Revenue and Taxation Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (30)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
SB140
· 8 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…this meeting's called to order, and we're going to look at Senate Bill 140. I think everybody's probably heard this once or twice. So…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1014
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1014 Leding TO CREATE THE TEACHER'S CLASSROOM INVESTMENT DEDUCTI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1028
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1028 Lemons TO EXEMPT CERTAIN BUSES, COACHES, AND OTHER MOTOR VE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1031
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1031 Bentley TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX EXEMPTION FOR INCENTIVES RE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1037
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1037 T TO REGULATE THE SALE OF TAX-DELIQUENT PROPERTY FROM BIDDI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1153
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1153 Boyd TO CLARIFY THE MEANING OF "ACTUAL AND OBVIOUS ERRORS"…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1221
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1221 Sabin TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE SALES AND USE TAX EXE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1225
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1225 Magie TO REPEAL THE EXEMPTION FOR AND REQUIRE THE DISCLOSUR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1227
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1227 Farrer TO REDUCE INCOME TAX RATES IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES;…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1252
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1252 Rye TO AMEND THE INCOME TAX DEDUCTION ALLOWED FOR MEDICAL A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1253
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1253 Wardlaw TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT THAT CERTAIN RETAILERS PR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1263
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1263 Jett TO CREATE A SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTION FOR PARTS FOR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1395
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1395 Leding TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR TAXPAYERS THAT EM…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1396
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1396 Leding TO EXEMPT FROM THE INDIVIDUAL INCOME TAX EDUCATION S…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1397
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1397 Leding TO EQUALIZE THE SALES TAX TREATMENT OF DUES AND MEMB…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1399
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1399 Ballinger HONOR ARKANSAS VETERANS ACT OF 2017.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1409
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1409 House TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION FROM THE INCOME TAX FOR SERVIC…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1412
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1412 BallingeR TO PROVIDE FOR A PARTIAL PROPERTY TAX EXEMPTION F…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1449
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1449 Dotson TO AMEND THE ANNUAL FRANCHISE TAX FOR CORPORATIONS T…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1512
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1512 Davis TO REDUCE THE INCOME TAX RATES APPLICABLE TO INDIVIDU…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1531
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1531 G. Hodges TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR EDUCATIONAL LO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1535
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1535 K. Hendren TO AMEND THE DISTRIBUTION AND USE OF SALES AND U…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1559
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1559 Jett TO AMEND THE CORPORATE INCOME TAX WITHHOLDING REQUIREM…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1565
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1565 Jett TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE ISSUANCE AND EXPIRATIO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1582
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1582 Dotson TO EXEMPT CERTAIN ELECTION EQUIPMENT FROM SALES AND…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1644
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1644 Tosh TO CHANGE THE FILING DEADLINE FOR FRANCHISE TAX REPORT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1647
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1647 C. Douglas TO EXCLUDE MANUFACTURER REBATES ON MOTOR VEHICLE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1649
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1649 C. Douglas TO AMEND THE SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTION FOR NEW…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB114
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB114 Hester TO AMEND THE NOTICE REQUIREMENTS RELATED TO PROPERTY…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB120
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB120 J. English TO AMEND ARKANSAS TAX LAW CONCERNING INCOME TAX…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 13, 2026
Okay, members, this meeting's called to order, and we're going to look at Senate Bill 140. I think everybody's probably heard this once or twice. So we're going to try to keep the testimony short and sweet as possible, but we also want everybody to have fair and honest open debate. So as we go along through this process, everybody keep in mind that everybody's on kind of a time schedule, and let's don't chase rabbits, but also give our colleagues the responsible approach to what they're trying to accomplish.
Representative Gray, I understand you have an amendment you want to offer. Members, if you look on your tablet on Senate Bill 140, I think the amendment, it'll be Amendment 219 if you want to bring that up. Does everybody have that? Everybody but me? Mr. Chairman. Yes, sir
Yes, but I don't
Representative Gray, I'm reading different language in this amendment than you offered up last time, sir. Can you use your
microphone, please? We've added one additional, but we've also changed some language to address the issue
that DFA brought to the table last time, so I'm making sure that that fits the- Are you going
to present this amendment? Yes, sir. Yes, sir. Can you go to
the end of the table and start, please? Mr. Chairman, the amendment, not to delay as much as we have already, I apologize.
The amendment to Senate Bill 140, very similar to the same amendment we presented a week ago to designate a small portion of potential revenue that's going to come out of the collection of this existing sales tax to specific needs. We, to further define those, we're basically asking that $25 million of these collections
be designated as follows, 50% of that $25 million to the Miscellaneous Agencies Fund to be used exclusively for rural fire protection and police protection grants. 50% each for those, 31 and 4 tenths percent to be designated with an account within the Arkansas Medicaid Program Trust Fund to be used exclusively for the Alternative Community Services Waiver Program, better known as the fund that would address the Disabled Disability Waiting List, 10% of that to the Department of Education Public School Fund account to
be used exclusively for Arkansas Better Chance, or better known as Pre-K, and 5% of that $25 million to be designated exclusively for grants to after-school programs. And 3.6 tenths of that present to a designated account within the University of Arkansas Pine Bluff Fund to be used exclusively to provide the required state match for land-grant universities under the Ag College Act of 1890, pointing out that Pine Bluff is the only land-grant
institution in the state that is not receiving funds for this match. I also addressed the language that DF&A was concerned about, but Representative Hendren is not here today to let him know that. The question was, we already have people who have a presence in the state that are collecting, that are remitting sales tax, and that there were some questions of how this bill would affect that. And DF&A determined that was $15 million, so we have excluded that group of revenue
from this amendment. With that, I'll
take any questions. Thank you, sir. Reference Section 6, under this code 2651-201, in 19-5-202, you're talking about 4.5 percent down to 4.5 percent for income tax rate deduction. Is that what I'm reading here, sir? I did not hear any of that in your testimony.
No, Mr. Chairman, what that is is addresses legislation passed in the 90th General Assembly that designated that the first X million dollars would go to a reduction in the income tax. This is basically language just to reconcile with that, so it would not contradict earlier legislation. Okay. Could I get DFA
to go down, please, and explain this? Paul, once again, it looks like you've got the short straw.
When you get down, Paul, please take a look at Section 6 and walk us through that. I mean, I'm sorry, Section 7, and walk us through
Speaker 24
7:04
that. Mr. Chair, Paul Gehring, Assistant Revenue Commissioner for the Department of Finance and Administration.
Under Section 7, this appears to be an amendment to existing law that's located in 2651-201. This code section was a part of a 2015 bill passed by in the regular session that provided that the sales tax collections from out-of-state retailers, if those sales tax collections were compelled by a change in federal law, the collections that were over and above $70
million dollars in current law would be utilized to provide income tax rate reductions to the 4.5% rate. The way that I'm reading Representative Gray's bill is that that's going to increase that threshold to $110 million. So the excess under this proposed amendment would be the excess of those sales taxes collected from the remote sellers, the taxes over and above the $110 million would be utilized for further reductions of the income tax.
Okay. So, Paul, it's fair to say that this is an amendment also to the current income tax rates. Is
Speaker 24
8:32
that fair to say? It alters the change. It alters the existing provision in 2651-201E to make the threshold $110 million instead of the current $70 million. The excess sales taxes over and above $110 million would be dedicated for purposes of reducing the 4.5% rate.
So nobody has a crystal ball here. So what we're looking at, we're seeing we don't know how much money is over $110 million plus the total money of Section 8. There's really no way of knowing what kind of money
Speaker 24
9:13
we're talking about here. Is that fair to say? DFA will not provide any type of estimate of what is going to occur in the future as to online sales tax collections. As Representative Gray mentioned, we do have the $15 million per year that we are, we're
estimated to collect for the 2016 tax year from the streamlined sales and use tax agreement. We have approximately 3,200 taxpayers that are signed up pursuant to the agreement, but But we could not certify with any type of certainty that all of those individuals that are signed up through Streamline have no physical presence in the state of Arkansas. There is an it's quite possible that when that a given taxpayer signed up with Streamline,
they may have established a physical presence following their registration with Streamline. So that is about the only number that we can provide. Once, if Arkansas enacts this proposed legislation in Senate Bill 140, in terms of gauging the impact of increased sales tax collections, it would be impossible for DFA to estimate what those collections would be. Thank you, sir. And I know this is
a very hard question for you to answer because you don't have the numbers in front of you. But if you drive this income tax rate down to 4.5 percent, realistically, you're looking
the $300 to $400 million what it's going to cost. Is that correct? Would you agree with that? I agree, Mr. Chair. So basically get it down, make sure we're clear, to drive this down to 4.5%, it's going to take from general revenues $300 to $400 million to do that? That's correct. Okay, thank you.
Representative Dawson, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and I apologize I was a little late if this has already been covered, but my question on this is the $70 million that was originally in this bill
that this amendment was striked through, can you explain to me why that number was in there? It seems to me as if it had something to do with reducing the grocery tax or something originally, And it is not necessarily necessary if we're, under current law, if we're reducing the grocery tax and offsetting that with DSEG payments as it's currently set up. So this is kind of a redundancy factor in the law, if I'm understanding it correctly.
I think you're understanding it correctly, Representative Dotson. So I guess my question would be, or follow up if I may, why would we increase that amount? to $110 million, as opposed to reducing that amount to if we're already taking care of that grocery tax with DSEC payments. I would
question. Representative Dodson, that's an absolutely perfect question.
And then my question when we asked to have this amendment drafted, I can answer your question and to the Chairman's comments about this section. $70 million is a number that the 90th General Assembly plugged into legislation sponsored by Representative then-Representative Link to say if the federal law was such that we were allowed internet sales tax collections that the first $70 million would be used to offset the reduction in the grocery tax. If we, in fact, find a way through DSEG money or other avenues to reduce the grocery tax,
And then that bill that is already on the books would have to be looked at to see where that $70 million would go. So this amendment won't affect that. The only reason it is in this amendment is because of existing law. We could not be contradictory with existing law. The increase to 110 is in deference to that bill that was passed by the 90th General Assembly to say that in that bill, after $70 million in collections, it would go to Mr. Chairman's
point. We passed in the 90th General Assembly that after $70 million in collections, any collection passed that would be used to reduce the sales tax rate or the income tax rate to what it is equally to a rate of 4.5%. The reason that we're at 110 is with the 70, the 25 million that this amendment has to designate to certain revenue, and the 15 million that Department of Finance has used as a number that is already being collected from participants that are already collecting and remitting
sales tax revenue. So if you take the 15 and the 25 and add it to the 70, that's where you get the 110. to not be contradictory with law that we passed in the 90th, that's why you have to put that number there. To the chairman's point, if federal law is such that we start collecting, there's already legislation in place that would reduce this rate. This amendment is just basically operating with the parameters of legislation that's already there. Mr.
Speaker 35
14:30
Vice Chair. Yeah. Let me ask you this.
We already clicked, I think the number I've got is $252 million for
Speaker 37
14:37
the businesses in Arkansas already. Does this coming, your new amendment, does it come
out of that? No, this would be new revenue, Joe, new sales stats collected. And that's how it's designated to, we set aside the $15 million that DF&A already says that they are collecting online and included that in the 110 number. So this is new revenue coming in upon internet sales collections.
Members, any other questions? Senator Fowles, Representative Douglas, do you have any questions for the
Speaker 43
15:16
sponsor of the amendment? No, just comments, speaking against it at the appropriate time.
Yes, sir. You'll be recognized then. Any other questions, members? Representative Fowles, I'm sorry, you just got a promotion. Mr. Fowles, you recognize. I won't
Speaker 43
15:37
I'm treading lightly. Just some brief comments, and we talked about this the other day. We can do this in RSA already. I feel like that this muddies the bill on a constitutional level. If this goes to a challenge and actually does get challenged, I think this makes it more difficult to defend, and it looks like a redistribution of revenue as opposed to just a policy decision. And I think that's very important because that is one of the main reasons that we're pushing forward with this language.
And other than that, I'm just asking the committee for a clean vote on the bill. If we don't have the clean vote on the bill, I can't determine if we need to do this. I think this is damaging, and I'll let Representative Douglas speak further on that. Thank
you, members. President Douglas, you're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Committee members, we can argue this back and forth, but on the merits of the policy and the needs for some of these appropriations,
where the money needs to go, we all know that we have needs in these states and everybody has different viewpoints on it. The thing is, let's get to the political reality of it. But if we attach this amendment, if we pass this bill out of here with this amendment, the political reality is that it doesn't get off the House floor. I don't believe, and I think most of you don't either, that with the political sentiment
for no tax increases and putting limitations on where this money goes, it's not going anywhere. It's going to die. There's old saying to cut off our nose to spot our face. I think that's what we'll be doing here. Everybody, some of us want tax cut reductions. Some of us want certain items funded. But we have the right to do that every time in the budget cycle.
We have the right to petition the governor or argue with the governor that, hey, this has to be included in RSA. We have the right to build coalitions. What we have here is something I've always heard of a conundrum. I've never really seen one, but I think this has all the smellings of one, because on the one hand, we attach the amendment, you get out of the committee what you want, but then it dies on the House floor. To use a Charlie Collins analogy, we all want a
piece of the pie, but if we never put the pie on the table, there's nothing to get there. So what I would urge, what I would ask, is that we do not attach the amendment, vote against the amendment, send a clean bill out of here that we can pass on the House floor, and then work together, work together to try to come up with solutions for some of these funding needs.
That's what we do every time in budget sessions when we do the budget, and that's what we're charged with. That's kind of the way it was set up, the process. So with
Speaker 49
19:06
that, that's all I've got to say. Thank you. President Murdoch, you recognize her.
Speaker 50
19:11
Thank you, Chairman. All right. Representative Douglas, appreciate your candor and the politics of the situation. And that being what it is, it makes sense that we, in trying to determine that certain
things happen specifically in certain areas, that we try to, in the legislative process, in the committee process, target those areas. You talked about the politics of the day that we are well aware of and that we are victims or benefactors of, depends on how you look at that. And so therefore, it makes all the sense that we put a good amendment on a good bill to make it better. And I hope that the politics will not prevail and that when it goes to the floor, if it
makes it there, that our colleagues will perform better than you think from a political standpoint, and they will make a good decision for good reasons, for good purposes. If you look at those amendments that was in this amendment, it's good. It's to help people. It's nothing to hurt anyone, and this is distribution of new revenue. Absolutely. We do it all the time through various processes. So I think we would not be representative if we sat here and did not in the proper process,
the legislative process, demand what we should demand at the proper time in the proper way. So respective of what you're saying, that's what we're doing. We're trying to do it in the manner that's proper to properly represent the
people that we're here to represent. And Representative Burdock, I do respect where you're coming from. I understand that, sir. I just have grave concerns, as we all do, that there's other ways to fight for these needs.
and some of these I strongly support along with you all. I strongly support some of them, and I would do everything in my power, and I hope that I have presented the character that if I say I'll do something, I'll damn sure try to do it. I'll do my best. Yes,
make this happen, and I appreciate that. I don't think we'll have that opportunity with the amendment on there, with all due respect to my colleagues, sir. Thank you. Okay.
Members, or people, does anybody in the audience want to speak against the amendment, for the amendment? Representative Gray, you want
to close for your amendment? Yes, sir, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Thank you for all the questions. I absolutely respect and appreciate the gentleman at the end of the table and give deference to the comments they made and respect the courage that both of them have shown in bringing legislation to address bringing this new revenue on an existing tax. So, gentlemen, thank you.
Mr. Chair, members of the committee, I would, being respectful and mindful of Representative Douglas' comments, I would say to you that the people on the waiting list, the members of the fire departments or police officers that would benefit from grants from this amendment do not care if it is a Democrat or Republican amendment, they would just appreciate the help. So I would ask you to help attach this to make this bill better, and I appreciate that. Thank you.
Members, I think we've about beat this horse plumb to death twice. Do I have a motion? I'd like
adopt the amendment. Representative Gray makes a motion for the adoption of this amendment. Any debate? All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, say no.
Speaker 56
23:12
No. Call the roll, Ms. Eden. Representative Warren.
Representative Watson. Representative Gray. Representative Flowers. REPRESENTATIVE JOHNSON, REPRESENTATIVE FERGUSON, REPRESENTATIVE EVES, REPRESENTATIVE HENDRON, REPRESENTATIVE
Douglas. Rep. Hodges. Rep. Sabin. Rep. Bragg. Rep. Armstrong. Rep. Dotson. Rep. Dotson. Rep. Representative Bolts. Representative Murdoch. Representative Collins. Representative
Representative Farrar. Your motion has failed or the amendment has failed, sir. Senator Fowles, are you ready to proceed?
Yes, sir. I'm sorry, Senator Fowles, are you ready
Speaker 43
25:06
to proceed, sir? Yes, sir, are you ready? Yes, sir. I don't want to, I appreciate the sentiment and understand the background on why you guys are trying to do what you're trying to do, and I do respect that a lot. I will tell you that I will try to help in these areas if I can at any juncture because I think these things are important to not just the folks that you represent
but the folks that all of us represent. Having said that, I think this is the right thing to do moving forward with a clean bill going to the floor, and I think it has the best chance of passage both here and then in concurrence on the Senate side. I'm not going to go back through the merits. I think we all have heard it and have heard from people, but I do think it's time that we do what's right by all of our cities and counties. I've heard from numerous mayors, other people that will be positively affected by this, and I would appreciate your support on it.
I'll defer to Representative Douglas as
well. You're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. We all know what the bill does and the merits of it. We all know, I feel like, that it's the right thing to do. A gentleman yesterday in testimony sitting right over here, can't remember your name. I apologize, sir. made the statement that he is a property owner in his area was having a millage increase that was going to cost his business $4,000 a year. And the reason they're having to raise the millage
is because the tax revenue or base is declining. If they were collecting the proper sales tax revenue, that would not happen. That's one of the best examples I've heard of how this affects other taxes. We don't want to put more burden on our people. We need to pass this. It's very important. We can fight for our individual desires, our individual priorities in other
ways, but I would urge this to go to the House floor. I would urge a yes vote to get this out, and let the Assembly as a whole decide. Thank you. Members,
any questions? Anybody in the audience? I think we have some people signed up to speak. Against the bill is Mr. Josh Waters and the audience want to speak against the bill. Please recognize yourself, sir, and when you get situated, proceed.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is Josh Waters. I'm an attorney for Political Strategies, Conduct for Actions, our client. I first wanted to begin by saying I respect Representative Douglas and Senator Files. I know they've worked really hard on this, so I do respect all the work that they've done on this, but I am here to speak against SB 140. I spoke last week about the constitutionality of this, so I'm not going to go back over that.
But in the interest of time, I deferred some arguments that I wanted to present. So I'm going to present those today. First, I wanted to talk about and provide a couple of examples of the real-life implications of what this bill will do. First is an example I thought of of a college student who's buying textbooks for their college courses. A single book may cost up to $200. A sales tax of up to 10% in some places in the state would mean that that would be $20 more
that they would be paying if they bought this textbook online. If they take five courses, that's five textbooks for $1,000. If this bill is passed and the Supreme Court changes the law or federal law is changed, That is $100 difference that the college student is no longer going to have. $100 to a college student is a very big deal. That's probably 10 or 11 meals. Another example I was thinking of, a single mother sits down at 9 or 10 o'clock at night for the first time all day,
and she needs to buy some products, some paper towels, dryer sheets, toothpaste, razors, whatever it might be. These items, let's say they cost her $40, and the sales tax in her area is the 10%. That's $4 more that she would have to pay. I don't think she's going to see this new tax and suddenly get in the car and drive to a store. She's tired. It's 10 o'clock at night, and she's just going to pay that tax. And that's $4 less that she would have on what is probably a very strict budget. Another example, well, I'll skip that example, but my point on that is for ordinary people all
across the state on strict budgets, this new revenue generation, we do consider a new tax, but I know there's some disagreement on that, will hit them the hardest. Most people in this room, including myself, may be able to afford this new amount that we're going to be paying, But for many hardworking Arkansans across the state, they will fill this new tax on every online purchase that they make. These examples I've highlighted, I just wanted to show kind of the interest involved.
Myself or Conduit for Action has any financial interest to gain by seeing this legislation pass or fail. I do understand and appreciate the frustration that some business owners are facing, you know, in the environment that we're in. with people going to more online shopping rather than in brick-and-mortar stores. However, I don't think that taxing people more is going to suddenly start pushing them into those stores. I think they will still decide to purchase online due to the convenience of shipping straight to their home.
I think this bill would simply mean that they have less money with which to make purchases. If you want to cut sales taxes for these other businesses, I guarantee you won't be seeing me down here at the end of the table speaking against that. Um, one other issue I wanted to address is, um, kind of the purpose of a sales tax. Um, we believe the sales tax is levied against persons in a specific location to make sure that those persons benefiting from those local government services are paying towards those benefits. With online purchases, however, the seller is not in the location and is therefore not
benefiting from those local government benefits. Um, the box stores in the locations do benefit from the roads, the sidewalks, the emergency and police services and other local government benefits from which an internet company in another state does not benefit. In the bill, it argues that the money is needed to support infrastructure for state and local services, but I wanted to present this scenario. A private person is at their private home using their private computer with their private internet, making a private purchase from a private company.
Nowhere in that transaction does the government provide any service in which they should be paid a tribute through the sales tax. The government coming into that process to tax it will only stifle further innovation on the internet of things to come. I also wanted to address a resolution. I think Representative Hendren mentioned before a resolution that the Benton County Republican Party had passed in opposition to internet sales tax. In just this week, the Washington County Republican Committee of Arkansas also
passed a resolution opposing specifically this bill, and I wanted to read a portion of that. Whereas the members of the Washington County Republican Party of Arkansas believe in a firm regarding taxes, the Arkansas Republican Platform of 2016, which states, without the rights to private property, individual rights are diminished. As such, we recognize the importance of lower taxes not only to spur economic growth, but to ensure that individuals reap more of the benefits of hard work. Whereas the members of the Washington County Republican Party of Arkansas believe in
inform the following regarding the internet and specifically stating the National Republican Platform of 2016, which states, we want government to encourage the sharing economy and on-demand platforms to compete in an open market, and we believe public policies should encourage the innovation and competition that are essential for an internet of things to thrive. We will will consistently support internet policies that allow people and private enterprises to thrive without providing new and expanded government powers to tax and regulate so that the internet
does not become the vehicle for dramatic expansion of government power, end quote. Whereas the members of the Washington County Republican Party of Arkansas believe in a firm party objectives, including the preamble of the Washington County Republican bylaws and setting rules as the fulfillment of the needs of the citizens of Washington County in a manner consistent with the beliefs and principles of the Republican Party. Therefore, be it resolved that the members of the Washington County Republican Committee hereby advise our elected officials at the national, state, and county levels as direct
representatives of the people to resist and oppose any legislation that would impose in any form a new or increase in taxes or fees, including taxing of internet sales, and to specifically resist and oppose the following pending legislation. Mr. Waters, I think we
all kind of get to jest. We've got a long ways to go here, too, sir, so I'm not trying to be belligerent to you. But certainly don't want to.
We understand where you're going. Okay. And then it goes on to specifically cite SB 140 in the opposition.
So I did want to point that out as well. I'll go ahead and go to my conclusion. I would appreciate that, sir. Sure. If this legislation passes, combined with other legislation passed impending this session, many around the state will be paying more taxes than what they're paying coming into this legislative session. I don't think that's what voters anticipated when casting their ballots just a few short months ago. According to the Tax Foundation, Arkansas has the third highest sales tax burden in the country at an average of 9.3% state and local sales tax rates.
Please do not make this an even heavier burden by passing this legislation. If we are looking to other states to find a way to generate more revenue, why not look at other states for tax cuts at the same time? At the end of the day, this bill will mean one thing. Consumers in Arkansas will have less money and the government will have more. For these reasons, I ask the committee to vote no on SB 140 at this time. I appreciate your time.
a question, sir? Okay. Representative Collins, you recognize? Thank you, Mr. Chair.
I just have to make sure whenever somebody gets at the end of the table and says a bunch of things which sometimes don't line up with the truth, that we get closer to the truth. So I want to go to the woman that you described. She's in her room, she's exhausted, she's got her kids, she's poor, she's buying things on the internet, and there is a use tax that she owes that was established in 1949 that she's supposed to be paying. And I want to make sure I understand what you're requesting
her to do. You're saying, please violate the tax laws of Arkansas. This is a yes or no question, sir. Are you encouraging her to violate the use tax laws of the great state of Arkansas? Because as a Republican, we also have things about law and order. So that's It's a yes or no question. Are you encouraging her to violate our use tax law, sir? No, I'm
not. I think there is a separate bill that addressed the use tax,
and so I'm speaking just on this sales
tax. Sir, there's a use tax that exists in Arkansas today when she orders on the Internet. Are you encouraging her to violate the use tax law of Arkansas? Yes or no? Please. No, I'm not
advocating that she did. I think the reality, though, is for many people out there, this tax will be automatically applied when they check out, and they're going to feel that. They're going to have less money than they have, but I'm not advocating anyone to violate the law.
Thank you, Mr. Waters. I appreciate your testimony. Thank you. Mr. Joe Donaldson, speaking for the bill, and I would ask the audience, we certainly want everybody to have a due course in their say, But please keep it short as possible, in the interest of time, please. Thank you, Mr. Chairman
and committee. I will keep this very short in respect to your time. My name is Joe Donaldson. I own Stams Furniture in Springdale, Arkansas, and I'm also the current president of the Arkansas Furniture Association.
Senate Bill 140, collecting tax online purchases, honestly is an absolute must for small business brick and mortar to continue growing. People say it's a tax increase, I've heard that mentioned this morning. As Representative Collins just mentioned, it's not a tax increase, it's already in law, but who's going to take it upon themselves to report themselves to pay this tax? Absolutely nobody. The only person who's paying the penalty, well, the state's paying the penalty as well, but small businesses are for us not collecting this tax, for us not following through.
I'm one small business. One small store in Northwest Arkansas does about $20 million a year. Last year I tracked almost a million dollars of sales walking out the door with customers on their phones asking me to drop the tax because they can find the same product online. It's absolutely an unfair practice of business from the moment I open my doors in the morning. I'm starting off with a 10% disadvantage to an online company, yet I am the one that's paying the property tax and the rent and hiring all the people in our local economy.
I assume nobody would justify saying that's okay that our brick and mortar stores that are supplying the jobs and the economic growth in our area should start off with a 10% disadvantage from day one. This last year in Black Friday, for the first time since 2000, as online sales have grown, just in the furniture industry, just in my industry, online sales on Black Friday, there was more furniture bought and sold online than out of brick and mortar stores. We're heading in the complete wrong direction.
Our legal system, our laws are not supporting the growth of our local businesses and that breaks my heart because that's how our country and our state got to where we are. I will close with two things. The gentleman just spoke was talking about lots of facts. Here's one fact. Pulled from the state and local sales use tax revenue losses, e-commerce sales in Arkansas from 2007 to 2012, we lost $520 million in five years. We're one of only about six states left, from what I recall, that are not collecting sales
tax online. Why are we not one of the 40 that's leading the way? Amazon even took the steps to voluntarily start collecting. They see the writing on the wall. It makes sense. It is not fair for the small businesses' brick and mortar. So I just ask and urge all of you to think about the businesses that are growing our state and that are supporting you guys, our lawmakers. Help us stay in business and grow our businesses. Thank you. Thank you, sir.
Mr. Paul Calvert, you want to testify, sir?
You're signed up to speak against the bill.
Thank you, committee. My name is Paul Calvert. I'm from the Faulkner County area. I am not a lobbyist, at least not a paid lobbyist, and I don't even work for the government. So the government's not even paying my check to come down here. I think it is a valid concern that many of these brick-and-mortar store owners have in regards to the state and local sales taxes making it unfairly difficult for them to do business
and compete with online sales. I think it's a valid concern. And I think that might be an indication that we should take a look at our tax structure and that if it's causing so much harm to our local businesses that maybe we should change it. Because I think it is clearly rather harmful to local businesses, and I don't like the idea that it is causing an undue disadvantage to local businesses, because I think tax policy
in general should endeavor to not interfere with free markets. So I think the obvious solution is to just abolish this harmful tax policy and either use it as an opportunity to cut government or else transfer it to some other taxation scheme. I would be okay with increasing income taxes if that's needed. That might make me kind of unpopular there, but I'm okay with that if we need to do that.
There's also some concern that internet sales are reducing the funding of local city governments. I'm actually in favor of that. I really don't like the way that so many city governments seem to be kind of bastions of left-wing policy that violate property rights. I'm a landlord up in Faulkner County, and the city of Conway there, some of the city codes are just plain property rights violations. So I'd suggest we pull this bill down, or vote it down, and then restructure the tax
program, such a tax policy, so that local businesses can compete fairly, rather than actually starting a new way to collect taxes unfairly. And I think it is a new way, and I think it's actually an unconstitutional way. I realize that some are suggesting that these people are already obligated to pay these taxes, but I would argue it's actually unconstitutional and illegal for the state of Arkansas to collect these taxes due to Article 1, Section 10 of the U.S. Constitution, it says no state shall, without the consent of Congress, lay any impost or duties on imports or exports,
except what may be absolutely necessary for executing its inspection laws, and the net produce of all duties and impost laid by any state on imports or exports shall be used before the use of the Treasurer of the United States. I think any of these taxes are collected. Actually, you have a duty to send them to the U.S. Treasury if you're going to collect them. Either way, I think it's illegal for you to collect them in the first place. I suggest that I ask that you vote this down, please. Thank
Mr. Scalbert? Seeing none, thank you, Mr. Scalbert. Okay, we have Mr. Darrell Crutchfield to speak for the bill. Thank you,
Mr. Chairman, committee members. Go ahead, sir. Recognize yourself. I'm sorry. My name is Darryl Crutchfield. I'm past president and chairman of the Arkansas Home Furnishing Association. I'm also operations director for Johnson's Warehouse.
We're a furniture company in South Arkansas with seven retail stores. I'm not a politician. I'm not a lobbyist. This is the first time I've ever got up and made a statement even in a committee, but I'm here today because I'm concerned. And I'm not just concerned about the furniture industry, I'm concerned about small business. When you look up and down Main Street of small towns that Arkansas is full of, it's your
furniture stores, jewelry and gift stores, your hardware stores, even your grocery stores that are competing on a daily basis with out-of-state remote sellers that are putting us at a 10% disadvantage every day when we open our doors. The tax is already on the books. This is a question to me of fairness. At what point do we do what's right?
We get all bogged down in where does the money go, where does this happen? Where does that happen? The big picture is small business in Arkansas is struggling, especially South Arkansas. When the economy's good, South Arkansas is usually on the verge of a depression then, in all honesty. I'm going to keep it very short. We need a fair playing field. That's all we want. The tax is already on the books.
We want to collect what's owed. And just because it generates a new revenue stream does not mean it's a new tax. The tax is already there. Seventy years ago, we had catalog sales. Today, we have the Internet we're having to address. You know, 20 years from now, who knows where we're going to be? SB 140 will catch Arkansas up to the present. and I would just ask for a vote yes for SB 140. Thank you, sir. Members, anybody
honest, will speak against the bill? We have one more person signed up. I think it's Mr. Don Zimmerman. Is that correct? Yes, sir. You're recognized, sir. He's speaking, Mr. Zimmerman, speaking for the
Speaker 96
47:07
bill. Well, that's why you're signed in. Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of committee. I'm Don Zimmerman with the Arkansas Municipal League. I'm here on behalf of your 500 cities and towns across the state who are vitally interested in SB 140. This is much needed at the local level. We don't have
an issue with how you all spend the state portion of this money, but your local communities vitally need a fair playing field for their local businesses. The local businesses are the backbone of your communities across the state. Most of your cities and towns depend on the local sales tax as their primary source of funding, local public safety, infrastructure, the needs at the local level. We need this bill passed. We need the businesses to have a fair opportunity to
compete. When they generate good sales tax returns, it helps their communities. The state will benefit. I appreciate the article that was in the Democratic Gazette on Monday, which talks about how we need to take advantage of this opportunity that's been presented to us in the form of expanding to pick up this revenue that really is supposed to be being paid currently. I can't overemphasize the importance of this to your cities and
towns in Arkansas. So we would appreciate a favorable vote and a due pass on Senate Bill 140. Thank you, sir. Okay, thank you, sir. Anybody
else will speak for or against the bill? If not, what is the pleasure of the committee? I'm sorry, I'm sorry. We've talked so long, I forgot where we were, Senator Files. You're free to close for you, Bill.
Speaker 43
48:57
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'll keep it short. I disagree with those who came down and encouraged people to break the law by not paying the tax. Dramatically disagree with them for that. I don't agree that it will stifle innovation. Here's what I look at when it all comes down to this. This is not a Democrat or Republican issue. You know, we come down here and we make a lot of caucus decisions. we make decisions based on what's right for somebody or what's right for this group or that
group. What I can tell you is that this bill is right for Arkansas. And it doesn't matter if you're a Democrat or Republican. I can promise you those small business owners in your district, whether they're Democrats or Republicans, they need this to happen. It's not fair to them. And I really can't, you know, we've all taken flack for voting for this from those who I think misinterpret the law. And there's a few that interpret it correctly and still give a little little grief, and I get that. That's part of our job. But I'm asking you not to look at this down
a party line, but to look at this as the right thing to do. And if you believe that this is the right thing to do, please vote for it. And if you don't believe it's the right thing to do, vote against it. I respect that too. But don't pigeonhole this into, well, all the Democrats voted for it. I hate when I go back home, somebody asked me a question, and the response to why some bill didn't fail is because some group got against it, and there were people in that group that I felt like were with me, and I felt like believed in the same things I did, but they voted against
it because they felt like they were being pushed that direction. So I would encourage and ask for a good vote. Let's see where this goes on the House floor, and then let's work together on the
backside of this to help the working people of Arkansas. Thank you. Thank you, Senator Files. Members, I think we're
down here to the bottom end of it again. What's the pleasure of the community. Mr. Chair? Yes, sir. Could I do a closing statement or two here? I'll keep it quick. Thank you. Okay. Members, what we heard here about the student that'd be paying more for his
textbooks there. Well, we've heard higher ed also say one reason tuition is so high, because we hadn't had state funding. We've got to have the money to do that. If we have more revenue, we might be able to give additional funding to higher education. We heard about the single mother who's going to be paying more for her internet purchases while she's sitting at home ordering. She may be sitting at home because the local store where she could have
worked is closed because of an unfair advantage of the online retailers. We have to take care of our state. You know, we have to take care of our local businesses. And it's not a Democrat or Republican issue. It's an Arkansas issue. And, you know, I don't know. We passed medical marijuana I didn't know we realized we'd start smoking it yet, but some of this stuff, let's do away with taxes, that's fine.
Which school you want to close? Which prison you want to shut down? Are we going to draw lots to throw people out of nursing homes? How are we going to fund these issues? We all know that. But let's take the approach. Let's pass this. Let's get it out. Let's get it on the House floor, have a good debate there, and then let's fight for our individual priorities and our group priorities and work together to try to make Arkansas better.
And we can't do it on the back of destroying our local businesses. Thank you. With that, Mr. Chair, motion at the proper time? I'll take your
motion right now, sir. Okay. Move do pass. And it's going to be do pass as amended because Senator Fowles amended
this bill. Do pass as amended by Senator Fowles' amendment. Thank you, sir. Is
there any debate on the motion? All in favor say aye. Aye.
All opposed, no. No. Senator Fowles, sorry again. The bill has failed. Representative Collins, you're recognized. Mr. Chairman, I have a motion. Let me hear
your motion. I move that we expunge the vote by which SB 140, as amended, was defeated. That is
a proper motion. Stand by just a second. Members, that is a debatable motion.
I'm recognizing that motion. So we have a motion on the floor on the table to expunge the vote, and that's two-thirds of the membership. Any debate? What I would,
Mr. Chair, if I could be recognized, the reason that I'm moving that we expunge this vote, and I think it is a good idea to expunge the vote, because I think there's
a lot of discussion that happened today, and I think we need further discussion to understand how a lot of these pieces fit together. And by expunging this vote, we position ourselves to have that discussion. If we don't expunge the vote, I don't think we're in nearly as good of a position, and I think everybody's going to
get hurt. Yes, sir. Representative Gray, you're recognized. Mr. Chair, I'd just like to voice that I concur with Representative Collins. I think it's a very reasonable position to take and discussion will be here in support of the motion.
Thank you, sir. Members, anybody else debate on the motion? Okay, we all know what the motion is. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Okay, the motion does pass. This will be expunged and I expect this to come up again. Thank you, Senator Fowles. Representative Douglas. Representative Douglas. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. You're welcome. Members, that was fun. We're down to, and we have one more bill, and it's going to be House Bill 1644.
1644. Representative Tosh.
Representative Toss, give everybody just a brief moment to clear out of the room. Please take the conversations outside of the committee room. I would appreciate it.
Representative Tosh, just give me just a couple more seconds. We'll get everybody kind of calmed down. Members, once again, this is House Bill 1644, I'm sorry, yeah, 1644. Representative Tauss, recognize yourself, sir, and feel free to
proceed. Thank you, Mr. Chair and colleagues. Mr. Chair, with your permission, I'd like to have Secretary of State Representative
here, Ryan Norris, at the table with
Norris with Business and Commercial Services for the Secretary of State. Colleagues, this bill here is a business-friendly bill. This bill was brought to us by the legislative audit out of BLR to the Secretary of State. And this bill, like I said, has a positive impact on our businesses. what it currently, under current law, the businesses have to file a franchise audit report.
They have to do this not only at the end of their fiscal session, but also the required again at the end of the calendar year. So basically what they're having to do is file two reports that contains the same information and try to relieve that burden from them and obviously take instead of them having to pay twice for an accountant to do their books, we're going to try to make it easier for them to say you can do it one time and that will be at the end of your physical year, whatever that may be.
As you well know, some businesses, the end of their fiscal year is December 31st. Others is from June the 30th, July the 1st. So to prevent any confusion and any duplication, this bill serves that purpose. If there is a fiscal impact, it's a positive impact on the businesses. and not on the state. And I would be open for any questions. Thank you, Representative Tosh. Members, any questions? Representative Armstrong? Motion
at the proper time, Mr. Chair. Got it, buddy.
Anybody in the audience want to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Armstrong, you're recognized for your motion, sir. I'd like to make a motion. Do pass. Representative Armstrong has a motion. Do pass. Any debate, members? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, Representative Tosh, you passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair, thank you, committee. Members, with that, that's all we have on agenda, and I hope you guys have the rest of a good day. This meeting is adjourned.
Agenda
REGULAR AGENDA Subtitle Number Sponsor
HB1565 Jett TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE ISSUANCE AND EXPIRATION OF GROSS RECEIPTS TAX PERMITS AND THE COLLECTION OF UNPAID TAXES UPON DISCONTINUATION OF BUSINESS.
HB1512 Davis TO REDUCE THE INCOME TAX RATES APPLICABLE TO INDIVIDUALS, TRUSTS, AND ESTATES USING THE REVENUES DERIVED FROM THE COLLECTION OF SALES AND USE TAX FROM SELLERS THAT DO NOT HAVE A PHYSICAL PRESENCE IN THE STATE.
SB140 Files TO PROVIDE FOR THE COLLECTION OF SALES AND USE TAX RATHER THAN USE TAX ON SALES BY CERTAIN REMOTE SELLERS.
HB1535 K. Hendren TO AMEND THE DISTRIBUTION AND USE OF SALES AND USE TAX REVENUES.
HB1559 Jett TO AMEND THE CORPORATE INCOME TAX WITHHOLDING REQUIREMENTS FOR MEMBERS OR OWNERS OF A PASS-THROUGH ENTITY.
HB1644 Tosh TO CHANGE THE FILING DEADLINE FOR FRANCHISE TAX REPORTS
HB1647 C. Douglas TO EXCLUDE MANUFACTURER REBATES ON MOTOR VEHICLES FROM THE DEFINITIONS USED FOR PURPOSES OF DETERMINING SALES AND USE TAXES.
HB1649 C. Douglas TO AMEND THE SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTION FOR NEW MOTOR VEHICLES PURCHASED BY NON PROFIT ORGANIZATIONS OR WITH URBAN MASS TRANSIT ADMINISTRATION FUNDS.
DEFERRED BILLS Subtitle Number Sponsor
HB1028 Lemons TO EXEMPT CERTAIN BUSES, COACHES, AND OTHER MOTOR VEHICLES FROM SALES AND USE TAXES.
HB1031 Bentley TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX EXEMPTION FOR INCENTIVES RECEIVED UNDER THE COMMUNITY MATCH RURAL PHYSICIAN RECRUITMENT PROGRAM.
HB1153 Boyd TO CLARIFY THE MEANING OF "ACTUAL AND OBVIOUS ERRORS" ON THE PART OF A COUNTY ASSESSOR IN THE ASSESSMENT OF REAL AND PERSONAL PROPERTY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1221 Sabin TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTION FOR SALES BY A CHARITABLE ORGANIZATION.
HB1225 Magie TO REPEAL THE EXEMPTION FOR AND REQUIRE THE DISCLOSURE OF CERTAIN FREEDOM ADVERTISING OF THE PROMOTION AND TAX UNDER RECORDS INFORMATION ACT OF 1967
HB1252 Rye TO AMEND THE INCOME TAX DEDUCTION ALLOWED FOR MEDICAL AND DENTAL EXPENSES; AND TO REMOVE THE THRESHOLD FOR CLAIMING AN INCOME TAX DEDUCTION FOR MEDICAL AND DENTAL EXPENSES.
HB1263 Jett TO CREATE A SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTION FOR PARTS FOR AND REPAIR OF AGRICULTURAL EQUIPMENT AND MACHINERY.
HB1227 Farrer TO REDUCE INCOME TAX RATES IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES; AND TO REDUCE INCOME TAX RATES BASED ON THE GROWTH OF INCOME TAX COLLECTIONS.
SB114 Hester TO AMEND THE NOTICE REQUIREMENTS RELATED TO PROPERTY TAXES; AND TO AMEND THE REQUIREMENTS FOR PUBLISHING NOTICE OF DELINQUENT TAXES ON MINERAL INTERESTS.
HB1399 Ballinger HONOR ARKANSAS VETERANS ACT OF 2017.
HB1409 House TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION FROM THE INCOME TAX FOR SERVICE PAY AND ALLOWANCES OF FOREIGN SERVICE PERSONNEL.
SB120 J. English TO AMEND ARKANSAS TAX LAW CONCERNING INCOME TAX FOR SERVICE PAY AND ALLOWANCES OF FORIEGN SERVICE PERSONNEL.
HB1037 T TO REGULATE THE SALE OF TAX-DELIQUENT PROPERTY FROM BIDDING ON OR PURCHASING TAX-DELINQUENT PROPERTY
HB1253 Wardlaw TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT THAT CERTAIN RETAILERS PREPAY SALES TAXES.
HB1412 BallingeR TO PROVIDE FOR A PARTIAL PROPERTY TAX EXEMPTION FOR DISABLED VETERANS IN PROPORTION TO THE EXTENT OF THE DISABILITY OF THE VETERAN.
HB1395 Leding TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR TAXPAYERS THAT EMPLOY A RECENTLY RETURNED VETERAN.
HB1396 Leding TO EXEMPT FROM THE INDIVIDUAL INCOME TAX EDUCATION SCHOLARSHIPS, AWARDS, AND GRANTS FROM NON PROFIT VOLUNTEER SERVICE ORGANIZATIONS.
HB1397 Leding TO EQUALIZE THE SALES TAX TREATMENT OF DUES AND MEMBERSHIP FEES FOR CERTAIN CLUBS AND FACILITIES; AND TO LEVY A SALES TAX ON DUES AND MEMBERSHIP FEES TO CERTAIN FACILITIES AND CLUBS.
HB1014 Leding TO CREATE THE TEACHER'S CLASSROOM INVESTMENT DEDUCTION.
HB1449 Dotson TO AMEND THE ANNUAL FRANCHISE TAX FOR CORPORATIONS THAT ARE IN PROCESS OF LIQUIDATION.
HB1531 G. Hodges TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR EDUCATIONAL LOAN PAYMENTS FOR QUALIFIED INDIVIDUALS AND EMPLOYERS OF QUALIFIED INDIVIDUALS.
HB1582 Dotson TO EXEMPT CERTAIN ELECTION EQUIPMENT FROM SALES AND USE TAXES; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Joe Jett Chair
Unverified
Speaker 9
Speaker 10
Chair
Unverified
Speaker 24
Representative Jim Dotson
Unverified
Speaker 35
Speaker 37
Speaker 43
Speaker 42
Representative Dan M. Douglas
Unverified
Speaker 49
Speaker 50
Speaker 56
Representative Charlie Collins
Unverified
Joe Donaldson
Unverified
Paul Calvert
Unverified
Speaker 92
Darryl Crutchfield
Unverified
Speaker 96
Representative Dwight Tosh
Unverified
Speaker 108