Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

State Agencies & Governmental Affairs

February 22, 2017 ·Committee Room 149 ·1:49:49
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (8)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HJR1003 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HJR1003 Gillam AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS THE CONSTITUTION CONCER…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1258 · 2 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…curring in the Senate amendments. And so we have two bills, HB 1258 and HB 1279. And does anyone actually come here with the pu…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1279 · 2 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…he Senate amendments. And so we have two bills, HB 1258 and HB 1279. And does anyone actually come here with the purpose of run…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1008 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1008 Dotson AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION TO PROVIDE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1011 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1011 Drown AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNING…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1016 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1016 Lundstrum AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERN…”
Pre-2017 bill
SJR1008 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Thank you, Mr. Chair. SJR 1008 is a relatively simple, straightforward amendment that can…”
Pre-2017 bill
SJR8 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SJR8 Irvin A CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT LIMITING CONTINGENCY FEES…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
Speaker 1 0:00
All right, Chair sees a quorum. Okay, we'll start off with just letting folks know, just so that they can be
▶ Play
relieved or disappointed in one way or another. But we are not here in SJR 8 this morning. We're going to be dealing with the House Resolution for Constitutional Amendment. We're going to get those done first before we deal with the Senate's resolution. So it is on the agenda and the calendar because it came over from the Senate yesterday and was assigned to this committee. But we're not going to hear it today. So if that's what you're here for, then, you know, feel free to hang around and watch because, you know, we're such wonderful people and a lot of fun. That would be entertaining. But at the same time, it's not going to come up today. For the committee members, there are some pins that you guys have that are for the state agency's committee. And, you know, those are your pins to do with what you want. I figure you can either have extras or you can give them away if you want. but I figure every team needs a jersey, so that's what that's for. So, yeah, anyway, so, yeah, you can, yeah, Representative
▶ Play
Douglas, you're recognized. Yes, just on behalf of the committee, I assume, I just thank you probably personally for getting these for us, and I think it's a great idea. I
▶ Play
Speaker 6 1:47
wear it with, sometimes, depends on the bill that we're running. Yeah, I was about to say, with SJRA out there, It
▶ Play
may be better not to identify yourself as a committee member. That's right. But thank you, Mr. Chair. All right. Well, that's my privilege and I appreciate you guys. Okay. So we are going to take up the House resolutions for constitutional amendments, the ones that were referred out from the subcommittee today. And so those are going to be the resolutions that we're dealing with. If you're here to speak for or against any of the four House resolutions, then please get signed up. We're going to run these. Basically, like we'd run a any other any other bill. So we'll have people come present them for and against and People can speak for and against and you know, basically run them like we would a normal normal bill However, in the end, we're not going to vote on them until after we've heard all the all the separate resolutions I am I'm running representative Gilliam's resolution. That's as This HJR 1003, that one is that we actually have another amendment that's coming. So it's not really ready to run. I have visited with some of the folks in the Senate, and I feel like that has a pretty good shot of being the third constitutional amendment. And that's, of course, you know, depends on the will of the committee as much as a lot of other things. But we're going to hold out and hope that that will be the third resolution. And so we're not actually running that today for consideration. So we'll have three, which is HJR 1008, HJR 1011, and HJR 1016. We're going to run those in the order that they were filed in. So we'll start with HJR 1008. And does anyone have any questions about the process? Oh, yes. And I'm sorry. I appreciate that, Ms. Sherry. First thing we actually want to get done is concurring in the Senate amendments. And so we have two bills, HB 1258 and HB 1279. And does anyone actually come here with the purpose of running those? All right. If not, then without objection from the committee, I'll run those, the concurring amendments from the floor, or from the chair, if that's okay, so I don't have to walk all the way to the end of the table. So House Bill 1258, we're concurring in Senate amendments. My presentation for it is essentially it's the Speaker's bill, and he's agreed to these amendments. It's his bill, his amendment. Is there any motion from the committee? We've got a motion to do pass from Representative Dodson. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? Okay, the ayes have it. So HB 1279, same thing, it's the Speaker's bill and his amendments, concurring in the Senate Amendments. Okay, it's Senate Amendment 1, is there a, what's the pleasure of the committee? Okay, we have a motion from Representative Gonzales, do pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Aye. occurred both in both of these bills or amendments to the bills. All right. Now are there any questions about the process today of how we're going to handle the resolutions? We're going to hear and run any of them that want to be ran. So as I've said, you know, HDR 1003, while I think it's a great amendment, I'd love for it to be the constitutional amendment that's the third amendment. We're actually working on doing a couple of amendments, one of them Representative Dotson suggests and some other things. So we're going to try to get all that done and cleaned up, and there's a couple of Senators have some ideas. So we're going to try to make sure that everybody is in agreement on it before we actually run it. So we're not running HJR 1003 today. So the next one would be your amendment, Representative Dotson. So as far as the presentation goes, it's completely up to you how you want to handle presentation on your resolution. Are we taking motions on them, or are we hearing them all first? We'll hear all three of them, the ones that we're going to hear today. We'll hear all three of them, and then at the end of the three, then we'll take a motion. On what goes out of this committee? On what goes out of this committee, yep. As the amendment. As the amendment for the House Amendment. Representative Douglas, do
▶ Play
Speaker 15 6:26
you have a question about that, or? I think I see the ones that, I thought there were, how many were there, we'll probably
▶ Play
next question this. Okay. How many were there that came
▶ Play
out of the committee yesterday? There were four that were referred from the committee yesterday. Those four are on the agenda as the regular agenda. Right. I see those. HJR 8 is on there, too. However, like I said, we're
▶ Play
not running that today. Okay. But we're not ready to hear. I'd like to hear what is in Gillum's
▶ Play
bill because I have not heard that yet. Okay. We ran that. I missed that one day. And when we get to the point where that's ready to run, I'll go ahead and run it just like we would any other resolution. I'd be happy to go over what's in it. But how can we vote? Are we? You're not voting on that one today. I have just said that we're not running that in consideration as the House's resolution that's coming out today. So, you know, if you want me to explain the resolution, I've lived with it, so I'm happy to do it. So we're making a vote between the other three.
▶ Play
That's correct. Okay. The other three are the options
▶ Play
that will be referred out today, one of those other three. Gotcha. Thank you. All right. Representative Womack, you have a question? Okay. All right, so seeing no other questions on the process, Representative Dotson, you are recognized to run HJR 1008.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. SJR 1008 is a relatively simple, straightforward amendment that can largely be summed up in the subtitle of the bill that provides that the State Highway Commission shall be governed in the same manner as all other state agencies. What this basically allows for is, if you look at the bottom of page one into page two, it strikes a little bit of language, but it gives the State Highway Commission shall be vested with all the powers and duties as may be prescribed by law. And so it creates the ability for the State Highway Commission or the General Assembly to enact any statute and for them to carry it out just like any other state agency in the state. It also makes sure that at least one member is appointed from each congressional district on the State Highway Commission, and it takes effect July 1, 2019. So if passed in 2018 general election, it would take six months before it actually went into effect. So it would be after the 2019 General Assembly. If the 2019 General Assembly regular session enacted any laws, those would go into effect there in July. And that's when this would take effect. So with that being said, that's the amendment in its entirety. And I'll be more than happy to try to answer any questions. Representative Hammer, are you recognized for a question? Thank you, Representative Dodson. Could
▶ Play
you just kind of speak as to what the intent is, the way that it's structured in the amendment? What are you hoping to achieve by this? Accountability. Follow-up, Mr. Chair? You're recognized for a follow-up. Are you just trying to get a greater representation spread around the state by using the congressional districts to make sure that somebody's appointed from each one of those and that it's spread
▶ Play
throughout the state or? Well, if you look on page two of the amendment, the language that struck in line 13 and 14 and then added, it basically just cleans up that section of the Constitution and makes it to where at least one member is appointed from each congressional district, so there's equal representation, where right now there's a, with five highway commissioners, four of them are basically coming from each of the congressional districts, but one is at large statewide. So since we have five highway commissioners, obviously two come out of a congressional district just by default. So, that's more of a clean-up provision, not necessarily a change in representation or where they can be appointed
▶ Play
from. Thank you. Representative Sabin, you're recognized for your question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Dotson, I was wondering if you could possibly educate us about the history of the current system, because it dates back about 65 years, I think. And maybe explain how the Highway Commission came to be created and made independent constitutionally of the legislature and the executive branch. Well,
▶ Play
I don't really recall that year from a personal historical standpoint. But I believe there was some back and forth between the Governor and the General Assembly at that point in time. And their solution was to make an independent highway commission, which in some ways makes a lot of sense. In other ways, if you're completely independent, then you only have the ability to spend the money, and there's no direct oversight by those that are elected to oversee the spending of state dollars. And so, you know, obviously they're in the Constitution as an independent body right now, today, and we've had 60-some-odd years to see whether this has been a good process or it's not been a good process. Without a lot of elected official oversight of an independent highway commission, And there's a lot of projects that get done and a lot of money spent that I get phone calls on, as I'm sure many of you do as well, that why are we spending money in this way? And from the perspective of a legislator who is charged with keeping of the state dollars And as a former city council member in a municipality, I can say that as a city council member in a municipality dealing with road projects almost every council meeting in some way, shape, fashion, or form, and with highway road projects that came through my municipality, I had more influence as a city council member on how revenue was spent and I could get more answers faster as a city councilman than I can as a legislator today, although I'm expected by my constituents to have more influence on the process, which is not the reality or the case. And so this amendment really is an effort for making sure that the duties that we're charged with as elected officials to oversee the spending of state dollars, we actually have influence on how those dollars are spent and can get a response from an unelected body, which is a highway commission.
▶ Play
Representative Douglas, you're recognized for a question. Uh, my question is, or maybe an observation, you know, we, we have trouble with all state agencies being accountable. How is this going to,
▶ Play
you know, bring more accountability? Well, obviously, any state agency has certain goals and certain perspectives that they're trying to push that may be in conflict with various members of this body. But collectively as a body, we do have a lot of influence over state agencies, and they actually have to listen to and follow the laws which we enact. The Highway Commission, as an independent constitutional organization, does not have that same level of accountability to the legislative process currently. They're constitutionally separated. So this is an effort to basically make sure that they're responsive to the elected representatives of the people from now on in the future. And if the voters approve it, if this body sends it out to them and they approve it, then the people will be better represented when it comes to one of the most accessible things in our state, which is our highways and transportation needs in our state.
▶ Play
But will we have any more hold over their budget? I mean, now we hold their
▶ Play
budget, right? We hold their budget collectively as a whole, but we really have virtually no say in, here's the totality, but as far as line items, there's not really any say that should we or should we not spend $98 million on a bridge or not that has structural issues and is going to fall down.
▶ Play
But would we have, if we pass this, I mean,
▶ Play
we would have direct access to those types of projects. If we chose to by law, obviously you have to pass things by law, and we wanted to have more direct access and say over particular projects of a certain dollar amount or something like that, We can certainly pass a law that says any of those types of projects that are above a certain dollar amount have to come through a legislative process or committee to get approved before they can be enacted. I'm sorry, Mr. Chair, just one last comment.
▶ Play
So it's going to take more legislation to actually put teeth into this amendment? That will be a policy discussion and debate
▶ Play
for future legislatures that we can't have right now. Okay. All right. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Tosh, you recognize her question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Dodson, you made a reference in when you started your presentation that We wanted to bring this commission more in line with the other commissions around the state, and I guess if it's possible, I'm not sure how much you know about the other commissions, but I'm just curious, could you give me some type of an example exactly what the differences are, say, in a commission that represents another state agency, what their role is, their authority is as compared to the Highway Commission and what their role is and what their authority is? Is that
▶ Play
a fair question? I think so. I'll try. So for the most part, and this isn't true of every commission, but there's a few commissions that are in the Constitution, but there's many that are not. Those commissions are established by law, where this particular one is established in the Constitution. And it would still be in the Constitution. We would be required to have a highway commission. The oversight factor is what we don't currently have as much authority in. The highway commission, the game and fish, those are a few examples that are in our Constitution that we have access to collectively their budget, but let's be realistic, we're never not going to pass the highway budget. So we get an up or down vote on their highway budget, and if we don't pass it, then that means there's no roads, and we all like roads, and we're all supportive of that. So as far as the details of what goes into where the money's spent, how it's spent, whether or not it's a good project or it's not a good project and whether or not it's the best use of tax dollars for road projects, we have virtually no say on it. The Highway Commission is independent of the legislative process in that manner. And so unlike other commissions that are established by state law, they come before us with budget and we kind of have a little bit of influence and say on whether or not that's a good use of the money or not and can strike some of the language within those appropriation lines where the Highway Commission is not quite the same entity because it's separated constitutionally right now. This would allow for that increased oversight and better citizen accountability of one of the most vital things throughout our state, which is our highways for economic development, for usage of citizens to be able to travel to and forth from and just overall accountability of a major portion of state government. Representative Smith, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Dotson, I'm just curious if you've had a chance to sit down with Director Scott Bennett, share your thoughts on this resolution and what his feedback may have been to
▶ Play
you? I have not on this particular resolution this year. I mean, I introduced this a couple years ago and had, I think, a couple of conversations at that point in time. Obviously, the Highway Commission is not in favor of additional oversight, So I don't think they're necessarily going to come and speak for this resolution. But as far as having the legislative oversight, I think it's a good government bill. And so I've introduced it this time as well. It came out of the subcommittee yesterday, and so now it's before you for further consideration. If it's one that we decide to pass out of this committee, then I'm sure we'll have continued debate on it going forward, both here and potentially on the Senate end. Thank you. Representative Davis, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
I have a note on my mic that says don't move it, so I'm going to lean over awkwardly like this. Representative Dodson, sort of a comment. I'll try to make it a question at the end, but you touched on something that is kind of a hot button for me, and that is legislature's knowledge and input on what's going on in funding processes and projects and things like that. In a special session last summer, summer before last, we created an ALC subcommittee called the ALC Highway Commission Review and Advisory Subcommittee specifically to try to give members a greater opportunity to have interaction with the department and with the commission. I hear members regularly in conversation ask about project this or project that or why don't they replace this bridge or that bridge. So we tried to create an avenue to have those conversations more easily, although I will admit this committee has met twice and attendance was low. So I would encourage everyone to, if you really have questions about what's going on, it's utilize the committee structures that we have and do that. And wouldn't you agree? Absolutely. All right. Thank you.
▶ Play
All right. Are there any other? Yes. Representative Sturge, you're recognized
▶ Play
Speaker 71 23:23
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Johnson, kind of in light of what Representative Davis is saying, he kind of hit a point that I was thinking about was, you know, what oversight do we already have in place besides, you know, the money and the committees that we have. I guess I'll play devil's advocate for just a minute to say that, you know, there is some need for independence of the legislature because we don't want Representative Hendren with his 40 years experience getting a road built to Northwest Arkansas because that's where the people are and that's where the economics are. When I've got a road in small town Batesville that's 30 years old with like potholes, you You know, and that was, I gathered, the reasoning for making the commission a little more independent of us was so that we couldn't influence where the roads would be built and why, that they have, you know, some set standards of formulas, how old the road is, what condition it's in and, you know, and so forth and so on. So my question is kind of, you know, how transparent would you want this to be? How much oversight would you want this to be other than
▶ Play
just the money and where it's going? Thank you for that question, and as far as those debates, those are policy questions that I believe the legislative body of state government should have the ability to have those substantive policy debates. So if things are currently working well and we have those types of things, we can enact those into state law and make those parameters that they must go by as far as where the roads are built, what standards of quality they are, if there's potholes they need to be fixed, and all that kind of stuff. I believe this will make the Highway Department as well as the Highway Commission much more responsive to those needs. But those are policy questions and things that we need to be able to discuss as a legislative body that's elected by the people and representative of the people that currently we cannot have. Or we can try to have those policy questions and debate, but if we try to pass a law, it's kind of whether or not they want to follow our suggestion. As an independent highway commission, they don't have to. And so this is an effort basically to make that process much more transparent and responsive to the elected representation of the people of the state of Arkansas.
▶ Play
Any other questions from the committee? Yes, Representative, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I feel like I want to help you out a little bit, Representative Dodson. Going back to the history of this thing, one of the sort of deals that was made, I think, as a result of the Highway Commission and the department becoming independent was that, you know, they would have their own dedicated revenue sources. More recently, we've seen that we're starting to dedicate general revenue to highway needs. in particular, we're dedicating surplus now to help them meet their federal match. So I was wondering if you could kind of speak to, again, the changing dynamics and maybe the dissolution of the original understanding and the need for perhaps this work to be governed in the same way
▶ Play
as other state agencies. So to that point, I would agree that that probably gives us more influence and say under current process, if this doesn't change, if we allocate more general revenue resources toward those types of expenses regarding highways, obviously we have much more influence and say over general revenue resources than the dedicated highway resources that are set up and established like they traditionally have been over the last 60 years. However, some of those policies, procedures, and processes that they currently operate under, obviously if we pass a state law, they have to follow that within certain guidelines, but as far as their policies and procedures and where they allocate those resources, we have a limited amount of influence over that. We can try to make strong suggestions, but often those are not always followed. I think that's probably increasing just because of the general revenue dynamic that you were discussing, but I'm not sure that in practice, long term, it will change much.
▶ Play
Any other questions from the committee? All right. Seeing none, we do have Mr. Scott Bennett is here. Mr. Bennett, if you don't mind, take the end of the table. If you don't mind introducing yourself for the
▶ Play
record, that'd be great. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My name is Scott Bennett. I'm the director of the Arkansas State Highway and Transportation Department. I think I can address several of the issues that have arisen here today. First of all, to say that we don't have to follow a law if we don't want to is pretty far from the truth. We do get our authority partly from the commission, but we also get our authority by any laws that are prescribed by you all. Even two years ago, I think it was, there was another act that was passed, a constitutional amendment, and when the rules were promulgated for it, we worked with some of the leadership and said, you know, when we have rules promulgated now based on the laws that you all pass, they're reviewed by the legislature. We're okay if those rules are approved by the legislature. And we've been down here to legislative council to have our rules promulgated and approved by you all. Had that done in just the past year. So it's not true that we just decide that we're not gonna follow any laws that you all pass. That's that's pretty far from the truth. As far as the history goes prior to the the amendment, prior to the Amendment 42, the makeup of the commission changed, the structure of the commission changed probably eight times in about 12 years, who they reported to, how they were appointed, how many of them were. And to put it plainly and simply, if you haven't read all the history, which is on our website, there are a lot of improprieties in the way the money was doled out and even to whom the work was being given from the legislative branch and the executive branch. And there was an audit that said this is something that's going to have to be fixed. And this was the way that the legislature chose to fix it, was to refer a constitutional amendment to the people that passed overwhelmingly. And there have been no changes since that time. The makeup of the commission in this joint resolution doesn't change. There are five commissioners. There are four congressional districts. There's still one commissioner appointed from each congressional district. So you're, in essence, going to have one congressional district that will have two members. As far as accountability, our accountability really goes even beyond this body and to the federal government because all of our projects now are federal aid projects. So we have performance measures that we have to meet from the federal government. We have, as far as developing our program, we have an extensive public involvement process where we put together a draft program and show it to everybody in the state, send it out to all the mayors, all the judges, all of you all, take a lot of input. We have input on projects specifically and not just the program. So there are a lot of steps we have in place. Legislative audit even has an office out of our building because they're there all the time. So we get it from the state side and we get it from the federal side as far as accountability goes. And I'm glad Representative Davis mentioned a special session because, you know, we had talked about several different things that we had already put in place. We have a governmental relations office that's doing a lot more outreach now, and as part of the special session in the act that was passed, there is the Highway Commission Review and Advisory Subcommittee where we're reporting on the status of projects of a certain size. I think there are like 150 projects that we report on and probably 200 more that are coming up that haven't been let to contract that we report on. So we put this report together every quarter. And like Representative Davis mentioned, I mean, the attendance at the meeting wasn't great. There wasn't a quorum at either one of the meetings that we have. But one of the other things that the act from the special session put into place was our development of a rule that explains how we develop a program. And I think that seems to be one of the things that some people don't really understand is how does a project get to be a project? How is this one funded? How is that one not funded? That rule is not due until September of this year, and we're developing it right now. I mean, it's something that we've done for years and years and something that we're putting in writing to be in rulemaking form. As far as responsiveness, I'm not sure that there's anybody in this room that we haven't been responsive to, including Representative Dodson. I mean, he has my cell phone number. He's called me about issues. He didn't have my cell phone number when he was a city council member. So I'm not sure how, you know, this is going to give you any more direct connection to us or any more direct or quick response because we do respond to all of those things. So with that, with my thinking, and I'll mention a $98 million bridge too. $20 million of that came from Belaski County. It wasn't us. And if you all want to have the responsibility of whether to pick this bridge or that bridge because it's structurally deficient, then you can do that. That's fine. That's the reason we have a staff of about 300 engineers, and we're really the largest engineering company in the state, is that's what we do. If you want that responsibility, then that's fine. But I don't think you want to shoulder the responsibility of determining which bridges that are going to be constructed based on the condition of the bridge. I really think that it would be good to let all of the things that have been put in place in the last couple of years and from the special session play out, because I think what you're going to find is there are a lot of things that we do that we're explaining how we do, and you all do have a lot of input. I'm not sure there's a project that anyone in here has asked us to do that we haven't been able to do at one time or another unless you really couldn't establish a purpose and need for it, unless there just strictly was not any money for it at the time. So with that, I mean, I just respectfully request that we let the processes that have been put in place play out over the near future. And I'll be glad to answer any questions. Thank you. Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm not sure you've been that responsive to me, but I'll
▶ Play
take that how it is. Maybe it just hasn't been the answer you wanted. That's not my question. He shouldn't answer yet. I wasn't done. I apologize. Yeah, that's on you. What I wanted to know is how do you see this proceeding with projects across the state if this was to pass? Do you perceive projects moving to the more populated areas? I, for one, represent a very rural area and very concerned about my constituents' safety on their roads when I don't have the representation that maybe northwest Arkansas has. I think there is that possibility if it moved this direction. I think there's that distinct possibility. and now when I go out I represent the whole state agriculture is a huge part of our economy and we have to be able to take care of those rural roads just like we're taking care of the roads in urban areas you recognize for a follow you know a lot of issues come forth up here and it begins to be the rural guys against the urban guys but But the facts are we have to get our goods to market. And getting our goods to market are pine trees, are tomatoes, are rice, are cotton. And I see the way the commission set up to ensure that that stuff is done evenly across the state. And I just wondered if you feel the same way. I do, and that's the reason the commission was set up the way it was, so there would be a somewhat even geographic distribution. When they set it up with five commissioners, there were actually six congressional districts in the state, so there was always going to be one that didn't have a representative. And then we got narrowed down to four. But that was really the purpose is to have some sort of relatively equal geographic distribution because all the roads we have are important. We have way too many of them. There's probably not a chance that we're going to be given 5,000 miles of highways back to the counties. which, by the way, were given to us by the legislature in the past. There's probably not a good chance that we're going to give those back to the county. So we've got to be able to take care of all of those things. And I think it could be difficult moving forward under this
▶ Play
proposal. Representative Hammer, are you recognized for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. And Scott, I want to remind you this Friday morning, you're going to be in Saline County talking to people about the I-30 widening at the legislative breakfast, so here's your public reminder of that. 7.30, yes, sir. No, 7
▶ Play
o'clock, actually. Wait. Okay, I'll see you at 7.30.
▶ Play
Okay, very good. Can I continue, Mr. Chair? Yeah. I don't know how many of that counted for. You got the floor, brother. Thank you. Thank you. How many people in a day do you make VAD versus how many people in a day you make happy? Does that include my wife
▶ Play
and kids? No, we'll leave them out. They have no jurisdiction. Leave them out. They have a lot of jurisdiction. You know, I hear a lot about people that we make happy every day. I don't know that you all hear that. Do we make people mad every day? Absolutely. When our funding stream will only meet about 25% of our needs, I say every day that every day I'm making one person happy and four people mad because there are things that I can't do. Follow up, Mr. Chair. You're
▶ Play
recognized. And that was a predictable answer because, and the point is that whether it's under your system or under a newly created system, there are always going to be people that don't think that they get a fair shake at the, you know, at the money that's available. And I know we're doing more to try to direct funds towards you, but regardless whether you're under the current system or under the proposed system in this amendment, how much of what you do is actually dictated to by federal laws when it comes to choices of which bridges gets replaced, which highways get done in front of others, and how much are your hands tied or not tied that regardless of the structure, you're 80 percent driven by what the feds say you
▶ Play
have to do? I'd say 80 percent is a pretty good number. We have performance measures for bridges. We have performance measures for pavement condition on our interstates and our national highway system, which is going to be really the backbone of our highway system. From that standpoint, we have targets that we're going to have to meet from the federal perspective. And when well over half of our revenue is federal money, and you end up not having enough flexibility to have construction projects that are 100% state funded and all of our construction projects become federal projects, then all of the federal rules are going to apply to our construction projects. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Miller, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Okay. All right. Seeing no other questions, Representative Sabin, you're recognized for a question. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. Director Bennett, ever since I've been in the legislature, I know there have been sort of moves to try to direct general revenue toward highways. There was a bill in the 13th session, bill in the 15th session. We've already addressed kind of the understanding we have about now directing the surplus toward meeting y'all's needs on the federal level. So obviously, once you get your nose in that tent, it creates concern for other state agencies that are competing for those dollars. And so my question would be, if the Highway Department is going to have access to general revenue, why not have the Highway Department govern just like every other state agency that gets general revenue instead of being an independent constitutional entity? Well, I'll give
▶ Play
you an analogy that a very wise man gave me one time, and that's about the old wing walkers at county fairs. When a guy was walking out on the wing of a plane, he's got a hold of that plane, and he's not going to let go of what he's got a hold of until he's got a really firm grip on the next thing that's as good or even better. And I don't think there's really been enough analysis, enough review of this to say that it's going to be any better than what we have now. Now, concerning the general revenue part, let me address the surplus first. You all have seen the reports on the surplus. 25% is zero zero. So if you want to direct 25% is zero, then that's okay. The proposals in the past have been put together by blue ribbon committees that included industry representatives, included legislators, included local officials. It's what we have historically deemed general revenue in Arkansas, but they're actually coming from road user sources. If we just got the road user revenue in Arkansas, we wouldn't be coming back every time asking for, you know, maybe there needs to be a fuel tax increase or anything else. But a lot of the revenue that goes to general sources in Arkansas is considered highway revenue in other states. So it all depends on how you look at it, but there are a lot of sources that are generated out there by road users that are general revenue. And there's a lot of additional advice, review, and oversight that has been put in place over the last few years. I mean, like I mentioned, now, our rules are not reviewed. Our rules are approved for any laws that you all prescribe for us. The Highway Commission Review and Advisory Subcommittee is in place for enhanced communication and information. We're actually developing that rule that shows how we develop a program. So there are a lot of things that have been put in place in just the last few years that we need to give a chance to work. And as far as the revenue that we get, that's right. We can't generate our own revenue. We can't go out there and raise our own fees. We can't raise fees on commercial vehicles or on cars or on electric vehicles who aren't paying anything to use the road now. We can't do those things. We rely on you all to do that, and when you all do that, you prescribe how that revenue is going to be used. In 1985 and in 1991, when additional taxes were passed, they were prescribed for a rural road program. When the bond issue was passed for the interstates, it was prescribed to be only for interstate rehabilitation. You all did that in the language. When the half-cent sales tax passed, you all prescribed that it was going to be for only widening highways. So you all have had a lot of that input from a program level anyway. Representative Hammer, you're recognized for a question. Scott, based on just what
▶ Play
you said, do you think it would be better if we gave you the money and let you and the commission figure it out and then be fully responsible for all the positive or negatives that come as a result of
▶ Play
it? No, I think it's still a combination. I mean, I think you all have to be involved because you all are the ones that are responsible for determining how the revenue is generated and how much of it. So I think it does have to be a combination, but I think it is that combination right now. But we do take responsibility for the way it's spent, for the projects that are selected, for the way it's spent, for the
▶ Play
Speaker 105 45:51
way it's not spent. MR. Follow-up, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair? MR. Thank you. But go back to maybe the issue where you said we passed the highway tax, whatever, and said it had to be assigned to specific issues. Do you feel that in that manner of which we go about doing business, that we are limiting you too much to where you can't have broader discretion to address some of the issues that are brought before you, either by us as legislators or by the general public?
▶ Play
Somewhat, but I think that happens at the federal level, too, and that's part of the politics of what you do is, how are you going to get an issue passed? I mean, we're not ever going to come down here and just ask you for carte blanche additional money to do whatever we want to do with it. We're always going to tell you what we're going to do with it up front
▶ Play
to justify the need for it. All right. Seeing no other question from the committee, I appreciate your testimony. Mr. Bennett, and Representative Dotson, you are recognized to close for your resolution.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. Purpose of introducing this is to get this discussion started and make sure that we have basically the ability to have the conversation on whether or not we want to make this commission more like other state agencies and more responsive to legislative oversight. I apologize if I misspoke before and said the commission doesn't have to follow laws that we pass. Obviously, every citizen in the state has to follow laws that we pass. However, I believe that there needs to be more accountability in this particular commission than what there has been over the last several years, anyway, that I've been involved in the process. And that's the purpose of this amendment, is to make sure that, or this proposal is to make sure that if it's passed and if it's put into place, that there is greater transparency in legislative oversight. And I think that would make better government. And so that's why I proposed it, and I appreciate your consideration of this as one of the proposals that we put out. Thank you very
▶ Play
much. Thank you, Representative Dotson. Okay, Representative Drown, are you prepared to run HJR 2011? Okay. One thing I want to do is, you know, I think our time, I think we're probably still in good shape, but if we'll just be mindful, you know, to, I mean, I understand, I think that what we're talking about is admitting the Constitution, so we do want to make sure that we give it its due diligence as far as the committee in asking questions, but let's also be mindful of the time, because we do need to get out of here before noon and the rules run. Also, Mr. Dan Roulette, is he still in the room? Okay, Mr. Dan Roulette, you're with the Arkansas Alliance for Boys and Girls Clubs, so I appreciate you being with us, and I appreciate the work that you've done, working with the legislature to do the fundraiser last night, even if it didn't end up so well for us.
▶ Play
So, thank you. Mr. Chair, if it's okay, I'm going to have Representative Lowry join me here to, he knows the history of
▶ Play
this bill. Absolutely. Or this amendment. Thank you. Yep. So, you
▶ Play
both are recognized to run your amendment. Thank you, Mr. Chair, committee. Like I just said, before we can go into the reason for amending Amendment 33, I think it's best if you heard the history behind Amendment 33. And Representative Lowry here has a pretty good handle on that, so I'm going
▶ Play
to yield to him. Thank you, and thank you, members, for allowing me to co-present with Representative Drown. The origination of this amendment dates back to 1942. I know I look like I probably was around then. with my white hair, but I was not. However, I've done a lot of reading. The historical perspective of this goes back to Governor Homer Adkins when he was elected. He had a specific bone to pick with the president at the University of Arkansas, which then was J.W. Fulbright. Governor Adkins was upset with Mr. Fulbright, who later became Senator Fulbright, Bill Fulbright, he was upset with Senator Fulbright's or President Fulbright's mother because she was a publisher of a newspaper and had opposed Governor Atkins' election. The first thing he did when he got into office is that he fired J.W. Fulbright as president of the university and dismissed the board first. that prompted and you know one of the things we think of when we look at initiatives, amendments that are forwarded by the people by petition process we just think that there's some groundswell actually the dean of the law school Dr. Leffler was the one that put this together it was passed by the people by a very narrow margin 51% to 49% and probably a lot of the reason that that was even able to pass is that it was written in such a way that it also took in corrections and also the highway department, that the governor could not come in and abolish a board. So it wasn't just dealing with higher education. And the truth is, if Amendment 33 only prohibited the abolishing of a board or a president, we probably would not have any issues. There wouldn't be concern, but there was a phrase that was put into the amendment that specifically says that the border commission of any institution, we're talking about higher ed institutions, governed by this amendment shall not be abolished, nor shall the powers vested in any such border commission be transferred. That is where the real rub comes, is because higher education traditionally, historically, taken the perspective, and this is in many different analyses and accounts, that higher education has taken that to mean that they have autonomy, that the legislature only has appropriation authority, does not have any power to make sure that there's uniformity in terms of tuitions, fees, and application of certain policies. There's only been one challenge in all those years about the autonomy, and it was the Higher Ed Coordinating Board, I believe in 1985 was formed before then, but it took on that name. They were given the powers to be able to regulate or to have input on degree programs that universities would have, and they exercised that authority until in the 90s they were opposed by the University of Central Arkansas, and the University of Central Arkansas actually filed a lawsuit against the state, against the Higher Ed Coordinating Board, because the Coordinating Board had refused to allow them a degree program. The case eventually went to the Supreme Court, however, the Coordinating Board removed their objection. So it's never been adjudicated. Attorney General's office has made several opinions through the years, and they have pretty much interpreted that those vested powers do make higher ed autonomous. And I think that that really is the background. It is problematic, and I know Representative Drown is going to speak to some of the manifestation of how that autonomy and that absolute power has been detrimental for the state of Arkansas.
▶ Play
Well, so we move on to today. And the experiences I've had regarding Amendment 33, probably within the last two months, myself and six other legislators, senators, and representatives alike, I sat down with board members of one of our institutions of higher education, and we started discussing different things that we were seeing and concerns that we had, and we were probably not into the conversation or the meeting very long that Amendment 33 was thrown up at us. Little did they know, we already had talked to the folks at BLR and had seen the problems that had been faced in the past and had already planned on drafting this legislation to amend Amendment 33, but that was the first real dealings I had had with a board in higher ed throwing that at us as a roadblock. So the second thing that happened, I was told to go look at the carryover funds for higher ed. Okay, easy enough. We go to BLR, we make a request, and once that request is made, we get the information nonpartisan. A week went by, I went back, BLR's like, sorry, we can't give you those hard numbers. They're given to us in a way that we are unable to, we want to make sure that you have a solid understanding of exactly what those carryover dollars are. And literally, the exact terminology is, we're at their mercy. Two weeks went by, still could not get those solid numbers. On the third week, they finally handed me two documents. They were the carryover funds for June 30th of 2015 and the carryover documents for June 30th of 2016. I was asked after the actual carryover numbers for, I want to say it was either December or January. It's been the time has to last probably January. So it's because of that that I have concerns that we, the people, meaning the legislature, or the people that are here to oversee how the taxpayer dollars are being spent are having roadblocks thrown up to keep us from seeing those for what they are. And to put it in perspective, the carryover funds for higher ed as a whole amount to about three-quarters of a billion dollars. You throw that in with the amount of monies they are getting for their yearly budget, And this is overall, you're talking about $1.5 billion that we are at their mercy, or should I say BLR is, if we want to see exactly how those monies are being used, distributed, and to what degree. Those monies, those revenue sources do not include the monies coming in from foundations and other revenue sources. That's just strictly the taxpayer dollars. So now you're stepping off into a whole different realm. so beyond $1.5 billion. And with that being said, I'll be glad to entertain any questions that you might have. Are there any questions from the committee?
▶ Play
Okay, seeing none from the committee, we do have, okay, yeah, you're recognized for a question, Representative Douglas. Can this
▶ Play
not be done just through the code? Do we have to have a constitutional amendment?
▶ Play
Representative Douglas, I had thought originally that much like I'm doing with the Amendment 51 voter ID that you could go in and by a two-thirds vote, you could amend it. At one time, the amendment that sets up the referendum process did give the legislature authority on any amendment, but that was later challenged in court and Supreme Court overturned that part of the referendum amendment. So unless the Amendment 33 specifically has within the language that the legislature can amend or promulgate rules or whatever by two-thirds vote, you cannot do that. So that's been one of the difficulties with Amendment 33. Thank you. Representative
▶ Play
Sturge, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Speaker 71 58:58
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Drowne, I'm reading Section B, Line 7, page 2. The General Assembly may enact laws transferring the powers vested in an institution of higher learning. Now, before that, it talks about when a school is consolidated or abolished, we can do a Board of Trustees to a Board of Visitors. We've done that here just recently, but I'm trying to figure out what do you mean in Section B? may enact laws transferring the powers vested in an institution of higher learning. So my question would be, to what? For what? To whom? You're looking at Section B, the language of the General Assembly may enact laws transferring the powers vested in an
▶ Play
institution. Yes, that's correct. I would surmise that what that is saying, we have a Higher Ed Coordinating Board, and the whole purpose of that is to make sure that there is some uniformity, but yet that has been challenged by Amendment 33, so the vested powers would probably be placed with the Higher Ed Coordinating Board to give them more power and authority to be able
▶ Play
Speaker 71 1:00:17
to provide the oversight that we want them to have. In general, then, for all institutions, or just in certain instances, or? For all institutions.
▶ Play
For all institutions. Okay. You just never know when Amendment 33 is going to be invoked. And this is what Representative Drown has run to in his situation. I have certainly perceived that as well in conducting the task force on higher ed realignment that the meetings we had over a year never had anyone specifically invoke Amendment 33, but it certainly was something that was always there in terms of limiting how far we would be able to go. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Hammer, you're recognized for her question.
▶ Play
Thank you. And would either one of you just touch on the subject of, you mentioned about the Bureau and trying to find out, but what about the auditing process of the higher ed and using that as an avenue to get to where they spend their money, how they spend their money. Did you all touch on that any
▶ Play
or could you? I don't think that there's been specific, I mean, you're absolutely right that there are audits that are done, and a lot of this information, campus by campus, you can see some of the dollar amounts, but I'll give you an example of one issue. Representative Hammer, I know you're familiar with it, because the issue came before joint performance review several years ago, where there was the issue of the Division of Advancement at University of Arkansas that had overspent by, I can't remember what the amount was, $10 million or something like that. And to really get down to getting answers on that, we had to, the Joint Performance Review had to bring in Dr. Gearhart and others to explain that process. Now there had been audits that had uncovered this, but one of the things that was discovered there is the question, the issue of, and Representative Drown mentioned foundation funding, the amount of money that's in foundations not being included in the numbers that he gave, the $1.5 billion. My argument, and it probably would take an attorney general's opinion to clarify this, but the case at the University of Arkansas was that the division, and I may use some terminology incorrectly, but my understanding of it was that the division of advancement would receive funds from the foundation in advance for their fundraising, and then they would pay the development back, or excuse me, pay the foundation back. My argument would be, and if you're familiar, foundations are not subject to FOI, they're not audited, at least not by the state. My argument is that that then makes those foundation funds co-mingled state funds. If the flow of money is going from the foundation to the university and then back to the foundation, it's commingled state funds, and those foundations should be audited. That's one of the areas where we are limited in what we can do in Amendment 33, or an amendment or change of Amendment 33 could give us that power. Quick follow-up, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. You recognize one follow-up. Thank you. Is it your intent through this amendment to be able to gain greater transparency into the finances that currently may be blocked from being looked at because of the way they're able to hide behind Amendment 33, as it's written now, and also the limiting ability of leg audit or private auditors that the schools may retain? Is that part of the intent of
▶ Play
what this bill is about? The original intent of the bill is transparency. We're talking about the taxpayer dollars. We're talking about the people's money. If in the future it is deemed, based on what comes out of amending Amendment 33, that it is deemed necessary for some reason to see what is going on with that flow of money, I can very well see that being the case. Thank you, Mr. Chair. MR. Representative Sabin, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. MR. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'd like to follow up on Representative Sturch's line of questioning, and this is admittedly somewhat of a technical question, but he kind of raised my concern about it. So that section at the top of page two that he had referred to initially, you know, Section A, which precedes, obviously, Section B, kind of really talks about how none of these powers can be transferred unless an institution is abolished or consolidated, which makes sense. But the way Section B is written in terms of allowing the General Assembly to enact laws transferring the powers vested in an institution of higher learning seems overly broad, and my concern for instance would be, you know, we've got right now Arkansas State University riding real high in the legislature because the Speaker is an ASU grad, the President pro-tem of the Senate is an ASU grad. We've got a lot of ASU folks in the legislature. In the future, there could be a lot of power in the legislature from UCA alums. And you could get 51 votes and maybe consolidate or transfer the powers at UAMS or one of the community colleges into UCA in the way that this is written. And I was wondering if you could kind of address whether or not that actually would be possible, that the General Assembly with 51 votes in the House, 18 votes in the Senate, could simply transfer the powers from one institution to another, and without there having been any abolition or consolidation of
▶ Play
any institution. Representative Sabin, I would say that your scenario that you give is certainly possible, the hypothetical, but the main intent of this, and sometimes we have to look at legislative intent, especially if you're talking about a constitutional amendment. The transfer of those powers would be to the divisions that we give that authority to currently. The Division of Higher Education, the Higher Ed Coordinating Board. To this issue of vested powers, of what are the vested powers, for instance. Sometimes it's left to this hypothetical interpretation as well. I mean, that was the case that we had in the 90s where the University of Central Arkansas said, we have the ultimate authority in deciding what degree programs we're going to have. You can't provide that oversight, so we're going to file a lawsuit against you saying that the vested powers are being taken away from us. So I think we just have to look at intent, and it probably more than likely would be within the division of higher ed. Yeah, you
▶ Play
Speaker 140 1:07:32
recognize very well. And I hear you loud and
▶ Play
clear, and I understand the intent. as you and Representative Brown have explained it, and I do wonder whether, though, there's somewhat of a lack of precision in this in terms of achieving that transparency and accountability because, you know, the courts sometimes consider intent, but they also look more closely at just the way, you know, it's written, and if it's in the Constitution and it says this can happen and it happens, then it's done, and that would be my concern is that maybe some of this is extraneous to the intention that you have in this amendment, but But you can address that, I guess I'll put that
▶ Play
in the form of a question, but I appreciate that. Well, Representative Saban, I'll use the example of the ethics amendment that you co-sponsored and put before the voters. There was still a necessity to promulgate rules, but the legislature was able to change. And if I remember, it was two-thirds votes, was it not, to clarify that. So in that case, a simple majority would not be able to go ahead and randomly or without reason move vested power somewhere where maybe they're not intended to be. It would take a supermajority in terms of promulgating the rules on that vested power. You're recognized. I don't think that's exactly right. I mean,
▶ Play
it would take two-thirds to change the language in the amendment, but the amendment It says the General Assembly may enact laws, and the General Assembly enacts laws with a simple majority, and it would be to transfer the powers from one institution somewhere else. I mean, that's what it says, literally, in the language in the amendment. So it's a little different than the point you made, I think. All
▶ Play
right, I don't see any other questions from the committee. We do have one person who's signed up to speak against. If you all don't, one of you don't mind moving to the room of President Bobbitt. IF YOU DON'T MIND INTRODUCING YOURSELF FOR THE RECORD.
▶ Play
ABSOLUTELY THANK YOU. MY NAME IS DONALD BOB AND I'M PRESIDENT OF THE UNIVERSITY OF ARKANSAS SYSTEM. I APPRECIATE A FEW MINUTES JUST TO COMMENT FROM OUR PERSPECTIVE IN THE U OF A SYSTEM ABOUT THE AMENDMENT THAT'S BEFORE YOU. I THINK IT'S VERY UNFORTUNATE TO HEAR ABOUT THE CIRCUMSTANCES THAT REPRESENTATIVE DROWN HAS HAD. I WILL TELL YOU THAT I CAN ONLY SPEAK FOR THE U OF A SYSTEM BUT I WORK FOR TEN MEN and women who were appointed by the governor, elected by the people of Arkansas. If any member sitting around this table or any other member went to a member of my board and said that we were being unresponsive, if I wanted to continue my job, we would address that issue in great speed. You know, the Amendment 33 provides dynamic tension, but not absolute power to any entity. It's a balance of power between the executive, legislative branches, and the board of trustees. And, again, I'll remind you that the governor appoints the Board of Trustees, and they're very thorough in helping us go through everything from our finances to our programs. In the issues, for example, of reserves, every year this body, through legislative audit, audits our financial statements. Those numbers are available in our auditive financials. I spend considerable time with legislative auditors, making sure and answering their questions, making sure that everything that we have in that book is correct so that you can do a proper job of taking care of the people's money. The leadership, I think, of higher education in general understand and respects the authority of this group. I have been here now for a little bit over five years, and I'll be honest to you, I've never heard Amendment 33 brought up in a single one of our board meetings or in any meeting that I know of and have attended between my staff and the General Assembly. Amendment 33, I think, though, does encourage compromise, which is sometimes important. By control of the appropriation process, I think this body really has the upper hand, AND IT FORCES US, EVEN IF WE DON'T WANT TO SOMETIMES, TO ANSWER THE QUESTIONS AND TO DO SO WITH GREAT SPEEDS THAT YOU CAN DO ABOUT YOUR BUSINESS. I THINK IT'S NO, I THINK IT'S NO, THERE'S NO QUESTION THAT HIGHER EDUCATION IN GENERAL IS FACING VERY CHALLENGING TIMES AND WE, WE FIND THAT COLLEGES AND OUR UNIVERSITIES HERE IN ARKANSAS WITHIN THE U OF A SYSTEM MUST BE VERY ENTREPRENEURIAL. We compete for students, we compete for employees, quality employees, and major grants from businesses, from foundations, from the federal government. And Amendment 33, to me, provides the ability to move nimbly to create programs to meet the needs of the state. I approach this from a free market perspective. I do not believe in central control. I believe in local control. This state, through its wisdom, has created a very robust system of four-year institutions, two-year institutions, and technical institutes. It's diverse however you want to look at it. It's diverse in terms of the cost of attendance. It's diverse in terms of the programs that are offered and including the accoutrements that that campus offers. To me, it seems obvious that choice is there and that individuals will pick the situation that makes most sense for them based on their finances, based upon their interests and their inclinations. I want to finish by just offering you a comment that I think takes this idea of the financial pressures that we face and what has been, I think, so beneficial in this state and allowed us to see our universities improve, even in spite of the challenging financial situations. And I have here a quote from the most recent Moody's Investor Service, their governance and management advice, and they say, as public funding continues to diminish as a percentage of their total budget, these rapidly evolving and complex organizations require increased operating freedom and a more flexible oversight structure in order to fulfill their mission. In the U.S., we generally view increased university autonomy as a credit positive because it tends to promote more efficient resource utilization and execution of long-term plans, which are critical for universities to succeed in a highly competitive higher education market. And I think those words were probably true many years ago when Amendment 33 was put into place. There are other reasons why it was put into place, too. It has served the state well, and that is why I think that the existing situation has done well for the state and for higher education. Thank you for this
▶ Play
opportunity. I'd be glad to take questions. I appreciate your testimony. I'm not seeing any questions, but Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 71 1:14:22
Sturge, you recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Dr. Bobbitt. We appreciate you being here. My question kind of involves Section 2, the heart of the bill. Representative Brown is presenting to us about Section 1, enacting legislation impacting an institution of higher learning, including without limitation the tuition and fees charged by an institution of higher learning. So my question to you is, how much oversight do you currently have over tuition and fees across the campuses within the U of A system? Is it the Board of Trustees have a final vote or individual institutions have a final vote? Can you explain
▶ Play
that process as it currently is? Absolutely. Thank you very much for that question. It's a very collaborative process. The requests originate on the campus. And obviously, the chancellor of the campus, along with his or her staff, look at the needs and what might be possible. We're constantly comparing ourselves to our peer institutions to make sure that we are not out of line. It then goes, in most circumstances, to a board of visitors. These are local community professionals and other supporters who take a look at it, and many times the request that comes from the campus is modified down at that point in time. If that comes up to our office, and we do a more thorough job of looking at their peers, we compare them both within and without the state to make sure that we're offering Arkansans a competitive product, obviously we do not want to see the quality diminish. And then it goes to the Board of Trustees, and sometimes those conversations take hours to debate it, and I can tell you I have a conservative board who views the cost of education for students as being a critical factor in their job responsibilities. We have over the course, several of our campuses, for example, tuition and fees are not the only cost, books are. We have several of our institutions that have eliminated textbooks, worked with the faculty to find either open educational resource materials or to use a set contract with a publisher. So we are working hard to keep these costs in line. And it's not just tuition and fees, but they extend to things that, for the most part, we don't control.
▶ Play
Speaker 71 1:16:31
MR. Can I have a follow-up, Mr. Chair? MR. One follow-up. MR. Could then you describe, is it possible then for, say, my community college at Batesville to say, we really only want to go up this amount, and your community college at Monticello to say, well, we need to really go up this amount, or whatever it might be, that those are two different amounts. It's not a broad spectrum across the board raised for anybody that you are already looking at where they are, what the needs are, what the population is, as local Board of Trustees as well as the system Board of Trustees. I could not summarize the
▶ Play
situation better, so it's- Okay. That's the way it currently is. Okay. All
▶ Play
right, not saying any other questions, I appreciate your testimony, Dr. Bobbitt. And Representative Drown, you are recognized to close for your motion.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I appreciate that from the U of A systems. And I no doubt believe that they have not thrown up the words of Amendment 33 as a roadblock over his time and his tenure with that system. But the fact is this. The roadblock has been thrown up in regards to myself and seven other senators and representatives regarding an institution of higher education in this state. And I remind you of the $1.5 billion of taxpayer dollars that we are elected to oversee. And it is because of that that this oversight, this amendment, is important so that we can maintain that oversight and continue to do the people's business. Thank you. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 147 1:18:08
you. I appreciate your presentation. Representative Lundstrom, are you
▶ Play
here to present your resolution? You're presenting HJR 1016. are recognized. Thank you, Chairman Ballinger. Folks, we've
▶ Play
all talked about voter ID. It's probably been one of the most discussed issues over the last few years because it's been on the ballot. It's been thrown out of court, all that good stuff. But the bottom line at the end of the day, the most important thing we have is voter security. The voters need to know that when their vote is cast, it counts. This amendment will assure the voters that we are doing everything from the point where that voter comes in to vote to the time they walk out the door, their vote will count. I'm saddened to say every time I go shopping or sit down to have a glass of wine or whatever, I'm still, fortunately, I get carded. I love that. It makes me feel good. But at every single step in life, cashing a credit card or using a credit card, checking in at a hotel, we have an ID, and the reason being for security. The one thing we don't have a mandated, required ID is when we go to the ballot box. Our whole system is built on voter security. And with that, I would ask for a good vote, and I'd open it up for any questions. Thank
▶ Play
you. Representative Bladyman, you're recognized for a question. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. You may not know the answer to this, but this came up in a discussion I had yesterday. Is it true that when you go to register to vote, it's been a long time since I've registered, so I don't remember, but you have to have some kind of ID when you go register. Don't you have to have something
▶ Play
Speaker 157 1:20:06
that shows that you can register? Well, when you mail in your
▶ Play
voter registration, you don't mail in an ID with it. Now, if you go down to the courthouse, they'll probably ask you for that. But we've all been door-to-door on different campaigns and had somebody ask us, well, I'm not registered, and we have to hand them that sheet of paper. And then they go fill it out on their own and send it. But there's no ID
▶ Play
Speaker 158 1:20:31
with it. So that's a flaw in the system.
▶ Play
All right. Representative Sabin, you're recognized for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lindstrom, we have considered this issue before, so I think I've probably asked these questions before. But not of you, of course, though. We're obviously talking about putting this into the Constitution, which makes this, you know, a bigger deal even than the legislation we've considered previously. Quite right. You had given some examples of, you know, cases in which we're required to present photo identification. My first question to you would just be none of those instances are actually constitutionally guaranteed rights. That's correct. You know, we don't have a right to board an airplane or, you know, to go into government controlled buildings, things like that. But we do have a right to vote that's enshrined not just in our state constitution, but in our United States Constitution. Correct. So, you know, what problem, I guess, are we trying to solve here? I mean, do you have data that shows that impersonating a voter is a problem that we're having here in Arkansas?
▶ Play
Every state, including Arkansas, has faced voter fraud, and I agree with you. It's not when you go into a federal building or you use your credit card. All those things are important, but this is even more, I would say, for lack of a better term, sacred. We ought to have ballot security. And when you mail in a ballot, you would mail in a copy of your ID. When you go to vote, you show a copy of our ID. It's a way of assuring the voter that we are doing the things that we need to do. Will this eliminate all voter fraud? No. Will it slow things down? You better believe it because you and I look a little different, and when we show an ID, they'll notice there's a difference. Every state has a myriad. There's even been books written about different states and their voter fraud. Hopefully, this will slow it down. Will it guarantee it? No. Can I give you specific examples of Arkansas? Not off the top
▶ Play
Speaker 140 1:22:35
of my head. Just one follow-up, and then I'll
▶ Play
yield. You're recognized for a follow-up. I appreciate that. And again, to me, I know there's voter fraud, but this is a specific type of voter fraud that this constitutional amendment is designed to try to combat against. And you mentioned that you don't have any examples, and we don't really have much data to show that this is a problem. So is it really necessary to put something like this in our Constitution? We actually do have examples of people who have been disenfranchised as a result of voter ID being enacted previously, but we don't have any examples of voter fraud occurring through impersonating a voter.
▶ Play
Yes, actually we do. I just apologize. I didn't bring a list of them with me today. This addresses one section of that.
▶ Play
Okay, I'll yield. Thank you. I mean, I had a situation where I had a client who contacted me. She's a client on another matter, but she showed up to vote on Election Day, was told specifically that she had already voted and that she couldn't vote. So she was actually able to work out and do a provisional ballot after she called me. So I don't know if the people didn't offer that originally. I don't know what happened with that. But after she called me, she was able to do a provisional ballot, go and have it contested. And she got her vote counted. But whatever vote that was cast some other place in Fayetteville, because of the fact that they have multiple locations, you can vote at any early voting place, somebody cast a vote in her name. And so her vote, if they voted differently than her, her vote was essentially offset by somebody who committed fraud and voted on her behalf. And my guess is that that is probably one example where it was discovered if somebody's smart about committing voter fraud, they select somebody who doesn't vote on a regular basis, and then it's never known. So, I mean, you know, that's just maybe it's been anecdotal. It is specific because I know of at least one person. But my argument would be is, you know, if that could happen to one person, it could happen to many. And if it is going to do that to one person, I do believe a person's vote is valuable, and we should be careful about that. But anyway, that's just my own anecdote. Having said that, taking up some time, I'm just going to let folks now know that we have like 20 minutes. So I've got several questions on the table and two motions on the table. And so if we get down close to the time, I'm going to take one of those motions and move on. So just let's try to make sure that we're mindful of everyone's time on that. I hate cutting off debate on something that is so important. However, like Representative Saban said, this is a dog we've kicked many times already, which is illegal in Arkansas and donkeys, so let's not do that. Although I feel like we're kicking donkeys more than dogs right now. All right. Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 12 1:25:25
Dotson, you are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Representative Lundstrom, I'm very supportive of voter ID and voter ID concept. We voted on it multiple times, and we already passed one voter ID law this session. I'm not sure why this is necessary or needed for a constitutional amendment until after we see whether or not that voter ID law that we've already enacted and that takes care of this actually stands up in court.
▶ Play
Why are you presenting this now? Thank you. I think that's a very legitimate question and one we need to talk about. First of all, the reason the first bill, Representative Lowry's bill that's coming through is well done. This is a companion bill for this. The same reason we lock our front door and we throw that deadbolt on, this is the same. This would be the same activity. We are guaranteeing the voters ballot security. If we didn't have this and we just had Representative Lowry, in the next session, another set of legislators could change that. This is something that's important to the people of Arkansas, so this is a combination effort, if you will, the belt and suspenders argument to make sure that this is set in the Constitution, that we are going to protect the ballot. Okay. Representative Hammer,
▶ Play
you're recognized for her question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I'm trying to scratch from my memory. It seemed like I remember in the last couple days that somebody amended a bill that in the absence of having a valid photo ID, that they would be able to sign, you know, a statement. And I don't see that listed in here as an option. Is that going to create problems down the road? Or could you speak to that?
▶ Play
No. What Representative Lowry's bill did was that if someone showed up and did not have a valid photographic ID, they could vote a provisional ballot, and that would allow them to have, they would sign an affidavit, and then they could run that provisional ballot. So nobody would be blocked from voting. This does not have that in there. We're waiting to see where that all lands. Also, it would give the legislature a chance to set the rules as backup. Quick
▶ Play
follow-up, Mr. Chair. You're recognized. Thank you. You know, in the constituents in my area that are engaged voters, this is a hot topic, and they'd really like to see it laid to rest because they get tired of us having to talk about it every time, so I hope this would do that. But as far as the county officials that oversee the voting procedures, have they expressed opinion about this or given any guidance on this? No, sir. The only
▶ Play
feedback I've heard is they like getting the photo ID. It makes their job easier in the long run because they can see the name, the address, it's written out, it speeds things up.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Representative Drown, you're recognized for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. And it's, if I'm not mistaken, and just piggybacking on Representative Saban, we have multiple amendments to the Constitution regarding voters' rights. but yet when it comes to the second amendment which is also amendment to the constitution we require an ID in order to buy a firearm from a store so the fact that we're using an argument or would you think that the fact that we're using an argument that because the right to vote is an amendment to the constitution would that not hold true for others if that was the case for the second amendment so on and so forth I mean, I would
▶ Play
go back to the argument that having the right to vote and knowing that vote counts is paramount to everything that we do, and we need to offer that security. Okay. All right. Thank you.
▶ Play
Any other questions from committee? Representative
▶ Play
Ferguson, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lundstrom, I want to go back to Representative Hammer's question. And you answered it in talking about the provisional ballot. However, in Representative Lowry's bill, it spoke specifically to those Arkansans who were in nursing homes. And it was a statement that could be written by the director of the nursing home or some nursing home staff that would legitimately identify that individual as a resident. Does this bill address any of that? No. I'm waiting until Lowry's gets through. I think what
▶ Play
he's done is very helpful, but this would allow us to promulgate the rules to match that bill. It gives us that flexibility. All right. Any other questions from the committee?
▶ Play
I'll represent a start. You're recognized for a question. Thank you,
▶ Play
Speaker 71 1:30:20
Mr. Chairman. Representative Ferguson was actually asking that. We do, in your bill, have a provisional ballot subdivision, correct? Yes, that is correct. But we don't have any, like you have to submit it within 10 days or anything like Representative Lowry's bill was. Okay. Thank
▶ Play
you. Okay. Any other questions from the committee? In fact, you're recognized, I guess, to close for your resolution. Thank you. I
▶ Play
want to thank you for the time. I know we have kicked this dog around quite a bit, but the reason we're doing it is because it matters to the voters. They keep bringing it up because it's important that they know their vote counts. And with that, I would ask for a good vote, and
▶ Play
thank you. Thank you. Just so the committee knows that we didn't have anybody sign up for or against that bill, so that's why we didn't go there. All right. So I'm sorry. Is anybody in the audience here to speak for or against? Okay. If you don't mind,
▶ Play
if you'd introduce yourself. Mr. Chairman, my name is Chris Burks. I signed up to speak against the bill briefly if it pleases the chairman. Okay. Just by way of brief introduction, I have two points for the committee to consider. My name is Chris Burks. I'm an attorney here in Little Rock. I've done several things, but one of the things I've done was to serve as a Pulaski County Election Commissioner. And I brought the lawsuit that overturned the past act from the legislature on voter ID. I also wear another hat. I'm an attorney for the Democratic Party of Arkansas. I'm not here in either of those capacities. I'm here as an attorney to ask you, in essence, to think about what you're doing in regard to the Arkansas Constitution. Constitutional rights are important. Reverend Drown mentioned the Second Amendment. I believe constitutional rights are important, and this committee has an important job. The two points I'll ask this committee to consider are, first, the case of Freedom Coles versus Mark Martin, which overturned the last act of the legislature on voter ID. It turned on Article 3, Section 1 of the Arkansas Constitution, which said there are four qualifications to vote in Arkansas. You must be a citizen of the United States of America. You must be a resident. You must be registered to vote, and you must be over the age of 18. The majority of the Supreme Court, and I have clerked for a current member of the Supreme Court of a different political party than me, have strictly applied that test in all voter cases in Arkansas. There are four qualifications to vote. Adding a qualification, as Representative Lowry's bill does, violates the Constitution. So my message for you to consider is, if you want to do voter ID, which I don't think you should. I think there's some other good constitutional amendments out there that you've considered here this morning. But if you want to do voter ID, in my opinion, as an election law attorney, as someone who's litigated this, you have to pass a constitutional amendment, as Representative Lundstrom has presented, Representative Lowry's bill will not pass because of Article 3. I know Representative Bollinger has made some comments about a different court composition. Having worked for members of the court, that is not my opinion. My opinion is that if you want to do voter ID, refer out a constitutional amendment. But I'm asking you to not do voter ID. I think the point that Representative Saban made is a great point, that there are no specific examples of this type of voter fraud in Arkansas. As a former election commissioner, if you want to fix election issues, the best way to do that is better training and funding of election coordinators at the county level. Representative Ballinger mentioned that there's an issue with a provisional voter in Washington County. The best way to fix that is to better train the poll worker and the election coordinator in that county. Elections are underfunded by about 20 to 25 million in this state. And I'll just conclude with this. There are issues with voting, just like there are issues with other constitutional amendments. Those issues are not voter impersonation. If you want to fix issues with voting, increase penalties for absentee fraud. Increase penalties for storage of ballots. Those are real issues with real examples I can provide you. If you want to do voter ID, I don't think you should, but you need to pass this constitutional amendment. You can't rely on just an act. But for all the reasons that Representative Sabin should, I think you should not pass this bill. I think you should consider some of the oversight of higher education or the Highway Commission as valid exercises of legislative power. Thank you. All right. I appreciate your testimony. Representative
▶ Play
Lundstrom, I know that you have closed, but things now we got out of order a little bit. You'll recognize if you want to close for your resolution now. We don't have anybody else's one. No one else has signed up. Okay. Representative Lundstrom, you are recognized.
▶ Play
No, I'm still as confident as the day I walked in here that we absolutely owe the people of Arkansas the ability to know that every step of the way that their ballot is secure, and I would appreciate a
▶ Play
good vote. Thank you. I appreciate that presentation. All right, having heard all the presentations, I do have two motions on the table. I've got three motions on the table. The first motion I'm going to hear is from Co-Chair Representative Vladyman.
▶ Play
You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'd like to make a motion of due pass for HJR 1016. Okay, so HJR
▶ Play
1016 is the resolution we just heard on voter ID. We have a motion of due pass. Is there any discussion on the motion? Representative Dotson, you're recognized for the discussion.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. You know, I've heard conflicting opinions on this particular one, on whether or not it's needed or necessary, or if it's not needed or necessary. I think giving the Representative Lowry's voter ID law that we've already enacted an opportunity to go forward and see how it'll work out is probably the best course of action on voter ID at this moment in time. So, if the Chair would entertain a substitute motion, I would.
▶ Play
Let's finish our discussion on this motion, and then I will. Make one of the proper time, then. Okay. Yes, Representative Sturge, you're recognized. Thank you,
▶ Play
Speaker 71 1:36:57
Mr. Chair. I was just going to ask, kind of piggybacking off Representative Dodson, say that if Representative Lowry's bill is not upheld, wants to keep county committees, county election commissioners, Is there anybody else doing a, you know, petition for it to be a ballot initiative just from the people? Is there anything to keep them from doing that? No, no. This
▶ Play
is something that could be initiated just like any other constitutional amendment. And as far as the same time frame, I mean, if we don't pass it out, then they, you know, conceivably could get it done by in time for 2018. You know, what I would just kind of going off from Representative Dotson's comment, and I just clarify, my comments from the well. We do have a different court. I think the new court could uphold it. But before we ever get to that court, and so my opinion would be different than the gentleman who just testified. However, I would agree with him on one thing, is that a lower court, I think, will be obligated to overturn it. So a lower court is going to be bound by precedent. The precedent that was set by the previous opinion is that Amendment 3, or because of of Article III, it would create a barrier to voting. So a lower court, especially if it's brought in the right court, and my guess is that gentleman will find the right court to bring it in, will overturn Lowry's bill. We can't be 100 percent sure, but there's a chance of it. Now, the issue is it would go to a Supreme Court that is made up completely different, and I think it would probably be a little more friendly for voter ID. However, I've got out of the business of predicting courts a long time ago. So one thing that we can know is by doing an amendment to the Constitution, just like the gentleman said, we can be certain of doing it correctly, and it being something that we can provide that security to our constituents, who frankly, I think, are wanting it. But that's my opinion. Yes, Representative Ladyman, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Well, just a couple of comments. Number one, to say that there's no evidence that there's voter fraud out there is just unbelievable to me. I mean, we know that there is fraud in many different places. In the presidential election of 2012, I think it was Philadelphia had over 100% of the voters voted. I mean, how do you say there's no fraud when there's, I think the number was 120% or 115, something like that. There's numerous cases of fraud out there. And I don't know how anyone can say that there's not evidence of that. And most of the people that I talk to would like to see this. I don't talk to a lot of people that are not for this, from my district at least. The other thing, the second comment I want to make, our world is changing. We are becoming more technology-based. If we had voter ID cards or whatever, a license or whatever that was readable, it would make our voter process a lot more efficient, a lot quicker. There's equipment available right now where you can take a card, read that card, and your information will be pulled up. The person at the poll can verify that that picture is you. They slide that card, all your information is automatically loaded onto the machine. It's a lot quicker. It would make the process of voting a lot quicker. So I think that's another reason to move forward with this amendment. The third thing is to make sure that we can bank on this being passed or being a law, we need to make an amendment and not just a
▶ Play
bill. Thank you. Okay. Representative Douglas, you're recognized. Once again, let me just say that we're getting pretty close on time, so we'll need to hear Representative Dodson substitute motion and then get back to getting a bill out or resolution out if we can.
▶ Play
But you're recognized. Yes. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I do think that if you poll the people in your districts, this is very high numbers. It's number one, you say, if you poll it. And, you know, when I heard the gentleman a while ago, he said there was four things that you're guaranteed, you know, or for, you know, rights there, you know, to vote. But when someone comes in and takes my vote without an ID, how were my rights protected? They're not. They're not protected unless an ID has to be shown. So you can give me those rights all day long to vote, to be registered, and all of that. But unless someone shows an ID, that right can be stolen from me. And I think it's time to put this to rest. We show an ID for everything. What is the resistance to showing an ID to vote? Who are we protecting by not showing an ID?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:42:17
I would just ask for a good vote on this. Thanks.
▶ Play
Representative Hammer, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question is probably going to be more to the chair for the purpose of input, if you would. You know, constituents I serve want something done, but they also want the right thing done so it doesn't, you know, turn into a mess. So my question to you is this, Ms. Chair, if I may. Sure. Just so I've got the logical process in place. Representative Lowry's bill gets gone, and in all probability, based on testimony in here today, chances it'll be sued. This constitutional amendment gets out of here, and if it mirrors it, and Representative Lowry's bill gets sued and, say, is defeated, by this being out there, at least the voters would have the ability to know whether they're going to have a chance to vote on this or not, and that's going to be two years down the road. So we've got kind of a system in place where the voters can react to what happens when Representative Lowry's bill gets sued. Is that a correct
▶ Play
interpretation? Yes, to some extent. And so what we'll have is that if this resolution makes it out of the committee and then it also makes it out of the Senate, you know, we've got it done, then at that point it will not go into law until after 2018. So irregardless of what happens with the lawsuit, if there would be a lawsuit on Representative Lowry's bill, if that makes it out of the Senate, then that is still on the ballot for the citizens. If it were to get overturned, then the citizens would have the opportunity to vote for it on the ballot. If it's, you know, there may be a chance that somebody wouldn't want to bring a lawsuit on it, since how the citizens are about ready to get a chance to vote on it anyway. I don't know. We'll have to ask him if he's ready to sue on it, irregardless of whether we pass this resolution out. But what we'd be assured is the citizens at least had a chance to make the decision on that.
▶ Play
And, Mr. Chair, my comments to that then is I'd like to put it in the hands of the citizens and let them decide, and if somebody chooses to, that will be on them, but we need to put it before the people and let them decide, so I speak positive
▶ Play
for this. Thank you. All right. Representative Dotsam, do you still want to make a substitute motion? I would, Mr. Chair. We haven't talked you out
▶ Play
of it. Okay. What's your motion? I would make a substitute motion that we consider a due pass on HJR 1011. Okay.
▶ Play
We have a substitute motion of a due pass on HJR 1011. Is there any discussion on that motion? All right. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, say nay. Nay. The nays have it. Okay. So having that substitute motion failed, we're back to the original motion. Is there any discussion on the original motion of Representative Ladyman for the passage of HJR 1016? Reverend Saban, you are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And
▶ Play
I promise I'll be brief because I know we're running out of time here. But I do want to talk about this particular amendment because it's truly only get a chance to refer one constitutional amendment out from the House every two years. And the question is whether it's really necessary to put this one forward to the voters. I understand that there's a perception maybe that this kind of voter fraud exists because of what we hear in the media and all of that. But the truth is that while there is voter fraud, Representative Bladyman, it's just not happening, you know, through voter impersonation. It's just not something that we see happening. And were somebody, you know, really intent on committing voter fraud that way and pretending to be Representative Douglas, it would be just as easy to create a fake ID and to go vote that way. But that's simply not what's happening. But on the other hand, you know, what we do see happening is voter disenfranchisement when voter ID laws are adopted. We saw that here when people, you know, who don't drive, you know, who are maybe older or who are confined to certain living situations, they don't have a driver's license and they show up at a polling place and they don't have an ID and they don't know how to go through the procedure or to the point made earlier, the people who are there to assist don't know how to instruct people on how to do a provisional ballot, ultimately they're disenfranchised. They don't take the time to either, you know, go back home to get an ID to fill out the provisional ballot or to do what's necessary to actually cast that ballot. And so the effect of adopting a voter ID law often, and we've seen that here in Arkansas, is to take away people's right to vote. And I think we need to be really careful about that. I think there are things that we can do through statute to maybe try to achieve some of the goals that we all share to assure that our vote is protected. I think automatic voter registration, for instance, is a way of consolidating state databases so that when people do apply for a driver's license, they're automatically registered to vote. When they have to have, you know, ID for things like EBT and other, again, services that they are registered to vote. And therefore, you know, any time that somebody's identity is being verified for any kind of state service, they're registered to vote. And that accomplishes a lot of the same goals. But again, I think the intent of this clearly is good. I mean, I know we're trying to protect our vote, make sure that people who, you know, who they are when they're casting their ballot and we're counting their vote. And that makes sense to me. But enshrining this in the Constitution, making this the one provision that the House refers to the voters to change our state constitution, and adding a qualification to what is a guaranteed constitutional right, both at the federal and the state level, to me is going too far. And I would just urge the committee to vote against this. Thank you.
▶ Play
I do appreciate you recognizing that the intent is honorable. That's not always the case. Representative Leidyman. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
I'll be brief on this, but, you know, the main opposition to voter ID is that it disenfranchises people from voting and that they're not able to get an ID. And I do not like to get personal, but in this case, I feel like I need to. I have a son who is in the Human Development Center. He's now 40 years old, but he has a mental capacity of five to seven-year-old. He has a voter ID. He got one when he was seven. It's very easy. Many of his friends who are in the HDC have a voter ID. It is easy to do. If people in the Human Development Center that have a mental capacity at five years old is capable of getting an ID, a picture ID, I think most anybody is capable of doing that. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right. Representative Sturge, you're recognized to
▶ Play
be the last person I recognize. We can go back to the motion. Well, I was just going
▶ Play
Speaker 71 1:48:55
to ask a question, Mr. Chair. We've all been talking about how important these issues are and how we need to be more deliberative. asking, is there a way that we couldn't just table all these until Friday until we make a final decision while it's two days to review?
▶ Play
I think as far as for scheduling purposes, and in fact, at this point, this is an idea and concept that's been on the table a long time. It's been something that has been debated and has been thought through at this point where I'm ready to move forward with a motion. I'm talking about all three in general. Yeah, but that's it. I'd still say we have a motion that's on the table right now, and I'm ready to move forward with that motion. Okay, we have a motion on the table, which is a motion to do pass HJR 1016. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed, say nay. Nay. No. All right, ayes have it. Congratulations. Representative Lunchtime, you passed your resolution.
▶ Play

Agenda

HJR1003 Gillam AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS THE CONSTITUTION CONCERNING PROPOSED MEASURES AND CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS CONSIDERED BY VOTERS AT AN ELECTION.

HJR1008 Dotson AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION TO PROVIDE THAT THE STATE HIGHWAY COMMISSION SHALL BE GOVERNED IN THE SAME MANNER AS ALL OTHER STATE AGENCIES.

7:24 - 48:12 111 segments 12 speakers

HJR1011 Drown AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNING THE APPLICABILITY OF ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION, AMENDMENT 33, TO INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER LEARNING.

48:12 - 1:18:12 85 segments 10 speakers

HJR1016 Lundstrum AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION CONCERNING VOTER IDENTIFICATION WHEN CASTING A BALLOT.

1:18:12 - 1:49:49 103 segments 18 speakers

SJR8 Irvin A CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT LIMITING CONTINGENCY FEES AND AWARDS OF PUNITIVE AND NON-ECONOMIC DAMAGES; AND CHANGING THE POWERS OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY AND THE SUPREME COURT REGARDING RULES OF PLEADING, PRACTICE, AND PROCEDURE.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Speaker 1
1 segment
Representative Bob Ballinger Chair Unverified
61 segments
Representative Dan M. Douglas Unverified
13 segments
Speaker 6
1 segment
Speaker 15
1 segment
Representative Jim Dotson Unverified
39 segments
Representative Kim Hammer Unverified
22 segments
Representative Warwick Sabin Unverified
25 segments
Representative Dwight Tosh Unverified
2 segments
Representative Brandt Smith Unverified
1 segment
Representative Andy Davis Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 71
15 segments
Representative Jeff Wardlaw Chair Unverified
37 segments
Speaker 105
1 segment
Representative Trevor Drown Chair Unverified
16 segments
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
25 segments
Speaker 140
2 segments
Donald Bob Unverified
14 segments
Speaker 147
1 segment
Representative Robin Lundstrum Unverified
16 segments
Representative Jack Ladyman Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 157
1 segment
Speaker 158
1 segment
Speaker 12
1 segment
Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson Chair Unverified
3 segments
Chris Burks Unverified
9 segments
Chair Unverified
1 segment