Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

State Agencies & Govt'l Affairs Constitutional Issues Subcommittee

February 15, 2017 ·Committee Room 151 ·1:31:25
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (20)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HJR1003 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HJR1003 Gillam AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION TO AMEND T…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1002 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1002 S. Meeks AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION TO PROVI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1004 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1004 Leding AN AMENDMENT TO ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION, ARTICLE 5, SE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1005 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1005 Lowery THE PUBLIC EDUCATION PARTNERSHIP AMENDMENT OF 2018.”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1006 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1006 K. Hendren A CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT REPEALING THE FISCAL…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1007 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1007 K. Hendren AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCER…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1008 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1008 Dotson AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION TO PROVIDE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1009 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1009 Dotson AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNING…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1010 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1010 Dotson AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNING…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1011 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1011 Drown AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNING…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1012 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1012 Shepherd AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION TO REVIS…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1013 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1013 Ballinger AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION REVISIN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1014 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1014 A. Mayberry AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1015 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1015 A. Mayberry A CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT TO PROVIDE THAT AN A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1016 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1016 Lundstrum AN AMENDMENT OT THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1017 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1017 C. Douglas AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION PROVID…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1018 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1018 Shepherd AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1019 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1019 Gazaway AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNIN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1020 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1020 Davis AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION TO REPEAL T…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1021 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1021 Sorvillo A CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT PROVIDING THAT A MONUME…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
We're going to go ahead and call this subcommittee of state agencies to order. We're meeting to hear the proposed amendments that will be referred to the full committee on state agencies. We're going to hear all the amendments before we make any, have any votes and make any decisions on them. So, we're just going to go down the line on the folks that are here and ready to present. Representative Meeks, are you ready to present H.J.R. 1-0-0-2? Yes, Mr. Chairman. You're recognized. Thank you,
▶ Play
colleagues. Thanks. HGR 1002, what it does is it gives the General Assembly the authority to make laws in the event that a catastrophic event should occur. Each one of us, unfortunately, we live in a time where any one of us could go to lunch and there would be a bright flash of light, and now all of a sudden we're the acting governor of a state in chaos. And unfortunately, the way our Constitution is laid out, we're very limited on our ability to make plans in the event that something like that should happen. And so what this constitutional amendment does very simply, it says the General Assembly can provide laws, can create plans in the event of a major catastrophic event. And it has to, the event, it's very specific, so it doesn't just open up willy-nilly. The event that occurs has to prevent the General Assembly, the Supreme Court, or our quorum court from being able to form a quorum. So we're talking about the death or incapacity of at least 50% of this body, 50% of the Senate, and also our constitutional officers, should such an event, God forbid, happen, we have nothing in place under the current system to be able to handle that event. And so the amendment that I bring before you today is probably the least controversial amendment on the agenda. It is the least, it's the one we pray we never need. But by the same token, I would submit it's probably one of the most responsible things that we as a body can do or that we need to do. And so my hope is that under the new system, we've got one amendment to be passed out by the House, one to be passed out by the Senate, and one to be passed out jointly. And my hope is, since this is the least controversial and one of the most responsible things that we need to do as a government, that this would be a strong candidate for that. And with that, I will try to answer any questions anyone has on it. Members, is
▶ Play
there anyone that has a question for Representative Meeks? Representative Blademan.
▶ Play
Oh, I'm broken. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Does this, Representative Meeks, does this address who would take offices, or is it a general, how does that work? That is a very
▶ Play
good question. As it stands right now, should the unthinkable happen, the Arkansas Constitution is, sorry, I kind of lost words. It always assumes that there's going to be a lieutenant governor in place to take the place of a governor. And we know that's not always the case. We saw that happen with Lieutenant Governor Mark Dahr, where we had a period of time where we didn't have a governor. After the lieutenant governor, the pro tem of the Senate is the one who would become an acting governor. He can never become the governor. He can only become an acting governor. And it would be his job to then call elections to elect a lieutenant governor. There's nothing within the Constitution that allows for the election of a governor other than general election. But if you got into a situation, say that, and this is one of those things you could win it, what if it to death, that let's say there were only three surviving senators. Could those three surviving senators say, we form a quorum, we're going to elect one of our members, and now he becomes the acting governor? Or if you get into a situation where there are only 10 House members that survive, and the Secretary of State also survives. Well, according to the line of secession, after the pro tem of the Senate, the next person in line should be the Speaker of the House. Well, do those 10 members have the authority to elect a Speaker, and then that Speaker be truly the acting Governor versus the next person in line who would become the Secretary of State? So you could end up in situations where you have a constitutional crisis where what would happen if all of us ended up dying in one of these events. You know, when the governor gave his State of the State address, second day of session, every single member of the central government was located in the House chamber. And while a lot of times we want to think of a, you know, a terrorist attack from foreign countries, you know, there's people in Arkansas who sometimes don't like the things that we do, and there's always the opportunity for a homegrown terrorist. And if every member of the central government were killed in such an event, or even if it was a natural event, what would happen then? You would end up with a constitutional crisis. Who would take over in that situation? We have nothing in place right now. And so what this would do is it would allow us as a General Assembly to make policies and rules to govern those events that we pray never happen.
▶ Play
Representative Wardlaw, do you have a question? Okay. Are there any other questions? We don't have anyone signed up to speak for or against this amendment. Is there anyone in the audience that would choose to speak for or against? Seeing none, thank you, Representative Meeks. And
▶ Play
thank you, colleagues, and at the appropriate time I would definitely appreciate your consideration
▶ Play
on this. Thank you. Representative Ballinger, I believe you are here to run HJR 1003, and I believe you have an amendment. You're recognized to
▶ Play
present your amendment. Thank you, Mr. Chair. The amendment is the bill, so if you want to actually look at the bill, then you'll see the amendment, obviously, with time constraints. It's kind of, we put it all together to make it easy to follow along, but the amendment essentially will fill in the speaker's shell bill, and so I would appreciate a good vote on the amendment and move to
▶ Play
pass. We have a motion to adopt the amendment. Is there any discussion? All those in favor, say aye. Nays. Ayes have it. You've adopted your amendment. Thank you, committee.
▶ Play
Okay, so this amendment is sort of a combination of several things. It's something that I was working on with the governor's office. It's something that actually Greg Ledding was working on with some other groups. It's also something that Representative Mayberry had been working on, And we sort of brought them all together because they actually applied to the same basic thing, and that's constitutional amendments. And so it is a bit of a big bill, and it starts with a really big title. So if you look at the amendment, it's the ugliest title, I think, that I've ever seen. So if you look at the resolution, and the reason for that is within this resolution, we're going to put us at a little bit of a higher standard of the titles that we refer out. And so we figured it would only be appropriate that we'd incorporate that title. So the very start, you see, you have like two pages of it. I'm going to try to do everything I can to twist Matthew Miller's arm to get this as small as we can and still comply with the title. But we're going to comply with the new standards of the title within the resolution that we used to set the new standards. So, all right, so let's start on page three. There are several things in here that are just cleanup, right? So if they used 8%, then they also used the parentheses 8%. So you see that that's just clean up there. There's not anything new on that. If you flip on over to page four, at the top of page four, you get the first thing that we're really doing with this amendment, and that is increasing the threshold for a constitutional amendment. And so as you see, the first paragraph on page four says, As for a petition considering the proposed amendment to the Arkansas Constitution, it shall be necessary to file from at least 25 of the counties. So what this will do is currently you have to have 75% correct signatures from 15 counties. Now it's increased that to 25 counties. The idea behind it is you should at least have a third of the counties in the state on board before you touch our Constitution. Now, later on, you'll see that we actually don't do that for initiated acts. And the reason is initiated acts is just an act. You know, we deal with the laws and acts all the time. They are something that can be amended. One of the things we want to do with this is we want to make it where amending our Constitution is not something that is done flippantly, easily. It's either something that's done purely by cleanup or it's something that's done because there's something that's fundamentally that needs to be changed. And so we've increased the threshold to even get an amendment out there. And then the next section is cleanup. But then if you come down to the bottom of page four, it's actually what my original resolution started as, and you have cleanup in order to clean up the ballot. So what this is is this moves up the deadline for submitting the signatures early enough that we can actually have a court challenge prior to the date in which it is kind of the drop-dead date for the ballot itself. So you have to know if something's going to be on the ballot or not on the ballot by August 15th in order to be able to get it kicked off and so that it doesn't actually show up on a person's ballot. And so that's something the governor's office and I had worked on in order to try to get that done. And so that's what this is. This just moves up the – it says that a challenge has to be made at least 60 days before – or 60 days after the filing of the petition, which gives the opportunity for the court to take it up if they want to hear it and get it done before August 15th. All right, so that's continued down to the next paragraph on the top of page 5. If you look on Section 6, then you'll see that it actually also increases the threshold for any amendment to be approved. So if you're going to amend the Constitution, you have to get it approved by three-fifths or 60% of the vote in order for it to actually amend and change the Constitution. And so the idea of this is, once again, we want to try to make the threshold higher. This is actually for anything we refer out, and it's also for anything that's initiated by the public. Now, once again, we don't want to hinder a person's ability to shape the laws. You know, if somebody wants to go out and they want an act, something enacted, they still can do so with the same standards that they have today. But if you want to amend the Constitution, we're going to bind ourselves to make it a little harder for us to do it, and we're going to bind the public to make it a little harder for them to do it as well. All right, the other thing that is included in this is a tool that I think is a unique and a good idea. It's something that if we're smart about how we do it, it'll be, I think, really efficient and effective in a way that we can get citizens involved in our government. It gives us the opportunity to refer out an act. So at the bottom of page five, we can do up to three acts a year. So if we have something that is particularly important to get the citizens' input on that we want them to approve, then it gives them the opportunity to do so, but only up to three a year. And it doesn't affect things like bond initiatives that are currently that you can refer out, and the Constitution limits us to those type of referred acts. So now it opened it up to any three referred acts. That issue continues on to the top of page six. If you look down, you come back down to the increased threshold, as once again referenced in the middle of page six. and i'm just trying to go through and hit some of the the uh notes the the issue where we where i talked about the new standard and the reason why we have the absurdly large and ugly ballot title is that is actually in the middle of page seven and so if you're going to if you're going to include a resolution you're going to have a ballot title then it needs to be intelligible honest and impartial. That's the language that's a wording from the Supreme Court itself that they apply to citizens if there's a citizen-led amendment. And so that's what we're going to apply that to ourselves as well. Now, the difference is what we don't want to do is create a private right of action in order for the court to be able to throw a measure off because of the title. And the reason for that is there's a bit of a balance of power that the court has given us deference on our title, but we still want our title to be able to be correct. So what we've done is just like the citizen has to go to the AG's office and have their title approved, we'll do the same thing. And if our title is not, doesn't meet that standard, then it actually gives the flexibility for the Attorney General's office to amend and change our title enough to make it actually comply with that. So that's at the bottom of page seven. All right. So then you see on the top of page eight. It's where it references the 60%. Again, then you have cleanup. And then you have something else. Representative Mayberry had a resolution that I thought was a good idea that we incorporated in here. It just says basically you can't include specific corporations or individuals within the Constitution. If you're going to amend the Constitution, you need to leave it to, you know, laws and not specific individuals. And so we incorporated that in there because it actually fit nicely in this resolution. I think it's a really good idea. All right, having said all that, I know that we've got a lot in here, and I'd be happy to answer any questions and try to help however I can.
▶ Play
Representative Laydeman, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So the 60-day rule, do you see that as something that would reduce what happened in the last election where you had amendments on the ballot and then everybody was out campaigning and then they got taken off the ballot. Is that the purpose of that? That is the purpose of that. And so it's
▶ Play
actually, they have to have their petition submitted within 180 days prior to the election date. And so they, if they have their petition submitted there, then a challenge has to be, has to be, be brought if there's going to be one within 60 days of, of that filing date. And the reason why we have it set at that, that time, it's going to be tight. It's going to be difficult. The court can get in and issue an opinion, but they're going to have to jump on it at that point. But we wanted to give everybody the opportunity to do it. One is the citizen who's working on amending the Constitution or amending the code. We want them to have the ability to collect signatures all the way up through at least the primary date. And so that's where you start because that's a good time to collect signatures. We want them to be able to do that. Then we want citizens to be able to make any claims and object to it and don't want to subvert their ability to do that. And we also want to give the court time to be able to make that decision. So this is working with the governor's office, secretary of state. It's kind of the best timing that we could come up with in order to feel like we've got all that handled and can still get it all done before August 15th, which is sort of the date that you've got to have it done by in order to have it on the ballot or not. So that's the idea. And just like, I mean, kind of a long answer to your question, but the answer to your question is, yes, if we do this this way, then we'll have a situation where we can keep, I think we had five ballot titles, something like that, that actually were on the ballot that had already been kicked off.
▶ Play
Members, any other questions? Representative Ballinger, I have one. How did you arrive at the
▶ Play
three-fifths threshold? The three-fifths threshold, or 60%, was just a number that we felt like was one that was manageable. What I've done is actually done a little research and looked at what the constitutional amendments have passed, actually all the way from the beginning, and I'd like to take credit for it, but actually Matthew Miller's office, BLR, did a good job of getting that stuff together. And in looking at them, we would probably still end up in a situation where we're a little over 50% pass rate if we required the three-fifths or 60% threshold. And it's really interesting, different times of history, we went a long time without passing very many or approving very many constitutional amendments, and then other times we approve them all. So it really is interesting. But for the most part, that 60% threshold will make it where a substantial number of them could be approved, but some of
▶ Play
them would not be. MR. Representative Dotson,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question. MR. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Going back to the ballot title, so if I understand this correctly, the legislature would not have the authority to actually approve the ballot title that they want to go out to the people, but the Attorney General's office would review it and they could change it and and then the Supreme Court could not weigh in on it at all? No. So to really give a little more detail to my answer, we can. I mean, we're the ones who make up our ballot title. So we'll be the ones that decide what title that we use for the ballot. The problem is that we have to meet a standard, which is not something that we just created to put it in the Speaker's resolution, but it's something that we did in order to to make it comply with what the court is already requiring for a citizen who amends the constitution and that that the title be intelligible honest and impartial and if we can't put together a title that and and if we can't meet the standard of intelligible honest and impartial then i don't think we're doing our job right so as long as we meet that standard then the ag will have only only function they'll have is approving it putting a stamp on it saying, yep, you met that standard the same way that we require a citizen when they initiate a constitutional amendment. And the reason why we use the Attorney General's office to do a reformation or reform the ballot title if it doesn't meet that standard is because I think that there is a separation of power issue that I think really needs to exist. You know, we do need to have a legislative and judicial. Currently, the judiciary gives us deference in our ballot titles. I think I appreciate that unless we're going to commit fraud. So you can have somebody who is the attorney for the state, the attorney general. You know, they go out and they defend our laws, our constitutional amendments, and all that in court. They are the most appropriate person to look at it and amend it because I don't think it would be a good idea for us to call a legislative session to come back and amend our titles the same way that private individuals and companies who are applying for constitutional amendments can and do that. Follow up, Mr. Chair? I think I understand what you're saying, but I think the challenge I might have is this would basically give the Attorney General veto authority on the ballot title over the legislature. So there's an option of doing nothing. And so if we do nothing and we have complete and total control of the ballot title, the question is, are we better off as a governmental service and representing our clients that we're able, without any limitation, to put together whatever ballot title that we want and not have to meet that standard? So if we're going to meet this standard, so if it's going to be honest, intelligible, and impartial, then we'll have to have some way of deciding whether or not that standard has been met. And so you have the AG who's already in the business of doing that. You know, they approve it on a regular basis or they don't approve it on a regular basis for other private citizens who are doing this. And so what we're doing is we're importing a standard that's well set within the law, within our judiciary, something that the Attorney General's office has been handling for a long time. The Attorney General's office is not actually one of the branches of government, either executive or judiciary. They're designed as being an impartial attorney for the state. And so if we're going to do this in a way that the legislature still retains our authority, but also that we're going to meet a standard. This is the best way that I could think to do it without yielding the ability to really have veto authority over whether or not that we get a resolution on the ballot. So there has been an effort out there for people to move us under the same standard as the public and allow a person a private right of action to sue to say our ballot title is not sufficient, and then that would require the courts to make a decision. one way or another, whether we met that standard. And in doing so, we would create a situation where we put the courts in a position where they can throw our resolutions off the ballot. And while I think that they would be restrained in how they do that, at the same time, I don't think that that is good governance to create a situation where we're not striking that balance in ambitions, checking ambitions. I hope that answers your question. Historically, we have done, I think, a pretty poor job of meeting this standard since I've been in the legislature, and I know that sometimes titles are put together with the intent to create either one person's view one way or another way. I think that when we're amending our Constitution and we're putting it out to a vote of the I think it's really important that we provide them with the information about what's in it. And this is something I would like to see done. But if they don't vote for this because of the fact that they don't like my ballot title, then I want the citizens to know what they're doing when they're amending their Constitution. And I just think that's probably a good plan for all of us to do.
▶ Play
Representative Dotson, there's no one else in the queue. So
▶ Play
if you have another question. Well, I don't know if I have another question as much as
▶ Play
Speaker 47 24:16
a thought or statement upon it, but I'm not really,
▶ Play
I understand your answer. Thank you. Okay. Thank you. I don't see any other questions, but I just want some clarification, Representative I see Representative Letting has 1-0-0-4 and Mayberry has 1-0-1-5. Are you telling me that they both agreed that they're rolling this into this proposal here, this bill? The answer is I
▶ Play
think absolutely yes. I'm not sure about Representative Letting, although I talked to him today about it. He wants to be part of this effort, but I can't say for sure that he's not planning on running his, Because although in visiting with him, he actually said that the timeframe in this, he thought worked better. So my guess is that he's probably not going to run his resolution and just help with this one.
▶ Play
All right. Thank you. We don't have anyone signed up to speak either for or against this. So thank you. Wait a second. Representative Gonzalez, you
▶ Play
Speaker 51 25:18
have a question? You recognize? Thank you, Mr. Chair. I was just having to be looking at Mayberry's 1015, and it talks about individuals or businesses, entities identified by name. Is that addressed and the one we're talking about as
▶ Play
well? It is. If you go to the page 8 at the bottom, starting in Section 11, it just basically incorporates Mayberry's language in there. Other people had great ideas and just stole their ideas to make my resolution better. Well, really not my resolution, but the speaker's resolution, which I didn't
▶ Play
want to point out as the speaker's resolution. All right. Thank you, Representative Ballinger. Thank you. Well, I don't believe Representative Letting is here, so we're going to assume that what you said is correct. Representative Lowry, are you ready to present HJR 1005? You are recognized to present your resolution. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. I can't trump what Representative Ballinger did in invoking the speaker's name, other than to say he used to be my seatmate, if that helps. This resolution that's before you is a mirror of what was presented over in the Senate by Senator Blake Johnson. He is also a co-sponsor on this. And to delve into this, I really feel like I've got to give some background of the issue that's facing. Any of us that have been involved in the education committee and adequacy hearings and such have grown very accustomed to hearing the reference to the Lakeview decision. The Lakeview decision started with Lakeview School District filing a lawsuit about inequity of funding. This has been a process that has been in place since 1992. That was the first time that the suit was filed. It's gone through several variations, gone through several administrations, and to this day still continues to be, I would say, a specter that hangs over any of our deliberations when it comes to setting decisions about funding at state level. As a matter of fact, it's such an ominous presence that there are a number of times that ‑‑ I'm sorry, I'm getting some feedback. The other one was on. It's such an ominous presence that sometimes attorneys or representatives from the Attorney General's office kind of wave us off if anyone ever talks about whether there is enough money to fund, that that is not supposed to be the issue. And the prevailing sense of that, and this does affect everyone, whether they've been in an education committee or not, is that the governor is not able to present his budget until the funding amount for education has been established first. Everything else has to wait on that. One of the things as we've been digging through this and looking at this issue, one of the the issues that I have raised a number of times is that while Lakeview does put a tremendous responsibility upon the state of Arkansas to make sure that public education is funded equitably, it also gives us a responsibility, and it's very seldom invoked or discussed or mentioned aloud, it also gives us the responsibility of making sure that we understand we have the oversight to make sure that school districts also spend the money equitably. And we've really not taken on that responsibility. We have not recognized that Lakeview doesn't just say that we have to provide money equitably. It has to be spent equitably. And I'll give you example, I will be filing a bill either tomorrow or Friday that looks at net legal fund balances that school districts are holding, money that they are able to carry over from year to year, over and above their expenses. And when I first started looking into this issue, I saw a chart that said that Arkansas school districts were sitting on, and of course this This was in reference to what's called the unrestricted fund balance, which is different from the net legal, and believe me, you don't want ... I've had to really drill down to try and understand the differences. But it alarmed me to find out that school districts are sitting at that time, this was two years ago, on $692 million. figure now when you look at net legal balance is $750 million. Money that's supposed to be spent on the kids. Money that should be spent on programs in school districts, but instead the school districts and parents, rightly so, come to the state and say, well, it's your responsibility to make sure that these programs are funded adequately. This constitutional, this resolution makes it very clear that the responsibility for funding education is the responsibility, and if you have it in front of you, you will see on page two, I think it's one little word change, but it's the most significant aspect of this, and it is on line 15, references in section B. The specific intention of this amendment is to authorize that in addition to existing constitutional constitutional or statutory provisions, the general assembly, and the language has been and or, we're changing that to and, the general assembly and public school districts may spend public funds for the education of persons over 21 years of age and under six years of age, as may be provided by law. And it goes on to point out, starting in line 22, the maintaining of a general suitable and efficient system of free public schools by the state and public school districts, and the actions of the General Assembly as part of the supervision of public schools shall not be violated. Our actions shall not be violated. In other words, the courts alone cannot dictate to us, if this resolution is referred to the the voters the equitable spending of money, that this would be a joint responsibility of both the state and the public school districts. And I think we have to recognize, and I will fully acknowledge that there have been some significant benefits of the Lakeview decision, something that, like I said, started in 1992. One thing that came about from it is school districts were mandated to carry at least 25 mils on the books. I think that that was a significant step forward in making sure that school districts do their part. But in many regards, we really have not held public school districts accountable for the funding that they receive and whether they are spending it equitably. This resolution would do that, and at the same time, it would also get us out from under the specter of court supervision in terms of making sure that the public school system, the free public school system is funded equitably. That does not mean that the courts are completely cut out of this. There still could be challenges. There could be legal challenges. But now the legal challenges would not just be against the state. But it would be that if a parent feels like their school district is not spending equitably, if they look over and they find out that the net legal fund in a school district that is upside down on every educational metric that that school district is sitting on $33 million that they could be using to fund one-on-one tutors or start quality pre-K programs or or expand those programs, that family would have the ability to be able to file a lawsuit against the school district, not just the state. And I know that that's a scary proposition, but most of us believe in local control. We also ought to believe in local responsibility. And that's what this resolution does, and I've tried to crystallize it as much as possible. I know that there will be a number of questions, and I think that there's even some testimony that will be presented against the resolution. So at that point, I'm open for any questions.
▶ Play
Members, do you have any questions for Representative Lowry? We have some people signed up to speak against this resolution. We're going to begin with Clayton Blackstock, is that correct, with the Arkansas Education Association? Yes, correct. Please identify yourself for the record, and you're
▶ Play
recognized. Thank you. My name is Clayton Blackstock. I'm general counsel for the Arkansas Education Association. I'm here speaking for the Arkansas Education Association, but I'm also here speaking as a parent who has had a child who has successfully made it through the entire 12 years of the Arkansas public school system. I moved here in 1983. That was just the year after, the first time that the Arkansas Supreme Court entered the foray of looking at school funding in the Alma versus Dupree case. When I came here in 1983, the Supreme Court had already spoken. They had determined that the system was unconstitutional, and in part, the reason why it was unconstitutional is we had some districts that were getting twice as much funding as other districts on a per-student basis. Some districts were only getting $700 in funding per student, and other districts were getting twice that amount. So the disparity, and if my child had been here at that time in 1983, if we happened to be in one of those districts that was only getting that small amount of money, my child would not be getting an adequate and equitable education. The Supreme Court at that point, when I got here in 1983, had left it up to this body to fix the problem. They did not come in and tell you how to do it. They just said, here it is, and it's not meeting the standards. Ten years later, the problem had not been fixed by this body. That was 1992, and that's when the Lakeview case was filed. At the time the Lakeview case was filed, the court looked again at the disparities in the different districts throughout the state. They found that in some districts, just like in 1982, conditions were so deplorable. Some districts had no computers, no laboratories for their science equipment, broken heating and air conditioning, roofs that leaked. There was even a math class that had a chalkboard they had to use to give their tests because the mimeograph machine was no longer working. The disparity was terrible, and so the lawsuit was filed in 1992. And what did the court do again? The court looked to this body and said, please, it's your responsibility here. It still hasn't been fixed. Fix it. Ten years went by. That litigation continued, and the court continued to say, do something about this. In the middle of that litigation in 19, excuse me, about 1996, Amendment 74 to the Arkansas Constitution was passed, and that's the amendment we're dealing with now that says every child in this state is entitled to an adequate and equitable education. But it also did one other thing, because when Lakeview was filed, the citizens of the state of Arkansas realized that there were some districts that had a little more money, and they wanted to be able to spend that little additional money in their district and not have to make things exactly equal. So Amendment 74 allows school districts to raise a little more money if they have it. And that means that they can spend that and have a little bit better for things for their kids in those districts. So Amendment 74 was passed. The court was still monitoring the legislature. Still nothing had happened. Ten years after Lakeview was filed, In 2002, the problem still had not been fixed, and that's when the Supreme Court came down and said, look, the problem is not fixed. It's been 10 years since Lakeview was filed. They once again reiterated all the deplorable conditions in some of the smaller school districts in the state and the ones that have low property values weren't able to raise any money. It still was not an equitable or adequate education. At that point in time, in 2002, is when the legislature finally became active. It had been now, 82, 92, 2002, the legislature finally got active. They did fix the system. They put a system in place, and by 2007, the legislature had a system in place that made sure that all students in Arkansas, not just some of them, would have an adequate and equitable education. From 2007 to this point in time, the court has not been involved. The system has been working. This body has been operating under that directive. And nobody, you'll notice, has brought the state back into court. My concern as a parent, and my concern for all of the students in the state of Arkansas and potential students coming up is that under this amendment, the Supreme Court is not going to be involved at all in looking at the school decisions that this body makes regarding schools. It will not be involved. There will not be any lawsuits filed. The bill actually takes the judiciary out of the process of determining whether there is ever an adequate and equitable education. And so I, as a parent, if I were a parent and 10 years from now, I am now in that school district that doesn't have the laboratories, that doesn't have the computers. And like the Supreme Court said, there are other districts at the same time who were teaching German and had fashion classes and who had marketing classes and had the highest technology ever. But I now am a parent in one of these small districts. I am stuck in that district. I have a low-paying job. I can't go anywhere else. That is where my child is going to be educated. I want to be able to go to the Supreme Court. I want to be able to go to somebody and say, fix this system in this small school district where I am. I could come to my legislator. I could come to my senator, but those are only two people. And they do not have the power to change what has happened in that district over the last 10 years. And we know historically it has happened. From 82 to 92, it didn't get fixed. From 92 to 2002, it has taken the courts each time to come in, and under this amendment, that will be taken away, and those small school districts will be stuck. The second thing this amendment does is creates what's supposed to be a partnership. That is, the school district and the state both have a responsibility to provide an equitable and adequate education. So let's take my scenario again where I am the parent, I am in the district that doesn't have the laboratories, that doesn't have the computers, I have nowhere to go. I come to my legislator and my senator and I say, please help me in my district. And they say, I'm sorry, this is a partnership. You need to go to your school district and tell them to fix the problem. It's not our problem anymore. And my school district doesn't have the money to do it and the state is not going to provide been with any money, and I'm stuck again, and I can't go to the Supreme Court. This amendment is not in the best interests of the students in the state of Arkansas. It puts them at risk. It puts them at high risk that we are going to go back down the same path we went before. Thank
▶ Play
you. Mr. Blackstone, you willing to take questions? Yes. Members, does anyone here have any questions for Mr. Blackstone? Seeing none, thank you, sir, you're dismissed. We do not have anyone signed up to speak for this resolution. Is there anyone in the audience that would desire to do so? All right, the next person signed up to speak against is Kristen Garner with ASBA. identify yourself for the record and you're recognized. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 71 43:21
I'm Kristen Garner, staff attorney for the Arkansas School Boards Association. I'm not going to repeat the substance of Mr. Blackstock's remarks. I thought he did a really good job of explaining the background and the history behind the Lakeview decision. Representative Lowry, I share your personal horror about the fund balances. I've been doing this for a while, and I was working in education pre-Lakeview. Some of our school districts still remember the battle days when the state would promise funding and then change their mind and not send the full amount. And some of the hoarding behavior and the refusal to spend money has its origins in those terrifying bad olden days when they simply couldn't rely on money flowing from the state. I'm not excusing that behavior, but I offer that as a partial explanation. What troubles us about this amendment is how vulnerable it makes Arkansas's children. There are only a handful of school districts in this state whose millage is sufficient to fund their operation maybe with some leftover as well. All the rest of them have to be topped off. In many cases, the vast majority of the funding per student comes from the state because the school district is in such a economically impoverished, low property value scenario or a lot of their territory is national forest or there's some other good reason. We're very concerned that when the word partnership is used, but the parties are vastly unequal in power and resources, that the state might be tempted, and I'm not talking about this legislature, but a future legislature might be tempted to shirk responsibility for public education and put it back on local communities which are incapable of taking care of the job. We feel like that it is public education that gives a child born into poverty, born into a disadvantaged situation, it's public education that puts the boots on the child for the child to be able to bootstrap himself into a successful and fulfilling life. And for those reasons, we're very concerned and would recommend that you not advance this amendment forward. Thank you.
▶ Play
Does any members have any questions for Ms. Garner? Ms. Garner, I think I have one based on what Representative Lowry said. I think he referenced the fund balances, unrestricted fund balances that a lot of school districts have. And if I understand, I think what his purpose was, was probably trying to require them to who spend some of those monies, would you disagree with that?
▶ Play
Speaker 71 46:27
Absolutely not. I absolutely support money that has been allocated to school districts being spent on children and facilities and salaries for teachers. That's what they're there for. Any other questions? Ms.
▶ Play
Garner, thank you very much. Thank you. The next person we have signed up to speak against the bill is Dr. Blankenship. Please identify yourself for the record
▶ Play
Speaker 78 47:15
and you are recognized. Hi, I'm Jenny Blankenship. I'm Education Policy Director for Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families. I do not like testifying against bills, especially when I had to do it two times yesterday against other people that I like very much on the same issue, and especially when Representative Lowry has been such a good friend of our organization over the years. And I don't want to repeat a lot of what's already been said. We're certainly not testifying against the intentions of the sponsors, the co-sponsors, or the House or Senate education committees, or this legislature in general. Our concern really is about unintended consequences that could come from future legislatures that don't have the kind of institutional memory that some of you do have about the history of the Lakeview decision and why it was made and why a lot of these decisions have been necessary. So we just were concerned about some of the language in this bill. It creates ambiguity in who ultimately would be responsible for education in this state. A lot of that has already been said. It removes judicial review, and it could undermine the progress that the state has made over the past few decades in education. Do we wish we were further along by this point? Yes. Do we share the concerns that Representative Lowry has about unspent fund balances? Yes. And I would be delighted to work to help support legislation that would require some of these districts to spend the money that they've been sitting on, especially when we're talking about national school lunch funding that's intended for some of the poorest students in our state. That is a problem. I understand where the representative and the senator are coming from on this issue and, you know, in principle, agree with a lot of it. We're just concerned about the specific language of what this resolution would do if it were adopted and passed as an amendment to our Constitution. We think it puts a lot of things at risk in the future, especially for our most vulnerable children. And we just have to maintain the checks and balances that we need to protect those kids. So thank you. I'll try to take questions if you have any. Members, are there
▶ Play
any questions for Ms. Blankstenship? Thank you. We have no one else signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Lowry, would you like to make some closing remarks? Yes, I will,
▶ Play
and I know we've spent a lot of time on this, so I will try to be as concise as possible. You know, I want to reiterate that I think that there have been some significant advantages that have come about through the process of Lakeview. I mean, you hope that over a 15 to 25-year period, you're going to see some improvements, and we have. However, I think that we still have, the legislature has really not fully addressed our responsibility in making sure that we do have this partnership. You know, if nothing else comes from presenting this today, at least I've found out where all my supporters are for my fund balance cap that I'm going to be presenting in committee soon. Because it's, you know, that's a significant issue. I just received today a spreadsheet showing me, you know, under that bill, we're not going to make them spend down immediately in one year because we don't want them to irresponsibly spend down. They would have five years. But even at that, one school district, in spending down at 20% per year to get to 20%, would have to spend down $3 million just to be showing progress in spending down. That would not have been the case if we had a true partnership. That's not what we have had. And this amendment would enforce that. And I do appreciate the testimony that has said that the concern is what a future legislature might do. I understand that. And they're very kind to say that they have confidence in the legislature that is currently here and the people that are here. But I think that that conscience of making sure that children are protected and taken care of and equitably and fairly educated, I don't think it's something that's just unique to this legislature. I think it will be something that will carry on. And I think it can carry on, especially if we codify the fact that this is a partnership. So thank you very much for your consideration of this amendment. Thank you.
▶ Play
Thank you, Representative Lowry. Representative Hendren was not able to be here today, so we're going to skip over the next two. Representative Dobson, are you prepared to present HJR 1008? And I believe you have an amendment. You're recognized to present. Yeah. Representative Dotson, I already have a motion to adopt your amendment. Is there any additional explanation required? To
▶ Play
adopt the amendment? No, the amendment is the
▶ Play
amendment. Right. Okay. We have a motion to adopt the amendment. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any
▶ Play
opposed? Nay. Your amendment is adopted. Thank you, Mr. Chair. House Joint Resolution 1008, as amended, is now a proposed amendment to the Constitution that would do simply one thing, make the Arkansas State Highway Commission a state agency. and that is the amendment or the proposal subject to the legislature and the administrative branch just like any other state agency would be. And that's the entire presentation.
▶ Play
Representative Lateman, you're recognized for a question. What would be the benefits of doing this? Why are we doing it?
▶ Play
How would we benefit? Well, over the course of the last several years that I've been in the legislature, as well as prior to when I came into the legislature, I'd heard a number of concerns people had had about the responsiveness of the State Highway Commission or the State Highway System. And now being in the legislature, I've experienced it. It's the one area of state government that it's very difficult to get a response from. So I think this would provide a lot more oversight. Being a member of a local municipality prior to joining the legislature, on the city council, I felt like I had a lot more oversight and say in how street projects were managed in the local town as well as how highway projects going through the town that I represented were handled than I do as a member of this body today. So although the vast majority of the public out there believes we have a lot of influence and say over what happens on our Arkansas highways and roads, bridges, construction, and of course they see a lot of construction going on, a lot of dollars being spent, we don't have any say in what happens on our Arkansas highways today. And I believe that this would help bring that into alignment and allow what happens with one of the major expenses in our state budget come into some sort of an oversight by the people. Any other questions
▶ Play
for Representative Dotson? Representative House, you recognize for a question. Representative
▶ Play
Dotson, do you know how much debt the State Highway Department has accumulated? I do not. At this time? I do. It's about a billion dollars, just shy of a billion dollars since last year, and that's debt that has to be paid. Do you know how much their annual payments of principal and interest amount to on that debt? I'm sure you do, and you're about to tell me. Well, it's enough to make up the shortfall they've been talking to us about meeting their needs.
▶ Play
I think I can agree with you that they're really good at spending the money, but they keep asking for
▶ Play
more. Yeah. Are you aware of any, are you aware of the Highway Department's Blue Ribbon Commission recommendations that it was formed a couple of years ago? I'm familiar with most of them. I'm not sure which one you're referring to. Okay. They've had several Blue Ribbon Commissions. And Mr. I'm sorry, Mr. Chairman. You're recognized. I apologize. Okay. THE HIGHWAY DEPARTMENT WENT THROUGH A SPATE OF SPENDING, BORROWING AND SPENDING IN RESPONSE TO THE SALES TAX THAT WAS VOTED IN BY THE PEOPLE, THAT WAS PRESENTED TO THE PEOPLE AND THEY VOTED IN. THEY WENT THROUGH A LOT OF CONSTRUCTION AND I THINK THEY'RE PRETTY MUCH ON THE TAIL END OF THAT CONSTRUCTION. Since that time, or at least as of last year, I guess it was, they have tended to move over into maintenance efforts more so than new construction. Do you, are you familiar with that particular issue and that emphasis from going from new construction to maintenance or have you had any discussions with them about that? I'm not familiar with what you're referring to specifically. Okay. There's some maintenance cost. You build a road, then you have to maintain it. Oh, ongoing. O&M. Yeah. Have you seen any numbers or figures on those maintenance costs? I haven't seen any recent figures on it, no. Okay. All right. Mr. Chairman, thank you very much. Any other
▶ Play
questions, members? We have no one signed up to speak for or against this resolution. Is there anyone in the audience that has failed to sign up to speak for or against this one? Representative Dodson, do you have any concluding remarks with this resolution? With this
▶ Play
1,008, I appreciate your consideration of the proposal. Okay, thank you. I believe
▶ Play
you're next up with 1,009. I believe we needed a motion to adopt your amendment. I'll move to adopt the amendment. We have a motion to adopt the amendment. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed,
▶ Play
nay? We've adopted your amendment. Thank you, Mr. Chair. House Resolution 1009, this is another amendment fairly similar to the previous one. Currently, higher education in the state of Arkansas under Amendment 33. There seems to be some confusion sometimes on whether or not higher education or institutions of higher learning always want to comply with some of the legislative legislative laws that we pass here. and they often issue or cite Amendment 33 as the purpose or reason for that. What House Resolution 1009 would do if adopted and voted upon by the people would simply clarify that for institutions of higher education as well as the General Assembly that institutions of higher education would be within or would have to comply with laws enacted by the General Assembly, particularly with regards to their operations and duties. And so that is the main intent of this, is to make sure that they have the clear directive that if we enact a law regarding their operation or duties, that they would have to comply with that law. And that's the amendment in a nutshell, or the resolution,
▶ Play
Speaker 97 1:01:30
I mean, in a nutshell. Are there any
▶ Play
questions for Representative Dotson? It has. We have no one in the audience that has signed up to speak for or against the resolution. Thank you, Representative Dotson. Thank you. Are you running this next one? No. Okay. That is all. All right. Representative Drown, are you ready to present 1-0-11? I believe you two have an amendment that needs to be adopted. We have a motion to adopt the amendment. All those in favor say aye. Any opposed? Representative Drown, your amendment has been adopted. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 100 1:02:30
you, Mr. Chair. I want to start off talking about
▶ Play
how we got to joint resolution number 1011 regarding the amending of Amendment 33 and to give this body a better understanding of how we have come to this point. And I would like Representative Lowry to give a little bit of history on the amendment itself and the actual verbiage that is used, that is being used to keep the legislature at
▶ Play
bay. Thank you. Thank you for allowing me to present again. Something else here. Hope it doesn't hurt him. The original Amendment 33 was ratified in 1942, and it was in response to—Governor Adkins, Homer Adkins was elected, and he—one of the things that he did is he purged the board of the University of Arkansas at Fayetteville in order—in other words, just totally changed the board because he wanted to fire future Senator J. William Fulbright, who was president of the university. So the amendment was a reaction to that, and the sole legislative intent of Amendment 33 was to remove the ability for a governor to replace a board, and by extension replace the president. That was the legislative intent. However, contained within Amendment 33 is language that refers to vested powers, that the vested powers of higher education should not be infringed upon. I don't have the exact language right in front of me. Um, currently it says the board or commission of any institution governed by this amendment, 33, shall not be abolished, nor shall the powers vested in any such board or commission be transferred unless the institution is abolished or consolidated with some other state institution. Higher education, by and large, has taken those few words, powers invested in the board, and interpreted them to mean many times that the legislature and the executive branch have very little oversight of higher education. Now, I'll give you an example of where that was actually exercised, I've got to bring up here, in 1995, the higher education, the Department of the Division of Higher Education, the Higher Ed Coordinating Board, rejected the University of Central Arkansas's plans for doctoral programs in physical therapy and school psychology. Their argument was that there were other programs at other universities within close vicinity. The University of Central Arkansas turned around and sued the coordinating board, coordinating board that is supposed to have oversight of them. They sued, alleging that they did not have the authority to usurp those vested powers. Before the case could ever get to the Supreme Court, which we probably could have used, we could have used the Supreme Court review to interpret what that actually meant, the Higher Ed Coordinating Board and the University of Central Arkansas settled out of court. To this day, there has not been any additional challenge to interpret that. However, there still has been an almost understanding that the universities have autonomy in terms of making their decisions and that really the legislature only has one thing that we can hold, and that is the pocketbook. And that is a significant hammer, but it really does not get into other areas that I know the legislature and the executive branch feels like is necessary. sometimes. So that's the history, and I'll go ahead and turn it over to Representative Drown for the rest. Thank you
▶ Play
for that. Committee, Mr. Chair, the reason we're here is a few months ago, I wound up getting directed towards an entity of higher education here in the state. So So we started doing some investigating, and I was pointed to one of the questions that was brought up. Of course, Amendment 33 was thrown up once or twice regarding questions we were asking. But one of the things that troubled me the most is when you brought up the amount of carryover that one institution has, and by the way, June 30th of 2016 was three quarters of a billion dollars. What troubled me the most is I wanted to, at about three to four weeks ago, I walked into BLR and I said I would like the numbers for the amount of carryover for higher ed wide. A week went by, I went back and I said, do you have those numbers yet? Well, you have to understand we're at their mercy. We're trying to get you the hardest numbers we can, but because they provide us those numbers in a way that we cannot tell exactly how money is being distributed, how much of that is actually on hand, we need a little bit more time. So two weeks went by. I went back. Same answer. We still don't have that. Now, this is the Bureau of Legislative Research. They should be able to pull those numbers up and have those to us within 24 hours. Three weeks went by, and the closest thing that they could get from me was June 30th of 2016 with three-quarters of a billion dollars. We're here to do the people's business. We're the voice of the people, and we should have the oversight that the people require us to have regarding how institutions of higher education, funded by taxpayer dollars, how that money is being spent, what monies are coming into that system from outside sources, and by amending, if you've looked at the amendment, that's exactly what we're addressing here is giving us the fiscal oversight, and regarding the finances and the fiscal dealings of the institutions of higher education. Members, are
▶ Play
there any questions for either Representative Drowned or Lowry? Seeing none, we have no one signed up to speak for or against the bill, so thank you. Thank you, committee. I believe next on the list, Representative Mayberry. Are you prepared to present H.J.R. 1014? You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
H.J.R. 1014, an amendment to the Arkansas Constitution concerning the increase of the rates for sales and use taxes. I think that most of us, if not all of us, in this room recognize the fact that Arkansas has one of the highest state sales taxes in the United States. In fact, if you look at sales tax on a combined average of city, county, local, Arkansas is second in the nation in sales tax, average sales tax across the state, 9.3% is the average trailing only Tennessee, which has no income tax. So certainly there's a difference in that. I believe that one of the reasons why we have such a high state sales tax is because that has been the easiest thing to do in years past when additional revenue was needed or perceived to be needed. If you look at page two of the actual resolution itself, I think it clearly illustrates the difference of what we're talking about. You know, it's beginning on the previous page, it says none of the rates for property, excise, privilege, or personal taxes now levied shall be increased by the General Assembly except after the approval of qualified electors, so forth, so on, by the votes of three-fourths of the members elected to each House of the General Assembly. So, it takes a very high standard, very high bar, in order to raise any of those other taxes. Conversely, it has only taken a simple majority in the General Assembly to be able to raise the state sales tax. And that's, again, why I believe that we have a state sales tax that is as high as it is. What this would do is raise that standard for raising the state sales tax as well. It would not be to that same level of three quarters, but it would raise it to two-thirds of the General Assembly as opposed to the simple majority. I think it's a good safeguard for the future. We have no idea, you know, what type of legislative body or executive branch that we may have 10 years from now, 15 years from now. And I think this is just a good safeguard for the
▶ Play
taxpayers of the state of Arkansas. Members, do you have any questions for Representative Mayberry? Once again, we have no one signed up to speak for or against the
▶ Play
resolution, so thank you, Representative. Thank you. And Representative Ballinger was correct on my HJR 1015. I'm happy that it's been rolled into the speaker's bill.
▶ Play
All right, thank you. Representative Lundstrom, are you prepared to present HJR 1016? You're recognized. Colleagues,
▶ Play
HJR 16 is the much-anticipated and much-awaited voter ID bill. As all of you know, every time you go somewhere, whether it's to have a drink, apply for a job, get on an airplane, I went through and listed all the different things that we have to have an ID for, except for voting. The most important thing we will do, and we do every single day, and we put it up on a chart so we can all see, one person, one vote. This bill locks that down. Representative Lowry is running a bill through the House now, and it's into the Senate. It's an excellent bill. This is a backup, a belt and suspenders argument. When we all go to bed at night, not only do we shut our door, but we lock it. This locks that down for voter ID, for the ballot, the most important thing that we have. and I'll open it up for questions. Members,
▶ Play
does anyone have a question for Representative Lundstrom? We didn't have anyone sign up for or against the bill. Does anyone in the audience desire to speak for or against the bill? Thank you, Representative Lundstrom.
▶ Play
Speaker 113 1:14:03
Thank you. Short and sweet. All right,
▶ Play
members, there was a couple of members that are not here to present their resolution. Oh, I didn't see Representative Gassaway, I'm sorry. Representative Gassaway, you're prepared to present HJR 1019, you're recognized. I am, thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman, members, what I would like to do and what I'm going to present to you today is HJR 1019, which is what I would style as an alternative measure of tort reform, as opposed to what we've seen come out of the Senate with SJR 8. And so what I'm going to attempt to do is, number one, explain my version of tort reform and then distinguish that from SJR 8, which just, as you may know, recently passed the Senate State Agencies Committee. I think that when we look at tort reform, the primary purpose of what we should be trying to do with tort reform, and I think this is what you hear from folks all over the state of Arkansas, is that they want to limit frivolous lawsuits. Okay? And when we look at SJR 8 and we look at House Joint Resolution 1019, my bill, my bill is targeted to limit frivolous lawsuits, whereas SJR 8 is not designed to do that. Specifically, the very first provision of my bill targets frivolous lawsuits and attorneys who file frivolous lawsuits. So essentially what my bill would do, and this constitutional amendment would do, would be to write into the Constitution sanctions that could be imposed by a judge on attorneys who file claims that are determined to be unmeritorious claims. In addition to that, what it does is it will require the attorney or the party who files the lawsuit that is determined to be frivolous or unmeritorious to pay the attorney's fees of the other side who had to defend against a claim that was determined to be frivolous. So what my bill does is it specifically targets the problem that I think all Arkansans are concerned about, which is frivolous lawsuits. And so to distinguish that from SJR 8, SJR 8 does not contain any specific provisions that target frivolous lawsuits. So that's a primary distinction, and that's a reason why I believe this constitutional amendment that I'm proposing is better. The other thing that my constitutional amendment would do is that it places a cap on punitive damages, okay? And so punitive damages are the types of damages that are designed in a civil lawsuit to punish a bad actor who has done something to intentionally, in some cases, intentionally harm another person. And so what we recognize is that with many corporations who, you know, billion-dollar corporations, the only way, you know, we can't put a corporation in prison. But what we can do to a corporation to make them know and to make them feel that what they've done is so wrong that it deserves to be punished is that we can hit them in the pocketbook. And so what my bill does is it does put a cap on punitive damages at no less than five times the compensatory damages. Now to distinguish that from SJR 8, what SJR 8 does is it places a cap on punitive damages at three times the compensatory damages or $250,000, whichever is greater. And so I think that my bill is better in that respect and how it deals with punitive damages because it still allows the people of the state of Arkansas who have been injured or killed or permanently disabled or hurt in a very serious way to hold a corporation accountable And what SJR 8 is going to do is it is going to limit the ability of everyday Arkansans who are killed or hurt to hold a billion dollar corporation accountable for their wrongs. And so that's why that's another reason why I believe that my constitutional amendment is better. So, to make some of the distinguishing arguments between the two bills, what my bill doesn't do, and this is probably the most important thing compared to what SJR 8 does, is that my bill does not cap attorney's fees, and so that's one of the first things that you see in SJR 8 is a cap on attorney contingency fees. And let me tell you why this is a bad idea. Because what it's going to do, in effect, is it's going to limit people's access to the court. And SJR 8 limits attorney's fees in a way that is truly unprecedented. I mean, the state of Arkansas would be unique to any other state in the nation to limit attorney contingency fees in the way that SJR 8 proposes to do so. Specifically, what SJR 8 does is it limits attorney contingency fees to one-third of the net recovery to the client. Now, I can tell you from practice and currently, most personal injury attorney fee cases are done on a one-third contingency fee of the net recovery. And that's just kind of an industry standard. But what you'll also see is if a case has to proceed to trial, because in a lot of these cases what happens is you have an insurance company on the other side who's not being reasonable. They're offering some settlement on a case that will barely cover a person's medical bills. And then as the attorney representing the injured person, the only way that you're going to get any justice or potentially get any justice is you're going to have to take that case to trial. And the amount of time and the amount of effort and the cost that's involved in taking a case to trial goes up exponentially when you have to take it to that level. And so I've seen in some attorney contracts that the fee would go up to 40% in that case. But that is typically of the gross recovery. But what this bill does, SJRA, which has come out of the Senate, is that it will limit attorney contingency fees to one-third of the net. And what that's going to do in the practical effect is it is going to limit meritorious claims from being taken by attorneys. You're going to have people that have real claims who have been legitimately and seriously injured who are not going to be able to find an attorney to take their case if you limit the recovery to one-third of the net to the client. Now, I understand that, you know, when this thing were to get on the ballot, that's going to be a great selling point to a lot of people because they're going to say, we're really going to stick it to those greedy trial lawyers, and we're really going to cut their fees, and it's going to sound good to the general public, and they're going to use this to get this law passed. But let me tell you, it is not good for the people of the state of Arkansas, And it will limit people who have meritorious claims from being able to bring those claims. And so I say that to say, to distinguish SJR 8, which limits attorney contingency fees, that my bill doesn't do that and will allow meritorious claims to proceed to court and actually have attorneys who will take the claim. The other thing, one of the other things that SJR 8 does that my bill does not do is that The SJR 8 limits what are known as non-economic damages, okay? And non-economic damages include everything from the loss of life, so someone who dies in an accident. If you have a child who dies in an accident, it limits non-economic damages or things like pain and suffering, future pain and suffering, suffering, loss of companionship, mental anguish. These are all measures of damages that we recognize as non-economic damages. They're not things that are going to be easily quantifiable like compensatory damages such as lost wages, medical bills. Those are your compensatory damages. We can pretty easily put a dollar figure on those. Your non-economic damages are things that are not as easily, we're not as easily able to put a dollar figure on. And so I think one of the questions that we have to answer is, can we cap non-economic damages? And I think the answer to that is that we probably can. But the better question that we have to answer is, should we cap non-economic damages? And my bill does not cap non-economic damages. SJR 8 caps non-economic damages at $250,000. And so let me tell you what the practical effect of that is. What that means is that if you have a child who dies in a car wreck or some other tragic event who has no economic damage, they have no compensatory damages because they won't have, a child's not going to have any lost wages. If the child dies, presumably, I mean, there will be no medical bills to pay in many cases. And so there's not going to be economic damage there. And so to compensate the surviving family members of the child who has passed away, the maximum amount of money under SJR 8 that would be allowed to be awarded under Arkansas law, if this were to pass, would be $250,000. And I'm going to tell you, that's wrong. And that's why you've seen people like groups like the Arkansas Right to Life, which is opposed to
▶ Play
SJR 8. I know in this— Representative Gasway, I think you need to stay on your bill and not
▶ Play
make references to SJR 8. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And so what I'm trying to do is clearly distinguish between SJR 8 and my bill. And so what you will not see in my bill are caps on non-economic damages. You will not see in my bill caps on attorney's fees, attorney contingency fees, and you will not see in my bill, and this is one of the big issues with some of the other proposals that are floating around, is limitations on the court's authority regarding the rules of practice, pleading, and procedure. And so that is not contained in my bill, and so I think those are certainly things that I would ask this subcommittee to please consider. We need to have a debate in the state agencies committee, and we need to have a debate in this body to be fair to the people of the state of Arkansas. And what this bill has done that I have filed will be to offer an alternative proposal so so that we can have a debate to talk about the policy that would be best for the people of the state of Arkansas. And so with that, I'll close and would certainly entertain any questions.
▶ Play
Thank you. Members, do you have any questions for Representative Gasway?
▶ Play
Representative Smith, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. That's okay. Representative Gasway, I've had a lot of pressure put on me out of Jonesboro from various attorneys. My phone number is everywhere, and they know where I live. So, I mean, I've really pulled in a lot of comments. So, does your resolution, does it kind of meet some of that threshold of what they would say, well, we don't really want tort reform at all, but at least we like yours, your version better. I mean, how is it being received specifically in Jonesboro on Main Street?
▶ Play
Well, I can tell you I probably know several of the people who've talked with you, and my understanding is it's well received by all of those folks. I mean, certainly I don't think that it's something that if they had their way, we wouldn't cap punitive damages and we wouldn't put into the Constitution. Actually, I think that most attorneys, even the attorneys who've contacted you, would be agreeable to putting into the Constitution sanctions and the payment of attorney's fees for any attorney who files a claim that's not meritorious or frivolous. Now, certainly, they probably wouldn't like the punitives, but, you know, there's an appetite in Arkansas, I believe, for tort reform. It's something that a lot of us talked about during our campaigns, and it's something that we ought to do. But if we're going to do it, we need to do it responsibly. We need to do it in a reasonable manner and in a manner that protects the people of the state of Arkansas. And I think that's what my bill does. And I think, just to answer your specific question again, I don't think that they'll have a problem with it.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair, thank you. We have no one signed up to speak for or against this bill, so thank you, Representative Gassaway. Thank you. I'm sorry, we do have someone in the audience. identify yourself for the record and you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is
▶ Play
Josh Waters. I'm an attorney for Political Strategies and Conduit for Action is our client. Conduit for Action has been a longtime supporter of tort reform, and they have come out actually in support of this version of tort reform. We think it's more in line with the goal of a loser pay type of tort reform in the language that Representative Gassaway was speaking about. We think that's more in line for a loser pay type of tort reform. I don't want to repeat everything he said. I think he made great distinctions between this version of tort reform and some other versions of tort reform. But one thing I did want to point out in Representative Gassaway's bill, There's no language that gives the power of rulemaking and procedure and rules of evidence over to the legislature. And I wanted to refer to a UAL or law review article that was written over basically how different states handle this rulemaking for attorneys to be held accountable to. And currently, there's no states that have exclusive authority that is given to the legislature. There are 20 states that have court-only power, and there's a majority of the states where the primary authority is given to the courts. There are about 30 states that have some role of the legislature involved. In the article, it talks about in Florida, there's no power of the legislature to basically annul some rules of procedure that they find disagreeable. And then in Tennessee, there's a version where it can be referred to the General Assembly for them to approve some oversight. So, again, I don't want to repeat anything Representative Gasway said. So those are kind of the points we had, and then along with the points he made, and we think this is the better version of tort reform for the people of Arkansas. Thank
▶ Play
you. Seeing no questions. Thank you, sir. You're dismissed. The day is getting late, and we have a couple that we're not going to be able to hear today, so I'm going to schedule another meeting for either Monday or Tuesday afternoon. Representative Powles. Mr. Chair, I just got a phone
▶ Play
call from Roy Raglin a few minutes ago. working friday but we're not working monday so that is correct so
▶ Play
we're gonna i'm gonna schedule one for two
▶ Play

Agenda

HJR1002 S. Meeks AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION TO PROVIDE FOR APPOINTMENT OF EMERGENCY INTERIM SUCCESSORS TO CERTAIN CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICES UPON THE OCCURRENCE OF A CATASTROPHIC EVENT.

0:36 - 26:02 69 segments 6 speakers

HJR1003 Gillam AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION TO AMEND THE PROCESS FOR PLACING PROPOSED AMENDMENTS ON MEASURES AND CONSTITUTIONAL BALLOT FOR THE CONSIDERATION BY VOTERS AT AN ELECTION.

HJR1004 Leding AN AMENDMENT TO ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION, ARTICLE 5, SECTION 1, CONCERNING THE FILING OF INITIATIVE PETITIONS AND THE PROCESS FOR CHALLENGING THE SUFFICIENCY OF A PETITION.

26:02 - 53:14 58 segments 5 speakers

HJR1005 Lowery THE PUBLIC EDUCATION PARTNERSHIP AMENDMENT OF 2018.

HJR1006 K. Hendren A CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT REPEALING THE FISCAL SESSION OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY.

HJR1007 K. Hendren AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNING THE BALLOT TITLES OF CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS PROPOSED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY.

HJR1008 Dotson AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION TO PROVIDE THAT THE STATE HIGHWAY COMMISSION SHALL BE GOVERNED IN THE SAME MANNER AS ALL OTHER STATE AGENCIES.

53:14 - 59:20 20 segments 4 speakers

HJR1009 Dotson AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNING LEGISLATIVE OVERSIGHT OF INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION AND HIGHER EDUCATION OFFERINGS IN THE STATE OF ARKANSAS.

59:20 - 1:02:14 10 segments 3 speakers

HJR1010 Dotson AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNING THE FUNDING OF PUBLIC EDUCATION OFFERED TO THE CITIZENS OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS.

HJR1011 Drown AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNING THE APPLICABILITY

1:02:14 - 7:31

HJR1012 Shepherd AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION TO REVISE THE METHOD OF SELECTION OF JUSTICES OF THE SUPREME COURT.

HJR1013 Ballinger AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION REVISING THE PROCESS FOR AMENDMENTS TO PROPOSED CONSTITUTIONAL SUBMITTING MEASURES AND VOTERS FOR APPROVAL OR REJECTION.

7:31 - 1:09:53 157 segments 14 speakers

HJR1014 A. Mayberry AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNING THE INCREASE OF THE RATES FOR SALES AND USE TAXES.

1:09:53 - 1:12:41 8 segments 2 speakers

HJR1015 A. Mayberry A CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT TO PROVIDE THAT AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION SHALL NOT SPECIFICALLY BESTOW POWERS, PRIVILEGES. OR AUTHORITY TO SPECIFIC INDIVIDUALS OR BUSINESS ENTITIES IDENTIFIED BY NAME.

HJR1016 Lundstrum AN AMENDMENT OT THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNING VOTERS IDENTIFICATION WHEN CASTING A BALLOT.

1:12:41 - 1:26:31 34 segments 5 speakers

HJR1017 C. Douglas AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION PROVIDING CERTAIN ADDITIONAL RIGHTS TO VICTIMS OF CRIMES.

HJR1018 Shepherd AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNING CIVIL ACTIONS AND COURT PROCEDURES.

HJR1019 Gazaway AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNING AWARDS IN CIVIL ACTIONS.

1:26:31 - 1:31:25 11 segments 4 speakers

HJR1020 Davis AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION TO REPEAL THE FISCAL SESSION OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY AND TO PROVIDE FOR ANNUAL REGULAR SESSIONS OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY.

HJR1021 Sorvillo A CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT PROVIDING THAT A MONUMENT OR STATUE SHALL NOT BE PLACED UPON THE STATE CAPITOL GROUNDS UNLESS AT LEAST TWO HUNDRED THOUSAND QUALIFIED ELECTORS OF THE STATE SIGN A PETITION IN FAVOR OF THE PLACEMENT

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Jon S. Eubanks Chair Unverified
47 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
12 segments
Representative Jack Ladyman Unverified
3 segments
Representative Jim Dotson Unverified
52 segments
Speaker 47
1 segment
Speaker 51
1 segment
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
29 segments
Clayton Blackstock Unverified
15 segments
Speaker 71
6 segments
Speaker 78
6 segments
Chair Unverified
1 segment
Representative Douglas House Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 97
1 segment
Speaker 100
1 segment
Representative Trevor Drown Unverified
7 segments
Representative Andy Mayberry Unverified
6 segments
Representative Robin Lundstrum Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 113
1 segment
Representative Jimmy Gazaway Unverified
25 segments
Representative Brandt Smith Unverified
2 segments
Josh Waters Unverified
4 segments