House Revenue and Taxation Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (4)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1451
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…Representative Douglas, you good? Okay, members, it will be House Bill 1451. This will be, we're just going to hear this bill.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1817
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1817”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1917
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1917”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1941
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…o his concurrent for the Senate Amendment. And this will be House Bill 1941.”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 14, 2026
Testing, testing, testing, testing, testing, testing, testing, testing, we got it, thank you very much. With all the members I'm going to do just a little bit of housekeeping first thing this morning.
First of all, I've got my county judge from Greene County here. Rusty McMillan, county judge. How you doing, buddy? Good seeing you. You're sitting by a good guy back there as well. I've got some folks from Clay County back there as well. So good seeing you guys. Representative Speaks would like to address
Speaker 9
1:03
our staff We want to express all the help that you've given us and I know the other girl is not here
Oh, is she here? She's here, okay Alright Not everybody had a chance to sign the cards but it's from all of us and thank you for all you've done for us. You've been over backwards for us. Thank you. Thank you. Representative
agenda. We're going to do two concurrence on Senate amendments this morning,
and Representative Douglas, we're going to listen to her bill as well. So Representative Rushing, are you ready, ma'am? And members, this will be House Bill 1817. Good morning. How are you doing?
Doing good. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is House Bill 1817, and it's a concur amendment from the Senate. They have removed the preamble, which was uncodified to start with, so you've really already voted on this bill, and I would appreciate a good vote.
Thank you, ma'am. Representative Dodson? Motion at the proper time. Thank you. Anybody in the United States want to speak against the bill? For the bill, Representative Dyson, you recognize. Make a motion, sir. Motion do pass. Motion for concur for Senate Amendment. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations. You passed your bill. Thank you, committee. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members, Representative Neal, his mother-in-law has passed away. He's not here today, but this is the last chance we get to do this,
to get this bill out for him. So Representative Meeks has agreed to do his concurrent for the Senate Amendment. And this will be House Bill 1941.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, committee. Basically, all this amendment does is the bill currently says information related to taxes collected by particular entities or industries. And basically, all the amendment does is strikes out industries. I guess our Senate colleagues thought that was repetitive, so this is just a little bit of cleanup language. And with that, Mr. Chair, I'll make a motion to do pass at the proper time.
Thank you. Any questions, members? Anybody not anything you want to speak against? Four. Representative Vaught, you reckon? At a proper time. Yeah, this is a proper time, ma'am. Motion do pass. Okay, we have a motion to concur for the Senate Amendment. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. No. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Representative Douglas, you good? Okay, members, it will be House Bill 1451. This will be, we're just going to hear this bill.
Representative Douglas has agreed to pull the bill down, put it in the interim study after our discussion, but she wants to have the opportunity
Speaker 31
4:04
just to present it. House Bill 1451, members. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, committee, for letting me present this. Bill 1451 involves rebates on motor vehicles, And in the definition right now in the Arkansas Code, it includes manufacturer's rebates in the list of taxable income.
And what I would do is just to simply, we've added one or two lines, two lines in two different places to say that gross receipts, gross proceeds, or sales price does not include, and then in Roman numeral 4, you see it adds a manufacturer's rebate on a motor vehicle and then it adds it in one other place.
Many of you have been to buy a car and you've gotten a rebate of $1,000 to $4,000 and then when you go to get your tags and pay your tax, you did not realize because of maybe the small print in your contract that that rebate is included in your sales price, and you pay taxes on that. So this would take that rebate out of the ability to be taxed,
and Arkansans are upset when they go to pay their taxes, and they realize that this is taxable income, and I hope that in the future we'll be able to deal with this and bring about a good resolution because I think it is a good way to affect a lot of people. I had all my car dealerships just congratulating me on such a great bill
and they see it as a way to pass on that savings to the customers whether it's used cars or new cars. So what would you like for me to? Well, you take questions, ma'am? I'd be glad to. I guess, I mean,
I believe in your bill so much, I actually co-sponsored it, probably would have killed a thing for you. I doubt that. It's a good bill. I mean, we all know the bottom line was just the lack of money to do this.
Can you speak to us real quickly about the cost associated with this and what's going to, the total cost and all that?
Speaker 31
6:41
Excuse me. In the fiscal impact, it came back with $10 million in year one and about $14 million in year two. Okay. And $14 million was the total number? No, it would be $24 million
over two years. Okay. Representative Collins? Thank you, Mr. Chair. And Representative Douglas, as you know, I think on virtually every tax we have in Arkansas,
with the exception of property, is egregiously high, number one. and we tax more things than virtually anyone. So the list of where do we go next to reduce taxes is longer than my lifetime to attack. But when it comes to making those decisions, I've kind of got two questions. The first one is with regard to structurally, the concept of rebates. So for example, I worked at Procter & Gamble for many years and one of the promotions we would run is buy oil of LA,
send in a certificate and get a rebate of $5 or $10 or whatever. And a person gets no sales tax relief when they cash that rebate because in the bucket of promotions called rebates, that's not considered a price reduction, right? As the brand manager of Olay or Noxzema or Ford F-150s or whatever, I could choose to promote my product with a lower list price or with many other things, including rebates. The second question is with regard to poor people and rich people.
Let's say I was really rich and wanted to buy a Rolls-Royce and the rebate on the Rolls-Royce was $100,000. And then let's say somebody was not so rich and they wanted to buy a small, inexpensive car and the rebate was $1,000. Don't we wind up encouraging people to have more luxury living and in the line of tax opportunities we've got to challenge, do we want to focus on things that the richer you are, the more you save,
or do we want to focus on things like the harder you work and the more you work, the more you save? Thank you. Hopefully the
Speaker 31
8:54
two questions, I didn't make it too confusing. I think I get the gist of where you're going with that, and I hope I answer your question. What I see with cars is that we're getting more reasonable with what we buy. And we're seeing that in a reduction in the taxes that are going to roads, our transportation taxes.
So I feel like even though cars are a luxury, that people are getting much more thrifty in what they're buying. and the reason why they're becoming more thrifty is because there's less money to go around. So I think something like this that would encourage dealerships to bring their prices down, and this is on new cars, but they can also pass that price savings on to used cars as well. And I hope I have touched on your question in some way.
but I'd be glad to move this into an interim study in one of your committees if you would like or you just give me some direction on that okay
any other questions members you go for one more question represent Douglas you bet go ahead you should recognize I'll get back with you
on what I think you ought to do thank you Mr. Chair I'm wondering if not necessarily for representative Douglas but I'm wondering if Mr. Tice or someone from DNF&A
could talk and give us a little more background on this issue and about why it's currently done the way it is because I know there's a lot of freshmen on the committee and it might be beneficial if that's agreeable with the chair. Absolutely. Mr.
Leathers, you're not going to get out of here on our very last meeting of the session without
having one more question. Because this has come up, you know, this issue, we've worked on this ever since I
Speaker 41
10:45
was a freshman. Right. Mr. Chairman, Tim Leathers, Department of Finance, and administration. I told the chairman before we started, this has made me mad
several times over the years, and I've seen the bill up several times over the years. Well,
here's what you need to do, Tim. Then next time we do this, when Representative Douglas comes back around, make the fiscal
Speaker 41
11:06
impact a little bit less and we'll get this thing out. I wish we could do that. I understand, sir. In theory, the sales tax is based on total gross proceeds, and it's included any consideration from any source, and that's just generally the sales tax. So any kind of a rebate from the manufacturer.
We used to use bread as an example, or bread coupon back in the day, but bread doesn't have much tax left on it, but if you have a coupon then you pay the tax on the value of that manufacturer's coupon if you take it to the grocery store. So this is consistent within that. It's just on a big ticket item, you know, it hits and it's a large amount of money for a person to pay if you've got a $1,000 or $2,000 rebate. Folks don't like paying that tax when they really are paying on that bottom line,
but that's the way the sales tax has always been structured.
You good, Representative Meeks? Thank you, Mr. Leathers. Members, are there any other questions? Representative Douglas, I think my suggestion, you'd be just seeing Martha today. Just tell her you want to put this in interim study, and then we'll talk to the speaker about pushing it back towards revenue and tax. I think you have a good bill. If you run it on the 91st, I'd be honored to co-sponsor it again
Speaker 31
12:23
with you. Okay, and I appreciate that, and I have another one as well I'll talk to you about.
Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, committee. Thank you, ma'am. Members, this is our last meeting of the session. I just want to tell you guys I personally think that we've got the best makeup of any committee. and I know we've got several chairmen sitting here so without the risk of getting myself in trouble I think overall we have a very good committee and I appreciate you guys due diligence and I appreciate you guys coming bringing your A game every time we had a meeting so any discussion before we adjourn? Yes ma'am Representative Meeks speaks Thank you very much
Thank you very much and certainly want to thank our staff as well you guys have done good and DFA you guys are the best we appreciate you guys all right this meeting is adjourned
Agenda
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Joe Jett Chair
Unverified
Speaker 9
Speaker 16
Representative Laurie Rushing
Unverified
Representative Jim Dotson
Unverified
Speaker 31
Representative Charlie Collins
Unverified
Speaker 41