Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Public Health, Welfare and Labor Committee

February 9, 2017 ·Committee Room 130 ·1:49:29
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (36)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1411 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…presentative Penzo, you're recognized to present your bill. House bill 1411 right yes sir all right you're recognized go ahead all righ…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1437 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…passed. uh vice chair ferguson you ready to go represent uh house bill 1437 i think we have some is there some amendments yes uh thank…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1478 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “the run house bill 1478. Mr. Chairman members What this bill does, it changes the l…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1021 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1021 Love TO PROVIDE PAY EQUITY FOR WOMEN; AND TO AMEND THE WAGE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1034 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1034 C. Fite TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING HEARING INSTRUMENT DIS…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1040 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1040 Farrer TO LIMIT THE PRACTICE OF ATHLETIC TRAINING IN A NONC…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1160 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1160 A. Mayberry TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF A "SPECIALIST SIGN E…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1180 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1180 Bentley TO AUTHORIZE ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES TO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1181 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1181 Sullivan TO CREATE THE TRANSITION TO PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1182 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1182 Sullivan TO AUTHORIZE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO ALLO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1183 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1183 Dotson TO PROVIDE CONSISTENCY AND EFFICIENCY OF CHIROPRACTI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1186 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1186 Brown TO REMOVE THE COLLABORATIVE PRACTICE AGREEMENT AS APP…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1204 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1204 Magie TO ALLOW PHARMACISTS TO MAKE BIOLOGICAL PRODUCT SUBST…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1205 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1205 Magie TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS ANESTHESIOLOGIST ASSISTANT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1215 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1215 Love TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING THE PRACTICE OF MASSAGE TH…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1228 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1228 Hammer TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY OF AN ADVANCED P…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1237 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1237 Hammer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS SURGICAL TECHNOLOGISTS ACT; A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1250 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1250 M. Gray TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS DENTAL PRACTICE ACT; TO AMEND…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1254 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1254 Magie TO TRANSFER REGULATORY AUTHORITY OVER ADVANCED PRACTI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1255 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1255 D. Ferguson TO CREATE A TEMPORARY CHARITABLE DENTAL LICENSE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1257 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1257 Richey TO CREATE THE COMMUNITY HEALTH WORKER ACT.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1264 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1264 Pilkington TO PROVIDE FOR REIMBURSEMENT FOR HEALTHCARE SERV…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1300 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1300 Miller TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES TO PRIOR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1405 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1405 Lundstrum TO AMEND LAWS RELEVANT TO UNEMPLOYMENT TAXES, UNE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1413 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1413 Boyd TO CREATE THE ALTERNATIVE TO DISCIPLINE ACT; AND TO PR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1428 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1428 Lundstrum TO AMEND LAWS CONCERNING UNLAWFUL ABORTIONS; TO A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1434 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1434 Collins TO CREATE THE SEX DISCRIMINATION BY ABORTION PROHIB…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1439 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1439 M. Gray TO AMEND THE HEALTHCARE QUALITY AND PAYMENT POLICY…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1462 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1462 McCollum TO AFFIRM THE LEGISLATIVE AUTHORITY OVER WAIVERS F…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1465 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1465 Miller TO CREATE THE MEDICAID EXPANSION ENROLLMENT FREEZE A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1472 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1472 Ladyman TO EXPAND THE AUTHORIZATION FOR THE USE OF TEMPORAR…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB170 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB170 Irvin TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION FOR LICENSURE FOR HEALTHCARE P…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB191 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB191 E. Cheatham TO ELIMINATE THE RECORD MAINTENANCE FEE FOR VIS…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB229 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB229 S. Flowers TO REQUIRE CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECKS FOR ALCOHO…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB78 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB78 Bledsoe TO REQUIRE THE ARKANSAS STATE MEDICAL BOARD TO PERF…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB95 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB95 Irvin TO WAIVE THE LICENSURE RENEWAL FEE CHARGED BY THE ARK…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
I'm going to pull a few bills out of order that members have told me are non-controversial. If they turn into being controversial, we'll pass over them and move on. Representative Penzo, you're recognized to present your bill. House bill 1411 right yes sir all right you're recognized go ahead all right what
▶ Play
this bill does is strike duplicate language the language can be found in section 20 were had some unintended consequences the the violation of could be something as simple as a seat belt violation and the nurse could lose her license permanently so what it does is it's still in the section under where they have discretion over how to handle any kind of penalty so it's just
▶ Play
cleaning up the bill representative Pilketon you're recognized for a question motion at the proper time I got you noted any questions from the committee. Anybody in the audience speak for or against this bill? Representative Pilkington makes a motion to do pass. Yes. Any discussion on a motion? All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? Congratulations Mr. Penzo you've passed your bill. Thank you Mr. Chairman. Representative Lynch you in the room? You recognize
▶ Play
the run house bill 1478. Mr. Chairman members What this bill does, it changes the licensing for our master and journeyman electricians. Had a constituent that, for whatever reason, let his license expire. He contacted the board. The way the statute was written, they could not relicense him. So he contacted us. We went and worked with the board and changed the statute to take care of some changes that they wanted and also take care of this man so he could get his license back. So that's basically what
▶ Play
it is. Any questions from the committee? Anybody in the audience speak for or against the bill? What's the pleasure of the committee? I've got a motion due pass from Representative Ritchie. Any discussion on the motion? It came from that area. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed, congratulations. Your bill passed. uh vice chair ferguson you ready to go represent uh house bill 1437 i think we have some is there some amendments yes uh thank you mr chair i do
▶ Play
have an amendment to add okay let's take up the amendment first
▶ Play
if you don't mind okay you want to go ahead and start explaining it and committee it's on your tablet or we'll be shortly here in just a
▶ Play
second if you want to go ahead and explain it while we're getting it right and I can just read through the amendment what we tried to do is address some concerns that people came to us with one we wanted to make sure that if it says regardless whether the health care professional is compensated for the health care of a health care professional seeks to provide health care services to a minor through telemedicine in a school setting and the minor is enrolled in Medicaid, that's the deal, if they're enrolled in Medicaid, then the health care professional shall be the designated primary care provider of the minor, have cross-coverage arrangement, have authorization from the PCP. If the minor does not have a primary care provider, then this section doesn't apply. It also makes it very clear, which if you're a healthcare provider, you know that you always have to have parental consent, and the parent certainly has the right of choice for the provider. ConnectCare has a 24-7, I don't know if it's 24, but a 7-day service where the parent, if they wanted to reassign a provider, they have that option. There's some people from DHS here if you have questions about that process, but the parent has complete control of who the provider is. All we're doing is making it comply with current Medicaid rules and regs. We've worked very hard to do patient-centered medical homes and reduce the cost of care by having someone that's sort of the captain of the team and making sure that the child's not over-prescribed antibiotics or, you know, that's in charge and knows what all is going on with the child's care. that person is chosen by the parent and if they wanted to provide school-based care as you know when you start school if you've been a parent you sign all of these consent forms you say who your child's doctor is you give them a copy of your insurance card you give them an emergency contact you you do all those things so it's just saying if the child has Medicaid or if they have insurance that requires them to list a provider that they get authorization to do that in the school. It's a one-time deal. It's good for six months. It's not any more burdensome than the consent forms for everything else. But that's all this does. That's what the amendment does.
▶ Play
Are there any questions on the amendment, committee? Representative Hammer? never doubted
▶ Play
Speaker 30 6:14
it thank you thank you mr. chair I just want to make sure because it's an amendment coming in here at the end what is this going to do and maybe you need to wait and speak to it at the bill but is this going to allow for the option that if a parent has a child at a school and they want that child to be seen through the arrangements that is under the grant that Children's Hospital is facilitating, will this allow that child to see the physician through the telemedicine arrangement as designed by the grant? Yes, it will. We just are asking
▶ Play
for continuity of care, and because through the Medicaid program and through the insurance that are doing the patient-centered medical home, that physician is charged with being responsible for all of the care for that child. So even if the service is being provided free in the school, if they go get a prescription and put it on Medicaid, that is going on that doctor's record of quality care. So, yeah, all they have to do, and I mean, my concern with the children's thing, if we're talking about trying to provide the best community care, they're video conferencing or calling the parent. I'm not sure why they couldn't call the patient's doctor as well and video conference them in instead of circumventing that process and doing it through a children's hospital doctor in a little while. But, yeah, it can be, like I said, the referral for Medicaid, that's done all the time, and it's good for six
▶ Play
months. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Ritchie, you recognize for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. So I'm just trying to understand. So how would that be different? So, like, we're out of town and my child gets sick. You know, one of our children we adopted does have Medicare or Medicaid, excuse me. So when we took him to see one of the clinics there in town, you know, So just because we're away from our hometown, we take them to see a clinic there. How is that different? It's not. That clinic, if they have Medicaid, they're going
▶ Play
to call and get a referral from your PCP if Medicaid's going to pay for it. I mean, they're not going to pay for it if they don't have the referral.
▶ Play
So it's no different, really. So if that was a Saturday on the weekend and they couldn't get a hold
▶ Play
of my doctor, how does that work? Well, part of almost every insurance plan in Medicaid, someone has to be available 24-7 on call. That's a requirement of all doctors now. They have to have cross-coverage 24-7. Okay, so
▶ Play
it operates basically the same way.
▶ Play
Exactly the same, except in that case, the difference is your child's going to be seen in person, which is a little different than a telemedicine visit. And I guess that's part of my problem with the school situation. And, you know, if a child is sick enough that it's something an RN can't see them for and give them Tylenol or something the parent's approved, then maybe they don't need to be in school and they need to go to the doctor. All right. We
▶ Play
can't follow up with that. Just a second. The amendment is now on your tablets committee, so you should be able to pull up the amendment and look at it. And you're now recognized for your follow-up.
▶ Play
Well, that will help. Thank you. But I guess I'm trying to put myself in the position of parents who are hourly employees and it's hard for them to get away, you know, and if that option was available to them, that they might prefer to be able to use that telemedicine option. But you're saying they'll sign something at the beginning. Representative Ritchie, would this not be on the bill and not the amendment? No, it's on the amendment.
▶ Play
No, you're right. I mean, the way I perceive it happening, because they have to get parental consent. You know, they have to have every provider that sees any patient. I'm a dentist. I mean, I'm not going to see a minor without a signed HIPAA form and consent. So I'm sure that in these school situations, the school nurse, they're getting parental consent to see the patient. And all we're saying, if the child comes into school and they have Medicaid and they have listed a provider to be responsible for their patient-centered medical home and their care, that you just get a referral authorization from their doctor so that they're in the loop, so there's continuity of care, and they know what's going on with the child because when they leave, say they see the telemedicine doctor and then it's 4 o'clock or it's the weekend or it's spring break or it's summer, Who do you think is going to take care of that child? Not the telemedicine doctor in Little Rock. It's got to be your local physician. Well, that makes sense. I understand that.
▶ Play
Thank you. Any further questions on the amendment? Pleasure of the committee on the amendment? I've got a motion to do pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed, your amendment is passed. You're
▶ Play
now recognized to present your bill as amended. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, committee. Thank you, Chair. I have Senator Bledsoe at the table with me, and for those of you who are new or weren't on public health last time, I might give a little history about the telemedicine. We had a telemedicine bill last time, and we've worked very closely with the medical board and with providers and nurses and everyone to try to assure that telemedicine is done not just to be convenient but to make sure that it's quality of care. I sort of see telemedicine on two different levels. It's access to specialty care, and then it's access to primary care. And sort of the bill we did last time was, I think, more access to specialty care. It's for APNs or people in rural areas that need a consult with a doctor or a specialist. It allowed the originating site to be where there was a health care provider. So there had to be a health care. You couldn't just do it if you're home. So we sort of built it on the UAMS model, the ANGEL program, where they put stroke telemedicine units in hospitals across the state. You had that golden hour for stroke that if you give the right medicine, the patient has a much better outcome. Also, UAMS was doing the program where they have access to high-risk pregnancy care. So obstetricians, if they had a patient that was high-risk pregnancy, They had the equipment for Dr. Lowry or someone at UAMS to see the ultrasound and follow the patient from the OB's office. In the interim, we've looked at expanding that originating site option. We've had several companies and some different home health and a lot of different people that felt like the originating site should be able to be where the patient is, that they didn't necessarily have to be at a health care facility or with a health care provider or personnel. So that's the main push of this bill, is that we have expanded the originating site to where the patient is. And that would allow, say, the J.D. Hunt and the trucking companies, their concern was that while the truckers are out on the road, They wanted to be able to contract with these telemedicine companies and have the person be able to access health care through the telemedicine company. There were numerous situations. There's electric companies. Most of these telemedicine companies contract with businesses, and the person gets online and gives them a credit card and pays their $40 copay or whatever it is, and they have access to care. so that the changing the originating site is the really the main change in the bill we also expanded it to all types of electronic information and communication and we added remote patient monitoring so this is particularly helpful in like home health situations and all this home all this health monitoring is really there's no telling where it's going to go. You know, they're starting to have kiosks and places where you can check your blood pressure and check all your vital signs and all that kind of stuff. Even my Fitbit, you know, now it, you know, it'll, it'll tell you things like your blood pressure. I have an app on my iPhone that'll tell me my blood gas. I mean, there are a lot of potential good uses for health monitoring, remote health monitoring. So we added remote health monitoring to the definition of telemedicine, and we're clarifying that you have to, in order to establish a relationship, before we said that had to be in person, but now we're saying you can establish a relationship with video, audio-visual with the patient, but once you've established that relationship and it's equal to an in-person visit, then just like a regular doctor, you know, if you go to your doctor, you can just call and he'll tell you if you need to come in on the phone and maybe call you an antibiotic or do whatever he needs to on the phone. So once that audiovisual visit is established with the telemedicine doctor, then you can just use the telephone for the follow-up calls. Now, the other big thing the bill does, it expands the coverage and reimbursement. It's providing insurance coverage and reimbursement parity for not just physicians, but for for all services provided via telemedicine, as long as the service, and this is very important, as long as the service is comparable to what the patient will receive in person. So that's sort of the quality standard I think we have to look at for telemedicine across the board. Does it address that the service is comparable to what the person is going to receive in person? So that's basically the bill, and like I said, we had the provisions for Medicaid and insurance when you're treating children in a school-based setting because those are already the Medicaid rules. We're just complying with what already exists in Medicaid in terms of needing the referral from your family practice. And even though, like I said, it's HIPAA law and everything that you have to have parental consent, and they have control over what provider the child sees and can change the provider in Medicaid, some senators felt like we needed to actually say that. So that was part of the reason for the amendment.
▶ Play
Do you want to add? The first telemedicine bill was restrictive because we wanted to hold up a standard of excellence. And legislation, even today, cannot keep up with the developments in telemedicine. So we will be amending the telemedicine bill probably way into the future. But what we did, because the companies that need this for the people in their companies that travel, your constituents that have jobs that take them out of the state and all of that, we worked with those companies, and they were willing to wait after we passed that first bill. But I've spoken with Walmart, J.B. Hunt, Tyson Foods, Black Hills Energy, Association of Counties, because, ladies and gentlemen, you can use telemedicine in the jails. And then, of course, that is a lot less expensive and it's safer for the public. I've talked to AARP of Arkansas. They are in favor of this bill because now, as Representative Ferguson said, some of these elderly people can be monitored in their home. And that is a great advantage for them. And I've talked to some of the hospitals, the one in my area, which is Mercy Health, the other one in Springdale, which is Northwest, and they all support this bill. And I believe some of them are here today. But we've worked very hard, and we're excited about the possibilities of this bill and what it can do not only in your rural communities to just extend the health care, but also when used properly, just anywhere that you can imagine that people would need help. I'm open for
▶ Play
questions. Representative Miller, are you on my list? Okay, I got you listed. Representative Hammer, you got a question? Representative Meeks was first, I'm sorry. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair, and I love the direction that this bill is going, so I appreciate you all recognizing the advances in technology. The question that I have, and I'm trying to make sure that I fully understand, is how a person would use telemedicine for the first time. Like, you know, we've talked about J.B. Hunt and some of the other ones that may have a business relationship, but for somebody like me who can download an app on my phone, whether it's doctor on demand, tele-doc or whatever the case may be you know before I think we had to go to actual doctor here in Arkansas to do it if I download this app it's audio video is that would that be sufficient enough for me to then start using services or would
▶ Play
I have to do something else in with the first bill it was restrictive it had to be at first person to person then during the interim we worked with the medical board and what the bill says now, this new bill, what it says now, that that first encounter, in other words, you pick up the phone or you go to your computer or whatever, that first encounter has to be audio-visual, but it's only the first encounter. After that, you can use the telephone anywhere, anytime. And also, there's a cross-coverage, and this question was asked, well, okay, do I have Let's say I wait two months and call MD Live. Do I have to make that call since I called them one time but waited a long time? Do I have to be using audio-visual? No. It's like going into a physician's office, and maybe their partner is the one you prefer, but he's out of town. That's called cross-coverage. You see him. And once you are established with MDLive or Doctors on Demand or whatever it might be, you do not have to use audio-visual again. And follow-up, Mr. Chair?
▶ Play
Thank you. And then, again, just for, I guess, safety purposes or whatever, do these, the doctors that we do the audio-visual with, because obviously most of them may not be in Arkansas or whatever, Or will they have to be certified here in Arkansas? And, I mean, how would that be enforced simply because of the fact we can't necessarily go into another state and say
▶ Play
your doctor has to be this way? Well, if you practice medicine in the state of Arkansas, even if you're providing telemedicine, you have to be licensed by the state medical board, and that's for your protection. And that's their job, to protect the people of Arkansas. But they are licensed in the state. They could live somewhere else, but they're licensed in the state.
▶ Play
All right. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I might add to that, Representative Meeks, that the reason people often ask, oh, why can't we just let anybody come here and practice? It is for patient protection because you want the medical board to have disciplinary. The medical board's job is to protect the patient. The medical society, I think a lot of people get this confused, represents doctors, but the medical board is to protect the public. And so you want any doctor that practices on patients in Arkansas to have a medical license in the state so that we have disciplinary control in case
▶ Play
there's a problem. I'll put you back at the bottom of the list. Representative Hammer,
▶ Play
Speaker 30 23:09
are you recognized? I think, Mr. Chair, the portion of the bill I want to focus on with my questions deal with what happens in a school setting. And with the amendment that we added, does it still require a PCP approval for Medicaid kids that are in that school over parental approval? Not over parental approval.
▶ Play
If a parent wants to change the PCP, they can call the 800-CONNECT-CARE number and do it immediately. I mean, we have patients do that all the time. Follow-up, Mr. Chair? You're recognized. Just to
▶ Play
Speaker 30 23:48
be 100% clear for my dense head this morning, if I have a child in a school, because the program that's currently being run by children, that school's actually in my district. So if I have a child that's in that school and that child does not have a PCP and the nurse, the child goes to the nurse in the school and the nurse wants to utilize the telemedicine option offered by children's but there is no PCP, is that child going to be denied that service because there's not a pre-existing agreement with a PCP?
▶ Play
No, there's not. It clearly says that in the amendment. If they, let me read it, might pull it up on your tablet. What did I do with that amendment? Well, y'all might have to pull it up on the tablet. Oh, here we go. Yeah, it says if the minor does not have a designated primary care provider, this section does not apply. So they do not have to do that. But I might point out the requirement for the PCP referral or approval, however you want to call it, is a Medicaid rule. It's not, I mean, we're just complying with what Medicaid already requires. All right, I may go
▶ Play
Speaker 30 25:15
to the bottom of the list, Mr. Chair. Thank
▶ Play
you. Representative Meeks you're recognized thank you and this kind of as a follow-up to the follow-up that I had and when regarding discipline of doctors and how we're dealing with out-of-state because again most of your telemedicine things that we actually use are going to be a service that's going to have 10 15 kind of like you have the doctor groups here in the state of Arkansas all so if you do have let's say a doctor or two doctors that you have to discipline I mean again how are we going to enforce I mean and that may be something that we promulgate rules for but if you can kind of help me to understand how can we discipline a doctor we can pull their license but they're still part of this doctors on demand and I you know I might and they may still be licensed in the other state. And so how do I know that that doctor is licensed here in the state of Arkansas or hasn't had any disciplinary problems within the state of Arkansas? Have you all thought about how that might work or has that been done in other
▶ Play
states that you can kind of let me know? Yeah, states communicate about infractions, you know, if you're licensed in several states. So the medical board, I don't, there's not anyone from the medical board here, I hope I,
▶ Play
Speaker 48 26:39
is Karen here? Yeah, I'm sorry,
▶ Play
Karen is the executive director of the medical board. Maybe she can tell exactly how it is, but there's a pretty lengthy process. They call the doctor into the board and it's, I mean, they, I don't, and they do a lot of, they have several doctors every month don't you if
▶ Play
you would please introduce yourself for the committee and then you're recognized answer question I'm
▶ Play
Speaker 83 27:06
Karen Watley I'm the executive secretary of the Arkansas State Medical Board and we do discipline physicians on a regular basis we just had a meeting last week where we disciplined a lot of them what happens is we would receive a complaint and we would be we would then contact that physician to get the response to that in the event that the board decided disciplinary action was required a A hearing would be set. The physician would be required to come into the state of Arkansas and appear in person before the board. They cannot appear via audiovisual. They have to come and appear before the board. The board at that point in time would have the opportunity to do a variety of disciplinary actions against that physician, and that disciplinary action is then reported to the National Practitioner Data Bank, which then communicates with other boards and lets them know what sort of discipline has occurred against that physician. And so the other boards throughout the country can then take action against that physician if it rises to the level that they have to. Most other boards in the country would also, every year at the annual renewal process, will say, have you been disciplined by any other medical board in the country? We ask that question every year. If they answer yes, they then have to provide the information as to what the discipline was, provide us with the orders, and be able to answer the questions as to what they did, why they did it. And then if a physician who is licensed in another state is conducting telemedicine in the state of Arkansas, and they were disciplined in that other state, we would then have the opportunity to bring that physician into the state of Arkansas and possibly also have disciplinary action against that physician. Okay, and
▶ Play
one more follow-up, if I could. And this may be a question or question for the bill's sponsors, But, again, when you're dealing with these companies that run the services, does this bill provide for an opportunity to where if they're not complying, you know, again, if you've disciplined a doctor, said you can't practice, and you have more people now that are using this app, and that doctor comes up and is still doing it, does this bill allow the capability to say that, okay, company, we've warned you? You know, you've still got doctors that are, you know, practicing here in the state of Arkansas. Can you just tell that company that you cannot operate in the state of Arkansas? I mean, I think you
▶ Play
only have control of the doctors, not the company, right?
▶ Play
Speaker 83 29:29
The board only has control of the physician. We do not have control of the company. In the event that that would, rising to the level that they're basically practicing medicine without a license in the state of Arkansas, the only thing that we could do at that point in time would be to refer that specific physician and possibly, I guess, even we would at least tell the local prosecuting attorney who the company was. That's all we could do would be to refer them for criminal prosecution in the county in which they were operating. Sounds good. All right, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Representative Lundstrom, you got a question? Yes, I'm still a little fuzzy on the parental consent issue. Could you go through that one more time with me? I understand that the parent consents, and then the PCP decides to refer. But if they don't decide to refer, that parent's left hanging. So would you tread over that for me
▶ Play
again? Yeah, if they have Medicaid, it's like I said, if the physician doesn't consent, which I think is unlikely, I mean, they usually will uphold a referral. I mean, I've never known a family practice doctor in our own situation not to send us a referral. They'll fax it over immediately, or they can only do an electronic signature these days. But if that is the case and the parent was aggravated, all they have to do is call Connect Care, 800 number, and get reassigned to a different PCP. And I'm sure, as they do it in the schools, they could get reassigned to the PCP that's the Teladoc in Little Rock. Right, but
▶ Play
would this be competition with the local physician? Or would the local physician be upset about this and to say, I'm not
▶ Play
going to give this referral, you're on your own? Well, it's really Medicaid's decision. It's not about the local physician. And our contention is, you know, like I said, these are kids, and it's really about the quality of care. We are supportive of them going into the school and providing care, you know, through telehealth. That's not the issue. It's just you don't want to completely cut out their provider, whether it's an APN or a physician, in their care. Because, like I said, who's going to see them after school hours and in the summer and spring break and, you know, after hours? It's not going to be, they're not going to call that doctor in Little Rock they talked to on telehealth from the school.
▶ Play
Speaker 79 31:53
They're going to call their doctor or their
▶ Play
APRN. Okay. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you. We got quite a few folks signed up for and against, so if you guys don't mind, we'll go ahead and get started with that. We'll start out with Ms. Mary Doppler against.
▶ Play
Speaker 97 32:12
Did I pronounce that right? Marcy Joderer, maybe? I got Mary. I got
▶ Play
Marcy on the other paper. Shall I approach? Yeah. Introduce yourself for the committee and carry
▶ Play
Speaker 111 32:31
on. Good morning. Thank you. My name is Marcy Doderer, and I serve as the CEO of Arkansas Children's Hospital. Appreciate the opportunity, Representative Wardlaw and Ferguson. Thank you. I think as many of you know that I've been an advocate for the expansion of telemedicine for a while. I came from a state where we were able to use this differently, and I applaud the work of our legislature to expand telemedicine to better serve families and patients across Arkansas. I commend you. It's a complex issue, and it takes a lot of thoughtful approach to land in the right place for Arkansas. I am here to express opposition to the bill as we have seen it. I have not had the opportunity to read the amendment as was earlier discussed just a little bit ago, because the bill, as it opens everything up for adults, does place different restrictions on children and treat them very differently, particularly school-aged children in school settings. We're very public about our mission at Arkansas Children's Hospital to be champions for children and help make them better today and healthier tomorrow, and that's for all children. 710,000 children in the state of Arkansas, 75 counties. We believe that when we look at the health indicators for the state of Arkansas, we're chagrined and actually somewhat embarrassed by the state of health of kids in our state And we should embark on innovative strategies to move the needle on child health in Arkansas. And we believe augmenting care in rural communities is one way to help elevate access to health care as well as to elevate health to very different and distinct strategies. We also know that when kids are healthy, they do well in school. And when they do well in school, they graduate and they go on to become contributing adults. And when they aren't healthy, they have a hard time performing well in school. Our goal is to help bring care as close to home as possible and delivering care through schools to help children have easy access to health care in school where they can remain in school whenever feasible and avoid time away from the learning environment is something that's helpful to all children. Parents aren't always able to leave work, I think that was mentioned a little bit ago, to take their child to a physician and we also know that many physician offices are overwhelmed, particularly in this time of year, with limited same-day appointments. School-based telemedicine services can help meet the needs of children with a minimal disruption to their school day or to the parent's work day, which should be equally important. School-based telemedicine provides a school nurse with a helping hand so that he or she has a student in the office that needs care beyond what they can do in the moment. They have someone to call for help. To that end, Arkansas Children's Hospital applied for and received a federal grant to the tune of just over $600,000 to support school-based telemedicine in rural, small communities in our state. We're concerned about our ability to be successful with that strategy, given the limiting language of the bill. It was expressed recently that the reason the school language was in there is a concern that Arkansas Children's was out here to negatively impact existing primary care practices. That is not true. National norm for physician practices is that most physicians see an average of 25 patients a day, and we actually just heard someone saying they're seeing upwards of 80 a day in this crazy time. The projections for school-based telemedicine program is that a school would refer two to four children a week to a telemedicine service. These visits are absolutely not a substitute for a primary care provider or for a patient-centered medical home. These visits are a way to support that care, reach the children who would potentially not receive any care, maybe not receive timely care, or receive care in an emergency room at a much higher cost. And to just be clear, to reiterate, it is in no way Arkansas Children's intention to divert a child's care away from local physicians. School-based telemedicine, like any telemedicine, in any venue, is only one tool for delivering care. it cannot replace those in-person visits. Another concern we've heard is that the continuity of care or the coordination of care for these children is at risk without the language in this bill. We've agreed to ensure that every child who has a regular primary care physician that is seen via telemedicine receives a summary of that visit that's been our practice to date in our one pilot program and a copy of the medical record created during that visit. We don't attempt to persuade a family to change their primary care to Arkansas Children's. That It makes no sense for someone in a community outside of Little Rock. The last thing we'd want to do is interfere with that child's medical home. Coordination of care should be a priority regardless of the age of the patient or the setting. However, the bill doesn't actually promote that. This bill doesn't attempt to promote coordinating care for adults or for children who aren't of school age or in settings such as home, retail centers, walk-in clinics, or other populations that don't need a PCP referral or authorization. I'd also like to make sure this is understood by everyone here that this is not about payment. It's not about the dollars. We understand that if any payer, such as Arkansas Medicaid, requires a PCP referral in order to be reimbursed for the service, that we would comply with all payer rules and contractual requirements. This is about being able to provide services to children regardless of whether or not we bill or are paid. Finally, at the core of the issue, Arkansas Children's believes that the parent has the choice to use telemedicine services or to seek care in a physician's office. The current language takes that choice out of the hands of the parent by requiring the PCP authorization on the front end. As adults, we don't willingly give up our decision of where and when and how we seek care, and parents don't always wish to give up that control for their children as well. We respectfully request that you consider removing the restrictions on the school-age kids for telemedicine in the schools and allow children in schools during school day to have the same access to telemedicine as you or me or an adult or any other child not in school would have in any other venue.
▶ Play
Thank you very much. We have a few questions. Representative McCulloch, did
▶ Play
I see you need a question? You did not, but I
▶ Play
do have a question if I can skip everyone. Go ahead. Representative Payton, you're recognized for a question. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair, but with that blatant honesty, I'd almost just give him my time. But no, I appreciate you coming, and I'm trying to comprehend exactly what you're saying about the restrictions that you refer to on the children's care. Does this bill place those restrictions or are those restrictions already in existence and you're just saying this bill doesn't go far
▶ Play
Speaker 111 39:32
enough to lift them? The bill creates the restrictions for the school-aged child while in school. So if a mother chose to use, I can't remember the example, the Teladoc or one of the other apps for her child outside of school, a PCP authorization would not be required unless that program opted to bill for the service. But when the same mom would like her child to have access to that telemedicine service while in school, a PCP authorization is required. So currently they
▶ Play
can do the telemedicine and this bill would restrict it? Or are you just saying that this bill does not go far enough? Bill adds a level of restriction to the
▶ Play
Speaker 111 40:09
schools by requiring a PCP referral before a telemedicine visit can be performed. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Representative Bentley, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you for coming today. I've worked at Children's for a number of years. It's a great place. I really brought some real concerns about this bill. I'm very concerned about the Children's Clinics, and that's why I brought this attention to some folks about what was going on because I went to my low town, Havana, that has one physician, one doctor's place, and the school was going for approval for the clinic there. And visiting with the PRNs that are there and the physicians that are there, they are concerned that visit parents, it's very anxious if they're at work or whatever, they can't get out and see their kids, And so they are very concerned that they're going to lose children to Children's Hospital because Children's is a great name, and everybody would like to use Children's because it's well-renowned across the state. Those physicians are under such strain right now with so many things that have been brought up with the ACA, so many rules, they're barely hanging on. They are barely surviving out there. I don't want my one physician to go under there because they're relying on these patients. And another thing, if that child is contagious, I really would assume that child went home and got out of the school and saw the physician there. So I have some real concerns. I understand where you guys are going. I would like to address the future. Are you guys planning on doing psychology? Any helps with that? What are the plans for this clinic moving forward? Because none of us had heard about it until I happened to be going to see my school nurse that day on an already planned visit out there in Havana. So if you can tell me what the plans are for that, I would appreciate it. I said, okay, Chairman, real quick on that. And, you know, I'm not trying to prohibit kids from being seen, but it's not unfair to me. I think this amendment addresses it. I wish you had looked at it a little bit before you came up and looked. I think the amendment totally addresses what our concerns are. You can ahead of time assign, so it's okay for them to be seen by the
▶ Play
Speaker 111 42:19
telehealth doctor. So I would just like you to address those concerns for me. Certainly, and I'll restate our position and our view that we are not here to compete and take patients away from a physician in Havana, Arkansas. School districts have asked if there is a way to get telehealth services into their schools. And they are very interested in augmenting the care that can be provided in a school-based clinic. And those are the conversations that have happened in various communities around the state by school districts wanting to leverage the time a school nurse has and the resources available to him or her. Arkansas Children's Hospital, and I want you to remember we are the hospital, so we are not the physicians, would never want to redirect a patient who has a primary care physician in Havana to our primary care clinic that sits on the campus of this hospital. It makes absolutely no sense logically that we would steal that patient. You didn't use those words, but redirect that patient away from their home physician. So it's illogical that we would expect a family to drive to Little Rock, that we would try to make that happen for the primary care visit. So that's not in the strategy, it's not in our vision that that's what this is about. It's an augmentation. You know, it's interesting about where this technology allows you to go in the future. It is the, well I think Representative Ferguson mentioned the speed at which the technology is training and allowing you to manage and care for a patient remotely is moving very, very quickly. What's available on our iPhones, what's available in stations you can place in schools or retail clinics or wherever. And so the ability to use that for any number of services, I suppose, could be out there for anyone. Arkansas Children's Hospital does not provide psychology and psychiatry services today. Those aren't on our list of services. We don't have any of those outpatient clinics. Those are UAMS-based clinics that do psychiatry and psychology. So I haven't had that conversation to know whether they hope to also add that specialty service. But, you know, a child is referred only into behavioral health, again, by a PCP. So the PCP would be very involved in understanding if that child was seeking the services of a Ph.D. psychologist or a physician psychiatrist. So I think this kind of technology, and that's why so much of this bill is wonderful, is because it does open up the ability for a patient who lives in a community that might not have that specialty care available right there, that they could maybe seek that services via telehealth or telemedicine in any number of venues. So could it be used for psychology? I mean, I suppose it could. I don't employ the psychologist who would sit on the end to know how that would work yet. So I'd have to think through that. We would work in partnership. If UAMS wanted to use that, UAMS providers using those telehealth units in schools, that supposedly could be an option, I guess. Real quick one. Real
▶ Play
quick. I just wanted to say I wish that we had used this in another direction because I think there's so many specialties there at Children's that I had the opportunity to work with that if we could get those specialties to those kids, through the PCP and in conjunction with the PCP would be phenomenal because there's so many kids that came to Children's that if they had been diagnosed earlier could have much better outcome on heart patients and all those kind of things. So I wish we could use it for the great specialty that you guys have there in conjunction with our PCPs. I don't think we've in any
▶ Play
Speaker 111 46:04
way said we would never use it for specialty care. I guess I have not seen
▶ Play
it in the language and what I had looked at in the program right now as it is, I thought it was just
▶ Play
Speaker 111 46:15
primary care. Once the equipment is in place, again, as I said, it could be used for any number of in-use.
▶ Play
Thank you, Chairman. Representative McCulloch, you are now
▶ Play
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm sorry if you feel like you're repeating something you've already stated. I'm just really trying to understand directly. if you mentioned that you're not, Children's doesn't want to compete with or redirect or in any way compete with PCPs, so my question really is then why not ask for authorization
▶ Play
Speaker 111 46:53
from the PCP first? Part of its time, administrative burden, quite frankly. We've piloted a program in Benton, I think Representative Hammer already mentioned that, to see how easy this is to actually do, how much can you improve what the nurse has access to, how timely can you respond to a call, what that all looks like, so we, I would say we're new at this as anyone in Arkansas is because it's not being done today. So the process of obtaining authorization on the front end is simply an administrative burden for the school nurse or for an Arkansas Children's Hospital employee. I think that's where we would probably land it if we moved forward with the strategy. You know, if Arkansas Children's moved forward with the strategy, we'd have to have staff employed to do this. So it's one of those administrative bureaucratic burdens that creates an opportunity to maybe not have access to this care. It's also a burden to then understand if the rules are, as I heard the amendment, it's specific to only one payer source. So it's a process you put in place from Medicaid only, but not a Blue Cross or an Aetna. It was hard for me to understand that if it's something you'd apply uniformly to all children or simply to one subsection of the pediatric population. So, you know, it's understandable to think that it would be easy to achieve on the front end, but I think from Representative Bentley's story, if I may be so bold, I think if I approach the doctor in Havana, Arkansas, he would likely, it sounds like, say, no, I'm not giving you authorization to take care of any of my patients. So I wonder how much it might limit which communities we would go to. And so you'd approach the physicians one-to-one as you go and find physicians who would like that to augment their care and could work with a school district then and build it out that way. I think that's a possibility. But I do think it adds a layer of bureaucratic rules that isn't there if we created some kind of telehealth, ask-a-nurse program in the home or something like that. Representative Ferguson, you've got a question? I do.
▶ Play
I guess I'm trying to also figure out why you think a six-month authorization is burdensome, but my question is you said you didn't have plans to extend to other things, and it's not about building a vertically integrated network that self-refers to children, but on page 15 of the grant it said first year will be primary care, second year chronic care, and third-year behavioral health so that specifically says in the grant your intention with this program right and as I said
▶ Play
Speaker 111 49:57
it would be working with the UAMS physicians to deliver those care I think it is important to remember that our physician partners are not employees of Arkansas Children's Hospital and so as we work with our I have my medical director for Arkansas Children's Hospital Tamara Perry with us today but as we work with our physician partners to talk about what could be, and that was how the grant was written, because it's an innovation-type grant, right? What could you do with this money? How could you improve care for children across the state of Arkansas where every public statistic would tell you we've got a challenge in the health of our children? And so when you look at how would you grow that, those are very reasonable, I think, and logical steps to the expansion of telemedicine in our state.
▶ Play
You recognize for one follow-up. Well, and you say it's not about Children's, but maybe people in this room realize, or they don't. In your outpatient centers, Children's is receiving, you're competing with private practice and get paid almost three times as much. Children's gets a facility fee, and the doctor gets paid two or three times the Medicaid reimbursement. And again, those
▶ Play
Speaker 111 51:03
physicians are not employees of Arkansas Children's Hospital. They are UAMS faculty, and the physician reimbursement goes to the University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences. But not the facility fee.
▶ Play
Representative Miller, you recognize for a question?
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ma'am, has Children's Hospital offered any amendments that
▶ Play
Speaker 111 51:27
would address your concerns? We've had a variety of conversations. I think there's even another one floating out there again today about that conversation with the PCP. So we've tried hard to find some middle ground here. here against taking, regardless of our own strategy, but just thinking broadly about the view of health care for kids in general. So yes, we've had conversations with Senator Bledsoe. And again, I think there's another one kind of floating in the ether
▶ Play
this morning. You're recognized for a follow-up. OK,
▶ Play
with these amendments or whatever in y'all's conversations, can you specifically nail down for me what y'all are being denied and why. So again I would ask that we make certain
▶ Play
Speaker 111 52:17
that it's for public record this is not about what Arkansas Children's Hospital is or isn't being denied and I realize that may be difficult for some to understand. What I find and what we as an organization representing the only children's hospital in the state of Arkansas is that the language is restricted to one subpopulation of the kids of our state. I think it's important to understand we have adults on Medicaid in our state. They are also in patient-centered medical homes. Their PCPs are also required to authorize care. The law doesn't address that. So we've narrowed our language to one subsection of children, and as the only children's hospital in the state, we feel that we have four missions, patient care, education, research, and advocacy, and so I'm here in terms of advocating on the children of Arkansas to ensure that access to health care is easily accomplished. It's actually not at all about our strategy. Our strategy will or won't
▶ Play
be based on the laws of this state. Thank you. Thank you, Representative Gonzalez.
▶ Play
You're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yeah, I'm pretty sure I don't understand everything that you're talking about here, but so currently you have clinics, school-based clinics, that are seeing kids, right?
▶ Play
Speaker 111 53:39
We operate a pilot telehealth program in the Angie Grant Elementary School in Benton, and we operate, at the request of Little Rock School District, an on-site care clinic at Franklin Elementary that will obviously go away since that school is closing.
▶ Play
Speaker 147 53:56
Okay, so currently, if I may have a follow-up,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair, so currently the way you operate, if you see a child in the school, you're taking that visit and sending a report to their PCP after the visit. Correct. So you don't have a prior auth, but you are reporting back to the primary care. In Benton,
▶ Play
Speaker 111 54:22
yes. So since that's a pilot, and we saw 13 children in the fall semester. We started just a little bit after Labor Day, and from that time until school closed for the winter break, we had 13 telemedicine visits with the Benton School. All of those patients with an identified primary care physician received a detailed letter from the physician who took the call and delivered the services via telemedicine with a copy of the medical record. In the Franklin Elementary School, which is a very different model, it's actually a school-based health center. There's a nurse practitioner on site, and primary care is actually delivered in that center, but those are all done in partnership with the local PCP. So a child is not, they have a school nurse who runs the regular kind of your traditional school health, and then we have the school health center that if the PCP of the child at Franklin Elementary authorized care to be delivered on-site versus redirecting, the patient is seen by that nurse practitioner. And again, follow-up is provided to the PCP, of course. But those are two very different programs. Representative Bentley
▶ Play
you recognize for a question real quick it's my
▶ Play
understanding answer yes or no is the only patients that are seen or on the contract you saw only Medicaid patients will be seen on the telehealth clinics that you're setting up in the different school districts isn't my understanding as I was in the meeting that only Medicaid patients will be seen by children I don't know the answer that I
▶ Play
Speaker 111 55:59
don't know what's been I honestly don't You know, that
▶ Play
was told by the children's person that was there at the meeting that I was at, setting up the telehealth clinic, that only Medicaid patients will be seen. I think that is a reason for the amendment the way it states. And could we make a motion at this point to limit
▶ Play
debate? When we're done with this witness, we can do that. Representative McGee, Dr. McGee, you're recognized for a question. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 165 56:28
you, Mr. Chair. So this grant that you were given was given to you to provide for a community benefit. That's what I would assume. So I'm a physician. I cannot see how not involving the local physician that takes care of that child on a day-to-day basis, on the weekends, on the summertime when you're not available, how not involving that local physician is a benefit to the community. What I can see it as actually a threat to that physician and his survival, particularly in small communities. Now, if you came to my community in Conway and you had this service, what is wrong? Tell me what's wrong with you, the children's people, going to those providers in that community on the front end and saying, Dr. Miller, we want to provide these services to your patients. Do we have your permission? And he says, yes. But then they go to Dr. Payton, and Dr. Payton said, no, I don't want any of my children that are in school to be part of that because I am their primary care provider. I am the one that knows the most about their medical care. I'm the one that gave them all their immunizations. I delivered that baby when she was born. I took care of her for the last 10 years. I know when she broke her arm. I know when her dog bit her. I know all the things about her. I live right down the street from her family, and you're in a small community. What's wrong with working that out on the front end and asking that the primary care provider be involved? I mean, you're telling me that you don't want the primary care. All you're going to do is send a letter, a detailed letter, to the primary care provider at the end. I can tell you all about detailed primary care letters that you get. They're computer-generated off electronic health record, and the doctor looks at them. They're about 15 pages long, and they throw them in the chart, and they never look at them. So to me it doesn't seem as conducive to the best care for the children.
▶ Play
Speaker 111 58:25
I appreciate your concern, and as we mentioned, I think being able to have that relationship with the 300 or so pediatricians across the state and then the innumerable family medicine physicians who care for probably about 20% of the kids in our state. On the front end, that would potentially be ideal. I think it's challenging to the school nurse to sit there and know real time. Dr. A said yes, Dr. B said no, in terms of just the administrative process. So coordination, communication, and really actually I would move it one step further to collaboration with the primary care physicians is essential if we're going to ever move the needle on child health in our state. You're absolutely right. Doing so by building strong relationships is probably the best way to start that. I think you're right. Knowing that the rules restricted from day one, I think, will shut down some innovation. So, for example, the grant that we've received with the money, and Arkansas Children's has to put up some money in match of that grant, buys the hardware. That's what the dollars are used to place the technology, and I think it would fund about 42 schools in our state. Based on how the telemedicine laws play out, we may or may not execute on that. We can return the money and not actually invest in that technology. If we feel like there is actually limited support, and that's an option. And, you know, so I think having laws versus rules versus how you build the relationship should probably be a few
▶ Play
different conversations. Okay. Representative Hammer, we recognize for a
▶ Play
Speaker 30 1:00:22
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And you just hit on one of the subjects I wanted you to speak on, and that is if this does not move forward or this bill with the amendment that was attached to a while ago moves forward, then you will have to, will you have to give the money back to the federal government? And did that money that you received from the federal government, did it allow for infrastructure to where any PCP could link into it so that it could be a shared system? So we have not actually drawn
▶ Play
Speaker 111 1:00:56
down any money yet. So because this has been in the conversation, so we, though the grant with the federal government is signed, we have not asked for any money because we don't want to go investing until we know what makes sense as a go forward with the Arkansas Children's Hospital strategy. If yes, the hardware is, what's the best way of saying it, it's agnostic to the, that it's a hospital owner or a physician owner, that the actual hardware can be purchased by any number of people and it could be used by any number. Now if Arkansas Children's Hospital places technology in a community and a private practice physician wishes to access that same technology, we can't provide that for free without violating the Stark laws of the federal government. So there would have to be an arrangement with a private practice physician. Stark laws prohibit us for giving free stuff to doctors because it is viewed as potential enurement, meaning they would then send us the patients. But there's a simple cost formula, I'm assuming, that we'd work out with a local provider and then they could use it themselves. So the physician in Havana, if we put a unit in the school in Havana and the physician in Havana wanted to provide telehealth services, technology, technologically, infrastructure wise, yes, that's an open highway I think is probably a good way to, assuming the doc has the same, has what they need on their end, which is usually pretty simple. an iPad, a computer, probably a high-resolution monitor is what you really need. Follow-up, Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker 30 1:02:37
Chair. You're recognized. Thank you. So in reality, moving this forward, if I hear what you're saying correctly, Children's is bearing the burden of getting, through the grant, the infrastructure out there that PCPs and local communities would be able to network into, would create for collaborative agreements between physicians at Children's and those in the community as to the fee that that local PCP would have to pay I didn't hear that addressed but it actually involves the local PCP to a greater level because they can't be at the school and the kid maybe can't get from school to the doctor's office but that doesn't what you're proposing doesn't block that local PCP out am I right or wrong in what I interpreted what you said no
▶ Play
Speaker 111 1:03:22
you're correct if Arkansas Children's Hospital chose to deploy technology to a variety of communities we would work with that local physician if he or she wished to be on to have use of that technology as well and I don't have a price for you sir I don't know what the cost of the local physician would be we would just because I've never I've never done the math um we'd have to likely involve attorneys but yeah we could come up with that fee but yes if we chose to deploy the technology. I think the challenge is if we don't see our own use of said technology, we may not choose to deploy it. Representative Payton,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This will be the last question for this witness.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And it's been a few minutes since you started, but I thought I heard you say at the beginning that you weren't familiar with the amendment that was adopted at the beginning here. So I just wanted to point out a couple of lines to you and see if it changes your opinion. it says if a minor does not have a designated primary care provider this section does not apply then it also says the designation of a primary care provider for a minor remains the right of a parent or legal guardian so I don't understand with this amendment how we would be limiting the parent because all they have to do is say you don't have a primary care provider or as Dr. McGee was saying the parent could say well I don't like this doctor anymore I'm gonna go to one that lets us use telemedicine so I think one
▶ Play
Speaker 111 1:04:57
of the good things with the state of Arkansas is we have a limited number of uninsured children so that that letter C I think it is or if the minor does not have a regular PCP it's probably because they don't have health insurance and that's a very small percentage of our children in the state and so that's a good thing. So it's a limited number of kids that that applies to. But in general, that's a really good thing for the state of Arkansas. The second piece, you're right, that the parent chooses the primary care provider. That happens every day. The language above it still requires that primary care provider to provide the authorization. So what we were initially looking for is the elimination of the administrative burden of acquiring the pre-authorization in advance of the care. And so that isn't removed from the rule. Okay, thank you, ma'am. Thank you very much, sir. Representative Bentley, you're a recognizer.
▶ Play
I've got a motion. I will hear that motion. Limit debate to
▶ Play
Speaker 162 1:06:15
12 minutes on each side, please. You want to make that an even 15?
▶ Play
Ten minutes. I'm trying to be gracious and make sure they had time to end their bill. Sorry. I got a motion that's non-debatable. Ten minutes to either side. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? No. Ayes have it. Motion passes. We'll be keeping time from the table, and Representative Ferguson, do you want to reserve any time to close? Okay, we'll keep you two minutes. Next we have Dr. Scott Cooper to speak for the bill. Dr. Cooper, if you would, introduce yourself to the committee
▶ Play
Speaker 165 1:06:57
and you're recognized to proceed. All right. I'm Scotty Cooper. I'm an orthopedic surgeon in Rogers. I practiced in Rogers for more than 20 years. I want to thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you, members of the House Public Health Committee, for having me in here. And don't worry, I'm not going over 10 minutes. Not a chance. But I just want to – I don't want to get down into the details of this. That's for the legislators and for the experts. But as president of AMS, I want to express our support for this bill. The sponsors of this bill have not just worked with us, we who represent the physicians of the state of Arkansas, but with, as mentioned previously, with people like Walmart and Tyson and J.B. Hunt and big medical organizations like Mercy, who I work for. It also heartens me to hear, and as Senator Brudsel alluded to, this is a fast-moving target. Telemedicine is not a bad thing. It's a good thing, and without doubt, it's an inevitable thing. And the way we're looking at it in 2017 is different than the way we looked at it in 2015. And so it's the way I see this, and I see more of an openness rather than a restriction, but the restrictions that apply have to do with maintaining the basis of good health care, which is the doctor-patient relationship. And no matter how good telemedicine gets, that's still the basis of good health care and thus good health. Once again, I just want everybody to know here that the Arkansas Medical Society is fully in support of this bill and specifically as amended, the part that helps to maintain that doctor-patient relationship for the Medicaid kids and in our small communities, like the one where I come from originally, Harrisburg. Dr. Cooper, we do have a few questions. Representative Hammer, you're
▶ Play
recognized for the first question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Doctor, and I
▶ Play
Speaker 30 1:09:17
respect you and your profession, let me ask you a question. If a parent has private insurance and wanted to utilize the option that is offered in the school, but something would prohibit that parent who has private insurance from being able to do that, What would be
▶ Play
Speaker 165 1:09:38
your view of that scenario? Well, I still come down on the side of the doctor-patient relationship. My preference would be for the patient's primary care doctor to be involved, and my understanding is that the amendment specifically talks about Medicaid patients.
▶ Play
Speaker 30 1:09:55
One follow-up, Mr. Chair, real quick. You recognize for a quick one. So if this bill with the amendment would preclude a parent who has a child in the school with private insurance from being able to utilize the telemedicine option that Children's is offering or that would be offered, would you say as a physician that that is not right, that a parent should be prohibited from making that
▶ Play
Speaker 165 1:10:16
choice? Well, prohibited is a strong word, but my preference is that it go through the primary care doctor at some level.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Pilkington, do I see you needing a question? all right seeing no further questions thank you doc thank y'all very much we have uh miss wagner to speak against if i pronounced that wrong you've no that's correct um you would introduce yourself for the committee and you're
▶ Play
Speaker 171 1:10:51
recognized to proceed my name is ronda wagner and i'm very ill prepared i ran up at the last minute. I'm at Angie Grant Elementary, and we were approached about 12 months ago from Children's and have been interacting with them ever since and trying to create a program to work with the students of Arkansas. Benton is not rural Arkansas, but they picked my school because I'm at about 78% free and reduced kids in the school, which means the majority of my kids are Medicaid students and that is probably a little bit more representative of the students that will be seen if this continues to go out. They came into the school and we've had meetings with local providers that was on the very front end with children's trying to explain what the program was about and have and shouldn't you know let them know what they were wanting to do. It's my understanding that that is how the program will work in the other districts as well, is that there will be meetings with the local providers so that there's an understanding. I'd like to point out that, I mean, the equipment is amazing. I have a video teleconferencing system in my office. It allows the doctor to see everything I see, whether it's a throat because of the camera capabilities, whether it's an eardrum because there's an notoscope piece. There's a stethoscope piece. So the technology is very amazing. I have a built relationship with the majority of these students. They are kids whose insurance fluctuates. I never know if they're going to be on our kids or not on our kids because their coverage has lapsed. So there is a barrier sometimes with that. I can see with the authorization piece if they are on are off or who's their provider or who isn't their provider. The majority of the cases I've seen so far, the students haven't seen their primary care physician in quite a while, and that is one of our biggest goals is to try to get them back with their primary care home, but instead of them leaving my office to try to get an appointment, the majority of them would go to the ER or an urgent care clinic where they don't have to have a referral, I'm assuming. The billing is beyond me, but that is where the majority of my students go. or they just wait and they don't go and they're sick and they're still in the classroom and they're not learning. So the biggest proponent I am is that this keeps my kids in their seats. I've had parents that can't be there when we see the physician, but I've always called them. There is prior approval. I have consents on file so I know who is and who isn't. Now, with that consent, you know, they indicate whether they're private, our kids, or, you know, no insurance. Of course, that changes, so I never know if that's current or not, and I try to have those conversations when I make those phone calls to parents, and they're always given the option of, I have your student, his ear's hurting. Would you like to go see your primary care physician, or we have the telemedicine service that is optional. And then after the visit, the parents are always involved with what was found. There's an after-visit summary, and then there's an after-visit summary sent to the physician as well. This last week, like everybody else, flu is running rampant. I struggled to find a sub for my office, and I'm here. I've been seeing 70 to 80 kids a day. And so the authorization piece is kind of difficult. It's not that I don't want physicians involved, and I feel like they have been, you know, because we're trying to build those relationships. It's opened doors for us. It's had conversations with providers where I have students that don't have insurance at all. So, you know, trying to open those doors in the community to accept those patients, it's opened some conversation for that because we've been able to come in and have more interaction with those providers where we haven't had them in the past. So I just, I am concerned about the authorization part. It's not because I don't want doctors involved, because I feel like they are. And I feel like we know these students, and we give them every opportunity to see their doctors, and we encourage that. We want them to go into the primary care physician so that they can stay healthy and they can learn. And one more thing I would like to point out. I mean, it has its limitations, and the one thing working with children is they know that. They can't go in and diagnose strep because we have to follow, I have to follow my nurse practice acts. Well, the doctors have to follow certain criteria, and so far I had one that could have had strep. Well, they can't diagnose that without a culture, and the doctor wasn't willing to do that. So then the parents, you know, are having to go to the physicians, but there are some basic things that can be addressed with it.
▶ Play
Speaker 30 1:15:58
Representative Hammer, you got a question? And I know you've come in here at short notice and appreciate that. Have you ever been in a situation where you had a child that needed to see the doctor but couldn't get in to see the doctor, and the services that you provided for that child helped in a scenario like that and kept that child out
▶ Play
Speaker 171 1:16:23
of the ER? I have not yet. I have had parents tell me that are trying to get their child seen, that especially when the offices are so busy um that they can't get an appointment till friday that was monday i had a had a mom talk to me about trying to get her child into the doctor and she was told to go to the er you can't see your child till friday go to the er so i mean it does happen and that happens frequently and sometimes more frequently when this the clinics are busy busy and I'd just like to point out I have seen 13 total of 13 kids that's about two a month and I have a hard time believing that two patients a month is going to affect my local pediatrician's office. And
▶ Play
Speaker 30 1:17:11
to that point what is the working relationship with Angie Grant in the local PCPs and do they view what's being done over there as hostile do they view it as a threat I can't speak for them.
▶ Play
Speaker 171 1:17:24
I was on a teleconference because I was out of town when they had the meeting with the physicians, but they were very welcoming. They got to ask questions. It was not hostile in any way when I was participating. Granted, I was not in person. I'll just admit that. And there were other people that were on those conversations. It didn't appear to be the sounds. It was very cordial and they were able to ask lots of questions and it went back and forth.
▶ Play
It was a two-way conversation for sure. Thank you. Thank you for representing Pilkin. Do you
▶ Play
have a question? I do have a question this time. Go ahead. You said you saw 70 to 80 patients. How many of those were telemedicine
▶ Play
Speaker 171 1:18:13
visits, though? 13. Okay, thank you. Well, I mean, that's a day. 13 a day? No, no. I see 70 to 80 kids a day. I have seen 13 telemedicine patients since September. total 13 so about two a month is what I've seen
▶ Play
okay thank you for testimony thank you
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:18:34
we have Austin Gaines to speak for the bill
▶ Play
Speaker 180 1:18:43
yes sir how much time they have so
▶ Play
Speaker 181 1:18:48
you got about four minutes Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Austin Gaines. I'm a vice
▶ Play
Speaker 182 1:18:53
president with Mercy Health. I'm here to testify for this bill because you're about to do something extremely important for us. We have a physician in northwest Arkansas who's ready to take advantage of this bill. And I need to add another dimension to this. It's not about schools or Teladoc or MD Live or primary care. Our application of telemedicine at home will allow us to add a tool for our 1% sickest patients. We've modeled this in Missouri. We've got 360 patients now in home care. They're Medicaid and they're Medicare, some commercial, but predominantly we're aimed at our sickest patients. the patient has to fit the situation has to fit a profile of about seven factors and I can do that in just a minute and then I'll be through first of all the patient needs a history of multiple admissions and their health wise is frail they have multiple issues the unfortunate profile is they have diabetes they have COPD, they have cancer, they'll have 15 medications, and they need close-up care. Something goes wrong frequently. Some have as much as six or seven admissions a year. Their day-to-day health status is at risk. The physician's office, the PCP, has to want to do this. Every doctor has a care team, and he's paying that care team, and they don't generate revenue for him. So some offices are bigger than others, but they've got to want to do this, and they've got to have the staff that wants to do it. And then the patient and their family have to be able to use the kit that we give them. Mercy has 395 primary care providers in Western Arkansas. 260 are doctors, 101 are advanced practice nurses, 18 are physician's assistants. All will participate in this if they're on a team that has the patients that need it, and if their physician who leads the team wants the team to do that. The patient has to have goals. Goals that motivate them to work with their care team. Our results have just been wonderful. I'll tell you about the kit. We provide an iPad. The iPad is purposed for this function only. They can't play games on it. There's no personal data on it. It's for communication. It connects by Bluetooth with a scale, a blood pressure cuff, and a pulse oximeter. They have to know how to use it. They have to want to use it. Some of these patients just want to go back to church. They just want to be able to play bingo. What's our motivation? We are now at risk for readmission for our patients, and soon we'll be looking at Arkansas Medicaid and other reimbursement methods where we're at risk for the total cost of care. Our kit prices at about $800. We give it to the patient. If we avoid one hospitalization, we're so far ahead. You can't have a patient with multiple needs come into a Mercy Hospital for $800. So it's 1% of a practice, and this will allow us to take the technology home. So thank you
▶ Play
very much, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. Thank you for coming and testifying today. We have no more signed up to speak against. We have three to have yielded to speak for, so I'll let, if there are anyone else in the audience, speak for or against, we have very limited time. Without any others, Representative Ferguson, Senator Bledsoe, you recognize closed for your bill. Thank
▶ Play
you, committee. And I might add, you know, we're not just talking about children's. I mean, it's interesting that that has become the issue with this bill, which we've worked on for two years to work out all the originating site. But we're not just writing it for children's. You have to consider if anyone else, even if you think children's is doing it responsibly, if we don't pass this amendment, anyone else who might be doing a school-based clinic and seeing patients, there's no guarantee that they will be including the PCP in the continuity of care, and that it will be done properly if this bill as amended doesn't pass. But just, you know, like I said, we've worked very hard. We think it's a responsible expansion of telemedicine, and I might address the emergency room issue. As Representative Pilkington knows, we've gone through a lot about if a patient goes to emergency, but this is sort of a misconception that it costs more. If they go for a non-emergent visit to an emergency room, they are paid for an exam, and if they don't have a PCP, they're assigned one. So that's just a little side note that will help him explain this bill later. But I have nothing else to say. I mean, I think it's a great bill. I think it's a great move forward, and like I said, I think it assures that whoever works in a school-based clinic that it will be done responsibly.
▶ Play
Ladies and gentlemen, this has been very hard for me because I have held Children's Hospital up, almost revered them for 30 years. So this is hard, but this is about the future and my vision of telemedicine was to go into the rural areas, use it as a tool, but for a team, and if this is not done correctly, it will bring down the very people that they want to help, the people in the rural areas. They will circumvent that hospital that many of your people have raised taxes to support. It will circumvent that family practitioner, that PCP, that has the medical record. If you're a Medicaid child, that PCP has your medical record. It is not that distant site physician, no matter where it is, that has that record. So I would say to you that what you have heard that they're doing is a good thing. They're just not doing it in the right way. And I know that there is another large hospital that has applied for the same type of grant. they are getting the equipment the telemedicine equipment and they're taking it into the communities and they're teaching the people that are already there providing care to use that equipment that's the right way so again telemedicine is the senator we're out of time okay i'm sorry
▶ Play
having seeing no more time for debate uh what's the pleasure of the committee representative Peyton motion representative Peyton has a motion do pass there any discussion on the motion representative Henry you're recognized for discussion on the motion thank you Mr. Chair
▶ Play
Speaker 30 1:26:29
and I was wanting to get this question in the sponsor I didn't get back in the loop the one pause I have on this and maybe if this gets out of here this morning and it gets to the floor the one pause I have on this is that if I'm a parent in a problem it's do pass is amended correct who passes amended thank you you're welcome to proceed sorry to interrupt you thank you mr. chair the one one concern I have on this is if I'm a parent who has a child in the school and I want to utilize this option am I going to be prohibited by this bill from making that choice of utilizing the technology and the services that have been awarded through through children's hospital and if as a parent I'm having that that option removed from me then I think that's a hindrance especially if a couple days ago we we've made the decision about tanning beds because we want to give more parent control now I may be just totally confused but I didn't get to ask the sponsor that question and we can have talk offline but if it gets to the floor and
▶ Play
Speaker 187 1:27:35
I'm right on that that's a problem if I'm
▶ Play
wrong then we'll clear it up between here the floor. Thank you. Yeah, I mean, that was a concern. Oh, I
▶ Play
can't discuss it. I'm on the committee.
▶ Play
I can discuss. You're good. You didn't get recognized, but you're good. I'm sorry. I thought the amendment made that clear, you know, that absolutely the parent is in charge. The parent chooses the PCP. The parent absolutely has control. And, you know, I don't think if they're seeing two a month, it's burdensome to get approval, especially when, like I said, they're getting all these consent forms on the front end. And the way it works in an office, it takes about two minutes to get on the Medicaid side and confirm eligibility and who the PCP is for a patient. That's a very easy process.
▶ Play
Thank you. Any further discussion, Representative Payton? Do you have a discussion? Well, I'll just try to explain why I made the motion do pass. I mean, for over two years, we've wrangled with how we could open the door some for the telemedicine. And a lot of people agree that telemedicine can improve care to Arkansans, not in the rural setting, of course, but also in other settings. I will support other legislation that will go further than this bill, but this bill is a great step forward. We'll have coattails for Children's Hospital and others that want to try to take further future steps. And so I just ask for a good vote. Thank you. see
▶ Play
it. No further discussion. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? Ayes have it. Congratulations. Your bill is passed. Thank you committee very much. Representative Lundstrow, you're recognized to present. I believe it's 1428. Is that right? House Bill 1428.
▶ Play
Thank you, Chairman. This is a cleanup bill of antiquated language in the state law. It also clarifies laws. Representative, we do have an amendment first. Your amendment first. We have an amendment. This was in the wrong section, and we changed that and put it in the correct section. Okay.
▶ Play
Well, it's the pleasure of the committee on the amendment. Our motion do pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed, ayes have it. You now
▶ Play
present your bill as amended. Thank you, Chairman. This bill cleans up antiquated language in the state law and clarifies state law concerning abortion clinic licensure and inspections, as well as the Department of Health's ability to suspend a license, and it protects the health of the patient. It does not stop abortions. It only protects the health of patients, and I would ask for a good
▶ Play
vote. Any questions from the committee? Okay, we do have some people signed up to speak against the bill in the audience. Representative Lundstrom, if you would move aside, we'll go ahead and get Ashley Wright from Planned Parenthood.
▶ Play
Ms. Wright, you're recognized to introduce yourself and proceed with your testimony.
▶ Play
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm Ashley Wright, and I'm with Planned Parenthood Great Plains Votes. And Planned Parenthood Great Plains votes, as opposed to House Bill 1428, Planned Parenthood Great Plains Health Center staff work very hard every day to make sure that patients receive high-quality health care in a safe and respectful environment. Ensuring the health and safety of our patients is central to Planned Parenthood Great Plains' mission, and it's their first priority. Planned Parenthood Great Plains Health Centers have rigorous standards in place, and as a high-quality provider of medical care, they are always working to improve safety. Planned Parenthood adheres to medical standards and guidelines that are informed by the most trusted medical knowledge and standards, as well as professional and scientific organizations, including the CDC, the Food and Drug Administration, the U.S. Preventative Services Task Force, and the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. Abortion facilities in Arkansas are currently heavily regulated. Facilities are subject to periodic, as well as unannounced inspections, which includes, but is not limited to a review of procedures, techniques, medical records, informed consent signatures, and parental consent signatures. Patient care is about making sure Arkansans have safe, compassionate, respectful care, and that is exactly what Planned Parenthood is focused on every day. These proposed regulations are politically motivated with the intent to shut down health centers, leaving thousands of Arkansans without care. Planned Parenthood welcomes oversight and regulations that protect patient safety, but these procedures are already in place, and there is no medical basis for this bill. I urge you to vote no on House
▶ Play
Bill 1428. Thank you. Do we have any questions from the committee for the witness? Representative
▶ Play
Payton, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm reading the bill, and it says that it requires a licensed physician. so currently we allow people to do abortions that are not a licensed physician no there's a law in place in arkansas that requires it to be a physician to perform an abortion okay well the language here in the says medical practitioner and we're changing that to physician i believe there's a different law i don't know that exact act off the top of my head but there's a different law that actually states that it requires it to be a physician licensed yes yes definitely a licensed position. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Seeing no further questions, thank you for
▶ Play
your testimony. Thank you for your time. Did anyone else in the audience speak for or against this bill? Yes, ma'am. Go ahead. If you would, ma'am, you can introduce yourself for the committee
▶ Play
Speaker 83 1:33:39
and you're recognized to speak for the bill. I'm Nancy Emmons. I would just like, those of you who know me, know that my passion is for the unborn, and my passion is for children, period. John and I just got through going to Washington, D.C., to the Right to Life March. I wished each one of you sitting at this table, and this is not our first time, I wished each one of you sitting at this table. Ma'am, can you speak on the bill, please? Yes. I believe that what has just been testified is not the truth. We have had 385,000 babies that have been aborted. And I want to tell you, we have women who have testified to me how abortion has affected their lives. And we have also not taken consideration of the health of the woman. It is very detrimental to the women, many of them. And I want to tell you, many of these women have had the heart to come out and tell how it has affected them. And our votes affect that unborn child, a child who has no way of helping itself. And it has become a war in the womb. One of the things that I have noticed is those who are for abortion have already been born. I want you to think about that for a minute. We have a responsibility to the women and to their health after they have this abortion. And many of them will tell you it has affected them greatly. and many of them will tell you, please vote and come down on the side of life. Thank you so much. I know you have a hard job, and I thank you for your time. Thank you.
▶ Play
We did have someone stand up in the back to speak against the bill. Okay. No worries. Representative Lundstor, you recognize a close for your bill. Thank you, Chairman Wardlaw.
▶ Play
As Planned Parenthood stated, they are working to comply with the law, so they should have no problems. This law simply requires licensure of facilities. This law allows for women to have safe health care, so no one should have a problem with safe health care for women. And I would ask for a good vote. Thank you.
▶ Play
It's a pleasure, committee. I've got a motion to do pass as amended by Representative Boyd. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? Ayes have it. Representative Lundstreet, congratulations. You passed your bill. Thank you, sir. Representative Collins, you recognize to present your bill. Thank you very
▶ Play
much, Mr. Chair. This is House Bill 1434. I appreciate the indulging of the committee. I know you've been here all day. I've got a big binder, but I'm going to spare you all of that. This is a very simple, straightforward idea. It has to do with how we value women and men. It has to do with sex discrimination, and it has to do with the fact that that's not currently outlawed in the state of Arkansas. I first thought about this in a discussion about five years ago, talking about population. Obviously, the country of China has a real problem with this, and in a discussion, somebody mentioned to me, well, that's not illegal here, which was pretty surprising to me. I plan to move forward with this in 2013, but in the last two sessions, there were some other things going on that made the timing not good, and then I decided to pursue and just get this on our books in 2017. So that's why we're here today as opposed to some other time. The way the bill addresses this is pretty simple. If the doctor asks the woman a question, do you know the sex of the child? And then if she does, he lets her know it is illegal to have an abortion solely based on the sex of the child. That's the essence of the bill. So it's intentionally narrow. It is not some type of a trick bag to, you know, do a whole bunch of things beyond that. It is very narrow. And so when it says no abortion based solely on the sex of the child, that's what it means. Now, the kind of argument some people may make is, well, it doesn't sound like it has a lot of teeth in it because somebody can manufacture lots of reasons to do what they want to do. And in fact, there's some videos out there in some states where women have been coached on how not to come across as having a sex election, abortion, and other things. And I understand that. So the way that this would come to fruition in terms of its enforcement would be much like the way we catch drug dealers. So somebody sells heroin. Well, there's usually a pattern, a pattern of behavior that then gets known, and as that pattern of behavior gets known, then people can investigate from a prosecutorial standpoint. My hope is we never get there. I don't expect that there would be a major thing in the near term because of technology. Today's technology does not allow sex to be determined very early in a pregnancy. So, viability, abortion timelines, et cetera, that exist today and when sex is determinable are such that it would be almost impossible for this to be a massive issue in the United States today. But things are changing, technology is changing, and when you talk about the pace of technology, this protects our Kansans from this practice becoming something that we have to be concerned about. same time make sure that if a woman goes to see the doctor maybe she's got some level of confusion maybe she's got some level of prevent of preference and if a doctor says this is an illegal practice I think that will also have a preventative effect to some degree so with that mr. chair I'm happy to take questions seeing
▶ Play
no questions we do have a few people signed up in the audience speak against bill um representative collins if you don't mind we'll get you guys to move over and we'll get miss ashley wright to the table again i think yeah yep miss wright you you ought to know the protocol but now introduce yourself and you recognize speak against the bill yes thank you
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. I'm Ashley Wright with Planned Parenthood Great Plains Votes. Planned Parenthood Great Plains Votes is opposed to House Bill 1434. House Bill 1434 intrudes on the doctor-patient relationship by requiring doctors to become investigators and patients their suspects and blocks women from expert, compassionate health care. Patients must be able to trust their doctors to keep their personal and private information confidential. These laws would interfere with open, honest communication between doctors and patients. Requesting the medical records of a woman's entire pregnancy history is a violation of privacy and potentially her safety by delaying care for an unspecified amount of time. Planned Parenthood opposes racism and sexism in all forms, and we work to advance equity and human rights in the delivery of health care. We can all agree that gender discrimination is a problem. This bill, however, does nothing to address that issue or actually solve that problem. Instead, it places a burden on providers and aims to make safe, legal abortion less accessible. This bill has the potential to jeopardize the health of some of our minority communities, particularly Asian American and Pacific Islanders, as it is often thought that these individuals migrating to the U.S. practice sex selection and bring these values with them. This stereotype is ugly and dangerous and could lead to a woman being denied care. That is why the National Asian Pacific American Women's Forum opposes these types of bills. Planned Parenthood condemns selection motivated by gender bias, and instead I urge committee members to challenge the underlying assumptions and conditions that lead to these beliefs and practices, including addressing the social, legal, economic, and political conditions that promote any such bias. The world's leading human rights organizations, including the World Health Organization, have issued a joint statement concluding that curtailing access to abortion services is not a legitimate means of addressing sex selection, and that gender bias can only be resolved by addressing the underlying conditions that lead to it. Gender bias and discrimination would be better addressed by advancing policies that have been shown to decrease discrimination and improve women's lives, like ratifying the Equal Rights Amendment, improving access to education and health care, passing pay equity legislation, strengthening our safety net programs, and making child care more affordable. Attempts to restrict or deny access to safe abortion under the guise of presenting gender bias is harmful to women's health, counter to a human rights agenda, and primarily an extreme political tactic to ultimately make safe legal abortion inaccessible. It's important that a woman make her own personal, private medical decisions, including whether to choose adoption, end a pregnancy, or raise a child. These decisions must be left to a woman, her family, her faith, and the counsel of her doctor. I urge you to vote no on House Bill 1434. I
▶ Play
guess I need to turn the microphone. Seeing no questions, thank you for your testimony. Thank you for your time. We do have one more signed up to speak against, and that's Ms. Rita Sklar. Sklar, I'm sorry. I'm just an old dirt farmer, so I don't pronounce these words all that well. If you would
▶ Play
introduce yourself for the committee and carry it on. Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you, committee. Good morning. My name is Rita Sklar. I'm the executive director of the ACLU of Arkansas, and I want to say, first of all, that I'm very heartened to see a bill that states in writing that women are a vital part of our society and culture and possess the same fundamental human rights as men. um it's unfortunate that we have to put that in writing because many of us uh just assume that to be the true uh to that that to be true um and I would point out that if women have the same fundamental human rights as men that it's surprising then that there are no laws that I'm aware of that interfere with a man's medical decisions unless of course it's at a religious facility, but certainly not any other kind of law that I'm familiar with, where women's decisions are second-guessed. Basically, I want to point out what you know I'm going to say, which is that any law passed about an abortion performed pre-viability under the current law is unconstitutional. It doesn't matter why. It doesn't matter the method. It's unconstitutional. There's a constitutional right to have an abortion before the fetus is viable. This, sorry, there are lawsuits in four states currently, and each of those states, the law has been put on hold. There's been an injunction against putting the law into effect. And that should give this committee and the legislature some guidance. So I simply want to let the committee know that there is a very good potential for litigation because of this burden on women obtaining abortions that they want for whatever reason. Thank you. Thank you. Seeing no questions, thank
▶ Play
you for – Representative Pilkenin has a question. I'm sorry. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. You make the argument
▶ Play
that it's not constitutional, but I would just like to ask you this question. In the past, in the history of the United States, the United States Supreme Court has ruled that slavery and segregation are both constitutional now, if it's no longer that way, I hope that one day abortion will be ruled unconstitutional. But just because something may pass constitutional muster does not make it necessarily right. Would you not agree with that statement? Yes, I
▶ Play
Speaker 204 1:47:22
would agree with that statement. Thank you. Thank you, Ms. Rita, for your
▶ Play
testimony. Representative Collins, do you want to close for your bill? Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
I had an opportunity to talk with Ashley in a previous meeting, and she brought up some good points about timelines on things like records, and I thought about it, and it was a way to get more specific as opposed to the reasonable standard, and I would have done it if we could have done that, but the problem is the way technology changes over time, what's reasonable today and what's reasonable in the future could be very, very different, and if I said one week or two weeks or three days or something like that, what I wind up doing is restricting the future in ways that just aren't practical. I appreciate Ms. Glauer's positive comments about portions of the bill, although I understand she's fully against it, totally against it, but I appreciate the kind words about some of what's in the bill. With regard to court challenges, I'm very sensitive to that as well. I don't want to waste the people of Arkansas' money. this bill has been extraordinarily narrowly tailored there are several things that other states have done when they have passed sex selection bills for example talking about race selection talking about genetic anomalies and talking about other things and when you start broadening the subject you you enter in a lot more confusion complexity etc and in some of those bills as she said I think have been challenged but two bills that we modeled this two states that put in bills that we modeled this over, North Dakota and Arizona, those laws have been challenged and they remain in effect today. And with that, committee, I'd appreciate a good vote. Seeing
▶ Play
no further questions, I got a motion by Representative Hammer of do pass. Are there any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? Ayes have it. Congratulations, Representative Colleges. Your bill is passed. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. Seeing no further business, As we stand adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1264 Pilkington TO PROVIDE FOR REIMBURSEMENT FOR HEALTHCARE SERVICES PERFORMED BY A WALK-IN CLINIC OR EMERGENT CARE CLINIC WHEN THE PATIENT DOES NOT HAVE A PRIMARY CARE PROVIDER ASSIGNED.

HB1405 Lundstrum TO AMEND LAWS RELEVANT TO UNEMPLOYMENT TAXES, UNEMPLOYMENT BENEFITS AND UNEMPLOYMENT ELIGIBILITY.

HB1411 Penzo TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECKS FOR NURSING LICENSURE TO REMOVE A CONFLICT IN THE LAW.

0:36 - 1:29:30 263 segments 27 speakers

SB95 Irvin TO WAIVE THE LICENSURE RENEWAL FEE CHARGED BY THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF DENTAL EXAMINERS, THE STATE BOARD OF OPTOMETRY FOR CERTAIN ACTIVE-DUTY MILITARY HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONS.

HB1413 Boyd TO CREATE THE ALTERNATIVE TO DISCIPLINE ACT; AND TO PROVIDE FOR TREATMENT OF NURSES LICENSED IN ARKANSAS WHO SUFFER FROM IMPAIRMENT.

HB1428 Lundstrum TO AMEND LAWS CONCERNING UNLAWFUL ABORTIONS; TO AMEND LAWS CONCERNING THE PROCEDURE OF DENIAL, SUSPENSION, OR REVOCATION OF A HEALTH FACILITIES SERVICE LICENSE; AND TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING ABORTIONS CLINICS.

1:29:30 - 1:37:06 28 segments 6 speakers

HB1434 Collins TO CREATE THE SEX DISCRIMINATION BY ABORTION PROHIBITION ACT.

1:37:06 - 3:30

HB1437 D. Ferguson TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING TELEMEDICINE; AND TO CREATE THE TELEMEDICINE ACT.

3:30 - 1:56

SB78 Bledsoe TO REQUIRE THE ARKANSAS STATE MEDICAL BOARD TO PERFORM AN ANALYSIS OF THE INTERSTATE MEDICAL LICENSURE COMPACT TO DETERMINE WHETHER THE STATE OF ARKANSAS SHOULD PARTICIPATE IN THE INTERSTATE MEDICAL LICENSURE COMPACT.

HB1439 M. Gray TO AMEND THE HEALTHCARE QUALITY AND PAYMENT POLICY ADVISORY COMMITTEE.

SB170 Irvin TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION FOR LICENSURE FOR HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONALS OFFERING FREE HEALTHCARE SERVICES THROUGH A PROGRAM IN PARTNERSHIP WITH THE FEDERAL INNOVATIVE READINESS TRAINING.

SB229 S. Flowers TO REQUIRE CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECKS FOR ALCOHOLISM AND DRUG ABUSE COUNSELORS LICENSEES; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ALCOHOLISM AND DRUG ABUSE COUNSELORS.

HB1300 Miller TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES TO PRIORITIZE SPENDING WITH THE DEPARTMENT AND THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO FULLY FUND HOME- AND COMMUNITY=BASED SERVICES FOR INDIVIDUALS WITH DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES.

HB1462 McCollum TO AFFIRM THE LEGISLATIVE AUTHORITY OVER WAIVERS FOR THE SUPPLEMENTAL NUTRITION ASSISTANCE PROGRAM; AND TO PROMOTE ECONOMIC ADVANCEMENT FOR ARKANSANS.

HB1465 Miller TO CREATE THE MEDICAID EXPANSION ENROLLMENT FREEZE ACT OF 2017; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

SB191 E. Cheatham TO ELIMINATE THE RECORD MAINTENANCE FEE FOR VISITS TO LOCAL HEALTH UNITS.

HB1472 Ladyman TO EXPAND THE AUTHORIZATION FOR THE USE OF TEMPORARY ELECTRICAL LICENSES ON LARGE INDUSTRIAL PROJECTS.

HB1478 Lynch TO ELIMINATE REQUIRED RE-TESTING OF AN ELECTRICIAN WHO FAILS TO TIMELY RENEW HIS OR HER LICENSE; TO PROVIDE MONETARY PENALTIES FOR FAILURE TO TIMELY RENEW A LICENSE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

1:56 - -43:39

HB1034 C. Fite TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING HEARING INSTRUMENT DISPENSERS.

HB1180 Bentley TO AUTHORIZE ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES TO HAVE SIGNATURE AUTHORITY.

HB1181 Sullivan TO CREATE THE TRANSITION TO PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY ACT; AND TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY OF ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES.

HB1182 Sullivan TO AUTHORIZE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO ALLOW AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE TO BE A PRIMARY CARE PROVIDER.

HB1183 Dotson TO PROVIDE CONSISTENCY AND EFFICIENCY OF CHIROPRACTIC COVERAGE IN THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM; AND TO ALLOW MEDICAID RECIPIENTS DIRECT ACCESS TO A CHIROPRACTIC PHYSICIAN WITHOUT REFERRAL FROM A PRIMARY CARE PHYSICIAN.

HB1186 Brown TO REMOVE THE COLLABORATIVE PRACTICE AGREEMENT AS APPLICABLE TO ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES; AND TO CLARIFY THE PROCESS NECESSARY FOR AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE TO QUALIFY FOR PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY.

HB1204 Magie TO ALLOW PHARMACISTS TO MAKE BIOLOGICAL PRODUCT SUBSTITUTIONS.

HB1205 Magie TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS ANESTHESIOLOGIST ASSISTANT ACT.

HB1215 Love TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING THE PRACTICE OF MASSAGE THERAPY TO INCLUDE THE PRACTICE OF CUPPING.

HB1228 Hammer TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY OF AN ADVANCED PRACTICE NURSE.

HB1237 Hammer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS SURGICAL TECHNOLOGISTS ACT; AND TO ESTABLISH THE REGISTRATION OF SURGICAL TECHNOLOGISTS.

HB1250 M. Gray TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS DENTAL PRACTICE ACT; TO AMEND THE DENTAL HYGIENIST COLLABORATIVE CARE PROGRAM; TO MODIFY THE APPOINTMENTS TO THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF DENTAL EXAMINERS; AND TO MODIFY DENTISTRY SPECIALTY LICENSES.

HB1255 D. Ferguson TO CREATE A TEMPORARY CHARITABLE DENTAL LICENSE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1257 Richey TO CREATE THE COMMUNITY HEALTH WORKER ACT.

HB1254 Magie TO TRANSFER REGULATORY AUTHORITY OVER ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES FROM THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF NURSING TO THE ARKANSAS STATE MEDICAL BOARD.

DEFERRED

Number Sponsor Subtitle

HB1021 Love TO PROVIDE PAY EQUITY FOR WOMEN; AND TO AMEND THE WAGE DISCRIMINATION LAWS CONCERNING PROHIBITED CONDUCT AND REMEDIES FOR VIOLATIONS OF THE WAGE DISCRIMINATION LAWS.

HB1160 A. Mayberry TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF A "SPECIALIST SIGN ELECTRICIAN".

HB1040 Farrer TO LIMIT THE PRACTICE OF ATHLETIC TRAINING IN A NONCLINICAL SETTING.

-43:39 - 1:49:26 322 segments 29 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Jeff Wardlaw Chair Unverified
53 segments
Representative Clint Penzo Unverified
2 segments
Representative Aaron Pilkington Unverified
5 segments
Representative Deborah Ferguson Unverified
48 segments
Speaker 30
20 segments
Chair Unverified
15 segments
Senator Cecile Bledsoe Unverified
11 segments
Speaker 48
1 segment
Speaker 83
10 segments
Representative Robin Lundstrum Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 79
1 segment
Speaker 97
1 segment
Speaker 111
53 segments
Representative Austin McCollum Unverified
2 segments
Representative John Payton Unverified
21 segments
Representative Mary Bentley Unverified
16 segments
Representative Josh Miller Unverified
2 segments
Representative Justin Gonzales Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 147
1 segment
Speaker 165
11 segments
Speaker 162
1 segment
Speaker 171
15 segments
Speaker 24
1 segment
Speaker 180
1 segment
Speaker 181
1 segment
Speaker 182
8 segments
Speaker 187
1 segment
Representative Charlie Collins Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 204
1 segment