Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Judiciary Committee

March 30, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (3)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB761 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…passes as amended. Without objection, we're going to go to Senate Bill 761. Senator Hendren, you're recognized. We've been in contact…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB852 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…s for this session. Without objection, we're going to go to Senate Bill 852. I believe Representative Tucker is presenting that. Thank…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB886 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…Thank you, members. Without objection, we're going to go to Senate Bill 886. Senator King, you're recognized.”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
Unknown speaker 0:00
and hopefully wrap up our business for this session. Without objection, we're going to go to Senate Bill 852. I believe Representative Tucker is presenting that. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This bill addresses the sentencing structure for the state crime of abuse of the public trust. as we unfortunately know there have been a few instances in the last couple years where we had elected officials who were convicted essentially of bribery but if you recall all those sentences were federal sentences and we do have a crime on the book it's called abuse of public trust and it spells out a bunch of different circumstances under which a public official can be convicted of essentially bribery all of those circumstances lead to the same possible sentence of a class d felony. If you look at the crime of theft in Arkansas, you can be sentenced to a Class B felony if what you steal is worth $25,000 or more, a Class C felony if what you steal is value between $5,000 and $25,000, and a Class D felony if what you steal is worth less than $5,000. And so this bill essentially seeks to mirror the value of the theft statute. As it stands right now, A 19-year-old kid who steals a truck worth $26,000 can be sentenced to prison in 20 years, but a public official who accepts a bribe of $100,000 can only be sentenced to six years in prison. And so it just seeks to have those sentences correspond with each other. And so all it does is if a public official accepts a bribe of $25,000 or more, they can be sentenced to a Class B felony. If they accept a bribe between $5,000 and $25,000, they can be convicted of a Class C felony. and if the bribe is $5,000 or below, it's a class D felony. That's the gist of it. There's no opposition that I'm aware of. I'm the House sponsor on the bill. I'd be glad to take any questions. Okay, I don't see any questions. Representative Broadway, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Representative Tucker, for bringing this. I think it's a good bill. I did note there is not technically a definition of bribe. I mean, I think we know what that is. But does it have to be a tit for tat? Does there have to be some kind of traceable specific favor or opinion or anything like that that you tie the payment of the money to the action? Or, you know, we've seen situations in the last year or so where someone received a whole lot of money from just different sources to curry favor, but there was no specific vote or action that anything was tied to. So I'm wondering, will this take care of those types of situations? It doesn't change the substantive law at all. And so, I mean, the word bribery is not actually used in the statute, and so that's just, in my opinion, the best one-word summary of the circumstances outlined in the statute. I mean, you can take a look at it, but basically, you know, I'll just go through an example or two, but if you solicit, accept, or agree to accept on behalf of yourself or your party or whatever, and you accept a benefit in exchange for appointing someone to a particular public office, You know, that's an example, and it has four examples that you go through. So it does sort of require specific actions that you take in exchange for the benefit that you receive. Thank you very much. All right, I see no further questions. No one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Are you closed for the bill? Yes, Mr. Chairman. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Whitaker? Motion do pass. We have a motion do pass. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Thank you, members. Without objection, we're going to go to Senate Bill 886. Senator King, you're recognized. And I understand you have an amendment. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, members of the committee. I do have an amendment. It should read, if you look down at the draft, it should be 628. should be the number we had a little confusion about the right amendment this morning it's a four-page amendment the other one was a three-page amendment let's just crap what do you guys got a pen you got a pen i loaned you one this morning yeah i know that's all right Just throw that pencil down here and be fine. Thanks, man. I have a motion to adopt the amendment, and then we can talk about the bill. Representative Farrar moves adoption of the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Any opposed? The amendment's adopted. Senator, you're recognized to present the bill as amended. All right. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Mr. Committee. Cherry, did Rebecca had a handout that passed out. Can the Chairman's indulge it kind of explains where we're at today a little bit? While she's passing out, let me explain. Many of you members that I can tell in here have not been here, but maybe the attorneys can remember a few years ago when the ALJ fund basically went bankrupt. And that fund paid for case reporters, case coordinators for judges. Can I have one too, please? and so what happened was in Carroll County the uh or Chief Justice Hand at the time was trying to get judges out there to get make sure fines court costs restitution those things were collected because those things helped fund the LJ fund we had a issue come up in Carroll County that I learned that is an issue in in many of the counties around the state is that many of these counties when it comes to circuit court records are not automated it's not like district court where they are automated now I understand that circuit court and district court can be different but so we started working on some changes and one of the things that we came out of the issues of Carroll County was that we asked for a special audit up there we found that records were, there was several million dollars. We just went back two years. We found that people timed out on probation or parole without paying their fines or court costs or restitution. Most of this came from the fact that they were not automated. If you wanted to go in and a judge or any individual and find out that who owes money to the state for what, for things that were assessed by an issue from the judge, you would have to go in and pull each individual file to find out where they're at. Now, some of these counties that have written records could be keeping good records, but you'll typically find that the counties that are automated know who owes what and are keeping up with it. And remember, we as the General Assembly a few years ago had to shore up the ALJ fund with money from general revenue to help keep it afloat and make changes to it so basically through the work that we've done and I've tried to work with the courts and all the prosecutors are here there's been several issues this bill would basically make those counties that are not automated get automated now many of you if you understand this we run for office you go into county clerk's office and you can run a search or find out the registered voters in your district you can find out voting history you can find out who voted and Watt elections, and the reason you can do that is because it's all electronic. Now, many of these counties do not have their records automated, so this would require by next year that they go back to year 2000, and in some of these counties, they don't have the records available. I've had a circuit clerk contact me, and we amended this bill because of that reason that some of them don't have the records back. So if Joe Smith in 2002 committed a crime or owed a thousand dollars to the court system, there may not be a record exist of that. So what we did was we amended the bill to say back to 2000 or the records that are available. Now understand some of these counties when they got automated and they got out there and started collecting, guess what? Their collections went up. So, and as I said, these collections help fund the LJ fund, and that money that gets collected comes back to the counties. Now, understand that the counties that are not doing a good job are costing our state, and the counties that are doing a good job of collections is what we need. And we need to have these things automated up to district court. We have allowances to next year that they have to have 25% of the records automated at the first quarter of next year, and each quarter go up 25% to, I don't know, does anybody want to listen to that while we take a break? By next year, they have to be 100% automated. Now, the context system which was sold to us from the courts was about the goal of it was to get it automated. And as somebody down here, we've spent millions of dollars on this system to get to this point. And the reason we're not is because it's not mandatory. So with that, Mr. Chairman, I'll take any questions. What's the cost of this? Well, if a county is not automated, they are going to have to come up with the funds to automate. Okay. Do we know which counties are automated? I've tried to visit with several. The Association of Counties tried to get feedback. there is a number of counties that are not automated. Now, understand this. I understand about, you know, the possibility if you looked at a criticism or raised a question, is this unfunded mandate? Well, the reality is, as I've said earlier, if these counties will get automated, will get out there on collections, they'll get enough back to be able to pay for this. We're asking for even as simple as just putting this in an Excel spreadsheet so that if somebody asks for it or if, say, the ALJ fund, which is my understanding is struggling right now, okay, it's not flush with cash, that we are making sure these counties get their record-keeping in line, get it automated, start doing a better job collecting because it's just like if Joe Smith gets arrested and he pays back his $500 fine, court cost, or restitution, or whatever it is, and then you have Joe Simpson that doesn't pay anything and they both time out on probation or parole, where's the fairness in that? All simply because of record keeping. We also have the issue of probation and parole officers to be able to do their jobs have to depend on accurate records from this system. Now, in many of these counties you have maybe it's a circuit clerk that does collections and, you know, takes all the circuit clerks, and somebody can correct me if I'm wrong, take the issues from the judge and enter those into the system. But yet in many counties, the sheriff may be the collector or the prosecutor may be the collector or, you know, they may have somebody else do it. So it's kind of an array, but the goal of it, like I said, is to make sure that these counties get automated. All right. Any questions? No one has signed up to speak on the bill. Are you closed for the bill? Did he have a question? I don't know. Representative Broadway, you're recognized for a question. Really quick. I just want to commend you, Senator, for bringing this. I was at the committee meeting when this was brought to light, and I think it is a real issue. It's an important issue that needs to be addressed, And I just thank you for getting the incentive together to do something about it. And I think this is a very good bill. Can everybody give her a hand? I don't get committed on very many of my bills down here. I really appreciate that. Do you want a Senate citation, by the way? Can I? Anyone else? What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Copeland? As amended. Moves to pass as amended. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes as amended. Without objection, we're going to go to Senate Bill 761. Senator Hendren, you're recognized. We've been in contact with the speaker. It looks like we're going back in upstairs at 410, 415. Oh, well, that's eight minutes more than I'll need. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senate Bill 761 is, to be honest with you, a bill I didn't expect to get out of committee, but it did. It's a bill to, while it's not as aggressive as some of us would have liked to have seen, it has to do with our legal system and the fact that we have too many frivolous lawsuits. Now, as an engineer, I hesitate to come down here and start talking about legal reform. And if you start asking real hard legal questions, I'm just going to tell you I'm going to start making stuff up. But what I will tell you is fundamentally, as a businessman, I have experienced frivolous lawsuits and the cost that those incur when attorneys file a lawsuit knowing full well up front that there is no basis for claim and that they also realize that my insurance company, without my permission, will settle with them because it's cheaper to settle with them than it is to litigate the case. And then they'll come back and raise my rates up. And you just have to experience that a few times in business to start asking the question, when is somebody going to do something that holds people accountable when they basically use the legal system for extortion. So I think what this bill does is put in place a step in the right direction. It's not a big step, but it's a step. And the reason I say it's not a big step is because it's capped at $10,000. So the most liability that someone would face in a situation where their case is dismissed because of lack of basis or claim or rule 12 is a $10,000 obligation to pay for court fees and costs and attorney fees and so on that goes along with it. The intent is to discourage frivolous lawsuits and harassment lawsuits or whatever you want to cover them. So this bill basically says that when a suit is dismissed under Rule 12b-6 motions for failure to state a claim, then they could be liable for up to $10,000. It has seven different exceptions. For instance, If you're suing governmental entities or public officials, if you're 60 days after the latest complaint, a whole bunch of other ones that good faith, non-fulbless for the purpose of extending or modifying precedents or regulations or laws, basically you're challenging state law or federal law. Anytime the law changes between the time you filed the lawsuit so that now it's dismissed on those grounds, multiple defendants after the formal discovery process begins. So there's lots of exceptions to make sure that lawsuits that are dismissed for good reason or filed that may be considered to be dismissed under this legislation won't be subject to that $10,000 potential penalty. So, again, the idea there is there's been several arguments against this on the other end that I don't see the merit in. some saying it will cause more lawsuits, and it's, I don't know, the logic to me doesn't make a lot of sense that attorneys are worried that we're passing legislation that's going to cause more lawsuits. I think the opposite will happen is that people will, I view this a lot like the property rights legislation that we just sent through. The purpose of this is to make people think before they do something that could cause cost to another party, whether it be a government entity or whether it be a private attorney. So what this says is the attorneys and the parties would have to think about the potential liability they might have if they know they're taking to court a case that has no merit. I think that's fair. I think it's, this doesn't, let me just say with regard to tort reform or legal reform or whatever you want to do, this bill helps the small people. This bill, this bill helps small businesses. It doesn't have punity caps. It doesn't have non-economic damages. This isn't going to help megacorporations who are worried about $20 million judgments. This is going to help the small businesses that are plagued with harassment lawsuits. I think it's a piece of legislation that we need, and I'd appreciate a good vote. Representative Broadway, you're recognized for a question. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair, and thank you, Senator Hendren. I do have some questions for you with regard to this, because actually the way I read this bill, you are basically forcing the judges and taking discretion away from the judges about awarding attorney's fees and certain types of suits. And have you discussed this with the judicial counselor, any judges? I haven't discussed it with judges. I've discussed it with lots of attorneys, and I have lots of attorneys in my family who I've discussed it with. Well, my question was judges. Thank you. I don't mean to cut you off, but that's where I'm going with this. Well, one of my families is a federal judge, and I have discussed it with him. And I guess my response to that would be this, is I think we sell judges short when we make the assumption that because of the fact that an attorney may have to pay some costs or a party may have to be liable for some costs, they're going to change their basis for dismissal. I don't think judges – I do think there's a real possibility that judges would call the parties in and say, you all probably ought to work this out because you may not like the outcome that's getting ready to come, and there may be some liability. So, no, I give judges more credit than to think that they are going to force court cases to go to jury because of a fear of dismissing because of this bill. Would it surprise you to hear that I have heard from several judges that are opposed to your bill because of the exact concerns that you've set forth? No, it wouldn't surprise me at all. It wouldn't surprise you. It wouldn't surprise me if I filed a bill like this and we didn't hear from a whole bunch of judges and attorneys. And also, just something that you said really shocked me, and it doesn't have to do so much with the judges, but you indicated that your insurance company actually have settled lawsuits on your behalf without your permission? That's exactly right. Well, I think that you have a real legitimate basis to sue your insurance company if they're doing that, Because they clearly are not supposed to do that in a violation of their duty to you. Well, I'll just tell you, I'm not alone in that. In the business community, it's common practice, and they'll settle that, and they'll send you a notification that we settled it, and here's why. I find that shocking, but I believe you. Thank you. Okay, I've got a couple more questions. We're about to have to shut this thing down, so Representative Tosche, you're recognized for a question. I'll make it quick, Mr. Chair. I know our judicial system is backlogged with cases, and I see this, and you correct me if I'm wrong, as an effort also to help relieve our system of that backlog and to keep it moving at a faster pace. Absolutely. The intent of this legislation is so less lawsuits will be filed and may be settled quicker. All right. That's all the questions from the committee. We do have a couple signed up. is there anybody I understood there were going to be some signed up to speak at the Bar Association ok alright well we've got just one Andrew Parker Randy Zook State Chamber are they here alright take a seat at the end of the table state your name who you represent and you may offer your testimony thank you Mr. Chairman Randy Zook with the Arkansas State Chamber of Commerce and I'm here simply to Amen, what Senator Hendren has had to say about the bill. I think this is a very modest step to discourage frivolous lawsuits and would be a very modest step toward meaningful civil justice reform in Arkansas that would result in improvement in the business climate and the attractiveness of the state of Arkansas. And we need everything we can get at this point to make Arkansas as attractive as possible as competitive as possible. We are often in conflict or competition with the state of Texas for industrial locations and expansions, and this is one of the primary areas where we get dinged by folks considering investment in Arkansas. So I would urge you to support the bill and appreciate any support. All right. See, no questions, and actually that's everybody that signed up to speak on the bill. Are you closed for your bill, Senator? What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Tosh moves due pass. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. When will the ayes have it? Pass the bill. One hand. Two hands. We'll call the roll. Go down from the bottom. Go from the bottom. Don't call me and I'll tell you. Yes. Yes. Representative Talley? No. Representative Broadway? No. Representative Farr? Yes. Representative Bain? No. Representative Whitaker? No. Representative Ballinger? Yes. Representative Armstrong? No. Representative Scott? Yes. Representative House? No. Representative Vines? No. The bill does not pass. We're adjourned. There will be the possibility of an additional meeting on the call of the chair.
▶ Play

Agenda

SB852

0:17 - 4:32 8 segments

SB886

4:32 - 14:36 18 segments

SB761

14:36 - 24:18 18 segments

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers