State Agencies & Governmental Affairs
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (1)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
SJR8
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SJR8 Irvin A CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT LIMITING CONTINGENCY FEES…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 13, 2026
Chair, see the quorum. All right, I appreciate everybody who did show up to deal with this. As we've talked about before, we are amending the Constitution of Arkansas. It's a big deal, and so it is appropriate that people would show up and take part and be here for the debate. I first would like to recognize a couple people in the room that I've seen, and particularly I think that they're superstars. but one is the Chief Justice Kemp is here, over here, and Justice Womack is here as well.
So I don't see any of our distinguished justices, so I appreciate them coming today, and I'm sure we probably will get a chance to hear from both of them or at least one of them at some point today. So I will actually be running this resolution, so I'm going to hand this over to the co-chair and let him recognize me and let him take care of trying to keep this train on the track. So I'll turn that over right now.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. If you would, you can present your bill. You're recognized to present your bill. I think there is an amendment to the bill. So is that amendment on the computers? Have you got that on your computers? Yes. Okay. There's also a hard copy that's been handed out. There's extra copies of the amendment at the end of the table. Is that correct? If you need a copy of those.
Representative Ballinger, you're recognized to present your amendment. Okay. This is an amendment
to Senate Joint Resolution No. 8. And something I meant to say is that if there are anybody here or if there is anybody here who wants to speak for or against, they should make sure they get signed up so that we know about it. But all right, so the first thing is running the amendment. What I'd like to say is that, you know, members and even members of this committee, but the members of the body in general, you know, you all have asked for amendments.
And I just want to say we heard you loud and clear. You know, I had committed from the very beginning to carry the Senate's resolution exactly the way the Senate wanted it. So it was hard for me to commit to doing anything at all. But we have senators who heard and understood the concerns that we had and were willing to make amendments to their resolution, I think, to make their resolution better. And frankly, just to be completely honest, I think the way the resolution was before,
we probably could have got it done. However, I think it would have caused some dissension and division within our body more than what is necessary. And I frankly think that these amendments are going to make it even better. So let me start by I'm going to go over the amendments, which could be a little bit difficult to get in the whole body of it. But I'm going to do that slowly, and I'll take any questions that you want. And then after we adopt the amendment, assuming that we do adopt the amendment, when I go over the bill, we'll be able to reference back to the amendment. So you guys do have a paper copy of
the amendment in front of you, I think. And if you don't have one, you're welcome to get one. But that's what we'll do. So starting off at the start of the amendment, you see that there is a subtitle here. Well, the reason why this is getting amended is simply because we amended the bill, so it makes it consistent with the bill. So if you go on down to the very first amendment underneath that, and it actually amends with page three, it deletes line seven, and it replaces it. Well, what that does is there was some question of diminished capacity and what
that meant. I think that clearly it was not, it didn't take that out of economic damages. It is part of economic damages, but it's unnecessary for the language. And so essentially what we've done is take the language diminished capacity out just to provide some clarity there so that we're not in a situation where we're creating undue confusion. So if you go on down past that line four or page four, line seven, I'm sorry, page three, line 24 is the next one. That's where we actually have increased the cap from $250,000 to $500,000. And both of the caps in this,
both on the punitive damage and the compensatory damages have been doubled to $500,000 from $200,000. And I do understand that there's still some people who aren't happy about that, but because of your work and your concerns and you working with us, we have, I think, got something that's probably a little more fair and, frankly, is going to be something that the public, I think, will have an easier time understanding and going forward with. So that's the change in that. If you go to page 4, line 7, that's where you see the other change from 250 to 500,000.
And then page 5, you're going to delete lines 1 through 14. And what this does is this changes the way we were doing the rulemaking authority. So before, the court would have to make a rule and then come and present it to the legislature for approval. And I understand, I mean, what I've told people several times is I want the court to be able to run their own business. I don't want us in the day-to-day operations of the court. I want us to be able to, like what happened prior to Amendment 80 and some Supreme Court decisions, there was a lot of deference given from the legislature to the court for them to manage their own business.
So from the very beginning, that was a position that I wanted to hold. Even if we had the authority to manage their day-to-day business, like prior to Amendment 80, I wanted them to have the ability to do that. I wanted that deference shown. Well, what we've done is within the constitutional provision basically done that. So they can have their own rulemaking authority. However, if we are in a situation where we want to do things like, you know, modify the caps or do joint several liability or do, you know, there's been a lot of talk of rule 11. I think rule 11 is great. It's probably not something we'd want to put in the Constitution, but it may be something that we'd want to we'd want to encourage the courts to try to work, do more work on and adopt and do some stuff.
That's essentially is a is a way that the court can do a loser pay that actually will function and work through sanctions. Well, if we wanted to encourage Rule 11 to be more utilized, we could do things like require continued education for Rule 11 or whatever. There are some things that you can do just as an example that we'd still be able to do some things. We just wouldn't have the day-to-day operation. I think someone used the example of the font size of pleadings. If they want to change that, we don't care about that. Let the court handle that. And then, you know, if they decide to go to size 4 font,
maybe we want to try to address that, but I don't expect that to happen.
down, that's on the next page. It's kind of where that continues. And then you see where we use the $500,000, $250,000. We had to amend that in the title to make it reflect, the ballot title, make it reflect these amendments. And that's basically it. And I'd be happy to answer any questions on the amendments or the amendment. Okay.
Are there any questions from the committee? Hearing none? Representative House, you're recognized for a question. Any other questions from the committee? Hearing none, Representative Wardlaw recognized for a motion.
Have a motion by Representative Wardlaw do pass on the amendment. All in favor say aye. All opposed? Motion carries. The amendment has passed.
All right. I appreciate that committee. All right. So now we're going to go to the actual resolution or actually am I recognized to run
the actual resolution. Sorry, Chair. Yes. Representative Algier, you are
recognized to represent your bill. And Mr. Chair, if I start trying to chair from this end, you have my permission to slap me around a little bit. Okay. So SJR 8 is the resolution that the Senate has proposed to us
and offered to us. We all understand we've talked about the new rule change. The Senate gets one resolution to amend the Constitution. The House gets one resolution to amend the Constitution. and, you know, we're kind of trading them out. Early on, I told them that, you know, it's not up to the House to choose a resolution. However, we do have an obligation and a job to decide whether or not it's something that is going to go out from this body. I appreciate the Senate being willing to make the amendments it has, and like I said, I feel like it makes it a better resolution. But let me go over and try to explain it and then answer any questions,
and I'll try to keep it just as short as I possibly can. Okay, so if you'll go to page two of the resolution, The first part of it deals with contingency fees. And what this does is this sets a cap on the contingency fees at 33 and a third percent. And something that I want to make sure that we point out is that one thing that I appreciate about this, and from a fundamental standpoint, and folks who I've had a conversation with, the reason why I support this, the reason why I like this resolution,
is I think it puts the policymaking back in the hands of the legislature. legislature. It's the body that should be setting policy. It's not, I mean, it's not our job to decide what the rules of civil procedure are, so long as they don't, don't, don't functionally change the policy that should be set for the state. And so, you know, within this, this gives the ability, you know, if you look down on lines 31 through, through 33, it gives you ability to amend this. So, you know, if this is a, is something that down the road, we find that it actually has some negative effects from a policy standpoint, then the legislature has the ability
to make some changes on that. So, um, you know, that's the thing that is attractive about this to me is ultimately we should set policy and we should let the, the, the judicial branch then be the, be the referee, be the ones that, that get to decide, you know, how the law is applied rather than, you know, basically what the laws ought to be. All right. So if you see on, on, uh, and by the way, I want to say again that I believe our court does a pretty good job of that. And right now, I mean, there's nobody, probably very few people in the state that's more excited
about our court than I am. So page two, that's what that provision does. And let me say this, that if the committee has any questions as I go through it, that's fine, or I'll go back and I'll answer any questions. So either way, however the committee wants to handle that, I'm good with that or the chair. All right. So on page three at the top, we deal with the non-economic damages, the definition of that. And if you see the first amendment that we deal with is on line seven, and that's when we deal with the definition of non-economic damages. We took that word out. So if you look on line seven, you look at the last four words, it says the word physical impairment,
that was taken out. So we wanted to take that out so that we didn't get in a situation where it's confusing about whether or not physical impairment would be considered non-economic damages, depending on how it's, you know, it all functions. Okay, so then you look on down. So that's where you have some definitions. And then you come on down that you get into sort of the meat of it starting in line 20. And it deals with the punitive damages awards. If you look and you know, if you have a pen, you want to write on line 24, which says 250,000, that's been changed to 500,000. So punitive damages is now a cap of whichever is more 500,000, or three times what
the compensatory or non-economic damages are. And then, so that goes on down. One thing that is also an exemption is, you know, intentional acts. If you mean to hurt somebody, that is taken out of this altogether. So, you know, OJ Simpson wasn't convicted for criminal charges, but then did get nailed for wrongful death. Well, that kind of activity, there would be no limit on punitive damage for that type of stuff. Um, you then back here at the bottom, you know,
in section three, it says, you know, that basically we can amend it with three fifths vote. We can, we can change this. Um, the caps are, are something that we can debate about and we can change. And I've had a lot of people who, who've had different opinions about what the, what the cap should be. And, and I think that there is good debatable points of whether the cap should be a million dollars or whether the cap should be $250,000. I think that's really debatable, and I think we should debate it. One of the things that this resolution does is it gives us that opportunity to have that debate, to say what should caps be.
And so, you know, over the next few years, I think as a legislative body, we have a responsibility to look and watch and see how this policy is affecting our citizens, and then we should come back, and if there is a reason to change the caps, we should change the caps and alter the caps. One thing I do want to say is that oftentimes we are calling them, and I'll call them caps, and they are caps. However, they're also floors. So these caps, as put in this resolution, can't go down. So they're fixed unless we come back and amend the Constitution some other time.
The caps can't drop from where they're that currently. Okay. Okay, so once again, if you come down to the next line 4, D1, we deal with the non-economic damages. Those non-economic damages, once again, the cap is raised from $250,000 to $500,000. And then if you go down, you notice on line 12, it once again, it's an issue that with three-fifths majority, I'm sorry, two-thirds majority, sorry, of each house, they can actually
amend these caps. So you have the ability to come back and make amendments to the caps if it's something that we're looking at and we need to change that. So starting down in E1, it actually makes it where the General Assembly has the ability to set rules and practices and procedures for the court. Like I said, I'm a person who believes the court needs to manage its own business.
We shouldn't be implementing rules, practices and procedures for the court unless it's something that from a policy standpoint, we need to do in order to effectuate the policy that our citizens have asked us to carry out. And so what will happen is that we will have enabling legislation like any constitutional amendment. If this were to go to the voters and the voters approve it and it passes, we'll have enabling legislation that we'll have to do. Some of that enabling legislation under the current Amendment 80 would be considered rules, practice, and procedure. And so we have to define the fact that we have the ability to do that. After the first year that
will have it. So 2019, all that is done by a simple majority vote. After that, it will take a three-fifths vote to make any amendments or change it. The first, in 2019, the caps can only be changed by virtue of inflation tied to the consumer price index. And then after that, then they could be raised by, you know, if we look at it and we say that we want to raise the caps and we can do so with a two-thirds vote. All right. So if you go down to page five, lines one through
14, this is the area that got amended. What is in your resolution before you has some language for review and approval of rules practice procedure of the court. That has been taken out. So there's no longer a requirement for us to review and approve the rules. They have the ability to make their own rules and and we don't we don't approve them the only situation is that they were to adopt something that you know is that we look at and it run afoul of whatever policy the decision that we feel like as a state then we
would have the ability with three-fifths vote to make a change to that but but on a day-to-day basis we won't be won't be in their business like like I said so and then just to make it clear on lines 15 through 17 that if we were to enact something that's directly rules practices procedure would supersede something that the court would enact then the next of the this there's a couple things that's kind of just cleanups you know the severability so for some reason there was something in here that was not upheld then it doesn't
mean the whole thing gets thrown out and then down here it deals with the effective date so this wouldn't be effective until January 1st of 2019 and then the rest of it deals with the ballot title and puts forth about ballot title, which has been amended to make it consistent with the meat of the resolution, which we've just went over. I know that's a little bit confusing. It is something that we've kind of been wrestling with. So I think almost everybody has a 30,000 foot view of it. And then we kind of got a little bit into the weeds on that. And I may not be the best person in the world to answer questions on
it, but I have worked hard to try to get to the point where I can. So
I would be happy to answer as many questions as you guys have. Okay, Representative Ballinger has presented his bill. Are there any questions from the committee? Representative Dobson, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. Something you just mentioned toward the end, you said that if a rule is adopted by the General Assembly, it supersedes a rule enacted by the court?
That's correct. Would the court have the authority to come back and overturn that rule or change that rule? Or that superseded deal that it's enacted by the General Assembly would stand? No, it
would stand. And that's why we have to amend the Constitution to do that. And, you know, for years, for decades, our state has existed in the situation where the court had this type of authority, or the legislature had this type of authority. And then in the late 90s, they did Amendment 80, which shifted that authority over to the court.
And then I think that, you know, it maybe went further than what was probably really considered because it was just shortly after that that the legislature introduced and passed a package of tort reform bills that since then had been ruled unconstitutional because they declared them rules, practice, and procedure. And so what this does is that is the provision that would take that out. So if it's something that the legislative body, you know, with the supermajority says, you know, we need this. This is something that needs to be done in order to effectuate the policy that we're given from our, you know, constituents.
Then that policy would stand over what the court would want to do. Thank you.
Okay, Representative Sabin, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Ballinger, are
there caps that currently exist that these are changing right now? No, there are not. Follow-up, Mr. Chair? Yes. Just curious, so why not trust juries to assess the facts in each individual situation and decide what the appropriate damages should be instead of creating an arbitrary cap?
That's a good question, but what I would say is that one of the things that we do is we set policy, right? So we tried to decide things like, I mean, every day in judiciary, we, today, in fact, I passed a bill off the House floor that will be going to the governor's desk that created actually a new offense. And what I've told by, you know, all of us who voted for it, I think almost all of us did vote for it, except for a few people I saw vote present, Mr. Womack. But anyway, the truth is what we did is we told a jury, look, if a person meets these elements, then you're going to send them to jail and send them to jail for a long time, class Y felony.
You're going to get locked up. And why did we do that? Well, we're limiting what a jury can do. I mean, we could actually not put any kind of classifications of a crime on it. we could allow a jury to just kind of make a decision as to how long they think each person should go to jail if they commit offense. And in fact, it also, I mean, like I said, it sets the elements of the offense. So not only did I tell them how long, you know, between 10 and 40 years that they should be locked up, but then I also told them that they could even lock them up, that, you know, if you were to pull a gun and you were to shoot at with the intent of
hurting a police officer, that you have committed a crime. And so I could just not tell them that. I could say, look, you know, these are the facts. Jury, you decide whether this is a crime or not, and then you decide how long to lock them up. And I do trust juries. However, there's a job they have, just like there's a job we have. We have a job to effectuate policy for the state, to decide what is best for our state, you know, in our limited function capacity within our Constitution to do so. And if we can do that on something that's as fundamental right as how long a person spends behind bars,
I think we could probably do that on financial decisions as well. And so the reason why we would do that is because it creates stability. It's because if you go to court in Benton County, you'll get one judgment on a matter like that. If you go to court in Mississippi County, it could be an altogether different judgment. And so that's the thing is what we've done is we've created some uniformity for businesses, for individuals, schools to know that, you know, maybe if there's a, if they get sued, that even though it may cost a lot, 500 grand is a lot of money, they may not have to go out of business because of it. And I
think that that's something that we need to do in order to have the kind of business climate that makes it where people feel comfortable going to business
and being a business in our state. Are there any other questions
from the committee? Representative House, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative In Ballinger, I'm looking on page 3, beginning at line 20, punitive damage awards. Now, this is under the provision, I think, for workers' comp.
Am I reading that correctly? Page 3, line 1, section 32. Correct. Line 1 says section 32, workers' compensation laws. It goes A, and then B, and then C, punitive damage awards for each claimant inaction for injuries. Correct. Am I totally lost? But we don't ever do punitive damage in workers' compensation cases, do we?
Not that I know of. And what we're talking about here is, I think, an anomaly that is within the Constitution itself. But that's the section that we have, the punitive damage awards. Wait, wait, wait. No, sir, this
is underlined language, so this is language that the drafters have added to that section. It's not already in the existing law. No, you're
right. So currently what you'd have under the existing law, I mean, you know how to read it as well as I do. Sure. But you would have Section B, which would be in there.
Yeah. And then you would have Section
C that would be in there as well. and says now we can have punitive damage awards for workers' compensation cases resulting in death and actions for injuries to persons or property including without limitation medical injuries and shall not exceed the greater of five hundred thousand dollars and that's the amendment or three times the amount of compensatory damages so we're now turning our workers compensation system into an adversarial system, which is something we have struggled to always
prohibit. Yeah. Is that what the... What
I would say is that my guess is that we'll have somebody who can speak to that directly. And so if, I mean, that's completely up to the chair, how he wants to handle that. But, you know, either I can continue to answer questions or somebody else can be called up to answer that directly. If somebody knows the... Representative Ballinger, if you'd like
to bring someone to answer that question, that would be
fine. I have Mr. Greenberg here, who's anxious to come and answer that question. Can I see that page?
Yes. Mr. Greenberg, if you would, identify yourself,
please. Hey, Dan. My name is Dan Greenberg. I'm president of the Advance Arkansas Institute here in Little Rock, and I'm also a lawyer. And I think Representative House's question was essentially, why is this under the workers' compensation laws section? Yeah. So the reason is, to make a long story short, is that when the Supreme Court decided that damage limits under the 2003 tort reform bill were impermissible, it looked to this section.
And this section, in my view, provides that there will be no damage limits in workers' compensation cases. Wait, wait, wait, wait. This section, what line are we talking about here?
I think what he's saying is the whole code section, which starts at the top
of the page. Okay, let's, I mean, let's go real quick because we're going to, let's don't have any red hearings here. Line one says workers' compensation laws, actions for injuries resulting in death
or injuries to persons or property. And that resulting in death or injuries to persons of property. That's new language inserted by the drafters of this amendment. Everything that's underlined in here. I'm sorry, Mr. Chairman, I'm taking liberties, if you don't mind. Go right ahead. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The stuff that's underlined is new words, and it looks like we're going to let our workers start suing our employers for injuries. That's the way this exactly reads. Now, tell me why I'm wrong. So
I think I'm going to have to
take about three or four sentences to answer your question, Representative. So the Supreme court, after the 2003 tort reform amendment was passed, decided that there couldn't be any damage limits. And the reason for this decision was the workers' compensation section, in which it says that there can't be any damage limits. And what the Supreme Court interpreted this section as saying is there can't be any damage limits for anything, which is to say it expanded its interpretation
beyond what some might find appropriate and said, not only can there not be any damage limits for workers' comp cases, but there can't be any damage limits in civil cases generally. And so in order to address this interpretation, the drafters of this amendment, in my view, said, you know, the only way that we can speak to this is to address the section that the Supreme Court rested this interpretation on. Perhaps that begins to address your question? And what I would say
is if you read Section B, which is still the, you know, we're not amending the Constitution there,
I mean, it goes back and it specifically limits what can be done, and so that's not changed. So I don't think that we're opening up anything that doesn't already exist or there's nothing new to it. We're just creating a new subsection. So, you know, maybe the argument that you could make is that we should have retitled the subsection. however, of the Constitution. Maybe that would be something, but there isn't anything in there that actually effectuates any change within workman's comp. Well, I've got as good a law
degree as you two fellows do. There's another 25 lawyers in here going to read exactly what I'm seeing, that you just authorized lawsuits by employees against employers the way this is drafted. I would have
is that a follow-up question here? Yes, sure it is. Because it says punitive, and then it goes on to list these things. It's all new language since it's underlined. And I know that in workers' compensation law, we have so many weeks if you lose a finger or an eye or a limb or a life,
And that's how much you get in lieu of being able to sue your employer. So there is a limit on workers' compensation, period. There's no damage. It's just an award that's to keep employees from suing employers, which was a nightmare at the turn of the century. Thank you, Teddy Roosevelt. So could you finish your question, please? And you disagree with this? With your interpretation, yeah. Thank you. Okay.
Representative Sabin, you're recognized for the question. Thank you very much, Mr.
Chair. So previously we've established that no caps exist currently, yet we're writing monetary caps into our state constitution. I was wondering if you could speculate on the realistic possibility that both houses of the General Assembly could muster two-thirds of a vote to ever increase those limitations when I've been lobbied all day long just about wine sales and grocery stores back and forth.
I mean, are we not, you know, possibly setting these monetary limits in stone and creating a situation where it's very difficult for the General Assembly to ever change those limits in spite of inflation and other factors? Honestly, I would disagree. Every appropriation
in Arkansas requires a 75 percent vote. And the reason why we do that is because it's something that's necessary we need to get done. And so we come together, even if we have differences, even if we don't agree on something, most of the time we pass our appropriations. I think that what that does, the higher threshold requires us to look at it and say, yeah, you know what, this is really an important thing.
We need to get together, build consensus, and get it done. So the answer is, you know, I believe this legislative body would be able to increase the caps if there is, if the policy for the state and for the citizens would require us to do so.
Follow-up, Mr. Chair? One follow-up. Yeah, and I'm not trying to be argumentative, but, you know, when I look at a letter like this and every, you know, major corporate entity in the state and the state chamber, you know, wants this, it just, and they employ lobbyists and the average citizen does not employ a lobbyist.
The idea that the legislature would be able to muster the ability to overcome, you know, a strong lobbying push to maintain the limitations as they're going to be currently set in the Constitution and to overcome a two-thirds threshold at that, to me, seems, you know, pretty steep. But, again, you know, I think it's different than an appropriation. Just, you know, if he could speak to the difference between an appropriation vote and a vote to overcome, you know, a big lobbying push by, you know, our state's biggest corporate entities.
Sure. Well, one of the things I'd want to point out is our state's biggest corporate entities supported this bill that provides for the fact it can be amended. You know, the resolution doesn't have to say that. The resolution can say this cap is set in stone, period, and it's not. I think that they realize that it is necessary to provide that kind of flexibility for us to be able to address it. And that's, frankly, that's the thing. The cap is not what is attractive to me about it. What's attractive to me about it is that we can have the policy debates that it takes to be able to effectuate the policy that the citizens ask us to do.
So that's, I mean, I honestly, I believe, I mean, if you look at it, we're dealing with things like implementing medical marijuana in Arkansas. We're doing it on a regular basis. You don't get a lot more controversial than that, besides for maybe wine and grocery stores. And so, you know, it's an extremely controversial issue. But what we're saying is the citizens of Arkansas have said we want medical marijuana, and so because of that, there's a policy direction that needs to go, and every one of those bills take a two-thirds vote. And I've yet to see any one of them fail, I don't think. And so the reason why they get done is because it's something that we know pretty clear
our citizens have want us to implement. Representative Hammer, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. First one I'd like to ask is, and all the
folks on the letter that's been handed out, they're all on board
with this? Yes. Yeah, I think that's exactly what the letter says. To tell you the truth, I haven't read the letter yet, but I think that's what the point of the letter is, that they're all on board and they want to see this get done. I mean, this is the thing. We're in a tough business environment in Arkansas. That's one of the things that we can do to improve that.
is to improve litigation, and every one of those industries and entities wants to see that done. Follow-up, Mr. Chair? Yes,
the list, if you would, please. I guess what I'm trying to resolve, and I'm not an attorney, and obviously by evidence today you can't get two or three attorneys in the room, and they all agree on the same thing. So I guess, first, why would all these folks sign this to Representatives House argument about employees being able to sue employers.
Help me understand why everybody would sign up on this list and
to his point. What I would say is that they probably share more of the interpretation that Mr. Greenberg and I hold of it than the one that Representative House holds. But that's the thing is you typically get three attorneys, you'll have four opinions.
We have a number of people signed up to speak for it, and I guess maybe they can address that, your question, Representative Hammer. Thank you. Representative Gray, you're
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I just wondered, as I think about this, I think about a trucking company.
They get sued. Their liability rates go up. They have to increase so many cents per mile or however it is that they adjust to make up for that. As I think my way through that, that would then affect the end consumer because, you know, if they don't have millions of dollars to pay or to pay for that extra, their cost and liability, that cost gets passed on to the consumer. Is there an economic impact to the average consumer? Do you know what that impact
would be? I don't know specifically, but we can say, you know,
obviously everything costs money. And so, you know, everyone's paying for liability insurance now. liability insurance now has to cover the situation that, you know, it could be the damages could be astronomical. And so what this does is create some stability in the ability for it, for an individual or a business to be able to calculate what that is. And so insurance companies would have to be able to do it. And honestly, the economic impact, and while, you know, the issue that I'm thinking of just as an example, off the top of my head isn't economic, it's really a personal impact.
You know, we have a hospital, a great little hospital in Berryville, is Mercy Hospital, that does, you know, full hospital service and actually used to have one of the best labor and delivery departments in the state. Very forward thinking, very innovative, you know, doing some really neat, you know, from my standpoint, some hands-off stuff that is really good. Well, you know, they couldn't continue to operate that clinic in Berryville because of the cost of insurance, because of the liability. They can't get doctors there to deliver babies. Now, you know, that's a business decision that the hospital had to make,
And, you know, would, if tort reform was there, would that have fixed that situation? I don't know exactly, but it would be a step in the right direction to make it where it's more affordable, where it's easier for them to take the risk to be there and deliver babies. And I had a friend of mine whose wife had a baby there, or had a baby, and they ended up at that hospital, and she was hemorrhaging, and they couldn't take care of her there. They had to transport her out. They actually kind of mishandled the situation because they didn't have anybody there who delivered babies.
And, you know, I don't want to blame anybody in that. And I don't know that it would have made a difference to her. But, you know, the trip to Springfield, she died on the trip to Springfield. And so, honestly, I can't say that there had been anything different in that situation. I'm not saying that, you know, that if we pass this, we're going to save the next Miss Wilhelm. But at the same time, what you can't say also is that that wouldn't have helped that situation. And so, you know, there is an economic impact, but there's also a personal impact. We are the least underserved, one of the least underserved states in the union as far as health care, access to health care.
You know, we spend a lot of money on health care. We're going to continue to spend a lot of money and try to figure out how to handle this. But one thing you can do is just not make it so darn expensive for them to practice here, make it easier for them to come. And, you know, if they don't have, you know, insurance prices that are through the roof, maybe they'll still be able to go to rural Arkansas and practice medicine. So that's, you know, kind of a personal
impact. Representative Hammer, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I
know this may sound simplistic, but I'm a layman. I'm not an attorney. So at the end of the day, this is a constitutional amendment that we're going to refer out of here,
possibly, possibly not. At the end of the day, it'll be referred out, and it's going to go before the citizens in order to vote on. That's correct. We're just trying to filter it to make sure it's the best one because the average person out there on the streets isn't going to have the time that we have in here to have this kind of dialogue, and they're going to trust us. So I'm curious as far as how did you arrive at the numbers that represent the caps, first of
all, please. Well, what I'd say is I didn't arrive at the numbers. You know, like I said from the beginning, I'm carrying the Senate's constitutional amendment.
I'm doing so because I'm the chair of this committee. Now, we've got to decide whether or not we're going to let it out. Now, what I'll tell you is because I do know, you know, how that process was done, there are several states who have caps. In fact, the majority of the states have some form of cap or another. You know, currently Texas has one at $250,000, and I think that that's probably one of the places that we've got the number now. You know, maybe somebody who will speak will give us a little more of a scientific explanation of that. But the truth is Texas has been operating for a long time under a cap of $250,000.
So that's where the numbers started at. The cap of $500,000, where that number came from, was this legislative body. So the House has, and from visiting with several people who requested amendments, that was the number that in order to try to provide comfort to this body, that's the number that we came up to. And going back to kind of the first part of your question, this is something that the voters will decide on. Now, as a member of this committee, I don't think that we lightly
decide this because we can say, ah, the public's going to decide. We still got to be concerned about it and make sure it is the best that we possibly can send out. However, part of the agreement was with the Senate, is that this
is their resolution that we're carrying. Representative Sturge, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Ballinger, I'm looking at page 3, line 27 through 32. Yep. And I guess piggybacking off what Representative House had kind of made mention of, this subsection
seems to kind of try to negate any wrongdoing that was intentional. So there are no caps. From what I understand, there would be no caps if you can prove that the conduct was intentional or that their intentional conduct harmed somebody by negligence or anything else. It's and, actually. You can
prove it's intentional, and then you've got to prove that the Intentional Act harmed them correctly.
Okay. So my question is, does that apply to all civil cases then, or would it just be for workman's comp, since this is in the same subsection.
It would apply to all civil cases. All civil cases brought under this. That's
correct. That's right. Thank you. Okay, are there any other questions from the committee? Seeing none, we have a number of people who have signed up to speak for and against the bill. I think we have four against and two for. The first person signed up to speak against the bill would be Denise Hoggart.
So, Ms. Hoggart, I hope I pronounced your name correctly, but
Speaker 100
41:12
would you identify yourself? Certainly. I'm Denise Hoggart, and I'm the president of the Arkansas Bar Association, and I'm here to speak to you in that capacity. I listened as Representative Ballinger talked about the numbers of attorneys in the room, that they would have differing opinions. But I come to you as the association's voice to tell you that 5,900 members with the, I'm sorry, 5,600 members of the Arkansas Bar Association have authorized me to speak on their behalf
against SJR 8 as written and as amended here today. There are a couple of reasons that are imperatives to the state of Arkansas why we oppose this. First of all is the balance of power and the separation of powers between the judiciary and the legislature, and that is of supreme and significant importance to us as we go forward. you guys are looking at right now defining the future of the civil justice system.
Back when Amendment 80 was passed, it was the combination effort of the Arkansas Bar Association, your Judicial Council, and the legislature working together. Before we made changes to the civil justice system in Amendment 80, we took years of study and work to make sure that the end product that we presented to the people was in their best interest. Today, as I arrived here, I learned of an amendment as it was being
passed out. That's particularly disturbing to me since I had already come and appeared and testified at the Senate hearing, but also because this morning I spoke with Representative Ballinger, and I didn't hear anything about it. So I've had no opportunity to be involved in that process, even though the civil justice system in our profession, as well as the public that we
serve, is impacted by that. Additionally, one of the key things that y'all are addressing in SJR 8, even as amended, is the ability of the contingency fee system to work to provide access to all Arkansans to our courts. The contingency fee system has been working in our state since the beginning of the civil justice system for those folks who can't afford to pay
hourly rates. Arkansas has one person out of every four at the 125 percent level of poverty. Additionally, we have working poor and folks who cannot afford hourly rates. What SJR8 does is take away the opportunity for folks to be able to hire the lawyer of their choosing because you're going to economically limit the types of cases that lawyers will be willing to invest their time
and their resources into. The contingency fee system is something that works that has not been impacted in other surrounding states. So it's particularly difficult in a state of this size with as many folks as we have that have to rely on the contingency fee system. So in that regards, the financing for folks to actually access the courts is very significant.
One of the things that I had hoped was that this body would consider having a study that would be meaningful of this before you presented it, because from my perspective, that's the responsibility to the people is for us to give them the very best possible amendment to choose from. We stand ready as the association to work cooperatively with the Judicial Council as well as with the legislature to come up with something that we think is worthy of
and merits the public's attention through an amendment. This particular amendment, as amended, does not serve the interest of the public. Instead, it serves the interest of a business over the interest of the public. It adversely affects the fair administration of justice. It is an interference, an impediment to the jury system.
It seems to me that I've heard the phrase that it would create stability because we'd have differing counties that would make differing decisions by juries there. Well, juries are the local control. They are the best local control in that situation. One of the things that's so perfect about the jury system is that we have a system of gatekeeper and rules that apply.
So a judge tells us those things that we can bring in as evidence. It doesn't let us rely upon hearsay, but instead it seeks the truth. When you go to the public in a campaign, you won't have those kind of safeguards, and the truth may not be what we find. There's no safeguard except the work that you do to make sure that we give them the best possible options.
I also heard Mr. Ballinger, Representative Ballinger, talk about the fact that this is a policy issue, but it's not. It takes away the rights that the public is currently guaranteed to have under their Constitution. I also heard the issue of economic impact, and I can tell you that there's going to be economic impact when injured people no longer have the ability to recover for their injuries
and then have to rely on the hospitals or public service in order to be able to make it. It will have an economic impact beyond the impact to the rates of insurance being paid by the businesses that have signed the letter in support of SJRA. I'm also confounded by the idea that we want to reduce the standards of responsibility and accountability so that we can attract more folks in here.
If they are the folks who in fact won't operate at our standards, won't be cautious, but in fact will commit acts of negligence that would subject them to liability, then those aren't the folks I would think that we would want. in our state. The Abar Association works very diligently to guard the rule of law, the fair and impartial administration of justice, and the rights of Arkansans.
It's our responsibility to do that in the public interest, and so today we are here opposing SJR 8 as amended and want to make sure that this body will consider the need for all Arkansans to have meaningful access and participation to the courts, which SJR 8 is contrary
to. Thank you. Thank you, Ms. Holger, for your comments.
Representative Douglas, you're recognized for a motion. Yes, Mr. Chair, I'd like
to limit debate to 10 minutes on each side. Okay, it's a valid motion, non-debatable. All in favor of the motion, it's 10 minutes on each side. in favor of that motion, say aye. Pardon, just a minute. Representative Ballinger, would you like to have some time set aside for
sure? I think it has to, yes. Representative Ballinger, how much time would you like?
I am subject to the will of the committee. I would like to reserve time, and so if Representative Douglas wants to make the motion that it doesn't include closing, that's fine. Or if you want to make it where I reserve five minutes of that time, that's fine too. But I would like to have the opportunity to close. Representative Douglas, would
you restate your motion, please? Yes, I'd like to limit debate to 10 minutes on each side and let Representative Ballinger have his closing outside
that time. All right. It's a valid motion. Non-debatable.
All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. Motion carries. Time will be kept here. Remember that questions are included. Ms. Augard, would you take a question or
Speaker 100
50:50
two? Yes, I will. And I also have an article that I've written on this issue that I would like
to distribute as well. Okay. Committee, remember, we're limited on time, so questions should be as short as possible.
Are there any questions? Hearing none. Thank you, Ms. Hobart. To speak for the bill, we have Randy Zook. Randy, I hope I pronounced your name correctly there, but please introduce yourself. It's
Speaker 113
51:29
been treated worse, but that was pretty close. Thank you very much, Representative.
And thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. I appreciate the time to speak with you about this very important subject that is reverberating literally across the state. And I want to thank all of you for the efforts that you have put into this and the attention you've devoted to this really important issue. It is, I think, clearly one of the most promising opportunities you have to improve Arkansas's competitive standing among the states. The letter that's been discussed that's before you comprises the employers of the overwhelming majority of the working population in Arkansas.
And those who have signed it have not done so lightly. They represent thousands of businesses in every part of our state. Many of them are association people with multiple thousands or hundreds of members, as is the case with us, with about 1,100 of Arkansas's most important and significant businesses. Examples run across the manufacturing sector, the trucking industry, the poultry industry, the Farm Bureau, doctors, hospitals, nursing homes.
Just about every sector of the economy in Arkansas is represented on that list, and it grows nearly frequently throughout the day. This conversation, this proposal, is not about one sector or one industry, though. It's about making the overall business legal climate in Arkansas more balanced and less threatening for all Arkansas employers and business owners, managers, entrepreneurs.
It's about creating a climate in Arkansas that enhances the health of our economy, resulting in more opportunity for our children and grandchildren as they continue to build our state. There was a lot of discussion on the other end of the building when this first was discussed down there in the committee about the Institute for Legal Reform ranking of the states in terms of our state liability systems. I'd like to clarify that because the conversation got a little off track.
Arkansas now ranks 41st among the 50 states in terms of the perceptions of our legal climate among corporate counsels and other leading attorneys across the country. It's a poll conducted by the Harris Poll over the last several years, beginning in 2008. From 2008 until today, we have drifted from 34th in 2008 down to the 10 worst list, namely the 41st spot in that climate survey.
This survey affects the perceptions of Arkansas as a business opportunity for countries all around the globe. And today I ask just simply that you allow our Arkansas voters the chance to decide for themselves whether or not to make Arkansas more appealing and more attractive to new and additional business prospects. So with that, I'd be happy to take any questions or close my comments.
You recognize Mr. Hammer, Representative Hammer? Thank you,
Mr. Chair. I think you're the first one to sit to the table that could maybe give input in your capacity about the debate that was had a while ago about employers being able to sue employees. And were you in the room? And if so, could you comment to that if you feel you're capable? You know,
Speaker 113
55:19
I think it'd be awfully dangerous for me, Representative Hammer. I am not a lawyer. You know, I seem to spend a whole lot of time with lawyers, but I'm not one.
And just all of it hasn't rubbed off yet. But I'd be afraid
to tackle that issue. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Any other questions? Representative Sabin, you're
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And Mr. Zook, I apologize for having to ask you this question, but with debate being limited now, I'm not sure I'm going to have the opportunity to ask Representative Ballinger. I did notice in the bill that when it comes to punitive damages, there is an exception where those caps can be blown through if the damage was intentionally inflicted.
But that doesn't seem to be the case for the non-economic damages on the next page. I was wondering if you knew why there are catbusters for the punitive damages, but not for the non-economic damages. You know,
Speaker 113
56:19
again, I'm not the legal scholar here, and I'm a little bit hesitant to step off into that. But I would offer just one thought as a layman and as a business manager, business owner, who's been around lots of different aspects of the economy.
At the end of the day, it's impossible to measure non-economic damages. They perplex all of us. They typically arise in really tragic situations. But at the end of the conversation, at the end of the day, you can't unring a bell. You can't make somebody whole. with the death of a child or the death of an elderly parent, anything of that sort. So I think it's just a recognition, frankly, in the law that there are some things that just can't be measured,
and therefore you just can't leave it completely open-ended. That would be my view of it, and I'd certainly defer to anybody else that has a more informed discussion or opinion of that. Well, I would agree they probably can't be
measured, but they are measured and quantified, and we're setting them in the Constitution, but I'll let Representative Ballinger address that maybe in his close. Thank you. Thank you very much. Are there any other questions for Mr. Zook? Hearing
none, thank you, Mr. Zook, for your comments.
Thank you very much. The next person signed up to speak against the bill is Paul Byrd. Would you come to the end of
Speaker 117
57:58
I'm an attorney here in Little Rock. What I'm here to talk about is the $250,000 cap or the $500,000 cap that can be measured. What you're saying is that my
wife- Mr. Byrd, would you please identify yourself?
Speaker 117
58:12
I'm Paul Byrd. I'm an attorney here in Little Rock, Arkansas. Thank you. My wife stayed home with our five children and was a stay-at-home mother. My My sister was a stay-at-home mother and a home-schooler, my sister-in-law, stay-at-home mother, home-schooler. They do not have an economic history of earning income, and you've decided by this that they're going to only be worth $500,000 no matter how they die, a drunk driver, egregious behavior, horrible death, burns, smoke inhalation, however it happens.
But what I want to also address is you just decided to only make it 10 minutes to talk about a major change to the Arkansas Constitution that's been there since 1874. That's amazing to me to have 10 minutes and I'm having to talk so fast. The other thing is good actors benefit from good law. Bad actors benefit from a law that takes away their responsibility. So the good trucking company that operates properly, that would have better insurance
rates than a bad trucking company, they're going to have the disadvantage now because the bad actor can now operate cheaper, take risks on having more claims, and make the good actor have to now compete in an unfair environment, much less that the victim is left unattended for. If you're going to leave it to the fair market, then let's just not enforce contracts either,
and we'll just go around and tell all the public that this business doesn't pay their contracts when you contract with them. Don't go to court, because that's bad for business and costs money. That's all I have. I don't want to take up your 10 minutes of time. There's other
people. Thank you. Thank you very much for your comments. In recognition of his time, I'd like to recognize Chief Justice Kemp to come and speak against the bill.
Speaker 126
1:00:31
Sir, if you would, please identify yourself. Mr. Chairman, I'm Dan Kemp, Chief Justice of the Arkansas Supreme Court, and I appreciate the opportunity to address the committee today. And I'm not speaking against the bill. I'm speaking specifically against proposal in paragraph 3 or section 3 of the proposed bill. And now as amended, it would be section 3B. So my limits, my comments are limited to section 3, 3B of the proposed amendment concerning the rulemaking authority for the judicial branch.
Neither I nor the Supreme Court nor others in the judiciary offer any comment or position on the other sections of the proposed amendment. One of the grounding principles of our democracy established at the time of our country's founding enshrined in our national constitution and replicated in the constitution of each of the states, including our own, is the separation of powers of each of the branches of government. Separation of powers was adopted out of a fear of the concentration of power
with any one institution or any one person and in order to protect the public generally from an overreaching government as well as to protect individual rights and their individual rights from an overreaching majority. The application of separation of powers throughout our history as a country and as a state has been contentious. The executive and legislative branches get angry and frustrated by the exercise of judicial powers.
The judicial and legislative branches get angry and frustrated by the exercise of executive powers. The executive and judicial branches get angry and frustrated by the exercise of legislative powers. And it's all consistent with the original design of our founding fathers and has served our country, our state, and our democracy well. Section 3, and specifically 3B of Senate Joint Resolution 8, destroys the delicate balance which our state constitution has provided
for the separation of powers within our state government. Article 5, Section 12 of our state constitution provides that the Arkansas House of Representatives and the Senate shall have the power to determine the rules of its proceedings. And I think you would agree with me that if the Supreme Court proposed to you a constitutional amendment, which provided that the Supreme Court should make and or approve all the rules of the House and of the Senate, you would find that proposition unacceptable.
And I agree with you. Each of our branches of government must have the ability to make the rules for the effective and efficient operation of proceedings for which we are responsible under the Constitution. That's why I, the Supreme Court, and all the members of the judicial branch react so strongly to this proposal. the process of rulemaking is a meticulous process in order to maintain fairness and impartiality it's a slow process subject to review by committees which study rule changes and propose those changes to the supreme court which puts them out for comment by the public in the
bar before adopting those rules it's important that the supreme court be fair and impartial in adopting these rules and also to be perceived as being fair and impartial Mr. Chairman, I thank you for this opportunity to make this presentation as to Section 3 today.
Thank you, Chief Justice, for your comments. Representative Gonzalez, did you have a question?
Chief Justice, would you take a question? CHAIRMAN BRYANT, Representative Gonzalez, you're
recognized for your question. REP. REP. REP. REP. REP. REP. REP. REP.
Speaker 126
1:04:46
REP. REP. REP. REP. REP. REP. REP. REP. REP. REP.
REP. REP. REP. REP. REP. REP. REP. REP. REP. Uh, the Rules Enabling Act are Section 28, 28 U.S.C. Section 2071 through 2074. So that act sets it up. Is there any other questions
Speaker 126
1:05:29
get that answered. MR. That's, uh, I believe the Supreme Court makes proposals to the Congress in May, and then those go into effect in December if there's no action by Congress. MR. So
Speaker 136
1:05:52
don't believe it specifically states that in that act.
I don't believe it's specifically stated.
Thank you. Thank you. Representative Gray, do you have a question?
I think the... Thank you, Mr. Chair. And that's my question. It was essentially the same as Representative
Gonzales. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, Mr. Paul Calvert, to speak for the amendment.
me on the four side? No. And how much time is there? There's four minutes left. I don't intend to take really that long. Respectfully, I think the fact is Congress does have the authority to control the policy of the court and the jurisdiction thereof.
Sir, would you identify yourself, please? Yes, sir. My name is Paul Calvert. I am from Faulkner County. I'm speaking here on behalf of myself. The reason why I was really excited about this bill is primarily because of the fact that the legislature would have some power to reign in the courts, I think that's a major problem in this country and the state of Arkansas as well.
And so that's really the primary reason why I'm excited
it. Are there any questions from the committee? Hearing none, thank you, Mr. Culliver. Representative Gassaway to speak against the bill. Representative Gassaway, you're recognized to speak against the bill.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Members, what I would ask you to do as we begin to consider this very important issue is before us of amending our Constitution and balancing the interests of reforming our tort system and also taking care of the victims and the most vulnerable people in our society. And the folks who I speak of are those people who are in nursing homes, those people who
have been severely and permanently injured and disabled through no fault of their own. And we see a lot of people in this room today, many of them have been talking to you over the last few days, and they represent certain interests. But there's hardly anyone down here that I'm aware of who is here to stand up for those people who are laying in a nursing home today, and unable to move, and on a feeding tube,
and unable to speak up for themselves. And so I think that as Republicans, what we know is that we need tort reform in this state. And many of us are not opposed to tort reform. But we have an obligation in this body to do it in a responsible and in a reasonable manner. I've talked to many of you, and I know that many of you are not happy with many of the proposals that were in the original SJR-8, and I don't think that all of the amendments
have satisfied many of the concerns that I have heard about SJR 8. So what I would ask you to do is, as we move forward, to please keep an open mind and that we move forward and consider a reasonable and responsible approach to tort reform in this state. Thank you. Thank
you. We have about a minute left if anyone has a question for Representative Gassaway. Representative Hammer, you're recognized for a question.
So what would, Representative, what would you propose are some of the changes that can
be made to it, given the fact that the amendment that was submitted today?
Well, thank you for that question. And I will tell you, I've been talking with numerous members of our body. I've been talking with the governor. The governor's made some suggestions to me that he would like to see in the form of an amendment. and I have undertaken that task and have been drafting an amendment that meets with what the governor has suggested to me
that he would like to see in an amendment, and I expect that I'll have that prepared very soon and ready for the members to consider, and I think it'll be a reasonable approach. I think we can do tort reform in this state, but we can do it in a reasonable and a responsible way that respects the business interests of this state, but also respects the most vulnerable members
of our society. All right. Thank you, Representative Gassaway. We're out of time. No more time for questions against.
We do have some time left to speak for the amendment. We have about three minutes. Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for the amendment? Hearing none, Representative Ballinger, are you ready to close for your bill?
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And if it is okay with the chair, Senator Trent Garner is going to sit down here,
since he was one of the Senate sponsors, the one who carried the bill in the Senate. Yes, that's fine. And it would be appropriate. Even though he's a senator, we'll let him at our table. Thank you for the privilege. You know, I appreciate you all, and I appreciate you, you know, enduring this. It has been difficult, and, you know, I do, I'm glad that everybody who signed up to speak for and against had a chance to speak. I do think admitting the Constitution is a big deal. I appreciate, actually, the motion to limit debate to 10 minutes because it is something
that we've all dealt with for a long time. And, you know, addressing some of the concerns about, you know, working together and doing a study, this is not something that's just sprung up overnight. In fact, it's most of it is what's been done since 2003 or was done in 2003. And this would be unnecessary if it weren't for the fact that what was done in 2003 has been undone by the court over the next 10 years or so. So now we're in a situation where if the policy that was set in 2013 has been worked on, and when I came in here in 2013 as green as gourd,
but came in and tort reform was an issue that we were working on, thought we had an agreement. A lot of people sat down at the table. Everybody sat down at the table. In fact, it looked like there was an agreement right up to the very end, but it was worked on. Since then, the court has had studies and had opportunities to implement many of the things that we were working on in that. I mean, this is not something that has sprung up overnight. Now, one thing that has happened just today was an amendment to this resolution. Well, why did that happen? It happened because this body that sets policy for the state debated, deliberated.
They said, I like what you have on this, this, and this, but this, this, and this is not right. We need to do something different, and we listened, and so we worked on it. And, you know, taking all those into account, we said, okay, we can come up with something. And so we did an amendment. And that's exactly what's supposed to happen, is we're supposed to set the policy. We're supposed to deliberate. And that's essentially what we have the opportunity to do. There's several things that was mentioned that need to be addressed. Some things I'm not going to worry about even going to. You guys are smart people and have heard all the arguments. There's no reason for me to reiterate.
But one thing that kind of struck me just a little bit is life is important to me. In fact, that's what got me down here. In fact, one of the things that got me involved was a place where I met Mr. Bird. It was at a conference that was a pro-life conference of people from all over the state. and I came down, and that was a, you know, protecting babies, protecting life was one of the reasons why I came down here, and by golly, I think this resolution goes a lot further to protecting life than it does to not protecting life, and it's almost offensive as somebody who is passionate about protecting life, and that cuts me to a chord.
You know, I have a wife who's a stay-at-home mom of seven kids. Well, one is out, you know, no longer in the house, only six. Six kids, homeschools them. Is her life not valuable to me? It is. It's invaluable. It can't have a price put on it. It's limitless. Now, one of the things that I think is a little bit disingenuous is to act like there's no compensatory damages that can be put on a housewife. Housewives have a lot of value, monetary value. She does so many things that enables me to go to work. If she wasn't back home in Berryville right now taking care of, actually she's in Tulsa
and her grandma, but let's pretend like she's back home in Berryville taking care of the kids, right? If she was doing that, I couldn't be down here. I couldn't go to work every day. There's monetary value associated with her life. And if every, you know, trial lawyer in here is willing to say, okay, we'll no longer try to put a monetary value on the time of a housewife, I think that that'd actually be a mistake. You know, they do, and they occasionally do. Now, is it harder to prove? Well, yeah, it is. You've got to get in all sorts of different type of evidence, but, you know, the cost of a nanny and, you know, the money that, you know, that she's able to save because, but I tell you, my wife has got a monetary value.
And, you know, if we're going to have an argument, let's have it all in the up and up. And I don't want to, I mean, this thing is, I don't want to discount somebody because they think it's a life issue and they see, but every time the jury deliberates, they put a value on human life. All we're doing is saying, hey, this is a policy decision that I think we should set here to be able to create some sort of standards, some sort of uniformity. You know, I think the issue of Congress, I mean, I think that that was settled. Congress sets the rules for the judiciary. You know, they do it.
And actually have since the original, since Washington, since Jefferson, since Madison, they have. Now, what do they do? What does Congress do? Because Congress is smart, they give deference to the court. They don't go in and change the rules all the time. And thank goodness for that, because when they change the rules, we'd probably change the rules. It would make my practice a lot harder. I'm glad that there's some stability. It's not as stable as I'd like, but I'm glad there is some stability. And I hope that we, as a body, will show deference to the court and let them manage their own business. But that we set the policy.
And that's all this is about, is having the ability to set the policy. You know, those folks who signed up on that letter and said that they support this, you know, they're businesses, but they're businesses made up of people, of workers, right? I mean, they're not, it's not like that they are, you know, no longer matter because they're out there working trying to make money and paying taxes. You know, they're generating revenue, you know, that's what we're after down here. Anyway, so I'm getting way off, and I don't want to kill this good resolution by my jabbering.
This is important to me. We need to have the ability to set policy, and so, I mean, I'm happy to answer any questions, but I would make a motion to do pass as amended.
Okay, we have a motion by Representative Ballinger of do pass. Is there any discussion on that motion? Representative House, you're recognized.
Mr. Chairman, there is much to be discussed and to be mentioned.
The first thing that struck me that was odd about this particular amendment and why it even got traction within this General Assembly is if you brought up something to limit the Second Amendment, right to carry arms, everybody would be up in arms. But the Seventh Amendment, which is also part of the Bill of Rights, So many people are willing to throw it in the trash can and limit the recovery to people of first 250,000, now 500,000. Thank you for the amendment. But it still doesn't make it right.
Every nation in this world can claim to be a nation of laws, including this one. China can claim, Russia can claim, Uganda can claim that they're a nation of laws. but there's only one thing that separates the Anglo-American system of law from the rest of the world, and that's the jury system. Juries are the triers of fact. They are the ones that determine what damages should be recovered.
That right is guaranteed to us as early as the Magna Carta in our colonial days. our U.S. Constitution, 1789, if I remember my dates, Seventh Amendment, our own Constitution, first one, 1836, it says that the right of trial by jury should not be invalid. Then we had another Constitution or two in there, and under our current Constitution, we still have the right to trial by jury. The right to trial by jury shall remain invalid and shall extend to all
cases at law without regard to the amount of controversy, but a jury trial may be waived by the parties, and so on and so forth. So basically, we're saying, listen, you can have a jury trial if you want to, but you're just going to get $500,000. That's exactly what it says, what this amendment says. So I can think of cases where punitive damages would certainly be warranted.
I remember the letter from, I believe it was an automobile manufacturer, internal memo that a lawyer friend of mine obtained. Some of y'all remember Tab Turner. He may be in the room. I don't know. He got a lawyer from, I believe it was one of the automobile companies. He said, yeah, we know this automobile is going to kill several hundred people by burning them to death. But, you know, we can take out an insurance policy and we can cover those deaths and we can still make millions and millions and millions of dollars and we'll let the insurance company pay off
for the poor people to get burned to death. Now, there's a good case for punitive damages. But each one of those under this amendment, because it's limited to just a certain percentage of the actuals, I mean, how much a child is a financial liability? A housewife, according to the law of non-economic damages that's set forth in this amendment, despite what Mr. Ballinger says, I love my wife and she is worth a lot to me. But according to that non-economic damage definition, not very much, $500,000, that's it.
You know, there's some people in this world that just hurt all the time. from the date of their injury to the day they die. And it's either massive amount of narcotics or continual therapy. Well, just $500,000. Sorry you feel so bad. Sorry you hurt so bad. You know, just going about your life. Have a good life. Take your pills.
Would you take $500,000 if I was sitting here cleaning my pistol and shot your privates off so you couldn't have a sex life? especially you young folks, $500,000, no sex, the rest of your life. Sorry, I feel real bad about that. But that's the limits. And what really struck me as so odd, and I asked one of my colleagues today, I said, what did you all pay for blood money in Afghanistan? Well, it depends on the victim. If we ran over a kid or a woman, it was just $200.
If it was a breadwinner, maybe $800. In Iraq, it was about $1,100, $1,200 to maybe $2,000 if we accidentally killed someone in an operation or an automobile accident or something like that. Because under the Sharia law system that they operate under, if you don't want to have somebody come after you and kill you, you just give them a few bucks and by their law and their faith, they have to just leave you alone. Well, an insurance company come around, hands you a $500,000 check and say, good luck.
Have a good life. Sorry about all your problems. We really feel bad about it. I will vote against this. I cannot think of a more horrible path to take than abandoning the jury system where 12 people in our community decide what's right, what's fair, what's just in each individual case. case. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you.
Is there any further discussion on the motion
as amended? Yes. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized. Thank you.
I just want to address a couple of things, and I kind of tried to do that a little bit before with the question from Mr. Saban, but I'll do it again. Jury system is a great system, and everything he said about how good the jury system is 100% true. However, we limit the jury all the time. Almost everything we do down here when we pass a bill would limit a jury. If it's a civil matter, it deals with contracts, deals with, you know, how a wastewater treatment
plant is supposed to work or whatever. If that went to a jury, the jury would be limited by the law that we pass, right? They will have jury instructions that kind of explain what the laws are that we pass. Every bill that we have affects the law or does nothing occasionally. But aside, if you have a bill that actually does something, it affects the law. We limit the jury. We specifically do so in ways where we set fines, or when we allow for restitution, or when we say how long a person is going to spend in prison for a certain act, and what acts
can send somebody to prison. All those things limit juries. There's been tort reform and caps around for a long time, and it's never, there's never been a case that was overturned on the basis of violation of the Seventh Amendment of the Constitution. And why is that? It's because all it is is further guidance. All it is is setting policy. That's what we do is we set policy. Now there's a good debate that can be had here about how high that ought to be. Should it be $500,000?
Should it be a million dollars? Should it be whatever? I think we should have that debate, but guess what? Right now we can't. We're not allowed to. We were told that's procedure. That's limited. That's outside. to Amendment 80 is what we've been told. So what we're saying is that we need to be able to have that debate. We need to be able to set that policy. You know, I appreciate it. And, you know, Representative House, he's, I've joked before that we're great partners in judiciary. Now, right now I'm not enjoying them quite as much, but he is a sharp guy. There's a lot of things
I totally disagree with him on. And a good attorney, I promise you, a person who has long-term major injuries, like he had mentioned, you know, there's going to be a lot of medical bills, there is an opportunity to get a lot of punitive damages there. And so, you know, that could be you get your compensatory, you get your punitive damages, and you get your non-economic damages in that case, and that's going to be a pretty big verdict. You know, any trial lawyer worth his salt is going to get a big verdict out of that one. And, you know, my point is that justice
finds a way and it's going to get done. Now, what we have to do is kind of be able to, in most cases, find a way to be able to set policies so people can feel like there's some sort of limitation that every single day they don't have to worry about being driven out of business. You know, every single day they don't have to worry about whether or not they're going to be sued and have a judgment against them the rest of their life that they're going to have to deal with. And, you know, it may be that they do. You know, $500,000, you know, if you start aggregating it, still could be a pretty big judgment. However, it's not the same kind of thing that makes it where they're driven out of business
and drives up insurance rates and everything else. I failed to answer Representative Sabin's question, and so let me answer that. The reason why you don't have that exception in non-economic damages is because the reason why the person would need more damages is they'd need to be punished, punitive damages. So if they did it on purpose, then your damages would fall in the punitive damages. So that's the, you know, if it's a, you know, willful act that you intended to cause damage
and you cause damage, then you have no cap on punitive, so you can get, you know, a limitless award in that case, and it would all be punitive damages, not non-economic damages. So having said that, you know, if there's further discussion and anything needs to be answered, I'd be happy to do so. But I do appreciate
the committee giving me a good vote. Is there any further discussion? Hearing none, you're voting on Joint Resolution SJR 8, due pass, as amended, thank you.
All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. Nay. The ayes have it. I
Speaker 158
1:27:44
have two members requesting a roll call, so we will do a roll call. Representative Wardlaw Representative Hammer Representative Eubanks Representative Eubanks Representative House Representative Douglas Representative Dotson
Representative Miller Representative Womack Representative Davis Representative Saban Representative Hendren, Representative Hendren, Representative Drown, Representative Gray, Representative Tosh, Representative Tosh, Representative Gonzalez, Representative Ferguson, Representative Sturge, Representative Smith, Representative Ballinger,
With a vote of 14 to 3, your motion has passed. Congratulations, Representative Boundary. Thank you, committee. Seeing no further business for the committee, we are adjourned.
Agenda
SJR8 Irvin A CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT LIMITING CONTINGENCY FEES AND AWARDS OF PUNITIVE AND NON-ECONOMIC DAMAGES; AND CHANGING THE POWERS OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY AND THE SUPREME COURT REGARDING RULES OF PLEADING, PRACTICE, AND PROCEDURE.
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Bob Ballinger
Unverified
Representative Jack Ladyman Chair
Unverified
Speaker 16
Representative Jim Dotson
Unverified
Representative Warwick Sabin
Unverified
Representative Douglas House
Unverified
Dan Greenberg
Unverified
Representative Kim Hammer
Unverified
Speaker 81
Representative Michelle Gray Chair
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Speaker 100
Representative Dan M. Douglas
Unverified
Speaker 106
Speaker 113
Paul Byrd
Unverified
Speaker 117
Speaker 126
Representative Justin Gonzales
Unverified
Speaker 134
Speaker 135
Speaker 136
Speaker 142
Paul Calvert
Unverified
Speaker 144
Representative Jimmy Gazaway
Unverified
Speaker 53
Speaker 158