Public Health, Welfare and Labor Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (34)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1205
· 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1205 Magie TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS ANESTHESIOLOGIST ASSISTANT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1021
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1021 Love TO PROVIDE PAY EQUITY FOR WOMEN; AND TO AMEND THE WAGE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1040
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1040 Farrer TO LIMIT THE PRACTICE OF ATHLETIC TRAINING IN A NONC…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1160
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1160 A. Mayberry TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF A "SPECIALIST SIGN E…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1181
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1181 Sullivan TO CREATE THE TRANSITION TO PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1182
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1182 Sullivan TO AUTHORIZE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO ALLO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1186
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1186 Brown TO REMOVE THE COLLABORATIVE PRACTICE AGREEMENT AS APP…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1204
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1204 Magie TO ALLOW PHARMACISTS TO MAKE BIOLOGICAL PRODUCT SUBST…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1215
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1215 Love TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING THE PRACTICE OF MASSAGE TH…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1228
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1228 Hammer TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY OF AN ADVANCED P…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1237
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1237 Hammer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS SURGICAL TECHNOLOGISTS ACT; A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1250
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1250 M. Gray TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS DENTAL PRACTICE ACT; TO AMEND…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1254
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1254 Magie TO TRANSFER REGULATORY AUTHORITY OVER ADVANCED PRACTI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1255
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1255 Ferguson TO CREATE A TEMPORARY CHARITABLE DENTAL LICENSE; A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1257
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1257 Richey TO CREATE THE COMMUNITY HEALTH WORKER ACT.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1300
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1300 Miller TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES TO PRIOR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1439
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1439 M. Gray TO AMEND THE HEALTHCARE QUALITY AND PAYMENT POLICY…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1462
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1462 McCollum TO AFFIRM THE LEGISLATIVE AUTHORITY OVER WAIVERS F…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1465
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1465 Miller DECLARE TO CREATE THE MEDICAID EXPANSION ENROLLMENT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1501
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1501 McCollum TO MODIFY AND REPEAL LANGUAGE REFERENCING THE SUPE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1502
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1502 S. Meeks TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION TO THE DEFINITION OF RESIDE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1504
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1504 Hammer TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTION DRUG MONITORING PROGRAM TO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1505
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1505 Davis TO CLARIFY THE DEFINITION OF AN NAAQS STATE IMPLEMENT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1511
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1511 Wardlaw TO CLARIFY THE TIME FOR ISSUANCE OF PERMITS UNDER T…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1513
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1513 Holcomb TO AMEND THE ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENTS FOR THE ASBES…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1515
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1515 Ladyman TO PROVIDE LOCAL CONTROL OVER FLUORIDE LEVELS IN WA…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1525
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1525 Magie AN ACT TO REQUIRE THE ARKANSAS STATE MEDICAL BOARD AN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1526
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1526 M. Gray TO MODIFY ACT 143 OF 2017 TO SPECIFY THAT A CRIMINA…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1545
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1545 Sullivan TO ALLOW THE DIVISION OF CHILD CARE AND EARLY CHIL…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1550
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1550 Davis TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING NONMUNICIPAL DOMESTIC SEW…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1551
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1551 Womack TO STIMULATE JOB CREATION AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT W…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1560
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1560 Gazaway TO AMEND LAWS REGARDING THE PRACTICE OF PHARMACY AN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB123
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB123 B. Johnson TO UPDATE THE DRUG SCREENING AND TESTING ACT OF…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB78
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB78 Bledsoe TO REQUIRE THE ARKANSAS STATE MEDICAL BOARD TO PERF…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 14, 2026
and get started. Chair, Cesar Quorum, Representative Love, you expressed to me you're not ready today. Tuesday. is Representative Michelle Gray. She's not running that bill
He's not running that one. Representative McGee, are you ready for House Bill 1205? Yes, sir. All
Representative McGee, they've got some handouts that we've already approved. They're going to go ahead and hand those out while you're presenting your bill. That's good. And, audience, if you guys don't mind, I know there are a lot of folks in here in tight, give the committee members all the room they need and the staff all the room they need to get around the table so that we can run this thing efficiently as possible. Representative McGee,
you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Committee, it's my pleasure this morning to present you House Bill 1205. It's the anesthesia assistant bill, and I'm going to try to go through this pretty quickly
for you. There are about four issues I want to talk about. First off is the bill itself, and then a brief fact sheet about the profession itself. I don't want to compare anesthesia, medical, MD, medical doctor anesthesia providers as compared to what are considered non-physician anesthesia providers, which include both the certified registered nurse anesthetists and the anesthesia assistants, and then I'll talk about these handouts a little bit that you're getting and about some of the information on it, and I'll try to go through it pretty quick so that if you have any questions, you
can shoot them at me. First off, with regards to the bill itself, basically this bill establishes a new class in Arkansas of anesthesia providers and their certified anesthesia assistants. It places them under, if you go through the act, it places them under the authority of the Arkansas Medical Board, so the medical board would be responsible for their rule and regulation and licensure, ensuring that they are appropriately certified and all that sort of thing, have appropriate national testing, passing national boards and that sort of thing. and then the medical board will establish all the rules and regulations with regards to their practice
and to ensure, as we all know, the board's function to ensure the safety of the public. So that's kind of the act in itself, and if you have any questions about that, we can go through that in a minute. What I really want to talk to you about are really what an anesthesiology assistant is, where they came from, what their training involves, and I encourage you to consider allowing them to practice in the state of Arkansas. The anesthesia assistants were started in 1969.
That's when the programs were started. It was started at Emory University. There are currently about, I think, 16 or 17 university-based, medical school-based programs where they train anesthesia assistants. In fact, even though we don't allow anesthesia assistants to practice under an anesthesiologist in Arkansas, at our own Arkansas Children's Hospital here in Arkansas, anesthesia assistants are trained in the anesthesiology program. So they're not allowed to practice here. We have students that are Arkansas students that could actually train at Children's Hospital.
Once they complete their externship program from another university and complete their time here, they're not allowed to practice in the state of Arkansas. So they train in the university setting. They train under the direction of anesthesiologists. The medical director of all the programs are MD or medical doctor anesthesiologists. they are part of what's considered the anesthesia care team. And the anesthesia care team consists of a supervising anesthesiologist and then one to four non-physician anesthesia providers.
Now, you have to really think about what this term means, non-physician anesthesia providers. That's how insurance companies and Medicare consider anyone that provides provides anesthesia that's not a physician, that's CRNAs and anesthesia assistants, they're considered non-physician anesthesia providers. And that has to do with billing. And we'll get into that in a minute with some of these handouts that they have, because these handouts that they have, if you look through them, they're a little bit confusing. It makes them
look like anesthesia assistants aren't properly trained or properly supervised, and that's not the case at all. They currently can practice, anesthesia assistants can currently practice in 17 states, including the District of Columbia, they can practice in the VA system and they can practice on military installations in TRICARE. The requirements for anesthesia assistants to enter a program, they have to have a bachelor's degree in a pre-medical type of program, they have to have at least a 3.0 grade average to be accepted from their undergraduate degree to be accepted into an anesthesia assistant
program. The anesthesia assistance programs vary between 24 to 28 months. It's a master's level degree when they're through. They're accredited. All of the schools that train these people are accredited by the Commission for Accreditation of Allied Health Educational Programs. And they're all recognized by the Council of Higher Education. So they average about 100. They average in training. They average 56 to 132 semester hours of didactic instruction. They have a minimum of 2,000 hours of clinical anesthesia education in all subspecialties of anesthesia.
There are not a lot of them. There are only 16 or 17 programs. As I said, it started at Emory. There's the closest program to us, I think, is the University of Missouri in Kansas City. In fact, I have a letter from a lady who's from Mintonville who's in the program in Kansas City, and she'd sure like to come back to Arkansas and practice. But they only graduate about 200 anesthesia assistants per year. So when you think about anesthesia providers, I think, and the people that are here with the CRNAs,
they can correct me if I'm wrong, but I think there's about 36,000 CRNAs in the United States. So there's a large number of them. There are about 2,000 anesthesia assistants. The difference between their practices are anesthesia assistants will always work under the supervision of an anesthesiologist. A certified registered nurse anesthetist in the state of Arkansas works under the supervision of a physician. It may not be an anesthesiologist, okay? When they work in small-town Arkansas, when they're down in Lake Village, Arkansas,
and they're putting somebody to sleep, this nurse anesthetist, they do great jobs. I have nothing wrong with nursing anesthesia. I'm not attacking their profession in any way, but when they put somebody to sleep, there is a physician there that's ultimately responsible. Now, I'm a physician. You guys all know that. When I go to surgery, I operate on people. I do eye surgery. When I go to surgery, if I'm operating at Baptist Hospital, typically it's a nurse anesthetist that is taking care of my patient who is supervised by an anesthesiologist.
I don't typically do a lot of general anesthesia. I don't put people to sleep. But very few of my, maybe 10% of the people I do end up getting intubated where they put a tube in and breathe for you the whole time. I do mine under what's called monitored anesthetic care. So they come in, the nurse anesthetist, administers the anesthetic drug, whatever that is, intravenously to sleep the patient so that they can have a comfortable time during their surgery. Most of the time they don't remember anything, and they do a great job. The anesthesiologist is there available, and he's supervising one to four of them at a time.
Now, when you get into these articles that they're talking about, these are really, really, really misleading. And what you have to understand, and I'm sure they may have something to say about it, but if you look at this one where it talks about lapse of supervision and critical elements of a surgical case, and if you have one anesthesiologist or one anesthesia assistant, and by the way, the information that they really extrapolated this, This didn't come from an article about, as far as I know, it didn't come from an article
about anesthesia assistance. It came from an article published in Anesthesiology in 2012, which looked at CRNAs and lack and lapses of supervision that occurred during what they call critical elements of a surgical case. But don't let this mislead you. That's not lapses that led to any bad outcome or anything with regards to medical care. What this refers to is the way that anesthesia services are billed. That's all that it is.
It has nothing to do with the quality of care, the safety of the care. It's all about how it was billed, and that was decided in 1982. I can't remember the name of the act. It's TIFRA. It's down at the bottom in the small print on this one, T-E-F-R-A. That was an act in 1982. It's the Tax Equity and Financial Responsibility Act of 1982, And that set up the program as to how anesthesia was going to be paid, how anesthesiologists were going to be paid, and how nurse anesthetists were going to be paid, and how anesthesia assistants were going to be paid.
And the way this works is if an anesthesiologist does medical direction, the billing, the billing, they bill for medical direction, they have to do all of these things and document in the chart that they did all those things. If they bill medical supervision, then they don't have to do all these things. So it just has to do with billing. So all of this information is billing. It has nothing to do with patient care or quality of care or safety of patient care. So I'm open to any questions. I'm sure there will be quite a bit of discussion about this issue.
I think that we have individuals in the state of Arkansas. I'll just read you a letter. This is from Cameron Gisselman from Bentonville, Arkansas. She's a second-year student, and I'm going to quote from her letter. She's at the University of Missouri-Kansas City. Representative McGee, we
need your testimony, not a letter from someone else. Okay, that's fine. I understand.
Well, my testimony is I've read her letter, and she would love the opportunity to come back to Arkansas and practice.
I can appreciate that. Okay. So, you know, committee, this is about expanding. This is a fairness issue. This is a right-to-work issue. This is not about attacking somebody's profession. You're not bringing it. You're not expanding the scope or practice of an anesthesia assistant. What you're allowing is you're allowing them to come to the state of Arkansas like they do in 17 other states. They're under physician supervision. The physicians are responsible for their care.
They're responsible for what happens. Quite honestly, in programs in general, what happens with anesthesia assistants is they end up working in major medical centers. And in the areas that they work, they work side-by-side with the CRNAs. They make pretty much equivalent salaries. They perform pretty much the same function when they're working under the supervision of anesthesiologists. So, you know, anesthesia assistants are not going to expand and go to McGee, Arkansas, or to Lake Village
where there's not an anesthesiologist. They will be limited to the metropolitan areas. but there is a need I understand there's a need at the university for more people they can't get enough nurse nurses at the university to satisfy the case situation so I don't think it's an expansion of practice I think it's allowing a group of individuals that are highly trained, that are qualified that are tested, that come from our state that can return to our state and ladies and gentlemen, it's not like you're going to have
a flood of anesthesiology assistants and it's taken all the jobs at the CRNAs. And I know that there's a concern. You have somebody competing, but, you know, let the, I mean, it's a free world. Let people compete. With that, I'm open
to any questions. We do have a few. Representative Payton,
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative McGee, on the bottom of page 5, you have what seems to be a grandfather clause. It's called licensure without examination. a person who engaged in anesthesiology work for at least one year before the effective date
would automatically receive the license without examination? Well, I think what that refers to is the medical board will allow someone that's from another state that's already been practicing, they don't have to take another national exam. Well, it doesn't
work doesn't have any level of education or certification? If that's an issue, we can change that. We can certainly change that. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you.
I'm going to interrupt and kind of lighten the mood up in here today a little bit. Today is 4-H Day at the Capitol. I don't know how many of you guys know that. And I'm going to take the liberty from being chair to recognize my group of 4-Hers that are here today. And if you guys would, let's give them a warm welcome. It's always good to get the young people in the Capitol and let them see how government works and understand it. And for y'all's information, this committee handles all public health, labor, and welfare activities.
And today is Doctors and Nurses Day. Just look around if you don't believe me. But I appreciate you guys coming today and hope you enjoy your day at the Capitol. Thank you.
Yes. Representative Ferguson, recognize for a question. In response to Representative Payton's question, the way I read this, I don't know, Dr. McGee, you may look at it, is that it's like the Dental Association has, Dental Board has reciprocity for licensure.
And is it likely that they would be licensed and working in another state without an exam? Yes, I agree. Thank you. It's not intense
not to let someone come in and practice that hasn't been properly trained. Representative Branscombe, did
you have a question? Okay. Seeing no further questions, we do have some people signed up to speak for and against.
So Representative McGee, if you would. Thank you. Thank you, Chair. We have Ms. Ann Cousins. Cousins? Yes, ma'am. You're recognized to go to the end table and speak against the bill. Representative Love, can I help you? Yes, I'd like
Speaker 72
15:24
to make a motion. Okay. I'd hear that motion. I have a motion to limit debate to
15 minutes to each side. That's a proper motion, non-debatable. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed?
Motion passes. So the time will be kept at the chair, and Representative McGee, would you like to reserve any time for close? Mr. Chair, I would
like to reserve, say, three minutes at the end to close if there are any comments. We'll hold you three minutes.
Okay, thank you. Hi, good morning, Mr. Chairman and committee. My name is Ann Cousins. I'm a certified registered nurse anesthetist. I practice primarily in Pine Bluff, Arkansas. I've worked in Stuttgart, and I do pick up as a locum here in Little Rock, Arkansas. I'm testifying before you today on behalf of myself and before my group in Pine Bluff, Arkansas.
I strongly oppose Bill 1205. Some may suggest CRNAs and anesthesiologist assistants are interchangeable. Let me be clear, we are not. There are over 50,000 CRNAs providing greater than 90% of the anesthetics in this country. We have a minimum of eight years of medical-based training prior to practicing anesthesia. We're licensed in every state. We administer the majority of anesthetics in the military. Nowhere in the United States are we required to work with an anesthesiologist.
Assistants are. CRNAs are expert clinicians. We are no one's assistants. In contrast, there are only 1,800 AAs in the United States. They have a minimum of two years of medical-based education prior to assisting an anesthesiologist. They're only licensed in 17 states. They're banned in Louisiana. They do not practice in the military. They're always required to work underneath the direction of an anesthesiologist. They are not experts. They are what their name implies. They are an assistant. An anesthesia practice model that includes AAs is one of the most expensive models
because an AA has to work closely under the direction of an anesthesiologist. Being as AA salaries are comparable to a CRNA, utilizing AAs would be more expensive than using a CRNA. Although I've briefly mentioned the expense an AA would pose on Arkansans, this isn't my basis for opposing AAs in Arkansas. in Arkansas. My first and foremost priority related in anesthetic is always safety. CRNA's safety has been validated by not only 150 years of experience, which is longer than any other ANA specialty, but also our safety is illustrated with multiple fact-based studies. AAs have only
been assisting anesthesiologists for approximately 50 years. For several reasons, AAs' safety has never been substantiated with any kind of scientific evidence. Let me reiterate, CRNAs and AAs are not interchangeable. The utilization of AAs would not only cost Arkansans more money, AAs would also jeopardize our safety due to their lack of education and clinical experience. Why is Bill 1205 being introduced? Bill 1205 supports extremely expensive yet grossly inferior patient care.
In anesthesia, things happen in an instant. So when seconds count, Arkansans deserve and expect an anesthesia provider who can think and perform independently. Arkansans do not deserve an anesthesia technician, otherwise known as an anesthesiologist assistant. I urge you to look at what's best for our Kansans patients and oppose Bill 1205. Thank you for your time today and your ongoing support for our state. Thank you. Do you have any questions for me?
We do have one. Representative Branscombe. Could you expand on grossly expensive and that phrase? Yes, based on
other states that I've contacted regarding the models they have set up utilizing AAs. Dr. Maggie had mentioned a one anesthesiologist to four AA ratio. That typically isn't utilized. What's typically utilized is a one anesthesiologist to two AA ratio. This is because they aren't trained to be an independent practitioner. They are trained to have to, you know, communicate quite closely with an anesthesiologist for direction on how to perform an anesthetic. And so if there was a critical event in the operating room or surgical suite
and an anesthesiologist needed to respond, it's much more difficult, as illustrated in the flyer that you received, to four people versus two. So typically that's how a model with an AA is set up, and that's why it ends up being more expensive.
You're done. Representative Love, you're recognized for a
Speaker 72
19:52
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Quick question. And you mentioned that Louisiana has banned AAs. That's correct. Can you kind of elaborate on that,
please? I can't elaborate on their decision why to do that.
They went before their committee, and they made the decision to ban them from ever being introduced again into the state of Louisiana. Again, there's nothing to show any kind of safety related to an anesthesia assistant. I looked this information up myself to see why, and primarily it's because there's not very many of them. And another reason is because they're actually practicing underneath an anesthesiologist. So you'd really, it wouldn't be comparing apples to apples because you're really looking at the anesthesiologist and the assistant.
So that's why there haven't been any studies. And I assume that's why Louisiana banned them, but I can't
be certain. Okay, thank you. Sure. Thank you, Madam, for your testimony. We can't have any clapping in the committee room. Let's keep the order. I've allowed everybody to be in the room, and I want to keep it that way, so let's keep the order in the room. Let's see Michael Harris. Does he testify for the bill?
Hello? If you would, introduce yourself to the committee and you're recognized.
Speaker 72
21:15
My name is Michael Harris. I'm a resident physician currently training in anesthesiology here in Arkansas. So currently, as we addressed earlier, we are training AAs at Children's. A lot of my colleagues, well myself, I haven't personally worked with some of my AAs. A lot of my colleagues do enjoy working with them. They felt that they are at similar training levels of a lot of the student nurse anesthetists that they've worked with. They felt that they
work in great collaborative agreements. There has been no issues in education, as mentioned earlier that their education is lacking. I feel personally for myself as well that it would benefit my education and my patients as well to be able to have AAs in the state of Arkansas. It actually opens up to people like myself that aren't from the state of Arkansas that would encourage us to want to stay in Arkansas because we could provide better care with these AAs.
I'm just trying to keep it brief. Any
questions? We do have a few. Representative Hammer, you're
Speaker 72
22:21
recognized for a question. In your position of advocating for this bill and what this bill would allow, are you stating that as far as this population being able to operate up to their scope of practice, that they could perform their duties in a positive manner to contribute to the overall need in Arkansas? Yes, I do believe that.
Put me to the bottom of the list, please. Thank you. Okay. Any other questions? I do have some more. Representative Pilkington, you're recognized for a question. You made the statement that you – thank you, Mr. Speaker. You made a statement that you feel that the AAs are up to the same standards as CRNA, even though they don't have the same level of education. So I disagree with that same level of education. I did hear, quote, the numbers eight years of education. I do believe that nurses are counting their ICU experience in that AAs do have,
most of them go to an undergraduate degree, just like a BSN, so that would be four years, and two years of AA training. A lot of nurse anesthetist schools are also two to three years. So to me, those numbers add up. So I would say
that that's absolutely comparable training. Got a follow-up? Representative Hammer, I'm back to you if you want it. Representative Love. Okay. All right. All right. Thank you for your testimony.
Can you get – hold on one second. We do
have a question. Representative Payton, you're recognized. Thank you for coming back. Thank you, Mr. Chair, for the late question. But I was reading in the bill another line that says the anesthesiologist assistant may work in any setting that is within the scope of practice of the supervising anesthesiologist practice. So you're basically testifying to us that you're just as well trained and just as capable. and the bill is going to give you the authority to work in the entire scope of the anesthesiologist.
Is that how you understand it, and you're comfortable and confident in that? I'm
So you're saying that the AAs have the same level of training as the CNAs and that you're comfortable with them working? Yes, I'd be comfortable working with anesthesiologists.
Speaker 72
24:44
The entire scope. The entire scope. That's correct. Okay. Thank you. I do have
another question. Representative Hammer, you recognize. I'm just
Speaker 72
24:54
curious what happens in the event something goes wrong in the surgery or in the process,
and you're stating that you feel that they are trained. I'm getting the impression that you're stating that they are trained equally or as good as. So I'm wondering if something goes south in the procedure, who bears the liability and who's going to be taken to court? So as a physician, we always bear responsibility. So I would ultimately say that as the supervising physician, I would be the one that would be burdening the legal.
Follow up, Mr. Chair. You recognize. Thank you. So let's say, in the event you should step out of the room, you're stating that you feel that if somebody's put under you, you're willing to accept that kind of responsibility that if something goes wrong, you're not going to blame them and you're going to take the full blunt of it when it comes to the legal responsibility, and you're okay with that? So as a physician, we're always responsible for everything that goes on with our patients at all times. I can't, as a physician, you can't be everywhere at it.
All hours of the time. So that's part of being a physician is being able to trust that provider, that their skill set is at the same skill set that you are comfortable. I'd like to go to the bottom of
the list. You are the bottom of the list. Thank you. Thank you. Doc, he's got another question, if you don't mind.
Speaker 72
26:32
So I guess what I'm hearing you say is that as a physician, you feel that you are competent in your position to make the decision that if that person operates up to, or say they even step beyond their scope of practice, that you as a physician feel that you're okay with having that kind of authority.
So we would assume that they're not going to step out of their scope of practice and that they would notify us. much like what's happening right now with nurse anesthetists they're supposed to know why they're attending physician of any changes that's that are going on in the surgery so that we can act and make the appropriate medical decisions that's that's pretty much what i'm saying is in the same scope all right thank you thank you mr.
chair representative lunch girl do you have a
question no i think representative hammer just hit that all
right representative ladyman you're recognized for a question thank you mr. chair my concern is the cost the medical cost to
individuals who are getting surgery and you know we need to do whatever we can to reduce medical costs I know the medical community is interested in that as well but my question is when I'm looking at this and it says that the AA can only work under supervision and the the RN might be able to work individually. My question to you is, as a doctor, if an AA is added to a surgery, would that extra person involved in the surgical team add cost to the process?
Speaker 72
28:03
So as far as I know, anesthesia billing has a flat billing. So regardless of who's ever providing anesthesia, Medicare still pays at the same rate. So I would assume that There would be no increase in cost. If anything, we're letting the free market take over. We're having more people being able to compete for a job, and I think that would encourage actually potentially lower rates, help lower costs in medical care. We're trying to improve our access, so I would imagine that that would decrease costs.
All right. Thank you, sir. Seeing no further questions, thank you for your testimony. Thank you. All right, we do have a Mr. Brian Mears. If you would introduce yourself for the committee and you
recognize, speak against the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Good morning, Mr. Chairman and committee members. My name is Brian Mears. I'm a CRNA. I practice here in Little Rock. I'm also in the military. I've been in the military for 21 years. I practiced as a CRNA there, recently home from Afghanistan. so I can speak on behalf of my experience practicing in multiple states, military, and Arkansas.
I stand in opposition to House Bill 1205 today. I practice in Florida, Tennessee, and like I said, currently here in Arkansas. We have a longstanding history as CRNAs of providing safe and effective anesthesia care. Patient safety is our number one priority in our profession, just like anesthesiologists. We work in great mutual coordination in multiple facilities throughout Arkansas, but we also work independently of anesthesiologist supervision throughout much of Arkansas.
We have provided a map to each of the committee members that represent where CRNAs practice without anesthesiologist presence. It's clear that over the history of Arkansas, we have not had a safety issue, or else we would not be allowed 150 years after the fact that we started providing anesthesia care that we would still be providing anesthesia care independently of anesthesiologist supervision. So this is not a supervision discussion really for us. This is a supervision for people that are not like us.
Our scope of practice is dictated by the State Board of Nursing. It tells us what we can and can't do. And at each facility we go to, they provide us with a delineation of privileges. That tells us the acts that we're responsible for, what we can and what we cannot do. So AAs, they have a different scope of practice than us. They are found under the Board of Medicine. They are not under the Board of Nursing. This comes to a couple. This separates us. Number one, we're under different scopes of practice, one in which we are allowed to practice to the full scope of our abilities, our education, and our training.
We can practice independently. I practiced independently in the military, recently in Afghanistan, cared for the most traumatic situations you could possibly imagine, practiced independently of any anesthesiologist present. There was no anesthesiologist in an entire section of the country I was in, but I had to care for 18 patients at one time, our own soldiers, and that's something that we're prepared to do, SCRNAs. AAs are not allowed in the military because they cannot make that independent judgment. They are not licensed independent practitioners, which we are.
We are considered LIPs. They are not licensed independent providers. Our license allows us to make decisions, and it's against our license. That's why we have a regulatory agency, the State Board of Nursing, that oversees us. Should we mess up, we have oversight that would send us, it would send our negligence up the chain and we would be punished for that. That leads us to malpractice. We carry the same malpractice insurance that anesthesiologists carry.
All right, so we have to because we're licensed independent practitioners. We are more than 50,000 strong, because we've been now providing anesthesia for over 150 years, where AAs are a relatively new profession, 50 years in the making, but there's only 1,800 of them. And that would lead me to question, why is there only 1,800 if there's such a necessity? Yet, 50 years after the fact, there's only 1,800. Like my colleague said, they're even banned from hearing this discussion again in Louisiana.
The reasons are unknown to us, but it's interesting that some states have taken that stance. In terms of access to care, that is our priority here in Arkansas. It has been demonstrated that CRNAs, we are extremely cost effective. We can bill CMS through a QZ modifier that is a billing code that allows us to bill directly for our care without the supervision of an anesthesiologist. That drastically drops the price of multi-provider teams.
So if we are in a team care setting and an anesthesiologist is supervising either two, three, or four of us, the fewer the people they supervise, the more the cost goes up. When we bill independently, we're billing in a completely different modifier through CMS, and the result is less money. We also primarily serve Arkansans in underserved areas where limited access to care exists.
So that's why we're really the primary independent providers in those facilities. In those areas, you'll see on your map, we are providing anesthesia services to primarily Medicaid and uninsured patients who do not have access to care like we do here in Little Rock. So this discussion really relates to medical hubs like Little Rock and Faulkner County, where 67% of anesthesiologists in the state exist. The vast majority of anesthesiologists do not exist outside of those two counties, but we do.
And that's where we're working primarily to increase access to care, which is what we've done throughout Arkansas's history, providing safe and effective anesthesia. And I would like to address education, okay? That was brought up by the physician that was sitting here before me. All of us have been through a tremendous amount of training. We all have bachelor's degrees in nursing. Then we go into critical care. In our critical care environments, we learn a tremendous amount.
That's where we learn to care for patients. We have to have worked in critical care before we can go to anesthesia school. When we're in critical care, it's where you learn all your IV medicines. You learn how to care for the patients. You learn what invasive monitoring is. You learn how to communicate. it is an invaluable resource for us to be in the critical care setting, which we averaged 3.2 years in critical care before we enter anesthesia school. Many of us, like myself, it was over 10 years before I started anesthesia school.
You cannot discredit the amount of experience we have working in intensive care units where AAs do not have that experience. Then we go back to school. When we go to school, we already present to school with a tremendous amount of assets and knowledge, which makes the schooling different for us. We're able to put it together a lot easier, and that's why we're able to make judgments immediately to the second when we need to in an operating room without having to call an anesthesiologist.
The physician that sat here said that he must be notified at all times. in his model that is correct for billing purposes not for safety purposes when we're working independently we do not notify anybody we make the decisions the outcome is safe and effective anesthesia that's what that's what we need safe and effective anesthesia that's what they would argue for and that's what we argue for we are mutually in agreement with that safe and effective anesthesia care right so when we go back to school we get a minimum of a master's degree
however our profession has moved to a doctorate level entry into practice for doctorates is soon to occur many many crnas already have doctorates our master's degree is is a minimum of three years or right at three years and our doctorate for me it was an additional i've been in school more than six years after my bachelor's
two minute warning Yes, sir. Just so you know. Thank you. Thank you. We do have studies that show that we are the most cost-effective model.
That's why we practice like we practice, and Medicare allows us to bill independently. All right. I'm very passionate about this. I appreciate you hearing my testimony, and I am free and open to any questions you may have. Representative Hammer, you're recognized for a
Speaker 72
37:17
question. I think you may just hit on it. But are your services billed separately from the anesthesiologist so you don't have to bill under the anesthesiologist? Is that
correct? When we're working in an independent model, that is correct. When we're working in a team care model, that is not correct.
When we're working in a team care model, we go under team care modifiers. And modifiers are simply a term that CMS uses to dictate how payments occur. Thank you. Yes, sir. Representative Ladyman, you're recognized for a question. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. What I'm trying to do is figure out in my own mind to differentiate your profession from the other profession. Yes, sir. And I know you've covered a lot of these subjects, but could you summarize what is the primary one or two things
that would separate your profession from an AA that would make you able to work independently? Just a summary, is it your training? Is it your RN training? Is it your critical care training? What are the two things that
separate you from an AA? Sure. Well, most importantly, it's our scope of practice. Scope of practice is dictated by law in this state. Our scope of practice, for us, shows that we can cover all areas of anesthesia care, independent of anesthesiologist supervision. That's why we can work in rural environments by ourselves.
They are not allowed to, so their scope of practice is different. So that's number one. Okay? Number two, billing. We bill independently when we're working alone. They cannot bill independently. If they cannot bill independently, by nature of what they do, it can increase cost. When we bill independently, it drops cost. That's all the time we have for against. Thank you. Thank you, sir. Seeing no one else signed up
to speak for or against, Representative McGee, I'll recognize you to close for your bill.
Yes, in the table, please. So, thank you, Mr. Chair, thank you, committee, for your indulgence. You have about eight minutes. I have about eight minutes? Oh, I can go eight minutes for sure. Well, let's hope not. Let me sit back. I can do it pretty quick. Well, I just want to comment. There's been a lot of discussion about the billing and the charges and what it's going to cost and all those sorts of things.
Number one, in Arkansas, they don't operate independent. Okay? There are some states where they do have independent practice, but not in the state of Arkansas. In Arkansas, when they're operating, and they're down in McGee, Arkansas, or Louisville, or a small hospital where there's not an anesthesiologist, they're still working under the supervision of the surgeon that's there. There's still a physician there that's responsible. Ultimately, now, are the CRNAs liable? You bet they're liable.
Do they buy malpractice insurance? You bet they buy malpractice insurance. Are they well-trained? Do I have confidence that they're doing a good job out there in rural Arkansas? You bet. I think they are. I have no issues with what they do. But when they say they're independent, Arkansas is a state that hasn't opted out of it, according to Medicare, so they still have to work under the supervision of a physician, and that doctor is responsible. Now, when you get into all of the billing where you're talking about an anesthesiologist supervising a nurse anesthetist or supervising anesthesia
assistant what you have to you have to go back all the way back into medicine and think about what kind of surgery are they doing down in mcgee arkansas what's dr burge what kind of surgery is dr burge undertaking he's evaluating that patient pre-operatively he knows that patient he knows all of their medical issues he knows what's wrong with them surgically and if dr burge in his medical opinion thinks this is this this patient needs a procedure that i could perform in mcgee but because of their medical issues i think that they would be better served by going
to a bigger institution as an example being referred to baptist hospital to a physician there or being referred to the university to a physician there where they had anesthesiology care now when they get there the nurse anesthetist or the aa if we allowed her they may be the one in the operating room putting that pace to sleep but they but they're then working under the supervision of an anesthesiologist. Is that more expensive care when you get to the university setting? Well, probably so because you have more difficult problems, more difficult management
problems. So it's the level of care that you're getting to. So the fact that each small town in Arkansas doesn't have an anesthesiologist doesn't mean that people are getting good care. They're getting good care, but there's still somebody responsible for that patient when something goes on. It's like I told you earlier, in all of my training, I don't have very much anesthesia training. Now, you could come into my office, and I could put an IV in you, and I could give you some sedation, and probably 99 times out of 100, that'd be okay, but that one time you quit
breathing on me, that's going to be pretty tough when we have to intubate you, particularly if I have to intubate you, which I've not done in 35 years, you know, so I want somebody there. I want nurse anesthetist there that knows what they're doing, that knows what they're doing anesthesia wise. But if that patient crashes medically in that operating room, I'm responsible for that patient. I'm responsible for taking care of them and making sure that they're treated appropriately and they're resuscitated appropriately. But anyway, that being said, so the supervision question to me is not really an issue. They are supervised in Arkansas.
They may not be supervised by an anesthesiologist. They mentioned that they They bill with this code as a QZ code. That all goes back to that act in 1982, whatever the acronym was for that federal act, where they set up the billing systems. If you do direct, if the anesthesiologist does direct medical billing, he codes an AA. If they do supervising, if they're supervising, they code a QZ. if the nurse anesthetists is out there and they do a case,
they code QZ to Medicare from Arkansas, that means they still had physician supervision. They get paid the same. The anesthesiologist gets paid the same as the CRNA. There's no differential between the cases. And then when the anesthesiologist supervises multiple cases at a time, they get paid differently. So it's not really a cost savings to say that they – I think that's a misnomer that they think that saves money. Maybe it does.
I don't know. We'd have to get into that at a different time. The only thing I'd like to say is something to the effect of their educational levels because I think that's really important, and I think everybody needs to know where they're coming from. Just because the person trains to be an anesthesia assistant and they work under the direction of physician supervision doesn't mean that they're not safe, doesn't mean that they're not going to deliver excellent care, doesn't mean that they're going to be terribly expensive to the medical system, okay?
These people are extremely well qualified. They're trained in university settings, medical school settings. They go through rigorous training. They have an undergraduate degree, a bachelor of science degree, just as nurses have a bachelor of science degree when they graduate. They have a master's level of training. two years, sometimes up to three years, they take national exams, and the bottom line is the doctor that's hiring them or that they're working under is responsible for their care.
I'm a physician. I'm not going to let anybody in my office do anything that I think that I'm going to be ultimately responsible for unless I have confidence that that person is going to do the right thing at the right time. It's all about taking care of patients and patient safety, and And we're all concerned about that. To their credit, CRNAs do a great job. They do a great job. Like I said, I work with them all the time. But I also would not have a minute's difficulty if an anesthesia assistant walked into the operating room tomorrow and said, I'm XYZ certified anesthesia assistant, and I'm working for the anesthesiologist at Baptist Hospital.
I would not have one, if it were my family, my wife, me, myself personally, I would not have one bit of difficulty in them sedating me or managing my anesthetic care. So with that said, committee, I appreciate good consideration, and I think my eight minutes are about up. And as a member of the committee, I'd move to pass. Thank
you. Committee, we have a motion on the floor. Is there any discussion on the motion?
Seeing none, all those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? No. Representative McGee, your bill has failed. Thank you, committee. We'll see you again next year. Look forward to it. All right, let's go on down the list. Representative Sullivan, are you ready to run HB 1181? All right, you're recognized.
Speaker 127
46:40
thank you mr. chair mr. chair may I have one of the APNs join me at the end of the table I have an expert may she join me at the end of the table yes sir thank you
if you would have her introduce herself for the committee I think we all know who she is but we need her own record. Cassie Gonzalez,
family nurse practitioner. Committee, it's good to be back in
Speaker 127
47:14
public health. I've missed y'all. We don't get crowded down there in Agri like we do here, so I look forward to this. We really don't like it when you lie to us. Don't start me off like that, Mr. Chair. Just several things. This is HB 1181, which is a scope of practice bill. and let me lift my copy of it here, to create a transition to prescriptive authority and to amend the prescriptive authority of the advanced practice registered nurse
and for other things. I know this is a very emotional bill charged. There are people that have strong beliefs on both sides, and I appreciate because those beliefs are very firmly held and they're valid. So I'm not trying to say in this presentation that folks don't have a basis for their approach. But I would like you to try to remove the emotion from this. I know you've got a lot of e-mails, a lot of phone calls from probably both sides.
One of the groups you haven't heard from probably is your constituents back in your regions, the people that receive medical services. Arkansas is, towards the end, 47, 48, 49, in the access to care for medical services. Now, just think about that for a second. We are 47, 8, and 9, depending on what data you see in access to care. This scope of practice does about three things, or two things. It creates a transition to prescriptive authority,
and it provides a transition to independent practice. In the testimony that you're going to hear, you're going to hear several personal anecdotal stories from both sides. and each presenter will have valid reasons for holding that position. And while anecdotal stories are important, I ask the committee not to be distracted from the facts or swayed by the emotions from either side. APNs are fully qualified and fully trained to provide the services.
Again, they're fully trained and fully qualified. You're going to hear it said that if they want to be doctors, they need to do ABC. folks, they don't want to be doctors. They want to be an APN. APNs were recently allowed full practice authority by the VA. So when you hear opposing testimony, I ask yourself, would those opposing this like to remove those services from our veterans around the state? That's an important question. You know, the federal government just authorized that full array of services for our
vets. And you ask why? Because of access to care. We have the same problem in Arkansas as we did in the vets. The feds saw fit at that time to make access to care, make care more accessible through APNs. Very soon we're going to be moving to a managed care model, most likely. We're going to see that managed care either in one of two or three forms. But one of the primary focuses of many managed care organizations is the utilization for
patient-centered care through APNs. So if we go down this road, and we'll probably see a bill here in a few weeks, if we go down this road and we don't go this direction, then we're not going to realize the access to care which leads to healthier Arkansans. not going to see the access to care which leads to cost reductions. How many local and regional and statewide or national news stories have you heard about rogue APNs? You would
think if you're going to hear testimony that if this happens or that happens we're going to have all these terrible things happen. However, how many times have you seen a national story on that? None. How many times have you seen a regional or statewide story where our APNs are not providing care to their licensure or not doing a good job? You'll hear that young people will quit the profession and not going into the medical profession. Yet we have a waiting list here in
our local schools. We have two new medical schools open up, one in Fort Smith and one in Jonesboro. So the idea that folks are going to quit going into the field just isn't, there's no evidence to support that. There's a lot of dread for out-of-control prescriptive drugs when, in fact, some of the top states with the lowest levels of prescriptive or with opioid problems allow full practice authority for APNs.
So the stories you're hearing that would exude the emotion from you that say terrible things are going to happen are just not proven by fact. I think there's also the 60% of APNs utilize the safety check, the prescriptive monitoring program. I don't know how many of you are familiar with that, but in that prescriptive practice, there is a prescriptive authority program.
Sixty percent of the APNs utilize this safety check to prescribe medications that have the potential for inappropriate use, whereas only 36 percent of MDs and DOs are utilizing this. These numbers support the safe practice for APNs. You know, I could go on with several, and I've got a whole stack, and I took about five minutes this morning and printed out research studies that are non-biased, not by the Nurses Association,
not by the Medical Society or Doctors' Associations. These are the Kaiser Foundation, the federal government, and others who are nonpartisan in this issue, and every one of them that I found recommends moving in this direction. They say the only reason they don't move in this direction is that local states and opposition in local states prevent it. But you know, I think there are 21 states that already allow it.
There's a bill on the governor's desk in South Dakota where what we're proposing is ready to be signed by the governor of South Dakota, and there's legislation in 10 other states doing this. There's no legislation rolling back what's been done. Now think about that. If there are 21 states already doing this, there is ready to be signed almost 22. There are 10 others moving this direction, yet you see no states walking this backwards.
And Arkansas is 49th. Folks, there is no reason for Arkansas not to move forward with this. You know, I've been here. This is my second session. We went through this last time. I was having to be here just observing when this came through four years ago, and I think we've been walking down this path for six or eight years. This group right here can change that. You can step up to the plate. I know you're getting a lot of pressure. I know where the pressure is coming from,
but your citizens and the people who need this care are relying on you not to listen to these anecdotal stories, but look at the greater good. What's going on nationally? The federal government allows it. You know, it's a part of Medicaid that APNs have this authority. Yet Arkansas, and all Arkansas has to do is flip the switch and we could do it. But Medicaid's decided not to. We'll talk about that later, maybe. But it's up to you to have the courage to do what's right for the citizens
of Arkansas. And with that, Mr. Chair, I'll take any
questions. all right are any questions from the committee representative payton you're
recognized for a question thank you mr. chair uh representative sullivan you know i love you and i think i'm glad to vote against your bill but my question is i mean do we have a shortage of people to write prescriptions i mean i know we have a prescription drug problem already out there and i don't know of anybody that's having trouble finding a physician that will write a prescription
Speaker 127
55:51
You know, I don't know what the data is on that, but Representative, I know you're a free market guy. This is a free market bill. You know, why would we restrict anyone? Why does there have to be a need for more people? If someone wants to go into the business, maybe they want to open a car dealership. Who knows? But whatever they want to do, why would we prohibit them from, I mean, one could make the same argument, we have enough car dealerships. Well, just for the record, they have to be licensed. And franchises sometimes.
– go ahead. Representative Payton, the other day we began to call clinics that accept Medicaid throughout the state for our adult Medicaid population after last year you passed the private option. So numerous citizens of Arkansas got insurance cards, and that was great. But the problem was when we began to call clinics and asked them that they would accept an Arkansas Medicaid patient, they immediately told us no, that they
were full. In our clinic in Arkadelphia, we see patients every day who do not have a PCP. They cannot find anyone to accept them as their PCP, their primary care provider in Medicaid. So we see numerous patients every day who have never seen a primary care provider, have never had the ability or the opportunity to sign up. Because in our state, how we have it set up that a physician is the only one who can have a PCP status. So they can cap their numbers at whatever
number amount they want. And that also controls the nurse practitioner who collaborates underneath them. So in my setting at one time, I was at a Baptist clinic, I wanted to accept more adult Medicaid patients because my numbers were not full. I was not to a full clinic staff or full staff of patients. But yet my collaborating physician did not want to accept any more adult Medicaid patients because she was full and so we had the struggle of I couldn't accept another patient because of that so if we made these changes we would be able to make that decision
do we want to accept more patients so in Arkadelphia and the surrounding areas that we serve we do see that limitation that people are not able
Speaker 127
58:07
to get in. Just to make one more comment on that Representative Payton you know that right now when a APN quite frequently when they bill the code for providing that service, they often bill that at the doctor's code rather than the APN code, which is at a 20% higher rate. So when we move to allowing prescriptive authority, that code is billed at a lower rate, 20% less.
So it's a significant cost savings for the very same service. And again, I think it's a free market issue. We've got people that want to come. Right now, we have people that are licensed that leave the state because they have higher-paying jobs than other states. We want to attract those people back here, and to do that, we need a free market that allows this, and it's happening all over the nation. Representative Miller, you have a question?
Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Sullivan, can you tell me a little bit? I know you all just brought up the issue of there being folks who don't have a PCP. Could you tell me how this would work in regards to the home health industry, home health agencies up in rural Arkansas who may have folks who don't have as close access to a PCP?
would this be beneficial? Would the nurse practitioners be able to serve better in that regard? Absolutely. And you know, that's part
Speaker 127
59:43
of the problem is in our rural areas. And people ask, well, you know, they won't go to rural areas. Well, if we don't pass this bill, they certainly won't. We're going to restrict them. It is an access to care. And under Medicaid, there are certain there's a list in the Medicaid manual of services that an APN can provide and coordinating care and home health care are listed in all those
services that can be provided so again it provides an excellent opportunity for access to care and access to quality care does that answer you you know we asked BLR if they could run the numbers to find the numbers of how many people don't have a PCP. The number is capped. I think it's 2,500 patients that a doctor can have who are Medicaid patients. Now, the doctor can extend that, but they were not able to find out how many doctors have asked to extend that. BLR couldn't determine that. But we know it happens quite
frequently, and we know quite frequently doctors do cap
a follow-up? you recognize thank you so will this bill allow for a nurse practitioner to serve basically in the same role as a PCP for someone involved in a home health setting
Speaker 127
1:01:10
you know the 1182 does that the next bill coming up
the Affordable Care Act you and I are both big fans of that I know But the Affordable Care Act actually allows APNs to be a PCP, and they're trying to promote that. That, in fact, is exactly what's happened with our Veterans Administration. They had poor access to care, and the way to care manage that and manage that case and for these APNs to be a PCP is allowed. Right here in the state of Arkansas, it's going on at our Veterans Administration.
But that very same nurse can't walk across the street and practice at the same level at the hospital right across the street from them. Thank
you. Seeing no further questions, we'll move to Representative Hammer. You recognize for a quick one. Only
Speaker 72
1:02:06
because it was just brought up a minute ago in some of the questions. as it is right now, APRNs are not able to authorize or write prescriptions as this bill would give them the freedom to do it.
So as far as there being a drug problem, to lay it off at the feet of the APRNs, being the fact that they've been removed from that scenario for the last
Speaker 127
1:02:32
year and a half, is that a fair characterization? More than fair, and I would even say that the, you know, And a collaborative practice agreement would require that APN to hand that prescription off to the physician to review, correct? And once that physician signs off on that, that's when it goes forward.
So if we do have APNs who are writing prescriptions, they're authorized by the physician. Currently, I don't know if it's reg or if it's just common practice, with a collaborative agreement, a physician might have an agreement where they're reviewing X number of charts, 10 charts a month, 10% of the charts a month. I'm not sure what that number is or how it's realized. I've talked with several APNs. I said, have you ever had one of your collaborating physicians call you up
and say you made an error on your chart. I'm finding problems in your chart. I have yet to find one. Now think about that. They're reviewing, and think how many patients they see. They may see 100 a month, several hundred a month. They're reviewing those charts, and I haven't spoken to an APN yet who has said I have my collaborating physician has called me up and told me I'm not doing proper work. not had them say this is an inappropriate prescription.
So the practice is they're prescribing now, folks. They're doing it right now. It just has to be signed off on by a doctor. So whatever problem is going on cannot be attributed to the APNs. And if this were a big problem, folks, you'd be seeing national news stories on this. These states that are doing this, if you had APNs that were prescribing drugs and things are going bad, it would be on the national news somewhere. that a state has allowed this to happen. We need to roll it back, and you'd see people rolling this prescriptive authority back,
Speaker 72
1:04:35
and it's just not happening. Follow-up, Mr. Chair, one quick one. One quick one. I'm going to hold you to that now. Thank you. I understand you also hit on a point a while ago that Medicaid could do this now, which other Medicades in other parts of the nation have already done this. It seems to me, and it's a softball, so hit it out of the park. It seems to me that what's on page two of this actually brings us to a higher standard than what may be required in other states if this bill goes through, and that's part of the safety precaution of giving the APRNs what I perceive already to be within their scope of practice.
You're just adding another layer of security to make sure there are no rogue APRNs. Is that a fair statement? That's a fair
Speaker 127
1:05:20
statement and very true. Thank you. And, again, if we move to a managed care model, which we're going to do, we very likely could be right back here trying to do the very same thing because when your managed care companies come in, they want to manage care. And that's primarily what your APNs do is that care management and case management. That's a huge part of this. And if we're going to have a managed care company come in, and I'm supportive of that,
we're going to have to make the cost cuts and the access to continue to improve health care That's exactly what your APNs do. Representative Love, you're recognized for a question. Mr.
slide. Can't do that as long as the sponsor is at the table. When they get through, we'll take that motion. Okay, thank you. Representative Gonzalez, you're
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Could you speak a little more to the collaborative practice agreement
and exactly what's in that that provides any patient protection? So in Arkansas, a
nurse practitioner can be out practicing, so they can assess the patient, diagnose the patient, and manage the patient, all without a collaborating physician agreement, except when they decide that they want to write a prescription, which in most clinic settings or ambulatory care settings or in ER settings, that is necessary that they need to be able to do that. So at that point, they apply for a collaborating physician agreement
with the state of Arkansas with the Board of Nursing. That collaborating agreement is not well-defined in that what that physician has to do, that physician does not have to be on site or even within a mile radius. That physician just has to have a license within the state of Arkansas. Me personally, my collaborating physician, he signs 10 charts per quarter. So I've already seen the patient. I've assessed the patient, diagnosed them, and prescribed a medicine a majority of the time.
and then he comes back into the clinic and reviews those charts quarterly. Every nurse practitioner and physician can have a different agreement depending on where they are and what setting that they're in, but it's after the fact in my situation that I've already seen the patient. He's just reviewing those charts. So there's really no patient protection in our current collaborating agreement. I feel like we will always still collaborate with physicians, even if it's our physician that we work with on most days
or if it's in my setting, I'm in a family practice setting. So I refer and collaborate with our cardiologists and GI doctors every day, depending on where that patient needs to go to. Just
Speaker 127
1:08:06
one more comment on that. There's nothing in this bill that says that a practicing APN has to diagnose. You know, you may hear later, well, who will they go to if they don't have a collaborating practice? What do they do if there's a problem? Oh, my goodness, what do they do if there's a problem?
Folks, they just refer it to a physician, just like they do now. They just say, this is out of my scope of practice. You can go to, I'm referring you to the physician of your choice. So to make the argument that the lack of a collaborating practice leaves the patient on an island is just not factual. You know, if the APN sees a case that they are not comfortable with, they would just refer them to their PCP. Representative Gonzalez, did you have a follow-up?
Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair. You're recognized. In the title of the bill, you call it a transition to prescriptive authority. Could you speak a little bit about how that transition piece works? So there's
three options with this bill. One is we would continue exactly like we are. The nurse practitioner would have a Bachelor of Science of Nursing, then get a Master's or a Doctorate degree, and then apply with the State Board of Nursing for a collaborating physician agreement and would practice exactly in that sense. The second option would be that that nurse practitioner would get out of school
and then would develop a transition to practice or like a residency piece for one year that they would work alongside a physician or a nurse practitioner that has been out of school and in a clinical setting for over three years. That transition to practice piece would have to be approved by the Board of Nursing, and it would be in a very in-depth program based upon where that nurse practitioner was going to practice, if it was going to be a specialty setting or in a family practice setting. Then the third option that comes into this bill is that if the nurse practitioner has already been out practicing
in a collaborating setting for over three years, they could apply to the Board of Nursing to have full scope of practice at that point. But that would also be reviewed by the Board of Nursing. They would review our licensure, how we prescribe medicine. They could review charts. There's lots that they could do to make sure that there was no issues with that licensure before they allowed that to happen. Representative Branscombe,
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Representative Sullivan, correct me if I'm wrong, but I think I remember back in the last few weeks seeing a news story about how the country and even the state of Arkansas had this huge problem of overprescription and how many overdoses there have been on opiants and stuff like that. So aren't you a little bit concerned with this bill, with giving all the new prescriptive authority, with how many APNs are the thousands in the state, if this new permission to write these prescriptions, that that might not enhance this problem?
Speaker 127
1:11:07
You know, first, if there's a problem now, it's not due to the APNs. Would you agree with that? I can't ask you questions, I guess. Well,
I mean, I get confused on that because you're wanting to do this
Speaker 127
1:11:31
with the first question. Yes, the top 10 states, I'll let you see, you'd know it
better than I, go ahead. Representative Branscombe, the top 10 states by the DEA's, by the DEA website, if you look up their data,
the top 10 states that have the less opioid addiction or abuse or prescribing in each one of those 10 states has nurse practitioners with full scope of practice with full prescribing ability from Schedule 2 to Schedule 5. and in Arkansas we were you reviewed the data from the Arkansas Department of Health with the PMP the monitoring system 60% of nurse practitioners are signed up and are using the PMP system currently to try to avoid opioid addiction or abuse of any scheduled drug sir all of those medicines as you know
are updated weekly at this point of what the patient is getting or receiving at a pharmacy right now currently 30 36.6 percent of physicians or do's are signed up and of that 36% only 58% are actually using the
Speaker 127
1:12:40
database I'm comfortable it's working in other states and I think I understand the committee that they're a
huge fear it's just not supported by the evidence representative love
I mean representing Henderson you're recognized for a question sorry about that thank you mr. chair I'm just trying
to get my hands around how big the scope is that we're talking about do you know how many APR ends are in Arkansas that this is going to affect 3,000 I'm not sure
3,200 nurse practitioners are in the state but like we said the nurse practitioner can choose Ms. Gonzalez if
you don't mind get real close to that microphone we can't hear
you right now 3,200 nurse practitioners in the state of Arkansas but like we said every nurse practitioner may not choose to change their model of practice they could continue as they are they also do not have to choose to prescribe Schedule 2s. That's all a personal choice that they will make between them and the clinic that they work at at this point. Follow-up, you recognize. In the states
that have adopted this in the past, do they see an influx of nurse practitioners going to those states to, you know, if they're able to work as a PCP, is there kind of an influx of nurses? Representative
Henderson, I think the PCP bill is next. This bill is a transition into prescription authority. Okay, scratch out PCP. Okay.
Speaker 127
1:14:22
But yes, you see people leaving the state
where more of a broader scope of practice is allowed. I mean, it's just, again, free market. If you can make X number of dollars and start my own business, I'm going to leave the state. And here in Arkansas, it's very difficult to start your own business without having all the hoops we make you jump through. Again, it's why you see 21 states doing it, 10 moving towards it, and one having the governor sign it. This is the direction medicine is going, folks. Arkansas is 49th.
It's time for this committee to move this at least forward to the full House for a vote. Well,
I do think that we just saw... Representative Henderson, you would like to be moved to the bottom of the list? I knew you were going to come
down. You're already there. You're ready to go. You're recognized to go around. Representative Henry said you're welcome to join him. You're recognized for your
question, Representative Henderson. So we must be about done. No, when you're talking about free market, and I do agree with free market,
but we just saw in our last bill that we looked at that we kind of stifled free market there too. So wouldn't you agree, though, that beyond free market? I'm trying to phrase this as a good question instead of a statement. Ken, Representative Henderson, please get close to
the mic so we can hear you. I've got people complaining. Thank you.
When we're looking at free market, though, I mean, don't you agree that it's probably what we do here
is more toward the health of Arkansans than when you're talking about free market? There certainly has to be a balance between protection
Speaker 127
1:16:21
and free market. I mean, God forbid we let people choose whether they want to go to a doctor. God forbid we don't let them choose to go to an APN versus a doctor. I would choose that. But this bill has protections built in. I mean, they're on prescriptive side. They are reporting all the drugs they're prescribing.
They go through a year of transition practice. I believe it fully protects patients in our current model. And again, would I say that Arkansas is protecting our patients? Absolutely. But please stop protecting me so much. Please let Arkansans have some freedom to let them choose how they want to be protected. I mean, we see the room full of doctors who are looking out for the patients.
But I hear patients all the time saying, look, let me have a choice. If I choose to go to an APN and if an APN wants to hang out a shingle that says I'm working under a collaborative agreement with the best doctor in the world and that attracts patients, hallelujah, go for it. If an APN wants to put up a shingle that says I'm an APN practicing without a collaborative agreement and you still get all the quality and people make that choice, that's up to people to choose. And I think for too long, Arkansans have, we as a legislature, have prevented Arkansans from having choice.
Seeing no further questions, Representative Gonzalez, one more, and then we're going to move
to witnesses. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So on the current model, the collaborative practice agreement that we have now, A nurse practitioner can graduate out of the program, contract with a doctor or hospital, go wherever they want to go. That doctor can put that nurse practitioner wherever on their own with just the collaborative agreement
that reviews 10 charts per quarter, and they can be out practicing in their own clinic, is the way I believe it's written now. And this bill, if I understand it right, would make them work alongside another provider that has been out practicing for the first year. So we're actually adding patient protection with this bill. Would you agree with that? I would, yes.
All right, you guys, we're going to go ahead and go to the witnesses. We got Evan Branscombe to speak against the bill.
oh representative love yes you got something
Speaker 72
1:19:05
for us yeah you have skipped my motion mr chair i would like i would um like to make the motion that we'd limit debate to 10 minutes per
side okay that's proper motion non-debatable all those in favor say aye aye all those opposed ayes have it uh we'll be keeping time from chair representative sullivan would you like to reserve time to close? How much time do you want to reserve? Five minutes? Well, I mean, you have
ten minutes total, so if you... I'd like to reserve five of that to close, yes, sir. That's fine. We'll retain five. Mr. Branscombe, if you don't mind, introduce yourself for the committee, and you're recognized
to carry on. Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My name is Evan Branscombe.
I'm a fourth year medical student from Marshall. If you would
get closer to the mic please. I'm a medical student here in Little Rock. I'm currently the president of the family medicine group on campus, past president of the rural medicine group on campus. I will go into family
medicine starting my residency this July. I'm here to speak against House Bill 1181. I'll keep this testimony brief because I'll be up here a few more times today, but my main concern from the perspective of a medical student is that during our training, we get extensive lectures, extensive training, not only in the pharmacology and prescribing of medications,
but also how to recognize and treat abuse and misuse of those medications. As medical students, we have more time than anyone in the hospital to get to know patients, to get to know them on a medical level and a social level, and I think the main issue with this bill is that you're giving out more prescription pads, which I don't see how it cannot exacerbate the already overgrowing
opiate epidemic in this state people usually follow the path of least resistance and you're giving prescription pads to people who have not as much training not as much experience as what we're given in medical school and residency which is the majority of the experience that you get but so from the interest of patients I believe this is a bad bill I don't see anything negative
with having more oversight another person looking over your shoulder to make sure that what you're doing is correct and best for the patient and like I said I'll keep it brief for the other testimonies and I'd be happy to take any questions Representative Hamer Thank
Speaker 72
1:22:00
you Madam Chair and I'm not doing this to do a gotcha but I think it's important to know before we walk out of this room, just as Representative Gonzalez was identified with his wife who was sitting at the end of the table, are you related to anybody in this room that's sitting at this table?
Unfortunately, no, not sitting at the table. No. At this moment. At this moment. Full disclosure, because I think that would be important moving forward for the protection of everybody. Absolutely. May I ask a follow-up, or can I have a question, Madam Chair? You're recognized. Madam. sir thank you um how many hours of training do you go through as you stated as part of your argument against this bill given the number of hours that the aprns would have to undergo in on-the-job training as defined in this bill can you do a comparison for us so i'll give you
a brief overview we have to go through four years of undergraduate four years of medical
school um in a minimum of three years of residency, the amount of hours that we're trained in prescription and pharmacology is almost impossible to calculate because every patient encounter is a learning experience for us on what the previous physician did, what the previous APRN did, what we should do for the patient, what is the correct way to practice for the patient. You know, we're not
just trained in medical knowledge. We're trained in decision making, and what is the best decision for this patient in the overall health. Just because they have pain doesn't mean an opiate is the right solution. A lot of people have neuropathic pain, and for some reason, or they have osteoarthritis, and they think that the best way to treat that is an opiate, and there have been several patients that have opiates for those conditions, and those are not going to help
because, you know, if it's neuropathic pain, there's a different medication for that. If it's osteoarthritic pain, there's a different medication for that. And so as doctors, we're trained to look at the whole patient and make the decision
Speaker 72
1:24:09
on what is best for them. Okay, you made your point, but one follow-up, please. You're recognized. Thank you. I'm glad to hear you say that it appears the opium problem is growing. and that's why APRNs are part of the PDM. So I'm going to take the position, unless you decline now, that in your role of leadership that you just expressed, that physicians are going to submit to becoming part of the PDM
because, to me, that's a defining moment that the APRNs are willing to do that to close in on the problem. But if the physicians are not, then I think the argument has just gotten shallow. Could you define the acronym? I'm sorry. That is where the physicians are required to consult. The physicians are required to participate in the program that the state pays for in order to make sure that prescriptions. Order. You recognize. That's not germane to this bill.
I would agree. Thank you. Thank you. Only because he brought it up,
view and experience is from a medical student perspective. So as a training physician, that will happen in a
few more months. Seeing no further questions, thank you for your testimony. We have a Ms. Angela Jones. Did I say that right? Yes.
If you would introduce yourself for the committee,
Speaker 208
1:25:40
and you're recognized to carry on. Hello. My name is Angela Jones. I'm a nurse practitioner from northeast Arkansas. I'm actually practicing in Jonesboro. I work for NEA Baptist Clinic there. I've been a practicing nurse practitioner and family, a family nurse practitioner for over 13 years now. I graduated from Arkansas State University. I have had 10-plus collaborating physicians in my 13-plus years experience.
I have practiced in Truman, Lake City, Paragould, and now in Jonesboro. And during those times, I have been probably in an office setting with the physician physically in my presence maybe a third of that time. I was actually in Truman and Lake City by myself. So my collaborating physician was available by phone. And as Representative Sullivan spoke of, they are required to review 10% of my charts.
And during that time, I have never had a physician ever call me and say that they disagreed with any of my clinical decisions. However, as Ms. Gonzalez also said, I've always felt that my collaborative agreement, it was a document we signed, we faxed to the State Board of Nursing. It was for my DEA, and we forgot about it. I've always relied on my colleagues, whether it was my collaborating
physician, the physician I was working with at the time, a nurse practitioner I was working with at a time at the time or a specialist that I might need to call for advice about something but as far as medications you know I'm I'm an educated professional I've been doing this for a long time we have resources and as Mr. Branscom mentioned I have years and years and years of clinical experience as well as pharmacology, and I rely up on that. And I haven't ever felt like
I've needed to call my physician or my collaborator each time I write a prescription. So to me, the transition to practice, it really isn't changing much. I've already got a prescription pad, and I've already got the DEA to write Schedule 2s because I wrote in, my physician signed the letter that said I was going to do it under our collaborative agreement.
So basically all it's changing is that, I really don't know what it's changing, it's just I'm transitioning, I'm choosing to do it now without a collaborative agreement. So it's basically saying that I'm just going to do it without that piece of paper. Does anyone have any questions?
Speaker 192
1:28:52
Representative Gonzalez, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Do you feel like without that collaborative agreement it would limit your ability to consult with a physician in any way? Absolutely not.
Speaker 208
1:29:05
Currently I'm in an office setting with three other physicians and another nurse practitioner. I'm feet across the hall from the very physician who trained me when I was doing my clinical to get my master's as a nurse practitioner, and I rely heavily upon him when I need something. We talk a lot. We bounce things off each other a lot. I would still walk across the hall and ask him if I needed advice on anything. Representative Ferguson, you're recognized for a question.
Yeah, I just want to clarify. I hope I misunderstood you, because last time we gave APRNs the ability to prescribe hydrocodone, which is a Schedule II, because it had been moved up in the Schedule II. Are you telling me you're prescribing all Schedule II? No, ma'am, just hydrocodone. I'm sorry. I should
in an office with a physician. Follow-up. I'm sorry. Yes. I'll just clarify what you're doing now.
You're not working in a collaborative agreement.
thank you. Thank you. We have 30 seconds left, Representative Henderson. I hope you can get
it out. Well, Representative Ferguson just kind of hit on my question, but I will take one quick one. Now, you practice currently in Jonesboro? Yes. Part of this bill would look at trying to serve underserved communities in our state,
and I think that's one of the big things that we're really looking at. Would you consider leaving Jonesboro and
going to? Representative Henderson, that's the end of your time. I'm sorry. Thank you. Thank you, ma'am, for testifying. We have approximately five minutes left on the against side, and I've got David Roden signed up to speak against.
Mr. Roden, if you would introduce yourself for the committee,
Speaker 72
1:31:27
and you're recognized. My name is David Roden, and I'm the Executive Vice President for the Arkansas Medical Society. Perhaps you've seen a lot of our emails floating around the last couple of days since they were hijacked and sent around by others, and that's okay because we don't put anything in our newsletters that we wouldn't want anybody else to see. I want to focus on this bill, not the next bill. The next bill deals with PCPs and expanding advanced practice nurses into PCPs.
This bill deals with the Collaborative Practice Agreement and it deals with Schedule II narcotics. So I want to focus on that. A comment that was made a few minutes ago that of the best ten states for opioid prescribing, meaning they prescribed less than others, they were all advanced practice nurse, full practice states. Folks, that's just not the case. Here's the list of those states right here. Based on Representative Sullivan's own map that he sent out,
Now, Florida, Illinois, Massachusetts, Texas, New Jersey, New York, and California are among those 10 states. All of those have limited scope of practice for advanced practice nurses. They either require collaborative agreement, joint monitoring by the two boards, or other things where they don't allow Schedule II. So to say that they're wide open states is not true. this is a map that representative sullivan said sent around a couple of weeks ago this shows the
states around the country that have some type of limits on what advanced practice nurses can do these green states here which is all of the southeast states is where arkansas is at right now. We're right in line with all of the other southern states, including Texas, Florida, Tennessee, Alabama, Oklahoma, Kansas, Missouri. We're right there. Let me say this issue is not about the quality of care provided by advanced practice nurses. No one is here saying advanced
practice nurses don't provide good care. We're not going to say that because it's just simply not true. Advanced practice nurses have a major important role to play in our health care system. But as the speaker right before me said, she works not only in collaboration with, but with along beside other physicians that are there all the time to help her out. That's the way it needs to be. That's the best way. That's the way you ensure that patients get the absolute best care.
Not by opening it up. This bill basically provides an avenue to get rid of the collaborative practice agreement. Folks, over the last few years, we have tried multiple times to strengthen the collaborative practice agreement. We came to this body one time with a bill. Representative Shelby had it when he was here. It would require the medical board and the nursing board to work together to develop a collaborative practice agreement that had teeth that forced the two groups to work together to improve things for everybody.
The nurses opposed that every step of the way. So that's why the collaborative agreement in some cases today may not work very well. But in most cases, it does. The vast majority of advanced practice nurses in this state work in a clinic with other physicians. This bill is about those that don't, that want to be out there on their own independently without any involvement of a physician other than someone that they might be able to call. If we take away the collaborative agreement, that's gone.
There's no more requirement that they do it. On Schedule II narcotics, some of you have already seen this. In the state of Tennessee, the report came out from the Department of Health last year, year before last, of the top 50 prescribers of opiates, 35 were advanced practice nurses, in spite of the fact that they represent only about 23% of the population that can write prescriptions. Now, let me take it a step further. On a national level, there is a study put out by a company that gathers data.
I can't think of the name of it. It's called IMS Health, and they've looked at this. They've measured opioid prescriptions from 2012 to 2015 nationwide. During that period of time, the number of opiates prescribed by everybody went down 12% For primary care and internal medicine, it went down 20%. For nurse practitioners during that period of time, it went up 30%.
So don't think for a minute that if we pass this bill and allow them to write Schedule 2s that we're not going to see more
Schedule 2s. And we have an epidemic. We are out of time. Thank you, Mr. Roden, for your testimony. We have five minutes reserved for the sponsor to close for his bill. So, Representative Pilkey didn't have a question while ago when we shut down, and I didn't see him,
Speaker 72
1:36:40
but if he wants to ask his question, I'll recognize him first. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Could you contrast this bill with Representative Hammer's bill, the 1228?
How is this different, just briefly? I'd have to have the bill in front of me. I don't have it. I
think they're very similar. We don't need to compare bills. let's talk on the bill please you recognize
Speaker 127
1:37:08
close for your bill thank you mr. chair and i'll be quick just to you know folks there just about studies defined about anything you want here the study i'm looking at aprn practice environments versus overall state health outcomes states with the
best health outcomes uh hawaii maine connecticut minnesota there are 10 of them eight of the 10 allow full practice, 8 of the 10. States with the worst health outcomes, 41 through 50, of which Arkansas is one, have reduced practice. So again, you just don't see the evidence at the national level that this is happening, and the opioids are a result of the advanced practice nurse again Arkansas is 49 folks so when you see a map that we're
along with everybody else we're not along with everybody else we're at the bottom of that list and those other states many of them as we listed here allow those well let me take that back number 50 is Mississippi 49 is Louisiana 48 Arkansas Alabama Oklahoma Kentucky Tennessee West Virginia South Carolina and Georgia all those dark states allow reduced practice and they have the worst health outcomes in the nation that's a fact it's time to change
the color of Arkansas and get us off of that whatever the color was blue or green and let's get up there with the folks that are having quality health outcomes and allow full scope of practice there's nothing in this bill that prevents an an APN from staying in a collaborative practice, nothing at all. And again, you don't see any states who are rolling this back. Folks, we need to get this to the full House. I urge you to vote yes on it. Let's continue to debate.
It's a good one, and I appreciate you listening. Thank you.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Representative Sullivan is closed for his bill. It's a pleasure to committee. Do pass. I got a motion do pass by Representative Miller. Any discussion on the motion? Vice Chair Ferguson, you're
recognized for discussion. Thank you. First of all, I think it might be circular logic to say that those states are healthier because of APRNs. You know, there are a lot of lifestyle issues, like we eat a lot of fried food, and we have a lot of overweight people that contribute to those healthier states being healthier,
which have nothing to do with practice APRNs. But my real problem with this is exactly the problem I had two years ago, and I was willing to allow APRNs to prescribe hydrocodone. But do we really want more people prescribing oxycontin and dilaudid and morphine? Those things bother me a lot. But there is a growing problem with kids and adults being prescribed stimulants for ADHD and ADD that we really need to get control of. this problem with Adderall and Vyvanse and all of those things are very lifelong chronic
prescriptions for patients that have real ramifications. And a lot of these kids grow up and end up with drug problems because they've been on those drugs. So I have a problem. I'm just trying to figure out what Schedule 2s that they think would be appropriate for them to prescribe because I don't see any additional Schedule 2s besides the hydrocodone that I would be willing to allow an APN to prescribe. The other thing, and I know that Representative Sullivan is in the behavioral health business,
when I look at the proposed possible managed care model that we're looking at, the provider-led managed care, all of those 30,000 people are going to be Tier 2 and Tier 3 people with chronic conditions that requires a lot of oversight and management that are well beyond the scope of an APN practice. Just my thoughts. you're not on the committee Representative
Sullivan are there any other discussion Representative Hammer thank you Mr. Chair Mr. Chair if
Speaker 72
1:41:13
I may I'd like to make a
public apology for something I did a minute ago if you give me a little latitude to do that thank you I want to apologize to Mr. Branscombe that sat at the end of the table because I may have caught him off guard or I may have misstated the acronym referring to the PMP or what is often referred to as the PDMP. And around here, a lot of acronyms get thrown around. And so if I caught him off guard to where his answer was not totally given all the facts of the statement, I want to apologize to him publicly.
It doesn't change my position on my statement, but I do want to apologize to him publicly if the acronym was misstated. Now, can I make my comment to the motion, Mr. Chair? Thank you, Mr. Chair. But when we hear the comments about the growing problem with any Schedule II or above, the statement that's been made in this committee, I think that is important to remember, is that currently, and at least for the last year and a half, nurse practitioners have been writing these scripts underneath the supervision of a primary care physician.
The idea that we're going to have a runaway of APRNs who are going to take advantage of this and go rogue or go out there and do something inappropriate, I think the fact that it was identified there was such a few number would imply that the impression of a runaway problem is not a very practical or realistic view of what this bill would do. We are simply making access to care to patients and the working arrangements between APRNs and the physicians more conducive to the needs of our Kansans.
And I think it's proper to put what we're about to do in that perspective.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Any further discussion? Representative Miller,
do you have a discussion? Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. One thing I would like to say in this discussion deal is we do have a problem with a lot of narcotic pain pills being prescribed. I think part of the reason for that, especially if you are from a small town like I am, you have some doctors who are more prone to be willing to prescribe these medicines than others.
So, therefore, their schedule books get filled up pretty quickly. These doctors may have good intentions, but they don't have the time in an 8- to 10- to 12-hour day to thoroughly visit with everyone who comes in there who may be seeking a prescription for pain pills. What that results in is a quick visit and a prescription. i personally think it might be a good idea if we've got more folks that are actually seeing
these people and vetting the patients and seeing if they need pain pills or not or if they can take other options i think this bill does that that's why i'm proud to support
it thank you representative miller i want to tell you guys i like discussion on the bills y'all have heard me say that since we've been here for six weeks so i encourage it uh representative gonzalez
you're recognize for your discussion. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'd just like to address what was said about Tennessee. You know, those facts may be accurate, but I'd also like to point out that Tennessee has
a very strict oversight of APRNs by physicians in that state, and apparently has a little effect on the prescribing practices. Thank you.
Any further discussion? Seeing none, all those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? No. Roll call. I got it. I can't call that. Representative Hammer.
Speaker 241
1:45:11
Representative Love. Yes. Representative Hammer. Yes. Representative Branscombe. No. Representative Meeks. Yes. Representative Ritchie. Representative Ritchie. Representative McGee. No. Representative Miller. Yes. Representative Womack.
Yes. Representative Payton. No. Representative Ladyman. Yes. Representative Lundstrom. Yes. Representative Bentley, Representative Gonzales, Representative Boyd, Representative Henderson, Representative McCollum, Representative Coleman,
With 9 votes for 10 votes against the bill has failed Representative Sullivan If you don't mind I'm going to take about a 2 minute break Let everybody get their meal and then you'll be recognized to present your next bill.
I forgot to say Tuesday that Representative Wardlaw paid for lunch, and today Representative Payton is paying for lunch, so thank you both. The third
Speaker 273
1:49:14
you.
of the discussions, so let's go pretty quickly. I've been practicing, I'm writing. There you go, that's what you wanted, right? Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. All right. I'm ready. It's all right. I can't believe it. I can't believe it. I can't believe it. I can't believe it. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I think I'll do it all day.
the table and get people's business done.
Representative Sullivan, if you would, let's keep the noise level down. Representative Sullivan, you're recognized to present 1182, I think. Is that right? Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I'm going to let my guest here introduce himself, Chair, if that's okay. Yes, sir. Please introduce yourself for the record, and you're recognized to carry on. Hi,
Speaker 72
1:51:14
my name is David Mitchell. I'm an associate professor of economics at UCA.
I'm also the director of the Arkansas Center for Research in Economics. My goal here is not to really discuss any of the specifics of the bill, but to talk about the data. So we can all agree that we want to improve access to care and that patients with fewer options have worse outcomes. My analysis shows that expanding the things that the nurse practitioners can do can lead to large Medicaid savings. So about one-third of Arkansans are covered by Medicaid or ARC kids. Medicaid is one of the largest expenditures in the Arkansas budget.
Even though the federal government covers some of these cost of cares, Medicaid is still about a fifth of the total state budget. Between 2000 and 2014, Arkansas spent a larger share of its own funds on Medicaid, even though Arkansas participates in the ACA. And this proportion will grow as the federal contributions begin tapering, and this year as the overall costs continue to escalate, despite some promises by ACA advocates. So studies by organizations like the Rand Corporation suggested if nurse practitioners
had wider scope of practice, that between 4.8 and 18.1 percent of the visits that currently go to physicians could go to nurse practitioners. When researchers look at outcomes, we find that nurse practitioners provide comparable primary care, even in randomized control studies. So not in anecdotes, but in randomized control studies. However, nurse practitioners are reimbursed by Arkansas Medicaid at a lower rate. So to analyze the potential savings, I looked at the most common bearable office visits,
and a very common one is something like a 15-minute visit by a new or established patient. And then I calculated the savings that would occur to Medicaid if some of those patients switched to nurse practitioners instead of physicians. And if just 5% of the patients who currently see physicians had seen a nurse practitioner in 2015, then Medicaid could have saved over 575,000. That's a little over 100,000 visits. And if 10% of those people had switched to nurse practitioners, then the savings would
have been $1.1 million. Imagine what the state could have done with an extra $1 million. I then broaden the analysis just a bit to the top 10 most common procedures that both nurse practitioners and physicians take care of. And then the savings for 5% would have been $880,000, and if 10% of those patients switched, it would have been $1.7 million annually. Now I wanted to be really conservative. So even though some patients currently show up on the EED, they could theoretically learn to switch to go to office visits or retail clinics.
I didn't include that in my analysis. Further, generally, managing chronic conditions with a usual source of care is much cheaper because you don't have the later expenses. I didn't include that in my thing. Again, I wanted to be as conservative as possible. And finally, I didn't include the savings from early diagnosis and management that comes from increased access to care. So if you expand access to care, if you expand the scope of practice for nurse practitioners, We will save money and help more people by broadening the scope and having better access
Speaker 127
1:54:32
to care. Thank you. The committee, this bill would allow a primary care provider, an APN, to be a primary care provider under Medicaid. In the Medicaid manual, there is a list of services that that PCP can perform. It's also on the second page of the bill. I know you have to put down your sandwich, but if you turn to that second page, it kind list all the different activities and services that can be provided and of
course now those will all be under a collaborative practice so there is oversight in all those services mr. chair I'm going to kind of shorten that up I think we've had most of discussion that's relevant to the issue again this This is done at the VA, and I would – do we have a handout? Again, this is very similar to what's done at the VA where – If
we would, we don't need members from the audience at the table until it's time.
Our House rules don't prevent anybody to
Speaker 127
1:55:40
approach the table. Thank you. So we talked about all the services before and all the array, what the differences are, The savings that can be accrued, the quality of health care, allowing those APNs to practice at that level and provide that direct care. Federal law allows it. The state now doesn't need a law to do this. They could flip the switch, do a rule, and we could be providing this.
So I hope the committee will consider allowing this. I think it's a good thing for our Kansans, and I'll
take any questions. Any questions from the committee? Representative Pilkington,
Speaker 72
1:56:19
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Would this somehow affect hospitalists? Would hospitals see that they could use an APN to replace a primary care provider that they have employed? I don't
Speaker 127
1:56:34
know if they would want to necessarily replace them. That would be their choice, but they might have an extender, which is what they are.
again I guess the answer would be yes if they so chose but that would be based upon that hospital's decision they could do it or not do it. Does that answer your question? Yes.
Seeing no further questions if you guys would we'll get the people speak for and against the bill up there.
We have Dr. Yelvington for speaking against the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman,
Speaker 72
1:57:23
and members of the committee. I'm Dennis Yelvington, private practice, family medicine, in Stuttgart, Arkansas. I oppose the bill for a number of reasons. Let me just say first about the economist that was here a while ago. He assumes that all the APMs want to keep the payment the same. You know what will happen, of course, is that they're going to want more money.
And that's okay if you get the same service. The VA, we've all been hearing about the VA system here recently. We all know how the VA is. We were talking about narcotics earlier, and this goes back to the patient center back at home. But it was the VA that started the narcotic rage years ago when I was in school. It was the fifth vital sign, and we see what that's got us. Okay, the physicians are the best suited to lead a patient-centered medical home. That's the way the system was designed with physician extenders,
whether it be APMs or physician's assistants. It was designed, especially with the new concept of the patient-centered medical home, it just expanded on the family medicine care model. We need a captain of the ship. We need a pilot on the airplane. We need someone that's going to take responsibility for the whole team. We need the APNs. They have excellent. I have APNs at my clinic. I work for the Baptist system as a contractor.
And we have the best APNs around there. But they all agree that they like the way it is. They like the situation the way it is. There was an issue about the number, about access to care, and that's true. We do have a problem with access to care in America, but we also have a problem with the nursing shortage.
It's estimated that there may be a quarter of a million RNs and LPNs needed down the road, And we're taking nurses away, and more nurses are going to APN, and putting those into provider care. We also have, as far as primary care in Arkansas, we have two new medical schools that are coming up pretty soon. They're going to be putting out close to 300 new physicians in the state of Arkansas. The patient-centered medical home concept is a good one.
We need to continue with Medicaid. Medicaid has made some savings in the state of Arkansas. They're going to make more. I think we may have managed care down the road, and I think it's going to be a good thing probably for us in most circumstances. So I speak opposition to this appeal, and I'll take any questions. Representative Hammer, you recognize for a question. Thank you. Regarding serving down there in Stuttgart, you have APRNs that are in your clink now that see patients under your care.
Is that correct? Yes. Follow-up, Mr. Chair. You're recognized. When that APRN sees that patient and Medicaid is billed in your office, do you bill it at the APRN rate or do you bill it at the physician rate with the APRN providing the services? We are a rural health clinic, so we have a different billing system. Rural health clinics, fairly qualified community health centers, have different billing rights, different billing codes. I'd like to go to the bottom of the list, please.
I think you're there. Would you expand on that different billing system that you, being a provider, I guess that's because you're in a medically underserved area, gives you latitude to bill Medicaid at a different rate than, say, somebody in an area that is not medically underserved, if that's the qualifying distinction? I'm not sure I can answer. I'm not sure I understand the question. But why are you allowed to bill under a different procedure?
The alternate payment method, 30 years ago, 20 years ago, the federal government has a rural health clinic program, and then subsequently they've developed the federally qualified community health centers also, which also bill differently than independent private pay-for-service. i don't ask me all the i don't know all the details of the payment because i i don't get in that is there anybody from medicaid here mr chair i think uh that's
going to happen next thank you yes sir any further questions for the witness seeing none thank you dr yelton for your testimony um without going to the next speaker i think i'm gonna pull uh miss tammy harland to the table if She's still in the room. There she is. Ms. Tammy, if you would introduce yourself, and I've got some members with questions for you. And your witness, please. My
Speaker 72
2:02:28
name is Tammy Harlan. I'm with Medicaid and the Department of Human Services.
I'm Janet Mann. I'm a financial consultant with DHS and Medicaid.
contacted you this week because I asked you to print a report for me of all the primary care providers that are available for Medicare. Representative Ferguson, that report is being handed out to the members as we speak. Okay, thank you. And I just wanted you to explain the report and sort of comment on the access issue.
Speaker 72
2:03:03
Yes, ma'am. We ran a report for Representative Ferguson to determine whether or not There was an access issue for PCPs in the state. We ran it by county, and we listed every PCP per county, and we also listed at the far end of the report their total amount of their list of patients that they have and then the total amount that they currently carry. I'm a lawyer, so I'm looking at caseloads. So their current caseload versus the total amount that they're allowed.
And somebody mentioned this earlier. Even when you hit your cap, if you want to expand your practice, you can always have an increase beyond what you currently carry, if that's what you'd like to do. And based on this report that we ran, and we ran it Monday, on current data as of Monday, there are not any counties that have a PCP shortage. Now, does that mean if you call your PCP on one day and he says, I'm sorry, I can't see you today? That could happen. But does that mean that he doesn't have a slot for you if you want him to be your PCP?
We don't see that based on the data that we
have in front of us. I'm messing up on the microphone now. Representative
Speaker 72
2:04:16
Love, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Now, what definition are we working with when we say PCP shortage? How are you defining a PCP shortage? We don't show based on what we have in our information. We do not show a PCP shortage. No, no. I said, how do you define it? How do you define, well, she didn't answer my first question, so.
Okay. I'm sorry. How I define it, based on what we have, we looked at whether or not we had PCPs that had full caseloads, meaning they could not take any more people. If a new Medicaid patient came in, there was no room for them to be in that particular county. and we don't have any counties that fail to have vacancies or the ability for a Medicaid person to be enrolled in that county with a PCP. Put me in the bottom of the queue, Mr. Chair, please.
I'm sorry. I got you there. I think what you're
Speaker 72
2:05:23
sorry. Representative Hammer, you're recognized for a question. the message that you're sending the message that you're sending implies to me that we therefore have no medically underserved areas in the state and we've been hearing that for a long time around here in various committee meetings so would you distinguish the difference between what this list says is plenty of PCPs to go around
and why we're still medically underserved a good portion of our state is still medically underserved or do you dispute that? Sure, to say that if there's a slot available and you want one that's one thing but to say that there's enough that's a different thing i mean you know we may need to have more i mean there are areas that that don't have a lot but there are that same county has an opening if you want to see a pcp follow up mr chair you recognize thank you okay so i'm still struggling with connecting the dots
because what i just you tell me if i'm misinterpreting what you're saying you're saying there's plenty of pcps to go around but that that are that there are plenty of pcps in every area of the state but that doesn't necessarily equate to access to care if the pcp says no i'm full we don't want to take any more or for whatever reason which they all may be legitimate i'm not arguing that or insinuating that that there's anything wrong help me understand why why we We can say we have plenty, but yet access to care is still a problem.
What I can tell you is based on this report that we have, it appears that if you want to have a PCP and you're a Medicaid patient, that there is a slot available for you. That's what this report shows. Representative Lundstrom, are you recognized for a question?
I want to tag off of what Representative Hammer said. yes there may be access to pcps but if they cap it because they can't afford to take all those medicaid patients where are those other people going we have a problem with access to care do we
Speaker 72
2:07:23
not in certain counties there there is an underserved there are underserved areas in this state yes ma'am
representative hammer you recognize for another question
Speaker 72
2:07:35
thank you mr chair have you you ever run a list or have you ever gone clinic by clinic, doctor by doctor, and asked or do you have any way to currently determine that a physician has says, no, I'm not going to take any more? I do know that that occurs, that people say, no, I'm not taking any more Medicaid patients.
I know that also occurs with Medicare patients or if you just want to call your physician and you're new to the state, that that also occurs. Follow up, Mr. Chair. Thank you. then my problem is you hand out this list and somebody's probably going to think I'm against doctors. I'm not, but I'm against lack of access to care. That I'm very much against. So if we are given a list like this, but you can't say that 30% of these, as of the printing of this list, are not taking patients,
I don't think it's a fair characterization or representation of the fact because you could have PCPs, but until you know how many are not taking any more, we're sitting here with half information. Am I right or wrong, or feel free to respond? All I can tell you is based on this list, a physician may say, I have room for 1,000 people, and I've only got 77 Medicaid patients. last one representative hammer
i would say this from my observation of the report
not not far against but if you look on the report it's got a different columns and on the far right it says case current caseload that's the patients are actually seeing as pcp and the farthest column is a max caseload set and if you go down through that list you can see the openings that are available in those such counties question to the
Speaker 72
2:09:27
chair yes sir we have no way of concluding if take the top one 420 current caseload maximum caseload 2500 though of determining if that 420 has been
determined by the physician or maybe that's all the people in that service area that need care is that a is that
a fair interpretation represent hammer i'm staying very neutral on all these bills I was just pointing out the point on the handout. Representative Ferguson is recognized
to question. I know how this works, Ms. Harlan, but it might be helpful for the committee to explain about how physicians have a panel in Medicaid,
and they can choose to limit the panel or leave the panel open and not close it until they've reached a limit that they feel comfortable with. So you might talk about limiting the panel and how the panel is established and how these numbers for current caseload and maximum caseload are established. A physician's office,
Speaker 72
2:10:23
I don't know how a physician's office determines how many they want to see, but I know that they let us know that this is how many we will take. It's something that the physician decides on his own. And then based on that, we look at data that says claims payment,
who have we paid for, and who is going to this particular physician. And that's how we know how many people are on Medicaid, and it's based on how
we pay claims. Thank you. Are there any further questions for the Department of Representative Love you
Speaker 72
2:10:58
recognize? Yeah, because it kind of bothers me that we have this information that says we have these amount of max slots, and then the physician can say, well, we can limit it to 20 slots if we want to.
Well, then you're saying that they're underserved in the first place. So I guess I'm a little perplexed and then bothered by DHS saying that we're not medically, well, you did say we're medically underserved. Then you said we have enough physicians, but if there's not enough slots for people that actually need to be seen, then we're just medically underserved and it doesn't, we need more. providers out there I mean that's just the the basis of this of the bill is we
need more providers and for DHS to sit here and argue that we have a thousand max slots say for instance for one doctor but he can limit it to 10 people or 15 people I don't know whether just to be appalled by what you all are doing right now or just to it kind of bothers me I'll be honest Tammy I mean I've been down here for about eight years and for the testimony that you're giving it that's this is really bothersome to me because if we're medically underserved
then we need more providers and so we shouldn't argue if we don't need more providers we do need more providers if the doctors can limit it to 10 or 15 or to see 15 or 20 patients. And I think that it just kind of rubbed me the wrong way. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Thank you, Representative. I hope there was a question in that somewhere. Well,
Speaker 72
2:12:43
I would ask if they agree, but I'm pretty sure that they don't agree, so I asked Representative Hamer, Representative Hamer, when you agree. You did well.
Representative Lundstrom, you're recognized for a question. We
have this chart, and it says what their capacity is and their max capacity, but there's nothing in here, even though a physician may have a maximum capacity, that tells us whether he or she is choosing not to take the maximum capacity. So that kind of doesn't really give us the full breadth of what's going on. I understand, but this is the report I was asked to run,
Speaker 72
2:13:18
and that's what I ran. Okay. Representative Coleman, you're recognized for a question.
Yes. Thank you, and I understand that you ran the report, but there's no way that you have any records of the physicians limiting the Medicare patients coming to them. I looked at one, and they have 1,000 openings. They have 77 patients, but I also know that that physician, if you call up and they're not taking any more Medicare patients because they can't afford to in their practice. So there's no way that you can document in this. So your figures don't actually show what they accept.
Speaker 72
2:14:01
Other than what is in that first column of this is how many people they have, no.
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just as clarification, this is only Medicaid? Yes, sir. Okay, so it doesn't take into account Medicare or just people that don't have Medicare or Medicaid?
claims data. Okay, so if I look at the first county there, Arkansas County,
and I look at the total number of 41,000 slots but only 5,000 taken, and this is only Medicaid, If I divide that by 21 physicians in that county, that's a caseload of 1,960 if they fill their slots. That does not take into account people have insurance, people have Medicare. So I'd like to know, what's the average caseload of a physician? I mean, can they take 6,000?
What's the normal number? 1,900 plus others seems to be a very high number for one physician. And I do not
Committee, I want to point something out from the chair. To my knowledge, DHS has not a position on this bill. They are just presenting information asked from a member, so I want to make that as clear as possible for the committee. Are there any further questions for the department?
Representative Hammer, you're recognized for one quick
Speaker 72
2:15:40
one. This will be the last one. Thank you, Mr. Chair. On the back page, I see that it says there's a total of 1,401,803 caseloads, and the current caseloads are 482,007. So my question is, are there that many people out there that need to be seen, and what's the primary cause for the big discrepancy between the numbers?
because that's almost a million people count difference. And I'm sorry, sir, but based on claims data, I cannot tell you the answer to that. I don't know what the difference is. Thank you. Thank you,
and thank you, Ms. Harlan, for coming today. We have Kurt. I don't know how to even start on that last name.
To speak for the bill, it's a Kirk Kopp.
Godwald, does that sound right? Grindwald? Yeah, maybe. May I? Dr. Grindwald was an orthopedic surgeon from Arkansas Ortho, and he left and he said that he just wanted to be told that he was for the bill. He had a caseload and he couldn't stay
any longer. Okay, we'll skip over him. Mr. David Mitchell presented the bill, but do you want to speak for the bill? as well, or you're signed up to speak for it?
Speaker 332
2:17:11
Oh, I'm signed up to speak for it. I think I've kind of already said what I want
to say. Okay, that'd be good. Okay. Dr. Seth Barnes. You'll be recognized to speak for the bill. If you would, introduce yourself
to the committee and you're recognized to speak. Okay, thank you so much for allowing me to speak. My name is Seth Barnes. I'm going to tell you a little bit about myself based on my mascots. I've been a red bug, a boll weevil, a razorback, and a Commodore. I trained at UAMS from medical school, received my MD there.
I did my residency at Vanderbilt, and I did a chief resident year at Vanderbilt University. And I settled in Batesville in 1999, and I'm a primary care provider. I practice general internal medicine there. And I want to tell you, I want to specifically address the removal of a physician as the primary care provider as in the patient-centered medical home, and I want to do that by telling you how we function in our clinic. We've worked with nurse practitioners for about a decade
in a role where we've vertically integrated our office and our clinic, and we did that in order to provide cost-efficient and timely care to the folks there that we serve. We accept Medicaid patients and because of our relationship, our working relationship with our nurse practitioners, we're able to accept patients almost on an immediate basis for their care and their medical issues.
And we do that through collaboration. We've built a pilot, co-pilot model with the patient welfare and safety being the paramount concern. I have two nurse practitioners that I work with in the clinic, both in the clinic and in the hospital setting. And we're in almost constant communication about patient issues. it's it's you know they'll see things that I don't necessarily recognize I see things certainly that
that they don't recognize and so as a team approach I think we provide much better care for the patients I've learned a bunch of medicine by working alongside nurse practitioners and so I'm certainly not anti-nurse practitioner but there's a there's a distinct difference in our training levels uh before we are allowed to go into practice just if you if you factor up 2080 hours on a 40-hour work week where you can do the math four years of college four years of
medical school and for me four years of residency training that's a ton of hours and training just to get to the point to take care of a patient and so if you compare the two levels of training that's just one component of why a physician should be squarely at the head of a patient-centered medical home and certainly serve as the PCP for Medicaid folks. And, you know, we can kick this around all we want to.
I understand free market and I understand those things, but we're not talking about selling Subway sandwiches. We're talking about taking care of your parents, your children, your friends, your relatives when they show up or when they need medical care, and a lot of times it's in fairly scary or dire situations. And so I think when you look at that, you want the most trained person guiding that care.
Certainly some of that care can be delegated out, but only after thoughtful discussion between the two caretakers. And so I think we really need to put the patient's welfare in the center of all this and who do you want there at the bedside when everything is falling apart. I mean, when the planes and the air and the engines are running, everything's fine. But when you start having trouble, that's when you need the most trained
person there to address the issues. So that's how we do things. It's been a great working model. It allows me to see Medicaid patients and to expand my Medicaid panel. It allows our clinic to do the same. We have six providers in our clinic, and we continue to see Medicaid patients and provide care there, but it's an integrated approach,
and the reason that we've done that is for patient welfare and safety, and I think that's what we need to address. You know, and I've heard the VA mentioned. The VA, we've got to remember, is completely 100% socialized. It's not, I don't think we can compare the VA to what is going on in the private practice or in the other world of medicine. And I'm not sure we want to design systems and features solely based on the VA.
So that's about all I have to say. I was going to try to keep it short. Thursday's little old lady Thursday, and I had to cancel Ms. Williams, and she told
me to keep it short and be nice. we have any questions for Dr. Barnes seeing none thank you doctor for your testimony we'll move along to Mr. David Roden to speak against and guys our room is so full I'm staying strictly with the sign in sheet so if anybody in the audience wants to
speak for or against they need to get with staff and make sure I get their name on the sign in list again I'm David hold on just a second representative Branscom recognize thank you Mr. Chair I'd like to limit the debate 10 minutes to each side that's proper motion non-debatable committee all those in favor say aye all those opposed motion passes Mr. Price will keep time representative Sullivan would you like to reserve 3 minutes
for closing I like your change up Three minutes reserved for Representative Sullivan. Mr. Roten, if you would like to introduce yourself for a committee and you're recognized to carry on. Again, I'm
Speaker 72
2:23:55
David Roten with the Arkansas Medical Society. I just wanted to touch base with you all on a couple of issues that have come up. First,
Speaker 339
2:24:02
the primary purpose of this bill is to allow... Can you get closer to the mic, please, sir?
Speaker 72
2:24:08
The primary purpose of this bill is to allow APR-ians to become PCPs in the Medicaid program. Now, this bill, as well as the other bills, the first thing that you hear brought up is access to care.
We need to expand access to care. You hear it over and over again. Granting increased scope of practice for APRNs does not increase access to care. The APRNs that are in Arkansas today are all working. They have jobs. They're working in clinics. They're working in hospitals. They're CRNAs. They're working in nursing homes. They're working in home health. Some of them are, a lot of them are working in our universities, educating people.
So in this case, allowing advanced practice nurses to become PCPs, the first thing is, is that what we need? If Medicaid needed advanced practice nurses to be PCPs, they would have already done it. The report that you saw a few minutes ago, one mistake that Ms. Harlan made is this report is not based upon claims, the number that you see that says the maximum caseload, when a physician signs up to be a PCP under Medicaid, and again, this is Medicaid, not Medicare,
they say on the front end how many Medicaid patients they are willing to take. That's the maximum caseload. The number of Medicaid patients that have selected those doctors as their PCP is the current caseload. see the difference. This is not their maximum caseload for Medicare or Blue Cross or private pay patients. This is their maximum caseload for Medicaid. The current caseload is their current caseload for Medicaid.
And when you see that someone says, I'll take 1,000 Medicaid patients, but they currently only have 500 more, that means when a new Medicaid patient comes into the program, They are helped to go online and select a PCP. Those PCPs that have not reached their maximum capacity, those patients are able to select that PCP. It happens. It's on the spot. It's done on computer. That physician then becomes their PCP.
Now, the difference between medically underserved and access to care or these numbers in the Medicaid program, Again, these numbers represent Medicaid, nothing else. Medically underserved designation is a federal designation that's been around for over 30 years. It's based on old data and old physician-to-population ratios. It's not always accurate. Yes, we have rural areas that we don't have as many physicians in them as some other states do.
Does that mean patients can't get in to see a physician? That's not the same thing. And in the Medicaid program, and if you ask someone in Medicaid, if you ask the physicians that are in this room that have excess caseload capacity, they will tell you if a Medicaid patient in their county needs to see them, needs to select them as a PCP, and they have space, they will take them. That's why Medicaid is not out here asking for this bill. They're not opposing it, but they're not asking for it, and they've never asked for it in
the past. And that is the main reason. Physicians support Medicaid because Medicaid is a very strong program in this state. We help our primary care physicians. We've created the patient-centered medical home. We're transforming how primary care is delivered, and we use that patient-centered medical home to do it. It requires nurses and doctors to work together in a collaborative arrangement, not a collaborative agreement, but as a team, in a team approach to care. That's what makes the patient-centered medical home work.
That's what we're doing. This bill takes that away.
Representative Hammer, you're recognized for a
Speaker 72
2:28:10
question. Thank you. With your expertise that you just shared, do you know or do you and your organization track how many physicians are turning away Medicaid patients now? No, sir, we do not. It would be good information to know. Follow up. You're recognized.
And do not take this as personal attack, but there is talk in the hallways, and I'd like to give you a public opportunity to respond to it because I think it does deal with access to care and everything we're talking about. But we have been 47th to 49th in the nation for a long time. And if access, which has been championed throughout all committee meetings we've had the last several years, is the banner that everybody flies,
then why is it that you'd want to take the position you do if we've been 47th to 49th for as long as we've been? And I'd like to hear your answer, please. I actually appreciate you asking that question, Representative Hammer. Being 48th, 49th in health is not the same as having access to care. we have somewhere around 1800 advanced practice nurses in this state today they're all out there working the only way to increase more access to care is to bring people in and to train more
physicians to get them out there you can double the number of physicians double the number of advanced practice nurses and it doesn't necessarily move that needle because that needle is not just about access, it's about quality of life, it's about people's eating habits, it's about obesity, it's about a lot of things that have absolutely nothing to do with access. The other issue I think that you have to consider is will doing this accomplish the goal? In states that have completely removed all barriers to advanced practice nurses, they have not gone out into
the rural areas in any greater number than they have in Arkansas, and there's plenty of data to support that. They tend to practice in the same places that physicians practice, for good reason. They need that support, and they want that support. So you can pass this bill, but it's not going to drive advanced practice nurses out into the rural area. It's not going to accomplish the goal that it says it's going to accomplish, and again, states that have done that, that's exactly what they found out. It did not work.
Representative Branscombe, you got a question? Yeah, this is probably to the chair. Has there
been a physical impact done on this
bill? I'm not sure. I have no idea personally. Representative Sullivan, can you answer that? I'll allow that. I would think there would
be, wouldn't there? Would the bill be of this
scope? Yeah, I'm seeing the department at the back. I'm happy to yield. Yeah, if you don't mind, that's an important question.
If you would, introduce yourself again for the record and your recognized
answer question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Janet Mann. I'm a financial consultant with DHS, including Medicaid. In state fiscal year 2016, Medicaid paid APNs approximately $1.9 million, which was total dollars. 30% of that is state general revenue. The rest of it is matched with the federal share. We are neutral on this bill. We anticipated doubling that with the utilization potential. We have no way to estimate if this bill were to pass what the utilization would be with APNs.
We just have historical knowledge. So, Senator Branscombe, you're recognized for a follow-up. Thank you. So what you're saying is if this bill were to pass, then we can be looking at, did you say $1.9 million or $1.3 million? $1.9 million, sir. So all right, almost $2 million, and we're going to double that
right off the bat. No, sir, we just took a stab in the dark because we don't know what utilization would be to estimate if the bill were to pass, how to trend it forward.
But it would be, and you're a follow-up?
I'm going to give you latitude on this one. But it would be a
significant increase in the state budget? Potentially, yes. There would be an increase
in the state budget. Yes, sir. All right, thank you. Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a question. I'm not sure
Speaker 353
2:32:49
to this lady here. Because if we're speaking about access to health care, and we do have more APRNs or even more doctors that come into the state, and more people are able to access health care,
would that not cause an increase in Medicaid that you actually pay out, regardless of whether it's an APN or a doctor? I mean, isn't that what we're
talking about here? Yes, sir. But based upon, I don't know how to answer your question without qualifying it by stating, if more physicians or more APNs come into the state and they choose to be a Medicaid provider, that would be an increase to the state. I have no evidence or knowledge of what that rate would be of X number of physicians or APNs entering the state,
what percentage would choose to be Medicaid, therefore to do an analysis of utilization and cost. So I'm not trying to avoid answering your question. I just don't have a base to begin with.
Speaker 353
2:33:49
Thank you, Representative. Well, I understand that, and so it's very hard to do that. But let's say, for instance, you had an equal amount of doctors and APNs that came into the state, and people chose to use APNs because we passed this bill.
would that not be a savings because APNs would be reimbursed less than doctors when you're comparing the two? Would that be an accurate statement? According to page two of this
bill, I believe the last amendment, the APNs would be reimbursed at 100% of the physician rate. So that's the version I'm... Sir? It's level. Okay, thank you. Representative
Hammer, do you have a question for the department?
the list beyond the other members, please? Yes. Representative Bentley and Peyton, I think your questions were for Mr. Roden. Members, we stopped the clock for this because this is not for or against. So if you have another question, I'm... Okay,
Speaker 72
2:34:56
then I have a question for... Go for it. You're recognized. Thank you. In your financial analysis, can you disseminate between the charges where an APRN charges in a physician's office under their code versus an APRN billing under a physician code to differentiate the difference of the amounts paid out?
There are different codes used for the billing. In the analysis, I looked at all APN's charges for the state fiscal year 2016. I'd have to go back to the analysis, to the details, to answer your question. So the number that you just gave out that we're
Speaker 72
2:35:30
about to make a decision on, is it an accurate number if you cannot answer that question? I'm sorry, Mr. Chair, follow-up, please. You're recognized. Thank you. Please be careful with that. Yes, sir.
Thank you. Sorry. We looked at what we paid APNs, be it billed at a physician rate,
be it billed at a regular APN rate. If they billed and it was attached to an APN, we looked at that. There's approximately, I believe, 2,200 APNs registered with Medicaid that bill. So we looked at the number of APNs that were in the Medicaid program, and then we looked at their charges and paid claims for state fiscal year 2016. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Representative Love, do
you have a question for this witness? I didn't, but
You were hugging that microphone like you did. No,
Speaker 72
2:36:25
I wasn't going to ask her a question. So are you familiar with this report that was just handed out by your agency? Somewhat familiar? I've
seen it. I have not studied it. So I'm not really sure I'm qualified to answer anything on the report. Would you like Ms. Tammy Harlan back to the table? Yeah,
Speaker 72
2:36:42
that would be fine. That would be fine. I'm just.
you recognize for your question thank you mr chair miss harlan i'm just i'm still stuck on this one point and so i'm looking at this report that you all handed out and i'm looking at i guess it's scott county scott county and searcy county this report that you all have yes sir and under scott and are these just the medicaid providers that you have the mb okay under scott county there are two doctors listed under Searcy County there are two doctors
listed and what I guess my question to you is do you think there is an adequate number of physicians to cover an entire county two physicians those are the only medicaid physicians i don't know if there are any other physicians in that county that don't take medicaid okay so i don't know the answer to
that whole question representative love i looked as you were referencing uh scott county does have two physicians searcy county has all those there
where your left thumb is and down i thought it was i thought that said sebastian i understand but if you look all the way through the report it lists the county below in that left hand column for some reason i know for a fact what my counties have and then i look back and it has the same
Speaker 72
2:38:23
reference to it all right well i'm looking this this report isn't doesn't decipher that mr chairman i'm not going to argue with you since you are the chair but i'm just i verified before i told you
but that is true so i guess um it is it still begs the question about the the adequate number of providers that we have in if not Searcy County then Scott County so I guess I'm just asking is that an adequate number of providers for I guess the the rough population there and you know I really don't know because I'm not a physician all I can say is that's how many Medicaid providers
there are I don't know how many other providers there might be that don't take Medicaid that just take Medicare or they just take regular insurance. I don't know. Okay. Or
Okay. Thank you. Representative Gonzalez, you recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Nurse practitioners are reimbursed at 80% of what a physician is paid on Medicaid. So if you're saying that there would be an increased cost to GR by allowing nurse practitioners to
see these patients, then are you not making the case that we have a need for more providers out there? Because we aren't increasing the number of people that are on Medicaid. We're just
allowing them to be seen. Right? The basis of stating that there could be an increase in potential state general revenue is if utilization went up. And if they're currently reimbursed at 80%, I believe this bill says that they would be reimbursed at 100%,
unless I'm looking at the wrong version, so that could be true.
Can I just clarify that? It states that they'll be reimbursed at 100% for x-rays and lab and things like that that are a hard cost, but their actual reimbursement rate for their time is still at 80%. It doesn't change that. Okay. Very well.
Seeing no further questions for the department, I'll have Mr. Roden come back, and we have questions for him.
And with this, I'd remind the committee we start the time back, and he is speaking against the bill. Representative Bentley, you'll be first on my list for a question for Mr. Roden. Mr. Roden, when I look at this
list, I see Perry Cannon. We have one doctor, and she's already seen her max. caseload. So I have folks that work for me that have to travel quite a ways to see a doctor because they don't have a doctor available. So to me, this report does not reflect the population in the community. It doesn't reflect the population at all. It says that those are the doctors that are there, but I see nothing that reflects
population. So could you talk to that? I mean, as far as the population in Arkansas, we know we don't have enough physicians available because I'm working hard to get some more docs out there in Little Arkansas, but I don't see any population listed in here. I just strictly see these are the docs. Those are how many Medicaid patients they're seeing. this time, and they could see, but I see nothing in here about population of the county, so it doesn't do anything here, because I know in Perry County, I have one doctor,
Speaker 72
2:41:40
she can't take any more patients. Well, I think the focus there is that this report is just Medicaid, and this bill is just Medicaid, so
that's what it's looking at, and we also, you know, I grew up in Osceola, and there's a little town a few miles away called Luxora. Luxora's never going to have a physician. It's just not big enough. It's not big enough to support a physician or a nurse practitioner. So how far away do they have to go? I've got family from Perry County. I've got family that, in fact, my family that grew up in Dice, Arkansas, originally are from Houston, not Houston, Texas,
but Houston, Arkansas. And so I'm fairly familiar with over there, and it's not that far to go to a physician. And that's kind of the way it is in most, in a lot of rural areas of Arkansas. Yeah, but the public has to drive a little, non-Medicaid public may have to drive a little ways to get to a health care provider as well. The question is, will passing this bill change that? And, again, in the states that have totally unlimited practice for advanced practice nurses, that has not been the case.
They tend to locate in the same urban areas that physicians do. And it's difficult to open and run a practice in some of these small communities. It's just as difficult for an advanced practice nurse to do it. Now, the fact that advanced practice nurses under the Medicaid program get paid less than physicians, I don't think that's a real good reason to allow them to be PCPs. Might it change costs a little bit? Yeah, but there are also studies that show they order more tests than physicians do.
There's some very good studies out there. There was one that appeared in 2014 that showed that advanced practice nurses order tests 50% more often Not 50% more tests, but 50% more often than primary care physicians. That's utilization. That has a tendency to increase cost. Again, if this would mandate that nurse practitioners went out into the real area, it would be different.
That's the end of the time, Mr. Roden. Thank you. We have Ms. Linda McIntosh speak for the bill.
Thank you very much for giving me this opportunity. When I closed my practice this morning and turned over all my patients and turned them away, I had no idea that I would be testifying before you today. I came because these bills are near and dear to my heart, and some of you talk about the fact that you've been hearing this for six years, eight years, and those type of things. I've been fighting this battle for 11 years. In 2005, I opened a clinic in my hometown, Desarck, Arkansas.
It's in Prairie County, a population of 9,000. My hometown of Desarck was a population of 2,000. I opened a clinic in a collaborative practice with an internal medicine physician and another APRN. And our desire was to go to rural Arkansas and take care of the people that we loved and we cared about. And we opened that practice, and we were able to keep it in business for five years with a struggle every bit of the way, and part of that was because of Medicaid.
26% of my population was Medicaid. 26% of my population was Medicare. There was about 18% that had no insurance, and the rest of it was private insurance. Medicaid at that time did not reimburse me for urinalysis, strep screens, EKGs, chest X-rays, because they said those were physician-only charges. So when I went to the State Insurance Commission and I said, what do I do? I have to have these things to diagnose. He said, you have to go and you have to change the law.
He said, you have to get on the Equal Reimbursement Act. And so I said, okay, tell me what I do. So I went to Arn and I said, what do I do? I want to take care of these patients. And so they said, we have a health policy committee. Let's go before public health and let's see what we can do. And they'd already been fighting the battle to get us recognized as primary care providers on Medicaid. Federal government says we can see the patients, but Arkansas Medicaid says we cannot be PCPs for those patients. So I paid a collaborative practice agreement physician $1,000 a month.
One physician told me he'd be my collaborative practice physician for $30,000 a year. I couldn't do that. So I paid a collaborative practice agreement, I did that, and in Medicaid, the collaborative practice agreement physician actually got the $3 per patient that I saw case management fee. Those fees were not reimbursed back to my practice. So the only thing I got was whatever Medicaid deemed was that they would consider as part of my scope of practice.
We're not here asking you to expand our scope of practice. We're asking you to allow us to practice to the level we've been trained and educated. That's all we're asking for. You know, Mr. Roten said that APRNs would go to the same areas and locate with the same physicians. You're tying our hands. The only way we can go out here and practice is if we have a collaborative practice physician who will do it for us. They don't want to go to rural Arkansas with us.
we have to be licensed and recognized as primary care providers. We provide the care. We're doing it now for the physicians. When you look at those studies and you can't determine who's getting paid for what, half of that is because the physicians are billing for our services and we're doing them for them, but they're getting the money for it, so you can't separate the pie and see what APRNs are doing and what they're getting paid for because it's all tied
in this underbelly of mess. That's all I can tell you is you can't figure out who's doing the work, but I can tell you we want to take care of the patients in Arkansas. And there is an access to care problem. Right now, I had to close my practice. In that time, I told you about the population. In that five-year period, I had a patient base of 6,000 patients. 6,000 out of 9,000 in that county and out of 2,000 in my town.
In five years, I saw 6,000 different patients. Closed the practice in five years, and I went to work for a community health center where I could take care of patients because they don't, we get paid differently in a community health center in that rural health standard says that there has to be an APRN in every rural health center in Arkansas. and then they bill it under one code, whether the doctor sees them or the nurse practitioner sees them, they bill it under the same code.
So you can't tell what we're doing in the rural health centers either. I thank you very much for your time and for allowing me to share
my story. Are there any questions for the witness? Seeing none, thank you for your testimony. We have approximately two minutes left, and I have Ms. Angela Jones to speak for the bill. What?
Speaker 208
2:49:18
I don't think I can top hers. I wanted to – Oh, that's with history. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. No. Now, I wanted to kind of elaborate on the patient-centered homes because that's what I've been doing in Jonesboro with the Baptist system. And I see a lot of Medicaid patients in Jonesboro, even though I have moved out of the more rural area. And I was seeing quite a bit in Lake City and Truman and Paragould,
but I found that even though I've gone to Jonesboro, it really hasn't decreased the number. What I've experienced is that the doctors do cap off the number of Medicaid patients they want to see. There's not enough money in it, and times of the essence, and they're being paid on production, and they want to see the patients that they're going to get to bill the most money for. And, you know, we have to make a living. We all do.
And in our system at Baptist, nurse practitioners get paid a base salary. You've got one minute left. We get a little bit of production over that. So it's easier for us to see the Medicaid patients. So it makes sense to let us see the Medicaid patients for them. So we
get stuck seeing all the Medicaid patients. But when
Speaker 208
2:50:44
we do, we bill direct. So we bill at the 80%. So that naturally saves Medicaid money.
Do you have any questions? Seeing none, thank you for your testimony. Having 20 seconds left, I'm going to go ahead and recognize Representative Sullivan to close for his bill. You have three minutes and 20 seconds. Yeah, you got a question? I'll spend 20 seconds, thank you. Hold on one second, we do have one question for Representative Payton. and I'm going to
let him ask you my question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I've had this question on my mind for some time, didn't know who to ask it of, so hopefully you can answer it.
I thought I knew something about this bill until you all started talking an hour ago, but I mean I thought it dealt with scope of practice. A lot of what I'm hearing is it deals with scope of billing or reimbursement. I'm trying to identify, does this change any of the authority in the realm of where they practice medicine, or is it
Speaker 127
2:51:49
all about billing? Well, it's somewhat about billing. It's more about access to care, whether people can set up independent clinics.
Folks try to say it's a rule bill. It's not a rule bill. This is a bill about people opening up a clinic where they can provide PCP, primary care provider services, as listed in the Medicaid manual. So there's an amendment on the bill that keeps the billing level. So if you provide services outside this PCP area, there is an 80% lower billing rate, and it's been a little confusing, I'm sure, listening to this.
But this bill, it stays level in that PCP billing rate. They'll be billed at the same rate. So there's no savings. There's no loss. There's no
difference. So there's no broadening of what the... Is there a broadening of what they are actually allowed to do? No. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You're recognized. Go ahead.
Speaker 127
2:52:55
Thank you, Mr. Chair. First of all, committee, I appreciate it.
This has been, let's push them into rules. Let's say this is a real bill. It's not a real bill. This is an access to care, and, you know, you have heard that there's no problem. you've been told several times there's no problem it's hard for me to believe that from what I see and what I know if you don't pass this bill you said that we have plenty of people and they all have jobs well folks we need more people coming into the state to provide jobs so why do we limit folks
and not incentivize them to come in this would incentivize people to come into the state and provide jobs I was going to talk about the utilization again it's level funding we talked about let's see well I'll end it at that you know we you've heard passionate discussion on both sides this is a difficult issue and I appreciate our medical
community I appreciate on the doctors and the APNs and all. It's been a great discussion. I appreciate the questions. But folks, you've come in here and you've heard there's no problem. Yet we remain medically underserved. And if we don't do something to change that, if we continue down this path, we'll continue. I lost my map. I don't know if you can see that, but 11 states do not recognize PCPs for Medicaid.
And there's a reference on here. I'll give it to you. 11 states. We are at the bottom at every level, yet we're being convinced that we don't need to change. There is no problem. As far as Medicaid asking, can we change this, folks, look around the room. The lobbying efforts from the group that oppose this are tremendous. Every one of you have been lobbied numerous times by the medical groups, the medical society, and you wonder why our state Medicaid doesn't want to take this problem on doesn't want to allow it it's because it's lobby just like this that's
just a fact mr. chair i appreciate the opportunity and i'm closed that's
the end of the time anyway you did that perfect oh it's a pleasure to committee i've got a motion due passed by representative miller any discussion on the motion representative pilketon you're recognized for discussion. Thank you,
Speaker 72
2:55:34
Mr. Speaker. No one really brought this up, but I think it's an important thing to think about when we vote on this bill. What about the hospitals, rural hospitals? Oftentimes
we have a system of approach in which we utilize clinics, and recruiting PCPs to rural parts of Arkansas is a Herculean task, and it's very hard. And I think that by passing this bill, it will allow some freedom in our ability to recruit APRNs to rural areas. Oftentimes to run clinics, the biggest expense we have are doctors' salaries. They're expensive. If you want to run a good clinic, like a four-man clinic, you can't run with four
doctors in a rural area and try to make money. You can. You can use one and three mid-levels and that's going to be the most profitable model. So if we really do and expand health care and we want to help our rural hospitals, I
think this is a good bill. That's it. Thank you, Representative Pilken and Representative McGee. You have a discussion. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. A couple of things, committee members. When you begin, two things.
One is when you begin to think about allowing somebody to be a primary care provider, what you're doing by passing this is you're making APRNs family practice doctors. That's what you're doing. And you're giving the State Board of Nursing the authority in line 20 to 22, the authority to conclusively interpret what their scope and licensure of the advanced practice nurse is. So to say that they won't be, I mean, they can do anything.
With this, the Board of Nursing could say, primary care doctors do colonoscopies. They could come back and say, you can do that. And they tried to do that a few years ago to Medicaid. So, I mean, there has to be, you know, we've talked about a lot of these bills. It all comes down to education. It comes down to who is going to deliver the care in the safest, most efficient manner. The patient-centered medical home that's a vertically integrated program with the doctor as the head of that medical care team delivers the safest, most effective care to patients.
And that doesn't mean that APRNs aren't an essential part of the medical care team. They are. But you have to have somebody who's the head of the team. Guys, you can say all you want to say about training, but when you're an APRN, when you can go to school online after an RN degree and in two years get a master's and never examine a patient, that causes me a lot of calls for pause when you're talking about taking care of a patient.
I'll just show you something personal. I have two instances personally. Everybody talks about there's never a problem. I've never heard of an issue. I've never had a problem. I've had two personal problems with APRNs in the last six months in my family. One made the wrong diagnosis. One made the wrong diagnosis, prescribed the wrong medication to one of my family members. that could have killed my family member. True story. Second one, they couldn't even make the diagnosis. So I have a real problem with making them the head of a primary care medical home,
and I just ask you to vote no
for this bill. Thank you. Thank you, Representative McGee.
Representative Ferguson, you're recognized for discussion. Yeah, and I just have a comment. This does expand the scope of practice. It allows them to go out without a collaborative agreement. And to Representative Pilkington's comment, I want him to hear me. To Representative Pilkington's comment, there's nothing that prevents APRNs being out in a collaborative agreement doing what you're talking about now to help hospitals.
I mean, they can still do that, and they bill at the 80% when they're not under the direct supervision of a physician. So what you're talking about and allowing to do, they can do that now without this bill.
Thank you. Any further discussion? Seeing none, all those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? No. I'll rule the ayes have
Speaker 127
2:59:56
it. We got a roll call. Mr. Price, if you would, we'll just call the roll.
Speaker 241
3:00:05
Representative Love. Representative Hammer. Representative Branscombe. Representative Meeks. Representative Ritchie. Representative Ritchie. Representative McGee. Representative Miller. Representative Walnut. Representative Payton.
Speaker 386
3:00:36
Representative Leidyman Representative Lundstrom Representative Bentley Representative Representative Gonzales,
Speaker 241
3:01:02
Representative Boyd, Representative Henderson, Representative
Representative McCollum, Representative Coleman, Representative Pilkington,
have ten yeses and nine no's your bill has failed thank you thank you mr. chair thank you bill has to have 11 yeses to
pass representative hammer are you can you run your bill in 30 minutes all right let's go with it which one you want to run first house bill 1228 let's go for it
Absolutely. Let's keep the order and respect for the guy presenting this bill.
Speaker 72
3:02:40
Thank you, Mr. Chair. With regards to House Bill 1228, I think we've had a lot of the discussion, but I want to just highlight a couple of things. I'd like to ask Linda Mack to make a few comments, if you would, please. First of all, over the last two years, I have sat on the health care task force,
and one of the issues that we've heard mentioned throughout that discussion are all the things that you heard today, probably some of which are going to come back based on the previous votes on the other bills. But the one thing that I found interesting, and I debated whether to run this bill at all on this session until I heard a comment one day in the Health Task Force, and that was that there continues to be and is an increasing problem with regards to prescriptions and opiate and the Schedule II.
And I guess the light that came on to me, and this is not a derogatory remark made towards the physicians, but in that comment that was made, it dawned on me that for the last year and a half, the APRNs have not been the ones at the table writing the scripts. And there was a comment made, or I think there was a percentage that was given out, not in the health care task force meeting, but a side note, that of the top 400 prescribers, that only 3% of those were APRNs.
And so based on those two pieces of information, you know, I decided to go ahead and try to run this because I do think that there are some disadvantages that occur out in the field whenever it is that an APRN has been limited from being able to have this opportunity and this privilege. What I'd like to do right now at this moment is just allow Linda Mack to talk a few things that I think would help to give some insight with the
chair's permission. Yeah, introduce yourself, please. Yes, my name is Linda McIntosh, and I'm an APRN,
and I've worked in two different settings, one in the rural area in DesArc, Arkansas, with a private clinic, and then I now work for ArcCare, which is a community health center, and they have 30 clinics throughout Arkansas. And they are a federally funded FQHC Real Health Center, and because of that, the real health guidelines say that there has to be an advanced practice nurse
in every one of those clinics, but there does not have to be an MD in those clinics. So the majority of our 30 clinics have and are staffed fully by APRNs on a daily basis every day. One of the issues that we run into is the problem with our children with ADHD. Because of the high population of children who have been diagnosed with ADHD and autism and the different issues, as advanced practice nurses, we are taught that we are to refer
them out for a diagnostic review, one of the things that, for a complete diagnostic workup, And one of the places that we do that is Dennis Development Center at Arkansas Children's Hospital. But the waiting list for that child to get there is over six months. And so what we see is that we have teachers who are writing us letters who describe the patient's behavior in the classroom. And it's total behavior of unruliness and they can't get him to sit still and those type things.
The problem with it is that all of the medications that an advanced practice nurse can write for an ADHD child is not covered under our kids or Medicaid. Medicaid does not cover the N2 nerves, does not cover the stratera, and the things that are not controlled substances. The only medication that Medicare covers for these children, and the majority of our children in Arkansas, are covered by our kids, A or B, and Medicaid. And so we have no alternative treatment for these children.
And so often they will fail a grade awaiting an appointment to have a definitive diagnosis. But there is something that you can do, and that is that we're taught and we're educated and we're trained as advanced practice nurses in our curriculum, in our pharmacology and those type things. We're trained at the level to administer Schedule 2s. It's in Arkansas that we do not have that advantage, but we are board certified and board tested during our testing as family practice and as pediatric nurse practitioners and as psych nurse practitioners
to actually prescribe those medications. But we can't do that because we're not authorized to do that in the state of Arkansas. So we could temporarily give them, and we're taught to do low dose, go slow, and to monitor the child and to work with the counselors and the teachers at the school. But for that six-month period or that year period, while they're awaiting definitive testing, they often fail. And that's one of the areas that we could assist with this. One of the other areas, we've heard a lot of talk today about Schedule 2s and the opioid and the narcotic problem
and the abuse problem in the state of Arkansas. I want to run down what happens in my clinic when I have a patient who comes to me who's seeking refills for their pain-controlled medications and those type things. Number one, every patient that walks through that door gets monitored by the Arkansas Prescription Monitoring Program. It's called the APMP. That is drawn on every patient. If they're wanting a refill of their narcotics or their Schedule II medications, whether it's Xanax or whether it is a hydrocodone, whatever it may be, they have to do a urine
drug screen. That urine drug screen is done in the office initially, and if it's abnormal, if the medication that they were prescribed does not show up there, or if something that was not prescribed does show up there, then they have to resend it out for confirmation. And if there's anything there that we haven't prescribed, and if the APMP doesn't coincide with what the patient tells us, they are sent a termination letter that we will no longer prescribe controlled substances for them,
and we will still see them for their chronic illnesses, such as their diabetes and those type of things, but we will not prescribe their controlled substances. If we sign, we do not do long-term pain management in any of our clinics. The only thing that we do is treat acute pain until we can get them to the pain specialist and that they can have the full workup and be followed by a pain specialist. But you run into one other problem, and that is that the majority of our patients are Medicaid. They're only allowed 12 visits a year. If you take a chronic illness patient who has diabetes and hypertension and cardiac problems
and he has a chronic back injury, he's going to choose to go to his pain specialist every month and get his pain medicines and do without the other life-saving things that he could have. So there's several different issues, but we do do everything within our power to make sure that the patients, if they are drug-seeking, we have another option for them, and that is that we have a drug substance abuse program in our care to where we have two clinics in Arkansas with physicians who run a Suboxone clinic.
And we also offer them different types of rehab services. One of the things that I offer out of my clinic is called Kelly's Second Choice, and it's a place that has a book that shows every rehab in the state of Arkansas. There are places that we can send them totally free where it doesn't cost them a dime. There's all different kinds of options that we can set and discuss with them. You do have a problem, we can help you get off the narcotics and off the drugs. drugs. So there are a lot of issues that nurse practitioners do on a daily basis and you've
already heard the statistics where 60% of the APRNs in Arkansas are signed up on the APRN and they have the APMP and they are running those every day. I think that's it. Thank
you. Any questions from the committee for the sponsor? Representative Branscombe. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You've been here way too
long. Asking you a question, Hammer, there's something else. What's the big difference in this bill than the one we just defeated, 1181?
Representative Branscombe, I wouldn't let others compare bills, so we're not going to do that on this one either. All right, I'll rephrase the question. Okay. In your opinion, is there any
difference in this than any? Representative Branscombe, after three and a half hours, let's stick to
the rules. Well, I looked at it, and I couldn't tell the difference, but I knew you would
have an answer for me. Well, let's keep your opinion. All right. I don't mind answering the question, Mr.
Chair. No, we don't need to do that. Okay, thank you. Representative Ferguson, you're recognized for a question.
Yes, and I have a real issue with all of this Adderall and all of these ADHD and ADD drugs, and I share your concern about the dentist center. I mean, I've heard about the backup and all that too, but I don't think the answer is to allow APNs to give these Schedule II drugs because those drugs should not be given without a complete assessment, And I have story after story from physicians who teachers refer to them,
and they say the child has ADHD or whatever. When they're fully assessed by a psychologist, it turns out it's a verbal auditory problem. It's not ADHD at all, and they certainly don't need drugs. So for you to say you think you should be able to prescribe these drugs in the interim before they're being assessed, do you not think that's totally irresponsible? No, ma'am, I don't think it's totally irresponsible because we have been trained to identify those students.
And like I said, we always start at a very, very low dose, and it's a temporary thing. We would not do it long term. We would only do it until that child could be fully assessed. And you monitor those children. You bring them in every month. I'm amazed at how many children, if we could give them the drugs that, we have no options of giving them the drugs. But to be honest with you, I start with discipline. I tell the parents that it needs consistent discipline because a lot of the issues and the behaviorist issues,
we talk about coping mechanisms and we talk about alternative interventions besides medicines. That's one of the things that nurse practitioners, we spend a lot of time on family dynamics and how we can assist them with, we do holistic things, essential oils and different things. We give the patients other options besides that, but right now, when you have a hardcore child that is disruptive to the entire classroom and that is failing, they need something, and those teachers need a little bit of help to get those children to where they can pass.
May I have a follow-up? Yes, ma'am. Well, I mean, my contention is rather than giving drugs irresponsibly, I agree with the holistic things you can already do in behavioral management, But rather than just giving drugs without a complete psychological assessment, maybe we need to see about expanding our psychological assessment accessibility. I think there was a question in that. Representative Bentley, you're recognized for a question. Representative
Hammer, does this have anything to do with a collaborative agreement with a physician?
No. I was trying to help Representative Brandt
come out a little bit with that question. Thank you. That's a better way to rephrase it, Representative Brasco. Seeing no further questions, we'll move to the people signed to speak for and against. And please, everybody, be mindful that we have to be back upstairs at exactly 1.30. You ready?
I'll take that at 2. Two minutes. Okay. Let me debate. We have a motion on the floor to limit debate. Two minutes on either side. That motion is not debatable. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed. Ayes have it. Motion passed. Representative Hammer will give you the courtesy. Do you want the whole two or one? I'd
Speaker 72
3:15:09
like to have the advantage of knowing if anybody's signed up to speak for it or against
it. There is one signed up to speak against, and the lady that signed up to speak for it has already spoken with you.
So I would say no one on your side. Well, thank you for that. I'm sorry for the way that sounded. I'm just a country boy, all right? You ask the question, I'll give you the answer. I know. I'll hold the two minutes for myself, please. All right. Mr. Roden, you recognize to speak against the bill. If you would, introduce yourself again for the
Speaker 72
3:15:40
committee, please. Again, members of the committee, I'm David Roten with the Arkansas Medical Society. And first, let me apologize. You've seen enough of me this morning. These are some of the most difficult decisions that you folks are ever asked to make,
and trust me, we appreciate what you do and how you do it. Whether you vote the same way we want you to or not, it doesn't matter. You guys are here to represent the people of the state, and we appreciate it. As far as this bill, it's the same as the other one as far as we're concerned. We don't need to allow another 15 to 18 to 2,000 people in this state to start writing Schedule II narcotics, and that's what this bill does, pure and simple. We love our APRNs, contrary to what they may think right now, but they're not physicians.
These are difficult things. Regarding the PDMP, the Prescription Drug Monitoring Program, some people here may not know that Blue Cross, Blue Shield, and Medicaid have both mandated that all prescribers, including physicians, must register with the PDMP. I think Blue Cross' deadline is somewhere around April. Most physicians, so it's not 30% anymore. Remember, the PDMP is new. You only passed it in 2011.
It's still, unless you fully fund it in this session, it's still a grant-funded program. So a lot of people have kind of been waiting around to see if it was going to last. So the PDMP is working well. There's a lot of things that need to be done to it. we actually have a bill that's been introduced that will mandate that physicians and others check the PDMP on a particular basis set by the boards. Thank you,
sir. Thank you. We have 20 seconds. Is there anybody have a question for the witness?
20 seconds. Seeing none, Representative Hammer, you're recognized to close for your bill. Thank you,
Speaker 72
3:17:34
Mr. Chair. A couple points I'd like to make. I'm glad to hear that there'll be no opposition to the bill that I helped introduce as far as the PDMP because it was just stressed how important that is. So then you've got to go back and ask yourself this question. Over the last two years, why has it not been participated in more than what it has been participated in? And then you've got to go to the next question after that.
Then you've got to take out of the discussion those that have been claimed historically for being the problem, and they haven't been at the table for the last two years so to blame them moving forward and live under the pretense of fear which an acronym for is false evidence appearing real you've got to ask yourself the question as long as the citizens of Arkansas which have been stated a minute ago if we're doing this for the citizens of Arkansas I tell you what some of my citizens have said and that is why do I have to get us why do I have to drive distances to to get a
a script in order to get it filled we've seen a lot of discussion on this matter but if the problem continues to go up the way it is if nothing else out of this bill I'm going to be glad to know that nobody is going to sit at the table to speak against the PDMP because if they do and this bill gets killed there's a level of hypocrisy that exists in the system that needs to be exposed. With that, I would ask for a good vote. Thank you, Representative Hammer. And motion do
pass, Mr. Chair. I appreciate that motion. With that motion, do we have any
discussion from the committee? See you, none. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed? No. Ayes have it. All right, I got two hands on a roll call. So,
Speaker 386
3:19:38
Representative Love, Representative Hammer, Representative Branscombe, Representative Meeks, Representative Richey, Representative Ritchie, Representative McGee,
Representative Miller Representative Wama Representative Payton Representative Ladyman Representative Lundstrom Representative Bentley Representative Gonzalez Representative Boyd Representative Henderson Representative McCollum Representative Coleman
Representative Pilkington Vice Chair Ferguson Chair Ward With ten yeses and
eight no's, the bill has failed. Seeing no further time, we will reserve the right to come back after session, so all witnesses that are pertaining to other bills on scope practice, we should come back after session upon adjournment.
Agenda
Scope of Practice Bills Will be Considered in Committee During the Week of February 13, 2017 - February 17, 2017
Number Subtitle Sponsor
HB1215 Love TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING THE PRACTICE OF MASSAGE THERAPY TO INCLUDE THE PRACTICE OF CUPPING.
HB1250 M. Gray TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS DENTAL PRACTICE ACT; TO AMEND THE DENTAL HYGIENIST COLLABORATIVE CARE PROGRAM; TO MODIFY THE APPOINTMENTS TO THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF DENTAL EXAMINERS; AND TO MODIFY DENTISTRY SPECIALTY LICENSES.
HB1255 Ferguson TO CREATE A TEMPORARY CHARITABLE DENTAL LICENSE; AND TO DECLARE AN D. EMERGENCY.
HB1257 Richey TO CREATE THE COMMUNITY HEALTH WORKER ACT.
HB1205 Magie TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS ANESTHESIOLOGIST ASSISTANT ACT.
HB1181 Sullivan TO CREATE THE TRANSITION TO PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY ACT; AND TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY OF ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES.
HB1182 Sullivan TO AUTHORIZE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO ALLOW AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE TO BE A PRIMARY CARE PROVIDER.
HB1186 Brown TO REMOVE THE COLLABORATIVE PRACTICE AGREEMENT AS APPLICABLE TO ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES; AND TO CLARIFY THE PROCESS NECESSARY FOR AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE.
HB1228 Hammer TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY OF AN ADVANCED PRACTICE NURSE.
HB1237 Hammer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS SURGICAL TECHNOLOGISTS ACT; AND TO ESTABLISH THE REGISTRATION OF SURGICAL TECHNOLOGISTS.
HB1254 Magie TO TRANSFER REGULATORY AUTHORITY OVER ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES FROM THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF NURSING TO THE ARKANSAS STATE MEDICAL BOARD.
HB1204 Magie TO ALLOW PHARMACISTS TO MAKE BIOLOGICAL PRODUCT SUBSTITUTIONS.
These bills will be returned to the Regular Agenda after presentations on the "Scope of Practice Bills" are made
Number Subtitle Sponsor
HB1439 M. Gray TO AMEND THE HEALTHCARE QUALITY AND PAYMENT POLICY ADVISORY COMMITTEE.
HB1300 Miller TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES TO PRIORITIZE SPENDING WITH THE DEPARTMENT AND THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO FULLY FUND HOME- AND COMMUNITY-BASED SERVICES FOR INDIVIDUALS WITH DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES
HB1462 McCollum TO AFFIRM THE LEGISLATIVE AUTHORITY OVER WAIVERS FOR THE SUPPLEMENTAL NUTRITION ASSISTANCE PROGRAM; AND TO PROMOTE ECONOMIC ADVANCEMENT FOR ARKANSANS.
HB1465 Miller DECLARE TO CREATE THE MEDICAID EXPANSION ENROLLMENT FREEZE ACT OF 2017; AND TO AN EMERGENCY.
HB1501 McCollum TO MODIFY AND REPEAL LANGUAGE REFERENCING THE SUPERSEDED ELDERCHOICES PROGRAM.
HB1502 S. Meeks TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION TO THE DEFINITION OF RESIDENTIAL CARE FACILITY AND THE DEFINITION OF ASSISTED LIVING FACILITY.
HB1504 Hammer TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTION DRUG MONITORING PROGRAM TO MANDATE PRESCRIBERS CHECK THE PRESCRIPTION DRUG MONITORING PROGRAM WHEN PRESCRIBING CERTAIN MEDICATIONS.
HB1505 Davis TO CLARIFY THE DEFINITION OF AN NAAQS STATE IMPLEMENTATION PLAN AND THE REQUIREMENT FOR WRITTEN EXPLANATIONS IN SUPPORT OF NAAQS IMPLEMENTATION PLANS.
HB1511 Wardlaw TO CLARIFY THE TIME FOR ISSUANCE OF PERMITS UNDER THE ARKANSAS WATER AND AIR POLLUTION CONTROL ACT.
HB1513 Holcomb TO AMEND THE ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENTS FOR THE ASBESTOS ABATEMENT GRANT PROGRAM.
HB1515 Ladyman TO PROVIDE LOCAL CONTROL OVER FLUORIDE LEVELS IN WATER SYSTEMS THAT SERVE FIVE THOUSAND (5,000) USERS OR FEWER.
HB1525 Magie AN ACT TO REQUIRE THE ARKANSAS STATE MEDICAL BOARD AND THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF NURSING TO DEVELOP A JOINT APPLICATION FOR COLLABORATIVE AGREEMENTS BETWEEN COLLABORATING PHYSICIANS AND ADVANCED PRACTICE NURSES.
HB1526 M. Gray TO MODIFY ACT 143 OF 2017 TO SPECIFY THAT A CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECK SHALL INCLUDE THE TAKING OF FINGERPRINTS; TO AUTHORIZE LICENSURE BY ENDORSEMENT FOR OPTOMETRISTS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1545 Sullivan TO ALLOW THE DIVISION OF CHILD CARE AND EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION OF THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES TO INDEPENDENTLY PROMULGATE RULES CONCERNING CHILD CARE FACILITIES.
SB123 B. Johnson TO UPDATE THE DRUG SCREENING AND TESTING ACT OF 2015; AND TO MAKE THE TWO-YEAR PILOT PROGRAM A PERMANENT PROGRAM.
SB78 Bledsoe TO REQUIRE THE ARKANSAS STATE MEDICAL BOARD TO PERFORM AN ANALYSIS OF THE INTERSTATE MEDICAL LICENSURE COMPACT TO DETERMINE WHETHER THE STATE OF ARKANSAS SHOULD PARTICIPATE IN THE INTERSTATE MEDICAL LICENSURE COMPACT.
HB1550 Davis TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING NONMUNICIPAL DOMESTIC SEWAGE TREATMENT WORKS AND THE NONMUNICIPAL DOMESTIC SEWAGE TREATMENT WORKS TRUST FUND.
HB1551 Womack TO STIMULATE JOB CREATION AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT WHILE PRESERVING HEALTH AND SAFETY STANDARDS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1560 Gazaway TO AMEND LAWS REGARDING THE PRACTICE OF PHARMACY AND THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF PHARMACY.
DEFERRED
Number Subtitle Sponsor
HB1021 Love TO PROVIDE PAY EQUITY FOR WOMEN; AND TO AMEND THE WAGE DISCRIMINATION LAWS CONCERNING PROHIBITED CONDUCT AND REMEDIES FOR VIOLATIONS OF THE WAGE DISCRIMINATION LAWS.
HB1160 A. Mayberry TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF A "SPECIALIST SIGN ELECTRICIAN".
HB1040 Farrer TO LIMIT THE PRACTICE OF ATHLETIC TRAINING IN A NONCLINICAL SETTING.
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Speaker 1
Representative Jeff Wardlaw Chair
Unverified
Speaker 8
Speaker 14
Representative Dwight Tosh
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson
Unverified
Speaker 72
Ann Cousins
Unverified
Representative David L. Branscum Chair
Unverified
Representative Robin Lundstrum
Unverified
Representative Jack Ladyman
Unverified
Brian Mears
Unverified
Speaker 127
Representative Justin Gonzales
Unverified
Representative Josh Miller
Unverified
Speaker 146
Speaker 168
Representative Ken Henderson
Unverified
Evan Branscombe
Unverified
Representative Bruce Coleman
Unverified
Speaker 208
Speaker 192
Speaker 241
Speaker 251
Speaker 255
Speaker 272
Speaker 273
Speaker 40
Speaker 99
Speaker 96
Speaker 332
Seth Barnes
Unverified
Speaker 339
Representative Stephen Meeks
Unverified
Speaker 353
Speaker 358
Representative Mary Bentley
Unverified
Speaker 386