr. Zook may want to have an opening comment
Speaker 81
16:40
on this. Thank you, Representative Jean, and thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee.
Very briefly, this bill is a continuation of our efforts to reduce Arkansas taxes on partial replacements of and repair parts for machinery used in manufacturing. We continue to be the only state in the region that taxes these business inputs and correcting this is important for our ability to be competitive in the manufacturing sector of the economy. Because of constraints on general revenue, provisions of this bill to further step down the sales tax on this input have been removed,
and as presented today, Senate Bill 332 has no revenue impact to general revenue. What's in this bill is a technical correction suggested by DF&A that will improve the opportunity for small manufacturing companies to take advantage of the existing sales tax reduction passed in the 2013 session without having to be a full-fledged direct pay permit holder and all the challenges that that would present for especially for smaller businesses.
This is called a limited direct pay provision. It will allow a company to calculate its own taxes to be paid on purchases for the appropriate repair and replacement parts and remits only those taxes directly to the state. While this will not further reduce the sales tax for Arkansas manufacturers, this change will put another tool in the toolkit that can be utilized by our state's existing small manufacturers, and we urge your approval of it. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Zooks.
Members also, we're handing some stuff out from the chamber also goes with this. Any questions? Representative Ferguson,
you recognize her. One quick question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I have an industry in my district that last year or so bought a very expensive piece of equipment, and they had to have some repairs to it. How does this affect them in terms of the tax situation? Or does it?
Representative, my name is Mike Parker. I'm tax counsel for the State Chamber of Commerce and have been involved with this bill. Presently, repairs are taxable based on your chart. They are taxable at a reduced rate of 1% below the current rate based on legislation passed in 2013. If your manufacturer is already what's called a direct pay permit holder, then this bill will not really affect it. However, if your manufacturer is not a direct pay permit holder, then it's not able under present law to take advantage of that 1% reduction in the rates that apply that we hope eventually will reduce on down to a nominal amount.
So what this will do is give your manufacturer an additional tool, an additional method that they can take advantage of that slight reduction in the tax rate without having to directly remit all of their taxes on everything that they buy. Thank you. Thank you. Any other questions,
members? Anybody not even want to speak against the bill, for the bill? Do you have a motion from Representative Ferguson?
Motion to do pass. I'm sorry I didn't ask you one closer bill, but that's kind of what I thought. I have a motion from Representative Ferguson for do pass. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, you passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, members of the committee. Representative Hodges, you good? You ready? Members will be sent at Bill 844.
Speaker 92
21:07
Do I have your permission? Yes, sir. Go ahead. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. If you don't mind, Mr. Chair, I'd like to call up Joel DePippa for any question that you may have. He was instrumental in drafting this piece of legislation. That's fine. Recognize yourself, sir, for the
committee, and you're free to proceed. Joel DePippa
Speaker 92
21:43
Senate Bill 844, in the 89th General Assembly, for those that were here are familiar with Amendment 82, the economic incentive package that the state offers for the first time, actually enacting that piece of legislation since it was passed, to the purpose of the legislation is to
draw or attract a super project to the state of which we attracted Big River Steel, which is in Mississippi County in Oceola, Arkansas, which is my district. And there were some concerns. We passed it in the 89th General Assembly, but some concerns came up this year during this session because it was brought to our attention that there's a possibility that they could use the entire amount of the tax
credit and it would be a $270 million hit to our coffers. So Senator Hickey and some others got together and put their heads together and worked embedded to put some safeguards in place and to make this a better piece of legislation. So that's what you have before you today. You know, I really appreciate Big River for agreeing. The governor has agreed to it.
Big River has agreed to it. DF&A, AEDC, they've all come together and made sure that this would be a good bill. I said in Revenue and Tax Senate Committee on last week, when Senator Burnett presented the bill. There was no controversy or no issues with it, and it also passed on the Senate floor, 34 to 0. And also, I appreciate Big River for agreeing. This proves and shows that they want
to be good corporate citizens to the state of Arkansas to agree to do this. And so at this time, if you have any questions, we'll be happy to answer those questions.
Thank you, Representative Hodges. On page 3 on line 31, I'm assuming that no more than $20 million of tax credits, possession, and controlled public retirement system, that that's the mechanism that the Senate put in place for your safeguard, what
Speaker 92
24:08
you're talking about? Absolutely. They put a cap on it where they can only utilize $20 million per year.
Is there any other? What was the other changes? Do you know off the top of
Speaker 94
24:27
go over the changes that were made. Some of the changes that have been made on this bill since originally discussed include provisions to protect Amendment 82 projects. For example, there is the $20 million cap, which is an annual cap. But we also have a provision that extends the carry forward if that cap would cause any of those credits to fall out of time.
So this cap will not endanger the carry forward provisions, periods, for any project that holds it. When a public retirement system is an investor in an Amendment 82 project, they are going to be granted the control and possession of all of these recycling credits, which they will then sell $20 million of to the state each year. the state will buy those for $16 million, saving the state $4 million every year on those credits until they are extinguished in their entirety.
There is a provision where if the state fails to buy those credits, that the retirement system may then sell those credits to other parties. However, the state is paying $16 million for $20 million worth of credits, And so the odds of the state declining to save money would be in the
hands, far outside of our hands. Thank you very much.
Members, any questions? Representative Collins? So Representative Hodges, my understanding is from talking with Senator Hickey several weeks ago
that he was concerned that a $250 to $300 million tax credit could hit DF&A at any moment. And what this legislation does is put in place a temporal usage of those credits and also answers the question, in what I think is a very creative and good way, about how the public retirement system handles its credits. So as I see what you've done here, it just seems like there's been a lot of good work,
and it makes me feel much more comfortable about that legislation that we passed last time because these were the kinds of things I, too, was concerned about. Wouldn't you
Speaker 92
26:40
agree? I would agree, and thank you. And I'm glad you mentioned that, Reverend Collins. I was going to tease you when I came to the end of the table about these changes that were made. And you did, you and I had some discussion about it during the 89th, so I would agree with you, and I appreciate the comments. Thank you, sir.
Members, any other questions? Anybody not that want to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Hodges, you closed
Speaker 92
27:10
for your bill, sir? I am, and I'm pretty surprised that Representative Meeks didn't have a question, but I thank you. Well, Representative Meeks,
pass? There you go. Good bipartisanship. We have a motion on the table for a do pass by Representative Meeks. Any discussion members? All in favor, say aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations. You passed your bill, sir. Thank you, Chair. And Gonzalez,
to move on to House Bill 1745. And while we're waiting on this, I think there's going to be an amendment on this.
Is anybody in the audience or anybody here, members? Yeah. Okay, that's fine. Senate Bill 1022, Senator Teague. Is anybody here going to run that? Does he ask you? Did I already ask you that? Okay, my apologies. Okay, we're going to do that just here in a little bit. There's going to be an amendment on House Bill 1745.
Is the amendment set? Do y'all have the amendments yet? Good morning, Representative Cervillo. How you doing? Doing fine. Thank you, Mr. Chair. When you get ready, just go ahead and proceed about your amendment, sir. Okay, sir.
Speaker 108
29:15
First of all, thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you so much for your help in letting me present this bill to my colleagues. Let me just go into the details and hopefully what we're striving to do on House Bill 1745. It actually sets up a tax credit for tuition payments for independents with certain disabilities. The purpose of this is that to create a scholarship for individuals that have disabilities.
The effects would be that you could contribute or entities contribute to this particular fund, a scholarship program, and would get a tax credit. The program would be set up where the entity that would be overseeing the scholarship program would take in applications based on their outlook of what they would choose to see in a disability.
So what would happen is that a child that has a disability could apply for this scholarship, and then if accepted, there would be a $4,400 tax credit that would be sent to the school of their choice, and it would be a private school that would fit their need best. Now, the $4,400 scholarship would be sent to the entity that they choose.
And once again, if that was approved, then they would be able to have the $4,400 go towards the tuition of that particular school. It does not go to the individual. It will go to the designated school. the benefits to this from a fiscal standpoint one I think the most important thing it gives children we looked at dyslexia I'll just give you as you looked at the impact statement we weren't real clear our hope is that we
would cap this at a hundred students and when the when we sent it to DF&A what happened is they looked at dyslexia and saw that 17% of the children that are in school have this particular disability and so they took they took all the private school children which was over at 28,000 and use the 17% with that you've got a tremendous amount of numbers so this was kind of in infinity
from the standpoint we didn't we didn't look at the ceiling so we've changed that and what we're looking at is having the scholarship available for a hundred children that have disabilities though that would end up coming back to meaning that we would end up having 400 impact of $440,000 if all hundred children were able to gain the scholarship. If we have less money that comes into the scholarship,
then it certainly would be less scholarships. But we're the, I think the numbers and what I've tried to do is show you where it makes sense. If you look at the general fund, when you look at adequacy, and these are rounded numbers, but I got them from Richard Wilson who, as you know. Excuse
me, Representative Seville, is this all in the amendment, sir? No, sir. Are
Speaker 108
33:04
you still on amendment? No, sir. Well, okay, let me go back to the amendment. The amendment, basically, what it ended up doing is just designating that it would be a disability.
That was changed. So disability from dyslexia was not indicated here. It has, I'm sorry, it does come back to dyslexia, and that's the one we have chosen. It also defines the scholarship going to a private school. And once again, it does cover the children that are in elementary and secondary education.
And then, of course, it's located in Arkansas as defined in our code. This is your amendment
to your own bill, though, right, sir? That is correct, sir. Okay. Is there any discussion on this? Do I have a motion for adopt this on amendment? I have a motion for Representative Tucker for adoption of the amendment to his bill. Any discussion? All in favor say
Speaker 108
34:09
aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Okay. You can recognize your bill, sir. Okay. Sorry, Mr. Chairman. I got the horse before the cart. And I pretty much explained to you basically what the bill does, and so I won't elaborate
and take any more time. And this particular issue was originated in Arizona, and it went all the way to the Supreme Court, and they ruled in favor of this. So we do have, I guess, judicial oversight on this. If I could go ahead and just move into the financial aspects of this, is in a very simple chart I show you, the general fund. And what happens is every student, as you know, the adequacy is about $6,400.
That is what Richard Wilson had given us. What would happen, that money, because the child is no longer in the public school, will stay in the general fund. Actually, the tax credit would have an impact on the general fund, as you can see, $4,400. So basically what you end up doing is you end up, for each one of these scholarships, the general fund actually gains $2,000. And so what the DF&A did, and, you know, they're limited.
All they could do when they gave you the forecast originally was an infant number and then the fact that now we've brought it down to 100, which will be amended in the Senate if we can get it there. So I think that number, once again, hopefully that you just will consider what I'm saying to you, and that would be in the amendment, that you see that there's $2,000 per student that could be saved or left into the general fund.
That would be at the discretion of the governors where he would want to use that general fund. If I could suggest my personally sending it back to education, The good thing about that, if you had 100 children that participated in this, you'd have $200,000 that would stay in the general fund. And I believe what that would mean is if they chose to send it to education, it would give them opportunities, whether it was any aspect of education.
It could even be facilities or whatever, so it's not earmarked. But anyway, that's basically the bill is that we're creating a tax credit for a scholarship for a child that has a disability and allowing that family to choose a school. And then the scholarship would go to the school and from that standpoint would have a tax savings. And then, once again, anybody that wants to participate in this, if you wanted to send $100 to this fund, once again, you would be able to deduct that off your taxes as a tax
credit. So with that, I would be open for any discussion.
Members, any questions? Representative Hodges. Thank
Speaker 92
37:16
you, Mr. Chair. Representative Cervelo, is this just for students that have dyslexia, or is this for any disabled? The amendment shows you that it would be for dyslexia. And let me just tell
Speaker 108
37:29
you why we've chosen that. And it's interesting in my research to find out 17% of our children have this particular, if you want to call it a disability.
So I didn't realize it affected that many children. I wish we had all the money that we could create for children with disabilities. But being that I was going to limit it to 100 children, we tried to specify something that we felt could be effective. And so that's why we've chosen that. But I would be open if you want to specify just children with disabilities. But that, I think, becomes a real, real broad, and it's a picking and choosing of certain,
and someone's going to gain and someone's going to lose. So we chose dyslexia. We think that's a good area to start with in a learning disability. Representative Seville, I'm still trying to have
a hard time getting my hands wrapped around the money part since DFA did not score this that I know of. Is that correct, DFA? Pardon me, sir? Do you want to speak to it? Thank you very much. Mr. Chairman, Tim Leathers from DFA.
Speaker 42
38:53
We appreciate what Mr. Savillo is trying to do, and it may well be in education that the children would be better off if the state paid for them to be in private school settings. That might be a better deal for the state even to accomplish that. But this is one of those situations where you layer over a bureaucracy, give 100% credit on a tax, so you pay for it dollar for dollar what the taxpayer puts in. You guys have seen these before, and there's a good purpose,
but if that good purpose is there, it ought to be vetted in education and part of that decision-making process there and part of that budget rather than laying a bureaucracy on top of it, taking it out of an income tax return where it's not reviewed and measured and those sort of things that ought to be accomplished with that. And we know Mr. Cevillo is well-intentioned with what he's doing, but I want to point out because we have consistently on these 100% credits
pointed that out in the past where we're just paying for something off the top of the Treasury there's some other procedural things I think John has an impact one of those is there's a limit of the number of people and this could be people that are currently in private schools that would be entitled to this so you know their parents could be paying for it now and we would just switch that over to the state paying for it throughout this through this process and those sort of things. So it has been a challenge for us to come up with a number on,
but we've worked on that. And Mr. Cervillo, in an attempt to keep the cost down, has put a top number of qualifiers during the year, which also adds to that bureaucratic process in that somehow there has to be a cutoff where somebody would apply to get it, and somebody's going to be unhappy if it goes to or above that point if you limit it to that and the last, you know, it's kind of the first person in gets it up to that number and then someone would be left out
and then it's up to us to catch it on the returns when the, you know, those things are filed. But I just want to point those things out to you, nothing against the intent of the bill or whether this might be the best deal for the state, but doing it as a 100% tax credit We just have to
be consistent in pointing that out. Thank you, sir. Representative Lateman? Question. You're
recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Lowe's, I'd like to ask just a simple question.
Based on this chart that we have here on discussion, would it be a net gain to the general fund of $2,000 per student if we pass this bill? I'd just like
Speaker 42
41:53
a yes or no. No, because what you're doing is you're taking, if it was a student that you're currently taking out of a school and you're only paying this amount for them on that student's basis, yes. But if you start looking at taking students that are currently in a private setting, then you have the other issue of where it is.
So those are the things that, again, need to be run through the education process with those committees reviewing, determining if it's the best idea to give scholarships to the state, and then fund that as part of the budget rather than taking it off on the tail end.
Follow-up, Mr. Chair? Yes. These students that are already in a private school, that money is already being paid. that $6,400 is already being paid to somebody.
Isn't that correct? Even though they're going to a private school, the private school is not getting that money. It's going
Speaker 42
42:57
to wherever they're allocated. If they're in a private school, their parents or someone else is paying for the private school and not
the state currently. But the public school in that district is
getting that money? No, sir. Okay. All right. Thank you. Hold on a second. Representative Collins. Representative Civillo, based on the conversation, and I'm just going to respectfully ask you,
and this is strictly your call, sir, but just based on where this conversation is going, my suggestion would be you consider to put this thing in interim study and work through some of these questions. Now, we'll proceed if you want to. It's strictly going to be your call, but that would be my recommendation just based on where
Speaker 108
43:38
the conversation is going right now. If the chair would give me the privilege, I'd like to ask someone to come and speak, a constituent that is in my district that has a lot of knowledge on this subject
that could maybe clarify, and he would be brief. May I do
that, sir? Yes, sir. And while we're doing this, Representative Collins, you recognize for your question. Thank
you very much, Mr. Chair. So Mr. Leathers has talked quite a bit about the other way of doing this, which is to actually address the general fund and approaching it that way. And there is a bill that's supposed to be on the House floor today, 1552, which follows the recommended path that Mr. Leathers talked about. So this is a great idea, and I love what you're doing, Representative Servillo,
in terms of trying to find a way to help children with disabilities be able to have the best option for them. Some of the issues that you're hearing about today, and I ran a bill very similar to this four years ago, so I'm with you 100%. I resolved in HB 1552 on the floor, number one, the person must be in a public school. The public school must be given at least one year in order to try and meet their needs before they'd be eligible to move to a private school scholarship,
which would be less than their foundation funding. Number two, it's not dyslexia only. It's a disability as defined by that child is on an IEP in their public school, And then number three, you don't have the administrative bureaucracy to try and manage the scholarship concept, nor do you have 100% tax credit. So read up on 1552 and see if that works. And maybe, Representative Cervillo, just pulling the bill down to see what happens with 1552 is a smarter way before trying to decide interim study today or not.
Speaker 108
45:26
Do you agree? I do. I appreciate it once again. And thank you for that information. I know you've been there and you know the intention of this. We do want to get it right. If I just have just a few moments, I think my constituent here would be able to just give a little bit
Speaker 122
45:47
clearer explanation than what I did. You bet. No problem. Recognize yourself for the committee, sir. Greg Kays. I'm a constituent of Representative Servillo's, and I'd be happy to work with you, Mr. Chairman, and other members of the committee and Representative Servillo with your idea of a study committee.
study report. Okay. With that, I do support
Speaker 108
46:09
your recommendation. I would like to take it to an interim study. Okay. Thank you very much, sir. I appreciate
you working with us, and I appreciate the way you've handled your business. Thank you. Okay, members, we have one more on agenda today. Representative Leaves, you ready, sir? It's going to be Senate Bill 1022.
Representative Eves, this is Larry Teague's bill, so feel free to butcher it up as much as
you want to. That is possible. I'm going to have Ms. Jodianne Tripp join me to answer any questions you might have. Thank you, Mr. Chair, by the way. This is Senator Teague's bill. It's already passed out of the Senate with no opposition, and it's just a simple technical correction.
Medicaid asked us to make this change to allow them to use more up-to-date information for calculating assessments. The federal government is very slow to close out cost reports, so many of the cost reports available from the feds are five or more years old. This means that DHS sometimes has to use old data to do its calculations. This law would not require DHS to use a newer cost report, but it does allow them to do this when they see that the closed-out cost report that is available is very old because of the federal backlog. That's it. Any questions?
Representative Collins. Representative Eads, I was in the Judiciary Committee on the Senate side yesterday, and Representative Womack opened up his commentary on his bill by explaining to the Senate chair, Senator Hutchinson, that there was zero opposition to the bill in the House. And Senator Hutchinson said, let me give you some advice, Representative Womack. We don't care if nobody in the House objected. Do you agree that we don't care
around here whether Senators objected? I absolutely agree, Representative Collins, and I fully respect your opinion.
Members, any other questions? Anybody in the audience want to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Deese, you closed for your bill? I am closed. Thank you, committee. Do we have a motion, members? Representative McGill? The motion do pass by Reverend McGill Any discussion? All in favor say aye Any opposed, no Congratulations, you passed your bill Members, here's what I know We have one more bill coming to us tomorrow and it's for a concurrent for an amendment out of the Senate
I don't know if anything else is coming out of the Senate other than this one bill The speaker is telling me that around 4.30 tomorrow we're going to adjourn just a little bit early let us come down here, take care of business account of the game plan tomorrow so that's kind of the game plan right now that's subject to change and we'll shoot out an email the staff will shoot out an email to make sure that we're still on track but I don't anticipate any problems with House Bill 1817 by Representative Rushing that they put an amendment on the Senate so we've got to concur
with that and I don't know of anything else coming down the Senate so probably take about 15-20 seconds tomorrow sometime around 430 if everything's on track for that so any discussion? If not, we're adjourned.
Agenda
HB1902
SB801
SB802
SB332
SB844
HB1745
SB1022
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Joe Jett Chair
Unverified
Speaker 9
Representative Charlie Collins
Unverified
Speaker 42
Representative Stephen Meeks
Unverified
Speaker 57
Speaker 66
Speaker 81
Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson
Unverified
Mike Parker
Unverified
Speaker 92
Speaker 94
Speaker 91
Speaker 101
Speaker 102
Speaker 108
Representative Jack Ladyman
Unverified
Speaker 122
Representative Les Eaves
Unverified