House Meeting
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (36)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1038
· 5 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1038 Davis 1 TO ALLOW THE MULTIYEAR REGISTRATION OF PERSONAL-USE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1019
· 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1019 Cozart 1 TO AMEND THE MEMBERSHIP OF THE SCHOOL LEADERSHIP C…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1172
· 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1172 Tosh 1 CREATING A SENTENCE ENHANCEMENT FOR CERTAIN CRIMINAL…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1319
· 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1319 Shepherd 1 TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 23 OF THE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1521
· 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…Richmond recommends that we concur in Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1521. Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Amendment 1. Senate Amendmen…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1320
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1320 Shepherd 1 TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 5 OF THE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1432
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…y and one present the bill has passed mr. clerk please read house bill 1432 house bill 1432”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1509
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Pick back up with House Bill 1509, so at this time would you please read House Bill 1509. Hou…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1590
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…e measure? Representative Gray, would you like to close for House Bill 1590? All right. You're recognized to do so at this”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1642
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1642 Wing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE APPOINTMENT OF THE CHI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1643
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…nd one present. The bill has passed. Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1643. House Bill 1643 by Representative Wing to amend the law co…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HCR1006
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…Notice I didn't say fun. All right, Mr. Clerk, please read House Concurrent Resolution 1006. House Concurrent Resolution 1006 by Representative Watson,…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1010
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…nd one present, the bill has passed. Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1010. House Bill 1010 by Representative Sabin to amend the law c…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1586
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…back up the calendar at this point. Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1586. House Bill 1586 by Representative Payton to amend certain…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB10
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…so the question now before the house will be the passage of house bill 10 10. pair the machine mr. clerk”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1360
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…blic retirement to whom was referred to House Bill 1365 and House Bill 1360. I beg leave to report that we have had the same under cons…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1365
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…are committee on public retirement to whom was referred to House Bill 1365 and House Bill 1360. I beg leave to report that we have had…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1377
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1377 Lemons CONCERNING A MANUFACTURER'S EXPRESS WARRANTY AGAINST…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB15
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Mr. Clerk, please read the House Bill 15...”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1527
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1527 Rushing CONCERNING CONTINUING EDUCATION REQUIREMENTS FOR RE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1536
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1536 M. Gray TO AMEND THE MINORITY BUSINESS ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1569
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1569 C. Douglas TO REDUCE THE STANDARD LICENSING FEE FOR CERTAIN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1581
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1581 Hammer TO IMPLEMENT A SURVEY OF EMPLOYEE ENGAGEMENT AS AN A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1585
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1585 Capp TO CREATE A PROCEDURE FOR THE DISPOSAL OF PERSONAL INF…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HR1006
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Mr. Clerk, please read House Resolution 1006 in its entirety. Whereas the Prescott High School Curly Woo…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB148
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB148 G. Stubblefield (C. Fite) TO CREATE BORN-ALIVE INFANT PROTE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB159
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB159 J. English (Drown) CONCERNING THE DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AF…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB174
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB174 J. English (Drown) TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DUTIES O…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB277
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB277 Hickey (McNair) CONCERNING THE PROCEDURES FOR OBTAINING TIT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB284
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB284 Hester (Eubanks) TO ESTABLISH A RETAIL OFF-PREMISES PERMIT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB328
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB328 A. Clark (C. Douglas) TO REQUIRE A PERSON WHO APPLIES FOR A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB340
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB340 J. Hutchinson (Pilkington) TO CREATE THE WRONGFUL BIRTH CIV…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB344
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB344 Rapert (Collins) TO MODERNIZE THE INSURANCE HOLDING COMPANY…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB348
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB348 Hickey (Womack) TO AMEND ARKANSAS LAW PERTAINING TO THE DUT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB42
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB42 J. Hutchinson (Capp) CONCERNING FITNESS TO PROCEED AND LACK…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SJR8
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SJR8 Irvin (Ballinger) A CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT LIMITING CONTI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 13, 2026
Unknown speaker
0:00
Thank you.
All right.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
um
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Members, the House will come to order at this time. I invite all of you to stand along with our guests in the galleries, our staff, and the press to be led in prayer today by our colleague, Representative Kim Hammer, and then to remain standing for our Pledge of Allegiance to be led today by Representative Greg Letting.
Would you join me in prayer, please? Heavenly Fathers, we come before your throne today. We thank you that you are God and you are the great I am. You loved us enough that you stepped aside and let your son die on the cross of Calvary, pay for our sin debt, that all who would trust in you might have the gift of eternal life if they just ask and believe in their heart that shall be saved. We thank you for being a God that has allowed us as members of this great institution to be able to be here to serve and father be able to hopefully be an extension of your wisdom and
your mercy your compassion and all the other fruits of the spirit we should display we ask your father upon our father upon our deliberations today your blessing may we speak to each other with kindness and may we speak to each other knowing that one day we'll answer to you and you'll speak to us and i just pray father for the decisions that have to be made today. Some of them are very difficult decisions. We all have our own reasons and justifications, but above all, we pray that, Father, we would just please you in all that we do, if nothing else, through the actions we show.
We just pray for our men and women, both here at home on the front lines in our police departments and fire departments and EMS. And, Father, we pray for the men and women that are serving abroad and here at home that just grant us the freedom to come out here and have the public debate. May we just remember them and may we remember their families especially those that have lost loved ones and the cause of freedom. And now Father we just pray for your Holy Spirit to guide us in the day and we just count it a privilege to be here and thank you for that opportunity.
And we ask all these things in the name of Father, Son, and Holy Spirit and all God's people said. Amen. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. All right, members, you know what to do. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk.
All right, let's cast out the ballots, Mr. Clerk. All right, with 97 present, the chair receives a quorum. Are there any requests for leave? Representative Jett, you are recognized. Leave for Representative Chris Ritchie, please. Is leave granted, members, for Representative Ritchie? Aye. All right, so noted. Any other requests for leave?
Representative De La Rosa, you're recognized. Leave for Representative Vaught. Is leave granted for Representative Vaught? All right, so noted. Representative Warren, you're recognized. Leave for Representative Gates. Leave granted for Representative Gates. All right, so noted. All right, Representative Jean moves that we dispense with the reading of the previous day's journal without objection, so ordered.
Are there any reports from select committees, Mr. Clerk? Are there any reports from standing committees? All right, let's read the reports, Mr. Clerk. Mr. Speaker, we are committee on public retirement to whom was referred to House Bill 1365 and House Bill 1360. I beg leave to report that we have had the same under consideration and herewith to turn the same with the recommendation they do pass. Respectfully submitted, Douglas House, co-chair. Mr. Clerk, is there any unfinished business?
Are there any executive communications? All right, members, before we proceed to our red calendar, Representative Fortner has with us up in the North Gallery our Marion County Sheriff Clinton Evans,
and he's got two friends and prominent citizens that are here today from Yellowville, Terry and Brady Madden. So let's welcome them. Thank you. All right, members, turn your attention to the red calendar.
We will begin what promises to be a long and eventful day. Notice I didn't say fun. All right, Mr. Clerk, please read House Concurrent Resolution 1006. House Concurrent Resolution 1006 by Representative Watson, congratulating the Prescott High School Curly Wolves football team on winning the state 3A championship. Representative Watson, you're recognized.
Representative Watson, after that applause, before you even come down, you may have a difficulty time getting them going again, so you're recognized to present your resolution.
Mr. Beaker, I'd like to have Representative Fielding with me in reference to HCR 1006, recognizing the Prescott Curly Wolves football team for their state championship this year. It's the 3A state champions. This is something many, many dream of, very few accomplish. Mr. Speaker, at this time, I'm going to ask you if you would have the House Clerk read the HCR 10-006 in its entirety, please.
Mr. Clerk, please read House Resolution 1006 in its entirety. Whereas the Prescott High School Curly Woods football team beat the Charleston High School Tigers for the 2016 Class 3A championship with a score of 37-26. And whereas head coach Tommy Poole helped lead them to victory. And whereas Coach Poole thanked Eddie Jackson, former coach of 28 years, for laying the groundwork for the Prescott football team, and whereas the team rushed for 3,368 yards, a new school record, passed for 2,429 yards, and had a total of 5,797 yards, which is the fourth
most in school history. And whereas the Curly Wolves demonstrated great leadership and effort, as well as support from their school administration, school board, and teachers, and the state title is a tribute to their talent, hard work, and with the support of their families, friends, and the community. Now, therefore, be it resolved by the House of Representatives of the 91st General Assembly of the State of Arkansas, the Senate concurring therein, that the General Assembly congratulates the Prescott High School Curly Wolves football team on winning the Arkansas Class 3A State Championship. Be it further resolved that upon its adoption, a copy of this resolution shall be presented
to the Superintendent of the Prescott Schools, Robert Poole, and Head Coach Tommy Poole by the Chief Clerk of the House of Representatives. Thank you very much for HCR 1006. I appreciate a favorable vote. Thank you. all right members you've heard an explanation of the resolution would anyone like speak against
the resolution or the resolution all right representative watson would you like to close for your resolution thank you colleagues appreciate appreciate a favorable vote in this resolution Thank you. All right, members, the question before the House will be the passage of House concurrent resolution 1006. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, say no. All right, the ayes have it.
Motion carries. The resolution has been adopted. Okay, members, we also have with us in the North Gallery
as guests of Representative Bragg. We have Mark and Sherry Lindsey from Big Springs, Texas that are here today. And then we also have Dr. Kazim Shoshy from Paya, Kosovo, who is here to get a chance for the first time to watch his son Liz play basketball for UALR. So let's welcome them.
We have with us in the back of the room our Doctors of the Day from Fort Smith. We have Dr. Chris Gast, and from Little Rock we have Dr. Michael Cope that are here with us. Let's welcome them. And we have Ms. Sherri Bernard that is here with us as our Nurse of the Day. So, let's welcome her.
All right, that's gonna conclude our morning hour. All right, members, Representative Tosh recommends that we concur in Senate Amendment 1 House Bill 1172. Mr. Clerk please read Senate Amendment 1. Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1172. Representative Tosh, you are recognized to explain
Amendment number one. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Friends, this is a Senate amendment. This was my bill, and they did contact me about it. It is a good amendment.
I actually believe it helps better clarify the intent of the bill. They only changed a couple of words on it. And without any questions, I would appreciate a good vote. All right, members, you've heard an explanation of the amendment. Would anyone like to speak against the amendment or the amendment? Representative Tosh has signified he's closed for the amendment.
All right. The question before the House will be the concurrence of Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1172. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk.
All right, let's cast the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 88 yeas, 0 nay, and 1 present, we have concurred with Senate Amendment 1 to House House Bill 1172. Representative Shepard recommends that we concur in Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill
1320. Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Amendment 1. Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1320. Representative Shepard, you're recognized to present the amendment. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, the amendment number one to House Bill 1320 just deletes some language that the state police had asked.
We delete. And, members, this is a technical correction bill. There was some discussion with the state police about making some changes. That has been dealt with in a substantive bill. And so now we're just making this legislation consistent with what was done with regard to the substantive legislation. And with that, I would appreciate a good vote. All right, members, you've heard an explanation of the amendment. Would anyone like to speak against the amendment for the amendment? Representative Shepard has signified that he is closed for the amendment.
So the question now before the House will be the concurrence of Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1320. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. has everyone voted all right let's cast out the ballots mr. clerk with 91 yeas zero nay and zero present we have concurred with senate amendment one to house bill 1320
our representative shepherd recommends that we concur with senate amendment one to house Bill 1319. Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Amendment Number 1. Senate Amendment Number 1 to House Bill 1319. Representative Shepard, you're recognized. Explain the amendment. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Senate Amendment Number 1 to House Bill 1319 is similar to the last bill. Just some clarification,
some language that the agency had asked for and really just makes a couple little minor changes and I would appreciate a good vote all right members you've heard an explanation of the amendment would anyone like speak against the amendment for the amendment our representative Shepherd has signified that he is closed for the amendment so the question now before the house will be the concurrence. Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1319. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk.
Everyone voted? All right, let's cast up the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 85 yeas, 1 1, nay, and 0 present. We have concurred in Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1319. Representative Davis recommends that we concur with Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1038. Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Amendment 1.
Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1038. Representative Davis, you're recognized to explain the amendment. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, this was the bill we looked at in the very early days of session that makes it so we can register motorcycles and RVs for multiple years. It got all the way to the Senate floor, and DF&A remembered that they needed an implementation date. So that's all we did. We added an implementation date of November 13th. Appreciate a good vote.
All right. Members, you've heard an explanation of the amendment. Would anyone like to speak against the amendment for the amendment? All right, Representative Davis signified he's closed for the amendment. So the question now before the House will be the concurrence of Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1038. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Everyone voted? All right, let's cast out the ballots, Mr. Clerk, with 91 yeas.
0 nays and 0 present, we have concurred in Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1038. Representative Cozart recommends that we concur in Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1019. Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Amendment 1. Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1019. Representative Cozart, you're recognized to explain the amendment. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. colleagues that what this does is adds some new language that we added another
group to this leadership council and we changed the number from 15 to 17 which would be the correct numbers instead of the wrong number there but it added the Arkansas Teachers Association in there with it also I appreciate a good vote all right members you've heard an explanation of the amendment when he would like speak against the amendment for the amendment there's in the codes already signified he's closed for the amendment so the question now before the House will be the concurrence of Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1019 prepare the machine Mr. Clerk
everyone voted all right let's cast the ballots Mr. Clerk 88 yay 0 nay and one present. We have concurred in Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1019. Representative Richmond recommends that we concur in Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1521. Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Amendment 1. Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1521. Representative Richmond, you're recognized to explain the amendment. Thank You Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, all this amendment does is add
a Senate co-sponsor to the bill I'd appreciate a good spoke all right representative Richmond has explained the amendment would anyone like speak against the amendment for the amendment he has signified he's closed for the amendment so now the question before the house will be the concurrence of Senate to Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1521. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk.
Everyone voted? Let's cast up the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 91 yeas, 0 nay, and 0 present, we have a concurred to Senate Amendment 1 to House Bill 1521. All right, Mr. Clerk, at the request of the sponsor, we're going to pass over the first item in our regular bills agenda for the House. And I do not see Representative Douglas with us, so we'll skip over that one for the time being. We may come back to that one today or we'll just pick it up tomorrow.
So at this time, Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1642. House Bill 1642 by Representative Wing to amend the law concerning the appointment of the chief of the Arkansas Highway Police Division of the Arkansas Highway Transportation Department. Representative Wing, you're recognized to present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, what this does is it helps clean up some administrative language. When the law was passed that created the opportunity for the Arkansas Highway Police to be under the banner of the Arkansas Highway and Transportation Department,
for whatever reason, it was listed to be under the commissioners rather than the director of the commission. And as a matter of practicality, he works for the director of the Highway and Transportation Department. Our Arkansas Highway Police Chief, Ron Burks, is in favor of this. so is the director it helps clean up some things and this would put them in alignment with the rest of the other auxiliaries within the organization all but one and I have a feeling we'll hear about that one in the very next bill but I'd appreciate a good vote on this one if you have any questions I'm happy to
take some thank you all right members you've heard an explanation of the bill would anyone like speak against the bill for the bill represent the wing he is signified he is closed for the bill so the question now for the house with the passage of House bill 1642 for the machine mr. clerk
everyone voted let's cast the ballots mr. clerk with 88 yeas one day and one present. The bill has passed. Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1643. House Bill 1643 by Representative Wing to amend the law concerning the state aid engineer of the Arkansas Highway and Transportation Department. Representative Wing, you're recognized to present your next bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The sequel is just as exciting as the first one. If you loved it, the second verse, same as the first,
1643. We do the same thing with a state aid engineer and what this does is brings everybody into alignment as they are with the rest of the department so I'd appreciate a good vote. All right. Members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Before the bill? Representative Wing has signified he's closed for the bill so the question now before the House will be the passage of House Bill 1643.
Excuse me, prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Everyone voted? All right. Let's cast the ballots, Mr. Clerk. 87 yeas, 1 nay, and 0 present. The bill has passed. Okay, Mr. Clerk, we're going to pass over the next item on the agenda.
Pick back up with House Bill 1509, so at this time would you please read House Bill 1509. House Bill 1509 by Representative Letting to create the Sudden Cardiac Arrest Prevention Act. Representative Letting, you're recognized to present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, sudden cardiac arrest is the number one killer of student athletes in the country. In 72% of those cases, the students exhibit symptoms of the cardiac arrest before it happens. What this bill does, it establishes a basic protocol for anybody observing students in a coaching position to be on the lookout for.
We already require that coaches look out for things like dehydration, concussions, even communicable diseases. So this just adds cardiac arrest to the list and adds a basic protocol for coaches to follow if they exhibit these signs. The Arkansas Athletic Trainers Association signed off on this bill. The Fayetteville and Springdale Public School District signed off on this bill, and we got it out of House education unanimously last week. I'd appreciate a good vote. All right, members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill or the bill?
All right, Reminds of Lettingham, signified he is closed for the bill. So the question now before the House will be the passage of House Bill 1509. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. everyone voted everyone voted all right let's cast with the ballots mr. clerk with 83 a's zero nay and one present the bill has passed mr. clerk please read house bill 1432 house bill 1432
by Representative Wing concerning the transportation of maltreated adults and to define impairment under the Adult Maltreatment Custody Act of the Adult and Long-Term Care Facility Resident Maltreatment Act. Representative Wing, you're acting nice to present your next bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues what this bill does is it helps fix a gap in transportation. If anybody has been, if an adult has been removed by DHS for their own safety and they're currently
in a psychiatric facility, a hospital, long-term care facility, or a nursing home, there is a rare occasion when they need to be brought in, when a judge will order them to come into their hearing. And it could be any of the probable cause hearings or long-term care facility hearings or any of that. And right now there is no way for Medicaid to be able to cover the cost of that transportation. What has happened in the interim is DHS employees have had to do this in their own personal
vehicles. And some of these people that are needing transportation need much more care than just a seat belt in a four-seater sedan. And so they need the opportunity to be able to be transported by someone who is licensed and bonded for that type of transportation. This bill helps fix that and gets the funding in a way that brings that all into fruition so that everybody gets to where they need to go. Happy to take any questions if needed.
Seeing none, I'd appreciate a good vote. Thank you. All right, members, I've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? for the bill representative wings signifies closed for the bill so the question now for the house will be the passage of house bill 1432 prepare the machine mr. clerk is everyone voted everyone voted
When I was cast at the ballots, Mr. Clerk, with 89 yeas, one nay, and one present, the bill has passed. Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1010. House Bill 1010 by Representative Sabin to amend the law concerning the filing and publication of certain campaign finance reports and to amend portions of the law resulted from initiated Act 1 of 1990 and initiated Act 1 of 1996. Representative Sabin, you're recognized to present your bill. Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker.
Colleagues, you may remember a few weeks ago we passed a bill here by Representative De La Rosa that requires the electronic filing of our campaign finance and expenditure reports. This bill replicates that bill almost exactly in its language, but instead of applying to candidates, it applies to political action committees and independent expenditure committees and exploratory committees. It doesn't create any new requirements for those groups, So it's the same reporting that they're already doing now on paper.
This would just simply require it to be done electronically. And as Representative De La Rosa pointed out when she brought her bill, when you require this kind of electronic filing, you make it more transparent. You make it easier to search. You're taking advantage of new technology. And it's just more transparent, more accountable, better for the citizens, and actually better for the people who run these committees. In fact, many of you might have received an email from at least one professional fundraiser that runs these kinds of PACs who thinks that we ought to be requiring this kind of electronic
filing already. So I've worked with the Secretary of State's office. There's no known opposition to this bill, but I'd be glad to take any questions if there are any. And seeing none, I appreciate a good vote. Thank you very much. All right, members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? for the bill all right representative Saban is signified he's closed for the bill so the question now before the house will be the passage of house bill 10 10. pair the machine mr. clerk
everyone voted all right let's cast the ballots mr. clerk with 86 yeas zero nay and zero present the bill has passed
Mr. Clerk, please read the House Bill 15...
After a recent incident at the governor's mansion, it came to the attention of the state police that if especially surveillance footage was available to be foiled for a certain amount of time that it would be possible for the general public or anyone interested to actually
be able to see what the security timeline was, what the schedule was, how the gates and entrances are checked. It would just compromise the security protocol for the governor's mansion and the grounds. So the state police asked Deanne, or asked Representative Vaught to run this bill for them to kind of shore that up to help keep the security intact around the governor's mansion. So I'd be glad to take any questions about it. Representative Rushing, for what purpose?
Question. You're recognized for your question, ma'am. Just a simple question on what does this do to transparency towards the governor's mansion, anything that may happen there? I mean, I understand them not wanting to know the schedules and everything, but the transparency issue of a FOIA is what that is there for. Yes, and we've had somewhere around 20 FOIA bills filed this session, and kind of as we look through all of them, having to make a decision between public safety or the safety of our constitutional officers in the General Assembly versus freedom of press and what they should be allowed to get.
And so the state police and obviously Representative Ott and myself felt that the safety of the governor and the governor's staff and the security of the perimeter of the property was in the best interest of the state of Arkansas. And this also includes like the security plans that they have on record, not just the surveillance footage. Representative Flowers, for what purpose? Thank you. Question? You're recognized for your question, ma'am. Excuse me. I'm just wondering, have there been any attempts prior to today to request that kind of information?
And if so, or even if not, have there also ever been any threats to the security of the governor's staff, the governor or any state police or anyone who might be affected by withholding this information? I believe there have been, and I know that in an incident that happened not too long ago, a large portion of video surveillance was FOIA'd. Now, because that was under a criminal investigation, it could not be released at that point in time.
But that brought the state police to stop and think. With the amount of footage that we're possibly having to release, it could compromise our security protocols. So that's kind of what really prompted this session, to my knowledge. Follow-up? You're recognized for your follow-up, ma'am. And I do apologize. I know that we had an opportunity to get a list of bills, but to be honest, I hadn't had an opportunity to look at the details of this one. And so I would ask, does this make any specific, does this define any specifics around which this information would not be provided?
Or is it a wholesale? We don't have to give it to the press if it's ever requested. Well, this bill is an exclusion. And so it excludes data, records, surveillance footage, security procedures, emergency plans, and other information compiled or possessed by the Department of the Arkansas State Police. So it has to be information that is theirs, that they keep, concerning the governor's mansion and the grounds. So it is an exclusion. Question to Blake, for what purpose?
Question? You're recognized for your question. Representative Gray, in line 27 and 28, it says data, records, surveillance footage, security procedures, emergency plans, and other information. That seems kind of broad. What does data, records, and other information mean? for me personally it just means anything that has to do with the security plans the data or the security protocols that the state police keeps any information that they keep that they deem to be contradictory to the security of the perimeter of the mansion
follow-up you recognize free follow-up sir have have you or other sponsors thought about tightening up because it says in the bill surveillance footage security procedures emergency plans but it also has data records and other information have you have this you have the sponsor thought about tightening up that this so it's because it's so broad and just leaving security footage security procedures and emergency plans that that seemed like it would cover what you're trying to do to my knowledge um no but i've without her being present today i'm not able to
ask her that. I'd be glad to ask her after today and see if she, you know, something she wants to amend possibly on the Senate end or talk with us about amending, but to my knowledge, no. Representative Brown, for what purpose? You're recognized for your question, ma'am. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It is my understanding and I'm just asking you to confirm and I do appreciate that it's difficult to present somebody else's bill. But it's my understanding, I heard this presented in committee, I believe
that it is in alignment with the security restrictions that are placed around the president of the United States and his family, and this was worded and collaborated with by federal security agents that protect the president. Is that correct? That is correct. That is what was testified to in committee that the protocols that are the exclusion that's here is also what's done on the federal level around the White House.
That is the testimony that I heard in committee. Thank you. Thank you. I appreciate a good vote. I'm stepping out. All right, members, you heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill, Representative Hammer, you're recognized to speak for the bill. It won't take a lot of time, but I was in committee when this was presented, and it
was totally presented along the line of the security of the governor and his staff, not anything intended to hide anything that the general public shouldn't know about. But in the day and age of which we live, we want to provide to the best security of our constitutional officers especially the governor and so all the testimony that was given in the committee was along the lines of making sure that we have the safest environment of which the governor and let's remember also the governor's family lives in so appreciate a good vote
members representative hammer has spoken in favor of the measure when he will I speak against the measure representative Blake you're recognized to speak against the bill. I hate to speak against this measure with Representative Vaught, not in the chamber, but if you look at the bill, it clearly outlines security procedures, surveillance footage, and then it gets extremely broad when it says all other information. So I would, if we are looking at tightening up,
taking out the security that is already stated in the bill, it just is kind of worrisome to me that we are actually saying all other information within the bill. It's very broad, and I would like to see this bill tighten up before it's passed out of the House. Thank you. All right, members. Representative Blake has spoken against the measure. Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Representative Lowry, you're recognized to speak for the bill.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This broad language is not broad at all. It specifically says any other information compiled or possessed by the Arkansas State Police. It's under specific heading of security. And in this day and time where people are being shouted down for mentioning the name of Jesus in a prayer or veterans are being shouted down by doing the Pledge of Allegiance,
we have to err on the side of caution in protecting our governor. And I believe the presentation of the representative, that this is in line with what is being done at the national level, and it should be carried through for safety and security of our governor. So I would ask that you would vote for the bill. All right, members, you've heard Representative Lowry speak in favor of the measure. Would anyone like to speak against the bill?
All right, for the bill, Representative Drown, you're recognized at this point to speak for the bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Dear colleagues, one of the questions I asked when this came through committee the other day was, does this fall under the guidelines that the Secret Service uses in regards to executive protection of the President of the United States, the White House, and when he's traveling around, whether it be the nation or around the globe?
And state police response was that they train with and under the guidelines of the Secret service, and this fell within the guidelines that they use for executive pression in Washington, D.C. All right. Members, Representative Drown has spoken in favor of the measure. Would anyone like to speak against the measure? Representative Gray, would you like to close for House Bill 1590? All right. You're recognized to do so at this
time. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. to Representative Blake's concern, and we'll look at it after today. But it says in Section 1 on Line 24, concerning the security of the Governor Capitol building is amended to add an additional subsection. So in the bill it talks about this is addressing the security. So it's the data, records, surveillance footage that pertain to the security. And it's also just the and other information compiled or possessed by the Department of the Arkansas State Police concerning the governor's mansion.
So it's just anything that they would compile, excuse me, for security reasons. So I would appreciate a good vote. Thank you. Okay, members, the question now before the House would be the passage of House Bill 1590. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. All right, has everyone voted?
All right, let's cast the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 77 yeas, 7 nays, and 8 present, the bill has passed. All right, members, we're going to go back up the calendar at this point. Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1586. House Bill 1586 by Representative Payton to amend certain provisions of the workers' compensation law enacted by Initiated Act No. 4 of 1948 and to declare an emergency.
Representative Payton, you're recognized to present the bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And members, first off, I really want to thank you all for making the vote the other day to expunge the vote on this. It came up very quickly without everybody having a good chance to vet it and understand it. I hope we've been able to answer many of your questions over the weekend. Of course, this is the bill that deals with the workers' comp because the trust fund was dissolved last May during a special session. The chamber and the governor's office and some other key players have been in negotiations about what could be done to try to prevent the exposure, taking the rates through the roof on workers' comp.
It's a very important small business bill, it's very important to economic development that Arkansas remains one of the lower states in workers' comp rates, and it will require a 67-vote threshold, so I really need every vote, and I'd appreciate a good vote. All right, members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? the bill. Representative Collins, you're recognized to speak for the bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
This is part two of a two-part solution. We did the easy part, part one in a special session last year. Because the government's insurance fund was going way over and we owe a lot of money, we eliminated that fund. That fund had a cap in it. There was a cap to the benefits that could be paid. In today's world, without any type of a cap,
we're at risk of having exorbitant increases over time on Arkansas businesses in their insurance rates. So the bottom line is we have got to have this part two, otherwise we risk scaring employers away over time. Thank you. All right, members, Representative Collins has spoken in favor of the measure. Will I speak against the bill? I've got Representative De La Rosa. You're recognized to speak against the bill.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I've got one question for everybody in here. If the rates were going to go through the roof, why are we not hearing from insurance companies? Because I guarantee you would be hearing from them if the rates were going to go through the roof. This is, in my opinion, wrong, capping it at 450 weeks. That means a 20-year-old person that gets permanently disabled is only going to get covered for 450 weeks, and they're on their own for the rest of their life. And they say, well, you know, they could get Social Security disability.
No, they can't, not at the age of 20 or 25, because they wouldn't have put in very much by then. Now, they can get Medicaid and all that, but think of what you're actually doing to somebody that's under the age of 30 with this that's the balance that you have to meet with this the needs of the worker versus the cost to the employer so in my opinion I think this is the right thing to do even though the self-insured employers are probably going to have to pay more because they're going to have to cover higher claims because we don't have the trust fund anymore but I think it's the right thing to do I'd appreciate a no vote okay members
representative de la Rosa spoken against the measure would anyone like speak for the bill representative miller you're recognized to speak for the bill all right i guess i could be like an evangelist and start out here in the crowd who in here has heard the story of Abraham all right real quick I want to
speak for this representative Peyton's worked hard on this folks and if there's anybody in here that believes in protecting the disabled I do and I don't believe that this bill is an unjust removal of protections for folks on disability one thing I would like to say is that you can get Social Security disability at a young age this is a matter of needing to needing to have
something in place for our employers also it's good to have something in place for the victims in this situation where they know we have such-and-such benefit that's going to last a certain amount of time that way they can plan and I will be happy to take a question from representative Walker okay anyway I would appreciate a good vote on this thank you all right members representative Miller
has spoken in favor of the measure. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative House, you are recognized to speak against the bill. I wasn't planning on speaking against the bill at all. I was just going to vote against it and leave it at that until I heard something said in there that's important.
Last year, around the fiscal session, Senator Standridge and I were tasked to close the death and total disability fund. Essentially, and I think it was something like 20-something million in the hole. In other words, we were paying out more for death and permanent disability than employers were paying in through contributions and insurance premiums to keep that fund alive.
Arkansas has the third lowest workers' compensation insurance rates in the country. That's due for two reasons. Number one is a worker and employer emphasis on safety. And number two, relatively low wages as compared to the rest of the country. Now, as we were closing that fund, there were extensive negotiations with representatives from the Chamber of Commerce and representatives of the insurance agency,
Director Webb from the Department of the Workers' Compensation Commission, and we were all in a room and we were hammering out the details. Everybody, and laborers, and representatives of labor, working people. We were hammering out the details. We were faced with two choices, either raise the premiums and the amount of money that employers have to pay into that fund to reconstitute it, which would mean massive increases in premiums,
or dissolve the fund, the employer will be responsible for the first $250,000 either directly, such as direct insurers, and we know some in this room, or by purchasing insurance policies or just paying out of their pocket. After that $250,000 is paid by the employer or their insurance company, then the insurance companies would take over the expense for death and permanent disability.
And that could include permanent total disability. Now that was the deal. I was there and so were others. If you look at the bill, it strikes out the language except in cases, it sets a cap except in cases of death and total disability. That is lined through in this bill in order to provide, as Representative Della Rosa just explained, just eight years of service.
So if you're totally and permanently disabled or killed, you get this much money and that's it. was not the deal that the insurance companies, the Chamber of Commerce, and all of the people that I just mentioned made. The idea is to pay the medical bills and a certain stipend so much a month for the rest of that person's life if that's the case. That's the way the deal was worked out. Mr. Speaker, thank you. Representative Allen, for what purpose?
Question. You're recognized for your question. So are you saying that we have been presented with inaccurate facts? No, I'm just saying there was a mistake made in a statement of fact, and I wanted to make sure that was corrected. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative House has spoken against the measure. Would anyone like to speak for the bill? All right, Representative Payton, would you like to close for your bill? thank you mr speaker and thank you members
it was definitely represented to me during the special session as an individual who they were lobbying for my vote that we would be back here in the regular session to fix the exposure that was being put out now since then i've been told by the chamber of commerce that they had several negotiations of which three or four items that they were asking for in this bill got taken out and the only thing left is the cap. So just to try to clear that up a little bit so you'll
understand where I'm coming from. Arkansas does have the third lowest rates and that is very attractive to business. But let me explain why Arkansas has the third lowest rates because until last June, July 1st, Arkansas had the trust fund that took over and capped the exposure for the employer and the workers comp carrier at about $200,000. That's why we have the lowest rates and obviously this will affect the rates if we continue down the road of not having a cap on exposure. Let me ask you this, have you ever bought a life insurance policy? Because when you go buy a
life insurance policy you have to make some tough decisions and you have to put a dollar value on what you want your survivors to have if you pass away and what you can afford to purchase. You know you may go in there and ask for a life insurance policy rate and they give you a quote and you find out, well, I can afford $200,000, so I'm going to buy $200,000 worth of coverage. But if you ask the people who sell life insurance, they usually recommend five times your annual salary. This cap goes out to eight and a half years. So what happens whenever somebody who is very young
gets totally disabled, there will be a settlement and then they'll have social security disability insurance. And the workers comp companies are usually very flexible in how that settlement can be paid all at once or over an extended period of time beyond eight and a half years. So you get to maximize your Social Security disability benefits. So I'm asking you to make a decision here this afternoon on keeping a business friendly environment in the state of
Arkansas, in keeping the third lowest workers' comp rates so that all of the money we invest in economic development does not end up wasted. I had several points to make, and I don't know how much time you all want me to spend, but I'll give you a brief, as brief as I can, understanding of what happens with workers' comp. It's very much like a public utility. The Public Service Commission controls utility rates based on what the utility
company is spending to produce the electricity. Okay, the Workers' Comp Commission, because Workers' Comp is mandated by law in the Arkansas Constitution, the Workers' Comp Commission, their job is to look at the insurance company's losses on Workers' Comp and set a rate that guarantees them them a profit, and that profit is about a cost plus 25%. Now, that's a very lucrative business to be in. The insurance companies can't lose money on workers' comp for more
than a year or two because the Arkansas Workers' Comp Insurance Commission will adjust the rates up based on their expenses. If their expenses and their losses are low, the Arkansas Workers' Comp Commission is going to adjust their rates down. So, Arkansas Workers' Comp carriers have very little interest in whether or not we pass this bill because the more exposure they have the more they can justify raising those rates and actually Arkansas the actuaries
had looked at Arkansas's losses in recent years and said that we are due about a six percent decrease in workers comp rates right now as we speak so the more money that the workers comp carriers can spend, the more they can justify where they are. The more risk and more money that they can spend, the more they can justify a rate increase. Now what does that do to small business? As a small business owner, I have to cover every employee except myself, and I can
exempt myself. Most small business owners with 10 or fewer employees exempt themselves and choose not to be covered at all. One of our colleagues here, and I hope he doesn't mind me calling him by name, but Mr. Coleman over there came to me after we just failed the other day. He ran a propane company and he had a few employees, but he exempted himself. Now he had to make the decision on what he was going to place on his own life value. And so when he exempted himself, he went
out and bought a wage policy that pays if you're down and you can't make wages. And he based it on five years. Is that right? Did you say five years? He based it on five years. Where here, we're basing it on eight and a half years. You know, these are tough decisions. And it's, you know, impossible to put a value on human life. But I'll remind you that a doctor gets $200 for putting a shot in your heart to bring you back to life when your heart stops you know what's that
worth I mean folks you just can't have an open-ended exposure if you go out to buy that life insurance policy and you tell them well I just want you to pay my beneficiary so much a week or so much a month for the rest of their natural life when I die see if anybody can even give you a quote on that I'd appreciate a good vote and every vote counts all right members the question now before the house will be the passage of House Bill 1586 prepare
the machine mr. clerk Voting on the bill and Submergency Clause, has everyone voted? All right, let's cast the ballots, Mr. Clerk. All right, with 68 yeas, 19 nays, and 7 present, the bill and Submergency Clause have passed.
All right, I see the requisite number of hands for the clincher and a request for a lower blood pressure amount from Representative Payton. So all right, this time for the motion of the clincher, all in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed say no. No. I'm going to rule the no's have it. The clincher has failed.
All right, Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1581. House Bill 1581 by Representative Hammer to implement a survey of employee engagement as an assessment tool to be used by all state agencies. Representative Hammer, you're recognized to present House Bill 1581. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Over the last interim, during JPR, we had a firm from the University of Texas at Austin come in and share about what they're doing in the state of Texas as far as an employee survey
and about how they utilize it to help improve efficiency within their agencies and make agreements as far as how they can take all their agencies in the right direction. And that's what this bill is about. It would set the expectation that each agency is supposed to have an employee engagement survey, and it has the criteria spelled out in the bill. The one thing that's good about it is that at the request of the legislative branch, a copy of that will be provided to the General Assembly. It would be our way to get a snapshot of how we see that the agencies are improving in areas where they could be more efficient.
I'll be glad to answer any questions. Appreciate a good vote. All right. Members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill, for the bill? all right representative hammer signified he's closed for the bill so the question now before the house will be the passage of house bill 1581 prepare the machine mr clerk
everyone voted all right let's cast the ballots mr clerk With 75 yeas, 6 nay, and 1 present, the bill has passed. Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1527. House Bill 1527 by Representative Rushing concerning continuing education requirements for real estate licensees. Representative Rushing, you're recognized to present your bill.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This is the CE bill that the realtors sent out a call to action against, and they sent out a call to action for. They're kind of like me. They're for, they're against. They're for, they're against. But no, realistically what happened is we had a CE bill that reduced their continuing education from nine hours back down to seven hours, which included an hour of safety. um this was this bill was passed in 2015 by myself to add it to nine hours we went back to
seven hours and then uh the real estate commission and the arkansas realtors association was against this bill originally we sat down i'm very thankful for representative ferguson and her idea to let keep a minimum of seven hours in statute which includes our safety hour and then allowing it to go to rules and regs at that point now it has to stay at seven hours until 2020 which was their original deal with me when i ran the bill in 2015 and from that point they will be able to go
to rules and regs and explain why they may or may not need additional hours for brokerage coverage and when they get their education to the quality that they need it to be i'll be glad to answer any questions there's no non-opposition to this other there's other than some people standing in this chamber that's about to ask me a question so. Representative Dotson for what purpose? Question. You're recognized for your question. Thank you Mr. Speaker. Representative Rushing my feelings on this bill are well known but can you answer after 2019 and 2020 is there a cap
on the amount of hours the real estate commission can bring before legislative council through rules and regs, can they request 100 hours, 200 hours, 5,000 hours? Is there a cap? There is not a cap, but you do not have to grant them 1,000 hours or 100 hours, and they need to have an explanation of why that they would want that continuing education. Representative Walker, for what purpose? Question. Be recognized for your question, sir.
On one of the bills that came before us last week, I think that one of the representatives made a point about the treatment and cure and comparative cost and education of physicians. And I think that the question was raised about realtors. Let me understand one thing. Is there a requirement in the law that in order for a person to be a realtor,
one has to be a high school graduate, or may one just be a dropout or a GED? There's not anything to my knowledge in law that you could have to be a high school graduate. It's a technical industry, which has proved good for my business. And is it also, may I follow up, Mr. Speaker? Yes, sir, absolutely. Is it also fair to say that in terms of the educational requirements,
that there is no comparison between the educational, continuing education requirement and those for the professions such as medicine? I am not aware of the continuing education for medicine, so I'm not a doctor, so I can't fairly answer that question. i'm willing to take any other questions for what purpose question you recognize for your question yes sir thank you mr speaker uh representative rushing is this seven hours every year two years
or three years the seven hours is every year one hour must include safety every year well i just want to let you know on the state level for state certification it's 15 hours but it's every three years so this is a little bit stronger than what state certification is thank you okay members you've heard an explanation of the bill would anyone like speak against the bill representative Dotson you're recognized
to speak against the bill thank you mr. speaker members Albert brief but two years ago when this came up continuing education hours were at six hours for Realtors the the bill that passed two years ago allowed them to go up to nine hours as a cap but obviously they said we'd only do seven and over the last couple years to get them to honor that agreement
representative rushing has has gone through back and forth with them repeatedly in order to keep it at seven. Where this bill was really good to begin with I thought lowering it from nine back to seven hours the original agreement originally taking the cap off of it and allowing after two years the real estate Commission to bring an unlimited number of hours to us through rules and regs that doesn't have proper vetting in front of this body and taking
the cap statutorily off of it I think is not a good idea and I would appreciate a no vote on this thank you all right members representative Dotson has spoken against the measure would anyone like to speak for the bill represent to Ferguson you're recognized to speak for the bill Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It certainly wasn't my intention to speak at all, but since Representative Rushing named
me personally, when this came to committee, my first question was, why are we doing this in statute? I mean, the medical board, the dental board, probably many of you are on other professions that have boards. And in all of those professions, the continuing ad and those things for licensure are done by the board or the commission. So that was my first question to Representative Rushing. You know, why are we doing this in statute when if it needs to be changed before two years, you don't really have any flexibility?
And certainly with it going through rules and regs and the council having that authority now, I think that's a better place. I know she brought it because she was concerned that she felt like she wasn't. The Real Estate Commission had not been honest with her, so I think this addresses both problems. It keeps it where they told her it would be, and then for future, we won't be coming back every two years, right, continuing it into statute. All right. Members, Representative Ferguson has spoken in favor of the measure.
Would anyone like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Rushing, would you like to close for your bill? you're recognized to do so at this time. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This time I'll close for my bill. I just want you to know that after we did make these amendments that the Real Estate Commission was in the room. Also, the Arkansas Realtors Association was present, and none of these bodies testified against it. There was also no known opposition at the time after the amendments were made. This is a good, solid deregulation bill, and I'd appreciate a good
vote all right members the question now before the house be the passage of house bill 1527 prepare the machine mr. clerk everyone voted everyone voted
let's cast it to ballots Mr. Clerk with 85 yeas, 3 nays and 3 present the bill has passed all right mr. clerk we're going to pass over the next item on the agenda and pick up with house bill 1377 so please at this time read house bill 1377 house bill 1377 by representative lemons concerning the manufacturers express warranty against defective asphalt roof shingles
Representative Lemons, you're recognized to present the bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This bill pertains to a manufacturer's warranty, materials warranty on asphalt shingles. I guess a lot of people could call this a consumer protection bill, maybe a common sense bill. Unfortunately, common sense seems to check itself at these doors back here from time to time. Typically, when someone builds a house and they put a new roof on it,
they're given a 20-, 25-, 30-year warranty. A lot of times, a person will sell that house before the warranty has expired. What you read on the fine print of most of your manufacturer's warranties is that it is for the first-time homebuyer and the next subsequent owner if the manufacturer is informed of the transfer. It is doubtful that any of us have had an issue like this. If we have, you would understand the importance of this bill. We want to make this to where the warranty goes with the house
and not with the owner because I don't think the shingles really care who owns it. It's what they're there to do. I'd be glad to take any questions. Now, I'd appreciate a good vote. Okay, members, I heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? for the bill. Representative Lemons has signified he's closed for the bill, so the question now before the House will be the passage of House Bill 1377.
Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. All right, has everyone voted? Let's cast out the ballots, Mr. Clerk. All right, with 88 yeas, one nay, and two present, the bill has passed.
All right, Mr. Clerk, please read the letter from the Senate. February 27, 2017, to the Honorable Sherry Stacks. Dear Ms. Stacks, the Senate respectfully requests the return of Senate Bill 291, respectfully submitted in Cornwell. All right, members, leave granted to return the bill back to the Senate. Leave granted. All right, so noted. Thank you.
All right, members, we're going to pick up with the Senate bills at this point. Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Bill 42. Senate Bill 42 by Representative Kapp, concerning fitness to proceed and lack of criminal responsibility and concerning a mental evaluation of a criminal defendant. Representative Kapp, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 42. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Senate Bill 42 is the latest effort to improve Arkansas's criminal forensic mental evaluation
system. This bill is part of the Arkansas Bar Association's legislative packet. This bill has the official support of the prosecutors, the public defenders, the Arkansas State Hospital, and DHS. It's the product of a task force of the stakeholders and mental health professionals who examined our current law and requested the revisions herein. Senate Bill 42 is largely a reorganization of the existing law, and it separates into
two types of forensic evaluations into two separate sections. It eliminates repeated, outdated, and unnecessary provisions. It separates out DHS's data collection obligations and puts them in a separate section. It clarifies existing law that the judge must determine a defendant's fitness to proceed, not the examiner. It puts limits on a judge and defense attorney's ability to routinely order unnecessary criminal
responsibility evaluations. The two types of evaluations are fitness to proceed and lack of criminal responsibility. The first involves the constitutional right of a defendant to be competent before taken to trial, and the second is an affirmative defense that can only be raised by the defendant, which embodies the principle that one cannot be held responsible for a crime if insane at the time of commission.
The problem that courts have faced here is that there's too many evaluations ordered in this state. In particular, there are way too many criminal responsibility examinations that are ordered at the same time as the fitness to proceed examination. Last year, there was approximately 1,500 examinations ordered. Of these, only 300 were declared unfit and 58 were not criminally responsible. This has resulted in a backlog of criminal defendants waiting months for their evaluations
often in jails, and it slows down the entire judicial process. It also results in a burden to our jails who must house these detainees waiting these mental evaluations. It's a violation of a defendant's Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination. Further, evaluators rather than the judges are the ones that are determining whether a defendant is fit, which is not following the law. In 2013, the legislature passed Act 506, which was an improvement on existing law
in an attempt to bifurcate the two types of examinations, but as the data and evidence showed, it didn't go far enough. Act 506 did make things better, but the language was confusing and it was still outdated. A change in the law with this bill will make the criminal defendant evaluation system more efficient by reducing the wait times for defendants waiting these evaluations, reduce the time pretrial detainees spend in our jails, will potentially reduce the cost to the
state because the state is the one burdening the cost of these evaluations, and it improves professional practice by following the model penal code and prevents courts from routinely ordering both examinations. When the defendant has not raised this as an affirmative defense, I'm willing to take a few questions. Seeing none, I'd appreciate a good vote. All right. Members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill, for the bill?
Representative Kapp signified she is closed for the bill, so the question now before the House will be the passage of Senate Bill 42, prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. All right, let's cast out the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 90 yeas, 0 nay, and 0 present, the bill has passed.
Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Bill 284. Senate Bill 284 by Representative Eubanks to establish a retail off-premises permit for the sale of wine at grocery stores and to provide additional grant funds to support Arkansas wine production and wine tourism in the state. Representative Eubanks, you recognize, present Senate Bill 284. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I know many of you probably have not heard anything about this bill.
So I'm just going to take a few minutes and try to share some key points with you. My involvement has been about four weeks, and it seems like a lifetime. But besides that, Senate Bill 284 is really not a very complicated bill. So it essentially allows grocery stores to expand the brand lines of the wines that they carry in their stores.
What it does not do, it does not expand to areas that are dry the ability of these grocery stores to sell wine. They have to be in currently wet areas. Currently, they can sell what is classified as small farm wines. And like I said, they're wanting to expand that product line. This bill does deal with a couple other issues, dealing with the small farm wines themselves and also how some of the permit fees would be used to promote tourism
in the state of Arkansas, specifically with regard to the wine industry. In the course of the last couple of weeks, I've had the opportunity to meet with both sides of the issue, both the liquor store owners and the small farm wines. I've tried to incorporate many of the items, the issues that they've identified. Now, one of the biggest concerns that the liquor store owners had was that they
would not be able to compete with the large chain stores such as Walmart or Kroger's or such. specifically in the bill it states that those stores would only be able to make those purchases based on that single store's orders and that they would not be able to combine those orders with other stores in order to try to get some sort of discount on their purchases. One of the things that the other items that the liquor store owners that opposed this bill said
was that they could not sell edibles or consumables. Now, that was something that we incorporated into Bill. Now, I don't know whether that's something that was truly important to a lot of these owners or not, but it was something that they brought to us, and we tried to incorporate into Bill to make it more amenable to them. Had the opportunity to meet with some of the small farm wineries as well and tried to, at the very last moment, incorporate some of the concerns that they had into it as well.
so at this point it's not a perfect bill I'm not going to sit here or stand here and claim that it is but there has been a an effort to try to incorporate the concerns that both sides of the issues have brought to me and frankly I think we probably tried to do a pretty good job with that and tried to listen to all those interests. Even calling a special order of business so everybody would know when the
bill would be presented in committee and be able to prepare their arguments and attend the meeting. With that, I'd be open to a couple of questions. Seeing none, I'd appreciate a good vote. All right, members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against Against the bill, Representative Deffenbaugh, you're recognized to speak against the bill.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. You don't see me down here much, so I don't have to say I'm not down here much. You know, one of my biggest concerns that really bothered me is the fact of how this bill even got this far because it was a quick, they ran this bill real quickly through the Senate before the public could even get organized against it. And then the way it got here was a bit
questionable. That bothers me a lot. This law it puts small locally owned liquor stores at a sizable disadvantage. We're just giving Kroger, Walmart, chain stores, we're giving them special privileges. And what that does to the local businessman that has one liquor store, it's probably going to do to them, is whereas if this bill passes and Walmart gets liquor license for a lot of
their stores, I don't know if it's all of them or a lot of but it's going to leave those small liquor store owners, they're going to be stuck in one ownerville for their life you understand? Okay the other thing is, I don't know if you know this but let's say you sell a case of beer alright, you have a small liquor store you sell a case of beer, 24 bottles or whatever it is how much do you think you make out of that? How much do you think a liquor store makes out of that?
about a dollar. You know where their profit comes from don't you? It's wine. Wine gets about it nets about 20% profit for liquor stores and that's where they depend on. Alright here's some other, I'm not going to take very long. I'm going to run, I got a little bit of list but I'm going to run right down. One thing it's going to do too is you're going to expose a lot of underage kids to liquor, whereas they don't use
anybody under 21 in any liquor store that I know of. So you've got underage workers, you've got more kids exposed to liquor, the liquor business. And then here's a big question. How are you going to handle the checkouts, the self-checkouts? Who's going to regulate that? Are they going to watch every kid that comes through the self-checkout, and also how they're going to take, how they're going to police the, you know, how you buy and then go pick it up? How are they going to do that? That's going to be an interesting question.
What I was told by one liquor store owner is they, you know, a lot of the small businesses give to charity, and if this bill passes, they'll cut a lot of the charity out that the small business people, the extra money they have where they can give to local events. The alcohol industry is highly regulated, but these stores they want to reduce restrictions, such as how close to schools and churches.
I'll stop there. Thanks. All right. Members, Representative Deftball has spoken against the measure. Would anyone like to speak for the bill? I think I've got Representative Collins who went hand up first, so you're recognized to speak for the measure. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I know this is another one of those very difficult scenarios. It's one of those challenges that's been out there for several years, and today, regardless of
what happens, the challenge will not go away. We'll continue to have this challenge, and The reason is because government regulates this industry, and it's regulated it for a long time. The bottom line here is, are we going to move toward free markets? Are we going to move toward a market system resolving issues, or are we going to do it via some other methods? The first thing I want to address is the notion how these stores would be able to handle wine from a structural standpoint. The answer is they're already doing it with local Arkansas wine,
so they will just continue to do that with an expanded selection. The bigger issue, the much bigger issue, is how do we move from where we've been, which generates very high prices for Arkansas consumers on restricted products, to where we're going, which will be a better scenario for our consumers. Last session, two years ago, two years ago, we had this very same issue in front of us. And what was the result? The result was, we're not ready to take action.
Everybody go back to the bargaining table. Everybody go back and work on it for two years and come back in 2017 with something that can move the ball down the field. Now, we're never gonna have perfect, but this is something. And what it does is it has some elements of balance. in areas that are wet today, grocery stores will be able to sell a broader selection of wines, but liquor stores have the benefit that there will not be pursuit of selling
alcohol, hard liquor, for a period of time. There are many liquor stores that spend lots and lots of money in elections trying to defeat efforts to broaden the availability of liquor and those types of things, so there's some benefit going in both directions. Now the final point I would make on this, it doesn't mean it's the last step of the process, and if there are things like Representative Deffenbaugh or others said that are restrictions
on liquor stores that need to be relaxed, there are things liquor stores can or cannot do that they would like to do that aren't in this bill, let's get that fixed, but let's not hold Arkansas consumers hostage to extraordinarily high prices when we've got the opportunity to move toward a free market. I'd appreciate a good vote. Members, Representative Collins has spoken in favor of the measure. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? All right, I've got Representative De La Rosa recognized to speak against the bill.
This is actually the bill I plan to speak against today, not the previous one. This one has been really hard for me, especially if you consider where I'm from, Northwest Stark and so I've got Walmart right in my backyard so this one is very very hard for me to oppose just because it's my district but my district also has liquor stores in it and I've got to take that into consideration and I've struggled back and forth and back and forth with this one and I know a lot of you guys have too because we we do have this struggle between you know free market but
also harming liquor stores so how do you decide how do you decide and I I'm usually yes or no pretty quickly. But on this one, I went back and forth and it finally settled in my mind when I figured out it's not the liquor stores that are the problem and it's not Walmart going after business that's the problem. It's us. We're the problem. What we are proposing or what's going to happen in this is you're taking folks that we, we have forced to operate in a closed system,
a closed market. They have not been allowed to set up a business model to operate in a free market atmosphere. We have kept them in a closed market atmosphere, and we are suddenly going to expose them to a free market atmosphere with the biggest giant there is in free market coming after them. They will die, not because they've chosen a poor business model, not because they've refused to compete in free market, but because we have prohibited them from doing so. We have set them
up to fail. If we want to open this thing up and we truly want free market, we need to start deregulating the alcohol business first and let them start truly competing with themselves. I mean, you guys know what all the regulations are. I don't need to go through the list, which I have written all these things that Walmart's never had to operate under. So their business model is all completely set up and ready to go free market. Our liquor stores aren't. That's why, that's why they're here. That's why they're scared. It's because, not because of what the deal is that's
going to be made, but rather because they're not prepared for it because we have not allowed them to prepare for it. So I am not against Walmart carrying wine. I am not against free market. I'm not against any of those things. But the problem is that we have not opened this up to allow them to start preparing to be in the free market and that ultimately is how I ended up settling on this and I would appreciate a no vote and instead propose that we start deregulating alcohol sales so that liquor stores can truly start competing with each other
and prepare for this type of move. All right, Representative De La Rosa has spoken. For our guests in the galleries, let's refrain from applause. All right, Representative De La Rosa has spoken against the measure. Would anyone like to speak for the measure? All right, Representative Kapp, you're recognized to speak for the bill.
Colleagues, I'm up here today in support of this bill, and I promise you it's not without some thoughtful deliberation. Please know I have so much respect for the senior members of this House because I have learned through firsthand illustration with this bill how some decisions that we have to make are really hard ones. Now, there is a lot of history with this bill. There's been some talk back and forth here about how this just popped up on the map, and that's not true. In 2015, a bill was filed to allow grocery stores in Arkansas to obtain permits to sell wine from any winery they choose, just like this bill.
Based on differing views and testimony in the Senate, that bill was killed. Those involved in that previous legislation, the wineries, the groceries, and the liquor block that have been represented here at the Capitol for several years have negotiated the bill that stands in front of you today. They have been involved in this process for two years. I've personally been involved for several months.
SB 284 represents all that time and communication. None of these parties got everything they wanted. That's part of a compromise. We have the option here today of accepting a deal that takes alcohol off the table for eight years. There is nothing that would prevent a statewide initiative from alcohol being placed on the ballot that has none of the compromise worked out here today.
Placing a state wine alcohol initiative on the ballot only requires 67,000 signatures. Now, you know with paid signature gatherers, it's not going to take that long to obtain those signatures. Arkansas voters have increasingly shown willingness to support efforts to liberalize laws like these. We're seeing that right now with last year's marijuana initiative. we can look to neighboring Oklahoma who just passed an alcohol initiative.
66% of the voters approved a measure allowing full-strength beer and wine in their grocery stores. Now, it's my position that I'd like to see small farm wines in all grocery stores solely, but that's not going to happen. That's not realistic. It's not just Arkansas wines. because of interstate commerce issues we've got out-of-state wines and in-state wines being sold in the grocery stores right now. The times are changing and we
have to adapt to the market. Any business that assumes that this is going to continue long term has a flaw in their business plan. I'm new to this chamber but it didn't take me very long to hear Nate Bell's key points I should analyze on voting for a bill. I looked at these last night in my thoughts about coming here today to relay what my feelings were. This bill drastically lessens government regulation. It removes a government enforced anti-free mark
barrier between the consumer and the supplier. This bill results in more of the economy being under private control, allowing Arkansans to benefit from a free market. The people of my district, as well as the entire state, will have significantly more liberty if this bill becomes law, because the legislation would drastically scale back the role of the government in the shopping choices Arkansans get to make. The people of Arkansas will have
more freedom to make responsible choices for themselves, as opposed to the government dictating where they have to purchase a product that is legal. This legislation will allow Arkansans more freedom to spend their hard-earned money the way they so choose, not within the confines which current state law dictates. It's my hope that in 20 years, future generations will look back and recognize how significant this legislation was in reducing the size and the scope of government
by allowing businesses to offer a selection that reflects the desires of Arkansas consumers. This legislation, which impacts my district more than any other in the state, stands to benefit from this legislation. After two years of discussion, this compromise reflects the wishes and the collective agreement for the entire wine industry that is consistent with the principles that we hold dear, the idea that a market is driven by individuals, not the government, and that best serves our
constituents. There are 34 other states that already allow sales of wine in grocery stores, and the liquor industry has remained competitive in those states. By allowing free market and trade to flourish it is predicted five million dollars will be generated in state revenue and 2.5 million in local revenue and with that I would ask that you please support this bill our members representative cap has spoken in favor
of the measure would anyone like to speak against the bill for the bill Representative Bragg, you're recognized to speak for the bill. Colleagues, I live in a dry county. In fact, my whole district is dry. You can't buy a bottle of beer, bottle of wine, liquor legally anywhere, so you wonder why
I would be concerned about this. I know there's been a lot said about free markets and and this is one of those bills that I really can't understand both sides. Both sides have valid arguments and you wonder, you know, how do you make a decision on this? The comments Representative Eubanks made, you know, concerning some of the restrictions on the sales and the lifting of some of the restrictions in the package stores, you know, makes sense to me. I'm all for lifting all the restrictions. Let the package stores, liquor stores sell anything they want to. Well, one thing that really struck me is I live in a
small town. We have a Walmart. Walmart seems to be the target of a lot of this discussion. Walmart has affected a lot of small towns but I can't think of any other small business in a small town that has been protected specifically because a Walmart came in. So there is a measure of a free market issue here. There are issues on the other side and I understand that but you know I think it is a measure of a free market and we really need to consider that. Thank you.
All right, members, Representative Bragg has spoken in favor of the measure. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Mr. Speaker, you're recognized to speak for the bill.
Members, I'm kind of like Representative Bragg. The thought of this being a bill that I would have to come down to speak in favor of would have never dawned on me. As many of you know, I don't drink. I live in a dry county, and so this will not affect me personally by any stretch of the means. But I've been involved in this debate now for a number of years, not necessarily of my choosing. But when I was in my second term, I was a member on House Rules, and this issue first came up and speaker carter and leadership was approached at the time about
this bill but it was later on in the session and uh they kind of said well we're going to hold off on it a little bit but i kind of got my first taste of some of the dynamics of this at that time and so flash come back up to 2015 at this point and a lot of the stakeholders uh that are involved in this now, had came to visit with me just prior to the session, and I think it might have been that week right before we started, and was interested in pursuing this idea again.
We challenged them to come up with something that was as close to a win-win scenario as you could get. Now, one thing I've learned about this particular dynamic is you are not going to get a win-win scenario without a package of legislation. So, there was an attempt made, not enough traction, not enough consensus could be built back in 2015, so when we left the session, the same challenge was initiated to them to gather up as many folks as they possibly could and come to some agreement, some consensus
that would work and move us forward in a dynamic, as many have referenced earlier, that would push us more towards some deregulation and into a free market scenario here. Now, Representative De La Rosa is not entirely wrong. There have been sets of rules that have been in place quite a bit down the road. This bill changes some of those and moves us forward in a capacity, along with some other legislation that is coming from the Senate,
to correct some of the things that she addressed. So I want to say real quick a couple of things kind of about, I've kind of mentioned the history of the bill, but there's a couple of things I think is important as we kind of look through this piece of legislation, and they apply to all the pieces of legislation that we deal with, but actually looking at the facts and the merits of the bill, there's a lot of emotion that is attached to a lot of our legislation that we have to deal with here. We're picking, a lot of times, unfortunately, there are winners and losers in about everything
that we do. with. Our goal is to minimize the collateral issues as much as humanly possible. Over the last two years, and especially over the last six months, there have been numerous attempts to minimize that collateral damage, those collateral issues. Have they completely gone away? No. Will they go away with some of the subsequent legislation? I do believe that that will lessen some of the issues that we have to deal with. But the important thing to remember as you're looking through this bill is the facts.
There have been a lot of things that have thrown out about this bill, things that it supposedly does or is going to do. But when you start to actually get down into it, what I'm wanting and challenging us to do is to look at the facts in this and not necessarily all the emotion. Okay, earlier Representative Deffenbaugh cited some of the rules that are different. And when I first met with a lot of the folks that are in opposition to this, a lot of it on the surface of it kind of catches you and you say, you know what, that's right.
And then when you actually start looking at it, you realize that it's almost comparing apples and oranges. You know, setbacks and things like that exist for a variety of parameters that are not necessarily applicable in this scenario. The liquor setbacks are in large part there because of, or the setbacks, rather, are there because of the sale of liquor. They're not there because of the sale of beer and wine. One thing that's important to remember is that these entities, these retailers are already selling beer and wine. And so this is not some new revolutionary idea
that all of a sudden they're going to start selling beer and wine. They're just going to sell some different labels. And with the small farm wineries, many of which are on board with this, It's important to remember that, you know, this affects them because they've kind of had that little monopoly going on for so long. Look, folks, I would love it if I could, if we could have some legislation that allowed me to have some protectionist idea, kind of goals with the blackberry industry.
The fact of the matter is we don't have them, which is part of the reason that, you know, we have a little difficulty around the farm every now and then because we don't have that. We're competing against sometimes states that put in their tobacco settlement money like in North Carolina to fund and give grant programs to the very people that are competing against me. We're going to have that happen in life. It's going to be there. But one thing that is important to remember about this, and I mentioned it just a little bit ago, is the efforts that have been made to limit those issues.
This was not just something that just came down here to our end of the building, that was filed one day in the Senate, ran through, suspension of the rules, all those things. This has taken a long time to get to where we're at. Okay, even last Sunday, Representative Kapp and Representative Eubanks took their Sunday to go and meet with a good number of the folks that were principals in this discussion and have been since the very beginning. They said, hey, put a couple amendments on here, we're good to go. So they did that. They delayed it even more and didn't run it the first part of the week.
They ran it later on in the week. What happened? Those same individuals came down and spoke against the bill. So there's a point in which you just have to ask yourself what more can be done to get us to a position that we could move forward with a piece of legislation. I think we're there. I think we've done what could be done with this particular bill. I think there are other things that can be done, and I welcome any of the members between now and bill filing deadline to look into those ideas, bring them forward, and try to be as consensus building as what I think Representative Eubanks and Representative Kapp and former Representative Gossage was before Representative Kapp got here.
One notion that I've heard repeatedly through this, and this is just kind of one of those things that the math, you have to decide in your opinion whether or not the math bears out on this, but a couple of things, is there's been a lot of talk about the loss of business that would come about from Walmart, Kroger, these entities being able to sell some of these wines. And I've heard various numbers, and I think Representative Deffenbaugh quoted one number. We've heard others in the hallway and in the emails and things, but that's all predicated
on the fact that every single customer that now goes to the current establishments will leave them and go someplace else, so just remember that. That could happen, but typically I think the laws of probability would work against that actually occurring. And then it was referenced earlier too, and I'll kind of say this as I kind of close here, the repeated efforts for a lot of these counties to go from dry to wet, the cost that goes into that. These liquor stores are having to spend millions of dollars defeating that, those proposals
just on a routine basis. So a couple of things that you have to ask yourself about that is how long can they keep it up? And the second thing is if they've got that kind of money to keep beating that back, exactly where are those margins? If they've got that kind of excess capital to spend on those campaigns so members i just i offer that to you as as things to think about through this and i would ask for a good vote thank you representative gillam has spoken for the bill wouldn't someone like to speak against the bill representing flyers you recognize speak against
the bill. I've said this to many people and I'm gonna make this point before I speak. This is my second term and we're about halfway through it and I have not had so many phone we've talked we've made decisions about folks health care
foster care abortion all kind of decisions I've not had so many phone calls and grappled so much because of the pressure and the different perspectives and I am NOT going to speak fully against the bill I made a pledge to a couple of folks and said, I'm going to vote against because so many of my constituents approached me, met with me on Saturday for two hours, came up Friday, came up today.
But I'm going to make a point of clarification because I could make a lot of statements and make a lot of points, and I'm not going to do that. The point of clarification that I think it's important for us to consider in this is that But just as Mr. Speaker talked about, there are a lot of opportunities for other bills to come forward so that we can address the issues that have been offered to us by lobbyists,
by county line liquor stores, by urban liquor stores. that said what would be the harm in an effort for us to cultivate the trust of those whose entire livelihoods are wrapped up in their ability to make a living as a small business what would be the harm in us to flesh those issues out and file that legislation and then move forward and I'm only make that point and I only rise to come here today because in every
conversation that I've had, one point that has been made that has never been refuted is that there are several hundred small businesses who sell wine and liquor, beer, wine, and liquor, who were not a part of that conversation at the table. I believe there are about 572 establishments, and only several of them have been involved over these past couple of years, and maybe rightfully so, because we can't have 572 folks
at the table. But now their lives are being affected. So I would just ask you to consider that. Okay, members, Representative Flowers has spoken against the measure. All right, Representative Eubanks, would you like to close for your bill? Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I apologize that all of you have been inundated by so many contacts, both for and against this bill. I believe the people that have spoke in favor of this bill have addressed some of the issues. Representative Deffenbaugh, it's not going
to increase the amount of exposure to people because these establishments are already selling beer and wine of some sort. They know how to handle the checkouts. Speaker Gillum addressed The setback, that may or may not be an issue for some of you, but it deals specifically without liquor, not beer and wine. Representative De La Rosa brought up the point about the rules that the liquor stores are currently required to work under,
and they will still be working under a situation where they have a monopoly on a certain product. So if people want to purchase that, they will have to visit their establishments. I find it difficult to believe that by these grocery stores, being able to carry expanded product lines is going to put any of these businesses out of business. It may obviously affect their bottom line. Competition may do that, but it may also make them better in what they do
and the service they provide to their consumers. I believe in a free enterprise type system. I don't know that we should be restricting what grocery stores could sell. In this case, these expanded brands of wine. And just as a side note, I would support prohibition, but that is another issue altogether. But with that, I'm closed, and I would appreciate a good vote.
Okay, members, Representative Eubanks is closed for his bill. We have a pair on the desk. So the question before the House will be the passage of Senate Bill 284. All right. As I mentioned, we have a pair on the desk. Representative Jeff Williams votes yes. representative Michelle gray votes no this is rep this is witnessed by representative Jim Dotson representative gray is the present member are there
any procedural objections to this pair all right please do not vote either of these two voting machines prepare the machine mr. clerk Okay, has everyone voted?
Everyone voted? All right, let's cast up the ballots, Mr. Clerk. All right, with 47 yeas, 33 nays, and 12 present, the bill has failed. Representative Letting, for what purpose? Motion. All right. Having voted on the prevailing side, I give notice for reconsideration. All right. How did you vote, Representative Letting?
I voted nay. Okay. All right, please enter the notice into the journal, Mr. Clerk. All right. All right, Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Bill 340. Senate Bill 340 by Representative Pilkington to create the Wrongful Birth Civil Liability Protection Act.
All right, Representative Pilkington, you're recognized. To present Senate Bill 340. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Clearly, I'm your favorite if I'm going after the wine bill and before tort reform. Today, I present to you Senate Bill 340, the Wrongful Birth and Civil Liabilities Act. This is a pretty simple bill. It does three things. It protects physicians and medical facilities from certain wrongful birth lawsuits.
It prevents the parents of a child from collecting damages in a wrongful birth lawsuit, alleging that it's the doctor's fault the child was not aborted, and it does not prevent a doctor from being sued for gross negligence. So some people have asked me to sum this up in a nutshell, and this is what it is. Parents sue for wrongful birth or wrongful life when they believe that had they had more information on how their child was going to be born, they would have aborted that child. Now that the child's born, they're looking for compensation.
I think that's a terrible thing. This bill will not prevent a single abortion, it merely changes some lawsuits. So what really got me on this bill, and I feel like I'm rambling here, but the reason I sponsored this bill was I would like you to think about a child who's 13, 12 years old and decides they want to Google their name, and they're a paraplegic, and they see that their parents had sued a doctor or a hospital because they felt that had they known
their child was going to have this disability, they would have aborted that child. So think about what that means to that small child when they see things like this pop up. And with that, I ask for a good vote. All right. Representative Pilkington has explained the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill? All right, Representative Pilkington has signified he is closed for the bill, so the question now before the House will be the passage of Senate
bill 340 for the machine mr. clerk has everyone voted everyone voted all right let's cast it the balance mr. clerk with 82 yeas six nay and zero present. The bill has passed. Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Bill 277.
Senate Bill 277 by Representative McNair concerning the procedures for obtaining title to a mobile home or manufactured home. Representative McNair, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 277. Thank You Mr. Speaker. Members, SB 277 changes a procedure for obtaining a title for manufactured homes. I can promise you most, if not all, your county assessors would appreciate a good vote. All right, members, you've heard an explanation
of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill? All right, Representative McNair signified he's closed for the bill, so the question now before the House will be the passage of Senate Bill 277. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. All right, has everyone voted? Everyone voted? All right, let's cast the ballots, Mr. Clerk.
With 83 yeas, 0 nay, and 1 present, the bill has passed. Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Bill 148. Senate Bill 148 by Representative Charlene Fite to create Born Alive Infant Protection. Representative Fite, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 148. Thank you, Mr. Speaker, colleagues. On March 12, 2002, the federal Born Alive Infant Protection Act passed the House of Representatives by a resounding voice vote.
Later, on June 19th of 2002, it was approved by a 98-0 vote in the U.S. Senate. Voting for this bill were Senators Hillary Clinton, Ted Kennedy, Barbara Boxer, and John Kerry. The bill I bring you today is modeled after that federal legislation. The reason we need this is because the federal legislation only covers those hospitals and
employees operated by the federal government or which receive federal funding. It would not prohibit private or state-operated clinics and hospitals from denying care or medical attention to born-alive infants. Twenty-six states, including every state that touches Arkansas, now have laws creating affirmative duty for physicians to provide medical care and treatment to born-alive infants
at any stage of their development. And I will be glad to answer any questions. Seeing none, I will appreciate a good vote. Representative Fite has explained the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill or the bill? Representative Fite has indicated she is closed for the bill. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk.
Question for the house is the passage of Senate bill 148 for one as everyone voted cast up the ballot vote of 84 yeas one nay and zero president present the bill has passed Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Bill 159.
Senate Bill 159 by Representative Drown concerning the Department of Veterans Affairs and to amend the law concerning certain employment requirements and qualifications of the director and the Veterans Claims Specialists. Representative Drown, you're recognized to explain the bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, Senate Bill 159, Section 1, district offices are going to be established in the Department of Workforce Services. That question was asked, and originally they were to be established in national guard robberies throughout the state,
but due to the enhanced security protocols from the shootings we've had across the nation over the last couple of years, it was found to be unrealistic. Section 2, due to the difficulty in filling the veterans' claims specialist positions, it was decided to change the language regarding the hiring practices. I appreciate a good vote. Representative Brown has explained the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Representative Brown indicates he is closed for the bill.
The question before the House is the passage of Senate Bill 159. Mr. Clerk, prepare the machine. Has everyone voted? By a vote of 85 yeas, 0 nays, and 0 present, the bill has passed.
Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Bill 174. Senate Bill 174 by Representative Drown to amend the law concerning the duties of the Arkansas Veterans Commission and to increase the amount of authorized annual stipend and expense reimbursement for members of the commission in certain circumstances. Representative Drown, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 174. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, Senate Bill 174 does two things. First, it consists of cleanup language to clarify the duties and responsibilities of the Arkansas Veterans Commission. Second, it allows the commission chair with approval of the director
to transfer unused funds from one member of the commission to another if they have exceeded their $1,000 stipend and reimbursement expenses and not to exceed $2,500. I appreciate a good vote. All right, members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill, Representative Drown has signified he's closed for the bill.
to the question now before the house will be the passage of senate bill 174 prepare the machine mr. clerk all right everyone voted everyone voted All right, let's cast out the ballots, Mr. Clerk.
With 85 yeas, 0 nay, and 0 present, the bill has passed. All right, Mr. Clerk, please read SJR 8. Senate Joint Resolution 8 by Representative Ballinger. A constitutional amendment limiting contingency fees and awards of punitive and non-economic damages, and changing the powers of the General Assembly and the Supreme Court regarding rules of the pleading, practice, and procedure.
Representative Ballinger, you're recognized to present SJR 8. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. All right, so most of the debate we had, I think, on Friday. However, I don't want to leave anything undone. This is not a small thing we're doing. We are amending the Constitution of Arkansas. And so, you know, as we worked through this process, it became real clear to me that I, at least I believe that we probably had the votes at some point last week to get this thing done, get it out. However, I don't think in amending the Constitution that we
should do so with just the slimmest of margins. What I'd really like is to have as many people as possible on board. I want to make sure that it's a good idea. And I do believe that what we're doing here is a good idea. We've made the amendments that a lot of people have asked for, and I think that we're going to be in good shape. So, what does this resolution do? Essentially, it does four things. One is it increases the cap on non-economic damages, or it sets a cap on non-economic damages at $500,000. The second thing it does, it sets a cap on punitive damages
at $500,000, or three times compensatory damages. Compensatory damages is the money damages, is the making somebody whole. Then it also sets a cap on contingency fees at one-third, 33 and a third percent, which is standard pretty much in the industry for contingency fees. And it sets a cap on that. And then it also gives us the ability to have some oversight of the rules, practice, and procedure. All right, so what does it not do? Okay, so some of the things it doesn't do, it doesn't put any cap on the ability to make somebody whole
or give a person monetary damages. So an example of that would be an individual who has the loss of the ability for earnings because of an injury, or a person, a child who is injured or passes away, he would have a potential through his life of making earnings. So that person would have monetary damages, whatever it is before this becomes law, when voted on by the people and put it into place, whatever it is beforehand and whatever it is after is going to be the same. So if there are money damages that affect a person's ability to earn, ability to pay their medical bills, anything like that, all of that will still be in place.
None of that changes. You know, issues like the, there are some questions that I think I have on this is how this will be implemented. And I think that there should be some valid concerns. However, anytime that we amend the Constitution, we do what's called enabling legislation. so to know exactly how this will be implemented we got to come back in 2019 we got to debate the policy we have to actually you know get in engage in the debate i expect some of you all who are working so hard to try to you know create some balance in this to stand with me and help me
you know create some balance and and how we interact with the court and in how we implement things like the contingency fees and and how we do that i think i mean that's where it's supposed to happen. And so, you know, for me, the exciting thing about this resolution, the thing that got me on board with it, is because it creates a balance, a better balance, when it comes to policy. Currently, I believe that there are probably too many policy decisions that have been made over the years, over the last 15 years, in the court. Since 2003, when they first passed the Judicial
Reform Act of 2003, there's been several policy decisions from that point to then that's come out this legislative body that have been struck down as unconstitutional, as a violation of Amendment 80. Well, what this will do is this will rebalance. It'll put those policy decisions back in the hands of the legislative body, which is what we're put down here for. This is what we're supposed to do is debate policy and then leave the courts for what their job is, which is to deal with and handle independently with balance the issues that come before it and to be a referee
and not a policymaker, and I think that that's what this resolution does. It's a big deal, and so I'll have no trouble with answering some questions. However, what I would say is that, you know, you'll have opportunities to speak against it. If you want to ask a question, I do want to be mindful of those questions. At the same time, let's make sure that we're doing things the right way. Representative Walker, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized for your question, sir. With respect to the resolution, I note that there have been a number of cases brought with respect to pharmaceutical drugs
and their impact upon large numbers of people in the population, or even small numbers of people in the population, and that there have been a few attacks upon the legitimacy of the medicine that may have caused injury or damage. And therefore, when lawsuits have been brought, it's taken a lot of work and taken a lot of time.
Would your resolution benefit the people who have those kinds of claims, or would it do harm to those kinds of claims and thereby enrich the pharmaceutical companies? It depends. So it depends on the facts of each situation. You would have to, if this is passed and this is put into law, you'd have to prove that there's some sort of real loss, something that can be quantitative, some monetary loss. And if that's the case,
then you have as much as three times monetary damages as your punitive damages. So it depends on the facts, but if there are things like people who've got sick, they have medical bills, they have to miss work, and if you're able to prove those type of damages, then you're talking about, especially if you're talking about a large number of people, you're talking about it in the multiple million, so maybe there would be no difference at all in it. A follow-up, Mr. Speaker? Yes, sir. have you contemplated the cost?
Are you aware of the cost of what it took to just bring one case against a pharmaceutical company in the state of Arkansas in the last several years? And are you aware of that where we recovered more than a large number of millions of dollars in a class action lawsuit, That case took many years and cost a lot of money, and it was not limited by a three-time special, which would not have given the state nearly the money that it got.
You familiar with what I'm talking about? Well, I mean, obviously, I don't know the inside of the details, because I wasn't that firm, but if you're asking me if I believe and understand that litigation is expensive, I'd say yes. It is expensive, expensive for a plaintiff, but it's also expensive for defendants. It's expensive for every one of our companies that work here and employ our people. The number one, two, three, four, five employers in each of your districts spends a lot of money trying to deal with litigation. It is extremely expensive, and that's one of the things that we're hoping to address and be able to have the policy debates.
It'll be interesting to see in 2019 when we come in here and we visit about some of these things that prior to this constitutional amendment being approved, if the people approve it, it'll be interesting to see how we line these things out and how we develop the policy here in this body that is the policy body in our government. Representative Fortner, for what purpose? Point of clarification. All right. Let's go ahead with your... Representative Ballinger, I know that you know.
Representative Fortner, is this a question? I can make it that if you'd like. Okay. That's... Yes, sir. Is this not going to be decided by the people of Arkansas and not by us? Because when you started, probably because you got a little bit of pressure, you said, when we pass this, we are not passing. We pass this. It's going to go to the people to make the decision. We are not making the decision. Am I correct? Please tell me that. That is correct. Mr. Fortner, I appreciate that.
Representative Fortner, I appreciate that clarification. you know the way the way we're doing this is we are referring so we will refer out this resolution to be debated on about between the different groups who have have concerns about this between the citizens and then they'll make the decision whether or not they want to amend their constitution and the only we is that we all get to have an opportunity but in that case we only have one vote however when we when we refer something out we should be mindful of what we refer out and be wise about it and so that's what we're doing right now and having having you know debate
about it, but at the same time, ultimately, I believe that our individuals back home have asked for some form of tort reform, most of them have, and so now we're giving them the opportunity to vote on it. Representative Charlotte Douglas, for what purpose? Question. Question, you're recognized. Yes. And I, Representative Ballinger, I asked you this just a while ago, but I'm still having a lot of heartburn over the 33 and a third percent on the net and why that just does
not seem like a Republican issue for us to set limits on someone's income and I know you've explained it but I still am not easy with that especially if we're putting it on the net? And if it is not a good policy, why haven't we gone back to the table to revise that and look at a compromise on that before we send it to the people?
I'm going to take that kind of in two questions. One is the cap anyway on the contingency fees, and the second part is why the cap the way we have it. And essentially the cap on contingency fees, we have we cap individuals fees all the time on different issues if you're an individual who provides services to medicaid there's a cap on on all the services that are being provided in this case as as attorneys we are all officers of the court when we're sworn in we have an obligation to the court itself and so we've i mean our rules are are many of them are set either by by the supreme court or
by code for that matter that limits us in a lot of different ways as attorneys so what we're dealing with is how attorneys interact with the government, the judicial system. And so I think that there's no, I mean, it is a limitation that is set within the government itself, and so I don't necessarily have a problem with that. Now, the question of how you do it and how we do it, that's something that I think should be debated. And I think that the only way that we'll really see how those fees are actually carried out, what it means in net, is in an enabling legislation that we'll have in
2019. So things like costs, how will those be associated with it? I haven't spoke with anybody who thinks like medical bills ought to be included in that. I think that those would come out first. You know, costs associated with court, all that is open for debate, and I think that we'll debate that vigorously in 19, and I would stand alongside you or anybody else in here to try to make sure we get something that's extremely clear in our enabling legislation. Follow-up? Yes, ma'am, you recognize for your follow-up. And I still, if you would reassure me that this 33 and a third on the net is something
that's normal, because we keep hearing that it is normal, but what does normal mean? Does that mean that all of the other states that have tort reform have this on the net, or does that mean it has become normal here in Arkansas? Okay, you're kind of two different things. A third on contingency fees is fairly standard. Now, there's different fluctuation with different firms, but most firms, very few firms go more than a third. So that's, I guess, probably where you're hearing normal.
Now, the way that we do it is, I mean, I don't think that we have a way to compare how we do our attorney's fees under this resolution, if approved by the voters, and any other state, because we don't have the enabling legislation. So after session of 2019, we'll know how that is and how that compares to other states. And I think it would be important for us to look and see how it operates other places, see how it's being carried out in that consideration. However, I think that there is pretty broad consensus on making sure that that doesn't include things like costs associated with medical bills and all that.
Okay. Representative Stephen Meeks, for what purpose? Question, please. You're recognized for your question. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative Ballinger, you made something, made a comment during your opening statement. that kind of caught my interest, and I'm wondering if you could expound on it a little bit for us. I know myself and many conservatives are concerned about justices who will legislate from the bench, we'll put it nicely, and you'd mentioned that this may create an opportunity for us to maybe rein that in a little bit. Would you talk to us a little bit about how this might allow us,
as the legislative body, to prevent the judges from legislating from the bench but still giving them the autonomy they need under the Constitution to perform their duties? I appreciate that question. You know, I really like our bench now. I think that they are doing a good job. Our Supreme Court is a pretty solid court, and I wouldn't expect to see a lot of legislating from the bench. But what we have seen through history is something that I would consider to be legislating from the bench. When this body passed out things like joint and several liability from the 2003 Civil Justice Reform Act,
when they when they put caps out when they said that that a expert witness should have to have some sort of certification before they can actually testify all those are policy decisions those are things that that's not refereeing anymore if the court decides to rule those out they're saying that that's you know rules practice and procedures how they defined it and i don't believe that that is what the legislature meant when they referred out amendment 8 or what became amendment 80 years ago and so what we're doing here is trying to pull back on some of that now My opinion is the court ought to be able to manage their own business.
That's one of the reasons why we have the amendment that we put in there is it allows them to set their own rules. However, what I want to be able to do is set policy. And if the court is going to interpret everything that we do as a legislative body as rules, practice, and procedure, we have to have the ability to address rules, practice, and procedure in order to be able to do that. And so that is why that section of the resolution is necessary. All right, having not seen any other questions, I do appreciate a good vote. All right, members, you've heard an explanation of the resolution. Would anyone like to speak against the resolution?
Representative Hendren, you're recognized to speak against the resolution. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. One of the things I wanted to do is to come down and explain how somebody that's 79 years old can still screw up down here and not get it right. When this came up, I came down here with the rest of you here earlier in this session, and I was met outside the chamber with some good friends of mine who happen to serve as lobbyists, a lot of them down here, and they serve a good purpose.
And they asked me about this resolution here and about this proposed constitutional amendment. And my question to them, because since I'm not a lawyer, I said, what does it do? Maybe you've asked some people that from time to time. I think it would help from time to time, at least it does for me, if I know what I'm voting on and what's it supposed to be doing. And they said, it's a tort reform bill. And then I asked the next question something that I could understand, I think, and I think I did understand it. I said, is this the same document, the same thing we did in 2003 when I was on the Senate
Judiciary Committee for a long time? We worked hour after hour to get that legislation through on tort reform, which I voted for and I think it was a good bill. And of course then the courts did their number on that bill, as they frequently do. And the answer to that, and I think it was true in what they believed, and what I believe they said, yeah, it's the same thing. And so I made the mistake, colleagues, that we shouldn't do, since when you get as old as I am you sure ought to know better than something like this.
I used to say, why didn't my dad tell me about stuff like that? And the answer is he did, I just didn't listen. So I signed on to the, and you'll see my name on here, and I haven't had it removed. But I do think I owe an explanation when I come down here and tell you I'm going to vote against this bill. Because it's not the same thing as we did in 2003. It's got a lot of other stuff in it. It passed the Senate, if you'll look back on your record there, but 21 votes this proposal did to present to the people.
not an overwhelming majority in a body that comprised of 35 members. Now it was said a while ago that we need to pass this thing so we can see what's in it. Seems like I heard that said somewhere before a few years back. But you know I looked at the if you look at this and I hope you looked at a copy of this ballot titles. Ballot titles concern me just a little bit and I think they concern the three million people in the state of Arkansas.
When we passed the deal with term limits and setting our salaries back in 2014, issue number three, that ballot title was named setting term limits. And ladies and gentlemen I found out since then that was misleading and the people that put that on the ballot were told before it was put on the ballot that it was a misleading statement to the people, the of the state of Arkansas. It said setting state term limits. And what we were doing what we did do with that amendment was to extend term limits. Now ladies and gentlemen when
I make a mistake and tell you something and I don't know any better which I do frequently then you can forgive me for it. But when you come up to me and you say, Kim you are misleading somebody by saying you are setting them instead of extending them I have a hard time justifying statement like that. And so I looked at the ballot title on this deal. I hope you've looked at it. If you'll turn to page 6 you can begin to see it because there's about 36 lines that the people are going to have to understand if this
gets on the ballot for them to vote on. If you'll look at where this starts on page 6. In fact I had some trouble with this. I said what am I talking about here? Page 6, Section 7, it says a ballot title and popular name. Well, Section 8 says this. When presented on the general... I better quit talking so loud. When presented on the general election ballot, the popular name for this proposed amendment shall be, parenthesis or quotes, an amendment concerning civil lawsuits
in the powers of the General Assembly and the Supreme Court to hear court rules. Quotation marks. And I thought, well, that's not too long a title, is it? But then I read on. Look at Section B. That goes on for 36 lines. And you know what I ought to do is just torture us with reading this all to us this afternoon. It starts something like this. I guess this is the title because I had to go and look. Well where is this next parenthesis? It says this is B. When presented on the general election ballot the
ballot title for this proposed amendment shall be, quote, a proposed amendment. Then I could read for the next 36 lines of what this thing does. And that just overloads me. So I'm going to vote against this thing because it does not do what we did. It does a whole lot more than what we did in 2003. And ladies and gentlemen it's time we started leveling with the people of the state of Arkansas. Tell them plain talk of what we're doing. And if we're extending term
limits by Georgia let's not say we're establishing them. All right, members, Representative Hendren has spoken against the measure. Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Representative Collins, you're recognized to speak for the bill. Here's another one. We've got a problem in our state, and it's very difficult to deal with,
and we've tried to deal with it again and again, and we're back here today. And the problem is the climate. The problem is the system. What we do in this body is we create a system within which businesses and workers and others operate. And the system we have today with regard to the litigation approach in Arkansas is ranked near the bottom of the 50 states from a business perspective because the way that we have it today,
businesses are at a very high-cost, high-risk situation. As Representative Hendren said, the legislature attempted in 2003 to make an adjustment. The court system and the litigants decided to throw that out, and through a series of court cases in 2008, 2009, 2010, They got that entire attempt to balance the system thrown away.
In 2009, the legislature attempted another approach to create risk pools. That didn't pass. In 2011, we tried to refer a constitutional amendment. That didn't pass. In 2013, we tried again for a constitutional amendment. That didn't pass. In 2015, we went for loser pay legislation. That wouldn't work. The bottom line is certain groups and individuals benefit mightily from the current system. There's nothing wrong with that, and I
understand how strongly they feel about that position. The problem is we need to turn our state into a good jobs magnet and move ourselves off the doggone bottom. And in order to do that, we need to make some adjustments. Now, one of the major changes in this approach compared to the prior efforts is to clarify that the courts do not have the authority to merely say anything
we do is not policy but is only procedure because in the past when they make that distinction that enables them to basically obviate much of what we do and so I'd appreciate a good vote. Alright members of Representative Collins has spoken in favor of the measure. Would anyone like to speak against the measure? Alright Representative Walker I actually had Representative Tucker he stood first earlier So I'm going to go in order here, and I'll catch the rest of the other two here in just a minute.
Representative Tucker, you're recognized to speak against the measure. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I very much appreciate the opportunity to address this body. You know, the first thought that comes to mind when I speak on this is that I wish I could deliver my argument with the voice of Representative Carlton Wien, because I think I would be able to be much more persuasive. But unfortunately, God did not bless me with that talent.
I also don't want to step in front of Representative Walker. But, you know, we've had a bunch of debate on this issue. I think that's good. That's the way the legislative process is supposed to work. I'm going to do my best not to cover points that have already been made. But I want to clarify a couple things that I believe need clarification and to look at this whole issue, I think, from a little different perspective. And the first issue is the one that we've just had a bunch of discussion about right now, and that is the rules, the rulemaking procedure versus substance. One concern I have is that a bunch of members are under the impression that Congress has a role
in the rulemaking procedure at the federal level, and so if we do the same, then we should be in good shape. It is true that Congress has a role, but there are two important distinctions, at least in my opinion, between what's proposed here and what exists at the federal level. But first, I think it's critical that we understand this distinction between substance and procedure. You know, substance is the law, and as Representative Ballinger put it, procedure is how a branch of government manages its own business. You know, if you look at the language of SJR 8,
you'll notice that it's not new language in the state constitution that the court cannot take any action that will abridge, enlarge, or modify a substantive right. So there's nothing about this that changes the ability of the court not to do that. Right now, the court sets its own procedure. This policy, the substantive law in Arkansas is set first by our state constitution and second by the legislature, and that's the way it should be. And, you know, the Civil Justice Reform Act has been brought up several times today. I practice under that act.
There are a lot of provisions in the CJRA that are still in effect that the court has upheld as substantive. The joint and several liability requirements have been upheld by the Supreme Court because they are substantive in nature. You know, one example of something that has been struck down is what an expert has to do in order to qualify to testify as an expert in court. That's procedural. The Supreme Court struck that down. One provision that got struck down was the cap on punitive damages. That was not struck down as something that was procedural by this body.
That was struck down because the Supreme Court viewed that it conflicted with the Arkansas Constitution. and that comes first. Then the legislature comes second, and then the courts interpret the laws that we pass. So I think it's a mistake to characterize all of the work that the Supreme Court did in striking down a few provisions of the CJRA as categorizing those provisions as procedural, because that's not what they did. And then, you know, it's important to understand what we mean by procedural. You know, for us, procedure is governed by this book right here. You know,
it's the rules that govern what happens in the house. And, you know, I can't imagine what our reaction would be if another branch of government, the governor or the judiciary came to us and tried to tell us how we were going to manage our business. In fact, you know, the Senate is in the same branch as us. And if they came to us to direct us how our rules were going to work, I dare say the reaction would be a lot more severe than Representative Fortner trying to tackle a senator or two in a basketball game. I think it would be a lot more serious than that. And so I think it's
important to try to separate out what we mean by substance and procedure. Now back to those two differences between what's proposed in SJR 8 and the federal law. The first is that the Congress only has an ability to comment on a law that has originated with the judiciary. And so this gives the legislature the right to create rules of procedure that the court does in and of itself? And I can't imagine, again, what our reaction would be if we approached Mr. Johnson and asked him for an interpretation of a particular rule, and he said, Representative, I'm going to have
to wait and see what the governor or the Supreme Court does about that. That's not the way that it should work. The second, I'm drawing a blank on the second distinction right now, but I'll get back to it. Apologies on that. But so that's, you know, the point though, the primary point here is that when we created our government, we created three co-equal branches, and that's a checks and balance system. And I know that legislators, myself included, get irritated when the Supreme Court throws out either specific provisions of big laws or throws out laws entirely, but that's the
purpose of the checks and balance system. If one branch has total control over the law, there is no check and there is no balance. And if you consider the fact that in our country, we have the youngest culture, right? But we have the oldest government in the world, when you think about world history. And the reason is because our founders got it right. We have three co-equal branches of government. And if we are able to control the rulemaking procedure of another branch, you no longer have co-equal checks and balances. The judiciary will be subservient to the legislature,
make no mistake about it, and I think that's a violation of one of the foundational principles of our constitutional democracy. So that's the first, kind of the rule-making category. The second category is I just want to take a step and look at, you know, what are we trying to achieve? What's our goal with this proposal? The only explanation that I have really heard is, we need to make the litigation climate in Arkansas more attractive to business, right? And so, first of all, I think it's important for me to say, just to clear the air, I'm a business I represent businesses in my practice. This proposal will not represent my practice. I bill
by the hour. I've had a handful of contingency fee cases in my career, but over 95% of my work comes through representing businesses and billing by the hour. I don't deal with non-economic damages. I occasionally deal with punitive damages, but I think the proposal in SJR 8 on that is reasonable, so I'm not going to talk about that. But just to make that clear, this will not affect my practice. But the three ways that I see that this can affect the litigation climate in Arkansas for businesses are, number one, to discourage the filing of frivolous lawsuits,
number two, to put caps on merit-based, meritorious lawsuits that are filed, and then number three, to discourage the filing of meritorious lawsuits. Now, I'm going to talk about the middle one of those first. I think everyone, as part of this discussion, realizes that when you put a monetary cap on of half a million dollars on non-economic damages that we're reining in what a jury in your community that wants to impose your community standards for some an injury that someone in your community has sustained a cap on their ability to do that and that affects a right
guaranteed once again by our founders in the seventh amendment to the u.s constitution now i've heard in this discussion you know from various proponents that we regulate what juries do all the time. We set sentencing ranges for crimes, or we impose fines and fees and that sort of thing. Well, that's true, but there are different rights at stake in those discussions. When you charge someone with a crime, the constitutional right at stake is with the criminal defendant, and their constitutional right is not to be subject to a cruel and unusual punishment. That's why we set sentencing ranges, so that if someone is convicted of shoplifting
$100, they can't be sentenced to 10 years in prison because that's cruel and unusual. But even though we set those ranges to make sure that people's constitutional rights aren't violated, they're still wide ranges so juries can impose their community standards as they should. There's no time in Arkansas history that I'm aware of that we are abridging someone's right to a jury the way that we are with this proposal. And so this is really groundbreaking legislation, and I think we should take it very seriously. And, you know, we're doing that in a way that
puts a dollar value on life. I think that ground has been plowed and I'm not going to cover that except to say you know one comment on that is it's also been discussed that oh there are Arkansas jury instructions about lost earning capacity and lost profits and that's true but in three years of law school and 11 years of practice I have never heard of a case where you can put economic value and a plaintiff can recover for lost earning capacity for a minor and the reason is because there is a prohibition on recovering damages that are speculative in nature. The burden of proof
still rests with the plaintiff. And if you have someone who's been injured, who's eight years old, 10 years old, or 12 years old, you cannot put on proof of what they might earn as an adult without speculating. And so I believe it's impossible in those cases for someone to recover any sort of monetary value. And so you're putting a cap on the non-economic as far as that goes. So now we're talking about what kind of lawsuits are we discouraging from being filed, frivolous or meritorious lawsuits. In my opinion, this does very little, if anything,
to discourage frivolous lawsuits. In my experience, frivolous cases are ones with a relatively low dollar value in the $10,000 to $50,000 range. And the reason for that is because lawyers don't want to take a big risk on a case they know does not have merit. And what kinds of risks do lawyers take by taking on contingency cases? Huge. And the risks go up the higher value the case is. Because if you have a case that's six figures, seven figures, eight figures in value,
I can guarantee you that the expenses the lawyer is going to incur can be a minimum of $20,000. I've heard of someone gave me a case this weekend where they spent $400,000 as a lawyer out of their own pocket on a case. Now, if you don't think that's an incentive not to turn away the frivolous cases, then I don't know what to tell you about it. And so what we are talking about here is an access to justice issue and access to the courts. You know, I bill by the hours I said, so I can
tell you it's a tedious process, and I detest it, and the bookkeeping firm, bookkeeping people in my firm can testify to that, but I can tell you down to the tenth of an hour how much time I've spent on a case, and then sometimes it's a thousand or twelve hundred hours, and depending on how much you work, that's six or eight months of work, and so a lawyer has to take a risk of working six or eight months on a particular case and having no income whatsoever, not only that, but losing 20 or $50,000 or $100,000 in the process. And so the incentive is there to not take frivolous cases.
And if anything, we're only, by capping it at a third of net, I know we're going to regulate that. But in some cases, that can drive, if it's truly net, it can drive the recovery a lawyer can make down to 27% or even in the teens, depending on how much medical expenses there are with a particular case. And so you're making it where a lawyer does not have a choice to take a case, and you're going to have people who suffer genuine injuries, not only through no fault of their own, but through the fault of someone else that will have no access to the
court. And so, you know, I'll wrap up, but I'll just say, you know, I'm skeptical of the evidence that I've heard that this can help the litigation climate for businesses in Arkansas. I think you can sort of make that argument on both sides, but I don't think it's very persuasive. But I'm very confident about the impact it will have on the balance of power and our constitutional democracy and I'm very confident that people who are injured through no fault of their own will suffer if this becomes the law in Arkansas and those people don't always have the time and resources
to be with us here at the state capitol every day but I know they are on our hearts and minds when we vote in this chamber and for those reasons I'll ask you to join me in voting no. All right, members, Representative Tucker has spoken against the measure. Would anyone like to speak for the measure? Against the measure? All right, I think I had Representative Walker up next.
All right. Representative Gassaway, or excuse me, Representative Walker has declined to speak. So in that spot, I had Representative Gassaway next on the list. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Thank you, members.
I'd like to begin by saying to to everyone here that I gave a very passionate speech the last time that we were in this chamber about this issue and I want everybody to know that if I offended anyone in the giving of that speech that I sincerely apologize my dad is in a nursing home. My daughter was involved in a head-on collision just a few weeks before this issue
came up. And so it's very personal to me. It's very emotional to me. And if I said anything that offended anyone, I sincerely apologize. And what I would ask you to do is to not take any feelings that you have against me about the presentation that I made against the bill or in support of my amendment into how you vote about this bill, because this bill and this referred constitutional amendment
is too important to get wrong. And it's too important to get wrong because of how you feel about me. And so I would ask you to just take me out of it and consider this on the merits. And so what I'd like to first talk to you about is our principles as conservatives, because I think this debate boils down to a few things I think that it boils down to our principles versus the power that we feel from outside this chamber
to influence us on how to vote and so with respect to our principles when you go through the bill you go through this amendment that we're going to refer to the people one of the first provisions is about attorney's fees and I don't want to get too caught up in that because I know everybody feels about attorneys. But we've heard arguments today from this well about free market principles. We've heard arguments from this well today about capitalism and about how these are things that we believe as conservatives and that these are things that are important to us. And I would submit
to you that if that is a true principle that we have and that we believe in, then limiting attorney's fees to one-third of a net violates those principles. And so for that reason, I'd ask you to vote against this bill. One of the other principles that I think is very important that we talk about is the right to life. And we've all campaigned on pro-life
issues. Because that's a principle that we believe in. And I think that this bill and this amendment really brings to a head that issue. Are we truly pro-life or are we just anti-abortion? Are we truly pro-life or are we just pro-fetus? Because there's a difference. And I would say, and I'm not saying by anyone voting for this bill
in its present form that you're not pro-life. I want to make that clear. I'm not saying that. But I'm saying that I think that we have to examine in ourselves when we consider this bill is this a pro-life bill? Because let me tell you what this bill does in its present form. And you can argue it any way you want, but it places a value on human life at $500,000. Period. If someone in this state who has no economic value because they're elderly
and infirm, they're in a nursing home, or they're a child, they're seven years old and they're in the second grade, they have no economic value. And so in the event of their death, what we say is is that the value of their life, this bill, would set a potential to cap that at $500,000. And so basically what we say to the world is that you can come into our state, if you own a nursing home, you can abuse or neglect the residents of our nursing home
until they die, and the maximum amount of recovery would potentially be $500,000. Is that pro-life? one of the other things that I want to deal with are the issues that we've heard about how we need to do this to improve the business community in Arkansas and that's a fair argument because that's something that we need to do is we need to improve the business community in the state of Arkansas
but the question is and as my good friend Representative Collins likes to say we're 47th in this we're 49th in this, we're 46th in this. If you want to talk about why businesses aren't coming to Arkansas, it's because we desperately need to improve our education system. It's because we desperately need to improve our skilled workforce. It's because we desperately need
to improve our tax policy. Those are the reasons why businesses aren't locating in Arkansas. So our tort policy, if that enters into the equation, would be way down on the list. So just to close, what I would ask you to remember is ultimately I think this debate comes down as who are we here to protect? Are we here to protect the most vulnerable members of our society?
Are we here to protect those who are in nursing homes and have no voice at this Capitol? Are we here to protect the children who have no economic value? Are we here to protect those people? Or are we here to protect profits? Are we here to protect the wealthy, the powerful, the insurance companies, the nursing homes, the wealthy corporations? That's really the choice. And so because of the things that this bill does, and that's not to mention our constitutional principle. I want to go back real quick to our constitutional principles.
As conservatives, we say that we believe in the strong and the separation of powers. We say that we believe in the Seventh Amendment right to trial by jury. But does this bill promote those things? And so from a principled standpoint, as a conservative, we say that this bill does not do that. And again, who are we here to protect? And so with that, I would ask you to please vote against this bill. Thank you.
All right. Members, Representative Gassaway has spoken against the measure. Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Okay. All right. We're going to say that Representative Douglas stood first. Representative Douglas, you are recognized to speak for the resolution. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. One thing I want to clarify, Representative Gassaway gave a good presentation here,
but I have worked on economic development projects many times. In fact, I sat down recently with a young lady that works for a major manufacturing site selection firm. These are companies that take in all the information on all the states and advise major manufacturers where is the best location in this country to locate their business. When I said, I've heard before that Arkansas was not even on the map,
and I said, why is this great state not on your radar screen? she told me that whenever she looked at it first of all we have a great geographical location for distribution we have the third lowest utility rates in the nation so we're very favorable there. Our economic incentives that we give through economic development are excellent but one place, this isn't all of it, we could do better
on our workforce development but we're working on that but one place that we fall down we're 41st in the nation on tort and that is a discouragement for a lot of manufacturers to come to this state. I would appreciate a good vote. Representative Douglas has spoken for the bill. Would anyone like to speak against
the bill, I have Representative Mayberry up next. You are recognized to speak against the resolution. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And members, I'll keep this short. I know everybody's getting weary. Very quickly, to address Representative Douglas, I used to work for the Economic Development Commission, and I would reiterate the point that Representative Gassaway was making with regards to workforce education, that that is likely the key, the top reason why businesses are not looking at Arkansas perhaps as much as they should.
I said on Friday that I am in favor of tort reform, as I know many people in this chamber are who do not intend to vote for SJR 8. The reason, and I'm going to touch on just a couple of points very quickly, one of the greatest concerns I have is that I feel like the people who are going to be most negatively affected by this are the people that we're supposed to be here to defend and protect. That would be the children, the elderly, the infirmed. And I have great concern about them
with regards to this bill, which leads me into the second point that I touched on on Friday, and that is the issue of life. I find it very disturbing that this body could collectively just reach into thin air and pull out a dollar figure and write that, write that dollar figure into our state's constitution as the maximum amount that a life can be valued at in the state of Arkansas.
George W. Bush once said that a society is measured by how it treats its most weak and vulnerable. I would encourage you members who are with me in the fact that you want tort reform to vote against this bill and let's work together to put together a better tort reform proposal to send out to the people of Arkansas for them to vote on. I'd appreciate a no vote. All right, members, Representative Mayberry has spoken against the measure.
I have Representative Bentley up next to speak in favor of the measure. You're recognized to do so at this time. Colleagues, I'm very passionate about this, so I'm going to up front apologize if I speak too passionately to you, but I'm very, very passionate about tort reform. There's a number of issues that I want to discuss, and I know that we're all aware. We've been here a long day, and you probably don't want to hear all that I have to say, so I'm going to ask again for your indulgence to let me speak what I have to say.
I am very strongly pro-life, and everybody in this building knows that I am. I'm very much in favor of this bill because there's not enough money on this planet to place my granddaughter, I can promise you that money is not the issue and that's not what we're here for. Because we go to court for some unknown reason we have to set a cap and there's caps all across the country and we're not the only country to place a cap. This is really one of the highest caps of many of the states that have put caps on this. So that issue, I want it to rest that we're very much pro-life, many of us that are voting for this issue. Another issue brought up is nursing homes and I can promise you that I
I worked nights in a nursing home when I was going to nursing school. And the people that worked in that nursing home absolutely adored the people that were there. They took care of those patients. If one of those patients happened to get a little red spot on them or a bed sore, they were just appalled. It was just like, it just hit our heart. We worked so hard for those. So I just am just offended by the negative comments that are made about so many folks that love folks in the nursing homes. My in-laws were just there, and thank goodness when my mother-in-law got Alzheimer's,
we had a place to put her that cared for her, that loved for her right there in our community. So there are many nursing homes here that are doing a phenomenal job. And when someone falls or gets hurt in a nursing home, it shouldn't be somebody's day for a lottery. And unfortunately, the way the lawyers have acted in our state, sometimes it's a lottery for somebody, and that has been just as offensive, and that's made a liability insurance in our states extremely high. And that's the other thing I want to bring up. I know Representative Tucker said, why do we want to do this? But one of the biggest reasons that I want tort reform is that, guys, we have a cliff that we're heading towards.
On Medicaid funding coming up in the future, we have a huge cliff coming up that we don't have the money to pay for it. And we have to start now. We've got so much in the air with the ACA and all those things. We have got to start now to make medical costs in this state less. We've got to do something. And right now, our liability insurance for physicians is 40 to 50% higher than the states around us. That's something we just can't laugh at and say that's not happening. Right now in this state, our liability insurance is 40% or 50% higher than other states. I was visiting with Representative Coleman one day, and I guess a lot of us get to talk to you, Bruce, on different things.
But he was talking about his hospital board had worked really hard to get an obstetrician into their small community. The guy comes in, he's going to work and deliver babies right there, but his liability insurance was so high it cost him $500 per child to deliver just for his liability insurance. So these are serious things that we've got to think about. We've got a big task ahead of us if we remain here for a few years, guys, on how in the world this state's going to pay for things when it comes to Medicaid. We don't have a printing press in the basement. There's no money that we can print.
We have a balanced budget, and we're going to have to pay for things. And so I think we have really, when we got there talking with our folks, we've got to decrease the cost of medical care in our state. And to me, this is a huge way that we can do it. Is it perfect? No. But another thing that I'd know that I trust these guys and you guys here in this chamber that we will make it right. We will do the very best for the states, for our constituents here, and we will bring up the rules that we need to for this liability insurance that we can make it the best that it can. So, guys, you know, I just wanted to say this is a hard vote, no doubt about it.
I am pro-life. I'm 100% for this legislation. I hope that you guys will take the time and give this out to the people of Arkansas because I certainly trust them on their votes on this. Thank you very much. All right, members, Representative Bentley has spoken in favor of the measure. Would anyone like to speak against the measure? I believe I have Representative House up next to speak against the bill, or the resolution, rather.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I will not repeat anything that I've heard said in the last hour or so. I was looking in the Bible yesterday. Jesus didn't have very many nice things to say about lawyers. Then I looked a little bit closer, and it was the lawyers for the rich and powerful that he was fussing at, not the plaintiff's lawyers, not the people that represented the common folk.
Representative Douglas, you asked a question a while ago. The purpose of this amendment is to deny people access to the courts, the kind of people that get hit and hurt in car wrecks, the kind of people that get hurt in all sorts of negligent situations, because that's what the bill does. it denies access to the courts. Number one, penalizing the attorneys to make it to the point where they can't make enough money to make it a go. And second, so that they've got enough money
to walk up and here's your blood money. We're sorry we killed your kid. Go off and have a good life. We did blood money in Iraq. You know, we would accidentally shoot a child or civilian man or a woman, and we would pay for a child $1,000, $1,200, maybe $1,500. For a woman, a few dollars more, and for a man, maybe $2,000. And for one of our colleagues, I learned the other day that in Afghanistan, for a man, it was about $800. For a woman, it was like maybe $400. A child, maybe $200.
That's called blood money. It's Sharia law. It's nothing new. Just give money to the people, and that's the end of it. You can walk away. They can't exact retribution. We have been placing values on human life for 800 years. We do it through the jury system. It is the best system ever invented by people. There is no other better way to do it. That is what distinguishes the Anglo-English American system of justice from all other nations. The jury. One of the complaints
about King George to King George in the Declaration of Independence was this, for depriving us in many cases of the benefits of trial by jury. After we came to the Constitution, after the Revolution in 1789, all of our founding fathers insisted on a Bill of Rights, all but perhaps two of those Bill of Rights. There was actually 12 of them to begin with. The first two were rejected, had to do with representation in Congress and salaries and
terms of service. But the first, but Numbers 3 through 12 were adopted by the people, and they became our First Amendment. They all have to do with our relationship, man against government, government against people, and man against man. And one of the bills of rights, one of the fundamental rights guaranteed to us as people is the right to trial by jury. And if you don't like the trial by jury, and if you just want to go to blood money, which is what this is, fine.
Why don't we say the same thing about guns? It's okay, we can just get rid of it. How about just one gun per household? Let's do that. I mean, it's just one of those bills of rights, really doesn't apply to us. Oh, well, maybe then, okay, we can maybe skip that part about free speech if you say anything bad about the government. Why don't we get rid of that? Why don't we regulate that? It's one of the fundamental rights enshrined in the bills of rights is the right to let 12 people
of your community decide what's just and fair and right in the premises. Representative Bentley had a good story about nursing homes, and we've got some really good nursing homes, and we've got some really bad ones too. And that good one that she's talking about, there's not a jury in probably Conway or Perry County. I don't know where she's talking, Conway County, but that jury is probably not going to find them negligent because they do know their reputation. They do know the quality of their work. I would much rather trust my business to the hands of 12 of my community
people who know me from church and Little League Ball Field and their mamas and their daddies were in my business. James Madison said, trial by jury in civil cases is as essential to the security of liberty of the people as any one of the pre-existing rights of nature. I like what John Adams said, representative government and trial by jury are the heart and lungs of liberty. Without them, we have no other fortification against government being ridden like horses,
fleeced like sheep, worked like cattle, and fed and clothed like swine and hounds. In our own Constitution, we find the right of trial by jury shall remain inviolate and shall extend to all cases at law without regard to the amount in controversy. Let's just do away with that. That's what we're doing. Another place in our Constitution, it says, talking about workers' comp and lawsuits, provided that otherwise no law shall be enacted limiting the amount to be recovered
for injuries resulting in death or for injuries to persons or property and in case of death from such injuries, the right of action shall survive and the General Assembly shall prescribe for whose benefit such action shall be prosecuted. Let's do it with all that. Oh yeah, you can have your jury trial. Here's $500,000. Y'all just go tell the jury all you want because here's our money.
We'll just plead that into court and walk away. It's that word net. It's that word net. Net means something if it's in the Constitution. So when we come back in two years, net's going to be after, first of all, the liens. Y'all probably didn't know this. Like, let's say you have medical bills. The hospitals and the doctors have, and Medicaid and Medicare, have liens on the lawsuit proceeds.
Let's just say you had an accident and you had $50,000 worth of medical bills, and you settle it or win a verdict for $100,000. The first $50,000 comes right out and goes to the hospital. Lawyer don't get part of that. Sometimes they do. Am I wrong? I'm correct. Any lawyer will tell you that. Sometimes you can get a little discount if you're doing some work, but in the case of Medicare and Medicaid, they just reach in and snatch it, either in form of a lien or a claim.
Insurance companies have a lien on it, too, by statute. So what does net mean? Probably means after they've got their money. Now you're way down, because remember we're trying to recover damages. $500,000, a third of that's pretty good money, but that's pretty much guaranteed at a wrongful death. The whole idea is to make it so that poor people can't get a lawyer. and we're going to enshrine in the Constitution that a plaintiff's lawyer can only get paid 33 and 3rd.
How come we're not mentioning the defense attorneys? That's who Jesus was talking about because they work for rich folks. Rich folks can hire lawyers. Insurance companies can hire lawyers. I'm going to leave this with you. It's from the Seventh Amendment. it's in our U.S. Constitution in suits at common law where the value in controversy shall exceed $20 the right of trial by jury
shall be preserved and no fact how fact meaning how much you're entitled to what happened who was negligent who was at fault and no fact tried by a jury shall be otherwise re-examined in any court of the United States than according to the rules of the common law. The common law is the English law, the 800-year-old law. Ask you to vote no. Thank you.
All right, members, Representative House has spoken against the measure. Representative Ballinger, would you like to close for the resolution? You're welcome to do so at this time. I'll make this fast, members, so we can get out of here hopefully soon. All right, I don't know about you, but as far as conservative credentials, I'm not sure how many people in here that can out-conservative me. I don't know how we do that. They're trying, but I'm not sure if they can. I mean, this thing is I love the Constitution. I love the
Seventh Amendment of the Constitution. I love the trial by jury. I think all that is really good stuff. I'm one of those dorks that listen to podcasts about that kind of stuff on a regular basis. Love it. In this case, what we're doing is we are reinforcing the constitutional separation of powers. That's what we're doing. The issue of the trial by jury, we do all the time set limits on jury. Every time we pass a bill, we are putting limits upon a jury because we're setting the law. We're creating policy. That's what we do. We create policy. Live or die, we create policy. Good or
bad we create policy that's what we do here all the time and so when we create the penalties for how long a person's going to spend their life in jail you know what what how much how many years does a person stay in jail we decide that what the elements of a tort are we can address all of that we do that that's what we do because we set policy love my jury love my people back home want them to be empowered but at the same time we need to be able to set policy here That's not necessarily a conservative issue or a liberal issue.
What that is is a good government issue, and that's what I'm arguing is it's a better government for us to have the ability to set the policy here, you know, in this deliberative body than it is for that to happen in one place, in one county, in another place, in another county, or on so forth. You know, what we're really doing here, there was a statement that said something like, the purpose of this, one individual said, the purpose of this is to exclude people from the courts. You know, I sit on a panel, the Access to Justice Commission.
You know what our commission's job is? Try to help people get access to justice. And then to say that the purpose of this is to prohibit access to justice is just crazy. The purpose of this is to end extortion that's happening now in Arkansas. Businesses are being extorted because they come in and they're faced with, do I go ahead and defend this even though I know it's a frivolous lawsuit? Or do I pay it? because in the end, a jury may very well slap on me a $10 million judgment, and I can't afford that. Some small business is a million-dollar judgment. That's enough to put us out of business.
You know, the truth is that's all it is. It's about ending extortion, about creating a balance that we need. And, you know, in the end, the ultimate jury is going to be the people. They get to the side. All we have to do is send it out there for them to make that decision. I appreciate you getting a good vote. All right, members, the question now before the House will be the passage of SJR 8.
All right, we have a pair on the desk. Representative Deanne Vaught votes yes. Representative Fred Love votes no. This was witnessed by Representative Jim Dotson. Representative Love is the present member. Are there any procedural objections to this pair? All right, please do not vote either of these two voting machines. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk.
All right, has everyone voted? Everyone voted? All right, let's cast out the ballots, Mr. Clerk. All right, with 66 yeas, 30 nays, and one present, the resolution has passed. All right, members, after consulting with the sponsors of the remaining bills,
they are going to hold off until tomorrow. So Representative Stephen Meeks, you are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. After the announcements, reading of the bills, transferring of the bills, placing the calendars on the desk, members amending their own bills with their own amendments, members withdrawing their own bills, excuse me, finalizing resolutions, reading communications, and any remaining committee reports. I move that we adjourn until 1.30 tomorrow afternoon. That is a proper motion, non-debatable. All those in favor, say aye.
Aye. All those against, say no. All right, the ayes have it. Motion carries. All right, are there any announcements? Representative Dan Douglas, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Third District Caucus, 7.30 in the morning. John Riggs with Riggs Caterpillar will be there to talk about workforce needs. All right, Representative Joe Jett, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
Revenue tax will not meet tomorrow morning. All right, Representative Gene, you're recognized. Joint budget 9 a.m. tomorrow, Big Mac A. All right, Representative Cozart, you're recognized. Education will meet in the morning at 10 o'clock, room 138.
Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized. Announcement, public health, 10 a.m. in the morning. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative Shepard, you're recognized. Announcement, House Judiciary, tomorrow morning, 10 a.m. Representative Holcomb, you're recognized. Announcement, public transportation, tomorrow morning, 10 a.m., Big Mac B.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
um
Yeah.
Thank you.
oh hey
Oh,
Thank you.
Read the bills, Mr. Clerk. House Bill 1685. Without objection, read the bill for the second time. House Bill 1685. Judiciary. House Bill 1686. Without objection, read the bill the second time. House Bill 1686. Judiciary. House Bill 1687.
Without objection, read the bill the second time. House Bill 1687. Judiciary. House Bill 1688. Without objection, read the bill the second time. House Bill 1688. Public Health. House Bill 1689. Without objection, read the bill the second time. House Bill 1689. Education. House Bill 1690. Without objection, read the bill the second time. House Bill 1690. Joint Budget. House Bill 1691. Without objection, read the bill the second time.
House Bill 1691. Transportation. House Bill 1692. Without objection, read the bill the second time. House Bill 1692. Agroforestry. House Bill 1693. Without objection, read the bill the second time. House Bill 1693. Revenue and tax. House Bill 1694. Without objection, read the bill the second time. House Bill 1694. Joint budget. House Bill 1695. Without objection, read the bill the second time.
House Bill 1695. Joint budget. House Bill 1696. Without objection, read the bill the second time. House Bill 1696. State agencies. House Bill 1697. Without objection, read the bill the second time. House Bill 1697. State agencies. House Bill 1698. Without objection, read the bill the second time. House Bill 1698. Joint budget. House Bill 1699. Without objection, read the bill a second time. House Bill 1699. Joint budget. House Bill 1700. Without objection, read the bill a second time.
House Bill 1700. Joint budget. House Bill 1701. Without objection, read the bill a second time. House Bill 1701. Education. House Bill 1702. Without objection, read the bill a second time. House Bill 1702. Joint budget. House Bill 1703. Without objection, read the bill a second time. House Bill 1703, City County, House Bill 1704, Without objection read the bill a second time, House Bill 1704, Joint Budget, House Bill 1705, Without objection read the bill a second time, House Bill 1705, Joint Budget, House Bill 1706, Without objection read the bill a second time.
I mean, we're not doing that one.
House Resolution 1034, without objection, read the bill a second time. House Resolution 1034, aging children and youth. Senate Bill 26, without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 26, education. Senate Bill 27, without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 27, education. Senate Bill 113.
Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 113. Judiciary. Senate Bill 131. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 131. State agency. Senate Bill 136. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 136. Judiciary. Senate Bill 178. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 178. Education. Senate Bill 278. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 278.
Education. Senate Bill 292. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 292. State agencies. Senate Bill 303. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 303. Education. Senate Bill 308. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 308. Education. Senate Bill 337. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 337. Education. Senate Bill 352.
Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 352. City, county, local. Senate Bill 358. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 358. Transportation. Senate Bill 359. without objection read the bill a second time senate bill 359 transportation senate bill 360. without objection read the bill a second time senate bill 360. transportation
senate bill 362. without objection read the bill a second time senate bill 362 revenue intact Senate Bill 363. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 363. Transportation. Senate Bill 366. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 366. Agroforestry. Senate Bill 369. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 369. Insurance and Commerce.
Senate Bill 373. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 373. State agencies. Senate Bill 377. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 377. State agencies. Senate Bill 379. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Bill 379. Transportation. Senate Concurrent Memorial Resolution 2. Without objection, read the bill a second time. Senate Concurrent Memorial Resolution 2. Judiciary.
the desk will remain open as needed for the reading of bills and upon completion of items named in the adjourned resolution the house will be adjourned until tomorrow afternoon at 1 30
Agenda
CALL TO ORDER
PRAYER AND PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
ATTENDANCE
RESOLUTIONS
HCR1006 Watson CONGRATULATING THE PRESCOTT HIGH SCHOOL CURLEY WOLVES FOOTBALL TEAM ON WINNING THE STATE 3A CHAMPIONSHIP.
End of Morning Hour
CONCUR IN SENATE AMENDMENT
HB1172 Tosh 1 CREATING A SENTENCE ENHANCEMENT FOR CERTAIN CRIMINAL OFFENSES TARGETING A CURRENT OR FORMER LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER, FIRST RESPONDER, OR HIS OR HER FAMILY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1320 Shepherd 1 TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 5 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING CRIMINAL OFFENSES AND THE CRIMINAL LAW.
HB1319 Shepherd 1 TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 23 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC UTILITIES AND REGULATED INDUSTRIES.
HB1038 Davis 1 TO ALLOW THE MULTIYEAR REGISTRATION OF PERSONAL-USE MOTOR VEHICLES.
HB1019 Cozart 1 TO AMEND THE MEMBERSHIP OF THE SCHOOL LEADERSHIP COORDINATING COUNCIL.
HB1521 Richmond 1 TO ALLOW COUNTIES TO BURN STORM DEBRIS BASED ON COUNTY-DECLARED DISASTER EMERGENCIES.
REGULAR BILLS
HB1536 M. Gray TO AMEND THE MINORITY BUSINESS ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ACT TO INCLUDE WOMEN-OWNED BUSINESSES.
HB1569 C. Douglas TO REDUCE THE STANDARD LICENSING FEE FOR CERTAIN MILITARY MEMBERS AND VETERANS.
HB1642 Wing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE APPOINTMENT OF THE CHIEF OF THE ARKANSAS HIGHWAY POLICE DIVISION OF THE ARKANSAS STATE HIGHWAY AND TRANSPORTATION DEPARTMENT.
HB1643 Wing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE STATE AID ENGINEER OF THE ARKANSAS STATE HIGHWAY AND TRANSPORTATION DEPARTMENT.
HB1586 Payton TO AMEND CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF THE WORKERS' COMPENSATION LAW ENACTED BY INITIATED ACT NO. 4 OF 1948; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1509 Leding TO CREATE THE SUDDEN CARDIAC ARREST PREVENTION ACT.
HB1432 Wing CONCERNING THE TRANSPORTATION OF MALTREATED ADULTS; AND TO DEFINE "IMPAIRMENT" UNDER THE ADULT MALTREATMENT CUSTODY ACT AND THE ADULT AND LONG-TERM CARE FACILITY RESIDENT MALTREATMENT ACT.
HB1010 Sabin TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE FILING AND PUBLICATION OF CERTAIN CAMPAIGN FINANCE REPORTS; AND TO AMEND PORTIONS OF LAW RESULTING FROM INITIATED ACT 1 OF 1990 AND INITIATED ACT 1 OF 1996.
HB1590 Vaught TO EXEMPT CERTAIN RECORDS OF THE DEPARTMENT OF ARKANSAS STATE POLICE CONCERNING THE GOVERNOR'S MANSION AND MANSION GROUNDS FROM THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967.
HB1581 Hammer TO IMPLEMENT A SURVEY OF EMPLOYEE ENGAGEMENT AS AN ASSESSMENT TOOL TO BE USED BY ALL STATE AGENCIES.
HB1527 Rushing CONCERNING CONTINUING EDUCATION REQUIREMENTS FOR REAL ESTATE LICENSEES.
HB1585 Capp TO CREATE A PROCEDURE FOR THE DISPOSAL OF PERSONAL INFORMATION CONTAINED IN A LEASED SELF-SERVICE STORAGE SPACE.
HB1377 Lemons CONCERNING A MANUFACTURER'S EXPRESS WARRANTY AGAINST DEFECTIVE ASPHALT ROOF SHINGLES.
REGULAR SENATE BILLS
Subtitle Sponsor Number
SB42 J. Hutchinson (Capp) CONCERNING FITNESS TO PROCEED AND LACK OF CRIMINAL RESPONSIBILITY; AND CONCERNING A MENTAL EVALUATION OF A CRIMINAL DEFENDANT.
SB284 Hester (Eubanks) TO ESTABLISH A RETAIL OFF-PREMISES PERMIT FOR THE SALE OF WINE AT GROCERY STORES AND TO PROVIDE ADDITIONAL GRANT FUNDS TO SUPPORT ARKANSAS WINE PRODUCTION AND WINE TOURISM IN THE STATE.
SB340 J. Hutchinson (Pilkington) TO CREATE THE WRONGFUL BIRTH CIVIL LIABILITY PROTECTION ACT.
SB277 Hickey (McNair) CONCERNING THE PROCEDURES FOR OBTAINING TITLE TO A MOBILE HOME OR A MANUFACTURED HOME.
SB148 G. Stubblefield (C. Fite) TO CREATE BORN-ALIVE INFANT PROTECTION.
SB159 J. English (Drown) CONCERNING THE DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING CERTAIN EMPLOYMENT REQUIREMENTS AND QUALIFICATIONS OF THE DIRECTOR AND OF VETERANS' CLAIMS SPECIALISTS.
SB174 J. English (Drown) TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DUTIES OF THE ARKANSAS VETERANS' COMMISSION; AND TO INCREASE THE AMOUNT OF AUTHORIZED ANNUAL STIPENDS AND EXPENSE REIMBURSEMENT FOR MEMBERS OF THE COMMISSION IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES.
SJR8 Irvin (Ballinger) A CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT LIMITING CONTINGENCY FEES AND AWARDS OF PUNITIVE AND NON-ECONOMIC DAMAGES; AND CHANGING THE POWERS OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY AND THE SUPREME COURT REGARDING RULES OF PLEADING, PRACTICE, AND PROCEDURE.
SB328 A. Clark (C. Douglas) TO REQUIRE A PERSON WHO APPLIES FOR A K-6 TEACHING LICENSE OR A SPECIAL EDUCATION K-12 TEACHING LICENSE TO SUCCESSFULLY PASS A STAND-ALONE READING TEST AND A MULTI-SUBJECT TEST AS A CONDITION OF LICENSURE.
SB344 Rapert (Collins) TO MODERNIZE THE INSURANCE HOLDING COMPANY REGULATORY ACT.
SB348 Hickey (Womack) TO AMEND ARKANSAS LAW PERTAINING TO THE DUTIES AND OPERATIONS OF ARKANSAS LEGISLATIVE AUDIT.
ANNOUNCEMENTS
POINT OF PERSONAL PRIVILEGE
READING OF THE BILLS
ADJOURNMENT
Documents
No documents posted.