Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

State Agencies & Govt'l Affairs

February 8, 2017 ·Committee Room 151 ·1:44:02
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (29)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB22 · 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB22 Bledsoe TO AMEND THE DEADLINE FOR CONDUCTING LOGIC AND ACCU…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1429 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1429 Tosh CONCERNING THE DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION; CONCERNING TH…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB256 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB256 Irvin TO TRANSFER THE ARKANSAS ENERGY OFFICE TO THE ARKANSA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1004 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1004 Blake TO CREATE THE DEMOCRACY ACT; TO REQUIRE AUTOMATIC VOT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1005 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1005 Tucker TO REQUIRE REPORTING AND DISCLOSURE OF ELECTIONEERIN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1008 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1008 Tucker TO INCREASE THE PENALTY FOR TAKING CAMPAIGN FUNDS AS…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1009 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1009 Leding TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING APPROVED POLITICAL ACTIO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1010 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1010 Sabin TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE PUBLICATION OF CERTAI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1011 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1011 Sabin TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING POLITICAL ACTION COMMI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1012 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1012 Sabin TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING POLITICAL ACTION COMMI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1046 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1046 Tucker TO PERMIT PAID MATERNITY LEAVE FOR STATE EMPLOYEES.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1065 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1065 Watson PERMITTING THE ARKANSAS COMMISSION ON LAW ENFORCEMEN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1151 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1151 Davis TO REQUIRE THAT REGISTERED VOTERS BE NOTIFIED BY MAIL…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1179 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1179 Ballinger TO AMEND PROVISIONS PROVIDING DEATH BENEFITS TO D…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1207 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1207 Dalby TO AMEND REQUIREMENTS FOR CAMPAIGN SIGNS AND MATERIAL…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1270 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1270 Johnson TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ELECTIONS AND BALLOTS.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1289 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1289 Ballinger TO PROMOTE AND IMPROVE EFFICIENCY AND QUALITY IN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1386 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1386 Lemons TO REQUIRE THE FILING OF FINAL AGENCY RULES WITH THE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1404 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1404 A. Mayberry TO CLARIFY THE ADMINISTRATIVE RESPONSIBILITIES…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1427 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1427 Della Rosa TO EXPAND THE USE OF TECHNOLOGY TO IMPROVE CAMPA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1430 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1430 Tosh CONCERNING LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER STANDARDS AND TRAIN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1440 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1440 M. Gray TO AMEND PROVISIONS IN THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1441 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1441 M. Gray TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE PAYMENT OF EXPENSES…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1443 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1443 M. Gray TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE ARKANSAS STATE BOAR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1447 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1447 M. Gray TO TRANSFER THE STATE BOARD OF ELECTION COMMISSIONE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1450 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1450 Drown TO CLARIFY ARKANSAS LAW RELATED TO NOTARIES PUBLIC.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1452 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1452 S. Meeks TO AMEND THE EMERGENCY INTERIM EXECUTIVE AND JUDIC…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1001 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1001 Ballinger APPLYING TO THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS TO CALL A…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB257 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB257 Irvin TO TRANSFER THE OFFICE OF HEALTH INFORMATION TECHNOLO…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
All right, we'll go ahead and get started, Chair sees a quorum. We do have several things on the agenda today. Some things are more interesting than other things, but we're going to try to get a couple the smaller bills out of the way first before we deal with Representative De La Rosa's bill, which will be a little more involved, I think, and have a little more discussion, but maybe not. We'll see how it goes. But first, what I'd like to do is find out from the committee if or anybody else in the room that they have a bill that they're looking at running or will be running soon. I know Representative Davis, you had some amendments to your bill. Are you still, Are you okay with it being deferred still? Okay. So are there any other bills that we have? I know that Representative Gray has several, so we're not going to move any of her bills to deferred, the 1440, 1441, 1447. We'll keep them on the active calendar. Representative Meeks is going to be in here to run his 1452. Representative Drown will be back to committee after he runs the bill, and we're going to run 1450, and obviously Representative De La Rosa, 1427. I think Representative Gray plans on running Senate Bill 22, and the other one Representative Gray has is 1443. Does anyone in here know who's running Senator Mitzi Irving's Senate Bill 256 and 257? You run them. Do you want them on the active calendar, or are they okay to go to deferred? I can leave them active. Okay. There's one more coming in. I'm going to wait and do all three at the same time. That's fine. And Representative Tosh, are both of your bills, do you want to leave on the active calendar or do you want to move one of them to deferred? I'll leave both. Leave both. Okay. Well, that's the case and we don't have anything we have to move to deferred, which is fine. All right. Having said that, Representative Tosh, you are recognized to run one of your bills. And I'm sorry, Representative Mayberry, I would have got you first, but we'll get you right after we'll get Representative Tosh. Yes, sir, Representative Davis. I
▶ Play
apologize. I just want to clarify for the audience. My bill that's on the deferred list, was it 1151? Yep. It has member's own amendments going on today. I could potentially run it next week, but I'll let you know. Okay,
▶ Play
if you'd let me know, I do think we'll have a meeting on Friday, so just as long as you let me know in two days, then we'll get it ready to go. Okay, Representative Tosh, you are recognized. Which bill are you running of the two? Mr. Chair, I'll be running House Bill 1429. Okay, you are recognized to
▶ Play
run House Bill 1429. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Committee, this bill was brought to me by the Arkansas Department of Correction. This is what we're wanting to do. There are actually two bills now that are in place, and they both require the Department of Corrections to submit two identical reports. We want to repeal 12-27-141. This is a report that is due by the Department of Corrections every July the 31st to the General Assembly. And then again in February, they have to submit the same report again to the General Assembly. So all we want to do with this bill is simply eliminate one of the bills or one of the documents that they're heading to submit. It's just a duplication. And also this bill also includes the fact that we have a reciprocal agreement with other states as far as if someone has to be moved across state line for a hearing. We have a reciprocal agreement with them as far as being a detainee. detainee, that's where we don't have to extradite them back and forth across the state line. And in that reciprocal agreement, it says that the only person that can resign that release for detainee is actually the director themselves, and we want a language change where it says that they can also assign one of their designees to be able to do that. That's all this bill does. It provides for less government and gives a little more freedom to the director to be able to handle her daily business. And I would
▶ Play
ask for any questions. Representative Douglas,
▶ Play
Speaker 24 4:45
you're recognized for a question. Yes, I appreciate the efficiency of the bill and commend you for that. I just wonder why you chose the February date when we're in session and Legislative Council is not in session to give a report to Legislative Council, and two, the February date is not at the end of a fiscal cycle, whereas the July date would be. So if you could kind of answer those concerns. And that's a
▶ Play
good question. And what happens is actually the February date, even though it's submitted in February, it is for the preceding year, and that's kind of the way the statute was written for that information in that particular statute. And the one in February actually provides just a little bit more information than the one in July. They're pretty much identical, except it is broader in scope as to what it gives to the Legislative
▶ Play
General Assembly. All right, Representative House, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. Tosh, I've been part of this judicial, attending the Judicial Task Force meetings, not a member of that task force, and so we've been vitally concerned with how many folks are in prison and what they're in prison for, and getting good information kind of tends to be a problem. Why do we want to cut out information
▶ Play
that we've got to, that we need? Well, the same information they are providing on July the 31st, that same information with even a little bit more additional information is provided in February. And there's no lack of information or any less information that's been given in one report from the other. Actually, Representative, it's probably, according to what I've been told, There's probably some additional information and some data that's provided in the February. It's just that there were two statutes in place requiring almost identical information to be submitted by this one agency, probably not six months apart, and we're just trying to eliminate that bureaucracy.
▶ Play
Follow-up? You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. So I'm only going to know how many folks are really in prison as far as the signed, sworn to, official document once a year instead of twice a year. That's exactly right. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Wardlaw, you recognize for a question? Representative Tosh, you've got to
▶ Play
– thank you, Mr. Chair. You've got to help me a little bit. I'm not smart enough to know how to read efficiently. But I don't see in here where it says February. Is that in another statute somewhere that it states that that report's due in February?
▶ Play
That's exactly right. The report that we're wanting to retain is that's in that report. The one that we're wanting to eliminate is the July 31st report. Representative Davis, you're recognized for a question. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Tosh, just kind of the same thing Representative Warlaw was asking. So is the February report requirement in statute, or is that a rule or regulation?
▶ Play
Is that voluntary? No, sir, that's in statute. We have two statutes that regulate that they submit these reports, and that's all we're trying to do is eliminate duplication of those reports. One is due July 31st. One is due in February, and they're both required by statute. I don't guess you know where that
▶ Play
is off the top of your head, do you? Mr.
▶ Play
Chair, if you don't mind, I'm going to bring to the table with me with the Arkansas
▶ Play
Department of Corrections. Yeah, that's no problem at all.
▶ Play
And if you don't mind, introduce yourself for the record. Solomon Graves, Arkansas Department of Corrections, Representative Davis. The other report that we're keeping is spelled out in 1227-107. That statute sets out the duties of the director of the Arkansas Department of Correction. And within those duties, there is a requirement that the director submits an annual report to the board and then to the governor and the General Assembly. The board has provided instructions to their directors by policy that those reports should be submitted at the end of the calendar year. The way the board meets, that is where that February date comes from. To follow up on what Representative Tosh stated, the report that we're looking to eliminate is simply a spreadsheet. It lists every criminal offense category that comes into the Department of Correction and provides an aggregate count for that offense. The statute does not provide any analytical or expansions or analysis of that data. 1227-107 specifically directs the director to not only provide data, but also provide an analysis of that data and also provide an impact of that data on our bed impact requires that we provide information on bed utilization and also recommendations as any for additional bed capacity and any other policies on behalf of the Arkansas Department of Correction. The General Assembly will not lose any information by this bill. We're simply looking to bring greater efficiency to our report and cut out some of the duplicative work that our staff is having to do right now. But the General Assembly will not lose any data as a result of this bill. Representative Hammer, are
▶ Play
you recognized for a question? To the
▶ Play
agency, I would ask, so instead of getting a twice-a-year snapshot of this information we're only going to get a once a year snapshot
▶ Play
is that you're only getting the same you're only getting the information you're only getting the same information so it's we're not providing the information in july 31st and then providing it an update of it in february 1st you're getting the same information again follow-up mr. chair you're recognized do you remember what the original
▶ Play
purpose was and maybe i was just not listening while going i'm sorry if i'm being repetitive, but do you remember what the original intent was, that it was set up to be twice instead of
▶ Play
once in the first place? No, sir. This report predates the tenure of most of our management in the Department of Correction. It's one of those things that's always been done, and nobody has any
▶ Play
real answer as to why. Can I keep
▶ Play
going on a couple, please? Yes. Thank you. Well, not too long. Thank you. I never go too long, Mr. Chair. Thank you. So I'm just wondering, And as moving forward, then there's really no purpose to keep it because it's not going to change from report to report from what I understand you're saying. Is that a correct interpretation? Yes, sir. And then finally, one of the reasons stated for the need for the bill is because it's so labor-intensive to prepare. So can you speak as to what goes into preparing the report and why it's so labor-intensive?
▶ Play
This report is not what we would style as a canned report. So it requires our staff to work with the entity that coordinates and develops our offender management system to write ad hoc queries each year that extracts this information. And then once the data is extracted, our staff has to take time and audit each of those records to ensure that it is accurate and complete before it's submitted to the General Assembly. In effect, this is about a 21- to 30-day process from start to finish. So it
▶ Play
is a valuable report. Your argument is it just doesn't need to be put out there twice once it's sufficient.
▶ Play
It doesn't need to be put out there twice. And as we told Representative Tosh when we presented this bill to him, the data is still going to be there. We simply want the ability as an agency to provide the data in the best way possible to the General Assembly. All right. Thank you.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Dotson, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just wanted to clarify something I heard before. You said this is the same data, so the report is the exact
▶ Play
same identical information? The report is not the exact same information. The report that you get right now in July is simply an offense breakdown. What we submit around the first of the following calendar year is what we style as the director's annual report. It includes an offense breakdown, also includes information on bed utilization, also includes information on our financials and programming. So the initial report
▶ Play
in February is a more comprehensive report. Yes, sir. And then this is a snapshot, but of the same information that was included in that first report. Yes, sir. Okay. Thank you.
▶ Play
Is there any other questions from the committee? Representative Howes, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This is not the CAFR report, is it? No, sir. Department of Corrections. This has nothing to do with CAFR. Thank you very much. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chairman. All right. Any other questions from the committee? There's nobody signed up from the audience to speak for or against. Representative Tosh, you want to close for your bill?
▶ Play
Mr. Chair, I appreciate the committee, and I would just ask for a due pass.
▶ Play
Okay, we have a motion from Representative Tosh to pass. What's the pleasure of the committee? Having heard that motion, if you're in favor, say aye. Opposed? Ayes have it. Congratulations, Representative Tosh, you passed your bill. Thank you. Okay, Representative Mayberry, if you want to present your bill.
▶ Play
Mr. Chair, with the committee's permission, I would also like to ask Grant Wallace with the Treasurer's Office and Alan McLean with Arkansas Rehabilitative Services to join me. Okay, that's fine. If you guys
▶ Play
would, if you'd introduce yourself for the record, we'd
▶ Play
appreciate it. Grant Wallace, Chief Deputy Treasurer for Treasurer Milligan. Alan McClain, Commissioner of Arkansas
▶ Play
Speaker 70 15:40
Rehab Services. Thank you. Thank you, members of the committee.
▶ Play
I think this is a fairly simple, non-controversial bill. This is some clarification to the enabling legislation that this body passed a couple of years ago to allow Arkansas to participate in the Achieving a Better Life Experience Program, otherwise known as the ABLE Act. A little bit of quick background information on that. The ABLE Act was federal legislation that was passed a little over two years ago, again at the national level. It amended Section 529 of the IRS Code, creating tax-free savings accounts for individuals with disabilities. It was co-sponsored by all six members of the Arkansas congressional delegation. But when passed on the federal level, it still had to be passed on a state-by-state level for states to participate in that program. Arkansas was one of the first five states to enact that enabling legislation. But it takes some time to get things up and running. And when we first passed that legislation, it was generally understood, I believe, that There would be three cooperating agencies, those being Arkansas Rehabilitative Services, DHS, and the Treasurer's Office, and that the Treasurer's Office would manage the program. We had language in there to that effect, saying that the Treasurer of State shall provide office space, staff, and materials for the committee. All this is is just kind of clarifying and providing a little more detail as to what goes into the management of that program. And with that, I think we're open to questions. And again, we have each of these gentlemen from these representative agencies here as well.
▶ Play
Okay. Thank you. Representative Dodson, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. On I guess it's point number two and three on page one, actually three and four, it looks like you're possibly expanding the responsibilities potentially quite significantly that might to increase the cost if you're conducting outreach and engaging in financial education activities with individuals as well as performing other services necessary. Do you have a cost estimate on what this would be
▶ Play
and where those funds will be coming from? Sir, I'll answer that if that's okay. The only estimate that we have seen thus far is looking at various program administrators that would essentially administer this program for the state that we would contract with. What we've seen is that's ranged anywhere from $50,000 upwards. What we have actually done in our Treasurer's Office Appropriations Bill is we've carved out money from our existing authorized funding levels and said $60,000 is what we would use for ABLE, 529, and financial education. So we've thrown an initial number out there of 60,000 and just setting aside 50,000 that our office could do to implement this program. Obviously, we would be looking at the other agencies that are a part of this board to assist in funding that as well. And
▶ Play
I would add, too, where you see that about the outreach activities, this is a really targeted audience. This is not a broad mass communication type of information. So if I understand you correctly,
▶ Play
right now this is not being done, so this would be an additional 50,000? Well, right now we are yet to actually be participating in the ABLE program because it's not up and running yet.
▶ Play
This is part of the clarification piece needed to get Arkansas up and running. As I mentioned, we were one of the first five states to pass the enabling legislation. But we've yet to get the program
▶ Play
going, and 16 states now do have it up and going. But there's no federal money that's actually going
▶ Play
into this program to support it. Thank you. What this does, again, to go back for some background information on it, currently if an individual with disabilities, for instance, wanted to let's say they wanted to put a wheelchair lift in a vehicle. It might cost $5,000 or $6,000 to do that. That individual is currently limited to only being able to have $2,000 worth of assets. And so if they're paying for this out of their own pocket, it may be someone who's on this DD waiver waiting list, for instance. If they're paying for this out of their own pocket, that individual is not allowed to save up enough money to actually install that wheelchair lift because once Once they get to $2,000, they are no longer eligible for other federal support services such as SSI or Medicaid. And so what this does, it increases, it goes from $2,000 to $14,000 of assets that an individual
▶ Play
could save. And just one point, unlike the 529 College Savings Program, which does get an administrative fee to self-fund the administration of that, there are no funds to start this up. These are just the startup costs that we're looking at. We would contemplate looking at an administrative fee that would be tied to these accounts that would end up coming over and being able to self-manage and self-fund the administration of the program. It's not new money that we're looking for. This would be out of our existing office appropriations.
▶ Play
Again, members, this is legislation we've already passed here. This is just clarification of how the program is
▶ Play
being managed. Representative House, you're recognized for a question. Uh, last year, I think in budget, there was a, it was in budget. We were looking at some audit findings about the secretary spending some money on an economics education program without statutory authorization. Do you remember us talking about that? Yes, sir, and this is a direct reaction to that. Once our legal counsel, we went through that experience, our legal counsel looked at other programs and statutes that relate to the treasurer's office, and this one was not clear that we could be able to administer and manage those day-to-day functions, so we are coming back asking for clarification language so we don't end up in
▶ Play
another situation. And that's why we made sure to make sure that this language was very specific to this program and this targeted group of individuals to inform that group who would be affected by it.
▶ Play
May I follow up, Mr. Chairman? Yes. How much that year that the auditors got upset about, how much that year did y'all spend? $75,000. Okay. Okay. And is that why in line four that you put financial education activities with individuals with disabilities, this is going to be targeting only our disabled crew? Is that correct? Yes, sir. And it does go back to the point that in order to get people to save, you have to teach them first how to save. And that is an important message and lesson that the treasurer has focused on and will continue to focus on. And we want to make sure that we are properly informing and educating not only about the ABLE program itself, but the importance of saving and how that this really can make an impact and change an individual's life, regardless of disabilities or not. One last question, Mr. Chairman. You'll recognize. Thank you. And how much is your appropriation for this program? I think we did approve appropriation in budget Committee. Right. In the November budget, we're actually writing a letter to amend and we'll be looking at $60,000 for this type of activity, for the ABLE program, the 529 program, and financial education. We're still working that out with BLR on exactly how that would be worded, but it is $60,000 that we would be looking at. And
▶ Play
Representative House, if I may be able to add to that, don't hold me to this figure, but from what I understand, potentially about 15,000 people would be at one time or any one time may be eligible to receive this type of financial education. Mr. Chairman, they didn't answer my question.
▶ Play
May I ask it again? Yes, you may. How much did we approve on your appropriation? That was my question. And you'll have not, sir, because this was not... I mean, back in November. Right in November, this was not part of what was in that bill that y'all reviewed at that time. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
All right. Are there any other questions from committee? Representative Hamer, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Let me just try to get back to the basics in my mind. When it comes to the bottom line that you're appropriated to spend, what you're wanting to do is represented in that bottom line. You're just trying to make sure that you've got the legal coverage in order to be able to provide this service under 529 and not be brought back up before leg audit again. Is that a fair summary? Okay. And because it has been brought up regarding that leg audit finding, in reality, there was a question that I think you had sought some outside counsel about. and that particular issue is going to be resolved by what we do here today. So moving forward, that's not going to be a debatable issue again. Is that correct? Yes, sir. Okay. And as far as the 529 and what you're wanting to do, can I one more, Mr. Chairman? Yeah, you're right. Sorry about that. I fear you would have cut me off. But as far as what you're trying to do by making sure all the full possibilities of the 529 to the disabled population that's been brought up, this will give you the ability to do that, and it's not going to affect your bottom line. You just want to get that appropriation in there to where it can be spent as you're intending to spend it. Is that correct? That is correct, sir. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right.
▶ Play
Seeing no further questions, there's nobody signed up to speak for or against. Representative Mayberry, you are recognized to close for your bill. Would appreciate a good vote. Thank you. So what's the will of the committee? I've got to have a motion due passed by Representative Hammer. All in favor, say aye. Aye. No, say nay. Nay. Ayes have it. Congratulations, Representative Mayberry. You passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, members of the committee. Okay. We are going to move back up to the top of the agenda. And Representative Gray, are you ready to run Senate Bill 22? All right, you are recognized to run Senate
▶ Play
Bill 22. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senate Bill 22 deals with conducting logic and accuracy testing during runoff elections. So currently there's only there's about three weeks from the time of a of a primary to a runoff election or not primary general to a runoff election. And they have about they have you have a week of early voting. And then that just leaves two weeks for them to do all the testing, the logic and accuracy testing. And so what they're what we're trying to do is take it from doing it seven days prior to five. That gives the clerks an extra two days to get all the testing done since they're in such a short time crunch period. So that's essentially all this bill is doing, is allowing the clerks an extra two days to prepare the machines.
▶ Play
Are there any questions from the committee? Representative Gray, you're recognized to close. Thank you. I
▶ Play
just appreciate a good vote, and I make a motion of due pass. Okay, we have a
▶ Play
motion due pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. Aye. Opposed? Say nay. Ayes have it. Congratulations. Representative Gray, you passed your bill. Thank you. Representative De La Rosa, are you prepared to run your bill now? We have plenty of other bills that we can kind of work through. In fact, we have Representative Gray at the end of the table, so she can continue working on them if you're not quite ready. Okay. Representative Gray, which bill
▶ Play
do you want to run? Let's run House Bill
▶ Play
1443. Okay. You're recognized to run House Bill
▶ Play
1443. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So House Bill 1443 deals with a board, and let me pull the bill up here. It's for the State Board of Chiropractic Examiners. Currently, we have an Arkansas Chiropractic Physicians Association that the governor should consult with before making appointments to the board. There's a second association or society of chiropractors in Arkansas, and it's the Arkansas Chiropractic Society. And they would like to essentially just have a seat at the table to be able to consult with the governor as well on recommendations. I don't know that the Arkansas Chiropractic Physicians Association, The one already in statute is necessarily happy with it, but they're not, to my knowledge, going to oppose the bill in any way.
▶ Play
Okay. Representative Hammer, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. One thing I wanted to bring out or ask about was on the floor yesterday in the House, we heard from one of the representatives about moving forward and consolidating boards to try to make us more efficient. And could you explain for me why we have two different entities related to the same occupation? And then based on the statement you just said, it seems like there's a potential for conflict. So could you kind of wrap that up or clear that for me?
▶ Play
Yes, sir. Well, and this originally, I had actually asked if we could put this into the original board bill or the omnibus bill that they're going to run through this session. And because we thought there might be some controversy, I just decided to leave it out separate. I didn't want to interfere with the governor's bill, but there are two associations or societies because years ago, the Arkansas Chiropractic Society, which is the one we're trying to add into this bill, they were formed in 1998, essentially because of political differences. So this association, I don't know the numbers for the one that's originally in the bill, but this society has over 200 members, chiropractors, and covers almost every county in Arkansas. So they feel that they've grown to the point that they should, for their membership to be heard and to have a voice at the table, that they should be allowed to consult with the governor. Follow-up, Mr. Chair? You're recognized. Thank you.
▶ Play
So, by the creation of this legislation, what was before an absence to have a presence in the, if there was a questionable item they wanted to debate before the board of chiropractors, an individual chiropractor would have to go before the board by themselves, and is this legislation creating where the society can debate issues before the board or have a voice at the table in addition to the board?
▶ Play
No, and I don't, maybe I'm not making that clear enough, but this is just for appointments to the board. So they just wanted to be able to have essentially a voice with the governor and possibly who he or she might appoint to the board. As far as having to go before the board, they'd still be represented in the same manner they are now. Follow up. One more, Mr. Chair. Yep, you're
▶ Play
recognized for one more question. Is there any additional cost that this is going to create to chiropractors that they're not having to bear already, or do either one of these entities, are we going to see a fee increase because of what we're doing
▶ Play
here? No, sir. There's no fee increase. This just essentially allows the governor to consult with two associations instead of one on making the appointments. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. Representative House, you're recognized for a question. Yes. The governor's duty to consult can consist of a phone call or two-week-long meetings, whatever he chooses, correct? That's correct.
▶ Play
And these are both private organizations? That's correct. They both have
▶ Play
membership dues, yes, sir. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. All right. Seeing no further questions from the committee, what is the – do you want
▶ Play
to close for your bill? Yes, I appreciate it, and I would just make a motion of do pass. Okay. The
▶ Play
motion of do pass has been made. All in favor, say aye. Opposed, say nay. Okay, eyes have it. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Committees. Do you want to run another one? Or do you want to?
▶ Play
Yeah. Okay. What do you want to run? Which was the, I told you I could do three today. What was my other one? 1441. 1441, okay. Okay. So House Bill 1441 deals with the payment for expenses for presidential electors. And if you look down on page one on line 30, it's amazing this is still in statute, but it says each elector, this is the part we're doing away with, each elector shall receive for every 20 miles of travel essentially the sum of $3. And so it's just so outdated. We just decided we need to update it. And the electors, they serve without pay, but he or she is eligible for reimbursement by Secretary of State for reasonable and necessary expenses. and they'll be reimbursed for travel at the same rate as prescribed by state employees. So this just brings them in line so they don't lose money on every trip that they take. They are volunteers anyhow. Okay. Any questions from the committee?
▶ Play
Representative Davis, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. What kind
▶ Play
Speaker 129 34:14
of meetings do they go to? I will call up. Who am
▶ Play
I calling up? I mean, I'm the dumb one here. I just don't really know what they
▶ Play
do. Well, this is the election commissioners. Kelly, do you want to come up? No, nobody wants
▶ Play
Speaker 132 34:29
to come up? Yeah, yeah, come up here. We're looking the wrong way. I'm looking for a project.
▶ Play
Speaker 136 34:38
I will let Mr. Boyd. Mr. Boyd, if you'd introduce yourself for the record. I'm Kelly
▶ Play
Speaker 138 34:49
Boyd, Chief Deputy Secretary of State. And the answer to your question is this only involves the electors to a presidential electoral college, and they would be coming to Little Rock once every four years to cast their ballots as the people of the state have directed them. So it only happens once every four years. The old language was written, I believe, in 47. This language just brings it in line with what we do
▶ Play
now. All right. Any other questions? So, Mr. Chairman Mayer? Yeah. So, we're just talking about one trip every four years to Little Rock? Could you please repeat that? We're talking about one trip every four years to Little Rock. Is that correct? No out-of-state meetings or anything like that?
▶ Play
Speaker 138 35:34
That is correct. It's a single meeting to Little
▶ Play
Rock. We're not talking air travel places or anything like
▶ Play
Speaker 138 35:39
that? We would only reimburse in accordance with state travel rules.
▶ Play
Okay. Thank you. All right. Seeing no other questions, are you prepared to close for your bill?
▶ Play
Yes. I'm closed for the bill and would appreciate a good vote and make a motion of due pass.
▶ Play
Okay. We have a motion of due pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed say nay. All right. Ayes have it. Congratulations. You've done it again. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right. Is there anybody else that is prepared and ready to run a bill today? Oh, Representative Meeks, I'm so sorry I didn't even see you hiding back there. Representative Meeks, you are recognized to run HB 1452. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, colleagues.
▶ Play
This morning, I bring you what is essentially a cleanup bill. Back this last spring, with all the terrorist attacks that are going on around the world, and being a former military guy, I began asking the question of our staff, what would happen if the unthinkable were to happen? Several weeks ago, when the governor gave his State of the State address, the entire central government was located in the House chambers, and all it would take is one incident, and the General Assembly, the entire constitutional offices would be gone. how would our state handle something like that? So back in the spring, I asked Mr. Miller to research what provisions do we have in place to handle that kind of emergency situation. So he did some research and we found some interesting answers. Evidently back during World War II, every lawmaker in the state had to list two emergency replacements should an attack have occurred on our Capitol. Back in 1961, they passed legislation also handling this. And of course, that was back during the height of the Cold War. And this is a legislation that I'm bringing you is an update to that. Now, unfortunately, because of some provisions within the Constitution, we can't go far enough to handle this. But what I want to try to do is to at least update this language, and then later I've also filed a constitutional amendment to allow us to have a little bit more flexibility in how we handle these extreme emergency situations that we pray never happen. So what this bill does is the law that was passed back in 1961 did a couple of things. Um, the first thing that, um, we're going to be doing is, in the event that the governor is incapacitated, the assumption is, is that there will always be a lieutenant governor to take his place. But if an event occurred where we lost both the, both the governor and the lieutenant governor, under current statutes, there is not a mechanism for us to replace the governor. Now, the president pro tem of the Senate can act as an acting governor, so he could call a special election, but what he would have to do is he would have to call a special election for a lieutenant governor's position. When the lieutenant governor was elected, he would then automatically become the governor, and then we would have to call another special election to replace the position of lieutenant governor again. Under these extreme situations, the line of secession or the one that could act as a governor would be the President Pro Tem, then we get down to the House of Representatives, the Speaker, and then after that, in statute, they said that the Attorney General would be next in line, the Secretary of State, the Treasurer, but they left off the Auditor and the Land Commissioner. So the first thing that this does is it just adds the Auditor and Land Commissioner to that line of succession. The second thing this piece of code requires is that the Governor lists between three and seven emergency successors for each of his deputies. So for the director of AEDC, the governor would have to have between three and seven people listed as backups to be able to step in in the event of an emergency. For the Department of AEDQ, another three to seven. DHS, another three to seven. So y'all can imagine how many times that's happened over the last 20 years? Probably never. So what we're doing with this language is we're striking that out. Should the unthinkable happen, we get a new acting governor, the new acting governor would have the power to replace these. And so essentially what we're doing is we're removing that language, we're adding the auditor of state, we're adding the land commissioner as two people in the line of succession, God forbid, should it ever be needed. And with that, I'll try to answer any questions. Are there any
▶ Play
questions from the committee? Representative Eubanks, you're recognized for a question. Representative
▶ Play
Meeks, shouldn't the proper succession be to the Speaker of the House rather than the President Pro Tem of the Senate?
▶ Play
Speaker 147 40:40
Yes. Personally, I think the Speaker should
▶ Play
be before the Senate, but I'm willing to have that
▶ Play
fight if you are, but thank you. Sounds like a hostile amendment to North. Yes, yes.
▶ Play
Representative Hamber, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm just curious, the governor weighed in on this and no opposition, given the fact we're kind of dealing with what would
▶ Play
happen there? Yeah, yeah. No, I talked to his chief of staff, and they didn't have any problems with that. As a matter of fact, like I said, we're taking away something that this law says they have to do. Okay, very good. Thank you. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. All right, any other questions from the committee? What is the will of the committee? We have a motion to do pass from Representative Hammer. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed, say nay. All right. Ayes have it. Congratulations, Representative Meeks. You passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. Okay. Representative De La Rosa, do you want to run your bill? I will run it. Okay. Is there anybody else in the committee that is prepared to run a bill? Okay. Then if you're ready to run it. Okay. Okay. Representative DeLaRosa, you have an amendment,
▶ Play
I think, to deal with, correct? Yes, sir. Okay. The amendment just adds Senator Cooper as a sponsor. We just forgot to put that on earlier.
▶ Play
Okay. All right, you are recognized to run the amendment for
▶ Play
1427. COMMITTEE, THE AMENDMENT JUST ADDS SENATOR
▶ Play
COOPER AS THE SENATE SPONSOR. WE HAVE A MOTION FROM REPRESENTATIVE DOTSON. ALL IN FAVOR, SAY AYE. AYE. OPPOSED? OK. SO YOUR BILL IS AMENDED. SO NOW YOU'RE
▶ Play
RECOGNIZED TO RUN HOUSE BILL 1427. COMMITTEE, HOUSE BILL 1427 DOES ONE THING. It requires that those that file for state office, which would be constitutional officers, judicial candidates, and us, file our campaign finance reports electronically instead of on paper. There is an exception built into it if you do not have access to sufficient technology, because I know that that was a big concern for people. If you want to do it that way, then you have to file a piece of paper at the beginning before you start filing, stating that, and then you're allowed to file on paper for the rest of the election cycle. The difference between when I ran this last year and this year is that in the meantime, we've spent almost $700,000 of taxpayer money on a new system. And there were two benefits of that new system. On one side is our benefit. It's much more accurate. It's much more easier, much more easier to use, much easier to use. It's got a lot of safeguards in it that our current system doesn't have. It will fix a lot of things for us that right now we're liable for when we make addition errors. If you have to go back and make an amendment, it will take care of all of that for you for all subsequent reports. It's a much, much nicer system than what we have today. And the reason that that money was spent is, again, there was a lot of concern from members last time that they didn't want to be mandated to have to report into a system that they didn't trust. So again, that money has been spent there. It's gone. The new system will be up and running the 1st of July. We'll be trained on it over the summer, regardless of whether this passes or not, but we'll be trained on it over the summer, and what I'm trying to do with this bill is make sure that the public gets their piece out of it. Our piece out of it is better, more accuracy and easier to use, more convenience. Their benefit out of it is a searchable database, which they do not have today, and this new system has a nice interface with it that would be great for the public, but if we do not report into it, it's useless to them because it will only have some of the information. So that's what I'm trying to accomplish with this bill.
▶ Play
And I will take any questions. Okay. Are there any questions
▶ Play
from the committee? Representative Dotson, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Over the last couple of years, I've noticed as people have filed their reports, in particular on one day, distinctly remember reports were due in the system that we currently have or had, the website went down. So there was absolutely no way to file it. And does this allow for a grace period if you miss the filing deadline because you can't log in to a website that's down? Currently, Everyone who weren't able to file that day had to go down and file a paper form in order to not have an ethics violation. The bill does not have a grace period for that because that doesn't have to do with what I'm trying to do in this bill. I would remind you that you have 15 days to file a campaign finance report. So if you choose to wait until the last day, which I realize is a strategic move and a A lot of us do choose to do that, but there's a risk that you take with that as well. I mean, the same exists on paper. Let's say you try and fax it in at midnight, and your fax machine doesn't work. I mean, you've got the same issue right now on paper as you would have with that, so you're always taking a risk if you wait until the last second to do it. But again, you have 15 days. Within a 15-day period, you should be able to get it in. And I would say, too, that this new system, again, is much more reliable than what we have today. And I wish that the members of the committee had been able to come see it when it was demoed, but I know that everybody was busy. So you're just going to have to take my word for it that it's a pretty slick system. And I've got, you know, Kelly Boyd, Secretary of State's office, is here if you want to hear from him because his office is the one that's responsible for that website and also for this software. And I've got Graham Sloan with the Ethics Commission if you want to hear from him what the results would be if you are unable to file due to no fault of your own because the system went down. So either one are here to answer that kind of question. You recognize for a follow-up. So if, and I understand that if you wait until the last second, there's always potential things that could happen, but currently, you can mail it in on the final day as long as it's postmarked by that day, it's in compliance, you don't have an ethics violation. You're striking through that language, if I'm understanding that correctly, and taking that option away from folks unless they go through and submit something saying that they are, don't have access to the technology. And I know for a lot of members just technology is not always perfect, even if it is a great system. There's certain challenges that always happen with technology. And there are also various folks that have challenges with technology in general, getting that to work. So as far as folks that have a hardship because they don't have access to sufficient Internet or something like that, see where they can make a waiver or whatever saying that they don't have access. But if they have a certain technological challenge in trying to figure out how to navigate the system. There's no waiver for that, is there? You have 15 days to file a report. I mean, the 15 days is the grace period. It's actually supposed to be turned in at the end of the period for which it's covering, but you get 15 days in which to file the report for that period. And I would say within a 15-day period, you should be able to get it turned in.
▶ Play
Speaker 162 49:18
Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Sturge, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Dale Rosa, we've talked several times about it, and I just kind of need to know in my head, basically, if the Secretary of State's office has given you any indication of how much money, ongoing money, it will cost as far as keeping up the electronic system, or if it actually will save money in the long run. For example, I know downstairs, you know, they have people who are constantly having to scan in our paper reports and so forth, and notaries to notarize them for us and so forth. So in my mind, I think it will save money over the long term, but I don't know what the electronic filing system's ongoing cost will be. You know, with electronic voter equipment, there's always ongoing cost with that, except This is, I'm assuming, a server and database and so forth that is already housed here somewhere. So could you answer that question? I'd rather let Kelly
▶ Play
Boyd answer. I know the answer, too, but I'd rather let him answer if he's still in the room. And actually, while he's getting over here, go ahead. That is one, something else that reminded me that I'd like to point out that we have an issue with paper filings right now is they don't always get scanned in. You know, we will fax them in or mail them in, and you're counting on people receiving the mail or receiving faxes to actually get these things in the system. And I know multiple cases where the paper just doesn't make it into the system. And then you think that somebody didn't turn in a report, and it turns out they actually did, and they've got to go back and search through the files to find it. So that's a flaw that we have with paper filing right now that this would alleviate. But I'll let
▶ Play
Speaker 136 51:00
you answer about the cost. If you'd introduce yourself, Mr. Boyd. Kelly Boyd, Chief Deputy, Secretary of
▶ Play
Speaker 138 51:06
State. Representative Sturge, there is an ongoing maintenance cost with any program that we put into the system. Quite frankly, we were going to be replacing this system at some point soon anyway, so we would have incurred that cost. That maintenance cost will not be offset by personnel savings, but personnel savings do exist. It's all hands on deck because we have a timeline that we have to scan these in. So, yes, there is a savings. I just could not quantify it for you because it depends on how many people elect to use the new
▶ Play
Speaker 162 51:37
system. Do you know the just a ballpark figure of the ongoing cost then for the new system? Is there a
▶ Play
Speaker 138 51:44
contract or anything like that? There is, and we have prepaid the first three years, but it will run around. Right now our e-notary system runs around $3,300 a month in the same organization, and we anticipate similar charges. Okay. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Howes, you're recognized for your question. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Representative Del Rosa, for all the work you've done on this, and you have done a tremendous yeoman's work on it, and I appreciate it. And you told me the other day the statement of financial interest, where we list all of our assets and sources of income and all that, will not be filed on this system. Is that still correct?
▶ Play
They will be able to be filed on this system, but this bill does not mandate it. So you will still have the option on statement of financial interest on whether you want to file on paper or if you want to use the new system. I'm correct in that. It will cover that, right? Yeah. So it will have the ability. I'm just not mandating it. There used to be an old
▶ Play
joke that we lived so far back in the country, we didn't get the Saturday night Grand Ole Opry until Sunday afternoon. And I'm one of those people because I've got terrible Internet service out in my neighborhood. Can I bring, under this system, can I bring a thumb drive with my reports on them? They can stick them in the plug and download them? Yes. Good. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Gonzalez, you're recognized for a question. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. So if you choose to do paper filing at the beginning of the election, then you aren't just allowed to do it for the rest of the election. You're actually required to do it for the rest of the
▶ Play
election. Is that correct? That's correct. And the reason for that is the whole point in all of this is to have a usable database for the public. And if folks switch back and forth between paper or electronic, we have no way of knowing what's in and what's out of there. Not to mention, if you go between paper and electronic, the system can't keep up with what happened when you did it on paper. If you file in September electronically, in October on paper, and then in November electronically, there's no way that the system's going to know what you did in between there because it's just a scanned image. So all your cumulative totals are going to be wrong because it's going to have no idea what you did. So you're going to have to stick with one or the other. And additionally, with the exception for the paper filing, we're going to list the paper filing separately. So at least the public will know what is in the system and what is not in the system, which is something we currently don't know today either. And a database that you don't know what's in it and what's not in it is useless to you. Nobody's going to use it because you don't know what's missing. You're just going to have to go through scanned images because that's the only way you're going to know you're not missing anything, assuming even those have all gotten scanned in because they could be sitting in a file in the Secretary of State's office and not have gotten scanned in or missed. So we have a very incomplete information system
▶ Play
currently. Yeah, you're recognized for a follow-up. Is
▶ Play
there no way to go in and update the system? Let's say if you did file paper for a month or two, is there no way to go back into the system and update it yourself? So your numbers would be correct.
▶ Play
Speaker 138 55:09
Yeah, I'm going to let you take that one. Representative Gonzalez, there is a way, but it involves the person making the filing to actually go back and file all this information for each report themselves. And in response to the way this is going to work, we in the Secretary of State's office, whether this bill passes or not, we have to have a signature card that says that you're filing online. All of you that are filing online now already filled one out. This signature card will have a notice on it. It won't be an affidavit, but it'll have a notice on it that tells you that if you start out filing by paper, we expect you to continue to file by paper for that election for that very purpose. If you switch over and start filing electronically and you have three or four months prior to that, the only way the system will track it all is for you to go back and input that information by hand. Even worse is if you start out electronically and then stop. It really creates a problem for the system. So we will not mandate you. We don't have that authority, but we will provide you that notice on your signature card that we need you to go one way or the other.
▶ Play
Representative Hammer, you recognize for a question?
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair, and I'm sorry I missed the demonstration, but just briefly, can you talk about the support services that will be available? Because as stated here, all of us are busy. A lot of times it's at night, and if it's 8 or 9 o'clock at night and I need some assistance, am I going to have to wait until the next day, or can you speak
▶ Play
on that? I'll let you take that one, too.
▶ Play
Speaker 138 57:02
Maybe she'll just have you sit down here. Representative Hammer, if you like what you have now, you'll really like what you have in the future. Our people are good, but they are also local people that work here during the day. If you have trouble on the last night of filing, you're probably going to have a problem, or if you have it on a Saturday or a Sunday. There won't be additional support, but we are committed, before this goes completely live, to ensuring that you've had some really good training.
▶ Play
Okay, so the answer to the question is it'll be a Monday 8 to 4.30 time that we can call and get support. But by the same token, give you a little coverage. Once we get through the first layer of it and it begins a repeat cycle, we should have it known. But the fact would be we wouldn't be able to access you except for 8 to
▶ Play
Speaker 138 57:53
5 Monday through Friday. That is correct. And the system is designed, once you actually see it and begin working, I believe you'll be very happy. It's designed to be an intuitive process, like software is these days. Those of you that file on the system we have now will especially appreciate it. Follow-up,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair? You're recognized. Thank you. This bill is going to force a change of behavior and habits if this thing goes through, which I understand, I appreciate, and I know, Representative Del Rosso, this is a champion piece of legislation for you, and I understand that, and I respect that. So for me to make that kind of decision, I would like you to tell me as far as what this is going to do for the general public to have a greater layer of transparency when they want to look at our records versus the paper to the new technology way, because I do think one thing the public wants is greater transparency. So would you just drill down on that a little bit and tell us how this
▶ Play
is going to help make that happen? That's the entire purpose. So currently, if you want to look up and see who Joe Smith donated to, let's just say that's the question you're wanting to answer. You could do that for past elections, because there is a national institute that takes our paper filings and enters them into their own database. But you're going to have to wait about six months if you're to find that out. if you want to know that during the election, which is usually when people want this kind of information, they want to know where the money's flowing, they're trying to make decisions on who they're going to vote for, they're trying to make these kinds of decisions, this will allow that. They currently do not have that ability, because if I wanted to know who Joe Smith gave money to, let's say I don't want to vote for anybody that Joe Smith gave money for, you would have to pull, oh goodness, I don't know how many hundreds, thousands of paper filings in PDF format and go through them by hand, just skimming through by hand. If this passes and we use this system the way that I have laid out, you will be able to just go into a database with a very nice user interface in it. It's very intuitive. I think the public will really like it. And just type that in and say, who all did he give money to? And it'll be there within a few seconds. I'd like to point out, too, what I'm asking us to do here is not anything that we haven't asked every agency to do for us and everybody that reports into us. I mean, think how absurd or angry we would be if every time we went to the Bureau of Legislative Research and said, can you tell me where in code I need to fix something, they just came and plopped down a big old book and paper and said, go find it. Well, you know, we expect that to be an electronic format. We expect reports to come to us in electronic format because it's such a huge waste of time for us to get the information when electronic filing is available, electronic reporting. So I'm asking us to do and report to the public, our bosses, essentially the same thing that we're requiring everybody do to us. And that's so that we can get the information we need from them in a timely manner. Well, This is so they can get the information from us in a
▶ Play
timely manner. You're recognized for another question. Representative
▶ Play
Hammer. Thank you. You're speaking to one aspect of it, and that is how money flows to the candidate as far as where we get our support to run our campaigns. So I'm curious about the other aspect where it's also problematic that, as I understood in testimony today, is not covered in this, and that is the financial interest statement. Because, you know, if you want to hide something, you can either hide it in one area or hide it in the other. So I'm just curious why you're not going all the
▶ Play
way and asking for the financial interest statement to be on there as well. Because it's a difference. Right now, if I wanted to look at you specifically, just who has Kim Hammer gotten money for or from? Thank you for that clarification. I would have to pull about 12, 15 reports by hand on paper. That's not unachievable right now. It's annoying, but it's not so tedious that it's impossible. What is not currently possible, in my view, is looking across candidates, and that's what this accomplishes. Because if I wanted to know who gave money to all of you guys all together, well, that's a whole different. I mean, it multiplies every time you're trying to look across more and more people. A statement of financial interest, in my opinion, doesn't really aid the public in any way if you file electronically, other than maybe perhaps legibility, because I've seen some that are illegible. So I didn't feel the need to put that in there because I didn't see any reason that the public would want to know an accumulated total between you and 50 other people as to what's on your statement of financial interest because they're so individual. So I felt that paper filing of that as an option didn't impede the public because if they're looking up your statement of financial interest, it's on you specifically, if that makes sense. But I'll be happy to run that next time and try and mandate it. Can that system
▶ Play
expand to where you could do that? If we go with this system, does it have the capabilities to expand to add that feature
▶ Play
next time? Statement of financial interest will already be included. in it. It's just I'm just not mandating that you use it. PACs and lobbyists will also be in this system, but I'm not changing the requirements. Well, lobbyists already have to file electronically anyway. But I'm trying to keep it more narrowly focused. Representative Douglas, you're recognized
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:03:44
for your question. Yes, thank you for your work on this. If the lobbyists are already and the PACs are already doing this electronically. If you were wanting to look at who is getting money from who, can't you go that
▶ Play
Speaker 183 1:04:01
route? PACs do not have to follow
▶ Play
electronically. They have the option right now, same as we do. Only lobbyists are required. Lobbyists are the only ones that we've mandated have to do it electronically.
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:04:16
Coming next week. So you have that capability of looking at the lobbyists and seeing who they've given to. You can search the lobbyist reports.
▶ Play
Right. Well, you can search lobbyists to see who they've given money to because they have to file electronically. Most of the lobbyist reports, really, all that's in there, though, is their expenses and things like that. if you've gone to look through the lobbyist reports, they don't tend to give donations directly. They do it through PACs. So the lobbyist reports really aren't useful in terms of campaign finance research. And I think I
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:04:58
would disagree with you on the 15 days being just a grace period. My year on my taxes ends in January, but I have until April to try to gather up all that information, try to get it packaged up, get it recorded. And I would say that 15 days is there for us to close out that period of time that we're reporting on and get our report together. And if something happens, and I'm still working on it on that 15th day, I think you need to make allowances for things to go wrong. And we're not penalized and in a panic, you know, trying to drive down here at midnight to get a report in if that's what happens. So, you know, I would be happier with you looking at possibilities of, you know, what's going to happen at the ninth hour and the Internet being out or, you know, the facts not working. And those are all things that happen to us in real life. So one of the things that's very nice illness, yeah, you're in the hospital. I mean, there's just lots
▶ Play
of things that happen. One of the things that's nice about this new system is it is not report based. It's transaction based, which means it works almost like an electronic checkbook. It's probably the easiest way to compare it. You can go in at any time, any time during, during, um, whenever the transactions occur, if you want to, and you can enter in these transactions anytime you want. So you don't have to wait until your election period, the reporting period has closed in order to even start putting this stuff in. You can do it just like you would in your checkbook. And when it's time for the report to be filed, first of all, the system will tell you it's time for the report to be filed, which is something we don't currently have right now that comes by mail, which means It's probably sitting in our P.O. boxes at home right now, if we have any reports due. It will tell you when it's due, and it will generate the report for you. So, I mean, if you're thinking that the new system is how the current one works, it's not how it is. Because the current system, you have to go in and you have to open up and create a new report, and then you have to start filling it out. And if you lose your Internet connection, oh, crud, I've lost this. Now I've got to start all over again. That's not how this one works at all. If the system goes down while you're entering something, you will just lose one line, one transaction, and you just have to start that one transaction over again. And by transaction, I mean either a donation or an expenditure. So it doesn't function the same way. I see that.
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:07:44
You know, I think a lot of people would be more comfortable with this if you had said, let's run a pilot for a year, let's let everybody get comfortable with it, Let's work out the kinks and let's give it a year to, you know, come back in and finalize it.
▶ Play
That's one possibility. But by the same token, I have a feeling that it doesn't matter what I do. There's always going to be something that's not going to be liked about it. There
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:08:17
are a lot of things about a pilot that really bring people, you know, to a comfort level because they see it working and they don't have that mandate that they've got to do it either paper or this other way, and then they kind of work through that process of making that transition. I would just suggest that maybe if you have great numbers of people that still aren't comfortable with it.
▶ Play
Well, again, there will be training during the entire summer, and it will be, what, four months, I think, before we start requiring usage. So you'll have four months of being able to play with it, use it, try it out while training is going on. So if you do have any kinks, if you do have any issues, Secretary of State's office is going to be conducting training. So it will be available if four months seemed sufficient to me to be able for everybody to get comfortable with using the system. And it'll be during a period of time when you don't really have very many transactions. So we didn't want to start it in November or October when you're in a crunch for the election, and now you've got to figure out how to use this new system. We were trying to hit a time period when it would be easiest on everybody. So they weren't in such a crunch to, you know, because you know how it is with campaigns, and I wouldn't put that on anybody. So I was trying to do it during the summer. That seems the easiest on everyone. And the goal with this, I mean, I'm not, I tried to hit both sides of this with this new system, and that's why we ended up doing it. I tried to make it so it was a win-win. It was a win for us because we have a lot of things that go wrong with our reports right now that are no fault of our own, and it becomes very tedious. There's a lot of negative things that we deal with right now, and I was trying to fix a lot of those. But by the same token, I wanted to make sure that the public got their piece out of it, which was the ultimate goal, and that was usable
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:10:22
database. And I guess that's my question as well. That's the balance I was trying to strike. I don't see a public outcry at the grassroots level. I'm not having any mail on this. I've never had anybody say, we'd like for you guys to be more transparent in your filing. It's a question as to where really this is being driven from. if it's not grassroots Arkansas, you know, who are we really making this easier for? And I would just close with that. Thank
▶ Play
you. Representative Davis, you're recognized for a question. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chairman. If you don't mind, my question is really for Mr. Sloan, if
▶ Play
you wouldn't mind. If you would, Mr. Sloan, if you'll
▶ Play
introduce yourself for the record. Graham Sloan, the director of the
▶ Play
Arkansas Ethics Commission. All right. Thank you, Mr. Sloan. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Director Sloan, my question for you is to try to clarify a point. We've had a couple of questions regarding, you know, what if something happens, whether it be illness and family or websites down or what have you, and an electronic filing isn't completed by the deadline on the 15th. Is it correct that current law allows a 30-day cure period for a member to file or correct an error in a filing? Yes, if
▶ Play
the filing was made on time, but the cure period wouldn't be to file something that had not been filed on time.
▶ Play
Okay. Is there any reason why we couldn't add an allowance, say the Secretary of State's office certifies that a website was down for some period of time to extend that deadline by the same amount of time? Well, that power
▶ Play
actually exists. The Secretary of State's office is the filing, the place of filing. The Ethics Commission is the enforcement agency. But in situations like the one described where somebody's sick or the Internet's down, if you want to go with that example, the commission, neither the commission nor its staff has the authority to extend that deadline. But I think those type circumstances would constitute good cause. And so the person who, and we've had that case, You know, I was in the hospital the day that was due, and so that would be good cause for missing the deadline. So while the commission doesn't have the authority to extend a deadline, it can recognize those type of circumstances which are beyond the filer's control would be good cause shown, and there wouldn't be any sanction imposed. To your knowledge, has anybody ever
▶ Play
had a sanction imposed for missing a deadline by a day or two? Actually, yes, but not for good cause. No, sir. Okay. No. Not with good cause. No,
▶ Play
and, you know, there was an ice storm, you know, and then the telephone lines were down, and people couldn't even drive to the post office because a lot of those same causes exist. You know, I mean, if you file electronically, you can do it from home. If you're filing on paper, you've either got to come to the Secretary of State's office or at least make it to the post office. But, you know, the bridge is out. I couldn't get to town to the post office. You know, those type examples exist. You know, sickness, you know, it doesn't matter if you're electronic or paper filer, you missed the deadline because you were sick. So, you know, but there, you know, no, if somebody demonstrates circumstances beyond their control, that's good cause shown. And so that's already built into the existing system. Okay. Thank you, sir. Representative Leidyman, you're recognized for your
▶ Play
question. Yes, Representative De La Rosa. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I hope I can formulate this question so you can understand what I'm asking here. But what you said, I believe, was that, let's just use an example. If I had an expense today, I could go fill out that report, put that expense in there for February report, correct? So I could file it with the new system. Correct.
▶ Play
You wouldn't be filing it in a report. You'd just be putting a transaction in. The new system, you just put in your transactions almost like a checkbook. And then when filings are due, when reports are due, it says, hey, a report is due, and would you like to file it? And you click yes, and it generates everything. It completes the report based on the transactions that you've put in. But, yes, you could put them in every single day if
▶ Play
you wanted to. Let me finish my question or restate it, maybe. But if I enter that today, I have filed a report in February. No. So, okay, how does it know when I file my report then? When you click yes, I
▶ Play
want to file the report. Oh, until it's complete. Right. You will enter in the transactions, and then when a report is due, it will notify you that a report is due, and it will pick out of the transactions that you have entered in what is due in that report. So you don't even have to worry about did I get this transaction in the correct report or not, because sometimes it gets a little fuzzy, does it go in this report or this other one? It will take care of all that because it's going to have all of our rules built into it. It will show you what the report is going to look like just to make sure you're happy with it, and then you click Submit. But the transactions are stored independently, so you can put them in at any time, and then you just click Generate Report and Submit at that time. But it does not create or file a report until you tell
▶ Play
it to. Okay, thank you. Representative
▶ Play
Smith, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative De La Rosa, I'm on board with you on this. I really appreciate the hard work you've done to bring us this far along, and I'd like to see this passed into law. I traditionally am one of those late filers. Until the grandkids go to bed, I'm moving around and taking care of other things. But I do appreciate it. But I do have one question. In addition to transparency and efficiency, is there any other motivation for wanting to place this in front of your legislators, your colleagues, and folks that need to file online? No hidden agenda then. No, I don't even know what the hidden agenda would be. I know, and that's
▶ Play
why I'm asking is because I've had people.
▶ Play
It's so hidden, I don't know what it is. Well, I've had people come to me with conspiracy theory type things, and I just said, that's not the case. That's not, this is going to make what we do and what we raise, what we spend and how we file a lot easier to access. And I look forward to that. So I appreciate what you've
▶ Play
done. Thank you. No, there is no hidden agenda with it. And I've heard the same theories. And all I can say is if you if you're subscribing to any of those, they're not the case. This is not so people can come after candidates any easier. You guys already know that you can become anybody can come after you right now. So clearly this is not going to enable something that doesn't exist. And this is not so anybody can target donors. I've heard that one as well, because that can already also be done. They can't do it during the election, but they can do it a few months after, after this is all entered into a national database. So everything, all the fears that I have heard circulating around, this will not affect those in any way, because those things can already happen. This is just trying to make it efficient and convenient and transparent for the people of Arkansas, and additionally, safer for us and more convenient and efficient for us to file. Representative Gray, you're recognized for a question. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. And thank you, Representative De La Rosa, for bringing this. I don't have any issues with it, necessarily. I have one question, though, as I read through it that I did not notice earlier. The start date, it's down here somewhere, is October 1st of this year. Correct. So part of the argument has been why you can't go back and forth is the cumulative totals won't work. But for this first, if you're going to start in October instead of at the beginning of an election cycle, none of our cumulative totals will carry over
▶ Play
anyhow. Your first filing, and we've had a lot of discussion about which way to go with that. Your first filing, you will just put in what your starting totals are, because there's no way for the system to know what's happened prior to that. And if you've been filing electronically, that's going to be really easy. If you've been filing on paper, you're going to have to look at your last report and just enter that in. But that's all you're going to have to do is put in what your cumulative totals are. So what, that'd be two numbers I think you'd have to put in there. And from that point forward, it will generate off of those. It's one of those things, we have an incomplete database right now. So you've got to draw a line at some point and say from henceforth, it will be clean, it will be complete, and I did not want to mandate that the Secretary of State's office have to go back and enter that information in, and I did not want to mandate that we go back and enter that information in, so I thought the best fix would be we just draw a line in the sand, and from this point
▶ Play
forward, it's going to be clean. In a follow-up, Mr. Chair? You are recognized, yes. Would it be easier just to start at the next election cycle, just from
▶ Play
scratch, clean, where everybody's on the same page? That was our other option, but you would have to wait through a year and a half. Am I adding that up right? It would be another year and a half before we could even start back up with that. And having spent three quarters of a million dollars, I didn't really want to have to explain to the public why it would take us essentially almost two years from passage today in order to get to that. So it was either start in the summer when everybody doesn't have very much going on and we've had time to get trained, and if you have any issues, they're training at that time, and then draw a line in the sand or explain to everybody why it takes us two years to start filing on something we spent three quarters of a million dollars on. So that was the subjective decision.
▶ Play
Thank you. President Hammer, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. One question to Graham, please. Graham, can you tell us from your perspective dealing with ethics, will a move such as this make your job easier, more difficult? Will you be able to identify things that potentially could violate ethics in a better manner? What would be the value and the asset that this would create for you to be able to carry out your
▶ Play
duties? Well, the first thing that comes to my mind is we look at a lot of reports, and believe it or not, legibility is an issue, and so, you know, an electronically filed report is legible, and we get calls, somebody has looked at a report, and basically the complaint to us is, it's like, this is meaningless because I can't read any of this, I can't decipher it. And we've got certain people on staff that are better at deciphering than others. And, but I mean, you know, we'll, we'll have to, um, you know, I mean, it really is hard sometimes. And then we'll end up sending a letter just saying, Hey, this filing is, you know, unreadable. Could you please resubmit it? And so I think, you know, legibility would be an issue, that we would review a filing once a complaint is made, and a lot of the errors we see are, it's just simple math errors, you know, somebody gets some numbers transposed and it adds up wrong, and so I think to the extent that this system is going to calculate that, you know, hopefully it would, you know, it's going to do it better than the human would, and this system is just such an improvement over the old system that, you know, the old one was built from the ground up, and then there are companies out there that market this type of software, you know, develop it, and so this is, you know, this is well-oiled software that it's just going to be an improvement over the existing system anyway. That's all I got, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Thank you. Okay. Seeing no further questions, we do have one individual from the audience who signed up to speak, Mr. Josh Waters with Political Strategies. He's signed up to speak for the bill. Mr. Waters, if you would introduce yourself for the record.
▶ Play
You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is Josh Waters. I'm an attorney with Political Strategies. and our client is Conduit for Action, and I'm here to speak in favor of Representative De La Rosa's bill. I appreciate her for bringing this forward. I'm not sure, I hope most of you are aware of Conduit for Action. It's a 501c4 organization focused on economic freedom and individual liberty, but another aspect we focus on is government transparency, and we think this is a great bill to have more government transparency for the people of Arkansas. all. There's been a lot of talk about a searchable database. I think that would be a great asset to the people. A few years ago, I actually set up some spreadsheets to be used for grassroots individuals and volunteers for a separate organization to basically track. And we would have to print off all the reports and look individually and make sure, is this the right total? Is this the right name? And so this would make it much easier for people to access that information, look and track the money and follow the money. Um, so I, you know, I don't think there's any hidden agendas or anything. It's just, um, more transparency. And I think when there's more government transparency, there's more accountability in government. And so that's why Conduit for Action is supporting this bill. And so we thank Representative De La Rosa and we would appreciate the other representatives to vote for this bill. Thank you. We have,
▶ Play
I do have a couple of questions, but before I do, I should have covered a bit of housekeeping, is communications actually was set to meet in here at 1130, and they are moved to room 130, so if anybody in here is here for communications, they will be in room 130. All right, we do have a couple of people who have requested a question, so Representative Hammer, you are recognized for a question. Thank
▶ Play
you. I appreciate your acknowledgment of transparency and the interest to make sure that everything is clear. So my question for you is, when your organization sends out mailings, do you identify on each mailing that you send out that is being sent from you?
▶ Play
I have not been involved in any mailing, so I
▶ Play
cannot answer that question. All right. Thank you. Thank you,
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:25:55
Mr. Chair. All right. Representative Douglas, you're recognized for a question. Yes. You know, I understand you wanting this to be a transparency issue. Where does conduit stand on the transparency of PACS, you know, giving that information out? Thank you
▶ Play
for that question, Representative Douglas. If y'all have seen our scorecard we send out, we actually put that we would support even further for PACS, lobbyists, all filings that have to be filed. We think that would be great to be included as well so that the people have more access to look at the full spectrum of any money coming into campaigns. I know that this is kind of a first step in that process, so we're fully supportive of this bill. But in the future, if that wanted to be added, that would be something we would be supportive of as well. All right. Thank you
▶ Play
very much. Thank you. Okay. Is there any other
▶ Play
questions from the committee? Mr. Chair, I had someone else that wanted to speak, and I thought they had signed in to speak for the bill, but I think they were expecting me to pull them to the table. So between the two, he hasn't gotten a chance to speak.
▶ Play
So if I could. Well, let me, Mr. Waters, are you finished? Yes, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Okay. I appreciate your testimony today. Is there anybody else in the audience who wanted to speak for or against this piece
▶ Play
Speaker 224 1:27:23
legislation? Good morning. My name is David J. Sacker. I'm the Executive Director of Judicial Discipline and Disability. It's an honor to be here. I apologize for not signing in. I thought I would be called up here by the sponsor. I just want to point out a few things, and you've had a lot of discussion already, but we don't support a whole lot of bills because we leave it to the legislative branch to decide policy. But when it comes to judicial issues, we certainly are always in favor of transparency. And this is an issue that is even more important for judicial elections. And while I know the sponsor definitely wants this to be in place for all levels of government, I encourage you to look at it even stronger when it comes to the judicial role. And that's because when it comes to an independent magistrate, we need to know who supported the judge, and we need to know in a timely, organized fashion. If I'm in a lawsuit and it is against a certain industry or a person or people from certain areas, and I can't sort that quickly, I might have a three to five day period to be in a temporary hearing. I get a negative result. Then I get the information because I finally go through all those reports. And as you know, judges don't like for you to make a motion to recuse after you've already gotten your initial result as if you laid behind the log. So we put a lot of it to be incumbent upon the lawyers and the parties to know whether they should make a motion to recuse in this case this would be perfect for allowing people to quickly go through and make a reasonable motion that a judge could consider so that's really where we stand on that as far as being able to go through there was a couple questions i thought i mean i know representative douglas when you were mentioning a pilot program while i i do hope the bill is considered in whole i i would consider uh, suggesting as well that for the judiciary, this would be, there'd be no reason not to impose this already. Uh, judges should be willing to type in who they get their money from and answer questions about whether they can be fair. Um, while legislators are elected by people who support certain positions, and that's what we expect of you, judges are not supposed to be leaning towards one way or the other, and that's a vital part of due process. Um, and as far as, uh, representative Hammer had a question about accessibility of the staff. Of course, no matter what issue you had before paper or electronic, at closing time, it's hard to get in touch with somebody. I can say this. On our behalf, I give safe haven to a lot of our judges. They contact me at all hours, text me or whatever, and so if they were to call me or text me and say I'm trying to get my reports in, we would be there to also explain that to Graham if if it became an issue, and say to the Ethics Commission, we did have contact with that judge. They all have my cell phone. They could text me. They could try to make that or email us late and say, I'm trying to do that. But basically, we don't have any opinion on carryover funds because judges don't have it. There are some other parts of the bill that don't apply to us. However, it's incredibly important for the judiciary to go forward without having people to go through mounds of paper months later to try to figure out whether they needed to make a motion and then lawyers face consequences on appeal, malpractice suits, all kinds of things where it could be simple in a sortable database. And I'll be happy to answer any questions on this or any other issue that anyone on the committee
▶ Play
has. Okay. I don't see any questions from the committee. I appreciate your testimony. Thank you very much. Okay. Are there any other questions from the committee and for the bill sponsor? All right. Not seeing any. I don't believe anybody else has signed up to speak for or against. Representative De La Rosa, you recognize the close for
▶ Play
your bill. I know that there's another committee that needs to be. I'm actually on that committee, and I know that Representative Saban is vice chair of it, so we need to get moving. So I'll just, I think all the arguments have been made on this. I
▶ Play
would just appreciate a good vote. Okay, and what's the will of the committee? We have a motion from Representative Hammer, do pass as amended. Motion do pass as amended. Yes.
▶ Play
Yeah. Is there any discussion on it? I just want to say I've heard you present this over the last, you know, two sessions. And I'm one of those guys that do it by paper, I fax it in, I have two witnesses to make sure it's in before midnight and go to a lot of effort to make sure I'm not singled out. I think you're trying to bring a change of habit that is better for the transparency of the public and should help conserve energy both at the Secretary of State but also as testified by David. And so I wanted to speak openly for it as one of those that's going to have to change some habits, but I think it will be a good change because I can get it done on the first day or I can get it done on the 15th. That's going to be my choice. So I wanted to explain why I'm going to vote for this bill. Thank
▶ Play
you. All right. I promised this committee that we would have discussion, and I haven't been doing that, so I appreciate Representative Hamber slowing me down a little bit. Is there any other discussion on the motion? Would you have a motion on the table? Do pass. Okay. Seeing no further discussion, all in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed, say nay. Nay. The ayes have it. Congratulations, Representative De La Rosa, you pass your bill. Thank you, committee. All right, Representative Drown, I know that we're waning, but you're recognized if you want to present your bill. You're recognized to present House Bill 1450. I don't think we have any other bills that we're seeing outside of this one.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Her name is State Representative Trevor
▶ Play
Speaker 230 1:33:32
Drown. Mr. Speaker, I'm Danielle Fusco, Notary Public Administrator with the Secretary
▶ Play
of State's office. And I'm going to let her go through the bill and entertain
▶ Play
Speaker 230 1:33:42
any questions. All right. This bill is in three sections. The first section modifies our current code pertaining to fees that could be collected by notaries. It's going to remove the maximum $5 cap and actually provide a free market solution for fees that notaries can charge. The second section adds a statement that an employer cannot cancel the surety bond of a notary. So it is a requirement that a notary have a type of insurance policy in order to be in good standing. So if this was to be canceled, this would be essentially like driving without car insurance. You could still have the car, still have your notary stamp, but you would not be in compliant, would be violating the law. And the third section adds clear guidance for notaries concerning what is a complete and proper notarial act. This applies to just typical notarizations like when you file your statements of financial interest, simple acknowledgement statement, as well as provides guidelines if someone needs to use a signature by mark or if someone cannot make a signature or a mark, It provides guidelines for allowing somebody else to make that signature for them. Okay. Are there any questions
▶ Play
from the committee? Representative Sabin, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
One important aspect of any kind of free market is information and competition. Is there a database or any kind of place that somebody could go to know what notary publics are available in their area so that if somebody is charging and when in their mind maybe too high of a fee, something they can't afford for something they really need to get done, that they could find somebody else to do it or at least know what their
▶ Play
Speaker 230 1:35:24
options are? Absolutely. We do have a free online public search feature, and you can narrow it down by your location. And we do have 50,593 notaries, so you're going to have plenty of options to find a notary. And this fee does have to be agreed upon between the notary and the client prior to the act taking place. So the client will know what the price is beforehand. Representative Douglas, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:35:54
question. Yes, thank you. Does this prohibit someone from doing this service for free? Absolutely not.
▶ Play
Speaker 235 1:36:00
We actually modified that law two years ago. Okay. Thank you. Just making sure. Okay. Are
▶ Play
there any other questions from the committee? We have a motion on the table. Are you closed for your presentation, Representative Drown? I'm closed and recommend do pass. Okay. So we have a motion do pass from Representative Drown. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Congratulations. You passed your bill. Representative Tosh, do you do have a bill you're wanting to run? Okay, well, let's get it off the agenda if we can do it. Representative Tosh, which bill are you running? Is it 1430? Yes, sir. That's correct. Okay. You're recognized around 1430. Mr. Chair, with your permission, could I have the director
▶ Play
of the Law Enforcement Training Academy join me at the end of the table? Yes, you may. If you would introduce yourself for the
▶ Play
Speaker 238 1:37:17
record, please. Hello, I'm Jamie Cook. I'm the director of the Arkansas Commission on Law Enforcement Standards and Training.
▶ Play
Okay. You all are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This bill here was brought to me by the Law Enforcement Training Academy. This is to eliminate some obsolete language and also make some technical corrections. And what I'll do is I'll try to just go through this as quickly as possible. And then if we have any questions, the director is here at the end of the table to hopefully answer those with me. But what it does, we just start out in the bill to, like I said, to eliminate obsolete language. An example, on page one, the Arkansas Police Corps Planning Commission, that commission was federally funded. Those federal funds have run out. That program no longer exists, so we're just removing it from state statute. On page two, in the definition of a law enforcement agency, we've added the Black River Law Enforcement Academy of O'Connor, as most of the language in our statutes refer to Arkansas Alita. We've changed that so that they are also included because they are a state-funded law enforcement training academy. And then at the bottom of that page, we give a definition for on page two of law enforcement officers. And as you can see, that does not include a law enforcement officer who is elected by qualified electors or political subdivision is simply what that means. Committee is that the laws that allows law enforcement officers in this state to have statutory statutory authority to enforce the law is done through statute and an elected official such as a sheriff or constable they are constitutional officers and their authority comes from the Constitution so that's why we want to make sure that that was clearly stated in this piece of legislation the only other thing we did on page three was we simply made sure that the Arkansas Municipal League has a member on the Arkansas Commission of course that's That's someone that's appointed by the governor, and really not any changes on four or page five or just more obsolete language on page six. The only thing that of significance here might want to point out is on page seven, where we under number 18, where we impose administrative penalties against law enforcement agencies or governmental entities of violations. The reason the need for this paragraph here is that currently, when minimum standards, if they go into a law enforcement agency and they find where they're not in compliance with the qualifications, an example, maybe they're working an officer that's a part two officer and they're working in 40 to 60 hours a week. The only penalties that minimum standards can impose is against the officer and all they do is just remove him from service where there's no penalties imposed on the agency. So all they do is just turn around and hire someone else and continue on. So this is to give minimum standards some type of authority to be able to hopefully regulate and keep those agencies in compliance with what's expected of our police officers. And then on just again, we strike in some obsolete language as we go through that. Page 8, it gives the minimum standard law enforcement training academy and standards. It gives them the authority if they find an officer that is working, that is not met the qualifications of law enforcement officers, such as no psychological test, no high school diploma. It just gives them the authority to remove them from service. And then the rest of it is just imposition of administrative penalties on page nine. Again, just giving them the authority to take what action they need. Also, we have some language where, for constables, we've changed their training hours and made it available to them if they want to attend from 120 to 110 to 160 hours, and the reason that's necessary that, again, constables are under the Constitution and not state statutory, and if they want to have access to the ACIC and NCIC, then they have to attend this course and to be able to meet the standards, to be able to access those files. The rest of that on page 10, again, is basically just the imposition of the authority granted to the Law Enforcement Training Academy, page 11, page 12, looks like the same language on 15, and just minor technical changes the rest of the way out. So that's a quick, quick overview of this statute. It's like I said, it's taking out a lot of obsolete language, make sure the definition of some things are clearly stated in this bill, and also make some technical corrections. All right, are there any questions from the committee?
▶ Play
I have one, and I've lost the space in it, but where it actually takes out the definition of a law enforcement officer for anybody who's elected. My question is, how does that functionally make a difference, especially when we talk about, let's say, a sheriff, for instance? I mean, I could see it being maybe different with a constable or sheriff, but does that have any impact? I've got an answer, but I think
▶ Play
you'll probably get a better answer from the director, so I'll let her answer. A
▶ Play
Speaker 238 1:42:48
sheriff does not have to be certified through the Commission on Law Enforcement Standards and training, and all of our statutes deal with statutory police officers, so the definition just reiterates that a sheriff does not fall under our rules, so long as a constable does not fall under our rules. The exception to that with constables is that if they want access to ACIC, NCIC, that they have to complete a certified training by us. That's the only difference.
▶ Play
And they're currently not being certified at all? Constables aren't?
▶ Play
Speaker 238 1:43:21
No, there is no certification for constables.
▶ Play
Right. I just want to make sure that we're not taking something away from them by changing that definition at all. All right. Are there any other questions from the committee? All right. Seeing none, you're recognized to close. I don't guess anybody from the audience is here to speak for or against. Okay. You're recognized to close for your bill, Representative Tosh. Mr. Chair, committee,
▶ Play
thank you. And I'm closed. I ask for a good vote. Okay. Is that
▶ Play
a motion for due pass? That is a motion, Mr. Chair. Okay, we have a motion due pass from Representative Tosh. Any discussion on that motion? All right, all in favor say aye. Aye. And opposed say nay.
▶ Play

Agenda

SB22 Bledsoe TO AMEND THE DEADLINE FOR CONDUCTING LOGIC AND ACCURACY TESTING FOR RUNOFF ELECTIONS.

26:24 - 41:36 62 segments 13 speakers

HB1427 Della Rosa TO EXPAND THE USE OF TECHNOLOGY TO IMPROVE CAMPAIGN FINANCE TRANSPARENCY, ACCURACY, AND CONVENIENCE, AND TO AMEND PORTIONS OF LAW RESULTING FROM INITIATED ACT 1 OF 1990 AND INITIATED ACT 1 OF 1996.

41:36 - 2:44

HB1429 Tosh CONCERNING THE DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION; CONCERNING THE ADMINISTRATION OF THE AGREEMENT OF DETAINERS; AND CONCERNING A DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION ANNUAL REPORT.

2:44 - 1:36:42 341 segments 32 speakers

HB1430 Tosh CONCERNING LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER STANDARDS AND TRAINING; CONCERNING THE ARKANSAS COMMISSION ON LAW ENFORCEMENT STANDARDS AND TRAINING; TO REPEAL OBSOLETE LANGUAGE; AND TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS.

1:36:42 - 32:57

HB1440 M. Gray TO AMEND PROVISIONS IN THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING ELECTION RUNOFFS, INITIATIVES, AND REFERENDA.

HB1441 M. Gray TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE PAYMENT OF EXPENSES FOR PRESIDENTIAL ELECTORS.

32:57 - 1:33:10 213 segments 23 speakers

HB1447 M. Gray TO TRANSFER THE STATE BOARD OF ELECTION COMMISSIONERS TO THE OFFICE OF SECRETARY OF STATE; TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING COMPLAINTS OF ELECTION LAW VIOLATIONS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1450 Drown TO CLARIFY ARKANSAS LAW RELATED TO NOTARIES PUBLIC.

1:33:10 - 36:14

HB1452 S. Meeks TO AMEND THE EMERGENCY INTERIM EXECUTIVE AND JUDICIAL SUCCESSION ACT.

36:14 - 15:30

SB256 Irvin TO TRANSFER THE ARKANSAS ENERGY OFFICE TO THE ARKANSAS DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY.

SB257 Irvin TO TRANSFER THE OFFICE OF HEALTH INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY TO THE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH; AND TO AMEND THE DUTIES OF THE OFFICE OF HEALTH INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY.

HB1404 A. Mayberry TO CLARIFY THE ADMINISTRATIVE RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE TREASURER OF STATE REGARDING THE ACHIEVING A BETTER LIFE EXPERIENCE PROGRAM; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

15:30 - 28:17 43 segments 7 speakers

HB1443 M. Gray TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF CHIROPRACTIC EXAMINERS.

28:17 - 1:44:03 266 segments 29 speakers

DEFERRED BILLS

Number Subtitle Sponsor

HB1008 Tucker TO INCREASE THE PENALTY FOR TAKING CAMPAIGN FUNDS AS PERSONAL INCOME; AND TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF ARKANSAS LAW RESULTING FROM INITIATED ACT 1 OF 1990 AND INITIATED ACT 1 OF 1996.

HB1005 Tucker TO REQUIRE REPORTING AND DISCLOSURE OF ELECTIONEERING COMMUNICATIONS; AND TO RESTRICT THE AMOUNT OF MONEY SPENT ON CAMPAIGN COMMUNICATIONS PRODUCED IN COORDINATION WITH A CANDIDATE FOR OFFICE.

HB1004 Blake TO CREATE THE DEMOCRACY ACT; TO REQUIRE AUTOMATIC VOTER REGISTRATION; AND TO AMEND AMENDMENT 51 OF THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION.

HB1046 Tucker TO PERMIT PAID MATERNITY LEAVE FOR STATE EMPLOYEES.

HJR1001 Ballinger APPLYING TO THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS TO CALL A CONVENTION FOR PROPOSING AMENDMENTS PURSUANT TO ARTICLE V OF THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION.

HB1010 Sabin TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE PUBLICATION OF CERTAIN CAMPAIGN FINANCE REPORTS.

HB1011 Sabin TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE CONTRIBUTIONS; AND TO PROHIBIT DIRECT CONTRIBUTIONS BETWEEN POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEES.

HB1012 Sabin TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEES; AND TO FROM POLITICAL COMMITTEES PROHIBIT DIRECT CONTRIBUTIONS ACTION TO CANDIDATES

HB1065 Watson PERMITTING THE ARKANSAS COMMISSION ON LAW ENFORCEMENT STANDARDS AND TRAINING TO MAKE ADDITIONAL SALARY PAYMENTS ABOVE THE BASIC CERTIFICATE LEVEL.

HB1151 Davis TO REQUIRE THAT REGISTERED VOTERS BE NOTIFIED BY MAIL OF THE DATES FOR CERTAIN SPECIAL ELECTIONS; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING SPECIAL ELECTIONS.

HB1179 Ballinger TO AMEND PROVISIONS PROVIDING DEATH BENEFITS TO DESIGNATED BENEFICIARIES OR SURVIVORS OF POLICE OF OFFICERS.

HB1207 Dalby TO AMEND REQUIREMENTS FOR CAMPAIGN SIGNS AND MATERIALS.

HB1009 Leding TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING APPROVED POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEES; AND TO PREVENT A MEMBER OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY FROM FORMING MORE THAN ONE (1) APPROVED POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE.

HB1270 Johnson TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ELECTIONS AND BALLOTS.

HB1289 Ballinger TO PROMOTE AND IMPROVE EFFICIENCY AND QUALITY IN THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES; AND TO REORGANIZE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES.

HB1386 Lemons TO REQUIRE THE FILING OF FINAL AGENCY RULES WITH THE ARKANSAS STATE LIBRARY; AND TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURE ACT.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Bob Ballinger Chair Unverified
61 segments
Representative Andy Davis Unverified
15 segments
Representative Dwight Tosh Unverified
24 segments
Speaker 24
14 segments
Representative Douglas House Unverified
20 segments
Representative Jeff Wardlaw Unverified
1 segment
Solomon Graves Unverified
14 segments
Chair Unverified
2 segments
Representative Kim Hammer Unverified
30 segments
Representative Jim Dotson Unverified
73 segments
Representative Andy Mayberry Unverified
14 segments
Speaker 70
1 segment
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
19 segments
Speaker 129
1 segment
Speaker 132
1 segment
Speaker 136
2 segments
Speaker 138
14 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
11 segments
Representative Jon S. Eubanks Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 147
1 segment
Speaker 162
3 segments
Representative Justin Gonzales Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 183
1 segment
Graham Sloan Unverified
10 segments
Representative Jack Ladyman Unverified
3 segments
Representative Brandt Smith Unverified
3 segments
Josh Waters Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 224
8 segments
Representative Trevor Drown Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 230
6 segments
Representative Warwick Sabin Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 235
1 segment
Speaker 238
4 segments