Insurance and Commerce Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (12)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
SB291
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB291 Standridge TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT FOR THE USE OF CERTAIN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1145
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1145 C. Douglas TO RESTRICT A JOINT TENANT'S ABILITY TO SEVER A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1166
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1166 Rushing TO CLARIFY THE OBLIGATIONS OF RESIDENTIAL LANDLORDS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1271
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1271 Hammer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HEALTH INSURANCE INNOVATION A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1377
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1377 Lemons WARRANTY EXPRESS DEFECTIVE AGAINST MANUFACTURER'S A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1448
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1448 M. Gray TO INCLUDE FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS INSURED BY THE NA…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1527
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1527 Rushing FOR REQUIREMENTS ESTATE REAL EDUCATION CONTINUING C…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1585
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1585 Capp DISPOSAL THE FOR INFORMATION PERSONAL OF TO PROCEDURE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1592
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1592 Leding TO PROVIDE PARITY IN HEALTH BENEFIT PLAN COVERAGE BE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1594
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1594 Sabin TO REVISE THE DEFINITION OF "PAID SOLICITOR" AS IT RE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1604
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1604 Jett TO PROVIDE FOR THE EXAMINATION AND REGULATION OF CERTA…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1667
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1667 Beck TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING A PROPERTY OWNER'S BILL OF…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 13, 2026
At this time, I'm going to turn over the chair to Vice
Chairman Lundstrom. Representative Collins, you're recognized to
present your bill. Thank you very much, Madam Chair. The bill that we're talking about is Senate Bill 291.
And obviously, there's a lot of question marks and discussion going on the bill. I'm going to have Mr. Smith with me, and Madam Chair, if it's okay with you, I'll let him introduce himself and who he's with, and
then I'll present the bill. Yes, please. Good morning, Madam Chair, my name is Derek Smith. I'm an
attorney here in Little Rock with Mitchell Williams, and I represent LKQ. So what I want to do is start off by saying that what this bill does is it strikes the requirement for a written approval by a consumer for a part.
Now what I want to do is I want to go through what exactly are we talking about. Because when I first heard this, the vision I had in my mind was somebody coming in and they're getting a transmission replaced or an alternator or a new engine. And while they were doing that, somebody was sneaking in a bunch of broken garbage. And then when they took their car home, all of a sudden the car was worthless.
That's what I thought. And I was very, very scared. But let's talk literally and specifically about what's going on here. The first thing is, what kind of parts are we talking about? I'm now reading from Arkansas Law 4-90-302, parentheses 1, an aftermarket crash part, and that's the limit of what we're talking about, means a replacement for any of the non-mechanical sheet metal or plastic parts,
which generally constitute the exterior of a motor vehicle, including inner and outer panels. So the plastic things around a headlight or a fender. It does not include things like alternators, engines, transmissions, differentials, and all of these complicated functional parts. Importantly, these parts are not a component of the vehicle safety system.
And multiple tests by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety have concluded that there is zero impact on the safety of the vehicle from these parts. But let's go a little further about what the law is today. There are two buckets of parts, aftermarket crash parts, which we just discussed as being plastic or sheet metal, and all the other parts.
Alternators and transmissions and all those other parts. Do you need a written consent on the other parts? No. Now there are two times somebody can get a part. When the car is under warranty, and when the car is not under warranty. When the car is not under warranty, do you need to get a written permission?
No. So in summary, there are two kinds of parts, fenders, plastic covers for lights, and another type of part, alternators, transmissions. You need written permission for the fenders and the plastic parts, you don't for the others. And there are two times you can get a part when your car's under warranty and when it's not. When it's not under warranty, you don't need a written permission. So basically what this bill does is align that one instance with all the other instances.
Now, what happens in the process if we don't have this written alignment? What happens is you bring your car into the repair shop or the dealership and they are required by law. I'll read the next section of the law, 4-90-305, repair disclosure. in all instances where non-original equipment manufacturer aftermarket crash parts are used
in preparing an estimate for repairs in all instances, the written estimate prepared by the insurer or the repair facility shall clearly identify such parts. So you take your car into the Chevy dealer or the Ford dealer or your repair shop, or you let your insurance company handle all those things, and you get your estimate. It will have annotated in nothing smaller than 10-point type a little paragraph about the fact that these are aftermarket parts.
And you always have the opportunity to say, I insist on an original equipment part if you want to pay the extra amount for that. So why are we bringing this bill forward in the first place? What is the purpose of the bill? The purpose is merely to eliminate the stigma. If you are asked to choose either A or B, and someone says, if you choose A, you don't have to sign for it, but if you choose B, you do,
not knowing anything else, your gut instinct is going to say, I'm taking some extra risk, and that's why my signature is required. But the reality here is, for these kinds of parts, there's no safety risk, there's no functionality risk, and it merely creates a stigma that puts these parts at a competitive disadvantage so people unwittingly pay more than they would otherwise have to pay. The last issue I want to cover, because I know there's a lot of people that are going to speak for and against this,
the last issue I want to cover is the warranties. So people say your warranty is going to be worthless. You broke your headlight. You have an $80,000 car. You put a plastic cover on it that was an aftermarket part. You drive off the lot. Your transmission falls out, and now you have a $10,000 bill you have to pay. That is not true. It is against federal law to do that. Here's what you void in your warranty. The manufacturer is not responsible for replacing that plastic part that was the aftermarket crash part.
They have their own guarantee when you buy them. So if the part is faulty, then that part will be replaced by the company that manufactured it, not by the warranty provider, not by the original issuer. That is true, but it does not void the warranty. The other situation where you could have a warranty issue is if that part caused the problem. So if the fender somehow blew up and knocked your engine out of the car,
and the manufacturer could prove that a faulty fender caused the engine to fall out of the car, then the part would have impacted the warranty and you would have a problem. But it's on the responsibility of the manufacturer to prove that that's the case. And these types of parts, where they are, have virtually no impact in that situation. So that's the warranty impact. And with that, I'll take questions with the help of Mr. Smith.
Representative Jett, you're first on the list. Thank
you, Madam Chair. Representative Collins, you know, when you reference, there's no safety issues involved, but, you know, a lot of these, you know, fenders and stuff now have these safety zone warning systems that my wife uses quite a bit. We drive down the road, and I feel like I'm on a flat tire sometimes because it shakes so much. But if you have, you know, they've got to be calibrated. So if you put an aftermarket piece that's got some of these safety issues or safety-type sensors in those,
and if they're not properly aligned, how's that going on? I mean, where's the recourse at on this? Representative Jett,
thank you for the question. I think one of the things about aftermarket parts is they have to be of like kind and quality. So to qualify as an aftermarket part, it has to be essentially an equivalent part to satisfy that. So to qualify under this statute, it has to be essentially an equivalent part.
But to my question, sir, but if it's not, I mean, where is the recourse? I mean, you know, in a perfect world, you know, we think everything's perfect. But sometimes, you know, somebody's having a bad day at the factory or when they set up the machinery, they get something off-centered, an eighth of an inch that might make a, you know, a five-foot difference in a safety zone on one of these sensors going into the bumper. I mean, where is the recourse? Who has a recourse on that? That was to happen.
The manufacturer of the aftermarket part have warranties on those parts. So your recourse would be to, you know, whoever made the part. It would not be to the manufacturer of the vehicle. And to the extent there are some sensors or those types of things, I mean, that would be a dramatically small portion of the overall animal here. But you would go back to the person that made the part. They have guarantees on them. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair.
Representative Payton. Thank you, Madam Chair. And Representative Collins, I appreciate your attempt to make this easily understood. But we can't look at this through very narrow blinders as if it's just one manufacturer, LKQ, with their warranty and their parts, their aftermarket parts. There are literally hundreds of aftermarket part manufacturers out there overseas, you know, coming from China or whatever.
And they don't necessarily have the same quality controls that LKQ has with their parts. This bill seems to open it up to, I mean, it doesn't limit it to one manufacturer. So could you speak to any testing that you are aware of that is required and that would be a standard to ensure the quality of these parts against corrosion and against, you know, weight and thickness, which all affects the crash, you know, in a crash situation?
You know, testing about whether a fender is going to break away or whether it's going to enter the passenger compartment and cut somebody's arm off. When we talk about exterior sheet metal, we're talking about the outside door skin, interior, inside door skin. Those are all things that protect a passenger in an accident. So, I mean, what manufacturers are we going to include in this? and what standards of testing are we going to require?
Or is it just all open-ended? Yeah, and the way I would respond to that, Representative Payton, is with regard to original equipment manufacturers, we have the same situation. There are multiple original equipment manufacturers. They come from all countries, China, Japan, and all the other countries. I mean, we're familiar with most of the brands, Ford and Chevy and Toyota, but there are so many new ones that are coming at all times. And so we've got the same situation with any time you have a free market, you have the same situation with the opportunity for multiple people to produce things and to ship them.
I'm not an expert on the testing. So, Mr. Smith, do you know anything about testing, whether you're original equipment and it's a fender
or whether you're an aftermarket and it's a fender? Like you, I'm not an expert on testing, but I can rely on reports I've seen from others that have tested, and specifically the National Highway Transportation Safety Administration, as you know, has not set standards for aftermarket parts because it has specifically found that they do not affect vehicle safety. Similarly, they say the problems with these parts tend to focus on fit and finish rather than on safety,
and there have been no trends identified and complaints that relate to safety. And also in their review in reviewing the concerns about safety is tended to find that there's been no evidence that aftermarket parts are any less safe or more safe. But it's certainly not any less safe than original equipment parts. Can I have a follow up? Thank you,
Madam Chair. Well, I can assure you that the manufacturers go through rigorous testing because they're on the hook for premature corrosion. If a fender rusts through or the bottom of the door rusts out.
They do a lot of crash tests because they are trying to achieve the highest possible crash test rating. And all these parts combined do create safety or hazard depending on how they're built. So let me ask you the question about warranty. In other words, I know some aftermarket parts companies do guarantee their product. But out of the hundreds of aftermarket parts companies that are going to be
allowed to sell these parts without the customer's approval, are they all going to be required to have a warranty? Because I own a car dealership, and I used to have a body shop, and most aftermarket parts do not come with a
warranty. As I think you know, Representative Payton, being you're in this business, the cars, original equipment manufacturers, have widely different warranties between them.
And in fact, when I watch television commercials, sometimes the car will say my warranty is XYZ and warranty is ABC. And sometimes the warranty sounds really, really, really, really good. But then when you go to use the warranty, what you discover is there was a lot of fine print that you didn't understand. And my point in all that is simply to say, in the free market, people compete on a number of variables, including price, quality, warranty, et cetera. And what happens is, as you know, the products that are designed well, that perform well,
that are a good value, those are the ones that rise to the top. The ones that are lousy, whether it's an original equipment manufacturer, an after parts manufacturer, those people usually go to the dogs, because you can fool some of the people some of the
time, but you can't fool everybody forever. Okay, and I understand that, but we're taking the customer's approval and the customer's choice out when we pass this bill. The customer no longer gets to make the choice. It's the insurance company, and all they're worried about is the lowest cost repair.
Well, I would submit to you that the insurance company is worried about the lowest overall cost for the price that they can get. And if what they find is they're using shoddy workmanship and they're having to redo repairs and things of that nature, it's very expensive. It's just like when we're managing medical care. We're always saying, how many times do you have to go back to the hospital because you fixed the bone wrong? It's the same thing here. Insurance companies are looking for the best value equation they can get. And when somebody comes in for a repair, obviously the person doing the repair has the option to say, I'm using XYZ parts.
It's an OEM part, and the reason is ABC, it's going to cost a little more. Or they can put, I'm using the aftermarket crash part, and the reason is because you're going to save money. And people are going to look to experts when they have questions. And all this does is level the playing field. It just levels the playing field by not making somebody sign as if their kid's going on a field trip, and they have to worry about their danger. Just put me in the bottom of the queue. I was going to say, we'll come
back around to you. Representative Rushing? Thank you, Madam Chair.
Representative Collins, I just have a couple questions. And I've dealt with, you know, original parts and aftermarket parts. I had a daughter that we actually called Tara Carr up because she wrecked her car so many times that her name was Tara. And so we just called her Tara Carr up. But anyway, my question is, is why are we not going to – I'm for a free market just like you are. And this kind of seems to, going back to Representative Payton's statement, we're limiting consumer choice.
So why can we not have something on there that says, instead of take this language out, that actually gives the consumer the right to make that decision, a checkbox of some sort, saying I'm willing to go with an aftermarket product or I'm willing to go with the one that's under warranty. I think
point, the consumer always has the choice because before an aftermarket part can be used, the consumer gets an estimate with the aftermarket
part, identifying the aftermarket parts and saying that they are warranted by the aftermarket parts manufacturer. At that point, the consumer decides whether they want to have the repair done that way or not. The consumer always has the choice. The thing that this bill does is just removes the one stigma where you only have to sign if you want to use an aftermarket part. That's all it does. Under current law, consumers are always given advance notice of the use of an aftermarket part or not, and the consumer gets to decide whether they want to have the repair. It's only in the instance where the aftermarket part is being used on a vehicle that's under
warranty that requires a signature. And because of that extra step, only in that one particular instance, it creates a stigma for the part. Let me ask the question this way. If we
change the bill to say whenever you get your estimate, you have to sign off on it, regardless of the part. So the playing field is leveled the other way. Everybody gets a permission slip. We can level the playing field that way. If you think somehow the signature enables, and when I go get my car, get an oil change, they make me sign the thing ten times. I don't even look anymore, to be honest with you. So if we want to make the signature that kind of a signature, like when you go to a closing, as you do a million of them,
and you just say to someone, sign, sign, sign, sign, sign, sign, sign, and the person just does it without reading it, we can get rid of the stigma that way, too, just by making a sign on every part. So if you think that's a better way to do it, I'm fine doing that. It's leveling the playing field that we're talking about here, so we don't give somebody a scenario where every time you walk in the room, you've got to sign in like there's something wrong with you. And that's really the intent of this, and that's the effect of it. Representative Hodges, you have a question?
Thank you, Madam Chair. I've heard a lot of conflicting things about this bill. Well, one question I have is in regard to cars that are leased. Do you know if someone leases a car and gets an aftermarket part put on the vehicle, if that could void the lease and
they'd be responsible for? Yeah, so what leasing companies can do is simply insist, if they want to do that, leasing companies can insist that only original equipment parts are used. That's an option they have if they would like to do that.
This does not stop that from happening. And I would mention that Arkansas is one of a very small number of states that has this requirement. I think it is one of four. And car companies and leasing companies tend to operate just fine in the overwhelming majority of states that do not have this signature requirement. It seems to me that they figured out how to make it work in those states. It can work here just as well. Question. Thank you, Madam Chair.
We're talking a lot about stigma, trying to get rid of the stigma, the level of the playing field. What I don't understand is why are we trying to do this legislatively? Why doesn't the company, through their marketing and other programs, remove the stigma and remove and create a level playing field? Because I know that if there's a stigma against the company I own, I'm not going to come here and say, hey, can you guys
fix this for me? Yeah, the answer is because we installed it. So the companies didn't do anything. They were just walking along whistling like everybody else, and then we jumped in and dove in and added a regulation on some companies that we didn't add on others.
When we talk about what does it mean to overregulate and pick favorites and pick winners, what does it mean? That's exactly what this is. So this is a deregulation bill to level the playing field, plain and simple. They're never easy. Everybody thinks regulations are always things like, oh, gosh, you must be regulating sex offenders and Chinese people. No, that's not it. It's always designed with the intent of helping somebody. But that's what overregulation amounts to. Nobody intentionally puts a regulation on there which is designed to hurt someone.
It's always under with a good intention. So this was, I'm sure, good intentions by a lot of folks. But the reality is today what we're doing is we're basically saying when you go this way and someone says, hey, wait a minute, in order to do that, you have to sign for it. I immediately think, what is wrong with that? And I get nervous and I get scared. And that's just a human reaction. And that's the impact. And this just levels the playing field. Representative Henderson.
I broke it. Sorry about that. Thank you, Madam Chair. Just a couple. And I may just nod, as Representative Collins would say, I'm kind of slow at this. So are you saying that you do have an option that if I wreck my truck and I want original parts put back on it at no extra cost?
I didn't say I did. No, no, no. Yeah, excellent point. Excellent. Now we get to the core of the issue. The prices are not the same. That's the reason it's nice to have a stigma on the cost that is more reasonable relative to the other price. That's why people, I would submit to you, are fighting so hard to keep the stigma on. Because obviously, the original equipment manufacturer could lower their prices to match these costs or come much closer to them,
which, knock, knock, knock, is probably what's going to happen if you vote for this and allow the free market to function. If it doesn't, come back in a year and say, you know what, we got rid of too much regulation. We need more. Go back to that if we're having a problem with it. But the reality is if we're serious about creating the opportunity for people to compete on a level playing field, then this is the way to go. And yes, you can ask for OEM parts, but no, they're not
the same price. follow up uh just going a completely different way have y'all checked with
being an ex-banker i mean have you checked with banks and finance companies how they feel about that you know they they're financing one thing in in return if you wreck it then you've kind of got something else, even though, even by name. I mean. So the way I would answer that, Representative Henderson,
is a lot of times if you have a bank loan on an expensive product, they're going to insist you have insurance or state law mandates you have insurance.
So the insurance policies that are approved by the state of Arkansas have in them all of the factors that insurance companies must deliver. To the extent an insurance company can use repair shops or dealerships or others where they make agreements with them to use aftermarket reports or non-aftermarket reports or whatever, all of that would be regulated by the state and would be in accord with how we manage insurance so that the insurance companies and all that stuff would not get out of whack.
But it's controlled that way. Representative Payton. Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Collins, I know you're a smart guy and you understand your investments in research. Thank you. Investments in research and development and what it takes to develop a product. I mean, we're talking about metals and alloys and how to make it thin and light and still maintain its strength and integrity and how to keep it from rusting and deteriorating and melting away in a year or two, all those things go into the creation of the OEM parts.
And then the aftermarket parts companies come along and stamp out a bunch of things that to the naked eye or maybe even to the tape measure seem to be the same product. This is the best analogy. I'm not near as good at coming up with analogies as you are. Thank you. If your house suffered damage and the siding blew off, would you want them to be able to replace that without you knowing it and without your approval with the cheapest siding they could buy?
Yeah, so the way you framed up the question, only an idiot would say yes, but that's not what we've got here. So the first thing I would say is with regard to product development and innovations and things of that nature, we have a patent system. so that when you come up with an innovation, you file a patent and you get the use of that for X amount of time before somebody else is allowed to steal your invention, and hence we don't allow them to steal your invention. So when you develop a better fender with better allies and all these other things and you patent that, there is no aftermarket part unless you've licensed that technology to those other people
for whatever the period of time the patent laws are good for. With regard to the notification, I have an insurance policy on my house with a particular company, and they said that when XYZ damage happens to it, they're going to bring it back up to a certain level. They're going to continue to insure it at that level. I have a deductible or depreciation or whatever I've got on it, and that's the deal I've cut with my insurance company. And I may not like everything that happens in that, and obviously when I do it, at least with my insurance company, They always give me the option, if I want to pay more, to spend more to do something more.
With this situation, the repair shop or the insurance company is forced to let people know exactly what parts are going in, whether they're aftermarket or not. That is not being deleted from the law. That still exists. So when you get your bill, you'll still see a scary paragraph that looks like a cigarette package warning that says this is an aftermarket crash report, which could very easily spur the question. In fact, I would submit, if I was really concerned about that and I own the repair shop, I'd say to the person, oh, look at this.
Are you sure you want that? I could give you an offer to the sell-up to the other part and the reasons why you would recommend that. And you're still allowed to do those things. The difference is we all know if somebody says, before I can allow you to buy that liquor or whatever, you have to sign this, and that's the difference, and that's all we're changing. It's not an awareness issue at
all. Follow-up. Well, and you make a great point about how scary it is. And that's, you know, somebody that's in the auto industry, very familiar with repairs, it is very scary to start gathering up aftermarket parts and replacing some of these.
And I'm not sure that everybody appreciates that. There is a stigma with it because in many cases they are substandard parts. However, I just want to clarify one thing. Have you studied the patent law, and are you telling us today that a manufacturer of a new automobile can patent a
left front fender for that automobile and be protected for a length of time? What I'm telling you is an invention that advances anything from a fender to a microphone to a medicine is patentable.
Now, if all you're saying is I'm going to call a tomato, will I qualify for a patent, that's a very different subject. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. Seeing no
other questions. Do we have anybody in the, oh, oh, I'm sorry. Representative Henderson, I
apologize. Just one more question, because I really am trying to get my handle around kind of the insurance factor on this.
Because you said that, I guess, if you want those parts, you can, and trying to do apples to apples. So if I wanted that policy, is a policy available to me that, say, my policy right now, I get manufactured parts if I wreck my truck. So is there two policies that you can get, like, if I don't care what you put on there, is my rate going to go down?
Am I going to have that insurance policy? You know, we do look here at insurance policies and have two different ones, you know, on that car. Am I starting to try to make sense?
I think I understand your question. Your question is, are there different policies that have different replacement part elements to them? I do not know, USAA is my insurance company. I have read the contract many times, but if you were to ask me, does it have a statement in there about whether they use only OEM parts or do they use aftermarket parts?
Is that true if it's the alternator or the transmission or offender? I couldn't tell you the answer to that, but I do know this. If I said to somebody, I want to have this, and I'm going to go shop for an insurance policy that gives me that, I could get it. Now, if I'm the only person in the world that wants it, if I said I'm the only person in the world that wants an insurance policy like this, I'm probably going to have to pay a lot. Warren Buffett is in specialized insurance, so if you wanted to insure your legs or something like that because you didn't want an injury, he'll do things like that, but you have to pay a very high price.
If there's a broad market for something, then there are lots of people that are offering those things, and you usually can get better pricing. But if you want something a certain way and you want your insurance to cover it and you're willing to pay the insurance premium to go with it, Warren Buffett literally lives in that business and does that for people all over the world. Follow-up,
Madam Chair? Yes. Well, that's not really where I'm going. Where I'm going is if I'm very happy with what I got in the price of my insurance right now
and I can get those manufactured parts, would I be able to keep those? Or we're still going to have one policy. And with that policy, is our insurance rates going
to go down because? This has absolutely no effect on insurance policies. It just has to do with whether or not you sign when you purchase an aftermarket part. That's all this deals with. The insurance market, four parts, aftermarket, and OEM, that's happening on its own.
All this does is if it's aftermarket, you no longer have to sign for it.
That's all this changes. I had a question. Those parts that aren't covered under warranty, I mean, those parts that are covered under warranty and you take your car in and now they're replaced with
aftermarket parts, unbeknownst to you, does that void the warranty? Representative Lundstrom, the notion unbeknownst to you suggests that this bill takes us from being notest to you to hidden from you, and that's an unfair characterization.
When you go and get a repair part estimate and you have an aftermarket repair, here's what is written on your bill. And this time I'm going to read the whole thing, since I don't want to be unbeknownst. Quote, this estimate has been prepared based on the use of aftermarket crash parts supplied by a source other than the manufacturer of your motor vehicle. The aftermarket crash parts used in the preparation of this estimate are warranted by the manufacturer or distributor of such parts instead of the manufacturer of your vehicle.
And here's the minimum font type that you can use. And this is on every estimate that uses one. So there's no such thing as unbeknownst here. The difference is you don't have to sign a document alongside of that if you choose to allow that to be
the case. Representative Rushing, did you have a question? Yes. Thank you, Madam Chair. It's kind of a follow-up, I guess, on Representative Lundstrom's unbeknownst to you, and you said that it's not.
then I don't understand the reason that we would be getting rid of this portion of the law to start with. So, okay, we are already going to give them notice that it's there. So what's the difference? I mean, why do we have to not give them? I mean, why does this have to go away if we're
already going to give them the notice anyway? Because whenever you ask somebody for a signature for something, the suggestion is that they're making some type of a risky choice.
You've, by law, you've implicated the item, and you've created a stigma. So the question I would almost ask in reverse is, why would we place this burden in one place but not the other? And if we're placing the burden, what is the purpose other than to create a stigma? What other purpose does it have? Follow up. Well,
I could almost, with all due respect, turn that back around to you, too.
well because are we going to please do are we going to say that that the the parts dealer is going to make them sign this and read this and say when they get the repairs made that these are aftermarket parts and you realize that they are and they're going to sign off on your insurance claim or whatever and uh but you're not going to have to sign off here so so again turn the question around again why are we going to do it in one place and not do it in the other well
the reason is because we're treating everything here
consistently. In other words, we're saying to somebody when you get a repair estimate for your car, you must sign the repair estimate in advance regardless of whether it's for one thing or another thing. We're just saying you acknowledge that you were given a repair estimate and the real purpose of that is quite simple is so that the repair place cannot say I'm going to charge you X unofficially and then when you get your bill, it's 10 times X. But instead of that, you've got an estimate and it has the prices and the items and the work that's going to be done, and to prove that you have read that and that you are
aware of it, you sign it. And that all remains in place. And when you do that, you look at what's going to be done, and if there's an aftermarket report, it has this paragraph, and you can say, that paragraph scares me, or why is this paragraph here, or do you recommend this, or should I do something else? The reality is, most of the times, it would be the repair shop or the insurance company, if it's an insured repair conceivably, that has an agreement or an arrangement that is determining these things. Obviously, if somebody goes in and says, I insist on the cheapest option
available to me, they might get one type of a repair estimate. If somebody goes in and says, I want all original parts, they would get another type. If somebody else has something else, they might get a little bit differently. But none of those things is designed to bias a person in favor or against a Ford or a Chevy or anything else. It just simply says, I'm getting an estimate, and I want to know what I'm getting. And in that process, if an aftermarket part is there, you will have this paragraph that reads like a cigarette package warning
so that you're fully aware of what you're looking at. And it's an even playing field, and importantly, the consumer protection of the consumer seeing how much is going to cost me and what am I getting done, and that's what I'm signing for. That's very different than the signature. Representative
Lauer, you had a question? Yes. Thank you, Madam Chair. I have two totally distinct questions, so I'm going to try my best to put them in a question and follow-up.
You made the comment, Representative Collins, that this has nothing to do with insurance, but that's not necessarily the case, right? I mean, we just recently heard a bill that talks about replacement value or depreciation. Is that distinction not also present in auto insurance policies? Well, to whatever degree that is true or not
true, I do not know. My point when I said this bill has nothing to do with that is simply to state this change is nothing with regard to those factors.
This changes nothing with regard to what an insurance company has insured or is directing somebody to do or any of those other things that affects that in exactly zero ways. All this does is when your repair estimate comes, you do not have to sign specifically for the fact that an aftermarket part is used. That's all this does. It will continue to be annotated on your repair bill and all of the insurance policies that exist and all the regulations on those things,
all of those remain intact as they are.
Okay. Follow-up. My follow-up actually is going to deal with a different part of that, and that is I know that your bill, and I guess I could say my bill too since I'm co-sponsored, but I still want to make sure that everything's clear here. You do not have to sign specifically for that disclaimer, but if you receive an estimate, do you not still have to sign that you have received that estimate?
Yes, sir, you do. Okay. Regardless of whether it's aftermarket parts or OEM parts, regardless of what kind of parts you sign your estimate because you're acknowledging that you're going to have a repair bill of X, Y, or Z, and they're going
to do these things. Okay. But what this bill does is it takes away the necessity to potentially initial the section where they inform you that they're using aftermarket parts. You don't have to have a separate approve. Correct. You are correct, sir. That is correct.
All right. Thank you. Any other questions? I'm sorry, Representative Bushing. I'm sorry. I promise this will be my last. Thank you, Madam Chair. Okay. I guess what I want to know is who is complaining about the written consent? Is it the consumers, or who exactly is wanting this portion out of the law right now?
If I said there are 10 people being made a stigma, and there's a stigma every time they have to do something,
who do you think would be interested in that? The person that feels their stuff is being stigmatized. So the answer is the people that are making the aftermarket parts are the ones that are asking for the stigma that we've written into our law be lifted from their arena. That's my understanding of who is requesting it. Follow up
real quickly. So the consumers are not the ones that are upset about this law, correct?
I have not polled any consumers, so I do not know how consumers feel. What I do know is consumers, if they're stigmatized out of buying something that's a better value, pay more for it every day, and may not even realize what's happening. In other words, regulations work in a very insidious way. They spread $10, $1, $5 over and over and over and over again, and the people never know what happened to them until they're regulated to death.
Any other questions from the committee? Audience members, we have a number of people set up to speak for and against. I would remind you to keep your comments to the subject. And not to repeat your comments. We have a couple of people due to time. We may need to collapse it together. We have the first person is Dennis Johnson to speak against.
We on now? Okay. Please state your name. Madam Chairman, thank you very much. members of the committee. My name is Dennis Youngmeyer and for 38 years I served as president of the Arkansas Automobile Dealers Association representing the franchise new car and truck dealers in the state. I've recently retired but I remain on staff for special projects and I guess this would be considered one. First let me tell you that I'm not an expert on OEM parts or aftermarket parts. There are experts here this morning that can make those distinctions. I've
I've been asked to give an overview of the history of the current legislation, which was passed in 1997. At that time, I was very involved in the legislation and led the proponents. In the late 80s and early 90s, there was proliferation of knockoff parts, or what was commonly called Taiwan 10. That was after market non-OEM crash parts. Excuse me. We wanted to address the issue as our body shop customers were being required by their insurance companies to accept aftermarket non-OEM parts, which in many cases were clearly inferior.
We proposed the legislation and initiated a prolonged and very deliberate dialogue, which was both objective and inclusive of all parties. To this end, we had the legislation addressed with a special order of business, which was well attended and most effective in demonstrating why consumers had the right to be in the know. I would point out that we were one of the first states to mandate disclosure of the use of aftermarket parts in the consent agreement.
I'm aware of the conflicting information regarding how many states require disclosures in their insurance estimates and the states who have written consent agreements. Of course, those same arguments were voiced then, which brings to mind a statement by the late Senator Yates. If it's the right thing to do for Arkansas consumers, then let Arkansas lead the way. Senator Yates was always a champion of Arkansas consumers. So we addressed two general classification of parts. The OEM, or original manufacturer parts, and the aftermarket generic parts,
which at that time were largely imported. And because of their failure to meet the quality standards of original manufacturer parts, they became known as Taiwan 10. I must point out that during the committee hearings, we brought in examples of bumpers, fenders, and such that compared the aftermarket parts to OEM. the differences were most apparent. So here were the interested groups at the time that were included. Body shops and repair facilities, both dealerships and independents. They were most concerns for their customers and the difficulty to get aftermarkets to fit. Are the non-OM parts
safe or inferior? That is like kind and quality, fit and fitness, performance, meet warranty standards and consideration of potential liabilities. Two, the manufacturers who of course wanted their own parts on their own vehicles under warranty to ensure customer satisfaction and maintain original warranty. Insurance companies, who, of course, wanted to limit the cost of claims repairs while utilizing cheaper aftermarket parts, which they claimed might provide a safe and economical alternative to OEM parts.
The consumer, who so often does not have a voice in the debate, but deserves the opportunity to require OEM parts, or by virtue of written consent, choose to have the cheaper aftermarket parts. thus weighing quality, safety, and the possibility of voiding their warranty. So some 20 years ago, this debate resulted in the Arkansas legislature supporting a consumer protection law that entitled consumers to have the choice of OEM parts in lieu of aftermarket parts and to have the right of a written consent agreement in that regard.
It seems to have worked rather well as I've never had a dealer report a consumer complain about this. I trust this history will help you in the consideration of the proposed legislation. By sound bias, I guess that's the result of my involvement in the original legislation and its benefit to Arkansas consumers for these past two decades. The legislature put them first, and hopefully they will remain there. I sincerely thank you for the opportunity to speak to you today. Thank you. Do
we have any questions? I see Representative Payton, and then I'll get to you, Representative McCollum.
Thank you, Madam Chair. Dennis, in your 38 years as the head of the association and the hundreds of dealers that you came to know and the thousands of conversations and things that you had with them, we've heard the term stigma thrown around as if it's a false accusation. Have you ever known or heard a dealer or a body shop or somebody in the industry that's familiar with these parts give them equal credence with an OEM part?
I would say that the dealer's number one objective is to make their customers happy. And to do so, they're going to use the best parts that they can to provide the customers with that service. Okay, can I follow up? Yes, please. So do you think that it's an unjustified
stigma that they are lower quality parts? You know, it would seem to me in 20 years if there was an
issue, it would have been brought up a long time ago. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative McCall. Thank you, Madam Chair.
So when you were speaking to the history just a minute ago and how that demonstrated why the consumers have the right to know, that seems to me to suggest that what is being attempted in this bill would take away the consumer's ability to know. So, and that actually has been a lot of the discussion here. So I'm wondering for your input. I'm going to hear your input on that, if this is taking away the consumer's ability to know when what was stated is that a consumer would still have the ability to see written that a part is a certain type of part.
Well, I think the consideration was then, as it is now, that I seriously doubt how many people read their policy, first of all. But if, in fact, there is a choice for a non-OEM part, and you just paid $30,000 for a car, it would seem that the written consent agreement would just make sense in customers having that right. Did that answer your
I heard you make the statement that, uh, regarding customers, whether or not they
read it or not. Right. Yeah. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. I think the consent agreement, uh, under circumstances that's been discussed here today, uh, is a logical consumer protection, uh, uh, action.
Seeing no further questions. Okay. Thank you, sir. Thank you. Please remember to keep your remarks to the point. We need a four by Mr. Robert House with O'Reilly Auto Parts.
Speaker 158
49:44
Thank you, sir. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, distinguished representatives. My name is Robert House. I'm from Piercey and Garland County. I've been 26 years with aftermarket work, and I'm an outside salesman currently for O'Reilly Auto Parts. I represent more than 24,000 aftermarket employees in my job. I'm calling on garages. I find that many of the mechanics challenge with competing with the manufacturers
and allowing them for aftermarket parts, keeping these folks, allowing them to keep continuing to use aftermarket parts is allowing them to support their communities and the much-needed services along with the much-needed jobs they have in their market. So I just kind of want to make a brief statement as a consumer and also as an aftermarket part salesman.
Any questions from the committee for Mr. House? Thank you. Thank you, Mr. House. Appreciate it. Next, we have a Kevin Strayhorn.
Thank you, sir. Please state your
Speaker 119
51:10
Thank you, Madam Chairman and committee. i'm kevin strayhorn president owner of custom auto service incorporated we're auto collision specialist since 1980 37 years we're a pair of quality luxury vehicle brands for partners like everett infinity owens murphy jaguar range rover volkswagen i have a background in manufacturing
tool and die research and development and quality control also commissioner with our street fire department i have a lot of data here as far as the testing you were questioning earlier and so what i will refer to is basically through the recognized organization is called kappa certified auto parts association and i will be referring to to, first I would like to share the facts on aftermarket crash parts. These are crash
parts. These aren't mechanical parts. These aren't parts that just wear out. I know it's a lot of O'Reilly's and Napa in the room. They don't sell crash parts. They sell wear parts, just to make that definition clear. As to why they are not as equal to the car company brand parts they replace as most people have accepted as the truth. Senate Bill 291 repeals a limited use of aftermarket parts unless owner consents. I was here in 1993 for the current law. I will be reading the exact wording from documentation as written by Kappa Certified Auto
Parts Association. You can find it at kappacertified.org, the highest independent authority on aftermarket parts. CAPA was established in the public interest in 1987 to set up and oversee a testing program to assure the suitability and quality of automotive replacement parts, independent, unbiased, non-profit, fully transparent, and with no vested interest in the outcome. CAPA has since become the industry's recognized authority on the quality and safety of parts used for collision repairs. Our comprehensive testing program is
a valuable public service that provides consumers, auto body shops, parts distributors, and insurance adjusters with the reliable objective means they need to identify quality replacement parts, parts that fit, perform, last, and be every bit as safe as the originals. Kappa certification is even recognized by government regulators as an assurance of quality. What makes Kappa stand out from the rest is the fact that we have no vested interest in what is at the core of CAPA program.
To date, 66 million replacement parts have earned CAPA certification by meeting or exceeding CAPA's stringent quality standards, making it one of the most widely respected quality assurance programs ever. That's the good news. Here's the bad news. There are millions of untested, problematic parts in the marketplace. To be sure you have a genuine CAPA certified replacement part, Look for the distinctive yellow and blue Kappa quality seal that comes on every Kappa certified part.
The Kappa quality seal appears on replacement parts that meet or exceed Kappa standards. It provides independent objective assurance of product quality. If there is no seal on the part, it is not Kappa certified, regardless of what the sellers say. Here's a note to shops. It says, if it's not on the part, don't even start. Note to consumers, it says, ask for proof. Here is the quality watch report number three, dated July 2014.
This is all in PDF form. It's kappacertified.org. It's in complete. The testing, the whole report is there. So if you want to get into the details of wells, galvanization, photometrics, those type of things that are in this report. I'm going to read the first half or the first page in the back page. A periodic report on non-CAPA certified aftermarket replacement parts.
An introduction. In order to make a general assessment of the quality of non-CAPA certified aftermarket parts, this CAPA quality watch report discloses the results of a comparative testing of 47 non-CAPA certified aftermarket cosmetic metal. Madam Chair, point of order. Yes, I recognize that point of order. Okay.
My understanding of House rules is that to read a report to us, you actually have to be a representative of the group that produced the report. My
understanding is you are a part of that group that presents that report,
but I would ask that you limit
Speaker 119
56:01
your remarks. That's why I was going to give the first part in the results. Could you just give us a summary? Okay. They tested 47 non-CAPA-certified parts. They took them out of the marketplace as where everybody would buy their aftermarket parts. This analysis showed that nearly 90%, that's 41, of 47 non-CAPA-certified aftermarket parts failed to meet CAPA's requirements for comparability to the car company brand.
And counterparts are federal motor vehicle safety standards of federal lighting compliance. Four of the five aftermarket parts used by collision repairers are not CAPA certified and thus not demonstrated compliance with the CAPA standards. Given that the vast majority of aftermarket parts are not CAPA certified, This analysis indicates that the industry complaints about the quality of the majority of the aftermarket parts used every day may be well-founded.
This means that consumers may get aftermarket parts that are not comparable to their car company brand counterparts. Like I see, you can find the full report at capitalcertified.org. Sir, we have seven people
on this list, so I want to make sure everybody has the time. So if you could land this plane, that would be
Speaker 119
57:29
good. So that means four out of five times when a collision repair uses independently produced parts they will be using a part that has not been capital certified to
be comparable to the car company brand. For years we were led to believe the majority of parts in the market to be superior and only a very small number to be inferior. In reality the market has been selling us just 20% capital certified parts as a high standard while along selling us 80 to 90% of inferior parts that don't fit or are unsafe. So after revealing the facts, it is clear repealing this law will only open the floodgates for all parts, mainly the 90% failed, inferior variety to be used on all vehicles no matter
the age. Thank you, sir. Questions? Will you entertain a few questions? All right. Representative Payton, I'll entertain that motion.
Well, it's my 30th anniversary, and I'm taking Rhonda to Branson. So could we limit debate to ten minutes precisely? In honor of
Rhonda and your 30th anniversary, I will accept that motion. Thank you, Madam Chair. I believe we have a question for you from Representative Hodges.
You're just seconding. Okay, I'm sure Rhonda appreciates your support as well. All right, we will limit debate now. Let's get, oh, I'm so sorry, shall we vote on that? All in favor? Aye. Thank you. Any questions, nays? No. Thank you so much. The cats and jammer gang are going to get interesting this afternoon. Mr. Strayhorn, any questions for Mr. Strayhorn? Seeing none, thank you.
All right, thank you. I believe next we have Lee Warman, manager with LKQ Corp. Yes, I'd love it if we'd start doubling up. Consolidating. Consolidating is good, all right. Please remember there is a timer. Would anybody like a warning? If you take all the time, it's going to hurt everybody else, so-
Speaker 134
59:48
Okay. Take off. I will do my best. Thank you, Madam Chair, and all of you. I appreciate the time for what we're going to do. This is my colleague, Morgan Blair. I'm just not anybody special. LKQ didn't fly anybody down here from corporate. I actually managed the place in Conway, Arkansas. I grew up in Conway, Arkansas. We are Arkansans. Basically, I just want to represent the 260 employees that are here in Arkansas with LKQ in our five facilities. And I just want to kind of talk a little bit about this law. I do feel like it is a stigma.
that is a little unfairly placed. And not to go over a lot, but we keep hammering on the safety part. I keep hearing the safety part. And I got to go home and sleep at night. I have two children. He's got to go home and sleep at night. We're not out here trying to peddle parts that are going to get people hurt. And I'm not taking that up personally, but I'll tell you right now, the people that are talking are good people. Kevin, good person. I've known him a whole lot. Craig that's sitting over there that we'll talk against, great person. Larry Golden, wonderful person.
All these people that I'm also going to speak against, I can't say a bad word about. But what I can tell you is I know them so well that I know they would never send a car home with anybody that they didn't feel safe after they fixed. And the reason I'm bringing that up is because they are fixing a number of cars with these very same parts that are not under warranty and sending them home. Think about that. Are we saying that the ones under warranty are not safe, but the ones that are outside of warranty they did put on were safe?
We can't have our cake and eat it, too. And I'm telling you right now, I don't think it is a safety issue at all, or I wouldn't be up here talking for it, because I can go home and not sleep. And those are good people that I'm on the other side. So it's not a bad word, but I am going to say that the safety issue on this part of it is overblown because I know they would never do that. And that's why I do think this stigma should not be where it is. I do think that everybody should know when aftermarket parts are being used on the car.
And I'll tell you right now, we've had several that have returned because the people wanted to go with OE. And it was not a warranty deal or anything. It's the insurance company being honest. Here's your estimate. I don't want that fender. I want a new fender. You know what we do? Send it back. We'll take it back. We want people to be comfortable. We're in this business to make money, but we're also in here to take care of people. And so when it comes to the consumer, we do have the consumer in mind as a company. I do promise you that. I can promise you personally I do. I've been working for LKQ only six years, but I grew up running a business that I sold
to LKQ and now run for LKQ. And this company is very ethical and very straightforward on taking care of the consumer. The one thing I also will say is I think we're losing light, and I don't have any stats to prove this. I'm not going to crunch all numbers. I can't get any insurance company to work with me. But it seems to reason. I heard one of you asking earlier about policies and whether or not you can get an OEM policy or something. I do know in other places you can. You can get a policy that says I will only have my car fixed by OEM, and you pay for that premium. But right now, what we have going on is everybody is paying for that premium
when it comes to these cars. So when we're talking about the consumer, the ones we're not thinking about are the ones that are paying extra money, more than likely, because it just stands to reason. Anything that's going to raise the cost of insurance companies is going to turn around and raise the premiums. That's just common sense. Now, I'm not going to sit here, like I said, I can't voodoo read all these numbers to you. I'm just a good old country boy. But I think all of y'all can agree that makes sense. If you raise the cost on an insurance company, what do they do?
They pass a loan because they're going to still make money. So the consumer we're not talking about is all the other consumers that don't have accidents that are helping pay for this. Those are the consumers we're not taking care of. And I do believe that all of us are here, and definitely all of you are here, and that's your main objective is to probably do the right thing for the consumer. And I can look every one of you in the eyes and tell you right now, repealing this, to me, is the right thing for the consumer. Because everybody that gets their car fixed is going to see what goes on their car.
They're going to sign off on it before it even happens. And the reason I know that is, is because an insurance company is not going to fix your car and then say, oh, by the way, could you sign off on this? Oh, we already fixed your car. No. You're going to know up front, regardless if this is here. So I think what this does, this little repealing it, actually in the end will help overall for all the consumers. I do believe that. I wholeheartedly believe that. And I heard somebody asking earlier about saying a fender and having to calibrate something.
And I'm not sure I asked that question, but it's a good question. But here's the thing. That car will not leave that shop with all those things not being calibrated and working before it leaves. So if we did sell you a part that was causing a problem on the calibration, the body shop would tell us, we can't get this calibrated because of your part. You know what we're going to say? Go get a new one. Bring it back. We're going to go send it to our testing facility and find out what happened to begin with to keep that from happening again. But at the same time, that car's not going to leave the shop not calibrated.
Body shop's not even going to sign off on that. So those things actually don't happen because of the checks and balances in the system already. So you can be assured that that's not an issue. And, you know, other than that, I mean, that's just me being just opening up and telling you this is how I really feel about it. Granted, I'm on this side of it, you know, which would make you feel like I'm biased, but I'm actually being totally upfront and honest when I tell you I respect everybody in that room that's been talking about this.
Thank you, Mr. Warman. The four side has four minutes and three seconds left. Well, then I
seconds. You might want to check with your cohorts on that. But I think we have a question or two. All
right, Representative Payton. Thank you, Madam Chair. And just full disclosure, I've bought a lot of your parts and sold a lot of your parts and put them on automobiles. My customers all knew what they were getting. They had a choice between that and OEM. But I don't want to imply that all aftermarket parts are dangerous or extremely substandard.
But, I mean, are you comfortable? Do you realize that this bill does not specify LKQ? I mean, it just says aftermarket parts. And I know you've got a family and you repair your own vehicle. I mean, would you not admit that there are aftermarket part manufacturers out there that you would not want their parts on your vehicle? You know, that's a great question. And what
Speaker 134
1:06:45
I can tell you is where my faith lies is actually in the people that are against me right now. And what I mean by that is none of those guys and none of the insurance companies
are going to let you fix that with that part that's not safe and leave that body shop. That's where I feel comfortable. I can't speak for all manufacturers. I've never been over to Taiwan and viewed all that. I do know several of the parts are actually made by the same manufacturers that make OEM parts. So I can't necessarily testify to someplace way off and, forgive me, coming up with Bangladesh or something I've never seen. I can't sit there and tell you that in good conscience that I'm comfortable with that. But I'm comfortable with the people that the insurance companies use to fix the car to
make sure that you're not going out like that. Gentlemen, I need to remind you, the last few seconds of this, this two minutes needs to go to the
bill sponsor so he can close. If I could just follow up real quick, are you aware that only 7% of the aftermarket parts are CAPA tested? So that means 93% are unknown quality. No, I have
Speaker 134
1:07:48
not had before we did this. Like I said, I'm just running a place in Conway, got an email, said, would you please come up here and represent your company? I would be lying if I sat here and told you I knew any statistics.
Thank you. Thank you, gentlemen. I'd like to reserve the remainder of this time for the sponsor. We have some folks signed up to speak against, and remember, you only have 10 minutes. So, have we doubled up? Are there people that want to go together? When you take the seat, please identify yourself and who you're with. Thank you, Madam Chair and members.
Speaker 143
1:08:36
I am Larry Golden, Golden Collision Center. I own a body shop here in Little Rock for the last 20 years where we've fixed about 25,000 cars. So I hope to bring a little perspective from the real world
Speaker 146
1:08:53
of actual repair. Thank you. I'm David Sample, service director at Guatney Buick GMC in Sherwood. I've been in the automotive industry or the collision repair industry all my life. I was a father on the collision center in Benton. I ran that for 23 years and found my way to the Watney organization.
Speaker 143
1:09:09
Thank you, gentlemen. If you'll make your remarks. I'd like to talk a little bit about part performance. We've been conveyed today that these parts are simply outer skin pieces, plastic parts that have no bearing on safety. I'd like to speak to the parts that do have a bearing on safety. There are structural aftermarket parts that impact specifically how airbags deploy and how cars crash. I'll give you a quick example. There's a bumper reinforcement on a vehicle. Right behind the pretty part of the bumper, there's a piece of steel or aluminum that keeps you safe.
How strong that piece is matters when that car gets hit and how it crushes. If it's too strong or if it's too weak, airbags may deploy too early or too late. It is a very specifically timed process how a car crushes in an accident. It impacts passenger safety. I have personally purchased certified aftermarket bumper reinforcements and OEM bumper reinforcements on the same vehicle. I've done a few simple measurements.
I weighed them. The aftermarket certified part weighed less. I counted the number of welds. There were fewer welds. That part is going to perform differently. Whether it's stronger or weaker is irrelevant. It's different, and that means airbags deploy different, and that means the car crushes differently, and when it does that, you've impacted customer safety, okay? That's the critical part. Here's the thing. During this warranty period, an aftermarket supplier would have an opportunity to test
and actually prove not just that the part fits, but that it will perform the way the OEM part does. So if we continue to have this three-year, that's about what the time is on most warranties, if we have that time, we're going to protect the Arkansas consumer while that manufacturer has an opportunity to not just show the part fits, but to show that it performs. And the only way you can do that is with crash testing and with a thorough research on the part, and they simply can't do it in a matter of months when it took the manufacturer years to develop it on the front end.
Speaker 146
1:11:26
He touched on the safety aspect of it. I'd like to touch a little bit on the fit and finish of the product and what I've seen out there on a day-to-day basis. As Lee Warman suggested, yes, a lot of the vehicles that we repair that are outside the bounds of the manufacturer's warranty does get a dose of aftermarket and LKQ parts. I can tell you just from the amount of repairs that we perform on vehicles that are outside of the warranty, the fit and finish that we have with the aftermarket parts that we use is very much an issue.
We still have to spend more time in trying to align these particular components to make sure that they are not only acceptable to the customer but also acceptable to our manufacturer's guidelines. We're taking a look at one piece of the cost when it comes to performing a repair to a vehicle, the part itself, but mostly as a collision center, we're selling our time. There's a lot of time that is invested that in some cases goes unaccounted for
in making sure that these parts are going to be presentable to the customer whenever we have to perform the delivery. We have the opportunity to make the first impression. We have the opportunity to make the last. And our best form of advertisement, obviously, is our customer service and the quality of product that we turn out and the timeliness of the repair. So there is, of course, I only had about a day and a half to prepare for this, but I can account for, since January, numerous credits, reimbursements that I've received back from our aftermarket providers in order to aid us in the time that we have spent in trying to get these parts fit.
when ultimately, if you take a look at those dollars, the dollars that are spent on rental, potentially while that vehicle is in our possession, and the dollars in labor, that OEM option is not one that's going to be too far off, and in most cases, it will actually be the cheaper repair. Are there any
questions by the committee? Thank you, Madam Chair. Could you just speak for a moment to the committee about the control that the insurance company has over the process as a body shop manager?
I mean, I've been there and I understand it. If you could just kind of explain to the committee that
Speaker 146
1:14:09
the insurance company is already completely in control of the process. Correct. Kind of going back on those vehicles that are outside the bounds of the manufacturer's warranty, Whenever we build that estimate, depending on the particular insurance company, it is necessary for us to write those aftermarket components and used parts on there. It was made mention earlier in the meeting that regardless of the signature, the consumer
has the right to choose in between OEM aftermarket LKQ. That is correct. The difference is, with changing the letter of this law, that's going to allow the insurance company to go the cheaper way. And then that will put the additional expense back into the consumer's hands to replace it with that OEM part. Did that, was that what you were getting
Speaker 143
1:15:02
Okay. If I could say something briefly on that, we're rated by insurance companies. We have things we have to tolerate and things that we do. But somebody said earlier that we treat people differently before warranty and after warranty. In the very specific parts that I'm talking about, these structural safety parts, there is no time on any year model vehicle before or after warranty that my business will put a structural aftermarket part on the car. It's how critical it is. This isn't a financial consideration. This bill doesn't have anything to do with somebody's stigma or not.
It is absolutely a consumer protection. Safety of the passengers in the vehicle is at stake. That's what this bill is really about. Thank you. Any other
questions by the committee? All right. We have two minutes and 47 seconds left on that side. And then on the fourth side, we have a minute 47. And we're going to reserve that back for the bill's sponsor. Anybody else want to speak against the bill in the short period of time left?
Speaker 158
1:16:12
Thank you, Madam Chairman. Chairwoman, I'm sorry. My name is Craig Griffin, and I drove from El Dorado, so I'm going to talk. I'm sorry, but it's been a long day. I came up here for a 9 o'clock meeting. Thank you all for letting me talk. I want to make three quick points, and that's all I'm going to do. I'm not even going to read what I brought. Mr. Warman, thank you for your remarks a while ago, and the feeling is mutual. LKQ is a vendor of ours, and we do business with them. And I've known Mr. Warman for years, and they're good folks. There was an article that came out on October 28, 2016,
where it was reporting on the third quarter earnings call for LKQ Corporation. As you know, they're a large corporation. On their third quarter earnings call, an analyst asked if the current environment, the current advancement in vehicle design was going to adversely affect their company because the repairs were going to end up going to the dealers because of these advanced safety systems and whatnot. I want to tell you the response that was given on that conference, on that call, and it came from the chief financial officer, Nick Sarkone of LKQ Corporation.
He said, even if there were more cars headed into dealer collision shops, that doesn't mean that there's more OE parts. The insurance companies are still mandating which parts to be used. Okay? On the same day, another article came out in our trade press. The headline of that article, the title of that article was, Top Insurers Respond to Inquiry About Notice of Aftermarket Parts Recall. There happened to be one.
and or no they asked they sent inquiries to the top 11 insurance companies in the country and said you're pricing these parts on your estimates for the body shops to use for the customers if there's a problem what happens of the 11 there were four responses printed okay all four said that's on the body shop basically i'm paraphrasing um as a small business makes me a little nervous You know, we're talking about fixing a car, and then you're going to put your family in it,
and you're going to sling them down the road at 70 miles an hour in that vehicle. So we want to make sure you're safe. And it sounds like, from what we're seeing in our trade press, that the insurance companies are ready for us to take that responsibility. So I want to make sure we understand what we're dealing with. Three points. Third point. Earlier it's been talked about that your insurance policy may specify some parts. I want you to remember that insurance policies also affect the person,
the insured that runs into you as a claimant. You're driving down the road and somebody just runs into you. You haven't agreed to their policy. So this law protects you. If their policy calls for those aftermarket parts and yours doesn't, then this consent law gives you an opportunity to have that conversation. i'm a little disappointed to tell you what i'm going to tell you now and it may actually come back to haunt me but i'm going to tell you i was on a conference call wednesday afternoon at 5 p.m with terry fortner who's the industry relations person for lkq
um this bill happened fast i don't know it just came up last week and and we started hearing about it lkq actually reached out to the automotive service association a trade association that i'm member of a National Trade Association, and they asked if there was somebody in Arkansas that they could talk to about the backlash that they were hearing about this bill. So they called me and asked me to call in, and I talked to these folks. And I asked them if it would be palatable to strike the word original manufacturer warranty
and replace that with five years. That's an ambiguous term I came up with, but with a defined period of time. Sir, you just have a few minutes. And I
kind of wish that's kind of where this could have went. But
Speaker 156
1:20:06
anyway, I just want to make sure y'all know that. Thank you for your time. Could I have a
question? We have a short question from a member, sir. Oh, sure.
Number one, I really want to thank you for driving all the way up here from El Dorado. Sorry to cut the time short. I understand. But I know your business, and I really appreciate the fact that you left it and came up here to make this argument.
But what the members here may not appreciate is the fact that if you repair a vehicle with original manufactured parts, a lot of times they cost more and your profit margin is lower than if you were to repair it with the aftermarket parts. So you're not just willing to sacrifice your time by being here. You're willing to sacrifice your profit margin to make sure
Speaker 158
1:20:58
the vehicle is repaired correctly. Just for clarification, I'd say on average, our discount or markup,
or everyone look at it on an OEM part is going to be between 28% and 32%. On an aftermarket part, it's going to be between 35% and 48%. I make more margin on aftermarket. It's less dollars on the list price, so the profit dollars comes out about the same, either way. Thank you for coming
back. If I could have the bill sponsor come back to the end of the table. I think we're out of time on both sides. And I think the committee may have questions for you, Representative Collins. Yes, ma'am.
Members, any questions for Representative Collins? Hearing none, Representative Collins, would you like to close for your bill? Yes, ma'am.
So I just want to hit on a couple things that were said, and then I want to hit on what I think it sounds like the main thing is going to be. So the first one is in how much money you make. there's a percentage on a smaller number, which is what you get with an aftermarket part if you're the shop, or a smaller percentage on a much bigger number. So the absolute number that you make on putting a part in can be much higher on the OEM side.
In 1997, when we passed this law to allow aftermarket parts to be used, I would have also agreed it was fine to have this signature. 20 years later, it's time to take it off. And finally, what I want to do is a little bit about the regulation. So the Motor Vehicle Safety Act in Congress gave the Secretary of Transportation broad authority to prescribe standards, safety standards. The Motor Vehicle Safety Act prohibits, in part, the manufacturing, selling, and importing of new vehicles and new vehicle equipment that do not comply with the NHTSA safety standards.
These provisions could apply to both OEM and new aftermarket crash parts, since new parts are classified as new motor vehicle equipment. Although the NHTSA has the authority to regulate aftermarket crash parts, the agency has not determined that these parts pose a significant safety concern and therefore has not developed safety standards for them. According to agency officials, the agency has not developed safety standards for aftermarket parts because, one, testing by IIHS concluded that the use of aftermarket crash parts does not affect vehicle safety.
Problems with aftermarket crash parts tend to focus on fit and finish rather than safety and other reasons. What I'm sharing with you is that the GAO of the federal government is saying that we don't have a significant safety concern here. And the final point I would make is I cannot imagine any of these gentlemen sending anybody off on their way knowing that their airbags are going to blow up in their face or that their cars are going to derail and go off a bridge. I just don't think any of them would normally do that. And with that, I would humbly ask you to fight for the little guy and see if we can move the puck one inch down the field
to help consumers have lower prices in Arkansas. Thank you very
much. Thank you, committee. What is the pleasure
of the committee? I move to pass on Senate Bill 291.
Members, all of, I'm sorry. Discussion, I'm so sorry. Discussion, Representative Payton. Thank you, Madam
Chair. Members, I should have jumped in there a while ago. I wanted to straighten up some misinformation that was given about whether there be three or four or six states that currently do this.
I think in 2009 there were six states, but as of last September, I think it was, last August, there are 10 states now that require consent. There's never been a state to repeal the consent requirement. This number's not going down. It's going up. Aftermarket parts have been around since the late 80s, and they've gained market share, and it has forced states to deal with it. And so what has happened, 35 states have implemented some type of disclosure requirement.
And of those, we now have 10 states that require, as of last August, 10 states that require permission from the customer to use the aftermarket part. So that number is going up, and
we would be the first state to repeal that requirement. Can you imagine that? Can you imagine Arkansas being number one to reduce regulations for the first time in the history of this state?
Any other discussion? Seeing none, I believe we have a vote to take. Those in favor? Aye. Those opposed? No. The no's have it. Thank you very much, Madam Chair. Thank you. I believe it looks like we're adjourned, that would be Representative Collins' call.
Speaker 167
1:26:24
heading home. You can't go all the way home. All right. You can't go all the way home. You can't go all the way home. Okay.
Agenda
HB1527 Rushing FOR REQUIREMENTS ESTATE REAL EDUCATION CONTINUING CONCERNING LICENSEES.
HB1585 Capp DISPOSAL THE FOR INFORMATION PERSONAL OF TO PROCEDURE A CREATE CONTAINED IN A LEASED SELF-SERVICE STORAGE SPACE.
HB1592 Leding TO PROVIDE PARITY IN HEALTH BENEFIT PLAN COVERAGE BETWEEN ORALLY AND INTRAVENOUSLY ADMINISTERED ADMINISTERED ANTICANCER MEDICATION ANTICANCER MEDICATION.
HB1594 Sabin TO REVISE THE DEFINITION OF "PAID SOLICITOR" AS IT RELATES TO SOLICITATION OF CONTRIBUTIONS FOR CHARITABLE PURPOSES.
HB1604 Jett TO PROVIDE FOR THE EXAMINATION AND REGULATION OF CERTAIN ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT FINANCE CORPORATIONS BY THE STATE BANK DEPARTMENT; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
SB291 Standridge TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT FOR THE USE OF CERTAIN AFTERMARKET CRASH PARTS IN REPAIR OF A VEHICLE.
HB1448 M. Gray TO INCLUDE FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS INSURED BY THE NATIONAL CREDIT UNION ADMINISTRATION AS INSTITUTIONS ALLOWED TO SERVE AS DEPOSITORIES OF PUBLIC FUNDS.
HB1667 Beck TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING A PROPERTY OWNER'S BILL OF RIGHTS.
DEFERRED Subtitle Sponsor Number
HB1145 C. Douglas TO RESTRICT A JOINT TENANT'S ABILITY TO SEVER A JOINT TENANCY WITH RIGHT OF SURVIVORSHIP IN REAL PROPERTY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1166 Rushing TO CLARIFY THE OBLIGATIONS OF RESIDENTIAL LANDLORDS AND RESIDENTIAL TENANTS; AND TO REQUIRE IMPLIED QUALITY STANDARDS FOR TENANTS OF RESIDENTIAL REAL PROPERTY.
HB1271 Hammer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HEALTH INSURANCE INNOVATION ACT OF 2017; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1377 Lemons WARRANTY EXPRESS DEFECTIVE AGAINST MANUFACTURER'S A CONCERNING ASPHALT ROOF SHINGLES.
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Charlie Collins
Unverified
Representative Robin Lundstrum Chair
Unverified
Derek Smith
Unverified
Representative Joe Jett
Unverified
Representative John Payton
Unverified
Representative Laurie Rushing
Unverified
Speaker 10
Representative Grant Hodges
Unverified
Representative Marcus E. Richmond
Unverified
Representative Ken Henderson
Unverified
Representative Mark Lowery
Unverified
Dennis Youngmeyer
Unverified
Representative Austin McCollum
Unverified
Speaker 111
Speaker 158
Speaker 118
Speaker 119
Speaker 134
Speaker 143
Speaker 146
Speaker 156
Speaker 166
Speaker 167