Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Meeting

January 24, 2017 ·House ·1:05:06
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (44)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HR1008 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HR1008 Wardlaw HONORING THE FORESTRY JUDGING TEAM OF THE HERMITAGE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HR1009 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “House Resolution 1009 by Representative Bragg to recognize and celebrate Forestry…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1161 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Bill 1161. House Bill 1161, by Representative Sabin, to create the Working Families Op…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1001 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…asure from the regular session of the 91st General Assembly House Bill 1001 is Act 3. House Bill 1026 is Act 4. House Bill 1158 is Act…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1016 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ker, we are committee on public health to whom was referred House Bill 1016, House Bill 1185, House Bill or Senate Bill 39, Senate Bill…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1030 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…peaker, we are committing on education to whom was referred House Bill 1030 and Senate Bill 10. beg lead to report that we've had the s…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1035 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ker, we are committee on public health to whom was referred House Bill 1035. Begley to report that we've had the same under considerati…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1067 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…aker, we are committee on joint budget to whom was referred House Bill 1067, House House Bill 1068, House Bill 1074, House Bill 1079, H…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1068 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…on joint budget to whom was referred House Bill 1067, House House Bill 1068, House Bill 1074, House Bill 1079, House Bill 1080, House B…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1074 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…o whom was referred House Bill 1067, House House Bill 1068, House Bill 1074, House Bill 1079, House Bill 1080, House Bill 1081, House”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1079 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ed House Bill 1067, House House Bill 1068, House Bill 1074, House Bill 1079, House Bill 1080, House Bill 1081, House”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1080 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…7, House House Bill 1068, House Bill 1074, House Bill 1079, House Bill 1080, House Bill 1081, House”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1081 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ll 1068, House Bill 1074, House Bill 1079, House Bill 1080, House Bill 1081, House”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1084 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Bill 1083, House Bill 1084, House Bill 1108, House Bill 1114, House Bill 1118, House B…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1108 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Bill 1083, House Bill 1084, House Bill 1108, House Bill 1114, House Bill 1118, House Bill 1121, House B…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1114 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Bill 1083, House Bill 1084, House Bill 1108, House Bill 1114, House Bill 1118, House Bill 1121, House Bill 1123, House B…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1118 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ll 1083, House Bill 1084, House Bill 1108, House Bill 1114, House Bill 1118, House Bill 1121, House Bill 1123, House Bill 1125, House B…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1121 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ll 1084, House Bill 1108, House Bill 1114, House Bill 1118, House Bill 1121, House Bill 1123, House Bill 1125, House Bill 1127, House B…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1123 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ll 1108, House Bill 1114, House Bill 1118, House Bill 1121, House Bill 1123, House Bill 1125, House Bill 1127, House Bill 1128, House B…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1125 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ll 1114, House Bill 1118, House Bill 1121, House Bill 1123, House Bill 1125, House Bill 1127, House Bill 1128, House Bill 1130, House B…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1127 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ll 1118, House Bill 1121, House Bill 1123, House Bill 1125, House Bill 1127, House Bill 1128, House Bill 1130, House Bill 1131, House B…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1128 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ll 1121, House Bill 1123, House Bill 1125, House Bill 1127, House Bill 1128, House Bill 1130, House Bill 1131, House Bill 1133, House B…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1130 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ll 1123, House Bill 1125, House Bill 1127, House Bill 1128, House Bill 1130, House Bill 1131, House Bill 1133, House Bill 1134, House B…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1131 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ll 1125, House Bill 1127, House Bill 1128, House Bill 1130, House Bill 1131, House Bill 1133, House Bill 1134, House Bill 1135, House B…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1133 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ll 1127, House Bill 1128, House Bill 1130, House Bill 1131, House Bill 1133, House Bill 1134, House Bill 1135, House Bill 1140, House B…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1134 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ll 1128, House Bill 1130, House Bill 1131, House Bill 1133, House Bill 1134, House Bill 1135, House Bill 1140, House Bill 1170, House B…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1135 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ll 1130, House Bill 1131, House Bill 1133, House Bill 1134, House Bill 1135, House Bill 1140, House Bill 1170, House Bill 1189, House B…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1140 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ll 1131, House Bill 1133, House Bill 1134, House Bill 1135, House Bill 1140, House Bill 1170, House Bill 1189, House Bill 1196, and Hou…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1147 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “committing on public transportation to whom was referred House Bill 1147. I beg to lead to report that we have had the same under co…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1164 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1164 M. Gray TO AUTHORIZE LICENSURE BY ENDORSEMENT FOR OPTOMETRI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1170 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ll 1133, House Bill 1134, House Bill 1135, House Bill 1140, House Bill 1170, House Bill 1189, House Bill 1196, and House Bill 1210. I b…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1172 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…on we are house committee on judiciary to whom was referred house bill 1172 house bill 1174 house bill 1176 house bill 1201 and house b…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1174 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…committee on judiciary to whom was referred house bill 1172 house bill 1174 house bill 1176 house bill 1201 and house bill 1202 beg lea…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1176 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…iciary to whom was referred house bill 1172 house bill 1174 house bill 1176 house bill 1201 and house bill 1202 beg lead to report that…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1185 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ttee on public health to whom was referred House Bill 1016, House Bill 1185, House Bill or Senate Bill 39, Senate Bill 111. Begley to r…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1189 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ll 1134, House Bill 1135, House Bill 1140, House Bill 1170, House Bill 1189, House Bill 1196, and House Bill 1210. I beg to lead to rep…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1196 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ll 1135, House Bill 1140, House Bill 1170, House Bill 1189, House Bill 1196, and House Bill 1210. I beg to lead to report that we have…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1201 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…as referred house bill 1172 house bill 1174 house bill 1176 house bill 1201 and house bill 1202 beg lead to report that we've had the s…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1202 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ll 1172 house bill 1174 house bill 1176 house bill 1201 and house bill 1202 beg lead to report that we've had the same under considerat…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1209 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…Speaker we are committee on education to whom was referred house bill 1209 beg lead to report that we've had the”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1210 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…140, House Bill 1170, House Bill 1189, House Bill 1196, and House Bill 1210. I beg to lead to report that we have had the same under co…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB10 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…tting on education to whom was referred House Bill 1030 and Senate Bill 10. beg lead to report that we've had the same under considera…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB111 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…e Bill 1016, House Bill 1185, House Bill or Senate Bill 39, Senate Bill 111. Begley to report that we've”
Pre-2017 bill
SB39 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…as referred House Bill 1016, House Bill 1185, House Bill or Senate Bill 39, Senate Bill 111. Begley to report that we've”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
Unknown speaker 0:00
I Thank you. Thank you. Oh
▶ Play
House will come to order. I invite the members, staff, press, and guests in the galleries to stand and be led in prayer by House Chaplain Reverend Tim Knoll from the Trinity Baptist Church in Searcy and to remain standing for the Pledge of Allegiance to be led by Representative Greg
▶ Play
Speaker 8 2:26
Letting. Good afternoon. It's funny. just in the back a little bit ago said whenever you share scripture I'd like for you to maybe think about Proverbs and God had already laid that on my heart today so that's pretty cool let's pray, Father we love you and God in Proverbs chapter 29 it says where there is no vision the people will perish and so God I pray that today you give this body, this house a unified vision together looking for the absolute best way to serve you and to serve the citizens of this great state. Father, we know ultimately the greatest vision that we can have is to point people towards you. But Father, also have our eyes on you, trusting you, allowing you to lead us. Because if we do that, God, we will not fail and we will not perish. God, we thank you for the promise of your word. We thank you for Jesus. and I thank you for representatives who love you and who know your word. God, we ask all these things in Jesus' name. Amen. Amen. Amen.
▶ Play
Speaker 9 3:35
I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which we stand, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of
▶ Play
America and to the republic for which we stand, indicate your presence by pushing your yellow present button. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 4:25
cast out the ballot mr. clerk
▶ Play
With 100 members present, let's see a quorum. Representative Lane Jean moves we dispense with the reading of the previous day's journal. No objection, so ordered. Are there any reports from select committees? Read the reports, Mr. Clerk. Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker, we are committee on joint budget to whom was referred House Bill 1067, House House Bill 1068, House Bill 1074, House Bill 1079, House Bill 1080, House Bill 1081, House Bill 1083, House Bill 1084, House Bill 1108, House Bill 1114, House Bill 1118, House Bill 1121, House Bill 1123, House Bill 1125, House Bill 1127, House Bill 1128, House Bill 1130, House Bill 1131, House Bill 1133, House Bill 1134, House Bill 1135, House Bill 1140, House Bill 1170, House Bill 1189, House Bill 1196, and House Bill 1210. I beg to lead to report that we have had the same under consideration and hear with the terms the same with the recommendation they do pass. Respectfully submitted, Lane Jean, Chair.
▶ Play
Are there any reports from standing committees? Read the reports, Mr. Clerk. Mr. Speaker, we are
▶ Play
committing on public transportation to whom was referred House Bill 1147. I beg to lead to report that we have had the same under consideration and hear with the term the same with the recommendation they do pass. Respectfully submitted, Mike Holcomb, Chair. Mr. Speaker, we are committing on education to whom was referred House Bill 1030 and Senate Bill 10. beg lead to report that we've had the same under consideration and here with the turn the same with the recommendation that do pass respectfully submitted Bruce Cozart chair Mr. Speaker we are committee on education to whom was referred house bill 1209 beg lead to report that we've had the same under consideration and here with the turn the same with the recommendation that do pass as amended number one respectfully submitted Bruce Cozart chair Mr. Speaker we are house on we are house committee on judiciary to whom was referred house bill 1172 house bill 1174 house bill 1176 house bill 1201 and house bill 1202 beg lead to report that we've had the same under consideration here with a term the same with the recognition that do pass. Respectfully submitted, Matthew Shepard, Chair. Mr. Speaker, we are committee on public health to whom was referred House Bill 1016, House Bill 1185, House Bill or Senate Bill 39, Senate Bill 111. Begley to report that we've had the same under consideration here with the term the same with the recognition that do pass. Respectfully submitted, Deborah Ferguson, Vice Chair. Mr. Speaker, we are committee on public health to whom was referred House Bill 1035. Begley to report that we've had the same under consideration here with the term the same with the recognition that do pass as amended number three. respectfully submitted Deborah Ferguson
▶ Play
vice chair is there any unfinished business are there any executive communications mr. clerk read the letter from the governor
▶ Play
January 24th 2017 to the speaker of the house dear mr. speaker this is to inform you that on January 24th 2017 I approved the following measure from the regular session of the 91st General Assembly House Bill 1001 is Act 3. House Bill 1026 is Act 4. House Bill 1158 is Act 5. Sincerely,
▶ Play
Asa Hutchinson. Mr. Clerk, read House Resolution 1008. House
▶ Play
Resolution 1008 by Representative Wardlaw, honoring the forestry judging team of the Hermitage Chapter of the Future Farmers of America.
▶ Play
Representative Wardlaw, you are recognized to explain your resolution. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Speaker. My fellow House members, I want to tell you all, I've never made it to this well to congratulate a team of any kind. And I want to tell you how much I am in honor today because I don't just get to congratulate a state champion. and I get to congratulate two, three national champions right up here to my left today. These guys traveled and won the 4-H National Forestry Contest, and then they traveled to the FFA Contest and won it too. And it takes a lot of studying, a lot of hours, a lot of good coaching from Mr. Taylor Gwynn and the 4-H extension agent, Michelle Carter. to put in a lot of hours with these kids to get them to this. So if you guys could help me give them a warm welcome to the house and the congratulations on that. And Mr. Speaker, with your permission, can we have the clerk read the entire resolution? Mr. Clerk, read the resolution.
▶ Play
issues and team collaboration, and whereas teams compete at the district and state level for the privilege of representing local FFA chapters at the national level, and whereas the team also won the Arkansas 4-H title and the 2016 4-H Invitational National title in Weston, West Virginia on August 4, 2016, which was the first for any team for the state. And whereas the team consists of Ethan Boykin, Hunter Sanders, Cade Wilkerson, and Connor Wilkerson has been coached by Taylor Gwynn and Joe Don Greenwood, current and former agriculture education teachers at Hermitage High School respectively. Now therefore be it resolved by the House of Representatives of the 91st General Assembly of the state of Arkansas that the House of Representatives commends the forestry judging team of the Hermitage Chapter of the Future Farmers of America for its hard work and accomplishments. Be it further resolved that upon the adoption of this resolution an appropriate copy shall be provided to the forestry judging team of the Hermitage Chapter of the Future Farmers of America by the Chief Clerk of the
▶ Play
House of representatives representative Wardlaw indicates he is closed for his resolution would anyone like to speak against the resolution for the resolution the question before the house is the passage of HR 1008 prepare all those in favor say aye any opposed The ayes have it. The resolution has been adopted. Mr. Clerk, Reed House, Resolution 1009.
▶ Play
House Resolution 1009 by Representative Bragg to recognize and celebrate Forestry Day, sponsored by the Arkansas Forestry Association at the state capitol on January 24th, 2017. Representative Bragg, you're recognized
▶ Play
to explain your resolution. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
▶ Play
In keeping with the theme for the day, today is Forestry Day at the capitol, and hopefully we'll have some future foresters out of that group someday. I can highly recommend it as a profession. If you've gone through the rotunda, you've seen some displays and exhibits of our forest industry and today we are recognizing the forest industry in arkansas for their contribution not only to the economic development but also the protection of our environment and i can stand here and say that the forests in arkansas are very healthy we are growing more fiber than we're harvesting and since the early since the 70s we have added over a million acres of forest land to the forest land base. So we're extremely grateful for the value that the forest industry has given. Before we read the resolution, I'd like to recognize some of the representatives from the Arkansas Forestry Association and the forest industry in general up in our gallery. Please welcome them. And Mr. Speaker, at this time, I'd ask you to have the clerk read the resolution.
▶ Play
Mr. Clerk, read the resolution. Whereas since 1947, the Arkansas Forestry Association has served as the voice of forestry for the state's entire forestry community, and whereas forests provide more than 5,000 products we depend on every day, and whereas the state's abundant forest resources have provided important economic and environmental benefits to our state and nation since the 1880s, and whereas the state's four-led lands on the diverse in their makeup with 6.1 million acres of softwoods, 1.9 million acres of oak and pine, 6.7 million acres of upland hardwoods, and 2.75 million acres of bottomland hardwoods, and 154,000 acres of non-stocked acres, and whereas forestry's added value annual contribution to the state's economy is $6.3 billion, and whereas the forest products industry supports 28,057 direct jobs and 41,755 indirect jobs, and whereas Arkansas families depend on the $1.46 billion in direct wages provided by the Arkansas products industry, and whereas the state's average annual compensation for the forest products industry is $38,849 per employee, and whereas every job created by the forestry industry in the state, two and a half additional jobs are created indirectly, and whereas timber harvesters and forest landowners follow voluntary best management practices that protect soil and water quality and whereas the state's forests provide unparalleled scenic beauty and whereas the forests in Arkansas support habitat for more than 600 species of fish and wildlife and whereas the state's forest landowners manage their land to protect and enhance habitat for threatened and endangered species therefore be it resolved by the House of Representatives of the 91st General Assembly of the State of Arkansas that the House of Representatives recognize and celebrates Forestry Day, sponsored by the Arkansas Forestry Association, at the State Capitol Building on January 24, 2017. Be it further resolved, upon its adoption, a copy of this resolution shall be presented to the President of the Arkansas Forestry Association by the Chief Clerk
▶ Play
of the House of Representatives. Representative Bragg has explained his resolution, but any would like to speak against the resolution. For the resolution, Representative Bragg indicates he is closed for his resolution. The question before the House is the passage of House Resolution 1009. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The ayes have it. Resolution has been adopted. We have a couple of special guests in the gallery. We have a Ms. Nina Boo from the University of Arkansas-Fort Smith, a Mr. Keith Lux with Ameriprise International. Representative Pitch is currently mentoring both of these. Please welcome them to the chamber. Representative Davis, for what purpose? Personal
▶ Play
Speaker 39 16:42
point of privilege, please. You're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, occasionally we get a little too busy and we miss an opportunity to recognize one of our constituents in a manner that we should. But that was the case this summer when I missed the Eagle Scout court of honor for Mr. Eli Driscoll. I promised his dad that if he would hang in there with me for a couple months and come join us in session one day, we'd make a big deal about it. So if you'll allow me just a second to address Mr. Driscoll, Eli, I want to tell you that we're real proud of you. I want to tell you that when we think about an Eagle Scout, we think of somebody that's disciplined, somebody that's used to hard work, somebody that knows how to set goals and achieve them. Those are all traits that we should all strive to have in building ourselves. And we just want to thank you very much for your hard work in that. Now, Mr. Driscoll, your dad, I also want to recognize him. Members always like to recognize the parents of Eagle Scouts because they've invested countless hours and time and treasure in raising these young people to be future leaders of our state and our country. So, Mr. Driscoll, I want to also thank you very much. And with that, members, if you would, would you please join me in giving Eli Driscoll a hearty congratulations. All right, thank you, members. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative Blake, for what purpose?
▶ Play
Point of personal privilege. You're recognized for point of personal
▶ Play
privilege. I'm here again. I hate losing. I'm a Little Rock Central Tiger, so you know I hate losing. But here we are. I know a lot of you have never seen this trophy. There's actually been no need to present the trophy to ourselves for three years, so that there hasn't been no presentation. But this is the Speaker's Cup for everyone that's never seen it before. It's the Speaker's Cup, and it's a golf match that happens between the Democrats and Republicans. And as you see, in 2013, the Democrats won. In 2014, the Democrats won. In 2015, the Democrats won. But we all know that 2016 was an unprecedented year. The Senate somehow won the basketball game, we have a new president, and the Republicans finally won a golf tournament. Now, we all are actually really, really happy for Representative Lowry. actually had to, he finally changed the rules enough so they could finally win, and he didn't even need a House resolution to do it. So he's not in here. But this presentation is the Speaker's Cup, and it's finally get a chance to present it to Representative Lowry and the House Republicans. You can give them a hand. Oh,
▶ Play
Speaker 49 21:02
don't go anywhere yet. Don't go anywhere yet. I told him that if he's going to roast me, he needs to be ready for some rejoinder. You have notes? Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. You went really. But, you know, I think you shouldn't be the only one up here bearing the brunt of being on the losing team because it is a team. So why don't you invite your team members up here to share in your sorrow. And I will invite my winning team up to accept this trophy along with me. I
▶ Play
don't know if enough of us survived the elections.
▶ Play
Speaker 49 21:45
Well, come on, Republican team, you guys want to come up here and take your bows because, you know, as Representative Blake pointed out, it did take us a fourth time. For those of you who have been in the legislature with me, you understand that I am the master of reconsideration. And so we had a reconsideration motion for us to win. We didn't change any rules. are continuing today the forestry theme because the Democrats were in the trees most of the day. That's why we were able to win. Majority Leader, I just wanted to give you one little piece of advice. I know you've been very effective in being able to effectuate party switches, but we picked up on the golf course that the Democratic team, you know, the Democrats wear blue and the Republicans wear red, I heard several of the Democrats say, you know, I'm getting tired of having blue shirts in my closet. I'm ready for a red shirt. So there you are. You can go to the golfers and tell them that they can wear a red shirt. So anyway, we are very excited to have this and we will be defending our championship this year. Oh no,
▶ Play
you don't get a rebuttal. Before we leave, I just know that Representative Lowry actually have, in the last couple years, have played a head-to-head match. Representative Lowry, who won that match? You talking about the match last year?
▶ Play
Speaker 49 23:22
The year before last? Okay, you won. Which we found out who the real country club set is. It's the Democrats. Representative Gonzalez, for what purpose? Well, I had a question, but it looks like they stepped out
▶ Play
of the way. you recognize for a question yes sir would you say it may have taken
▶ Play
Speaker 61 23:41
the republicans a while to win because you don't have as much time to practice without what i'm sorry what's that i
▶ Play
don't i don't know representative rushing for what purpose question you recognize for a question
▶ Play
would you like to say that maybe you had some girl power on your team this time and you know last time the girl power even when we lost in 2015 girl power still
▶ Play
Speaker 49 24:08
got you all your four points. Absolutely. I think Representative Rushing is probably just about the only undefeated member of either one of the teams. She's won all of her matches, and so we're so excited to have her. But anyway, this, what's that? Okay. Any other comments from the winners? No? Okay. Join us this year as we're putting the teams up. You know, the Democrats, we'll try and help you field a full team. Don't know how we're going to do that, but we're sure not letting you bring back any ringers
▶ Play
like you have in years past. Morning hour is over. Mr. Clerk, read House
▶ Play
Bill 1161. House Bill 1161, by Representative Sabin, to create the Working Families Opportunity
▶ Play
Act. Representative Sabin, you're recognized to explain
▶ Play
the bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, today I feel a little bit like the lamb that's being led to slaughter, but I'm really actually very grateful for this opportunity to be able to discuss this legislation, and I want to express my appreciation also to the House Revenue and Tax Committee for giving it a due pass. And, you know, I want to begin by saying that, you know, I definitely don't relish the fact that this bill is put up in opposition to what the governor proposed and what we passed yesterday, but I want to make sure that you understand the context of the bill and why and when it was introduced. I actually brought this legislation two years ago in the 2015 session, and even at that time it had bipartisan co-sponsors. It was sponsored by the chairs of the House and Senate Revenue and Tax Committees, and that occurs again today with this bill as well.
▶ Play
Speaker 75 26:14
and you know as we look for excuse me
▶ Play
sorry the reason why we brought this bill initially was because in 2013 you know we offered a tax break to the wealthiest Arkansans those who benefited from the cut we did to capital gains and And then, of course, two years ago, we came back again and we offered a tax break to the middle class. And really, the only Arkansans that were left out of the tax cuts that we've offered have been the working poor, those low-income, working Arkansans. And so to the extent that the governor's tax cut addresses that group, you know, of course, you know, we're supportive of it. But the policy you have in front of you, the earned income tax credit, really is a more effective policy. And the first reason why is because it's more targeted. The governor's tax cut, because it's a cut to the marginal rate, it actually affects more than just the tax brackets at the lower income levels. And, in fact, if you take a look at who's actually going to benefit from the tax cut, it's more than just those who make less than $21,000. In fact, a greater proportion of the tax cut will benefit those who make greater than that. Whereas the Earned Income Tax Credit, the Working Families Opportunity Act, actually is a very, very targeted policy. And I'm going to get kind of into the history of it. But it's a policy that was started really under President Gerald Ford. It was expanded under President Ronald Reagan. It was Ronald Reagan's favorite anti-poverty program. And in fact, as Representative Collins pointed out in our committee meeting, it was actually originated with a conservative economist, Milton Friedman, who called it a negative income tax. And the idea behind it really was to incentivize work. And I think that's one of the most important things about the proposal that you have in front of you. Whereas, you know, we're not just cutting a tax rate that is only going to benefit, you know, a small group of people. We're actually, you know, going to incentivize work with this proposal. And because this proposal is more targeted to the low-income working Arkansans that it's designed to benefit, it's actually more efficient. And if you've looked at the fiscal impact, this bill actually has a $40 million fiscal impact as opposed to the $50 million fiscal impact in the legislation that we passed yesterday. So that's a $10 million difference. And as we're considering the fact that we're going to have to come back with offsets and basically raise taxes on low-income working Arkansans, either through a tax on manufactured homes or a tax on unemployment benefits, this actually gives us the opportunity to avoid those tax increases that are coming. We can save $10 million. We can avoid raising taxes on the very people that we're trying to benefit. But the third reason why this is more effective than the governor's policy is because it's a proven policy. As I mentioned, it's been in place at the federal level for several decades. And because it's been there, it's been studied, and we know that it works. And in fact, 26 states now across the country have enacted their own version of the Earned Income Tax Credit. And those that have enacted it have actually tried to increase the amount of that credit because it's been so effective. And what I'd like to do really quickly right now is just read to you a few things from a couple of nonpartisan policy institutes that really underscore how effective this policy has been in, number one, incentivizing people to work. Number two, in stimulating the economy. Number three, in reducing benefits, sorry, reducing dependence on social services. And number four, moving people out of poverty, which ultimately is really, ought to be our goal because one reason why we need to target this kind of tax relief to low-income working Arkansans is because nobody should have to work one job or even two jobs and still be in poverty. I think we all agree about that. And, you know, people have to make really hard choices sometimes about, you know, what they're going to do. If you're a single mother with two kids and you're wondering, how am I going to have a job, but still be able to afford child care, for instance. A lot of people will make that decision to accept social services rather than move into the workforce. but a policy like this actually helps people overcome that hump and get the income that they can earn through a job that allows them to afford the necessities of life that many of us take for granted. But just a quote from the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, they say that research indicates that families mostly use the EITC to pay for necessities, repair homes, maintain vehicles that are needed to commute to work and in some cases obtain additional education or training to boost their employability and earning power. They go on to say the EITC is designed to encourage and reward work. As noted, a worker's EITC grows with each additional dollar of earnings until reaching the maximum value. This creates an incentive for people to leave welfare for work and for low-wage workers to increase their work hours. This incentive feature has made the EITC highly successful. Studies show that the EITC encourages large numbers of single parents to leave welfare for work, especially when the labor market is strong. And specifically, a highly regarded study found that EITC expansions are the most important reason why employment rose among single mothers with children during the 1990s. The EITC was more effective in encouraging work than either welfare reform or the strong economy. And in 2015, the EITC lifted about 6.5 million people out of poverty, including about 3.3 million children. The number of poor children would have been more than one quarter higher without the EITC. And the credit reduced the severity of poverty for another 21.2 million people, including 7.7 million children. And the last place I'm going to quote from just very briefly is the Tax Policy Center. They said that research shows that the EITC encourages single people and primary earners in married couples to work. If the EITC were treated like earnings, it would have been the single most effective anti-poverty program for working-age people, lifting about 6.5 million people out of poverty, including 3.3 million children. So if we're just kind of reviewing and comparing apples to apples, we know that the EITC has several decades of a track record in targeting tax relief to low-income working people. And that's exactly what I think we're all agreed upon doing with this round of tax cuts that we're considering right now before the legislature. We know that one proposal is $50 million and the other is $40 million. And in addition to targeting the relief, we have a proven track record. We also have support from Entergy Corporation, which testified on behalf of the bill, Southern Bancorp, which is one of the largest development banks in the country, based here in Arkansas, the March of Dimes, and others who are very familiar with this policy. And I just kind of want to say one more thing about the process before I take some questions about the bill. You know, obviously the governor has a lot of influence over all of us in terms of his direction about the budget in particular and policies. And I absolutely 100% respect that and I think it's important for us to hear what he has to say. But I also think it's really important for the legislature to have the opportunity to present its own ideas. He gets to be governor every day for four years straight. We get to come here once every two years with a very limited window to propose policies that we think are just as worthy of consideration. And, you know, if you remember your old civics lessons, it's the legislature that makes the laws, and the governor that enacts the laws. And I think that's an important thing for all of us to consider, because the legislature is the closest body to the people, and that's why the system is designed that way. And so I think as much as I, you know, obviously don't enjoy having, you know, this bill kind of put in opposition to what the the governor has proposed. I do enjoy a good policy discussion. I think it's important for us to bring our ideas and to have them considered at the same level. And with that, I would take any questions that you may have.
▶ Play
Representative Meeks, for what purpose? Question and a follow-up, Mr. Speaker. You're recognized for a question first. Okay. I have two questions. I'll fire the first one and then we'll see if I get permission for round two. Looking at the fiscal impact from DF&A, they state one of their concerns, and it's a concern I share, is that currently about 25 percent of the federal earned income tax credit is paid to people who don't earn it. In other words, there's about 25 percent fraud within the system. If the same thing were to occur under the current bill with the current estimates, that would bring it up to $50 million. So in your mind, how would we prevent people from taking advantage of the system and prevent that fraud that is on the federal level from draining our system? Sure. Well, I think
▶ Play
that the fraud numbers are ones that are often mentioned by opponents to this policy. But there are a lot of studies to show that those fraud numbers are oftentimes very much exaggerated. And I did bring several sort of responses to that. I'll read two of them to you. And again, this does come from CBPP, which I quoted from earlier. They said many times fraud isn't really fraud. 40% of EITC claims that were found to have had errors during audits end up being cleared when they were investigated by the Taxpayer Assistance Service, which is a division of the IRS. And then it also says that, for context, the EITC error rate is much lower than many other error rates. This includes errors in business reported income. The IRS found that 56% of business income was unreported in 2006, which is about 10 times higher than EITC overpayments that year. So, you know, I think that there's a question about the numbers. Certainly, we need to try to minimize fraud, and it's a very important issue but it may not be as big of an issue as people you know really make it out to be and it's one that clearly you know is the job of in our case DFNA and at the federal level of the IRS to root out follow up you
▶ Play
recognize for a follow-up thank you the other question that I had and this this may be a bigger concern for me is in the legal analysis it talks about this credit may actually create a subsidy whereas with the governor's tax plan we're cutting everyone's liabilities, if you will. But in this situation, we may actually be creating a subsidy. In other words, the taxpayer would be getting more than what they paid in. So in essence, what's going on is we're taking tax dollars from one citizen and paying them to another citizen. And that, to me, is also an issue. So if you would please address that. And
▶ Play
again, that's also a fair enough argument that's made. I mean, it's a tax credit like any other tax credit that many of us get to claim in our taxes, you know, in all kinds of different scenarios. And, you know, it's very much sort of akin to getting a tax refund often, where, you know, your tax liability is determined, you know, by the laws that exist, and sometimes when you file your personal income taxes, you get a refund, sometimes you have to pay out to the government, and it really just all depends on how the formula worked out for you that year and what you actually took in net taxable income versus gross, and so, you know, I don't see it people getting back money from other people. The formula has been designed by some very smart economists over many decades to be very efficient in trying to reward work, that it's based on earned income. And it takes into account also the fact that people at those low income levels pay a disproportionate amount of their income in regressive taxes like sales taxes and gas taxes and things that don't really get counted when you're talking about your federal or state income tax liability. So when you just cut the marginal tax rate, like we are doing in the bill that we passed yesterday, you're giving a very small marginal benefit to people who are trying to do the right thing by working to pull themselves out of poverty. And in some cases, you're actually incentivizing them not to work, as opposed to going with a formula that Milton Friedman and Gerald Ford and Ronald Reagan and people on both sides of the aisle have really found to be effective in making sure that people are incentivized to work, and that they're not really getting anything for free, and they're not getting more than they deserve. They're getting enough to pull themselves out of poverty, and then eventually get off the kind of social services that truly do cost everybody money, the kind of money that you're talking about when you talk about the redistribution
▶ Play
of wealth. Representative Sullivan, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. I support the principles that you're behind. I appreciate that. Since I believe Arkansas's rate is tied to the federal rate, so if the federal rate goes up, is there a risk to Arkansas? I mean, you talk about $40,000, but if that Fed rate changes, then it could fluctuate. Could you speak to
▶ Play
that, please? Absolutely. So if you look at the legislation, it's actually written pretty simple because it's basically 5% of the federal EITC. And to the extent that the federal EITC would go up, yes, you know, our credit would go up by 5% of whatever the federal rate went up by. You can imagine, you know, I'm not trying to, again, overly minimize it, but it would be a small increase if the federal government ever increased the EITC. Now, you know, Paul Ryan really likes the EITC, the Speaker of the House up in Washington. And so, yeah, it's possible that it could go up, but it would only go up
▶ Play
very slightly here. I appreciate that. Follow-up? You're recognized for follow-up. Is there any provision in the bill that the feds pay out on that tax credit, but Arkansas knows there's fraud involved? Is there any provision there that Arkansas could exercise the ability or the opportunity to pull that back?
▶ Play
Well we would be administering our own credit so to the extent that we either wanted to you know revise the policy here in the legislature you know or if DF&A you know wanted to change through administrative rules you know how they actually you know monitor for fraud and things like that I mean all of those things are at our disposal it's it's our credit it's just based on what the federal government does.
▶ Play
Thank you. Thank you. Representative De La Rosa for what
▶ Play
Speaker 88 41:36
purpose. You recognize her question? Could you explain the phase in and phase out portion of this where the rates change and what the purpose is for that? Because I don't think that was
▶ Play
covered. Sure, that's fine. And again, you know, the EITC, as I mentioned, you know, is designed as a formula, and the formula is based on the income that you're earning from a job as well as the size of your family so the credit kind of starts at a very low income level you know basically you know as low as maybe even fifteen thousand dollars if that's somebody's income from a job and uh and then the credit will increase as somebody earns more up to a certain point and that average is right around you know basically nineteen twenty twenty one thousand dollars again it all depends on whether you have, you know, no kids, one kid, two kids, three kids. And then the credit actually begins to reduce as people make over that kind of top amount until they're basically weaned off of the credit. And so it really has been very effective, like I said, in moving people past the point where they're living in poverty as they work. And then when, you know, obviously they're earning more than that, they're off the credit, and they are, you know, obviously just, you know, functioning based on just their earned income through that job. So, it creates that incentive without kind of giving more than it has to, to achieve the end result, and that's why it's such a brilliant design, and again, you know, I know Representative Collins' hero, Milton Friedman, was a pretty smart guy in putting that together. Representative Brown, for what purpose?
▶ Play
Speaker 91 43:18
question you recognize for a question thank you mr. speaker I too have high regard for Milton Friedman and conservative principles but one of my concerns is that we have a lot of people in Arkansas who are low income many of them are low income but they are not wage earners your bill would not affect them would it? It would not give them any additional assistance. I guess I'd have
▶ Play
to understand. I mean, my guess is the answer is yes, but what kind of income are you talking about? For
▶ Play
Speaker 91 43:56
example, some people strictly live on their Social Security or their disability income and things like that. Yeah, this would not provide a
▶ Play
benefit for that. The Earned Income Tax Credit truly is about income that's that's earned from from a job thank you representative Hendren for what
▶ Play
purpose for a question you recognize for a question representing Saban maybe you can help me with
▶ Play
this I talked a little bit of asking a little bit with the majority leaders in his bill yesterday and I'm prepared to to go to Bentonville tonight 500 mile trip between now and tomorrow and I'll be asked about how I'll vote on this bill. So I want to follow up on a question that we discussed yesterday. There's a document that was passed out the other day that says this is targeted flow income, and I think $21,000 was figured. And if you look in that bill yesterday, there are percentages applied to those different rate changes to make it appear to what it appears. And so I asked this question yesterday, and the response by the majority of the sponsor was that DFA had different information than that. So what I want to do is pose this question to you and tell you, is his information right? Or is this information that I'm about to read to you that was presented to our committee the other day correct? And just very quickly, it says this. For the bottom 40% of the income people in this state, the majority leader's plan would reduce their taxes by $44.99 at a cost of $50 million. For your plan, as I read it right here, as this document again says it that was handed out to our committee, for $40 million, that same group's taxes would be reduced by $90.61. Now, what I'm going to have a hard time to explain it, and I want you to help me. How do I vote for a bill that costs $50 million, and it costs it half as much as the one that I can buy for $40 million, which cuts it twice as much.
▶ Play
Can you help me with that? Well, I don't know if I can help you answering the question from your constituent. I mean, I can tell you that, you know, as I kind of explained at the beginning, that this proposal that I'm putting before you, it's cheaper because it's more efficient in what it sets out to do, which is to deliver tax relief to low-income working Arkansans. The reason why the governor's proposal and the one we passed yesterday costs more money is because when you cut a marginal tax rate, you're cutting it on net taxable income. And net taxable income is the income that you claim on your tax return after you've taken all the deductions. So, for instance, somebody who makes $40,000 or $50,000 can get their net taxable income down to below $21,000 if they've got enough deductions to claim. And so not only that, but the way the Arkansas tax system works is that at those levels that we're cutting, those low levels, all of us are taxed for that income to the extent that our income falls into those brackets. So you're taxed at that percentage at the very lowest levels until you get to a certain point. And therefore, when you look at kind of who gets the tax benefit, and there's a chart here, you know, of course, everyone in the low income levels gets it at the low income levels, but even those who make more than the low income levels still get a benefit from the proposal that we passed yesterday. So, this proposal is more targeted to the people we're trying to help, therefore it's more efficient, therefore it's $10 million cheaper.
▶ Play
Representative Rye, for what purpose? Mr. Saban, is there a possibility that
▶ Play
within this legislation that a person could actually be getting more back from the government, from the state of Arkansas, actually, than they actually pay in for income taxes? And we kind of addressed that
▶ Play
question a little bit earlier where, I mean, it's definitely possible that people could get more than they paid in, but it's based on a credit that is a function of how much income they earned, and it's taking into account a tax burden that we don't measure when we're measuring income taxes because of all the other regressive taxes that they're paying in a disproportionate amount compared to other people in other tax brackets. And so, you know, that's the reason why the formula was designed that way. And, again, anybody who's ever gotten a refund on their income taxes has experienced the same phenomenon. I
▶ Play
Speaker 96 48:53
guess that's it. I'll move out of the way. Representative
▶ Play
Saban has explained the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Collins, you recognize to speak against the bill.
▶ Play
I appreciate Representative Sabin bringing this bill again. We talked about it in the last session. I think one of the most exciting things about the health care task force, excuse me, the tax reform and relief task force that's coming is we're going to have the opportunity to discuss a lot of different ideas. And as Representative Sabin said, Milton Friedman designed the negative income tax as the best way of distributing benefits of welfare-type support. So if you look at what's happening in the country, there are going to be some changes in Washington, D.C., on health care. And when those changes happen, we may not have the same levels of welfare support on health care. There could be other elements of change. So in the context of those changes and in the context of the Tax Reform and Relief Task Force, The earned income tax idea will be a viable and powerful discussion point. But for now, that's not the direction we need to go. For now, the point is let's reduce the burden, the marginal tax rates, on our lowest income workers. We can afford to do with all the other things we've got, the $50 million in the governor's plan. Let's vote no on this today. Let's include it in the task force and see what we come up with after that. Thank you. Representative Collins has spoken against the bill. Would anyone like to
▶ Play
speak for the bill? Representative Flowers, you're recognized to speak for the bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I felt compelled to come to the well because I heard, with all due respect, Representative Collins' explanation. Many of us represent people in our districts who make the average, whose household incomes amount to what the average is, which is about $40,000. In some of those households, there are not two people. Those are folks who make about $20,000, and they work. They make about $20,000, and they work. So any reference to a credit that would incentivize work for people who are going to work and making a check and making a living I think is a little bit, I'll just say, inaccurate. Many of us represent people in this state, which is relatively a poor state. We have to keep that in mind. Many of us in this room have or claim credits because of the investments that we make, because the improvements to our homes that we make. That's not reflective of what we do to earn our checks, but we still make the credits. And sometimes that provides us with a refund for more than the taxes that we pay. Is that welfare? I don't think so. So I think that if we're going to look at what we are voting for and look at the efficiency of the bill, look for what it does, look at other states that have utilized this as a proven method to lift people out of poverty and also incentivize work, For me, no matter who sponsors the bill, when I'm looking at one bill that costs the state $50,000 and another bill that costs $40 million, we all wish it costs $40,000. But for one that costs $50 million, one that costs $40 million, and the one that costs $40 million provides more for our people who are working. I don't see how we can do anything else but support the earned income tax credit thank you representative flowers has
▶ Play
spoken for the bill would anyone like to speak against the bill would anyone like to speak for the bill represent Tucker you recognize speak for the bill thank you mr.
▶ Play
Speaker 108 53:44
speaker I think this has been fleshed out pretty well I just want to add one point for consideration for the body and before I do I just want to echo what representative Saban said that I totally fundamentally support the governor's effort to focus on this group of earned income excuse me of the this range of people who are in this amount of income and Representative Pitch has done a great job, and I voted for that bill yesterday, and when the Senate version comes down here, I'll vote for that bill as well. As far as this particular discussion goes, I wanted to add one point. A lot of states have enacted state-level earned income tax credits, and one of the things that they've found is that people who earn the amounts of money in this income range a lot of times just don't file tax returns that are currently eligible for the federal earned income tax credit. And so what the result of that is, is that they leave a lot of money on the table, a lot of federal dollars on the table, and there are literally billions of unclaimed earned income tax credits across the country. And I was visiting with someone who has worked on the state-level earned income tax credits in other states, and this is not a formal analysis, so I wouldn't hold it up to intense scrutiny, but he basically did a rough estimate of what he thought Arkansans were leaving on the table based on the populations of other states and what he has worked on, and what he told me was that Arkansans are probably leaving in the range of $200 million federal dollars in earned income tax credits on the table. And so when other states have enacted a state-level EITC and they get behind it and promote it, more people in this income range file tax returns, and then they not only get their state earned income tax credit, they're pulling down a lot of federal dollars as well. And as Representative Sabin explained very articulately, when that money goes into the economy, it has a real severe economic impact for job growth. They are spent at retailers all over Arkansas. That's what those funds are spent on. And so the impact is actually even bigger than the dollars that are pulled down. And so when you consider this policy, it's not just about the 40 million in state dollars. I think it's also about the other federal dollars that we could pull down and inject into our local economy in the range of non-figures. So I just wanted to add that point to our discussion and appreciate a good vote
▶ Play
on this bill. Representative Tucker has spoken for the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill, for the bill. Representative Sabin, would you like to close for your bill?
▶ Play
Well, again, I just want to thank everybody for doing what I think, you know, this institution was very well designed to do, which is to have a substantive policy debate on issues that are really important to the people that we represent. And, you know, I think that, you know, I'm in my third term here now. I've worked with a lot of you. I think you know that when I bring policy, You know, I try to do it in a way that brings us together, that has elements that all of us can support, and that's well thought through, and, you know, that's designed, obviously, to have the maximum benefit for the people of Arkansas. And I hope you understand that, you know, that's the spirit with which I bring this legislation. And I think it's really important for us, again, to consider this today, you know, even because, you know, we've already passed the governor's proposal yesterday. today. There's a legislative process. I mentioned that my lead sponsor in the Senate is Jake Files, the chairman of the Senate Revenue and Tax Committee. He's filed a companion version of this bill. There may be an opportunity to have it considered on the Senate side. If we pass this bill today, it doesn't mean that we've enacted $90 million in tax cuts, the 50 from yesterday and the 40 from today, because nothing becomes law until the governor signs a bill. So we have a chance to continue the discussion to make sure that we're enacting the very, very best policy that we can for the citizens of Arkansas. And if you consider what we're trying to do with a policy like this, that we're trying to move people out of poverty, that we're trying to incentivize them to work, that we're trying to reduce dependence on social services, and we're trying to stimulate the economy in a way that's proven, in a way that's happened over decades, in a way that other states across the country have enacted and found success with. Why wouldn't we do that for the state of Arkansas? And so I've made my case. I appreciate the time. I appreciate the spirited debate, the good questions, and I'd appreciate a good vote. Thank you very
▶ Play
much. Representative Sabin is closed for the bill. The question before the House is passage of House Bill 1161. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Cast up the ballot, Mr. Clerk. With 28 yeas, 66 nays, and two present, the bill has failed. Representative Payton moves for the clincher all in favor say aye opposed I believe the clincher failed I don't see five hands Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk, for the . . . Has everyone voted? Cast up the ballot, Mr. Clerk. With 64 yeas, 28 nays, and one present, the clincher is passed, is adopted.
▶ Play
Representative Meeks, you're recognized. Just speak loudly.
▶ Play
the proper base motion non-debatable all in favor say aye any opposed the motion carried are there any announcements representative Collins for what purpose but announcement you're recognized for
▶ Play
announcement house insurance and Commerce Committee will not meet tomorrow no meeting at 10 a.m. tomorrow house insurance and commerce representative Hodges for what
▶ Play
purpose announcement you're recognized for announcement here is meeting immediately after we adjourn
▶ Play
Speaker 118 1:01:38
over at uh b big mac representative fight for what purpose announcement you're recognized for announcement
▶ Play
aging children youth military will meet tomorrow at 10 a.m.
▶ Play
Representative Lemons, for what purpose? Hello. You're recognized for announcement. City County Local will meet tomorrow
▶ Play
Speaker 123 1:02:10
morning at 10 o'clock at Big Mac B. Thank you, sir. Representative Ballinger, for what
▶ Play
purpose? Announcement. You're recognized for announcement. State agencies will meet tomorrow at 10
▶ Play
a.m. We have a couple of bills to consider, so show up to work.
▶ Play
Representative Davis, for what purpose? Announcement. You're recognized for announcement. House Rules
▶ Play
Speaker 128 1:02:40
will meet tomorrow at noon in Big Mac B. Representative Sullivan, for what purpose? You're recognized for announcement. Prayer Crockus will meet in the morning, 7 o'clock, in
▶ Play
the old Supreme Court room. Representative Gene, for what purpose? Announcement. You're recognized for announcement. no joint budget tomorrow representative hillman for what purpose announcement you're recognized for announcement
▶ Play
agri meet in the morning at 10 a.m room 138. representative house for
▶ Play
what purpose announcement you're recognized for announcement special language 8 a.m big mac
▶ Play
Are there any other announcements? Read the bills, Mr. Clerk.
▶ Play
House Bill 1256. Without objection, read the bill a second time. House Bill
▶ Play
Speaker 32 1:03:46
1256. Agriculture, forestry, economic development. House Bill 1258. Without objection, read the bill a second time. House Bill 1258. agencies. House Bill 1259. Without objection read the bill the second time. House Bill 1259. Public Health. House Bill 1260. Without objection read the bill the second time. House Bill 1260. Judiciary. House Bill 1261. Without objection read the bill the second time. House Bill 1261. Aging children youth. House Bill 1262. Without objection read the bill the second time. House Bill 1261. the second time. House Bill 1262. Public Health. House Bill 1263. Without objection, read the bill a second time. House Bill 1263. Revenue and Tax. House Bill 1264. Without objection, read the bill a second time. House Bill 1264. Public Health. Senate Bill 114. Without objection, read the bill the second time. Senate Bill 114. Revenue in tax. The
▶ Play
desk will remain open for the reading of bills until 3.30 and upon completion of the items named in the adjourn resolution the House will be adjourned until 1.30 tomorrow.
▶ Play

Agenda

CALL TO ORDER

2:14 - 2:31 2 segments 1 speaker

PRAYER AND PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE

2:31 - 4:01 3 segments 3 speakers

ATTENDANCE

4:01 - 19:19 40 segments 7 speakers

POINT OF PERSONAL PRIVILEGE

19:19 - 17:28

CITATION - EAGLE SCOUT

17:28 - 8:11

HR1008 Wardlaw HONORING THE FORESTRY JUDGING TEAM OF THE HERMITAGE CHAPTER OF THE FUTURE FARMERS OF AMERICA.

8:11 - 12:08 9 segments 3 speakers

HR1009 Bragg TO RECOGNIZE AND CELEBRATE FORESTRY DAY, SPONSORED BY THE ARKANSAS FORESTRY ASSOCIATION, AT THE STATE CAPITOL ON JANUARY 24, 2017.

12:08 - 24:51 36 segments 9 speakers

End of Morning Hour

24:51 - 25:04 2 segments 2 speakers

REGULAR BILLS

25:04 - 25:07

HB1161 Sabin TO CREATE THE WORKING FAMILIES OPPORTUNITY ACT.

25:07 - 1:01:25 91 segments 13 speakers

HB1164 M. Gray TO AUTHORIZE LICENSURE BY ENDORSEMENT FOR OPTOMETRISTS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

ANNOUNCEMENTS

1:01:25 - 1:03:33 14 segments 9 speakers

READING OF THE BILLS

1:03:33 - 1:05:04 4 segments 2 speakers

ADJOURN

1:05:04 - 1:15:04

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Jon S. Eubanks Unverified
39 segments
Speaker 8
3 segments
Speaker 9
1 segment
Chair Unverified
16 segments
Representative Jeff Wardlaw Unverified
3 segments
Representative Ken Bragg Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 39
1 segment
Representative Andy Davis Unverified
4 segments
Representative Charles Blake Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 49
8 segments
Speaker 61
1 segment
Representative Laurie Rushing Unverified
1 segment
Representative Warwick Sabin Unverified
45 segments
Speaker 75
1 segment
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
5 segments
Representative Dan Sullivan Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 88
2 segments
Speaker 91
2 segments
Representative Kim Hendren Unverified
3 segments
Representative Johnny Rye Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 96
1 segment
Representative Charlie Collins Unverified
4 segments
Representative Vivian Flowers Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 108
5 segments
Speaker 118
1 segment
Representative Charlene Fite Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 123
1 segment
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 128
1 segment
Representative David Hillman Unverified
1 segment
Representative Douglas House Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 32
3 segments